Fate-mapping early and late postnatally generated hair cells

In the postnatal mouse utricle, most hair cells are added during the first week after birth in both the striolar and extrastriolar regions [21]. To label the postnatally generated hair cells (HC^PG), we fate-mapped supporting cells in Plp1^CreERT/+; Rosa26R^tdTomato/+ (Plp1-Tomato) mice (S1A Fig) [9]. Tamoxifen (0.075 mg/g intraperitoneal [IP]) administration at postnatal day (P) 3 induced tdTomato labeling of 73.0 ± 10.3% and 14.1 ± 4.0% supporting cells in the extrastriolar and striolar regions, respectively, two days later (n = 4, Fig 1A–1C, S1A and S1B Fig). Hair cells were rarely tdTomato-labeled at this age (0.5 ± 0.3 and 0.3 ± 0.5%, n = 742 extrastriolar and 663 striolar hair cells from 4 mice) (Fig 1C and 1F, S1B and S1E Fig). At P30, 14.1 ± 3.7% of Myosin7a⁺ hair cells in the extrastriola and 5.2 ± 3.7% in the striola were tdTomato-labeled (n = 2,507 extrastriolar and 1,858 striolar hair cells from 11 mice, Fig 1D and 1F, S1C and S1E Fig), both significantly more than P5 (p < 0.001 in extrastriola and p < 0.01 in striola). Control experiments using corn oil on P3 Plp1-tdTomato mice revealed no labeled hair cells (n = 665 and 608 hair cells in the extrastriola and striola from 3 mice) and only rare labeled supporting cells at P30 (0.5% of 954 extrastriolar and 0.1% of 946 striolar supporting cells from 3 mice, S1F Fig). This suggests that P3 Plp1⁺ supporting cells contribute to postnatally generated hair cells, which we term HC^PG3 hereon.

Download:

• PPT
  PowerPoint slide
• PNG
  larger image
• TIFF
  original image

Fig 1. Characteristics of postnatally generated hair cells in the mouse utricle.

A) Plp1^CreERT/+; Rosa26R^tdTomato/+ mice were treated with tamoxifen at P3 (early tracing) and P8 (late tracing) to fate-map supporting cells. Organs were examined at P5 and P30. B) Diagram illustrating the extrastriolar and striolar regions of the utricle. C) Rare tdTomato⁺/Myosin7a⁺ hair cells were detected in the extrastriola 2 days after early tracing with tamoxifen given at P3. D) Many traced hair cells (asterisks) were found in the extrastriola at P30. E) After late tracing initiated at P8, few traced hair cells (asterisks) were detected in the extrastriola at P30. Representative high magnification images were selected from the extrastriola region (white boxes). F) Compared to P5, the percentage of tdTomato⁺/Myosin7a⁺ cells was significantly higher at P30 after early tracing from P3. It is also significantly higher than that of late tracing from P8 (n = 4–16 mice). G-I) Currents from hair cells were elicited using the delayed rectifier protocol described in the methods. J-L) Conductance-voltage plots were generated and values for maximal conductance, half-activation voltage and slope of the Boltzmann function were extracted (n = 9–13 cells). All examined hair cells from three groups displayed measurable conductances representative of gDR, with some significant differences in half-activation voltage and slope. Data shown as mean ± SD, compared using Student t tests and one-way ANOVA by Kruskal Wallis-Dunn's multiple comparison tests. ***p < 0.001, **p < 0.01, *p < 0.05. Scale bars: 50 μm. The underlying data can be found within S1 Data. P, postnatal day.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pbio.3000326.g001

The number of hair cells in the mouse utricle continues to increase during the first postnatal week, with marginal increases thereafter [21]. To identify these late postnatally generated hair cells, we administered tamoxifen (0.075 mg/g IP) to P8 Plp1-Tomato mice and found 4.6 ± 2.0% and 2.5 ± 2.5% of Myosin7a⁺ hair cells tdTomato-labeled in the extrastriola and striola, respectively, at P30 (n = 3,002 extrastriolar and 2,561 striolar hair cells from 16 mice, Fig 1E and 1F, S1D and S1E Fig). There were significantly fewer late traced hair cells (HC^PG8) than HC^PG3 (Fig 1F, S1E Fig, S1 Data), consistent with the decline in hair cell production after the first postnatal week [21]. To assess the electrophysiological properties of HC^PG3 and HC^PG8, we probed both cohorts at P30, allowing time for both groups of hair cells to mature. Traced hair cells (HC^PG3 and HC^PG8) and untraced hair cells (controls), which likely contained more mature hair cells derived from supporting cells earlier than P8, were probed for delayed rectifier potassium currents (IDR). Normally found in nascent and mature vestibular hair cells [14,16], IDR were observed in all three groups of hair cells (n = 13 HC^PG3, 9 HC^PG8, 9 untraced hair cells, Fig 1G–1I). From conductance-voltage plots, we found that values for maximal conductance, half-activation voltage and slope of the Boltzmann function were similar among groups (Fig 1J–1L, S1 Data), with small but significant differences among the latter two measurements possibly attributed to splice variants or phosphorylation state. Lastly, we used two additional measurements to estimate hair cell maturation: 1) cell capacitance as a proxy for cell size and 2) resting potentials which become more negative as hair cells mature [15]. We found that traced hair cells (HC^PG3 and HC^PG8) most closely matched perinatal hair cells in both size and resting potentials and estimate that they were comparably mature (S2 Table) [15]. Together, these data show that both early and late postnatally generated hair cells exhibit fundamental hair cell properties, leading us next to probe whether they acquire specialized hair cell subtype characteristics.

Specialization of postnatally generated hair cells into type II hair cells

Vestibular hair cell subtypes can be identified based on morphology, molecular markers, electrophysiological and synaptic properties. In addition, hair cell age can be intimated by the complement of ion channels present, synaptic function, and the morphology and functional state of hair bundles. Here, we first used molecular markers and electrophysiological properties to determine whether traced hair cells differentiate into hair cell subtypes.

Type I hair cells display amphora-shaped cell bodies and long thin apical necks, endowed with a consistent and simple electrophysiological fingerprint: a hyperpolarized activating delayed rectifier current (IKL) [16]. Type II hair cells are goblet-shaped with short, thick necks and basolateral cytoplasmic processes, but are more complex in that they contain diverse ion channels that vary with age and location, including the voltage-gated inward rectifying, nonspecific cation currents (IH) [26,16].

Since markers such as Calbindin and Oncomodulin are expressed in only striolar type I hair cells [34,35,29], we immunolabeled for Osteopontin for type I hair cells and for Annexin A4 and Mapt for type II hair cells [23]. We found that Osteopontin was expressed at the apical neck of type I hair cells with Tuj1⁺ calyces, while Annexin A4 and Mapt were expressed in the cell membrane of type II hair cells throughout the P30 utricle (Fig 2A–2D and 2K–2N, S2J and S2K Fig).

Download:

• PPT
  PowerPoint slide
• PNG
  larger image
• TIFF
  original image

Fig 2. Early and late postnatally generated hair cells primarily show type II hair cell characteristics.

A) P30 whole mount utricle (early tracing) labeled for Annexin A4 (ANXA4). B) Cartoon depicting nucleus level of ANXA4⁺ (green) type II hair cells. C-D) Almost all postnatally generated tdTomato⁺/Myosin7a⁺ hair cells from early and late tracing expressed ANXA4 (asterisks). Inset shows orthogonal view of traced goblet-shaped, ANXA4⁺ type II hair cells with basolateral processes. E-G) Representative tracings of voltage-gated currents in response to the inward rectifier protocol from HC^PG3, HC^PG8 and untraced hair cells (n = 5–10 cells). H-J) All three groups demonstrate similar inward rectifier electrophysiological (gH) properties: peak conductances, half-activation and slopes. K) P30 utricle from early tracing labeled for OPN. L) Diagram illustrating the nucleus level of OPN⁺ (green) type I hair cells. Occasional tdTomato⁺/Myosin7a⁺ hair cells from early M) and late tracing N) expressed OPN on the apical neck (arrowhead). Inset shows orthogonal view of traced OPN⁺ type I hair cells with amphora shape, and a long and narrow apical neck. O-Q) Examples of low voltage activated potassium current (IKL) responses during the step displacements for HC^PG3, HC^PG8 and untraced hair cells (n = 8–12 cells). Green dashed lines define zero current levels. R-T) Similar tail current and reversal potential analysis were performed with resultant data for conductance, half-activation and slope. Data shown as mean ± SD, compared using one-way ANOVA by Kruskal Wallis-Dunn's multiple comparison test. Scale bars: A, K) 100 μm; C-D, M-N) 20 μm. The underlying data can be found within S1 Data. ANXA4, Annexin A4; HC^PG, postnatally generated hair cell; OPN, Osteopontin; P, postnatal day.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pbio.3000326.g002

When examining HC^PG3 in the P30 Plp1-Tomato utricles, we found that most traced hair cells expressed Annexin A4 (85.1 ± 25.8% of 117 and 94.9 ± 8.9% of 24 HC^PG3 in the extrastriola and striola from 3 mice, respectively) (Fig 2C, S1A and S1B Fig, S3 Table). Similarly, most HC^PG8 were Annexin A4⁺ (95.2 ± 8.2% of 24 and 100% ± 0% of 12 HC^PG8 in extrastriola and striola from 3 mice, respectively) (Fig 2D, S2A and S2C Fig, S3 Table). We examined 95 Annexin A4⁺ HC^PG3 and 35 Annexin A4⁺ HC^PG8 and found that 69–79% were goblet-shaped, with other rare morphologic subtypes also present (Fig 2C and 2D, S2B, S2C and S2F Fig). Lastly, Annexin A4⁺ HC^PG8 also expressed Mapt, a marker of mature type II hair cells [23] (82.4% of 17 extrastriolar cells and 76.5% of 17 striolar cells from 3 mice) (S2I–S2K Fig, S4 Table), suggesting that most postnatally generated hair cells from the Plp1 lineage have acquired a type II hair cell phenotype.

To verify their identity as type II hair cells, we probed HC^PG3 and HC^PG8 from P30 Plp1-Tomato utricles for both IKL, characteristic of type I hair cells, and IH non-specific cation currents [14,16]. The presence of IKL indicates a type I hair cell electrophysiological phenotype. To account for possible variations in measurements, we compared traced hair cells to untraced cells in a similar location within the sensory epithelium. To probe for IH we voltage-clamped hair cells at -69 mV and hyperpolarized between -74 and -156 mV for 400 ms and then back to -69 mV. Hair cells from each group (10/10 HC^PG3, 9/9 HC^PG8 and 5/5 untraced hair cells) displayed IH (Fig 2E–2G), with similar properties (peak conductance, half-activation and slope) measured in all three groups (Fig 2H–2J, S1 Data).

To assess whether postnatally generated hair cells can acquire features of type I hair cells, we immunostained for and found that a subset of HC^PG3 and HC^PG8 expressed Osteopontin (21.2 ± 32.6% of 87 and 19.3 ± 26.2% of 49 HC^PG3 in the extrastriola and striola, respectively, from 3–4 mice, and 4.0 ± 6.8% of 81 and 1.7 ± 4.1% of 28 HC^PG8 in the extrastriola and striola from 7–8 mice) (Fig 2M and 2N, S2D and S2E Fig, S3 Table). Among 24 Osteopontin⁺ HC^PG3 and 2 HC^PG8 examined, most (75–100%) displayed the classic amphora shape (Fig 2M and 2N, S2D, S2E and S2G Fig).

To further investigate whether postnatally generated hair cells exhibit type I hair cell electrophysiological properties, we probed and found no significant IKL in either HC^PG3 or HC^PG8 (n = 10 and 8 cells, respectively), suggesting that these groups do not contain HCs with a type I electrophysiological phenotype (Fig 2O, 2P and 2R). By contrast, IKL was detected in 75% of (9 of 12) untraced hair cells (Fig 2Q and 2R, S1 Data), with half-activation and slope comparable to those in mature type I hair cells (Fig 2S and 2T, S1 Data) [16].

The presence of IH and the lack of IKL in fate-mapped HC^PG3 and HC^PG8 suggest a non-type I hair cell phenotype. Although few postnatally generated hair cells displayed molecular and morphologic features of type I hair cells, none displayed such electrophysiological properties. This is consistent with the previous results that most postnatally generated hair cells displayed molecular and morphologic features representing a type II hair cell phenotype.

Of note, several conductances were not explored in detail, in part because they were not observed. Sodium conductances, often described in immature hair cells [14,36] were not observed in either traced or untraced cells, likely suggesting that all cells had matured past this developmental stage. A-type potassium conductances, which are often found in extrastriolar hair cells and used as a marker for maturation [14,37,16], were not observed in traced or untraced cells, likely indicating that we recorded from a location where this conductance was not observed.

In summary, these data indicate that Plp1⁺ supporting cells primarily give rise to type II hair cells, whereas few type I hair cells were generated in the postnatal period. In comparison, untraced Myosin7a⁺ hair cells, which likely represent hair cells that arose earlier than P8, more commonly expressed the type I hair cell marker Osteopontin (S3 Table) and the signature IKL at P30.

Active presynaptic components in postnatally generated hair cells

To determine whether postnatally generated hair cells are neurally integrated, we first examined innervation in P30 Plp1-Tomato utricles. All HC^PG3 (n = 127 extrastriolar and 18 striolar hair cells from 3 mice) and HC^PG8 (n = 73 extrastriolar and 18 striolar hair cells from 9 mice) were juxtaposed to Tuj1⁺ neurites (Fig 3A–3C, S3A and S3B Fig). However, neither HC^PG3 nor HC^PG8 showed any Tuj1⁺ calyx-shaped nerve terminals, supporting the notion that postnatally generated hair cells were primarily type II hair cells.

Download:

• PPT
  PowerPoint slide
• PNG
  larger image
• TIFF
  original image

Fig 3. Synaptic properties of postnatally generated hair cells.

A) Diagram illustrating hair cells with the presynaptic element Ctbp2 (red) and associated Tuj1⁺ vestibular neurites (beige). B-C) Representative confocal images of tdTomato⁺/Myosin7a⁺ hair cells (asterisks and dashed lines) from early and late tracing associated with Tuj1⁺ neurites (arrowheads in orthogonal views, n = 127 cells from 3 mice for early tracing and 73 cells from 9 mice for late tracing). D-E) Expression of Ctbp2 on the basolateral surfaces of traced hair cells (arrowhead). Shown are high magnification XY and orthogonal views of cells of interests in boxes (n = 53 cells from 3 mice for early tracing and 56 cells from 6 mice for late tracing). F) Quantification of Ctbp2⁺ puncta in tdTomato⁺/Myosin7a⁺ hair cells in the extrastriola. No significant difference was found between early and late tracing. G-I) Representative calcium currents from Plp1-traced HC^PG3, HC^PG8 and untraced hair cells. Calcium currents were isolated from voltage-clamped hair cells by replacing intracellular potassium with Cs and tetra-ethyl ammonium. Currents in response to the calcium current protocol were monitored and analyzed. J-K) Current-voltage plots were generated from peak current responses and maximal current and half activating voltage were extracted from these plots (n = 4–14 cells). Data shown as mean ± SD, compared using Student t tests and one-way ANOVA by Kruskal Wallis-Dunn's multiple comparison test. *p < 0.05. Scale bars: B-E) 20 μm, XY views in D-E) 5 μm. The underlying data can be found within S1 Data. HC^PG, postnatally generated hair cell.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pbio.3000326.g003

Ctbp2 is a major component of the hair cell presynaptic ribbon [38]. We found Ctbp2 expressed in all HC^PG3 (n = 53 extrastriolar and 19 striolar hair cells from 3 mice) and HC^PG8 (n = 56 extrastriolar and 25 striolar hair cells from 6 mice) examined (Fig 3A, 3D and 3E, S3C and S3D Fig). No significant difference was found in the number of Ctbp2⁺ puncta between HC^PG3 and HC^PG8 (Fig 3F, S3E Fig, S1 Data). In comparison to tdTomato-negative, untraced hair cells, the number of Ctbp2⁺ puncta of HC^PG3 and HC^PG8 also were also not significantly different (p > 0.05 for all).

We next examined whether HC^PG3 and HC^PG8 were capable of synaptic vesicle release. Calcium currents were isolated (Fig 3G–3I, S1 Data), current-voltage plots were generated from peak current responses, and the maximal current and half activating voltage were extracted from these plots (Fig 3J and 3K, S1 Data). Like untraced hair cells (4/4), all 14 HC^PG3 and 8 HC^PG8 displayed calcium current responses supportive of the potential for presynaptic activity. The presence of calcium currents is also supportive of traced cells taking on a hair cell phenotype. Slight differences in half-activation values may indicate different states of maturity and warrants further investigation.

To assess functional activity of presynaptic sites, vesicle fusion was monitored using a dual sine wave technique as previously described [39,40]. Three groups of hair cells (HC^PG3, HC^PG8, and untraced hair cells) were depolarized to the voltage of maximal calcium current for three seconds and changes in capacitance were monitored in real time (S3F–S3H Fig). We found that most (13/17 HC^PG3, 7/8 HC^PG8, 4/4 untraced hair cells) of the recorded cells had greater than 50 fF of capacitance change. Although quite variable, no differences in maximal release were observed among the groups (S3I and S3J Fig, S1 Data), supporting the conclusion that postnatally generated hair cells were presynaptically active. The presence of presynaptic activity also supports the conclusion that traced cells behave as hair cells.

Immature stereociliary bundles and MET channels in postnatally generated hair cells

Another defining feature of hair cell maturation is the acquisition of stereociliary bundles and MET [14,41]. First, we marked these actin-rich structures using fluorescence-conjugated phalloidin and found that most HC^PG3 and HC^PG8 displayed either immature or no bundles (Fig 4A–4C). We categorized bundles based on established morphologic criteria (long, short and absent) [42] and discovered that most HC^PG3 and HC^PG8 displayed short or no stereocilia (74.8% and 21.3% of 127 HC^PG3 from 4 mice and 72.9% and 19.8% of 96 HC^PG8 from 8 mice; Fig 4D–4G, S1 Data). By contrast, more than 80% of untraced hair cells displayed mature-appearing (long) stereociliary bundles (n = 794–849 cells from 4–8 mice, Fig 4H, S1 Data). Immature bundles were similarly prevalent in HC^PG3 and HC^PG8 residing in the striolar and extrastriolar regions.

Download:

• PPT
  PowerPoint slide
• PNG
  larger image
• TIFF
  original image

Fig 4. Bundle features of early and late postnatally generated hair cells.

A) Diagram illustrating hair cell stereociliary bundles. B-C) tdTomato⁺/Myosin7a⁺ hair cells (dashed circles) added from early and late tracing with long (asterisks), short (arrows) and absent bundles (arrowheads) in both the hair bundle and cell body level. D-F) High magnification images of representative cells with long (D, asterisks), short (E, arrows) and absent bundles (F, arrowheads). G-H) Proportion of bundle morphology in traced and untraced hair cells. The majority of traced hair cells had short bundles from early (n = 127 HCs from 4 mice) and late tracing (n = 96 from 8 mice), whereas majority of untraced hair cells had long bundles (n = 849 HCs from 4 mice at P3, 794 HCs from 8 mice at P8). I-J) Representative confocal images of GTTR⁺/tdTomato⁺/Myosin7a⁺ (arrowhead) and GTTR^-/tdTomato⁺/Myosin7a⁺ (arrows) hair cells from early and late tracing. I’) High magnification images of panel I. K-L) Significantly more untraced hair cells than traced hair cells were GTTR-labeled in both early (n = 117 and 48 traced HCs, 649 and 700 untraced HCs from 3 mice in the extrastriola and striola) and late tracing experiments (n = 30 and 16 traced HCs, 951 and 740 untraced HCs from 4 mice in the extrastriola and striola). Data shown as mean ± SD, compared using Student t tests. ***p < 0.001, **p < 0.01, *p < 0.05. Scale bars: B-C, I-J) 20 μm; D-F, I’) 10 μm. The underlying data can be found within S1 Data. P, postnatal day.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pbio.3000326.g004

To test whether MET channels were functional in HC^PG3 and HC^PG8, we administered Texas-Red conjugated gentamicin (GTTR, 0.85 mg/ml for 1 hr), which enters hair cells via MET channels [43], to freshly harvested utricles. The presence of GTTR labeling indicates a population of MET channels that have a non-zero open probability. From early tracing (P3-P30) experiments, we found that GTTR labeled 83.7 ± 11.0% and 61.0 ± 7.8% of untraced hair cells in the extrastriola and striola of undamaged P30 utricles (n = 649 and 700 from 3 mice, Fig 4I–4L, S1 Data). This starkly contrasts the Plp1-traced hair cells, of which only 31.0 ± 19.0% and 38.9 ± 9.6% were GTTR-labeled (n = 117 and 48 in the extrastriola and striola regions from 3 mice). Similarly in the late tracing experiments (P8-P30), significantly more untraced hair cells were GTTR-labeled (84.2 ± 7.2% of 951 and 73.4 ± 3.4% of 740 hair cells in the extrastriola and striola from 4 mice) than traced hair cells (29.2 ± 6.7% of 30 and 39.2 ± 7.8% of 16 traced HCs in the extrastriola and striola from 4 mice, Fig 4I–4L, S1 Data). In summary, postnatally generated hair cells exhibit relatively underdeveloped bundles and MET channel activities in comparison to untraced hair cells.

Hair cell regeneration and recovery of vestibular function after hair cell ablation

We previously characterized hair cell regeneration in the neonatal utricle and found that both Plp1- and Lgr5-marked supporting cells contribute to the population of regenerated hair cells [9]. To examine the properties of regenerated hair cells (HC^R), we ablated hair cells using the Pou4f3^DTR/+ mouse [44], in which the hair cell promoter Pou4f3 drives the expression of human diphtheria toxin receptor (DTR). Diphtheria toxin (DT) injection at P1 led to a loss of 91.5 ± 9.1% of hair cells two weeks later (P15, n = 6, Fig 5A, 5C and 5J, S4B and S4F and S4G Fig, S1 Data). At P30 and P60, hair cell numbers were restored to 25.1 ± 14.4% and 42.5 ± 18.5% of aged-matched controls, respectively (n = 15 from P30, 11 from P60, Fig 5B, 5D–5F and 5J, S4A and S4C–S4H Fig, S1 Data). Compared to P15, Myosin7a⁺ hair cell numbers at P30 and P60 in both the extrastriola and striola significantly increased, in line with previous results [9].

Download:

• PPT
  PowerPoint slide
• PNG
  larger image
• TIFF
  original image

Fig 5. Hair cell number and vestibular function recovers after hair cell ablation.

A) Pou4f3^DTR/+ mice were treated with DT at P1 and examined at P15 and P30 and P60. B-F) After DT treatment, both the hair cell number and area of sensory epithelium decreased at P15, followed by a partial recovery at P30 and P60. G-I) Representative VsEP waveforms of normal responses of a P15 wild-type animal (0.4 g/ms threshold shown in red) (G), absent responses in a damaged P15 Pou4f3^DTR/+ mouse (H), and an elevated response threshold in a damaged P30 Pou4f3^DTR/+ mouse (0.7 g/ms threshold shown) (I). J) Normalized Myosin7a⁺ hair cell counts at P30 are significantly higher than P15 (n = 6 at P15 and 15 at P30). Damaged tissues normalized to age-matched controls. K) Many animals displayed partial VsEP thresholds recovery (blue dots) at P30 and P60 although some still showed no responses (red dots). Compared to P15, the average thresholds at P30 and P60 are significantly lower (n = 48 at P15, 39 at P30 and 27 at P60), but still significantly higher than age-matched controls (n = 20 at P15, 22 at P30, and 15 at P60). Data shown as mean ± SD, compared using Student t tests and one-way ANOVA by Tukey’s multiple comparison test. ***p < 0.001, **p < 0.01, *p < 0.05. Scale bars: 50 μm in B-F. The underlying data can be found within S1 Data. DT, diphtheria toxin; P, postnatal day; VsEP, vestibular-evoked potential.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pbio.3000326.g005

We next assessed function of the regenerating utricle by measuring vestibular-evoked potentials (VsEPs), which represent compound action potentials of the vestibular nerves and central relays as a result of a transient linear acceleration applied along the naso-occipital axis [45]. After DT-induced hair cell loss, all 51 P15 Pou4f3^DTR/+ mice displayed elevated VsEP thresholds with 48 of 51 (94.1%) displaying no detectable responses, whereas undamaged P15 wild-type animals uniformly displayed robust VsEP thresholds (0.43 ± 0.24 g/ms, n = 20, Fig 5G, 5H and 5K, S1 Data). Among the 48 P15 animals that demonstrated no detectable VsEP thresholds, serial measurements showed that 35.9 and 59.3% regained thresholds at P30 and P60 with average response thresholds of 0.83 ± 0.31 g/ms and 0.83 ± 0.34 g/ms, respectively (n = 14 of 39 from P30 and 16 of 27 from P60). At these ages, the average responses significantly improved compared to P15 damaged animals (p < 0.001 for both, Fig 5I and 5K), but remained elevated compared to age-matched, undamaged animals (0.39 ± 0.12 g/ms and 0.43 ± 0.19 g/ms at P30 and P60, n = 22 and n = 15, Fig 5I and 5K, S1 Data). Thus, our data suggest that a subset of animals partially restore their ability to detect linear acceleration.

In support of this notion, VsEP latencies, which represent timing of the population of activated neurons, also significantly improved from P15 to P30 and P60 in DT-treated Pou4f3^DTR/+ mice (S4I Fig). Similarly, VsEP amplitudes, which correlate with the size and synchrony of the population of activated neurons, also significantly improved from P15 to P30 and P60 of DT-treated Pou4f3^DTR/+ mice (S4J Fig, S1 Data). We correlated the number of hair cells and VsEP thresholds and found the two to have a modest, inverse relationship (R² = 0.62, S4K Fig, S1 Data). Together our data indicate that organ function is partially recovered following hair cell ablation in the neonatal utricle.

Specialization of Plp1-traced regenerated hair cells into type II hair cells

We next sought to examine the properties of regenerated hair cells (HC^R) in the regenerating utricle in P30 Pou4f3^DTR/+ mice. To identify HC^R, we fate-mapped supporting cells in Pou4f3^DTR/+; Plp1^CreERT/+; Rosa26R^tdTomato/+ (Pou4f3-DTR; Plp1-Tomato) mice. To minimize labeling of hair cells normally added postnatally, we administered tamoxifen at P8 (0.075 mg/g, IP) to fate-map Plp1⁺ supporting cells in the damaged utricle (Fig 6A, S5A–S5C Fig). As expected, we found significantly more fate-mapped, Myosin7a⁺ hair cells in both the extrastriolar and striolar regions (17.4 ± 5.1% and 14.0 ± 5.5%, n = 762–798 hair cells from 10 mice) than undamaged controls (4.6 ± 2.0% and 2.5 ± 2.5%, respectively, p < 0.001, n = 2,561–3,002 hair cells from 16 mice) (Fig 6B–6F, S1 Data). Consistent with published data [9], these results indicate that Plp1-marked supporting cells regenerated hair cells in the damaged neonatal mouse utricle.

Download:

• PPT
  PowerPoint slide
• PNG
  larger image
• TIFF
  original image

Fig 6. Plp1⁺ supporting cells regenerate hair cells after hair cell loss.

A) Pou4f3^DTR/+; Plp1^CreERT/+; Rosa26R^tdTomato/+ mice were treated with DT at P1, followed by tamoxifen at P8 to fate-map Plp1⁺ supporting cells. Organs were examined at P30. B-E) Damaged P30 utricles had more tdTomato⁺/Myosin7a⁺ hair cells (asterisks) than controls. F) Quantification shows that the percentage of tdTomato⁺/Myosin7a⁺ hair cells in damaged utricles (n = 10) was significantly higher than in undamaged controls (n = 16). G-H) Almost all traced, regenerated hair cells (asterisks) expressed the type II hair cell marker ANXA4 in both the extrastriola and striola. Inset shows orthogonal view of a traced, regenerated ANXA4⁺ hair cell with a short, round cell body and no basolateral processes. I-J) Occasionally traced, regenerated hair cells (arrowhead) expressed the type I hair cell marker OPN in both the extrastriola and striola. Inset shows orthogonal view of traced, regenerated OPN⁺ hair cells appearing pear-shaped, with a short neck. Data shown as mean ± SD and compared using Student t tests. ***p < 0.001. Scale bars: 20 μm. The underlying data can be found within S1 Data. ANXA4, Annexin A4; OPN, Osteopontin.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pbio.3000326.g006

In utricles from the P30 Pou4f3-DTR; Plp1-Tomato mice, almost all HC^R expressed Annexin A4 (95.8 ± 7.2% of 19 extrastriolar and 97.0 ± 5.2% of 22 striolar hair cells from 3 mice) and few expressed Osteopontin (16.2 ± 13.0% of 85 extrastriolar and 15.6 ± 12.0% of 83 striolar cells from 7 mice) (Fig 6G–6J, S3 Table). Most Annexin A4⁺ HC^R, expressed the mature type II hair cell marker Mapt (76.5% of 17 extrastriolar cells and 58.8% of 17 striolar cells from 4 mice, S5F and S5G Fig, S4 Table). By contrast, the majority of untraced hair cells from damaged utricles expressed Osteopontin (68.0 ± 9.2% of 266 and 68.5 ± 11.4% of 292 untraced hair cells from 4 mice in the extrastriola and striola, respectively, S3 Table). Thus, the composition of untraced hair cells from damaged utricles, which likely represent surviving hair cells, is consistent with the previously reported ratios of type I and II hair cells in the striola and extrastriola (1.47 and 1.19) [46], whereas HC^R mainly displayed a type II hair cell phenotype. Unlike HC^PG3 and HC^PG8, many regenerated Annexin A4⁺ hair cells displayed short, rounded cell bodies without basolateral processes, while others displayed basolateral processes associated with classic type II hair cells (n = 37 cells from 3 mice) (Fig 6G and 6H, S5D Fig).

All regenerated Osteopontin⁺ hair cells examined (18/18) were also morphologically distinct from undamaged counterparts, appearing pear-shaped with short necks (Fig 6I and 6J, S5E Fig) and no amphora-shaped Osteopontin⁺, Plp1-traced hair cells were detected in the damaged organs. These results suggest that Plp1-traced HC^R, like HC^PG3 and HC^PG8, preferentially acquire properties of type II hair cells and less commonly those of type I hair cells. However, many type II HC^R and all type I HC^R observed were morphologically distinct from HC^PG3 and HC^PG8.

We next assessed the electrophysiological properties of Plp1-traced HC^R and untraced hair cells in P30 Pou4f3-DTR; Plp1-Tomato utricles (Fig 7A and 7C), and compared them to Plp1-traced HC^PG8 from undamaged Plp1-Tomato utricles (Figs 2F and 7B). IDR were detected in all hair cells from the three groups (Fig 7A–7C, n = 17 HC^R, 9 HC^PG8 and 14 untraced hair cells, respectively) with similar corresponding maximal conductances (Fig 7D–7F, S1 Data), despite differences in half-activation and slope. Cell capacitance was used as a proxy for cell size, which serves as a marker for hair cell maturation. Traced hair cells, like untraced hair cells, displayed capacitance measurements similar to those of postnatal utricular hair cells (S2 Table) [14]. Similarly resting potential data varies with cell maturity and measured values suggest that HC^R were at least as mature as postnatal hair cells previously reported. Although the absolute level of maturity cannot be deduced from these parameters, these data suggests that traced hair cells match untraced hair cells.

Download:

• PPT
  PowerPoint slide
• PNG
  larger image
• TIFF
  original image

Fig 7. Plp1-traced, regenerated hair cells display electrophysiological features of type II hair cells.

Three groups of hair cells were examined: 1) traced (black, HC^R) and 2) untraced hair cells (blue) from P30 Pou4f3^DTR/+; Plp1^CreERT/+; Rosa26R^tdTomato/+ mice treated with DT at P1 and tamoxifen at P8; and 3) traced hair cells (red, HC^PG8) from Plp1^CreERT/+; Rosa26R^tdTomato/+ mice treated and tamoxifen at P8. A-C) Representative tracings of IDR from hair cells from each group (HC^R, HC^PG8 and untraced hair cells, n = 9–17 cells). D-F) All three groups demonstrate similar peak conductances but significant differences between half-activation and slopes. G-I) Tracings of IH measurements from HC^R, HC^PG8 and untraced hair cells (n = 9–17 cells). J-L) All three groups demonstrate similar peak conductances, half-activation, and slopes. M-O) IKL responses from untraced hair cells from the damaged utricles, but not HC^R or HC^PG8 (n = 8–16 cells). P-R) Similar tail current and reversal potential analysis were performed and the resultant data for conductance, half-activation and slope for untraced hair cells are presented. Data shown as mean ± SD and compared using one-way ANOVA by Kruskal Wallis-Dunn's multiple comparison tests. Green dashed lines define zero current levels. ***p < 0.001, **p < 0.01. The underlying data can be found within S1 Data. HC^PG, postnatally generated hair cell; P, postnatal day.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pbio.3000326.g007

Next, we probed for and found IH in all three groups of hair cells (17/17 HC^R, 9/9 HC^PG8 and 11/11 untraced hair cells) (Fig 7G–7I). Although hair cells from the three groups showed comparable voltages of half-activation and voltage dependence (slope), conductances of HC^R were lower than those of untraced hair cells suggesting fewer channels are present in these newly formed cells (Fig 7J–7L, S1 Data) and perhaps indicating a less mature population. Conversely, IKL was not detected in any Plp1-traced HC^R or HC^PG8 (0/16 and 0/8, respectively, Fig 7M and 7N) but was detected in 5/12 untraced hair cells examined (Fig 7O–7R, S1 Data). These data indicate that Plp1-traced HC^R displayed electrophysiological properties representative of non-type I hair cells, and together with the molecular markers support a type II hair cell phenotype.

Regenerated hair cells display synaptic elements but immature bundles

We next examined HC^R for formation of presynaptic terminals and innervation by immunostaining for Ctbp2 and Tuj1 in P30 Pou4f3-DTR; Plp1-Tomato utricles. In all HC^R examined (n = 106 cells in both extrastriola and striola from 5 mice) we found adjacent Tuj1⁺ neurites with no calyces observed (Fig 8A and 8B). HC^R also uniformly expressed Ctbp2, with the number of Ctbp2⁺ puncta similar to those of HC^PG8 (combined from both extrastriola and striola, n = 81 and 35 cells from 6 control and 3 damaged mice, Fig 8C–8E, S1 Data). These data suggest that HC^R had presynaptic machinery and innervation consistent with a hair cell phenotype.

Download:

• PPT
  PowerPoint slide
• PNG
  larger image
• TIFF
  original image

Fig 8. Synaptic properties of Plp1-traced, regenerated hair cells.

A-B) Representative images of regenerated tdTomato⁺/Myosin7a⁺ hair cells (asterisks) with associated with Tuj1⁺ neural elements (arrowheads) in the extrastriola and striola (n = 106 cells from 5 mice). C-D) All Plp1-traced hair cells examined expressed Ctbp2 on the basolateral surfaces (arrowheads, n = 35 cells from 3 mice). E) Quantification of Ctbp2⁺ puncta in traced hair cells in the extrastriola and striola. No significant difference was found between hair cells from control and damaged utricles (n = 56 extrastriolar and 25 striolar hair cells from 6 control mice utricles, n = 18 extrastriolar and 17 striolar hair cells from 3 damaged mice utricles). F-H) Representative calcium currents from traced hair cells (HC^R from damaged utricles and HC^PG8 from undamaged utricles) and untraced hair cells. Calcium currents were isolated using methods described in Fig 3. I-J) Peak current responses and maximal current and half activating voltage were not statistically different among groups (n = 4–17 cells). Data shown as mean ± SD, compared using Student t tests and one-way ANOVA by Kruskal Wallis-Dunn's multiple comparison tests. Scale bars: A-D) 20 μm, XY view) 5 μm. The underlying data can be found within S1 Data. HC^PG, postnatally generated hair cell.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pbio.3000326.g008

To further characterize HC^R for the presence of functional presynaptic elements, we assessed calcium currents and monitored presynaptic vesicle fusion via capacitance changes in response to depolarization in HC^R (Fig 8F–8H, S5H–S5J Fig, S1 Data). Like HC^PG8 (8/8) and untraced hair cells (4/4) from the damaged organ, calcium currents were detected in all HC^R (17/17) examined and found to be of comparable sizes and voltage-dependence (Fig 8I and 8J, S1 Data). The presence of calcium currents supports a hair cell phenotype and the potential for presynaptic activity. Capacitance measurements showed calcium driven changes indicative of vesicle release in almost all HC^R (14/15, 7/8 HC^PG8 and 3/3 untraced hair cells, S5K and S5L Fig, S1 Data), suggesting that the morphologically identified presynaptic elements were likely functional.

Next, we examined the bundles of HC^R via labeling with fluorescence-conjugated phalloidin (Fig 9A) and found that they, like HC^PG8, mostly displayed immature stereociliary bundles: 14.5% long, 82.3% short and 7.3% absent stereocilia (n = 124 cells in both extrastriola and striola from 6 mice, Fig 9A–9E, S1 Data). By contrast, most untraced hair cells in damaged tissues displayed long bundles (n = 617 cells in both extrastriola and striola from 6 mice in damaged utricles, Fig 9E, S1 Data).

Download:

• PPT
  PowerPoint slide
• PNG
  larger image
• TIFF
  original image

Fig 9. Regenerated hair cells display immature stereociliary bundles.

A) Regenerated traced hair cells (dashed circles) with long (asterisks), short (arrows) and absent bundles (arrowheads). Shown are images taken at the focal planes of hair bundle and hair cell body. B-D) Representative high magnification images of hair cells with long (B) (asterisk), short (C) (arrow) and absent bundles (D) (arrowhead). E) Proportion of traced and untraced hair cells displaying the above bundle morphology. Most regenerated hair cells had short bundles (124 cells from 6 damaged mice), whereas most untraced hair cells had long bundles (617 cells from 6 damaged mice). F-G) Representative confocal images of GTTR⁺/tdTomato⁺/Myosin7a⁺ (arrowhead) and GTTR^-/tdTomato⁺/Myosin7a⁺ hair cells (arrows) in damaged utricles. F’) High magnification images of panel F. H) Compared to traced hair cells, significantly more untraced hair cells were GTTR-labeled in the damaged utricles (n = 25 and 11 traced HCs, 172 and 148 untraced HCs from 4 mice in the extrastriola and striola). Data shown as mean ± SD, compared using Student t tests. **p < 0.01, *p < 0.05. Scale bars: A, F-G) 20 μm; B-D, F’) 10 μm. The underlying data can be found within S1 Data.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pbio.3000326.g009

After adding GTTR to acutely isolated damaged/regenerated P30 utricles, we found that GTTR labeled 74.7 ± 7.4% and 71.7 ± 21.4%% of untraced hair cells (n = 172 and 148 untraced HCs in the extrastriola and striola, respectively, Fig 9F–9H, S1 Data) versus 49.3 ± 21.5% and 33.3 ± 21.5% of traced hair cells (25 and 11 traced HCs in the extrastriola and striola from 4 mice). These data suggest that fewer traced, regenerated hair cells have open MET channels (with non-zero open probability) than untraced hair cells. Taken together, these results suggest that Plp1-traced regenerated hair cells display some somatic properties of type II hair cells, yet immature stereociliary bundles and MET.

Damage-activated Lgr5⁺ supporting cells regenerate type I and II hair cells

Thus far, we have shown that the Plp1-lineage supporting cells primarily regenerated hair cells displaying a type II hair cell phenotype. Previously, we found that damage activates Lgr5⁺ supporting cells in the striolar region to regenerate both type I and II hair cells, which were defined only by expression of Calbindin, Sox2, and the presence of Tuj1⁺ calyx nerve terminals [9]. To further investigate the properties of HC^R from the Lgr5⁺ lineage, we fate-mapped Lgr5⁺ supporting cells in Pou4f3^DTR/+; Lgr5^CreERT2/+; Rosa26R^tdTomato/+ (Pou4f3-DTR; Lgr5-Tomato) mice (DT at P1 to induce hair cell loss and tamoxifen at P3 to trace Lgr5⁺ cells) (Fig 10A). The latter time point (P3) was selected because Lgr5 is transiently up-regulated in supporting cells [9]. DT-induced damage led to significantly more tdTomato⁺, Myosin7a⁺ hair cells than in undamaged controls at P30 (82.6 ± 11.0% and 65.4 ± 12.7%, p < 0.01, n = 135–164 cells from 9–10 mice, Fig 10B and 10C). Lgr5-traced HC^R primarily resided in the striola, and more often expressed the type I marker Osteopontin (61.8 ± 25.2% of 71 cells from 7 mice) than the type II marker Annexin A4 (46.9 ± 2.8% of 36 cells from 3 mice, Fig 10D–10F, S3 Table). Moreover, 24.4 ± 15.0% of Lgr5-traced HC^R displayed Tuj1⁺ calyces (n = 40 cells from 4 mice, Fig 10G, S6E Fig, S3 Table). In undamaged controls, many Lgr5-traced hair cells expressed Annexin A4 (76.6 ± 20.3%, n = 57 cells from 4 mice), but none expressed Osteopontin (n = 65 cells from 6 mice) or displayed Tuj1⁺ calyces (n = 26 cells from 3 mice) (Fig 10H, S6A–S6D Fig, S3 Table, S1 Data). Similar to Plp1-traced hair cells, most Lgr5-traced hair cells displayed short or no bundles (74.2% and 3.2% of 31 cells from 6 mice) and 22.6% of them displayed long bundle (Fig 10I–10K). These data suggest that Lgr5-traced supporting cells, in contrast to Plp1-traced supporting cells, can give rise to both type I and type II hair cells, although mostly presumably nonfunctional given the presence of immature stereociliary bundles.

Download:

• PPT
  PowerPoint slide
• PNG
  larger image
• TIFF
  original image

Fig 10. Lgr5⁺ supporting cells regenerate type I and type II hair cells.

A) Pou4f3^DTR/+; Lgr5^CreERT2/+; Rosa26R^tdTomato/+ and Lgr5^CreERT2/+; Rosa26R^tdTomato/+ mice were treated with DT at P1, followed by tamoxifen at P3 to fate-map Lgr5⁺ supporting cells. Organs were examined at P30. B-C) Whole mount preparation of P30 control and damaged utricles. Traced cells primarily occupied the presumed striolar region of the damaged organ. D) Diagram illustrating type I and II hair cells, the former of which are endowed with Tuj1⁺ calyx. E) Representative images of ANXA4⁺ (arrowhead) and ANXA4^- (arrow) traced hair cells in the P30 damaged utricle. 46.9% of Lgr5-traced hair cells expressed ANXA4 (n = 36 cells from 3 mice). F) Representative images of OPN⁺ (arrowhead) and OPN^- (arrow) traced hair cells in the P30 damaged utricle. 61.8% of Lgr5-traced hair cells were OPN⁺ (n = 71 cells from 7 mice). G) In the P30 damaged utricle, Lgr5-traced hair cells expressed OPN (arrowhead) and were surrounded by Tuj1⁺ calyx (arrowhead, 24.4% of Lgr5-traced hair cells, n = 40 cells from 4 mice), or were OPN^- and innervated by Tuj1⁺ boutons (arrow). Representative orthogonal view shows round, pear-shaped, regenerated hair cells with OPN⁺, short neck and Tuj1⁺ calyx (arrowheads). H) Compared to undamaged controls, the damages utricles had significantly fewer ANXA4⁺ traced HC^R and more OPN⁺ and OPN⁺/Tuj1⁺ (Calyx) traced HC^R. No OPN⁺ and OPN⁺/Tuj1⁺ (Calyx) traced hair cells were seen in the undamaged utricle. Data shown as mean ± SD, compared using Student t tests. (I-K) Representative high magnification images of traced hair cells with long (I) (asterisk), short (J) (arrow) and absent bundles (K) (arrowhead). ***p < 0.001, *p < 0.05. Scale bars: B-C) 100 μm; E-G) 20 μm. (I-K) 10 μm. The underlying data can be found within S1 Data. ANXA4, Annexin A4; OPN, Osteopontin.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pbio.3000326.g010

We next compared the electrophysiological properties of Lgr5-traced HC^R which demonstrated comparable gDR and gH and voltage-dependent properties relative to control, untraced hair cells in damaged and undamaged P30 utricles (n = 4–12 cells) (Fig 11A–11L, S1 Data). Remarkably, gKL, a marker for type I hair cells, were prominent in 4 of 14 patched, Lgr5-traced HC^R (as compared to 6 of 12 untraced hair cells from damaged utricles and 7 of 10 untraced hair cells from undamaged utricles) (Fig 11M–11R, S1 Data). Among these 4 Lgr5-traced HC^R with prominent gKL, three demonstrated large conductances (>20 nS) typically detected in mature type I hair cells [47,16].

Download:

• PPT
  PowerPoint slide
• PNG
  larger image
• TIFF
  original image

Fig 11. Lgr5-traced, regenerated hair cells display electrophysiological features of type II and type I hair cells.

Three groups of hair cells were examined: 1) traced (black, HC^R) and 2) untraced (red) hair cells from P30 Pou4f3^DTR/+; Lgr5^CreERT2/+; Rosa26R^tdTomato/+ mice treated with DT at P1 and tamoxifen at P3; and untraced (blue) hair cells from Lgr5^CreERT2/+; Rosa26R^tdTomato/+ mice treated with tamoxifen at P3. A-C) Representative tracings of IDR from hair cells from each group (HC^R, untraced hair cells from damage and controls, n = 4–10 cells). D-F) All three groups demonstrate similar peak conductances, half-activation and slopes. G-I) Tracings of IH measurements from HC^R, and untraced hair cells from damaged and undamaged organs (n = 5–12 cells). J-L) All three groups demonstrate similar electrophysiological properties: peak conductances, half-activation and slopes. M-O) IKL responses from HC^R, and untraced hair cells from damaged and undamaged organs (n = 10–14 cells). P-R) Conductance, half-activation and slopes were no different among the three groups. Data shown as mean ± SD, compared using one-way ANOVA by Kruskal Wallis-Dunn's multiple comparison tests. Green dashed lines define zero current levels. The underlying data can be found within S1 Data.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pbio.3000326.g011

Calcium currents and capacitance were measured in Lgr5-traced HC^R to assess for presynaptic activity (S6F–S6H Fig). In comparison to untraced hair cells in damaged and undamaged organs, calcium currents in HC^R were of comparable size and voltage-dependence, suggesting that these cells were presynaptically active and consistent with a hair cell phenotype (n = 5–8 cells) (S6I and S6J Fig, S1 Data). Capacitance changes were found in ~50% of HC^R, with no differences in maximal release properties among groups (n = 4–7 cells) (S6K–S6O Fig, S1 Data), implying the presence of vesicle release in a subset of Lgr5-derived, regenerated hair cells. Together, these results indicate that Lgr5⁺ supporting cells can regenerate hair cells with either a type I or II hair cell phenotype as defined by molecular and electrophysiological features.

Discrepancy between bundle and somatic features in postnatally generated and regenerated hair cells

In the developing utricle, hair cells are first specified between E11.5–12.5 with a second wave appearing at approximately E15, with hair cell addition presumably mainly in the peripheral regions of the sensory epithelia [49,11,50]. Hair cell bundles first emerge at E13.5 and remain relatively uniform in height throughout the central region at E15, when hair cells gain mechanosensitivity [49,13,14,51]. Géléoc and colleagues reported that a delayed rectifier potassium conductance (gDR) and a fast inward rectifier potassium conductance (gK1) begin to appear around E14-E15 and continue to be present into the postnatal period [14]. The transient expression of sodium conductances (gNA) in immature hair cell has also been described [14,36]. In addition, cell size based on capacitance measurements and resting membrane potentials change as hair cells mature from the embryonic to postnatal periods [14].

Transmission electron microscopy shows that afferent neurites appear as early as E13, and bouton synaptic contacts between hair cells and afferent nerve fibers form at E15 [52]. However, calyceal afferent endings, which are uniquely coupled to type I hair cells, only begin to take shape several days before birth and continue developing and maturing during the first postnatal month [16,53]. Moreover, embryonic hair cells acquire synaptic elements and display calcium-dependent exocytotic activities, which have been reported to mature postnatally although the time course is largely unclear [54,55].

Lastly, the type I hair cell-specific delayed rectifier potassium conductance (gKL) [56–58,16] is first detected at E18, shortly before birth. The delayed, inward rectifier H-type conductance (gH) is also detected in embryonic hair cells and both types of hair cells in the postnatal period [16]. In the mature utricle, the inward rectifier potassium conductances (gKIR) are expressed in type II hair cells [14].

The maturation process of hair cells derived from the prenatal period is orderly with the maturation of bundle and somatic properties seemingly coupled (Fig 12A). Our current and previous data [9] indicate that hair cells generated in vivo in the postnatal utricle have dramatically underdeveloped hair bundles and MET channel function, though seemingly mature for defined properties in the somatic compartment (presence of gDR, gKIR, gH, gKL, lack of gNA, large cell size, negative resting membrane potentials) (Fig 12B–12D). These somatic properties suggest that postnatally re/generated hair cells are comparable to those present in the postnatal utricle, although the underdeveloped stereociliary bundles and MET function imply components of the hair bundle lagged behind in maturation. This interpretation is further supported by the findings that postnatally re/generated hair cells have comparable somatic properties to untraced hair cells (presumably older and derived from the embryonic period). It is therefore possible that overlapping but distinct mechanisms direct the maturation of hair cell apical and somatic domains. In support of this notion, Oshima and colleagues reported that vestibular hair cell-like cells differentiated in vitro from mouse embryonic stem (ES) and iPS cells acquired mechanosensitivity and stereocilia with certain mature features (e.g. staircase pattern), but relatively immature basolateral ion channel properties [20]. Moreover, ectopic cochlear hair cells formed as a result of in utero gene transfer of Atoh1 to the developing inner ear were crowned with relatively immature stereociliary bundles while displaying age-appropriate conductances and synaptic components on their basolateral surfaces [48]. At present, there is a paucity of knowledge on mechanisms regulating the maturation of individual components of postnatal vestibular hair cells.

Download:

• PPT
  PowerPoint slide
• PNG
  larger image
• TIFF
  original image

Fig 12. Maturation pathways of developing and regenerating hair cells.

A) Vestibular hair cells specified early during embryonic period acquire stereocilia, differentiate into subtypes of hair cells, and subsequent innervation. Postnatally generated/regenerated hair cells develop somatic features including differentiation into hair cell subtypes and innervation but were delayed in apical bundle development. B) In the undamaged utricle, majority of Plp1⁺ supporting cells generate type II hair cells, with type I hair cells are only occasionally added. C) In the damaged utricle, majority of Plp1⁺ supporting cells regenerate type II hair cells, type I hair cells are occasionally regenerated. D) By contrast, in the damaged utricle, Lgr5⁺ supporting cells regenerate a similar ratio of type II and type I hair cells. A subset of type I HC^R was innervated with Tuj1⁺ calyx (24.4%).

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pbio.3000326.g012

Classification of vestibular hair cells subtypes

Vestibular hair cell subtypes are traditionally characterized according to morphology, molecular markers, electrophysiological properties, and innervation patterns [59,26,16,29]. Recent studies have further characterized the unique basolateral processes of type II hair cells [60,26]. Using markers of type I and II hair cells identified via single cell RNA sequencing [23], we found type I and II hair cells with various morphologies: around 69–79% of the Annexin A4⁺ type II hair cells displayed typical basolateral process, while others were devoid of this feature (S2F Fig). Conversely, type I hair cells showed more uniform morphologies, with the majority (75–100%) being amphora-shaped with long apical necks (Fig 12B). We found occasional Osteopontin⁺ type I hair cells with shorter cell bodies and necks, with nuclei located in the upper third of the epithelium closer to the type II hair cell nuclei level (S2G Fig). Interestingly, we also observed occasional type II hair cells with thick apical necks with nuclei located in the middle third of the epithelium as seen in type I hair cells (S2F Fig). While one may perceive similarities in morphology between some type I and II hair cells, whether their lineages are related remains unclear. Such a relationship between type I and type II hair cells has been previously proposed [61]. In the undamaged tissues, one likely explanation for the various morphologies is that the P30 utricle, though functionally mature, contains a heterogeneous population of hair cells at various developmental stages. Similarly, in the neonatal utricle where new hair cells continue to be generated, hair cells with various morphologies were observed [16]. Cell shapes were further modified as a result of damage, where a noticeable flattening of the sensory epithelium leads to shortening/rounding of both type I and II hair cells (Fig 12C).

Despite the heterogeneous morphologies of Annexin A4⁺ type II hair cells, they displayed remarkably similar channel (gDR and gH) and presynaptic properties, suggesting acquisition of these features may occur before cell morphology becomes more uniform. On the other hand, none of the Osteopontin⁺ type I hair cells derived from Plp1⁺ supporting cells displayed gKL or calyx-type nerve terminals, and only a subset of those from Lgr5⁺ supporting cells showed gKL (28.6%) or calyx nerve terminals (24.4%). Using embryonic and neonatal hair cell development as a reference [14,16], we hypothesize that type I hair cells first express Osteopontin and become amphora-shaped before acquiring gKL, with calyx formation being one of the last maturation steps. In other words, Plp1-traced Osteopontin⁺ type I hair cells, unlike the Lgr5-traced Osteopontin⁺ type I hair cells, failed to display gKL or calyx nerve terminals, and as such are likely to be more immature. Whether these immature type I hair cells further mature over time should be of interest for future studies.

As a cardinal feature of mature hair cells, stereociliary bundles elongate as hair cells mature and gain mechanosensitivity [13,41]. Hair cell subtypes also display different bundle morphologies, with type I hair cells having thicker and longer stereociliary bundles than type II hair cells [62]. Traditionally, bundle length and morphology have been employed as criteria for hair cell identity and maturation. Since results from the current and other studies suggest that hair bundles of postnatally produced hair cells might develop at a different pace compared to other hair cell properties, we propose that bundle features should not be the sole measure of hair cell maturity.

Supporting cells with distinct competence to regenerate hair cells

In the adult mouse utricle, the ratios of type I and type II hair cells are estimated to be 1.47 and 1.19 in the striola and extrastriola, respectively [46]. While both hair cell types are presumably important for organ function, only regeneration of type II hair cells has been reported in the mature utricle [3–6]. However, our previous and current study suggest that the striolar region in the neonatal utricle uniquely harbors hair cell progenitors capable of regenerating bona fide type I hair cells. The overwhelming majority of Plp1-traced supporting cells occupied the extrastriolar region with few striolar supporting cells also traced, but ~90% traced hair cells displayed type II characteristics and the ~10% Osteopontin⁺ type I hair cells failed to display gKL or calyx innervation. By contrast, Lgr5 becomes highly expressed in striolar supporting cells after damage [9], giving rise to type I hair cells fulfilling morphologic, molecular, electrophysiological, and innervation criteria. Therefore Lgr5⁺ striolar supporting cells may represent a specialized supporting cell population capable of regenerating both type I and II hair cells via mitotic regeneration [9]. In support of the concept that distinct populations of hair cell precursors/progenitors exist, striolar supporting cells are more competent to divide and form ectopic hair cells upon inhibition of Notch signaling [63,42,64].

Time course of functional recovery and hair cell maturation

Hair cell regeneration is robust in avian auditory and vestibular organs, leading to near-normal densities of hair cells and functional recovery [1]. In the mammalian utricle where regeneration is limited, previous studies examining whether a recovery of function occurs have yielded mixed results [65,66]. In the current study, after hair cell ablation in the neonatal utricle, only 8% of hair cells remained at P15 and 94% of mice lost VsEP responses. At P30 and P60, 36% and 59% of these mice partially regained VsEP thresholds, which coincided and correlated with increases in hair cell numbers (R² = 0.62, Fig 5, S4 Fig). As most of the regenerated hair cells we characterized displayed immature apical stereociliary bundles and poor GTTR uptake, they are unlikely to be fully functional or to significantly contribute to the observed functional recovery. Since many hair cells derived from the Plp1-traced and Lgr5-traced supporting cells appear nonfunctional, it is possible that other supporting cells/progenitor cells contribute to functional hair cells that are produced in the postnatal utricle.

Overall, we estimate that postnatally generated hair cells with immature stereociliary bundles constitute ~13% of the hair cell population. It is possible that these hair cells act as a reserve population that replenishes lost hair cells in response to damage. Alternatively, they may function to replace hair cells lost during the homeostatic turnover of hair cells in the adult utricle [60]. Moreover, surviving hair cells and a change in the innervating patterns may permit the activation of neurons from fewer stimulated hair cells, which in turn contribute to functional recovery. The Pou4f3-DTR mouse is an ideal model to further investigate these possibilities.

In summary, both hair cells generated in the postnatal utricle and hair cells regenerated after damage demonstrated features of mature somatic properties yet immature apical stereociliary bundles and MET function. Based on these results, we propose a new classification of postnatal vestibular hair cells independent of apical bundle morphology, which warrants further characterization in the normal and damaged postnatal utricle. Moreover, our data may guide future efforts in inner ear regeneration, including delineating the relationship between hair cell regeneration and vestibular function.

Ethics statement

All protocols (#18606) were approved by the Animal Care and Use Committee of the Stanford University School of Medicine.

Mice

Plp1-CreERT (Jackson Laboratory, #5975)[67], Lgr5-EGFP-CreERT2 (Jackson Laboratory, #8875)[68], Rosa26R-tdTomato (Jackson Laboratory, #7908)[69], and Pou4f3-DTR [44] mice were used. For Cre activation, tamoxifen (0.075 mg/g, dissolved in corn oil; Sigma) was given via IP injection to neonatal mice. Diphtheria toxin (4 ng/g intramuscular [IM], EMD Millipore) was used for hair cell ablation.

Immunohistochemistry

Utricles were fixed for 40 minutes in 4% paraformaldehyde (in PBS, pH 7.4; Electron Microscopy Services) at room temperature. Tissues were blocked with 5% donkey serum, 0.1% TritonX-100, 1% bovine serum albumin (BSA), and 0.02% sodium azide (NaN₃) in PBS at pH 7.4 for 1–2 hours at room temperature, followed by incubation with primary antibodies diluted in the same blocking solution overnight at 4°C. The next day, after washing with PBS, tissues were incubated with secondary antibodies diluted in 0.1% TritonX-100, 0.1% BSA, and 0.02% NaN₃ solution in PBS for 2 hours at room temperature. After PBS washing, tissues were mounted in antifade Fluorescence Mounting Medium (DAKO) and coverslipped. Antibodies against the following markers were used: Myosin7a (1:1000; Proteus Bioscience or Labome), Sox2 (1:400, Santa Cruz Biotechnology), Sox2 (1:250; or Alexa Fluor 488-conjugated, 1:20; R&D), Tuj1 (1:1000; Neuromics), Ctbp2 (1:1000; BD Transduction Laboratories), Annexin A4 (1:200; R&D), Osteopontin (1:200; R&D) and Mapt (1:200, Cell Signaling). Secondary antibodies were conjugated with FITC (1:500, Invitrogen), TRITC (1:500, Invitrogen), CY5 (1:250, Invitrogen) or Alexa 405 (1:250, Abcam). Fluorescence-conjugated phalloidin (1:1000; Sigma) and DAPI (1:10000; Invitrogen) were also used. Utricles were incubated with Texas Red-conjugated gentamicin (GTTR) for 1 hour with 1:100 of stock solution (0.85 mg/mL) [70,71]. Images were acquired using epifluorescent or confocal microscopy (LSM700 or LSM880, Zeiss) and analyzed with ImageJ (64 bit), Fiji (NIH) [72], and Photoshop CS6 (Adobe Systems). Optical slices 1 μm thick were used in z-stack images.

Cellular quantification and statistics

Cells were quantified from z-stack images of 10,000 μm² or the whole sensory epithelium using ImageJ (64 bit) unless otherwise stated. Images were taken from 1–2 representative areas from striolar and extrastriolar regions or the whole sensory epithelium for analysis. For all experiments, n values represent the number of cells or mice examined unless otherwise stated. Statistical analyses were conducted using Microsoft Excel (Microsoft), GraphPad Prism 7.0 software (GraphPad), Origin (Microcal) and scripts written in MATLAB when necessary. Two-tailed, unpaired Student t tests and one-way ANOVA by Tukey’s and Kruskal Wallis-Dunn's multiple comparison tests were used to determine statistical significance. p < 0.05 was considered statistically significant. Data shown as mean ± SD.

Genotyping

PCR was performed to genotype transgenic mice using genomic DNA. DNA was isolated by adding 200 μl of 50 mM NaOH to cut tail tips, incubating at 98°C for 1 hour, and then adding 20 μl of 1 M Tris-HCl. Primers used are listed in S1 Table.

Vestibular physiology

VsEPs were recorded from mice at various ages (P15, P30 and P60) as previously described [45]. Briefly, mice were first anesthetized with a 1:1 cocktail of ketamine (60 to 100 mg/kg) and xylazine (6 to 10 mg/kg). Subcutaneous stainless steel electrodes were then placed, and a head clip was used to secure the head to the mechanical shaker used to deliver linear motion stimuli along the naso-occipital axis. Vertical motion of the shaker was monitored with an accelerometer (model no. 1018, Vibra-Metrics) and adjusted to produce the stimulus waveforms. Jerk stimuli ranging from 0.1 to 2.0 g/ms were presented (g/ms where 1 g = 9.8 m/s²) [45]. Signals were amplified and filtered. Responses from normal and inverted stimulus polarities were collected and added together for a total of 256 sweeps for each waveform. A masker (90 dB SPL; bandwidth 50 Hz to 50 kHz) from a free-field speaker driver (model no. FF1, Tucker Davis Technologies) was used to prevent responses from the auditory components of cranial nerve VIII. All primary response parameters were blindly quantified via three components: threshold (g/ms), P1 latency (ms) and P1-N1 amplitude (μV). Thresholds were defined as the stimulus intensity halfway between the minimum response intensity and the maximum intensity that failed to elicit a response. Latencies were measured as the time to onset of the stimulus for the first positive response peak (P1). Amplitudes represented peak-to-peak magnitudes between P1 and N1 waveforms. Whereas the first positive and negative response peaks (P1 and N1, respectively) reflect activity of the peripheral vestibular nerve, peaks beyond N1 reflect activity of the brainstem and central vestibular relays [45].

Electrophysiology

Utricular tissues were dissected from mice at ages denoted and secured in a recording chamber where epifluorescence, cell morphology and location could be observed for identification and classification. An Olympus, BX50 microscope with a 100x (1.0 NA) objective was used for all observations. Tissues were isolated and incubated for recording in a solution containing 140 mM NaCl, 5.4 mM KCl, 2.8 mM CaCl₂, 1 mM MgCl₂, 10 mM 4-(2-hydroxyethyl)-1-piperazineethanesulfonic acid (HEPES), 6 mM D-glucose, 2 mM creatine, 2 mM ascorbate, 2 mM Na pyruvate, pH 7.4 adjusted with NaOH. 100 nM apamin was included to block the SK K⁺ channel. The patch pipette contained 135 mM KCl, 1 mM ethylene glycol-bis (B-aminoethyl ether)-N,N,N’,N’-tetraacetic acid (EGTA), 3 mM MgCl₂, 3 mM Na₂ Adenosine triphosphate (ATP), 5 mM creatine phosphate, 10 mM HEPES, and 5 mM ascorbate. For isolation of the calcium current and for capacitance measurements, KCl was replaced with 90 mM CsCl and 15 mM tetraethylammonium (TEA). Additionally, 3 mM CsCl was added to the external solution to block inward rectifier currents.

Whole-cell patch-clamp recordings were elicited using standard technology including axopatch 200b amplifier, an A/D, D/A board (IOTech) driven by JClamp software (SciSoft). The various conductances were grossly separated using specific voltage protocols as outlined below.

For characterizing the delayed rectifier currents IDR, cells were voltage clamped at -69 mV and stepped in 10 mV increments for 400 ms between -94 mV and 24 mV. Activation curves were generated from the tail current responses using peak current at 3 ms following the end of the step. To convert from current to conductance we assayed reversal potential using a protocol that held the cell at -89 mV for 10 ms, stepped to 14mV for 250 ms and then stepped between -116 mV and 14 mV in 5 mV increments for 50 ms after which it returned to -89 mV. A plot of peak current against voltage during the 5 mV incremental steps allows for estimation of the reversal potential. From this protocol, the reverse potential is estimated at -73 mV.

We used IKL to define type I hair cells. The absence of IKL and the presence of IH were used to define non-type I, and thus a type II, hair cell phenotype. We did not assess IH in the presence of IKL.

Characterization of IKL involved voltage-clamping cells at -89 mV, stepping to -124 mV for 250 ms and then stepping between -124 mV and -45 mV in 5 mV increments for 150 ms. A trace showing the classical deactivation of the IKL is shown in S7F Fig. Plots of peak current versus voltage step were generated and converted to conductance plots after the reversal potential was identified from a protocol where a cell was voltage-clamped at -89 mV depolarized to -69 mV for 250 ms and then stepped between -124 and -41 mV in 5 mV for 150 ms, returning then to -89 mV. From this protocol, the reverse potential is estimated at -73 mV.

For characterizing the inward rectifier current IH, cells were voltage clamped at -69 mV, hyperpolarized between -74 and -156 mV for 400 ms, and then back to -69 mV. Current-voltage plots were generated for maximal current elicited during hyperpolarization. These were converted to conductance plots by obtaining reversal potentials using a protocol that voltage-clamped a cell at -104 mV for 500 ms and then stepped between -120 and -55 mV for 5 ms, at which time it returned to -84 mV. Current-voltage plots identified the reversal potential that allowed for conductance estimates as shown in the text. From this protocol, the reverse potential is estimated at -62 mV.

From conductance-voltage plots of IDR, we found values for maximal conductance, half-activation voltage and slope of the Boltzmann function using methods detailed in S7 Fig. Similar methods were used for IH and IKL.

Calcium currents were isolated by replacing potassium with a cesium-based intracellular solution using a protocol that voltage-clamped the hair cell at -69 mV and stepped for 10 ms between -69 mV and 26 mV in 10 mV increments. Current-voltage plots were generated from peak current responses and maximal current and half activating voltage were extracted from these plots.

To assess functional activity of presynaptic sites, vesicle fusion was monitored using a dual sine wave technique as previously described [39,40]. Hair cells were depolarized to the voltage of maximal calcium current for 3 seconds, and changes in capacitance were monitored in real time. The sine wave amplitude was 30 mV and the frequencies selected were 6250 and 3125 Hz. Protocols were run after 10 minutes to ensure equilibration of internal solution and stabilization of calcium currents.