https://orcid.org/0000-0003-1592-0400
Figures
Abstract
Climate change and variability influence temperature and rainfall, which impact vector abundance and the dynamics of vector-borne disease transmission. Climate change is projected to increase the frequency and intensity of extreme climate events. Mosquito-borne diseases, such as dengue fever, are primarily transmitted by Aedes aegypti mosquitoes. Freshwater availability and temperature affect dengue vector populations via a variety of biological processes and thus influence the ability of mosquitoes to effectively transmit disease. However, the effect of droughts, floods, heat waves, and cold waves is not well understood. Using vector, climate, and dengue disease data collected between 2013 and 2019 in Kenya, this retrospective cohort study aims to elucidate the impact of extreme rainfall and temperature on mosquito abundance and the risk of arboviral infections. To define extreme periods of rainfall and land surface temperature (LST), we calculated monthly anomalies as deviations from long-term means (1983–2019 for rainfall, 2000–2019 for LST) across four study locations in Kenya. We classified extreme climate events as the upper and lower 10% of these calculated LST or rainfall deviations. Monthly Ae. aegypti abundance was recorded in Kenya using four trapping methods. Blood samples were also collected from children with febrile illness presenting to four field sites and tested for dengue virus using an IgG enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) and polymerase chain reaction (PCR). We found that mosquito eggs and adults were significantly more abundant one month following an abnormally wet month. The relationship between mosquito abundance and dengue risk follows a non-linear association. Our findings suggest that early warnings and targeted interventions during periods of abnormal rainfall and temperature, especially flooding, can potentially contribute to reductions in risk of viral transmission.
Author summary
Dengue is a rapidly spreading mosquito-borne disease transmitted primarily by Aedes aegypti mosquitoes. As climate change leads to extremes in rainfall and temperature, the abundance and populations of these vectors will be affected, thus influencing transmission of dengue. Using satellite-derived climate data for Kenya, we classified months that experienced highly abnormal rainfall and temperature as extreme climate events (floods, droughts, heat waves, or cold waves). We compared the average monthly Ae. aegypti abundance and confirmed dengue counts following extreme climate months using lag periods of one month and two months, respectively. This study utilized several statistical models to account for differences among study sites and time. Floods resulted in significantly increased egg and adult abundance. Our results contributed to a better understanding of the effect of climate variability and change on dengue. As suggested by our observed increase in vector counts yet a relatively unchanged dengue infection risk, human behavior can help reduce viral transmission. Targeted interventions should be focused on both reducing vector populations and limiting human-vector contact, especially during these climate anomalies.
Citation: Nosrat C, Altamirano J, Anyamba A, Caldwell JM, Damoah R, Mutuku F, et al. (2021) Impact of recent climate extremes on mosquito-borne disease transmission in Kenya. PLoS Negl Trop Dis 15(3): e0009182. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pntd.0009182
Editor: Elvina Viennet, Australian Red Cross Lifelood, AUSTRALIA
Received: June 29, 2020; Accepted: January 26, 2021; Published: March 18, 2021
Copyright: © 2021 Nosrat et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Data Availability: Data are available from the Stanford Repository at the following URL: https://purl.stanford.edu/rz262rz1347.
Funding: This research was supported by National Institutes of Health (NIH) grant R01AI102918 (ADL). The Stanford REDCap platform (http://redcap.stanford.edu) is operated by Stanford Medicine Research IT team. The REDCap platform services at Stanford are subsidized by a) Stanford School of Medicine Research Office, and b) the National Center for Research Resources and the National Center for Advancing Translational Sciences, National Institutes of Health, through grant UL1 TR001085⤉. JMC was supported by a Stanford Woods Institute for the Environment - Environmental Ventures Program grant. The funders had no role in the collection, analysis, or reporting of the data.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Introduction
Climate change’s influence on temperature and rainfall can dramatically impact vector abundance and thus the dynamics of vector-borne disease transmission. Scientific evidence suggests that as global climate change continues to intensify, so will the frequency of extreme climate events, including floods, drought, heat waves, and cold waves [1–4]. Extreme climate events result from both natural internal climate variability and climate warming [5]. Climate variability arises spontaneously within the climate system even in the absence of climate forcings [5]. With regards to climate warming, sea-surface temperature increases of 1–2° Celsius can result in greater trapped greenhouse gas molecules and energy flux in the lower atmosphere, resulting in stronger, more unpredictable weather patterns [1]. Water availability during extreme climate events, including droughts and floods, can have important implications for mosquito-borne disease transmission, as pools of water provide breeding sites for infectious disease vectors. Similarly, local temperatures can alter mosquito dynamics, including the development of immature mosquitoes, and rates of reproduction and biting [6]. Most notably, transmission of dengue fever, a prevalent arthropod-borne disease in Kenya that is the focus of this study, can be affected by variability in temperature and rainfall [6, 7].
Dengue is the most common and the fastest spreading vector-borne disease globally, resulting in close to half of the world’s population living in areas at risk for dengue virus (DENV) transmission [8]. DENV is a flavivirus with four distinct serotypes (1–4) found mostly in tropical and sub-tropical regions of the world [8]. It is transmitted by Aedes aegypti and Aedes albopictus mosquito vectors [9]. In 2019, the largest number of DENV infections were reported globally; annual infection counts have increased 15-fold over the past two decades, resulting in large dengue epidemics [8]. DENV is transmitted by mosquitoes throughout daylight hours and human populations living in close contact with mosquito vector breeding sites are at risk for DENV infection. The prevalence of vector breeding sites, both natural and artificial, in combination with ambient temperatures can influence vector abundance, vector growth, and infectious disease transmission. However, the effect of extreme climate events, including floods, droughts, heat waves, and cold waves on mosquito-borne disease transmission is not well understood.
Previous studies indicate that accumulated rainfall increases vector habitats, but floods and excessive rainfall flush breeding sites, thus diminishing vector populations of several mosquito species, including Ae. aegypti [10–13]. For example, in Singapore between 2014–2015, researchers observed excessive rainfall flushed Ae. aegypti breeding sites and decreased the risk of dengue outbreaks six weeks following rainfall [11]. Several epidemiological studies also support strong associations between accumulated rainfall and higher vector abundance 4+ weeks later [14–16]. For example, Aedes albopictus, a closely related species of Ae. aegypti and vector for dengue virus and chikungunya virus, was observed to be positively associated with accumulated rainfall at a lag of four weeks in southern France. This ultimately contributed to an increased risk of chikungunya transmission in France in 2014 [17]. Such a relationship held true for dengue as well, as researchers in Jakarta and Bali observed the number of dengue cases to increase with higher monthly mean rainfall up to 16.2 mm over the past decade [18]. As such, the relationship between rainfall and dengue transmission is not clearly delineated.
While a common view is that reductions in water availability removes vector breeding sites and diminish mosquito populations, drought conditions seem favorable for certain mosquito species [19, 20]. There are several modes through which drought is believed to promote greater vector abundance, according to a UK literature review; the primary mechanism through which Ae. aegypti abundance is promoted is through increased storage of water, which increases the availability of aquatic habitats for mosquitoes [20]. Such droughts contributed to several mosquito-borne diseases outbreaks, including a chikungunya virus outbreak in coastal Kenya between 2004–2005 [20, 21].
Temperature can affect many mosquito biological processes (e.g., reproduction, biting rate, development rate, etc.), thus influencing the prevalence of mosquitoes and the extent of disease spread [22]. Researchers have identified that the thermal response curve for Ae. aegypti transmission of dengue virus peaks at 29°C, which is higher than optimal transmission temperatures for other vector species [23]. However, much remains unknown about whether such laboratory-measured temperature thresholds lead to defined thresholds in reality. A study examining the effect of climatic factors on dengue transmission between Bali and Australia observed the number of dengue cases in Bali to increase with increasing mean temperature [18]. Heat waves have also been associated with increased dengue transmission; between December 2010-February 2011, seasonal land surface temperatures were 5–20°C above normal, and these above-normal temperatures were associated with the first known large-scale outbreak of dengue fever in East Africa [24]. We hope to better contextualize previous temperature thresholds and trends associated with DENV transmission using field data in Kenya.
Kenya is an ideal study site to better understand the relationship between climate variability, vector abundance, and mosquito-borne disease transmission due to the endemicity of mosquito-borne diseases, like dengue fever, and the region’s interannual variable climate due to the El Niño Southern Oscillation [25, 26]. Due to the generally low levels of endemic DENV transmission in the region, more than a handful of cases are usually associated with small dengue outbreaks. Using existing vector (January 2014 –September 2018), climate (November 2013 –February 2019), and disease (January 2014 –February 2019) data systematically collected over the past six years at four sites in Kenya (Fig 1), this study aims to identify how periods of extreme rainfall and temperature affect mosquito abundance and the risk of dengue infection in a cohort of Kenyan children.
Methods
Ethics statement
The study protocol was approved by the Stanford University Institutional Review Board (Protocol ID #31488) and the Kenya Medical Research Institute (KEMRI) National Scientific and Ethical Review Committee (SSC # 2611). Meetings were held at all four sites with local government administrators (village elders, chiefs, and assistant chiefs) and with the local residents in each sub-location to introduce the research study and staff to the public. Written consent was obtained from all participants to collect blood samples and from household heads to sample mosquitoes within their houses and their compounds. Parents and guardians provided written consent on behalf of children and children >7 years of age also provided written assent. Mature minors provided written consent.
Study sites
This study took place at two sites in western Kenya, Chulaimbo (rural) and Kisumu (urban), and two sites in coastal Kenya, Ukunda (urban) and Msambweni (rural) (Fig 1). The study sites vary in DENV burden, climate, geography, population size, and urbanization.
Climate anomalies
Monthly mean land surface temperatures were extracted from the National Aeronautics and Space Administration’s global monthly MOD11C3 version 6 data set derived from MODIS Terra. LST data are available at a spatial resolution 0.05° x 0.05° (≈5.5 km), thus allowing us to compare more recent monthly LSTs to long-term means for a 30 km x 30 km grid centered on each study location (S1 Appendix). The monthly long-term means were calculated using the 2003–2018 base period; that is, the long-term mean for each month was calculated by averaging the monthly mean LST for each month between 2003–2018. The study period was included in the base period, as the inclusion of all available observations allows for a more accurate characterization of the study locations’ climate [27]. Average monthly temperatures between 2013–2019 were similarly gridded at 30km x 30km centered on each study location.
In order to assess rainfall variability for the study sites in Kenya, we used the daily African Rainfall Climatology Version 2 (ARC2) dataset from the archives of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA)–Climate Prediction Center (CPC). The rainfall estimates are gridded at 0.1° x 0.1° (≈11 km) spatial resolution operationally produced by a combination of rain gauge measurements and METEOSTAT satellites, thus providing rainfall estimates from 1982 to the present over Africa. Monthly long-term means were calculated for 30km x 30km grids for two counties, Kwale and Kisumu, using the 1982–2019 base period. As referenced in the WMO’s Guidelines on the Calculation of Climate Normals, the inclusion of all available observations allows for a more accurate characterization of the study locations’ climate, especially when fewer than 30 years of data are available [27]; as a result, the reference periods for LST and rainfall differ for this study. To calculate absolute monthly rainfall between 2013–2019, we aggregated data to a 30 km x 30 km grid centered on each study location. Absolute monthly rainfall for the coastal sites of Msambweni and Ukunda were compared to the long-term monthly mean rainfall for their county, Kwale. Monthly rainfall for the western sites of Kisumu and Chulaimbo were compared to the long-term monthly mean rainfall for their county, Kisumu.
Monthly climate anomalies (Xa) were defined as the difference between absolute monthly measurements (X) and long-term monthly means (Xu) for rainfall and land surface temperature:
(1)
Extreme climate events were defined as anomalies greater than the 90th percentile and lower than the 10th percentile of anomalies (Fig 2). Since this study is concerned with how climate anomalies resulting from climate variability influence dengue transmission, classification of climate events does not consider absolute values of rainfall and LST but rather deviations from what is typically expected. More specifically, a flood is categorized as a positive rainfall deviation (i.e., above the 90% rainfall threshold), and a drought is categorized as a negative rainfall deviation (i.e., below the 10% rainfall threshold). A heat wave is categorized as a positive LST deviation (i.e., above the 90% LST threshold), and a cold wave is categorized as a negative LST deviation (i.e., below the 10% rainfall threshold). Such a method of defining extreme climate periods allows for sufficient observations for analysis.
Extreme climate anomalies were defined as the upper and lower 10% of all anomalies (difference compared to long-term mean). For rainfall, upper 10% is designated as a “flood”; lower 10% is designated as a “drought.” For LST, upper 10% is designated as a “heat wave”; lower 10% is designated as a “cold wave.”
Vector abundance
Mosquitoes of different life stages were sampled and classified by trapping method, date of collection, species and sex. This study is concerned with the abundance of Aedes aegypti and Aedes spp. (i.e. Aedes ochraceus, Aedes fulgens Aedes pembaensis), as they are primarily responsible for the transmission of DENV in Kenya. While traditionally an endophilic species, these mosquitoes have been observed to be primarily exophilic daytime feeders with peak biting periods early in the morning and in the evening before dusk in our study sites [28]. Vector abundance was recorded using various sampling methods to recover mosquito life stages, including ovitrap (eggs), pupal sampling (pupae), Prokopack aspiration (adults), and Biogents-sentinal (BG) trapping (adults) (S2 Appendix). The use of various collection methods allows for a more representative and accurate estimate of vector abundance, as each method allows for the collection of different mosquito life stages.
Disease transmission
Dengue (DENV) incidence was assessed based on blood samples collected from children with acute febrile illness presenting to one of the four study sites (Mbaka Oromo Health Centre in Chulaimbo, Obama Children’s Hospital in Kisumu, Msambweni District Hospital in Msambweni, and Ukunda/Diani Health Center in Ukunda) (Fig 1). The study population consisted of 7,653 children less than 18 years of age (median = 5 years [1 year, 15 years]). Unlike other places around the world, children in Kenya spend a lot of time outside during the day, which is when Ae. aegypti are actively biting. Blood samples were tested on site in Kenya by Ministry of Health collaborators at Msambweni District Hospital for coastal Kenya sites and KEMRI Kisian Field Station for western Kenya sites; samples were also tested at Stanford University. Cases of DENV were defined as a positive by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) and/or IgG-positive enzyme linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA)–children were considered dengue positive at the initial visit if viremia was found in the blood at the initial visit (e.g. by PCR) and if they seroconverted based on the follow-up visit (e.g. by PCR and IgG-ELISA). If a child presented PCR negative and already had antibodies at the initial visit, they were not included in the totals because this indicates that they had dengue previously at some point in their life and we would not be able to distinguish whether an infection occurred in the last few weeks.
Statistical analyses
We conducted bivariate analyses, including Kruskal-Wallis tests by ranks and Wilcoxon rank sum tests, to investigate whether average Ae. aegypti abundance one month following each extreme climate event was significantly different compared to following “normal” climate (S3 Appendix). A one-month lag period was used between mosquito abundance and meteorological variables, as has been traditionally been supported in the literature and also expected by the cycle of infection [29]. An identical analysis was done for DENV infection counts at a lag of two months following the anomaly (S3 Appendix). While there have been observed time lags of 1–3 months between dengue incidence and meteorological variables, we made use of a two month lag period; rainfall and temperature have been observed to have the most prominent effects on dengue incidence at a lag period of two months [30, 31].
To test the effect of magnitude of rainfall and temperature anomalies on Ae. aegypti abundance after one month, we developed generalized log-linear mixed models for each mosquito life history stage (i.e., trapping method). The predictor variables for the model include rainfall anomalies and LST anomalies while site, month, and year are included as random effects. We also tested for a possible interaction between rainfall anomalies and LST anomalies. Other variables, such as monthly accumulated rainfall, monthly LST, monthly ambient temperature, and humidity were excluded from the model because of their collinear relationships with rainfall anomalies and LST anomalies.
In addition to a generalized log-linear mixed model, we conducted a multinomial logistic regression model using the classification of rainfall anomalies and LST anomalies as our primary independent variables in explaining expected vector abundance classification the following month. Vector abundance was classified as low, intermediate, and high for each trapping method. Due to the non-normal distributions of the outcome, cutoffs for grouping were established non-uniformly across the trapping methods (S3 Table). As such, we were interested in observing how our categorization of climate anomalies helps predict vector counts. We calculated adjusted odds ratios including fixed effects for site and month, allowing us to consider site and time-endogenous variation.
Similarly, we tested the effect of rainfall and temperature anomalies on the number of monthly DENV infections using a two-month lag. We developed a binary logistic regression model, with the first outcome defined as <7 confirmed DENV infection in a month and the second outcome defined as 7+ confirmed DENV infections. 7+ confirmed DENV infections represent the upper 10% of monthly cases and can thus be defined as “higher” than normal in a region with low levels of DENV transmission. The model controlled for seasonality and regional differences by considering month, year, and site.
A second binary regression model tested the effect of rainfall and LST anomaly categorization on dengue transmission, again accounting for month, year, and site. Missing data was excluded from all models (S4 Table).
Descriptive and inferential analyses were conducted using the statistical software R (version 1.1.383, 2017, Boston, USA).
Results
Climate anomalies
Establishing defined thresholds for our categorization of extreme climate events allows us to compare related climatic variables of interest between types of extreme climate. Calculations and categorization of extreme climate events were based on previous guidelines [32]. A comparison between these groups suggests appropriate categorization of anomalies (S1 and S2 Tables). However, such categorizations of extreme climate events are unevenly distributed among the study sites (Tables 1 and 2).
Vector abundance
Ae. aegypti eggs. In our generalized log-linear model, rainfall anomalies were positively associated with egg abundance (p = 0.017); thus, for every ten-millimeter increase in rainfall anomalies (i.e., more severe floods) in any given month, a 2% increase in Ae. aegypti egg abundance would be expected, when site, month, and year, are included as random effects (Table 3). The effect of LST anomalies, and the interaction between rainfall anomalies and LST anomalies were insignificant.
Floods significantly increased the odds of egg abundance being classified as “high” when site, month, year, and LST classification were held constant in our multinomial logistic model (OR = 13.8 [6.5, 29.3], p < 0.001); flood classification increased the odds of “high” mosquito egg abundance by 1280% (Table 4). Drought, on the other hand, decreased the odds of egg abundance to be classified as “high” (OR = 0.70 [0.54, 0.90], p = 0.01) (Table 4). Heat waves decreased the odds of both “low” egg abundance (OR = 0.32 [0.23, 0.44], p < 0.001) and “high” egg abundance (OR = 0.22 [0.20, 0.23], p < 0.001), meaning that excessively increased LST anomalies (i.e., heat waves) would be expected to result in intermediate vector counts the following month. Cold waves decreased the odds of “low” egg abundance the following month (OR = 0.25 [0.20, 0.32], p < 0.001) (Table 4).
Ae. aegypti pupae.
Our generalized log-linear model did not find any significant effects of rainfall anomalies, LST anomalies, and the interaction between rainfall anomalies and LST anomalies on pupal abundance.
Similarly, for Ae. aegypti pupae, we observed that lower-than-expected levels of rainfall, as are consistent with the definition of a drought, promoted lower Ae. aegypti pupal abundance (OR = 2.41 [1.09, 5.32], p = 0.03) and significantly lowered the odds of high pupal abundance (OR = 0.85 [0.77, 00.95], p = 0.004) (Table 4). Heat waves significantly increased the odds of low Ae. aegypti pupal abundance (OR = 2.22 [1.04, 4.75], p = 0.04) while cold waves significantly increased the odds of high Ae. aegypti pupal abundance (OR = 2.33 [1.48, 3.64], p < 0.001) (Table 4).
Ae. aegypti adults.
For adult Ae. aegypti abundance collected with Prokopack aspirators, the severity of LST anomalies significantly influenced vector abundance: for every 1°C increase in a monthly LST anomaly, an 8.7% decrease in Ae. aegypti abundance would be expected the following month (Table 3). However, for adult Ae. aegypti collected with BG-traps, we did not observe a significant relationship between anomaly severity and vector abundance (Table 3). Rainfall anomalies and the interaction between rainfall anomalies and LST anomalies remained insignificant for both trapping methods. Compared to Chulaimbo, a significantly increased odds of higher adult abundance as collected by Prokopack aspirators was observed in the model for the urban sites of Kisumu (OR = 6.99 [2.87, 17.00], p < 0.001) and Ukunda (OR = 4.21 [1.71, 10.37], p = 0.002) while a decreased odds of higher adult abundance was observed for Msambweni (OR = 0.12 [0.05, 0.26], p < 0.001). A similar relationship was observed for adults collected by BG-traps. Compared to Chulaimbo, a significantly increased odds of higher adult abundance was observed for Kisumu (OR = 18.17 [6.21, 53.44], p < 0.001) while a decreased odds of higher abundance was observed for Msambweni (OR = 0.17 [0.06, 0.43], p < 0.001).
For adult Ae. aegypti collected with Prokopack aspirators, heat waves reduced the odds of “high” mosquito abundance by 67% (OR = 0.33 [0.19, 0.57], p <0.001). Similarly, drought reduced the odds of “high” Ae. aegypti abundance by 80% (OR = 0.20 [0.17, 0.24], p < 0.001) (Table 4). However, unlike the results from our bivariate analyses (S2 Fig), once site, month, year, and rainfall anomalies were accounted for, cold waves did not significantly increase the odds of “high” vector abundance for Prokopack (OR = 2.43 [0.80, 7.39], p = 0.12). Moreover, cold waves were expected to decrease the odds of “low” vector abundance (OR = 0.57 [0.45, 0.72], p < 0.001), suggesting that abnormally cold temperatures promoted intermediate vector counts (Table 4). For adult mosquitoes as recorded by BG-traps, we observed that floods significantly increased the odds of “high” vector abundance (OR = 2.41 [1.36, 4.27], p = 0.002) when the analysis was controlled for site, month, year, and LST anomaly (Table 4).
Dengue transmission
Our binomial logistic regression results suggest that both rainfall and LST anomaly severity are not significantly associated with the transmission of dengue in Kenya when using a two-month lag (Table 5). Moreover, site, month, and year did not significantly influence the results, and the interaction between rainfall and LST anomalies was insignificant at p < 0.05. Similarly, when studying the effect that classification of rainfall and LST events has on dengue transmission, we failed to observe any significant effect (Table 6).
Discussion
The impact of recent climate extremes on mosquito vector abundance in Kenya is dependent on various factors, and observed results vary depending on the trapping method. Such a finding suggests that the effect of climate extremes differs based on the particular life stage of Ae. aegypti.
We found that one month following floods resulted in a significantly greater abundance of Ae. aegypti eggs. When adjusting for the potential modifying effects of site, month, and year, we observed flooding to result in a significant increase in the odds of higher egg abundance (Table 4). Moreover, more extreme rainfall resulted in increased egg abundance (Table 3). As suggested by significant differences in the effect of flooding between sites, urbanization likely influences the impact that flooding has on the abundance of Ae. aegypti eggs (S1A and S2 Figs). In our stratified bivariate analyses, we observe only rural sites to experience significantly higher egg abundance following flooding (S2 Fig). Rural areas tend to absorb excess water during periods of extreme rainfall better than urban areas and their human-made water catchments [33], potentially preventing a “flooding out” effect and instead providing more stable pools of water for mosquito breeding. Modifying human behavior during floods, such as the use of artificial and human-made containers, outdoor trash disposal, are necessary in removing potential breeding sites for mosquito vectors.
For Ae. aegypti pupae, we observed significant increases in abundance following cold waves, but both droughts and heat waves were associated with significantly fewer vectors (Table 4). From the unstratified bivariate analysis, pupal abundance was not significantly associated with extreme climate events (S1B Fig). However, in the stratified analysis, pupal abundance was significantly lower following a heat wave in Chulaimbo, a rural study site in western Kenya (S3B and S4 Figs). Even sites that are close in proximity to one another can experience different climate anomalies due to differences in local topography, wind, etc. Of all trapping methods assessed, pupal counts were consistently the lowest across study sites and were zero for more than a third of the observation periods, potentially affecting this study’s ability to assess the effect of extreme climate events on Ae. aegypti pupal abundance.
Drier climatic conditions, including drought and heat waves, seem to promote lower vector abundance. In terms of anomaly severity, we observed that more anomalous cold temperatures promoted greater adult abundance, as recorded by Prokopack (Table 3). Our bivariate analysis supports such a finding, as we observed an increased abundance of adult Ae. aegypti mosquitoes following periods defined as cold waves, for both trapping methods of Prokopack and BG-traps (S3C and S4C Figs). However, this association was likely driven by the fact that the average observed LST during cold waves was 29.99°C, which is in line with the 29°C optimal ambient air temperature threshold for Ae. aegypti [23]. Moreover, site and year were significant predictors of abundance classification, as supported by the multinomial regression and bivariate analyses. For example, many of the of the study’s cold wave observations actually took place during the 2015–2016 summer months (S5 Fig). This finding suggests that Ae. aegypti find cooler than expected months to be more favorable for growth because of the extremely warm average Kenyan temperatures year-round. However, the most notable finding was that for adult Ae. aegypti mosquitoes, as recorded by BG-trap, we observed significantly greater odds of higher adult abundance following floods, which is consistent with what we observed for Ae. aegypti eggs (Table 4). Such a finding suggests that of all extreme climate events, flooding most likely contributes to higher adult abundance by providing additional breeding sites for Ae. aegypti.
Our results primarily suggest that flood seasons contribute to significantly higher Ae. aegypti egg and adult abundance after one month. While such a finding is unique for Kenya, it is consistent with several previous epidemiological studies [14–17]. Periods defined as “floods” in Kenya considered a monthly accumulation of rainfall that was extreme but that did not always cause physical floodwaters that might have resulted in mosquito habitats being washed away. This was in contrast to previous tightly controlled simulations and experiments, which resulted in a “flooding-out effect” of vector breeding sites [10–13].
When adjusting for site, month, and year, we did not observe statistically significant relationships between extreme climate anomalies (specifically floods and cold waves) and confirmed cases of dengue infection, but this result may still inform our understanding of these relationships. This finding suggests that mosquito abundance and dengue risk do not necessarily share a linear association, as human behaviors can modify the relationship and influence infection risk. For example, previous studies of dengue dynamics in China have observed nonlinear statistical relationships between vectors, human incidence, and climate [29, 34]. This nonlinear relationship is in part driven by the extrinsic incubation period (EIP), the time it takes for the virus to disseminate in the mosquito, and mosquito lifespan. EIP duration and the mosquito lifespan are temperature-dependent. EIP becomes faster at higher temperatures, but the mosquito must survive longer than the EIP for transmission to occur [35]. The 29° C thermal optima derived from the full suite of Ae. aegypti temperature-dependent traits and widespread occurrence of the Ae. aegypti vector throughout Africa, suggests that as temperatures increase, dengue burden is also likely to increase throughout sub-Saharan Africa [36].
Preventative measures taken by our study population in the four villages may have contributed to reductions in the risk of dengue transmission. A recent study found that the primary control method utilized by participants in our study sites was bed-nets; of 5,833 enrolled patients at our four Kenyan clinic sites, 4,397 (75.4%) reported always using bed-nets [37]. While bed-nets can be protective against several mosquito species, they are not as useful against a diurnal mosquito species like Ae. aegypti. In addition to the removal of outdoor breeding sites, greater education and promotion of other preventative measures is necessary. The use of outdoor spray and repellant targeting this exophagic and anthropophagic mosquito species can significantly drive down the increased risk of dengue infection following extreme climate events.
An improved understanding of the relationship between extreme climate and dengue transmission can also allow for the development of climate-based early warning systems in Kenya. The El Niño Southern Oscillation (ENSO) and Indian Ocean Dipole (IOD) are responsible for changes in the sea-surface temperature that moderate seasonal rainfall and temperature variability in eastern Africa. As such, there is an increased likelihood of extreme climate events during extreme ENSO and positive IOD. By discerning the spatiotemporal relationship between extreme climate and dengue transmission, we can use ENSO and IOD indices to predict periods of heightened arboviral infection risk.
This study effectively investigates the impact of recent climate extremes on various life stages of Ae. aegypti abundance. With the availability of long-term satellite data, monthly rainfall and LST anomalies were calculated in order to determine associations with vector abundance and disease risk. A strength of the study is the calculation of monthly anomalies to explain both mosquito and disease data trends. The observational nature of the study offers high external validity. The study’s results can be generalized to dengue endemic regions similar in climate and demography to Kenya and the effects related to rainfall and LST can be more widely applicable. However, there are several limitations that are important to consider for future studies.
Due to the lack of long-term climate data available for analysis, this study makes use of satellite-derived data for four study sites in Kenya, which can provide us with a reference for the effect of extreme climate events more generally in the region (S6 Fig). As such, satellite-derived climate data offers the ability to compare deviations in recent climate conditions from long-term records. Minimum and maximum temperature values can impact temperature variability to differing extents. We are unable at the moment to reconstruct the data as produced and provided to tease out the effect of minimum and maximum temperatures. so future studies should consider temperature anomalies in the context of these extreme values rather than the mean. Additionally, future studies can make use of lag periods of differing temporal resolutions. Our lag periods were established based on the traditional cycle of dengue infection [29–31]; however, it is not a perfect model and other lag periods, especially with regards to dengue risk, have been observed in the literature. Furthermore, it is necessary to consider “anomalies” in the context of established biologically relevant thresholds for both temperature and rainfall.
Underreporting and misclassification of fever can influence results as well. Since DENV is heavily underreported in the region, all enrolled participants were tested for dengue and malaria. In a study of undifferentiated fever in Kenya between 2014–2017, 150 (51.5%) of 291 participants with dengue viremia were malaria smear positive, suggesting a large overlap in infections [38]. Additionally, flaviviruses, which include West Nile virus (WNV), ZIKA virus (ZIKAV), and yellow fever virus (YFV), have the potential to cross-react with DENV. However, WNV has a comparatively lower seroprevalence compared to DENV [26] while ZIKAV and YFV are essentially absent from our study sites.
As climate change accelerates and increases the intensity and severity of extreme climate events, understanding how they impact infectious disease transmission is essential. Climate change continues to blur and transform previously discrete seasons, which will influence vector dynamics and disease burden in Kenya. Ultimately, efforts should be focused on eliminating mosquito-breeding sites through the removal of human-made containers and trash in order to reduce vector populations. At the same time, encouragement of the use of spray, coils, and repellant can reduce the heightened risk of viral transmission during periods of anomalous climate and more specifically, floods.
Supporting information
S2 Appendix. Mosquito Trapping Method Timing and Frequency.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pntd.0009182.s002
(DOCX)
S3 Appendix. Crude Bivariate Analysis Methods.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pntd.0009182.s003
(DOCX)
S1 Fig. Effect of Rainfall Anomalies on Vector Abundance.
Boxplot of vector abundance by A) ovitrap B) Prokopack C) BG-trap and D) pupal trap one month following anomaly classified as normal, drought, or flood. Wilcoxon test p-values displayed between groups.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pntd.0009182.s004
(TIF)
S2 Fig. Effect of Rainfall Anomalies on Egg Abundance Stratified by Urbanization.
Boxplot of Ae. aegypti egg abundance one month following anomaly classified as normal, drought or flood. Stratified by rural (Chulaimbo and Msambweni) and urban (Kisumu and Ukunda) sites. Wilcoxon test p-values displayed between groups.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pntd.0009182.s005
(TIF)
S3 Fig. Effect of LST Anomalies on Vector Abundance.
Boxplot of vector abundance by A) ovitrap B) Prokopack C) BG-trap and D) pupal trap one month following anomaly classified as normal, heat wave, or cold wave. Wilcoxon test p-values displayed between groups.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pntd.0009182.s006
(TIF)
S4 Fig. Effect of LST Anomalies on Adult Abundance Stratified by Geography.
Boxplot of adult Ae. aegypti abundance (Prokopack) one month following anomaly classified as normal, heat wave or cold wave. Stratified by western (Kisumu and Chulaimbo) and coastal (Ukunda and Msambweni) sites. Wilcoxon test p-values displayed between groups.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pntd.0009182.s007
(TIF)
S5 Fig. Anomaly Severity by Site.
Heat map displaying monthly anomaly severity for A) accumulated rainfall and B) average LST between November 2013—February 2019, stratified by study sites.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pntd.0009182.s008
(TIF)
S6 Fig. Relationship Between Land Surface Temperature and Ambient Air Temperatures.
Across all four study sites, there is a strong correlation (R > 0.50, p < 0.05) between land surface temperature and ambient air temperatures between November 2013 –February 2019; however, there is clear variability between the two measurements.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pntd.0009182.s009
(TIF)
S1 Table. Characteristics of Rainfall Classification.
Mean and standard deviation of monthly LST (°C), LST anomaly (°C), monthly rainfall (mm), rainfall anomaly (mm), monthly ambient air temperature (°C), and monthly humidity (%) between previously defined groups of “flood,” “drought,” and “normal rainfall.” LST and rainfall anomalies refer to difference between observed monthly values and long-term means. p-values indicate significance values from Kruskal-Wallis Rank Sum tests among three groups. *p ≤ 0.05, ** p ≤ 0.01, *** p ≤ 0.001 for Wilcoxon-test where “Normal Rainfall” is considered the reference group.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pntd.0009182.s010
(DOCX)
S2 Table. Characteristics of LST Classification.
Mean and standard deviation of monthly LST (°C), LST anomaly (°C), monthly rainfall (mm), rainfall anomaly (mm), monthly ambient air temperature (°C), and monthly humidity (%) between previously defined groups of “heat wave,” “cold wave,” and “normal LST.” LST and rainfall anomalies refer to difference between observed monthly values and long-term means. p-values indicate significance values from Kruskal-Wallis Rank Sum tests among three groups. Note: *p ≤ 0.05, ** p ≤ 0.01, *** p ≤ 0.001 for Wilcoxon-test where “Normal LST” is considered the reference group.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pntd.0009182.s011
(DOCX)
S4 Table. Missing Data for Outcomes.
Missing data was excluded from the regression models.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pntd.0009182.s013
(DOCX)
Acknowledgments
This retrospective study assesses the effect of extreme climate events on mosquito abundance and DENV transmission in Kenya using data from a study performed by the LaBeaud Lab, Technical University of Mombasa, and the Kenya Medical Research Institute (KEMRI). Vector, climate, and disease data is housed in the Research Electronic Data Capture Database (REDCap) at Stanford University. The Stanford REDCap platform (http://redcap.stanford.edu) is operated by Stanford Medicine Research IT team.
References
- 1. McMichael AJ. Extreme weather events and infectious disease outbreaks. Virulence. 2015;6(6):543–7. pmid:26168924
- 2. Gubler DJ, Reiter P, Ebi KL, Yap W, Nasci R, Patz JA. Climate variability and change in the United States: potential impacts on vector- and rodent-borne diseases. Environmental Health Perspectives. 2001;109(suppl 2):223–33. pmid:11359689
- 3. Epstein PR. Climate change and human health. N Engl J Med. 2005;353(14):1433–6. pmid:16207843
- 4. Gage KL, Burkot TR, Eisen RJ, Hayes EB. Climate and vectorborne diseases. Am J Prev Med. 2008;35(5):436–50. pmid:18929970
- 5.
IPCC, 2014: Climate Change 2014: Synthesis Report. Contribution of Working Groups I, II and III to the Fifth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change [Core Writing Team, Pachauri R.K. and Meyer L.A. (eds.)]. IPCC, Geneva, Switzerland, 151 pp.
- 6. Chen SC, Hsieh MH. Modeling the transmission dynamics of dengue fever: implications of temperature effects. Sci Total Environ. 2012;431:385–91. pmid:22705874
- 7. Sumi A, Telan EF, Chagan-Yasutan H, Piolo MB, Hattori T, Kobayashi N. Effect of temperature, relative humidity and rainfall on dengue fever and leptospirosis infections in Manila, the Philippines. Epidemiol Infect. 2017;145(1):78–86. pmid:27608858
- 8.
World Health O. Dengue guidelines for diagnosis, treatment, prevention and control: new edition. Geneva: World Health Organization; 2009.
- 9. Bhatt S, Gething PW, Brady OJ, Messina JP, Farlow AW, Moyes CL, et al. The global distribution and burden of dengue. Nature. 2013;496(7446):504–7. pmid:23563266
- 10. Koenraadt CJ, Harrington LC. Flushing effect of rain on container-inhabiting mosquitoes Aedes aegypti and Culex pipiens (Diptera: Culicidae). J Med Entomol. 2008;45(1):28–35. pmid:18283939
- 11. Benedum CM, Seidahmed OME, Eltahir EAB, Markuzon N. Statistical modeling of the effect of rainfall flushing on dengue transmission in Singapore. PLoS Negl Trop Dis. 2018;12(12):e0006935. pmid:30521523
- 12. Duchet C, Moraru GM, Segev O, Spencer M, Hayoon AG, Blaustein L. Effects of flash flooding on mosquito and community dynamics in experimental pools. J Vector Ecol. 2017;42(2):254–63. pmid:29125248
- 13. Paaijmans KP, Wandago MO, Githeko AK, Takken W. Unexpected high losses of Anopheles gambiae larvae due to rainfall. PLoS One. 2007;2(11):e1146. pmid:17987125
- 14. Roiz D, Ruiz S, Soriguer R, Figuerola J. Climatic effects on mosquito abundance in Mediterranean wetlands. Parasites & Vectors. 2014;7(1):333. pmid:25030527
- 15. Shaman J, Stieglitz M, Stark C, Le Blancq S, Cane M. Using a dynamic hydrology model to predict mosquito abundances in flood and swamp water. Emerg Infect Dis. 2002;8(1):6–13. pmid:11749741
- 16. Linthicum KJ, Davies FG, Kairo A, Bailey CL. Rift Valley fever virus (family Bunyaviridae, genus Phlebovirus). Isolations from Diptera collected during an inter-epizootic period in Kenya. J Hyg (Lond). 1985;95(1):197–209. pmid:2862206
- 17. Roiz D, Philippe B, Simard F, Paupy C, Fontenille D. Autochthonous Chikungunya Transmission and Extreme Climate Events in Southern France. PLoS Negl Trop Dis. 2015;9:e0003854. pmid:26079620
- 18. Xu Z, Bambrick H, Yakob L, Devine G, Frentiu FD, Marina R, et al. Using dengue epidemics and local weather in Bali, Indonesia to predict imported dengue in Australia. Environmental Research. 2019;175:213–20. pmid:31136953
- 19. Subra R. The regulation of preimaginal populations of Aedes aegypti L. (Diptera: Culicidae) on the Kenya coast. I. Preimaginal population dynamics and the role of human behaviour. Ann Trop Med Parasitol. 1983;77(2):195–201. pmid:6882066
- 20. Brown L, Medlock J. Impact of drought on vector-borne diseases–how does one manage the risk? Public Health. 2013;128. pmid:24342133
- 21. Chretien JP, Anyamba A, Bedno SA, Breiman RF, Sang R, Sergon K, et al. Drought-associated chikungunya emergence along coastal East Africa. Am J Trop Med Hyg. 2007;76(3):405–7. pmid:17360859
- 22. Shapiro LLM, Whitehead SA, Thomas MB. Quantifying the effects of temperature on mosquito and parasite traits that determine the transmission potential of human malaria. PLoS Biol. 2017;15(10):e2003489. pmid:29036170
- 23. Mordecai EA, Cohen JM, Evans MV, Gudapati P, Johnson LR, Lippi CA, et al. Detecting the impact of temperature on transmission of Zika, dengue, and chikungunya using mechanistic models. PLoS Negl Trop Dis. 2017;11(4):e0005568. pmid:28448507
- 24. Anyamba A, Small JL, Britch SC, Tucker CJ, Pak EW, Reynolds CA, et al. Recent weather extremes and impacts on agricultural production and vector-borne disease outbreak patterns. PloS one. 2014;9(3):e92538–e. pmid:24658301
- 25. LaBeaud AD, Banda T, Brichard J, Muchiri EM, Mungai PL, Mutuku FM, et al. High rates of o’nyong nyong and Chikungunya virus transmission in coastal Kenya. PLoS Negl Trop Dis. 2015;9(2):e0003436. pmid:25658762
- 26. Vu DM, Banda T, Teng CY, Heimbaugh C, Muchiri EM, Mungai PL, et al. Dengue and West Nile Virus Transmission in Children and Adults in Coastal Kenya. The American journal of tropical medicine and hygiene. 2017;96(1):141–3. pmid:27821697
- 27.
World Meteorological Organization–WMO (2017), WMO Guidelines on the Calculation of Climate Normals, WMO, Geneva. Accessed 1 April 2020.
- 28. Ngugi HN, Mutuku FM, Ndenga BA, Musunzaji PS, Mbakaya JO, Aswani P, et al. Characterization and productivity profiles of Aedes aegypti (L.) breeding habitats across rural and urban landscapes in western and coastal Kenya. Parasites & Vectors. 2017;10(1):331. pmid:28701194
- 29. Li R, Xu L, Bjørnstad ON, Liu K, Song T, Chen A, et al. Climate-driven variation in mosquito density predicts the spatiotemporal dynamics of dengue. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2019;116(9):3624–9. pmid:30808752
- 30. Arcari P, Tapper N, Pfueller S. Regional variability in relationships between climate and dengue/DHF in Indonesia. Singapore Journal of Tropical Geography. 2007;28(3):251–72.
- 31. Wu PC, Guo HR, Lung SC, Lin CY, Su HJ. Weather as an effective predictor for occurrence of dengue fever in Taiwan. Acta Trop. 2007;103(1):50–7. pmid:17612499
- 32.
IPCC, 2012: Managing the Risks of Extreme Events and Disasters to Advance Climate Change Adaptation. A Special Report of Working Groups I and II of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change [Field C.B., Barros V., Stocker T.F., Qin D., Dokken D.J., Ebi K.L., Mastrandrea M.D., Mach K.J., Plattner G.-K., Allen S.K., Tignor M., and Midgley P.M. (eds.)]. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, United Kingdom and New York, NY, USA, 582 pp.
- 33. Wasko C, Sharma A. Global assessment of flood and storm extremes with increased temperatures. Scientific Reports. 2017;7(1):7945. pmid:28801569
- 34. Xu L, Stige LC, Chan KS, Zhou J, Yang J, Sang S, et al. Climate variation drives dengue dynamics. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2017 Jan 3;114(1):113–118. pmid:27940911
- 35. Tjaden NB, Thomas SM, Fischer D, Beierkuhnlein C. Extrinsic Incubation Period of Dengue: Knowledge, Backlog, and Applications of Temperature Dependence. PLoS Negl Trop Dis. 2013;7(6): e2207. pmid:23826399
- 36. Messina JP, Brady OJ, Golding N, Kraemer MUG, Wint GRW, Ray SE, et al. The current and future global distribution and population at risk of dengue. Nat Microbiol. 2019 Sep;4(9):1508–1515. pmid:31182801
- 37. Shah MM, Krystosik AR, Ndenga BA, Mutuku FM, Caldwell JM, Otuka V, et al. Malaria smear positivity among Kenyan children peaks at intermediate temperatures as predicted by ecological models. Parasites & Vectors. 2019;12(1):288. pmid:31171037
- 38. Shah MM, Ndenga BA, Mutuku FM, Vu DM, Grossi-Soyster EN, Okuta V, et al. High Dengue Burden and Circulation of 4 Virus Serotypes among Children with Undifferentiated Fever, Kenya, 2014–2017. Emerg Infect Dis. 2020;26(11):2638–2650. pmid:33079035