Peer Review History
| Original SubmissionFebruary 27, 2026 |
|---|
|
PCSY-D-26-00027 Kicking politics: towards a framework for detecting political influence in online communities PLOS Complex Systems Dear Dr. Pacheco, Thank you for submitting your manuscript to PLOS Complex Systems. After careful consideration, we feel that it has merit but does not fully meet PLOS Complex Systems's publication criteria as it currently stands. Therefore, we invite you to submit a revised version of the manuscript that addresses the points raised during the review process. Please submit your revised manuscript by Jun 21 2026 11:59PM. If you will need more time than this to complete your revisions, please reply to this message or contact the journal office at complexsystems@plos.org. When you're ready to submit your revision, log on to https://www.editorialmanager.com/pcsy/ and select the 'Submissions Needing Revision' folder to locate your manuscript file. Please include the following items when submitting your revised manuscript: * A letter that responds to each point raised by the editor and reviewer(s). You should upload this letter as a separate file labeled 'Response to Reviewers'. This file does not need to include responses to any formatting updates and technical items listed in the 'Journal Requirements' section below. * A marked-up copy of your manuscript that highlights changes made to the original version. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Revised Manuscript with Track Changes'. * An unmarked version of your revised paper without tracked changes. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Manuscript'. If you would like to make changes to your financial disclosure, competing interests statement, or data availability statement, please make these updates within the submission form at the time of resubmission. Guidelines for resubmitting your figure files are available below the reviewer comments at the end of this letter. We look forward to receiving your revised manuscript. Kind regards, Giulio Rossetti Academic Editor PLOS Complex Systems Hocine Cherifi Editor-in-Chief PLOS Complex Systems Journal Requirements: 1. In the online submission form, you indicated that your data will be submitted to a repository upon acceptance. We strongly recommend all authors deposit their data before acceptance, as the process can be lengthy and hold up publication timelines. Please note that, though access restrictions are acceptable now, your entire minimal dataset will need to be made freely accessible if your manuscript is accepted for publication. This policy applies to all data except where public deposition would breach compliance with the protocol approved by your research ethics board. If you are unable to adhere to our open data policy, please kindly revise your statement to explain your reasoning and we will seek the editor's input on an exemption. 2. Some material included in your submission may be copyrighted. According to PLOS’s copyright policy, authors who use figures or other material (e.g., graphics, clipart, maps) from another author or copyright holder must demonstrate or obtain permission to publish this material under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0) License used by PLOS journals. Please closely review the details of PLOS’s copyright requirements here: PLOS Licenses and Copyright. If you need to request permissions from a copyright holder, you may use PLOS's Copyright Content Permission form. Please respond directly to this email or email the journal office and provide any known details concerning your material's license terms and permissions required for reuse, even if you have not yet obtained copyright permissions or are unsure of your material's copyright compatibility. Potential Copyright Issues: a. Figure 1: Please confirm whether you drew the images / clip-art within the figure panels by hand. If you did not draw the images, please provide (a) a link to the source of the images or icons and their license / terms of use; or (b) written permission from the copyright holder to publish the images or icons under our CC-BY 4.0 license. Alternatively, you may replace the images with open source alternatives. See these open source resources you may use to replace images / clip-art: - https://commons.wikimedia.org 3. We ask that a manuscript source file is provided at Revision. Please upload your manuscript file as a .doc, .docx, .rtf or .tex. 4. Please upload separate figure files in .tif or .eps format. Also, remove the figures from your manuscript file but keep the legends. For more information about figure files please see our guidelines: https://journals.plos.org/complexsystems/s/figures https://journals.plos.org/complexsystems/s/figures#loc-file-requirements 5. We notice that your supplementary figures and tables are included in the manuscript file. Please remove them and upload them with the file type 'Supporting Information'. Please ensure that each Supporting Information file has a legend listed in the manuscript after the references list. If the reviewer comments include a recommendation to cite specific previously published works, please review and evaluate these publications to determine whether they are relevant and should be cited. There is no requirement to cite these works unless the editor has indicated otherwise. Additional Editor Comments (if provided): After a round of revisions, the manuscript is considered to address an interesting and relevant topic. However, several substantive limitations remain. In its current form, the paper does not yet provide sufficient support for the robustness of the proposed methodology nor for the generalizability of the reported results. The authors are therefore encouraged to carefully consider and address the reviewers’ comments provided below. In particular, clarifying methodological assumptions and mathematical formalization, and strengthening empirical validation and generalizability would significantly improve the overall quality and impact of the work. [Note: HTML markup is below. Please do not edit.] Reviewers' Comments: Reviewer's Responses to Questions Comments to the Author 1. Does this manuscript meet PLOS Complex Systems’s publication criteria?> Reviewer #1: Yes Reviewer #2: Partly Reviewer #3: Yes ********** 2. Has the statistical analysis been performed appropriately and rigorously?-->?> Reviewer #1: Yes Reviewer #2: Yes Reviewer #3: Yes ********** 3. Have the authors made all data underlying the findings in their manuscript fully available (please refer to the Data Availability Statement at the start of the manuscript PDF file)??> The PLOS Data policy Reviewer #1: Yes Reviewer #2: Yes Reviewer #3: Yes ********** 4. Is the manuscript presented in an intelligible fashion and written in standard English??> Reviewer #1: Yes Reviewer #2: Yes Reviewer #3: Yes ********** Reviewer #1: The manuscript investigates the embedding of political discourse within online cultural communities, using UK football fandom on Twitter as a case study. The authors construct a hybrid methodological framework that applies established complex network analysis techniques to a large dataset of over 152 million tweets, isolating a subset of political interactions for detailed examination. The underlying data extraction, structural mapping, and network construction demonstrate technical competence. The transition from topological structure to sociological categorization represents a methodological shift that warrants careful examination, as the paper relies heavily on qualitative interpretation of network phenomena. The computational foundation of the study is robust for its intended descriptive purpose. The authors appropriately generate a null distribution to filter noisy edges in their user-hashtag bipartite matrix projections, retaining only statistically significant connections to identify discourse affiliations. The application of standard centrality measures alongside the Louvain community detection algorithm is properly executed to map conversational sub-groups and influential nodes. The temporal analysis of time lags to identify automated amplification reveals a solid technical understanding of anomalous information diffusion and the behavior of cyborg accounts. The primary analytical limitation emerges in the lack of a formalized mathematical model defining the proposed influence mechanisms. The network signatures are observed retrospectively and interpreted qualitatively within five selected case studies. Consequently, the proposed framework remains a descriptive mapping rather than a generalizable, predictive classifier of system dynamics. The authors observe hub-and-spoke and tightly reciprocal structures but do not provide quantitative thresholds or mathematical definitions that would allow these patterns to be automatically detected or verified in other cultural datasets. The manuscript provides a valuable observational study bridging network science and computational social science. The underlying statistical mechanics of the data filtering and network projections are valid. To elevate the analytical rigor, the authors should address the purely descriptive nature of their final categorizations and discuss the mathematical steps required to formalize the identified network signatures into an automated classification system. Subject to these considerations, the paper represents a meaningful contribution to the understanding of information flow in complex social systems and is suitable for publication with minor revision. Reviewer #2: PCSY-D-26-00027 Kicking politics: towards a framework for detecting political influence in online communities This paper uses historical data from X to examine the diffusion of political content in European football clubs. In particular the authors develop a “conceptual framework” (their term) for identifying diffusion using the substantive context and social network methods. They show that even in this community, which is not explicitly political, that political content emerges and spreads. Is it fair to call it influence? Influence usually refers to a change in belief or behavior – what is being changed in this context? It doesn’t seem that anything is sufficiently measured to be called influence. Is a conceptual framework something that is falsifiable? Do you have an argument to support it or it a series of measures? I am not sure if this is a descriptive exercise or something that is meant to be generalizable. Using vague terms like conceptual framework does not help. How is network position itself a mechanism? What they do to spread influence matters, their reach varies by position. Isn't position a moderator of behavior rather than a distinct mechanism? Can you identify what share of users were exposed to the content you analyzed? What are the implications of this when its only .1% of tweets? In Data Availability, you refer to the study as an experiment. It is not. Nothing is varied by the researcher. It is an observational study. Reviewer #3: The manuscript examines how political narratives infiltrate ostensibly non-political cultural communities on Twitter. Using a large corpus of UK football-related tweets collected via the Twitter streaming API, the authors extract a subset of 94,846 tweets containing political markers through an iterative keyword and hashtag filtering pipeline. Then, they map political influence structures by combining interaction networks (retweets, replies, quotes, and mentions) with similarity networks derived from a bipartite user–hashtag matrix. Centrality and community detection methods identify conversational subgroups and prominent actors. The authors formalize a conceptual framework of political influence mechanisms (hashtag hijacking, coordinated inauthentic amplification, hybrid activism, political megaphone, media provocation, structural vector, inadvertent amplification, and casual conversation) and operationalize it through network signatures and content patterns. Five case studies illustrate how political messages entered fan spaces via appropriation of football hashtags, inauthentic cliques, activist mobilization, elite political broadcasting, and media provocation. The article concludes that even low volumes of political content achieved disproportionate visibility when aligned with structurally central nodes or cohesive communities, and argues that the proposed hybrid network-content framework is transferable to other cultural contexts. The paper addresses a timely and under-examined phenomenon: political mobilization within cultural online communities. While previous work has studied political manipulation during elections or in explicitly political spheres, the authors show that political narratives permeate sports fan conversations and propose a taxonomy of influence mechanisms beyond simple bot detection or influencer ranking. The use of multiple network views (interaction versus similarity) and iterative content filtering is methodologically interesting, and the dataset is unusually large for a targeted domain. The case study narratives (e.g., pro-Trump hijacking of #MUFC and a Labour activist cluster around a Corbyn banner) demonstrate how seemingly trivial events can be leveraged for political mobilization. To further clarify the methodology and strengthen the manuscript, I encourage the authors to address the following questions: 1) Political tweets are extracted through an iterative keyword and hashtag filtering process that combines curated lists with a manually labeled hashtag co-occurrence network. While the iterative process is described clearly, precision and recall trade-offs are not quantified. The authors note that political tweets constitute less than 0.1% of the corpus. However, manual curation and the addition of co-occurring hashtags may introduce bias. A systematic evaluation (e.g., annotating a random sample of false negatives and false positives) would strengthen confidence in the extraction method. 2) The political marker lists were expanded using a manually labeled hashtag co-occurrence network. How did you mitigate potential bias introduced by manual annotation? Were multiple annotators involved? How would the results change if different thresholds or labels were used? 3) The conceptual framework distinguishes several influence mechanisms, but the empirical identification appears largely qualitative. For example, coordinated inauthentic amplification is inferred from a clique of three accounts and posting synchronicity. Do you plan to formalize detection criteria (e.g., using established bot-detection tools or entropy measures) and quantify the prevalence of each mechanism across the corpus? 4) Structural vectors and casual conversations are mentioned in the framework but, if I am correct, are not illustrated through case studies. Could you provide examples or analysis for these mechanisms, or explain why they were omitted from the results? 5) The five case studies are vivid, but it is unclear how representative they are. What proportion of hashtag-hijacking attempts result in significant amplification? How many coordinated cliques did you find in total? Do hybrid activist clusters emerge around other political events? A more systematic analysis would help assess generality. Addressing these questions will clarify methodological details and strengthen confidence in the robustness and generalizability of the findings. In summary, this paper tackles an important problem at the intersection of online behavior modeling and political communication. The combination of network analysis and content filtering, the conceptual framework of influence mechanisms, and the rich case studies make it a significant contribution. However, several methodological aspects are exploratory and rely on manual curation. For acceptance, the authors should strengthen the quantitative evaluation of their extraction and network construction methods, justify their parameter choices, and formalize the detection of influence mechanisms. ********** what does this mean?). If published, this will include your full peer review and any attached files. Do you want your identity to be public for this peer review? If you choose “no”, your identity will remain anonymous but your review may still be made public. For information about this choice, including consent withdrawal, please see our Privacy Policy Reviewer #1: No Reviewer #2: Yes: David Melamed Reviewer #3: No ********** [NOTE: If reviewer comments were submitted as an attachment file, they will be attached to this email and accessible via the submission site. Please log into your account, locate the manuscript record, and check for the action link "View Attachments". If this link does not appear, there are no attachment files.] Figure resubmission: After uploading your figures to PLOS’s NAAS tool - https://ngplosjournals.pagemajik.ai/artanalysis, NAAS will process the files provided and display the results in the "Uploaded Files" section of the page as the processing is complete. If the uploaded figures meet our requirements (or NAAS is able to fix the files to meet our requirements), the figure will be marked as "fixed" above. If NAAS is unable to fix the files, a red "failed" label will appear above. When NAAS has confirmed that the figure files meet our requirements, please download the file via the download option, and include these NAAS processed figure files when submitting your revised manuscript. Reproducibility: To enhance the reproducibility of your results, we recommend that authors of applicable studies deposit laboratory protocols in protocols.io, where a protocol can be assigned its own identifier (DOI) such that it can be cited independently in the future. Additionally, PLOS ONE offers an option to publish peer-reviewed clinical study protocols. Read more information on sharing protocols at https://plos.org/protocols?utm_medium=editorial-email&utm_source=authorletters&utm_campaign=protocols |
| Revision 1 |
|
PCSY-D-26-00027R1 Kicking politics: towards a framework for detecting political influence in online communities PLOS Complex Systems Dear Dr. Pacheco, Thank you for submitting your manuscript to PLOS Complex Systems. After careful consideration, we feel that it has merit but does not fully meet PLOS Complex Systems's publication criteria as it currently stands. Therefore, we invite you to submit a revised version of the manuscript that addresses the points raised during the review process. Please submit your revised manuscript by Oct 10 2026 11:59PM. If you will need more time than this to complete your revisions, please reply to this message or contact the journal office at complexsystems@plos.org. When you're ready to submit your revision, log on to https://www.editorialmanager.com/pcsy/ and select the 'Submissions Needing Revision' folder to locate your manuscript file. Please include the following items when submitting your revised manuscript: * A letter that responds to each point raised by the editor and reviewer(s). You should upload this letter as a separate file labeled 'Response to Reviewers'. This file does not need to include responses to any formatting updates and technical items listed in the 'Journal Requirements' section below. * A marked-up copy of your manuscript that highlights changes made to the original version. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Revised Manuscript with Track Changes'. * An unmarked version of your revised paper without tracked changes. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Manuscript'. If you would like to make changes to your financial disclosure, competing interests statement, or data availability statement, please make these updates within the submission form at the time of resubmission. Guidelines for resubmitting your figure files are available below the reviewer comments at the end of this letter. As the corresponding author, your ORCID iD is verified in the submission system and will appear in the published article. PLOS supports the use of ORCID, and we encourage all coauthors to register for an ORCID iD and use it as well. Please encourage your coauthors to verify their ORCID iD within the submission system before final acceptance, as unverified ORCID iDs will not appear in the published article. Only the individual author can complete the verification step; PLOS staff cannot verify ORCID iDs on behalf of authors. We look forward to receiving your revised manuscript. Kind regards, Giulio Rossetti Academic Editor PLOS Complex Systems Giulio Rossetti Academic Editor PLOS Complex Systems Hocine Cherifi Editor-in-Chief PLOS Complex Systems Journal Requirements: If the reviewer comments include a recommendation to cite specific previously published works, please review and evaluate these publications to determine whether they are relevant and should be cited. There is no requirement to cite these works unless the editor has indicated otherwise. Additional Editor Comments (if provided): [Note: HTML markup is below. Please do not edit.] Reviewers' Comments: Reviewer's Responses to Questions Comments to the Author Reviewer #1: All comments have been addressed Reviewer #2: All comments have been addressed Reviewer #3: All comments have been addressed ********** Reviewer #1: Yes Reviewer #2: Yes Reviewer #3: Yes ********** 3. Has the statistical analysis been performed appropriately and rigorously?-->?> Reviewer #1: Yes Reviewer #2: Yes Reviewer #3: Yes ********** 4. Have the authors made all data underlying the findings in their manuscript fully available (please refer to the Data Availability Statement at the start of the manuscript PDF file)??> The PLOS Data policy Reviewer #1: Yes Reviewer #2: Yes Reviewer #3: Yes ********** 5. Is the manuscript presented in an intelligible fashion and written in standard English??> Reviewer #1: Yes Reviewer #2: Yes Reviewer #3: Yes ********** Reviewer #1 : I have reviewed the revised manuscript and the accompanying response to the reviewers. The authors have approached the methodological critiques with commendable intellectual honesty, recalibrating the claims of the paper to accurately reflect the observational nature of the study. Reviewer #2 : I raised the issue that the paper doesn't tackle influence because you dont measure behavioral or attitudinal change. That is still an issue, but I am willing to accept that there may be disciplinary differences in the use of influence. Otherwise, nice job on the revisions. Reviewer #3: Thank you to the authors for carefully addressing my first-round comments. In sum, most of my concerns have now been resolved, and the revised taxonomy, observable signatures and three-stage analytical procedure make the paper clearer and more transparent. I recommend acceptance after minor revisions to address the remaining points below. The operational definition added to the Introduction clarifies that political influence refers to the propagation and amplification of political content, rather than changes in beliefs or behaviour. This addresses my main conceptual concern. However, some claims elsewhere in the manuscript still go beyond what the data support, including statements about “disproportionate visibility,” “influence effectiveness” and shaping opinion. Please revise these statements to consistently reflect the focus on observable diffusion and potential visibility. The new operationalisation subsection, Table 1 and Figure 2 provide a more concrete analytical procedure, including indicative thresholds for reposting behaviour and shared content. I am satisfied with presenting the framework as an exploratory analytical taxonomy, with further validation left to future work. However, Figure 2 still contains a branch labelled “Organised Online Campaigning ? TBC”. This appears to be an unfinished draft note and introduces a category not included in Table 1. Please resolve or remove this branch and ensure that the figure matches the taxonomy. My concern about network position has been satisfactorily addressed. The former “structural vector” mechanism has been removed, and the Discussion now treats network position as an enabling condition that shapes the circulation and potential visibility of political content. The correction identifying the research as an observational study is also appropriate. The authors acknowledge that actual exposure cannot be determined from the available data. Aggregate Follower Capacity provides useful context about potential dissemination, but the numerical reporting needs clarification. Football-related accounts are reported to account for 230.6 million of the total 511.4 million followers, which is approximately 45.1%, rather than more than half. If the intended denominator is the follower capacity held by the top 1% of accounts, please state this explicitly. The Methods already acknowledge that follower overlap and exposure cannot be measured, but should also make clear that AFC counts shared followers multiple times and therefore does not estimate unique reach or actual exposure. Finally, Table 1 defines six mechanisms, while the Abstract and Author Summary list five. Although inadvertent amplification is illustrated as a secondary mechanism in Case 1, this relationship should be made explicit so that readers understand how the five case studies illustrate the six mechanisms. A separate case study is not necessary, but the presentation should be consistent throughout the manuscript. ********** what does this mean?). If published, this will include your full peer review and any attached files. Do you want your identity to be public for this peer review? If you choose “no”, your identity will remain anonymous but your review may still be made public. For information about this choice, including consent withdrawal, please see our Privacy Policy Reviewer #1: Yes: Gabor Vattay Reviewer #2: No Reviewer #3: No ********** [NOTE: If reviewer comments were submitted as an attachment file, they will be attached to this email and accessible via the submission site. Please log into your account, locate the manuscript record, and check for the action link "View Attachments". If this link does not appear, there are no attachment files.] Figure resubmission: After uploading your figures to PLOS’s NAAS tool - https://ngplosjournals.pagemajik.ai/artanalysis, NAAS will process the files provided and display the results in the "Uploaded Files" section of the page as the processing is complete. If the uploaded figures meet our requirements (or NAAS is able to fix the files to meet our requirements), the figure will be marked as "fixed" above. If NAAS is unable to fix the files, a red "failed" label will appear above. When NAAS has confirmed that the figure files meet our requirements, please download the file via the download option, and include these NAAS processed figure files when submitting your revised manuscript. Reproducibility: To enhance the reproducibility of your results, we recommend that authors of applicable studies deposit laboratory protocols in protocols.io, where a protocol can be assigned its own identifier (DOI) such that it can be cited independently in the future. Additionally, PLOS ONE offers an option to publish peer-reviewed clinical study protocols. Read more information on sharing protocols at https://plos.org/protocols?utm_medium=editorial-email&utm_source=authorletters&utm_campaign=protocols |
| Revision 2 |
|
Kicking politics: towards a framework for detecting political influence in online communities PCSY-D-26-00027R2 Dear Dr. Pacheco, We're pleased to inform you that your manuscript has been judged scientifically suitable for publication and will be formally accepted for publication once it meets all outstanding technical requirements. Within one week, you'll receive an e-mail detailing the required amendments. When these have been addressed, you'll receive a formal acceptance letter and your manuscript will be scheduled for publication. An invoice for payment will follow shortly after the formal acceptance. To ensure an efficient process, please log into Editorial Manager at https://www.editorialmanager.com/pcsy/ click the 'Update My Information' link at the top of the page, and double check that your user information is up-to-date. For questions related to billing, please contact billing support at https://plos.my.site.com/s/. If your institution or institutions have a press office, please notify them about your upcoming paper to help maximize its impact. If they'll be preparing press materials, please inform our press team as soon as possible -- no later than 48 hours after receiving the formal acceptance. Your manuscript will remain under strict press embargo until 2 pm Eastern Time on the date of publication. For more information, please contact complexsystems@plos.org. Kind regards, Giulio Rossetti Academic Editor PLOS Complex Systems Additional Editor Comments (optional): Dear Authors, Thank you for your careful and thorough revisions. Your responses satisfactorily address the concerns raised during the review process, and the corresponding changes to the manuscript are clear and appropriate. In particular, the issues highlighted by Reviewer 3 have been adequately resolved, and the presentation of the work has been improved. I have no further comments or requests for modification. |
Open letter on the publication of peer review reports
PLOS recognizes the benefits of transparency in the peer review process. Therefore, we enable the publication of all of the content of peer review and author responses alongside final, published articles. Reviewers remain anonymous, unless they choose to reveal their names.
We encourage other journals to join us in this initiative. We hope that our action inspires the community, including researchers, research funders, and research institutions, to recognize the benefits of published peer review reports for all parts of the research system.
Learn more at ASAPbio .