Skip to main content
Advertisement
Browse Subject Areas
?

Click through the PLOS taxonomy to find articles in your field.

For more information about PLOS Subject Areas, click here.

  • Loading metrics

Reliability-oriented performance evaluation of PV inverters using wide bandgap semiconductors

  • Sainadh Singh Kshatri,

    Roles Conceptualization, Data curation, Formal analysis, Investigation, Methodology, Resources, Software, Validation, Visualization, Writing – original draft

    Affiliation Department of Electrical and Electronics Engineering, B V Raju Institute of Technology, Narsapur, India

  • Javed Dhillon,

    Roles Conceptualization, Data curation, Formal analysis, Investigation, Methodology, Resources, Software, Supervision, Validation, Visualization, Writing – review & editing

    Affiliation School of Electronics and Electrical, Lovely Professional University, Phagwara, Punjab, India

  • Sachin Mishra ,

    Roles Conceptualization, Data curation, Formal analysis, Investigation, Methodology, Resources, Software, Supervision, Validation, Visualization, Writing – review & editing

    vinay.jadoun@manipal.edu (VKJ); sachin.20444@lpu.co.in (SM)

    Affiliation School of Electronics and Electrical, Lovely Professional University, Phagwara, Punjab, India

  • Naveen Kumar Sharma,

    Roles Conceptualization, Data curation, Formal analysis, Investigation, Methodology, Resources, Software, Supervision, Validation, Visualization, Writing – review & editing

    Affiliation Department of Electrical Engineering, I. K. Gujral Punjab Technical University, Main Campus, Kapurthala, Punjab, India

  • Vinay Kumar Jadoun

    Roles Conceptualization, Formal analysis, Funding acquisition, Investigation, Methodology, Resources, Software, Validation, Visualization, Writing – review & editing

    vinay.jadoun@manipal.edu (VKJ); sachin.20444@lpu.co.in (SM)

    Affiliation Manipal Institute of Technology, Manipal Academy of Higher Education, Manipal, India

Abstract

The recent development of power electronic devices that utilizes the advantages of wideband gap semiconductor components for electrical conversion is expected to create a new class of reliable and efficient inverters. However, the photovoltaic inverter is considered a critical component in grid-connected PV systems with respect to reliability performance. Therefore, this paper proposes a wide-bandgap semiconductor (WBS) based photovoltaic inverter, specifically utilizing silicon carbide (SiC) MOSFETs and gallium nitride (GaN) HEMTs, to enhance reliability and performance. In this paper, reliability-oriented performance is evaluated on a grid connected 3 kW photovoltaic (PV) inverter system under real-time Mission Profile (MP) in India. Environmental factors are assessed based on a one-minute resolution yearly MP, in which solar irradiance (SI) and ambient temperature (AT) are considered. To model the lifetime with a two-Parameter Weibull distribution, the Monte Carlo simulation (MCS) is utilized to produce 10,000 samples with 5% parameter variation. The B10 lifetime a reliability measure indicating the time by which 10% of population are expected to fail, is calculated for the Narsapur, Indian location and analyzed with regard to performance metrics, such as PV power, switch losses, inverter efficiency, and output power. In addition, this study compares the performance of conventional IGBT, super junction MOSFET (SJ-M), silicon carbide (SiC) MOSFET (SiC-M), and gallium nitride (GaN) HEMT (GaN-H) based inverters. Results show that WBG semiconductors can increase reliability and efficiency by eliminating 40% of losses compared to the conventional IGBTs.

Introduction

The need for sustainable energy sources increased the interest in photovoltaic (PV) systems, with grid connected inverters plays a vital role in energy conversion. The traditional silicon IGBT based inverters are affected by efficiency limitations due to the switching losses. Recent advancements in the WBS technology, including SiC-M and GaN-H are the promising alternatives with their superior thermal and electrical performance. The WBS will significantly impact the reliability performance of the PV inverter. The major types PV inverters are tabulated in Table 1.

The integration of WBS will improve the performance of the inverters. The larger bandgap of WBS enables the operation with lower intrinsic carrier concentration which improves the switching performance even at higher temperatures. This results in higher critical electric field strength about 10 times greater than silicon, thereby it permits the use of thinner drift regions for the same blocking voltage. The superior thermal conductivity of WBS provides the efficient heat dissipation, this leads to the reduction in junction temperature and improves the device lifetime. The work reported by W. M. Hamanah et al., [2] presented an evaluation of various advanced WBS, such as GaN and SiC. These are utilized in a DC drive system for solar power applications. In addition, it demonstrates their implementation in a heliostat unit. The research carried out by W. Van De Sande et al., [3] explores the thermal-mechanical stress generated by the bond wires and die attach wires of certain GaN and SiC MOSFETs in photovoltaic systems. It emphasizes the need for reliable electronic components in urban areas. Through an electro-thermal simulation, it can also analyze junction losses caused by clear and cloudy skies. The investigation undertaken by S. S. Kshatri et al., [4] presents the development of a PV inverter that utilizes a hybrid power module that consists of a SiC/IGBT dual anti-parallel diode and a Si-IGBT hybrid power transistor. This technology can help improve the efficiency of the system and address the financial concerns that come with using SiC components. The findings presented by by A. M. Ganose et al., [5] explores the challenges encountered by wide-band semiconductors when it comes to achieving optoelectronic capabilities that can compete with small-bandgap devices.

The work reported by E. Gurpinar et al., [6] presented the thermal loading of gallium nitride HEMTs and IGBTs in three-level passive PV inverters. In this paper yearly MP of these components, such as solar irradiance and ambient temperature are considered. Finally, comparison between the performance of GaN HEMTs and Si IGBTs with different thermal interface materials are presented. A report on the reliability analysis of 1500 V PV inverters is presented in [7]. The reliability issues are caused by the increasing load stress on the power devices when the maximum DC voltage is extended from 1000 to 1500 V. To address these issues, this paper proposed silicon carbide MOSFETs with variable gate resistance. The approach proposed by D. W. Cunningham et al., [8] evaluated the advantages of utilizing gallium nitride and silicon carbide in power electronic components for photovoltaic systems. It highlights their capability to produce reliable, lightweight, and efficient devices. The work reported by S. A. Ansari et al., [9] compared the cost and efficiency of soft and hard-switched DC-DC boost converters using gallium nitride and SiC devices. The observations made by O. Idbouhouch et al., [10] analyzed the degradation and efficiency of PV inverters in arid regions, which highlights the need to consider their dependability. Inverters with a yearly failure rate of 1–15% are examined. The study utilized a monitoring technique to analyze the efficiency of PV inverters. It compared the actual outputs with the predicted outputs, which revealed that the Sandia model accurately models typical operation of the devices. The comparison of Si with SJ, SiC and GaN in tabulated in Table 2.

thumbnail
Table 2. Comparison of Si Vs SJ Vs SiC Vs GaN [11,12].

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0346925.t002

J. He et al., [13] presented the issues encountered by 1500-V PV inverters in terms of their reliability. The increasing load stress and thermal loading are some of the issues that can affect this type of device. This issue can lead to higher system costs. Q. Chai et al., [14] proposed a methodology to improve the performance of PV inverters using power smoothing control. This method can be used in combination with active distribution networks’ volt/var control. It also develops new constraints that can limit the apparent power variation of the device. The study also proposes an optimization strategy that can help minimize power losses.

P. Kut et al., [15] reviewed that the European Union’s rapid growth in renewable energy sources, such as solar power, has been driven by the government’s efforts to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. From 2005 to 2019, the number of PV installations has increased from 2.17 gigawatts to over 130 gigawatts. O. Alavi et al., [16] presented the impact of degradation rare in the PV inverter reliability at various climatic conditions. M. J. Abed et al., [17] presented the performance improvement of reliability indices based on loss of load expectations in renewable generation unit. J. H. Choi et al., [18] a hybrid PWM strategy is implemented for the reliability improvement of NPC PV inverters. A reliability based approach for the preventive maintenance of PV system is presented in [19]. T. Ryu et al., [20] proposed the reliability based DPWM approach for the 5 – level T Type PV inverter for the improved performance.

Despite of extensive studies on WBS for PV inverters, along with significant work on reliability of PV inverter, several critical gaps are remains unaddressed. Prior research addressed the reliability and thermal performance of WBG semiconductor such as SiC and GaN for various PV applications. However the research gaps such as limited real time reliability analysis in Indian climatic conditions, comprehensive lifetime evaluation, comparison across different semiconductors are evident in terms of reliability performance. Hence to address these gaps this paper proposes a wide-bandgap semiconductor-based photovoltaic inverter, specifically utilizing SiC-M and GaN-H, to enhance reliability and performance. The objective of the paper is to improve the reliability of the PV inverter with the WBG semiconductor based switches which offer superior efficiency, thermal performance and lifetime in comparison with the conventional Si based switches. In this paper, reliability-oriented performance is evaluated on a grid connected 3 kW photovoltaic (PV) inverter system under real-time MPs in India. Environmental factors are assessed based on a one-minute resolution yearly MP, in which solar irradiance and ambient temperature are considered. To model the lifetime with a two-Parameter Weibull distribution, the MCS is utilized to produce 10,000 samples with 5% parameter variation. The B10 lifetime a reliability measure indicating the time by which 10% of population are expected to fail, is calculated for the Narsapur, Indian location and analyzed with regard to performance metrics, such as PV power, switch losses, inverter efficiency, and output power. In addition, this study compares the performance of conventional IGBT, SJ-M, SiC-M and GaN-H based inverters. Due to the superior characteristics of WBS, i.e., SiC-M and GaN-H, enhances the inverter reliability by reducing switch losses, conduction losses, and thermal stress.

Reliability oriented performance evaluation methodology

In the PV inverter, the semiconductor switch is considered the most crucial component, making reliability-oriented performance a major concern. Hence in this paper, reliability oriented performance evaluation methodology is presented. Initially, the reliability oriented performance is evaluated at the individual switch level, and then by using a series reliability block diagram approach, the inverter level is evaluated. This approach involves analysing the performance under MP conditions over a period of one year. The key procedure steps are presented in Fig 1.

Step: 1 – MP Data Logging – One-minute resolution yearly MP, in which SI and AT are considered.

Step: 2 – Junction Temperature Extraction – The temperature at the junction layers of the semiconductor switches will be extracted using the foster electro thermal model. The mathematical representation for the junction temperature (JT) at any given moment is delineated in Eq. 1 [21].

(1)

where

  • Zth(j−c) = Junction to case Thermal Impedance
  • PT = Total Power Loss
  • Tc = Case Temperature

The mathematical formulation for the Case Temperature (Tc) is elucidated in Eq. 2.

(2)

Where

  • Ta = Ambient Temperature
  • Zth(c−h) = Case to Heat Sink Thermal Impedance
  • Zth(h−a) = Heat sink to Ambient Thermal Impedance

The power dissipation within the semiconductor switch is attributable to thermal energy loss. Predominantly, there exist two categories of power losses, which are

  • Conduction Losses (Pc)
  • Switching Losses (Ps)

The total power loss is determined utilizing the Eq. 3.

(3)

The Switching loss is determined utilizing the Eq. 4.

(4)

where

  • f = Fundamental switching frequency,
  • Eon = Turn-on loss
  • Eoff = Turn-off loss.

Step: 3 – Rainflow Counting Assessment (RCA) –The variations in the extracted JT are caused by the irregular nature of MP. A cycle counting algorithm is required to assess these variations. Hence in this work Rainflow Counting Assessment (RCA) is utilized. From this assessment Total number of cycles, mean temperature and amplitude cycle are evaluated. [22]

Step: IV – Lifetime Evaluation – Lifetime is evaluated using miners rule as per Eq. 5

(5)

Where

  • Total number of cycles are evaluated using RCA.
  • No.of Cycles to failure Nf is evaluated using bayerers model [23] as per Eq. 6
(6)

Step: V – Monte Carlo Simulation – To model the lifetime with a two-Parameter Weibull distribution, the Monte Carlo simulation is utilized to produce 10,000 samples with 5% parameter variation.

Step: VI – Reliability (B10) Evaluation – The reliability function of the generated samples is calculated by fitting them to the Weibull distribution with 95% confident bounds. [23,24]

The individual switch level reliability is evaluated as per Eq. 7

(7)

where ∝ is Scale Parameter (characteristic life, i.e., 63.2% of the population has failed)

γ is Shape Parameter (Failure rate behaviour over time)

The inverter level reliability is evaluated as per Eq. 8

(8)

Finally, B10 lifetime is evaluated as per Eq. 9.

(9)

were

x is percentage of population

∝ is Scale Parameter

γ is Shape Parameter.

Case system

This paper proposes a wide-bandgap semiconductor-based photovoltaic inverter, specifically utilizing SiC-M and GaN-H, to enhance reliability and performance. These wideband gap semiconductors exhibits the improved performance over the conventional semiconductor, including efficiency, thermal conductivity etc. utilization of these wideband gap semiconductors are expected to reduce the power loss and improve the reliability of the grid connected inverter system, which is more suitable in variable environmental conditions. The proposed system is implemented on a grid connected 3 kW photovoltaic (PV) inverter system under real-time MPs in India as shown in Fig 2. The details of semiconductor switches and the system parameters of the test case are tabulated in Table 3.

The environmental factors based on a one-minute resolution yearly MP, in which SI and AI are meticulously recorded from 1st September 2023–31st August 2024 at Narsapur, Medak District, Telangana, India as shown in Fig 3. The yearly MP logging process will ensures the accuracy and captures the variation trends of environment which will impact the systems performance.

thumbnail
Fig 3. Environmental Factors (Mission Profile).

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0346925.g003

Results and discussions

In this paper, reliability-oriented performance is evaluated on a grid connected 3 kW photovoltaic (PV) inverter system under real-time MPs in Narsapur, India. To model the lifetime with a two-Parameter Weibull distribution, the MCS is utilized to produce 10,000 samples with 5% parameter variation. The B10 lifetime a reliability measure indicating the time by which 10% of population are expected to fail, is calculated for the Narsapur, Indian location and analyzed with regard to performance metrics, such as PV power, switch losses, inverter efficiency, and output power. The reliability-oriented performance is evaluated under the following cases

  • Performance Evaluation with Si-IGBT based PV Inverter
  • Performance Evaluation with Sj-MOSFET based PV Inverter
  • Performance Evaluation with SiC-MOSFET based PV Inverter
  • Performance Evaluation with GaN-HEMT based PV Inverter

Performance evaluation with Si-IGBT based PV inverter

In this scenario, the reliability-oriented performance of grid connected 3 kW photovoltaic (PV) inverter system considering Si-IGBT based PV Inverter is evaluated. The JT corresponds to the real-time MPs is extracted using the FET model as depicted in Fig 4. Over the span of a year, the average JT recorded over a year is 56.04 °C.

These variations in the extracted JT arise from the irregular nature of MP. A cycle counting algorithm is required to assess these variations. Hence in this work Rainflow Counting Assessment (RCA) is utilized. From this assessment, RCA parameters such as total number of cycles, mean temperature and amplitude cycle are evaluated as shown in Fig 5. The RCA parameters are tabulated in Table 4.

thumbnail
Table 4. Static B10 Lifetime Si-IGBT based PV Inverter.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0346925.t004

To model the lifetime with a two-Parameter Weibull distribution, the Monte Carlo simulation is utilized to produce 10,000 samples with 5% parameter variation and life time is calculated using the Eq. 5 and Eq. 6 as shown in Fig 6.

The reliability function of the generated samples is calculated by fitting them to the Weibull distribution. The individual switch level reliability is evaluated as per Eq. 7, The inverter level reliability is evaluated as per Eq. 8 as depicted in Figs 7 and 8 respectively.

thumbnail
Fig 7. Individual Switch Level Reliability Si-IGBT based PV Inverter.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0346925.g007

thumbnail
Fig 8. Inverter Level Reliability Si-IGBT based PV Inverter.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0346925.g008

From the above reliability curves it is observed that the B10 lifetime at individual switch level is 28 year, while the B10 lifetime at inverter level is 21 years. In addition to reliability assessment, performance metrics such as such as PV power, conduction losses, switching losses, total switch losses, output power and inverter efficiency are evaluated as shown in Fig 9. The yearly average PV power, conduction losses, switching losses, total switch losses, output power and inverter efficiency are tabulated in Table 5. These metrics are significant in understanding the overall performance of Si-IGBT based PV inverter.

thumbnail
Table 5. Yearly Average Parameters Si-IGBT based PV Inverter.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0346925.t005

thumbnail
Fig 9. Yearly Performance Metrics Si-IGBT Based PV Inverter.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0346925.g009

Performance evaluation with SJ-MOSFET based PV inverter

In this scenario, the reliability-oriented performance of grid connected 3 kW photovoltaic (PV) inverter system considering SJ-MOSFET based PV Inverter is evaluated. The JT corresponds to the real-time MPs is extracted using the FET model as depicted in Fig 10. Over the span of a year, the average JT recorded over a year is 53.10 °C.

These variations in the extracted JT arise from the irregular nature of MP. A cycle counting algorithm is required to assess these variations. Hence in this work Rainflow Counting Assessment (RCA) is utilized. From this assessment, RCA parameters such as total number of cycles, mean temperature and amplitude cycle are evaluated as shown in Fig 11. The RCA parameters are tabulated in Table 6.

thumbnail
Table 6. Static B10 Lifetime SJ-MOSFET based PV Inverter.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0346925.t006

To model the lifetime with a two-Parameter Weibull distribution, the Monte Carlo simulation is utilized to produce 10,000 samples with 5% parameter variation and life time is calculated using the Eq. 5 and Eq. 6 as shown in Fig 12.

The reliability function of the generated samples is calculated by fitting them to the Weibull distribution. The individual switch level reliability is evaluated as per Eq. 7, The inverter level reliability is evaluated as per Eq. 8 as depicted in Figs 13 and 14 respectively.

thumbnail
Fig 13. Individual Switch Level Reliability SJ-MOSFET based PV Inverter.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0346925.g013

thumbnail
Fig 14. Inverter Level Reliability SJ-MOSFET based PV Inverter.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0346925.g014

From the above reliability curves it is observed that the B10 lifetime at individual switch level is 37 year, while the B10 lifetime at inverter level is 27 years. In addition to reliability assessment, performance metrics such as such as PV power, conduction losses, switching losses, total switch losses, output power and inverter efficiency are evaluated as shown in Fig 15. The yearly average PV power, conduction losses, switching losses, total switch losses, output power and inverter efficiency are tabulated in Table 7. These metrics are significant in understanding the overall performance of Si-IGBT based PV inverter.

thumbnail
Table 7. Yearly Average Parameters SJ-MOSFET based PV Inverter.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0346925.t007

thumbnail
Fig 15. Yearly Performance Metrics SJ-MOSFET based PV Inverter.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0346925.g015

In this scenario, the reliability-oriented performance of grid connected 3 kW photovoltaic (PV) inverter system considering SJ-MOSFET based PV Inverter exhibited the improved performance than the conventional Si-IGBT based PV Inverter. The JT is decreased from 56.04 °C to 53.10 °C. The B10 lifetime at individual switch level is improved from 28 Years to 37 year, while the B10 lifetime at inverter level is improved from 21 Years to 27 years. In addition to reliability assessment, performance metrics such as such as PV power, conduction losses, switching losses, total switch losses, output power are also improved. Inverter efficiency is improved from 92.69% to 93.47%.

Performance evaluation with SiC-MOSFET based PV inverter

In this scenario, the reliability-oriented performance of grid connected 3 kW photovoltaic (PV) inverter system considering SiC-MOSFET based PV Inverter is evaluated. The JT corresponds to the real-time MPs is extracted using the FET model as depicted in Fig 16. Over the span of a year, the average JT recorded over a year is 50.15 °C.

These variations in the extracted JT arise from the irregular nature of MP. A cycle counting algorithm is required to assess these variations. Hence in this work Rainflow Counting Assessment (RCA) is utilized. From this assessment, RCA parameters such as total number of cycles, mean temperature and amplitude cycle are evaluated as shown in Fig 17. The RCA parameters are tabulated in Table 8.

thumbnail
Table 8. Static B10 Lifetime SiC-MOSFET based PV Inverter.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0346925.t008

To model the lifetime with a two-Parameter Weibull distribution, the Monte Carlo simulation is utilized to produce 10,000 samples with 5% parameter variation and life time is calculated using the Eq. 5 and Eq. 6 as shown in Fig 18.

The reliability function of the generated samples is calculated by fitting them to the Weibull distribution. The individual switch level reliability is evaluated as per Eq. 7, The inverter level reliability is evaluated as per Eq. 8 as depicted in Figs 19 and 20 respectively.

thumbnail
Fig 19. Individual Switch Level Reliability SiC-MOSFET based PV Inverter.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0346925.g019

thumbnail
Fig 20. Inverter Level Reliability SiC-MOSFET based PV Inverter.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0346925.g020

From the above reliability curves it is observed that the B10 lifetime at individual switch level is 54 year, while the B10 lifetime at inverter level is 39 years. In addition to reliability assessment, performance metrics such as such as PV power, conduction losses, switching losses, total switch losses, output power and inverter efficiency are evaluated as shown in Fig 21. The yearly average PV power, conduction losses, switching losses, total switch losses, output power and inverter efficiency are tabulated in Table 9. These metrics are significant in understanding the overall performance of Si-IGBT based PV inverter.

thumbnail
Table 9. Yearly Average Parameters SiC-MOSFET based PV Inverter.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0346925.t009

thumbnail
Fig 21. Yearly Performance Metrics SiC-MOSFET based PV Inverter.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0346925.g021

In this scenario, the reliability-oriented performance of grid connected 3 kW photovoltaic (PV) inverter system considering SiC-MOSFET based PV Inverter exhibited the improved performance than the conventional Si-IGBT based PV Inverter. The JT is decreased from 56.04 °C to 50.15 °C. The B10 lifetime at individual switch level is improved from 28 Years to 54 year, while the B10 lifetime at inverter level is improved from 21 Years to 39 years. In addition to reliability assessment, performance metrics such as such as PV power, conduction losses, switching losses, total switch losses, output power are also improved. Inverter efficiency is improved from 92.69% to 94.24%.

Performance evaluation with GaN-HEMT based PV inverter

In this scenario, the reliability-oriented performance of grid connected 3 kW photovoltaic (PV) inverter system considering GaN-HEMT based PV Inverter is evaluated. The JT corresponds to the real-time MPs is extracted using the FET model as depicted in Fig 22. Over the span of a year, the average JT recorded over a year is 48.31 °C.

These variations in the extracted JT arise from the irregular nature of MP. A cycle counting algorithm is required to assess these variations. Hence in this work Rainflow Counting Assessment (RCA) is utilized. From this assessment, RCA parameters such as total number of cycles, mean temperature and amplitude cycle are evaluated as shown in Fig 23. The RCA parameters are tabulated in Table 10.

thumbnail
Table 10. Static B10 Lifetime GaN-HEMT based PV Inverter.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0346925.t010

To model the lifetime with a two-Parameter Weibull distribution, the Monte Carlo simulation is utilized to produce 10,000 samples with 5% parameter variation and life time is calculated using the Eq. 5 and Eq. 6 as shown in Fig 24.

The reliability function of the generated samples is calculated by fitting them to the Weibull distribution. The individual switch level reliability is evaluated as per Eq. 7, The inverter level reliability is evaluated as per Eq. 8 as depicted in Figs 25 and 26 respectively.

thumbnail
Fig 25. Individual Switch Level Reliability GaN-HEMT based PV Inverter.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0346925.g025

thumbnail
Fig 26. Inverter Level Reliability GaN-HEMT based PV Inverter.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0346925.g026

From the above reliability curves it is observed that the B10 lifetime at individual switch level is 62 year, while the B10 lifetime at inverter level is 45 years. In addition to reliability assessment, performance metrics such as such as PV power, conduction losses, switching losses, total switch losses, output power and inverter efficiency are evaluated as shown in Fig 27. The yearly average PV power, conduction losses, switching losses, total switch losses, output power and inverter efficiency are tabulated in Table 11. These metrics are significant in understanding the overall performance of Si-IGBT based PV inverter.

thumbnail
Table 11. Yearly Average Parameters GaN-HEMT based PV Inverter.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0346925.t011

thumbnail
Fig 27. Yearly Performance Metrics GaN-HEMT based PV Inverter.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0346925.g027

In this scenario, the reliability-oriented performance of grid connected 3 kW photovoltaic (PV) inverter system considering GaN-HEMT based PV Inverter exhibited the improved performance than the conventional Si-IGBT based PV Inverter. The JT is decreased from 56.04 °C to 48.31 °C. The B10 lifetime at individual switch level is improved from 28 Years to 62 year, while the B10 lifetime at inverter level is improved from 21 Years to 45 years. In addition to reliability assessment, performance metrics such as such as PV power, conduction losses, switching losses, total switch losses, output power are also improved. Inverter efficiency is improved from 92.69% to 94.73%. The reliability of PV Inverter at Indian location for Si-IGBT is reported in literature, a comparison table it presented in Table 12 for validation

thumbnail
Table 12. B10 Lifetime Comparison at Indian Location.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0346925.t012

The practical design implications are listed below

  • Increasing the heatsink size improves thermal performance and thereby enhances reliability.
  • Oversizing the PV panel increases thermal stress, leading to a reduction in reliability.
  • Derating of semiconductor switches reduces thermal stress and thereby improves reliability.

Conclusion

In this paper, reliability-oriented performance is evaluated on a grid connected 3 kW photovoltaic (PV) inverter system under real-time MPs in Narsapur, India. Environmental factors are assessed based on a one-minute resolution yearly MP, in which solar irradiance and ambient temperature are considered. To model the lifetime with a two-Parameter Weibull distribution, the Monte Carlo simulation is utilized to produce 10,000 samples with 5% parameter variation. The B10 lifetime a reliability measure indicating the time by which 10% of population are expected to fail, is calculated for the Narsapur, Indian location and analyzed with regard to performance metrics, such as PV power, switch losses, inverter efficiency, and output power. The proposed wideband gap semiconductor based PV inverter exhibited the improved performance than the conventional Si-IGBT and SJ-MOSFET based PV Inverter. The JT is decreased from 56.04 °C to 48.31 °C. The B10 lifetime at individual switch level is improved from 28 Years to 62 year, while the B10 lifetime at inverter level is improved from 21 Years to 45 years. In addition to reliability assessment, performance metrics such as such as PV power, conduction losses, switching losses, total switch losses, output power are also improved. Inverter efficiency is improved from 92.69% to 94.73%. The wideband gap semiconductors, SiC-M and GaN-H exhibited the same performance. Due to the scope limitations, the current work addresses only a single location; however, in future work, we plan to extend this analysis to additional sites and provide the comparison and impact of climatic zone on inverter reliability.

References

  1. 1. Rivera S, Kouro S, Wu B, Leon JI, Rodriguez J, Franquelo LG. Cascaded H-bridge multilevel converter multistring topology for large scale photovoltaic systems. Proceedings - ISIE 2011: 2011 IEEE International Symposium on Industrial Electronics. 2011. p. 1837–44.
  2. 2. Hamanah WM, Salem A, Abido MA. Evaluation of advanced wide bandgap semiconductor-based DC-DC converter for solar power tower tracker application. 2023.
  3. 3. Van De Sande 3 W, Alavi O, Nivelle P, D’Haen J, Daenen M. Thermo-mechanical stress comparison of a GaN and SiC MOSFET for photovoltaic applications. 2020.
  4. 4. Kshatri SS, Dhillon J, Mishra S, Haghighi AT, Hunt J, Patro ER. Comparative reliability assessment of hybrid Si/SiC and conventional Si power module based PV inverter considering mission profile of India and Denmark locations. Energies. 2022;15(22):8612.
  5. 5. Ganose AM, Scanlon DO, Walsh A, Hoye RLZ. The defect challenge of wide-bandgap semiconductors for photovoltaics and beyond. 2022. Available: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-022-32131-4.pdf
  6. 6. Gurpinar E, Yang Y, Iannuzzo F, Castellazzi A, Blaabjerg F. Reliability-driven assessment of GaN HEMTs and Si IGBTs in 3L-ANPC PV inverters. 2016. Available: https://vbn.aau.dk/ws/files/233182038/IEEE_JESTPE_Reliability_Comparison.pdf
  7. 7. Design for Reliability of SiC-MOSFET-Based 1500-V PV Inverters With Variable Gate Resistance. 2022. Available: https://vbn.aau.dk/ws/files/479485487/Design_for_Reliability_of_SiC_MOSFET_Based_1500_V_PV_Inverters_With_Variable_Gate_Resistance.pdf
  8. 8. Cunningham 8 D W, Carlson EP, Manser JS, Kizilyalli IC. Impacts of Wide Band Gap Power Electronics on Photovoltaic System Design. 2020.
  9. 9. Ansari SA, Davidson JN, Foster MP. Evaluation of silicon MOSFETs and GaN HEMTs in soft‐switched and hard‐switched DC‐DC boost converters for domestic PV applications. 2021. Available: https://ietresearch.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdf/10.1049/pel2.12085
  10. 10. Idbouhouch 10 O, Rabbah N, Lamrini N, Oufettoul H, Abdelmoula IA, Zegrari M. Assessing PV inverter efficiency degradation under semi-arid conditions: A case study in Morocco. 2024.
  11. 11. Buffolo M, et al. Review and outlook on GaN and SiC power devices: industrial state-of-the-art, applications, and perspectives. IEEE Trans Electron Devices. 2024;71(3).
  12. 12. Muthuseenu K, Barnaby HJ, Galloway KF, Koziukov AE, Maksimenko TA, Vyrostkov MY, et al. Analysis of SEGR in Silicon Planar Gate Super-Junction Power MOSFETs. IEEE Trans Nucl Sci. 2021;68(5):611–6.
  13. 13. He J, Sangwongwanich A, Yang Y, Zhang K, Iannuzzo F. Design for Reliability of SiC-MOSFET-Based 1500-V PV Inverters With Variable Gate Resistance. 2022.
  14. 14. Chai Q, Zhang C, Tong ZY, Lu S, Chen W, Dong ZY. PV inverter reliability constrained volt/var control with power smoothing via a convex-concave programming method. 2023.
  15. 15. Kut P, Pietrucha-Urbanik K, Tchórzewska-Cieślak B. Reliability-oriented design of a solar-pv deployments. 2021.
  16. 16. Alavi O, Kaaya I, De Jong R, De Ceuninck W, Daenen M. Assessing the impact of PV panel climate-based degradation rates on inverter reliability in grid-connected solar energy systems. Heliyon. 2024;10(3):e25839. pmid:38356569
  17. 17. Abed MJ, Mhalla A. Reliability assessment of grid-connected multi-inverter for renewable power generation sector. AGJSR. 2023;42(1):68–84.
  18. 18. Choi J-H, Choi U-M, Blaabjerg F. Hybrid Pulse Width Modulation for Improving Reliability of DC-Link Capacitors of NPC Inverter in Photovoltaic Systems. IEEE Access. 2024;12:18752–63.
  19. 19. Chen W, Li M, Pei T, Sun C, Lei H. Reliability-Based Model for Incomplete Preventive Replacement Maintenance of Photovoltaic Power Systems. ENERGY. 2024;121(1):125–44.
  20. 20. Ryu T, Choi U-M. Reliability-Oriented Optimal DPWM Strategy for Single-Phase Five-Level T-Type Inverter in PV Systems. IEEE J Emerg Sel Topics Power Electron. 2023;11(2):2227–35.
  21. 21. Wang J, Li Z, Jiang X, Zeng C, Shen ZJ. Gate Control Optimization of Si/SiC Hybrid Switch for Junction Temperature Balance and Power Loss Reduction. IEEE Trans Power Electron. 2019;34(2):1744–54.
  22. 22. Kshatri SS, Dhillon J, Mishra S. Impact of Solar Irradiance and Ambient Temperature on PV Inverter Reliability Considering Geographical Locations. IJHT. 2021;39(1):292–8.
  23. 23. Bayerer R, Herrmann T, Licht T, Lutz J, Feller M. Model for power cycling lifetime of IGBT modules – various factors influencing lifetime. In: CIPS 2008 - 5th International Conference on Integrated Power Electronics Systems, Proceedings. 2008.
  24. 24. Sangwongwanich A, Yang Y, Sera D, Blaabjerg F, Zhou D. On the impacts of PV array sizing on the inverter reliability and lifetime. IEEE Trans Ind Appl. 2018;54(4).
  25. 25. Gatla RK, Chen W, Zhu G, Zeng D, Nirudi R. Lifetime estimation of modular cascaded H-bridge MLPVI for grid-connected PV systems considering mission profile. Microelectron Reliab. 2018;88–90:1051–6.
  26. 26. Gatla RK, et al. Impact of mission profile on reliability of grid-connected photovoltaic inverter. J Eur Syst Automat. 2022;55(1).