28 May 2020: Hinnebusch BJ, Bland DM, Bosio CF, Jarrett CO (2020) Correction: Comparative Ability of Oropsylla montana and Xenopsylla cheopis Fleas to Transmit Yersinia pestis by Two Different Mechanisms. PLOS Neglected Tropical Diseases 14(5): e0008344. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pntd.0008344 View correction
Transmission of Yersinia pestis by flea bite can occur by two mechanisms. After taking a blood meal from a bacteremic mammal, fleas have the potential to transmit the very next time they feed. This early-phase transmission resembles mechanical transmission in some respects, but the mechanism is unknown. Thereafter, transmission occurs after Yersinia pestis forms a biofilm in the proventricular valve in the flea foregut. The biofilm can impede and sometimes completely block the ingestion of blood, resulting in regurgitative transmission of bacteria into the bite site. In this study, we compared the relative efficiency of the two modes of transmission for Xenopsylla cheopis, a flea known to become completely blocked at a high rate, and Oropsylla montana, a flea that has been considered to rarely develop proventricular blockage.
Fleas that took an infectious blood meal containing Y. pestis were maintained and monitored for four weeks for infection and proventricular blockage. The number of Y. pestis transmitted by groups of fleas by the two modes of transmission was also determined. O. montana readily developed complete proventricular blockage, and large numbers of Y. pestis were transmitted by that mechanism both by it and by X. cheopis, a flea known to block at a high rate. In contrast, few bacteria were transmitted in the early phase by either species.
A model system incorporating standardized experimental conditions and viability controls was developed to more reliably compare the infection, proventricular blockage and transmission dynamics of different flea vectors, and was used to resolve a long-standing uncertainty concerning the vector competence of O. montana. Both X. cheopis and O. montana are fully capable of transmitting Y. pestis by the proventricular biofilm-dependent mechanism.
The ecology of plague is complex and its epidemiology is enigmatic. Many different flea species are able to transmit Yersinia pestis, the plague bacillus, and they can transmit in two different ways. Early-phase transmission can occur during the first week after a flea has fed on a diseased animal. Thereafter, transmission occurs only as bacterial growth in the flea foregut interferes with and eventually blocks blood feeding. Comparisons of the relative ability of different flea vectors to transmit have been problematic, and contradictory results have been reported for the ability of the ground squirrel flea Oropsylla montana to transmit beyond the early phase. Our results show that O. montana readily develops foregut blockage, and transmission by that mechanism was as good as or better than observed for Xenopsylla cheopis, a flea known to block at a high rate. In contrast, very few bacteria were transmitted in the early phase by either of these fleas compared to later times after infection, suggesting that early-phase transmission is pertinent only to highly susceptible animals. Improved characterization of the transmission patterns of different flea vectors will aid in modeling plague incidence in its various natural settings.
Citation: Hinnebusch BJ, Bland DM, Bosio CF, Jarrett CO (2017) Comparative Ability of Oropsylla montana and Xenopsylla cheopis Fleas to Transmit Yersinia pestis by Two Different Mechanisms. PLoS Negl Trop Dis 11(1): e0005276. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pntd.0005276
Editor: Christian Johnson, Fondation Raoul Follereau, FRANCE
Received: June 22, 2016; Accepted: December 21, 2016; Published: January 12, 2017
This is an open access article, free of all copyright, and may be freely reproduced, distributed, transmitted, modified, built upon, or otherwise used by anyone for any lawful purpose. The work is made available under the Creative Commons CC0 public domain dedication.
Data Availability: All relevant data are within the paper.
Funding: This work was supported by the Intramural Research Program of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, National Institutes of Health. http://www.niaid.nih.gov/about/organization/dir/Pages/default.aspx. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Once fleas had been implicated as important vectors of the plague bacillus, Yersinia pestis, attention quickly turned to the mechanism and dynamics of flea-borne transmission. The first experiments, conducted between 1904–1907 by members of the Indian Plague Research Commission and others, characterized what is now termed early-phase transmission [1–4]. When fleas that had just fed on a rodent with terminal plague bacteremia were collected and used to challenge naïve rodents, they remained infective for about a week, with the transmission rate peaking about three days after the infectious blood meal and then waning. Transmission very rarely occurred from challenge with a single flea, but challenges with 10 to 25 fleas resulted in a transmission rate of 20 to 70%. Because simultaneous challenge with multiple fleas was required, early-phase transmission has also been referred to as mass transmission. Although long assumed to be a form of mechanical transmission, recent studies suggest that it is not that simple ; however, the mechanism of this early-phase transmission has yet to be determined.
In 1914 a second mode of transmission was discovered [6, 7]. This later phase of transmissibility occurs after Y. pestis forms a dense biofilm in the proventriculus, a valve in the flea foregut . As the biofilm grows and consolidates it interferes with the valvular function of the proventriculus. Because the infected valve is unable to close completely, blood flowing into the midgut can flow back out again, carrying bacteria along with it, and be regurgitated into the bite site. The proventriculus can eventually become completely blocked in some fleas, preventing any blood from reaching the midgut. Inflowing blood is stopped by the bacterial mass that fills the proventriculus, and transmission occurs when blood mixed with bacteria from the surface of the biofilm is refluxed back into the bite site. As they begin to starve, such completely blocked fleas make continuous, persistent attempts to feed, thereby increasing the probability of transmission. Each feeding attempt by a single blocked X. cheopis flea has a 25 to 50% transmission success rate [9–13].
The ecology of plague is complex, involving many different rodent-flea transmission cycles. The relative competence of several flea vectors has been examined to varying degrees (reviewed in ). In general, these studies indicate that different flea species vary in their potential to become infected and subsequently transmit Y. pestis. The comparative early-phase transmission efficiency of different flea vector species has been systematically evaluated in several recent studies [14–17]. However, comparisons of the ability to transmit after the early phase are problematic because a variety of experimental methods have been used. This has led to variable and sometimes contradictory results. For example, some studies indicate that the North American ground squirrel flea Oropsylla montana transmits very poorly by the proventricular biofilm-dependent mechanism [9, 10, 18, 19], whereas other studies show it to transmit as efficiently as Xenopsylla cheopis, the flea often cited as the most efficient transmitter by that mechanism [12, 20].
A second unresolved issue is the relative ecologic importance of the two transmission mechanisms. Transmission efficiency studies to date have concentrated on either the early-phase or the proventricular biofilm mechanism, making direct comparisons of their relative efficiency problematic, again due to the variety of experimental conditions used.
To begin to address these shortcomings, we developed a standardized, carefully controlled experimental model system to infect cohorts of fleas and to characterize infection, proventricular blockage, and transmission dynamics during a four-week period following a single infectious blood meal. Comparative results for O. montana and X. cheopis establish that both develop proventricular blockage and transmit efficiently via the biofilm-dependent mechanism. For both species, transmission efficiency in the early phase was lower than at later times after infection.
Y. pestis KIM6+ was inoculated from frozen stocks maintained at the Rocky Mountain Laboratories (RML) into 5 ml of brain-heart infusion (BHI) broth supplemented with 10 μg/ml hemin and incubated at 28°C. After overnight incubation, 1 ml of this culture was used to inoculate 100 ml of BHI that was incubated at 37°C for 18 to 19 hours without aeration. The KIM6+ strain lacks the Yersinia virulence plasmid and is attenuated in mammalian virulence but infects fleas normally . O. montana were from a laboratory colony originally established at the CDC, Fort Collins and maintained at RML since 2011. X. cheopis colonies were derived from fleas collected in Los Angeles, CA or Baltimore, MD and have been maintained at RML for ~ 10 to 25 years, respectively. Fleas were pulled randomly from colonies and starved for four days. Groups of about 300 fleas were allowed to feed through a mouse skin affixed to an artificial feeding device  containing 5 ml of heparinized mouse blood (collected from RML Swiss Webster mice on site) containing ~1 x 109/ml Y. pestis KIM6+, or with KIM6+ that had been transformed with pAcGFP1 (Clontech; Mountain View, CA), a plasmid containing a constitutively expressed green fluorescent protein (GFP) gene. After the 1-hour feeding period, fleas were collected and immobilized by placing the tube containing them on ice. Fleas were then arrayed on a chill table (BioQuip; Rancho Dominguez, CA) under a dissecting microscope, and only those that had taken an infectious blood meal, evidenced by the presence of fresh red blood in the midgut, were kept and used for experiments. A sample of 20 female fleas was placed at -80°C for later determination of the initial infectious dose.
Flea blockage, mortality, and infection rates
In conjunction with experiments to assess proventricular blockage, a second group of fleas from the same cohort used for infection was allowed to feed the same day on sterile mouse blood to serve as uninfected controls. After feeding, ~100 infected and control fleas (equal numbers of males and females) were put into separate flea capsules  that were kept at 21°C and 75% relative humidity. These fleas were allowed to feed on neonatal mice for 1 hour on days 2, 6, 9, 13, 16, 20, 23, and 27 after infection. An additional sample of 20 infected female fleas was maintained identically but collected and placed at -80°C on day 7 after infection. A shallow layer of sterile sawdust was added to the bottom of capsules containing O. montana. Following each maintenance feed, infected fleas were collected and examined microscopically for evidence of proventricular blockage, diagnosed by the presence of fresh red blood in the esophagus only, with none in the midgut. Blocked fleas were segregated into a separate capsule after diagnosis for separate maintenance. Mortality was also recorded on each maintenance feed day. A sample of 20 surviving female fleas was placed at -80°C when the experiment was terminated on day 28. Three independent blockage experiments were conducted for both O. montana and X. cheopis. After being diagnosed as blocked, O. montana fleas infected with the GFP+ strain were dissected and examined by fluorescence microscopy to verify proventricular blockage.
Determining Y. pestis CFU in infectious blood meal and infected flea samples
Dilutions of the infectious blood meal were plated on blood agar to determine the Y. pestis CFU/ml. Samples of fleas that had been collected at different times after infection and stored at -80°C were thawed, surface sterilized, individually triturated, and then dilutions were plated in BHI soft agar overlays . All plates were incubated at 28° C for 48 hours prior to colony counts.
Monitoring transmission dynamics
For transmission experiments, fleas that took an infectious blood meal were housed as described above. On days 3, 10, 17, 24, and 31, ~200 fleas (approximately equal numbers of males and females) were allowed to feed on sterile defibrinated rat blood (BioreclamationIVT, New York) in the artificial feeding system. After 90 min, fleas were collected and examined microscopically as described above to determine how many had fed, and of those, how many were completely or partially blocked. A sample of 20 unblocked female fleas that had fed were placed at -80°C. Day 3 was the first feeding opportunity after the infectious blood meal and represents early-phase transmission. In addition to the transmission test artificial feedings, fleas were also fed on neonatal mice on days 6, 13, 20, and 27.
Immediately after each transmission test feeding, blood was removed and the interior of the feeder was washed ten times with 3 ml PBS. The entire volume of blood was distributively plated on blood agar plates. Pooled washes were centrifuged 9,800 ×g for 30 min, most of the supernatant removed and the remainder was mixed thoroughly to resuspend any bacteria and spread onto blood agar plates. During the period of peak transmission by O. montana (10 to 24 days after infection) dilutions of the blood and wash samples, instead of the entire sample, were plated. The external (haired) surface of the mouse skin membrane was disinfected with ethanol, cut into small pieces that were added to 1 ml PBS in a lysing matrix H tube and subjected to 2 min treatment in a FastPrep homogenizer (MP Biomedicals, Santa Ana, CA) to dislodge any transmitted bacteria associated with the interior surface of the mouse skin. Skin sample supernatants were pooled and centrifuged at 20,000 ×g for 15 min. Most of the supernatant was discarded and the remainder was vigorously mixed to resuspend any bacteria and then plated on blood agar. Three independent transmission experiments were conducted with both O. montana and X. cheopis.
Flea proventriculus and esophagus measurements
Fleas were placed in PBS on a glass microscope slide and dissected with a set of fine forceps. The flea exoskeleton was removed and an 18 x 18 mm glass cover slip was gently placed over the top of the digestive tract. Images of flea digestive tracts were obtained using a Nikon Eclipse E800 microscope with an Olympus DP72 camera and cellSens imaging software. To calculate an esophagus:proventriculus (E/PV) width ratio, the width of the base of the esophagus was measured above the proventricular spines, where the musculature ends, and the proventriculus was measured at its widest position, near the midpoint of the valve.
All analyses were performed using GraphPad Prism 6 (GraphPad Software Inc., La Jolla, Ca.). Statistical tests used and relevant P values are indicated in the figure legends.
All experiments involving animals were approved by the Rocky Mountain Laboratories, National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, National Institutes of Health Animal Care and Use Committee (protocols 13–036 and 14–006) and were conducted in accordance with all National Institutes of Health guidelines.
Comparative infection and blockage rates of O. montana and X. cheopis
Groups of fleas were infected by allowing them to feed on highly bacteremic blood in an artificial feeding device, and thereafter provided twice-weekly maintenance feeds on uninfected mice for four weeks. Immediately after each maintenance feed, fleas were examined individually for the development of proventricular blockage, indicated by the presence of fresh red blood in the esophagus but not in the midgut.
Contrary to some previous reports, we found that O. montana readily became blocked, but at a lower incidence than X. cheopis (mean blockage rates 22% and 36%, respectively; Fig 1A and Fig 2). However, O. montana tended to become blocked sooner (mean = 9.6 days after infection) than X. cheopis (mean = 14.7 days) and to survive longer after becoming blocked (Fig 3). Blocked O. montana fleas survived up to 2 weeks after being diagnosed (range = 1 to 16 days; mean = 7 days; median = 4 days), whereas blocked X. cheopis survived a maximum of 4 days (range = 1 to 4 days; mean = 2 days; median = 1 day). The mortality rate of uninfected control fleas at 28 days was 6 to 7% for both species (Fig 1B). Since blocked fleas die from starvation, the excess mortality of infected fleas is a surrogate indicator of blockage. The majority of the mortality of infected X. cheopis (60%) and O. montana (28%) was in fact due to the death of blocked fleas, and reflects the difference in blockage rate between the two species.
(A) Percentage of fleas that developed complete proventricular blockage. The mean and SD are indicated. (B) Mortality rate of uninfected (open symbols) and infected (closed symbols) O. montana (red symbols) and X. cheopis (blue symbols). (C) Percentage of O. montana (red symbols) and X. cheopis (blue symbols) still infected 7 and 28 days after an infectious blood meal. (D) Mean bacterial load in infected O. montana (blue symbols) and X. cheopis (red symbols) immediately after the infectious blood meal (day 0) and at 7 and 28 days after infection. The cumulative results of three independent experiments (n = 99 to 113 fleas each) are shown in (A, B); the results of each of the three experiments are plotted in (C, D). *P = 0.0003; **P < 0.0001 by Fisher’s exact test (two-tailed).
The left panels show the typical blockage phenotype in O. montana fleas immediately after a feeding attempt. Fresh red blood (arrows) that was unable to enter the midgut (MG) is seen in the esophagus (E). The fleas were infected with GFP-expressing Y. pestis. The middle and right panels are images of the dissected digestive tracts from the same fleas visualized by DIC and a combination of DIC + fluorescence microscopy, respectively, and confirm the presence of a dense Y. pestis biofilm that completely fills and blocks the proventriculus (PV). Scale bars = 100 μm.
Histograms of the temporal incidence of complete blockage in O. montana and X. cheopis (A, B) and their life span after becoming blocked (C). Dashed lines indicate the mean; curve fitting used a Gaussian model of the frequency distribution data. Blocked O. montana survived significantly longer than blocked X. cheopis; P < 0.0001 by log-rank (Mantel-Cox) test.
The average number of Y. pestis that the fleas acquired in the infectious blood meal was 1.3 to 6.4 x 105 for all experiments (Fig 1D). By 7 days after infection, a significantly greater percentage of O. montana than X. cheopis had eliminated the infection (Fig 1C). However, the average bacterial load in the infected fleas was equivalent for both species at all time points (Fig 1D).
In other experiments, groups of infected fleas were allowed to feed from a sterile blood reservoir at different times after infection. After feeding, fleas were collected and examined for evidence of feeding and proventricular blockage, and the number of Y. pestis that the fleas had transmitted was determined. The transmission test at 3 days after infection was the first feeding opportunity after the infectious blood meal, when transmission by the early-phase mechanism is maximum [1, 2, 5]. Between each weekly transmission test thereafter, fleas were provided a separate maintenance feed on an uninfected mouse. By the second transmission test on day 10 the fleas had had two uninfected blood meals since infection, and were beyond the early-phase transmission period. Thus, transmission on days 10 to 31 after infection was via the proventricular biofilm-dependent mechanism.
Few Y. pestis were transmitted by the early-phase mechanism, and no transmission was detected in some experiments, even though over 100 fleas fed (Fig 4, Tables 1 and 2). Additional experiments were done to further evaluate early-phase transmission only (3 days after an infectious blood meal). The number of Y. pestis transmitted was below the detection level in 7 of 16 trials and ranged from 1 to 164 CFU in the nine others (Fig 4C). Fleas of both species transmitted many more bacteria after the early phase, peaking 10 to 24 days after infection at ~104 CFU for X. cheopis and >105 CFU for O. montana. Maxima of Y. pestis CFU transmitted (10 to 17 days after infection for O. montana and 17 to 24 days for X. cheopis) correlated with the mean time for proventricular blockage to develop (Fig 3A and 3B). At most time points after infection, the cumulative number of Y. pestis CFU transmitted by O. montana cohorts was 10-fold or more higher than the number transmitted by X. cheopis (Fig 4, Tables 1 and 2).
The number of Y. pestis CFU transmitted by O. montana (A) and X. cheopis (B) fleas by the early-phase (EPT, day 3) and proventricular biofilm-dependent (PBT) mechanisms in three independent experiments. See Tables 1 and 2 for details. (C) Number of Y. pestis CFU transmitted in the early phase (3 days after an infectious blood meal) by O. montana and X. cheopis in 8 independent experiments. Horizontal bars indicate the median. For these 16 EPT experiments, 103 to 202 fleas fed on day 3. The bacteremia level in the infectious blood meals ranged from 1.9 x 108 to 3.0 x109 CFU/ml.
Comparative anatomy of the foregut of O. montana and X. cheopis
While examining the digestive tracts of dissected fleas, we noticed that the base of the esophagus, where it joins the proventriculus, appeared to be wider in O. montana than in X. cheopis. This was especially evident in blocked O. montana, in which the base of the esophagus was often grossly distended (Figs 2 and 5). To evaluate this quantitatively, we measured the esophageal and proventricular widths in uninfected and blocked specimens of the two species and calculated a ratio. The esophagus:proventriculus (E/PV) width ratio was significantly greater for O. montana than X. cheopis (Fig 5E). In blocked fleas of both species, the Y. pestis proventricular biofilm extended into the esophagus. This expanded the relative width of the esophagus in blocked vs. unblocked O. montana to a greater extent than in blocked vs. unblocked X. cheopis. In some blocked O. montana, the esophagus was nearly as wide as the proventriculus (mean E/PV ratio = 0.71; range = 0.60 to 0.84).
(A-D) Representative images of foreguts from dissected uninfected and blocked O. montana and X. cheopis. Dashed red lines indicate the location of esophageal (E) and proventricular (PV) measurements used to calculate the E:PV ratio of uninfected fleas (open symbols; n = 20) and blocked fleas (closed symbols; n = 10 to 15) in (E); the mean and SD are indicated. *P < 0.05; **P < 0.01, ***P < 0.0001 by one-way ANOVA and Tukey’s multiple comparison test. Scale bars = 100 μm.
In 1911, McCoy demonstrated that O. montana was able to transmit Y. pestis during the early phase, and more recent work has indicated that O. montana and X. cheopis are comparable in early-phase transmission efficiency [16, 25–30]. X. cheopis has also consistently been shown to become blocked and transmit after the early phase. However, conflicting results have been reported for the rate at which O. montana becomes blocked after infection and its corresponding ability to transmit by the proventricular biofilm-dependent mechanism. Wheeler and Douglas found that O. montana was an even better vector than X. cheopis during the four-week period after the early phase [12, 20], but other studies of O. montana reported little or no blockage and transmission during this time frame [9, 10, 18, 19]. Based on the negative data, the recent literature now states that O. montana rarely becomes blocked [26, 31]. A first objective of this study was to resolve the contradictory conclusions of the earlier studies by using standardized methods to directly compare the post-infection blockage rates of O. montana and X. cheopis.
We found that obvious, complete blockage of O. montana is not a rare but a regular occurrence (Fig 2). Differences among O. montana strains used for infection experiments has previously been suggested as a potential cause for conflicting results . However, our O. montana colony originated from one used for a study that reported a 0% blockage rate . A more likely reason for discordant results stems from the very high mortality rate associated with the studies that report negative results for O. montana blockage. Two studies that reported a 0 to 3% blockage rate also recorded a 23 to 59% die-off during the first week after the infectious blood meal, 58 to 79% at two weeks, and few fleas surviving after four weeks [10, 19]. In initial experiments, we also noted high mortality, even of uninfected control O. montana, and low and inconsistent blockage rates. Adult fleas maintained in proper conditions should live for a period of months, and we had previously observed that results with unhealthy X. cheopis cohorts (indicated by a 4-week mortality rate of >25% for uninfected control fleas) were unreliable and grossly underestimated the normal blockage rate observed for healthy X. cheopis (mortality rate of uninfected controls <10%). We found that unless O. montana were kept on a layer of sawdust, they became entangled via the long, curved pretarsal claws at the end of their legs, which led to stress-related mortality. The addition of a sawdust substrate to capsules containing O. montana (which is not necessary for X. cheopis) eliminated this problem and reduced uninfected control flea mortality at four weeks from 60 to 75% to <10%. Infected O. montana mortality was 20% at two weeks and 28% at four weeks after infection, correlating with the timing and incidence of blockage-induced mortality (Fig 1). A high mortality rate during the first week after infection indicates that the fleas were unhealthy or stressed, complicating the interpretation of the results. For this reason, experiments designed to compare long-term infection and transmission dynamics should include uninfected control fleas to verify normal viability. Different flea species may require different maintenance conditions to maintain health. The consistent high blockage and transmission rates reported for X. cheopis compared to other species may in part be due to the fact that X. cheopis is more easily adaptable to the laboratory.
A second objective was to compare the vector efficiency of O. montana and X. cheopis by the proventricular biofilm-dependent mechanism. The vector efficiency of a given flea species is a product of several factors, including infection potential (the percentage of individuals that become infected after feeding on blood containing Y. pestis), vector potential (the % of infected fleas that develop a transmissible infection; i.e., the % of infective fleas), and the transmission potential (the average number of transmissions effected by a group of infective fleas) [12, 32]. We measured the infection potential directly and found that it was lower for O. montana (45 to 75%) than for X. cheopis (87 to 100%; Fig 1C). This is consistent with previous reports that O. montana clears itself of infection at a higher rate than X. cheopis [10, 19, 20]. Although complete blockage is not required for transmissibility, the blockage rate is often used as a surrogate marker for vector potential by the proventricular biofilm-dependent mechanism. Like the infection rate, the blockage rate was also lower for O. montana (17 to 25%) than for X. cheopis (30 to 40%); however, blockage rates of stably infected fleas (rather than the total that took an infectious blood meal) were roughly equivalent for the two species. In this study, we monitored transmission by a population of infected fleas, which allowed an overall comparison of transmission dynamics and kinetics. To directly calculate the vector efficiency, it will also be necessary to monitor the vector potential and transmission potential of individual fleas after infection. We are currently adapting our model system for this purpose.
Despite its lower infection and blockage rates, O. montana transmitted greater numbers of Y. pestis than did X. cheopis in mass transmission experiments, and transmission peaked earlier. Several factors could account for these results. O. montana developed proventricular blockage sooner than X. cheopis, and blocked O. montana survived significantly longer than blocked X. cheopis. The blocking-surviving potential, defined as the mean day of death after becoming blocked divided by the mean day of becoming blocked after an infectious blood meal, has been described as an important component of flea vector efficiency [11, 18]. Based on the results shown in Fig 3, the calculated blocking-survival potential of O. montana (0.73) is 5-fold higher than that of X. cheopis (0.14). It is also important to note that, as mentioned previously, complete blockage is not required for transmission—partially blocked fleas can also transmit efficiently . Partially blocked fleas, with fresh blood in the esophagus but some also in the midgut, were observed frequently during transmission trials (Tables 1 and 2). Complete blockage appeared to develop more gradually in O. montana or was more ephemeral, as sometimes a small amount of blood appeared to seep through into the midgut when a flea previously diagnosed as completely blocked fed again.
Differences in foregut anatomy may also enhance transmission efficiency of O. montana. The esophageal-proventricular junction is much broader in blocked O. montana than in blocked X. cheopis (Fig 5). The increased esophageal distension observed in fully blocked O. montana would be expected to expose a greater surface area of the infectious biofilm to contact with incoming blood during a feeding attempt, potentially enhancing regurgitative transmission. This may in part account for the greater number of CFUs recovered from O. montana mass transmission experiments. We have hypothesized that foregut anatomical differences may also account for the larger numbers of Y. pestis transmitted by X. cheopis than by the cat flea Ctenocephalides felis .
A third objective of this study was to evaluate, in the same cohorts of infected fleas, the relative importance of the two transmission mechanisms. The transmission efficiency of both O. montana and X. cheopis, defined here as the number of Y. pestis transmitted per infective flea, was very low by the early-phase mechanism compared to later proventricular biofilm-dependent transmission. In half of the day-3 early-phase transmission trials, no Y. pestis CFUs were recovered from the blood reservoir fed upon by >100 fleas. Based on trials in which we added known numbers of Y. pestis to the blood in the feeding system, the expected recovery rate is ~95%. Thus, we estimate that 0 to 5 CFU were transmitted in the negative early-phase transmission experiments. Our results are in line with previous work indicating that early-phase transmission is inefficient. In 1907 the Indian Plague Commission reported that only 1 of 67 fleas that had fed on a septicemic plague rat and then individually placed on naïve rats transmitted plague in the early phase . Recent studies estimate a ~0 to 10% probability of a single O. montana or X. cheopis flea transmitting by the early-phase mechanism [16, 26–30]. These estimates were based on both disease incidence and seroconversion following challenge by groups of ten fleas, indicating that the number of Y. pestis transmitted was sometimes at or below the LD50, estimated at 1 to 10 CFU for the highly susceptible laboratory mice used. The bite of a single blocked X. cheopis results in transmission 25 to 50% of the time [9–12]. The number of CFU transmitted by the bite of a blocked X. cheopis is highly variable, ranging from <10 to several thousand [10, 13]. No data are available on the transmission efficiency of partially blocked fleas or the number of CFUs they transmit. Our system allowed us to monitor transmission by cohorts of infected fleas (“mass” transmission). This allowed an overall comparison of transmission dynamics and kinetics and vector potential at the population level, but not the transmission rate (the percentage of fleas that transmitted) or transmission potential (defined above). Consistent with our results, however, a recent study estimated that the percent transmission efficiency of an individual O. montana flea is lower in the early phase compared to later time points after infection .
Early-phase transmission has been proposed to largely account for epizootic spread by flea vectors that purportedly do not readily become blocked [33, 34]. However, it is recognized that comparative data regarding transmission by the proventricular biofilm (“blockage”) mechanism are limited and problematic, and warrant reexamination [5, 20, 35]. A variety of experimental conditions and designs have been used with respect to infectious blood meal source, infectious dose, and flea maintenance conditions, all of which are known to influence infection and transmission dynamics. In some cases, small numbers of fleas were used that were likely poorly adapted to laboratory conditions. As in the case of O. montana, results have sometimes been inconsistent. Furthermore, early-phase transmission has only been demonstrated from fleas that fed on blood with a very high bacteremia to highly susceptible laboratory rodents (ID50 <10 CFU) . The California ground squirrel, the major host of O. montana, reportedly has an ID50 of >250 CFU . Based on the previous reports that O. montana rarely blocks or transmits beyond the early phase, a recent study that modeled O. montana-ground squirrel plague made the assumption that only early-phase transmission was important, and that transmission beyond that was negligible . Our results indicating that very few bacteria are transmitted early (less than the reported ID50 of ground squirrels), but that subsequent transmission is robust, suggest that the converse assumption is probably more realistic. However, factors specific to different ecological settings and host and vector populations may also affect transmission dynamics.
In this study, we present a standardized, stringently controlled model system to more reliably compare vector efficiency and to monitor transmission dynamics of a population of infected fleas. Key elements of this experimental system and their rationale include: 1) Fleas are infected on a specific blood source containing comparable concentrations of Y. pestis. Both the type of blood used and the bacteremia level significantly affect the infection potential and incidence of blockage [13, 19, 39]. Use of an artificial feeding device allows the infectious blood meal to be matched in different experiments. 2) A subset of the same flea cohort used for infection is fed on sterile blood of the same type for use as uninfected controls. Infected and uninfected fleas are kept in the same environment and provided the same type and frequency of maintenance feeds. The mortality of uninfected control fleas after 4 weeks should be low. If not, the fleas were physiologically stressed and results based on them are unreliable. Mortality of infected fleas should also be recorded, as it is a surrogate indicator of blockage-induced starvation. 3) Fleas are individually examined immediately after the infectious blood meal and only those that took a full blood meal are included in the study. The mean initial infectious dose acquired by the fleas is determined from a sample of these fleas, collected immediately after the infectious blood meal. Some flea species may be reluctant to feed on other than their natural blood source, resulting in a lower infectious dose and subsequent lower infectivity rate. 4) Fleas are examined microscopically immediately after each maintenance feed for evidence of partial or complete proventricular blockage using good quality optics and light source. Fluorescence microscopy of the digestive tract dissected from fleas infected with GFP-expressing Y. pestis is very useful to determine proventricular blockage status. This is particularly helpful for fleas that have a darkly pigmented exoskeleton that is less transparent to direct microscopic visualization of the esophagus, proventriculus, and midgut . 5) Infection rate and bacterial load are monitored by plate counts of flea samples collected at different times after the infectious blood meal. 6) Transmission dynamics are monitored for a population that received the same infectious blood meal during a timeframe that encompasses both modes of transmission.
Our results resolve a long-standing controversy about the susceptibility of O. montana to become blocked and to transmit Y. pestis by the proventricular biofilm-dependent mechanism. We previously used this experimental system to show that C. felis, normally a poor vector by either mechanism, readily becomes blocked and transmits if its usual daily feeding behavior is altered . The transmission dynamics of other flea vector species can be systematically reevaluated by using this system, with the important prerequisite that appropriate laboratory maintenance conditions can be established for them.
We thank K. Gage and J. Montenieri (CDC; Fort Collins, CO) for providing the O. montana fleas used to start our colony; and Tom Schwan and Phil Stewart (RML) for reviewing the manuscript.
- Conceptualization: BJH DMB.
- Formal analysis: BJH DMB.
- Funding acquisition: BJH.
- Investigation: BJH DMB CFB COJ.
- Methodology: BJH DMB COJ.
- Project administration: BJH.
- Supervision: BJH.
- Validation: BJH DMB CFB COJ.
- Writing – original draft: BJH.
- Writing – review & editing: BJH DMB CFB COJ.
- 1. Indian Plague Research Commission. Further observations on the transmission of plague by fleas, with special reference to the fate of the plague bacillus in the body of the rat flea (P. cheopis). J Hyg 1907;7:395–420. pmid:20474318
- 2. Verjbitski DT. The part played by insects in the epidemiology of plague (1908 translation). J Hyg 1904;8:162–208.
- 3. Hinnebusch BJ. Biofilm-dependent and biofilm-independent mechanisms of transmission of Yersinia pestis by fleas. Adv Exp Med Biol. 2012;954:237–243. pmid:22782769
- 4. Eisen RJ, Dennis DT, Gage KL. The role of early-phase transmission in the spread of Yersinia pestis. J Med Entomol 2015;52:1183–1192. pmid:26336267
- 5. Eisen RJ, Eisen L, Gage KL. Studies of vector competency and efficiency of North American fleas for Yersinia pestis: state of the field and future research needs. J Med Entomol. 2009;46:737–744. pmid:19645275
- 6. Bacot AW, Martin CJ. Observations on the mechanism of the transmission of plague by fleas. J Hyg 1914;13:423–39. pmid:20474555
- 7. Bacot AW. Further notes on the mechanism of the transmission of plague by fleas. J Hyg 1915;14:774–776. pmid:20474604
- 8. Jarrett CO, Deak E, Isherwood KE, Oyston PC, Fischer ER, Whitney AR, et al. Transmission of Yersinia pestis from an infectious biofilm in the flea vector. J Inf Dis 2004;190:783–92.
- 9. Eskey CR, Haas VH. Plague in the western part of the United States. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Public Health Service; 1940.
- 10. Burroughs AL. Sylvatic plague studies. The vector efficiency of nine species of fleas compared with Xenopsylla cheopis. J Hyg 1947;45:371–396. pmid:20475778
- 11. Kartman L, Prince FM, Quan SF. Studies on Pasteurella pestis in fleas. Comparative plague-vector efficiency of Xenopsylla vexabilis hawaiiensis and Xenopsylla cheopis. Bull World Health Org 1956;14:681–704. pmid:13356144
- 12. Wheeler CM, Douglas JR. Sylvatic plague studies. V. The determination of vector efficiency. J Inf Dis. 1945;77:1–12.
- 13. Lorange EA, Race BL, Sebbane F, Hinnebusch BJ. Poor vector competence of fleas and the evolution of hypervirulence in Yersinia pestis. J Inf Dis 2005;191:1907–1912.
- 14. Eisen RJ, Holmes JL, Schotthoefer AM, Vetter SM, Montenieri JA, Gage KL. Demonstration of early-phase transmission of Yersinia pestis by the mouse flea, Aetheca wagneri (Siphonaptera: Ceratophylidae), and implications for the role of deer mice as enzootic reservoirs. J Med Entomol. 2008;45:1160–4. pmid:19058643
- 15. Eisen RJ, Borchert JN, Holmes JL, Amatre G, Van Wyk K, Enscore RE, et al. Early-phase transmission of Yersinia pestis by cat fleas (Ctenocephalides felis) and their potential role as vectors in a plague-endemic region of Uganda. Am J Trop Med Hyg. 2008;78:949–56. pmid:18541775
- 16. Johnson TL, Hinnebusch BJ, Boegler KA, Graham CB, MacMillan K, Montenieri JA, et al. Yersinia murine toxin is not required for early-phase transmission of Yersinia pestis by Oropsylla montana (Siphonaptera: Ceratophyllidae) or Xenopsylla cheopis (Siphonaptera: Pulicidae). Microbiology 2014;160:2517–2525. pmid:25187626
- 17. Wilder AP, Eisen RJ, Bearden SW, Montenieri JA, Tripp DW, Brinkerhoff RJ, et al. Transmission efficiency of two flea species (Oropsylla tuberculata cynomuris and Oropsylla hirsuta) involved in plague epizootics among prairie dogs. Ecohealth 2008;5:205–12. pmid:18787922
- 18. Kartman L, Prince FM. Studies on Pasteurella pestis in fleas. V. The experimental plague-vector efficiency of wild rodent fleas compared with Xenopsylla cheopis, together with observations on the influence of temperature. Am J Trop Med Hyg. 1956;5:1058–1070. pmid:13381882
- 19. Engelthaler DM, Hinnebusch BJ, Rittner CM, Gage KL. Quantitative competitive PCR as a technique for exploring flea-Yersina pestis dynamics. Am J Trop Med Hyg 2000;62:552–560. pmid:11289663
- 20. Douglas JR, Wheeler CM. Sylvatic plague studies. II. The fate of Pasteurella pestis in the flea. J Inf Dis 1943;72:18–30.
- 21. Hinnebusch BJ, Perry RD, Schwan TG. Role of the Yersinia pestis hemin storage (hms) locus in the transmission of plague by fleas. Science. 1996;273:367–370. pmid:8662526
- 22. Engelthaler DM, Gage KL, Montenieri JA, Chu M, Carter LG. PCR detection of Yersinia pestis in fleas: comparison with mouse inoculation. J Clin Microbiol. 1999;37:1980–1984. pmid:10325359
- 23. Wade SE, Georgi JR. Survival and reproduction of artificially fed cat fleas, Ctenocephalides felis Bouché (Siphonaptera: Pulicidae). J Med Entomol 1988;25:186–190. pmid:3392715
- 24. Bland DM, Hinnebusch BJ. Feeding behavior modulates biofilm-mediated transmission of Yersinia pestis by the cat flea, Ctenocephalides felis. PLoS Negl Trop Dis 2016;10:e0004413. pmid:26829486
- 25. McCoy GW. Studies upon plague in ground squirrels. Publ Hlth Bull 1911;43:3–51.
- 26. Eisen RJ, Bearden SW, Wilder AP, Montenieri JA, Antolin MF, Gage KL. Early-phase transmission of Yersinia pestis by unblocked fleas as a mechanism explaining rapidly spreading plague epizootics. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 2006;103:15380–15385. pmid:17032761
- 27. Eisen RJ, Lowell JL, Montenieri JA, Bearden SW, Gage KL. Temporal dynamics of early-phase transmission of Yersinia pestis by unblocked fleas: secondary infectious feeds prolong efficient transmission by Oropsylla montana (Siphonaptera: Ceratophyllidae). J Med Entomol 2007;44(4):672–677. pmid:17695024
- 28. Vetter SM, Eisen RJ, Schotthoefer AM, Montenieri JA, Holmes JL, Bobrov AG, et al. Biofilm formation is not required for early-phase transmission of Yersinia pestis. Microbiology. 2010;156:2216–2225. pmid:20395271
- 29. Williams SK, Schotthoefer AM, Montenieri JA, Holmes JL, Vetter SM, Gage KL, et al. Effects of low-temperature flea maintenance on the transmission of Yersinia pestis by Oropsylla montana. Vector Borne Zoonotic Dis 2013;13:468–478. pmid:23590319
- 30. Schotthoefer AM, Bearden SW, Vetter SM, Holmes J, Montenieri JA, Graham CB, et al. Effects of temperature on early-phase transmission of Yersina pestis by the flea, Xenopsylla cheopis. J Med Entomol 2011;48:411–417. pmid:21485382
- 31. Laudisoit A, Leirs H, Makundi RH, Van Dongen S, Davis S, Neerinckx S, et al. Plague and the human flea, Tanzania. Emerg Infect Dis. 2007;13:687–693. pmid:17553245
- 32. Wheeler CM, Douglas JR. Transmission studies of sylvatic plague. Proc Soc Exptl Biol Med 1941;47:65–66.
- 33. Webb CT, Brooks CP, Gage KL, Antolin MF. Classic flea-borne transmission does not drive plague epizootics in prairie dogs. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 2006;103:6236–6241. pmid:16603630
- 34. Wilder AP, Eisen RJ, Bearden SW, Montenieri JA, Gage KL, Antolin MF. Oropsylla hirsuta (Siphonaptera: Ceratophyllidae) can support plague epizootics in black-tailed prairie dogs (Cynomys ludovicianus) by early-phase transmission of Yersinia pestis. Vector Borne Zoonotic Dis 2008;8:359–367. pmid:18454591
- 35. Pollitzer R. Plague. Geneva: World Health Organization; 1954, pp. 315–408.
- 36. Boegler KA, Graham CB, Johnson TL, Montenieri JA, Eisen RJ. Infection prevalence, bacterial loads, and transmission efficiency in Oropsylla montana (Siphonaptera: Ceratophyllidae) one day after exposure to varying concentrations of Yersinia pestis in blood. J Med Entomol 2016;53:674–680. pmid:26843450
- 37. Williams JE, Moussa MA, Cavanaugh DC. Experimental plague in the California ground squirrel. J Infect Dis 1979;140:618–621. pmid:512421
- 38. Buhnerkempe MG, Eisen RJ, Goodell B, Gage KL, Antolin MF, Webb CT. Transmission shifts underlie variability in population responses to Yersinia pestis infection. PLoS One 2011;6:e22498. pmid:21799873
- 39. Eisen RJ, Vetter SM, Holmes JL, Bearden SW, Montenieri JA, Gage KL. Source of host blood affects prevalence of infection and bacterial loads of Yersinia pestis in fleas. J Med Entomol 2008;45:933–938. pmid:18826038