Figures
Abstract
The effect of cropping system on the distribution of organic carbon (OC) and nitrogen (N) in soil aggregates has not been well addressed, which is important for understanding the sequestration of OC and N in agricultural soils. We analyzed the distribution of OC and N associated with soil aggregates in three unfertilized cropping systems in a 27-year field experiment: continuously cropped alfalfa, continuously cropped wheat and a legume-grain rotation. The objectives were to understand the effect of cropping system on the distribution of OC and N in aggregates and to examine the relationships between the changes in OC and N stocks in total soils and in aggregates. The cropping systems increased the stocks of OC and N in total soils (0–40 cm) at mean rates of 15.6 g OC m-2 yr-1 and 1.2 g N m-2 yr-1 relative to a fallow control. The continuous cropping of alfalfa produced the largest increases at the 0–20 cm depth. The OC and N stocks in total soils were significantly correlated with the changes in the >0.053 mm aggregates. 27-year of cropping increased OC stocks in the >0.053 mm size class of aggregates and N stocks in the >0.25 mm size class but decreased OC stocks in the <0.053 mm size class and N stocks in the <0.25 mm size class. The increases in OC and N stocks in these aggregates accounted for 99.5 and 98.7% of the total increases, respectively, in the continuous alfalfa system. The increases in the OC and N stocks associated with the >0.25 mm aggregate size class accounted for more than 97% of the total increases in the continuous wheat and the legume-grain rotation systems. These results suggested that long-term cropping has the potential to sequester OC and N in soils and that the increases in soil OC and N stocks were mainly due to increases associated with aggregates >0.053 mm.
Citation: Chu J, Zhang T, Chang W, Zhang D, Zulfiqar S, Fu A, et al. (2016) Impacts of Cropping Systems on Aggregates Associated Organic Carbon and Nitrogen in a Semiarid Highland Agroecosystem. PLoS ONE 11(10): e0165018. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0165018
Editor: Dafeng Hui, Tennessee State University, UNITED STATES
Received: June 17, 2016; Accepted: October 5, 2016; Published: October 20, 2016
Copyright: © 2016 Chu et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Data Availability: All relevant data are within the paper.
Funding: This study was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (31300204) to YH, and research fund from Northwest University (NH13025) to YH. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Introduction
Crop rotation effects on soil organic carbon (OC) and nutrients from agroecosystems and improve soil fertility, OC and nitrogen (N) contents and nutrient-use efficiencies [1–4]. Al-Kaisi et al. reported that increasing crop diversity by including perennial grasses could effectively improve C and N sequestration in Iowa soils [3]. Dwivedi et al. suggested that the inclusion of forage cowpea in a rice-wheat system could increase the use efficiencies of N and phosphorus on the Indo-Gangetic Plain of India. Acosta-Martinez et al. demonstrated that a peanut-based cropping system significantly improved the structure and functionality of the microbial community in a sandy soil [4]. Aziz et al. reported that multiple cropping system effect soil carbon and nitrogen status, and also improve soil functional properties [5–7]. Such information need to be well addressed to understand the mechanism behind the responses of soil OC and N to changes in cropping systems.
The distributions of soil aggregates and aggregate-associated OC and N are often used to indicate changes in soil structure and in OC and N stocks and to assess the stability of the OC and N in soils to changes in soil-management and cropping systems [8–11]. The effects of different tillage practices on the distribution of aggregates and aggregate-associated OC in agroecosystems have been extensively studied. For example, Paul et al demonstrated that conventional tillage reduced the stability of aggregates and aggregate-associated OC compared with reduced tillage [12]. Six et al. observed higher OC contents in aggregates in untilled soils than in conventionally tilled soils [13]. They suggested a faster turnover rate of macroaggregates and a lower stability of new OC in aggregates with conventional tillage compared with no tillage. Simpson et al. found a preferential accumulation of microbial C in aggregate structures of untilled soils compared with conventionally tilled soils [14]. Denef et al. reported significant C sequestration in microaggregates of untilled soils with drastically different clay minerals [15]. Little is known, however, about the effects of different cropping systems on soil OC and N associated with aggregates.
Most previous studies of the effect of cropping system on soil OC and N usually included fertilizer (organic or chemical) treatments, while very few studies have compared the effects of cropping systems that did not include fertilization. The application of fertilizers can significantly affect soil OC and N. For example, Jagadamma et al. found significantly higher OC and N contents with the application of N in continuously cropped corn and in corn-soybean rotation systems [16]. The effects of fertilization should thus be carefully treated and be separated from those of the cropping systems.
Fallow treatments (bare land without crops) have often been ignored, and the effect of cropping system on soil OC and N has mostly been assessed by only comparing different cropping systems [16–17]. The inclusion of a fallow treatment can provide basic information about the study site and can be used as a true control for analyzing the effects of cropping systems, because the stocks and distributions of OC and N are significantly different in fallow and cropped land. For example, Yousefi et al. found that the soil of a cropping system that included fallow land had relatively lower OC mean weights and aggregate diameters than a cropping system without fallow land [18]. The effects of fertilization should thus be assessed separately, and fallow treatments should be included to provide a more accurate understanding of how soil OC and N respond to cropping systems.
In this study, a 27-year experiment in a highland agricultural area compared the distributions of aggregate and aggregate-associated OC and N among three unfertilized cropping systems. The objectives were to understand the effect of cropping system on the distribution of OC and N in aggregates and to examine the relationships between the changes in OC and N in total soils and in aggregates.
Materials and Methods
Study site
The field experiment was initiated in September 1984 in Changwu County, Shaanxi Province, China (35°12′N, 107°40′E). The study site has a warm-temperate, subhumid, continental climate. During the period 1984 to 2011, the mean annual temperature was 9.1°C, the average frost-free period was 171 days and the mean annual precipitation was 584 mm. Rain falls mainly between June and September. Soil pH value is about 8.3, and the content of CaCO3 is 10.5%. The soil is a Calcarid Regosol according to the FAO/UNESCO classification system. The OC and N contents of the soils at the start of the experiment were 6.09 and 0.8 g kg-1, respectively. Soil loss due to erosion from water and wind is very low.
Experimental design and soil sampling
The experiment was conducted in plots of 10.3 × 6.5 m with three replicates. Routine agriculture management practices were used in this region. Fertilizers were applied before seeding on soil, and plowed twice about 20 cm. In this study, three cropping systems were studied: continuously cropped alfalfa (Medicago sativa), continuously cropped winter wheat (Triticum aestivum L.), pea (Pisum sativum L.)-winter wheat-winter wheat-millet (Panicum miliaceum L.) rotation system (legume-grain rotation system). A fallow treatment, in which no crops were planted but which received the same practice of tillage as the cropping treatments, was used as a control.
For the continuously cropped alfalfa system, the alfalfa was sown in rows 50 cm apart in 1984 and was cut and removed from the plot twice each year. The land in the alfalfa plots was tilled with a moldboard plough to a depth of ~20 cm in mid-April of each year to minimize the effects of tillage among the cropping systems. Winter wheat was sown in mid-September and harvested in late June, pea was sown in mid-March and harvested in early July and millet was sown in early July and harvested in early October. Prior to seeding, the land was ploughed with a moldboard plough to a depth ~20 cm. Wheat and pea were sown in rows 25 cm apart. Millet was broadcast-sown. The crops were harvested at ground-level and removed from the plots. No crop was planted in the fallow plot. The land in the fallow plot was tilled in June of each year. The weeds in each plot were removed by hand, also including the fallow plot.
Previous studies have indicated that the stocks and distributions of soil OC and N in the fallow treatment did not change significantly during the experimental period [19–20]. Kaber et al found that the management of tillage had limited influence on the fractions of organic matter in the surface layer of silty soils under rotations of cereals with root crops [21]. We therefore assume that tillage had the same effects on the three cropping systems and the fallow treatment, and any changes in the distributions of aggregates and aggregate-associated OC and N were due to the cropping systems.
The soils and density fractions were treated with HCl to remove the carbonates before analysis. We measured soil bulk density in September 2011 at the 0–20 and 20–40 cm depths of each plot using a stainless-steel cutting ring 5.0 cm in length and 5.0 cm in diameter. Five random soil samples were collected from both depths in each plot with a tube auger 5 cm in diameter. Visible pieces of organic material were removed. The moist samples were air-dried in the laboratory and prepared for the analyses of soil aggregates and OC and N contents.
Laboratory and statistical analyses
Four size classes of aggregates were separated by wet-sieving through 2, 0.25 and 0.053 mm sieves following the procedures described by Cambardella and Elliott [22]. The size-class samples were dried at 50–60°C, weighed and stored at room temperature. A subsample of air-dried, undisturbed soil from each plot was ground to pass through a 0.25-mm sieve for the measurement of OC and N in total soils. Soil OC and N in total soils and aggregates were analyzed using a C/N/H/S-analyzer (Vario ElementarIII, Germany).
Soil OC and N stocks (kg m-2) in bulk soils were calculated as:
(1)
where D is the thickness (cm) of the soil layer, ρb is the bulk density (g cm-3) and OC (or N) is the OC (or N) content (g kg-1) at the 0–20 or 20–40 cm soil depths. Stocks of OC (or N) (g m-2) in each size class of the 0–20 or 20–40 cm depths were calculated as:
(2)
where OC (or N)i is the OC (or N) content of the ith aggregate size class (g kg-1 aggregates).
A two-way analysis of variance was conducted to test the effects of cropping system and soil depth on the distribution of soil aggregates, mean weight diameter, mean geometric diameter, OC and N contents and stocks in total soils and aggregates and the C/N ratio in total soils and aggregates. Linear regression analysis was used to examine the relationships between OC stocks in total soils and aggregates and between changes in OC stocks in total soils and aggregates. The variance and regression analyses were conducted using JMP version 10 software.
Results
The effects on bulk density and aggregate distribution
Across all cropping systems, bulk density was 5% lower at the 0–20 cm depth than at the 20–40 cm depth (P = 0.0302). The continuous alfalfa system had the largest difference in bulk density between the two soil depths, and the fallow plot had the smallest difference. Compared with the fallow treatment, 27 years of cropping significantly decreased bulk density at the 0–20 cm depth (P = 0.0299) but did not affect bulk density at the 20–40 cm depth. The continuous alfalfa system had the largest decrease in bulk density (12%) (Fig 1).
FA: Fallow treatment, CA: Continuously cropped alfalfa system; CW: continuously cropped winter wheat system; LG: Legume-grain rotation system.
The <0.053 mm size class accounted for most of the total soil mass (40%) across both depths, and the >2 and 0.25–2 mm size classes accounted for the least (16 and 17%, respectively). We did not observe a significant difference in size classes between the two soil depths across the cropping systems (Fig 2). The effect of cropping system on the distribution of aggregates varied with size class and soil depth (Fig 2). At the 0–20 cm depth, the amount of each size class was not affected by the cropping system (P>0.05). At the 20–40 cm depth, the amount of the >2 mm size class significantly increased in the continuous wheat and legume-grain rotation systems (by 82 and 117%, respectively) but decreased in the continuous alfalfa system (30%) (P = 0.031). The amount of the 0.053–0.25 mm size class significantly increased in the continuous alfalfa system (19%) but decreased in the continuous wheat and legume-grain rotation systems (by 27 and 19%, respectively) (P = 0.0010). The amounts of the 0.25–2 and <0.053 mm size classes were not affected by the cropping systems (P>0.05).
FA: Fallow treatment, CA: Continuously cropped alfalfa system; CW: continuously cropped winter wheat system; LG: Legume-grain rotation system.
The effects on OC and N in total soils
The stocks of OC and N across all cropping systems were 30 and 27% higher, respectively, at the 0–20 cm depth than at the 20–40 cm depth (P = 0.0004). Within the cropping systems, the stocks of OC and N were significantly higher at the 0–20 cm depth than at the 20–40 cm depth in the fallow treatment (15 and 22%, respectively), continuous alfalfa system (59 and 58%, respectively) and legume-grain rotation system (21 and 27%, respectively) (Fig 3).
FA: Fallow treatment, CA: Continuously cropped alfalfa system; CW: continuously cropped winter wheat system; LG: Legume-grain rotation system.
Long-term cropping led to the recovery of OC and N in the soils (Fig 3). The cropping increased the stocks of OC and N in total soils at mean rates of 13.2 g OC m-2 yr-1 and 0.8 g N m-2 yr-1 at the 0–20 cm depth and of 2.4 g OC m-2 yr-1 and 0.4 g N m-2 yr-1 at the 20–40 cm depth. The continuous alfalfa system had the largest increases at the 0–20 cm depth. The stocks of OC and N in this system increased by 45 and 36%, respectively, (with recovery rates of 31.1 OC m-2 yr-1 and 2.4 g N m-2 yr-1) at the 0–20 cm depth and by 5 and 6%, respectively, (with recovery rates of 3.0 OC m-2 yr-1 and 0.03 g N m-2 yr-1) at the 20–40 cm depth. For the continuous wheat and legume-grain rotation systems, the stocks of OC increased by 6–7% at the 0–20 cm depth but decreased by 1% at the 20–40 cm depth. The stocks of N increased by 1–6 and 4–10% at the two depths, respectively. The C/N ratio or interaction was not affected by cropping system or soil depth (Fig 3).
The effects on OC and N associated with aggregates
The OC and N stocks in the aggregates varied significantly with soil depth, cropping system and their interactions (Table 1). Averaged across the cropping systems, the OC and N stocks associated with each size class were 12–67 and 13–63% higher, respectively, at the 0–20 cm depth than at the 20–40 cm depth (P<0.05). The stocks of OC and N in the <0.053 mm size class were 1.4–2.3 and 1.5–2.4 times higher, respectively, than the stocks in the other size classes (P<0.01) (Fig 4). Averaged across the 0–20 and 20–40 cm depths, 27 years of cropping increased the OC stocks in the >2, 0.25–2 and 0.053–0.25 mm size classes at mean rates of 3.37, 1.74 and 0.55 g m-2 yr-1, respectively, but decreased the OC stocks in the <0.053 mm size class at a mean rate of 0.66 g m-2 yr-1. The 27 years of cropping increased the N stocks in the <2 and 0.25–2 mm size classes at mean rates of 0.38 and 0.17 g m-2 yr-1, respectively, but decreased the N stocks in the 0.053–0.25 and <0.053 mm size classes at mean rates of 0.02 and 0.08 g m-2 yr-1, respectively.
FA: Fallow treatment, CA: Continuously cropped alfalfa system; CW: continuously cropped winter wheat system; LG: Legume-grain rotation system.
The changes in the stocks of OC and N associated with the aggregates varied with cropping system and soil depth. The legume-grain rotation system decreased the OC and N stocks in the <2 mm size class (2–9 and 8–12%, respectively) but increased the OC and N stocks in the >2 mm size class (71 and 61%, respectively) at the 0–20 cm depth. At the 20–40 cm depth, the legume-grain rotation system decreased the stocks of OC and N in the 0.053–0.25 and <0.053 mm size classes (15 and 16% for OC and 18 and 16% for N, respectively) but increased the OC and N stocks in the >2 and 0.25–2 mm size classes (118 and 6% for OC and 120 and 5% for N, respectively) (Fig 4).
The continuous alfalfa system led to larger increases in OC (34–105%) and N (26–97%) stocks in the >0.053 mm size class but to smaller increases in the <0.053 mm size class at the 0–20 cm depth. At the 20–40 cm depth, the OC and N stocks in the 0.053–0.25 mm size class increased by 14 and 15%, respectively, and the OC and N stocks in the other size classes decreased by 2–26 and 2–23%, respectively (Fig 4).
The continuous wheat system led to 9–35 and 4–28% increases in the OC and N stocks, respectively, in the >0.053 mm size class but to no changes in the <0.053 mm size class at the 0–20 cm depth. At the 20–40 cm depth, this system led to 10 and 12% decreases in the OC and N stocks in the 0.25–2 mm size class and to 19 and 25% decreases in the 0.053–0.25 mm size class, respectively, but to 93 and 87% increases in the >2 mm size class and to 10 and 8% increases in the <0.053 mm size class, respectively (Fig 4).
The effects on C/N ratios in the aggregates
The C/N ratios averaged across all cropping systems were relatively higher in the >0.053 mm size class than the <0.053 mm size class at both depths. For example, the average C/N ratios in the >2, 0.25–2 and 0.053–0.25 mm size classes were 3–7% higher at the 0–20 cm depth and 1–6% higher at the 20–40 cm depth than in the <0.053 mm size class (Fig 4).
The effect of long-term cropping on the C/N ratio in each size class varied with soil depth. At the 0–20 cm depth, 27 years of cropping increased the C/N ratio in the >0.053 mm size class but decreased it in the <0.053 mm size class. At the 20–40 cm depth, the continuous wheat and legume-grain rotation systems increased the C/N ratio in most aggregates, while the continuous alfalfa system decreased the C/N ratio in most aggregates (Fig 4).
The contribution of the changes in aggregate-associated OC and N to the recovery of OC and N in total soils
The changes in the OC and N stocks in total soils after 27 years of cropping were mainly due to the changes in the OC and N stocks associated with the aggregates >0.053 mm. The OC and N stored in total soils were significantly correlated with the OC and N stored in the >2, 0.25–2 and 0.053–0.25 mm size classes (Fig 5). The changes in the OC and N stocks in total soils were also significantly correlated with the changes in the OC and N stocks in the >2, 0.25–2 and 0.053–0.25 mm size classes (Fig 6). Additionally, the OC and N stocks in the continuous alfalfa system in the >2, 0.25–2 and 0.053–0.25 mm size classes throughout the 0–40 cm depth increased by 84, 289 and 184 g OC m-2 and by 9, 33 and 19 g N m-2, respectively, which accounted for 99.5 and 98.7% of the total increases in OC and N, respectively. Similarly, the increases in the OC and N associated with the >0.25 mm size class accounted for 97 and 100% of the total increases in OC and N in the continuous wheat system and for 100 and 100% of the total increases in the legume-grain rotation system, respectively.
The units for OC and N stocks in total soils and aggregates are kg m-2.
The units for the changes in OC and N stocks in both total soils and aggregates are kg m-2.
Discussion
Our results showed that the cropping system did not affect the distribution of soil aggregates at the 0–20 cm depth but significantly changed the distribution at the 20–40 cm depth. These results were expected because each system, including the fallow treatment, received the same tillage practice, which occurred at the 0–20 cm depth. The aggregate distribution changed significantly at the 20–40 cm depth mainly due to the activities of the plant roots in the deeper soils. Plant roots can significantly accelerate the aggregation of soil particles [23]. The effects on the aggregate distribution varied with cropping system. Alfalfa has tap roots, and the development of coarse roots in soils leads to increases of macroaggregates (>0.25 mm). Wheat and millet have fibrous roots, and the development of fine roots in soils leads to increases of microaggregates (0.053–0.25 mm). More roots were distributed at the 0–20 cm depth than at the 20–40 cm depth in the cropping systems, but the breakdown of aggregates induced by tillage is greater than the aggregation of particles induced by roots [12–15].
Intense tillage and the conversion of natural vegetation to cropland can lead to the loss of soil OC and N [3, 11–13, 24]. Changes in soil OC and N after long-term cropping, however, have not been well studied but would provide essential information for understanding the potentials of C sequestration in agricultural soils. Our results demonstrated the recovery of OC and N in semiarid highland agricultural soils. These results are consistent with other findings that OC and N accumulate in both untilled and tilled soil [17, 25, 26]. For example, Somnrero and de Benito observed significant increases in soil OC after ten years of conservative tillage and crop rotation in a semiarid area of Spain [26]. Norton et al reported that the wheat-fallow system and a conservative system of tillage increased soil OC content by 66 and 73% [17], respectively, compared with the traditional system, in a semiarid in southeastern Wyoming. The recovery of soil OC and N after the long-term planting of crops is mainly attributed to the accumulation of root biomass in the soils, because the aboveground biomass and crop litter are generally removed from the land. Roots play a primary role in the dynamics of soil OC and N in farmland, grassland and forest and after changes in land use [24, 27, 28]. The leaching of OC and N from crop canopies may be another source of soil OC and N in cropping systems [29].
In addition to the direct input of OC and N to soils, the roots in cropping systems provide a C source for microbial activity, which, together with the root biomass and exudates, induces the binding of residues and soil particles into aggregates [24, 30]. In our study, the amounts of macro- and/or microaggregates were significantly increased by the cropping systems compared with the fallow treatment (Fig 2), which enhanced the physical protection of the initial and newly input OC and N from mineralization and thus decreased the loss of soil OC and N [31].
Additionally, the crop cover may have helped to reduce the loss of soil OC and N in the cropping systems relative to the fallow treatment. The interception of raindrops by crop canopies leads to less destruction of soil structure and less loss of soil OC and N relative to fallow treatments [32]. Crop covers also decrease the variability of soil temperature and water in cropping systems compared with fallow treatments [33], which decreases the mineralization of soil OC and N and thus their loss from soils. Highly variable soil temperatures increase the mineralization of soil organic matter and the release of CO2 and N2O from soils [34]. In our study, soil OC and N contents in the fallow treatment decreased by 1 and 5%, respectively, after 27 years. Although not directly verified, the decreases of initial soil OC and N in cropping systems should be lower than those in fallow treatments. We therefore assume that the recovery of soil OC and N in the cropping systems was mainly due to the increased accumulation of newly input OC and N and to the decreased loss of the initial OC and N.
The continuous alfalfa system had the highest recovery rates of OC and N due to its large biomass. The biomass of this system averaged over the 27 years was 10 and 17% higher than those of the continuous wheat and legume-grain rotation systems, respectively (data not shown). Additionally, the improvement of soil structure in rotation systems with legumes, by increasing the amounts of aggregates, can provide more physical protection to the soil OC and N. For example, Hajabbasi and Fallahzade observed higher stabilities of aggregates and OC in a rotation system that included a legume (alfalfa and wheat) than in a rotation system without a legume (wheat-fallow-barley) in arid sandy soils in Iran [35].
In addition to high biomass and the improvement of soil structure, the fixation of N by alfalfa also contributes to higher OC and N recovery rates, because the accumulation of N enhances the sequestration of OC in soils [36, 37]. Similarly, the lower amounts of biomass in the continuous wheat system in our study led to lower recovery rates of OC and N in the soil. These results were consistent with the findings that legume plots had higher levels of soil OC than cereal plots and that higher plant biomasses often led to more soil OC sequestration [26, 38, 39]. Huggins et al, however, reported that continuous corn and corn-soybean systems had relatively higher recovery rates of soil OC (0.45–3.35 and 0.38–2.53 Mg C ha-1 yr-1, respectively) and that a continuous soybean system had a relatively lower recovery rate (0.02–1.29 Mg C ha-1 yr-1) throughout the 0–45 cm depth, because the biomass was larger for corn than for soybean [40].
Our results showed that the recovery of OC and N mainly occurred in the >0.053 mm size class and varied with cropping system. The recovery in the continuous alfalfa system mainly occurred in the >2, 0.25–2 and 0.053–0.25 mm size classes (557 g OC m-2 and 61 g N m-2), and the recovery in the continuous wheat and rotation systems mainly occurred in the >2 mm size class. The stabilities of the recovered OC and N in the aggregates, however, were determined by the size class. Tillage often breaks up aggregates and decreases their stability and thus decreases their ability to physically protect soil organic matter [11, 41]. Additionally, the C/N ratios averaged across all cropping systems throughout the 0–40 cm depth were relatively higher in the 0.25–2 and 0.053–0.25 mm size classes than in the >2 mm size class (Fig 4). Lower C/N ratios favor the decomposition of organic materials [11, 42] and thus decrease the stability of organic matter in macroaggregates. Organic matter associated with macroaggregates is also assumed to be more susceptible to loss due to mineralization compared with organic matter associated with microaggregates [11, 43]. For example, the turnover rate of organic matter can increase as aggregate size increases and mean residence time decreases [11, 43]. The sequestrated OC and N in our study were thus relatively more stable in the continuous alfalfa system than in the continuous wheat and legume-grain rotation systems.
We have shown that various cropping systems have the potential to recover soil OC and N due to the accumulation of above- and belowground biomass. We therefore assume that any practices that can increase the biomass, particularly belowground biomass, such as irrigation and fertilization, have the potential to enhance the recovery of soil OC and N in semiarid agroecosystems.
Conclusions
We demonstrated that long-term cropping led to the recovery of OC and N in soils of a semiarid highland agroecosystem at mean recovery rates of 15.6 g OC m-2 yr-1 and 1.2 g N m-2 yr-1 throughout the 0–40 cm depth. The continuous alfalfa system had the highest recovery. Recovery mainly occurred in the >0.053 mm aggregate size class, which varied with cropping system. The continuous alfalfa system led to the accumulation of OC and N in the 0.25–2 and 0.053–0.25 mm size classes, and the continuous wheat and rotation systems led to the accumulation of OC and N in the >2 mm size class. The accumulated OC and N were relatively more stable in the continuous alfalfa system than in the continuous wheat and rotation systems.
Acknowledgments
We thank the reviewers for their comments that improved the quality of this paper. This study was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (31300204) to YH, and research fund from Northwest University (NH13025) to YH.
Author Contributions
- Conceptualization: YH.
- Data curation: JC DZ SZ.
- Formal analysis: JC TZ.
- Funding acquisition: YH.
- Investigation: JC TZ WC DZ.
- Methodology: YH AF JC.
- Project administration: YH.
- Supervision: YH AF.
- Validation: JC DZ SZ.
- Writing – original draft: JC YH WC.
- Writing – review & editing: YH JC AF.
References
- 1. Kong YY, Fonte SJ, van Kessel C, Six J. Transitioning from standard to minimum tillage: Trade-offs between soil organic matter stabilization, nitrous oxide emissions, and N availability in irrigated cropping systems. Soil Tillage Res. 2009; 104: 256–262.
- 2. Dwivedi BS, Shukla AK, Singh VK, Yadav RL. Improving nitrogen and phosphorus use efficiencies through inclusion of forage cowpea in the rice-wheat systems in the Indo-Gangetic Plains of India. Field Crop Res. 2003; 80: 167–193.
- 3. Al-Kaisi MM, Yin XH, Licht MA. Soil carbon and nitrogen changes as influenced by tillage and cropping systems in some Iowa soils. Agric. Ecosyst. Environ. 2005; 105: 635–647.
- 4. Acosta-Martinez V, Rowland D, Sorensen RB, Yeater KM. Microbial community structure and functionality under peanut-based cropping systems in a sandy soil. Biol. Fertil. Soils. 2008; 44: 681–692.
- 5. Aziz I, Mahmood T, Islam KR, Ashraf E. Estimation of cropping system impacts on C and N status of soil. Int. J. Agric. Appl. Sci. 2013; 5:1–7.
- 6. Aziz I, Mahmood T, Islam KR. Impact of sole cropping and multiple cropping on soil humified carbon fractions. Pak. J. Bot. 2014; 46: 2157–2162.
- 7. Aziz I, Mahmood T, Islam KR. Impact of long-term tillage and crop rotation on concentration of soil particulate organic matter associated carbon and nitrogen. Pak. J. Agric. Sci. 2014; 51, 827–834.
- 8. Nie M, Pendall E, Bell C, Wallenstein MD. Soil aggregate size distribution mediates microbial climate change feedbacks. Soil Biol. Biochem. 2014; 68: 357–365.
- 9. Wang X, Cammeraat ELH, Cerli C, Kalbitz K. Soil aggregation and the stabilization of organic carbon as affected by erosion and deposition. Soil Biol. Biochem. 2014; 72: 55–65.
- 10. Grandy AS, Robertson GP. Aggregation and organic matter protection following tillage of a previously uncultivated soil. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J. 2006; 70: 1398–1406.
- 11. Wei XR, Shao MA, Gale W, Zhang XC, Li LH. Dynamics of aggregate-associated organic carbon following conversion of forest to cropland. Soil Biol. Biochem. 2013; 57: 876–883.
- 12. Paul BK, Vanlauwe B, Ayuke F, Gassner A, Hoogmoed M, Hurisso TT et al. Medium-term impact of tillage and residue management on soil aggregate stability, soil carbon and crop productivity. Agric. Ecosyst. Environ. 2013; 164: 14–22.
- 13. Six J, Elliott ET, Paustian K. Aggregate and soil organic dynamics under conventional and no-tillage systems. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J. 1999; 63: 1350–1358.
- 14. Simpsom RT, Frey SD, Six J, Thiet RK. Preferential accumulation of microbial carbon in aggregate structures of no-tillage soils. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J. 2004; 68: 1249–1255.
- 15. Denef K, Six J, Mercks R, Paustian K. Carbon sequestration in microaggregates of no-tillage soils with different clay mineralogy. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J. 2004; 68: 1935–1944.
- 16. Jagadamma S, Lal R, Hoeft RG, Nafziger ED, Adee EA. Nitrogen fertilization and cropping system impacts on soil properties and their relationship to crop yield in the central Corn Belt, USA. Soil Tillage Res. 2008; 98: 120–129.
- 17. Norton JB, Mukhwana EJ, Norton U. Loss and recovery of soil organic carbon and nitrogen in a semiarid agroecosystem. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J. 2012; 76: 505–514.
- 18. Yousefi M, Hajabbasi M, Shariatmadari H. Cropping system effects on carbohydrate content and water-stable aggregates in a calcareous soil of Central Iran. Soil Tillage Res. 2008; 101: 57–61.
- 19. Wei XR, Hao MD, Shao MA, Gale W. Changes in soil properties and the availability of soil micronutrients after 18 years of cropping and fertilization. Soil Tillage Res. 2006; 91: 120–130.
- 20. Fan J, Hao MD, Malhi SS, Wang QJ, Huang MB. Influence of 24 annual applications of fertilisers and/or manure to alfalfa on forage yield and some soil properties under dryland conditions in northern China. Crop Pasture Sci. 2011; 62: 437–443.
- 21. Kader MA, Sleutel S, D’Haene K, Neve DS. Limited influence of tillage management on organic matter fractions in the surface layer of silt soils under cereal-root crop rotations. Aust. J. Soil Res. 2010; 48:16–26.
- 22. Cambardella CA, Elliott ET. Carbon and nitrogen distributions in aggregates from cultivated and grassland soils. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J. 1993; 57: 1071–1076.
- 23. Six J, Bossuy H, Degryze S, Denef K. A history of research on the link between (micro)aggregates, soil biota, and soil organic matter dynamics. Soil Tillage Res. 2004; 79: 7–31.
- 24. Qiu LP, Wei XP, Zhang XC, Cheng JM, Gale W, Guo C et al. Soil organic carbon losses due to land use change in a semiarid grassland. Plant Soil. 2012; 355: 299–309.
- 25. Gál A, Vyn TJ, Michéli E, Kladivko EJ, McFee WW. Soil carbon and nitrogen accumulation with long-term no-till versus moldboard plowing overestimated with tilled-zone sampling depth. Soil Tillage Res. 2007; 96: 42–51.
- 26. Somnrero A, de Benito A. Carbon accumulation in soil. Ten-year study of conservation tillage and crop rotation in a semi-arid area of Castile-Leon, Spain. Soil Tillage Res. 2010; 107: 64–70.
- 27. Guo LB, Gifford RM. Soil carbon stocks and land use change: a meta analysis. Glob. Chang. Biol 2002; 8: 345–360.
- 28. Qiu LP, Wei XR, Zhang XC, Cheng JM. Ecosystem carbon and nitrogen accumulation after grazing exclusion in semiarid grassland. PLoS ONE. 2013; 8(1): e55433. pmid:23383191
- 29. Potter CS. Nutrient leaching from Acer rubrum leaves by experimental acid rainfall. Can. J. For. Res. 1991; 21: 222–229.
- 30. Slobodian N, Van Rees K, Pennock D. Cultivation-induced effects on belowground biomass and organic carbon. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J. 2002; 66: 924–930.
- 31. Kristiansen SM, SchjØnning P, Thomsen IK, Olesen JE, Kristensen K, Christensen BT. Similarity of differently sized macroaggregates in arable soils of different texture. Geoderma. 2006; 137: 147–154.
- 32. Bissonnais YL, Arrouays D. Aggregate stability and assessment of soil crustability and erodibility: II. Application to humic loamy soils with various organic carbon contents. Eur. J. Soil Sci. 1996; 47: 425–437.
- 33. Flerchinger GN, Pierson FB. Modelling plant canopy effects on variability of soil temperature and water: model calibration and validation. J. Arid Environ. 1997; 35: 641–653.
- 34. Matzner E, Borken W. Do freeze/thaw events enhance C and N losses from soils of different ecosystems? A review. Eur. J. Soil Sci. 2008; 5: 274–284.
- 35.
Hajabbasi MA, Fallahzade J. Aggregation, carbohydrate, total and particulate organic carbon changes by cultivation of an arid soil in Central Iran. 19th World Congress of Soil Science, Brisbane, Australia, August 2010.
- 36. Liu JX, Price DT, Chen JM. Nitrogen controls on ecosystem carbon sequestration: a model implementation and application to Saskatchewan, Canada. Ecol. Model. 2005; 186: 178–195.
- 37. Thomas RQ, Canham CD, Weathers KC, Goodale CL. Increased tree carbon storage in response to nitrogen deposition in the US. Nat. Geosci. 2010; 3: 13–17.
- 38. Wright AL, Hons FM. Tillage impacts on soil aggregation and carbon and nitrogen sequestration under wheat cropping sequences. Soil Tillage Res. 2005; 84: 67–75.
- 39. Masri Z, Ryan J. Soil organic matter and related physical properties in a Mediterranean wheat-based rotation trial. Soil Tillage Res. 2006; 87: 146–154.
- 40. Huggins DR, Allmaras RR, Clapp CE, Lamb JA, Randall GW. Corn-Soybean Sequence and Tillage Effects on soil carbon dynamics and storage. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J. 2007; 71:145–154.
- 41. Barreto RC, Madari BE, Maddock JEL, Machado PLOA, Torres E, Franchini J et al. The impact of soil management on aggregation, carbon stabilization and carbon loss as CO2 in the surface layer of a Rhodic Ferralsol in Southern Brazil. Agric Ecosyst Environ. 2009; 132: 243–251.
- 42.
Heal OW, Anderson JM, Swift MJ. Plant litter quality and decomposition: an historical overview. CAB International, Oxon, 1997.
- 43.
Six J, Jastrow JD. Soil organic matter turnover, in: Lal R. (Ed), Encyclopedia of Soil Science. USA Marcel Dekker, New York; 2002. pp. 936–942.