Table 1.
Minimum (min), maximum (max), mean, standard deviation (sd), and median of ratings by Ra and Re on the scientific significance, scientific quality, and presentation quality of a manuscript and final publication recommendations.
Table 2.
Differences between the ratings by Ra and Re on three evaluation criteria and on the reviewers' final publication recommendations for those manuscripts that were each reviewed by both an Ra and an Re (n = 135).
Table 3.
Final publication recommendation by Ra and Re for those manuscripts, for which an Ra and an Re gave identical ratings on three evaluation criteria (n = 24).
Table 4.
Description of the dependent and independent variables included in the ORM.
Table 5.
Results of the ORM predicting reviewers' ratings for three evaluation criteria and the final publication recommendation.