Figures
Abstract
Foliar fertilization is a reliable technique for correcting a nutrient deficiency in plants caused by inadequate nutrient supply to the roots in acid soil. Soluble nutrients in banana pseudostem sap might be effective to supplement chemical fertilizers. However, the limited nutrients in sole banana pseudostem sap as foliar fertilization may not meet-up the nutritional demand of the crop. Field trials were, therefore, conducted with the combination of soil-applied fertilizers with foliar spray of banana pseudostem sap to increase nutrient uptake, yield, and quality of sweet corn planted in acidic soil. Three treatments viz., 100% recommended dose of fertilizers (RD) as control (T1), 75% of RD applied in soil with foliar application of non-enriched banana pseudostem sap (T2), and 50% RD applied in soil with foliar spray of enriched banana pseudostem sap (T3) were replicated four times. The combination of soil-applied fertilizer with foliar spray of enriched banana pseudostem sap (T3) showed a significant increase in leaf area index (11.3%), photosynthesis (12%), fresh cob yield (39%), and biomass of corn (29%) over control. Besides, the 50% RD of soil fertilization with foliar spray of enriched pseudostem sap increased nutrient uptake in addition to an increase in sugar content, phenolic content, soluble protein, and amino acids of corn. Considering the economic analysis, the highest net income, BCR (3.74) and MBCR (1.25) values confirmed the economic viability of T3 treatment over the T1. The results suggest that foliar spray of enriched banana pseudostem sap can be used as a supplementary source of nutrients to enhance nutrient uptake by corn while increasing yield and minimizing chemical fertilizer use in acid soil.
Citation: Islam MS, Kasim S, Amin AM, Alam MK, Khatun MF, Ahmed S, et al. (2023) Foliar application of enriched banana pseudostem sap influences the nutrient uptake, yield, and quality of sweet corn grown in an acidic soil. PLoS ONE 18(8): e0285954. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0285954
Editor: Mojtaba Kordrostami, Nuclear Science and Technology Research Institute, ISLAMIC REPUBLIC OF IRAN
Received: February 4, 2023; Accepted: May 5, 2023; Published: August 29, 2023
Copyright: © 2023 Islam et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Data Availability: All relevant data are within the paper.
Funding: The study was funded by the National Agricultural Technology Programme, Bangladesh Agricultural Research Council, and Bangladesh Agricultural Research Institute for providing fellowship to perform research at the Faculty of Agriculture, Universiti Putra, Malaysia. The study was alsopartially funded by the Researchers Supporting Project number (TURSP - 2020/39), Taif University, Taif, Saudi Arabia. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
1. Introduction
Sweet corn is one of the most popular cereal crops in the world [1]. The demand for sweet corn has been expanding in food commodities because of its sweetness and high supplement content [2]. It is mainly utilized for either preparation for nourishment or non-processed food products for the substitute rice. Corn production is remarkably low (average 5.2 t ha-1 and the total area is around 10000 ha) in Malaysia due to soil acidity [3]. Soil-applied fertilizers react with Fe, Al, and Ca-containing compounds in soils which reduces the potency of fertilizers for plants. [4, 5]. Besides, plant roots become injured and are inhibited nutrient acquisition by the roots in low-pH soil [6, 7]. Thus, a lavish dosage of chemical fertilizers is required to optimize production, which increases acidity. In this case, foliar spray can be the alternative option to feed the crops.
On the other hand, banana waste is considered an influential resource to use as organic liquid fertilizer [8]. But the producers, simply let banana pseudostem as waste after harvesting the banana [9]. Recently, the foliar application of organic liquid fertilizer has been started in different areas or on crops under organic farming practices considering the soil and plant interaction issues [10]. It is thought extremely secure and sharply responsive to nutrients than soil-applied fertilizer [11]. The negative effects of soil acidity oppose nutrient availability through the roots. The effectiveness of foliar fertilization in these circumstances is higher than that of the use of soil fertilizer. According to Kuepper [12], foliar fertilization can be 8–20 times more effective for nutrient absorption than soil application of fertilizers. This may be due to the leaves proximity, stomatal activity, and quick absorption of available nutrients from the spray solution [13]. Thus, foliar feeding of plants is expected a bypass option to minimize the uncertainty of nutrient uptake from the acidic soil.
Although banana plant especially in pseudostem contains 80–85% fluid [14] and have the opportunity to be considered an effective organic fertilizer [8, 15] due to higher concentration of NO3-N, NH4-N, K, P, Ca, Mg, Zn, and Fe in it [16–18]. Moreover, a few researchers have reported that phytochemicals such as amino acids, 3-amino-2-naphthoic acid, cyclopentene-1-acetic acid, aminobenzoic acid, etc. present in banana pseudostem [19] have an influential role in plant growth, metabolism, and also anti-pathogenic activity on the plant [20–22]. In this regard, Mohapatra et al. [23] recorded high contents of K, P, Ca, and Mg in banana pseudostem sap. The soluble nutrients in any liquid fertilizer increase nutrient use efficiency through the minimize nutrient loss and ensuring better return [24, 25]. Similarly, organic liquid fertilizer-based nutrients and bioactive compounds improved growth, and yield, as well as created protection against disease and insect infestation of plants [26].
A previous study showed that the banana corm or hump extract increased the N, P, and K uptake of corn [21], and initiated the growth and yield of soybean [27]. The amendment of banana waste organic fertilizer increased the plant height, leaf size, and yield of cabbage [28] due abundance of inherent mineral nutrients. Similarly, N, P, K, and S foliar spray increase uptake of N and P as well as grain production [29]. Amal et al. [30] studied a foliar application of a mixed nutrient solution containing N, P, K, Mg, Zn, Fe, Mn, Cu, S, and B that had a significant effect on nutrient content in plants. Bio-stimulants in seaweed extract-initiated plant growth, biomass, and nitrogen assimilation in tobacco plants [31]. Foliar application of phosphorus (P) enhanced P use efficiency via uptake and translocation to the wheat grain [32]. The zinc concentration in maize, wheat, and rice grains increased by 63, 25, and 30%, respectively through the foliar spray of Zn over soil application [33, 34]. Likewise, iron deficiency results in reduced yields and nutritional quality of many crop plants [35]. The foliar use of amino acids had a positive effect on the growth, tuber yield, and nutrient content of cassava [36]. Moreover, foliar-applied plant extracts consistently increased nutrient uptake, growth, yield, and quality of sweet corn [37]. Previously, few studies evaluated the effects of banana stem compost on the yield of soybean [15] and sap on corn [38], fenugreek [39], and onion [40]. Besides, soil applications of inorganic fertilizers with banana pseudostem sap as foliar application resulted in influential effects on the pod yield of cowpea [41] in a neutral soil environment.
Nevertheless, the limited research on enriched banana pseudostem sap as a liquid organic fertilizer has been focused on and looks down upon the existence of micro nutrients in it to satisfy the yield potential and quality of corn. The corn production stability or enhancement, using minimum chemical fertilizers is the key challenge using the enriched banana pseudostem sap foliar application. The inadequate nutrients in fresh banana pseudostem sap as foliar fertilization or the sole application of chemical fertilizer may not meet-up the nutritional demand of crops. In this manner, the frequent spray with enriched banana pseudostem sap would be supplemented with soil-applied nutrients for better nutrient uptake, yield, and quality of corn. We hypothesized that the foliar application of enriched banana pseudostem sap with a lower fertilizer dose will reduce the chemical fertilizer use for corn production. To the best of our knowledge, this type of research is partial to crop production against acidic soil. Thus, the study has been executed to evaluate the effects of foliar application of enriched banana pseudostem sap with lower doses of chemical fertilizers on the growth, yield, and quality of sweet corn.
2. Materials and methods
2.1 Site description and soil
Two consecutive cycles of field studies were conducted in the same research field-15, under the Department of land management, Universiti Putra Malaysia from December 2019 to July 2020. The location of the field was latitude of 2°56′01.3″ N and longitude of 101°43′57.0″ E in the geographic position (Fig 1). The maximum temperature, minimum temperature and rainfall during the trial period were collected using LCD Digital Temperature and Humidity Meter (HTC-1, China) and shown in Fig 2. The soil was the order of Ultisol whose basic properties were tested before the initiation of the experiment and are presented in Table 1. The land was well-drained and slightly sloping and the soil was generally acidic, sandy-clay in texture, and low in available P.
2.2 Collection and preparation of banana pseudostem sap
The banana pseudostem were collected from the banana field in Banting (2°48′17.1″ N and 101°30′12.99″ E), Selangor, Malaysia on 1st October 2019. The banana pseudostem were cleaned properly by washing them with fresh tap water. It was chopped into small sizes and separated from the leaf sheath. The leaf sheath was then passed through the electric crusher twice (locally made sugarcane crusher, ESM Machinery (JB) SDN, BHD, Malaysia) to collect the sap. About 60 liters of banana pseudostem sap was collected in a cleaned airtight bottle and preserved at 5 °C in the refrigerator for further use.
2.3 Enrichment of banana pseudostem sap
The banana pseudostem sap was enriched with N 20%, P2O5 15%, K2O 15%, and boric acid 1.14% (20% N, 6.5% P, 12.45% K, and 0.2% B, respectively). In this regard, the used TSP fertilizer was finely grinded with an electrical grinder (Blue-Magic®, India). The enriched banana pseudostem sap was shaken for 6 hours using an orbital shaker at 160 rpm for proper mixing and then preserved at 5°C in the refrigerator.
2.4. Chemical analysis of both non-enriched and enriched banana pseudostem sap
The banana pseudostem sap (both the non-enriched and enriched) was shaken for 30 minutes by an orbital shaker at 160 rpm and directly measured the pH and EC followed by an automatic pH meter model HI 2211 (Hanna instrument, Woonsocket, Rhode Island, USA) and EC meter (Hanna 2300), respectively. The NH4-N and NO3-N were determined by using the distillation method [42]. The P, K, Ca, Mg, Na, Fe, Zn, Cu, Al, and B were determined from the non-enriched and enriched banana pseudostem sap separately by the Inductively Coupled Plasma (Perkin Elmer, Optima 8300) and spectroscopy (ICP) following 50 and 400 times dilution, respectively with distilled water [19]. The chemistry of banana pseudostem sap is shown in Table 2.
2.5 Experimental design, treatments, and management
A consecutive field trial (two cycles) was conducted with three treatments (i) soil application of 100% chemical fertilizer (N120-P60-K90 kg ha-1) as control (T1) (ii) 75% soil-applied chemical fertilizers (N90-P45-K68 kg ha-1) with foliar application of non-enriched banana pseudostem sap (T2), (iii) 50% (N60- P30-K45 kg ha-1) recommended chemical fertilizers with foliar application of enriched banana pseudostem sap were tested (T3) in the study to evaluate the banana pseudostem sap as organic liquid fertilizer alone or with chemical fertilizers on sweet corn planted in acidic soil. The study was designed in a randomized complete block design (RCBD) with four replications. The hybrid sweet corn Leckat 592 was tested at the plant-to-plant and row-to-row distance of 75 cm × 20 cm, and a unit plot size of 3 m × 2 m. Each unit plot had 40 plants. The nitrogen fertilizer was applied in two installments, 10 and 30 days after planting, while the full amount of P and K fertilizers were applied at the final land preparation. The seeds were sown followed by a 2-1-2 alternative pattern. The population density was maintained by gap-filling after three days of emergence. The non-enriched and enriched banana pseudostem sap were sprayed at the rate of 30 mL plant-1 with five installments at 15, 25, 35, 45, and 58, days after sowing. To prevent armyworm infestation, plants were sprayed with a mixture of banana pseudostem sap and pesticides from the first (15th day) to the third (35th day) installments. The last two installments (45th and 58th days) were sprayed with detergent @ 2g 10L-1 of the same spray solution to avoid the toxic effects of pesticide. Before spraying, 15% aqueous non-enriched sap and 1% enriched sap solution were ensured separately with distilled water. Irrigations were applied at each day interval considering the rainfall. The crop was harvested at the dough stage.
2.6 Data collection
2.6.1 Measurement of SPAD value and photosynthesis in leaf.
Chlorophyll content was measured at 45 days by using Soil Plant Analysis Development (SPAD) meter (SPAD 502 plus, Minolta, Japan) followed by Yuan et al. [43]. The portable LI-COR (LI-6400XT) was used to measure the rate of photosynthesis in the leaf at silking stage (45th day).
2.6.2 Growth and yield parameters.
The data on agronomic parameters were the mean of two consecutive cycles of corn. The shoot length (cm) and cob length (cm) were measured by measuring tape while the root length (cm) was measured by measuring scale. The digital slide calipers were used to measure cob diameter (mm). The number of grain cob-1 was counted with the multiplication of the number of rows of grain in each cob and the number of grains in each row. In addition, the fresh cob yield (t ha-1) was measured from the whole unit plot (40 plants) by electric balance. Then the average weight of fresh cob per plant was multiplied by the number of plants in one hectare of land (66666) following the above-mentioned plant-to-plant and row-to-row spacing. The leaf area index was measured by using the equation [44].
(1)
Where (A) express the area of a leaf (cm2), ‘L’ indicates the leaf length from leaf collar to leaf tip (cm), ‘W’ means the maximum width of the leaf (cm), the constant leaf area regression coefficient of 0.75 is related to leaf shape, the total leaf number of a sampled plant is N, plant density m-2 is D, and the factor 10,000 is used to convert from m-2 to cm-2.
The dry matter of the above-ground plant part and the cob was done by oven-dry method at 105°C for 24 hours and calculated with the equation;
(2)
Where W1 is the initial weight and W2 means the weight after dry.
2.6.3 Determination of nutrient concentration and uptake in plants and grain sample.
The harvested cob and shoot samples were collected from the respective plot which was then cleaned and kept in paper bags, separately. The plant’s samples were analyzed from the second cycle crop to determine the nutrient concentration and quality parameters. The fresh cob samples were weighed in the paper bags, then dried in an oven at 70°C until a consistent weight. The dried materials were then ground and passed through a 4 mm sieve. The Leco TruMac CNS analyzer was used to calculate the total N. The total content of P, K, Ca, Mg, Cu, Zn, and Mn in plant and grain samples was extracted by the dry ashing method [45]. The amount of P was determined by auto-analyzer (Yellow method) from the same sample and the other elements was measured by atomic absorption spectrophotometer (A Analyst 800, PerkinElmer Corporation, Norwalk, Connecticut, USA). The nutrient uptake was estimated by multiplying with biomass (oven-dry weight) by nutrient concentration using the following equation [46];
(3)
2.6.5 Extraction and determination of total soluble protein.
The soluble protein was extracted from corn samples following the Bradford assay method described by Ahmed et al. [47] and the extracted sample was read at 595 nm wavelength by UV-spectrophotometer (Model: Shimadzu. UV-160A Visible Recording Spectrophotometer, Japan). The formula used to calculate the soluble protein is;
(4)
Here, C = Soluble protein (μg) content in the sample calculated from the standard curve line
V = Volume of the buffer solution used to extract the enzyme
W = Fresh weight of the sample taken for extraction
2.6.6 Identification and quantification of amino acid.
Acid hydrolysis of amino acid was performed by Cooper et al. [48] and then analyzed by High-Performance Liquid Chromatography (Waters, Alliance e2695). The total amino acid content was the sum of amino acid derivatives.
2.6.7 Sample extraction procedure for determination of antioxidant.
Samples extraction was done following the method described by [49] to measure the total phenolic content and antioxidant activity (DPPH Free Radical Scavenging Capacity). The absorbance was recorded at 765 nm and 517 nm wavelength, respectively by UV-spectrophotometer. The measurement was expressed as mg of gallic acid equivalent per 100 g of sample for phenolic content, while the percentage of antioxidant scavenging capacity was calculated by the equation as follows:
(5)
2.6.8 Extraction and determination of sugar.
Sugar profiling was done from the corn samples (dry) with some modification of Lu et al. [50] method and analyzed using high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) (Agilent, Santa Clara, California, USA). The total sugar content was the sum of sugar derivatives.
2.7 Benefit-cost analysis
Benefit-cost analysis was performed according to the method [51] where several equations were used as follows;
(6)
(7)
(8)
(9)
(10)
2.8 Statistical analysis
ANOVA was done using PROC following RCBD design (SAS, 9.4). The combined analysis of the two consecutive trials’ data especially growth and yield found non-significant differences, therefore, the mean data of the two trials were presented in the results section. The nutrient content and qualitative data were considered for analysis from the second cycle of planted corn. The mean separation was compared by protected least significance differences (LSD) at a 5% probability level.
3. Results
3.1 Effects of banana pseudostem sap on physiological attributes of sweet corn
3.1.1 SPAD value.
The SPAD value (greenness) showed an increasing trend up to the silking stage, after that, a little decline was observed in all treatments (Fig 3). The enriched sap (T3) treated plants provided a significantly higher SPAD value (28.9, 46.9, 59.0, and 55.7 in seedling, vegetative, silking, and dough stages, respectively) compared to sole chemical fertilizers (23.8, 40.6, 54.3, and 49.2 in seedling, vegetative, silking and dough stage, respectively) (T1). The chlorophyll content in T2 was very close to the T1 treatment in the study periods while the silking stages showed greater chlorophyll content in all treatments than in other crop growth stages.
The vertical bars denote the standard error of means, and the value of each marker point indicates the mean of four replications (n = 4). The vertical bar denotes the ± standard error of mean the different letters are statistically significant with p≥ 0.05 of LSD test.
3.1.2 Photosynthesis.
The photosynthesis rate of corn plants was significantly affected by the foliar application of enriched banana pseudostem sap (Fig 4). The photosynthesis rate was found to be higher (47.2 mmol m-2 S-1) in enriched sap (T3) treated plants compared to T1 (42.3 mmol m-2 S-1) and T2 (44.1 mmol m-2 S-1) treatments. Although the foliar spray of non-enriched sap (T2) showed a statistically identical but numerically higher value to the T1 treatment. The foliar application of enriched banana pseudostem sap (T3) increased photosynthesis by 12% while the non-enriched sap (T2) increased by 4% compared to soil-applied chemical fertilizers.
The vertical bar denotes the ± standard error of mean the different letters are statistically significant with p≥ 0.05 of LSD test.
3.2. Effects of enriched banana pseudostem sap on grain nutrient content of sweet corn
The nutrient concentration in grain was varied due to the combined use of soil-applied chemical fertilizers with foliar fertilization of banana pseudostem sap (Table 3).
The highest content of N (1.93 g 100 g-1) was measured from T3 compared to T1 (1.74 g 100 g-1) and T2 (1.77 g 100 g-1) treatments. A similar trend was observed in the case of grain K and Ca concentrations of corn. The Mg and Zn concentration varied significantly by the foliar application of banana pseudostem sap. Results showed that the highest concentrations were 7.05 and 25.6 mg 100 g-1 of Mg and Zn, respectively which was recorded in T2 treatment while the lowest Mg (5.69 mg 100 g-1) and Zn (21.0 mg 100 g-1) were recorded in T1 treatment. It is calculated that the grain nutrients concentration of N, K, Ca, Mg, and Zn, in T3 was increased by 10.9, 11.5, 25.6, 16.3, and 3.48%, respectively over the T1 treatment.
3.3 Nutrient uptake of sweet corn
The nutrient uptake by sweet corn was varied due to the foliar application of banana pseudostem sap (Fig 5A–5F). The result showed that the dual application of soil-applied chemical fertilizers with foliar spray of enriched banana pseudostem sap has significantly increased the nutrient uptake by corn compared to the control. Of the three treatments, T3 showed superior results in terms of nutrient uptake except for Mg and Zn. From the results, it is apparent that 15.40, 1.68, 11.74, 6.64, 0.30, and 0.210 g kg-1 of N, P, K, Ca, Mg, and Zn, respectively in T3 treatment which increased by 25.81% N, 8.38% P, 32.80% K, 32.53% Ca, 87.5% Mg, and 10.52% Zn, over the control (T1). The results also demonstrated that N, phosphorus (P), potassium (K), calcium (Ca), magnesium (Mg), and Zinc (Zn), were increased by 14.8, -2.58, 5.56, 16.6, 250, and 21.05% in T2 treatment over the control, respectively. However, the magnesium and zinc uptakes in the plant were significantly higher in T2 followed by T1 and T3 treatments.
(A-F). Effects of enriched banana pseudostem extract on total nutrient uptake of sweet corn. The vertical bar denotes the ± standard error of mean the different letters are statistically significant with p≥ 0.05 of LSD test.
3.4 Growth and yield components of sweet corn
The root length, leaf area index, the number of grains, fresh cob yield, and biomass weight of corn was varied by the fertilizer application (Table 4). The treatment of 50% soil-applied chemical fertilizers with foliar spray of enriched banana pseudostem sap (T3) resulted in superior growth and yield performance than that of 75% soil-applied chemical fertilizers with non-enriched (T2) sap as foliar and sole chemical fertilizers (T1) of soil application. In this study, combined fertilization in soil and foliar spray of enriched sap increased root length, leaf area index, number of grains, cob yield, and dry biomass by 12, 11.3, 35.0, 39.0, and 29.0%, respectively over control. The results of the T1 and T2 treatments were statistically identical while T2 performed numerically better results than the T1 treatment.
3.5 Enriched banana pseudostem sap on the nutritional quality of sweet corn
3.5.1 Protein and amino acid composition.
The protein and amino acid composition of sweet corn was varied due to the foliar application of banana pseudostem sap. The highest protein content (24.5 g 100 g-1) was obtained from foliar application of enriched banana pseudostem sap, followed by non-enriched sap (22.1 g 100 g-1) while the lowest protein and amino acid (21.0 g 100 g-1) were found in soil-applied chemical fertilizers (Fig 6a–6q).
(a—r). Combined application of soil-applied fertilizers with foliar spray of banana pseudostem sap influenced the amino acids composition as well as total amino acids content. Mean ± standard error within the bar followed by the different letters are significantly different at p ≥0.05 (LSD test).
In this case, the total soluble protein showed a significant (p≤0.05) increase by 5.23% and 16.5% in T2 and T3 treatments, respectively compare to soil-applied chemical fertilizers (T1). Results represented that both the non-enriched or enriched banana pseudostem sap treated plots provided significantly (p≤0.05) higher concentrations of most of the amino acids (Fig 6a–6q). Among the amino acids (17), aspartic acid, arginine, threonine, isoleusine, and leusine had no remarkable variations by foliar fertilization (Fig 6).
But the significantly higher content of hydroxyproline, serine, glutamic acid, glycine, histidine, alanine, valine, methionine, and phenylalanine was measured in the foliar spray treatments, especially in enriched banana pseudostem sap over the soil-applied chemical fertilizers which fairly reflected on total amino acid content. In this regard, the highest (10.5 g 100 g-1) total amino acid was measured in enriched sap (T3) followed by (10.36 g 100 g-1) non-enriched banana pseudostem sap (T2) compared to (9.58 g 100 g-1) in chemical fertilizers plots (T1). The total amino acid concentration over soil-applied chemical fertilizers was increased by 9.60% due to foliar application of enriched banana pseudostem sap (Fig 6a–6r).
3.5.2 Phenolic content, DPPH scavenging capacity and sugar content of corn.
The quality of corn was significantly influenced by the foliar application of banana pseudostem sap as shown in Table 5. The DPPH scavenging capacity and total phenolic content showed an increasing trend that was 4.43 to 7.38% and 3 to 27.8% in T2 and T3 treatments, respectively over the sole chemical fertilizers due to the free radicle scavenging capacity of phenolic compounds. The results revealed that as compared to soil-applied chemical fertilizers, the sugar content was considerably higher by 4.26% and 15.5% from T2 and T3 treatments, respectively. In this study, applied banana pseudostem sap contained a considerable amount of macro and micronutrients, especially K, Ca, and Mg that could gain in increasing sugar content than that of soil-applied chemical fertilizers.
3.5.3 Relationship among the nutrient uptake, growth, yield and quality factors of corn.
Pearson’s correlation analysis showed potassium uptake had strong and significant relationship with leaf area index, biomass and phenolic content while the cob yield had a positive and significant correlation with Pn, TSS and TSP (Fig 7). Besides, the negative and non-significant relationship was found from P with Mg and Zn uptake, and K with Mg uptake. Similarly, Mg showed weak and negetive relationship on leaf area index, biomass and phenolic content. These relationship mean that the K uptake from enriched banana pseudostem sap influenced growth, yield and quality of corn.
LAI: Leaf area index, Pn: Photosynthesis rate, TSP: Total soluble protein, TSS: Total sugar content, TAA: Total amino acid and PC: Phenolic content.
3.5.4 Economic analysis.
The highest total return (RM. 51496) was found in the combined application of soil-applied fertilizers with foliar spray of enriched banana pseudostem sap (T3) treatment while the lowest return (RM. 44840) was in the sole chemical fertilizers (T1) (Table 6). Considering the total cost of production, the lowest cost involvement was found from the treatment with foliar spray of enriched banana pseudostem sap (Table 7). Similarly, the superior benefit-cost ratio (4.14) and marginal benefit-cost ratio (1.29) were also higher for treatment T3 and the lowest for treatment T1 (Table 7).
4. Discussion
4.1 Chlorophyll content
The enriched banana pseudostem sap significantly improved the SPAD value of corn at all growth stages might be due to the abundance of macro and micronutrients (N, P, K, Ca, Mg, and Zn) in the foliar application of enriched sap (T3) and their faster absorption helped increase the chlorophyll synthesis significantly. According to Duarte et al. [52], the repeated spraying within the vegetative-silking stage ensured better nutrient uptake by corn might be the cause of higher chlorophyll content. Besides, banana pseudostem contains bio-active molecules such as amino acids [53], proline, betaine, and glutamic acid that have stimulatory effects on chlorophyll synthesis [54] which could be promoted a higher SPAD value in T3 treatment. In the senescence stage, chlorophyll catabolites naturally broke leading to the degradation of SPAD value in the dough stage [55]. That’s why all the treatments showed a declining chlorophyll content after the silking stage (Fig 3).
4.2 Photosynthesis
Foliar application of enriched banana pseudostem sap with soil-applied chemical fertilizer (T3) significantly increased the photosynthesis rate of corn (Fig 4) might be due to an improved level of inherent and enriched K in banana pseudostem sap (Table 2). This agreement was supported by the findings of Ali et al. [56], who reported that foliar spray of K2O solution increased the photosynthesis by 61.6% of corn over the control. Besides, the ionic forms of nutrients in enriched banana pseudostem sap being absorbed with water have increased the leaf area which thereby may help to capture more light for higher photosynthesis [57]. Moreover, the uptake of N, P, K, Ca, and Mg by plants have an influential role in electron transport and photosynthetic activities [58] and these nutrients were available in banana pseudostem sap (Table 1). Besides, the appropriate content of P, K, Ca, or Mg strongly influenced plant metabolism [59], which was responsible for higher photosynthesis [56].
4.3 Nutrient uptake by corn
The combined effects of soil-applied fertilizers with foliar-applied banana pseudostem sap fairly influenced the nutrient uptakes of corn (Fig 5A–5F). In the study, soil-applied fertilizers with foliar spray of enriched sap (T3) provided higher nutrient uptake except for Mg and Zn. This might be the fact of opening the stomata by leaf hydration [60] that allowed the rapid access of foliar spray into the leaves [5]. Results were also consistent with the findings of Pangaribuan et al. [37] who explored the higher uptake of N, P, and K in sweet corn from the combined application of soil-applied fertilizers and foliar spray of plant extract. Likely, the N, P, and K content of corn were found 38.75, 18.16, and 16.92% higher by the foliar application of amino acids containing organic liquid fertilizer reported by Tadros et al. [61]. Similarly, the higher N, P, K, and S concentrations in soybean plants have been found from foliar spray with 15% aqueous seaweed extract [62]. In this study, non-enriched banana pseudostem sap (T2) resulted in higher Mg and Zn uptake than T3, which might be due to the antagonistic effect of high concentrations of K and Ca with the Mg and Zn in the enriched banana pseudostem sap (Table 3) as supported by Sun et al. [63]. Moreover, the presence of glutamic acid, proline, and benzoic acid in banana pseudostem sap [53] could have induced better root growth which might be helped the higher nutrient uptake by plants [64, 65]. In the control treatment (T1), nutrient uptake showed a significantly lower value due to the fixation or leaching loss caused by soil-nutrient interactions in low-pH soil [5]. Therefore, soil-applied chemical fertilizers with foliar spray of enriched sap (T3) resulted in higher nutrient uptake compared to the control (T1) treatment.
4.4 Yield and yield contributing characters of corn
In this study, soil-applied chemical fertilizers with enriched banana pseudostem sap promoted 11.25, 39, and 29% higher leaf area index, fresh cob yield, and biomass, respectively over the soil-applied chemical fertilizers (Table 4). These findings were corroborated by various liquid organic fertilizers studies. For example, the foliar application of amino acids containing liquid organic fertilizer was increased by 6.6–23% LAI and 17–32% higher maize yield [24]. Likely, Aulya et al. [66] observed a significant increase in maize leaf area through the application of 10% organic extract. Cassim et al. [67] studied that foliar application enriched N solution increased by 14.7% higher corn yield over the control. Similarly, Paramesh et al. [68] obtained higher cob yield and biomass of wheat compared to 100% RD of soil application. The cause of our findings may be due to the faster absorption of nutrients in the sprayed sap by the leaves without interfering with any soil-related limitations [30]. Moreover, the secondary metabolites in banana pseudostem sap, such as 4-aminobenzoic acid, glutamic acid, cyclopentene-1- acetic acid, proline betaine, butanoic acid, hydroxysouric acid, and aluminium acetate related to promoting plant growth and development [53]. Application of enriched sap as foliar spray through frequent splitting supported to meet-up the nutrients demand which helped to escape the soil-related constraints. In the current study, enriched N in banana pseudostem sap was absorbed quickly, and increased leaf area, photosynthesis, and shoot height which contributed to higher biomass [69]. This means that frequent application of enriched sap optimized both macro and micronutrients, which in turn, enhanced the growth and yield attributes of corn in acidic soil.
4.5 Nutritional quality of corn
The protein, amino acids, phenolic contents, and sugar contents are the major indicator of the quality of sweet corn which is governed by the availability of nutrients either from soil-applied fertilizers and/or foliar fertilization. In our study, the foliar-applied banana pseudostem sap was rich in K, Ca, and Mg as well as contain some extent of micronutrients (Table 2) that was in agreement with Islam et al. [14]. Moreover, inherent nutrients with enriched N, P, K, and B in the banana pseudostem sap created an enriched liquid fertilizer (Table 2). Thus, the foliar spray of enriched sap provided 16.5% higher protein content of corn which was consistent with the finding of Ali et al. [56] who recorded 15.3% higher protein in maize over control. This might be possible from the balance of macro and micro-nutrients and their faster absorption by the shoot. Besides, the soil-applied P and enriched P in the banana pseudostem sap have been found to enhance better root growth, N uptake, and metabolism, thereby the protein concentration in grain increased considerably [70]. Similarly, acid soil had limited P availability leading to a reduction of nitrogen acquisition in the plant, thereby reducing protein and amino acid synthesis which occurred in sole chemical treatment (T1). In the same study, Gao et al. [70] showed a positive correlation of zinc with protein and amino acid in wheat. Likely, Zn in banana pseudostem sap may have stimulated the function of indole acetic acid thereby contributing to higher protein and amino acid content [68]. The soluble nutrients in banana pseudostem sap have been gained by plants. In this regard, P excited the nitrate reductase to efflux nitrate in the internal pathway and later on stored in the embryo which is the key component of protein and amino acid [71]. In terms of leaf hydration, rapid access to ions, and nutritional balance in a plant, K might be activated by enzymes and photosynthesis which could increase sugar content, free amino acids, and anti-oxidant content (Table 5). The findings were supported by Bakry et al. [72] who studied the banana peel extract with tryptophan on the quinoa plant. Thus, the enriched banana pseudostem sap could be a reliable nutrient supplementing organic liquid fertilizer to improve the quality of corn.
4.6 Economic performance of corn
Cost-benefit analysis is an important tool to test the economic viability of an approach or product which includes the relevant materials and non-material costs that fairly influenced the net income [51]. In the current study, the high price of a maximum number of improved-size corn (Table 7) in T3 treatments contributed to the increased value of total income (RM. 51496). Besides, the same treatment required half (50%) of the chemical fertilizers applied to T1 decreasing the total cost, ultimately resulting in a net higher income (RM. 39075), benefit-cost ratio (4.14), and marginal benefit-cost (1.29) (Table 7).
5. Conclusion
The application of enriched banana pseudostem sap as foliar spray with 50% recommended dose of soil-applied fertilizer increased fresh cob yield by 39% compared with the 100% chemical fertilizer. The combined effects of soil-applied fertilizers with enriched banana pseudostem sap also promoted the protein content (16.5%), amino acid (9.6%), phenolic content (27.8%), antioxidant capacity (7.4%), and sugar content (15.5%) of corn compared to the sole chemical fertilizer. Besides, the higher BCR and MBCR values confirmed that the foliar application of enriched banana pseudostem sap is a profitable option. Thus, foliar-sprayed enriched banana pseudostem sap can be utilized as a supplementary nutrient source or organic liquid fertilizer but it is recommended that more validation of the findings from the multilocation trials is needed in acid soil.
Acknowledgments
The authors would like to express his gratitude to the authority of the National Agricultural Technology Programme, Bangladesh Agricultural Research Council, and Bangladesh Agricultural Research Institute for providing fellowship to perform research at the Faculty of Agriculture, Universiti Putra Malaysia. All faculty members and staff of the Department of Land Management are highly acknowledged because of their continuous technical support and cooperation in order to complete the research. Authors would also like to extend their sincere appreciation to Taif University, Taif University, Taif, Saudi Arabia for providing resources to conduct the study.
References
- 1. Friedman M. Analysis, nutrition, and health benefits of tryptophan. Int J Tryptophan Res. 2018;11: 1–12. pmid:30275700
- 2. Martajaya M, Agustina L, Syekhfani . Organic sweet corn cultivation in Tlogomas, Malang. J Dev Sustain. 2010;1: 2087–3522.
- 3. Ch’ng HY, Haruna AO, Majid NMNA, Jalloh MB. Improving soil phosphorus availability and yield of maize (Zea mays L.) using biochar and compost derived from agro-industrial wastes. Ital J Agron. 2019;14: 34–42.
- 4. Patil B, Chetan H. Foliar fertilization of nutrients. Marumegh. 2016;3: 49–53.
- 5. Noack SR, McBeath TM, McLaughlin MJ. Potential for foliar phosphorus fertilisation of dryland cereal crops: A review. Crop Pasture Sci. 2010;61: 659–669.
- 6. Lichtfouse E. Genetic engineering, biofertilization, soil quality and organic farming: A rewiew. Sustain Agric. 2010;4: 347–369.
- 7. Emamverdian A, Ding Y, Mokhberdoran F, Xie Y. Heavy metal stress and some mechanisms of plant defense response. Sci World J. 2015;4: 1–18. http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2015/756120 pmid:25688377
- 8. Cao S, Yang Z, Pareek S. Tropical and subtropical fruits: Postharvest biology and storage. J Food Qual. 2018;4: 1–2.
- 9. Sharma M, Patel SN, Sangwan RS, Singh SP. Biotransformation of banana pseudostem extract into a functional juice containing value added biomolecules of potential health benefits. Indian J Exp Biol. 2017;55: 453–462.
- 10. Kim MJ, Shim CK, Kim YK, Hong SJ, Park JH, Han EJ, et al. Effect of aerated compost tea on the growth promotion of lettuce, soybean, and sweet corn in organic cultivation. Plant Pathol J. 2015;31: 259–268. pmid:26361474
- 11. Xu D, Liu D, Tang Z, Yu G, Yuan J, Shen Q, et al. Structure of chemical components in different compost extracts characterized by chromatogram and spectroscopy analysis and its influence on plant growth promotion. J Mater Cycles Waste Manag. 2012;14: 325–333.
- 12.
Kuepper G. Foliar fertilization. ATTRA (Appropriate Technology Transfer for Rural Areas). 2003. pp. 1–10. http//http://www.attra.ncat.org
- 13. Hu Y, Burucs Z, Schmidhalter U. Effect of foliar fertilization application on the growth and mineral nutrient content of maize seedlings under drought and salinity. Soil Sci Plant Nutr. 2008;54: 133–141.
- 14. Islam MS, Kasim S, Alam KM, Amin AM,, Hun TG, Haque MA. Changes in chemical properties of banana pseudostem, mushroom media waste, and chicken manure through the co-composting process. Sustainability. 2021;13: 8458.
- 15. Faozi K, Yudono P, Indradewa D, Maas A. Banana stem bokashi and its effect to increase soybean yield in coastal sands area. Agrotechnology. 2018;7: 1–7.
- 16. Bahtiar SA, Muayyad A, Ulfaningtias L, Anggara J, Priscilla C, Miswar M. Compost use banana weevil (Musa acuminata) to boost growth and content of sugar sweet corn (Zea mays L. Saccharata). J Agric Sci. 2017;14: 18–22.
- 17. Pradhan B, Deo B. Detection of phytochemicals and in vitro propagation of banana (Musa spp.). Journl Med plant Stud. 2019;7: 46–49.
- 18. Suprihatin . A production process of liquid fertilizer from the banana trunk. J Tech Chem. 2011;5: 429–433.
- 19. Islam MS, Kasim S, Amin AM, Hun TG, Alam K, Haque MA. Banana-pseudostem sap growing media as a novel source of phytochemicals and mineral nutrients: Influence on seedling growth of sweet corn. Chil J Agric Res. 2021;82: 135–145.
- 20.
Sugiarti H. The application of banana compost on seedling growth of Jabon (Anthocephalus cadamba Miq). Bogor Agricultural University. 2011.
- 21. Minardi S, Hartati S, Widijanto H, Wulandari D. The use of extract banana corm and phosphate rock to increase available-P in Alfisols. Sains Tanah, J Soil Sci Agroclimatol. 2015;12: 76–81.
- 22. Zhang L, Yang X, Gao D, Wang L, Li J, Wei Z, et al. Effects of poly-γ-glutamic acid (γ-PGA) on plant growth and its distribution in a controlled plant-soil system. Sci Rep. 2017;7: 1–13. pmid:28729559
- 23. Mohapatra D, Mishra S, Sutar N. Banana and its by-product utilisation: An overview. J Sci Ind Res (India). 2010;69: 323–329.
- 24. Brankov M, Simić M, Dolijanović Ž, Rajković M, Mandić V, Dragičević V. The response of maize lines to foliar fertilizing. Agric. 2020;10: 1–12.
- 25. Balawejder M, Matlok N, Gorzelany J, Pieniazek M, Antos P, Witek G, et al. Foliar fertilizer based on calcined bones, boron and molybdenum-a study on the development and potential effects on maize grain production. Sustainability. 2019;11: 1–12.
- 26. Sharma G, Kumar A, Devi KA, Prajapati D, Bhagat D, Pal A, et al. Chitosan nanofertilizer to foster source activity in maize. Int J Biol Macromol. 2020;145: 226–234. pmid:31866543
- 27. Aini DN, Sugiyanto B, Herlinawati . Application of local microorganism derived from stem of banana and goat manure on the yield of soybean (Glycine max L. Merrill) var. Agriprima, J Appl Agric Sci. 2017;1: 35–43.
- 28. Ding Y, Zhao J, Nie Y, Fan B, Wu S, Zhang Y, et al. Salicylic acid induced chilling- and oxidative-stress tolerance in relation to gibberellin homeostasis, C-repeat/dehydration-responsive element binding factor pathway, and antioxidant enzyme systems in cold-stored tomato fruit. J Agric Food Chem. 2016;64: 1–6. pmid:27754653
- 29. Giskin M, Efron Y. Planting date and foliar fertilization of corn grown for silage and grain under limited moisture. Agron J. 1986;78: 426–429.
- 30. Amal G, Ahmed MS, Hassanein , El-Gazzar MM. Growth and yield response of two wheat cultivars to complete foliar fertilizer compound “Dogoplus.” J Appl aciences Res. 2006;2: 20–26.
- 31. González A, Castro J, Vera J, Moenne A. Seaweed oligosaccharides stimulate plant growth by enhancing carbon and nitrogen assimilation, basal metabolism, and cell division. J Plant Growth Regul. 2013;32: 443–448.
- 32. Peirce CAE, McBeath TM, Priest C, McLaughlin MJ. The timing of application and inclusion of a surfactant are important for absorption and translocation of foliar phosphoric acid by wheat Leaves. Front Plant Sci. 2019;10: 1–11. pmid:31824546
- 33. Olusegun AY, Meki C. Soil and foliar application of zinc to maize and wheat grown on a Zambian Alfisol. African J Agric Res. 2014;9: 963–970.
- 34. Wei Y, Shohag MJI, Yang X. Biofortification and bioavailability of rice grain zinc as affected by different forms of foliar zinc fertilization. PLoS One. 2012;7: 1–10. pmid:23029003
- 35. Rout GR, Sahoo S. Role of iron in plant growth and metabolism. Rev Agric Sci. 2015;3: 1–24.
- 36. Hassan NMK, Marzouk NM, Fawzy ZF, Saleh SA. Effect of bio-stimulants foliar applications on growth, yield, and product quality of two Cassava cultivars. Bull Natl Res Cent. 2020;44: 1–9.
- 37. Pangaribuan DH, Sarno , Hendarto K, Priyanto , Darma AK, Aprillia T. Liquid organic fertilizer from plant extracts improves the growth, yield and quality of sweet corn (Zea mays L. Var. Saccharata). Pertanika J Trop Agric Sci. 2019;42: 1157–1166.
- 38. Syawal Y, Sodikin E, Irmawati , Sugiarti H. Application of liquid organic fertilizer from banana pseudostem on growth and yield of sweet corn (Zea mays L. Saccharata). Russ J Agric Socio-Economic Sci. 2018;80: 434–438.
- 39. Misal NB, Patil RG, Krittika . Effect of shade net, phosphorus fertilizer and banana pseudostem sap on nutrient uptake of fenugreek. Ann Biol. 2019;34: 148–151.
- 40. Salunkhe JR, Patel AM, Patil RG, Pisal RR. Effect of banana pseudostem sap as liquid fertilizer in onion. Indian J Agric Res. 2013;47: 258–262.
- 41. Fernando WSLV, Karunarathna B. Effect of foliar application of banana pseudostem sap on yield of cowpea (Vigna unguiculata L. Walp.). Int Lett Nat Sci. 2020;79: 9–15.
- 42.
Keeney DR, Nelson DW. Nitrogen inorganic forms. In: In Page A. L., Keeney D.R., Baker D. E., Miller R. H., Ellis R. J. & DR J (Eds), editor. Methods of Soil Analysis Part 2. Madison, Winconcin: Agron. Monogr 9. ASA and SSSA; 1982. pp. 159–165.
- 43. Yuan Z, Cao Q, Zhang K, Ata-Ul-Karim ST, Tan Y, Zhu Y, et al. Optimal leaf positions for SPAD meter measurement in rice. Front Plant Sci. 2016;7: 1–10. pmid:27303416
- 44. Elings A. Estimation of leaf area in tropical maize. Agron J. 2000;92: 436–444.
- 45.
Cottenie A. Soil testing and plant testing as a basis of fertilizer recommendation. FAO Soils Bulletin, 38. 1980. pp. 70–73.
- 46. Ahmed R, Uddin K, Quddus A, Yusoff M, Samad A, Hossain MAM, et al. Impact of foliar application of zinc and zinc oxide nanoparticles on growth, yield, nutrient uptake and quality of tomato. Horticulturae. 2023;9: 1–23.
- 47. Ahmed IM, Cao F, Han Y, Nadira UA, Zhang G, Wu F. Differential changes in grain ultrastructure, amylase, protein and amino acid profiles between Tibetan wild and cultivated barleys under drought and salinity alone and combined stress. Food Chem. 2013;141: 2743–2750. pmid:23871019
- 48. Cooper C, Packer N and, Williams K. Amino acid analysis Protocols. J Chem Inf Model. 2000;53: 1–265.
- 49. Musa KH, Abdullah A, Jusoh K, Subramaniam V. Antioxidant activity of pink-flesh guava (Psidium guajava L.): Effect of extraction techniques and solvents. Food Anal Methods. 2011;4: 100–107.
- 50. Lu XH, Sun DQ, Wu QS, Liu SH, Sun GM. Physico-chemical properties, antioxidant activity and mineral contents of pineapple genotypes grown in China. Molecules. 2014;19: 8518–8532. pmid:24959679
- 51. Rahman S, Kazal MMH, Begum IA, Alam MJ. Competitiveness, profitability, input demand and output supply of maize production in Bangladesh. Agriculture. 2016;6: 1–14.
- 52. Duarte AP, de Abreu MF, Francisco EAB, Gitti DDC, Barth G, Kappes C. Reference values of grain nutrient content and removal for corn. Rev Bras Cienc do Solo. 2019;43: 1–12.
- 53. Deng G, Sheng OO, Bi F, Li C, Dou T, Dong T, et al. Metabolic profiling in banana pseudo-stem reveals a diverse set of bioactive compounds with potential nutritional and industrial applications. Phyton (B Aires). 2020;89: 1102–1130.
- 54. Godlewska K, Michalak I, Tuhy L, Chojnacka K. Plant growth biostimulants based on different methods of seaweed extraction with water. Biomed Res Int. 2016;25: 1–11. pmid:27366749
- 55. Hörtensteiner S, Kräutler B. Chlorophyll breakdown in higher plants. Biochim Biophys Acta-Bioenergetics. 2011;1807: 977–988. pmid:21167811
- 56. Ali A, Hussain M, Habib HS, Kiani TT, Anees MA, Rahman MA. Foliar spray surpasses soil application of potassium for maize production under rainfed conditions. Turkish J F Crop. 2016;21: 36–43.
- 57. Taub DR. Rising carbon dioxide levels and plants effects of rising atmospheric concentrations of carbon dioxide on plants. Nat Educ Knowl. 2010;3: 1–5.
- 58. Sitko K, Gieroń Ż, Szopiński M, Zieleźnik-Rusinowska P, Rusinowski S, Pogrzeba M, et al. Influence of short-term macronutrient deprivation in maize on photosynthetic characteristics, transpiration and pigment content. Sci Rep. 2019;9: 1–12. pmid:31578358
- 59. Samborska IA, Kalaji HM, Sieczko L, Goltsev V, Borucki W, Jajoo A. Structural and functional disorder in the photosynthetic apparatus of radish plants under magnesium deficiency. Funct Plant Biol. 2018;45: 668–679. pmid:32290968
- 60. Eichert T, Burkhardt J. Quantification of stomatal uptake of ionic solutes using a new model system. J Exp Bot. 2001;5: 1–10. pmid:11413213
- 61. Tadros MJ, Omari HJ, Turk MA. The morphological, physiological and biochemical responses of sweet corn to foliar application of amino acids biostimulants sprayed at three growth stages. Aust J Crop Sci. 2019;13: 412–417.
- 62. Rathore SS, Chaudhary DR, Boricha GN, Ghosh A, Bhatt BP, Zodape ST, et al. Effect of seaweed extract on the growth, yield and nutrient uptake of soybean (Glycine max) under rainfed conditions. South African J Bot. 2009;75: 351–355.
- 63. Sun X, Kay AD, Kang H, Small GE, Liu G, Zhou X, et al. Correlated biogeographic variation of magnesium across trophic levels in a terrestrial food chain. PLoS One. 2013;8: 1–8. pmid:24223807
- 64. Sumalan RL, Croitor L, Petric M, Radulov I, Bourosh P, Sumalan RM, et al. P-aminobenzoate organic salts as potential plant growth regulators for tomatoes. Molecules. 2020;25: 1–15. pmid:32252303
- 65. Bojórquez-Quintal E, Escalante-Magaña C, Echevarría-Machado I, Martínez-Estévez M. Aluminum, a friend or foe of higher plants in acid soils. Front Plant Sci. 2017;8: 1–18. pmid:29075280
- 66. Aulya NR, Noli ZA, Bakhtiar A. Effect of plant extracts on growth and yield of maize (Zea mays L.). Pertanika J Trop Agric Sci. 2018;41: 1193–1205.
- 67. Cassim BMAR, Machado APM, Fortune D, Moreira FR, Zampar É. J. D. O., & Batista MA. Effects of foliar application of urea and urea-formaldehyde/triazone on soybean and corn crops. Agronomy. 2020;10: 1–12.
- 68. Paramesh V, Dhar S, Dass A, Kumar B, Kumar A, El-Ansary DO, et al. Role of integrated nutrient management and agronomic fortification of zinc on yield, nutrient uptake and quality of wheat. Sustainability. 2020;12: 1–12.
- 69. Chen JW, Yang ZQ, Zhou P, Hai MR, Tang TX, Liang YL, et al. Biomass accumulation and partitioning, photosynthesis, and photosynthetic induction in field-grown maize (Zea mays L.) under low- and high-nitrogen conditions. Acta Physiol Plant. 2013;35: 95–105.
- 70. Gao C, El-Sawah AM, Ali DFI, Hamoud YA, Shaghaleh H, Sheteiwy MS. The integration of bio and organic fertilizers improve plant growth, grain yield, quality and metabolism of hybrid maize. Agronomy. 2020;10: 1–27.
- 71. Iqbal A, Qiang D, Alamzeb M, Xiangru W, Huiping G, Hengheng Z, et al. Untangling the molecular mechanisms and functions of nitrate to improve nitrogen use efficiency. J Sci Food Agric. 2020;100: 904–914. pmid:31612486
- 72. Bakry BA, Ibrahim FM, Abdallah MMS, El-Bassiouny HMS. Effect of banana peel extract or tryptophan on growth, yield and some biochemical aspects of quinoa plants under water deficit. Int J PharmTech Res. 2016;9: 276–287.