Peer Review History
| Original SubmissionMay 28, 2026 |
|---|
|
PCSY-D-26-00068 When legs and bodies synchronise: Two-level collective dynamics in dense crowds PLOS Complex Systems Dear Dr. Chatagnon, Thank you for submitting your manuscript to PLOS Complex Systems. After careful consideration, we feel that it has merit but does not fully meet PLOS Complex Systems's publication criteria as it currently stands. Therefore, we invite you to submit a revised version of the manuscript that addresses the points raised during the review process. Please submit your revised manuscript by . If you will need more time than this to complete your revisions, please reply to this message or contact the journal office at complexsystems@plos.org. When you're ready to submit your revision, log on to https://www.editorialmanager.com/pcsy/ and select the 'Submissions Needing Revision' folder to locate your manuscript file. Please include the following items when submitting your revised manuscript: * A letter that responds to each point raised by the editor and reviewer(s). You should upload this letter as a separate file labeled 'Response to Reviewers'. This file does not need to include responses to any formatting updates and technical items listed in the 'Journal Requirements' section below. * A marked-up copy of your manuscript that highlights changes made to the original version. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Revised Manuscript with Track Changes'. * An unmarked version of your revised paper without tracked changes. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Manuscript'. If you would like to make changes to your financial disclosure, competing interests statement, or data availability statement, please make these updates within the submission form at the time of resubmission. Guidelines for resubmitting your figure files are available below the reviewer comments at the end of this letter. As the corresponding author, your ORCID iD is verified in the submission system and will appear in the published article. PLOS supports the use of ORCID, and we encourage all coauthors to register for an ORCID iD and use it as well. Please encourage your coauthors to verify their ORCID iD within the submission system before final acceptance, as unverified ORCID iDs will not appear in the published article. Only the individual author can complete the verification step; PLOS staff cannot verify ORCID iDs on behalf of authors. We look forward to receiving your revised manuscript. Kind regards, Ning Cai, Ph.D. Academic Editor PLOS Complex Systems Ning Cai Academic Editor PLOS Complex Systems Hocine Cherifi Editor-in-Chief PLOS Complex Systems Journal Requirements: 1. Some material included in your submission may be copyrighted. According to PLOS’s copyright policy, authors who use figures or other material (e.g., graphics, clipart, maps) from another author or copyright holder must demonstrate or obtain permission to publish this material under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0) License used by PLOS journals. Please closely review the details of PLOS’s copyright requirements here: PLOS Licenses and Copyright. If you need to request permissions from a copyright holder, you may use PLOS's Copyright Content Permission form. Please respond directly to this email or email the journal office and provide any known details concerning your material's license terms and permissions required for reuse, even if you have not yet obtained copyright permissions or are unsure of your material's copyright compatibility. Potential Copyright Issues: a. Figures 1, 6: Please confirm whether you drew the images / clip-art within the figure panels by hand. If you did not draw the images, please provide (a) a link to the source of the images or icons and their license / terms of use; or (b) written permission from the copyright holder to publish the images or icons under our CC-BY 4.0 license. Alternatively, you may replace the images with open source alternatives. See these open source resources you may use to replace images / clip-art: - https://commons.wikimedia.org 2. We ask that a manuscript source file is provided at Revision. Please upload your manuscript file as a .doc, .docx, .rtf or .tex. 3. Please provide separate figure files in .tif or .eps format. For more information about figure files please see our guidelines: https://journals.plos.org/complexsystems/s/figures https://journals.plos.org/complexsystems/s/figures#loc-file-requirements 4. We have noticed that you have cited Supporting Information in your manuscript. However, there are no corresponding files uploaded to the submission. Please upload them as separate files with the item type 'Supporting Information'. If the reviewer comments include a recommendation to cite specific previously published works, please review and evaluate these publications to determine whether they are relevant and should be cited. There is no requirement to cite these works unless the editor has indicated otherwise. Additional Editor Comments: The reviewers unanimously recognize the model’s originality and explanatory elegance, but agree that the current contribution remains largely qualitative. The authors must strengthen empirical grounding through quantitative comparison with published data, systematically test robustness against initial disorder and parameter variations, and clarify the model’s predictive limitations versus its interpretive value. Additional technical clarifications—including numerical stability, normalized metrics, and figure labeling—are also required. Overall, a thoughtful revision addressing these points is required. [Note: HTML markup is below. Please do not edit.] Reviewers' Comments: Reviewer's Responses to Questions Comments to the Author 1. Does this manuscript meet PLOS Complex Systems’s publication criteria?> Reviewer #1: Yes Reviewer #2: Yes Reviewer #3: Yes ********** 2. Has the statistical analysis been performed appropriately and rigorously?-->?> Reviewer #1: Yes Reviewer #2: Yes Reviewer #3: Yes ********** 3. Have the authors made all data underlying the findings in their manuscript fully available (please refer to the Data Availability Statement at the start of the manuscript PDF file)??> The PLOS Data policy Reviewer #1: Yes Reviewer #2: Yes Reviewer #3: Yes ********** 4. Is the manuscript presented in an intelligible fashion and written in standard English??> Reviewer #1: Yes Reviewer #2: Yes Reviewer #3: Yes ********** Reviewer #1: This manuscript proposes a simple yet interesting two-level model that separates upper-body and leg dynamics to explain collective motion in ultra-dense crowds; the idea is original, physically interpretable, and potentially valuable for the field. A main strength is that the model reproduces two qualitatively important emergent patterns—density waves and collective chiral rotations—without imposing global coordination rules, which is an appealing result. However, the current contribution remains mainly qualitative: (1) The manuscript shows that the model can generate plausible patterns, but it does not yet convincingly demonstrate that these mechanisms are necessary or sufficient to explain real dense-crowd dynamics. (2) It needs validation against data or experiments; at minimum, the authors should compare measurable outputs (wave speed, dominant frequency, correlation length, rotational period, etc.) with published observations. (3) More evidence is needed on sensitivity to initialization, density, system size, boundary conditions, and parameter perturbations, especially because periodic boundaries may themselves favor coherent large-scale modes. (4) The mechanical interpretation in terms of inverted pendula is interesting, but the model remains highly stylized; the authors should better clarify which aspects are meant as biomechanics and which are only heuristic abstractions. Reviewer #2: Dear Editor, I have reviewed the manuscript entitled “When Legs and Bodies Synchronize: Two-Level Collective Dynamics in Dense Crowds” by Thomas Chatagnon et al. The manuscript presents a model in which a crowd of pedestrians is simulated using a novel approach. Instead of the traditionally simple 2D disc (or, in a few cases, other 2D shapes), the authors propose representing each pedestrian with two coupled discs positioned vertically. These two discs simplistically represent the legs and the upper body of pedestrians, respectively. The objective of the model is to simulate the loss and recovery of human balance in ultra-dense crowd scenarios. In my opinion, this work presents an interesting and original idea, as it constitutes a first step toward the challenging yet important task of simulating pedestrians while accounting for their three-dimensional nature. Only through such approaches can we eventually achieve a better understanding of collective pedestrian behavior and, ultimately, predict scenarios in which falls occur. Naturally, I view this work as only an initial step in this direction, and there are many aspects of the model that will require future attention and possible refinement. Nevertheless, I consider this contribution valuable and anticipate that it will attract interest from the pedestrian dynamics community as well as related research fields. Therefore, I support its acceptance in PLOS Complex Systems. Below, I suggest several points that could be addressed to improve the clarity of the manuscript. My main concern relates to the way the coupling mechanism is modeled. It is not clear to me whether, in ultra-dense crowd conditions, balance recovery is indeed achieved in the manner proposed by the authors, namely through forces acting on the legs. This assumption seems reasonable under dilute conditions. However, in scenarios such as those presented in the manuscript, I would not rule out the possibility that pedestrians also exert forces through their upper bodies and arms to maintain an upright posture. Although incorporating such mechanisms is clearly beyond the scope of the present work, I believe that these ideas could be briefly discussed in the manuscript. The authors mention that their system can be viewed as a collection of interacting inverted pendulums. This is an appealing interpretation that broadens the relevance of the model and may attract interest from communities working in complex systems, nonlinear dynamics, and related areas. However, this perspective also suggests the potential importance of incorporating a more sophisticated coupling mechanism in which the pendulum length (or, equivalently, participant height) is explicitly considered. This raises additional questions, such as: what is the most relevant characteristic length? Should it be the distance from the feet to the center of mass of the upper body, or perhaps the distance from the feet to the hips? Again, I do not expect the authors to investigate these questions in the present work, but I believe that a brief discussion of these issues would enrich the manuscript. Regarding Fig. 6, I think the crystallized state should be identified with a letter. Then, in lines 206–212, all regions denoted by letters should be explicitly mentioned to facilitate the reader’s understanding. In addition, a few words should be devoted to explaining the meaning of the incoherent state (region C), which is currently not discussed in that section. I do not believe that the current title fully reflects the main contribution of the work. To increase its impact, I would recommend considering a simpler title that focuses more directly on the 3D nature of the modeling framework rather than on synchronization. Finally, please carefully check the manuscript for typographical and grammatical errors, as I noticed several minor issues throughout the text. Reviewer #3: The authors present a very simple two-level “pedestrian” model to provide evidence for their main hypothesis: that “the loss and the recovery of standing balance” explain “the mechanisms of individual absorption and transmission of perturbation forces” in “ultra-dense crowds” and through this also explain the “collective motion” in these ultra-dense crowds. By ultra-dense they mean crowds where there are “continuous inter-individual contacts”. They model a person or agent by two sets of disks, a bigger one representing the upper body, positioned on top of a smaller one, representing the legs. These upside-down “pendula” are positioned into 2D space X. For each level, sets of Langevin type differential equations are formulated for speed v (upper), and vl (lower), and location x (upper), xl (lower) and an index n for the n-th agent. Newly, the equations describe a plausible unbalancing mechanism on the top level, and a plausible recovery mechanism on the lower level. This is also the only place where the two layers are loosely coupled, since the balance recovery term is driven by a displacement between the leg disk and the body disk. There are two essential parameters: \lambda_u > 0 describes how strongly the agents are unbalanced on top, and \lambda_b > 0 describes how strongly they re-balance below. Both parameters are identical for all agents. In addition there is a “damping” term, where an agent’s acceleration on the upper level is damped proportionally to its velocity v_n. The authors suggest to insert an external desired velocity v* here, if one wishes to include some forward motion in the crowd. The strength of the dampening is given by \lambda > 0 which is chosen identical for all agents. The equations also describe interaction between neighbouring bodies on both levels using a classic potential formulation, and classic potential functions. The equations are discretized, again very simply, into an Euler-type scheme so that the equations can be solved numerically. The authors also define two numbers, the kinergetic energy \epsilon, where the agents’ upper velocities are squared and added, and local velocity correlations \in [-1,1] which indicates how much the agents’ motion is locally aligned. Then, simulation experiments are set up. For this, all agents are placed on a square field so that they form a completely regular lattice. Thus, on the top level, the agents are packed like a (non-optimal) crate of oranges. There is no space to move, but the densest possible packing has not been achieved. Two parameter configurations are considered: Scenario “density wave”: \lambda_u = 0.5/s < lambda_b/s = 1, and v= vb = 1 m/s V is the balancing speed in the crucial re-balancing term b_n = v e_n(t) that moves the legs of agent n back underneath the agent’s upper body (in direction e_n). Scenario “chiral motion”: \lambda_u = 1/s > lambda_b = 0.5/s > 0, and v=vb=0.2 m/s Indeed, when one runs the sample code, one can observe a wave in the crowd for the first parameter choice and a chiral motion in the crowd for the second parameter choice. (Fig. 2) The authors also observe their energy and correlation indices over time. They finally vary \lambda_u and v (for fixed \lambda_l) to derive a "phase diagram" of the two observed behaviours. I find it really rather beautiful, that such simple physically plausible balancing rules suffice to see waves and chiral movement emerge in a crowd of upside down pendula. I agree with the authors, that this provides strong evidence for their claim: The fact that individuals again and again lose and recover balance in a densely packed crowd may be what makes waves form and chiral motion appear. In my eyes, the model therefore belongs, very firmly, to the class of explanatory models. It explains how waves or chiral motion may emerge, similar to how the Nagel-Schreckenberg model explains how congestions emerges out of the blue. It is, however, most definitely not a predictive model, since one has to guess the correct parameter constellation to achieve one phenomenon or the other. In conclusion, I find the explanatory power so compelling that I would like the paper to be published as soon as the authors have addressed a few issues. I consider only one as major: a more realistic discussion of the predictive power of the model and of future extensions. Minor issues – or rather questions: I am wondering, if the phenomena persist, if the extreme regularity of the scenarios chosen by the authors is broken: for example, if the initial lattice is no longer chosen near perfect, or, if \lambda, \lambda_u, lambda_l are not chosen identical for all agents, but drawn from distributions (one would perhaps try normal distributions?). I am also wondering, whether or not, and under which parameter constellations, the two levels might partially or completely decouple. The balancing does not seem to be a very strict connection between body and legs. Minor issue – numerical treatment: What happens numerically when the disks are in perfect balance, so that e_n in Eqn (4) is 0 (or close to it): As it is, the scheme divides by 0 in Eqn (9). I assume the authors use a suitable method to avoid this? For the sake of easy reproducibility, the authors may want to discuss numerical issues, perhaps in an appendix. Minor issue: The energy definition is not useful to compare crowds of different sizes, since it depends on the number of agents. Issue with limitations: The authors list in their discussion several extensions that would lead to a predictive tool. Some of them sound rather complicated which would cost the model its simplicity. I would regret that. More importantly, I find the biggest issue missing in the list: As it is, a practitioner who would want to use the model to predict whether a crowd will produce waves, or swirls, or neither, would have to guess the parameter constellation first: \lambda_u > _lambda_b? Or the other way round? The odds stand 50:50. In my eyes, we are confronted with an interesting new research question: How can one infer the parameters \lambda_u and \lambda_b \lambda from some observables in an experiment or field trial. Then, perhaps, there is a chance to fit them to the occasion of interest. I hope the scientific community will tackle this in the future. ********** what does this mean?). If published, this will include your full peer review and any attached files. Do you want your identity to be public for this peer review? If you choose “no”, your identity will remain anonymous but your review may still be made public. For information about this choice, including consent withdrawal, please see our Privacy Policy Reviewer #1: No Reviewer #2: No Reviewer #3: No ********** [NOTE: If reviewer comments were submitted as an attachment file, they will be attached to this email and accessible via the submission site. Please log into your account, locate the manuscript record, and check for the action link "View Attachments". If this link does not appear, there are no attachment files.] Figure resubmission: Reproducibility: To enhance the reproducibility of your results, we recommend that authors of applicable studies deposit laboratory protocols in protocols.io, where a protocol can be assigned its own identifier (DOI) such that it can be cited independently in the future. Additionally, PLOS ONE offers an option to publish peer-reviewed clinical study protocols. Read more information on sharing protocols at https://plos.org/protocols?utm_medium=editorial-email&utm_source=authorletters&utm_campaign=protocols |
| Revision 1 |
|
Giving Particles Legs: How Balance Recovery May Drive Emergent Collective Dynamics in Ultra-Dense Crowds PCSY-D-26-00068R1 Dear Dr. Chatagnon, We're pleased to inform you that your manuscript has been judged scientifically suitable for publication and will be formally accepted for publication once it meets all outstanding technical requirements. Within one week, you'll receive an e-mail detailing the required amendments. When these have been addressed, you'll receive a formal acceptance letter and your manuscript will be scheduled for publication. An invoice for payment will follow shortly after the formal acceptance. To ensure an efficient process, please log into Editorial Manager at https://www.editorialmanager.com/pcsy/ click the 'Update My Information' link at the top of the page, and double check that your user information is up-to-date. For questions related to billing, please contact billing support at https://plos.my.site.com/s/. If your institution or institutions have a press office, please notify them about your upcoming paper to help maximize its impact. If they'll be preparing press materials, please inform our press team as soon as possible -- no later than 48 hours after receiving the formal acceptance. Your manuscript will remain under strict press embargo until 2 pm Eastern Time on the date of publication. For more information, please contact complexsystems@plos.org. Kind regards, Ning Cai, Ph.D. Academic Editor PLOS Complex Systems Additional Editor Comments (optional): Reviewers' comments: Reviewer's Responses to Questions Comments to the Author Reviewer #1: All comments have been addressed Reviewer #2: All comments have been addressed Reviewer #4: All comments have been addressed -------------------- Reviewer #1: Yes Reviewer #2: Yes Reviewer #4: Yes -------------------- 3. Has the statistical analysis been performed appropriately and rigorously?-->?> Reviewer #1: Yes Reviewer #2: Yes Reviewer #4: Yes -------------------- 4. Have the authors made all data underlying the findings in their manuscript fully available (please refer to the Data Availability Statement at the start of the manuscript PDF file)??> The PLOS Data policy Reviewer #1: Yes Reviewer #2: Yes Reviewer #4: Yes -------------------- 5. Is the manuscript presented in an intelligible fashion and written in standard English?<br/><br/>PLOS Complex Systems does not copyedit accepted manuscripts, so the language in submitted articles must be clear, correct, and unambiguous. Any typographical or grammatical errors should be corrected at revision, so please note any specific errors here.-->?> Reviewer #1: Yes Reviewer #2: Yes Reviewer #4: Yes -------------------- Reviewer #1: n my opinion, the manuscript is now fully acceptable for publication in PLOS Complex Systems. The authors have addressed all reviewer concerns thoroughly and constructively. Reviewer #2: The authors have succesfully addressed all my comments and criticisms. I think the manuscript can be published almost as it is. Please have a look to typos; specially the reference to figures in caption of Fig 2, Fig 4, and other places (line 190...) Reviewer #4: The authors have revised the manuscript point by point in accordance with the previous round of reviewers' comments, and all issues have been properly resolved. The current version meets the journal's requirements in terms of academic quality and readability, and I recommend its acceptance. -------------------- what does this mean?). If published, this will include your full peer review and any attached files. Do you want your identity to be public for this peer review? If you choose “no”, your identity will remain anonymous but your review may still be made public. For information about this choice, including consent withdrawal, please see our Privacy Policy Reviewer #1: No Reviewer #2: No Reviewer #4: No -------------------- |
Open letter on the publication of peer review reports
PLOS recognizes the benefits of transparency in the peer review process. Therefore, we enable the publication of all of the content of peer review and author responses alongside final, published articles. Reviewers remain anonymous, unless they choose to reveal their names.
We encourage other journals to join us in this initiative. We hope that our action inspires the community, including researchers, research funders, and research institutions, to recognize the benefits of published peer review reports for all parts of the research system.
Learn more at ASAPbio .