Reader Comments
Post a new comment on this article
Post Your Discussion Comment
Please follow our guidelines for comments and review our competing interests policy. Comments that do not conform to our guidelines will be promptly removed and the user account disabled. The following must be avoided:
- Remarks that could be interpreted as allegations of misconduct
- Unsupported assertions or statements
- Inflammatory or insulting language
Thank You!
Thank you for taking the time to flag this posting; we review flagged postings on a regular basis.
closeHuman low stomach pH: littoral omnivory rather than carrion-feeding?
Posted by marc_verhaegen on 01 Aug 2015 at 15:54 GMT
Very interesting paper: this is an original approach to comparative physiology, although the data on stomach pH, as you say, are still scarce, e.g. on apes. The interpretation of low pH in human ancestors for carrion feeding e.g. on the African savannas, however, is extremely unlikely, not only because "Not only vultures, but also canid, felid and hyaenid carnivores were much better preadapted for such a niche. They possessed sharp beaks or long canine teeth and did not need to carry stones for cutting carcasses" (Verhaegen 1985), but also because recent paleo-anthropological publications (see below) show that Pleistocene Homo did not run over open plains as often popularly assumed without scientific evidence (google e.g. econiche Homo), but instead dispersed intercontinentally along African & Eurasian coasts & rivers (coastal dispersal, Munro 2010), beach-combing, diving & wading bipedally for littoral, shallow aquatic & waterside foods, especially shellfish, which are uniquely rich in brain-specific nutrients (Cunnane 2005). Although Pleistocene Homo is known to feed on carrion occasionally such as stranded whale carcasses (Gutierrez cs 2001), the waterside omnivorous diet & shellfish in particular can well explain human low stomach pH (e.g. pied oystercatchers pH 1.3, your Table 1).
-J.Joordens, S.Munro cs 2014 Homo erectus at Trinil on Java used shells for tool production and engraving, Nature doi 10.1038/nature13962
-M.Verhaegen, S.Munro 2011 Pachyosteosclerosis suggests archaic Homo frequently collected sessile littoral foods, HOMO 62:237-247
-M.Verhaegen, S.Munro, P-F.Puech 2002 Aquarboreal ancestors? TREE 17:212-7
-S.Munro 2010 Molluscs as ecological indicators in palaeoanthropological contexts, PhD thesis Univ.Canberra
-J.Joordens cs 2009 Relevance of aquatic environments for hominins: a case study from Trinil (Java, Indonesia), J.hum.Evol. 57:656-671
-M.Gutierrez cs 2001 Exploitation d’un grand cétacé au Paléolithique ancien: le site de Dungo V à Baia Farta (Benguela, Angola), CRAS 332:357-362
-K.Choi, D.Driwantoro 2007 Shell tool use by early members of Homo erectus in Sangiran, central Java, Indonesia: cut mark evidence, J.archaeol.Sci.34:48-58
-M.Verhaegen 1985 Origin of hominid bipedalism, Nature 325:305-6
-S.Cunnane 2005 Survival of the fattest: the key to human brain evolution, World Scient.Publ.Comp.
-M.Vaneechoutte cs eds 2011 Was Man more aquatic in the past? eBook Bentham Sci.Publ.
-P.Rhys Evans cs eds 2013-2014 Human Evolution conference London May 2013 proceedings, special editions Hum.Evol.28 & 29, e.g. M.Verhaegen 2013 The aquatic ape evolves: common misconceptions and unproven assumptions about the so-called Aquatic Ape Hypothesis, Hum.Evol.28:237-266, google researchGate marc verhaegen.