Fig 1.
Neighbor-joining tree of ITS-2 rDNA sequences obtained from 8 different parasitic nematode species from cattle.
ITS-2 rDNA amplicons were directly sequenced by Sanger sequencing from 15 individual L3 larvae obtained from experimentally passaged strains for each of eight cattle parasite species. The neighbor-joining tree (Jukes-Cantor model) was computed with 2000 bootstrap replicates and rooted on C. elegans ITS-2 (Accession: JN636100) using Geneious version 7.1.5 created by Biomatters. Available from http://geneious.com/. Bootstrap values >70 are shown, values >80 are considered to be significant.
Fig 2.
Assessment of sequence representation bias and the determination of correction factors for the amplicon sequencing assay.
A DNA lysate was prepared from a pool of 140 L3 larvae comprising 20 individual L3 larvae from each of the following species; N. helvetianus, C. oncophora, T. axei, T. colubriformis, C. punctata, O. ostertagi and H. placei. The sequencing assay was applied to this lysate eight times; three, two and three times at 25, 30 and 35 cycles of amplification respectively (as denoted on the x-axis of panels A and B). 2A. The chart shows the species proportions as determined by the actual number of ITS-2 rDNA sequences generated by the amplicon sequencing assay. The p-values above each column indicate whether the species proportions, as determined by the uncorrected numbers of ITS-2 rDNA sequences generated, are statistically different from the actual proportions of larvae in the pool (non-parametric Chi-square test with significant differences between expected and observed results (p≤0.001) for all replicates). 2B. The chart shows the same data as in panel 2A but following the application of a correction factor for each species. The correction factor was calculated for each species by dividing the true proportion of that species in the pool (based on counted larvae) by the mean proportion of Illumina sequences generated from the eight replicates (correction factor = %Actual / %Observed). The correction factors were: N. helvetianus = 0.68871028, C. onchophora = 1.183576925, T. axei = 1.296071418, T. colubriformis = 0.584257283, C. punctata = 2.779407405, O. ostertagi = 1.294841767 and H. placei = 0.919208106. Their application removed the significant variation (p>0.05). The p-values above each column indicate whether the species proportions, as determined by the corrected numbers of ITS-2 rDNA sequences generated, are statistically different from the actual proportions of larvae in the pool (non-parametric Chi-square test). 2C. Replicates were grouped and averaged based on cycles of amplification. A one way ANOVA was performed to detect if number of cycles of amplification affected the proportional representation of each species with non-significant results (N. helvetianus, F = 1.200, p = 0.375; C. oncophora, F = 3.035, p = 0.137; T. axei, F = 0.098, p = 0.908; T. colubriformis, F = 0.752, p = 0.518; C. punctata, F = 2.683, p = 0.162; O. ostertagi, F = 2.501, p = 0.177; H. placei, F = 1.672, p = 0.278)
Fig 3.
The determination of species proportions of a series of pairwise parasite species combinations using the amplicon sequencing assay.
DNA lysates were prepared from mock pools of 2000 L3 larvae comprising varying proportions of two different nematode species and the amplicon sequencing assay applied. Panel 3A, O. ostertagi and H. placei; Panel 3B, C. oncophora and O. ostertagi; Panel 3C, O. ostertagi and C. punctata; Panel 3D, C. oncophora and C. punctata. The left hand chart of each pair shows the expected results based on the known numbers of larvae added to each pool and the right hand chart of each pair shows the results of the amplicon sequencing assay (after the application of the appropriate correction factors). The ratios by which the two species of each pair vary from left to right on each chart are as follows: Column 1, 99:1; Column 2 90:10; Column 3; 70:30, Column 4, 50:50; Column 5; 30:70, Column 6; 10:90 and Column 7; 1:99.
Fig 4.
Detection threshold of the amplicon sequencing assay.
Separate mock pools of ~2000 larvae were created consisting of equal proportions of 6 parasite species. The seventh species was then added in increasing numbers of 0, 1, 5 and 20 larvae respectively. The charts show the species proportions estimated from the results of the amplicon sequencing assay (following application of the appropriate correction factor). In each case, the Y-axis shows the percentage proportions of each species and the X-axis indicates the number of H. placei or O. ostertagi larvae added as well as the numbers of reads assigned to H. placei and O. ostertagi for Fig 4A and 4B respectively. Fig 4A. Results when H. placei was added in increasing numbers to a pool comprising an equal number of N. helvetianus, C. oncophora, T. axei, T. colubriformis, C. punctata and O. ostertagi. Fig 4B. Results when O. ostertagi was added in increasing numbers to a pool comprising an equal number of shows N. helvetianus, C. oncophora, T. axei, C. punctata, T. colubriformis and H. placei.
Fig 5.
Repeatability of the amplicon sequencing assay when applied to field samples.
The amplicon sequencing assay was applied to DNA lysates made from populations of L3 larvae collected from field samples from six Canadian cattle farms (Field samples 1–6). Fig 5A: The results of three technical replicates of the amplicon sequencing assay applied to the same single DNA lysate made from larval populations of each farm. Each DNA lysate was made from 300–2000 larvae (Field sample 1 = 1000 L3; Field sample 2 = 400 L3; Field sample 3 = 1000 L3; Field sample 4 = 2000 L3; Field sample 5 = 300 L3 and Field sample 6 = 2000 L3. Fig 5B: The results of three technical replicates of the amplicon sequencing assay applied to three independent DNA lysates made from separate batches of 1,000 and 2,000 larvae from field samples 1 and 4 respectively. The Y-axis of both charts shows the percentage species proportions as determined by the amplicon sequencing assay (25 cycles of amplification and following application of the appropriate correction factor). The field sample number is indicated on the X-axis.
Fig 6.
Comparison of the amplicon sequencing assay with visual morphological identification of larval populations from field samples.
Fecal samples were collected from 39 individual calves entering feedlots from pasture at different locations in Oklahoma, Arkansas and Nebraska. 100 L3 larvae harvested from each coproculture were fixed and identified to the species level on the basis of morphological features on microscopy. The amplicon sequencing assay was applied to several hundred to several thousand L3 larvae from each sample. Fig 6A. Two bars are shown for each sample on the chart. The left bar of each sample shows the species proportions as determined by larval morphology. The right bar of each sample shows the proportions of each species as estimated by the amplicon sequencing assay (values shown are after application of the appropriate correction factor). The Y-axis shows the percentage proportions of each species as determined by morphology or the sequencing assay respectively. Fig 6B. Linear regression analysis was performed to assess the correlation between the percentage composition of each parasite species in each of 39 field samples as determined by the amplicon sequencing assay and morphological identification. The linear regression plots were produced using SPSS Statistics (IBM Corp. Released 2012. IBM SPSS Statistics for Macintosh, Version 21.0. Armonk, NY: IBM Corp), by plotting the percentage representation of each species from the morphological data (Y-axis) against the percentage representation of each species from the amplicon sequencing data (X-axis) for each sample. The values for R2 (coefficient of determination), b (y-intercept) and m (slope) are shown adjacent to each plot. If values are the same the y-intercept (b) will be zero and the slope (m) will be 1.