Artificial feeding of young infants is considered a modern phenomenon. However, historical sources note its practice in some past European populations. This research explores factors that contributed to a short to absent period of breastfeeding in pre-modern Netherlands. Stable nitrogen and carbon isotope analysis is undertaken on 277 19th century individuals from Beemster, a, rural, mainly Protestant, dairy farming community. An intra-individual sampling approach for ≤6 year-olds compares newer metaphyseal to older diaphyseal long bone collagen to classify feeding status at death. Archivally identified individuals permit analyses of sex and year-of-death. Few infants have isotopic evidence for breastfeeding and, if present, it was likely of short duration or a minor source of dietary protein. From only a few weeks to months of age infants were fed cow’s milk and paps with sugar. There is broad dietary homogeneity with no sex or temporal isotopic differences, but young infants (1–11 months) have the most ẟ15N and ẟ13C variation highlighting the effect of multiple dietary and physiological processes. Beemster had many factors associated with high rates of breastfeeding in other Dutch communities, yet, most mothers did not breastfeed, or not for long, showing that regional variation in infant feeding is influenced by community values and traditions. On top of child rearing and domestic chores, female dairy farmers were in charge of milking cattle and dairy production, an important income source, suggesting high workload was also a factor in short or absent breastfeeding periods, aided by the constant supply of fresh milk that could be fed to an infant by an older sibling.
Citation: Waters-Rist AL, de Groot K, Hoogland MLP (2022) Isotopic reconstruction of short to absent breastfeeding in a 19th century rural Dutch community. PLoS ONE 17(4): e0265821. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0265821
Editor: Luca Bondioli, University of Padova: Universita degli Studi di Padova, ITALY
Received: May 14, 2021; Accepted: March 8, 2022; Published: April 13, 2022
Copyright: © 2022 Waters-Rist et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Data Availability: All relevant data are within the manuscript and its Supporting Information files.
Funding: A portion of this research was funded by a European Research Council (ERC) Marie Curie International Incoming Fellowship (#302801) held by AWR. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Bioarchaeology lacks studies of pre-modern populations with short to absent periods of breastfeeding largely because, until the advent of commercialized formulas, most infants were breastfed at least until they were ready for other foods beginning around 4 to 6 months-of-age. Thereafter, mixed maternal and non-maternal feeding often continued for several years during the process of weaning. The archaeological record contains infants who were not breastfed, perhaps because of maternal death [e.g., 1], but research thus far has found this was the exception, not the rule. After all, breastmilk is the perfect food for infants (at least until ~6 months of age) because it is nutritious, sterile, confers immunity, promotes gastrointestinal maturation and health, and during the period of exclusive breastfeeding, prevents the infant from ingesting contaminated foods.
Isotopic reconstructions of infant feeding practices from a wide geographic and temporal range of past populations have found weaning ceased between one- to six-years of age, with an average around two to three-years [2, 3]. The shortest breastfeeding periods have been found in European post-Medieval populations (from roughly CE 1500–1900) where weaning was complete around the first year [4, 5]. These populations came from large urban centres and one included a lower-class rapidly industrializing area where mothers worked outside the home; these factors are often noted to have caused a decline in breastfeeding in historical times [6–10]. Technological advancements in infant feeding devices made during the post-Medieval period, and the widening availability of animal milks, enabled artificial feeding [9–12]. Devices included buddy-pots and pap boats. The former were like a small coffee-pot with the neck coming from the bottom and a spout with small holes over which a cloth was tied through which the infant could suck milk, and the latter held variable mixtures of ‘water-milk-broth-bread-flour-grain’ and included a spoon with a hollow stem through which food could be blown down the infant’s throat [10, 12–14]. Another simple, common feeding method was to spoon-feed the infant animal milk or even have them drink directly from the teat. Cow’s horns and clay and wood vessels have also been used as infant feeding devices. Glass bottles were invented in 1851 and advances in rubber production made odorless rubber nipples available by the latter part of the 19th century [10–13].
Infant feeding was an understudied topic in historic times, but some texts discussed breastfeeding in the context of concerns about high infant mortality rates (IMR). In 19th century Netherlands, the focus of this study, around one in four or five infants died in their first year [15–20]. This prompted investigations into the causes of high IMRs, which found strong correlations with a lack of breastfeeding or its early cessation, combined with unsuitable breastmilk alternatives and/or other harmful weaning practices [15, 21–27]. This prompted several historical Dutch texts to strongly advocate for maternal breastfeeding [22, 25, 28–30].
For such a small country, the Netherlands had marked regional variation in IMR during the post-Medieval period, implying considerable variation in infant feeding practices [9, 16, 19, 20, 31, 32]. Several variables likely affected 19th century Dutch breastfeeding practices. Debate surrounds the idea that Dutch Catholic communities had lower rates and shorter durations of breastfeeding (which resulted in higher IMRs) compared to Liberal Protestant communities (Liberal Protestant denominations consist of the Dutch Reformed (majority) and Mennonites, Lutherans, and Remonstrants (minority) and excludes Orthodox Protestant denominations such as Dutch Calvinism, which often had high infant mortality ) [9, 27, 31, 33–44]. Catholic ideology considered female nudity shameful such that breastfeeding should only take place in private and, in some communities, there was resurgence of a custom of binding young women’s breasts combined with dresses with tight bodices that could cause problems with lactation [39, 41, 42].
Occupations where mothers worked outside of the home were obviously the least conducive to breastfeeding, and this was most common in urban factory workers [9, 12, 32]. However, during harvest season, crop farmers wives often needed to work in fields far away from home, thus also limiting breastfeeding for at least part of the year [16, 45, 46]. Some studies found breastfeeding was common amongst poor or landless urban families because they could not afford or access other types of food like animal milk [47, 48]. Farmers and farm-workers often had amongst the lowest IMRs of different occupation groups [43, 49, 50] which has been used to infer a moderate to long breastfeeding period . Farmers owned or leased the land upon which they lived and worked and are of higher socioeconomic status than landless farm-workers which includes permanent year-round employees and temporary short-term workers, the former having more stable positions with slightly higher wages with benefits. Yet, IMRs are influenced by a host of factors including maternal nutrition, maternal support (unmarried mothers had the highest IMRs of any group), family size and wealth, weaning food quality and age-of-introduction, and infectious diseases (related to water quality, sanitation, and the density of people in a living area), so are not necessarily a reliable method of inferring the length of breastfeeding [9, 25, 32, 44]. Infants of upper class mothers may have been fed by a wet-nurse, but the practice was never as popular in the Netherlands as in other western European nations [51, 52].
The role of dietary differences in Dutch infant feeding practices has not been explored. Common weaning foods included animal, mostly cow’s but also goat’s milk, often diluted with water, and pap, also called porridge, gruel, and panada, which was a liquid to semisolid food made from flour, bread or cereals and cooked in water, milk or broth; sugar was purportedly often added to these foods [13, 53] (pap, panada and gruel/porridge are actually different dishes, varying in consistency and the use of grains vs. flour/bread and broth vs. water/milk  but many authors use the terms synonymously). For the rest of the population the national staples were rye, wheat or barley bread, potatoes, oats, and vegetables like cabbage, carrots, peas, broad beans, endive, cucumber, and onion; diets usually contained little meat [20, 54]. Chicken eggs were a common source of animal protein . Yet, there were regional dietary differences with the province of North Holland being a part of ‘Western Dutch cuisine’, characterized by its high production and consumption of bovine dairy products, especially cheese, butter, and buttermilk [54, 56]. The commonality of dairy foods may have implications for infant feeding practices. Coastal provinces like North Holland also had access to more seafood .
The objective of this study is to understand the breastfeeding and weaning practices of 19th century rural villagers from Beemster, North Holland (Fig 1). Stable isotope analyses of bone collagen are used to elucidate the presence and approximate duration of breastfeeding and the common types of weaning foods. Stable nitrogen (ẟ15N) and carbon (ẟ13C) isotope ratios undergo, respectively, roughly three and one permil trophic level increases in a breastfeeding infant relative to its mother (or wet-nurse); a change that is absent in non-breastfed infants [57–62]. Many researchers have used this phenomenon to reconstruct the infant feeding patterns of past populations [63, 64]. Archival information permitting identification of a subset of Beemster individuals is used to explore if there were differences in infant feeding according to sex and time-period from 1830 to 1867. Infant feeding patterns are then discussed to elucidate the key factors that affected breastfeeding and weaning behaviors in Beemster.
This research concerns 19th century inhabitants of the rural Beemster polder (land reclaimed ‘from the sea’) (Fig 1). The post-Medieval economy of North Holland was based on international trade, financial services, and in the rural regions like Beemster, cattle breeding and dairy farming . Dairy farms had on average 20 cows and focussed on quality goods for export, such as butter and cheese . The sale and price of these exports, as well as cattle, increased substantially in the 1800s, making dairy farming a generally reliable and profitable occupation [66, 67]. Farms were run by families as knowledge about the animals, pastures, and market products was passed down through the generations and there was room for several children to hold important roles in the business . Wives were in charge of dairy production and, with children of suitable age, would milk cows, churn butter, and make buttermilk and cheese . Traditional forms of labor and methods of food preparation would have been followed as the site preceded industrialization of the farming industry in the Netherlands .
Middenbeemster is the principle village of the Beemster. It contains the Dutch Reformed Protestant Keyser Church, completed in 1623. The village of Westbeemster was a small Catholic enclave within the polder. It lacked its own Church and graveyard until 1848; before that both Catholics and Protestants were buried at the Protestant Church. At the request of the community, in 2011 approximately 500 individuals were excavated from the Protestant Church cemetery by Hollandia Archeologen and Leiden University, Faculty of Archaeology. Civil and church registers show most individuals were buried between 1830 to 1867 (when cemetery use ceased). The practice of wealthier individuals paying to be buried inside a Church was prohibited in 1829, so the analyzed sample contains all socioeconomic groups [69, 71]. For the archival identification of individuals, parish registration records are linked to the municipal registration of death (Begraafregister) and civil registration records of vital events.
Stable isotope analysis is performed on 277 individuals, of which 185 (67%) are identified by name, age-at-death, and year-of-death. Table 1 shows this information per age category. Standard osteological methods were used to estimate the age-at-death and sex (male = M; female = F) of individuals who could not be archivally identified [detailed in 72]. Sex was only estimated for adults (≥18 years) and adults of indeterminate sex are not included in this research.
Ethical approval was granted by the Social Sciences and Humanities Ethics Committee of Leiden University. No permits were required for the described study, which complied with all relevant regulations. A full list of specimen numbers are provided in S2 Table. Skeletons are stored at the Laboratory for Human Osteoarchaeology, Faculty of Archaeology, Leiden University, The Netherlands.
Human ẟ15N and ẟ13C values reflect the isotopic composition of their diet and can be used to estimate the proportion of terrestrial vs. marine foods, plants that use different photosynthetic pathways (C3 vs. C4), and the trophic level of consumed protein [62, 73, 74]. ẟ15N values can also be affected by malnutrition or illness that causes tissue catabolism and it is critical to consider this, rather than breastfeeding, as a cause of higher ẟ15N values in infants and children (and to distinguish the two causes of 15N enrichment if possible) [75–79]. The plants in the Dutch diet follow a C3 photosynthetic pathway, associated with lower ẟ13C values, with one possible exception: the C4 plant sugarcane (as opposed to sugar beet which is a C3 plant) [20, 80].
Dietary interpretations should be done using the isotopic values of the animals and plants that were likely consumed by humans. Faunal and floral remains were not found at the Middenbeemster cemetery but published isotope data for terrestrial and marine animals from five Dutch Medieval sites are used to aid in the interpretation of human results [81–84] (S1 Table). Bone collagen ẟ15N values only reflect the protein component of the diet; δ13C values are also largely reflective of protein (~three-quarters) with smaller contributions from carbohydrates and lipids (~one-quarter) [85, 86].
Intra(within)-individual sampling, from different mineralized tissues or between different parts of the same anatomical element, is useful for reconstructing an individual’s diachronic dietary history. This study compares ẟ15N and ẟ13C values from the metaphyseal area of a growing long bone with those from the diaphysis of the same bone in all individuals ≤6-years-of-age (n = 87). The long bones studied herein begin formation in the seventh to eighth week of fetal life, with the bone shaft, the diaphysis, mineralizing first . Growth in length (longitudinal growth) then occurs at the ends of the long bone, under the growth plate located between the end of the bone shaft, the metaphysis, and the unfused secondary growth centre, the epiphysis. Thus, the metaphyses contain tissue formed most recently before death, while the diaphysis contains tissue formed at an earlier age [88, 89]. Rates of bone growth and remodelling will determine how much bone tissue in a particular area was formed during any particular time-period before death . All metaphyseal samples were taken from the end of the bone that undergoes the most growth (proximal humerus, distal radius and ulna, distal femur, and proximal tibia [91, 92]) while diaphyseal samples were collected from the area of the primary nutrient foramen (S2 Table).
Bone samples for juveniles (7–12 years), adolescents (13–17 years) and adults (18+ years) were taken from a rib body when available; if not available, a long bone fragment containing some trabecular bone or a small phalanx were used (S2 Table). These bone areas should reflect an individual’s diet over the last 5 to 10 or more years of life with trabecular bone typically containing more younger tissue than cortical bone [90, 93, 94]. A total of 715 samples were analyzed. Statistical analyses are performed in SPSS v25.
Samples were manually cleaned and then washed ultrasonically in distilled H2O. Collagen was extracted following the ‘Sealy method’  by immersion in dilute HCl (0.5%), which was changed every 24–48 hours until demineralization was complete. A 0.125% solution of NaOH was applied for 20 hours to remove humic contaminants. Finally, the sample was rinsed and soaked in distilled H2O until reaching a neutral pH and then freeze-dried.
Collagen samples were combusted using a Thermo-Scientific Flash 2000 organic elemental analyser with the resultant gases introduced into the Delta V plus isotope ratio mass spectrometer via a continuous flow (Conflo) inlet located in the Stable Isotope laboratory, Vrije Universiteit, Amsterdam. Isotopic values are reported as ẟ values in permil (‰). ẟ13C values are reported relative to the Vienna PeeDee Belemnite (VPDB) marine limestone standard, and ẟ15N values are reported relative to the international nitrogen standard, air. Internal reference standards (USGS40, USG41, USG42, glycine) and ~5% of samples analyzed in duplicate or triplicate were used to determine that the precision of the mass spectrometer was 0.2‰ for ẟ13C and ẟ15N. All samples had acceptable collagen yields that varied from 1.7 to 27.0%, atomic C/N ratios between 3.0 to 3.5, and %N and %C by weight values between 12.3–18.2 and 35.6–52.2, respectively (S2 Table), suggesting the lack of post-mortem alteration [96–98].
Two methods are used interpret the patterning of isotope values of the ≤6-year-olds to suggest their feeding status at death, where the pattern is either consistent with breastmilk consumption with or without evidence of weaning (i.e. classified as weaning or breastfeeding, respectively) or the lack of detectable breastmilk consumption (i.e. classified as no breastfeeding). Fig 2 shows how the metaphyseal-diaphyseal ẟ15N values for ≤6-year-olds are interpreted using interpretive method 1. To establish that an infant’s ẟ15N values are possibly reflective of breastfeeding, one must take into account the ẟ15N data of both the fetuses/neonates (n = 52; = 14.1‰; SD = 0.7‰) and adult Fs of reproductive age (includes young adults (YA) and middle adults (MA); n = 47; = 13.7‰; SD = 0.7‰). To do so, we use the standard deviations (SD) of these groups as a conservative marker of meaningful dietary difference. As the fetal/neonate mean is higher, its mean (14.1‰) plus one SD (0.7‰), equalling 14.8‰, establishes that ẟ15N values ≥14.9‰ are possibly suggestive of the nursing trophic effect. Using the same SD of 0.7‰, one can infer if the individual’s predominate protein source had changed from breastmilk to weaning foods (with lower ẟ15N values). If the newer bone in the metaphysis has a ẟ15N value that is at least 0.7‰ higher than the older bone in the diaphysis (with the lower diaphyseal value reflecting bone formed in utero), this suggests breastmilk may have been the predominate protein source and the individual is classified as ‘breastfeeding’. In contrast, if the metaphyseal ẟ15N value is lower by 0.7‰ or more than the diaphyseal value, this is suggestive of weaning (with the higher diaphyseal value having accrued during breastfeeding). If the metaphyseal and diaphyseal ẟ15N values do not differ by 0.7‰ but are both ≥14.9‰, this suggests the entire bone is reflecting breastfeeding or another cause of high ẟ15N. Finally, if only one of the sampling locations has a ẟ15N value ≥14.9‰, but the two values do not differ by 0.7‰, it is not possible to suggest feeding status, resulting in a classification of indeterminate.
It is important to keep in mind that the use of the fetal/neonate ẟ15N mean and SD could be imperfect because these individuals are non-survivors and some of their isotope values may reflect poor maternal-infant health and physiological stress experienced in utero. Acute causes of death, such as birth obstruction/complications, which were fairly common in 19th century Netherlands , would not lead to altered bone collagen ẟ15N values but it is not possible to distinguish acute from chronic conditions and the two may have co-occurred. However, we retain use of the threshold of ‘fetal/neonate ẟ15N mean + 1 SD’ to identify breastmilk consumption because it is a better gauge of early life diet than the adult F mean and it avoids overinterpreting small isotopic differences. We acknowledge that breastfeeding (and hence weaning) may be underrepresented in our interpretations if there were breastfeeding individuals whose ẟ15N values did not exceed this conservative threshold.
Using the ẟ15N mean of the adult Fs or fetuses/neonates can be problematic because infants who were born from or breastfed by mothers with low ẟ15N values would in turn have low δ15N values compared to other infants and thus be categorized as ‘no breastfeeding’. To avoid this potential source of inaccuracy, interpretive method 2 instead considers the pattern of covariation of ẟ15N and ẟ13C values which has been shown to be a reliable indicator of breastfeeding and weaning when working with incremental dentine collagen samples [100, 101]. Method 2 thus examines the correspondence, extent, and ratio of isotopic change. As shown in Fig 3, first, it is noted if an individual’s diaphyseal to metaphyseal ẟ15N and ẟ13C values both increase (consistent with breastfeeding) or decrease (consistent with weaning). If not, the pattern is likely inconsistent with breastmilk consumption (whether exclusive or during weaning) and the classification is ‘no breastfeeding’. If yes, the pattern may be consistent with breastmilk consumption. To avoid overinterpreting minor isotopic variation arising from non-dietary factors (e.g., measurement imprecision, sample heterogeneity) the extent of the ẟ15N change must exceed the standard deviation of the maximum diaphyseal-metaphyseal difference of the fetal/neonate group, which is 0.4‰. Finally, if this criterion is met, the ratio of ẟ15N to ẟ13C change needs to be similar to the respective standard trophic shift of +3‰ to +1‰, thus 3:1 (or 3.0). As a certain amount of variation in this ratio is expected, especially during weaning when non-maternal foods will interfere with a pure breastfeeding signal, a ratio between 7:5 to 6:1 (or 1.4 to 6.0) is considered as possibly arising from breastfeeding or weaning while values outside this range are more likely due to other dietary changes or non-dietary factors.
Note, S3 Table contains the results of statistical comparisons not mentioned here. Table 2 shows the mean ẟ15N and ẟ13C results for each age group and for the different sampling locations of the ≤6 year-olds. Adult M and F ẟ15N and ẟ13C values do not differ significantly (ẟ15N t = 0.352, p = 0.725; ẟ13C t = 0.516, p = 0.607). Fig 4 depicts these results (with certain age groups combined) with the published ẟ15N and ẟ13C values of archaeological fauna from five Dutch Medieval sites dating from CE 400–1573 (S1 Table).
Symbols in solid square = site of Sint-Oedenrode ; dashed square = site of Oosterbeintum ; solid circle = site of Canadaplein, Alkmaar ; dashed circle = site of Doelenstraat, Alkmaar ; no border = site of Oldenzaal .
Table 3 displays the results of the application of interpretive methods 1 and 2 for isotopic categorization of feeding status at death as shown in Figs 2 and 3. Both methods classify the majority of nonadults as ‘no breastfeeding’, and hence no weaning, however, otherwise the methods yield somewhat different results (denoted by italicized text in the last columns of table 3). We cannot determine which method is more accurate until ongoing incremental dentine isotope research is completed, however, we can use the fetal/neonate group as a gauge of a methods appropriateness given that all such individuals were not breastfed (or if a neonate, they were breastfed for such a short time it is unlikely to be evident in their isotopic values). Method 1 results in slightly fewer fetal/neonate individuals (n = 3) being interpreted as breastfeeding or weaning compared to method 2 (n = 4). As well, method 1 classifies three 1-11-month-olds as breastfeeding (and 2 as weaning) while method 2 does not classify any of these infants as breastfeeding (it does have 2 individuals as weaning although only one of these is the same as in method 1). This suggests method 1 may be more appropriate for detecting breastfeeding and weaning in this sample. The use of isotopic covariation may not be well suited to our data as we have only two data points (the metaphysis and diaphysis) for each individual.
In interpretive method 1, the 1-11-month-olds (young infants) have five out of 20 individuals (25%) with evidence of being breastfed (3 categorized as breastfeeding and 2 as weaning). The individuals classified as ‘weaning’ are very young, both around 1-month of age. The individuals categorized as ‘breastfeeding’ are 1.0±1.0 month, 11 weeks, and 6.0±3.0 months of age. The other 15 individuals (75%) lack isotopic evidence suggestive of breastfeeding or weaning, being thus classified as ‘no breastfeeding’. In interpretive method 2, none of the 1-11-month-olds are classified as breastfeeding, two (10%) are classified as weaning, and the remaining 18 (90%) are thus denoted as ‘no breastfeeding’.
In interpretive method 1, none of the 1-year-olds (older infants) have isotopic evidence for having been breastfed, although the sample size is small (n = 4). In interpretive method 2, one (25%) of the 1-year-olds is classified as weaning while the other three (75%) are classified as ‘no breastfeeding’. In method 1, the 2-year-olds (toddlers) have seven of nine individuals (77.8%) who lack isotopic evidence of having been breastfed, with one individual (11.1%) categorized as ‘weaning’ and another as ‘indeterminate’ (11.1%). In method 2, all nine 2-year-olds are classified as ‘no breastfeeding’. Finally, in the 3-6-year-olds (children), method 1 results in 18 out of 22 individuals (81.8%) being categorized as ‘no breastfeeding’, while three (13.6%) are categorized as ‘weaning’ and one (4.5%) is ‘indeterminate’. In method 2, two individuals (9.1%) are classified as weaning and the remaining 20 (90.9%) are classified as ‘no breastfeeding’. In all individuals, elevated ẟ15N values consistent with breastfeeding or weaning could instead be due to other causes of 15N enrichment (i.e. protein catabolism from malnutrition or wasting disease; high trophic-level foods). Given the short to absent period of breastfeeding in the infants, alternative causes of 15N enrichment are quite likely in the toddlers and children.
Fig 5 plots the ẟ15N values of all nonadults (using diaphyseal values) and adults. Fig 6 plots the diaphyseal and metaphyseal ẟ15N values of the ≤6-year-olds so the isotopic variation can be seen more clearly. The fetuses/neonates have a spread of ẟ15N values of 3.8‰ which closely corresponds to the spread of reproductively-aged Fs at 3.6‰. The young infants (1–11 months) have the largest spread of ẟ15N values, at 4.7‰, suggesting considerable variation in diet and physiology, some of which may be due to breastfeeding (even if of short duration). Yet, the breastfeeding signal is minor, nowhere near the 2 to 3‰ we might expect, as the young infant mean (14.3‰) is only 0.2‰ higher and not statistically different than the fetal/neonate mean (14.3‰; t = 0.732, p = 0.468) and only 0.6‰ higher than the mean of the Fs of reproductive age (13.7‰); this latter difference is statistically significant (t = 3.227, p = 0.002; the fetal-neonate and reproductively-aged F means also differ significantly, t = 2.711; p = 0.008). By 1 year-of-age ẟ15N values means have dropped such that sample-wide interpretations suggest the absence of breastfeeding although individually-based interpretations show a few individuals with isotopic patterning that could be consistent with continued breastmilk consumption (but other factors could be the cause). The older infants and toddlers have rather small ẟ15N spreads (1.3 and 2.4‰, respectively) which is likely in part related to the smaller sample sizes of these groups. The larger sample of children has a correspondingly larger spread of ẟ15N values at 4.0‰, and with a ẟ15N mean of 13.7‰, suggests that even in the absence of breastfeeding, dietary and physiological variation can cause considerable isotopic variation. Finally, the juveniles (7–12 years) and adolescents (13–17 years) have rather low ẟ15N means, at respectively, 13.4‰, and then the lowest of all, 12.9‰, with moderate ẟ15N spreads of 2.4‰ and 3.0‰.
The blue line is the best-fit smoothed (local) regression line (using loess algorithm) and the grey bands are the 95-percent confidence interval.
A) Diaphyseal values, B) metaphyseal values. The blue line is the best-fit smoothed (local) regression line (using loess algorithm) and the grey bands are the 95-percent confidence interval.
No significant ẟ15N differences are found between archivally identified nonadult M and F age groups, but sample sizes are often small (S3 Table). To generate larger sample sizes, all 1-month to 6-year-olds with an archival sex identification are compared (M = 18; F = 14): no statistical differences are present (metaphysis: t = 1.516, p = 0.140; diaphysis: t = 1.615, p = 0.117) nor are differences precent when comparing all post-neonate nonadults (using the diaphyseal values of the young infants to children) (M = 23, = 13.6‰, SD = 0.94‰; F = 25, = 13.9‰, SD = 0.94‰; t = 1.054, p = 0.297).
Fig 7 plots the ẟ13C values of all nonadults (using diaphyseal values) and adults while Fig 8 plots the diaphyseal and metaphyseal ẟ13C values of the ≤6-year-olds. Like the ẟ15N data, the young infants (1–11 months) have the largest spread of ẟ13C values at 5.5‰ and the highest ẟ13C mean of -19.8‰. This compares to a fetal-neonate ẟ13C spread of 3.4‰ and significantly different mean of -20.4‰ (U = 182.000, p = 0.012) and a reproductively-aged F ẟ13C spread of only 1.1‰ and significantly different mean of -20.7‰ (U = 208.000; p = 0.000; the fetal-neonate group also differs significantly from the reproductively aged F group, U = 381.500, p = 0.003). The older infants (1 year) have the next highest ẟ13C mean at -20.2‰ with a spread of 3.4‰. The remaining nonadult and adult age groups have similar ẟ13C means, of -20.6 to -20.8‰ and maximum to minimum spreads of 3.9‰ (child) to 0.7‰ (MA F). Thus, the ẟ13C data support the suggestion that a short period of breastfeeding in some young infants may be contributing to their high isotopic variation, but fairly high levels of ẟ13C variation are present in other age groups and, as will be discussed, special weaning foods may be contributing to the young infant results.
The blue line is the best-fit smoothed (local) regression line (using loess algorithm) and the grey bands are the 95-percent confidence interval.
A) Diaphyseal values, B) metaphyseal values. The blue line is the best-fit smoothed (local) regression line (using loess algorithm) and the grey bands are the 95-percent confidence interval.
No significant ẟ13C differences are found between archivally identified nonadult M and F age groups (S3 Table). The statistical comparison of combined groups with larger sample sizes yielded no significant differences (all 1-month to 6-year-olds: metaphysis: t = -0.016, p = 0.987, diaphysis: t = -0.228, p = 0.821; all post-neonate nonadults (using the diaphyseal values of the young infants to children): t = -0.729, p = 0.470).
The final set of statistical assessments involve investigation of temporal trends for those individuals with archival data specifying year of death. There are no significant correlations between year of death and ẟ15N or ẟ13C for any age or age-sex group (S3 Table).
The isotope data are consistent with historical information about the average western Dutch diet, supporting that the staples consisted of C3 grains and vegetables and, less commonly, animal protein from domesticated fowl/eggs and terrestrial herbivores. Some of the domesticated herbivore isotope values are higher than might be expected (between 8–10‰), which is likely due to a ‘manuring effect’ . We know dairy products were a staple, but these have isotopic values in the range of the cattle, so it is not possible to distinguish how much protein was derived from dairy vs. meat/eggs. Marine foods seem to have been rarely consumed in 19th century Beemster, in keeping with suggestions from a modern-day Beemster historian (Visser, personal communication).
Overall the diet appears to have been fairly homogeneous, shown by temporal continuity in adult and nonadult isotope values, the high similarity of M and F isotope data (i.e., in all the adults and nonadults with archival identification), and the moderate similarity between nonadult and adult diet. The isotopic differences among the means of the different age groups are fairly small (maximum 1.4‰ for ẟ15N and 1.0‰ for ẟ13C) even including the young infant age group which often has the greatest isotopic dissimilarity because of breastfeeding. For the mean ẟ15N results, it is the adolescents that vary the most, with a low value of 12.9‰. The juveniles also have a slightly low δ15N mean at 13.4%. Several studies have found similarly low ẟ15N values in juveniles/adolescents [see 3], suggesting a common physiological event such as growth may the cause. However, research thus far has found limited support for this explanation so it may be that this age group often consumed foods from lower trophic levels [3, 103, 104]. Amongst the overall population-wide isotopic homogeneity, there is variation amongst the nonadults that is now discussed as it relates to infant feeding practices.
Infant feeding practices
Interpreting the nonadult isotope data is challenging because infant bone collagen values reflect multiple sometimes co-occurring variables, specifically fetal metabolism, maternal diet, breastfeeding, complimentary feeding, and infant and mother physiology and health, that are difficult (even impossible) to completely disentangle . This is clear in Figs 5–8 which show that the young infants have the most isotopic heterogeneity. Viewed cross-sectionally, the slightly higher δ15N and δ13C means of the young infants probably suggest some individuals were breastfed, for at least a short period. Even with metaphyseal samples meant to capture a shorter period of time than other bones, the time-averaging may be too great to clearly pick up a short breastfeeding period, especially if the δ15N tropic shift is less pronounced because complimentary feeding began at a very young age meaning breastfeeding episodes were less frequent and non-maternal foods made up a significant portion of the diet. This is a large part of why this intra-long bone approach seemingly worked better in a population with a long breastfeeding-weaning period of 3–4 years [89, 105, 106]. δ15N values reflect dietary protein, and, if soon after birth, the predominate protein source was cow’s milk we would not see markedly higher infant values. Breastfeeding could conceivably have continued for longer than suggested by the bone collagen data especially if feeding episodes were infrequent and/or of short duration.
Yet, whether looking cross-sectionally or at the individual data (i.e. categorization of feeding status at death), and whether using interpretive method 1 or 2, the isotopic data suggest that most infants were either not breastfed or only breastfed for a short period (weeks to a few months). Depending on the interpretive method, only two to five out of twenty young infants (10–25%) have isotopic evidence of having been breastfed while the remainder lack such patterning. There are no clear age differences between young infants with and without isotopic evidence of breastfeeding, as both contain 1 to 6-month-olds. While there are a few individuals in the toddler and child categories with δ15N values that could be due to breastfeeding, given the short or possibly absent period of breastfeeding in the infants, it is more likely these individuals have elevated δ15N values because of consumption of high trophic foods, malnutrition or a wasting disease.
Three (12%) or four (16%) Beemster fetuses/neonates, depending on which interpretive method is used, have δ15N values that would be interpreted as suggesting breastfeeding or weaning if they were in the infant category. If these individuals are indeed fetuses/neonates (none have archival identification but age-estimation was based on dental formation standards [107, 108] which is the most accurate method available so the majority are probably not infants), they were obviously not breastfed and their elevated ẟ15N values are likely due to (a) maternal or infant physiological stress during the gestational period, (b) fetal amino acid metabolism or placental isotope fractionation, or (c) maternal dietary change (consumption of more 15N-enriched foods). It is unlikely Beemster women consumed a special pregnancy diet, given the similarity of adult isotope values across the sexes and age-groups (granted these values derive from bone collagen which reflects a long time-averaged signal that would miss short-term dietary changes) and a lack of historical documents that mention any such practice. A common 17th and 18th century household Dutch medical manual warned expectant mothers about the ills of eating hot, cold, and spicy foods and to ensure proper nutrition, but specific foods are not detailed . Given the post-Medieval Dutch dietary staples, common cooking techniques (e.g., large pots of once heated ‘stews’ eaten throughout the day), and the obvious absence of refrigeration and temperate climate, this would seemingly apply to few foods. Nineteenth century texts only mention the importance of good nutrition during pregnancy without further detail [28, 30, 110]. Thus, while we cannot rule out maternal dietary changes as the cause of high fetal ẟ15N values the more likely explanation lies in physiological processes.
Other bioarchaeology studies have found high fetal/perinate ẟ15N values (relative to adult females) [100, 111] and research on modern mother-infant dyads suggests a non-dietary cause related to fetal amino acid metabolism, placental fractionation, and/or maternal nutritional stress [58, 112–114] [also see 115]. The latter seems slight or uncommon in this sample because nutritional stress causes maternal fat stores, depleted in 13C relative to proteins and carbohydrates, to be used by the fetus causing lower fetal ẟ13C values [76, 116] which is absent here (the fetal ẟ13C mean is 0.3‰ higher than the reproductively-aged Fs which is similar to the 0.4‰ difference in modern paired fetal-maternal samples observed by ). Thus, the explanation for elevated fetal/neonate δ15N values is most consistent with fetal physiological processes.
The ẟ13C data shed light on the nature of the weaning foods. Interestingly, the ẟ13C by age results (Fig 8) are a better example of the ‘curve’ we expect to see with breastfeeding than the ẟ15N by age results (Fig 6), due to young infants having values that are 0.6‰ and 0.9‰, respectively, above the fetal/neonate and reproductively-aged F means. Indeed, our ẟ13C results are consistent with the roughly 1‰ ẟ13C breastfeeding trophic shift and may suggest breastfeeding was more common/prolonged than suggested by the ẟ15N data. A similar pattern was observed by Craig-Atkins et al. , who argued that the absence of a rise in infant δ15N values accompanied by a peak in δ13C values suggested limited breastfeeding alongside supplementary foods with less negative δ13C values than maternal diet, and Beaumont et al. , who suggested ẟ13C values were less affected by physiological changes than ẟ15N values so provided a more robust measure of breastfeeding and weaning. We also suggest that the enriched ẟ13C values are most likely due to the isotopic composition of weaning foods, which the ẟ15N results and historical information suggest were offered at a very young age. Several historical texts mention that sugar was added to paps and animal milks and some of this would have come from the C4 sugarcane plant with elevated ẟ13C values [28, 29, 117, 118]. For example, “In 1876 the infant food in Friesland was, as a rule, mother’s milk…It was the habit, in addition to breast milk, to give the infant very soon [after birth] milk from animals (cows, sheep, goats), either diluted with water alone or as a buttermilk with buckwheat flour and sugar or syrup, or a porridge (of white bread, rusk, buckwheat groats with diluted milk, butter and sugar)"[16: 10, 11, translation ours]. Sugarcane had become popular in post-Medieval continental Europe. While it was unavailable in the early 1800s as a result of Napoleon’s Continental Blockade (closing European markets to British ships and goods, circa 1806–1814), which spurred the development of a new sugar beet industry, by the ~1830s the Dutch sugarcane industry had recovered such that Amsterdam became Europe’s chief ‘sugar town’ with both cane and beet varieties available [20, 22]. While much of the product was for export, Dutch consumption of sugar increased in tandem with its decreasing cost over the rest of the century [20, 119]. Many Beemster farmers could likely afford sugar, or a syrup made from it, given their advantageous economic position. Previous isotope studies have considered higher ẟ13C values in infants as a result of weaning foods containing maize and millet (or animals consuming these plants) [59, 120–122] but sugarcane has not yet been seriously considered.
Why was breastfeeding short to absent in Beemster?
In 17th century Netherlands, breastfeeding purportedly lasted for about two years  but we lack data about geographic or temporal variation in this century and the next. By the 19th century there are reports that breastfeeding lasted for a year or two, for example, an 1812 report said most Dutch mothers breastfed for one year but that in North Holland feeding young infants both breastmilk and porridge was especially common [Persman, 1812 in 16]. Other historical texts discuss the common use of pap with or instead of breastmilk in Amsterdam, with pap being given sometimes as early as a few days, and that infants of low SES workers in Utrecht were often not breastfed (in contrast to the wealthy of the city) [22, 124].
To the best of our knowledge there are no historical texts that refer to infant feeding in Beemster specifically, however, many of its characteristics suggested that breastfeeding would have been fairly common and of at least average duration. These are that it was a predominately Protestant community of moderate to high SES, its northern, rural location, and that mothers worked in/near the home. Yet, this is the opposite of what we found. This highlights the importance of studying each region and not assuming these characteristics can be used as predictors of infant feeding practices. For late 19th to early 20th century France, Rollet  found the geographical distribution of dairy farming was associated with low rates of breastfeeding so there is precedence for this pattern in one other European nation. These studies suggest dietary differences between geographic regions do affect infant feeding practices, specifically that dairying regions might be more inclined to fed infants animal milks instead of breastmilk and to offer these from a very young age. Future research should study the breastfeeding and weaning practices of other (post-)Medieval dairying communities; perhaps these will reveal populations that were regularly practicing artificial feeding even earlier than the 19th century.
Other European areas with historically reported communities that had high rates of artificial feeding in the post-Medieval period are northern and southern Germany, the Tyrol area of Austria, northern France, western Finland, northern Sweden, and Iceland [118, 125–127]. Excessive workload and cultural values and traditions were the common reasons given by mothers for not breastfeeding . Several Dutch studies have found that, indeed, regional variation actually supersedes all other variables in understanding differential IMRs, which thus implies regional variation in infant feeding practices [32, 35]. The impact of an overarching religious ideology such as Catholicism on infant practices has especially been questioned lately [33, 38, 43]. Women’s clothing that was harmful or inconvenient for breastfeeding has been mentioned as factor in Catholic communities  but the traditional dress of 19th century Protestant women from North Holland also had a very tight bodice that may have dissuaded breastfeeding.
North Holland women usually did not state an “occupation” on marriage certificates if their work was subsumed within the business of the male head of house (i.e. father, husband) and/or if they did not receive a separate wage [128, 129]. Thus, despite their extensive work on the farm, census enumerators and household members tended to underreport women’s contributions . Still, historical texts shed some light on the working conditions at North Holland dairy farms . The average workday was 12 to 16 hours with a ~2 hour midday break for the main meal; a half day was worked on Sunday . Women were in charge of milking cows and dairy production, on top of meal preparation, domestic chores and rearing children, certainly leading to long working days [69, 70, 129]. Thus, perhaps an important factor in Beemster’s short-absent breastfeeding period was the many other responsibilities of women. While the mother and infant were not separated in space like mothers working in urban factories, the multitude of time-consuming essential tasks may have limited the time available for infant feeding. Children were expected to start working in the house and farm from about 5 years-of-age  and could be tasked with feeding an infant cow’s milk, which was always available, thus freeing up the mother to care for the cattle and produce the dairy products that were a major element of the family’s livelihood.
Our study supports suggestions that too singular a focus on religion, location, or occupation, risks missing other factors important in infant feeding behaviours. On top of illustrating the need for regional characterization this work shows the benefits of combining isotopic data with historical texts. Isotopic data can reveal the limitations of historical literary sources as most are generalized, anecdotally-based, subjective estimates that do not reflect actual practice [7, 130–132]. Yet, in this study, historical sources never suggested there was a difference in how long boys vs. girls were breastfed or weaned, which concurs with our isotopic data. As well, the historical records provided invaluable information to refine our interpretations, for example, that the elevated infant ẟ13C values were most likely the result of sugar being added to cow’s milk or pap.
Limitations and future research.
Ongoing incremental dentine collagen sampling should provide the precision needed to more accurately gauge longitudinal dietary changes, infer the presence or absence of a breastfeeding period, determine the heterogeneity of infant feeding practices, and permit a more detailed assessment of temporal changes. Given the rapid innovation of artificial feeding devices, their lowering cost, and increasing availability in the 19th century, we might have expected to see a temporal change in infant feeding patterns across the nearly four decades of Beemster life. On the other hand, if older siblings were usually available to fed babies cow’s milk then these changes might have been irrelevant for Beemster mothers. Because tooth dentine does not turnover (remodel) once formed, its analysis will also yield important information about the feeding patterns of survivors vs. non-survivors to determine if our current results need revision because of a mortality bias wherein those that survived infancy and childhood were breastfed more frequently or for a longer duration. While we can conclude from these data that breastfeeding was short or even absent in most individuals, we recognize that a population-wide weaning trajectory may not have existed.
Compared to traditional protocols involving the analysis of a single sample per individual, this intra-long bone method proved useful in detecting both the presence and direction of isotopic change in the weeks to months before death. Metaphyseal samples from growing long bones will be less affected by the time-averaging caused by modeling and remodeling of bone collagen in other bones like ribs, so can record shorter-term isotopic changes. Yet, our method assumes that a long bone was somewhat continuously growing during its formation, such that a period of dietary change will be recorded in the newly formed metaphyseal collagen. However, growth is saltatory and especially if an individual experienced a period of malnutrition or disease, bone growth may have ceased such that any co-occurring dietary change would be not recorded . This is another reason for ongoing dentine isotope analyses, as dental formation is less prone to growth interruption meaning it is less likely to miss recording the isotope values of periods of physiological stress .
The limitations of using population-level aggregate means to interpret individual feeding patterns (a component of interpretive method 1) have been mentioned and the use of isotopic covariation to distinguish dietary from non-dietary isotopic change (the basis of interpretive method 2) may not work well with only two data points per individual. The suitability of using the adult F aggregate results is strengthened by the large sample size, as the reproductively-aged F δ15N mean likely included many pregnant and breastfeeding mothers. As well, the use of a fairly large sample of fetuses and neonates is a plus since they are a more appropriate baseline against which to gauge isotopic variation in the young infants. Yet, the data are still cross-sectional and future longitudinal dietary data from incremental dentine may change our interpretations. There is no doubt that bulk bone collagen isotope data provide a less accurate and detailed infant feeding reconstruction than incremental dentine data [79, 100, 133]. However, we were able to study many more individuals than would have been possible if analyzing multiple dentine samples for every individual. This approach provided a broad overview of population diet and detected a short to possibly absent breastfeeding period that can be investigated in more detail through informed selection of individuals for subsequent incremental dentine analyses. This work also initiated research on demographic variables that are affected by breastfeeding and weaning practices and using the historical archival data we have found support for a short or absent breastfeeding period in the infant mortality rate, birth intervals, and differential seasonal mortality, to be detailed in a forthcoming publication.
Stable isotope research on a large sample of 19th century rural villagers from Beemster, the Netherlands, highlighted the importance of regional cultures of infant feeding. Despite Beemster having many cultural characteristics associated with high breastfeeding rates of long duration in other parts of the country (i.e., Protestant, rural, northern, moderate-high SES, mothers worked at home) breastfeeding was likely of short duration or not practiced at all. There are many bioarchaeological studies about past populations that had moderate to long breastfeeding periods, as artificial feeding was generally not an option. But as this work shows, there are communities in our historic past that had short to even absent breastfeeding periods that are in need of study . The reasons for artificial feeding and choice of breastmilk substitutes are underexplored topics that are aided by historical texts. The great range of human cultural variation not only includes populations who breastfed for markedly different lengths of time, but also past populations that did not breastfed whose investigation will demonstrate the multitude of complex biological, environmental, socio-economic and ideological factors that influenced how a mother decided to feed her baby.
S2 Table. Sample, isotope and preservation results for Beemster individuals.
We thank Jessica Palmer for processing collagen samples and Vrije Universiteit, Amsterdam, for mass spectrometry. We thank Ina Gabel, Theo Molenaar, Jaap Oostwouder, Jose Schenk and Klaas Visser, of the Beemster Historical Society, for archival and historical research that has greatly improved our understanding of this remarkable community. We thank the reviewers for strengthening this work through thoughtful questions and suggestions.
- 1. Craig-Atkins E, Towers J, Beaumont J. The role of infant life histories in the construction of identities in death: An incremental isotope study of dietary and physiological status among children afforded differential burial. Am J Phys Anthropol. 2018;167(3):644–55. pmid:30132793
- 2. Tsutaya T, Yoneda M. Quantitative Reconstruction of Weaning Ages in Archaeological Human Populations Using Bone Collagen Nitrogen Isotope Ratios and Approximate Bayesian Computation. PLOS ONE. 2013;8(8):e72327. pmid:24015234
- 3. Waters‐Rist AL, Katzenberg MA. The effect of growth on stable nitrogen isotope ratios in subadult bone collagen. Int J Osteoarchaeol. 2010;20(2):172–91.
- 4. Britton K, McManus‐Fry E, Cameron A, Duffy P, Masson‐MacLean E, Czére O, et al. Isotopes and new norms: Investigating the emergence of early modern U.K. breastfeeding practices at St. Nicholas Kirk, Aberdeen. Int J Osteoarchaeol. 2018;28(5):510–22.
- 5. Henderson RC, Lee‐Thorp J, Loe L. Early life histories of the London poor using δ13C and δ15N stable isotope incremental dentine sampling. Am J Phys Anthropol. 2014;154(4):585–93. pmid:24898314
- 6. Fildes V. Breastfeeding and wet nursing. Midwife Health Visit Community Nurse. 1986;22(7):241–7. pmid:3537643
- 7. Fulminante F. Infant Feeding Practices in Europe and the Mediterranean from Prehistory to the Middle Ages: A Comparison between the Historical Sources and Bioarchaeology. Child Past. 2015;8(1):24–47.
- 8. Haydock H, Clarke L, Craig‐Atkins E, Howcroft R, Buckberry J. Weaning at Anglo-Saxon raunds: Implications for changing breastfeeding practice in Britain over two millennia. Am J Phys Anthropol. 2013;151(4):604–12. pmid:23868173
- 9. Vandenbroeke C, Van Poppel F, van der Woude AM. De zuigelingen- en kindersterfte in Belgie en Nederland in seculair perspectief [Infant and child mortality in Belgium and the Netherlands in a secular perspective]. Tijdschr Voor Geschied. 1981;94:461–91.
- 10. Wickes IG. A History of Infant Feeding. Arch Dis Child. 1953;28(142):495–502. pmid:13114930
- 11. Osborn ML. The rent breasts: a brief history of wet-nursing. Midwife Health Visit Community Nurse. 1979;15(8):302–6. pmid:381849
- 12. Stevens EE, Patrick TE, Pickler R. A History of Infant Feeding. J Perinat Educ. 2009;18(2):32–9. pmid:20190854
- 13. Obladen M., Pap Gruel, and Panada : Early Approaches to Artificial Infant Feeding. Neonatology. 2014;105(4):267–74. pmid:24577423
- 14. Obladen M. Technical Inventions That Enabled Artificial Infant Feeding. Neonatology. 2014;106(1):62–8. pmid:24819029
- 15. Godefroi MJ. De kindersterfte te ‘s Hertogenbosch beneden het eerste levensjaar, over de jaren 1858 tot 1867 [Child mortality in ‘s-Hertogenbosch below the first year of life, over the years 1858 to 1867]. 1868.
- 16. Hofstee EW. Geboorten, zuigelingenvoeding en zuigelingensterfte in hun regionale verscheidenheid in de 19de eeuw [Births, infant feeding and infant mortality in their regional diversity in the 19th century]. Bevolk En Gezin. 1983;7–60.
- 17. Van Poppel F. Sociale ongelijkheid voor de dood: het verband tussen sociaal-economische positie en zuigelingen-en kindersterfte in Nederland in de periode 1850–1940 [Social inequality before death: the link between social economic position and infant and child mortality in the Netherlands in the period 1850–1940]. Tijdschr Voor Soc Geschied. 1982;(27):231–81.
- 18. Van Poppel F, Beekink E. Mapping Infant Mortality in the Netherlands: Its History and Current Status. In: Hubbard WH, Pitkänen K, van Poppel F, Schlumbohm J, Sogner S, editors. Historical studies in mortality decline, II. Oslo, Norway: Novus Forlag in association with the Centre for Advanced Study, at the Norwegian Academy of Science and Letters; 2002. p. 113–34. (Hist.-Filos).
- 19. Van Poppel F, Mandemakers K. Sociaal-economische verschillen in zuigelingen- en kindersterfte in Nederland, 1812–1912 [Socio-economic differences in infant and child mortality in the Netherlands, 1812–1912]. Bevolk En Gezin. 2002;31:5–40.
- 20. Wintle M. An Economic and Social History of the Netherlands, 1800–1920: Demographic, Economic and Social Transition. Cambridge University Press; 2000. https://doi.org/10.1121/1.428461 pmid:10738830
- 21. Barentsen PA. Het oude Kempenland: eene proeve van vergelijking van organisme en samenleving [The old Kempenland: a test of comparison of organism and society]. Noordhoff; 1935.
- 22. Burema L. De voeding in Nederland van de Middeleeuwen tot de twintigste eeuw [Nutrition in the Netherlands from the Middle Ages to the Twentieth Century]. Van Gorcum; 1953.
- 23. Haakma Tresling T. Rapport over de voeding in verschillende weeshuizen in nederland [Report on nutrition in different orphanages in the Netherlands]. 1877. (Tijds. Weez.). Report No.: VII.
- 24. Hofstee EW. Regionale sterfte-verschillen [Regional Mortality Differences]. Tijdschr Soc Geneeskd. 1958;36(20):499–511.
- 25. Israëls AH. De sterfte der kinderen in de drie eerste jaren des levens te Amsterdam, in de jaren 1850–1859 [The mortality of children in the first three years of life in Amsterdam, in the years 1850–1859]. Ned Tijdschrit Voor Geneeskd. 1862;6:289–99.
- 26. Rombouts KH. Beschouwingen over het geboorte en kindersterftecijfer van Nederland gedurende het tijdvak van 1875–1899 [Statements about the birth and infant mortality rates in the Netherlands during the period of 1875–1899]. Ned Tijdschr Geneeskd. 1902;46:1347–50.
- 27. van der Heijden PEG. De zorg voor moeder en kind in Noord-Brabant [Care for mother and child in North Brabant] [PhD Dissertation]. University of Amsterdam; 1934.
- 28. Allebé GAN. De Ontwikkeling van het kind naar ligchaam geest: eene handleiding voor moeders bij de eerste opvoeding [The Development of the Child by Body Mind: A Mother’s Manual for Initial Education]. Amsterdam: Carelsen; 1845.
- 29. Allebé GAN. Het kind in zijne eerste levensjaren: wenken voor ouders [The Child in the First Years of Life: Tips for Parents]. D. du Mortier & Zoon; 1853.
- 30. Bruin J de, Lange C de. De voeding van het kind in het eerste levensjaar [The nutrition of the child in the first year of life]. Scheltema & Holkema; 1904.
- 31. Schrover M. The demographic consequences of changing employment opportunities: Women in the Dutch Meierij in the nineteenth century. Hist Fam. 1997;2(4):451–80. pmid:12293227
- 32. Van Poppel F, Jonker M, Mandemakers K. Differential infant and child mortality in three Dutch regions, 1812–19091. Econ Hist Rev. 2005;58(2):272–309.
- 33. Walhout EC. Is breast best? Evaluating breastfeeding patterns and causes of infant death in a Dutch province in the period 1875–1900. Hist Fam. 2010;15(1):76–90.
- 34. Barensten PA. Het gezinsleven in het oosten van Noord-Brabant [Family life in the east of North-Brabant]. In: Werk, kerk en bed in Brabant: demografische ontwikkelingen in oostelijk Noord-Brabant 1700–1920. ‘s-Hertogenbosch: Stichting Brabantse Regionale Geschiedbeoefening: Het Noordbrabants Genootschap; 1989.
- 35. Boomen N van den, Ekamper P. Denied their ‘natural nourishment’: religion, causes of death and infant mortality in the Netherlands, 1875–1899. Hist Fam. 2015;20(3):391–419.
- 36. Ekamper P, van Poppel FWA. Infant mortality in mid-19th century Amsterdam: Religion, social class, and space. Popul Space Place. 2019;25(4):e2232.
- 37. Janssens A, Messelink M, Need A. Faulty genes or faulty parents? Gender, family and survival in early and late childhood in the Netherlands, 1860–1900. Hist Fam. 2010;15(1):91–108.
- 38. Janssens A, Pelzer B. Lovely Little Angels in Heaven? The Influence of Religiously Determined Cultural Life Scripts on Infant Survival in the Netherlands, 1880–1920. Hist Soc Res. 2014;39(1):19–47.
- 39. Meurkens PCG. Sociale verandering in het oude Kempenland (1840–1910) [Social change in the old Kempenland (1840–1910): Demography, economy and culture of a pre-industrial society]. Mijmegen: Katholieke Universiteit Nijmegen; 1984.
- 40. Thorvaldsen G. Was there a European breastfeeding pattern? Hist Fam. 2008;13(3):283–95.
- 41. Van Poppel F. Religion and Health: Catholicism and Regional Mortality Differences in Nineteenth-Century Netherlands. Soc Hist Med. 1992;5(2):229–53. pmid:11623087
- 42. Van Poppel F, Schellekens J, Liefbroer AC. Religious differentials in infant and child mortality in Holland, 1855–1912. Popul Stud. 2002;56(3):277–89.
- 43. Walhout EC. An infants’ graveyard? Region, religion, and infant mortality in North Brabant, 1840–1940 [PhD thesis]. [Brabant]: Tilburg University; 2019.
- 44. Wolleswinkel-van den Bosch JH, van Poppel FW, Looman CW, Mackenbach JP. Determinants of infant and early childhood mortality levels and their decline in The Netherlands in the late nineteenth century. Int J Epidemiol. 2000;29(6):1031–40. pmid:11101544
- 45. Golde G. Catholics and Protestants: agricultural modernization in two German villages. Academy Press; 1975. (Studies in Anthropology).
- 46. Treffers PE. Zuigelingensterfte en geboorten in de 19e en begin 20e eeuw [Infant mortality and births in the 19th and early 20th centuries]. Ned Tijdschr Geneeskd. 2008;152(51–52):2788–94. pmid:19177920
- 47. Moring B. Motherhood, Milk, and Money. Infant Mortality in Pre-Industrial Finland. Soc Hist Med. 1998;11(2):177–96. pmid:11620426
- 48. Pitkanen K. Infant mortality decline in a changing society. Finn Yearb Popul Res. 1983;21:46–74.
- 49. van Dijk IK. Death and the Family [PhD thesis]. [Nijmegen]: Radboud Universiteit; 2019.
- 50. Van Poppel F, Ekamper P, Mandemakers K. Season of birth and early childhood mortality: a review of the debate and a case study for the Netherlands, 1812–1912. In: Building Bridges Scholars, History and Historical Demography A Festschrift in Honor of Professor Theo Engelen. Nijmegen: Valkhof Pers.; 2018. p. 590–625.
- 51. Roberts B. Through the Keyhole: Dutch Child-Rearing Practices in the 17th and 18th Century: Three Urban Elite Families. Uitgeverij Verloren; 1998.
- 52. van Eekelen A. Naar een rationele zuigelingenvoeding: voedingsleer en kindergeneeskunde in Nederland (1840–1914) [Towards rational infant formula: nutrition and pediatrics in the Netherlands (1840–1914)]. Radboud Universiteit; 1984.
- 53. Verdoorn JA. Het gezondheidswezen te Amsterdam in de 19e eeuw [The health care system in Amsterdam in the 19th century]. Nijmegen: SUN; 1981. pmid:6268557
- 54. Gilissen LJWJ. Food, nutrition and health in the Netherlands. In: Braun S, Zübert C, Argyropoulos D, Casado Hebrard FJ, editors. Nutritional and Health Aspects of Food in Western Europe. Academic Press; 2020. p. 85–108. (Nutritional & Health Aspect—Traditional & Ethnic Food).
- 55. Braudel F. Civilization & Capitalism, 15-18th Centuries, Vol 1: The Structures of Everyday Life. London: William Collins & Sons; 1981.
- 56. Knibbe MT. De hoofdelijke beschikbaarheid van voedsel en de levensstandaard in Nederland, 1807–1913 [The availability of food and the standard of living in the Netherlands, 1807–1913]. Tijdschr Voor Soc En Econ Geschied. 2007;4(4):71.
- 57. Fogel M, Tuross N, Owsley D. Nitrogen Isotope Tracers of Human Lactation in Modern and Archaeological Populations. Carnegie Inst Wash Yearb. 1989;88.
- 58. Fuller BT, Fuller JL, Harris DA, Hedges REM. Detection of breastfeeding and weaning in modern human infants with carbon and nitrogen stable isotope ratios. Am J Phys Anthropol. 2006;129(2):279–93. pmid:16261548
- 59. Katzenberg MA. Age Differences and Population Variation in Stable Isotope Values from Ontario, Canada. In: Lambert JB, Grupe G, editors. Prehistoric Human Bone. Springer Berlin Heidelberg; 1993. p. 39–62. https://doi.org/10.1002/ajpa.1330900302 pmid:8460651
- 60. Millard AR. A model for the effect of weaning on nitrogen isotope ratios in humans. In: Goodfriend GA, Collins M, Fogel M, Macko S, Wehmiller JF, editors. Perspectives in amino acid and protein geochemistry. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 2000. p. 51–9.
- 61. Minagawa M, Wada E. Stepwise enrichment of 15N along food chains: Further evidence and the relation between δ15N and animal age. Geochim Cosmochim Acta. 1984;48(5):1135–40.
- 62. Schoeninger MJ, DeNiro MJ. Nitrogen and carbon isotopic composition of bone collagen from marine and terrestrial animals. Geochim Cosmochim Acta. 1984;48(4):625–39.
- 63. Humphrey LT. Isotopic and trace element evidence of dietary transitions in early life. Ann Hum Biol. 2014;41(4):348–57. pmid:24932748
- 64. Tsutaya T, Yoneda M. Reconstruction of breastfeeding and weaning practices using stable isotope and trace element analyses: A review. Am J Phys Anthropol. 2015;156(S59):2–21. pmid:25407359
- 65. Van Bavel J, Kok J. Birth Spacing in the Netherlands. The Effects of Family Composition, Occupation and Religion on Birth Intervals, 1820–1885. Eur J Popul Rev Eur Démographie. 2004;20(2):119–40.
- 66. Bieleman J. Technological Innovation in Dutch Cattle Breeding and Dairy Farming, 1850–2000. Agric Hist Rev. 2005;53(2):229–50.
- 67. Mokyr J. The Industrial Revolution in the Low Countries in the First Half of the Nineteenth Century: A Comparative Case Study. J Econ Hist. 1974;34(2):365–91.
- 68. Bijman J. Exploring the sustainability of the cooperative model in dairy: The case of The Netherlands. Sustainability. 2018;10(7):2498.
- 69. Aten DK, Bossaers K, Dehé J, Kurpershoek E, Misset C, Schaap E, et al. 400 jaar Beemster 1612–2012. [400 years of the Beenster]. Wormerveer: Stichting Uitgeverij Noord-Holland; 2012.
- 70. Meerkerk E van N, Paping R. Beyond the census. Reconstructing Dutch women’s labour market participation in agriculture in the Netherlands, ca. 1830–1910. Hist Fam. 2014;19(4):447–68.
- 71. Bossaers K. Begraven in de Beemster in de 17e tot 18e eeuw [Buried in the Beemster in the 17th to 18th century]. In: De Nieuwe Schouwschuit. Middenbeemster, The Netherlands: Tijdschrift van het Historisch Genootschap Beemster; 2012. p. 22–8.
- 72. Lemmers S, Schats R, Hoogland M, Waters-Rist AL. Fysisch antropologische analyse Middenbeemster [Physical anthropology analysis of Middenbeemster]. In: De begravingen bij de Keyserkerk te Middenbeemster. Zaandijk: Hollandia Archeologen; 2013. p. 26.
- 73. DeNiro MJ, Epstein S. Influence of diet on the distribution of nitrogen isotopes in animals. Geochim Cosmochim Acta. 1981;45(3):341–51.
- 74. DeNiro MJ, Epstein S. Influence of diet on the distribution of carbon isotopes in animals. Geochim Cosmochim Acta. 1978;42(5):495–506.
- 75. Beaumont J, Montgomery J, Buckberry J, Jay M. Infant mortality and isotopic complexity: New approaches to stress, maternal health, and weaning. Am J Phys Anthropol. 2015;157(3):441–57. pmid:25773670
- 76. Beaumont J, Montgomery J. The Great Irish Famine: Identifying Starvation in the Tissues of Victims Using Stable Isotope Analysis of Bone and Incremental Dentine Collagen. PLOS ONE. 2016;11(8):e0160065. pmid:27508412
- 77. Fuller BT, Fuller JL, Sage NE, Harris DA, O’Connell TC, Hedges REM. Nitrogen balance and δ15N: why you’re not what you eat during nutritional stress. Rapid Commun Mass Spectrom. 2005;19(18):2497–506. pmid:16106342
- 78. Katzenberg MA, Lovell NC. Stable isotope variation in pathological bone. Int J Osteoarchaeol. 1999;9(5):316–24.
- 79. Reynard LM, Tuross N. The known, the unknown and the unknowable: weaning times from archaeological bones using nitrogen isotope ratios. J Archaeol Sci. 2015;53:618–25.
- 80. Hondelink MMA, Schepers M. The common and the rare: a review of Early Modern Dutch plant food consumption based on archaeobotanical urban cesspit data. Veg Hist Archaeobotany. 2020;29(5):553–65.
- 81. Esser K, Kootker L, van der Sluis L. Dineren in de burcht van Rode: Archeozoölogisch en isotopenonderzoek naar de samenstelling, productie en distributie van voedsel uit de burcht van Sint Oedenrode [Dining in the castle of Rode: Archaeozoological and isotope research into the composition, production and distribution of food from the fortress of Sint Oedenrode]. Noord-Brabant: Archeoplan Eco; 2014.
- 82. Kootker LM. Mapping Migrations: The application of strontium isotopes in Dutch cultural heritage research [PhD thesis]. [Amsterdam]: Vrije Universiteit; 2017.
- 83. McManus E, Montgomery J, Evans J, Lamb A, Brettell R, Jelsma J. “To the Land or to the Sea”: Diet and Mobility in Early Medieval Frisia. J Isl Coast Archaeol. 2013;8(2):255–77.
- 84. Schats R, van Hattum IJ, Kootker LM, Hoogland MLP, Waters‐Rist AL. Diet and urbanisation in medieval Holland. Studying dietary change through carious lesions and stable isotope analysis. Int J Osteoarchaeol. 2022;32(1):142–55.
- 85. Ambrose SH, Norr L. Experimental Evidence for the Relationship of the Carbon Isotope Ratios of Whole Diet and Dietary Protein to Those of Bone Collagen and Carbonate. In: Lambert JB, Grupe G, editors. Prehistoric Human Bone: Archaeology at the Molecular Level. Berlin, Heidelberg: Springer; 1993. p. 1–37.
- 86. Fernandes R, Nadeau M-J, Grootes PM. Macronutrient-based model for dietary carbon routing in bone collagen and bioapatite. Archaeol Anthropol Sci. 2012;4(4):291–301.
- 87. Scheuer L, Black S. Development and ageing of the juvenile skeleton. In: Cox M, Mays S, editors. Human osteology in archaeology and forensic science,. U.K.: Cambridge University Press; 2000. p. 9–22.
- 88. Schurr MR. Stable Nitrogen Isotopes as Evidence for the Age of Weaning at the Angel Site: A Comparison of Isotopic and Demographic Measures of Weaning Age. J Archaeol Sci. 1997;24(10):919–27.
- 89. Waters‐Rist AL, Bazaliiskii VI, Weber AW, Katzenberg MA. Infant and child diet in Neolithic hunter-fisher-gatherers from Cis-Baikal, Siberia: Intra-long bone stable nitrogen and carbon isotope ratios. Am J Phys Anthropol. 2011;146(2):225–41. pmid:21837688
- 90. Hedges REM, Clement JG, Thomas CDL, O’Connell TC. Collagen turnover in the adult femoral mid-shaft: Modeled from anthropogenic radiocarbon tracer measurements. Am J Phys Anthropol. 2007;133(2):808–16. pmid:17405135
- 91. Anderson M, Green WT, Messner MB. Growth and Predictions of Growth in the Lower Extremities. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1963;45A:1–14. pmid:14040773
- 92. Pritchett JW. Growth Plate Activity in the Upper Extremity. Clin Orthop. 1991;268:235–42. pmid:2060215
- 93. Klepinger LL. Nutritional Assessment From Bone. Annu Rev Anthropol. 1984;13(1):75–96.
- 94. Stenhouse M, Baxter M. The uptake of bomb 14C in humans. In: Berger R, Suess H, editors. Radiocarbon Dating. Berkeley: Proceedings of the Ninth International Radiocarbon Congress; 1979. p. 34.
- 95. Sealy J, Johnson M, Richards M, Nehlich O. Comparison of two methods of extracting bone collagen for stable carbon and nitrogen isotope analysis: comparing whole bone demineralization with gelatinization and ultrafiltration. J Archaeol Sci. 2014;47:64–9.
- 96. Ambrose SH. Preparation and characterization of bone and tooth collagen for isotopic analysis. J Archaeol Sci. 1990 Jul 1;17(4):431–51.
- 97. DeNiro MJ. Postmortem preservation and alteration of in vivo bone collagen isotope ratios in relation to palaeodietary reconstruction. Nature. 1985;317(6040):806–9.
- 98. van Klinken GJ. Bone Collagen Quality Indicators for Palaeodietary and Radiocarbon Measurements. J Archaeol Sci. 1999;26(6):687–95.
- 99. Ory BE, Van Poppel FWA. Trends and risk factors of maternal mortality in late-nineteenth-century Netherlands. Hist Fam. 2013;18(4):481–509.
- 100. Beaumont J, Atkins E-C, Buckberry J, Haydock H, Horne P, Howcroft R, et al. Comparing apples and oranges: Why infant bone collagen may not reflect dietary intake in the same way as dentine collagen. Am J Phys Anthropol. 2018;167(3):524–40. pmid:30187451
- 101. Beaumont J, Gledhill A, Lee‐Thorp J, Montgomery J. Childhood Diet: A Closer Examination of the Evidence from Dental Tissues Using Stable Isotope Analysis of Incremental Human Dentine. Archaeometry. 2013;55(2):277–95.
- 102. Bogaard A, Heaton THE, Poulton P, Merbach I. The impact of manuring on nitrogen isotope ratios in cereals: archaeological implications for reconstruction of diet and crop management practices. J Archaeol Sci. 2007;34(3):335–43.
- 103. Reitsema LJ, Muir AB. Growth velocity and weaning δ15N “Dips” during ontogeny in Macaca mulatta. Am J Phys Anthropol. 2015;157(2):347–57. pmid:25711380
- 104. Tsutaya T. Post-weaning diet in archaeological human populations: A meta-analysis of carbon and nitrogen stable isotope ratios of child skeletons. Am J Phys Anthropol. 2017;164(3):546–57. pmid:28786488
- 105. Scharlotta I, Goude G, Herrscher E, Bazaliiskii VI, Weber AW. Shifting weaning practices in Early Neolithic Cis-Baikal, Siberia: New insights from stable isotope analysis of molar micro-samples. Int J Osteoarchaeol. 2018;28(5):579–98.
- 106. van der Haas VM-L. Growing up in the Cis-Baikal region of Siberia, Russia: reconstructing childhood diet of Middle Holocene hunter-gatherers [PhD Dissertation]. [Edmonton, Canada]: University of Alberta; 2020.
- 107. Demirjian A, Goldstein H, Tanner JM. A new system of dental age assessment. Hum Biol. 1973;211–27. pmid:4714564
- 108. Moorrees CF, Fanning EA, Hunt EE Jr. Formation and resorption of three deciduous teeth in children. Am J Phys Anthropol. 1963;21(2):205–13. pmid:14110696
- 109. van Beverwijck J, Cats J. De schat der gezondheid [The treasure of health]. van Gemert L, editor. Amsterdam: Em. Querido; 1992.
- 110. Mauriceau AM. The Married Woman’s Private Medical Companion: Embracing the Treatment of Menstruation, Or Monthly Turns, During Their Stoppage, Irregularity, Or Entire Suppression: Pregnancy. 1852.
- 111. Burt NM. Individual dietary patterns during childhood: an archaeological application of a stable isotope microsampling method for tooth dentin. J Archaeol Sci. 2015;53:277–90.
- 112. de Luca A, Boisseau N, Tea I, Louvet I, Robins RJ, Forhan A, et al. δ15N and δ13C in hair from newborn infants and their mothers: a cohort study. Pediatr Res. 2012;71(5):598–604. pmid:22398698
- 113. Burt NM, Garvie-Lok S. A new method of dentine microsampling of deciduous teeth for stable isotope ratio analysis. J Archaeol Sci. 2013;40(11):3854–64.
- 114. Reissland N, Millard AR, Wood R, Ustun B, McFaul C, Froggatt S, et al. Prenatal effects of maternal nutritional stress and mental health on the fetal movement profile. Arch Gynecol Obstet. 2020;302(1):65–75. pmid:32409928
- 115. Lübcker N, Whiteman JP, Newsome SD, Millar RP, de Bruyn PN. Can the carbon and nitrogen isotope values of offspring be used as a proxy for their mother’s diet? Using foetal physiology to interpret bulk tissue and amino acid δ15N values. Conserv Physiol. 2020;8(1):coaa060. pmid:32765882
- 116. Neuberger FM, Jopp E, Graw M, Püschel K, Grupe G. Signs of malnutrition and starvation—Reconstruction of nutritional life histories by serial isotopic analyses of hair. Forensic Sci Int. 2013;226(1–3):22–32. pmid:23374882
- 117. Colonel SSr. De volksvoeding in Friesland [The common people’s food in Friesland]. Ned Tijdschr Geneeskd. 1876;(20):103–29.
- 118. Kintner HJ. Trends and regional differences in breastfeeding in Germany from 1871 to 1937. J Fam Hist. 1985;10(2):163–82. pmid:11611845
- 119. Grigg D. The nutritional transition in Western Europe. J Hist Geogr. 1995;21(3):247–61.
- 120. Dupras TL, Schwarcz HP, Fairgrieve SI. Infant feeding and weaning practices in Roman Egypt. Am J Phys Anthropol. 2001;115(3):204–12. pmid:11424072
- 121. Wright LE, Schwarcz HP. Stable carbon and oxygen isotopes in human tooth enamel: Identifying breastfeeding and weaning in prehistory. Am J Phys Anthropol. 1998;106(1):1–18. pmid:9590521
- 122. Yi B, Liu X, Yuan H, Zhou Z, Chen J, Wang T, et al. Dentin isotopic reconstruction of individual life histories reveals millet consumption during weaning and childhood at the Late Neolithic (4500 bp) Gaoshan site in southwestern China. Int J Osteoarchaeol. 2018;28(6):636–44.
- 123. Clerkx L, van IJzendoorn MH. Child Care in a Dutch Context: On the History, Current Status, and Evaluation of Nonmaternal Child Care in the Netherlands. In: Lamb ME, Sternberg KJ, Hwang C-P, Broberg AG, editors. Child Care in Context. New York: Psychology Press; 1992. p. 55–79.
- 124. de Vooys AC. De sterfte in Nederland in het midden der 19e eeuw [Mortality in the Netherlands in the middle of the 19th century]. Tijdschr Van Het K Ned Aardrijkskd Genoot. 1910;223–71.
- 125. Rollet C. Allaitement, mise en nourrice et mortalité infantile en France à la fin du XIXe siècle—Persée [Breastfeeding, wet nursing and infant mortality in France at the end of the 19th century]. Popul Fr Ed. 1978;33(6):1189–203.
- 126. Guttormsson L. Parent-child Relations. In: Kertzer DI, Barbagli M, editors. Family Life in the Long Nineteenth Century (1789–1913). New Haven: Yale University Press; 2003. p. 360–3.
- 127. Knodel J, Walle E van de. Breast feeding, fertility and infant mortality: An analysis of some early German data. Popul Stud. 1967;21(2):109–31. pmid:22085037
- 128. Hilgenga J. The Situation of Agricultural and Horticultural Workers in the Netherlands Reports and Enquiries. Int Labour Rev. 1938;37(1):44–58.
- 129. Schmidt A, Meerkerk E van N. Reconsidering The “First Male-Breadwinner Economy”: Women’s Labor Force Participation in the Netherlands, 1600–1900. Fem Econ. 2012;18(4):69–96.
- 130. Bourbou C, Fuller BT, Garvie-Lok SJ, Richards MP. Reconstructing the diets of Greek Byzantine populations (6th–15th centuries AD) using carbon and nitrogen stable isotope ratios. Am J Phys Anthropol. 2011;146(4):569–81. pmid:21952735
- 131. Bourbou C, Fuller BT, Garvie-Lok SJ, Richards MP. Nursing mothers and feeding bottles: reconstructing breastfeeding and weaning patterns in Greek Byzantine populations (6th–15th centuries AD) using carbon and nitrogen stable isotope ratios. J Archaeol Sci. 2013;40(11):3903–13.
- 132. Prowse TL, Saunders SR, Schwarcz HP, Garnsey P, Macchiarelli R, Bondioli L. Isotopic and dental evidence for infant and young child feeding practices in an imperial Roman skeletal sample. Am J Phys Anthropol. 2008;137(3):294–308. pmid:18615573
- 133. Beaumont J. The whole tooth and nothing but the tooth: Or why temporal resolution of bone collagen may be unreliable. Archaeometry. 2020;62(3):626–45.
- 134. Fildes VA. Breasts, Bottles and Babies: A History of Infant Feeding. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press; 1987.