It is well documented that the density of Plasmodium in its vertebrate host modulates the physiological response induced; this in turn regulates parasite survival and transmission. It is less clear that parasite density in the mosquito regulates survival and transmission of this important pathogen. Numerous studies have described conversion rates of Plasmodium from one life stage to the next within the mosquito, yet few have considered that these rates might vary with parasite density. Here we establish infections with defined numbers of the rodent malaria parasite Plasmodium berghei to examine how parasite density at each stage of development (gametocytes; ookinetes; oocysts and sporozoites) influences development to the ensuing stage in Anopheles stephensi, and thus the delivery of infectious sporozoites to the vertebrate host. We show that every developmental transition exhibits strong density dependence, with numbers of the ensuing stages saturating at high density. We further show that when fed ookinetes at very low densities, oocyst development is facilitated by increasing ookinete number (i.e., the efficiency of ookinete–oocyst transformation follows a sigmoid relationship). We discuss how observations on this model system generate important hypotheses for the understanding of malaria biology, and how these might guide the rational analysis of interventions against the transmission of the malaria parasites of humans by their diverse vector species.
Malaria, one of the world's most devastating parasitic diseases, is caused by protozoan parasites of the genus Plasmodium and is transmitted between mammalian hosts by Anopheles mosquitoes. Within the mosquito, the parasite undergoes four sequential developmental transformations as it passes from the bloodmeal through the mosquito's midgut epithelium to the salivary glands, from where the parasite is inoculated when the mosquito bites the vertebrate host. This study demonstrates, in a laboratory model, that parasite input density at every developmental stage in the mosquito regulates output to the ensuing form. Statistical models were fitted to experimental data to identify and describe the most appropriate functional relationships. In all cases, the relationships between two consecutive parasite stages can saturate at high parasite densities, suggesting that at high parasite densities parasite numbers may have to be reduced substantially to effect an appreciable decrease in parasite transmission. These results may help establish a rational basis for new studies on species of medical importance and further our understanding of how interventions designed to reduce parasite survival within the mosquito might be expected to impact upon transmission.
Citation: Sinden RE, Dawes EJ, Alavi Y, Waldock J, Finney O, Mendoza J, et al. (2007) Progression of Plasmodium berghei through Anopheles stephensi Is Density-Dependent. PLoS Pathog 3(12): e195. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.ppat.0030195
Editor: Kenneth Vernick, University of Minnesota, United States of America
Received: January 16, 2007; Accepted: November 5, 2007; Published: December 28, 2007
Copyright: © 2007 Sinden et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: This work has been supported by The World Health Organization (YA), the Wellcome Trust (GAB, JM), the EU RTN networks and EU Biomalpar programmes (RES), and the Medical Research Council, UK (EJD and M-GB).
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Abbreviations: AIC, Akaike Information Criterion; CI, confidence interval; df, degrees of freedom; IFAT, indirect fluorescent antibody test; GFP, green fluorescent protein; LRS, likelihood ratio statistic; ML, maximum likelihood; NBD, negative binomial distribution; PCR, polymerase chain reaction; WM, Williams' mean; VMR, variance over mean ratio
The availability of the genomes of man, the mosquito and the malarial parasite has enabled penetrating new studies on the molecular organization of Plasmodium in its two hosts. Yet, we do not fully comprehend how parasite population densities may affect transmissibility. Without this knowledge our understanding of the impact of host responses, or of external intervention, upon the transmission of the parasite through endemic populations will remain incomplete.
Within the mosquito, Plasmodium transforms from macrogametocyte to ookinete, oocyst, and finally to sporozoite. The many studies reporting marked fluctuations in parasite numbers during this development have been elegantly summarized by Vaughan . In susceptible mosquitoes it is the oocyst that frequently represents the nadir of parasite numbers in the life cycle (Figure 1). Within the oocyst, parasite numbers reportedly increase by two or three orders of magnitude [2,3] before the daughter sporozoites make their inefficient passage to the salivary glands. Few are inoculated into the vertebrate host when the female mosquito takes a subsequent bloodmeal [4–8]. In a number of well characterized parasite–mosquito combinations, ookinetes completely fail to cross the midgut epithelium or sporozoites fail to invade the salivary glands [9,10]. An important question that has eluded enquiry, however, is whether the ookinete-oocyst bottleneck and the other developmental transitions through the mosquito are density-dependent. (In this context, a transition is density-dependent when the rate at which such process occurs is determined by the parasite density of the previous stage.) Contributory factors for this omission may include the facts that most previous studies have compared parasite numbers in just two life stages, looked at a single infection intensity, or investigated densities within narrow ranges [11–13].
Reported changes in numbers of P. berghei as it develops in An. stephensi, starting from an intake of 104 macrogametocytes. Note the use of a log-scale on the y-axis. Figure adapted from Sinden , based on data from Alavi et al. .
In this paper we have attempted to address this question by measuring the relationships between wide-ranging densities of successive life stages (macrogametocytes, ookinetes, oocysts and salivary gland sporozoites) achievable in the laboratory model Plasmodium berghei–Anopheles stephensi, and by statistically fitting functional forms to these relationships. Determining the form of these relationships may increase our understanding both of the processes regulating the transmission of this parasite by the mosquito, and (by extrapolation) of the potential impact of intervention measures. Although the biological bases for the parameters thus estimated can be inferred, we make no attempt to verify them experimentally. We recognize that they may include, among others: interspecific competition between the parasite and its vertebrate and invertebrate hosts (the former being largely, though not exclusively, confined to the mosquito bloodmeal, and the latter mediated, for instance, by immune attack from the mosquito); intraspecific competition between parasites; and the possible “altruistic” apoptotic death of the parasite . The incorporation of the functional forms that we report in this paper into a mathematical model describing the transition of Plasmodium within the mosquito, and its linkage to malaria models that take into account parasite density in the human host , will be presented elsewhere.
The following results describe the dynamics of P. berghei within An. stephensi observed in one laboratory, with experiments conducted by many different researchers on numerous occasions. We recognize that some of the parasite densities achievable in this parasite–insect combination lie outside those normally recorded in most infections of human parasites in their natural vectors; nonetheless, these “extreme values” permit a more objective fitting of functional forms that span the full range of values anticipated in the latter species.
Estimating the Type and Severity of Density Dependence
The fitting procedures investigated the frequency distribution among mosquitoes of the outcome variable (parasite numbers of the ensuing stage); fitted an appropriate distribution (usually overdispersed); explored the relationship between the degree of overdispersion and mean parasite density; and fitted models to both the means (to allow comparisons to be made with the literature) and to the individual parasite counts (to allow maximum use of the data available) for the relationships between two consecutive parasite stages.
Density dependence can be positive (facilitation) or negative (limitation), characterized by the per capita parasite yield increasing or decreasing, respectively, with parasite density. Initial facilitation may be followed by subsequent limitation, producing a sigmoid relationship. Absence of density dependence, where the rate of success is constant with parasite density is characterized by proportionality. To encompass all these possible behaviors, we fitted the following generalized formula, where x represents the input and y the output parasite density. This function can describe a linear (α > 0; β = 1; γ = 0); a saturating (α > 0; β = 1; γ > 0); or a sigmoid (α > 0; β > 1; γ > 0) relationship, with each function being nested into the following one. The attributes of each of these functional forms are described in Table 1.
Macrogametocyte to Ookinete Transition
Data for this transition originated from two researchers on four separate occasions. The behavior of this transition was independent of the worker conducting the infections (results not shown). Analysing the datasets jointly revealed that the overall distribution of the number of ookinetes per mosquito was strongly overdispersed, confirmed by a variance over mean ratio (VMR) of 1108 (where a VMR of 1 suggests a Poisson, random distribution). A negative binomial distribution (NBD) was fitted to the overall frequency of mosquitoes harboring a given number of ookinetes; this revealed an arithmetic mean infection of 643 ookinetes per mosquito and an overdispersion parameter estimate of 0.45 (95% confidence interval (CI): 0.02–3.59) (Figure 2A). The chi-square goodness of fit test indicated good agreement between the observed and expected distributions (χ2 = 13.2, degrees of freedom (df) = 12, p = 0.36). When a separate NBD was fitted for each macrogametocyte density and its parameters estimated, the most overdispersed distributions were found among the lowest ookinete densities, and the degree of overdispersion decreased with increasing density (Figure 2B) as found in other parasite–vector systems .
(A) Frequency distribution of the number of ookinetes per mosquito. Observed frequency (red bars), expected frequency according to negative binomial distribution (blue bars) with k = 0.45 (an inverse measure of the degree of overdispersion; i.e., the lower the value of k, the greater the departure from the Poisson, random distribution), estimated by maximum likelihood.
(B) Maximum likelihood estimates of parameter k (for each macrogametocyte density) against arithmetic mean ookinete density. The degree of overdispersion decreases (k increases) with mean ookinete density with a saturating relationship when the outlying red point (from OF's experiments) is excluded.
(C) WM number of ookinetes per mosquito against number of macrogametocytes per bloodmeal. Ookinete density increases nonlinearly with macrogametocyte density when the outlying red point (from JM's experiment) is excluded. Error bars denote standard errors of WMs.
(D) Number of ookinetes per individual mosquito against number of macrogametocytes per bloodmeal. The fitted curve corresponds to a saturating function (with underling nonlinear relationship between overdispersion parameter and mean ookinete density).
All data pertain to P. berghei in An. stephensi. Markers in (B–D) refer to three experiments by OF (blue) and one by JM (green).
Due to the overdispersion found in the data, the relationship between the number of macrogametocytes offered in the bloodmeal, and the resulting mean ookinete density, was investigated using the geometric mean of Williams (WM)  as a measure of central tendency for ookinete density. Excluding one outlying datapoint (where exceptional parasite death occurred) the best-fitting expression proved to be a saturating, hyperbolic function (with α = 0.008 (0.006–0.009) and γ = 2.36 × 10−6 (1.09 × 10−6–4.27 × 10−6)), indicating that the efficiency of this transition declines monotonically with increasing macrogametocyte density (Figure 2C). Initially ∼125 macrogametocytes are required to produce one ookinete and ookinete numbers saturate at a value (given by α/γ) of ∼3,500 per mosquito.
A hyperbolic relationship between the number of ingested macrogametocytes and the resulting numbers of ookinetes produced, was again indicated when plotting the ookinete counts for individual mosquitoes (with α = 0.013 (0.012–0.014) and γ = 3.57 × 10−6 (2.56 × 10−6–4.67 × 10−6); Figure 2D). This again suggests that the probability of a macrogametocyte becoming an ookinete declines with increasing input. This analysis predicts that initially ∼77 macrogametocytes make one ookinete, and this relationship again saturates at a density of ∼3,500 ookinetes per mosquito.
Ookinete to Oocyst Transition
Data for this transition came from three researchers and nine experiments. We recognize that the following analysis may be influenced by the atypical relationship that might exist between the pre-formed ookinetes in the bloodmeal and the midgut of the insect. As in the previous transition, oocyst numbers were overdispersed (VMR = 63). An NBD was fitted to the combined datasets, and to the oocyst frequency distributions for each ookinete input density. However in this case, the NBD was not the most appropriate to describe the frequency of mosquitoes with a given oocyst density (χ2 = 158.8, df = 29, p < 0.001) (unlike ); this may be because our ookinete feed technique (unlike the gametocyte feeds used in ), rarely fails to infect mosquitoes. As in the previous transition, the degree of overdispersion was maximal at low oocyst mean densities, and decreased with increasing density.
The fitted relationship between input ookinete density and the resulting WM oocyst number (Figure 3A) indicated a sigmoid relationship, suggesting the operation of initial facilitation and subsequent limitation (with α = 6.87 × 10−5 (5.28 × 10−5–8.85 × 10−5); β = 1.98 (1.89–2.11) and γ = 2.64 × 10−6 (1.88 × 10−6–3.81 × 10−6)). Initially, 120 ookinetes produce one oocyst; at the point of maximum yield ∼60 ookinetes produce one oocyst; and as the number of ookinetes increases further, the transformation becomes constrained above a mean density of ∼26 oocysts per mosquito.
(A) WM number of oocysts per mosquito against number of ookinetes per μl of blood. Mean oocyst density is related to ookinete density by a sigmoid function. Error bars denote standard errors of the WMs.
(B) Number of oocysts per individual mosquito against number of ookinetes per μl of blood. The black line is fitted to the combined data; the brown line to data from ; the green line to data from JM; and the pink line to data from experiments by JW. In all cases the fitted curve corresponds to a sigmoid function (with an underlying nonlinear, power relationship between overdispersion and mean oocyst density). Assuming a bloodmeal volume of 2.13 μl, ookinete density can be expressed per mosquito by multiplying by 2.13.
All data pertain to P. berghei in An. stephensi. Markers refer to one experiment by JM (green), three by JW (pink/violet), and five by  (orange/yellow/brown).
As with the relationship identified for the means, the best fitting model for the number of oocysts per individual mosquito as a function of ookinete density (Figure 3B), was sigmoid (with parameters α = 5.84 × 10−4 (5.55 × 10−4, 6.12 × 10−4); β = 1.74 (1.73, 1.76); γ = 7.44 × 10−6 (6.89 × 10−6, 8.11 × 10−6)). Initially ∼72 ookinetes are required to produce one oocyst; at the point of maximum yield this requirement decreases to ∼35 ookinetes per oocyst; and the relationship saturates at a maximum of ∼80 oocysts per mosquito as the number of ookinetes increases. When testing inter-experimenter variation it was clear that even in the same laboratory, oocyst production from ookinete membrane-feeds varied markedly between different researchers. Nonetheless each experimenter's data invariably indicated that, despite the differing overall efficiency of oocyst production, every relationship was sigmoid (Figure 3B, Table 2).
Parameter Estimates for Sigmoid Models Fitted to the Ookinete to Oocyst Transition
Recognizing that the transformation of the ookinete into an oocyst is dependent not only on the ookinete locating and invading the midgut wall, but also on the ability of the intracellular ookinete to survive attack by the mosquito's innate immune mechanisms, we have, in replicate studies, examined directly the ability of green fluorescent protein (GFP)-expressing ookinetes to invade the gut cells. Following the ingestion of 3,600 GFP-tagged ookinetes, a mean of 516 (or 14%) were detected 24 hours later in the midgut epithelium. This number of ookinetes would be expected to produce 80 oocysts (Figure 3B) and thus at this infection intensity just 16% (80/516) of the ookinetes in the midgut epithelium are predicted to be detected as oocysts 9 days later.
Oocyst to Sporozoites in the Salivary Glands
Data for this transition came from three independent experiments by one researcher. The number of sporozoites per mosquito showed strong overdispersion (VMR = 1,393). The distributions resulting from each oocyst density were separately examined for an NBD, and again, overdispersion decreased with increasing sporozoite density. However, as for the frequency distribution of oocysts, the NBD did not fit the distribution of the number of salivary gland sporozoites per mosquito (χ2 = 41.3, df = 19, p < 0.002) as well as it did for the ookinete distribution.
The relationship between the output WM number of salivary gland sporozoites per mosquito and the input WM oocyst density per mosquito (Figure 4A) was most parsimoniously fitted by a linear model (with α = 14.61 (11.58–17.63)) based on the likelihood ratio statistic (LRS) analyses, although this model was only marginally better than the hyperbolic fit. (The latter was suggested as the better model according to the Akaike Information Criterion (AIC) and this discrepancy may indicate insufficient power to distinguish between the two models.) This relationship predicts that in this study on average, each oocyst produces between just 12 and 18 sporozoites that successfully invade the salivary glands. This relationship became significantly nonlinear when analyzing the number of salivary gland sporozoites per individual mosquito as a function of the mean oocyst density (Figure 4B). In this case, the best fitting model was hyperbolic (with α = 62.21 (53.98–72.20) and γ = 0.018 (0.013–0.024)), indicating that initially 54–72 salivary gland sporozoites are produced per oocyst, and thereafter the efficiency of conversion declines with rising oocyst density, reaching a plateau of ∼3,500 salivary gland sporozoites per mosquito irrespective of rising oocyst input.
(A) WM number of sporozoites in the salivary glands against WM number of oocysts per mosquito. Mean sporozoite density increases linearly with oocyst density. Error bars denote standard errors of the WMs.
(B) Number of salivary gland sporozoites per individual mosquito against the WM number of oocysts per mosquito. The fitted curve corresponds to a saturating function (with underling linear relationship between overdispersion and mean ookinete density).
All data pertain to P. berghei in An. stephensi. Markers refer to three experiments by JW.
The Role of Experimental Models
We recognize that one model system cannot accurately reflect the diverse biology of the hundreds of natural malaria–vector combinations found worldwide; nonetheless we also recognize that studies on the biology of Plasmodium spp., and their interactions with Anopheles spp., have been advanced considerably by the analysis of malaria parasites of rodents. Exploiting the rare opportunity to study, in a controlled environment, cloned populations of P. berghei in an inbred line of An. stephensi at widely differing parasite densities has permitted us to raise questions in the model that are orders of magnitude more difficult to study in the parasites of man. Under these specific conditions, we show that parasite's developmental transitions within the mosquito are density-dependent. These conclusions are consistent with limited (mainly laboratory based) studies on the malaria parasites of humans (see below). They help generate key hypotheses that now require to be tested on other parasite–vector combinations. We recognize that future laboratory studies on , for example, P. falciparum–An. gambiae, would have to conduct experiments with lab adapted strains of both parasite and vector; not only are these experiments more costly (in addition to requiring extensive safety management), but also the lab strains themselves lack the diversity of natural populations. We recognise therefore that the key studies will be those on the parasites and vectors in their numerous and different endemic areas. If validated in the human malarias, the hypotheses generated in this study may have important implications for the design of anti-malarial intervention programs.
To our knowledge, this is the first quantitative investigation of the impact of parasite density upon all transitions between Plasmodium stages within the mosquito. Our data have permitted analyses not only of measures of central tendency in groups of mosquitoes (the most frequent type of (aggregate) analysis reported in the literature), but also of parasite counts in individual mosquitoes, and their distribution.
Gametocyte numbers in the bloodmeal are variously described as being normally distributed [1,19] or overdispersed [20,21]; ookinete numbers in the ingested bloodmeal as being normally distributed  or overdispersed [19,22]; and oocysts and salivary gland sporozoites as being markedly overdispersed [6,18,19,22,23]. Recognising that the NBD can originate, for instance, when each host /vector is infected according to a Poisson process whose mean is gamma-distributed (i.e., there is marked heterogeneity in mosquito susceptibility ), we were interested to find that even using highly “inbred” organisms, ookinete, oocyst, and gland sporozoite numbers per mosquito exhibit strong overdispersion (see also [24,25]). As previously observed [16,18], the severity of overdispersion was itself density-dependent, decreasing with mean parasite density both when the relationship between overdispersion and parasite load was analyzed separately (having fitted distributions to each parasite density previously), and when the degree of overdispersion was allowed to vary with parasite density whilst jointly fitting models to individual parasite counts.
Oocyst Development within the Mosquito
In designing these experiments we were cognizant of early studies which recognized that infectivity of individual gametocyte carriers differs widely over the course of an infection [26–28]. Whereas P. berghei ookinete production in vitro faithfully reflected gametocyte density in the blood, oocyst formation in the mosquito host was severely compromised after day 5 of the blood infection . Whereas some prior studies have concluded that gametocyte-oocyst intensities are linearly related [11,12], others noted a nonlinear relationship in P. falciparum within, but not between experiments . Ponnudurai et al.  and Pichon et al.  reported the operation of density-dependent suppression of oocyst development in P. falciparum; we have similarly found that the gametocyte-oocyst transformation is density-dependent. Notwithstanding the operation of nonlinearities, the efficiency of this conversion in our experimental P. berghei–An. stephensi system tends to be lower than that estimated in the natural combinations P. gallinaceum–Aedes aegypti  and P. falciparum–An. gambiae  (results not shown).
The numerous blood-borne variables responsible for modulating gametocyte-oocyst development in vivo transcend species, and many suppress the early conversion of gametocytes to ookinetes [31–40]. Mosquito factors regulating infection are less well understood but include physiological, immunologic and biotic variables [41–44], the expression of which varies with both mosquito and parasite species [45,46], as well as with genotypes [31,47]. Interestingly, it has been suggested that Plasmodium may have immunosuppressive effects upon the vector . Consistent with the above, recent analyses on P. vivax concluded that it is vertebrate factors that impact largely upon fertilization, whereas mosquito factors determine ookinete losses .
Unlike these previous studies which investigated the relationship between gametocytes and oocysts (and found or not some evidence of nonlinearity), our work has aimed at teasing out where exactly nonlinearities may be occurring, and therefore we have examined the transition from gametocytes to ookinetes separately from that of ookinetes to oocysts. In P. falciparum the efficiency of macrogametocyte to ookinete conversion in vivo reportedly varies widely (from 0.025% to 42%) . In P. berghei, we find that the efficiency of conversion for the transition of macrogametocytes to ookinetes is maximal at the lowest parasite densities (i.e., the hyperbolic models were found to best fit this relationship). At the lowest macrogametocyte densities investigated (i.e., ∼7,000 per bloodmeal) the efficiency of ookinete production in vivo is ∼1.3%; thereafter the efficiency falls progressively with increasing density (0.6% for 360,000 macrogametocyes/bloodmeal). This fall suggests competition for limited resources, or density-dependent stimulation of a parasite-killing response in the mosquito [44,51,52].
Interestingly, when examining ookinete to oocyst development we found a sigmoid relationship, indicating that at low ookinete densities, and with this experimental design, the transition was positively density-dependent (i.e., the per capita probability of successful oocyst establishment was very low at the lowest ookinete densities but increased initially with increasing ookinete density in the bloodmeal). Similarly, a sigmoid zygote-oocyst relationship was reported by Rosenberg et al. when P. gallinaceum female zygotes produced in vitro were membrane-fed to Ae. aegypti . The maximal parasite yield (100%) was achieved for zygote densities of ∼4/mosquito, but at ∼40,000/mosquito the per zygote efficiency had decreased to 0.3%. A possible biological explanation for this initial facilitation may lie in the difficulty that individual ookinetes may have to disrupt the mosquito's peritrophic matrix or midgut epithelial cells, whereas at higher ookinete densities, those which succeed in penetrating these structures may make it easier for other ookinetes to do so, facilitating their passage and ultimately their establishment under the basal lamina of the midgut epithelium. These results are entirely consistent with an earlier study by Munderloh and Kurtti , who observed that low numbers of P. berghei ookinetes do not reliably produce oocyst infections. Assuming a bloodmeal volume of 2.13 μl , our data suggest that to ensure infection with at least one oocyst, approximately 40–140 ookinetes/mosquito are required (Table 2), whereas they estimated that ∼1,100 (purified) ookinetes would be necessary. We attribute these differences in number to recent improvements in the parasite culture. Studies on P. falciparum in vivo  similarly indicate an apparent “threshold” ookinete density of 30/mosquito in An. gambiae. Sigmoid relationships have a “turning” parasite density at which the maximum probability of transformation is achieved and beyond which negative density dependence operates. The turning-point ookinete density (assuming β = 2 for simplicity) is 355 for the model fitted to mean P. berghei oocyst density (Figure 3A), and 212 for the model fitted to all individual data combined (black curve in Figure 3B; see Table 2 for researcher-specific turning points). Other examples of initial facilitation followed by subsequent limitation within a vector have been found among filarial parasites . Earlier studies [50,55–57] remarked on the high cost of ookinete-oocyst transformation, and suggest it to be a critical block. Published work suggests that at this stage of development, mosquitoes can be significantly (P. falciparum / An. albimanus ; P. yoelii / An. albimanus [22,58]) or totally refractory (P. berghei / Ae. Aegypti ). However, in compatible parasite–vector combinations, e.g., P. falciparum / An. freeborni  and P. yoelii / An. stephensi , transformation can be efficient and parasite losses at the late ookinete stage rare. It will be interesting to explore whether the specificity and/or magnitude of the mosquito's immune responses are sensitive to ookinete density. It is known that immune responses are qualitatively different in different parasite–vector combinations , and their cost to vector fitness and survival is not insignificant [48,60–62].
Oocyst Maturation and Sporozoite Delivery
The transition from oocyst to salivary gland sporozoite is usually inefficient and can be totally inhibited in some Plasmodium/mosquito combinations ; whether sporozoites released from the oocyst are removed from the hemocele by hemocytes, or lysed by immune peptides is still unknown . Salivary gland burden is markedly increased if oocyst-infected mosquitoes take a second, uninfected bloodmeal, typically 4 days after infection . This may overcome inter-oocyst competition for nutrients, but it has been suggested that it synchronizes sporozoite maturation [29,65]. Whilst some authors suggest that mosquito survivorship is not adversely impacted by oocyst density [10,66], others found that mosquito mortality increased with oocyst burden [67,68]. Our experimental design was not influenced by these variables; the experiments were all subjected to the same (single) blood-feed regimen, and all examined mosquitoes were alive immediately prior to dissection.
The mathematical relationship between abdominal oocysts and salivary gland sporozoites is complicated by the variable and unknown sporozoite production within oocysts [64,69,70]. Previous studies have reported that the number of sporozoites produced per oocyst is not density-dependent , and studies on P. vivax [13,66] reported linear relationships between oocyst and salivary gland sporozoite prevalences. Others have described only a weak (Pearson) correlation between oocyst, and sporozoite number in the glands in both P. falciparum, and P. vivax . Geometric mean oocyst loads of 2.6 (1–197) and 2.2 (1–26) in, respectively, naturally infected An. gambiae and An. funestus have been correlated with mean loads of 962 and 812 salivary gland sporozoites. Assuming a production of ∼10,000 sporozoites per oocyst , this would translate in only 4% of sporozoites invading the salivary glands . Our data suggest that mean oocyst numbers are linearly related to mean salivary gland sporozoite load (Figure 4A, r = 0.9), but that a saturating (hyperbolic) relationship best describes the sporozoite numbers per individual mosquito (Figure 4B). At most naturally occurring oocyst burdens (1–5 per mosquito), our results suggest that the number of sporozoites in the glands is most likely to be directly proportional to oocyst load, as found with P. falciparum in An. gambiae, however the latter combination exhibits a much higher efficiency (i.e., ∼400–700 P. falciparum gland sporozoites/oocyst [23,50] versus 54–72 P. berghei gland sporozoites/oocyst). However at the high oocyst numbers (>50) achievable in P. berghei / An. stephensi, it is evident that salivary gland numbers are rate-limited (Figure 4B).
Previous authors have discussed, for P. berghei, P. yoelii, and P. falciparum [2,5–9,71–74], the importance of sporozoites being located in the salivary gland ducts at the time of feeding in relation to the probability of a sporozoite being inoculated into the skin of the host. Figure 5 illustrates the enormous variation reported in sporozoite inocula in the bites of An. stephensi with wide-ranging salivary gland burdens of sporozoites of the rodent malarias. Whilst it is widely conjectured that sporozoites of different Plasmodium spp. differ dramatically in their infectivity to their vertebrate hosts, published and unpublished data kindly made available to us (Table 3) suggest that for all species studied, inocula of just 10 sporozoites can be infectious. It is therefore relevant to investigate the question “At what salivary gland sporozoite density, will the number of sporozoites in the bite fall below 10?” Whilst the data suggest gland burdens as high as 30,000 can result in inocula below this “threshold”, it is clear that gland infections of just a few hundred sporozoites (that could be derived from 1–2 oocysts in the P. falciparum / An. gambiae combination) have clear infection potential. It is thus obvious that the prevalence and not the intensity of oocysts or salivary gland sporozoite infections will be the key practical parameter when considering the potential infectivity of individual mosquitoes to the vertebrate host.
Data from Medica and Sinnis  (P. yoelii in An. stephensi) illustrating the relationship between the number of sporozoites counted in dissected salivary glands and the number of sporozoites observed in the saliva ejected by a single bite. Note the use of a logarithmic scale on the x-axis.
Implications for the Modeling of Transmission-Blocking Strategies
Our overarching goal is to develop mathematical models of the population biology of malaria within the mosquito that ultimately relate the prevalence and intensity of gametocytaemia in the vertebrate host with the entomological inoculation rate and the force of infection, and to link these frameworks with novel models of malaria in the human host . Thus far, these studies have found little relationship between the infectiousness of human populations to vectors and the resulting transmission intensity from vectors back to humans.
The very poor correlation between salivary gland burden and sporozoite inoculum at the next bite, suggests that reductions in oocyst number may not correlate well with the potential impact of intervention upon transmission. In contrast, it is abundantly clear that any effective transmission-blocking strategy will have to reduce both oocyst intensity and prevalence (their inter-relationship being nonlinear ). The biological consequences of reductions in prevalence cannot be contested —uninfected mosquitoes cannot transmit. The varying reduction in prevalence that would be induced, by a 90% reduction in oocyst intensity, at different initial oocyst densities is illustrated in Figure 6. If studies into transmission-blocking strategies were to discuss their efficacy in terms that unequivocally reduce the number of infectious bites (and therefore the force of infection), as argued by those applying anti-vector policies, they might facilitate the wider understanding and acceptance of the obvious impact of such interventions in endemic communities. We will report elsewhere how our data will permit us to forward hypotheses as to how interventions targeted at different mosquito stages, e.g., gametes, ookinetes, oocysts or sporozoites, might be expected to reduce the prevalence of infectious mosquitoes in a theoretical population.
Materials and Methods
To eliminate the impact of host and parasite genetic variability, parasite clones, and one inbred mosquito line were used. All but one experiment reported here used clone 234 of the rodent malarial parasite P. berghei strain ANKA. The parasite was maintained by serial passage, but no more than eight sequential mechanical blood passages took place before passage through mosquitoes [27,33]. This regimen maintains gametocyte infectivity to the mosquito, a critical property for this study. Gametocyte density and male: female ratios were determined in Giemsa stained smears, and infections were always done on days 3–5 when a low but rising gametocytaemia prevailed [27,33]. Male:female ratios invariably fell within the normal range for low-passage P. berghei infections, i.e., 1.64 ± 0.93SD (Dearsly, unpublished). All details of direct, or membrane feeds and parasite enumeration are as described previously . Those experiments in which there was significant insect mortality were excluded, on the understanding that this phenomenon may itself be related to infection intensity . In an effort to facilitate parasite identification, one set of experiments used the GFP-expressing transgenic clone (PbGFPCON)  derived from the HP line of P. berghei. Experiments counting ookinetes in the bloodmeal used the indirect fluorescent antibody test (IFAT) to reveal parasites expressing P28/Pbs21 . In all calculations it has been assumed that the bloodmeal volume in A. stephensi is 2.13 μl .
All gametocytes were raised in Theiler's Original (TO) mice and transmitted to A. stephensi strain Sd 500, maintained at 19 °C and 80% RH, and fed on 5% fructose/0.05% para-amino-benzoic acid as described previously .
The impact of numerous extraneous factors (e.g., host serum; mosquito midgut milieu) upon gametocyte infectivity complicates the design and reproducibility of experiments in P. berghei [34,27]. Pools of gametocytes were therefore washed free of variable serum factors and re-suspended in a single pool of serum known to support P. berghei infectivity. Gametocytes, re-suspended at known parasite densities, were fed to replicate aliquots of A. stephensi from the same rearing brood. Fifteen hours later, GFP-expressing, or P28-positive retorts and ookinetes were counted by IFAT in dissected bloodmeals. Ten days after blood feeding, oocysts were counted by phase contrast microscopy of freshly dissected midguts. Sporozoites were similarly counted on days 21–25 by hemocytometry of dissected salivary glands. Unless otherwise stated, all experiments were repeated in triplicate and all mosquitoes examined were alive immediately prior to dissection. We have not attempted to study oocyst infections below a mean of 10 as the proportion of uninfected mosquitoes rises rapidly making the necessary group sizes unmanageably large . To study the impact of ookinete density upon oocyst formation we exploited our ability to culture P. berghei ookinetes in vitro. Following culture ookinetes were resuspended at known densities in fresh heparinised mouse blood and fed by membrane feeder . Under these conditions it is anticipated that some ookinetes will invade the midgut epithelium earlier than when mosquitoes are infected by gametocytes.
Even with the advent of GFP-tagged parasite lines it is not possible to count midgut oocysts in vivo without compromising the subsequent development of the sporozoites in the mosquito, due to direct UV irradiation, or stress/damage to the insect. Thus, batches in excess of 200 mosquitoes were each infected with different ookinete numbers such that different oocyst burdens could be determined by dissecting groups of at least 50 mosquitoes . The remainder of each mosquito batch (>50) was incubated a further 8–15 days before counting the salivary gland sporozoites. With this design, both input and output parasite densities are random variables.
Sporozoite counting by polymerase chain reaction (PCR).
Efforts to enumerate sporozoites in the saliva secreted into a bloodmeal, using PCR, were not successful, and have been superseded by the elegant studies of others [5,6,72]. However, for the sake of completeness, we give an account of our procedures in Text S1.
Frequency distributions. Frequency distribution histograms were prepared for each of the output life stages of interest, i.e., the number of ookinetes, the number of oocysts, and the number of salivary gland sporozoites per mosquito. The VMR was calculated for each distribution, which indicated the presence of overdispersion (the ratio was significantly greater than 1 as ascertained by chi-square tests ). An NBD (whose parameters are the arithmetic mean, and the exponent, k, an inverse measure of the degree of overdispersion) was fitted to the data using maximum likelihood (ML). The goodness of fit of the negative binomial distribution to the observed frequency distribution was assessed using chi-square tests . For each life stage, values for k were thus estimated for the combined data, and for each input parasite density separately, and plotted against the corresponding arithmetic mean number of parasites to assess whether the overdispersion parameter was independent or related to the means of the distributions. The functional form of the relationship between k and the mean was determined by fitting various models (detailed in Text S2) using ML, which were compared using the LRS  for nested models and the AIC  for non-nested models. The LRS and AIC results can be found in Table S1, and the resulting parameter values in Table S2.
Models fitted to mean parasite densities. Functional relationships were fitted to mean parasite densities as a function of the (pre-defined) previous life stage density, using the WM  as a measure of central tendency for the outcome variable (given the overdispersed nature of the data as assessed above). Asymmetric CIs were estimated for the WMs . When the explanatory variable was also the mean of a random variable (rather than a pre-determined parasite density fed to mosquitoes), CIs were also calculated for the variable plotted on the horizontal axis. Heterogeneity in the data between experiments and between workers was examined to determine whether a single model should be fitted to the entire dataset, to individual experiments, or to experimenter subsets. The form of the relationship between two subsequent life stages, using the mean values, was determined by fitting Equation 1 by ML using quasi-Newton algorithms. We maximized a sample size-weighted log-likelihood for a normally distributed variable after applying a suitable (square root) transformation of the means. The weighting procedure allowed us to take into account the number of mosquitoes contributing to each mean value in addition to the total number of mean values . In this case, y was the WM of the outcome variable and x was the parasite density of the previous (input) life stage. Parameters α, β, and γ determine the shape of the functional form as described in Table 1, and the resulting models were compared using the LRS  as the models were nested (linear versus hyperbolic and versus sigmoid; hyperbolic versus sigmoid). (Details of the LRS results are provided in Table S3.) Asymptotic 95% CIs  were estimated for each parameter in the final model.
Models fitted to individual parasite densities. In order to make better use of the data available, models were also fitted to individual parasite densities rather than the mean values, using parasite densities from individual mosquitoes against the pre-defined (or mean) parasite densities of the previous life stage. The form of the relationship between two subsequent life stages using the individual values was determined by fitting the functional form given in Equation 1, where x, α, β, and γ, were as described above, and y was the parasite count of the subsequent stage as observed in individual mosquitoes. Parameters were estimated, using quasi-Newton algorithms, by maximising a negative binomial log-likelihood that allowed the overdispersion parameter to be a function of the mean . Again, models were compared using LRS, and asymptotic 95% CIs  were estimated for the parameters in the final model, including overdispersion parameters. Details of model comparison can be found in Table S4. In all cases p < 0.05 was considered to indicate a significant departure from the null hypothesis in question. Limitations of the statistical analyses are discussed in Text S3.
Table S1. Model Comparisons for Relationship between Overdispersion Parameter and Mean Parasite Density
(54 KB DOC)
Table S2. Parameters of the Most Parsimonious Models for Relationships between Overdispersion and Mean Parasite Density
(28 KB DOC)
Table S3. Model Comparisons for Relationship between Output Mean Parasite Density and Parasite Density of the Preceding (Input) Life Stage
(39 KB DOC)
Table S4. Model Comparisons for Relationship between Output Individual Parasite Density and the Parasite Density of the Preceding (Input) Life Stage
(38 KB DOC)
Text S1. Sporozoite Counting by PCR
(24 KB DOC)
Text S2. Parasite Overdispersion
(25 KB DOC)
Text S3. Limitations of the Statistical Analysis
(25 KB DOC)
We would like to thank all the many Biology undergraduate students at Imperial College who have contributed to the accumulated datasets as part of their research projects over a period of many years. We also thank Drs. Steve Hoffmann and Bill Collins for their unpublished data on sporozoite infectivity.
RES conceived the study. YA, JW, OF, JM, and GAB performed the parasitology experiments. LA, SG, and AH designed and performed the sporozoite PCR studies. EJD and M-GB conducted the statistical modelling. RES, EJD, and M-GB wrote the paper.
- 1. Vaughan JA (2007) Population dynamics of Plasmodium sporogony. Trends Parasitol 23: 63–70.
- 2. Pringle GA (1965) Count of the sporozoites in an oocyst of Plasmodium falciparum. Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg 59: 289–290.
- 3. Rosenberg R, Rungiwongse J (1991) The number of sporozoites produced by individual malaria oocysts. Am J Trop Med Hyg 45: 574–577.
- 4. Amino R, Thiberge S, Martin B, Celli S, Shorte S, et al. (2006) Quantitative imaging of Plasmodium transmission from mosquito to mammal. Nat Med 12: 220–224.
- 5. Frischknecht F, Baldacci P, Martin B, Zimmer C, Thiberge S (2004) Imaging movement of malaria parasites during transmission by Anopheles mosquitoes. Cell Microbiol 6: 687–694.
- 6. Medica DL, Sinnis P (2005) Quantitative dynamics of Plasmodium yoelii sporozoite transmission by infected anopheline mosquitoes. Infect Immun 73: 4363–4369.
- 7. Rosenberg R, Wirtz RA, Schneider I, Burge R (1990) An estimation of the number of malaria sporozoites ejected by a feeding mosquito. Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg 84: 209–212.
- 8. Ponnudurai T, Lensen AHW, van Gemert GJA, Bolmer MG, Meuwissen JHET (1991) Feeding behaviour and sporozoite ejection by infected Anopheles stephensi. Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg 85: 175–180.
- 9. Rosenberg R (1985) Inability of Plasmodium knowlesi sporozoites to invade Anopheles freeborni salivary glands. Am J Trop Med Hyg 34: 687–691.
- 10. Gamage-Mendis AC, Rajakaruna J, Weerasinghe S, Mendis C, Carter R, et al. (1993) Infectivity of Plasmodium vivax and P. falciparum to Anopheles tessellatus; relationship between oocyst and sporozoite development. Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg 87: 3–6.
- 11. Eyles DE (1951) Studies on Plasmodium gallinaceum I. Characteristics of the infection in the mosquito, Aedes aegypti. Am J Hyg 54: 101–112.
- 12. Carter R Graves PM (1988) Gametocytes. In: Wernsdorfer WH, McGregor I, editors. Malaria: Principles and practice of malariology. Edinburgh: Chuchill Livingstone. pp. 253–305.
- 13. Swellengrebel NH, De Buck A (1931) Correlation between intestinal and salivary infection in Anopheles maculipennis. Proceedings of the Koninklijke Akademie Van Wetenschappen Te Amsterdam 34: 182–185.
- 14. Al-Olayan EM, Williams GT, Hurd H (2002) Apoptosis in the malaria protozoan, Plasmodium berghei: a possible mechanism for limiting intensity of infection in the mosquito. Int J Parasitol 32: 1133–1143. Erratum in Int J Parasitol 2003, 33: 105.
- 15. Smith T, Killeen GF, Maire N, Ross A, Molineaux L, et al. (2006) Mathematical modelling of the impact of malaria vaccines on the clinical epidemiology and natural history of Plasmodium falciparum malaria: Overview. Am J Trop Med Hyg 75: 1–10.
- 16. Basáñez M-G, Remme JH, Alley ES, Bain O, Shelley AJ, et al. (1995) Density-dependent processes in the transmission of human onchocerciasis: relationship between the numbers of microfilariae ingested and successful larval development in the simuliid vector. Parasitol 110: 409–427.
- 17. Williams CB (1937) The use of logarithms in the interpretation of certain entomological problems. Ann Appl Biol 24: 404–414.
- 18. Medley GF, Sinden RE, Fleck S, Billingsley PF, Tirawanchai N, et al. (1993) Heterogeneity in patters of malarial oocyst infections in the mosquito vector. Parasitol 106: 441–449.
- 19. Vaughan JA, Noden BH, Beier JC (1994) Sporogonic development of cultured Plasmodium falciparum in six species of laboratory-reared Anopheles mosquitoes. Am J Trop Med Hyg 51: 233–243.
- 20. Gaillard FO, Boudin C, Chau NP, Robert V, Pichon G (2003) Togetherness among Plasmodium falciparum gametocytes: interpretation through simulation and consequences for malaria transmission. Parasitol 127: 427–435.
- 21. Pichon G, Awono-Ambene HP, Robert V (2000) High heterogeneity in the number of Plasmodium falciparum gametocytes in the bloodmeal of mosquitoes fed on the same host. Parasitol 121: 115–120.
- 22. Vaughan JA, Hensley L, Beier JC (1994) Sporogonic development of Plasmodium yoelii in five anopheline species. J Parasitol 80: 674–681.
- 23. Beier JC, Onyango FK, Ramadhan M, Koros JK, Asiago CM, et al. (1991) Quantitation of malaria sporozoites in the salivary glands of wild afrotropical Anopheles. Med Vet Ent 5: 63–70.
- 24. Boes J, Medley GF, Eriksen L, Roepstorff A, Nansen P (1998) Distribution of Ascaris suum in experimentally and naturally infected pigs and comparison with Ascaris lumbricoides infections in humans. Parasitol 117: 589–596.
- 25. Barbour AD, Kafetzaki M (1993) A host-parasite model yielding heterogeneous parasite loads. J Math Biol 31: 157–176.
- 26. Huff CG, Marchbank DF, Shiroishi T (1958) Changes in infectiousness of malaria gametocytes. II. Analysis of the possible causative factors. Exp Parasitol 7: 399–417.
- 27. Dearsly AL, Sinden RE, Self I (1990) Sexual development in malarial parasites: gametocyte production, fertility and infectivity to the mosquito vector. Parasitol 100: 359–368.
- 28. Collins WE, Warren MCW, Skinner JC Richardson JB, Kearse TS (1977) Infectivity of the Santa Lucia (El Salvador) strain of Plasmodium falciparum to different Anophelines. The J Parasitol 63: 57–61.
- 29. Ponnudurai T, Lensen AHW, van Gemert GJA, Bensink MPE, Bolmer M, et al. (1989) Infectivity of cultured Plasmodium falciparum gametocytes to mosquitoes. Parasitol 98: 165–173.
- 30. Pichon G, Robert V, Tchuinkam T, Mulder B, Verhave JP (1996) Analyse quantitative de la distribution des oocystes de Plasmodium falciparum chez Anopheles gambiae. Parasite 3: 161–167.
- 31. Lambrechts L, Halbert J, Durand P, Gouanga LC, Koella JC (2005) Host genotype by parasite genotype interactions underlying the resistance of anopheline mosquitoes to Plasmodium falciparum. Mal J 4: 3.
- 32. Noden BH, Beadle PS, Vaughan JA, Pumpuni CB, Kent MD (1994) Plasmodium falciparum: the population structure of mature gametocyte cultures has little effect on their innate fertility. Acta Trop 58: 13–19.
- 33. Birago C, Bucci A, Dore E, Frontali C, Zenobi P (1982) Mosquito infectivity is directly related to the proportion of repetitive DNA in Plasmodium berghei. Mol Biochem Parasitol 6: 1–12.
- 34. Sinden RE, Butcher G, Billker O, Fleck SL (1996) Regulation of infectivity of Plasmodium to the mosquito vector. Adv Parasitol 38: 53–117.
- 35. Motard A, Baccam D, Landau I (1990) Temporary loss of Plasmodium gametocytes infectivity during schizogony. Ann Parasitol Hum Comp 65: 218–220.
- 36. Naotunne TD, Karunaweera ND, Delgiudice G, Kularatne MU, Grau GE, et al. (1991) Cytokines kill malaria parasites during infection crisis - extracellular complementary factors are essential. J Exp Med 173: 523–529.
- 37. Sinden RE, Smalley ME (1976) Gametocytes of Plasmodium falciparum: phagocytosis by leucocytes in vivo and in vitro. Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg 70: 344–345.
- 38. Rutledge LC, Gould DJ, Tantichareon B (1969) Factors affecting the infection of anophelines with human malaria in Thailand. Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg 63: 613–619.
- 39. Healer J, Mcguinness D, Hopcroft P, Haley S, Carter R, et al. (1997) Complement-mediated lysis of Plasmodium falciparum gametes by malaria-immune human sera is associated with antibodies to the gamete surface antigen Pfs230. Infect Immun 65: 3017–3023.
- 40. Margos G, Navarette S, Butcher G, Davies A, Willers C, et al. (2001) Interaction between host complement and mosquito midgut stages of Plasmodium berghei. Inf Imm 69: 5064–5071.
- 41. Weathersby AB, McCall JW (1968) The development of Plasmodium gallinaceum Brumpt in the haemocoels of refractory Culex pipiens pipiens Linn. and susceptible Aedes aegypti (Linn.). J Parasitol 54: 1017–1022.
- 42. Gass RF (1977) Influences of blood digestion on the development of Plasmodium gallinaceum (Brumpt) in the midgut of Aedes aegypti (L.). Acta Tropica 34: 127–140.
- 43. Gass RF, Yeates RA (1979) In vitro damage of cultured ookinetes of Plasmodium gallinaceum by digestive proteinases from susceptible Aedes aegypti. Acta Tropica 36: 243–252.
- 44. Christophides GK, Zdobnov E, Barillas-Mury C, Birney E, Blandin S, et al. (2002) Immunity-related genes and gene families in Anopheles gambiae. Science 298: 159–165.
- 45. Thathy V, Severson DW, Christensen BM (1994) Reinterpretation of the genetics of susceptibility of Aedes aegypti to Plasmodium gallinaceum. J Parasitol 80: 705–712.
- 46. Dong Y, Aguilar R, Xi Z, Warr E, Mongin E, et al. (2006) Anopheles gambiae immune responses to human and rodent Plasmodium parasite species. PLoS Pathog 2: e52.
- 47. Peyerl-Hoffman G, Jelinek T, Kilian A, Kabagambe G, Metzger WG, et al. (2001) Genetic diversity of Plasmodium falciparum and its relationship to parasite density in an area with different malaria endemicities in West Uganda. Trop Med Int Health 6: 607–613.
- 48. Boete C, Paul REL, Koella JC (2004) Direct and indirect immunosuppression by a malaria parasite in the mosquito vector. Proc R Soc Lon B 271: 1611–1615.
- 49. Zollner GE, Ponsa N, Garman GW, Poudel S, Bell JE, et al. (2006) Population dynamics of sporogony of Plasmodium vivax parasites from western Thailand developing within three species of colonized Anopheles mosquitoes. Mal J 5: 68.
- 50. Vaughan JA, Noden BH, Beier JC (1992) Population dynamics of Plasmodium falciparum sporogony in laboratory-infected Anopheles gambiae. J Parasitology 78: 716–724.
- 51. Richman A, Kafatos FC (1996) Immunity to eukaryotic parasites in vector insects. Curr Opin Immunol 8: 14–19.
- 52. Dimopoulos G, Christophides GK, Meister S, Schultz J, White KP, et al. (2002) Genome expression analysis of Anopheles gambiae: responses to injury, bacterial challenge, and malaria infection. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 99: 8814–8819.
- 53. Rosenberg R, Koontz LC, Carter R (1982) Infection of Aedes aegypti with zygotes of Plasmodium gallinaceum fertilized in vitro. J Parasitol 68: 653–656.
- 54. Munderloh UG, Kurtti TJ (1987) The infectivity and purification of Plasmodium berghei ookinetes. J Parasitol 73: 919–923.
- 55. Alavi Y, Arai AM, Mendoza J, Tufet-Bayona M, Sinha R, et al. (2003) The dynamics of interactions between Plasmodium and the mosquito: a study of the infectivity of P. berghei and P. gallinaceum to Anopheles stephensi, An. gambiae and Aedes aegypti. Int J Parasitol 33: 933–943. Erratum in: Int J Parasitol 2004, 34: 245–247.
- 56. Vaughan JA, Narum D, Azad AF (1991) Plasmodium berghei ookinete densities in 3 Anopheline Species. J Parasitol 77: 758–761.
- 57. Gouagna LC, Bonnet S, Gounoue R, Verhave JP, Eling W, et al. (2004) Stage-specific effects of host plasma factors on the early sporogony of autologous Plasmodium falciparum isolates within Anopheles gambiae. Trop Med Int Health 9: 937–948.
- 58. Noden BH, Pumpuni CB, Vaughan JA, Beier JC (1995) Noninfectious sporozoites in the salivary glands of a minimally susceptible anopheline mosquito. J. Parasitol 81: 912–915.
- 59. Tahar R, Boudin C, Thiery I, Bourgouin C (2002) Immune response of Anopheles gambiae to the early sporogonic stages of the human malaria parasite Plasmodium falciparum. EMBO 21: 6673–6680.
- 60. Koella JC, Boete C (2003) A model for the coevolution of immunity and immune evasion in vector-borne diseases with implications for the epidemiology of malaria. Am Nat 161: 698–707.
- 61. Ferguson H, Gandon S, McKinnon M, Read A (2006) Malaria parasite virulence in mosquitoes and its implications for the introduction and efficacy of GMM malaria control programmes. In: Boete C, editor. Genetically modified mosquitoes for malaria control. Landes Bioscience. pp. 103–116.
- 62. Marelli MT, Li C, Rasgon JL, Jacobs-Lorena M (2007) Transgenic malaria-resistant mosquitoes have a fitness advantage when feeding on Plasmodium-infected blood. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 104: 5580–5583.
- 63. Shahabuddin M, Fields I, Bulet P, Hoffmann JA Miller LH (1998) Plasmodium gallinaceum: Differential killing of some mosquito stages of the parasite by insect defensin. Exp Parasitol 89: 103–112.
- 64. Ponnudurai T, Lensen AHW, van Gemert GJA, Bensink MPE, Bolmer M, et al. (1989) Sporozoite load of mosquitoes infected with Plasmodium falciparum. Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg 83: 67–70.
- 65. Bell AS, Ranford-Cartwright LC (2004) A real-time PCR assay for quantifying Plasmodium falciparum infections in the mosquito vector. Int J Parasitol 34: 795–802.
- 66. Boyd MF (1940) On the correlation between the incidence of stomach and salivary gland infection in Anopheles quadrimaculatus infected with Plasmodium vivax. Am J Trop Med 20: 129–131.
- 67. Klein TA, Harrison BA, Grove JS, Dixon SV, Andre RG (1986) Correlation of survival rates of Anopheles dirus A (Diptera: Culicidae) with different infection densities of Plasmodium cynomolgi. Bulletin WHO 64: 901–907.
- 68. Hogg JC, Hurd H (1995) Plasmodium yoelli nigeriensis: the effect of high and low intensity of infection upon the egg production and bloodmeal size of Anopheles stephensi during three gonotrophic cycles. Parasitol 111: 555–562.
- 69. Baton LA, Ranford-Cartwright LC (2005) Spreading the seeds of million-murdering death: metamorphoses of malaria in the mosquito. Trends Parasitol 21: 573–580.
- 70. Beier JC (1998) Malaria parasite development in mosquitoes. Annu Rev Entomol 43: 519–543.
- 71. Mitzmain B (1916) Anopheles infectivity experiments. An attempt to determine the number of persons one mosquito can infect with malaria. Repr. 359 Public Health Reports. [Data reproduced in Boyd MF (1949) Epidemiology: factors related to the definitive host. In: Boyd MF, editor. Malariology, volume 1. Philadelphia: W.B.Saunders.]. pp. 608–697. Chapter 26, pp.
- 72. Frevert U, Engelmann S, Zougbede S, Stange J, Ng B, et al. (2005) Intravital observation of Plasmodium berghei sporozoite infection of the liver. PLoS Biol 3: e192.
- 73. Beier JC, Davis JR, Vaughan JA, Noden BH, Beier MS (1991) Quantitation of Plasmodium falciparum sporozoites transmitted in vitro by experimentally infected Anopheles gambiae and Anopheles stephensi. Am J Trop Med Hyg 44: 564–570.
- 74. Beier JC, Onyango FK, Koros JK, Ramadhan M, Ogwang R, et al. (1991) Quantitation of malaria sporozoites transmitted in vitro during salivation by wild afrotropical Anopheles. Med Vet Ent 5: 71–79.
- 75. Sinden RE, Butcher GA, Beetsma AL (2002) Maintenance of the Plasmodium berghei life cycle. In: Doolan DL, editor. Methods in molecular medicine. Volume 75. New Jersey: Humana Press. pp. 25–40.
- 76. Gad AM, Maier WA, Piekarski G (1979) Pathology of Anopheles stephensi after infection with Plasmodium berghei berghei. I. Mortality rate. Z Parasitenkd 60: 249–261.
- 77. Franke-Fayard B, Trueman H, Ramesar J, Mendoza J, van der Keur M, et al. (2004) A Plasmodium berghei reference line that constitutively expresses GFP at a high level throughout the complete life cycle. Mol Biochem Parasitol 137: 23–33.
- 78. Winger LA, Tirawanchai N, Nicholas J, Carter HE, Smith JE, et al. (1988) Ookinete antigens of Plasmodium berghei. Appearance on the zygote surface of an Mr 21 kD determinant identified by transmission-blocking monoclonal antibodies. Parasite Immunol 10: 193–207.
- 79. Billingsley PF, Medley GF, Charlwood JD, Sinden RE (1994) Relationship between prevalence and intensity of Plasmodium falciparum infection in natural populations of Anopheles mosquitoes. Am J Trop Med Hyg 51: 260–270.
- 80. Elliott JM (1977) Some methods for the statistical analysis of samples of benthic invertebrates. 2nd edition. Freshwater Biological Association, scientific publication no. 25. Cumbria: Titus Wilson & Son Ltd.
- 81. Clayton D, Hills M (1993) Statistical models in epidemiology. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
- 82. Akaike H (1973) Information criterion as an extension of the maximum likelihood principle. In: Petrov BN, Csaki F, editors. Second Annual Symposium on Information Theory. Akademi Kiado: Budapest. pp. 267–282.
- 83. Kirkwood BR (1988) Essentials of medical statistics. Oxford: Oxford Scientific Publications.
- 84. De Groot MH, Schervish MJ (2001) Probability and statistics. 3rd edition. Addison Wesley.
- 85. Cox DR, Hinkley DV (1974) Theoretical statistics. London: Chapman and Hall.
- 86. Subramanian S, Krishnamoorthy K, Ramaiah KD, Habbema JDF, Das PK, et al. (1998) Relationship between microfilarial load in the human host and uptake and development of Wuchereria bancrofti microfilariae by Culex quinquefasciatus: a study under natural conditions. Parasitol 116: 243–255.
- 87. Sinden RE (2004) A proteomic analysis of malaria biology: integrating old literature and new technology. Int J Parasitol 34: 1441–1450.
- 88. Ranawaka GRR (1993) Effects of transmission blocking antibody on the development of Plasmodium berghei in Anopheles stephensi [dissertation]. London: University of London.
- 89. Rickman LS, Jones TR, Long GW, Paparello S, Schneider I, et al. (1990) Plasmodium falciparum infected Anopheles stephensi inconsistently transmit malaria to humans. Am J Trop Med Hyg 43: 441–445.
- 90. Shute PG, Lupascu G, Branzei P, Maryon M, Constantinescu P, et al. (1977) A strain of Plasmodium vivax characterized by prolonged incubation: the effect of numbers of sporozoites on the length of the prepatent period. Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg 70: 474–481.
- 91. Ungureanu E, Killick-Kendrick R, Garnham PCC (1977) Prepatent periods of a tropical strain of Plasmodium vivax after inoculations of tenfold dilutions of sporozoites. Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg 70: 482–483.
- 92. Collins WE, Contacos PG, Stanfill PS, Richardson BB (1973) Studies on human malaria in Aotus monkeys. 1. Sporozoite transmission of Plasmodium vivax from El Salvador. J Parasitol 59: 606–608.
- 93. Coatney GR, Cooper WC, Young MD (1950) Studies in human malaria. XXX. A summary of 204 sporozoite-induced infections with the Chesson strain of Plasmodium vivax. J Natl Malar Soc 9: 381–396.
- 94. Yoeli M, Most H (1965) Studies on sporozoite-induced infections in rodent malaria 1. The pre-erythrocytic tissue stage of Plasmodium berghei. Am J Trop Med Hyg 14: 700–714.
- 95. Vanderberg JP, Nussenzweig RS, Most H, Orton CG (1968) Protective immunity produced by the injection of x-irradiated sporozoites of Plasmodium berghei II. Effects of radiation on sporozoites. J Parasitol 54: 1175–1180.
- 96. Collins WE, Skinner JC, Richardson BB, Stanfill PS (1975) Studies on the transmission of simian malaria VI. Mosquito infection and sporozoite transmission of Plasmodium fragile. J Parasitol 61: 718–721.
- 97. Russell PF, Mohan BN (1942) Some mosquito hosts to avian Plasmodia with special reference to Plasmodium gallinaceum. J Parasitol 28: 127–129.
- 98. Coatney GR, Cooper WC, Trembley HL (1945) Studies on Plasmodium gallinaceum brumpt II. The incidence and course of the infection in young chicks following the inoculation of infected salivary glands. Am J Hyg 41: 119–122.
- 99. Greenberg J, Trembley HL, Coatney GR (1950) Effects of drugs on Plasmodium gallinaceum infections produced by decreasing concentrations of sporozoite inoculum. Am J Hyg 51: 194–199.
- 100. Jasinskiene N, Coleman J, Ashikyan A, Salampessy M, Marinotti O, et al. (2007) Genetic control of malaria parasite transmission: threshold levels for infection in an avian model system. Am J Trop Med Hyg 76: 1072–1078.
- 101. Fink E (1968) Experimentelle Infektion von Kanarien mit Plasmodium cathemerium Hartman, 1927, durch den Stich infizierter Mucken (Culex pipiens L.) und durch Inokulation isolierter Sporozoiten. Parasitol Res 31: 232–253.