Figures
Abstract
Background
Chagas disease is endemic to the southern Andean region of Ecuador, an area with one of the highest poverty rates in the country. However, few studies have looked into the epidemiology, vectors and transmission risks in this region. In this study we describe the triatomine household infestation in Loja province, determine the rate of Trypanosoma cruzi infection in triatomines and study the risk factors associated with infestation.
Methodology/Principal Findings
An entomological survey found four triatomine species (Rhodnius ecuadoriensis, Triatoma carrioni, Panstrongylus chinai, and P. rufotuberculatus) infesting domiciles in 68% of the 92 rural communities examined. Nine percent of domiciles were infested, and nymphs were observed in 80% of the infested domiciles. Triatomines were found in all ecological regions below 2,200 masl. We found R. ecuadoriensis (275 to 1948 masl) and T. carrioni (831 to 2242 masl) mostly in bedrooms within the domicile, and they were abundant in chicken coops near the domicile. Established colonies of P. chinai (175 to 2003 masl) and P. rufotuberculatus (404 to 1613 masl) also were found in the domicile. Triatomine infestation was associated with surrogate poverty indicators, such as poor sanitary infrastructure (lack of latrine/toilet [w = 0.95], sewage to environment [w = 1.0]). Vegetation type was a determinant of infestation [w = 1.0] and vector control program insecticide spraying was a protective factor [w = 1.0]. Of the 754 triatomines analyzed, 11% were infected with Trypanosoma cruzi and 2% were infected with T. rangeli.
Conclusions/Significance
To date, only limited vector control efforts have been implemented. Together with recent reports of widespread sylvatic triatomine infestation and frequent post-intervention reinfestation, these results show that an estimated 100,000 people living in rural areas of southern Ecuador are at high risk for T. cruzi infection. Therefore, there is a need for a systematic, sustained, and monitored vector control intervention that is coupled with improvement of socio-economic conditions.
Author Summary
Chagas disease is a major health problem in Latin America. Its infectious agent, Trypanosoma cruzi, is transmitted mainly by the feces of insects called triatomines. Although great progress has been made in reducing transmission in the countries in the southern cone of South America, limited progress has been made in the Andean countries, partly because of lack of knowledge and partly because of limited resources and technical capability of control efforts. We report the first entomological survey conducted in southern Ecuador to learn the distribution of triatomines, their habitat and microhabitat preferences, and factors that favor their presence. The results of the study show that 9% of households in 92 rural communities harbor well-established triatomine populations. These rural areas in the southern Andean region are among the poorest in the country; most of the population lives in sub-standard housing, under conditions that favor the presence of Chagas disease vectors. These results, combined with recent reports of widespread triatomine infestation of wild animal nests in sylvatic areas throughout the region and frequent reports of reinfestation after control intervention, indicate the need for effective, monitored, and sustained vector control to reduce the high risk of infection to which approximately 100,000 people living in rural areas of southern Ecuador are exposed.
Citation: Grijalva MJ, Villacis AG, Ocaña-Mayorga S, Yumiseva CA, Moncayo AL, Baus EG (2015) Comprehensive Survey of Domiciliary Triatomine Species Capable of Transmitting Chagas Disease in Southern Ecuador. PLoS Negl Trop Dis 9(10): e0004142. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pntd.0004142
Editor: Eric Dumonteil, Universidad Autónoma de Yucatán, MEXICO
Received: May 18, 2015; Accepted: September 15, 2015; Published: October 6, 2015
Copyright: © 2015 Grijalva et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited
Data Availability: All relevant data are within the paper and its Supporting Information files.
Funding: This work received financial support from the UNICEF/UNPD/World Bank/WHO Special Programme for Research and Training in Tropical Diseases (TDR) [A20785], Pan American Health Organization [A60655], the National Chagas Control Program-Ecuadorian Ministry of Health, Pontifical Catholic University of Ecuador [http://www.puce.edu.ec], Plan Internacional Ecuador [http://www.plan.org.ec/], Childrens Heartlink USA [http://www.childrensheartlink.org/] and the Division of Microbiology and Infectious Diseases, National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, National Institutes of Health (DMID/NIADID/NIH) [AI077896-01]. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Introduction
Chagas disease constitutes a serious problem in Latin America, where it has been estimated that about 10 million people are infected with the causative parasite, Trypanosoma cruzi [1]. Important advances have been made in reducing transmission by the vector Triatoma infestans, particularly in countries within the southern cone of South America [1], [2], [3], and Rhodinus prolixus in Central America [4],[5]. However, limited progress has been achieved in Ecuador, where neither accurate estimations of prevalence nor of people at risk of becoming infected by T. cruzi currently exist.
In Ecuador, there is limited understanding of Chagas disease incidence and prevalence, and vector distribution and biology. Loja Province, located in the southern portion of the Andean region, has long been considered endemic for Chagas disease, but few studies had been focused there. However, some recent efforts have aimed to fill knowledge gaps about this region. For example, previously, little was known about the extent to which Chagas is a problem; now studies have found that 35% of households in some areas of Loja are infested with triatomines and cited seroprevalences of 3.6% and 3.9% [6], [7]. However, the sample size and geographical coverage of these serological studies prevent them from being representative of the entire region. In addition, there is ample documentation of the presence of T. cruzi infected sylvatic triatomine populations in this region [8].
Loja Province encompasses about 11,100 km2 characterized by a mix of hilly and mountainous topography that ranges from 150 to 3,800 meters above sea level (masl). This province has approximately 448,966 inhabitants, of which 58% live in rural areas. The main economic activity in this region is agriculture, especially coffee (Coffea arabica), corn (Zea mays), peanut (Arachis hypogaea), and tree fruit. Poverty, defined as “unmet basic needs,” has been estimated at 60.1% for Ecuador overall and 83.4% for rural areas. In Loja, the prevalence of rural poverty is estimated to be 93.2% (all classified as chronic poverty). Indeed, several counties within this province exhibit the highest poverty rates in the country [9–11]
In Ecuador, 16 species of triatomines have been reported [12]. Studies in Loja province have documented a high prevalence of household infestation and colonization mainly by Rhodnius ecuadoriensis and Triatoma carrioni, and to a lesser extent household infestation without colonization by Panstrongylus chinai, P. rufotuberculatus, and Eratyrus mucronatus [6]. In addition, sylvatic R. ecuadoriensis highly infected with T. cruzi were recently reported in this region in association with squirrel nests [8,13].
This report presents the results of a province-wide survey designed to document the distribution of domiciliary triatomine infestation in Loja Province, describe the microhabitats where triatomines are found, determine the rate of trypanosome infection of triatomines, and study the risk factors associated with household infestation.
Methods
Study area
We visited 92 rural communities in all 16 counties of Loja Province between 2005 and 2009 (Fig 1). Community selection was based on a combination of a geographical location and accessibility. The sampled domiciles were at an altitude ranging from 150 to 2440 masl and included five vegetation zones: deciduous forest, semi-deciduous forest, green low mountain forest, cloud forest, and dry mountain bush forest [14].
Location of each community surveyed is marked. The size of the symbol corresponds to the % of houses infested with triatomines in each community. The colors represent the four triatomine species found: Red = R. ecuadoriensis, blue = T. carrioni, green = P. rufotuberculatus and yellow = P. chinai. Classification of ecological regions as per Sierra et al [14].
Ethics statement
Written informed consent was obtained from the head of the household following protocols approved by the institutional review boards of Ohio University and Pontifical Catholic University of Ecuador, and triatomines were collected under Ecuadorian collection permit N° 002–07 IC-FAU-DNBAPVS/MA.
Household surveys
We visited all domiciles in each community (n = 4,782). The location of each domicile was recorded using GPS receivers (Garmin, Etrex), and photos were taken of the four sides of each domicile. We documented house construction materials and characteristics of the peridomestic area. A questionnaire was administered to the head of the household that included questions about livestock and insecticide spraying, among others. In 2008, the questionnaire was abridged to make it compatible with a common questionnaire being prepared by the Surveillance and Information Systems workgroup for use in endemic countries as part of the Chagas Disease initiative created by the Neglected Diseases Division of the World Health Organization (www.who.int).
Community education
We delivered a 10-min educational talk about triatomines and Chagas disease at each house (3,191 DUs), supported by a booklet for each family member. The booklet contained color life-size pictures of adults and nymphs of local triatomine species, cartoon- and text-based explanations about triatomine feeding, T. cruzi transmission via feces, drawings of favored triatomine habitats in the intra and peridomicile, games (search the triatomine labyrinth, triatomine color, cut and paste, draw activities and word puzzle), instructions on how to safely collect and report triatomine infestation to the local health promoter, information about Chagas disease signs and symptoms, and practical recommendations to prevent triatomine infestation. A calendar (passive detection device) with educational information was affixed to one of the bedroom walls, usually near the bed. Educational talks, reinforced by presentation of a video, participatory classroom activities, and outdoor didactic games were conducted at the elementary schools in each community. This study does not include the evaluation of the effectiveness of these activities.
Triatomine collection
Two-person teams searched domiciles and peridomiciles during one hour (30 minutes in each area) using a modification of the one-man-hour method previously described [6,15]. Briefly, if no bugs were found after the initial 20-min search, the searches were continued for an additional 10 min with the use of 6% aqueous pyrethrin solution (PRENTOX, ExciteR, Prentiss Inc., Sandesville, GA, USA). This solution was hand-sprayed in cracks and crevices as an irritant to prompt the exit of triatomines and increase collection efficiency [16]. Collected triatomines were placed in individually labeled plastic containers and transported to either the field laboratory or the insectary of the Center for Infectious and Chronic Disease Research at Pontifical Catholic University of Ecuador in Quito. Details of the insects’ place of capture (intra- or peridomicile and microhabitat), species, number of insects found dead or alive, and insects’ developmental stages were noted by each team in the field and corroborated by trained entomologists at the field laboratory [17], [18]. If live triatomines were found in or around the domicile, both environments were sprayed. Kitchen wares, food, bedding, clothes, and personal items were removed from infested domiciles before complete indoor and outdoor spraying of all surfaces of the dwellings and peridomestic structures. Spraying was done with 5% deltamethrin WP that was applied at 25 mg/m2 by trained personnel from the National Chagas Control program using Hudson X-pert sprayers (H. D. Hudson Manufacturing Co., Houston, TX). We instructed inhabitants to leave bedding and clothes exposed to direct sunlight and not to enter the dwelling for at least one hour after the spraying. At the end of the day, each team stored the remaining insecticide and the water used to wash the spraying equipment in a plastic container for use the following day [15].
Natural infection with trypanosomes
Intestinal content of live triatomines was analyzed for the presence of Trypanosoma sp. by microscopy and PCR as previously described [8]. This procedure allows for discrimination between T. cruzi and T. rangeli and each PCR reaction was run with a positive control for T. cruzi, T. rangeli and a reagent control (without DNA). The infection index (100 x number of infected individuals/total number of analysed individuals) was calculated for each type of microhabitat. Trypanosoma cruzi discrete typing units (DTU) were characterized as previously described [19]. The sensibility and specificity (95% CI) of microscopy for detecting Trypanosoma sp. (T. cruzi and/or T. rangeli) infection in triatomines were calculated using PCR as the gold standard. The level of agreement between the two techniques was estimated by the Kappa index (k).
Data management
House surveys were entered into a Microsoft Access database (Office 2003) using custom made data entry forms and the data was then exported to Excel (Office 2003). Entomological field and laboratory results were entered into Excel spreadsheets. Datasets were manually and independently compared twice with the source documents to ensure accuracy. Datasets were imported and merged into Statistical Package for the Social Sciences v17.0 (SPSS, Inc., Chicago, IL). Frequencies were calculated to identify outliers or response inconsistencies. Discrepancies related to house characteristics were resolved by examination of digital pictures taken of the domicile and peridomicile at every DU. Discrepancies that could not be resolved due to illegible hand writing in the forms or other obvious errors were eliminated from the data sets and reported as missing values.
Data analysis
The distribution of each triatomine species was described in terms of the ecological zones and altitude where they were found. We also noted where several species overlapped. The following entomological indexes were calculated for only live triatomines: Infestation rate (100 x number of houses infested /number of houses searched), density (number of triatomines captured/number of houses searched), crowding (number of triatomines captured/number of houses infested), and colonization index (100 x number of houses with nymphs/number of houses infested) [20].
We conducted a descriptive analysis of the variables in the household surveys to characterize the domiciles and the extent of the infestation.
A multimodel inference approach based on Akaike’s Information Criterion (AIC) [21] was used to identify the strongest determinants for intradomicile and peridomicile infestation by R. ecuadoriensis and T. carrioni. First, for each outcome, we fit three subset of models: 1) only-household level covariates (roof, floor and wall materials, presence of toilet, type of sewage and water, crowding, cooking fuel, self-reported and vector control program insecticide spraying and intradomicile storage of firewood and agriculture products); 2) only domestic animals covariates (dogs, cats, guinea pigs, pigs and sheep/goats); 3) only peridomicile covariates (vegetation: bushes, brush/scrub and fruit trees and accumulation of: firewood, wool for construction, rock/brick piles, household trash, agriculture refuse and products). Unfortunately, important variables such as: roof and floor material construction, cooking fuel, type of sewage, sheep/goats were not included in the model for peridomicile infestation by T. carrioni because zero or small numbers in some categories. For the same reason, presence of chickens were not included in models for any bugs. Second, among each subset the models we selected variables according their relative importance (w>0.35) for predicting DUs infestation in order to fit the final models. Vegetation type variable was included in all final models. Final models considering every possible combination of selected variables were run: 12 variables gave 4096 models for intradomicile infestation by R. ecuadoriensis, 13 variables gave 8192 models for peridomicile infestation by R. ecuadoriensis and intradomicile infestation for T. carrioni and 9 variables gave 512 models for peridomicile infestation by T. carrioni.
The Akaike’s weight (wi) of each model was calculated as the quotient of the log-likehood of the particular model divided by the total sum of the log-likehood of all considered models. The relative importance of a particular variable (w) was then calculated as the sum of Akaike weights of all models that contained this particular variable. Variables with w>0.9 were considered of high importance in defining DUs infestation, variables with 0.7<w<0.9 were considered of secondary importance and variables with w<0.7 had limited contributions.
Finally, we performed model averaging to estimate weighted mean effect-sizes estimates (OR, 95% CI) resulted from averaging the parameter value in each model where the variable was present weighted by the Akaike weight of the respective model.
Descriptive analysis was conducted using Statistical Package for the Social Sciences v17.0 (SPSS, Inc., Chicago, IL). Multimodel inference and model averaging were performed in the software R (v. 2.12.1).
Results
Distribution of triatomines by species, ecological region, and altitude
The most common species was R. ecuadoriensis, which was found in 59% of the 63 infested communities. All R. ecuadoriensis-infested communities were located in the central and western portions of Loja at altitudes ranging from 275 to 1,948 masl (Fig 1) and encompassing four ecological zones: deciduous forest (60% of communities examined were infested, n = 20), semi-deciduous forest (33%, n = 43), green low mountain forest (47%, n = 15), and dry mountain bush forest (33%, n = 12). The second most common species was T. carrioni, which was found in 41% of infested communities. T. carrioni infestation was dominant in the northern and southern areas of the province. Overall, this species was found infesting domiciles at altitudes ranging from 831 to 2,242 masl and encompassing three ecological zones: semi-deciduous forest (30%), green low mountain forest (27%), and dry mountain bush forest (75%). Although less abundant, P. chinai was found in 32% of infested communities at domiciles located in a wide range of altitude (175 to 2,003 masl) and four ecological zones: deciduous forest (35%), semi-deciduous forest (19%), green low mountain forest (27%), and dry mountain bush forest (8%). Finally, P. rufotuberculatus was found in 11% of the infested communities in domiciles located at altitudes ranging from 404 to 1,613 masl and in three ecological zones: deciduous forest (5%), semi-deciduous forest (12%), and green low mountain forest (7%). Thus, simultaneous infestation of species occurred in many communities: R. ecuadoriensis and P. chinai were both found in 24% of infested communities; R. ecuadoriensis was also found with T. carrioni in 13% of infested communities and with P. rufotuberculatus in 3%. P. chinai was found with T. carrioni in 6% of infested communities and with P. rufotuberculatus in 2% (Fig 1). Triatomine infestation was not found in the two communities located in the cloud forest ecological zone.
Infestation indexes
Four species of triatomines, R. ecuadoriensis, T. carrioni, P. chinai, and P. rufotuberculatus, were found in or around 8.8% of the domiciles examined (S1 Table). A total of 11,115 live triatomines, 372 dead triatomines, and 614 triatomine eggs were collected. Only live triatomines were included in the analyses. The density was 3.5 insects per examined domicile, the crowding was 39 bugs per infested domicile, and the colonization index was 80% (S1 Table). Triatomines were found in 68% of the 92 communities searched. Twenty (32%) of the 63 infested communities had infestation rates between 10% and 20%, ten (16%) presented infestation rates between 20% and 30%, and 4 (6%) presented infestation rates higher than 30% (S1 Table). The highest infestation rate (48%) was found in Chaquizhca, Calvas County. The highest density (46.5 bugs per domicile searched) and crowding (270 bugs per infested domicile) were found in Tacoranga, Paltas county. A 100% colonization index was observed in 51% of the infested communities (32 of 63; S1 Table).
Species-specific entomological indexes and habitat
R. ecuadoriensis was found infesting 4.1% of searched domiciles. This species showed a preference for the peridomestic habitat, where it was 11 times more abundant than in the domestic habitat (Table 1). Thus, infestation, colonization (presence of nymphs), density, and crowding by this species were higher in the peridomicile than in the domicile. T. carrioni was found in 3.4% of searched domiciles. Although 1.5 times more bugs were captured in the peridomicile than in the domicile, the number of houses with intradomiciliary infestation was 2.4 times higher than those with peridomiciliary infestation. Nevertheless, all entomological indexes were higher in the peridomicile. Conversely, the less abundant P. chinai and P. rufotuberculatus were found mostly in the intradomicile and had significantly lower colonization indexes (Table 1).
Species-specific microhabitat preferences
R. ecuadoriensis was found to have clear preference for chicken nests in the peridomicile (91% of insects collected). In the intradomicile, this species was found mostly in or near the bed (89%) and was less commonly associated with chicken nests (4%) and guinea pigs (3%) kept inside the house. Similarly, T. carrioni was found mostly associated with chicken nests (64%) in the peridomicile and to a lesser degree, was also found in guinea pig pens, dog houses, and piles of wood, bricks, and firewood (22%). In the domicile, this species was found primarily in the bedroom (86%), with some infestation also in indoor chicken nests and guinea pig pens (8%). The less abundant P. chinai was found mostly in microhabitats located in the bedroom (75%) and in indoor guinea pig pens (10%). Finally, P. rufotuberculatus was found mainly in the bedroom (82%).
Species-specific population structure
Fig 2 shows the population structure of each species collected. An abundance of R. ecuadoriensis and T. carrioni nymphal instars was found in and around domiciles, indicating that these were well established populations that were actively reproducing. Although with significantly fewer individuals, similar results were found for P. chinai in both domestic and peridomestic habitats and for P. rufotuberculatus in the domestic habitat. Males and females were found in similar proportions for all species within each habitat except for P. rufotuberculatus, for which more females were found.
Number of live Nymphal I—V instars and adult female and male bugs collected in domestic (Dom) and peridomestic (Peri) habitats. A) R. ecuadoriensis, B) T. carrioni, C) P. chinai and D) P. rufotuberculatus.
Characteristics of domiciles
The average population of each community was approximately 240 people. We visited 4,782 domiciles. Of these, 3,191 (67%) were examined for the presence of triatomines. The main reason for failing to search a house was that the house was closed or the head of the household was absent at the time of visit (66%). Other reasons were that the house was uninhabited (25%) or the head of the household refused to participate in this study (9%). House characteristics can be found in Table 2. Table 3 shows the characteristics of the peridomicile, including the presence or absence of accumulated materials and their distance from the domicile, and Table 4 shows the presence and median number of domestic animals and livestock. The vast majority of domiciles had chickens (91%), usually roosting in coops or pens located immediately adjacent to the domicile’s walls or between large roof eaves. Although dogs were common, only 5% of domiciles reported that dogs slept indoors. Cats were also common (57%) but often lived in a semi-feral condition. Finally, guinea pigs (Cavia porcellus) were kept by 25% of domiciles either for consumption or to be sold in the market. Most guinea pigs were kept either in pens adjacent to the domicile (83%) or roaming free within the house.
Risk factors for triatomine infestation
Data for factors associated with triatomine infestation in bivariate analysis are provided in S2 Table. The Akaike weight of each variable in the average model indicated that three variables could be considered of high importance in defining intradomicile infestation by R. ecuadoriensis with w > 0.9, one additional variable were of secondary importance with 0.7 < w < 0.9, and the remaining had limited contributions (Table 5). Houses with presence of pigs showed a high risk of infestation and had a very high weight (w = 1.0). Similarly, vegetation type was a very important variable (w = 1.0). Houses located in the green low mountain forest had a higher risk to be infested. Number of bedrooms >2 was a major protective factor (w = 1.0). A risk factor of secondary importance was keeping sheep/goats in peridomicile (w = 0.76)–it result in a 1.9 fold higher risk of infestation by R. ecuadoriensis. Finally, the lack of latrine/toilet (w = 0.67), the storage of agricultural products (w = 0.59) inside house and the presence of fruit trees (w = 0.68) and brush/scrub (w = 0.54) in the peridomicile had very minor weights in the model and may thus be of limited relevance as determinants for R. ecuadoriensis intradomicile infestation.
Important factors that increased the risk of peridomicile infestation by R. ecuadoriensis were: presence of pigs (w = 1.0), vegetation type (w = 1.0), self-reported insecticide spraying (w = 1.0), accumulation of agricultural products in the peridomicile (w = 0.97) and lack of latrine or toilet (w = 0.95) (Table 5). Vector control program insecticide spraying (w = 1.0) and presence of guinea pigs (w = 0.99) had a negative association with peridomicile infestation. Accumulation of firewood in the peridomicile evidenced a moderately high relative importance (w = 0.72) and a positive association with peridomicile infestation (Table 5).
The most relevant factors positively associated with T. carrioni intradomicile infestation (Table 6) were: sewage to environment (w = 1.0), keeping guinea pigs (w = 0.99) and presence of fruit trees in the peridomicile (w = 1.0). Vegetation type was also a high importance variable in defining infestation (w = 1.0). In addition, households located in the dry mountain forest and green low mountain forest result in 2.05 and 1.67 higher risk of infestation, respectively, when compared to households located in semi deciduous forest (reference category). A secondary predictor that increase the risk of infestation were dirt floor (w = 0.77) whereas well drinking water decrease the risk (w = 0.73). Other less important factors were: firewood cooking fuel (w = 0.55), presence of pigs (w = 0.52), self-reporting insecticide spraying (w = 0.46), presence of sheep/goats (w = 0.42), number of bedrooms >2 (w = 0.39) and accumulation of household trash in the peridomicile (w = 0.36).
Vegetation type was a major determinant of peridomicile infestation by T. carrioni (w = 1.00) (Table 6). Households located in green low mountain forest had higher risk of infestation. Accumulation of household trash in peridomicile was a secondary factor in defining peridomicile (w = 0.7) infestation with a high protective effect. Variables that showed limited importance were: accumulation of rocks/bricks (w = 0.63) and firewood (w = 0.57) in the peridomicile, well drinking water (w = 0.52), self-reported insecticide spraying (w = 0.51), presence of bush or scrub (w = 0.38) and fruit trees (w = 0.37) in the peridomicile.
Natural infection of triatomines by trypanosomes
Of the 754 triatomines examined, 10.6% were infected with T. cruzi and 1.7% were infected with T. rangeli (Table 7). All T. cruzi isolates that were genotyped belong to the DTU TcI.
Three out of the four species of triatomine collected presented infection with T. cruzi. R. ecuadoriensis and P. chinai showed high rates of infection, 14.4% and 12.8%, respectively; while T. carrioni presented 6% of infection. No Trypanosoma sp. were detected in the 12 P. rufotuberculatus individuals that were examined.
Overall, higher infection rates with T. cruzi were detected in the domicile (11.9%) than in the peridomicile (9.5%). This tendency was evident especially in R. ecuadoriensis which showed three times higher infection in the domicile (29.7%) than in the peridomicile (10%). In P. chinai the infection rate in the domicile was 13.6% while 9.5% in the peridomicile. T. carrioni presented a different tendency in which the infection in the peridomicile (8.3%) was higher than in the domicile (4.5%) (Table 7).
Although less frequent, T. rangeli infection was detected in the three species in the domicile but only infecting R. ecuadoriensis and P. chinai in the peridomicile. Mixed infections with T. cruzi and T. rangeli were detected in all three species in rates <1%.
Among the 751 specimens tested using both methods, 42 (5.6%) were positive by microscopy for trypanosomatids (determined by the presence of flagellates in the thick smear of intestinal content) and 90 (12.0%) were positive (for the presence of T. cruzi and T. rangeli) by PCR (Table 8). The sensitivity of microscopy was 30.0% (IC 95% 20.8–40.6) and the specificity was 97.7% (IC 95% 96.3–98.7). The two methods had a poor degree of agreement (κappa = -0.3422, p > 0.05).
Discussion
This first comprehensive survey of triatomines in southern Ecuador found intradomiciliary and peridomiciliary infestation by R. ecuadoriensis, T. carrioni, P. chinai, and P. rufotuberculatus in all ecological zones below 2,200 masl in Loja Province. Triatomine infestation was characterized by high rates of colonization, indicating a well-adapted and thriving bug population. Triatomines were readily recognized by the population as a nuisance and inflammatory reactions to bites were recounted. Infestation was mainly associated with presence of domestic animals (guinea pigs and pigs), poor sanitary infrastructure, accumulation of agricultural products outdoors and presence of fruit trees outdoors. Houses located in the green low mountain forest and dry mountain forest had a higher risk to be infested. Vector control program insecticide spraying was a major protective factor. However, the fact that most variables studied have either none or weak association with triatomine infestation could be related to overall abundance of substandard living environments through rural areas of Loja province, where 93.2% of the population lives in chronic poverty otherwise defined as unmeet basic needs [11]. Triatomine infestation was higher in some counties of the province, specifically Calvas, Celica, Espíndola, Gonzanamá, Paltas, and Quilanga. Poverty among the population living in these counties ranges from 70 to 90%, some the highest in Loja Province and Ecuador[11]. Among infested communities, more than half had infestation rates higher than 10%; one-third had infestation rates higher than 20%. When coupled with the finding of a 10.6% rate of T. cruzi infection in collected triatomines, these findings indicate a high risk of transmission of T. cruzi in Loja Province.
The results of this study corroborate and expand on previous reports regarding triatomines in southern Ecuador [6,8,13]. Although triatomines were found in all ecological regions below 2,200 masl, there were clear ranges of altitude: R. ecuadoriensis was found below 1,800 masl and T. carrioni at altitudes above 800 masl. The fact that there was significant geographic overlap between species, especially R. ecuadoriensis and P. chinai, and R. ecuadoriensis and T. carrioni needs to be taken into consideration for the monitoring and evaluation of vector control interventions.
R. ecuadoriensis and T. carrioni were found more frequently than P. chinai and P. rufotuberculatus, leading us to conclude that while all four species can colonize domiciles, R. ecuadoriensis and T. carrioni are particularly adapted to do so. Previous reports have indicated that P. chinai and P. rufotuberculatus are primarily sylvatic [6],[22],[23]. However, our findings of colonization indexes of 63% for P. chinai and 58% for P. rufotuberculatus, plus populations with individuals of all nymphal instar stages, indicate domiciliation. The adaptation of P. chinai to reproduction in synanthropic habitats, coupled with a 12.8% T. cruzi infection rate, indicates that these species could become important vectors if they occupy the ecological niches that may be left open as a result of control interventions targeted toward other species.
While earlier reports [6],[12],[24] suggested that triatomines in Loja province are found only in domestic and peridomestic habitats, T. cruzi infected sylvatic R. ecuadoriensis has since been documented throughout the province [8,13]. To date we have not found any sylvatic P. chinai or T. carrioni in this region. Preliminary analyses indicate that the abundance of domestic/peridomestic infestation correlates with the abundance of sylvatic R. ecuadoriensis, which has important implications for control interventions in terms of reinfestation risk and early detection of this process. Our previous results suggest that there is flow of R. ecuadoriensis from the sylvatic to the domestic environments [25]. This is somewhat similar to what has been previously reported for T. infestans in Bolivia [26]. It will be interesting to further study the potential role of peridomestic structures as barriers for domestic infestation as previously proposed for T. infestans [27].
The presence of T. rangeli in this area has been previously reported [8,28]. In our study, a relatively low T. rangeli infection was observed in three of the four species of triatomines examined. The presence of this parasite is important for two reasons: First T. rangeli is widely believed to be pathogenic to triatomines, and thus might affect the survival and strength of bug populations. Second, transmission of this parasite via direct inoculation during feeding is more effective than T. cruzi transmission via contaminated feces. Although the persistence of the parasite in vertebrate blood appears to be transient, the presence of anti-T. rangeli antibodies might be a confounding factor for epidemiological studies [29].
In general, the detection of infection with trypanosomes (T. cruzi and T. rangeli) by microscopy was less sensitive than PCR. Moreover, the identification of the species of trypanosomes present in thick smears of intestinal content proved difficult and mixed infections were not detected by microscopy.
The high infestation rate found in our study is consistent with a recent report of 7.1% anti-T. cruzi seropositivity among school children <10 years of age found in Loja Province; in that study the rate of seropositivity was lower in older age groups, suggesting a fairly recent increase in transmission rates in this region [30]. Earlier studies had found seroprevalence in Loja Province to be 3.9% and 3.6% [6],[7]. Previous risk factor analysis for anti-T. cruzi seroprevalence in Ecuador includes data from Loja Province. The results show weak association of house construction materials, but not characteristics of the peridomicile, with anti-T. cruzi seropositivity [7],[30]. The power of analyses based on seropositivity is limited due to it being a cumulative measure of exposure to T. cruzi. In spite of the probable existence of congenital transmission in this area, the current analysis based on the presence of the vector is more appropriate to determine factors related to current T. cruzi transmission risk.
One of the major problems faced by field research surveys is quality control of the efforts. To address this problem, theoretical and practical training was provided to field personnel of the National Chagas Disease Program and the National Vector Control Services from many regions of the country. In addition, field teams were often accompanied by either Ecuadorian students and staff from Pontifical Catholic University of Ecuador and/or foreign students participating in Education Abroad programs organized by the Tropical Disease Institute at Ohio University.
Before the visit by our research team, knowledge about Chagas disease and its vectors was consistently low to nonexistent among the population in this region [6]. The process of searching for triatomines is highly disruptive to inhabitants of the domicile being examined. Besides the understandable resistance to allowing strangers to enter and search a house, the process is time consuming (at least 60 min). Moreover, if a domicile is found to be infested, it needs to be prepared with help from the inhabitants and then sprayed with insecticide (at least an additional 60 min). However, the educational efforts of this study, which employed interactive delivery of knowledge at each household and at schools, were well received. These community education efforts increased the acceptance of the entomological survey and produced an important commitment to community-based triatomine surveillance. Indeed, a pilot surveillance system was put in place in 34 communities in 2006, which during the next 12 months produced frequent reports of triatomine infestation and reinfestation. Regretfully, the program had to be discontinued in 2007 due to the lack of action and response to these reports by local vector control services. Nevertheless, this approach was proved to be feasible and effective at the community level and should be an integral part of future control efforts.
The results of this study probably would be extended to northern Peru, particularly in Piura province, which has similar ecological characteristics, human habitation, and vector species [31],[32]. Interestingly, a recent report by Alroy et. al [33] only found P. lignarius (formely P. herreri) in four communities located further south, in Cutervo Province in northern Peru. However, we did not find this species in our study in southern Ecuador. Current research by our group is aimed at understanding the T. cruzi transmission cycles in the southern region of Ecuador via examination of the genetic relationships among and between triatomine populations occupying domestic, peridomestic, and sylvatic habitats and the trypanosomes that infect vectors, reservoirs, and humans [19]. Future efforts will be aimed at increasing the capacity of the local health care system to detect, accurately diagnose, and treat acute and chronic Chagas disease[34].
Overall implication for public health and control efforts
Chagas disease has historically been associated with poverty [35],[36]. The results of this study reinforce this notion. Estimating the actual risk of T. cruzi transmission in southern Ecuador would be very complex. However, the national census conducted in Ecuador in 2010 shows that Loja province has 155,046 domiciles of which 39% (60,420) are located in rural areas below 2,200 masl[11]. Therefore, taking into consideration only the population data of rural parishes below 2200 masl, about 155,533 people live in areas where triatomines are present. Moreover, an estimated 18,622 rural households have dirt floors, 24,562 have adobe walls and 13,536 dwellings lack any form of sanitation [10,11]. Consequently, approximately 98,248 people living in Loja province are exposed to a high risk of T. cruzi transmission due to an increased risk of triatomine infestation.
The situation is complicated by recent findings that indicate a high rate of triatomine reinfestation as early as six months year after insecticide is applied by spraying [37]. The high household reinfestation observed could be explained by the widespread presence of sylvatic R. ecuadoriensis in this region [13]. Morphometric analysis shows that the sylvatic populations of this species have high adaptive plasticity that allows them to readily establish colonies in houses and their surroundings [25].
Our findings support the conclusion that transmission of T. cruzi is actively occurring in Loja Province. Presently, government control efforts in this region are hampered by an ineffective local administration that had carried out minimal and uncoordinated triatomine control activities tangential to mosquito control. To date, the only substantial triatomine control efforts have been limited to the joint activities undertaken by our academic research group with support from the National Chagas Control Program. The results of this study provide important information to the National Chagas Control Program and the Ministry of Health whom should step up their vector surveillance and control activities in this region. Moreover, these results should prompt the implementation of a renewed effort to conduct seroprevalence studies and to provide this region with currently lacking Chagas disease diagnostic and treatment capacity.
A systematic, sustained, and monitored vector control intervention that incorporates community education and community-based surveillance, and that addresses the socio-economic structural causes of poverty with particular attention to substandard housing construction, needs to be implemented in southern Ecuador.
Supporting Information
S1 Table. Entomological indexes and altitude range of triatomine infestation in rural communities of Loja Province.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pntd.0004142.s001
(DOCX)
S2 Table. Bivariate analysis of house and peridomestic characteristics, livestock and rodent/marsupial pests with triatomine infestation in rural communities of Loja Province.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pntd.0004142.s002
(DOCX)
Acknowledgments
Technical assistance was provided by Mauricio Lascano, Paula Castellanos and Victor Heh from Ohio University, Alejandra Zurita from the Pontifical Catholic University of Ecuador, the personnel from the National Chagas Control Program, National Service for Malaria Eradication (SNEM), Ecuadorian Ministry of Health. This research benefited from international collaboration through the ECLAT network and technical advice from Christopher Schofield. Training in insecticide application was provided to field workers by Manuel Lluberas from H. D. Hudson Manufacturing Company USA. Assistance on data management, data analyses, and manuscript preparation was provided by Mario Chen, Suzanne Fischer, Patrick Murphy and Kenneth F. Schulz from Family Health International and the International Clinical Sciences Support Center (ICSSC), under contract to the Division of Microbiology and Infectious Diseases, National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, National Institutes of Health (DMID/NIADID/NIH).
Author Contributions
Conceived and designed the experiments: MJG AGV. Performed the experiments: MJG AGV CAY EGB SOM. Analyzed the data: MJG AGV SOM CAY ALM. Wrote the paper: MJG AGV SOM CAY ALM EGB.
References
- 1. Schofield CJ, Jannin J, Salvatella R (2006) The future of Chagas disease control. Trends Parasitol 22: 583–588. pmid:17049308
- 2. Rojas de Arias A (2007) Social and epidemiological determinants of Chagas disease: basic information for a surveillance and control policy in the Southern Cone. Mem Inst Oswaldo Cruz 102 Suppl 1: 19–21. pmid:17891279
- 3. Amelotti I, Catala SS, Gorla DE (2009) Response of Triatoma infestans to pour-on cypermethrin applied to chickens under laboratory conditions. Mem Inst Oswaldo Cruz 104: 481–485. pmid:19547876
- 4. Dias JC, Silveira AC, Schofield CJ (2002) The impact of Chagas disease control in Latin America: a review. Mem Inst Oswaldo Cruz 97: 603–612. pmid:12219120
- 5. Coura JR (2009) Present situation and new strategies for Chagas disease chemotherapy: a proposal. Mem Inst Oswaldo Cruz 104: 549–554. pmid:19722074
- 6. Grijalva MJ, Palomeque-Rodriguez FS, Costales JA, Davila S, Arcos-Teran L (2005) High household infestation rates by synanthropic vectors of Chagas disease in southern Ecuador. J Med Entomol 42: 68–74. pmid:15691011
- 7. Black CL, Ocana S, Riner D, Costales JA, Lascanro MS, et al. (2007) Household risk factors for Trypanosoma cruzi seropositivity in two geographic regions of Ecuador. J Parasitol 93: 12–16. pmid:17436937
- 8. Grijalva MJ, Suarez-Davalos V, Villacis AG, Ocana-Mayorga S, Dangles O (2012) Ecological factors related to the widespread distribution of sylvatic Rhodnius ecuadoriensis populations in southern Ecuador. Parasites & Vectors 5.
- 9.
(2003) Informe Social 2003. Desarrollo Social y Pobreza en el Ecuador, 1990–2001. Quito: SIISE. http://www.siise.gov.ec/Publicaciones/2inf7.pdf. Accessed 3 February 2010.
- 10.
(2010) Sistema Integrado de Indicadores Sociales del Ecuador. Quito: SIISE. http://www.siise.gov.ec/Principal.aspx. Accessed 10 March 2010.
- 11.
INEC (2010) Resultados del Censo 2010 de Población y Vivienda en el Ecuador. www.inec.gob.ec: Instituto Nacional de Estadistica y Censo.
- 12. Abad-Franch F, Paucar A, Carpio C, Cuba CA, Aguilar HM, et al. (2001) Biogeography of Triatominae (Hemiptera: Reduviidae) in Ecuador: implications for the design of control strategies. Mem Inst Oswaldo Cruz 96: 611–620. pmid:11500757
- 13. Grijalva MJ, Villacis AG (2009) Presence of Rhodnius ecuadoriensis in sylvatic habitats in the southern highlands (Loja Province) of Ecuador. J Med Entomol 46: 708–711. pmid:19496445
- 14.
Sierra R (1999) Propuesta preliminar de un sistema de clasificación de vegetación para el Ecuador Continental. Quito: Proyecto INEFAN/ BIRF y Ecociencia.
- 15.
Schofield CJ (2001) Field Testing and Evaluation of Insecticides for Indoor Residual Spraying against domestic vectors of Chagas Disease. Geneva: World Health Organization.
- 16. Grijalva MJ, Villacis AG, Ocana-Mayorga S, Yumiseva CA, Baus EG (2011) Limitations of selective deltamethrin application for triatomine control in central coastal Ecuador. Parasit Vectors 4: 20. pmid:21332985
- 17. Lent H, P. W (1979) Revision of the Triatominae (Hemiptera: Reduviidae), and their significance as vectors of Chagas disease. Bulletin of the American Museum of Natural History 163: 123–520.
- 18.
Carcavallo RU, Galíndez-Giron I, Jurberg J, Galvao C, Lent H (1998) Pictorial keys for tribes, genera and species of the subfamily Triatominae. In: Carcavallo RU, Galíndez-Giron I, Jurberg J, Lent H, editors. Atlas of Chagas´ Disease Vectors in the Americas. Rio de Janeiro: Editora Fiocruz. pp. 107–244.
- 19. Ocana-Mayorga S, Llewellyn MS, Costales JA, Miles MA, Grijalva MJ (2010) Sex, subdivision, and domestic dispersal of Trypanosoma cruzi lineage I in southern Ecuador. PLoS neglected tropical diseases 4: e915. pmid:21179502
- 20.
WHO (2002) Control of Chagas disease: World Health Organization. i-vi, 1–109, back cover p.
- 21. Burnham KP, Anderson DR (2004) Multimodel inference—understanding AIC and BIC in model selection. Sociological Methods & Research 33: 261–304.
- 22. dos Santos CM, Jurberg J, Galvao C, Rocha Dda S, Fernandez JI (2003) [Morphometric study of the genus Panstrongylus Berg, 1879 (Hemiptera, Reduviidae, Triatominae)]. Mem Inst Oswaldo Cruz 98: 939–944. pmid:14762522
- 23. Patterson JS, Barbosa SE, Feliciangeli MD (2009) On the genus Panstrongylus Berg 1879: evolution, ecology and epidemiological significance. Acta Trop 110: 187–199. pmid:18929527
- 24. Abad-Franch F, Aguilar VH, Paucar CA, Lorosa ES, Noireau F (2002) Observations on the domestic ecology of Rhodnius ecuadoriensis (Triatominae). Mem Inst Oswaldo Cruz 97: 199–202. pmid:12016443
- 25. Villacis AG, Grijalva MJ, Catala SS (2010) Phenotypic Variability of Rhodnius ecuadoriensis Populations at the Ecuadorian Central and Southern Andean Region. Journal of Medical Entomology 47: 1034–1043. pmid:21175051
- 26. Breniere SF, Salas R, Buitrago R, Bremond P, Sosa V, et al. (2013) Wild populations of Triatoma infestans are highly connected to intra-peridomestic conspecific populations in the Bolivian Andes. PLoS One 8: e80786. pmid:24278320
- 27. Gurtler RE, Yadon ZE (2015) Eco-bio-social research on community-based approaches for Chagas disease vector control in Latin America. Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg 109: 91–98. pmid:25604759
- 28. Pinto CM, Ocana-Mayorga S, Lascano MS, Grijalva MJ (2006) Infection by trypanosomes in marsupials and rodents associated with human dwellings in Ecuador. J Parasitol 92: 1251–1255. pmid:17304802
- 29. de Moraes MH, Guarneri AA, Girardi FP, Rodrigues JB, Eger I, et al. (2008) Different serological cross-reactivity of Trypanosoma rangeli forms in Trypanosoma cruzi-infected patients sera. Parasit Vectors 1: 20. pmid:18611261
- 30. Black CL, Ocana-Mayorga S, Riner DK, Costales JA, Lascano MS, et al. (2009) Seroprevalence of Trypanosoma cruzi in rural Ecuador and clustering of seropositivity within households. The American journal of tropical medicine and hygiene 81: 1035–1040. pmid:19996434
- 31. Cuba CA, Abad-Franch F, Roldan Rodriguez J, Vargas Vasquez F, Pollack Velasquez L, et al. (2002) The triatomines of northern Peru, with emphasis on the ecology and infection by trypanosomes of Rhodnius ecuadoriensis (Triatominae). Mem Inst Oswaldo Cruz 97: 175–183. pmid:12016438
- 32. Vargas F, Cordova Paz Soldan O, Marin C, Jose Rosales M, Sanchez-Gutierrez R, et al. (2007) Epidemiology of American trypanosomiasis in northern Peru. Ann Trop Med Parasitol 101: 643–648. pmid:17877882
- 33. Alroy KA, Huang C, Gilman RH, Quispe-Machaca VR, Marks MA, et al. (2015) Prevalence and Transmission of Trypanosoma cruzi in People of Rural Communities of the High Jungle of Northern Peru. PLoS Negl Trop Dis 9: e0003779. pmid:26000770
- 34. Viotti R, de Noya BA, Araujo-Jorge T, Grijalva MJ, Guhl F, et al. (2014) Towards a Paradigm Shift in the Treatment of Chronic Chagas Disease. Antimicrobial Agents and Chemotherapy 58: 635–639. pmid:24247135
- 35. Hotez PJ, Bottazzi ME, Franco-Paredes C, Ault SK, Periago MR (2008) The neglected tropical diseases of latin america and the Caribbean: a review of disease burden and distribution and a roadmap for control and elimination. PLoS Negl Trop Dis 2: e300. pmid:18820747
- 36. Briceno-Leon R (2009) [Chagas disease in the Americas: an ecohealth perspective]. Cad Saude Publica 25 Suppl 1: S71–82. pmid:19287869
- 37. Grijalva MJ, Villacis AG, Ocana-Mayorga S, Yumiseva CA, Baus EG (2011) Limitations of selective deltamethrin application for triatomine control in central coastal Ecuador. Parasites & vectors 4: 20.