https://orcid.org/0000-0002-0355-7563
Figures
Abstract
Objective
To systematically evaluate the effectiveness and potential underlying mechanisms of acupuncture in the treatment of experimental model of migraine in rats.
Methods
Nine electronic databases, including CNKI (China National Knowledge Infrastructure), WanFang, VIP (Chinese Scientific Journals Database), Sinomed, PubMed, Cochrane Library, Web of Science and EBSCO, were searched for randomized experimental studies on migraine in rats involving acupuncture intervention. The search period ranged from inception to June 2022. The methodological quality was assessed using the SYRCLE’s risk of bias tool for animal studies. Data were analyzed using the Revman 5.3 software.
Results
A total of 13 studies were included in this analysis. Findings from the available experimental studies documented that acupuncture significantly reduced behavior scores of rats with migraine (MD = -15.01, 95%CI = [-18.01, -12.01], P<0.00001) and downregulated the expression of calcitonin gene-related peptide (CGRP) (MD = -16.14, 95%CI = [-21.45, -10.83], P<0.00001), substance P (SP) (MD = -11.47, 95%CI = [-15.97, -6.98], P<0.00001) and nitric oxide (NO) (MD = -3.02, 95%CI = [-3.79, -2.26], P<0.00001) in serum, and stimulatory G protein (Gsa) (MD = -62.90, 95%CI = [-69.88, -55.92], P<0.00001) in brainstem. Acupuncture also significantly increased the content of inhibitory G protein (Gia) (MD = 24.01, 95%CI = [20.10, 27.92], P<0.00001) in brainstem and 50% paw withdrawal threshold (50%PWT) (MD = 1.96, 95%CI = [1.15, 2.77], P<0.00001).
Citation: Su P, Xie X, Xu Y, Luo X, Niu J, Jin Z (2023) Effectiveness of acupuncture in migraine rats: A systematic review. PLoS ONE 18(1): e0280556. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0280556
Editor: Ming Tatt Lee, UCSI: UCSI University, MALAYSIA
Received: August 31, 2022; Accepted: January 3, 2023; Published: January 20, 2023
Copyright: © 2023 Su et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Data Availability: All relevant data are within the paper.
Funding: Prof. Jin was funded by National Natural Science Foundation of China (funding reference number 81774010) and played the following specific roles: Prof. Jin designed and supervised the study, reviewed and revised the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
1 Introduction
Migraine is a common primary headache, characterized by recurrent unilateral or bilateral throbbing severe headache accompanied by nausea and photophobia [1]. The underlying etiology of the disease is due to disturbances in nerve cell excitability, genetic, endocrine and metabolic factors, and is easily triggered by insomnia, stress, exertion, noise, diet, weather and menstrual cycle, etc. The pathogenesis of migraine has not been fully elucidated in Western medicine, and the mainstream is the trigeminal vascular inflammatory theory [2]. This theory suggests that the main physiopathological changes that occur in migraine are the dilation of meningeal blood vessels and the release of inflammatory factors leading to a neurogenic inflammatory response, which results in headache symptoms. At present, migraine is mainly treated with analgesic and sedative drugs. Although their immediate efficacy is positive, their safety, tolerability and long-term curative effects are not satisfactory [3]. Therefore, the active exploration of effective and low-risk treatment methods is the current focus of migraine prevention and treatment.
Migraine is the preponderant illness for therapy in Chinese acupuncture. Studies have shown that acupuncture can reduce migraine frequency, pain degree and duration, with low side effects [4,10]. To date, there is a substantial body of animal experiments that demonstrated better therapeutic outcomes of acupuncture in the treatment of migraine, but the relevant systematic evaluation of its effects is limited.
The objective of our systematic review and meta-analysis is to explore the efficacy of acupuncture and to discuss the potential working mechanisms of acupuncture in protecting against migraine. Results obtained from this analysis may provide the therapeutic basis of acupuncture in the treatment of migraine in humans.
2 Materials and methods
2.1 Eligibility criteria
Inclusion criteria: (1) Research type: aniaml studies published in Chinese and English; (2) Research subject: experimental migraine model in rats with nitroglycerin; (3) Intervention study: the control group was migraine model group, the experimental group was migraine rat model treated with acupuncture. The difference of intervention measures between the control and experimental groups should only be whether acupuncture treatment was used. (4) Efficacy evaluation index: behavioral scores, calcitonin gene-related peptide (CGRP), substance P (SP), 50% paw withdrawal threshold (50%PWT), stimulatory G protein (Gsa), inhibitory G protein (Gia) and nitric oxide (NO).
Exclusion criteria: (1) Research type: non-animal experiments, reviews, case reports, etc.; (2) Research subject: non-nitroglycerin-induced migraine models such as electrical stimulation; (3) Insufficient data; (4) Inconsistent outcome measures.
2.2 Study strategy
We selected relevant studies published by June 2022 through searching databases including Chinese National Knowledge Infrastructure (CNKI), and Wanfang Data information site, vip Database (VIP), Chinese Biomedicine Database (CBM), PubMed, Cochrane Library, Web of Science and EBSCO. Search terms were: (Acupuncture OR Pinprick OR Moxibustion OR Acupoint) AND (Disorder Migraine OR Disorders Migraine OR Migraine Disorder OR Cerebrovascular Accident OR Cerebrovascular Accidents OR CVA Cerebrovascular Migraine OR Migraines OR Migraine Headache OR Headache Migraine OR Headaches Migraine). Comprehensive and systematic retrieval were conducted according to different database situations.
2.3 Data extraction
Two researchers with the same training independently screened and extracted the data, and any disagreement was resolved by the third researcher. The following data were extracted from the selected studies: (1) General information including the title, author, year, the animal quantity, weight, species and model; (2) Intervention including acupuncture point, acupuncture manipulation method and acupuncture duration; (3) Outcomes. For the literature that only reported data in the form of images, we extracted data from the images through GetData Graph Digitizer software; (4) Adverse reactions.
2.4 Quality assessment
Statistical software SYRCLE’s Risk of Bias tool [5] was used to make judgments for each entry.
2.5 Data analysis
Statistical software Revman 5.3 was used to analyze the collected data. Counting data were expressed as relative risk (RR) and its 95% confidence interval (CI), and continuous variables were represented as mean difference (MD) or standardized mean difference (SMD) that was to calculate 95% confidence interval (95% CI). When interventions are measured in identical methods or units, MD was used. When they were different, SMD was used. When heterogeneity test results were P>0.05 and I2<50%, the fixed effect models were used. When the heterogeneity test results were P<0.05 and I2>50%, the random effect models were used. In order to find out the sources of heterogeneity, sensitivity analysis or subgroup analysis were performed. For the literature with excessive heterogeneity, the final results were described and analyzed by forest and funnel maps.
3 Results
3.1 Inclusion of literature analysis
We identified a total of 6832 literatures, 2845 studies remained after excluding duplicate articles, and 442 studies remained after excluding non-migraine, non-acupuncture, and non-nitroglycerin models. Eventually, 13 studies were included in the final meta-analysis (Fig 1). The basic characteristics of the included studies were shown in Table 1. The risk of bias for the included studies were shown in Table 2.
3.2 Behavioral scores analysis
Six studies [6–11] reported behavioral scores. Meta-analysis of these studies showed that there was heterogeneity (I2 = 88%, P<0.00001), so the random effect model was adopted. The results showed that acupuncture could effectively reduce behavioral scores (MD = -15.01, 95%CI = [-18.01, -12.01], P<0.00001), and the difference was statistically significant (Table 3).
3.3 CGRP analysis
Three studies [8,11,13] reported CGRP and showed relatively high heterogeneity (P<0.00001, I2 = 97%), and the random effect model was used. The results showed that acupuncture could reduce the content of CGRP in serum (MD = -16.14, 95%CI = [-21.45, -10.83], P<0.00001), and the difference was statistically significant (Table 3).
3.4 SP analysis
Four studies [8,10,11,15] reported SP. The study showed that the heterogeneity was relatively large (P<0.00001, I2 = 96%), and the random effect model was used. The results showed that acupuncture was effective and could significantly reduce the content of SP in serum (MD = -11.47, 95%CI = [-15.97, -6.98], P<0.00001), and the difference was statistically significant (Table 3).
3.5 50%PTW analysis
Four studies [6,7,10,12] reported 50%PTW. Meta-analysis of these studies indicated that there was heterogeneity (P<0.0001, I2 = 87%), so the random effect model was adopted. The results showed that acupuncture could obviously improve 50% PTW (MD = 1.96, 95%CI = [1.15, 2.77], P<0.00001), and the difference was statistically significant (Table 3).
3.6 Gsa analysis
Three studies [16–18] reported Gsa. The forest plot showed that there was heterogeneity (P = 0.87, I2 = 0%), so the fixed effect model was adopted. The results showed that acupuncture could significantly reduce the content of Gsa in brainstem (MD = -62.90, 95%CI = [-69.88, -55.92], P<0.00001), and the difference was statistically significant (Table 3).
3.7 Gia analysis
Three studies [16–18] reported Gia. They showed that there was heterogeneity (P = 0.50, I2 = 0%), so the fixed effect model was adopted. The results showed that acupuncture could significantly increase the content of Gia in brainstem (MD = 24.01, 95%CI = [20.10, 27.92], P<0.00001), and the difference was statistically significant (Table 3).
3.8 NO analysis
Two studies [12,14] reported NO. They showed that there was heterogeneity (P = 0.99, I2 = 0%), so the fixed effect model was adopted. The results showed that acupuncture could effectively reduce the content of NO in serum (MD = -3.02, 95%CI = [-3.79, -2.26], P<0.00001), and the difference was statistically significant (Table 3).
3.9 Sensitivity analysis
3.9.1 Behavioral scores.
Subgroup analysis was performed using acupoints as grouping criteria, and the results of the heterogeneity test showed that the subgroup I2 increased to 95% for acupoints Fengchi, Waiguan, and Yanglingquan, and decreased to 0% for acupoints Baihui, Fengchi, Neiguan, and Taichong, indicating that the different acupoints had an effect on the heterogeneity of this study. However, the results still support that acupuncture is effective in reducing behavioral scores and improving behavioral performance in migraine rats (Fig 2).
3.9.2 CGRP.
We conducted the sensitivity analysis of CGRP by separately leaving each one study out. Study reported by Meng, Xianhui [13] is the main source of heterogeneity, and I2 after excluding the study by Meng, Xianhui [13] was reduced from 97% to 0%. Due to the limited studies included in the meta-analysis, we speculated that the method of CGRP measurement in the study was radioimmunoassay [13], while others were ELISA [8,11]. Differences in the methods of CGRP measurements might lead to heterogeneity. However, the results still support that acupuncture can reduce the content of CGRP in serum of rats with migraine.
3.9.3 SP.
The subgroup analysis of SP showed that I2 increased to 96% in the subgroup that did not describe the acupuncture manipulation. I2 decreased to 0% in the subgroup that used the reinforcing-reducing method. Fig 3 shows that difference in acupuncture manipulation is the main cause of heterogeneity of SP. The results also support that acupuncture was effective in reducing SP in serum of rats with migraine.
3.9.4 50%PTW.
The subgroup analysis of 50%PWT showed that I2 decreased to 0% in the subgroup that the method of calculating 50%PWT was clearly described, and I2 increased to 95% in those that the method of calculating 50%PWT was not described. Fig 4 shows different methods calculating of 50%PWT that are the main cause of heterogeneity. The results also support that acupuncture was effective in increasing 50%PTW, thereby improving pain sensitivity in rats with migraine.
3.10 Publication bias
The publication bias of behavioral scores was assessed by the funnel plot, as shown in Fig 5. The results showed a symmetrical trend and some publication bias.
4 Discussion
Migraine is commonly encountered in clinical practice. In recent years, acupuncture has been used widely to treat patients with migraine and other pain conditions. In order to better understand the clinical effect of acupuncture on migraine, we conducted a meta-analysis that included randomized, controlled experimental studies in rat models of migraine. This study is the first systematic review of acupuncture treatment of migraine rats. We demonstrated that acupuncture attenuates migraine in rats and that its beneficial effect associated with the reduction of CGRP, SP, Gsa, Gia, and NO, thus improving behavioral scores and 50%PWT.
CGRP plays a pivotal role in the pathogenesis of migraine [19]. In the peripheral trigeminal vascular system, CGRP is released and participates in the activation of meningeal injury receptors. CGRP can enhance pain-sensory transduction by activating mast cells, immune cells and endothelial cells, leading to dilation of intracranial arteries [20]. SP participates in the regulation of pain perception, which can both cause pain and relieve pain in the nervous system. SP can stimulate the secretion of inflammatory factors by binding to the specific receptor, resulting in increased nerve cell excitation and sensitivity that induce neuroendocrine and neuroinflammation. CGRP and SP coexist in sensory ganglion nerve cells. SP interacts with CGRP promoting the secretion of SP, which in turn strengthens the transmission of pain signals. G protein plays an important role in intra- and extra-cellular signal transduction systems. Both Gsa and Gia are closely related to cerebral vasomotor function [21]. In the neurovascular endothelial cell receptor-adenylase (AC) signaling system, Gsa activates AC and converts adenylate into cAMP, while Gia inhibits AC activity and affects cAMP production, thus regulating the release of vasoactive substances and neuropeptides in the brain. Acupuncture treatment can effectively reduce the content of Gsa and increase the content of Gia, thereby reducing the production of cAMP and improving the intracranial vasodilatory function. NO plays a key role in migraine by regulating the diastolic function of brain microvascular endothelial cells. NO can not only mediate endothelium-dependent relaxation, but also mediate cerebral vascular dilation caused by local neuronal excitation [22]. NO can cause the onset of pain sensation by directly affecting paravascular sensory nerves to activate sensory nerve fibers, improving the sensitivity of nociceptive sensory neurons, mediating the transmission of pain signals [23]. NO exerts migraine inducing effect by upregulating inflammatory cytokines such as interleukin-1 and tmor necrosis factor-α that stimulate trigeminal nerve fibers to promote the release of CGRP, SP and other vasoactive substances [24].
As shown in the meta-analysis, the levels of GCRP, SP and NO were increased in migraine models in rats, and the increase of these neuroinflammatory mediators were attenuated by acupuncture treatment. Based on the current systematic review and mete-analysis, acupuncture protects against migraine in rats was associated with elevated the 50%PTW value, decreased levels of Gsα, increased the level of Giα, and reduced Gsα/Giα protein ratio, thus regulating the signaling system inside and outside the cell membrane and the transcriptional expression of various target genes in the nucleus, leading to the improvement of the intracranial vasomotor function (Fig 6).
The limitations of this system review included: (1) The studies included in the data analysis were limited, which might have a certain bias on the conclusion. (2) There is a risk of uncertainty bias in multiple evaluation items, suggesting that randomized controlled trials with standardized experimental designs should be selected in the future to exclude the implementation bias and measurement bias in the study.
5 Conclusion
In conclusion, this systematic review and meta-analysis demonstrated that acupuncture attenuates and prevents migraine in rats, compared with the sham acupuncture group. This study illustrates that the effectiveness of acupuncture treatment in migraine is mainly by alleviating neurogenic inflammation and central nociceptive conduction via the regulation of meningeal vasodilation and inflammatory factors, providing a therapeutic basis for acupuncture in the treatment of migraine. However, potential publication bias still exists. In the future, high-quality trials are needed to minimize bias, thus proving more persuasive findings that can be used to improve migraine patient care.
References
- 1. Mehrotra S, Gupta S, Chan KY, Villalón CM, Centurión D, Saxena PR, et al. Current and prospective pharmacological targets in relation to antimigraine action[J]. N-SArch Pharmacol. 2008; 378(4): 371–394. pmid:18626630
- 2. Dong LZ, Pu SX, Zhou JY. Research progress of migraine and neurogenic inflammation[J].Chongqing Medicine. 2015(8): 1126–1128.
- 3. R Michael G, Robert K. Migraine medication attributes important for patient compliance: concerns about side effects may delay treatment[J]. Headache. 2003; 43(1): 36–43. pmid:12864756
- 4. Liu SS, Luo SL, Yan TW, Ma W, Wei XY, Chen YL, et al. Differential Modulating Effect of Acupuncture in Patients With Migraine Without Aura: A Resting Functional Magnetic Resonance Study[J]. Front Neurol. 2021; 12: 680896. pmid:34122321
- 5. Chen KY, Ma B, Wang YN, Chen CH, Zhao YQ, Zheng JX, et al. Introduction to SYRCLE animal experiment bias risk assessment tool. Chinese Journal of Evidence-Based Medicine. 2014; 14(10): 1281–1285.
- 6. Song BQ, Zhang YL, Wang GN, He YJ, Yang LY, Fu L, Liu WA. Effect of acupuncture at Fengchi, Waiguan and Yanglingquan on NF-κB P65, IKKβ and IκBα in migraine model rats[J]. Journal of Hunan University of Traditional Chinese Medicine. 2021; 41(9): 1350–1355.
- 7. Zhang YL, Song BQ, He YJ, Yang LY, Fu L, Liu WA. Effects of acupuncture at Fengchi, Waiguan and Yanglingquan on the levels of IL-6, TNF-α and CGRP in the spinal nucleus of the trigeminal nerve in the brainstem of rats with migraine[J]. Chinese Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine Information. 2022; 29(01): 59–64.
- 8. Huang SL, Wang SY, Wang MM, Han J, Yang DH. Effect of liver sparing and tonifying acupuncture on the expression of vasoactive substances and adenosine A1 receptors in migraine model rats[J]. Chinese Journal of Basic Chinese Medicine. 2021; 27(04): 579–582+622.
- 9. Huang SL, Wang MM, Geng W, Han J, Yang DH. Effect of liver sparing and tonifying acupuncture on brain neurokinin-1 receptor gene and protein expression in migraine rats[J]. Shi-Zhen National Medicine. 2020; 31(04): 986–989.
- 10. Wang QN, Liu QJ, Ye YH, Liu WA, Fu L. Effect of electroacupuncture of specific points of Shaoyang meridian on serum 5-HT and SP levels in migraine rats at different periods[J]. Shi-Zhen National Medicine. 2019; 30(11): 2795–2798.
- 11. Wang MM, Yu XH, Geng W, Cui HF, Wang CC, Han J, et al. Effect of detoxification of the liver and tonifying acupuncture on behavior and expression of related neuropeptides and inflammatory substances in blood of migraine rats[J]. Acupuncture Research. 2018; 43(06): 375–379.
- 12. Yihong Ye, Qiujia Liu, Leqiangwei Kang, Wang GN, Liu WA, Yue ZH, et al. Effect of electroacupuncture on NO and ET-1 levels and 50%PWT in serum of migraine rats at specific points of Shaoyang meridian[J]. Journal of Hunan University of Traditional Chinese Medicine. 2018; 38(12): 1453–1457.
- 13. Meng XH, Zhang ZG, Xiang LH. Effect of acupuncture with distant and near acupuncture on plasma CGRP and ET-1 in migraine model rats[J]. Chinese Journal of Basic Chinese Medicine. 2014; 20(05): 664–665.
- 14. Zhao ZE, Xu Y, Hu K, Li LH. Effect of acupuncture and acupoint injection on plasma ET, 6-K-PGF1α, TXB_2 and NO content in brain tissue of migraine rats[J]. Chinese Journal of Gerontology. 2013; 33(18): 4487–4489.
- 15. Li LH, Zeng Y. Preliminary investigation on the intervention of acupuncture and acupuncture point burial on migraine attacks in deconditioned rats[C]. Proceedings of the 2011 Annual Meeting of the Chinese Society of Acupuncture and Moxibustion (abstract). 2011; 454–464.
- 16. Li ZY, Li W, Gong Q, Zhong GW, Wang S, Wen LB. Effect of acupuncture of the bile meridian on the G protein content of brainstem tissue in migraine rats[J]. Journal of Hunan College of Traditional Chinese Medicine. 2005; (05): 54–56.
- 17. Wang SE, Li W, Zhong GW, Li ZY, Wen LB. Effect of acupuncture on G protein content in brain tissue of migraine rats[J]. Journal of Modern Traditional Chinese and Western Medicine. 2005; (03): 303–305.
- 18. Zhong GW, Li W, Wang SE, Li ZY, Wen LB. Effect of acupuncture on G protein content in brainstem tissues of migraine rats[J]. Chinese Journal of Modern Medicine. 2004; (17): 29–33+36.
- 19. Ho TW, Edvinsson L, Goadsby PJ. CGRP and its receptors provide new insights into migraine pathophysiology[J]. Nat. Rev. Neurol. 2010; 6: 573–82. pmid:20820195
- 20. Karl M. The big CGRP flood—sources, sinks and signalling sites in the trigeminovascular system[J]. The Journal of Headache and Pain. 2018; 19(1): 22. pmid:29532195
- 21. Wu YH, Hu R, Cai J, Zhong XY, Tang X, Liu HD, et al. Effects of Qinggan Qufeng Tongluo Recipe on Migraine Model Cell Proliferation and Expression of CGRP and SP Proteins[J]. Chinese Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine. 2020; 38(01): 196–199+280–281.
- 22. Wang ZW, Lu WJ, Yang J. Effects of Xiongzhi Decoction on Serum NO, 5-HT and Hemorheology in Migraine Patients[J]. Sichuan Traditional Chinese Medicine. 2020; 38(10): 137–141.
- 23. Zhao YL, Wang YL, Gao Y, Wang AC. The role of nitric oxide in the pathogenesis of migraine[J].China Clinical Rehabilitation. 2006; 10 (7): 138–139.
- 24. Song DN, Wang X, Zhou L, Han D. Effects of Compound Angelica Chuange Granules on Plasma NO, NOS, CGRP, ET and 5-HT, DA in Brain Tissue in Migraine Rats[J]. Jilin Traditional Chinese Medicine. 2019; 39(12): 1635–1637.