https://orcid.org/0000-0002-3555-0147
Figures
Abstract
Background
Pain is an unpleasant sensory and emotional experience associated with or resembling that actual or potential tissue damage. Different study findings show that about 55% to 78.6% of inpatients experience moderate-to-severe pain. Nurses are one of the health professional who may hear of pain suffered by the patients and who can manage patient suffering by themselves. Therefore, their correct skill is very important in non- pharmacology and pharmacology pain management methods.
Objective
To assess non-pharmacological pain management practice and barriers among nurses working in Debre Tabor Comprehensive Specialized Hospital, Ethiopia.
Methods
Data were collected using structured observational check list with interviewer administered questionnaires that measure nurses’ practice on non-pharmacological pain management. Data were entered using Epi Data version 3.1 and analyzed using SPSS (Stastical Package for Social Sciences) version 23. Bivariable and multivariable analysis were conducted to examine the association between independent and outcome variables.
Results
A total of 169 nurses participated in the study, with a response rate of 100%. Among the study participants 94 (55.6%) were females, and the mean age of nurses were 34.9(SD = 5.7) years. Only 44(26%) of nurses had good practice on non- pharmacology pain management methods. About 130(77.55%), 125(74.0%), and 123(72.8%) of nurses reported that inadequate cooperation of physicians, multiple responsibilities of nurses and insufficient number of nurses per patient ratio as barriers for practice of non -pharmacology pain management respectively.
Conclusion
Majority of nurses didn’t apply non-pharmacological pain management practices for their patients in pain and the overall practice level of nurses was very poor. The major identified obstacle factors for the poor practice of non–pharmacological pain management methods were nurses’ fatigue, inadequate cooperation of physicians, heavy workload, multiple responsibilities of nurses, and insufficient number of nurses per patient ratio and unfavorable attitude of nurse on non-pharmacology pain management. Even if nurses experiences different challenges, they shall use non‐pharmacological pain management methods complementary to pharmacological treatment of pain as they are low cost and safe. And also boosting nurse’s attitude towards the effect of non–pharmacological pain management methods is crucial.
Citation: Zeleke S, Kassaw A, Eshetie Y (2021) Non-pharmacological pain management practice and barriers among nurses working in Debre Tabor Comprehensive Specialized Hospital, Ethiopia. PLoS ONE 16(6): e0253086. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0253086
Editor: Walid Kamal Abdelbasset, Prince Sattam Bin Abdulaziz University, College of Applied Medical Sciences, SAUDI ARABIA
Received: March 18, 2021; Accepted: May 27, 2021; Published: June 15, 2021
Copyright: © 2021 Zeleke et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Data Availability: All relevant data are within the paper and its Supporting Information files.
Funding: The author(s) received no specific funding for this work.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Abbreviations: ANA, American Nursing Association; BSc, Bachelor of Sciences; SPSS, Statistical Package for Social Sciences
Introduction
Pain is an unpleasant sensory and emotional experience associated with, or resembling that actual or potential tissue damage [1]. Pain also can be further defined as, whatever the patient says it is, and it exists whenever the patient says it does [2]. Studies have reported that 55% to 78.6% of inpatients experience moderate-to-severe pain. There are still problems regarding pain management despite countless training courses, application strategies, and multidisciplinary pain teams [3]. According to the American Nurses Association (ANA), the role of nurses in pain management includes the entire nursing process, assessment of pain, plan of pharmacologic and non-pharmacologic pain management strategies, implementation and evaluation of the response of the patient to the interventions [4]. Pain is the major symptom that brings patients to the healthcare setting and is also the commonest symptom with approximately 79% of hospitalized patients suffer from it [5,6]. Pain management practices are defined as a set of activities that should be provided by nurses to manage the patients’ pain effectively which includes assessing the patients’ pain, providing appropriate nurse’s interventions to relieve the patients’ pain and reassessing the patients’ pain after intervention [7,8]. According to the ANA, one of the role of nurses are managing patient pain based on non-pharmacologic pain management strategies such as psychological, educational and parental support [9,10]. Pain is influenced by psychological [11], cultural [12], social [13], and spiritual [14] factors. Even if non-pharmacological pain management do not replace pharmacological treatment, but these non-pharmacological pain management strategies used as a complementary to reduce symptoms, affect pain perception, assist with relaxation and to improve sleep pattern [15,16]. Specific non- pharmacological pain management strategies that Nurses can use to relief the suffering of patients in the health institution include music therapy, acupuncture, col/hot application, exercise, positioning therapy, massage therapy, social support, spiritual and religious support, hot and cold therapy, relaxation therapy, deep and slow breathing exercise and distraction therapy [15,17,18]. Nurses are one of the health professional who may hear of pain suffered by the patients and who can manage patient suffering by themselves. Therefore, their appropriate and accurate skill is very important in non- pharmacology and pharmacology pain management methods. Based on research studies in different areas of the country there is a knowledge and attitude gap on non-pharmacology pain management among practicing nurses in hospitals [19,20]. But, to the authors’ knowledge, it is hard to find studies that have been conducted in the study setting as well as in Ethiopia regarding to the practice of nurses on non-pharmacology pain management methods. So, these facts prompted the researchers to embark on the assessment of Nurses’ non-pharmacological pain management practice and barriers in Debre Tabor Comprehensive Specialized Hospital, Ethiopia.
Methods
Study setting and design
The study was carried out in Debre Tabor Comprehensive Specialized Hospital, which is found in North Central Ethiopia. Debre Tabor is located 50 kilometers east of Lake Tana and 665 kilometers from the capital city of Ethiopia, Addis Ababa. The study was conducted from October 1st to December 30, 2020 with descriptive cross-sectional study design.
Population and sample
The study populations were all nurses (N = 169) working in Debre Tabor Comprehensive Specialized Hospital wards(Medical ward, Surgical ward, Intensive Care Unit ward, Orthopedic ward, Pediatrics ward, Psychiatry ward, Emergency ward, Recovery ward). Since the study population was small, we did not determine the sample size rather census was conducted.
Study variables, tools, and data collection procedure
The outcome variable was the practice of nurses on non-pharmacology pain management. The data were collected using observed structured cheek list with interviewer administered tools which contained socio-demographic questions, non-pharmacological pain management checklist and barriers that hindered the use of non-pharmacological pain management methods questions (S1 File). The tools were validated and adapted from a previous study with in-depth literature review [14,18,21,22]. The questionnaires were prepared in English and deployed for the respondents. The questionnaire was also checked thoroughly for objectivity and variable assessment before it was distributed to the data collectors. Half-day training was given to the data collectors and the supervisors on the study protocol, including the study objectives, the relevance of the study and confidentiality of information, respondent’s rights, and informed consent. One supervisor was a nurse holding Masters Science degree and two data collectors were nurses holding a Bachelor of Science degree. The scoring method for the outcome variable was adopted from a previous study [21]; good practice was recorded for nurses who apply non-pharmacology pain management methods routinely (≥75%).
Ethics approval and consent to participate
An ethical clearance letter was obtained from a Research Ethics Committee of Debre Tabor University, College of health sciences (reference number: 972/2012 E.C./CHS). The permission and agreement consent was obtained from the study hospital prior to the study after a brief explanation of the purpose of the study through support letter. Informed written consent was obtained from all participants after a brief explanation of the aim of study. Confidentiality of information and privacy of participants’ was respected. The participants were told that information they provide use only for the purpose of this study. The names of the participants did not include questionnaire rather specific codes were used.
Data processing and analysis
Data were entered into the computer using Epi Data version 3.1 and transported to Statistical Package for Social Sciences (SPSS) version 23.0 for analysis. Descriptive and inferential statistics were analyzed and presented. Initially, bivariate logistic regression was carried out to see the association of each independent variable with the outcome variable. Thereafter, to see the relationship of Nurses’ practice on non-pharmacology pain management, and socio-demographic and other variables multivariable logistic regression was used. Variables with a P-value ≤0.2 in the Bivariable logistic regression were used in the multiple logistic regression analysis. P-value ≤0.05 and 95% confidence level were considered as statistically significant.
Results
Socio-demographic characteristics of the nurses
A total of 169 nurses participated in the study, with a response rate of 100%. Among the study participants 94 (55.6%) were females, and the mean age of nurses were 34.9(SD = 5.7) years. About three fourth 125 (74%) of nurses marital status were married. Regarding educational status 132 (78.1%) were qualified with BSc degree in nursing, and only 24(14.2%) of nurses had training on non -pharmacology pain management (Table 1).
Nurses practice on non-pharmacological pain management methods
Regarding to nurses non pharmacology pain management practice 37(21.9%) of nurses apply movement restriction/resting, 31(18.3%) routinely use therapeutic communication with patient and family, 26(15.4%) apply hot or cold local packages routinely and 9(5.3%) of nurses provide quiet and comfortable room/reduce light intensity & alarms for the patients as non- pharmacology pain management. But, 169(100%) of nurses were never used acupuncture/acupressure as non-pharmacology patient pain management method. The overall non- pharmacology pain management practice level of nurses in Debre Tabor Comprehensive Specialized Hospital showed that only 44(26%) of nurses had good practice on non- pharmacology pain management methods (Table 2).
Barriers to the use of non-pharmacological pain management methods
Among the major obstacles or barriers identified by nurses for poor performance of non-pharmacological pain management for patients admitted in the ward; the following factors take the greatest responsibility. Based on nurses response around 121 (71.6%) said Nurses’ fatigue, 130(77.55%) inadequate cooperation of physicians, 121(71.6%) Nurses insufficient motivation to use non -pharmacology pain management methods because of low salary, about three fourth 125(74.0%) said heavy workload, 122(72.2%) disinclination and unwillingness to use non-pharmacological pain management, 125(74.0%) multiple responsibilities of nurses, 123(72.8%) an insufficient number of nurses per patient ratio and 113(66.9%) of nurse reported that inadequate training of nurses on non-pharmacological pain management methods (Table 3).
Factors associated with nurses’ practice on non-pharmacological pain management
In this study; Nurses who have non-pharmacology pain management training were three times (adjusted odds ratio [AOR] = 2.28, 95% CI = 1.14–6.32) more likely to have good practice on non-pharmacology pain management than nurses who didn’t have the training. Nurses who said that heavy workload and multiple responsibilities are an obstacle for the practice of non-pharmacology pain management were two times (adjusted odds ratio [AOR] = 2.61, 95% CI = 1.08–13.46) and three times (adjusted odds ratio [AOR] = 3.35, 95% CI = 1.42,-11.23) high likely to have good practice on non-pharmacology pain management than nurses who denies the obstacle respectively. Nurses with favorable attitude for non-pharmacology patient pain management were a positive predictor for good practice of non-pharmacology pain management (adjusted odds ratio [AOR] = 2.68, 95%CI = 2.13–8.01) (Table 4).
Discussion
In Ethiopia, few studies have assessed the practice of nurses’ regarding to non-pharmacological pain management; hence, the goal of this study was to assess the practice of nurses’ towards non-pharmacological pain management among nurses working in Debre Tabor Comprehensive Specialized hospital.
This study revealed that only 26% of nurses had good practice on non-pharmacological pain management. Our research result is similar with research done in Cairo University Hospital, Egypt the majority of nurses didn’t use non- pharmacological pain management methods/didn’t have good practice [23] and 40% of nurses in Illinois Wesleyan University have good practice on non-pharmacological pain management [24]. In our study setting for the poor implementation of non-pharmacological pain management methods; nurses’ infrequent training on non-pharmacological pain management methods, nurse’s unfavorable attitude towards non-pharmacological pain management, incorporation of physicians with nurses, poor nursing process implementation are the major accountable obstacles. The present finding shows that nurse’s experiences shortage of time due to increase work load and multiple responsibilities therefore nurses simply use pharmacological pain management protocol rather than using these therapeutic approaches of non-pharmacological pain management methods. This outcome is quite similar with study done at Makkah El-Mukarramah hospitals [25]. Regarding to nurses’ knowledge on non- pharmacological pain management methods 53.3% of participants had good knowledge. Our study finding is in congruent with research done at Benshangul Gumuz Hospitals 51.2% [20] and Iran Bindura Hospital 48.2% [26]. But, this study finding is lower compared with studies done in Zimbabwe 64.5% [27] and southern part of Ethiopia 78.1% [28]. The possible reasons may be variations in study setting, lack of training on non-pharmacological pain management, unwillingness of nurses to know the methods and disinclination of managers for non-pharmacological pain management. Regarding to nurses’ attitude this study showed that 35.5% of nurses’ have favorable attitude towards non-pharmacological pain management methods. It is lower than studies done at Benshangul Gumuz Hospitals 47% [20] and Iran Bindura Hospital 54% [26]. This discrepancy may be due to personal rating differences, sample size and socio demographic variation among the practicing nurses. In our study nurses with favorable attitude for non-pharmacology pain management methods were statistically significant associated with good practice of non-pharmacology pain management (adjusted odds ratio [AOR] = 2.68, 95%CI = 2.13–8.01). Moreover, nurses’ education showed that no statistically significant association with the practice of non-pharmacological pain management methods This finding is similar with research done in Egypt [21]. This similarity indicates that even the educational level of nurses has been increased, their practice on non-pharmacological pain management methods is low rather their attitude matters for their implementation. The major barriers that hindered non-pharmacological pain practices from being used by nurses were lack of time, nurses’ workload and multiple responsibilities of nurses. This result also congruent with the above research [21]. This similarity might be due to most African countries share similar characteristics in the health care system.
Conclusion
Majority of nurses in Debre Tabor Comprehensive specialized Hospital didn’t apply non-pharmacological pain management practices for their patients in pain and the overall practice level of nurses were very poor. Nurses with favorable attitude had significant association with good practice of non–pharmacological patient pain management methods. So, boosting nurse’s attitude towards the effect of non–pharmacological patient pain management methods is crucial. The major identified obstacles factors for the poor practice of non–pharmacological patient pain management methods were nurses’ fatigue, inadequate cooperation of physicians, nurses insufficient motivation to use non -pharmacology pain management methods because of low salary, heavy workload, disinclination of the managers to use non-pharmacological pain management, multiple responsibilities of nurses, and an insufficient number of nurses per patient ratio. Therefore, theoretical and practical non-pharmacological pain management interventions should be incorporated in nursing curricula and advocating of the need and importance of non-pharmacological pain management methods. Moreover, regular dissemination of updated information to the nurses on these non-pharmacological pain management methods is recommended. And also they shall use non‐pharmacological pain management methods complementary to pharmacological treatment of pain as they are low cost and safe.
Supporting information
S1 File. Socio-demographic questions, non-pharmacological pain management checklist and barriers that hindered the use of non-pharmacological pain management methods questions.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0253086.s001
(DOCX)
References
- 1. Raja SN, Carr DB, Cohen M, Finnerup NB, Flor H, Gibson S, et al. The revised International Association for the Study of Pain definition of pain: concepts, challenges, and compromises. Pain. 2020;161(9):1976–82. pmid:32694387
- 2.
Lilley LL, Collins SR, Snyder JS. Pharmacology and the Nursing Process E-Book: Elsevier Health Sciences; 2019.
- 3.
Benimana O. Knowledge, attitudes, practices and challenges faced by nurses in pain management among surgical patients, in one Referral Hospital in Rwanda: University of Rwanda; 2017. https://doi.org/10.4155/fmc-2017-0001 pmid:28632424
- 4. Fosnocht DE, Heaps ND, Swanson ER. Patient expectations for pain relief in the ED. The American journal of emergency medicine. 2004;22(4):286–8. pmid:15258870
- 5. Alzghoul BI, Abdullah NAC. Pain management practices by nurses: an application of the knowledge, attitude and practices (KAP) model. Global journal of health science. 2016;8(6):154.
- 6. Lui LY, So WK, Fong DY. Knowledge and attitudes regarding pain management among nurses in Hong Kong medical units. Journal of clinical nursing. 2008;17(15):2014–21. pmid:18720572
- 7.
Hossain MS. Nurses’ knowledge and attitudes, and pain management practice of post-operative children in Bangladesh: Prince of Songkla University; 2010.
- 8. Kwekkeboom KL, Herr K. Assessment of pain in the critically ill. Critical care nursing clinics of North America. 2001;13(2):181–94. pmid:11866401
- 9.
Dukes IM. Increasing Patient Satisfaction Scores on the Pain Management Section of the Hospital Consumer Assessment of Healthcare, Providers, and Systems Survey: University of Hawaiʻi at Mānoa; 2018.
- 10. Fosnocht D, Swanson E, Stephen R. Patient Expectations for Pain Relief in the Emergency Department. Annals of Emergency Medicine. 2005;3(46):49.
- 11. Linton SJ, Shaw WS. Impact of Psychological Factors in the Experience of Pain. Physical Therapy. 2011;91(5):700–11. pmid:21451097
- 12. Callister LC. Cultural Influences on Pain Perceptions and Behaviors. Home Health Care Management & Practice. 2003;15(3):207–11.
- 13. Craig KD. The social communication model of pain. Canadian Psychology/Psychologie canadienne. 2009;50(1):22. pmid:19627668
- 14. El Geziry A, Toble Y, Al Kadhi F, Pervaiz M, Al Nobani M. Non-pharmacological pain management. Pain management in special circumstances. 2018:1–14.
- 15. Lakha SF, Pennefather P, Badr HE, Mailis-Gagnon A. Health services for management of chronic non-cancer pain in Kuwait: a case study review. Medical Principles and Practice. 2016;25(Suppl. 1):29–42. pmid:26595816
- 16. Rawlinson F, Gwyther L, Kiyange F, Luyirika E, Meiring M, Downing J. The current situation in education and training of health-care professionals across Africa to optimise the delivery of palliative care for cancer patients. Ecancermedicalscience. 2014;8.
- 17. Snell K, Leng M, Downing J, Barnard A, Murray S, Grant L. A Palliative Care Curriculum Toolkit.
- 18. Kumar S. Models of delivering palliative and end-of-life care in India. Current opinion in supportive and palliative care. 2013;7(2):216–22. pmid:23635881
- 19. Liyew B, Dejen Tilahun A, Habtie Bayu N, Kassew T. Knowledge and Attitude towards Pain Management among Nurses Working at University of Gondar Comprehensive Specialized Hospital, Northwest Ethiopia. Pain research & management. 2020;2020:6036575. pmid:32256910
- 20. Jira L, Weyessa N, Mulatu S, Alemayehu A. Knowledge and Attitude Towards Non-Pharmacological Pain Management and Associated Factors Among Nurses Working in Benishangul Gumuz Regional State Hospitals in Western Ethiopia, 2018. Journal of Pain Research. 2020;13:2917. pmid:33235490
- 21. Khalil NS. Critical care nurses’ use of non-pharmacological pain management methods in Egypt. Applied Nursing Research. 2018;44:33–8. pmid:30389057
- 22. Kia Z, Allahbakhshian M, Ilkhani M, Nasiri M, Allahbakhshian A. Nurses’ Use of Non-Pharmacological Pain Management Methods in Intensive Care Units: A Descriptive Cross-Sectional Study. Complementary Therapies in Medicine. 2021:102705. pmid:33677019
- 23. Ali NS. Critical Care Nurses’ Application of non pharmacological Pain Management Approaches at Cairo University Hospitals. Egyptian Journal of Nursing. 2015;10(1).
- 24. Bicek E. Nurses’ attitudes, knowledge, and use of nonpharmalogical pain management techniques and therapies. 2004.
- 25. Ali HS, Ibrahim Y, Mohamed E. Non-pharmacological pain management: nurses’ knowledge, attitudes and practices in selected hospitals at Makkah El-Mukarramah. Life Science Journal. 2013;2(10).
- 26. Manwere A, Chipfuwa T, Mukwamba MM, Chironda G. Knowledge and attitudes of registered nurses towards pain management of adult medical patients: a case of Bindura hospital. Health Science Journal. 2015;9(4):1.
- 27. Moceri JT, Drevdahl DJ. Nurses’ knowledge and attitudes toward pain in the emergency department. Journal of Emergency Nursing. 2014;40(1):6–12. pmid:22841012
- 28. Woldehaimanot TE, Saketa Y, Zeleke A, Gesesew H, Woldeyohanes T. Pain knowledge and attitude: a survey among nurses in 23 health institutions in Western Ethiopia. Gaziantep Med J. 2014;20(3):254–60.25.