Following the publication of this article , concerns were raised regarding the flow cytometry data reported in Fig 3:
- There are similarities in dot plot patterns between the right panel of Fig 3A and the right panel of Fig 3C. Although the plots are not exact duplicates, the similarities observed are not expected from plots derived from distinct datasets.
The original data underlying Fig 3 are no longer available and thus it is not possible to resolve the concerns pertaining to the reliability of the integrity of the published figure.
The Commission on Research Integrity at Oslo University Hospital and Institute of Clinical Medicine, University of Oslo has completed an investigation and concluded that there was evidence of scientific misconduct.
In light of the outstanding concerns with panels in Fig 3 that question the integrity of these data and the outcome of an internal institutional investigation, the PLOS ONE Editors retract this article.
PW, QG, ZS, EM, LM, and GG did not agree with the retraction. SS, MW, NACW, and GK did not respond to the retraction decision.
Lung cancer (LC) with its different subtypes is generally known as a therapy resistant cancer with the highest morbidity rate worldwide. Therapy resistance of a tumor is thought to be related to cancer stem cells (CSCs) within the tumors. There have been indications that the lung cancer is propagated and maintained by a small population of CSCs. To study this question we established a panel of 15 primary lung cancer cell lines (PLCCLs) from 20 fresh primary tumors using a robust serum-free culture system. We subsequently focused on identification of lung CSCs by studying these cell lines derived from 4 representative lung cancer subtypes such as small cell lung cancer (SCLC), large cell carcinoma (LCC), squamous cell carcinoma (SCC) and adenocarcinoma (AC). We identified a small population of cells strongly positive for CD44 (CD44high) and a main population which was either weakly positive or negative for CD44 (CD44low/−). Co-expression of CD90 further narrowed down the putative stem cell population in PLCCLs from SCLC and LCC as spheroid-forming cells were mainly found within the CD44highCD90+ sub-population. Moreover, these CD44highCD90+ cells revealed mesenchymal morphology, increased expression of mesenchymal markers N-Cadherin and Vimentin, increased mRNA levels of the embryonic stem cell related genes Nanog and Oct4 and increased resistance to irradiation compared to other sub-populations studied, suggesting the CD44highCD90+ population a good candidate for the lung CSCs. Both CD44highCD90+ and CD44highCD90− cells in the PLCCL derived from SCC formed spheroids, whereas the CD44low/− cells were lacking this potential. These results indicate that CD44highCD90+ sub-population may represent CSCs in SCLC and LCC, whereas in SCC lung cancer subtype, CSC potentials were found within the CD44high sub-population.
Citation: Wang P, Gao Q, Suo Z, Munthe E, Solberg S, Ma L, et al. (2013) Identification and Characterization of Cells with Cancer Stem Cell Properties in Human Primary Lung Cancer Cell Lines. PLoS ONE 8(3): e57020. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0057020
Editor: Dean G. Tang, The University of Texas M.D Anderson Cancer Center, United States of America
Received: June 26, 2012; Accepted: January 21, 2013; Published: March 4, 2013
Copyright: © 2013 Wang et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: This work was supported by a grant from the Norwegian research council (SFI-CAST). The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
The “cancer stem cell” (CSC) theory implies a hierarchical organization within the tumor in which CSCs represents the apex of the hierarchy. Similar to normal stem cells, CSCs have the capacity to undergo self-renewal as well as asymmetric cell division. These key features enable CSCs to initiate and maintain tumors. In addition to the classical term, i.e. CSC, various terms have been used in the recent scientific literature to describe essential characteristics of CSCs such as self-renewal and tumor initiating/maintaining property. Among others are such terms as tumor initiating cell (TIC), cancer initiating cell (CIC) and tumor propagating cell (TPC). In this report we will use the CSC term to characterize cells that were able to initiate and sustain tumor formation in animals and long-term liquid culture.
Current studies in the field of cancer stem cell research have provided increasing evidence for the existence and identification of CSCs using several specific biomarkers, such as CD44, CD133 and CD90. These markers have been widely accepted for isolation of CSCs in human haematological malignancies ,  as well as in solid tumors –. Furthermore, CSCs have been found to be more resistant to conventional chemotherapy and radiotherapy than the major population of more differentiated cancer cells, indicating that the CSCs may remain in residual tumors after treatment and contribute to cancer recurrence and spreading. Therefore, new treatments targeting CSCs may potentially prevent tumor recurrence and prolong survival of patients. The epithelial-mesenchymal transition (EMT) plays an important role in embryonic development . It causes epithelial cells to lose their epithelial behavior, changing their morphology and cellular properties to resemble mesenchymal cells . EMT has been suggested to contribute to the invasive and metastatic growth of many types of cancers –. Recent study showed that stem cell-like cells from epithelial cancers having a mesenchymal phenotype express markers associated with EMT .
Lung cancer is the leading cause of cancer-related mortality worldwide, and has a poor prognosis with 5-year survival rates of approximately 15%. According to the histological heterogeneity, lung carcinomas are categorized into four major subtypes: small cell lung cancer (SCLC), squamous cell carcinoma (SCC), large cell carcinoma (LCC) and adenocarcinoma (AC). In this study, following the “Cancer Stem Cell” hypothesis, we focused on the identification and characterization of CSCs in above mentioned subtypes of lung cancer.
The cell surface marker CD133 has previously been identified as a reliable marker for CSCs in some of lung cancer subtypes . However, the reliability of this marker as a CSC marker for lung cancer has recently been disputed . Therefore, we focused on another marker, i.e. CD44, which has been suggested to characterize CSCs in breast, prostate, head and neck, colorectal, pancreatic and gastric cancers , , –, .
In this study, we took advantage of the primary lung cancer tissues removed during resection and focused on establishing of PLCCLs from freshly isolated tumors. We assumed that PLCCL may provide a more representative and appropriate source of cancer cells that can be used for identification of cells or cell populations with stem cell-like properties. We first successfully established a panel of the primary lung cancer cell lines from freshly obtained specimens of the major subtypes of lung cancer. Based on detailed phenotypic and functional analysis of representative cell lines from SCLC, LCC and SCC, we provide evidence indicating that CD44high population may harbour CSCs in these cancer subtypes. In addition, co-expression of CD90 further narrowed down population of CSCs in SCLC and LCC. The picture for AC, however, remains less clear, and at the present we have no convincing evidence that either of the markers, i.e. CD44 and CD90, is characteristic for CSCs in this particular cancer subtype.
Materials and Methods
Collection of tumor specimens and establishment of primary lung cancer cell lines
This study was approved by the Regional Ethical Committee and the Institutional Review Board of Oslo University Hospital and performed according to the guidelines of the Helsinki Convention. Upon signed informed consent, human lung cancer tissues were obtained from 20 patients with primary lung cancer (age range 55–81 years) undergoing lobectomy or pneumonectomy at Oslo University Hospital from July 2007 to October 2009. Histological diagnosis was determined based on microscopic features of carcinoma cells (Table 1).
Freshly obtained tumour tissue (within 1–2 hours after surgical removal) was washed in RPMI-1640 medium (Invitrogen, USA) containing penicillin-streptomycin (PS, penicillin 100 U/ml and streptomycin 100 μg/ml; Lonza, Belgium). Blood vessels and connective tissue were carefully removed and the cancerous part was then minced into small pieces less then 1 mm3 using scalpel, followed by extensive washing in RPMI-1640 medium and centrifugation at 300 g for 5 min. Finally, the cells were re-suspended in RPMI-1640 medium containing collagenase II (Invitrogen, USA) at the concentration of 200 U/ml and digested for 2–4 hours at 37°C in a humidified incubator. The enzymatic digestion was stopped when most of the cells were in the single cells suspension. Following washing in RPMI-1640 and 3x centrifugation at 300 g for 5 minutes, cells were transferred into standard tissue culture coated flasks (Corning Life Sciences, USA) and cultured in the Defined Keratinocyte-Serum Free Medium (DK-SFM) supplemented with L-glutamine (Invitrogen, USA), EGF 20 ng/ml, basic-FGF 10 ng/ml (PeproTech Inc., USA), 2% B27 (Invitrogen, USA), PS and amphotericin B (0.25 μg/ml; Invitrogen, USA). The cultures of all PLCCLs were maintained at 37°C in a humidified incubator with 5% CO2. Culture medium was changed every 2–3 days. Cells were passaged after detachment with TrypLE™Express (Invitrogen, USA), when the cells reached 80–90% confluence. All the studies were performed with the initial five passages of established PLCCLs.
Isolation of nucleic acid and DNA fingerprinting assay
To establish a genetic fingerprint for each of the new cell lines, DNA fingerprinting assay was performed on the representative PLCCLs (LC004, LC006, LC007 and LC021) as well as on a re-established cell line from xenograft of LC021. Genomic DNA was isolated from Dulbecco's phosphate-buffered saline (DPBS, Invitrogen) washed cell pellets. Total genomic DNA was obtained using NucleoSpin Tissue kit (Macherey-Nagel, Germany) according to manufacturer's protocol. The identity of the DNA profiles was determined by STR profiling using Powerplex 16 System (Promega, Madison, WI). This kit amplifies 15 STR loci and amelogenin for gender identification: Penta E, D18S51, D21S11, TH01, D3S1358, FGA, TPOX, D8S1179, vWA, Amelogenin, Penta D, CSF1PO, D16S539, D7S820, D13S317 and D5S818. The PCR products were size determined in a MegaBace 1000 (Applied Biosystems, USA) using the software Fragment Profiler (GE Healthcare). These fingerprints were then compared to DNA profiles in a fingerprint database of previously established lung cancer cell lines to ensure their uniqueness.
The primary cultured lung cancer cell lines were embedded into paraffin blocks by the following method: cells from the liquid culture were detached and washed with DPBS and subsequently centrifuged at 300 g for 5 minutes. The supernatant was carefully removed before 3 drops of plasma and 2 drops of thrombin were added and mixed by tube rotation. Buffered formalin (4%) was added after the mixture was coagulated. The coagulated mass was then placed in linen paper before being embedded in paraffin blocks by standard procedure. Some sections were stained with Hematoxylin and Eosin (H&E) to assess cellular morphology, while other sections were used for immunohistochemistry (IHC) analysis. Four micrometer thick sections were dewaxed and hydrated in graded ethanol. To unmask the epitopes, sections were then microwaved in different buffers optimised for different antibodies. Low pH 10 mM citrate buffer (pH = 6.0) was used for antibodies P53, Ber-EP4 and CD44. To inhibit the endogenous peroxidase, the sections were incubated with 3% hydrogen peroxide (DakoCytomation, USA) for 5 minutes at room temperature (RT). Sections were then incubated with primary mouse anti-human P53, CD44 and Ber-EP4 (DAKO, 1∶1000, 1∶100 and 1∶300 dilutions, respectively) and CD133 (Miltenyi biotec, clone AC133/1 1∶40 dilution) antibodies for 30 minutes at RT followed by incubation with corresponding secondary antibodies for 30 minutes at RT and stained with 3,3′-diaminobenzidine tetrahydrochloride (Dako EnVision™+System Peroxidase (DAB) (K4007, DakoCytomation, USA)) before they were counterstained with hematoxylin, dehydrated and mounted in Diatex. All sections were rinsed thoroughly with TBS-Tween washing buffer (Dako Cytomation, USA) after each incubation step. Sections from paraffin blocks containing human seminoma and breast cancer specimen were used as positive controls for antibodies P53, Ber-EP4 and CD44, respectively; Sections from the paraffin block containing colon cancer cell line CaCo-2 were used as positive control for CD133 antibody. Isotype control antibodies at the same concentration were used as negative controls. All controls were performed and the antibody reactivity was verified before experimental applications of antibodies. Each stained section was reviewed independently by two pathologists.
All animal experiments were approved by and performed according to the guidelines set by the Animal Research Ethics Board at University of Oslo. Female NOD/SCID mice (NODSC-M-F/M-M Homozygous NOD/mrkBOMTac-Prkdcscid; Taconic, Denmark) were purchased. After being kept in quarantine one week for monitoring in the sterile environment of the animal facility in the Oslo University Hospital, Rikshospitalet, 4–5 weeks old NOD/SCID mice were used in all experiments. To assess the tumorigenicity of established PLCCLs, 3×106 cells of each cell line suspended in DK-SFM were inoculated subcutaneously into the right flank of NOD/SCID mice (3 mice in each group) at a maximum volume of 100 µl. The mice were inspected twice a week and tumor size was measured with callipers. Mice were sacrificed by cervical dislocation when the size of the tumor reached a diameter of 15 mm. Xenografts were then removed and used for histological analysis and establishing of liquid cell cultures. Serial xeno-transplantations were performed with the LCC LC006 cell line by implanting pieces of the primary xenograft subcutaneously into secondary recipient NOD/SCID mice. Xenografts derived from each passage were taken out and fixed in 4% buffered formalin for histological analysis.
Flow cytometry analysis and Fluorescence-Activated Cell Sorting (FACS)
Flow cytometry analysis was performed on PLCCLs at logarithmic growth phase. Cells were first detached with TrypLE™Express and washed with DPBS. Re-suspended cells were counted and transferred into 75 mm polystyrene round-bottom test tubes (BD Falcon, USA) at a cell concentration 1×106 cells/ml, and subsequently stained with antibodies at dilutions determined by previous titration. Human immunoglobulin staining buffer (DPBS+0.1% human serum albumin (Octapharma, Stockholm, Sweden)) and 5 µL of 10 mg/ml gamma globulin (Gammagard, Baxter, UK) was added to the cells to block the FcR and minimize unspecific binding of antibodies. Fluorochrome coupled monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) were added to the test tubes at saturating concentrations and the cells were incubated for 20 minutes on ice avoiding light exposure. A screening for markers was performed with a panel of mAbs (see detailed data in Table 2) on four PLCCLs representing each lung cancer subtype. Cells stained with isotype-matched mAbs (BD Pharmingen, USA) served as negative controls. Different populations of cells were sorted based on the expressions of CD44 alone, or in combination with CD90 using a FACSAria II cell sorter (Becton Dickinson, Franklin Lakes, NJ). Flow data were acquired on the FACSAria II or LSR II cytometer (Becton Dickinson, Franklin Lakes, NJ). The results were analyzed using the BD FACSDiva software (Version 6.1.3). The viability of sorted cells was routinely checked using Trypan blue (Invitrogen, USA) staining and usually was >70%.
Cell proliferation assay
FACS sorted CD44high and CD44low/− cells at density of 150 or 500 cells per well were plated in triplicate in 200 µl DK-SFM with supplements in standard coated 96-well plates. Wells containing medium only were used as a background negative control. The cells were allowed to adhere at 37°C in a 5% CO2 humidified incubator for one day before they were used in the proliferation assay. Cell proliferation was measured during the following 8 days using CellTiter 96® AQueous One Solution Cell Proliferation Assay kit (Promega, Madison, WI) according to the protocol provided by the manufacturer. Absorbance at 490 nm was measured on a Wallac Victor2 plate reader (Perkin Elmer, Waltham, MA). The growth curves were drawn according to the mean value of absorbance, related to the background.
2 dimensional (2D) single cell colony forming and heterogeneity assay
CD44high and CD44low/− cells from the SCLC cell line LC004 and the LCC cell line LC006 were sorted and seeded at a single cell per well into standard coated 96 well plates containing 200 μl DK-SFM supplemented with EGF 20 ng/ml, basic-FGF 10 ng/ml, and 2% B27. Single cell plating was validated by phase-contrast microscope (Nikon, Germany). Cultures were kept at 37°C in a 5% CO2 humidified incubator. After 2 weeks the number of positive wells containing colonies was counted and morphological characteristics of the colonies were evaluated. To study self-renewal and differentiation of single cells, the colonies of different types i.e. holoclones, meroclones and paraclones, were subjected to serial passages by picking and re-seeding them first into 24-well, then 6-well plates (Corning Life Science, USA), and eventually into the flasks (Corning Life Science, USA) where they were further expanded. Colony growth in 2D single cell colony forming assay and the long-term liquid cultures derived from these colonies were observed using phase-contrast microscope (Nikon, Germany).
2D colony formation efficiency assay
FACS sorted CD44high, CD44low/− and CD44highCD90+ and CD44highCD90− cells from the cell lines SCLC LC004 and LCC LC006 were seeded in triplicates at a density of 200 cells per well into standard coated 6 well plate (Corning Life Science, USA) containing 5 ml DK-SFM with supplements per well. The sorted cells were kept in culture at 37°C in 5% CO2 humidified incubator for ∼10 days. When the generated colonies were visible and contained >100 cells, the supernatant was aspirated and the wells were rinsed twice with DPBS, fixed in 4% buffered formalin for 15 min at RT followed by staining with crystal violet for another 15 min at RT. After rinsing away the dye, the colony number was counted and colony formation efficiency (CFE), i.e. the number of colonies per plated cell, was calculated and compared between different sub-populations.
Spheroid formation assay
FACS sorted cells were seeded at density of 100 cells per well into ultra low attachment (ULA) 96 well plate (Corning Incorporated) containing 200 μl DK-SFM with supplements and cultured at 37°C in a 5% CO2 humidified incubator until cells started forming spheroids. The medium was changed every 2 days by carefully removing 50 μl of the upper layer of medium and replacing it with equal volume of fresh medium. The wells were inspected every 2 days using phase-contrast microscope. When the spheroids were big enough (most of the cell spheroids were >200 μm), they were counted and photographed (Nikon, Germany).
RNA extraction and real-time PCR analysis
Total RNA was extracted from 105 FACS sorted cells and subsequently reverse transcribed using Taqman Cell-to-CT kit (Applied Biosystems, USA) according to the protocol provided by the manufacturer. Real-time PCR was performed using Taq-Man Gene Expression Assay system (Applied Biosystems, USA) on 7900HT Fast Real-Time PCR System (Applied Biosystems, USA) according to the manufacturer's instructions and the data were analyzed by the SDS 2.3 Software (Applied Biosystems, USA). Each sample, including no template controls, was performed in duplicate. PCR reaction without template served as the negative control. Thermal cycling conditions were 50°C for 2 min and 95°C for 10 min followed by 40 cycles of 15 s at 95°C, followed by 1 min at 60°C. The expression levels were determined for the following genes Nanog (assay ID 8S02387400_gl), Oct4 (assay ID Hs03005111_g1), Sox2 (assay ID Hs01053049_sl), E-Cadherin (assay ID Hs01023895_m1), N-Cadherin (assay ID Hs00169953_m1), Vimentin (assay ID Hs00958111_ml), high mobility group AT-hook 2 (HMGA2) (assay ID HS00171569_ml) and phosphoglycerate kinase 1 (PGK1) (assay ID Hs99999906_m1). The expression of target genes was related to the expression of PGK1 and normalized to the unsorted control cells using the ddCT method.
Radiation sensitivity assay
FACS sorted cells were seeded at a density of 500 cells per well in duplicates in standard coated 96 well plates (Corning Incorporated) containing 200 μl DK-SFM with supplements. After 24 hours of conventional incubation, cells in the monolayer cultures were irradiated at RT with doses of 1Gy, 2Gy and 4Gy, respectively using a Siemens Stabilipan X-ray unit, operated at 200 kV, 20 mA, with 0.5 mm copper filtration (Siemens, Germany). The cells were then cultured in regular culture conditions for 5 additional days with medium change every 2 days. The effect of irradiation on different cell populations was tested by the CellTiter 96® AQueous One Solution Cell Proliferation Assay as described above. The effect of irradiation on proliferation is given as the inhibition ratio and was calculated according to the formula: inhibition ratio = ((non-irradiated control well absorbance – irradiated well absorbance)/non-irradiated control well absorbance) ×100%.
1. Primary lung cancer cell lines
To provide a basis for the present study, a novel, robust method for culture of lung cancer cells from freshly resected lung carcinomas was established (see material and methods). Fifteen primary lung cancer cell lines were successfully established from 20 lung cancer tissues removed. These included 7 ACs, 6 SCCs, 1 LCC and 1 SCLC (Table 1). The success-rate of establishing primary cultures was 75%. The majority of failures occurred in the first part of the study, before optimal concentrations of the growth factors had been determined. The DK-SFM did support the selective growth of typical epithelial cells, clearly inhibiting the growth of co-existing fibroblasts. This was in contrast to cultures containing serum used in the beginning, where rapid overgrowth by fibroblasts occurred (data not shown). Monolayer cells with typical epithelial morphology were obtained at very high purity in each of the established PLCCLs (Figure 1). The primary cell lines maintained under these conditions were passaged for multiple generations with the longest passage so far over 30 generations, without any sign of growth decline.
A. The SCLC cell line LC004; B. The LCC cell line LC006; C. The AC cell line LC007; D. The SCC cell line LC021. All the representative images were from primary cultured lung cancer cell lines at the second passage. Photomicrograph magnification, ×200.
To ensure that the established cell lines were of unique origin and not contaminated by previously established cell lines , DNA profiles using a set of highly polymorphic microsatellite markers were generated from a subset of the cell lines representing the four different types of lung cancer. The results demonstrated that the four cell lines were unique and unrelated (Table Sl).
2. Phenotype of PLCCLs and parental cancer tissues have similar/are comparable for expression of P53, Ber-EP4 and CD44
We focused our work on four PLCCLs representing the four lung cancer subtypes: the SCLC cell line LC004, the LCC cell line LC006, the AC cell line LC007 and the SCC cell line LC021. From the selected representative PLCCLs, we prepared paraffin blocks, and sections from these cell lines were stained with H&E. Morphological evaluation of the PLCCLs confirmed their epithelial origin with signs of malignant transformation. Moreover, the primary cell lines derived from each of the four lung cancer subtypes were morphologically heterogeneous both at the cellular and nuclear level (Figure 2A).
A. H&E staining of the 4 representative primary lung cancer cell lines for different lung cancer subtypes: the SCLC cell line LC004; the LCC cell line LC006; the AC cell line LC007 and the SCC cell line LC021. The cells derived from the four subtypes of lung cancer showed heterogeneity in cellular and nuclear morphology. Cells of each primary cell line had epithelial morphology. Photomicrograph magnification, ×200. B. Analysis the expression of P53, Ber-EP4 and CD44 in the 4 primary cell lines and their corresponding archival patients' tumor tissues. All the primary cell lines investigated showed diffuse positive staining for P53 except the original SCC tissue of cell line LC021. Epithelial membrane antigen Ber-EP4 was widely positive in all the original lung cancer tissues and diffuse positive in all the primary cell lines. CD44 showed diffuse positive staining with different intensity in the primary cell lines and their corresponding archival patients' cancer tissues except weakly positive in the original tumor tissue of the AC cell line LC007. Sections from paraffin blocks containing human seminoma and breast cancer specimen were used as positive controls for antibodies P53, Ber-EP4 and CD44, respectively. Photomicrograph magnification, ×200.
Tumor-suppressor protein P53 mutations is a hallmark of cancer and is generally up-regulated . We next compared expression levels of P53 in serial sections from the archival patients' tumor tissues and the newly established PLCCLs using IHC. All four PLCCLs showed diffuse positive staining for P53. The same type of staining was observed in the original patient's cancer tissue with the exception of the SCC parental tissue, which was negative for P53 (Figure 2B). Interestingly, the cell line derived from the SCC (LC021) expressed P53. The expression levels of the Ber-EP4 and CD44 were investigated in the same way. The archival patients' tumor tissues and their corresponding PLCCLs showed broadly positive staining for the pan-epithelial marker Ber-EP4. Diffuse positive staining with different intensity in the archival patients' tumor tissues and their corresponding cell lines was seen with CD44 staining, except for the AC parental tumor tissue, which was weakly positive over most of the section studied (Figure 2B, Table S2). Expression of CD133 in the parental tumor tissues was also investigated by IHC staining. CD133 displayed a more variable pattern, with all the parental tumors being negative, except the SCLC (LC004) where expression in isolated areas was observed (data not shown). All PLCCLs derived from the corresponding parental cancer tissues were uniformly negative for CD133 expression by IHC staining.
Taken together the summarized experiments suggest that the PLCCLs in early passages (up to 5) are representative of the parental tumor tissue in all four cancer subtypes.
3. Primary cultures of lung cancer cells are as tumorigenic as xenotransplants
Malignant potential of the PLCCLs was investigated in an experimental animal model. A tumorigenesis assay was performed on 5 to 6-week old female NOD/SCID mice. Seven of the PLCCLs were tested in early passages and all were able to generate xenografts within 3 weeks after injection. The four cell lines SCLC LC004-P4, LCC LC006-P2, SCC LC021-P2 and AC LC007-P3, were chosen for further studies, propagating subcutaneous bulk tumors in 2/2, 3/3, 2/2 and 2/2 animals, respectively. Moreover, we were able to re-established PLCCLs in vitro from the xenografts taken from these animals (Figure S1). In addition, DNA fingerprinting was useful to track individual cell lines from the xenografts of LC021 (Table S1 and Figure S1).
Based on these results we conclude the PLCCLs with the tumorigenesis capacity in immunodeficient mice can easily and reproducibly be generated from all four subtypes of lung cancer and propagated in in vitro liquid culture.
Secondary xeno-transplantation was performed by implanting subcutaneously pieces of the primary LCC xenograft (LC006) into secondary recipient. Primary recipient transplanted with LC006 cells revealed lung metastasis in addition to subcutaneous tumor. However, in the following serial xeno-transplantations, tumors were formed only subcutaneously. When morphological features of the PLCCL and the serial xenografts and parental tissues were compared, they displayed high similarity supporting the observation that PLCCLs and xenotransplants represent the original tumor.
4. Expression of CSC associated cell surface markers is dynamic in the long-term culture of PLCCLs
To identify subpopulations of putative lung cancer stem cells in the primary cancer cell lines, we investigated the expression of a broad panel of markers previously described as differentially expressed in a variety of human cancer stem cells. Data from six representative PLCCLs analyzed at different passages are given in Table S3. The expression profile revealed a variable pattern with some common features. In two cell lines (SCLC LC004 and SCC LC021) tested repeatedly the phenotype shifted during long term in vitro culture (Table S3). Some markers (CD29, CD49b and CD49f) were uniformly expressed at high levels in all passages and all cell lines studied, while others, such as CD44, CD166 and CD142, showed a higher expression in later compared to earlier passages. The opposite was observed for CD90 and CD326 expression, where the proportion of positive cells diminished with increasing passage number. Interestingly, distinct minor subpopulations expressing CD117, CD184 and CD15 were present in each of the cell lines tested. CD24 and CD326 showed variable expression level in different PLCCLs. The expression of CD133 was low, as tested by two different antibodies, and varied between 0–2.4% confirming the results obtained by IHC.
Thus, the expression level and the frequency of CD44 and/or CD90 positive sub-populations was dynamic, revealing differential expression of the antigens at different time points. These distinct changes that occurred during long-term culture indicate either possible selection of certain sub-populations in long-term culture or response to in vitro culture conditions.
All in all, our results clearly show that multiple cell surface antigens described to be differentially expressed in human CSCs, were also expressed on established PLCCLs, independent of the cancer subtype.
5. CD44high cells from primary SCLC and LCC primary cell lines harbour cells with CSC characteristics
CD44 has been reported as a candidate CSC marker in many types of cancer , , –. All our PLCCLs expressed CD44 (Table S2). The flow cytometry analysis revealed the existence of distinct sub-populations with differential expression of CD44: a small sub-population of CD44high cells could be identified in both the SCLC cell line LC004 and the LCC cell line LC006, representing 6.63% (Figure 3A) or 2.79% of total cells (Figure 3B), respectively. Similar results were obtained for cell lines AC LC007 and SCC LC021 (Percentage of CD44high cells was 6.69% and 14.95%, respectively) (Figure 3C, D). The main cell population was either negative or weakly positive for CD44. To investigate possible functional differences between these subpopulations, CD44high and CD44low/− cells of SCLC LC004 and LCC LC006 were FACS-sorted and tested in several functional assays. The results from the colony formation efficiency assay suggest that CD44high cells from the SCLC LC004 and LCC LC006 cell lines have a significantly higher potential to form colonies compared to CD44low/− cells (data not shown and Figure 4A). The fact that CD44high cells formed bigger colonies suggests that CD44high cells from LC006 cell line proliferate more vigorously and for longer time than cells with low expression or negative for CD44.
A small sub-population of CD44high cells could be identified in the SCLC cell line LC004 (6.63%) (A); the LCC cell line LC006 (2.79%) (B); the AC cell line LC007 (6.69%) (C) and the SCC cell line LC021 (14.95%) (D), respectively. Left panel: isotype control Ab; right panel: CD44 Ab. Data shown are from representative experiments (n>3).
A. Comparison of FACS sorted CD44high and CD44low/− cells from the LCC cell line LC006. Cells were seeded at 200 cells per well and grown in standard 6 well plates for ∼10 days. Upper wells: CD44high cells. Lower wells: CD44low/− cells. B. Comparison of FACS sorted CD44highCD90+ and CD44highCD90− cells from the SCLC cell line LC004 (upper plate) and the LCC cell line LC006 (lower plate). Cells were seeded at 200 cells per well and grown in standard 6 well plates for ∼10 days. In each 6-well plate: upper wells: CD44highCD90+ cells; lower wells: CD44highCD90− cells. X denotes empty wells.
To investigate the proliferative potential of single cancer cells from PLCCLs, we next performed a single cell colony formation assay. Colony formation was observed 7∼10 days following plating. Only the CD44high cells from the two cell lines SCLC LC004 and LCC LC006 were capable of forming a full range of colonies: holoclones, which consisted of tightly packed small cells, paraclones representing loosely packed colonies and meroclones with characteristics between holoclone and paraclone. CD44low/− cells did not form holoclones, but were able to form a few meroclones and paraclones (Figure S2 and Table S4). To further study self-renewal and differentiation potential of cells isolated from the different colony types, the single cell derived colonies were picked, expanded and maintained in common cell culture flasks for long-term serial passages. Only the cells from holoclones, which were derived from the sorted CD44high cells, had potential to maintain in vitro long-term cultures. When re-seeded into the colony assays, these cells formed all three types of colonies. Paraclones and meroclones both from CD44high and CD44low/− sorted cells stopped proliferating after one passage (data not shown).
These results demonstrate that CD44high cells from SCLC and LCC cell lines contain cells with self-renewal and long-term growth potential. These stem cell-like properties were found only in CD44high expressing cells.
We next compared the spheroid formation potential of CD44high and CD44low/− cells under serum-free conditions. Sorted cells were seeded at the concentration of 100 cells per well in ULA 96-well plate. Development of spheroids was evaluated 2 weeks after plating. Seven of ten wells with CD44high cells from the SCLC cell line LC004 and 6/10 wells with CD44high cells from the LCC cell line LC006 were identified with spheroid formation. Wells containing CD44low/− cells from both cell lines did not reveal any formation of spheroids, and the cells eventually died (Figure S3).
Finally, growth curves of cell line LCC LC006 were determined by the CellTiter 96® AQueous One Solution Cell Proliferation Assay. At the highest cell concentration tested (500 cells/well) no significant difference in the proliferation of CD44high and CD44low/− cells was observed (Figure S4). However, when cells were seeded at a lower density (150 cells/well) CD44high cells demonstrated higher proliferative potential compared to CD44low/− cells (Figure S4B). Taken together, these results indicate that CD44high population harbour cells with stem cell-like properties.
6. The CD44highCD90+ phenotype identifies sub-population of cells with stem cell-like properties in the SCLC and LCC
In order to narrow down the phenotype of the CSC population, the expression of additional putative stem cell markers were investigated. The initial analysis of PLCCLs by flow cytometry suggested that both CD44high and CD44low/− populations could be further sub-divided based on CD90 expression, namely CD44highCD90+, CD44highCD90−, CD44low/−CD90+, and CD44low/−CD90− sub-populations (Figure 5). Since CD44low/− population did not seem to contain cells with stem cell properties, CD44low/−CD90+, and CD44low/−CD90− cells were sorted as one CD44low/− population irrespective of CD90 expression. We then repeated the experiments described above, now testing 3 different sub-populations. In the 2D single cell colony forming and heterogeneity assay, only the CD44highCD90+ cells from the SCLC LC004 and LCC LC006 cell lines were able to form all three types of colonies (Figure 4B). Importantly, the cells derived from holoclones of sorted CD44highCD90+ cells maintained long-term in vitro growth and formed all three types of colonies when re-plated. CD44highCD90− cells from the SCLC cell line LC004 gave rise to a single holoclone. This clone, however, did not sustain cell growth for more than one generation (Table S5). Repeatedly, CD44low/− cells from SCLC and LCC cell lines, were able to form only a few meroclones and paraclones, which were not able to sustain a long-term growth in liquid culture and stop proliferating after one passage. These data indicate that CD44high cells from SCLC and LCC cell lines that co-express CD90 have stem cell-like characteristics and sustain cell growth in liquid culture.
Staining by anti-CD44 FITC and anti-CD90 APC. All the cell lines showed heterogeneous staining and could be divided into 4 sub-populations: CD44highCD90+, CD44highCD90−, CD44low/−CD90+ and CD44low/−CD90−. For the SCLC cell line LC004 (A), the frequency of CD44highCD90+ cell was 16.6%, and the CD44highCD90− cells was 8.2%. For the LCC cells line LC006 (B), the frequency of CD44highCD90+ cells was 1.1%, the CD44highCD90− cells was 2.5%. For the AC cell line LC007 (C), the frequency of CD44highCD90+ cells was 9.4%, and the CD44highCD90− cells was 23.4%. For the SCC cell line LC021 (D), the frequency of CD44highCD90+ cells was 2.3%, the CD44highCD90− cells was 1.1%.
Above mentioned cell populations were also tested in the spheroid forming assay. Cell spheroids were detected in 8/10 wells with sorted CD44highCD90+ cells from SCLC LC004 (Figure S5A) and in 8/10 from LCC LC006 (Figure S5B) cell line. In contrast, only 1/10 wells with CD44highCD90− cells of both cell lines formed spheroids. As expected, no spheroids were formed in the wells with CD44low/− cells irrespective of CD90 expression supporting the data from the 2D colony forming assay. These results clearly indicate that the spheroid forming cells are mainly harboured within the CD90+ subpopulation of the CD44high cells.
We also tested the spheroid-forming capacity of the CD44highCD90+, CD44highCD90−and CD44low/− cell populations in the SCC cell line LC021. Here 10/10 wells of CD44highCD90+ cells formed spheroids (Figure S6A), but contrary to the results of the SCLC cell line LC004 and LCC cell line LC006, 9/10 wells with CD44highCD90− cells also formed spheroids (Figure S6B). No spheroids were formed in the wells with CD44low/− cells (Figure S6C). Taken together, these results indicate that cells with stem cell-like characteristics are enriched in the CD44high population also in the SCC cell line LC021. CD90, however, may not enrich further for the cells with stem cell-like properties.
A CD44highCD90+ population was also identified in the AC cell line LC007. However, neither CD44highCD90+, CD44highCD90− nor CD44low/− cells formed spheroids. Since this cell line did not form spheroids under the defined culture conditions, we cannot conclude whether either of the markers, i.e. CD44 and CD90, is a stem cells markers in the tested AC cell line.
7. The CD44highCD90+ sub-population exhibits stem cell and EMT associated gene expression profile in LC004 and LC021 primary cell lines
The observations that some sub-populations sorted based on expression of CD44 and CD90 had stem cell-like properties, prompted us to investigate whether the expression of stem cell related genes, such as Nanog, Oct4 and Sox2, was different in these sub-populations of the cell lines LC004, LC006 and LC021. Detectable expression levels of these genes were found in all the sorted sub-populations. Interestingly, the expression of Nanog, Oct4 and Sox2 were higher in the CD44high population compared to the CD44low/− population in all the examined cell lines (Figure 6). Furthermore, the expression level of Nanog and Oct4 genes was higher in the CD44highCD90+ population compared to the CD44highCD90− population in the cell lines LC004 and LC006 (Figure 6A, B). However, no differences in gene expression levels except Nanog were observed between CD44highCD90+ and CD44highCD90− populations in the LC021 cell line (Figure 6C).
Detectable expression levels of the genes were found in all sorted sub-populations from the cell lines LC004 (A), LC006 (B) and LC021 (C). PCR reaction without template served as a negative control. The relative expression of target genes was related to the expression of PGK1 and normalized to the unsorted control cells. X axis shows the target genes, Y axis shows the relative expression level (RQ). The error bars reflect the variation within the triplicates, P<0.05. (B). The FACS sorted cell sub-populations derived from the cell line LC006 were cultured in the serum-free culture system for 1–2 weeks and revealed different cell morphology for different sorted sub-populations: (a) CD44highCD90+ cells; (b) CD44highCD90− cells; (c) CD44low/−CD90+ cells, and (d) CD44low/−CD90− cells. Photomicrograph magnification, ×200.
CSCs are proposed to play an important role in cancer invasion and metastasis seeding. Increasing evidence shows that epithelial-mesenchymal transition may impose stem cell characteristics on tumour cells, and accordingly, stem cell-like cells from carcinomas have a mesenchymal phenotype and express markers associated with EMT . Culture of the different sorted cell populations derived from the LC006 cell line in our serum-free culture system shows that the sorted cell populations display different cell morphologies (Figure 6B). For example, the CD44highCD90+ and CD44highCD90− cells have a mesenchymal morphology, while the CD44low/−CD90+ and CD44low/−CD90− cells grow as cobblestones, a hallmark of epithelial cells. Therefore, we examined the expression profiles of EMT associated genes N-Cadherin, E-Cadherin, Vimentin, and HMGA2 in the sorted sub-populations from the cell lines LC004, LC006 and LC021. Interestingly, higher expression of the mesenchymal marker genes N-Cadherin, Vimentin and HMGA2, accompanied by a decreased expression for the epithelial marker gene E-Cadherin was found in the CD44high population compared to the CD44low/− population in all three cell lines (Figure 6A, B, C). The expression level of N-Cadherin and Vimentin were higher in the CD44highCD90+ population compared to the CD44highCD90− population from the cell lines LC004 and LC021 (Figure 6A, C), however, this was not the case for the same populations derived from the cell line LC006 (Figure 6B). The expression level of HMGA2 was higher in the CD44highCD90+ population compared to the CD44highCD90− population in the cell line LC004 (Figure 6A), no difference was observed between the subpopulations CD44highCD90+ and CD44highCD90− of the cell lines LC006 and LC021 (Figure 6B, C).
Altogether, our results of stem cell and EMT associated gene expression profile indicate a higher stem cell-like potential for the CD44high population for all the examined cell lines. Co-expression of CD90 further enriched putative lung CSCs in the cell lines LC004 and LC006.
8. CD44highCD90+ cells from LCC primary cell line display the highest resistance to radiotherapy
The resistance to irradiation of CD44high and CD44low/− cells from the LCC cell line LC006 was compared in an X-ray radiation resistance assay. Five days post irradiation with different doses, CellTiter 96® AQueous One Solution Cell Proliferation Assay was performed to compare the difference in cell proliferation of irradiated monolayer cultures from different cell sub-populations. The inhibition ratio of X-ray to the cells was calculated. The CD44high cells were more resistant to irradiation at each dose tested (Figure 7A). To investigate whether resistance to irradiation was associated with the CD44highCD90+ phenotype, the same assay was applied to determine the relative resistance to irradiation of the four cell populations derived from the same cell line. Among the four sub-populations, CD44highCD90+ cells displayed the highest resistance to irradiation at each dose tested (Figure 7B). This result further supports the notion that CD44highCD90+ population is enriched for putative lung CSCs.
The relative resistance to irradiation of the FACS sorted CD44high and CD44low/− cells derived from the LCC cell line LC006 was compared in an X-ray radiation resistance assay. The inhibition ratios were compared among the different cell populations after irradiating the monolayer cultures at 1, 2, 3 and 4Gy. The CD44high cells displayed the higher resistance to X-ray radiation at each dose tested. P<0.01. B. relative resistance to irradiation of the four different FACS sorted cell populations derived from the LCC cell line LC006 was compared in an X-ray radiation resistance assay. Four populations: CD44highCD90+, CD44highCD90−, CD44low/−CD90+ and CD44low/−CD90− cells were sorted into 96-well plates at 500 cells per well in 10 replicates. The inhibition ratios were compared among the four sub-populations after irradiation of the monolayer layer of the cultures at 1, 2 and 4Gy. The CD44highCD90+ cells displayed the highest resistance to irradiation at 2 and 4G. P<0.01.
9. The primary cell lines from long-term cultures changed their morphological features and the phenotype with time
In order to study the potential changes of established primary cell lines during long-term culture in vitro, we monitored the morphology and phenotype in the cell lines LC004 and LC021 at different passages. Although these primary lung cancer cell lines can successfully sustain long-term in vitro culture (the longest passage so far is over 30 generations of LC006) without growth decline, we observed certain changes in cell morphology. Cells from the first several passages demonstrated predominantly epithelial-like morphology, and then, the cells showed the change to mesenchymal features. Thereafter, shift towards more stressed epithelial-like morphology was observed following prolonged in vitro liquid culture.
We further employed flow cytometry to monitor phenotypic changes of the LC004 and LC021 cells at different passages, focusing on the CD44 and CD90 expression. In early passages (within passage 5), the cultured primary lung cancer cells maintained a sub-population of CD44highCD90+ cells. In later passages, the expression level of the CD44high cells markedly increased while the expression level of CD90 decreased. The majority of the cells thus moved to the CD44highCD90− region (Figure S7 A, B).
Concomitant with the changes in phenotype, cells from early passages demonstrated better colony forming potential compared to cells from later passages, corresponding to the decrease in the CD44highCD90+ subset from the prolonged culture (Figure S7 A, B).
The changes of morphology and phenotype during passaging of the cell lines may be caused by selection of certain sub-populations with distinct properties in an in vitro culture environment.
Tumor growth is hypothesized to depend on CSCs within a tumor, which shares the similar self-renewal function and capacity to generate differentiated cells with their normal stem cell counterparts. These cells can be identified by tumor stem cell associated antigens and other markers. Identification of reliable markers for CSC/TIC, which can be detected by robust tests such as flow cytometry using monoclonal antibodies, may open new opportunities for early diagnosis and staging, as well as the identification of novel targets leading to improvement of treatment for cancer in the clinic. By the use of different surface markers, CSCs/TICs have been identified in a variety of human cancers including acute myeloid leukemia, brain tumor, breast cancer, colon cancer, pancreatic cancer and prostate cancer –.
In 2005, bronchioalveolar stem cells (BASCs) localized at the bronchioalveolar duct junction were identified as the tumor initiating cells for adenocarcinoma in a mouse model . Recent attempts to identify lung CSCs in humans have suggested that CD133  and also CD44 independently  could define a cell population with CSC characteristics. Later, several lines of evidence indicated that the ability of CD133 expression to discriminate lung CSCs may have been overestimated . This is in line with our own observations showing that CD133 expression on lung cancer cell lines may be gained upon culture of sorted CD133 negative subpopulations and lost upon culture of CD133 positive subpopulation (Ping et al. unpublished). In the present study we accordingly focused on differential expression of CD44 in 4 representative primary cancer cell lines established from freshly resected tumors.
In order not to be restricted by the low number of cells available from surgical specimens and to be able to perform consecutive and repeated experiments on cancer cells derived from the same primary sample, we choose to study primary cell lines, which may also more accurately represent the situation in the patient compared to cell lines that have been established decades ago. In the present study, we successfully established a panel of novel cell lines from the primary cultures directly from different subtypes of freshly resected primary lung tumors. We used early passages of the generated cell lines to isolate phenotypically distinct sub-populations with stem cell features from these cell lines.
CD44 has been identified as a CSC marker for many cancer types, including breast cancer , prostate cancer , colorectal cancer  and lung cancer . Flow cytometry and immunohistochemistry analyses showed that all the primary cultured lung cancer cell lines expressed CD44, but with marked differences in intensities and frequencies. A series of experiments aimed to evaluate whether lung CSCs could be enriched by the expression of CD44, demonstrated that CD44high cells always showed a stronger proliferative potential than CD44low/− cells, and only CD44high cells in the LC004 and LC006 cell lines were enriched in cells that could form holoclones, meroclones and paraclones reported to be associated with cancer stem cells . The CD44high cells could form cell spheroids, whereas CD44low/− cells lacked this potential. Moreover, the CD44high sub-population showed a more mesenchymal morphology than the CD44low/− population. Together these results indicated that CD44high expression was associated with several stem cell characteristics in cell lines both from primary SCLC and LCC. These results confirm and extend the finding reported recently , which were mainly based on studies of established non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) cell lines. We did not investigate the potential co-expression of CD133 on the CD44high subpopulation. Such a co-expression might have solved the apparent controversy regarding the role of these two markers on lung cancer stem cells. The main reason for not doing so was the absence of CD133 expression in the surgical samples and the corresponding low or absent expression in the early passages of the cell lines derived from these samples.
CD90 is a marker expressed in mesenchymal stem cell  and liver cancer stem cell . We found that it is also expressed in the primary lung cancer cell lines. By further co-staining with CD44 and CD90, all four representative primary cultured lung cancer cell lines could be divided into 4 heterogeneous sub-populations: CD44highCD90+, CD44low/−CD90+, CD44highCD90− and CD44low/−CD90− cell populations. In the SCLC cell line LC004 and the LCC cell line LC006, CD44highCD90+ cells had much stronger colony and spheroid forming potential. The self-renewal and differentiation analysis, demonstrated that only CD44highCD90+ cells were capable of forming holo-, mero- and paraclones. All the holoclones from CD44highCD90+ cells could be serially passaged and were capable of giving rise to all the same set of clones, while the only holoclone developed from CD44highCD90− cells was only able to sustain one generation. These results indicate that CD44highCD90+ cells may be able to undergo asymmetric divisions, giving rise to mature cells with a limited life span . Fitting with the other findings, CD44highCD90+ cells in the LCC cell line LC006 also showed the highest level of resistance to irradiation. For the lung squamous cancer cell line LC021, CD44high expression alone may be a stem cell marker, since no further enrichment for colony formation or clonal growth was observed when CD90 was included. For the AC cell line LC007, only marginal differences in colony formation was observed in the four different sub-populations (data not shown). We are therefore unable to make any firm conclusion about the role of CD44 or CD90 as CSC marker in AC. Taken together, these result therefore indicate that CSCs in the four main subtypes may differ considerably in their phenotype.
Increasing evidence shows a direct link between the EMT and CSCs. Both EMT and CSC are implicated in the generation of invasive cells and formation of distant metastases. Furthermore, CSCs have been found to express EMT associated genes in addition to stemness associated genes . Our observation that CD44high cells exhibited an increased expression of EMT associated genes indicates that CD44high cells may play a key role in progression of SCLC and LCC. Interestingly, CD44+CD90+ cells isolated from human hepatocellular carcinomas demonstrated a more aggressive phenotype than single positive, here CD90+/CD44− cells, forming more metastatic lung lesions in immunodeficient mice , indicating an important role of CD44 also in this type of cancer. The high mobility group A2 gene (HMGA2) is abundantly expressed in embryonic stem cells . Aberrant re-expression of HMGA2 is correlated with tumor aggressiveness in a variety of human cancers , . Furthermore, there is an increased expression of HMGA2 in cancer cells with stem cell characteristics, and the expression increase upon EMT –. In our study, the expression of HMGA2 was increased in the CD44high population compared to the CD44low/− population in three cell lines investigated, consistent with the increase of other EMT associated genes and stem cell related genes in this population.
In CSC research, established cancer cell lines are widely used to isolate and identify CSCs. Although it is relatively easy to use established cancer cell lines that have been grown for a long time in vitro, the CSCs identified in such cell lines may not truly reflect all biological features of primary CSC due to culture adaptation and genetic alterations taking place during long-term culture under hyperoxic culture conditions. The robust method for generating such primary cell lines from surgical specimens of lung cancer and identification of lung CSCs in these cell lines may provide a valuable and unique tool for further studies. With more reliable biomarkers available, these cell lines can also be used for screening of panels of different drugs targeting CSC related pathways.
The flow cytometry analysis of xeno-cell line LC021. Xeno-cell line LC021 displayed a hierarchical organization similar to that found in primary cultures, CD44highCD90+ cells were found in xeno-cell line LC021. Anti-Tra-1-85 Ab was used to gate human cells; Anti-H2Kd Ab was used to gate mouse cells.
Clonal heterogeneity assay of sorted cell populations from the cell lines LC004 and LC006. Sorted cells were cultured under serum-free condition for 2 weeks after seeding of 1 single cell per well in 96-well standard plate. Two weeks later, heterogeneous colonies of distinct morphologies were identified in CD44high cell populations from the SCLC cell line LC004 (A) and the LCC cell line LC006 (B). Left column: Typical holoclones which are generally more round and tightly packed composed of homogenous cells. Middle column: meroclones which are colonies made of cells of intermediate morphology and cell numbers. Right column: paraclones which are irregular in shape and contain fewer and more elongated or flattened cells. Representative colony images were acquired at 100×.
Potential of sorted CD44high and CD44low/− cells to form spheroids under serum-free culture condition. Cells were seeded at 100 cells per well in ULA 96-well under serum-free condition. CD44high cells of the SCLC cell line LC004 (A) and the LCC cell line LC006 (C) developed cell spheroids 7–10 days after plating, while CD44low/− cells from both cell line LC004 (B) and LC006 (D) formed no spheroids. The assay was repeated twice with similar results. The photomicrograph shows representative sections of the wells. Photomicrograph magnification 200×.
Proliferation of CD44high and CD44low/− cells from the PLCCL LC006 at different cell concentrations and different time points. A. Proliferation of sorted CD44high (blue line) and CD44low/− (purple line) cells seeded at 500 cells per well in 96 well plate. B. Proliferation of sorted CD44high and CD44low/− cell populations seeded at 150 cells per well under identical culture conditions. Data represent the mean value of at least three wells.
Potential of sorted sub-populations from LC004 and LC006 PLCCLs to form spheroids under serum-free culture condition. Four populations were sorted based on expression of CD44 and CD90 surface markers. Results are shown only for the CD44highCD90+ sub-population that had the potential to form spheroids. Sorted cells were seeded at 100 cells per well in ULA 96-well under serum-free condition. Cell spheroids were formed only in wells with CD44highCD90+ cells from LC004 (A) and from LC006 (B). Photomicrograph magnification 200×.
Comparison of cell spheroid formation of different sub-populations from the LC021 under serum-free condition. CD44highCD90+, CD44highCD90− and CD44low/− cell populations were sorted from the SCC cell line LC021. Spheroids were formed by CD44highCD90+ cells (A) and by CD44highCD90− cells (B). None of spheroids was formed by CD44low/− cells (C). Photomicrograph magnification 200×.
Morphological and phenotypic changes of PLCCLs LC004 and LC021 upon long-term in vitro culture. A. Monitoring of the morphology and phenotype of the cell line LC004 at different passages upon long-term in vitro culture. a. In early passages, the cultured cells predominantly demonstrated mesenchymal morphology, while a shift towards a more stressed epithelial-like morphology was observed following prolonged in vitro culture in serum free medium. Photomicrograph magnification 200×. b. Monitoring of the phenotypical changes of the LC004 cells at different passages, based on the expression level of CD44 and CD90 by flow cytometry. c. The charts showing the changes of phenotype (upper left and right), colony forming efficiency (lower left) and propagation (lower right) of the LC004 cells upon long term in vitro culture. B. Monitoring of the morphology and phenotype of the cell line LC021 at different passages upon long-term culture in vitro. a. Monitoring of the phenotypical changes of the LC004 and LC021 cells at different passages based on expression of CD44 and CD90 by flow cytometry. b. The charts show the changes of phenotype (upper left and right), colony forming efficiency (lower left) and propergation (lower right) of the LC021 cells upon long term in vitro culture.
Summary of immunoshistochemical analysis of P53, Ber-EP4, and CD44 of PLCCLs and their corresponding parental tumor tissue.
Expression of a broad panel of cancer stem cell associated markers analyzed in six representative cell lines at different passages.
Single cell 2D colony forming and heterogeneity assay.
We thank Ingjerd Solvoll from the Pulmonary Biobank project at Radiumhospitalet for her assistance in collection of tumor samples and clinical data; Dr. Lars Jørgensen from the Thoracic Surgery Department at Rikshospitalet for the assistance in obtaining tumor samples; Anna Berit Wennerstrøm and Menaka Sathermugathevan from SFI-CAST for their assistance with the long-term cultures; Karen-Marie Heintz from Tumorbiology at Radiumhospitalet for her assistance in performing DNA fingerprinting assay. This work was supported by the Cancer Stem Cell Innovation Centre (SFI-CAST).
Conceived and designed the experiments: PW QG GG LM. Performed the experiments: PW QG EM MW NW. Analyzed the data: PW QG ZS EM NW GG. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: PW QG ZS EM SS LM GK GG. Wrote the paper: PW GK GG.
- 1. Lapidot T, Sirard C, Vormoor J, Murdoch B, Hoang T, et al. (1994) A cell initiating human acute myeloid leukaemia after transplantation into SCID mice. Nature 367: 645–648.
- 2. Bhatia M, Wang JCY, Kapp U, Bonnet D, Dick JE (1997) Purification of primitive human hematopoietic cells capable of repopulating immune-deficient mice. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 94: 5320–5325.
- 3. Dalerba P, Dylla SJ, Park IK, Liu R, Wang X, et al. (2007) Phenotypic characterization of human colorectal cancer stem cells. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 104: 10158–10163.
- 4. Al-Hajj M, Wicha MS, ito-Hernandez A, Morrison SJ, Clarke MF (2003) Prospective identification of tumorigenic breast cancer cells. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 100: 3983–3988.
- 5. Hermann PC, Huber SL, Herrler T, Aicher A, Ellwart JW, et al. (2007) Distinct Populations of Cancer Stem Cells Determine Tumor Growth and Metastatic Activity in Human Pancreatic Cancer. Cell Stem Cell 1: 313–323.
- 6. Singh SK, Hawkins C, Clarke ID, Squire JA, Bayani J, et al. (2004) Identification of human brain tumour initiating cells. Nature 432: 396–401.
- 7. O'Brien CA, Pollett A, Gallinger S, Dick JE (2007) A human colon cancer cell capable of initiating tumour growth in immunodeficient mice. Nature 445: 106–110.
- 8. Ricci-Vitiani L, Lombardi DG, Pilozzi E, Biffoni M, Todaro M, et al. (2007) Identification and expansion of human colon-cancer-initiating cells. Nature 445: 111–115.
- 9. Prince ME, Sivanandan R, Kaczorowski A, Wolf GT, Kaplan MJ, et al. (2007) Identification of a subpopulation of cells with cancer stem cell properties in head and neck squamous cell carcinoma. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 104: 973–978.
- 10. Li C, Heidt D, Dalerba P, Burant CF, Zhang L, et al. (2007) Identification of pancreatic cancer stem cells. Cancer Res 67: 1030–1037. 10(1158/0008-5472): CAN–06-2030.
- 11. Collins AT, Berry PA, Hyde C, Stower MJ, Maitland NJ (2005) Prospective Identification of Tumorigenic Prostate Cancer Stem Cells. Cancer Research 65: 10946–10951.
- 12. Hay ED (1995) An overview of epithelio-mesenchymal transformation. Acta Anat (Basel) 154: 8–20.
- 13. Thiery JP (2002) Epithelial-mesenchymal transitions in tumour progression. Nat Rev Cancer 2: 442–454.
- 14. Ding W, You H, Dang H, LeBlanc F, Galicia V, et al. (2010) Epithelial-to-mesenchymal transition of murine liver tumor cells promotes invasion. Hepatology 52: 945–953.
- 15. Mani SA, Guo W, Liao MJ, Eaton EN, Ayyanan A, et al. (2008) The epithelial-mesenchymal transition generates cells with properties of stem cells. Cell 133: 704–715.
- 16. Sethi S, Macoska J, Chen W, Sarkar FH (2010) Molecular signature of epithelial-mesenchymal transition (EMT) in human prostate cancer bone metastasis. Am J Transl Res 3: 90–99.
- 17. Du Z, Qin R, Wei C, Wang M, Shi C, et al.. (2010) Pancreatic Cancer Cells Resistant to Chemoradiotherapy Rich in “Stem-Cell-Like” Tumor Cells. Dig Dis Sci.
- 18. Eramo A, Lotti F, Sette G, Pilozzi E, Biffoni M, et al. (2008) Identification and expansion of the tumorigenic lung cancer stem cell population. Cell Death Differ 15: 504–514.
- 19. Sullivan JP, Minna JD, Shay JW (2010) Evidence for self-renewing lung cancer stem cells and their implications in tumor initiation, progression, and targeted therapy. Cancer Metastasis Rev 29: 61–72.
- 20. Takaishi S, Okumura T, Wang TC (2008) Gastric cancer stem cells. J Clin Oncol 26: 2876–2882.
- 21. Capes-Davis A, Theodosopoulos G, Atkin I, Drexler HG, Kohara A, et al. (2010) Check your cultures! A list of cross-contaminated or misidentified cell lines. International Journal of Cancer 127: 1–8.
- 22. Hollstein M, Sidransky D, Vogelstein B, Harris CC (1991) p53 mutations in human cancers. Science 253: 49–53.
- 23. Kim CF, Jackson EL, Woolfenden AE, Lawrence S, Babar I, et al. (2005) Identification of bronchioalveolar stem cells in normal lung and lung cancer. Cell 121: 823–835.
- 24. Leung EL, Fiscus RR, Tung JW, Tin VP, Cheng LC, et al. (2010) Non-Small Cell Lung Cancer Cells Expressing CD44 Are Enriched for Stem Cell-Like Properties. PLoS One 5: e14062.
- 25. Li H, Chen X, Calhoun-Davis T, Claypool K, Tang DG (2008) PC3 Human Prostate Carcinoma Cell Holoclones Contain Self-renewing Tumor-Initiating Cells. Cancer Research 68: 1820–1825.
- 26. Dominici M, Le Blanc K, Mueller I, Slaper-Cortenbach I, Marini F, et al. (2006) Minimal criteria for defining multipotent mesenchymal stromal cells. The International Society for Cellular Therapy position statement. Cytotherapy 8: 315–317.
- 27. Yang ZF, Ho DW, Ng MN, Lau CK, Yu WC, et al. (2008) Significance of CD90+ Cancer Stem Cells in Human Liver Cancer. Cancer Cell 13: 153–166.
- 28. Morrison SJ, Kimble J (2006) Asymmetric and symmetric stem-cell divisions in development and cancer. Nature 441: 1068–1074.
- 29. Li O, Li J, Droge P (2007) DNA architectural factor and proto-oncogene HMGA2 regulates key developmental genes in pluripotent human embryonic stem cells. FEBS Letters 581: 3533–3537.
- 30. Di Cello F, Hillion J, Hristov A, Wood LJ, Mukherjee M, et al. (2008) HMGA2 Participates in Transformation in Human Lung Cancer. Molecular Cancer Research 6: 743–750.
- 31. Sarhadi VK, Wikman H, Salmenkivi K, Kuosma E, Sioris T, et al. (2006) Increased expression of high mobility group A proteins in lung cancer. The Journal of Pathology 209: 206–212.
- 32. Watanabe S, Ueda Y, Akaboshi Si, Hino Y, Sekita Y, et al. (2009) HMGA2 Maintains Oncogenic RAS-Induced Epithelial-Mesenchymal Transition in Human Pancreatic Cancer Cells. The American Journal of Pathology 174: 854–868.
- 33. Thuault S, Valcourt U, Petersen M, Manfioletti G, Heldin CH, et al. (2006) Transforming growth factor- β employs HMGA2 to elicit epithelial-mesenchymal transition. The Journal of Cell Biology 174: 175–183.