Functional and Genetic Analysis of Coronavirus Replicase-Transcriptase Proteins

The coronavirus replicase-transcriptase complex is an assembly of viral and cellular proteins that mediate the synthesis of genome and subgenome-sized mRNAs in the virus-infected cell. Here, we report a genetic and functional analysis of 19 temperature-sensitive (ts) mutants of Murine hepatitis virus MHV-A59 that are unable to synthesize viral RNA when the infection is initiated and maintained at the non-permissive temperature. Both classical and biochemical complementation analysis leads us to predict that the majority of MHV-A59 ORF1a replicase gene products (non-structural proteins nsp1–nsp11) form a single complementation group (cistron1) while the replicase gene products encoded in ORF1b (non-structural proteins nsp12–nsp16) are able to function in trans and comprise at least three, and possibly five, further complementation groups (cistrons II–VI). Also, we have identified mutations in the non-structural proteins nsp 4, nsp5, nsp10, nsp12, nsp14, and nsp16 that are responsible for the ts phenotype of eight MHV-A59 mutants, which allows us to conclude that these proteins are essential for the assembly of a functional replicase-transcriptase complex. Finally, our analysis of viral RNA synthesis in ts mutant virus-infected cells allows us to discriminate three phenotypes with regard to the inability of specific mutants to synthesize viral RNA at the non-permissive temperature. Mutant LA ts6 appeared to be defective in continuing negative-strand synthesis, mutant Alb ts16 appeared to form negative strands but these were not utilized for positive-strand RNA synthesis, and mutant Alb ts22 was defective in the elongation of both positive- and negative-strand RNA. On the basis of these results, we propose a model that describes a pathway for viral RNA synthesis in MHV-A59-infected cells. Further biochemical analysis of these mutants should allow us to identify intermediates in this pathway and elucidate the precise function(s) of the viral replicase proteins involved.


Introduction
Coronaviruses are positive-strand, enveloped RNA viruses that infect vertebrates and are associated mainly with respiratory and enteric disease. They have long been recognized as important pathogens of livestock and companion animals, and they are a common cause of respiratory tract infections in humans [1][2][3]. More recently, a coronavirus has been identified as the causative agent of SARS, a form of atypical pneumonia in humans with a case fatality ratio of approximately 10% [4]. Clearly, there is an urgent need to develop new strategies to prevent or control coronavirus infections, and understanding the biology, replication, and pathogenesis of these viruses is an essential part of this process. Murine hepatitis virus, strain A59 (MHV-A59), is a group II coronavirus with a genome of approximately 31,400 nucleotides. The genomic RNA encodes the structural proteins of the virus, non-structural proteins involved in viral RNA synthesis (the nsp or replicase proteins), and proteins that are non-essential for replication in cell culture but appear to confer a selective advantage in vivo (accessory proteins) [1]. In the MHV-A59-infected cell, the expression of the replicase protein genes is mediated by translation of the genomic RNA, and the expression of the structural protein genes is mediated by the translation of a set of 39-coterminal subgenomic mRNAs. The subgenomic mRNAs are produced by a unique mechanism that involves discontinuous transcription during negative-strand RNA synthesis [5][6][7]. The organization and expression of the MHV-A59 genome are illustrated in Figure 1.
In the course of an infectious cycle, the MHV-A59 replicase-transcriptase complex amplifies the genomic RNA and synthesizes subgenomic mRNAs. Amplification of the genomic RNA involves full-length negative-strand templates, and the synthesis of subgenomic mRNA involves subgenomelength negative-strand templates [24,25]. The structures engaged in the replication and transcription of positivestrand MHV-A59 RNA have been characterized [26]. Approximately 70% of the replicating and transcribing structures that accumulate in infected cells are multi-stranded intermediates (replicative and transcriptive intermediate RNA, RI/TI RNA) and 30% are found in structures with only one or very few nascent strands (native replicative and transcriptive forms, RF/TF RNA). Although the structures engaged in negative-strand RNA synthesis have not yet been characterized, it is known that MHV negative-strand templates are unstable and turn over during viral replication [27].
The cis-acting RNA elements involved in the different phases of MHV RNA synthesis have been studied quite extensively. It has been shown that 59-and 39-UTR, as well as  [45]. The hatched box represents the common 59 leader sequence and the hatched circle represents the programmed (À1) frameshifting element. The translation products of the genome and sub-genomic mRNAs are depicted and the autoproteolytic processing of the ORF1a and ORF1a/ORF1b polyproteins into non-structural proteins nsp1 to nsp16 is shown. A number of confirmed and putative functional domains in the non-structural proteins are also indicated: 3CL, 3C-like cysteine proteinase; ExoN, exonuclease; HEL, superfamily 1 helicase; MT, S-adenosylmethioninedependent 29-O-methyl transferase; NeU, endoribonuclease; PL1, papain-like protease 1; PL2, papain-like protease 2; POL, RNA-dependent RNA polymerase; X, adenosine diphosphate-ribose 19-

Synopsis
Coronaviruses infect both humans and animals and are associated mainly with respiratory and enteric diseases. The recent outbreak of SARS emphasizes the need to develop new strategies to control these infections. This paper focuses on the proteins involved in the replication of the coronavirus genome and the production of viral mRNAs in the host cell. These so-called replicase-transcriptase proteins are likely to make good targets for the development of anti-coronaviral drugs. The approach used here is to analyze conditional, temperature-sensitive mutants of Murine hepatitis virus that are normal at 33 8C (the permissive temperature) but are unable to replicate and transcribe viral RNAs at 39.5 8C (the restrictive temperature). By identifying the genetic changes responsible for these temperature-sensitive mutations and by analyzing the precise nature of the defect in RNA synthesis at the restrictive temperature, the authors are able to propose a model that describes a pathway for viral RNA synthesis in the infected cell. Further analysis of these mutants should allow the elucidation of the precise function(s) of the viral proteins involved.
59-UTR-adjacent regions of the genome are required for MHV replication and transcription [28,29]. Also, studies on MHV, and other nidoviruses, have shown the critical role of the so-called transcription-regulating sequence (TRS) element in the discontinuous phase of the transcription process [7,[30][31][32][33]. These data show that the stability of the leader-TRS/body-TRS duplex, which forms during the discontinuous extension phase of negative-strand template synthesis, is an important determinant of subgenomic mRNA abundance. However, it is also evident from these studies that the regions flanking the TRS elements have a profound affect on the amounts of subgenomic mRNAs that are produced. In the context of the discontinuous-extension model [5], this is explained as different degrees of ''attenuation'' at each of the TRS elements during negative-strand synthesis.
In contrast, there is still very little known about the structure, functions, and interactions of viral and cellular proteins in the replicase-transcriptase complex as it is engaged in different modes of RNA synthesis. As mentioned above, bioinformatic and biochemical studies have identified a number of (putative) enzymatic activities associated with individual coronavirus replicase proteins, and a number of cellular proteins have also been implicated as components of the MHV replicase-transcriptase complex [34][35][36]. However, the essential nature of some of these cellular proteins has been questioned [37], and further work is needed to determine the exact protein composition of the coronavirus replicase-transcriptase complex and how the composition is altered, or how the proteins are modified to regulate the different activities of the complex.
In order to address these sorts of questions, we have embarked upon a detailed analysis of temperature-sensitive (ts) mutants of MHV-A59 that are unable to synthesize viral RNA when the infection is initiated and maintained at the non-permissive temperature. The essential feature of these mutants is that they are likely to be defective in different aspects of viral RNA synthesis and a detailed characterization of their genotype and phenotype should provide insights into the mechanisms of RNA synthesis, the functions of individual viral replicase proteins, and the protein-RNA and protein-protein interactions that regulate the activity of the replicase-transcriptase complex. These conditional-lethal mutants may also be used in a cis-trans test to define the number of complementation groups, or cistrons, that contribute to a specific phenotype. This sort of analysis can also provide valuable insight into the possible pathways that polyproteins must travel to assume functional configurations and has been used with success for other RNA viruses [38].
The MHV-A59 mutants that we study have been produced in a number of laboratories over a period of 20 years [39][40][41]. They have been selected to have a low efficiency of plaque formation at the non-permissive temperature compared with the permissive temperature and hence a reversion frequency indicative of single point mutations. In this study, we describe a complementation analysis, and by sequence analysis of both ts virus and revertants, we identify the causal mutation for eight of these mutants. We also describe a more detailed phenotype for selected mutants and suggest a model that describes the different modes of RNA synthesis during coronavirus replication and transcription. Table S1 lists the ts mutants of MHV-A59 used in our collection. All the ts mutants failed to form plaques or synthesize viral RNA when infection was initiated and maintained at the non-permissive temperature. While many mutants failed to form plaques at 37 8C, other mutants formed plaques at 37 8C and were considered leaky. This included Alb ts22 that produced pin-prick-sized plaques after 2 d at 37 8C (compared with the wild-type [wt] A59 virus, which produced uniform plaques of 4-5 mm in diameter) and Wü ts18, Wü ts36, and Wü ts38, which produced smaller than wt plaques at 37 8C. However, even for these mutants, the ts defects responsible for their RNA-negative phenotype appeared to be caused by a single point mutation because each ts mutant possessed a characteristic low reversion frequency between 10 À4 and 10 À8 per average base [42]. The virus produced at 37 8C by Alb ts22, Wü ts18, Wü ts36, and Wü ts38 was also ts, i.e., the efficiency of plating (EOP) was less than 10 À4 .

Characterization of ts Mutants and Revertants
For most mutants, the revertant virus obtained from plaques formed at the non-permissive temperature had properties identical to wt MHV-A59. One exception was Alb ts17, which produced equal numbers of revertant viruses causing A59-sized plaques and revertant viruses with noticeably smaller plaques ( Figure S1). We isolated revertant viruses from a large (A59-sized) plaque (Alb 17R L ) and a small plaque (Alb 17R S ) for sequence analysis (see below). Some of the ts mutants did not produce revertant viruses (e.g., LA ts3, Alb ts19) or produced revertant viruses that were markedly different from the parental MHV-A59 virus.

Complementation Analysis
We began our complementation analyses using Alb ts16, LA ts6, and Alb ts22 because they each had a distinct ts viral RNA synthesis phenotype (see below). Cells were singly infected or doubly infected with two ts mutants and the cells and medium were harvested after the completion of a single round of replication, i.e., 8 h post-infection (hpi) at 40 8C. We also confirmed that if infection with a ts virus alone was allowed to proceed for up to 2 h at 30 8C, and then the culture shifted to 40 8C and the virus harvested at 12 hpi, the titer we obtained was low (;10 4 plaque-forming units [pfu]/ml). Thus, this protocol prevented the production of revertant virus by a second round of replication. Complementation was measured by determining the complementation index (CI) as described in Materials and Methods. By definition, if the mutations are in the same cistron, the viruses will not complement each other. On the other hand, if the mutations are in different cistrons, the mutants will complement each other and progeny ts virus will be recovered.
The results of six individual crosses between Alb ts16 and LA ts6 are shown in Table 1. All of these crosses failed to show complementation. The average CI value was 0.5 (0.5 6 0.18 SD), which is the theoretical value for two mutants with mutations in the same cistron [43]. This CI value was obtained using only the titers determined at 30 8C and was not corrected for the presence of revertants (or recombinants) as was done by others [39,44]. We found it unnecessary to make this correction because it did not significantly change the CI value (at most a decrease of one tenth) and whether or not the mutants scored as able to complement one another. From these results, we concluded that Alb ts16 and LA ts6 had a mutation in the same cistron and were, therefore, in the same complementation group. We next determined if Alb ts22 would complement Alb ts16 or LA ts6. As shown in Table 1, in three separate experiments Alb ts22 clearly complemented both Alb ts16 and LA ts6. Therefore, the mutation in Alb ts22 was in a different cistron than the mutations in Alb ts16 and LA ts6, thus identifying a second complementation group. In a series of further experiments, we extended our complementation analysis to include Alb ts6, Wü ts18, Wü ts36, and Wü ts38. Using the same assay, we found that Alb ts6 complemented Alb ts22 but failed to complement Alb ts16 or LA ts6. Thus, we conclude that Alb ts6 was in the same complementation group as Alb ts16 and LA ts6. Finally, we found that Wü ts18, Wü ts36, and Wü ts38 were in a different complementation group(s) from that of either Alb ts6 or Alb ts22, and thus, these mutants defined at least a third complementation group.
In our analysis of the ts mutants of MHV-A59 described above, values for the CI were always less than two or more than five and thus readily interpreted as positive or negative without correction for the presence of revertants or recombinants. However, from the results we obtained, it was clear that recombination did occur when there was complementation. The EOP of the virus harvested from cells co-infected with two complementing viruses was usually ;10 À2 , and not the EOP of the individual ts mutants, which was 10 À4 -10 À8 . This result is in contrast to similar experiments using Sindbis virus in complementation assays, where we obtained similar EOPs to the input viruses when assaying the progeny from complementing ts mutants (unpublished data). We took these results to indicate that complementation allowed recombination in MHV.
This finding provided the means to develop a more convenient and more rapid method of determining complementation for MHV-A59 ts mutants. We reasoned that because recombination appeared to be driven by complementation, biochemical complementation (i.e., viral RNA synthesis) might be detected in cells co-infected with complementing ts mutants, but not in cells infected with ts mutants in the same complementation group. We devised such an assay. Cells were infected at the permissive temperature and were then re-fed with medium prewarmed to the non-permissive temperature and containing dactinomycin to inhibit DNA-dependent RNA synthesis and 3 H-uridine to label viral RNA. The infected cells were incubated until 7-8 hpi at 39 8C to 40 8C or 8-12 hpi at 30 8C, and RNA synthesis was measured by the incorporation of 3 H-uridine into acidprecipitable material. Figure 2A shows the results of single and double infection with the Alb ts6, Alb ts16, Alb ts22, and LA ts6 mutants. The data show that at 40 8C, the mutants Alb ts6, Alb ts16, and LA ts6 were not able to rescue the RNAnegative phenotype of each other and thus, the three mutants were in the same complementation group. In contrast, Alb ts Mutants Cells were mock-infected or infected with MHV-A59, one of the ts mutants, or with a mixture of two ts mutants. The cells were incubated at 40 8C in medium containing dactinomycin and 3 H-uridine and, at 8 hpi, 3 H-uridine incorporation into trichloroacetic acid-precipitated RNA was determined. Cells were infected with: M, mock-infected; A59, MHV-A59; A6, Alb ts6; A16, Alb ts16; A22, Alb ts22; A17, Alb ts17; L6, LA ts6; W18, Wü ts18; W36, Wü ts36; W38, Wü ts38; A6xA16, Alb ts6 and Alb ts16; A6xL6, Alb ts6 and LA ts6; A6xA22, Alb ts6 and Alb ts22; A16xL6, Alb ts16 and LA ts6; A16xA22, Alb ts16 and Alb ts22; L6xA22, LA ts6 and Alb ts22; A17x A16, Alb ts17 and Alb ts16; A17xL6, Alb ts17 and LA ts6; A17xA22 or A22xA17, Alb ts17 and Alb ts22; A17xW38, Alb ts17 and Wü ts38; A17xW18, Alb ts17 and Wü ts18; A17xW36, Alb ts17 and Wü ts36; A22xW18, Alb ts22 and Wü ts18; A22xW36, Alb ts22 and Wü ts36; A22xW38, Alb ts22 and Wü ts38; W18xW36, Wü ts18 and Wü ts36; W18xW38, Wü ts18 and Wü ts38; W36xW38, Wü ts36 and Wü ts38. DOI: 10.1371/journal.ppat.0010039.g002 ts22 was able to rescue the RNA-negative phenotype of Alb ts6, Alb ts16, and LA ts6 and thus, was the sole member of a separate complementation group. This result is identical to that obtained using classical complementation assays and served to validate the new method. The assay was as specific as classic genetic complementation, which measures progeny virus production, but is less time-consuming. Using this assay, we were able not only to confirm the prediction of at least three complementation groups that were obtained using classical complementation procedures but also to identify a fourth complementation group. The results are presented in Figure 2B and 2C and show that mutants Alb ts17, Wu ts36, Wu ts38, and Wu ts18 define not one but two additional complementation groups. We found Alb ts17 and Wü ts38 belong to the same complementation group based on their failure to complement each other's defects. However, both of these mutants complemented Wü ts36 and Wü ts18, which did not complement each other.
Finally, we extended this assay to include the full collection of mutants that we have available and Table 2 summarizes the complementation patterns of the RNA-negative ts mutants of MHV-A59 assayed to date. The numbers shown in Table 2 represent the percentage of viral RNA synthesis found for the mixed mutant-infected cells compared to A59 virus-infected cells at 40 8C. A value less than zero means the 3 H-uridine incorporation was less than that obtained from mockinfected cells. With this type of assay, we took less than 1% of the MHV-A59 incorporation as indicating failure to complement and greater than 1% as evidence of positive complementation. Based on these results, it was possible to assign a further ten mutants (Alb ts2, ts8, and ts9, and ts19; Ut ts88 and ts329; LA ts3 and ts9; and NC ts2 and ts3) to the same complementation group as Alb ts6, Alb ts16, and LA ts6 and, it was possible to assign mutant Ut ts145 to the same complementation group as Wü ts18 and Wü ts36. Thus, it was possible to assign the entire collection of 19 RNAnegative ts mutants of MHV to one of four complementation groups, which we have tentatively named cistrons I, II, IV, and VI based on the locations identified for their causal point mutations (see below). This numbering scheme leaves open the possibility of finding two additional complementation groups (cistrons III and V) in the future that would represent gene products of ORF1b (see below).

Identification of Mutations Responsible for the ts Mutant Phenotype
The entire coding region of the replicase genes (ORF1a and ORF1b) was sequenced for each of eight ts mutant/revertant pairs. In each case, a single nucleotide change was identified as the mutation responsible for the ts mutant phenotype. Using the numbering that we have assigned to the infectious cDNA clone of the MHV-A59 genome [45] (GenBank accession number AY700211), the nucleotide changes compared to wt MHV-A59 were identified as: Alb ts6, Figure 3A). We also identified a number of nucleotide differences between mutants isolated in different laboratories, but in no case did they correlate with the ts phenotype. With the exception of the Alb 17R S revertant, all of the revertants we isolated were true, i.e., they were genetically and phenotypically identical to the wt MHV-A59. The Alb 17R S revertant was a pseudorevertant in that the nucleotide at position 19288 had reverted from A! C, which resulted in a substitution of Tyr with Arg. This radical substitution was reflected in a small plaque phenotype ( Figure S1).
All of the nucleotide changes responsible for the ts mutant phenotype were non-synonymous mutations. The amino acid substitutions are shown in Figure 3B. Conservative substitutions were identified in nsp5 and nsp10 of the Alb ts16 and LA ts6 mutants, respectively. Moderately conservative substitutions were identified in nsp4 and nsp12 of the Alb ts6 and Alb ts22 mutants, respectively. And radical substitutions were identified in nsp14 of the Alb ts17 and Wü ts38 mutant, as well as nsp16 of the Wü ts18 and Wü ts36 mutants [46]. A comparison of the predicted replicase protein sequences from different coronaviruses showed that there was, by and large, conservation of the amino acids that were substituted in the proteins with a ts phenotype. For example, the Gln 65 residue of nsp10, the His 868 residue of nsp12, and the Cys 408 residue of nsp14 appear to be well conserved in Group I, II (including SARSCoV), and III coronaviruses. In contrast, the Asn 258 residue of nsp4 is only found in MHV strains, although in the majority of other coronaviruses, it is substituted by an aspartic acid. Finally, it is possible, with different degrees of confidence, to predict the structural environment in which the residues in question are found. On the one hand, it is highly likely that the Phe 219 residue of nsp5 is located in an extended area that connects the a-helices B and C in the carboxyl-terminal domain III of nsp5, the 3C-like proteinase. This conclusion is based upon the similarity in the sequences of coronavirus nsp5 proteins and the crystallographic structures that have been solved for the transmissible gastroenteritis virus (TGEV), SARSCoV, and HCoV-229E nsp5 proteins [23,47,48]. On the other hand, programs that predict protein secondary structure [49] indicate that the Gln 65 residue of nsp10, the His 868 residue of nsp12, and the Cys 408 residue of nsp14 are located in disordered loop structures, while the Asn 258 residue of nsp4 and the Leu 153 residue of nsp16 are involved in a-helices. Obviously, more definitive structural data will be needed to confirm these predictions.

Phenotypes of the MHV-A59 ts Mutants
We focused our phenotypic analysis on the eight MHV-A59 ts mutants that had been genotyped and began by measuring ''total'' viral RNA synthesis in infected cells prior to and following shift from the permissive to the non-permissive temperature. This analysis was done after 8 h of incubation at 30 8C, a time at which the replicase-transciptase complex produces mainly (.90%) positive-strand RNA, and ;20% of the maximum rate of RNA synthesis has been reached. Mutant virus-infected cells were shifted to 40 8C at 8 hpi and a duplicate set was left at 30 8C. Both sets of cultures were labeled for 1 h with 3 H-uridine in the presence of 10 lg per ml of cycloheximide (CH) to monitor the replicase-transcriptase activity at the time of shift. The results are shown in Figure 4. In MHV-A59 infected cells, the amount of 3 Huridine incorporation doubled, as expected, when the temperature was increased by 10 8C. The group I mutants had about the same level of viral RNA synthesis at both temperatures, while in the group II, IV, and VI mutantinfected cells, viral RNA synthesis diminished by 50% or more in the hour following temperature shift. We interpret  this to mean that mutations in replicase proteins encoded in ORF1a appeared to confer temperature-sensitivity to the viral replicase-transcriptase complex, but once it had formed at 30 8C, its positive-strand synthetic activity was relatively resistant to higher temperature. In contrast, mutations in ORF1b-encoded proteins, namely nsp12, nsp14, and nsp16 appeared to affect the positive-strand synthetic activity of already-formed replicase-transcriptase complexes. We then went on to analyze the phenotypes of three ts mutants in more detail.
Alb ts22. The phenotype described above for group II, IV, and VI mutants would be consistent with a defect in any stage of positive-strand RNA synthesis. In the case of mutant Alb ts22, however, we have shown that the ts lesion is located in nsp12, the viral RNA-dependent RNA polymerase subunit. This suggested to us that the Alb ts22 might be defective in the elongation phase of RNA synthesis. To analyze the phenotype of Alb ts22 in more detail, RNA synthesis in Alb ts22-infected cells was determined using 1 h pulse labels with 3 H-uridine in the presence of dactinomycin, given between 1-6 hpi at 40 8C or between 5-14 hpi at 30 8C ( Figure 5A). At 40 8C, Alb ts22-infected cells incorporated only mock levels of 3 H-uridine, as expected for an RNA-negative ts mutant. In contrast, cells infected with wt MHV-A59 or with Alb 22R (a revertant of Alb ts22) made RNA at high rates and at identical times. At 30 8C, Alb ts22 was defective in viral RNA synthesis and never reached the levels of viral RNA synthesis shown by wt MHV-A59 or Alb 22R. These results are consistent with our finding that, at 30 8C, the plaques formed by Alb ts22 were smaller that those formed by wt MHV-A59. Analysis by gel electrophoresis of the species of positive-strand RNA made in Alb ts22-infected cells at 30 8C showed the typical pattern of seven RNAs (genome and six subgenomic mRNAs), although the six subgenomic mRNAs were reduced equally in amount relative to the genome RNA when compared to Alb 22R infected cells (unpublished data). We conclude that Alb ts22 not only produced less overall RNA compared to wt MHV-A59 and Alb 22R, even at the permissive temperature, but also under-produced all of the subgenomic mRNA species relative to the genome RNA.
We also examined the ability of Alb ts22-infected cells to continue viral RNA synthesis after shift from 30 8C to 40 8C at 13 hpi ( Figure 5B). This allowed us to follow the activity at 40 8C of the viral RNA-dependent RNA polymerase that was made and assembled at 30 8C. At this time, Alb ts22 RNA synthesis was at its maximum rate and RNA synthesis by wt MHV-A59 and Alb 22R was declining. The results show that a shift to 40 8C led to the rapid loss of RNA synthesis by Alb ts22 but not by wt MHV-A59 or Alb 22R. This result is consistent with a failure of the viral RNA-dependent RNA polymerase to continue transcription at the non-permissive temperature. We concluded Alb ts22 had a ts defect in elongation, although we do not know if elongation is directly affected or if the amino acid change in nsp12 affects its interaction with an as yet unknown, but essential protein. We have also shown that, as expected, Alb ts22 is unable to synthesize negative-strand RNA at the non-permissive temperature (unpublished data).
Alb ts16 and LA ts6. Although both Alb ts16 and LA ts6 are unable to synthesize viral RNA when the infection is initiated and maintained at the non-permissive temperature, the data shown in Figure 4 suggests that they are not significantly impaired in their ability to synthesize positive-strand RNA at this temperature. This conclusion is strengthened by the results shown in Figure 6A, which demonstrate the kinetics of overall viral RNA synthesis in Alb ts16 and LA ts6 virusinfected cells after shifting the incubation temperature from 30 8C to 40 8C at 8 hpi. With wt MHV-A59, viral RNA synthesis increased rapidly within the first 60 min after temperature shift, consistent with the synthesis of both additional negative-strand templates and their nascent positive-strand product. The addition of CH at the time of shift resulted in a constant rate of viral RNA synthesis for at least 1 h. As we know that negative-strand synthesis in MHV-A59-infected cells is short-lived and stops within 30 min of the inhibition of protein synthesis [24], we deduce that the addition of CH prevented the synthesis of new viral proteins, which in turn prevented the formation of additional replicase-transcriptase activity and negative-strand templates.
In cells infected with complementation group I ts mutants Alb ts16 and LA ts6, viral RNA synthesis continued at 40 8C at the level ongoing at the time of temperature shift ( Figure 6A). This meant that the replicase-transcriptase complexes assembled at 30 8C continued to function at 40 8C in the synthesis of positive-strand RNA. However, unlike A59infected cells, the group I mutants did not increase their rates of RNA synthesis after shift to non-permissive temperature, indicating that no new active complexes were formed. This phenotype resembled that seen with MHV-A59-infected cells treated with CH, and we conclude that the complementation group I mutants are defective in their ability to form active replicase-transcriptase complexes at 40 8C but retain the positive-strand synthesis activity of the complexes formed at the permissive temperature.
At least two possibilities could account for a failure of group I ts mutants to form fully competent replicasetranscriptase complexes at the non-permissive temperature. Either no new negative-strand templates were made, i.e., a defect in negative-strand synthesis, or, if they were made, they could not be used as templates for positive-strand synthesis. The latter phenotype has been observed for certain alphavirus mutants [50], which were called conversion-defective mutants. To distinguish between these two possibilities, it is necessary to shift the ts mutant-infected cells to the nonpermissive temperature and determine their ability to continue negative-strand RNA synthesis. Mutants that fail to continue negative-strand RNA synthesis would be defective in this step, while mutants that continued to make negative strands would be designated as conversion-defective mutants. Cells infected with wt MHV-A59, Alb ts16, and LA ts6 were shifted from 30 8C to 40 8C at 8 h (Alb ts16) or 9 h (LA ts6) post-infection and were pulse-labeled with 3 H uridine at 40 8C. Then, viral negative-strand templates in replicating and transcribing structures were purified free of single-stranded RNA, and the incorporation of radioactivity into negativestranded RNA was measured by nuclease protection assays. In this assay, the results are expressed as the percentage of the 3 H-uridine incorporated into the negative-stranded component of the purified, nuclease-resistant RNA cores of the replicative-transcriptive structures. As these structures represent double-stranded RNA, if 40%-50% of the total incorporation in the core RNA is found in negative strands, it means that 80%-100% of the negative strands that were active as templates during the pulse period had been made during this same period. This occurred when negative-strand synthesis was measured early in the infection cycle, when viral RNA synthesis was ;20% of the maximum [24]. Figure 6B shows that in wt MHV-A59-infected cells, negative-strand synthesis continues following a shift from 30 8C to 40 8C at a time when the amount of viral RNA synthesis is ;20% of maximum. This is seen by the similar high values of 20%-25% of the labeled RF RNA being in negative strands for successive 30 min pulse-periods in the absence of CH. Also, as shown previously, continued negativestrand synthesis in MHV-A59-infected cells is dependent on continued translation and abruptly declines in the presence of CH. In the case of LA ts6, the percentage of 3 H-uridine incorporated in negative strands declined abruptly after shifting to 40 8C and this decline was the same in the absence or the presence of CH. With Alb ts16, negative-strand synthesis continued during the 20-40 min and the 40-60 min pulse-periods in the absence of CH but was inhibited in the presence of CH. For this mutant, to find that negativestrand synthesis continued at 40 8C without an increase in the rate of positive-strand synthesis, as seen for MHV-A59, was consistent with Alb ts16 having a ts defect affecting the ability of the negative-strand templates to be efficiently used at 40 8C. Thus, we conclude that LA ts6 was defective in continuing negative-strand synthesis after shift to 40 8C and Alb ts16 displayed what appears to be a conversion phenotype.

Discussion
Taken together with the complementation analysis, the identification of the mutations responsible for the ts phenotypes of Alb ts6, Alb ts16, Alb ts17, Alb ts22, LA ts6, Wü ts18, Wü ts36, and Wü ts38 leads to a number of important conclusions. First, our data strongly suggest that most of the replicase gene products of ORF1a are cis-active and form a single complementation group (cistron I) encompassing, at least, the nsp4 to nsp10 coding region. If correct, our conclusion must mean that a large proportion of nsp1-nsp11 proteins function as a polyprotein, if only initially or transiently, or they associate as a cis-acting complex before they are proteolytically processed. We favor a model in which a pp1a-related polyprotein represents a large modular scaffolding protein that displays binding sites for ORF1bencoded pp1ab processing products. While the large number of mutants that fall into cistron I clearly suggest that it is extensive and polygenic, it is not yet clear if all of the ORF1aencoded proteins function in cis. We are aware that the arterivirus Equine arteritis virus ORF1a-encoded protein nsp1 can function in trans [51] and it has recently been shown that the MHV-A59 ORF1a-encoded protein nsp2 is nonessential for virus replication [52]. The genetic analysis of further MHV-A59 ts mutants will be needed to define the precise boundaries of MHV-A59 cistron I.
Second, our results suggest that the replicase gene products encoded in ORF1b (i.e., nsp12-nsp16) are diffusible and thus assemble and function in viral RNA synthesis after cleavage from pp1ab. This also leads us to the prediction that there will be five cistrons in ORF1b, each corresponding to one of the proteolytic cleavage products, and we have designated them tentatively as cistrons II-VI in a 59 to 39 direction (nsp12, cistron II; nsp13, cistron III; nsp14, cistron IV; nsp15, cistron V; and nsp16, cistron VI). The idea that the MHV-A59 ORF1b-encoded replicase proteins function in trans is consistent with the results of Brockway et al., who have shown that a green fluorescent protein-tagged MHV-A59 nsp12 is able to diffuse into the replicase-transcriptase complex if expressed individually in virus-infected cells [9]. However, we would also like to note that our data does not exclude the possibility that some of the ORF1b-encoded proteins may function as intermediates, rather than the end products of proteolytic cleavage. For example, functional proteins comprising nsp12/nsp13, nsp13/nsp14, nsp14/nsp15, nsp15/nsp16 as well as nsp13/nsp14/nsp15 could all be accommodated as single cistrons based upon our complementation data. This would lead to the prediction of either three or four cistrons encoded in ORF1b. The idea that a number of the enzymes involved in coronavirus RNA synthesis may be linked not only functionally, i.e., sequentially in a concerted reaction pathway, but also structurally (i.e., as multifunctional proteins) is also suggested by other studies. For example, Ziebuhr and colleagues [53] have shown that 29-O-ribose-methylated RNA substrates are resistant to cleavage by the SARS-coronavirus endoribonuclease (nsp15), indicating a functional link with the S-adenosylmethionine-dependent 29-O-methyl transferase (nsp16). We are currently searching for further ts mutants that might help resolve this issue and we are attempting to trans-complement ts mutants with cell lines that constitutively express ORF1b-encoded replicase proteins. Despite these reservations, the genetic data do allow us to conclude that not only nsp5, the 3C-like cysteine proteinase, and nsp12, the putative RNA-dependent polymerase (as might have been predicted), but also nsp14, the putative MHV exonuclease, nsp16, the putative MHV 29-O-methyltransferase, nsp4, and nsp10 are essential for the assembly of a functional replicase-transcriptase complex.
In contrast to most other positive-stranded RNA virus, the viral replicase-transcriptase complex of coronaviruses (and most other nidoviruses) functions to amplify the genome via a full-length negative-strand intermediate and to produce, via a discontinuous process, subgenome-length negative-strand templates that are then copied directly into subgenomic mRNA. How the replicase-transcriptase complex accomplishes these various activities is not understood in any detail. For example, it is not known whether the same replicase-transcriptase complex functions to produce fulllength and subgenome-length RNA or how the conversion from negative-to positive-strand RNA synthesis is regulated. Does the analysis of MHV-A59 ts mutants help us to understand these complex processes?
We have shown previously that negative-and positivestrand RNA synthesis occurs simultaneously throughout MHV-A59 infection but that negative-strand synthesis is short-lived, i.e., its synthesis halts within several minutes after protein synthesis is inhibited [24]. This contrasts with positive-strand synthesis, which continues unabated for 1 h and then gradually declines and disappears about 4 h after the inhibition of translation. These observations suggest that unprocessed forms of the replicase polyprotein(s) might function in negative-strand synthesis and that cleavage of the nascent polyprotein inactivates the negative-strand activity of the replicase, as it does for alphaviruses [54,55]. The replicasetranscriptase activity for positive-strand synthesis can be restarted after the block of translation is reversed [27] but, for this to happen, new negative-strand templates need to be synthesized. In other words, it appears that the coronavirus replicase-transcriptase complex ages, losing both its negativestrand templates and its activity. This interpretation fits well with our genetic analysis of the mutants LA ts6, Alb ts16, and Alb ts6, which shows that they all fall into a single complementation group. It is also consistent with our proposal that the replicase proteins encoded in ORF1a are expressed and function as a polyprotein, or that they assemble as a cis-acting complex before they are proteolytically processed. It is also worth noting that in vivo protein labeling experiments indicate that proteolytic processing of both MHV-A59 ORF1a and MHV-A59 ORF1b-encoded replicase proteins is measured in hours rather than minutes [56][57][58] and that the fully processed 3C-like cysteine proteinase is first detected several hours post-infection [59], a time at which the rate of viral RNA synthesis is already increasing rapidly [24].
The idea that the MHV replicase-transcriptase complex is active in negative-strand RNA synthesis before pp1a is extensively processed also fits well with our detailed phenotypic analysis of cistron I mutants. In the case of LA ts6, negative-strand synthesis was inhibited after shift to the non-permissive temperature and, in time, this leads to a decline in positive-strand RNA synthesis (unpublished data). Thus, at the non-permissive temperature, LA ts6 could not sustain positive-strand synthesis, nor replace or replenish aging replicase-transcriptase complexes. The causal mutation in LA ts6 would substitute a Glu for the Gln 65 residue of wt nsp10. As noted above the Gln 65 residue is conserved in Group I, II (including SARSCoV), and III coronaviruses and its substitution with Glu might prevent the proper folding of pp1a into a conformation that would allow it to participate in the formation of a replicase-transcriptase complex with negative-strand activity. It would be interesting to determine if, at the non-permissive temperature, nsp10 of LA ts6 could associate with nsp12, nsp13, nsp14, nsp15, or nsp16. Also, it was curious that LA ts6 had a very low reversion frequency of ;10 À8 . Why certain bases fail to revert at the typical frequency of 10 À4 to 10 À5 is unknown but may be indicative of a region of the genome that is transcribed with higher fidelity than other regions. Alternatively, this low reversion frequency may be an inherent property of the LA ts6 replicase-transcriptase complex.
In contrast to LA ts6, Alb ts16 appeared to be able to continue to form negative strands after shift to the nonpermissive temperature, but these negative strands were not converted into templates for positive-strand synthesis. We speculate that Alb ts16 has a ts defect in the conversion of the replicase-transcriptase complex from one able to synthesize negative strands to one able to synthesize positive strands. It is certainly suggestive that Alb ts16 had a mutation in nsp5, which is the 3C-like proteinase of the virus, but it has yet to be determined if this mutation affects the activity of the proteinase, or if it affects the folding of pp1a or pp1ab, or if the nsp5 C-terminal domain itself could have a function in positive-strand RNA synthesis. Nevertheless, because negative-strand RNA synthesis was inhibited in Alb ts16-infected cells treated with CH at the time of shift to non-permissive temperature, we propose that the Alb ts16 replicase-transcriptase complex does not retain its activity for minus-strand synthesis. Rather it fails to gain positive-strand synthesis activity at the non-permissive temperature. We favor a model where the activity that makes positive strands is gained at the expense or loss of the activity to make negative strands.
Finally, although we are able to rationalize the genotype of Alb ts22, i.e., a mutation in nsp12 (the RNA dependent RNA polymerase) with its phenotype (i.e., an immediate effect on RNA synthesis at the non-permissive temperature) we were surprised to find that Alb ts17, Wü ts18, Wü ts36, and Wü ts38 also showed the same phenotype but had mutations in other replicase proteins. Generally, it is unusual to find so many ts mutants that show an effect on RNA synthesis if the replicasetranscriptase complex is first allowed to assemble at the permissive temperature. Most RNA-negative ts mutants of alphaviruses, for example, fail to make viral RNA when the infection is initiated at the non-permissive temperature but continue to make viral RNA if shifted to the non-permissive temperature late in infection (unpublished data). One possibility is that nsp14 and nsp16 dissociate or become less tightly associated with the replicase-transcriptase complex after shifting to the non-permissive temperature and this causes the complex to lose elongation activity. Another possibility is that the enzymatic activities associated with nsp14 and nsp16 are altered in the group IV and group VI mutants. Further studies will be required to explain this phenotype.
In summary, our detailed phenotypic analysis of MHV-A59 ts mutants allows us to propose a working model that describes a pathway for viral RNA synthesis in MHV-A59infected cells. In this model, the replicase-transcriptase complex forms initially and creates a negative-strand template. It is then converted to utilize the negative strand as a template for positive-strand synthesis and, finally, the complex is inactivated by the degradation of negative-strand templates (Figure 7). Our analysis also allows us to place some of our ts mutants at specific points on this pathway. We hope that a more detailed biochemical analysis of these mutants will allow us to identify intermediates in the pathway of RNA synthesis and will provide valuable information of the precise function(s) of the viral replicase proteins involved. Furthermore, we believe that the characterization of these mutants provides an excellent starting point for the generation of second site reversion mutants. This could be done, for example, by using the recently developed MHV reverse genetic system [45] to generate ts mutants with codon, rather than nucleotide substitutions. Second site reversion mutants may then provide valuable information on protein-protein interactions within the replicase-transcriptase complex.

Materials and Methods
Cells and viruses. Seventeen clone one (17Cl-1) mouse fibroblast cells [60] were cultured at 37 8C in Dulbecco's modified Eagle's medium (DMEM) supplemented with 6% fetal bovine serum (FBS), 5% tryptose phosphate broth (TPB), penicillin (100 units/ml), and streptomycin (100 lg/ml). Sac(À) cells [61] were cultured at 37 8C in minimal essential medium (MEM) supplemented with 5% FBS, penicillin (100 units/ml), and streptomycin (100 lg/ml). The A59 strain of MHV and a set of ts mutants derived from MHV-A59 (Alb prefix) were originally obtained from the laboratory of L. Sturman, Wadsworth Center for Laboratories and Research, Albany, New York, United States [40]. Mutants prefixed with LA (Los Angeles) and NC (North Carolina) were obtained from M. Schaad and R. Baric, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, North Carolina, United States and have been initially characterized [39]. Mutants prefixed with Ut (Utrecht) were obtained from W. Spaan, Leiden University Medical Center, Leiden, The Netherlands and have been initially characterized [41]. The LA, NC, and Ut ts mutants were derived from different but related lineages of the Albany isolate of MHV-A59. Mutants prefixed with Wü (Wü rzburg, Germany) were isolated as described below.
For our studies, virus stocks were derived from the original mutant isolates after plaque purification and propagation in 17Cl-1 cells cultured at 30 8C or 33 8C in low pH DMEM (pH 6.4) containing 6% FBS, 5% TPB, penicillin (100 units/ml), and streptomycin (100 lg/ml) [24]. Revertants were picked from plaques of mutants titered at 39.5 8C, followed by another plaque purification at 39.5 8C. The virus stocks used were first passage and were obtained by using virus from a single plaque (;10 7 pfu) to infect a dish of ;4 3 10 7 17Cl-1 cells to yield 30 ml of stock virus with a titer of 1-6 3 10 9 pfu/ml.
Isolation of Wü ts mutants. Sac(À) cells were infected with 10 pfu/ cell of MHV-A59 (originally obtained from P. Carthew, Medical Research Council Laboratories, Carshalton, United Kingdom), and incubated for 15 h at 37 8C in medium containing 150 lg/ml of 5fluorouracil. This concentration of pyrimidine analogue was determined to inhibit virus replication by 80%. The mutagenized virus stock was diluted to 15 pfu/ml in medium and 100 ll aliquots were incubated with 10 4 Sac(À) cells at 30 8C for 48 h. The supernatant was taken from cultures that displayed syncytium formation and used to infect duplicate cultures of 10 4 Sac(À) cells that were incubated at 30 8C or 39.5 8C for 24 h. The supernatant was taken from replica cultures that developed cytopathic effect at 30 8C but not at 39.5 8C, and potential ts mutants were isolated by two plaque purifications. Sequence analysis of the Wü rzburg strain of MHV-A59 suggests that approximately 8,000 nucleotides at the 59 end of the genome have been exchanged by recombination with a related but different MHV strain (unpublished data).
Characterization of mutant stocks for titer and EOP. 17Cl-1 cells in 60 mm petri dishes were infected with 0.5 ml of 10-fold dilutions of Figure 7. A Model to Describe the Pathway for Viral RNA Synthesis in MHV-A59-Infected Cells Shows a working model that describes a pathway for viral RNA synthesis in MHV-A59-infected cells. The model proposes that the replicasetranscriptase complex forms initially and creates a negative-strand template. It is then converted to utilize the negative strand as a template for positive-strand synthesis and, finally, the complex is inactivated by the degradation of negative-strand templates. It is also proposed that proteolytic processing of the replicase polyproteins plays a role in regulation of this pathway. Also depicted are the putative defects of specific MHV-A59 ts mutants. It remains to be shown whether or not the group IV and VI mutants (Wü ts38, Alb ts17, Wü ts18, and Wü ts36) are defective in negative-strand RNA synthesis at the non-permissive temperature. DOI: 10 6.6]). The inoculum was removed after 30 min and the cells were overlaid with DMEM containing 6% FBS, penicillin (100 units/ml), streptomycin (100 lg/ml), and 0.1% Gelritee gellan gum (Sigma, St. Louis, Missouri, United States) and incubated at the appropriate temperature in 7.5% CO 2 . After incubation for 3 or 4 d at 30 8C or 2 d at 37 8C or 39.5 8C, cells were rinsed with 0.15 M NaCl, fixed with methanol, and stained with a solution of 0.2% toluidine blue, 0.2% azure blue, and 1% boric acid. The EOP was calculated by dividing titers at 39.5 8C by the titer at 30 8C. We found that all of the ts mutants produced the same titer at 30 8C as at 33 8C and in all cases 6 39 8C was non-permissive for plaque formation of the ts mutants.
Complementation analysis. Classic or genetic complementation was done by infecting 17Cl-1cells in 35 mm petri dishes either singly with each mutant or doubly with two mutants at a multiplicity of infection (MOI) of 20-30 pfu/cell. After incubation at room temperature or 30 8C for 30 min, the virus inoculum was removed and the infected cells were rinsed with HBSS and re-fed with low pH DMEM or DMEM supplemented with 6% FBS, penicillin (100 units/ml), and streptomycin (100g/ml). The infected cells were incubated at 39.5 8C or 40 8C in 10% CO 2 . One hour later the cells were rinsed again and re-fed with warmed medium and the dishes returned to the incubator until 8 hpi. The medium was harvested, clarified at 10,000 rpm for 5 min, and virus titers were determined by plaque assays at 30 8C. CIs were calculated using the following formula: A CI greater than two between mutant pairs was consistent with complementation, i.e., 6 4-fold difference above background, while a CI less than two was negative for complementation [43]. Biochemical complementation was done by mock-infecting or infecting 17Cl-1cells at 30 pfu/cell with MHV-A59, or one of the ts mutants, or with a mix of 15 pfu/cell each of two ts mutants. After the adsorption period at room temperature for 30 min, the virus inoculum was removed, 1 ml of prewarmed medium containing dactinomycin and 3 H-uridine (1.85 MBq/ml) was added and the cells were incubated at 40 8C. The wt and the ts mutant-infected cells were harvested at 8 hpi and the 3 H-uridine incorporation into trichloroacetic acid-precipitated RNA was determined.
Viral RNA synthesis. Viral RNA synthesis was measured by determining the amount of 3 H-uridine incorporated in the presence of dactinomycin (20 lg/ml) into acid-precipitable material. [5-3 H] uridine (!1.0 TBq/mmol) was added to the medium at either 1.85 or 7.4 MBq/ml. After incubation, the radioactive medium was removed and the cells dissolved with 5% lithium dodecyl sulfate and 200 lg/ml proteinase K in LEH buffer (0.1 M LiCl, 0.001 M EDTA, 0.01 M HEPES, [pH 6.6]) at 2-5 3 10 5 cells per ml. The DNA was sheared by repeated passage through a 27-gauge needle attached to a 1-ml tuberculin syringe. Triplicate samples of 5 3 10 4 cells were precipitated with trichloroacetic acid and the precipitates collected on glass fiber filters (Whatman Incorporated, Clifton, New Jersey, United States), dried under a heat lamp, and the radioactivity determined by liquid scintillation spectroscopy. To measure negative-strand synthesis, the dissolved cells were extracted with low pH phenol (pH 4.3), which removed DNA from the aqueous phase, and then with cholorofom:isoamyl alcohol (95:5), and the RNA was precipitated with ethanol. RF RNA was generated by treatment of the RNA with RNase T1 (1U/ug RNA, 30 8C for 30 min in 0.3 M NaCl) and collected by chromatography on CF-11 cellulose and ethanol precipitation. The incorporation of 3 H-uridine into negative strands was measured by denaturing the RF RNA with heat and annealing in the presence of .100-fold excess of unlabeled RNA obtained from purified virions of MHV [24].
Isolation of viral RNA. Two different procedures were used to obtain viral RNA for RT-PCR and sequencing. Virions were purified from ;3 3 10 8 17Cl-1 cells that had been infected at a MOI of ;10 pfu/cell and incubated in low pH DMEM at 30-33 8C. The medium from the infected cells (;225 ml) was collected at 24 hpi and clarified at 4,000 rpm for 30 min. The virions were pelleted by centrifugation at 24,000 rpm for 3 h at 4 8C. The virus pellet was allowed to suspend overnight on ice in 0.4 ml/tube of 0.15M NaCl and 20 mM HEPES (pH 6.6). The suspended virus from six tubes was pooled and layered over one SW28 tube containing a linear gradient of 40% potassium tartrate (bottom) and 20% glycerol (top), in 0.0.2 M HEPES (pH 7.4).
After centrifugation at 24,000 rpm for 3-4 h at 4 8C, the visible band containing the virions was collected, diluted, and pelleted by centrifugation at 24,000 rpm for 3 h at 4 8C. The pelleted virions were suspended in 0.15M NaCl and 20 mM HEPES (pH 6.6), and LiDS and proteinase K were added to 5% and 400 lg/ml, respectively, After incubation at 42 8C for 10 min, the viral RNA was extracted with phenol followed by chloroform:isoamylalcohol (19:1). Viral RNA was ethanol-precipitated and the pellet was washed with 70% ethanol, dried under vacuum, and resuspended in water. Alternatively, 10 7 17Cl-1 cells were infected with virus, incubated for 13 h at 30 8C to 33 8C in 7.5% CO 2 . The poly(A)-containing RNA was then isolated from the infected cells using oligo-dT 25 Dynabeads as described previously [62].
RT-PCR and sequencing. The entire replicase gene-coding region (ORF1a and ORF1b) was sequenced for eight ts mutant and revertant pairs. To do this, we used a set of 121 synthetic oligonucleotides that are complementary to sequences spaced at approximately 350 nucleotide intervals along the positive-and negative-strand copies of the viral RNA (sequences available on request). Five oligonucleotides, P17, P31, P46, P61, and P65, were used to prime the RT of viral RNA with Superscript II RT (Invitrogen, Carlsbad, California, United States). The reaction mix (20 ll), which contained, in addition to presupplied buffer, 35 ng of primer, 10-100 ng of viral RNA, 1 mM dNTPs, 10 mM DTT, 25 U of RNAguard (Amersham, Little Chalfont, United Kingdom), and 200 U of reverse transcriptase, was incubated at 42 8C for 60 min and then at 94 8C for 2 min. The five cDNA templates were then amplified using eight primer pairs, P1/P16, P2/ P22, P3/P30, P4/P38, P5/P45, P6/P53, P7/P60, and P8/P64, and thermostable, recombinant Taq DNA polymerase. The reaction mix (100 ll), which contained, in addition to pre-supplied buffer, 70 ng of primer pair, 1 ll of RT reaction product, 200 lM dNTPs, 2 mM MgCl 2 , and 2.5 U of DNA polymerase, was incubated at 94 8C for 1 min, then 94 8C for 20 s, 50 8C for 20 s, 68 8C for 3 min, for a total of 35 cycles and a final 10-min extension at 68 8C. The PCR reaction products were purified by ethanol precipitation using ammonium acetate. Finally, sequence analysis was done using primers P1-P121 and standard cycle sequencing methods. Sequencing reaction mixes (10 ll), which contained 70 ng of primer, 100 ng of PCR product, and 3 ll of cycle sequencing mix (BigDye Terminator v.3.1, Applied Biosystems, Foster City, California, United States), were incubated at 96 8C for 10 s, 50 8C for 5 s, and 60 8C for 4 min, for a total of 25 cycles. The reaction products were purified by retention on a size exclusion membrane (Montagee SEQ 96 , Millipore, Billerica, Massachusetts, United States) as described by the manufacturer; eluted and analyzed with an ABI 310 Prism Genetic Analyzer. Computer-assisted analysis of sequence data was done using the Lasergene biocomputing software (DNASTAR). Figure S1. Plaque Morphology of Alb ts17 Revertants The plaque morphologies of Alb ts17 L and Alb ts17 S are illustrated. Alb ts17 had a reversion (back mutation) frequency of 2 3 10 À6 and there was a mixture of large and small plaques at 40 8C. The virus from the small and large plaques produced progeny that formed uniformly small or large plaques at 40 8C, respectively. At 30 8C, both 17R L and 17R S produced plaques of equal diameter and Alb 17R L produced the same size plaques at 40 8C as the parental or wt MHV-A59. Found at DOI: 10.1371/journal.ppat.0010039.sg001 (1.7 MB PPT).