Variant calling in genomics: A comparative performance analysis and decision guide
Fig 5
Change in precision from chromosome 20 to whole-genome sequencing.
Comparison of precision metrics for four variant callers (GATK, Octopus, FreeBayes, SAMtools) between the chromosome 20 subset and the whole-genome (WGS) dataset. All tools showed increase in precision on WGS data. GATK exhibited the largest improvement (from 0.662 to 0.777, ), followed closely by FreeBayes (
). Octopus, which had the highest precision on chr20 (0.741), maintained the highest absolute precision on WGS (0.801) with a gain of +0.060. The precision shift suggests that a whole-genome context provides enhanced statistical power for filtering false positives. Metrics were computed with RTG Tools’ vcfeval against the Genome in a Bottle (GIAB) truth set.