Skip to main content
Advertisement
  • Loading metrics

Protecting streams in urban catchments from excess runoff: International examples of stormwater target guidance and implementation

  • Geoff J. Vietz ,

    Roles Conceptualization, Data curation, Formal analysis, Investigation, Methodology, Visualization, Writing – original draft, Writing – review & editing

    geoff@streamology.com.au

    Affiliation Streamology Pty Ltd, Melbourne, Australia

    ⨯
  • Kathryn L. Russell,

    Roles Conceptualization, Formal analysis, Investigation, Methodology, Writing – original draft, Writing – review & editing

    Affiliation School of Agriculture, Food and Ecosystem Sciences, The University of Melbourne, Richmond, Australia

    ⨯
  • Ryan J. Winston,

    Roles Conceptualization, Writing – original draft, Writing – review & editing

    Affiliations Department of Food, Agricultural, and Biological Engineering, Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio, United States of America, Department of Civil, Environmental, and Geodetic Engineering, Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio, United States of America

    ⨯
  • Hermann L. Paulenz,

    Roles Writing – original draft, Writing – review & editing

    Affiliation Behörde für Umwelt, Klima, Energie and Agrarwirtschaft, Hamburg, Germany

    ⨯
  • Birgit Jordan,

    Roles Writing – original draft, Writing – review & editing

    Affiliation Streamology Pty Ltd, Melbourne, Australia

    ⨯
  • Kira Woods,

    Roles Conceptualization, Methodology, Visualization, Writing – original draft, Writing – review & editing

    Affiliation Streamology Pty Ltd, Melbourne, Australia

    ⨯
  • Rodney P. Ubrihien,

    Roles Conceptualization, Writing – original draft, Writing – review & editing

    Affiliation Centre for Applied Water Science, University of Canberra, Bruce, Australian Capital Territory, Australia

    ⨯
  • Lucy Peljo,

    Roles Writing – original draft

    Affiliation Brisbane, Australia

    ⨯
  • Scott A. McKendrick

    Roles Conceptualization, Writing – original draft, Writing – review & editing

    Affiliation School of Agriculture, Food and Ecosystem Sciences, The University of Melbourne, Richmond, Australia

    ⨯

Abstract

Excess stormwater from cities and suburbs is recognised as the dominant driver of waterway degradation in urban and urbanising catchments, including the loss of aquatic ecosystems and societal values. Global academic evidence makes the case for streamflow targets for waterway protection. The focus for management in these cities and suburbs is moving beyond target pollutant concentrations or loads (e.g., from wastewater or industry) to consider stormwater runoff quantity targets, i.e., addressing excess stormwater impacts. Despite some applications of stormwater targets worldwide, the application is inconsistent, contentious and commonly contested (often during development phases), leaving waterways vulnerable to unabated excess runoff and often irreversible negative impacts. Given global levels of urban development, and loss of freshwater systems, there is an urgent need for flow targets that protect waterway values through guidance to reduce stormwater quantity from urban areas while concurrently increasing groundwater recharge (e.g., to sustain baseflow) and evapotranspiration. This paper is structured to address four questions: (1) What do stormwater targets and guidance look like?, (2) What are the impediments to the development of targets?, (3) What are the impediments to implementation of targets?, and (4) What are the research gaps? With examples from Australia, Germany and the United States, we conclude that there is adequate knowledge and technical understanding, and ultimately stormwater targets must balance completeness of the underlying concepts, social tolerance, and simplicity of application by designers and regulators. The main impediment to the future of healthy waterways in developing and developed urban areas is inadequate policy and political will. Thus, there is an important role for decision makers in this space to shift the current paradigm towards water sensitive cities and a need for clear, enforceable stormwater targets — supported by adequate guidance, governance and capacity — to protect waterways in urban catchments.

Introduction

With a global urban population projected to reach 6.6 billion by 2050, urban catchments are under increasing stress, and climate change is exacerbating the problem [1,2]. Catchment urbanisation results in almost universal negative physical, ecological, and social impacts on streams [3], wetlands [4] and the urban environment [5, Fig 1]. The effects of urbanisation on runoff, and consequently on streamflow, are well-known worldwide as the ‘urban stream syndrome’ [6–8]. One of the most defining characteristics is the increased volume and rate of stormwater to receiving waters resulting in flashy stream hydraulics and channel incision, alongside water quality changes due to contaminants and thermal alteration [9–11].

thumbnail
Fig 1. The relationship between stormwater volumes and the health of waterways and bays applies universally across urban areas (Streamology and Ooid Scientific).

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pwat.0000390.g001

Historically, stormwater management has focused on eliminating nuisance, pluvial flooding of urban surfaces and mitigating fluvial flooding downstream. In recent decades, ameliorating water quality became a focus within stormwater management (e.g., Australian Best Practice Environmental Management (BPEM), United States Total Maximum Daily Loads (TMDL) [12,13]. However, these approaches have done little to provide appropriate hydrologic regimes for freshwater ecosystems and transformation of urban stormwater treatment schemes is urgently needed to protect stream health [14–16]. In simple form, the essential requirements of ecologically-sensitive stormwater design standards are to restore: (1) runoff frequency (and timing), (2) groundwater recharge, ultimately provisioning baseflow, and (3) total annual volume from an urban area to near their natural levels [17,18]. This would mitigate impacts to hydraulic and geomorphic processes while concurrently reducing pollutant loads, thus addressing multiple aspects of the urban stream syndrome [19].

Urban stormwater poses an environmental flow problem [20] requiring maximum limits on streamflow, which is inverse of more ‘normal’ environmental flow problems which require augmenting streamflows [21]. Urban runoff delivered through conventional drainage systems is a complex environmental flow problem that can, in large part, be solved through harvesting or infiltrating and filtering (capturing and slowly releasing) stormwater before it reaches aquatic ecosystems [17]. This ensures total flow volumes are reduced, and that groundwater is recharged to provide baseflow to streams while limiting the occurrence of critical discharge during higher flows [22]. Approaches to address the urban stream syndrome — such as Water Sensitive Urban Design (WSUD), Low Impact Development (LID), Sustainable Urban Drainage Systems (SUDS) or Integrated Water Management [23–25] — generally aim to restore aspects of the pre-development water cycle. This includes reducing flood runoff [26,27], stormwater harvesting and reuse for domestic, agricultural and industrial demands (e.g., [28,29]), infiltration to promote groundwater recharge (e.g., [30]), and increasing evaporation and transpiration (e.g., [31]), all of which reduce the runoff component of the urban water balance.

Yet, despite improvements in the management of stormwater over the last several decades, current practice worldwide is commonly insufficient either in terms of guidance, implementation or outcomes to address common urban hydrologic stresses [20,32–35]. The business-as-usual approach to stormwater management has numerous unaccounted costs [36], including impacts to stream health, public health, and infrastructure. There is an urgent need to inform urban development at a range of scales, including at the catchment, precinct or lot scale, to address stormwater runoff and reduce urban streamflow impacts on the values of streams [37]. With more than a decade of understanding of the problem, progress has been slow toward these pragmatic goals, as stated by Fletcher et al. [18, p.4]:

“While there is agreement on the merits of protecting and restoring more natural flow regimes in urban and urbanizing catchments, stormwater managers need guidance on how to achieve such an objective. Such guidance requires the development of explicit links between components of the flow regime and ecological and geomorphic values, selection of appropriate flow metrics, and specification of performance targets.”

Stormwater targets are required for engineers to design the most effective stormwater management features to protect streams. But how do we develop quantitative targets that are digestible and enforceable for engineers, developers, regulators, and policy professionals at a range of scales?

This paper captures the current status of stormwater targets from development to implementation, for greenfield (developing) and brownfield (developed) catchments. Inspired, and structured, by the International Symposium on Urbanization and Stream Ecology (SUSE) workshop collaborations through an international cohort of water professionals, the paper incorporates perspectives and examples from Australia, North America, and Europe. Achieving stream protection will be more likely given a consistent understanding of the types of stormwater quantity targets, recognition of the technical and implementation challenges that currently curtail efforts, and a consensus on a path forward.

Methods

The genesis of this paper was a workshop conducted during the sixth international Symposium on Urbanization and Stream Ecology (SUSE6), held at Queensland University of Technology, Brisbane, Australia, from the 29th of May to the 1st of June, 2023. This conference brought together researchers, managers and industry professionals across multiple water-related disciplines from across the globe and represented the focused experience and geographic diversity required to holistically consider this topic. The 16 workshop attendees represented disciplines from hydrology, geomorphology, water quality, ecology, stormwater engineering, and planning, and represented experience from five countries (Australia, Germany, New Zealand, Singapore, and the United States of America).

During the conference, two workshop sessions were held. The first session established a common understanding of what we refer to as stormwater targets, before developing and confirming four questions (Fig 2) that structured the workshop and ultimately the work herein. The second session used this structure with four breakout groups working on each of the questions, reporting back to the broader group, and tabulating findings.

thumbnail
Fig 2. Nexus for developing and implementing stormwater targets to protect urban waterways.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pwat.0000390.g002

Subsequently, we (a subset of workshop attendees) developed this review of stormwater targets, influenced by both the material discussed and produced at the workshop, and a review of published and grey literature on the topic. Geographically, our scope was limited to jurisdictions where we had familiarity with relevant legislation, policies and guidance documents (Australia, Germany and the United States). Key papers in the academic and grey literature (e.g., local council, state and territory government, and federal government policy guidelines) were reviewed to identify current approaches to stormwater targets, technical and implementation challenges, and pathways to move towards successful and effective stormwater targets. Rather than a comprehensive systematic review of the academic literature, the work contrasts and draws lessons from different approaches to stormwater targets in several developed western countries around the world.

What types of stormwater targets exist?

The current status of stormwater flow guidance in the regions we studied covered a broad range of guidance types, from policy to look up charts or mapped datasets, to design guidance, with justification for stormwater targets based on protection of values (Fig 3).

thumbnail
Fig 3. Summary of worldwide stormwater target guidance.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pwat.0000390.g003

Our focus in this section is on examples of types of targets currently implemented around the world, with a focus on Australia, Germany and the United States (Table 1). Their diversity is unsurprising given the range of urban design paradigms that exist globally [38] and the landscape settings they occur in. For example, stormwater impacts can be compounded in combined sewer areas, where wet weather overflows have more serious water quality and public health impacts than stormwater from separate sewer systems [39]. In such cases (e.g., the German cities of Berlin, Munich and Hamburg or the American cities of New York, Chicago, and Cleveland), limiting stormwater quantity serves the dual purpose of protecting streams and maintaining the capacity of sewers for sanitary purposes [40]. In other cases, infiltration and inflow of stormwater into aging separate sanitary sewers may similarly cause sewage overflows, with cities such as Columbus, Ohio, using sanitary sewer lining in conjunction with green infrastructure at the sewershed scale to reduce these sanitary sewer overflows (SSO; [41]). In most American and Australian cities, stormwater quantity targets serve to limit efficient delivery of runoff to streams through separate storm sewer systems, thus addressing the ecological and societal impacts of increased streamflow peaks, volumes, and flashiness [42].

thumbnail
Table 1. Types of stormwater targets with selected examples.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pwat.0000390.t001

Types of streamflow targets range in complexity (Table 1), from simple impervious area or stormwater connection limits (e.g., Berlin; [43]), to the comprehensive assessment of a suite of flow metrics (e.g., urban streamflow impact assessment; Kermode et al. 2021). Assessing a suite of flow metrics is similar to a functional flow assessment for environmental water requirements in non-urban contexts (e.g., [44]). We provide the first version of a taxonomy of these types.

Intermediate options include guidance on rainfall depth interception or flow volume to capture and reuse or infiltrate, peak flow targets, and flow-duration-curve (FDC) matching approaches [45]. For example, in the Australian Capital Territory, two options of differing complexity are available for calculation of onsite stormwater retention requirements [45]. Either a fixed 1.4 kL of storage volume per 100 square metres of total impervious area can be adopted, or the designer must capture the runoff from the first 15 mm of rainfall for a specific development arrangement.

The range in stormwater target complexity reflects the balance that is struck between the completeness of the conceptual model behind the targets, the scientific rigour with which the linkages in that conceptual model are defined, the social tolerance for degradation of natural flow regimes and ecosystems, and the simplicity of application by designers and regulators. Balancing these complexities requires an integrated understanding of ecohydromorphic science (i.e., research into physical changes to flow and stream channel morphology and their ecological effects), social dimensions of stream degradation and protection, and the institutional landscape that implements and regulates stormwater design to more effectively set and apply targets [58].

Types of targets may be defined in absolute terms (e.g., capture, infiltrate, or evapotranspire the first X mm of rainfall, limit directly connected imperviousness to Y%) or relative to pre-urban conditions (e.g., maintain flow volume within X% of pre-urban level, flow duration curve matching, or peak flow mitigation to pre-development conditions). Alternatively, they may be defined relative to a baseline scenario, such as to a business-as-usual stormwater management condition. Defining absolute targets is potentially simpler to implement but care is needed to ensure their scientific basis stands up to scrutiny. The quantum of targets can vary spatially, as defined by different climate zones or soil types, to provide simple guidance that is sensitive to local conditions (e.g., Melbourne, Australia; see Table 1). Stormwater targets for protection of ecological values can also depend on existing ecological condition. For example, Melbourne, Australia’s stormwater infiltration and harvesting targets are much more stringent in priority areas which are defined by spatially-explicit ecological modelling of stormwater reduction benefits for biological conditions [59].

Justification for stormwater targets is often based on high-level goals such as ensuring good governance, increasing community capital or providing ecological services [60], or alignment with a high-level vision, such as moving toward a water sensitive city [61], in line with institutional and community priorities. The targets we refer to in Table 1 are the quantitative targets placed on the amount of stormwater discharged from urban settings which are guided by these high-level goals, particularly those which relate to limiting the impact of stormwater on stream health [62]. In general, targets in stormwater policy could be differentiated as site scale or stream-scale targets (see Table 1). Site-scale targets, such as connection limits, rainfall depth intercepted, or retention/detention storage capacity, can easily be connected to design of site-scale stormwater management infrastructure. Stream-scale targets, which address the ecologically amenable flows within the waterway (e.g., allowable change to streamflow metrics such as baseflows or the pattern of stormwater flow frequency and volume) are less tangibly connected to stormwater design. These stream-focused targets need to be down-scalable, to provide guidance at the site scale (e.g., [18]) and allow development regulatory processes to be well connected to environmental outcomes in streams and receiving waters. These targets must be clear, transparent, robust, and easy to apply by industry and regulators to ensure uptake when development occurs. There are numerous examples of stormwater targets worldwide, but there is little consistency, even within countries, and commonly such targets gain little traction in terms of implementation.

What are the challenges to developing stormwater targets?

In developing stormwater targets, regulators must consider what type of target is required, where it will be applied, and whether it will meet objectives. This must be done in the context of geographical and physical variability of the developing cities and suburbs. The scenarios are often complex and varied which presents a number of challenges to developing stormwater targets (Fig 4).

thumbnail
Fig 4. Summary of challenges associated with defining stormwater targets.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pwat.0000390.g004

Politics and policy

Politics, and the lack of relevant policy development, are a major impediment to change (with consensus amongst workshop attendees at SUSE, 2023). There is a dearth of mandatory guidance and related planning mechanisms, and recommendations are commonly vague (and too-often ignored). In Australia’s state of Victoria, for example, the Environmental Protection Authority has well specified targets for runoff and infiltration requirements from development, but these are not mandated and application has been poor. There is, under State legislation, a General Environmental Duty (GED) where what must be done is ‘reasonably practicable’. This means ‘…you have put in ‘proportionate’ controls to eliminate or minimise risks of harm. Proportionate means the greater the risk of potential harm, the greater the expectation for you to manage it.’ As such, the lack of explicit links to harm mean that it is consistently tested, and adoption of stormwater management on this basis is low.

Development and implementation of guidance requires significant strengthening of political impetus. In particular, the weight given to environmental protection concerns needs to be dramatically raised in relation to development goals. It was concluded that not only do we require an approach that crystallises the importance of stormwater targets, but that distilling the complex into simple messages is needed to greatly increase advocacy for improved stormwater management.

Translating the science

Understanding the science and translating it on the ground requires knowledge as a central basis to environmental protection guidance and regulation. Generalised conceptual models of how urban flow alteration leads to stream degradation have been defined for some time [63] and local agencies have developed their own region-specific conceptual models based on global and local research (e.g., [64]). Defining targets based on conceptual models like this requires an understanding of stressor-response relationships (i.e., quantifiable relationships between increases in stormwater and stream degradation). Targets must be explicitly related to objectives, and ideally derived from local studies. For example, the most recently adopted stormwater volume and infiltration targets for Victoria, Australia [49] were based on a review of decades of stormwater science [65]. These targets represent a shift from former peak flow targets (which we know can lead to perverse outcomes; e.g., [66]), and instead reflect a greater understanding of the importance of runoff volume as an integrating measure of stormwater impacts on streams [20]. Duncan et al. [67] demonstrated that important flow components for the physical and ecological integrity of a stream cannot be maintained in the face of urbanisation without significant reductions in flow volume. In this regard the overall volumetric stormwater runoff could be the defining stormwater target for any guidance, if quantification of the target is achievable.

There is increasing recognition that it is not impervious surfaces that are necessarily causing excess stormwater runoff, but the way in which they are connected to the waterway [68]. Defining targets that are simple will increase uptake, yet the effectiveness of these simple targets, and the applicability across a range of settings, has not been demonstrated. We know that one-size-fits-all does not always work and that place-based approaches that consider catchment characteristics, development objectives and characteristics of receiving waters (e.g., waterways versus natural wetlands or estuaries) are required.

A number of approaches and tools are being developed to assist in determining stormwater targets that predominantly focus on streamflow. To reach the strict target of reaching a good status in all surface waters set in the EU Water Framework Directive [69], Germany has developed a technical guideline (DWA-M 102–5) that describes a methodology for determining potential damage of a stormwater connection to the hydromorphological structure of the stream bank and bed [70]. Any new discharge is required to cause no harm to the hydromorphology of the stream and to a set of biological criteria specific for the type of stream.

The lack of consistency of metrics used and the variability in the nomenclature used can add to the difficulty of choosing the appropriate metric. Reviewing a broad suite of metrics, Duncan et al. [67] noted that one of the challenges with defining streamflow targets is narrowing down the inordinate number of hydrologic metrics that relate to ecological value (up to 1000 metrics were identified). They refined this number to a more sensible suite of 5.

Drawing upon this, the Urban Streamflow Impact Assessment (USIA) identified a range of data and tools while relying upon an expert panel, to consider allowable streamflow metrics to be addressed as targets in development applications [71]. ‘Allowable’ is based on deviation from a natural/unimpacted scenario, using modelled streamflows. For example, geomorphic assessments of field-identified bed and bank sediments provide inputs to two-dimensional hydraulic modelling to assess erosion thresholds which inform the sediment mobilisation metric. The deviation of streamflow from baseline conditions for these metrics under urban development scenarios is displayed using a ‘traffic light’ matrix, i.e., how close to ‘natural’ is the urban scenario for that particular metric. These metrics must be determined for the catchment and can subsequently be used to model and design approaches to water sensitive urban design or modifications to wastewater treatment plant outflows that achieve desirable streamflows. The greatest benefit of this approach is an understanding of ‘what flows to take out?’ and ‘what is lost if you don’t?’, informing cost-benefit analyses. The method, however, does not define the controls, but informs them, and it has struggled to gain traction because at this stage it is stream-specific and requires modelling to demonstrate the change (i.e., it is not a simple metric).

The science recognizes that baselines for comparison of change are critical, but are limited by data availability. Developing stormwater targets often requires an understanding of what constitutes ‘natural’. In the German cities of Hamburg and Berlin, there has been a goal to work towards a natural flow regime in the receiving waters, despite not having what would be considered natural creeks in these centuries-old cities [72]. As such, studying a natural flow regime is difficult. This has led to modelling approaches with natural land cover for the catchment, providing an understanding of flow rates under natural conditions to then define limits.

A key complexity in the on ground application of approaches, or tools and guidance for developing targets, is the varying scales at which stormwater targets are applied. Development proceeds as extensions, infill lots, or sub-divisions all the way to precinct and regional-scale developments. The relatively small impact of a lot scale development, for example, cannot be discounted when multiple developments are combined: the proverbial ‘death by a thousand pipes’. Large-scale developments such as precinct-scale may have greater potential for stormwater control measures; however, given that multiple developers may be involved in one precinct, each lot must consider the effect on the whole-of-catchment streamflow impact, and equitability must be considered. The benefit of hydrologic metrics is that they are often readily scalable. Their issue, however, may be the challenge in modelling and defining hydrologic metrics at a range of scales, and the varying factors across a catchment (e.g., slope, vegetation cover, infiltration capacity). In this sense, the simplicity versus complexity argument may drive approaches such as percentage imperviousness to derive the impact of development on stormwater runoff.

Demonstrating the case for stormwater targets

There are few incentives to implementing stormwater flow targets, making the economics a major impediment. The Cooperative Research Centre (CRC) for Water Sensitive Cities, Australia, highlighted that ‘... there are very few incentives for water authorities/utilities to co-develop water resource management strategies with local government’ [73]. Funding mechanisms are available across the various jurisdictions, e.g., Local Government Authorities collect rates and water authorities are funded through a State-government essential services price determination. There are also State-government grants and incentives programs and organisation specific mechanisms, e.g., offset and development schemes. The key challenge with any funding mechanism is to present compelling business cases that justify both the costs and benefits, while effectively prioritising and allocating budgets to ensure all required services are delivered by the authority.

One such tool to demonstrate the business case for stormwater target ‘efforts’ was the development of the Method for Regional Stormwater Prioritisation (MrsP) [74]. This analysis approach generates streamflow metrics using a simplified rainfall-runoff model for urban scenarios with impervious area, the level of connectedness of stormwater systems to waterways, and climatic scenarios as inputs. The metrics are then transformed into a hydrologic ‘stress’ score based on deviation of streamflow metrics from a base case, ultimately characterising the “likelihood” of changes to ecological conditions. Next the ecological condition of each waterway is defined using available ecological datasets. Higher scores are applied to waterways and riparian areas in “good” ecological condition and lower scores to those in “poor” ecological condition. Therefore, any changes to the ecological score as a result of stormwater flows would describe the “consequence” of such flows. Combining hydrologic stress and ecological conditions and comparing the results to the base case then allows the potential impact score (essentially a measure of risk) of different development scenarios to be mapped across all waterways in a catchment. The next step is to apply scenarios with different stormwater targets, such as different % of harvesting and infiltration, and then rerunning the analysis to see how the impact score changes. This allows comparison between the scale of harvesting and infiltration needed in different development areas and intensities. Initial applications of the approach have been positively received, particularly by local Councils managing rapid urban development in multiple locations across a catchment. The approach is intended to demonstrate opportunities and the quantum of stormwater management effort to affect change.

Ensuring the capacity and capability to deliver

The stormwater management industry’s capacity (the resources focusing on the problem) and capability (the understanding and ability to tackle the problem) were seen as major limitations. Inter-agency coordination is required to develop targets at the full range of scales. This requires collaboration and shared goals across different authorities and internal teams from drainage, water supply and waterway management. As stated by the Environment and Communications References Committee [73], the ownership of stormwater is seen as a problem. They found: ‘one consistent attribute in how water and wastewater is managed is that ‘the water utilities do not manage or own the stormwater assets’. Instead, local government is responsible. Various stakeholders consider that this arrangement, where different water sources are managed by different entities, is problematic’ (pg. 43). Similar conditions exist in the United States, where federal National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System permit authority is delegated to state agencies. Considering the value of applying stormwater controls at a catchment scale, cross jurisdictional challenges will commonly apply. CSIRO Publishing [75] suggested that up to 8 organisations have needed to be consulted to develop a single stormwater harvesting scheme.

A number of organisations have been set up to assist with disseminating information on stormwater management and to assist with capacity building. In Australia, a number of capacity building organisations exist including Clearwater (Melbourne), the CRC for Water Sensitive Cities (National), the Water by Design program by Healthy Land and Water (Queensland), and Water Sensitive SA (South Australia). In Germany, the water and wastewater association DWA and the association of engineers in water, waste and civil engineering BWK (www.bwk-bund.de) have set up working groups disseminating knowledge and developing new standards. In the United States, standards and data sets used to support stormwater targets are often developed by state agencies, non-profit organizations (American Society of Civil Engineers, Center for Watershed Protection) or collaboratives (International Stormwater BMP Database).

What are the impediments to implementation of stormwater targets?

Even well-designed stormwater targets can fail on implementation. Ensuring that WSUD measures that reduce excess stormwater runoff are integrated into the urban fabric is the greatest challenge. To be successful, they must be planned and designed early, with adequate space reserved and budget for construction and long-term maintenance. They must also have a sound scientific basis, community support, and appropriate incentives to hold up to the inevitable scrutiny associated with developers testing their limits (e.g., shrinking footprints, placement in suboptimal locations) in attempts to maximise developable land and minimise costs. A range of barriers to implementation have been identified (Fig 5). These barriers intersect with challenges to development of targets outlined in the previous section, but here we focus on how these targets get translated into works on the ground, and at what points implementation can fail.

thumbnail
Fig 5. Summary of impediments to implementation of stormwater flow targets.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pwat.0000390.g005

Firstly, appropriate types, sizing and spatial distribution of interventions need to be defined. Standard designs and rules of thumb can help here, but can also stifle creative solutions. Stormwater targets need to be accompanied by design guidance and a shared vision of what affordable, financially viable, and compliant urban development could look like with the targets in place (e.g., [76]). Without this envisioning work, regulators risk having developers challenge targets on the basis of them being unworkable within current urban design paradigms. Whether assets are centralised or distributed can depend on industry capabilities or experience with one or the other, or often fashion and familiarity for regulating organisations. Determining a mix of centralised versus distributed assets can be complex, leading to a lack of understanding of which approach provides the most benefits for the cost. Sizing and scaling assets, particularly given often piecemeal development and uncertainty in upstream development, further complicates design.

Organisational and contextual challenges occur in the industry at large. At its core, stormwater has often been seen by local governments as a problem that needs to be ‘avoided and discharged as quickly as possible’ [73]. An organisational challenge comes from the capture of stormwater and finding a ‘need’ for the resource. Supply and demand constraints are particularly evident, for example, in large industrial areas with high fractions of impervious surfaces and significant runoff volumes but minimal water demands. Creating demand, and supplying storage for harvesting, should be a key focus for industry and development. For example, Europe was previously lacking a unified legal framework for water re-use which changed in 2020 with the EU Water Reuse Directive (https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2020/741/oj/eng). Additionally, stormwater quantity management infrastructure typically requires larger footprints than infrastructure focused solely on water quality, creating challenges in space-constrained areas, such as infill and retrofit sites. Underground storage should be a future focus for development and the management of large stormwater volumes.

Policy and governance is often hindered by multiple owners and distributed responsibility. Localised approaches may increase opportunities, such as in Germany where regulations regarding stormwater management are highly localised and based on centuries-old requirements. Responsibilities for managing runoff could range from individual landholders (states of Lower-Saxony, Hesse, Saxony-Anhalt) to the community at large (Hamburg). In Hamburg for example, every landholder has the right to be connected to the stormwater drainage system and is required to pay a fee for the construction of the stormwater drain (e.g., Hamburg Wastewater Act, 2001). Requiring the same landholder to manage stormwater on-site contradicts this right and the connection fees already paid, especially if responsibility by law lies with the city. This one example suggests that policy requirements are not even clear-cut within the water authorities themselves because goals like stream health conflict with the desire to manage stormwater on a lot-scale.

The practicalities and politics of implementation often lead to ineffectual policy and even policy repeal. In Australia, a frequent flow management objective was developed in regulatory documents for Queensland State Planning Policy ‘Healthy Waters’ [77]. Specifically, the objective required the capture and loss or reuse of the first 10–15 mm of runoff from impervious surfaces. In practice, the objectives were not enforced by all local governments. Although the full list of reasons for the lack of implementation are unclear, the primary reasons included difficulty in finding demand for reuse of captured stormwater, lack of cooperation between organisations responsible for different parts of the water cycle (e.g., state government, local governments, and water authorities), lack of clarity on when the requirements would be triggered, and lack of simple compliance assessment tools. The kinds of solutions that could achieve the demand needed (e.g., large-scale irrigation or dual reticulation to indoor uses) were not considered feasible by proponents and local governments in most situations. The requirement to meet the frequent flow management objectives was subsequently removed from regulatory documents in 2013 as part of the update of the State Planning Policy [78].

In Victoria, Australia, stormwater flow targets are established in policy, and clear guidance is provided for infrastructure solutions [79], but implementation of stormwater management is currently falling well short of targets [64]. Two key policy and governance barriers hinder broader implementation, namely: (1) the absence of obligations within the planning framework and (2) a lack of clearly defined roles and responsibilities for implementation. Unlike stormwater quality performance objectives, stormwater quantity targets [49] are not mandated by the State Planning Policy Framework. Land developers are not specifically required to address stormwater flow targets in new developments, limiting authorities’ ability to enforce compliance or secure funding. In the United States, developers are often only required to manage the water quality volume and flood flows, such that stormwater controls are not designed with stream health in mind [80]. Consequently, developers also lack a basis for budgeting for the necessary works to manage flow targets. Clarifying roles and responsibilities has been a big focus of regulators and coordination organisations. While bodies such as the state government-led Integrated Water Management Forums have had success in coordination of integrated catchment-scale planning among organisations with interests and roles across all aspects of the water cycle, progress has been slow on implementation of stormwater quantity controls. New legislated policy [81] mandates that local governments develop and publish plans identifying stormwater risks and actions to mitigate them. Whether this policy will lead to broader implementation, particularly in regional Victoria where stormwater management falls under local government responsibility, remains to be seen.

Economics and incentives are seen as one of the greatest impediments to implementation, either because the business case is considered weak or because questions around cost-sharing have not been fully settled [82]. Decentralised solutions to stormwater management are perceived by developers and many regulators as a costly alternative to centralised conveyance infrastructure. This is especially true if no framework requiring or incentivising runoff reduction exists. However, such judgements may not factor in the full cost of traditional, pipe and pond stormwater management or the benefits to society of decentralised systems (like ecosystem health, water availability and urban cooling). A comparison study between Berlin and Singapore showed that decentralised stormwater management resulted in higher economic efficiency for government [83]. Others have argued that decentralized infrastructure can result in development of otherwise ‘difficult’ parcels and provide improved runoff reduction relative to, e.g., traditional ponds [84]. Given that urban development, and particularly water, cross jurisdictional boundaries, the challenge of ‘who pays’ is commonplace. A polluter-pays model is often preferred (i.e., the creator of the stormwater problem should pay), but this may be difficult to apportion in reality when stormwater sources are diffuse. Furthermore, cost and performance data may be unknown for new infrastructure types, which can lead to an aversion to trying new solutions. Consequently, authorities struggle to build compelling business cases for funding such infrastructure. Breaking this cycle will be challenging without funded demonstration projects that clearly showcase the costs and benefits.

Recommendations for developing and implementing stormwater targets

Address knowledge gaps to improve development.

In developing stormwater targets the main question is ‘how much stormwater capture is enough?’. The answer has hampered stormwater targets of all types. Victoria’s stormwater flow targets, for example, are based on what is considered ‘reasonably practicable’ to prevent harm to human health and the environment from pollution and waste; a similar ‘maximum extent practicable’ approach is taken in the United States. However, the application of what ‘reasonably practicable’ means on the ground is not yet well defined. Guidance lacks the detailed information that government and private industry need to effectively plan, design, assess, construct, and maintain stormwater flow management infrastructure. Further work is required to determine what ‘baseline’ conditions and acceptable change is in a range of urban settings. This requires further development of protocols and tools that link values (what is to be lost) to hydrologic metrics (what needs to be modified) within a range of contexts. In some ways, this may require further study of baseline hydrologic conditions in undeveloped watersheds in a regional context [11].

Stormwater targets based on Total Impervious Areas (TIA) may be easier to determine, but Effective Imperviousness (EI) is considerably more appropriate to the goals of stormwater management. Determining targets based on EI, however, is often more challenging than it sounds. Stormwater management devices rarely achieve perfect disconnection or perfect mimicking of natural catchment processes. Therefore, methods of EI calculation must be developed to ensure the effectiveness of using EI as a target for stormwater design [85].

Infiltration of stormwater is an essential component to effective stormwater management to return the appropriate hydrologic signature. While stormwater harvesting is relatively well understood and implemented in Australia, stormwater infiltration is less so. Conversely, stormwater infiltration predominates in the US, with stormwater harvesting schemes only recently appearing at scale. Two significant knowledge gaps exist around stormwater infiltration. The first concerns infiltration potential mapping in regions around the world, similar to what has been done in the United States Soil Survey maps [86]. Certain soils and groundwater catchments are unsuitable for stormwater infiltration, yet often clear limits are not well defined. Further complicating this is the often highly modified nature of urban soils, which leads to uncertainty in mapping and a need to confirm infiltration rates using site-scale testing [87]. Infiltration is a key focus for ‘reversing’ the urban hydrologic signature, supplying stormwater to groundwater, and provisioning stream baseflow. This requires an understanding of geology, soils, and potential impacts to infrastructure (e.g., urban karst; [88]) to anticipate where the stormwater will go once it is in the soil. This lack of guidance creates challenges for authorities and developers, particularly when stormwater infiltration is desired in areas that may be unsuitable, leading to time-consuming and costly investigations. Secondly, the infiltration of contaminants has not been completely addressed, albeit studies on this question are ongoing and date back decades [89]. Although established nutrient and sediment targets provide a useful starting point, limits for heavy metals, organics, pathogens, and other emerging contaminants have yet to be defined.

Address impediments to implementation.

Adoption of stormwater targets must be ambitious and strict. Even low levels of imperviousness have an impact, and retrofitting stormwater controls is very difficult. Degradation of waterway ecosystems occurs with even very small levels of urbanization when business-as-usual approaches to stormwater management are used [36,63,85]. Findings from the Lower Stringybark Creek (LSC) catchment study revealed only modest benefits for the stream, indicating that the level of disconnection needs to be near-complete to have potential to reverse degradation trajectories [20]. Despite around 40% of the EI in the LSC catchment being disconnected to some extent, the effect on stormwater was only equivalent to around half of those surfaces being totally disconnected. The steep trajectory in stream health decline from excess urban stormwater runoff (i.e., from even as little as 1% effective imperviousness) adds urgency to the case for implementing infrastructure that manages stormwater from the early stages of development using methods such as capture, evapotranspiration, infiltration, and filtering.

Development plans must, at an early stage, address space constraints in streetscapes and at end-of-pipe in the stream reserve, as well as find demand for reuse of captured stormwater [85]. Targets which explicitly account for demand (e.g., reuse volume targets) are potentially a next step in this direction. Better demand modelling and design solutions are required to stimulate greater demand for stormwater reuse as part of standard urban infrastructure, to improve outcomes of stormwater disconnection measures.

Infill development poses its own challenges to stormwater targets. In the LSC study (Melbourne, Australia), an initial drop in EI was followed by EI gradually increasing as small-scale infill development proceeded (e.g., construction of sheds, concrete pads, secondary dwellings). Targets for stormwater reduction must therefore be implemented alongside targets or measures that prevent ongoing increases in EI in other parts of the catchment, to prevent successes being eroded by incremental ongoing urbanisation. In this case a planning mechanism was developed to trigger local government regulatory processes and additional stormwater management at very low levels of added impervious development on private property.

Demonstration projects are an essential component of moving forward on stormwater targets to evolve the state of knowledge and industry guidance. For example, since 2021 in Berlin, Germany, areas with combined sewers are not permitted to discharge any stormwater, with all rainfall infiltrated on site, providing the opportunities exist. Implementation of these measures was supported by tools like the environmental benefit (EB) calculator which converted the area of impervious surfaces disconnected to a dollar value for the benefit to the stream. Thus, the targets were directly linked to incentives at the property scale. Other large scale distributed infrastructure projects in the United States, including Blueprint Columbus, Green City, Clean Waters (Philadelphia), Rain Check (Buffalo), and Green Alleys (Chicago) have reduced EI and provided incremental benefits, although connecting these watershed-scale benefits to improvements in stream health remains a missing link and an area of much research need.

With a modicum of success, we could ask where to from here? Firstly, coordinated efforts are required whereby the stormwater industry associations must consider all elements of the water cycle holistically, including water supply, sewerage and drainage (e.g., [73]).

As a lofty goal, the development of a global community of practice is in order, given that the hydrologic signature of urbanisation does not vary greatly worldwide: drawing upon scientists, practitioners, planners, policy makers etc., across various industries. As a first step, these may start by country or State. In Germany, a broad alliance has been formed across different industry bodies in the construction, landscaping, environmental advocacy, hydrobiology, town planning, and water engineering sectors to develop a shared understanding of a water-sensitive city and influence policy. This has already resulted in a proposed change to the German town planning law introducing a limit on imperviousness in planning applications and the possibility to change town planning schemes based on deficiencies in water management and climate adaptation, e.g., by the Federal Ministry of Housing, Urban Development and Construction in 2024. A working group comprised of environmental ministries from all states published a paper outlining the required policy changes for development of water sensitive cities in Germany [90].

In Australia, there is currently impetus to develop guidance and mandates for stormwater management. The State Government of Victoria has developed Integrated Water Management Forums, which provide example mechanisms for the coordinated and integrated catchment scale planning and implementation of stormwater targets [23]. In a similar approach to that with water supply, fostering stronger and more in-depth collaboration by key entities including utilities, local government, and State government is required to build technical capabilities and capacity [82]. This will increase the ability to accept and adopt alternative or non-conventional solutions that can stack up against ‘business-as-usual’ without concerns over risk or return on investment.

Whilst we have focused on streams and rivers, this guidance should apply more broadly to waterways, including channels and ditches. These may efficiently carry pollutants and stormwater energy to receiving waters and as such controls on stormwater discharges are highly relevant based on the endpoint. Similarly, changes to water quantity and quality also adversely impact the ecological integrity of the downstream estuarine waterbodies and their aquatic or aquatic-dependent species [4]. Coastal and estuarine foodwebs are inextricably linked to river ecosystems and urban stormwater dramatically changes nutrient fluxes, organic matter processing, and ecosystem metabolism [91]. This has far-reaching impacts with population declines of diadromous species, whose life histories occupy both fresh and marine systems, relaying the degradation of freshwater ecosystems to the marine environment, shifting populations, biological interactions, and energy transfers [92]. Stormwater targets must be expanded to enhance knowledge of how urban stormwater modifies these environments and what can be done to reduce the impact.

Define what success looks like

Healthy stream and river ecosystems are a fundamental prerequisite to achieving sustainable water management in our cities. Given the UN Resolution on the need to ‘halt, prevent and reverse’ ecosystem degradation, including in freshwater and marine systems (by 2021–2030, as per the United Nations General Assembly, 1987), this provides a worthy start in the urban context. Without stormwater quantity targets we know that the global outcome of healthy waterways in urban catchments is not possible. Success could be seen as addressing the cause of the problem, protecting streams, rivers, wetlands, and estuaries from the threat of excess stormwater runoff.

Key elements and pathways to success in this space, for defining and implementing stormwater targets, both structural and non-structural measures, include:

  • Dissemination of information on the explicit links between stormwater runoff, protection targets and impacts to surface and groundwaters,
  • A well-defined business case, with a value (monetary or otherwise) associated with the impacts,
  • Well-developed, place-specific targets that are appropriate for the context, and draw upon a common approach for the region (or a common approach more broadly),
  • Stormwater targets that have as a goal simplicity, while not being oversimplified and losing the link to the goals for stormwater management,
  • Governmental and societal support for developing stormwater targets, including advocacy, guidance and tools,
  • Capacity and technical capability across the industry to ensure consistency, robustness of measures and an ability to manage and mitigate risk,
  • Political impetus and support for goals to protect streams and rivers from excess stormwater runoff and uphold goals and policy.

Take-away messages

  • Urbanisation’s role in developing a stormwater runoff ‘problem’ is no longer uncertain, with a plethora of research identifying the explicit link and negative impacts to stream health. The problem is consistent worldwide and reduces the potential uses of urban waters for recreation, drinking, or industry. Yet, despite this, stormwater targets have struggled to gain traction. Government organisations have an important role in identifying the problem and communicating to the broader public.
  • Addressing the excess stormwater runoff problem requires identifying stormwater targets: how much needs to be removed? The approaches to this are highly variable worldwide, and even across jurisdictional boundaries within a country or state. Yet, there are two consistent approaches, either (1) stormwater targets define the water balance for rainfall on the catchment to runoff, storage, evapotranspiration, or infiltration, or (2) define allowable changes to streamflow relative to a baseline value. Either of these approaches may be reasonably protective, but consistent enforcement is ultimately key.
  • We must develop and formalise tools that explicitly link stormwater runoff to values, and inform the question of ‘how much?’ This includes tools that assist in valuing the business case for protection of streams and rivers through an increased understanding of the cost, benefits, and co-benefits provided by stormwater control measures.
  • We require improved governance of the holistic management of stormwater and a community of practice to inspire, direct and implement this.
  • We must build on worldwide successes in stormwater target development, implementation and stream and river protection.
  • We require the political impetus to acknowledge and address this problem and ensure stormwater targets are mandated and enforceable to ensure ongoing environmental protection.

Acknowledgments

This paper was greatly informed by numerous attendees at the SUSE6 workshop (Brisbane, Australia, 29 May–1June, 2023) who are not authors on this paper, including: Chris Beardshaw, Sally Boer, Professor Tim Fletcher, Carlos Bambirazio, Dr. Jack Kurki-Fox, Dr. Christine Lauchlan Arrowsmith, John Macris, Greg Peters, Paulo Vitor Ribeiro Marques Da Silva, Amanda Valois, and Yan Ling Yen. We thank the organisors of the conference, and Dr. Alison Roy and Dr. Megan Fork for organising this special issue. Thanks to Streamology/Ooid Scientific for preparation of Fig 1.

References

  1. 1. Wijesiri B, Liu A, Goonetilleke A. Impact of global warming on urban stormwater quality: from the perspective of an alternative water resource. J Clean Prod. 2020;262:121330.
  2. 2. Hathaway JM, Bean EZ, Bernagros JT, Christian DP, Davani H, Ebrahimian A, et al. A synthesis of climate change impacts on stormwater management systems: designing for resiliency and future challenges. J Sustain Water Built Environ. 2024;10(2).
  3. 3. Vietz GJ, Walsh CJ, Fletcher TD. Urban hydrogeomorphology and the urban stream syndrome: treating the symptoms and causes of geomorphic change. Progr Phys Geogr: Earth Environ. 2015;40(3):480–92.
  4. 4. Lee SY, Dunn RJK, Young RA, Connolly RM, Dale PER, Dehayr R, et al. Impact of urbanization on coastal wetland structure and function. Austral Ecol. 2006;31(2):149–63.
  5. 5. Coutts AM, Beringer J, Tapper NJ. Impact of increasing urban density on local climate: spatial and temporal variations in the surface energy balance in Melbourne, Australia. J Appl Meteorol Climatol. 2007;46(4):477–93.
  6. 6. Finkenbine JK, Atwater JW, Mavinic DS. Stream health after urbanization1. J Am Water Resour Assoc. 2000;36(5):1149–60.
  7. 7. Walsh CJ, Roy AH, Feminella JW, Cottingham PD, Groffman PM, Morgan RP. The urban stream syndrome: current knowledge and the search for a cure. J North Am Benthol Soc. 2005;24(3):706–23.
  8. 8. Wenger SJ, Roy AH, Jackson CR, Bernhardt ES, Carter TL, Filoso S, et al. Twenty-six key research questions in urban stream ecology: an assessment of the state of the science. J North Am Benthol Soc. 2009;28(4):1080–98.
  9. 9. Jones MP, Hunt WF, Winston RJ. Effect of urban catchment composition on runoff temperature. J Environ Eng. 2012;138(12):1231–6.
  10. 10. Simpson IM, Winston RJ, Dorsey JD. Monitoring the effects of urban and forested land uses on runoff quality: implications for improved stormwater management. Sci Total Environ. 2023;862:160827. pmid:36509280
  11. 11. Simpson IM, Winston RJ, Andrew Tirpak R, Dorsey JD, Stagge JH, Hathaway JM. Hydrologic responses of single land use urban and forested watersheds and their implications to improving urban drainage design. J Hydrol. 2023;620:129430.
  12. 12. Park D, Jang S, Roesner LA. Evaluation of multi-use stormwater detention basins for improved urban watershed management. Hydrol Process. 2012;28(3):1104–13.
  13. 13. Hoss F, Fischbach J, Molina-Perez E. Effectiveness of best management practices for stormwater treatment as a function of runoff volume. J Water Resour Plann Manage. 2016;142(11).
  14. 14. Urbonas B, Glidden MW. Potential effectiveness of detention policies. Southwest storm drainage symposium. College Station, Texas, 1983.
  15. 15. Ladson AR, Walsh CJ, Fletcher TD. Improving stream health in urban areas by reducing runoff frequency from impervious surfaces. Australas J Water Resourc. 2006;10(1):23–33.
  16. 16. Fletcher TD, Burns MJ, Russell KL, Hamel P, Duchesne S, Cherqui F, et al. Concepts and evolution of urban hydrology. Nat Rev Earth Environ. 2024;5(11):789–801.
  17. 17. DeBusk KM, Hunt WF, Line DE. Bioretention outflow: does it mimic nonurban watershed shallow interflow? J Hydrol Eng. 2011;16(3):274–9.
  18. 18. Fletcher TD, Vietz G, Walsh CJ. Protection of stream ecosystems from urban stormwater runoff; the multiple benefits of an ecohydrological approach. Progr Phys Geogr: Earth Environ. 2014;38(5):543–55.
  19. 19. Larson M, Walsh CJ, Fletcher TD, Bos D, Rossrakesh S. Stream Restoration through Stormwater Runoff Management and Retrofit: New Objectives, New Approaches. In: Low Impact Development for Urban Ecosystem and Habitat Protection. 2008. pp. 1–10.
  20. 20. Walsh CJ, Booth DB, Burns MJ, Fletcher TD, Hale RL, Hoang LN, et al. Principles for urban stormwater management to protect stream ecosystems. Freshwater Sci. 2016;35(1):398–411.
  21. 21. Vietz G, Lauchlan Arrowsmith C. Challenges and opportunities in environmental water management: what’s working and what can we do better? In: Proceedings of the Hydrology and Water Resources Symposium. Sydney: National Committee on Water Engineering; 2023.
  22. 22. Hawley RJ, Vietz GJ. Addressing the urban stream disturbance regime. Freshw Sci. 2016;35(1):278–92.
  23. 23. State of Victoria Department of Environment, Land, Water and Planning. Integrated Water Management Framework for Victoria. 2017. Available from: https://www.water.vic.gov.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0031/663556/integrated-water-management-framework-for-victoria-an-iwm-approach-to-urban-water-planning-and-shared-decision-making-throughout-victoria.pdf
  24. 24. Fletcher TD, Shuster W, Hunt WF, Ashley R, Butler D, Arthur S, et al. SUDS, LID, BMPs, WSUD and more – The evolution and application of terminology surrounding urban drainage. Urban Water J. 2014;12(7):525–42.
  25. 25. Karamoutsou L, Veliou E, Kvernberg EB, Psilovikos A. Urban stormwater management: a sustainable approach. Water. 2024;16(15):2089.
  26. 26. Urban Drainage and Flood Control District. Urban Storm Drainage Criteria Manual Volume 2: Structures, Storage, and Recreation. Denver, Colorado: Urban Drainage and Flood Control District; 2016.
  27. 27. Vlotman WF, Wong T, Schultz B. Integration of drainage, water quality and flood management in rural, urban and lowland areas. Irrig Drain. 2007;56(S1):S161–77.
  28. 28. Wilson CE, Hunt WF III, Winston RJ, Smith P. Assessment of a rainwater harvesting system for pollutant mitigation at a commercial location in Raleigh, NC, USA. Water Supply. 2013;14(2):283–90.
  29. 29. Feng W, Liu Y, Gao L. Stormwater treatment for reuse: current practice and future development - a review. J Environ Manage. 2022;301:113830. pmid:34600425
  30. 30. Bhaskar AS, Hogan DM, Nimmo JR, Perkins KS. Groundwater recharge amidst focused stormwater infiltration. Hydrol Process. 2018;32(13):2058–68.
  31. 31. Thom JK, Szota C, Coutts AM, Fletcher TD, Livesley SJ. Transpiration by established trees could increase the efficiency of stormwater control measures. Water Res. 2020;173:115597. pmid:32087439
  32. 32. Barbosa AE, Fernandes JN, David LM. Key issues for sustainable urban stormwater management. Water Res. 2012;46(20):6787–98. pmid:22687523
  33. 33. Thorne CR, Lawson EC, Ozawa C, Hamlin SL, Smith LA. Overcoming uncertainty and barriers to adoption of Blue‐Green Infrastructure for urban flood risk management. J Flood Risk Management. 2015;11(S2).
  34. 34. Warter MM, Tetzlaff D, Marx C, Soulsby C. Impact of drought hazards on flow regimes in anthropogenically impacted streams: an isotopic perspective on climate stress. Nat Hazards Earth Syst Sci. 2024;24(11):3907–24.
  35. 35. Warter MM, Tetzlaff D, Soulsby C, Goldhammer T, Gebler D, Vierikko K, et al. Understanding ecohydrology and biodiversity in aquatic nature-based solutions in urban streams and ponds through an integrative multi-tracer approach. Hydrol Earth Syst Sci. 2025;29(12):2707–25.
  36. 36. Vietz GJ, Rutherfurd ID, Walsh CJ, Chee YU, Hatt BE. The unaccounted costs of conventional urban development: protecting stream systems in an age of urban sprawl. In: Vietz G, Rutherfurd ID, Hughes R, editors. Proceedings of the 7th Australian Stream Management Conference; Townsville: 2014. pp. 418–24.
  37. 37. Boening-Ulman KM, Winston RJ, Wituszynski DM, Smith JS, Andrew Tirpak R, Martin JF. Hydrologic impacts of sewershed-scale green infrastructure retrofits: outcomes of a four-year paired watershed monitoring study. J Hydrol. 2022;611:128014.
  38. 38. Schneider A, Woodcock CE. Compact, dispersed, fragmented, extensive? A comparison of urban growth in twenty-five global cities using remotely sensed data, pattern metrics and census information. Urban Stud. 2008;45(3):659–92.
  39. 39. Botturi A, Ozbayram EG, Tondera K, Gilbert NI, Rouault P, Caradot N, et al. Combined sewer overflows: A critical review on best practice and innovative solutions to mitigate impacts on environment and human health. Crit Rev Environ Sci Technol. 2020;51(15):1585–618.
  40. 40. Vietz G, Whiteoak K, Ehrenfried L. Incentivising stormwater management in cities and suburbs: examples from Germany and Opportunities for Australia. Water e-J. 2018;3(1):1–15.
  41. 41. Smith JS, Winston RJ, Wituszynski DM, Tirpak RA, Boening-Ulman KM, Martin JF. Effects of watershed-scale green infrastructure retrofits on urban stormwater quality: A paired watershed study to quantify nutrient and sediment removal. Ecol Eng. 2023;186:106835.
  42. 42. Sage J, Berthier E, Gromaire M-C. Stormwater management criteria for on-site pollution control: a comparative assessment of international practices. Environ Manage. 2015;56(1):66–80. pmid:25855072
  43. 43. Wild T, Fuchs G, Davis M. Sitting in our own soup? Combined sewers, climate change and nature-based solutions for urban water management in Berlin. Nat-Based Solut. 2024;5:100113.
  44. 44. Yarnell SM, Stein ED, Webb JA, Grantham T, Lusardi RA, Zimmerman J, et al. A functional flows approach to selecting ecologically relevant flow metrics for environmental flow applications. River Res Apps. 2020;36(2):318–24.
  45. 45. ACT Government. ACT Practice Guidelines for water Sensitive urban Design: Module 1 Introduction to WSUD in the ACT. 2017. Available from: https://www.environment.act.gov.au/water/water-strategies-and-plans/water_sensitive_urban_design
  46. 46. Philadelphia Water Department. Green City, Clean Waters. Year 10 Evaluation and Adaptation Plan. Consent Order & Agreement. City of Philadelphia Combined Sewer Overflow Long Term Control Plan Update. 2022. Available from: https://water.phila.gov/wp-content/uploads/files/gccw-year-10-eap.pdf
  47. 47. State of Connecticut. A Total Maximum Daily Load Analysis for Eagleville Brook, Mansfield, CT. Connecticut: State of Connecticut Department of Environmental Protection. 2007. Available from: https://media.clear.uconn.edu/projects/TMDL/library/tmdl/reports/eaglevillefinal_TMDL.pdf
  48. 48. ACT Government. Variation to the Territory Plan No. 354 Water Sensitive Urban Design. Final variation prepared under s76 of the Planning and Development Act 2007. Canberra: Department of Environment, Planning and Sustainable Development; 2019.
  49. 49. EPA Victoria. Urban stormwater management guidance. Publication 1739.1. Victoria: EPA Victoria; 2021. Available from: https://www.epa.vic.gov.au/-/media/epa/files/publications/urban-stormwater-management-1739-1.pdf?la=en&hash=297A34E91AFF7A774C472B9F338063C8
  50. 50. NSW Government. Technical guidance for achieving Wianamatta–South Creek stormwater management targets. Sydney: Department of Planning and Environment; 2022.
  51. 51. City of Berlin. Berlin water law §36a. Germany; 2005. Available from: https://gesetze.berlin.de/perma?d=jlr-WasGBEpP36a
  52. 52. DWA. Principles for the management and treatment of rainwater runoff discharged into surface waters (Part 3). Technical Guideline DWA-M 102-3/BWK-M 3-3. Germany. 2021. Available from: https://shop.dwa.de/en/DWA-M-102-3-Grundsaetze-zur-Bewirtschaftung-und-Behandlung-von-Regenwetterabfluessen-zur-Einleitung-in-Oberflaechengewaesser-Teil-3-Immissionsbezogene-Bewertungen-und-Regelungen-Oktober-2021/M-102-T3-21
  53. 53. Ohio Environmental Protection Agency. Rainwater and Land Development. 2014. Available from: https://epa.ohio.gov/dsw/storm/rainwater
  54. 54. Department of Infrastructure, Local Government and Planning. State Planning Policy. 2017. Available from: https://dsdmipprd.blob.core.windows.net/general/spp-july-2017.pdf
  55. 55. Santa Clara Valley Urban Runoff Pollution Prevention Program. Hydromodification Management Plan: Final Report. California; 2005. Available from: https://scvurppp.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/08/hmp_complete_032905.pdf
  56. 56. Kermode S, Vietz G, Tippler C, Russell K, Fletcher T, van der Sterran M, et al. Urban Streamflow Impact Assessment (USIA): a novel approach for protecting urbanising waterways and providing the justification for integrated water management. Australas J Water Resourc. 2020;25(2):211–21.
  57. 57. Schleswig-Holstein. Water law requirements on dealing with rainwater in Schleswig-Holstein. Part 1: Quantity management. Germany: Schleswig-Holstein State Office for the Environment; 2023. Available from: https://www.schleswig-holstein.de/DE/fachinhalte/A/abwasser/Downloads/wasserrechtlicheAnforderungen.pdf?__blob=publicationFile&v=2
  58. 58. Murphy BM, Russell KL, Mould S, Vietz G, Nelson PA. Managing urban riverscapes: An assessment framework to integrate social-ecological values and physical processes. J Environ Manage. 2022;322:115862. pmid:36049312
  59. 59. Coleman RA, Chee YE, Bond NR, Weeks A, Griffiths J, Serena M, et al. Understanding and managing the interactive impacts of growth in urban land use and climate change on freshwater biota: a case study using the platypus (Ornithorhynchus anatinus). Glob Change Biol. 2022;28(4):1287–300.
  60. 60. Chesterfield C, Rogers BC, Beck L, Brown RR, Dunn G, De Haan F, et al. A Water Sensitive Cities Index to Support Transitions to More Liveable, Sustainable, Resilient and Productive Cities. Proceedings of the Singapore International Water Week. Singapore, 2016.
  61. 61. Brown RR, Rogers BC, Werbeloff L. A framework to guide transitions to water sensitive cities. Urban sustainability transitions: Australian cases-international perspectives. 2018:129–48.
  62. 62. Brown RR, Rogers BC, Werbeloff L. Moving towards water sensitive cities: a guidance manual for strategists and policy makers. 2016.
  63. 63. Walsh CJ, Fletcher TD, Ladson AR. Stream restoration in urban catchments through redesigning stormwater systems: looking to the catchment to save the stream. J North Am Benthol Soc. 2005;24(3):690–705.
  64. 64. Melbourne Water. Healthy Waterways Strategy Mid-term Review: Summary. Melbourne: Melbourne Water Corporation; 2024. Available from: https://mwhwsstorage.blob.core.windows.net/files/2024-06/Healthy%20Waterway%20Strategy-Mid-term%20Review-Summary.pdf
  65. 65. Ewert J, O’Halloran D, Lintern A, Weber T, McCarthy D. Review of stormwater science. Melbourne: Cooperative Research Centre for Water Sensitive Cities; 2018. Available from: https://www.epa.vic.gov.au/sites/default/files/epa/publications/1919.pdf
  66. 66. Hawley RJ, Russell KL, Olinde LJ. Qcthreshold departs from theoreticalQcin urban watersheds: The role of streambed mobility data in managing the urban disturbance regime. Freshw Sci. 2022;41(3):489–506.
  67. 67. Duncan HP, Fletcher TD, Vietz G, Urrutiaguer M. The feasibility of maintaining ecologically and geomorphically important elements of the natural flow regime in the context of a superabundance of flow. Melbourne Waterway Research-Practice Partnership Technical Report 14.5. 2014.
  68. 68. Sultana R, Mroczek M, Sengupta A, Dallman S, Stein ED. Improving Effective Impervious Estimates to Inform Stormwater Management. Water Resour Manage. 2020;34(2):747–62.
  69. 69. European Commission. Water Framework Directive 2000/60/EC. 2000. Available from: https://environment.ec.europa.eu/topics/water/water-framework-directive_en
  70. 70. DWA. Stormwater runoff: Hydromorphological and biological methods for assessing emission impacts. Technical Guideline DWA-M 102-5/BWK-M 3-5. Germany; 2023. Available from: https://de.dwa.de/de/regelwerk-news-volltext/merkblatt-dwa-m-102-5-bwk-m-3-5-regenwetterabfluesse-hydromorphologische-und-biologische-verfahren-zur-immissionsbezogenen-bewertung.html
  71. 71. Vietz G, Tippler C, Russell K, Kermode S, van der Sterren M, Fletcher T, Dean M. Development and application of the Urban Streamflow Impact Assessment (USIA) to inform stream protection and rehabilitation. In: Vietz GJ, Rutherfurd ID, editors. Proceedings of the 9th Australian Stream Management Conference. Hobart, Tasmania; 2018. pp. 538–45.
  72. 72. City of Hamburg. Limit of Precipitation Water Discharges in Hamburg. Information sheet Nr. 02/2024. Germany; 2024. Available from: https://www.hamburg.de/resource/blob/925898/f3c05ddf22e7d7fbfff0c1dce09de638/d-merkblatt-emb-data.pdf
  73. 73. Environment and Communications References Committee. Stormwater management in Australia: Inquiry into stormwater resources in Australia. Canberra: Parliament of Australia; 2015.
  74. 74. Jordan B, Lauchlan Arrowsmith CS, Vietz G, Gunn A, Urich C, Cheeseman J. Stormwater flow targets are here: What does this mean for our growing regions? Stormwater Victoria Conference. 2024.
  75. 75. WSUD Engineering Procedures: Stormwaterw. CSIRO Publishing; 2005.
  76. 76. Hoban A, Freeman J, Mendis H, Stanish O, Ip I, Gillam P, et al. Western Parkland City: Urban Typologies and Stormwater Solutions. Bligh Tanner, Architectus and Sydney Water. 2020.
  77. 77. Department of Environment and Resource Management. State Planning Policy 4/10 Healthy Waters. 2010. Available from: https://cabinet.qld.gov.au/documents/2010/oct/state%20planning%20policy%20for%20healthy%20waters/Attachments/spp-healthy-waters[1].pdf
  78. 78. Department of State Development, Infrastructure and Planning. State Planning Policy 2013. 2013.
  79. 79. State of Victoria. Healthy Waterways Strategy Stormwater Targets Practitioner’s Note. 2021. Available from: https://www.melbournewater.com.au/media/16916/download
  80. 80. Tillinghast ED, Hunt WF, Jennings GD. Stormwater control measure (SCM) design standards to limit stream erosion for Piedmont North Carolina. J Hydrol. 2011;411(3–4):185–96.
  81. 81. Victorian Government. Order for Obligations of managers of land or infrastructure (Urban stormwater management and On-site wastewater management) – Environment Protection Act 2017. Victoria Government Gazette No. S 226. 2024. Available from: https://www.gazette.vic.gov.au/gazette/Gazettes2024/GG2024S226.pdf
  82. 82. Keller J. Why are decentralised urban water solutions still rare given all the claimed benefits, and how could that be changed? Water Res X. 2023;19:100180. pmid:37168677
  83. 83. Zhang D, Gersberg RM, Ng WJ, Tan SK. Conventional and decentralized urban stormwater management: a comparison through case studies of Singapore and Berlin, Germany. Urban Water J. 2015;14(2):113–24.
  84. 84. Wilson CE, Hunt WF, Winston RJ, Smith P. Comparison of runoff quality and quantity from a commercial low-impact and conventional development in Raleigh, North Carolina. J Environ Eng. 2015;141(2).
  85. 85. Walsh CJ, Burns MJ, Fletcher TD, Bos DG, Poelsma P, Kunapo J, et al. Linking stormwater control performance to stream ecosystem outcomes: incorporating a performance metric into effective imperviousness. PLOS Water. 2022;1(2):e0000004.
  86. 86. United States Department of Agriculture, Division of Soil Survey, Bureau of Plant Industry, Soils, and Agricultural Engineering. Soil survey manual. Handbook No. 18. Washington, D.C.: United States Department of Agriculture; 1951.
  87. 87. Winston RJ, Dorsey JD, Smolek AP, Hunt WF. Hydrologic performance of four permeable pavement systems constructed over low-permeability soils in Northeast Ohio. J Hydrol Eng. 2018;23(4).
  88. 88. Bonneau J, Fletcher TD, Costelloe JF, Burns MJ. Stormwater infiltration and the ‘urban karst’ – a review. J Hydrol. 2017;552:141–50.
  89. 89. Pitt R, Clark S, Field R. Groundwater contamination potential from stormwater infiltration practices. Urban Water. 1999;1(3):217–36.
  90. 90. Bund/Länder-Arbeitsgemeinschaft Wasser (LAWA). Pathway to a water sensitive city. Position paper. Germany; 2021. Available from: https://www.lawa.de/documents/lawa-positionspapier-wassersensible-stadtentwicklung-barrierefrei_1689856479.pdf
  91. 91. Kinsella CM, Crowe TP. Variation in rocky shore assemblages and abundances of key taxa along gradients of stormwater input. Mar Environ Res. 2015;105:20–9. pmid:25637878
  92. 92. Levin PS, Howe ER, Robertson JC. Impacts of stormwater on coastal ecosystems: the need to match the scales of management objectives and solutions. Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci. 2020;375(1814):20190460. pmid:33131444