Citation: Smyth CW, Sarmiento-Ramírez JM, Short DPG, Diéguez-Uribeondo J, O’Donnell K, Geiser DM (2019) Unraveling the ecology and epidemiology of an emerging fungal disease, sea turtle egg fusariosis (STEF). PLoS Pathog 15(5): e1007682. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.ppat.1007682
Editor: Deborah A. Hogan, Geisel School of Medicine at Dartmouth, UNITED STATES
Published: May 16, 2019
This is an open access article, free of all copyright, and may be freely reproduced, distributed, transmitted, modified, built upon, or otherwise used by anyone for any lawful purpose. The work is made available under the Creative Commons CC0 public domain dedication.
Funding: The authors received no specific funding for this work.
Competing interests: The authors have declared no competing interests exist.
Emerging fungal diseases of wildlife are increasingly common, with far-reaching consequences for biodiversity and ecosystem health . These include white-nose syndrome of bats in North America, which has killed over 5.5 million bats in the last decade , and chytridiomycosis, which has led to the global decline or extinction of at least 200 frog species . Sea turtle egg fusariosis (STEF) is a newly emergent fungal disease linked to egg mortality in endangered sea turtle nests worldwide [4,5]. Two closely related fungal species, Fusarium keratoplasticum (Fk) and F. falciforme (Ff), have been implicated as the causative agents of STEF , but questions remain regarding the etiology and epidemiology of these pathogens. Primarily, it is unclear whether Fk and Ff are invasive pathogens or natural nest inhabitants causing disease under changing environmental conditions.
Effective management strategies for the control of emerging fungal diseases such as STEF require an understanding of whether a pathogen is novel or endemic . A novel pathogen gains access to and infects naïve hosts as a result of migration of the pathogen or the development of novel pathogenic genotypes. Thus, effective management strategies must aim primarily at preventing pathogen introduction and expansion, often with a focus on potential disease vectors or other means of pathogen transmission. In contrast, endemic pathogens naturally occur in the host’s environment, but shifts in environmental conditions and/or host susceptibility heavily influence pathogenicity. Hence, management of disease caused by endemic pathogens relies on an understanding of environmental and host factors that influence disease emergence and severity. Because of these fundamental differences in management strategies, defining a pathogen as novel or endemic is a key first step toward mitigating disease impact on host populations .
Determining whether Fk and Ff are novel or endemic agents of STEF first requires an understanding of their ecology and distribution. This review focuses on the known ecological and epidemiological connections between Fk and Ff as human pathogens and inhabitants of the built environment and their recent emergence in association with STEF. Emphasis is placed herein on the importance of investigating these connections within a population biology framework to assess the endemic or novel nature of these pathogens for management purposes.
What do we know about the Fusarium pathogens Fk and Ff?
Fusarium is a diverse genus of ascomycete fungi, currently containing approximately 300 phylogenetic species distributed in 23 monophyletic lineages referred to as species complexes [7,8]. Fusaria are best known for their economic impacts as plant pathogens, such as Panama disease of bananas caused by F. oxysporum f.sp. cubense race 4 . They are also well known for the public health impacts associated with production of mycotoxins such as trichothecenes, zearalenone, and fumonisins . In addition, phylogenetically diverse Fusarium species are responsible for mycotic infections in humans and other animals. Approximately 75% of fusarioses are caused by members of one lineage, the F. solani species complex (FSSC) . Fk and Ff, the two species known to be associated with STEF, are common, cosmopolitan members of the FSSC. They can cause life-threatening mycoses in immunocompromised or immunosuppressed humans, as well as cutaneous and subcutaneous infections, with a particular propensity to cause corneal infections in healthy individuals (Fig 1A) . Outside of these infections, Ff is found around the world mostly as a soil-associated species (Fig 1B); however, prior to its discovery in association with STEF, Fk had only been isolated from nonsoil sources of high anthropogenic influence, particularly plumbing systems (Fig 1C) [13,14].
(A) Fk and Ff are both associated with clinical infections, especially keratitis of the eye. (B) Ff is a common soil inhabitant, which is the reservoir implicated in corneal infections caused by this species. (C) Fk and Ff have both been found in the built environment, but Fk is typically present in much larger numbers. (D) Fk and Ff have both been found in association with sea turtle egg fusariosis. However, the epidemiology of these species as disease agents, and their potential connection to the built environment and human infections, is unknown. Ff, F. falciforme; Fk, F. keratoplasticum.
Anaissie and colleagues  formally proposed a link between nosocomial Fusarium infections and hospital water systems, finding evidence that these opportunistic fungi reside in certain parts of the hospital environment, such as showerheads and sink drains. Molecular evidence later reinforced these findings [11,16]. Fk, initially referred to as FSSC 2 , was later identified as one of the two most common species in the 2005 and 2006 outbreaks of fungal keratitis in contact lens users in Southeast Asia and North America . A subsequent study, explicitly looking at Fusarium diversity in bathroom sink drains across the eastern United States, found Fk to be a dominant species, but Ff was also present in low levels , further suggesting that plumbing biofilms may serve as a reservoir for these opportunistic pathogens. Outside of these outbreaks associated with contact lens use, most Ff keratitis infections have been attributed to traumatic introduction of soil particles or plant debris into the eye, consistent with this species’ widespread association with soil environments .
What is STEF?
Fusarium species have been isolated from the eggshells and embryonic tissue of failed sea turtle eggs for several decades, with hypotheses concerning their ecological role ranging from decomposition to pathogenicity . Previous studies on the mycobiota from failed sea turtle eggs have reported a number of species, including members of the FSSC and F. oxysporum species complex . Artificial incubation of sea turtle eggs with sand from nesting beaches suggested that once fungal invaders have colonized a failed egg, they are able to spread to adjacent healthy eggs and cause mortality . In 2010, Fk and Ff, originally identified as F. solani, were associated with mass mortalities in the nests of loggerhead sea turtles (Caretta caretta) in Boa Vista, Cape Verde . Koch’s postulates conducted with a strain of Fk isolated from eggs in Boa Vista provided evidence supporting Fk as a causative agent of STEF . Koch’s postulates have not been conducted with Ff. Following this discovery, a worldwide survey of sea turtle nesting sites revealed that Fk and Ff were isolated from infected eggs from six of seven sea turtle species at major nesting sites in the Atlantic, Indian, and Pacific Oceans, as well as the Caribbean Sea [4,20]. Despite their global distribution in sea turtle nests, little is known about local and regional impacts of Fk and Ff on nesting sites and the factors that play a role in disease development.
Symptoms indicating that sea turtle eggs might be infected with Fusarium include the presence of atypically colored areas (e.g., yellow, blue, gray, red) on the eggshell, with more severe infections showing gray hyphal mats on the outside and the inside of the eggs and on the embryos . However, Fk and Ff have also been isolated from asymptomatic eggs, suggesting that the presence of the pathogen may not be sufficient for disease to occur. Factors such as changing environmental conditions have been shown to influence hatching success and may also influence disease development . Results of the aforementioned study also documented that disease incidence and nest mortality were significantly higher in nests exposed to tidal inundation or in sand with silt/clay composition compared with dry sand nests. High levels of clay and silt on nesting beaches have been shown to severely impact hatching success, particularly for loggerhead sea turtles, independent of disease .
There is still much we do not know about STEF, including the source(s) of Fk and Ff, as highlighted in Fig 1D, as well as environmental factors that may contribute to disease development. Are Fk and Ff native to sandy beach environments? Is their association with inundated nests indicative of a marine or sand-borne origin? Or are these pathogens introduced into the nest environment via runoff from the built environment, where they are associated with plumbing systems and opportunistic human infections? Distinguishing among these potential sources has important implications regarding the epidemiology and etiology of STEF and for formulating informed approaches focusing on prevention and management. The known global distribution of these opportunistic pathogens, in addition to the role environmental conditions play in disease incidence and severity, suggest an endemic nature, but more evidence is needed to support this hypothesis. Future research on this topic should include studies testing the association of Fk and Ff presence with hatch success in sea turtle nests, as well as experiments to determine the influence of environmental factors on Fusarium pathogenicity on sea turtle eggs.
How can population genetics help unravel the ecology and epidemiology of the STEF pathogens?
Population genetic data provide a useful means for differentiating source and migrant populations of an emerging pathogen. Multilocus sequence-based genotyping has been used to determine the novel or endemic nature of fungal diseases, including white-nose syndrome , chytridiomycosis , and Fusarium diseases of humans . The latter study significantly advanced our understanding of pathogen identity, genetic diversity, and clonal versus recombinant modes of reproduction and enabled key epidemiological inferences about populations of the opportunistic human pathogen Fk. By analyzing Fusarium populations from sea turtle eggs and nesting environments in the context of these studies, this method could be used to relate STEF to the known diversity of Fk, which is based mostly on human clinical and plumbing environments, and Ff, which is based mostly on human clinical and soil environments.
Short and colleagues  used a 9-locus sequence-based genotyping system that revealed very high levels of genetic diversity among a large collection of Fk isolates (n = 231) from human infections and other sources, with the majority isolated from plumbing environments. This analysis also revealed that the Fk 2-d sequence type was prevalent in human infections and sink drains. Fk 2-d was one of the two most common sequence types recovered from the 2005 and 2006 contact lens–associated outbreaks of mycotic keratitis . On top of this strongly clonal pattern, evidence for historical recombination was discovered in Fk 2-d across a diverse array of genotypes. These results suggest a mixed reproductive model, involving sexual and asexual reproduction, allowing for adaptation to a changing environment and rapid spread of successful genotypes through clonal expansion . Based on a simpler 3-locus typing system, Ff appears to be even more diverse than Fk . However, research on Ff has not been conducted to assess whether it possesses a dominant expanding clone complex associated with human infections.
Key questions raised by our current level of knowledge regarding Fk and Ff derived from human infections and other environments include the following: (1) Is Fk 2-d disproportionately represented in STEF, as it is in human fusarioses and in plumbing systems? (2) If so, were the introduction and subsequent establishment of Fk 2-d in sea turtle nests due to anthropogenic influence? (3) Or does STEF-associated Fk diversity reflect a pattern we currently infer in Ff, in which diverse local genotypes cause opportunistic infections? And (4) do Fk and Ff isolated from sandy beach environments reflect an endemic source or migrant populations with regard to disease occurrence?
The answers to these questions should provide a framework for designing management strategies. Because of bottlenecks and clonal selection, novel pathogens of sea turtle eggs are expected to exhibit reduced allelic variation and increased association among loci when compared with non-STEF-associated populations (i.e., from sink drains, human infections, hatched turtle eggshells, beach sand). If they are endemic, we predict that isolates from diseased sea turtle eggs and non-STEF-associated sources will not exhibit population subdivision . More structured sampling of the built environment and intertidal ecosystems is necessary to elucidate the global population structure and genetic diversity of Fk and Ff.
As fungal diseases of wildlife become more common, it is imperative that the biological and ecological factors that contribute to the emergence and severity of outbreaks be identified. Establishing whether a pathogen is endemic or novel is an essential first step toward informed management and control of a newly emergent fungal disease . Population genetics provides a key framework for addressing this question. We currently have assembled large collections of Fk and Ff from the built environment and clinical sources to which STEF-associated isolates can be compared. In addition, a validated sequence-based typing system is available for rapid genotyping and assessment of population structure. These tools, combined with more intensive sampling of sea turtle nesting sites for Fusarium species, are key to understanding the current and future impact of STEF worldwide.
Mention of trade names or commercial products in this publication is solely for the purpose of providing specific information and does not imply recommendation or endorsement by the US Department of Agriculture (USDA). The USDA is an equal opportunity provider and employer.
- 1. Fisher MC, Henk DA, Briggs CJ, Brownstein JS, Madoff LC, McCraw SL, et al. Emerging fungal threats to animal, plant and ecosystem health. Nature. 2012;484:186–194. pmid:22498624.
- 2. U. S. Fish and Wildlife Service. North American bat death toll exceeds 5.5 million from white-nose syndrome [press release]. 2012 Jan 17 [cited 2018 Sep 20]. Available from: https://www.batcon.org/pdfs/USFWS_WNS_Mortality_2012_NR_FINAL.pdf.
- 3. Skerratt LF, Berger L, Speare R, Cashins S, McDonald KR, Phillott AD, et al. Spread of chytridiomycosis has caused the rapid global decline and extinction of frogs. EcoHealth. 2007;4:125–134.
- 4. Sarmiento-Ramírez JM, Abella-Pérez E, Phillott AD, Sim J, van West P, Martín MP, et al. Global distribution of two fungal pathogens threatening endangered sea turtles. PLoS ONE. 2014;9(1):e85853. pmid:24465748.
- 5. Sarmiento-Ramírez JM, Abella E, Martín MP, Tellería MT, López-Jurado LF, Marco A, et al. Fusarium solani is responsible for mass mortalities in nests of loggerhead sea turtle, Caretta caretta, in Boavista, Cape Verde. FEMS Microbiol Lett. 2010;312(2):192–200. pmid:20875054.
- 6. Rachowicz LJ, Hero JM, Alford RA, Taylor JW, Morgan JAT, Vredenburg VT, et al. The novel and endemic pathogen hypotheses: competing explanations for the origin of emerging infectious diseases of wildlife. Conserv Biol. 2005; 19(5):1441–1448.
- 7. O’Donnell K, Rooney AP, Proctor RH, Brown DW, McCormick SP, Ward TJ, et al. Phylogenetic analyses of RPB1 and RPB2 support a middle Cretaceous origin for a clade comprising all agriculturally and medically important fusaria. Fungal Genet Biol. 2013;52:20–31. pmid:23357352.
- 8. Zhou X, O'Donnell K, Aoki T, Smith JA, Kasson MT, Cao ZH. Two novel Fusarium species that cause canker disease of prickly ash (Zanthoxylum bungeanum) in northern China form a novel clade with Fusarium torreyae. Mycologia. 2016;108(4):668–81. pmid:27055569.
- 9. Ploetz RC. Panama Disease: Return of the first banana menace. International Journal of Pest Management. 2008;40(4):326–36.
- 10. D’Mello JPF, Placinta CM, Macdonald AMC. Fusarium mycotoxins: a review of global implications for animal health, welfare and productivity. Animal Feed Science and Technology. 1999;80(3):183–205.
- 11. Zhang N, O’Donnell K, Sutton DA, Nalim FA, Summerbell RC, Padhye AA, et al. Members of the Fusarium solani species complex that cause infections in both humans and plants are common in the environment. J Clin Microbiol. 2006;44(6):2186–90. pmid:16757619.
- 12. O’Donnell K, Sutton DA, Fothergill A, McCarthy D, Rinaldi MG, Brandt ME, et al. Molecular phylogenetic diversity, multilocus haplotype nomenclature, and in vitro antifungal resistance within the Fusarium solani species complex. J Clin Microbiol. 2008;46(8):2477–90. pmid:18524963.
- 13. Short DP, O'Donnell K, Zhang N, Juba JH, Geiser DM. Widespread occurrence of diverse human pathogenic types of the fungus Fusarium detected in plumbing drains. J Clin Microbiol. 2011;49(12):4264–72. pmid:21976755.
- 14. Short DP, O’Donnell K, Geiser DM. Clonality, recombination, and hybridization in the plumbing-inhabiting human pathogen Fusarium keratoplasticum inferred from multilocus sequence typing. BMC Evol Biol. 2014;14:91. pmid:24766947.
- 15. Anaissie EJ, Kuchar RT, Rex JH, Francesconi A, Kasai M, Müller FMC, et al. Fusariosis associated with pathogenic Fusarium species colonization of a hospital water system: A new paradigm for the epidemiology of opportunistic mold infections. Clin Infect Dis. 2001;33(11):1871–78. pmid:11692299.
- 16. O’Donnell K, Sarver BAJ, Brandt M, Chang DC, Noble-Wang J, Park BJ, et al. Phylogenetic diversity and microsphere array-based genotyping of human pathogenic fusaria, including isolates from the multistate contact lens associated U.S. keratitis outbreaks of 2005 and 2006. J Clin Microbiol. 2007;45(7):2235–48. pmid:17507522
- 17. Chang DC, Grant GB, O’Donnell K, Wannemuehler KA, Noble-Wang J, Rao CY, et al. Multistate outbreak of Fusarium keratitis associated with use of a contact lens solution. JAMA. 2006;296(8):953–63. pmid:16926355.
- 18. Phillott AD, Parmenter CJ. The distribution of failed eggs and the appearance of fungi in artificial nests of green (Chelonia mydas) and loggerhead (Caretta caretta) sea turtles. Aust J Zool. 2001;49(6):713–18.
- 19. Phillott AD, Parmenter CJ, Limpus CJ. Occurrence of mycobiota in eastern Australian sea turtle nests. Mem. Queensl. Mus. 2004;49:701–3.
- 20. Sarmiento-Ramírez JM, Sim J, Van West P, Diéguez-Uribeondo J. Isolation of fungal pathogens from eggs of the endangered sea turtle species Chelonia mydas in Ascension Island. J Mar Biol Assoc U.K. 2017;97(4):661–67.
- 21. Marco A, Abella-Perez E, Tiwari M. Vulnerability of loggerhead turtle eggs to the presence of clay and silt on nesting beaches. J Exp Mar Biol Ecol. 2017;486:195–203.
- 22. Warnecke L, Turner JM, Bollinger TK, Lorch JM, Misra V, Cryan PM, et al. Inoculation of bats with European Geomyces destructans supports the novel pathogen hypothesis for the origin of white-nose syndrome. PNAS. 2012;109(18):6999–7003. pmid:22493237.