Figures
Abstract
In this paper, we focus on a second-order dynamical system designed to solve inverse quasi-variational inequalities (IQVIs) in Hilbert spaces, focusing on strongly monotone operators under Lipschitz continuity assumptions. This study establishes the existence and uniqueness of strong global solutions under standard conditions, ensuring the robustness of the proposed system. Furthermore, we derive a discrete-time formulation of the dynamical system, which leads to a relaxed inertial projection algorithm that achieves linear convergence under suitable parameter conditions. Beyond theoretical analysis, stability is verified using a Lyapunov function. Finally, numerical experiments confirm the theoretical results and provide deeper insight into inverse quasi-variational inequality problems within the framework of dynamical systems.
Citation: Gan T, Khan VK, Ahmad MK, Cai Q-B (2026) A second-order dynamical system for solving inverse quasi-variational inequalities and its application. PLoS One 21(3): e0344815. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0344815
Editor: Mohamed Kamel Riahi, Khalifa University of Science and Technology, UNITED ARAB EMIRATES
Received: October 11, 2025; Accepted: February 25, 2026; Published: March 19, 2026
Copyright: © 2026 Gan et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Data Availability: All relevant data are within the manuscript.
Funding: This work was supported by the General Program of the National Social Science Fund of China (Grant No.~24BWW051) and the Fujian Provincial Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant No.~2024J01792). The funding agencies had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
1 Introduction
The real n-dimensional Euclidean space with an inner product and its corresponding norm
is denoted by
. Assume that
is a continuous operator and
be a nonempty, closed, and convex set. We consider the standard formulation of the variational inequality problem (VIP), which requires determining
satisfying the following condition.
Variational inequality problems (VIPs) have been widely studied in both theoretical and applied fields, including optimization, complementarity problems, saddle-point (min-max) problems, Nash equilibrium models, and fixed-point theory [1]. Consequently, various solution approaches, particularly projection-type methods, have been extensively explored (see, for example, [2–7]). From [1], we use the well-established projection theorem, where we conclude that the solution of is
defined in (1) ⇔ it has the following projection equation, for a fixed constant
:
A key extension of the variational inequality problem is the inverse formulation of . Suppose that
is a single-valued mapping. If the inverse function
exists, then VIP can be formulated as an inverse variational inequality problem (IVIP), denoted as
, which requires determining
satisfying the following conditions
While inverse variational inequality problems (IVIPs) appear in various fields, including economic equilibrium models [8] and traffic network analysis [9], there are relatively few theoretical and numerical approaches available for solving the (3). It is equivalent to finding a solution to the following projection equation,
where μ is any fixed constant and is the nearest point projection from
onto
defined by
In 2019, Zou et al. [10] introduced a dynamical system, referred to as a neural network, to solve (3) by formulating the following system:
where ,
is defined in (5) and
be a fixed parameter. He et al. [11] formulated the IVIP
and developed a projection-based iterative algorithm for its solution, applying their approach to solve many equilibrium problems. IVIP
have significant applications in engineering science, including transportation and telecommunication networks [12].
Several researchers have devoted their attention to the generalization of IVIPs, leading to the important class of problems known as inverse quasi-variational inequality problems [13,14]. This work addresses the inverse quasi-variational inequality problems (IQVIPs), where the objective is to determine a point such that
where be a single-value mapping and
be a set-valued mapping.
It is evident that when for all
, the inverse quasi-variational inequality problem (IQVIP) described above simplifies to the IVIP. Numerous analytical and computational methods have been developed by various researchers to address this IQVIP. Dynamical systems have become a focal point of study in recent years for addressing a range of optimization problems, including variational inequalities, monotone inclusions, and fixed point problems (see, e.g., [15–17]). In addition, numerous algorithms have been proposed to solve associated VIPs and monotone inclusions through discrete forms of dynamical systems.
Han et al. [8] investigated IQVIP formulated in (7), establishing the existence of a solution through the application of a fixed-point theorem and the Fan–Knaster–Kuratowski–Mazurkiewicz (KKM) Lemma. They also demonstrated its relevance to road pricing models, where the goal of traffic authorities is to regulate environmental impact within acceptable limits. This existence result was later generalized by Dey et al. [18].
Aussel et al. [13] proposed a new framework for IQVIP in 2013, establishing both local and global error bounds through the use of a gap function to highlight its practical utility. To illustrate the effectiveness of the model, they examined a road pricing scenario where environmental impacts from traffic flow are incorporated into the determination of road taxes. In subsequent years, this line of research has been further developed and generalized by numerous authors, including the extension to vector-valued IQVIPs (see [19,20] and the references therein).
In 2024, Dey S. and Reich S. [14] took the dynamical system to solve for inverse quasi-variational inequalities (7) by formulating the following system:
where ,
is defined in (5) and
be a parameter, which is fixed. Several first- and second-order dynamical systems have been introduced to solve different types of variational inequalities, utilizing their stability properties and convergence guarantees [16,21,22]. Motivated by the above findings, we propose a second-order dynamical system to solve IQVIPs (7). The state variable
evolves according to the following second-order dynamical system with initial conditions:
where ,
and
are Lebesgue measurable functions. If we assume that the set-valued mapping
associated with the IQVIP (7) has nonempty, closed, and convex values. Then a point
solves the IQVIP (7) if and only if it satisfies the projection equation
The existence and uniqueness of the solution to the IQVIP follow from the structural properties of the operator Ψ and the projection mapping associated with Φ; see [14] for related results. Moreover, is a solution of the IQVIP (7) if and only if it is an equilibrium point of the proposed dynamical system (9), that is, the constant function
is a trajectory of the system. Assuming that Ψ is Lipschitz continuous ensures the global existence and uniqueness of system trajectories, while strong monotonicity of Ψ guarantees that all trajectories of the system (9) converge globally to the unique solution of the IQVIP (7). In these applications, real-time solutions are often required; however, conventional iterative methods can be computationally expensive due to the problem’s complexity and high dimensionality.
Dynamical systems have recently attracted considerable attention for solving optimization problems, variational inequalities, monotone inclusions, and fixed-point problems [22–30]. In particular, neurodynamic and inertial-type approaches have been widely developed for classical variational inequality problems. However, their extension to inverse quasi-variational inequalities (IQVIs) remains limited. Most existing methods focus on first-order dynamics or static projection schemes and do not provide a second-order dynamical framework that simultaneously guarantees the existence and uniqueness of global solutions, Lyapunov-based stability of the continuous-time system, and linear convergence of the associated discrete algorithm.
Motivated by these limitations, this paper proposes a second-order dynamical system to solve IQVIPs (7). The proposed framework addresses these challenges by providing a robust and well-posed model under strong monotonicity and Lipschitz continuity assumptions. The use of a second-order formulation introduces a momentum term that accelerates convergence toward the equilibrium point, leading to faster, smoother, and more stable trajectories compared to first-order systems. Consequently, stronger convergence guarantees, such as linear or fixed-time convergence, can be established.
The main contributions of this paper are summarized as follows:
- We propose a second-order dynamical system for solving inverse quasi-variational inequality problems (7) in Hilbert spaces.
- We establish the existence and uniqueness of strong global solutions under strong monotonicity and Lipschitz continuity assumptions.
- A Lyapunov function is constructed to prove the global asymptotic stability of the proposed dynamical system (9).
- A relaxed inertial projection algorithm is derived from the continuous system (9) and shown to converge linearly to IQVIPs (7).
- Numerical experiments validate the theoretical results and demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed method.
2 Definitions and preliminaries
We include in this section some required definitions and lemmas.
Definition 1. [31] The operator is characterized as follows:
- (a) It is monotone on
, if for all
,
- (b) It is strongly monotone on
with modulus
, if for all
,
Observe that the implication is valid, but the reverse is not necessarily true in general. This indicates that monotonicity is a weaker property compared to strong monotonicity.
Definition 2. [31] The operator is called ζ-Lipschitz continuous on
if there exists a
, such that
Lemma 1. [32] Suppose that is a subset of
with non-empty, closed, and convex. Then, we obtain the following results: (a) In (5), we defined
be the projection operator. Then
(b) is a nonexpansive operator, if the following inequality holds:
Lemma 2. For any ,
, the following inequalities holds:
.
- For some
, we have
.
Theorem 1. [14] theorem 1 Suppose that is a set-valued mapping whose values are nonempty, closed, and convex, and let
be a λ-strongly monotone and ζ-Lipschitz continuous. In addition, suppose that there is a constant
such that
and the condition
holds for some constant , then IQVIP (7) admits a unique solution.
Definition 3 (Strong Global Solution). We define as a strong global solution of the dynamical system (9), if it satisfies the system’s equations for all
and meets the necessary conditions for existence and uniqueness over the set
, and the following properties hold:
- If we define the functions
and
, which means they are absolutely continuous on every interval
, where
.
for almost every
.
and
.
3 Main results
The subsequent result illustrates the existence and uniqueness of the trajectory for equation (9), with the proof adapted from [23]. Suppose be a set-valued mapping such that each value is nonempty, closed, and convex throughout this paper.
Theorem 2. If are Lebesgue measurable functions, then
(i.e.,
for each
). Consider the ζ-Lipschitz continuous operator of Ψ. Then, the dynamical system (9) has a unique strong global solution for each
.
Proof. We define by
Consequently, the dynamical system (9) can be alternatively represented as:
By the Cauchy-Schwarz inequality and Lemma 1(b), due to the Lipschitz continuity of Ψ, it follows that and
:
Thus, A is Lipschitz continuous with modulus . Our dynamical system (15) can be alternatively reformulated as a first-order dynamical system within the product space
:
where ,
, and
We give the scalar product
and the associated norm
.
By utilizing the Lipschitz continuity of A, we establish that for arbitrary and
, i.e.,
According to ,
has a locally integrable Lipschitz constant. Now, we prove that
In fact, if and
are arbitrary, then
This integral is finite from the assumptions on . By using the theorem of Cauchy-Lipschitz and Picard, we ensure the unique strong global solution for the system (16) in first-order (refer to Proposition 6.2.1 in [33] for more details). This conclusion arises from the equivalence between (9), (15), and (16).
3.1 Linear Convergence of a Discrete System
By applying a finite-difference scheme to equation (9) with respect to the time variable s, and using a step size , a relaxation variable
, a damping variable
, along with initial points
and
. Consequently, the iterative process can be expressed as follows:
We observe that, due to the Lipschitz continuity of , there is some flexibility in its selection. Thus, we can express (18) as
Setting ,
, the scheme can be reformulated as:
This algorithm is a relaxed inertial projection and the convergence properties of (20) are examined in this section. Using the dynamical system (9), we examine the convergence of the trajectories . The next result is essential for our convergence analysis.
Theorem 3. Let Ψ be λ strong monotone and ζ-Lipschitz continuous on . Suppose that
be the unique solution of IQVIP (7). If we denote
,
,. Then
and
Proof. From Lemma 1(a), we have the following,
Let and
we obtain
Taking , we deduce that
On the other hand, since solves IQVI and the definition of
makes it evident that
, we obtain
or equivalently,
Using strong monotonicity of Ψ and the Cauchy-Schwarz inequality as well as Young’s inequality (for ) in (26), we obtain
Now, we use the Lipschitz continuity of Ψ in (27)
Thus, we obtain
or equivalently
Also, based on conditions (13) and (14), Theorem 1 guarantees the existence and uniqueness of a solution to the IQVIP (7), denoted by . Furthermore, by utilizing the Lipschitz continuity of the function Ψ and the nonexpansiveness property of the projection operator, we obtain the following inequality for all
:
Note that , combining (21) and above inequality, we obtain
Theorem 4. Let Ψ be λ strong monotone and ζ-Lipschitz continuous on . Assume that
and
or equivalently
Then, the sequence produced by the algorithm (20) converges linearly to the unique solution
of IQVIP (7).
Proof. Suppose be the sequence, which is generated by (20), we obtain
We know that
Therefore, from equations (30) and (31), we get
Setting and combining with (22), it follows from (32) that
Now, we applying in equation (33), we obtain
We substitute the value from (21) in equation (34) to obtain
The last inequality follows from (28), (29) and (21). let be defined as
Then (35) can be rewritten as
After applying n iterations in the above inequality, we obtain the following result
Let . Then we have
Using the conditions (28) and (29), we get
Combining (36) with (37), we obtain
As a result of equation (38), we can determine that the sequence remains bounded. Additionally,
which implies that generated by the algorithm (20) converges strongly to solution
.
Corollary 1. Let Ψ be a monotone and ζ-Lipschitz continuous operator on . Assume that
and
or equivalently
Then, the sequence produced by the algorithm (20) converges linearly to the unique solution
of the IQVIP (7).
4 Application of Lyapunov’s direct method for stability verification
Suppose be a Lyapunov function for the dynamical system (9), if it approximately characterizes the equilibrium point
and satisfies the following conditions:
(C1) The function is positive definite; that is,
for all
, and
⇔
.
(C2) Along the trajectories of the dynamical system (9), the time derivative is negative definite. In other words, for any solution
of (9), it holds that
for all
, and
whenever
.
The following theorem represents a fundamental result in neurodynamic systems theory.
Theorem 5. [Theorem of Lyapunov’s] Let denote an equilibrium point of the dynamical system (9). If the Lyapunov function is associated with
, then it follows that
serves as a globally asymptotically stable state of the system (9).
We apply Theorem (5) to establish the stability of the solution corresponding to the system (9). Then, using Lyapunov’s direct method, we verify that the proposed second-order neurodynamic system (9) demonstrates asymptotic stability. For this purpose, we consider a Lyapunov candidate function defined as:
where is clearly positive definite, i.e.,
, and
⇔
. Thus, the derivative of the Lyapunov function
is:
Now, from the equation (9), we have
Now, substitute into
, we obtain
Simplifying, we get:
The dominant terms contributes to damping when
. The term
ensures stability for
. The last term
represents interaction between position and velocity, then
, ensuring Lyapunov stability
is negative definite for all
in the Lyapunov sense. This implies that the equilibrium point
for the dynamical system (9) is globally asymptotically stable.
4.1 Numerical Illustration
In this section, two numerical examples are presented to demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed dynamical system (9) in solving IQVIP (7).
Example 1. Suppose the operator is defined as:
with parameters and
be a symmetric matrix. Let
be the closed unit ball centered at the origin. then we defined
.
The unique solution to the variational inequality is
The parameters for this dynamical system (9) are
,
,
,
,
and
(smallest eigenvalue of A), then
and
. The numerical solution confirms that the trajectories of
globally converge to
. The numerical behavior is illustrated in Figs 1 and 2. Fig 1. This is the first figure of Example 1. Fig 2. This is the second figure of Example 1.
Example 2. Suppose the operator is defined as:
with parameters and
be a symmetric matrix. Let then we define the set-valued map
. The parameters are
,
, and compute
. Also, we assume that the time-dependent coefficients for the dynamical system (9) are
. Then choose
The unique solution of the corresponding IQVI is . Numerical simulations indicate that each component
(
) converges smoothly to zero as
, confirming global convergence of the system. The numerical behavior is illustrated in Figs 3 and 4. Fig 3 This is the first figure of Example 2. Fig 4. This is the second figure of Example 2.
5 Conclusion
This paper introduces a second-order dynamical system for solving IQVIP involving a strongly monotone and Lipschitz continuous operator. Under suitable parameter conditions, we establish the existence and uniqueness of strong global solutions, ensuring that the proposed continuous-time model is mathematically well-posed and robust.
Moreover, we proved that the discrete sequence generated by the relaxed inertial projection scheme corresponding to the dynamical system (9) converges linearly to the unique solution of the IQVIP (7). The corresponding discrete algorithm achieves linear convergence, supported by the theoretical conditions of our main theorem. The Lyapunov-based analysis establishes global asymptotic stability of the system (9), ensuring reliability and robustness of the approach. Finally, numerical illustration confirms that all trajectories of the proposed dynamical system converge smoothly to the unique solution of the IQVIP (7), demonstrating both the existence and stability of the solution. Overall, the proposed framework deepens the connection between IQVIP and dynamical system techniques, offering a foundation for further development in optimization and nonlinear analysis.
Future work includes extending this approach to higher-order systems and refining stability criteria for broader applications. These findings contribute to the analysis and computation of dynamical systems in Hilbert spaces.
References
- 1.
Facchinei F, Pang JS. Finite-dimensional variational inequalities and complementarity problems. Springer; 2003. https://doi.org/10.1007/b97544
- 2.
Bauschke H. Convex Analysis and Monotone Operator Theory in Hilbert Spaces. Springer; 2011.
- 3. Censor Y, Gibali A, Reich S. Extensions of Korpelevich’s extragradient method for the variational inequality problem in Euclidean space. Optimization. 2012;61(9):1119–32.
- 4. Malitsky YuV, Semenov VV. An Extragradient Algorithm for Monotone Variational Inequalities. Cybern Syst Anal. 2014;50(2):271–7.
- 5. Solodov MV, Svaiter BF. A New Projection Method for Variational Inequality Problems. SIAM J Control Optim. 1999;37(3):765–76.
- 6. Awwal AM, Pakkaranang N. New structured spectral gradient methods for nonlinear least squares with application in robotic motion control problems. J Comput Appl Math. 2025;469:116671.
- 7. Huang H, Agwu IK, Ishtiaq U, Alraddadi I, Saleem K, Argyros IK. An algorithm for nonlinear problems with variational inequality methods. PLoS One. 2025;20(8):e0329105. pmid:40875783
- 8. Han Y, Huang N, Lu J, Xiao Y. Existence and stability of solutions to inverse variational inequality problems. Appl Math Mech-Engl Ed. 2017;38(5):749–64.
- 9. Vuong PT, He X, Thong DV. Global Exponential Stability of a Neural Network for Inverse Variational Inequalities. J Optim Theory Appl. 2021;190(3):915–30.
- 10. Zou X, Gong D, Wang L, Chen Z. A novel method to solve inverse variational inequality problems based on neural networks. Neurocomputing. 2016;173:1163–8.
- 11. He B, He X-Z, Liu HX. Solving a class of constrained ‘black-box’ inverse variational inequalities. Eur J Oper Res. 2010;204(3):391–401.
- 12. He X, Liu HX. Inverse variational inequalities with projection-based solution methods. Eur J Oper Res. 2011;208(1):12–8.
- 13. Aussel D, Gupta R, Mehra A. Gap functions and error bounds for inverse quasi-variational inequality problems. J Math Analys Appl. 2013;407(2):270–80.
- 14. Dey S, Reich S. A dynamical system for solving inverse quasi-variational inequalities. Optimization. 2024;73(6):1681–701.
- 15. Vuong PT. A Second Order Dynamical System and Its Discretization for Strongly Pseudo-monotone Variational Inequalities. SIAM J Control Optim. 2021;59(4):2875–97.
- 16. Cavazzuti E, Pappalardo M, Passacantando M. Nash Equilibria, Variational Inequalities, and Dynamical Systems. J Optim Theory Appl. 2002;114(3):491–506.
- 17. Usman M, Khaliq A, Azeem M, Swaray S, Kallel M. The dynamics and behavior of logarithmic type fuzzy difference equation of order two. PLoS One. 2024;19(10):e0309198. pmid:39423196
- 18. Dey S, Vetrivel V. On approximate solution to the inverse quasi-variational inequality problem. Sci Math Jpn. 2019;81(3):301–6.
- 19. Chang S, Salahuddin, Liu M, Wang X, Tang J. Error bounds for generalized vector inverse quasi-variational inequality Problems with point to set mappings. AIMS Math. 2021;6(2):1800–15.
- 20. Wang Z, Chen Z, Chen Z. Gap functions and error bounds for vector inverse mixed quasi-variational inequality problems. Fixed Point Theory Appl. 2019;2019(1):14.
- 21.
Hu X, Wang J. Global stability of a recurrent neural network for solving pseudomonotone variational inequalities. In: 2006 IEEE International Symposium on Circuits and Systems (ISCAS). 2006. 4 p. http://doi.org/10.1109/ISCAS.2006.1692695
- 22. Vuong PT. The Global Exponential Stability of a Dynamical System for Solving Variational Inequalities. Netw Spat Econ. 2022;22(2):395–407.
- 23. Cao Y, Khan VK, Sarfaraz Mohd, Arbi A, Ahmad MdK. Second-order dynamical system to solve the sum of monotone operators via the KM algorithm. Alex Eng J. 2025;123:341–5.
- 24. Boţ RI, Csetnek ER. A Dynamical System Associated with the Fixed Points Set of a Nonexpansive Operator. J Dyn Diff Equat. 2015;29(1):155–68.
- 25. Boţ RI, Csetnek ER, Vuong PT. The forward–backward–forward method from continuous and discrete perspective for pseudo-monotone variational inequalities in Hilbert spaces. Eur J Oper Res. 2020;287(1):49–60.
- 26.
Nagurney A, Zhang D. Projected dynamical systems and variational inequalities with applications. vol. 2. Springer Science & Business Media; 2012. Available from: https://books.google.co.in/books?id=CvTpBwAAQBAJ
- 27. Pappalardo M, Passacantando M. Stability for Equilibrium Problems: From Variational Inequalities to Dynamical Systems. J Optim Theory Appl. 2002;113(3):567–82.
- 28. Vuong PT, Strodiot JJ. A Dynamical System for Strongly Pseudo-monotone Equilibrium Problems. J Optim Theory Appl. 2020;185(3):767–84.
- 29. Raheem A, Alamrani FM, Akhtar J, Alatawi A, Alshaban E, Khatoon A, et al. Study on Controllability for Ψ-Hilfer Fractional Stochastic Differential Equations. Fractal Fract. 2024;8(12):727.
- 30. Pakkaranang N. Double inertial extragradient algorithms for solving variational inequality problems with convergence analysis. Math Methods Appl Sci. 2024;47(14):11642–69.
- 31. Karamardian S, Schaible S. Seven kinds of monotone maps. J Optim Theory Appl. 1990;66(1):37–46.
- 32.
Kinderlehrer D, Stampacchia G. An introduction to variational inequalities and their applications. SIAM; 2000. https://doi.org/10.1137/1.9780898719451
- 33.
Haraux A. Systèmes dynamiques dissipatifs et applications. Collection recherches en mathématiques appliquées. Masson; 1991. Available from: https://cir.nii.ac.jp/crid/1971149384889544105