Figures
Abstract
Gyrinops walla Garten., which is an endemic and endangered species of Sri Lanka, produces the world’s most expensive agarwood used in perfume industry. The high demand for agarwood has resulted in indiscriminate felling of trees, thus threatening the survival of the species. The present study aimed to develop an efficient in vitro rapid multiplication technique to conserve the existing trees from extinction, by ensuring the sustainable supply of planting materials for commercial cultivations and to investigate the possibility of producing fragrance compounds by in vitro plantlets without felling trees. Efficient micropropagation protocol was developed from axillary buds and shoot tip explants. Murashige and Skoog (MS) medium supplemented with 1.0 mg/L BAP was the best for the establishment of both shoot tips (80.0%) and axillary buds (86.0%). Regenerated buds were further multiplied (10.6 ± 0.93 shoot buds/regenerated shoot) and elongated (4.0 ± 0.26 cm) by transferring to MS medium supplemented with 1.0 mg/L BAP, 0.1 mg/L IBA and 40 g/L sucrose. Highest in vitro rooting percentage (66.7%) was recorded in ½ MS medium supplemented with 1.0 mg/L IAA and 40 g/L sucrose. However, none of the shoots rooted on MS media could be acclimatized. Significantly higher percentage of rooted shoots (93.3%) were produced on sand medium without auxin treatment compared to shoots cultured on MS medium supplemented with 1.0 mg/L IAA (66%) and successfully acclimatized with 83.6% survival rate in a medium consisted of sand, topsoil, and compost (1:1:1 ratio). TLC fingerprints of ethyl acetate extracts of in vitro grown plantlets and agarwood produced similar spots at the retention factors (Rf) of 0.60, 0.66, and 0.87 under 15% methanol: 85% chloroform solvent system. Chemicals present in in vitro plantlets were identified and compared with the agarwood of naturally grown G. walla by GC-MS. Both natural agarwood and in vitro grown shoot extracts contained 4-Hydroxypyridine 1-oxide (23.2%), 2-tetradecene (16.3%), 1-hexadecene (0.3%), E-15-heptadecenal (19.8%), 18-norabietane (0.6%) and eicosane (0.4%). Present study successfully developed a protocol for rapid multiplication of G. walla and indicates the possibility of using of in vitro plantlets to produce agarwood resinous compounds.
Citation: Selvaskanthan S, Jayasinghe L, Eeswara JP (2025) Rapid micropropagation and chemical profiling of in vitro plantlets and agarwood of Gyrinops walla Gaertn. by gas-chromatography and mass-spectrometry. PLoS ONE 20(4): e0321049. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0321049
Editor: Pankaj Bhardwaj, Central University of Punjab, INDIA
Received: December 24, 2023; Accepted: February 28, 2025; Published: April 8, 2025
Copyright: © 2025 Selvaskanthan et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Data Availability: All relevant data are within the paper and its Supporting Information files.
Funding: National Research Council, Sri Lanka for the financial support to conduct the experiments (NRC/2017/017). However, the funding agency had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Abbreviations: TLC, Thin Layer Chromatography; GC-MS, Gas chromatography- mass spectrometry; PGR, Plant growth regulator; BAP, 6-Benzylaminopurine; NAA, 1-Naphthaleneacetic acid; IBA, Indole-3-butyric acid; IAA, Indole-3-acetic acid; MS, Murashige and Skoog medium
Introduction
Gyrinops walla Gaertn., belongs to the family Thymelaeaceae, produces fragrant resinous compounds widely used in the perfumery and cosmetic industry [1,2]. It has been protected under the Flora and Fauna Protection Ordinance (Amendment) No 49 of 1993 in Sri Lanka since 2004 and listed in Appendix II of the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora (CITES), since 2005. The higher international demand for the perfume industry in the Middle East countries has driven large-scale illegal harvesting of the trees from tropical rainforests in Sri Lanka. Extensive exploitation of this species has resulted in enhanced tree mortality, reduced growth rate and the percentage of adult trees that produce seeds [3].
Even though, sexual propagation is a reliable method for G. walla, rare seed production, low seed viability, and low germination rate makes it inadequate to meet the current demand of seedling supplies. Furthermore, delayed rooting of seedlings and long life cycle of this plant species are the barriers for conventional propagation under natural conditions [4]. Thus, in vitro propagation of G. walla would be a better and viable alternative for production of plantlets to fulfil the existing demand.
The use of shoot cultures is another alternative to produce resinous fragrance compounds than the felling of mature trees. Thus, identification of chemicals composition of in vitro plantlets of G. walla and comparison with the chemicals present in agarwood is necessary before employing tissue culture techniques for product synthesis. Thin Layer Chromatography (TLC) is a versatile method for primary screening of phytochemicals present in any sample. Gas chromatography- Mass spectroscopy (GC-MS) is another useful technique for screening, identification, and quantification of many non-polar and semi-polar volatile compounds. Its high separation power accompanied with a mass spectroscopy detector makes this technique an important tool in the analysis of ultra-trace levels of compounds present in a sample.
Therefore, the present study aimed at rapid multiplication of G. walla that would reduce the gap created due to over-exploitation of this species while giving an opportunity to conserve the natural population in the wild habitats. Furthermore, identification and comparison of chemical constituents of in vitro plantlets and agarwood provides an opportunity to produce fragrance compounds through shoot cultures of G. walla protecting the trees growing in natural ecosystems.
Materials and methods
Experimental locations
All the micropropagation studies were conducted at the Department of Crop Science, Faculty of Agriculture, University of Peradeniya while chemical analysis was done at the Natural Product Laboratory, National Institute of Fundamental studies.
Plant materials
One year old G. walla seedlings obtained from the Divisional Forest Office, Ratnapura, Sri Lanka were grown in pots containing the mixture of compost, soil, and sand at a 1:1:1 ratio. Seedlings were kept inside the glasshouse at 27 ± 2 °C and the photoperiod of 12 hours light/12 hours dark at the Agricultural Biotechnology Centre, Faculty of Agriculture, University of Peradeniya, Sri Lanka.
Mother plants were pre-treated with 0.1% w/v of redoxyl metalaxyl (CIC, Sri Lanka) once a week continuously for 4 weeks before collecting the explants to reduce the contamination during the establishment of in vitro cultures.
Establishment of axillary buds and shoot tip cultures
Freshly excised nodal and apical segments of G. walla were washed thoroughly under slow running tap water for 10 minutes. The explants were then washed in liquid soap (teepol Lankem, Sri Lanka) for 1 minute and rinsed thoroughly with H2O for another 10 minutes.
Then shoot tips and axillary buds were excised and sterilized separately using the procedure reported earlier under a laminar flow cabinet (Labgard Class II, Type A/B3) [5]. The surface sterilized shoot tips and axillary bud explants were trimmed to 1.2–1.5 cm in length and single explant was placed on culture tube containing sterilized (121 °C for 20 minutes at 15 psi) MS [6] medium supplemented with 30 g/L sucrose with four different concentrations (0, 1.0, 2.0 or 5.0 mg/L) of Benzyl Amino Purine. Media pH was adjusted to 5.8 before autoclaving. Then 5–8 growing buds were transferred to the culture jars containing the same media (establishment media) at four week interval regularly until 4th sub-culture. Based on the results of this experiment, MS medium supplemented with 1.0 or 2.0 mg/L BAP was selected for further studies on elongation and multiplication of proliferated shoots.
In vitro multiplication and elongation of established shoots
After 4th subculture (16th weeks after establishment), the multiple shoots were separated from the clusters into single shoots and all the dead tissues were removed. Every single shoot was cut at the basal end and growing shoots were transferred to fresh MS media containing either 30 or 40 g/L of sucrose supplemented with BAP (1.0 or 2.0 mg/L), 0.1 mg/L filter sterilized gibberellic acid (GA3) or 1.0 mg/L BAP in combination with 0.1 mg/L indole-3-buteric acid (IBA) (Table 1). Sub-culturing was done regularly every four weeks intervals.
In vitro rooting on MS medium
The effect of different concentrations of IAA, IBA, NAA (0, 0.5, 1.0 and 2.0 mg/L) at 30 or 40 g/L sucrose concentration on rooting was investigated in a preliminary study [7]. The results showed (not included in the present paper) very low success for rooting at all IBA and NAA concentrations [7]. Majority of the shoots grown on IBA and NAA media showed senescence and necrosis. Therefore, the experiment was repeated only with IAA. The shoots elongated and multiplied on MS medium supplemented with 40 g/L of sucrose, 1.0 mg/L BAP and 0.1 mg/L IBA were transferred into ½ MS media containing two sucrose levels (30 or 40 g/L), with two different concentrations (0.5 and 1.0 mg/L) of IAA.
In vitro rooting on sterilized sand medium
The basal ends of the healthy, vigorous shoots originated from the MS medium supplemented with 40 g/L of sucrose, 1.0 mg/L BAP and 0.1 mg/L IBA were dipped in two different concentrations (0 or 1000 mg/L) of IAA or IBA solutions either for 15 or 30 minutes. The treated shoots were established in glass jars (350 mL) containing sterilized sand (nearly 167.5 g) wetted with sterilized distilled water (35 mL). All these procedures were conducted under sterile conditions inside a laminar flow cabinet. Then the bottles were covered with polypropylene sheets and transferred to the culture room. Based on the results obtained for in vitro rooting on MS medium, few samples were removed at weekly intervals to observe the rooting process and data obtained at the 8th week after planting was used for analysis.
Culture conditions
All the cultures were maintained inside glass containers covered with polypropylene sheets maintaining 100% RH inside the culture bottles. Cultures were incubated under cool white fluorescent light (1000 lux), with the photoperiod of 16/8 hours light/dark at 25 ± 2 °C which has shown highly successful in previous studies [8,9]. Temperature of the culture room was maintained using an air conditioner since the laboratory is situated in mid country wet zone of Sri Lanka where average temperature was about 23–28 °C and RH is 75–80%.
Acclimatization
All the in vitro rooted shoots on ½ MS media supplemented with 30 or 40 g/L sucrose and 0.5 or 1.0 mg/L of IAA were transferred to potting mixture consisting of soil, sand and compost in 1:1:1 ratio for acclimatization inside the single propagators prepared by using polypropylene bags. Then the plants were gradually exposed to the outside environment by making holes starting at two weeks after transferring into single propagators.
The sand bottles containing rooted shoots were directly transferred to the plant house and allowed to adapt into outside environment by gradually making small holes on polypropylene cover starting two weeks after transferring to the plant house. Four weeks after transferring to the plant house, the polypropylene cover was removed completely.
The plantlets were allowed to remain in the opened sand bottles or single propagators for another two weeks before transferring into pots consisting of soil, sand and compost in 1:1:1 ratio.
Data collection
Percentage of explants induced shoot buds, mean length of shoot bud and mean number of shoot buds from shoot tip and axillary budswere recorded at the establishment stage. During elongation and multiplication stage, the number of shoots multiplied per cluster, number of leaves per shoot and shoot length were recorded. Percentage of rooted shoots, number of roots per shoot and mean root length were recorded weekly after eight weeks of transferring shoots into the rooting media.
Data analysis
Experiments were laid in complete randomized design (CRD). In all the experiments each treatment was replicated five times and each replicate contained five to eight shoots. Parametric data were subjected to analysis of variance (ANOVA). Mean separation was done by Tukey’s test at the 5% level using Minitab 17 statistical software package (minitab.com).
Phytochemical analysis of in vitro plantlets and agarwood of G. walla using chromatographic techniques
Preparation of extracts for chromatographic studies.
Freeze-dried in vitro plantlets and agarwood samples were crushed separately to a fine powder by using a mortar and pestle. The crushed samples were subjected to ultrasound-assisted solvent extraction (ROCKER ultrasonic cleaner, model- soner 206H) for 30 minutes with 100 mL of HPLC grade hexane (Sigma, UK). The extracts were filtered using a Whatman number 1 filter paper and residue was further extracted twice with hexane. Then the solvents collected from three extractions were combined and evaporated to dryness using a rotary evaporator (Heidolph, Laborota 4000) at 90 rpm and temperature below 40 °C, until viscous semi-dried crude extract was obtained. The residual materials were again extracted thrice with HPLC grade dichloromethane (Sigma, UK) and ethyl acetate (Sigma, UK) sequentially and the extracts were evaporated to dryness using a rotary evaporator as described for hexane extracts.
The crude extract (5 mg) obtained after drying was dissolved in l mL of HPLC grade hexane, dichloromethane or ethyl acetate based on the original extracting solution. Then the extracts were filtered using a glass syringe attached with 0.45-micron disposable membrane filters before being injected to GC-MS.
Development of TLC fingerprints.
Ethyl acetate has been reported to be the best solvent for extraction for Thin Layer Chromatography of G. walla samples based on numbers and intensity of spots [10]. Both hexane and dichloromethane extracts did not produce clear bands on TLC plates [10]. Thus, 5.0 mg/mL of ethyl acetate extracts of in vitro plantlets and agarwood were spotted using capillary tubes on TLC silica plates pre-coated on aluminium foil (Merck, 105554, TLC Silica gel 60 F). Then the solvents were allowed to evaporate completely and the spotted plates were placed in a chromatographic solvent chamber containing 15% methanol (Sigma, UK): 85% chloroform (Sigma, UK), which was identified as the best mobile phase in an earlier study [10]. The TLC plates were propped vertically in the solvent chamber and allowed to stand for sufficient time for elution. When the solvent front had nearly reached the top of the stationary phase, the plate was removed from the chamber and the developed TLC plates were air dried. UV monitoring at 254 nm was performed for the detection of the compounds present in the crude extract using UV lamp (VILBER LOURMART CN-15-LC, 230 V- 50/60 Hz).
Rf (Retention factor) was calculated using the following formula [11]:
Headspace analysis of GC-MS.
Hexane, dichloromethane, and ethyl acetate extracts of in vitro plantlets and agarwood of G. walla were used for the headspace analysis of GC-MS to detect volatile compounds and their comparison. GC-MS analysis was performed on 5975C gas chromatograph (Agilent technologies, USA, www.agilent.com) fitted with a fused silica HP-5MS capillary column (30 m × 0.25 mm; film thickness 0.25 μm). Helium was used as carrier gas at a flow rate of 2 mL/min. The gas chromatograph was coupled with 7693 mass selective detector (Agilent technologies, USA, www.agilent.com). Headspace auto-samplers were used to have provision to pressurize the vial at a constant pressure equivalent to the column inlet pressure for better quantification. Vials were placed on auto-sampler and generated results for each sample was obtained as chromatograms showing the chemicals composition with the help of the software attached to the instrument.
Results
Establishment of shoot tip and axillary bud cultures
Both shoot tips and axillary buds were successfully established on MS medium supplemented with 1.0 mg/L of BAP (Fig 1).
(A) shoot tip cultures. (B) axillary bud cultures.
MS medium supplemented with 1.0 mg/L BAP was found to be best for inducing shoot buds from both shoot tips (80.0%) and axillary buds (86.7%) (Fig 2A). The same medium was proven to be superior by significantly increasing the mean length of regenerated shoot buds (1.8 cm and 1.0 cm for shoot tips and axillary buds, respectively) after eight weeks of inoculation (Fig 2B). After the 16th week of inoculation (4th subculture), the highest number of shoot buds per explant (3.6 and 9.6 for shoot tips and axillary buds, respectively) was regenerated in the same medium (Fig 2C). MS media, without any PGRs, was not efficient in inducing the shoot buds from both explants (6.7% and 13.3%) (Fig 2A). Axillary bud explants, which were in MS media containing 5.0 mg/L BAP, started to proliferate rapidly, but when they were subsequently transferred to the same medium, the shoot buds were twisty and further elongation was not recorded (Fig 2B and Fig 3). Multiplied shoots on medium consisted of 5.0 mg/L BAP became vitrified and showed abnormalities and could not be isolated for further multiplication. Based on the results of this experiment, MS medium supplemented with 1.0 and 2.0 mg/L BAP were selected for the elongation and further multiplication of proliferated shoots in the second experiment.
(A) percentage explants induced shoot buds out of 25 shoots. (B) mean length (cm) of shoot buds eight weeks after inoculation (2nd subculture). (C) mean number of shoot buds 16 weeks after inoculation (4th subculture).
(A) 0 BAP. (B) 1.0 mg/L BAP.(C) 2.0 mg/L BAP.(D) 5.0 mg/L BAP.
Elongation and further multiplication of in vitro established shoots
In the first experiment, both shoot tip and axillary bud explants established on MS medium supplemented with 30 g/L sucrose and 1.0 or 2.0 mg/L BAP did not elongate beyond 2 cm (Fig 2A). Selection of concentration and combination of PGRs is critical for shoot multiplication and elongation before rooting and acclimatization of micropropagated shoots. Thus, it was decided to investigate the effect of higher concentration (40 g/L) of sucrose in combination with 0, 1.0 or 2.0 mg/L BAP or 0. 1 mg/L GA3 on shoot elongation and further multiplication. When the shoots were sub-cultured continuously on to the hormone-free MS medium, irrespective of the sugar concentration (30 or 40 g/L), yellowing of leaves, ultimately necrosis and senescence was observed. Shoots transferred to MS media supplemented with 0.1 mg/L GA3 also showed stunted stem growth with elongated leaves disproportional to the stem size. Eventually, chlorosis and shedding leaves followed by senescence of shoots occurred in this medium. Furthermore, none of the shoots transferred to the media containing 1.0 or 2.0 mg/L BAP alone did not elongate beyond 2.0 cm, both at 30 and 40 mg/L sucrose concentration (Table 1). However, shoots grown on medium containing 1.0 mg/L BAP showed significantly higher elongation and multiplication compared to medium consisted with 2.0 mg/L BAP (Table 1). Furthermore, lower concentrations of IBA (0.1 mg/L) was incorporated into MS medium supplemented only with 1.0 mg/L BAP to investigate the combined effect of BAP and IBA on shoot elongation and multiplication.
Interestingly, significantly higher elongation (4.0 cm) and multiplication (10.6 shoots per cluster) of shoots could be achieved eight weeks after transferring the shoots (24th weeks after establishing) to MS medium supplemented with 1.0 mg/L BAP, 0.1 mg/L IBA and 40 g/L sucrose (Table 1, Fig 4). Furthermore, when 40 g/L of sucrose was added to full MS medium supplemented with 1.0 mg/L BAP and 0.1 mg/L IBA performed well compared to 30 g/L of sucrose with same concentrations of BAP and IBA showing that there is an interactive effect (P ≤ 0.05) between sucrose concentration when 1.0 mg/L BAP was in combination with 0.1 mg/L IBA.
(A) at the time of transferring (16th week of establishment). (B) at the end of 1st subculture (20th week of establishment). (C) at the beginning of 2nd subculture (shoots cluster separated). (D) multiplication of shoots at the end of 2nd subculture (at the end of 24th week of establishment). (E)one cluster of multiplied shoots at the end of 24th week.
In vitro rooting of G. walla on MS medium
Adventitious roots initiation was observed after five weeks of transferring the shoots into the rooting media. Highest rooting percentage (66.7 ± 5.27%) with highest mean root length (6.15 ± 0.34 cm) was observed when the microshoots were transferred to ½ MS medium fortified with 1.0 mg/L IAA and 40 g/L sucrose concentration. However, this treatment produced lowest mean number of roots/shoots (1.56 ± 0.241). The highest average number of roots was observed in ½ MS medium supplemented with 0.5 mg/L IAA either with 40 (2.45 ± 0.47) or 30 g/L (2.31 ± 0.24) sucrose concentrations (Table 2 and Fig 5).
Moreover, among all treatments, ½ MS media supplemented with 40 g/L of sucrose, induced roots well, compared to 30 g/L of sucrose fortified ½ MS media. However, all the treatments produced very fragile looking roots initiated from the callus produced at the base of the shoots (Fig 5).
In vitro rooting of G. walla on sand medium
Root initiation was observed 5–6 weeks after transferring the shoots into the sand medium. The highest percentage (93.3 ± 4.08%) of rooting was recorded, when micro-shoots were transferred to sand without IAA or IBA treatment. Eight weeks after transferring, the lowest percentage of rooted shoots (33.3 ± 5.27%) were recorded when micro-shoots were dipped in 1000 mg/L IBA for 30 minutes before planting in the sand bottle (Table 3). Majority of the shoots treated with 1000 mg/L IBA became yellow and die back was observed as in the preliminary study conducted under in vitro conditions [7].
Statistical analysis showed that there was a significant difference in inducing number of roots per shoot in between IAA and IBA containing media (Table 3). The highest average number of roots per shoot was observed in the shoots, pulsed with 1000 mg/L IBA for 15 minutes (4.0), followed by 1000 mg/L IBA for 30 minutes (3.88).
Even though, there was no significant difference among treatments for the average root length per shoot at P ≤ 0.05 probability level (Table 3), the highest root length (1.79 cm) was observed when the shoots treated with 1000 mg/L IAA for 30 minutes. Meanwhile, shortest root (1.41 cm) was recorded under 1000 mg/L IBA for 15 minutes treatment (Fig 6).
(A) 1000 mg/L IAA for 15 minutes. (B) 1000 mg/L IAA for 30 minutes. (C) 1000 mg/L IBA for 15 minutes. (D) 1000 mg/L IBA for 30 minutes.(E) control.
Furthermore, development of good quality roots without callus was observed in the sand medium irrespective of the hormones used for rooting and pulsing time.
Acclimatization
All the rooted shoots, produced in sand medium were successfully acclimatized within four weeks and 83.6% of them were grown to full plants in the sand: soil: compost media at 1:1:1 ratio (Fig 7). However, none of the plants rooted on MS media survived during acclimatization showing the superiority of the sand medium for rooting of micropropagated G. walla plants.
(A and B) Plants during acclimatization. (C) in vitro propagated one year old G. walla plants.
Comparison of chemical constituents present in micropropagated plantlets and agarwood of G. walla using TLC and GC-MS
TLC fingerprints of in vitro plantlets and agarwood.
Ethyl acetate extracts of in vitro grown plantlets and agarwood produced similar spots at the retention factors of 0.60, 0.66 and 0.87 (Fig 8) indicating that three similar, less polar compounds might be present in in vitro grown plantlets and agarwood of G. walla, under 15% methanol: 85% chloroform solvent (v/v) system.
(A) in vitro plantlets (TC). (B)agarwood of G. walla (Ag).
Gas chromatography and mass spectrometric profiles of in vitro plantlets and agarwood.
In the GC-MS profile of micropropagated plantlets, total of 46 compounds were identified while agarwood sample of G. walla contained total of 95 compounds. Hexane, dichloromethane and ethyl acetate extracts of micropropagated shoots contained 7, 7 and 32 compounds respectively, while agarwood extracts contained 63, 15 and 17 compounds respectively. All the seven compounds detected in hexane extracts of micropropagated shoots were eluted before 16.13 (RI) while all the chemicals except 4 Hydroxypyridine 1 –oxide present in hexane extracts of agarwood eluted after 16.13 minutes. Furthermore, 4 Hydroxypyridine 1 –oxide, which was eluted at 15.27 minutes was common for both agarwood and hexane extracts (Supplementary information).
In the present study, many compounds identified in the agarwood GC-MS profile of G. walla were already reported in earlier studies done in agarwood producing tree species, especially in Aquillaria species. Agarospirol (0.5%) [12–14], aristolene (6.5%) [14,15], β -neoclovene (4.5%) [16], heptadecane, 2-methyl (1.0%) [14] and octadecane, 1-chloro (2.0%) 14] were the compounds identified in hexane extracts of agarwood (Supplementary Information). Furthermore, nonadecane (2.3%), aristolene (7.1%) [14], hexadecane (5.0%) [14], eicosane (4.1%) [15] and octacosane (5.0%) [17] were the compounds identified in dichloromethane extract of agarwood. However, none of these chemicals were present in hexane and dichloromethane extracts of microshoots. Interestingly, 2-tetradecene (11.9%) [18] and 1-hexadecene (23.5%) [14], E-15-Heptadecenal (19.8%) and 18-Norabietane (0.6%) were detected in ethyl acetate extracts of both agarwood and micro-shoots as reported in the earlier studies for Aquillaria species.
Compounds identified in the micropropagated plantlets such as, dodecane [14], 2,6,10-trimethyl-, 12-octadecenoic acidmethyl ester [14], hexanedioic acid, mono(2-ethylhexyl) ester [14], 2-tetradecene [18], 1-hexadecene [14], E-15-heptadecenal, 1-octadecene [15,19], eicosane [19] and heptadecane [19] were also reported in previous studies done in development of chemical profiles of Aquillaria species (Supplementary information).
Discussion
Development of a micropropgataion procedure for mass cultivation of G. walla
The present study was focused on direct proliferation of the shoot tips and axillary bud explants of G. walla since it is the most reliable method for clonal propagation to achieve the genetic uniformity among the progenies. Even though, proliferated shoot tip explants were taller than the shoots proliferated from the axillary buds, the mean number of generated shoot buds during establishment stage was higher in the axillary bud explants (Fig 2C). Furthermore, the availability of axillary buds from a single mother plant is higher than the shoot tips. Thus, axillary bud explants can be considered as a better source of explants for the establishment of G. walla shoot cultures.
In agreement with the results of earlier studies [20], low concentrations of BAP was effective in stimulating shoot buds initiation from both shoot tips and axillary buds. The increase of BAP concentration above 1.0 mg/L BAP showed drastic reduction in shoot establishment as well as shoot elongation. At highest BAP concentration (5.0 mg/L) further elongation of initiated shoot buds did not occur. Moreover, those shoots showed symptoms of vitrification which may happen as a result of high cell division associated with high concentrations of cytokinins [21] and inhibition of adventitious meristem elongation [20,22].
Micropropagated plantlets growing under in vitro conditions are not autotrophic and therefore need to have a supply of energy source for in vitro cell growth, maintenance, and differentiation [23]. Previous studies stated that sugar alone or through its interaction with different phytohormones and nitrogen can induce or suppress many growth-related gene responses in higher plants [24,25]. Thus, in the present study importance of maintaining the balance between the carbon source and PGRs for the shoot elongation and multiplication during in vitro growth of G. walla was investigated. The shoots transferred to MS medium without BAP had low multiplication, slow rate of shoot elongation, and ultimately shoots became necrotic and died irrespective of the sugar concentration of the medium. In agreement with the results of the present study differences in the shoot growth, shoot tip dieback, defoliation, and necrosis has been reported when nodal explants of avocado were grown on hormone-free media for 30 days [26]. Furthermore, MS media supplemented only with BAP (1.0 or 2.0 mg/L) also did not elongate at higher sucrose concentrations (40 g/L) than the recommended level (30 g/L). Even though, gibberellic acid (GA3) cause internodal elongation [21], in the present study further elongation of microshoots could not be achieved on MS media supplemented with 0.1 mg/L GA3 both at 30 and 40 g/L sucrose concentrations. In contrast, stunted stem growth occurred while elongating the leaves disproportional to the size of the stem. Eventually, chlorosis and leaf shedding leading to senescence of shoots was observed. In agreement with the results of the present study, deleterious effects of GA3 on elongation and rooting of Prunus instititia L. rootstock [27] resulting chlorosis and apical die-back of in vitro shoots has been reported [27]. Furthermore, GA3 alone in the media had no effect on multiplication and elongation of tea shoots [21]. Interestingly, shoots transferred to MS medium supplemented with 1 mg/L BAP combined with 0.1 mg/L IBA performed well at both sucrose concentration and better performance was observed at 40 g/L sucrose concentration compared to 30 g/L concentration (Table 1). Thus, it may be possible that 30 g/L sucrose concentration is insufficient to supply the energy required for the high cell division and differentiation occurred in the medium supplemented with 1.0 mg/L BAP combined with 0.1 mg/L IBA while increase of the sucrose concentration up to 40 g/L may supply the required level of energy for the growth and development. Furthermore, the exogenous supply of sucrose may increase the endogenous content of carbohydrate stocks in in vitro plants, which may accelerate physiological adaptations of the in vitro shoots [28]. In addition, higher sucrose concentration of the in vitro medium may support water conservation, maintain the osmotic potential of cells by acting as an osmoticum and consequently reducing vitrification of in vitro cultures [28]. In agreement with the results of the present study 40 g/L of sucrose has been shown to increase the number of shoots/ explant and shoot length of developed shoots in Harpagophytum procumbens [29] and taller shoots in in vitro beech cultures with lower rate of vitrification [30]. In the present study, half strength of MS medium was selected for in vitro root induction, since the rooting ability of in vitro shoots have been reported to be affected by the mineral concentration of the medium [31]. In many species such as Dendrocalamus longispathus [32], Chlorophytum borivilianum [33] and Dalbergia sissoo [34], the percentage of rooted shoots was higher when shoots were rooted on half strength MS medium.
A higher concentration of sucrose (40 g/L) than the recommendation (30 g/L) in MS medium with reduced nitrogen strength by half, showed better in vitro root induction in the current study. In agreement with the results of the present study, sucrose at concentrations of 40–50 g/L is reported to increase the number of roots (5.8–6.0) in the media containing reduced level of nitrogenous salts in Helleborus niger microplants [35]. The rooting ability is strongly dependent on the carbon to nitrogen ratio of plants [36]. The effect of modification in carbon abundance has an impact on nitrogen metabolism and vice versa. An integration of C/N nutrient signals with the phytohormone act on developmental process in plants [37]. Thus, the presence of higher sucrose concentration in the culture medium may contributed to the process of cell division in the root apical meristem, which caused an increase in root length [38].
Auxins play an important role in root formation. The composition of rooting media, concentration, and type of auxin has been shown to effect the in vitro rooting [39]. Many studies have shown that exogenous application of auxins results in increased initiation of lateral roots. Thus, series of experiments were conducted to develop a protocol for rooting in Gyrinops walla microshoots. Results of preliminary study [7] showed that percentage rooting of microshoots transferred to ½ MS medium containing both NAA and IBA was very less ( < 50%). At higher IBA and NAA concentration (2.0 mg/L) none of the shoots produced roots while highest rooting percentage for IBA (25%) was achieved when media were supplemented with 0.1 or 0.5 mg/L IBA with 40 g/L sucrose. Most of the shoots cultured on media containing IBA and NAA started chlorosis and senescence indicating that continuous exposure to auxin rich medium does not favour the growth of micro shoots [7].
IAA is one of the effective auxins used in in vitro rooting of shoots in many plant species. In agreement with the results of the present study in vitro root induction and growth was highly inhibited with NAA and IBA than with IAA in apple variety ‘Jork 9’ [40].
Ex vitro rooting of micro shoots is an efficient technique in many of the difficult to root woody plant species [41,42]. Ex vitro rooting was found superior since plantlets developed through this method had lateral roots without any callus at the base of microcuttings, higher root lengths, rooting rates, and transplant survival rate compared to the in vitro rooted plantlets [43]. In the present study, rooting experiment on sand medium was conducted to improve the success rate of rooting of micro shoots as well as to develop a new technique to overcome drawbacks occurred in the in vitro rooting experiments.
Tissue-cultured microshoots of 23 tree species and bamboo had developed roots in the sand and these microplants can easily survive in the field because of their healthy roots grown in the sand [44]. Therefore, sand was selected as the rooting medium replacing the MS medium in the present study.
Our study showed the possibilities of successful rooting of G. walla without any auxin treatments on sand medium in agreement with the results obtained during ex vitro rooting of two Lonicera. caerulea var. kamtschatica cultivars ‘Wojtek’ and ‘Zojka’ [45].
On the other hand, lowest rooting percentage was observed, when the shoots were treated with IBA. In contrast, IBA has been reported as most effective in inducing roots in Siraitia grosvenorii [46]. Toxicity at high IBA concentration might be the reason for reduction in the survival and root initiation observed in the present study. In many research, lower concentration of IBA for shorter period of treatment were reported as highly efficient in inducing roots under the ex vitro condition. Ex vitro rooting of micropropagated shoots of Bauhinia racemosa Lam. treated with IBA 400 mg/L for seven minutes [47] and Couroupita guianens, treated with 400 mg/L of IBA for five minutes [48] had shown effective for rooting. It is also confirmed that Solanum muricatum Aiton. cuttings treated with 500 mg/L IBA were more effective than the concentration of 1000 mg/L [49]. In the present study higher efficacy of rooting on sand medium was observed when the in vitro grown shoots were treated with IAA compared with IBA for 15 minutes and 30 minutes. The photooxidation of IAA occurs rapidly (50% within 24 hours) compared to that of IBA (10% within 24 hours [50]. Thus, IAA may also not effective in rooting of G. walla microshoots due to this character. This implies that internal auxin concentrations of the micro-shoots are adequate for root initiation as observed in the untreated micro-shoots.
Furthermore, all the roots developed in the sand medium were healthy and did not form callus at root base. Under the in vitro rooting conditions, the roots were developed from the callus base, which were fragile and difficult to acclimatize. In vitro media are rich in mineral nutrients, plant growth regulators as well as carbohydrates. Thus, cells at base of shoots can absorb nutrients easily by diffusion resulting high rate of cell division and multiplication compared to the microshoots growing on sand media with low mineral nutrient contents resulting callus formation.
Furthermore, sand media do not supply carbohydrate to the microshoots and become autotrophic during rooting process resulting better growth with morphologically strong and well-developed root system that sustains under field conditions [43].
Acclimatization is a critical stage of micropropagation of woody species. Commercialization of micropropagation technology has been hampered by the poor rate of survival of in vitro raised plantlets during acclimatization [28,51]. Many in vitro propagated plant species show a high mortality rate during the process of transferring to ex vitro conditions [52].
In the present study, 83.6% survival rate was recorded during acclimatization of plants rooted on sand medium while none of the plants rooted on MS medium could be acclimatized. This results implies the importance of successful rooting [53] for acclimatization and field establishment of plantlets.
Comparison of chemical constituents present in in vitro plantlets and agarwood of G. walla by TLC and GC-MS.
TLC fingerprint with a visible pattern of bands provides fundamental data which can be used to determine the number of components in a mixture and to identity them by comparing with Rf of a known compound when both run on the same TLC plate using the same eluent [54]. In the present study, similar spots at the retention factors of 0.60, 0.66, and 0.87 of ethyl acetate extracts of tissue culture plantlets and agarwood indicate that in vitro grown plantlets also produce very similar compounds to chemicals produced by agarwood of G. walla. Thus, it may be possible to use these bands as TLC fingerprints for identifying plant samples derived from G. walla.
Plant cells can be considered as miniature factories successfully producing high-value secondary metabolites [55]. Previous studies done in several plant species proved the potential for the industrial production of secondary metabolites through plant cell cultures, such as berberine [56], rosmarinic acid [57] and sanguinarine [58]. Compounds identified in the GC-MS belonged to the groups of aldehydes, phenol, ether, ketone, sesquiterpenes hydrocarbons, oxygenated sesquiterpenes, fatty acid methyl esters, and sterols.
Interestingly GC-MS results obtained by hexane, dichloromethane and ethyl acetate extracts of microshoots and agarwood confirmed the results reported for TLC finger prints of G. walla callus extracts [10], where phytochemicals present in callus could be visualized clearly by using thin layer chromatography when calli were extracted with ethyl acetate compared to hexane and dichloromethane extracts. Furthermore, TLC profiles obtained in the present study produced three similar compounds based on retention time while GC-MS results confirmed it by resulting five similar compounds in ethyl acetate extracts of both agarwood and microshoots.
Most of the compounds detected in the present study have not been reported elsewhere and some of the important compounds identified in this study were already reported in earlier studies done for agarwood of Aquillaria species. However, the compounds such as Agarospirol, aristolene and β –neoclovene which contribute to fragrance were not present in the microshoots. In the present study, microshoots were grown in nutrient rich environment and it is a known fact that agarwood resinous compounds are produced as a response to fungal invasions. Thus, it may be possible to enhance the production of resinous compounds through the in vitro shoot cultures of G. walla by using elicitors such as salicylic acid, chitosan and methyl jasmonate.
Conclusions
Shoot tips (80.0%) and axillary buds (86.0%) could successfully be established on MS medium supplemented with 1.0 mg/L BAP. Further multiplication (10.6 shoot buds/ regenerated shoot) and elongation (4.0 cm) of established shoot buds could be achieved by transferring to MS medium supplemented with 40 g/L sucrose and 1.0 mg/L BAP combined with 0.1 mg/L IBA. None of the shoots rooted on in vitro MS media containing IAA, IBA or NAA could be acclimatized. Higher rooting efficiency (93.3%) could be achieved by transferring microshoots to sand medium without application of auxins and 83.6% of them were successfully acclimatized in the medium containing sand, soil, and compost at 1:1:1 ratio.
TLC fingerprints of in vitro plantlets and agarwood revealed the presence of three similar compounds at Rf values of 0.60, 0.66 and 0.87, which could be used as possible markers for G. walla. In the GC-MS analysis, 4-Hydroxypyridine 1-oxide, 2-tetradecene (23.2%), 1-hexadecene (0.3%), E-15-heptadecenal (19.8%), 18-norabietane (0.6%) and eicosane (0.4%) were the similar compounds identified in both in vitro plantlets and agarwood of G.walla.
The present study successfully standardized the culture conditions of each stage of micropropagation of G. walla and elucidates the possibilities of producing agarwood resinous compounds using the in vitro shoot culture techniques.
Key message
Efficient micropropagation protocol was developed for rapid regeneration and multiplication of G. walla, an endangered species, to conserve from extinction. TLC and GC-MS chemical profiles of in vitro plantlets and agarwood extracts were compared, and similar resinous compounds were identified.
Supporting information
S1 Fig. GC-MS Chromatograms of different solvent extracts of in vitro propagated plantlets and agarwood of G. walla . (A) Hexane extract, (B) dichloromethane extract, ethyl acetate extract of in vitro propagated plantlets and (D) hexane extract (E), dichloromethane extract (F), ethyl acetate extract of agarwood of G.walla.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0321049.s001
(PDF)
S1 Table. Effect of BAP concentrations in MS media on percentage explants induced shoot buds, mean length of shoot bud and mean no. of shoot buds from shoot tip and axillary bud explants.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0321049.s002
(PDF)
S2 Table. Comparison of phyto-chemicals identified by GC-MS analysis in agarwood and microshoots of G. walla.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0321049.s003
(PDF)
References
- 1. Chaudhari D. Agarwood from Aquilaria malaccensis, (A. agallocha, Roxb.). MFP News. 1993;3(4):12–3.
- 2. Qi S-Y, He M-L, Lin L-D, Zhang C-H, Hu L-J, Zhang H-Z. Production of 2-(2-phenylethyl) Chromones in cell suspension cultures of Aquilaria sinensis. Plant Cell Tiss Organ Cult. 2005;83(2):217–21.
- 3. Dharmadasa R, Siriwardana A, Samarasinghe K, Adhihetty P. Standardization of Gyrinops walla Gaertn. (Thymalaeaceae): newly discovered, fragrant industrial potential, endemic plant from Sri Lanka. World Journal of Agricultural Research. 2013;1(16):101–3.
- 4. Subasinghe SMUP, Hettiarachchi D. Agarwood resin production and resin quality of Gyrinops walla Gaertn. International Journal of Agricultural Sciences. 2013;3(1):357–62.
- 5. Selvaskanthan S, Pushpakumara DKNG, Eeswara JP. Development of a protocol for In- vitro establishment of Gyrinops walla. Trop Agric Res. 2018;29(3):330.
- 6. Murashige T, Skoog F. A Revised medium for rapid growth and bio assays with tobacco tissue cultures. Physiologia Plantarum. 1962;15(3):473–97.
- 7. Selvaskanthan S, Eeswara JP. In vitro Rooting of Gyrinops walla in activated charcoal-containing semi-solid culture and filter paper-bridged liquid culture systems. Trop Agric Res. 2024;35(4):332–42.
- 8. Farzana AFR, Bandara RMIEK, Aluwihare PC, Eeswara JP. In vitro regeneration of shoots from Garcinia quaesita leaf explants. J Natn Sci Foundation Sri Lanka. 2010;38(3):157.
- 9. Eeswara JP, Stuchbury T, Allan EJ, Mordue Luntz AJ. A standard procedure for the micropropagation of the neem tree (Azadirachta indica A. Juss). Plant Cell Rep. 1998;17(3):215–9. pmid:30736503
- 10. Selvaskanthan S, Kaushalya DBR, Pushpakumara DKNG, Jayasinghe L, Eeswara JP. A Comparison of chemical profiles of callus, plant and agarwood extracts of Gyrinops walla using thin layer chromatography. Trop Agric Res. 2020;31(2):97.
- 11.
Harborne JB. Textbook of phytochemical methods. A guide to modern techniques of plant analysis. 5th ed. Chapman and Hall Ltd.: London; 1998.
- 12. Ahmaed DT, Mohammed M, Masaad AM, Tajuddin SN. Investigation of agarwood compounds in Aquilaria malaccensis and Aquilaria rostrata chipwood by using solid phase microextraction. BJSTR. 2017;1(6):1609–16.
- 13. Tsan P, Gas MR. Gas chromatography-mass spectrometry analysis of agarwood extracts from mature and juvenile Aquilaria malaccensis. International Journal of Agriculture and Biology. 2014;16(3):644–8.
- 14. Sen S, Dehingia M, Talukdar NC, Khan M. Chemometric analysis reveals links in the formation of fragrant bio-molecules during agarwood (Aquilaria malaccensis) and fungal interactions. Sci Rep. 2017;7:44406. pmid:28290512
- 15. Wang S-C, Wang F, Yue C-H. Chemical constituents from the petioles and leaves of Aquilaria sinensis. Biochemical Systematics and Ecology. 2015;61:458–61.
- 16. Wu W, Tran W, Taatjes CA, Alonso-Gutierrez J, Lee TS, Gladden JM. Rapid discovery and functional characterization of terpene synthases from four endophytic xylariaceae. PLoS One. 2016;11(2):e0146983. pmid:26885833
- 17. Bhuiyan MNI, Begum J, Bhuiyan MdNH. Analysis of essential oil of eaglewood tree (Aquilaria agallocha Roxb.) by gas chromatography mass spectrometry. Bangladesh J Pharmacol. 2009;4(1):24–8.
- 18. Dahham SS, Tabana YM, Iqbal MA, Ahamed MBK, Ezzat MO, Majid ASA, et al. The Anticancer, antioxidant and antimicrobial properties of the sesquiterpene β-caryophyllene from the essential oil of Aquilaria crassna. Molecules. 2015;20(7):11808–29. pmid:26132906
- 19. Cui J, Guo S, Fu S, Xiao P, Wang M. Effects of inoculating fungi on agilawood formation in Aquilaria sinensis. Chin Sci Bull. 2013;58(26):3280–7.
- 20. He M, Qi S, Hu L. Rapid in vitro propagation of medicinally important Aquilaria agallocha. J Zhejiang Univ Sci B. 2005;6(8):849–52. pmid:16052722
- 21. Gonbad RA, Rani Sinniah U, Aziz MA, Mohamad R. Influence of cytokinins in combination with GA₃ on shoot multiplication and elongation of tea clone Iran 100 (Camellia sinensis (L.) O. Kuntze). ScientificWorldJournal. 2014;2014:943054. pmid:24605069
- 22. Borchetia S, Das SC, Handique PJ, Das S. High multiplication frequency and genetic stability for commercialization of the three varieties of micropropagated tea plants (Camellia spp.). Scientia Horticulturae. 2009;120(4):544–50.
- 23. Chen Y, Lin S, Duguid S, Dribnenki P, Kenaschuk E. Effect of sucrose concentration on elongation of shoots from flax anther culture. Plant Cell, Tissue and Organ Culture. 2003;72(2):181–3.
- 24. Smeekens S. Sugar-induced signal transduction in plants. Annu Rev Plant Physiol Plant Mol Biol. 2000;51:49–81. pmid:15012186
- 25. Gibson SI. Control of plant development and gene expression by sugar signaling. Curr Opin Plant Biol. 2005;8(1):93–102. pmid:15653406
- 26.
Bandaralage J, Hayward A, O’brien C, Mitter N. Gibberellin and cytokinin in synergy for a rapid nodal multiplication system of avocado. Proceedings of the World Avocado Congress VIII, Lima. 2015.
- 27. Reeves DW, Couvillon GA, Horton BD. Effect of gibberellic acid (GA3) on elongation and rooting of ‘St. Julien A’ rootstock in vitro. Scientia Horticulturae. 1985;26(3):253–9.
- 28. Joshi P, Trivedi R, Purohit S. Micropropagation of Wrightia tomentosa: Effect of gelling agents, carbon source and vessel type. Indian Journal of Biotechnology. 2009;8:115–20.
- 29. Jain N, Bairu MW, Stirk WA, Van Staden J. The effect of medium, carbon source and explant on regeneration and control of shoot-tip necrosis in Harpagophytum procumbens. South African Journal of Botany. 2009;75(1):117–21.
- 30. Cuenca B, Vieitez AM. Influence of carbon source on shoot multiplication and adventitious bud regeneration in in vitro beech cultures. Plant Growth Regulation. 2000;32(1):1–12.
- 31. Fotopoulos S, Sotiropoulos T. In vitro rooting of PR 204/84 rootstock (Prunus persica x P. amygdalus) as influenced by mineral concentration of the culture medium and exposure to darkness for a period. Agronomy Research. 2005;3(1):3–8.
- 32. Saxena S, Bhojwani SS. In vitro clonal multiplication of 4-year-old plants of the bamboo, Dendrocalamus longispathus kurz. In Vitro Cell Dev Biol - Plant. 1993;29(3):135–42.
- 33. Purohit SD, Dave A, Kukda G. Micropropagation of safed musli (Chlorophytum borivilianum), a rare Indian medicinal herb. Plant Cell Tiss Organ Cult. 1994;39(1):93–6.
- 34. Thirunavoukkarasu M, Panda P, Nayak P, Behera P, Satpathy G. Effect of media type and explant source on micropropagation of Dalbergia sissoo Roxb. - an important multipurpose forest tree. International Research Journal of Plant Science. 2010;1:155–62.
- 35. Gabryszewska EA. Effect of different sucrose and nitrogen salt levels in the medium and temperature on in vitro propagation of Helleborus niger L. Acta Agrobot. 2015;32(2):161–71.
- 36. Coruzzi G, Bush DR. Nitrogen and carbon nutrient and metabolite signaling in plants. Plant Physiol. 2001;125(1):61–4. pmid:11154297
- 37. Zheng Z-L. Carbon and nitrogen nutrient balance signaling in plants. Plant Signal Behav. 2009;4(7):584–91. pmid:19820356
- 38. Ferreira W de M, Suzuki RM, Pescador R, Figueiredo-Ribeiro R de CL, Kerbauy GB. Propagation, growth, and carbohydrates of Dendrobium Second Love (Orchidaceae) in vitro as affected by sucrose, light, and dark. In Vitro CellDevBiol-Plant. 2010;47(3):420–7.
- 39. Al Malki A, Elmeer K. Effect of medium strength and charcoal combined with IBA and NAA on root initiation of Ficus anastasia. Academic Journal of Plant Sciences. 2009;2:169–72.
- 40. De Klerk G-J, Brugge JT, Marinova S. Effectiveness of indoleacetic acid, indolebutyric acid and naphthaleneacetic acid during adventitious root formation in vitro in Malus ‘Jork 9’. Plant Cell, Tissue and Organ Culture. 1997;49(1):39–44.
- 41. Benmahioul B, Dorion N, Kaid-Harche M, Daguin F. Micropropagation and ex vitro rooting of pistachio (Pistacia vera L.). Plant Cell Tiss Organ Cult. 2012;108(2):353–8.
- 42. Vibha JB, Shekhawat NS, Mehandru P, Dinesh R. Rapid multiplication of Dalbergia sissoo Roxb.: a timber yielding tree legume through axillary shoot proliferation and ex vitro rooting. Physiol Mol Biol Plants. 2014;20(1):81–7. pmid:24554841
- 43. Yan H, Liang C, Yang L, Li Y. In vitro and ex vitro rooting of Siratia grosvenorii, a traditional medicinal plant. Acta Physiologiae Plantarum. 2010;32:115–20. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11738-009-0386-0
- 44.
Saiju HK. Tree tissue culture and ex vitro sand rooting for reforestation. In: Suzuki K, Ishii K, Sakurai S, Sasaki S. (eds) Plantation Technology in Tropical Forest Science. Springer: Tokyo; 2006. https://doi.org/10.1007/4-431-28054-5_14
- 45. Wojtania A, Markiewicz M, Góraj-Koniarska J. Ex vitro rooting, acclimatization and genetic stability of lonicera caerulea var. kamtschatica. Journal of Horticultural Research. 2020;28(2):61–70.
- 46. Bhatia NP, Bhatia P, Ashwath N. Ex Vitro rooting of micropropagated shoots of Stackhousia tryonii. Biologia plant. 2002;45(3):441–4.
- 47. Sharma U, Kataria V, Shekhawat NS. In vitro propagation, ex vitro rooting and leaf micromorphology of Bauhinia racemosa Lam.: a leguminous tree with medicinal values. Physiol Mol Biol Plants. 2017;23(4):969–77. pmid:29158643
- 48. Shekhawat MS, Manokari M. Impact of auxins on vegetative propagation through stem cuttings of Couroupita guianensis Aubl.: A conservation approach. Scientifica (Cairo). 2016;2016:6587571. pmid:28083155
- 49. AGHDAEI M. Effect of rooting medium, cutting type and auxin on rooting of pepino (Solanum muricatum aiton) cutting. Appl Ecol Env Res. 2019;17(5).
- 50. Nissen SJ, Sutter EG. Stability of IAA and IBA in nutrient medium to several tissue culture procedures. HortSci. 1990;25(7):800–2.
- 51. Kozai T, Kubota C, Ryoung Jeong B. Environmental control for the large-scale production of plants through in vitro techniques. Plant Cell, Tissue and Organ Culture. 1997;51(1):49–56.
- 52. Pospís̆ilová J, Synková H, Haisel D, Čatský J, Wilhelmová Na, Šrámek F. Effect of elevated CO2 concentration on acclimation of tobacco plantlets to ex vitro conditions. Journal of Experimental Botany. 1999;50(330):119–26.
- 53. Klerk G-J. Rooting of microcuttings: Theory and practice. In Vitro Cell Dev Biol - Plant. 2002;38(5):415–22.
- 54.
Reich E, Schibli A. High performance thin layer chromatography for the analysis of medicinal plants. Thieme Publishing Group: Stuttgart, New York; 2007. https://doi.org/10.1055/b-002-66241
- 55. Namdeo A. Plant cell elicitation for production of secondary metabolites: a review. Pharmacogn Review. 2007;1(1):69–79.
- 56.
Ikuta A, Itokawa H. Berberine: Production Through Plant (Thalictrum spp.) Cell Cultures. In: Bajaj YPS. (ed) Medicinal and aromatic plants I. Biotechnology in Agriculture and Forestry: Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg; 1988, 282–293. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-642-73026-9_15
- 57.
Ulbrich B, Wiesner W, Arens H. Large-scale production of rosmarinic acid from plant cell cultures of coleus blumei benth. In: Neumann KH, Barz W, Reinhard E. (eds). Primary and secondary metabolism of plant cell cultures. Proceedings in Life Sciences. Springer: Berlin, Heidelberg; 1985, 293–303. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-642-70717-9_28
- 58. Eilert U, Kurz WGW, Constabel F. Stimulation of sanguinarine accumulation in Papaver somniferum cell cultures by fungal elicitors. Journal of Plant Physiology. 1985;119(1):65–76.