Research for biotechnological applications of cyanobacteria focuses on synthetic pathways and bioreactor design, while little effort is devoted to introduce new, promising organisms in the field. Applications are most often based on recombinant work, and the establishment of transformation can be a risky, time-consuming procedure. In this work we demonstrate the natural transformation of the filamentous cyanobacterium Phormidium lacuna and insertion of a selection marker into the genome by homologous recombination. This is the first example for natural transformation filamentous non-heterocystous cyanobacterium. We found that Phormidium lacuna is polyploid, each cell has about 20–90 chromosomes. Transformed filaments were resistant against up to 14 mg/ml of kanamycin. Formerly, natural transformation in cyanobacteria has been considered a rare and exclusive feature of a few unicellular species. Our finding suggests that natural competence is more distributed among cyanobacteria than previously thought. This is supported by bioinformatic analyses which show that all protein factors for natural transformation are present in the majority of the analyzed cyanobacteria.
Citation: Nies F, Mielke M, Pochert J, Lamparter T (2020) Natural transformation of the filamentous cyanobacterium Phormidium lacuna. PLoS ONE 15(6): e0234440. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0234440
Editor: Jean-François Humbert, INRA, FRANCE
Received: February 14, 2020; Accepted: May 25, 2020; Published: June 12, 2020
Copyright: © 2020 Nies et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Data Availability: All relevant data are within the manuscript and its Supporting Information files.
Funding: This work was supported by the PhD fellowship of the Nagelschneider Foundation to Fabian Nies. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Biotechnology oriented research with cyanobacteria ranges from the production of low-cost material like bulk chemicals or biofuels  to high-value compounds like pharmaceutics . Advancements in cyanobacterial biotechnology are based on continued optimization of photobioreactors, the introduction and improvement of metabolic pathways by recombinant DNA technology, and the search for suitable organisms [3, 4]. The establishment of protocols for gene transfer can be challenging for new cyanobacteria because of barriers like extracellular materials and nucleases (reviewed in ). There are three common methods for gene transfer into cyanobacteria: electroporation, conjugation, and natural transformation (NT). For NT, cells have to be in a physiological state, termed natural competence (NC), in which the recipient cell is able to actively transport DNA into the cytoplasm. Protocols for NT are generally simple and straight forward , but only few naturally competent cyanobacteria (NCC) are known: diverse Synechococcus [7, 8] and Synechocystis [9, 10] strains, Microcystis aeruginosa PCC 7806  and Thermosynechococcus elongatus BP-1 . These cyanobacteria have a unicellular lifestyle, and NT was frequently described as a unique feature of few unicellular cyanobacteria [6, 13, 14]. There is also one report about NT of Nostoc muscorum , which belongs to the filamentous cyanobacteria with heterocysts, but no report about other filamentous cyanobacteria.
DNA uptake in natural transformation is dependent on Pil proteins of type IV pili. Furthermore, the competence proteins ComEA, ComEC, and ComF as well as the DNA processing protein DprA and the DNA recombination and repair protein RecA are essential [16–18]. For the cyanobacterium Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803, comEA, comF, pilA1, pilB1, pilD, pilM, pilN, pilO, pilQ, and pilT1 knockout mutants are deficient in NT [19–22]. The role of these proteins (among others) during natural transformation was recently also demonstrated in Synechococcus elongatus PCC 7942 by a transposon mutagenesis approach . In recent surveys, homologs of these and other competence related genes were found in many cyanobacterial genomes [23, 24] but there is so far no experimental evidence for NT in a novel species since more than a decade.
During transformation, the introduced DNA can either be integrated into the genome by homologous recombination or must be on a self-replicating plasmid. For integration into the genome it must be considered that cyanobacteria might possess multiple chromosomes per cell [25–29]. Isolation of homozygous transformants can be achieved by selection on increasing antibiotic concentrations. Until complete segregation of selection marker is achieved, the transformants may be unstable and the integrated sequences can be lost again under nonselective conditions [30, 31].
In this work we established an NT protocol for Phormidium lacuna, a filamentous non-heterocystous cyanobacterium. Our workgroup has isolated several strains of this newly described species from marine rockpools on Helgoland, North Sea, Germany, and on Giglio, Mediterranean, Italy, and the genome of strain HE10JO was sequenced . The genus was characterized as Phormidium based on sequences of 16S rRNA and of core proteins . Among the different isolated strains, 16S RNA sequences are identical. We characterized Phormidium lacuna as a promising candidate for biotechnological applications because it is tolerant against differing salt concentrations, temperatures up to 50 °C, and strong light. Phormidium lacuna is cultivable on agar medium, in liquid culture, and in stirring tank photobioreactor . On agar medium the filaments show twitching motility along their longitudinal axes, as other filamentous non-heterocystous cyanobacteria, e.g. Oscillatoria salina . This report is to our knowledge the first report of a gene transfer for the genus Phormidium and the first report of NT for a filamentous cyanobacterium without heterocysts. Phormidium lacuna was transformed by the integration of the kanamycin (Km) resistance cassette (kanR) into the genome via homologous recombination. Clones were selected by Km resistance and integration into genome was validated by PCR. During clone validation it was found that Phormidium lacuna is polyploid. This was confirmed by a DAPI fluorescence assay. By comprehensive BLAST analysis based on sequences of essential proteins for natural transformation (natural transformation factors, NTFs) we predict that a large fraction of cyanobacteria might be naturally transformable.
Material and methods
Species and strains
Phormidium lacuna strains used in this study, HE10JO and HE10DO, were collected from marine rockpools in Helgoland, North Sea, as described . The genome of strain HE10JO is sequenced . The 16S rRNA sequence of HE10JO and HE10DO is identical while the phytochrome sequence differs at one position between the two strains . We assume that both genomes are almost identical; also the sc_7_37 sequence is identical. Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803 was obtained from Annegret Wilde .
Plasmids for transformation
The present transformation vectors contain a homologous sequence that is interrupted by a resistance cassette. The homologous sequences are based on a Phormidium lacuna open reading frame sequence sc_7_37, which is the 37th open reading frame of DNA scaffold 7. sc_7_37 sequence encodes for a protein (Refseq ID: WP_087706519) that is annotated as hypothetical protein and which has close BLAST homologs that are annotated as hydrogenase. The coding sequences of both strains, HE10DO and HE10JO, are identical. An 1138 bp and a 2167 bp product were generated by PCR using Q5 polymerase (NEB, Ipswich, MA, USA) and genomic DNA of Phormidium lacuna as PCR template. The primer pairs were T256 / T257 for the short sequence and F114 / F115 for the long sequence, primers are listed in Table 1. The short and long sequences were integrated into pGEM-T by TA cloning (Promega, Madison, WI, USA). pGEM-T plasmids are not propagated in cyanobacteria due to incompatible origin of replication .
Each plasmid for transformation was generated based on two PCR products–one of the plasmid with homologous sequences and one of the kanR resistance cassette. For plasmid pFN_7_37_2k_kanRn the kanamycin resistance cassette kanR was PCR amplified from pUC4K  using the primer pair GG1 / GG2. The plasmid with the long sc_7_37 insert was amplified with the primers GG3 / GG4. The resulting plasmid pFN_7_37_2k_kanRn was generated by the digestion of the PCR products by type IIS restriction enzyme BbsI and subsequent ligation by T4 DNA ligase (both NEB, USA).
Two additional vectors were constructed that contained a version of kanR with slightly different 5´ and 3´ UTR. Primer pair F13 / F14 was used for PCR amplification of this kanR cassette. This cassette was inserted in the plasmids with the long and the short homologous sc_7_37 sequence, respectively. Both plasmids (with long and short sc_7_37 insert) were amplified with the primer pair F5 / F6. The resulting plasmids are termed pFN_7_37_kanR and pFN_7_37_2k_kanR and were generated by the digestion of the PCR products with XbaI and BmtI and subsequent ligation by T4 DNA ligase (both NEB, USA). Correct insertion of the respective fragments into the pGEM-T backbone was verified by Sanger sequencing. Plasmids for transformation were purified using the midi-prep plasmid purification kit from Macherey Nagel (Düren, Germany).
Cultivation of Phormidium lacuna
Phormidium lacuna strains HE10DO and HE10JO were cultivated at 23 °C in f/2 salt water medium —but generally without Na2SiO3 or in f/2+ (in which nitrate and phosphate are 10x increased) under permanent illumination (30 μmol m-2 s-1 white light from fluorescent tubes Lumilux-DeLuxe L 18/954, Osram, Munich, Germany) and continuous shaking (70 rpm). For agar plates, f/2 medium with 1.5% Bacto Agar (BD Diagnostics, Franklin Lakes, NJ, USA) was used.
For transformation, Phormidium lacuna  was cultivated in 100 ml f/2 medium to an optical density OD750 nm of 0.25–0.35. The cell suspension was homogenized using an Ultraturrax (Silent Crusher M. Heidolph, Schwabach, Germany) with the dispersion tool 18F at 10,000 rpm for 3 min. The cell suspension was centrifuged at 6000 g and 4°C for 15 min. After each centrifugation step, the supernatant was removed. Cells were resuspended in 20 ml water (4 °C) and centrifuged again. This washing step was repeated. The cells were finally suspended in the residual liquid, transferred into 1.5 ml tubes and centrifuged again at 6000 g at 4°C for 15 min. Cells were finally suspended in 1 ml supernatant. Portions of 100 μl were mixed with 3–30 μg DNA in 10 μl water, transferred into 10 ml f/2 medium, and cultivated for 2 d. Cells were again centrifuged, resuspended in 1 ml medium and transferred to f/2 agar plates with 0, 70, and 120 μg/ml Km. Resistant lines were identified after 10–28 d by light microscopy (single filament and smaller filament bundles) or by eye (bigger filament bundles) through the lid of the closed agar plate. An overview about the protocol is given in Table 2. Resistant cell filaments can be distinguished from wild type cell filaments by color. Relevant regions were marked on the petri dish and the respective cells were transferred to suspension culture under sterile conditions by an inoculating loop. Transgenic cells were cultivated on increasing Km concentrations in f/2+ suspension culture until complete segregation of selection marker was achieved. For electroporation experiments, mixtures of cells (as prepared above) and DNA were transferred into 1 mm cuvettes and with 300 V, 2 ms pulses (Gene Pulser Xcell, Bio-Rad, Hercules, CA, USA) before they were transferred into 10 ml f/2 medium and 2 d cultivation step.
Validation of transformants
To test for homologous integration, ca. 10 mg cell samples (wet weight) were homogenized and lysed mechanically by micropestle and subjected to PCR with Taq Polymerase (NEB, USA). The following primers were used: F25 / F28 for transformants of plasmid pFN_7_37_kanR and F120 / F121 for transformants of either plasmid pFN_7_37_2k_kanR or pFN_7_37_2k_kanRn (see Table 1 for primer sequences). These primers bind only in the Phormidium lacuna genome, upstream or downstream of the integration site.
Protein sequences of the NTFs of Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803 were obtained from the NCBI data base. NTF sequences of 6 naturally competent cyanobacteria (NCC) were identified by the offline NCBI tool BLAST+ (version: 2.7.1 ) based on the annotated NTFs of Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803. All NTFs identified in this way were used in a BLAST query against all cyanobacterial sequences of the NCBI non-redundant database (August 2018). Bit score as indicator of homology was processed by a minimum homology quotient method: For each homolog, the bit score of each alignment was divided the by smallest bit score of the respective NCC pairs.
Fluorescence was measured with a JASCO FP-8300 fluorimeter (Jasco, Tokio, Japan). Fluorescence emission was usually recorded at 490 nm. For a DNA calibration curve, 100 ng/ml DAPI were dissolved in f/2 growth medium and the fluorescence was recorded. Calf thymus DNA (Sigma-Aldrich, St. Louis, MO, USA) at a given concentration was dissolved and the exact concentration determined by UV/vis absorbance at 260 nm. The DNA was then added at various concentrations to the DAPI solution and the fluorescence recorded again. For the calibration curve, the difference between both spectra at the peak excitation of 363 nm was plotted against the DNA concentration.
Phormidium lacuna liquid cultures were homogenized by an Ultraturrax for 3 min at 10,000 rpm. To determine the cell concentration, the total length of all filaments in a given volume of a counting chamber was estimated (about 50 filaments for each sample) and divided by the average cell length (4 μm). Cells were quantitatively disrupted using an Aminco French pressure cell (Thermo Fischer, Waltham, MA, USA). A fluorescence excitation spectrum (300 to 400 nm) was recorded. Thereafter, DAPI was added to a final concentration of 100 ng/ml and the spectrum was measured again. After addition of 5 μl DNase (75 Kunitz) the fluorescence decreased over 30 min—2 h. The difference of the value at the excitation peak of 363 nm before and after DNA digestion was taken as measure for DNA concentration. The DNA concentration d in the solution was obtained from the calibration and the multiplication by 41.87/51.30 to correct for the slightly different GC contents of both species (41.87% for bovine and 51.30% for Phormidium lacuna sp. HE10JO); GC does not induce DAPI fluorescence . The number n of chromosome copies per cell was calculated by with Avogadro constant a = 6.02 · 1023 mol-1, molecular mass of one basepair m = 660 g (bp mol)-1, genome size g = 4.8 Mbp, concentration of cells in the measuring solution c. A genome size of 4.8 Mb from genome sequencing was taken for Phormidium lacuna .
Transformation of Phormidium lacuna
We initially established a transformation protocol for Phormidium lacuna strains HE10JO and HE10DO by electroporation that was based on protocols for other filamentous cyanobacteria [39–42]. For integration into cyanobacterial DNA we used homologous recombination, which works efficiently in diverse cyanobacteria such as Synechocystis PCC6803, Synechococcus elongatus PCC7942, or Nostoc Os-1 [43–45]. In the transformation vectors, the homologous sequence “sc_7_37” was interrupted by a kanR resistance cassette. sc_7_37 stands for the 37th open reading frame of DNA scaffold 7, the Genbank database entry for the protein is WP_087706519. It is annotated as a hypothetical protein. Since homologous proteins in other cyanobacteria (based on BLAST analysis) are annotated as hydrogenases, we considered this function as relevant in our study. Hydrogenases are oxygen sensitive; oxygenic photosynthesis and hydrogenase activity is usually separated either temporally in non-heterocystous cyanobacteria or spatially in heterocystous species . Since the non-heterocystous Phormidium lacuna was cultivated under continuous illumination, we considered an interruption of this open reading frame to have no or minor consequences on growth of the transformants. With the vectors pFN_7_37_kanR, pFN_7_37_2k_kanR, and pFN_7_37_2k_kanRn (see Methods section and below), we obtained Km resistant lines in about 40% of trials in the initial electroporation experiments (Table 3). During these studies we isolated a resistant line from a control experiment with the strain HE10DO in which cells were incubated with DNA, but no electroporation pulse was given. The transformation protocol could be optimized (Table 2 and Methods section) so that in almost all natural transformation assays, DNA was integrated in Phormidium lacuna HE10DO cells (Table 3). Fig 1A shows examples for filaments on selection medium at different time points after transformation.
(A-C) Filaments of Phormidium lacuna HE10DO after transformation with pFN_7_37_kanR during or after selection on agar plates. (A, B) Two weeks after transformation (A. 70 μg/ml Km; B. 120 μg/ml Km); (C) 4 weeks after transformation, selection on 120 μg/ml Km. In A brownish (red arrows) and greenish (white arrows) filaments can be distinguished, which represent non-transformed and transformed lineages, respectively; in B an area of the agar plate with a high frequency of disintegrated filaments was chosen, the intact filaments are transformed and alive; in C all filaments are alive and transformed. Bundles of parallel filaments are characteristic for growth of Phormidium lacuna on agar medium, the growth pattern is comparable to that of wild type on Km-free agar medium. Scale bars 100 μm. (D) Kanamycin resistance of Phormidium lacuna HE10JO wild type and pFN_7_37_kanR transformants (liquid cultures 1 week after inoculation). Wild type cannot proliferate at 50 μg/ml Km or above, while pFN_7_37_kanR transformants can grow up to 14 mg/ml Km.
Plasmid pFN_7_37_kanR has short ca. 500 bp homologous sequences flanking the kanR resistance cassette on each side, whereas pFN_7_37_2k_kanR and pFN_7_37_2k_kanRn have ca. 1000 bp homologous sequences on each side. The two bigger plasmids differed only in the 5’ and 3’ UTR of the selection marker and were therefore summarized as pFN_7_37_2k_kanR(n). A scheme of pFN_7_37_kanR is shown in Fig 2A. In a comparison of electroporation and NT that were performed under similar conditions, the success rate was always higher for NT as compared to electroporation (Table 3). When the pFN_7_37_2k_kanR(n) vectors were used, 15 out of 16 NT transformation trials were successful, i.e. resulted in the isolation of resistant lines that could be confirmed by PCR (see below). In the electroporation experiments, only 44% transformation trials were successful. We assume that the deleterious effect of the electric pulse overrides the positive effect that the pulse might have on DNA incorporation into the cells. We can even not rule out that in the electroporation experiments that DNA is taken up by NT only and that the electropulse has only deleterious effects. For transformation of Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803 it was observed that longer flanking sequences are beneficial for homologous integration into the genome . For Phormidium lacuna, we found no significant difference of transformation success between 500 bp and 1000 bp flanking sequences: rates were the same in the electroporation trials and the number of replicates in this comparison were too low in the NT experiments (Table 3). Since longer homologous sequences had at least no negative effect on transformation in electroporation experiments, we performed most of the NT experiments only with the bigger plasmids. The experiments presented in Table 3 were performed with Phormidium lacuna strain HE10DO. Additional electroporation experiments, which resulted in resistant transformants, were also performed with strain HE10JO.
(A) Plasmid map of pFN_7_37_kanR, red—homologous sequences of the sc_7_37 locus, blue—kanamycin resistance cassette kanR, yellow—origin of replication (f1—bacteriophage origin, other—pUC origin for E. coli), purple—ampicillin resistance cassette; (B) Integration site of pFN_7_37_kanR and primer binding sites. red—homologous sequences encoded on the vector, pale red—Phormidium lacuna chromosome, blue—kanamycin resistance gene. Primer pair: F25/F28 covering whole insertion site; (C) agarose gel for the PCR with the primer pair that covers the full insert for Phormidium lacuna HE10DO WT and pFN_7_37_kanR transformants. Transformants T1a and T1b were cultivated after selection on agar plate for one cultivation period (7 days) in f/2+ liquid medium with 250 μg/ml Km and one period in f/2+ with 1000 μg/ml Km. T2a and T2b were cultivated only for one period at 250 μg/ml Km. M: 1kb DNA ladder (NEB, USA). Integration of the kanR cassette into the genome of Phormidium lacuna is indicated by the larger PCR product (2560 bp), the native sequence in indicated by the small PCR product (1213 bp).
Strong resistance against kanamycin
We found that transformants of Phormidium lacuna HE10JO and HE10DO with the kanR cassette were resistant against very high Km concentrations. Transformed lines could be routinely cultivated up to 14 mg/ml Km (Fig 1B and S1 Fig). Escherichia coli DH5α and Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803 cells, transformed with the same kanR, were resistant up to ca. 200 μg/ml and ca. 500 μg/ml Km, respectively. The upper limit of the Km resistance of transformed lines was repeatedly detected between 14 mg/ml and 30 mg/ml Km; at 30 and 50 mg/ml Km Phormidium lacuna transformants could not proliferate anymore (S1 Fig). In an extensive literature survey we found a report about an environmental Enterococcus strain that was resistant up to 2 mg/ml Km , but no report about higher Km resistance. Thus, transformed Phormidium lacuna has probably the strongest Km resistance reported so far. Besides the Km resistance the Phormidium lacuna transformants showed no apparent phenotype.
Selection of homozygous mutants
The integration into the genome was validated by PCR. Fig 2 shows results from a transformation with pFN_7_37_KanR. The used primers bind to regions in the genome of Phormidium lacuna just upstream or downstream of the insertion site, respectively (Fig 2B). In wild type extracts, an expected short PCR product of 1213 bp was detected (Fig 2C). Lines T1a and T1b are from filaments transformed with pFN_7_37_KanR that had been cultivated in liquid medium with 250 μg/ml and 1000 μg/ml kanamycin after transformation and the expected long PCR product with 2560 bp was detected. In T2a and T2b, which are from filaments transformed with pFN_7_37_KanR that were cultivated for 9 d in liquid culture with 250 μg/ml Km, both the 1213 bp and the 2560 bp PCR products were present. The integration of kanR into the chromosome of Phormidium lacuna transformants was confirmed by PCR for all selected transformants. When the PCR tests were performed after prolonged cultivation on high Km concentration (like 1000 μg/ml), the pattern of T1a/T1b was obtained (Fig 2C). In 8 independent transformation experiments the pattern of T2a/T2b was obtained, which indicates the presence of the wild type chromosome and the recombinant chromosome with the kanR insertion at the same time. A possible explanation for this pattern is that Phormidium lacuna has more than one chromosome copy, i.e. that it is polyploid as reported also for several other cyanobacteria . kanR could be first integrated in a subfraction of the chromosomes after transformation. Prolonged selection on antibiotics results in an increase of the fraction of targeted chromosomes until finally all chromosomes bear the insertion and homozygous transformants are selected. Tests for the presence of the vector backbone using PCR primers for the ampicillin resistance cassette showed negative results.
Ploidy of Phormidium lacuna
In order to find out whether Phormidium lacuna cells are also polyploid, we estimated the number of chromosome copies by a DAPI based fluorescence assay. For these measurements, we used extracts of Phormidium lacuna HE10DO wild type cells that were cultivated in f/2 medium for 2 to 7 days. DAPI is used for DNA detection in microscopy  and extracts . The staining is based on intercalation into double stranded DNA that results in a strong increase of fluorescence quantum yield. Double stranded RNA and DAPI are also fluorescent . RNA did only slightly interfere with our assay. In preliminary experiments we found that the fluorescence of DAPI added to a Phormidium lacuna extract (details as described in the Methods section) is only slightly reduced by RNase addition, these changes were in the range of 10%. DAPI (without DNA) had an excitation maximum at 345 nm in our assay, the addition of calf thymus DNA resulted in a major increase of fluorescence with an excitation at 363 nm (Fig 3A). The background fluorescence of the Phormidium lacuna cell extract without DAPI was monitored in each set of measurements. The excitation maximum of the extract was 359 nm (Fig 3B). Fluorescence was drastically increased upon addition of DAPI and the excitation maximum was shifted to 363 nm. This maximum wavelength is identical with that of pure DNA and DAPI (Fig 3A). This shows again that RNA does not contribute in a significant extent to the fluorescence spectrum of extract and DAPI, since the DNA and RNA DAPI fluorescence spectra have different maxima . To further distinguish a DNA-specific signal from background fluorescence and from the signal of free DAPI, we included a DNase treatment in the assay. This resulted in a loss of most of the fluorescence signal in each sample (Fig 3B). We used the difference before and after complete DNase digestion as measure for the DNA concentration, for the calculation of DNA concentration we used calibration measurements with calf thymus DNA (Fig 3C). Details for calculation of DNA concentration and chromosome numbers per cell are given in the methods section.
(A, B) excitation spectra from 300 nm to 400 nm, fluorescence emission were measured at 470 nm. (A) spectra of DAPI (black) and DAPI with calf thymus DNA (red); excitation maxima are indicated by arrows; (B) spectra of Phormidium lacuna extract (thick line, black), extract after addition of DAPI (thick line, red) and after DNAse addition, measured at intervals as given in the legend (thin lines, various colors), after 30 min, fluorescence was constant (thick line, brown), excitation maxima of extract and extract+DAPI are indicated; (C) calibration curve, fluorescence of DAPI with calf thymus DNA as used for calculation of DNA concentrations, correlation coefficient 0.998; (D) number of chromosome copies of Phormidium lacuna calculated according to the methods section and plotted against cell densities, correlation coefficient and slope of a linear regression are 0.3 and -41, respectively, the number of cells is 22 Mio / OD750 nm.
The calculated number of chromosomes per cell differs and is for most measurements between 20 and 90 (Fig 3D). Although for some values of OD750 nm (which indicates cell density and culture age as well) different chromosome copies are measured, especially at low cell density, it is apparent that the copy number reduces at higher OD750 nm. Despite the variations we assume that our method is precise enough to say that Phormidium lacuna is polyploid (chromosome copy numbers between 20 and 90) and that it can vary due to culture conditions, as demonstrated for OD750 nm. Strong variation of chromosome copy number was reported for Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803 in dependency on growth phase and environmental factors  and a chromosome copy number of more than 600 was reported for the filamentous Trichodesmium erythraeum IMS 101 .
Selection of homozygous transformants
We also studied how the Km concentration in the medium affects the selection of homozygous transformants by detection of kanR in the genome via PCR (Fig 4). After transformation of HE10DO with pFN_7_37_KanR, selection of a resistant line, and one cultivation cycle in suspension culture with 100 μg/ml Km, the filaments were divided and cultured at 0, 0.1, 0.98 and 8.3 mg/ml Km in suspension culture with subcultivation every 7 d for 4 weeks. After the first subcultivation, two PCR bands were observed in all cultures, indicating that Km resistance was integrated in a part of the chromosomes but not in all (Fig 4A). Without antibiotic pressure, the 2560 bp PCR product decreased transiently and increased again after the 4th subcultivation (Fig 4B–4D), and the 1213 bp wild type PCR product was present through all subcultivations. In the 100 μg/ml Km samples, the wild type band was diminished after the third subcultivation and almost, but not completely, lost after the 4th subcultivation. The results were similar for the selection on 980 μg/ml Km. With 8300 μg/ml Km, the wild type band disappeared almost completely already after the 2nd subcultivation and was apparently lost after the 3rd and 4th subcultivations. Thus, high concentrations of Km result in rapid segregation of kanR into all chromosomes. The high Km resistance of Phormidium lacuna transformants could provide an advantage for fast selection of homozygous mutants.
(A-D) Following cultivation in 0.1 mg/ml Km until 2 weeks after transformation, the sample was divided and subcultivated one to four times on different Km concentrations (A, 0 mg/ml; B, 0.1 mg/ml, C, 0.98 mg/ml; D, 8.3 mg/ml). Primers: F25, F28. PCR product length: native– 1213 bp, recombinant– 2560 bp. Marker: 1 kb DNA ladder (NEB, USA).
Prediction of potentially naturally competent cyanobacteria
Phormidium lacuna HE10DO is the first filamentous non-heterocystous cyanobacterium for which a NT protocol was established. According to mutant studies with Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803, proteins of the type IV pili PilA1, PilB1, PilD, PilM, PilN, PilO, PilQ, PilT1 and the DNA receptor ComEA and ComF are NTFs, i.e. required for NT [19–22]. Other NTFs that are essential for NT in general (but for this was not explicitly demonstrated by knock-out mutants) are ComEC, DprA, and RecA . A functional type IV pilus in combination with this set of expressed non-pili proteins is the essential prerequisite for NT. We can therefore assume that the probability for NT is high if a species has functional homologs of all proteins. The protein sequences of Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803, which were proven or predicted to be essential for natural transformation, were received from the NCBI database. In order to get an overview about the distribution of NTF in selected cyanobacteria, first the selected protein sequences of Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803 were used as query to identify the NTF with BLASTp in the other naturally competent cyanobacteria (NCC) Synechococcus elongatus PCC 7942, Synechococcus sp. PCC 7002, Thermosynechococcus elongatus BP-1, Microcystis aeruginosa PCC 7806, and Phormidium lacuna HE10JO [7–12]. The strains Phormidium lacuna HE10JO and HE10DO are very similar and the genomic data for HE10JO is considered also relevant for the strain HE10DO , see also Methods section. This set of proteins of all NCC is used to define a range of similarity to decide whether other homologs could be functional for NT or not. We compared all NTFs of all NCCs with the predicted proteins of the genomes of selected other cyanobacteria using BLASTp. In order to normalize each target, the highest bit-score (out of 6) was divided by the lowest bit-score among the 6 NCCs (i.e. the most unrelated NTF pair among NCCs). If the quotient is ≥ 1, we regard the target protein as functional homolog, because it is then within the range of NCC. More precisely, a value above 1.0 indicates that are protein shares a higher homology with at least one of the NCC than this protein shares among the most distantly related species inside the NCC group. If all NTF homologs of a species have values ≥ 1, the chances are high that all NTFs are functionally present in this species. Among 28 cyanobacterial species for which no NT is reported, 19 have quotients ≥ 1 for all 13 NTF homologs and are thus promising candidates for NT (Table 4). Among them are 14 filamentous cyanobacteria including two members of the genera Arthrospira / Spirulina and Trichodesmium with high economic or ecological impact. For other species the quotient for one or more NTFs is below 1, yet all essential genes for NT seem to be present in the genome but in lower homology to the NCC. These organisms may also be naturally transformable but lower likelihood of success. Quotients ≤ 0.2 are considered as indicative for random hits during the BLAST search. Therefore, the 3 species that have at least one quotient ≤ 0.2 are regarded as critical for NT.
The minimum bit score quotient of (putative) natural transformation factors (NTFs) of 34 cyanobacterial species are summarized. In the first step, NTF homologs of 6 naturally competent cyanobacteria (indicated by NCC in the last line) were identified. These NTFs were used as queries in a BLAST search against protein sequences of 28 cyanobacterial species. The bit score of each homology hit was divided the by smallest bit score of the respective NCC pairs resulting in the minimum bit score quotient. Therefore a quotient above 1.0 indicates that a protein sequence shares a higher homology with at least one of the NCC than the most distantly related species among the NCC group share with each other. If all values are 1.0 or higher the respective organism is predicted as potentially naturally competent (PC). For some NTFs the homology between the respective species and the NCC is lower (indicated by a quotient between 0.2 and 1.0), yet BLAST results seem to be specific and the respective NTF seem to be present. These organisms may also be naturally transformable but lower likelihood of success. Quotients ≤ 0.2 are considered as indicative for random hits during the BLAST and the respective species are predicted to be not naturally competent. (* full strain name: Prochlorococcus marinus subsp. marinus str. CCMP1375).
Even though NC is known for several single celled cyanobacterial species and one filamentous cyanobacterium, Nostoc muscorum , this mechanism was considered as rare trait among cyanobacteria [6, 13, 14]. The finding of NC in Phormidium lacuna, the first filamentous non-heterocystous cyanobacterium, was therefore unexpected and surprising. Based on this finding we assume that NC is more common among cyanobacteria. Our bioinformatic studies on the distribution of NTF homologs among 29 species, which are intended to be a representative selection of the cyanobacterial phylum with a focus on filamentous non-heterocystous cyanobacteria, supports this hypothesis: functional homologs of all NTFs are present in at least 19 species. Thus, NC seems to be a widely distributed physiological function in cyanobacteria and could contribute more to evolutionary adaptations than previously suggested. It might play a major role in horizontal gene transfer, genetic recombination, and DNA repair in this phylum. Natural transformation is easy and uncomplicated and a more widespread use would be a benefit for basic and applied research in the field.
Our bioinformatic analysis gives example that the rapidly increasing numbers of cyanobacterial genomes will help to identify potentially transformable species and offers a simple way to rank potential candidates for their probability of NT based on the sequence homology to strains already described as natural competent. Two recently published works  also demonstrate that genes for NC are frequent in the cyanobacterial phylum. We chose a different selection of proteins for our analysis. We did not considered proteins, which were demonstrated to be involved in NC in certain cyanobacteria species but whose function in NC is either not completely understood, or which play a role in NC regulation that might be species specific (see also below). We focused on proteins, whose function is understood for NC and which seem to be universal in gram negative bacteria to test for the essential prerequisite for NC. This includes the type IV pilus and competence proteins but also additionally the proteins RecA and DprA, which are not directly included in the DNA uptake into the cell but are essential for the subsequent recombination . RecA is found is all analyzed strain, which is not surprising since RecA-like proteins are nearly ubiquitous in bacteria , and are also present in archaea and eukaryotes . DprA is present in all species in our analysis except the Prochlorococcus strain, which misses also most other NTFs. DprA is highly conserved in naturally competent species  and is thus an essential factor to predict NC together with the competence and pilus proteins. We want to point out that the presented analysis can be used as first indication if a certain species might be naturally competent or not but it is no definitive prediction. If a particular interest exists for a species that is predicted as non competent, one could consider a fresh and/or deeper analysis (for example under consideration of updates or reformation of the respective databases). On the other side not only the complete set of essential genes is relevant for NC but also their coordinated expression is important. Thus, even if the complete set for NC is present in an organism, the physiological state of NC may be hard to stimulate. Gene expression of NTFs is probably dependent on internal and environmental parameters. Molecular studies on the regulation of NC are concentrated on the gram negative Vibrio cholerae and the gram positive genera Bacillus and Streptococcus [55, 56]. For the cyanobacterium Synechococcus elongatus PCC 7942 it was demonstrated recently that the circadian clock controls the expression of NTFs . While in Synechococcus elongatus PCC 7942 transformation efficiency peaks at dusk and early dark phase, transformation efficiency in Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803 is higher when cells are incubated under light instead of darkness . This illustrates that the uptake machinery for DNA via NC might be conserved in the cyanobacterial phylum, but the regulation of NC might be more diverse.
Phormidium lacuna filaments are highly motile on agar medium  and motility of cyanobacteria is thought to be dependent on type IV pili , the same structure that mediates NT. Motility indicates that pil genes are expressed, and a preselection of motile strains or conditions that increase motility could help in successful NT. The filamentous growth and motility on agar surfaces and different membranes is the reason why no colonies are obtained after transformation and the respective frequencies cannot be calculated as cfu/μg of plasmid DNA.
Several negative factors could reduce or abolish DNA transfer, such as extracellular polymeric materials, different types of nucleases, and CRISPR/Cas systems. However, DNA is taken up in single stranded form and bound by single strand binding proteins, DprA, and RecA  before its integration into the genome. Intracellular DNA during NT could be thus less vulnerable to negative factors that target double stranded DNA such as the restriction endonucleases. Gene transfer into Nostoc sp. PCC 7120 by conjugation or into Arthrospira platensis C1 by electroporation was improved if DNA was protected from restriction endonucleases by methylation or by the use of suitable inhibitors [58, 59]. Genes for single strand exonuclease RecJ , for several endonucleases, and for CRISPR/CAS [61–63] are present in the genome of Phormidium lacuna and widely distributed among other cyanobacteria including also other naturally competent species.
In principle, transformation success can be improved by stimulating positive factors or by inhibiting negative factors. In the present Phormidium lacuna transformation protocol the cell suspension is homogenized and washed subsequently, this treatment could reduce extracellular transformation barriers as extracellular polymeric materials or extracellular nucleases  and thereby promote NT. In NT experiments with other species, the use of more DNA, additional DNA methylation, or temperature variations could inhibit other negative factors.
We have shown that a newly isolated cyanobacterium Phormidium lacuna can be transformed by natural transformation during which a kanR resistance cassette is integrated into the genome by homologous recombination, that the transformants are extraordinarily resistant against Km, and that this cyanobacterium has multiple chromosome copies. The established protocol includes few washing steps, DNA addition and subcultivation, and homozygous transformants are obtained after about 4 weeks. Genetic engineering is now possible for another cyanobacterium, which can be used in the future for basic research and biotechnological applications. We hope that our results stimulate trials on natural transformation of other cyanobacteria and thereby contribute to a broadening of research on more species, especially the filamentous ones.
S1 Fig. Kanamycin limit for Phormidium lacuna HE10JO pFN_7_37_kanR transformants.
Cultures were inoculated to OD750 = 0.2 and were cultivated for 1 week at standard growth conditions. Km concentrations are given above and below. (A) Liquid cultures of one example after 1 week inoculation at given Km concentration. Phormidium lacuna HE10DO wild type (WT) and pFN_7_37_kanR transformants. (B) Quantification of OD750 nm as measure cell density. ΔOD750 nm was calculated by the difference of the between the values at day 7 and the start OD750 nm. Negative ΔOD750 nm indicates that cells died during inoculation. Mean values +- SE, n = 3. T-test error probabilities p for transformation efficiency are indicated by *, p < 5% and **, p < 0.5%.
- 1. Angermayr SA, Rovira AG, Hellingwerf KJ. Metabolic engineering of cyanobacteria for the synthesis of commodity products. Trends Biotech 2015;33:352–61.
- 2. Vijayakumar S, Menakha M. Pharmaceutical applications of cyanobacteria—A review. Journal of Acute Medicine 2015;5:15–23.
- 3. Johnson TJ, Katuwal S, Anderson GA, Gu L, Zhou R, Gibbons WR. Photobioreactor cultivation strategies for microalgae and cyanobacteria. Biotechnol Prog 2018;34:811–27. pmid:29516646
- 4. Dexter J, Armshaw P, Sheahan C, Pembroke JT. The state of autotrophic ethanol production in cyanobacteria. J Appl Microbiol 2015;119:11–24. pmid:25865951
- 5. Stucken K, Koch R, Dagan T. Cyanobacterial defense mechanisms against foreign DNA transfer and their impact on genetic engineering. Biol Res 2013;46: 373–82. pmid:24510140
- 6. Koksharova OA, Wolk CP. Genetic tools for cyanobacteria. Appl Microbiol Biot 2002;58: 123–37.
- 7. Shestakov SV, Khyen NT. Evidence for Genetic transformation in blue-green alga Anacystis-nidulans. Mol Gen Genet 1970;107: 372–5. pmid:4999302
- 8. Stevens SE, Porter RD. Transformation in Agmenellum quadruplicatum. P Natl Acad Sci-Biol 1980;77: 6052–6.
- 9. Devilly CI, Houghton JA. Study of genetic transformation in Gloeocapsa alpicola. J Gen Microbiol 1977;98(Jan):277–80.
- 10. Grigorieva G, Shestakov S. Transformation in the cyanobacterium Synechocystis Sp 6803. FEMS Microbiol Lett 1982;13(4):367–70.
- 11. Dittmann E, Neilan BA, Erhard M, vonDohren H, Börner T. Insertional mutagenesis of a peptide synthetase gene that is responsible for hepatotoxin production in the cyanobacterium Microcystis aeruginosa PCC 7806. Mol Microbiol 1997;26:779–87. pmid:9427407
- 12. Onai K, Morishita M, Kaneko T, Tabata S, Ishiura M. Natural transformation of the thermophilic cyanobacterium Thermosynechococcus elongatus BP-1: a simple and efficient method for gene transfer. Mol Genet Genom 2004:50–9.
- 13. Vioque A. Transformation of cyanobacteria. Adv Exp Med Biol 2007;616:12–22. pmid:18161487
- 14. Al-Haj L, Lui YT, Abed RM, Gomaa MA, Purton S. Cyanobacteria as chassis for industrial biotechnology: progress and prospects. Life 2016;6(4).
- 15. Trehan K, Sinha U. DNA-mediated transformation in Nostoc muscorum, a nitrogen-fixing cyanobacterium. Aust J Biol Sci 1982; 573–7.
- 16. Mell JC, Redfield RJ. Natural competence and the evolution of DNA uptake specificity. J Bacteriol 2014;196(8):1471–83. pmid:24488316
- 17. Johnsborg O, Eldholm V, Havarstein LS. Natural genetic transformation: prevalence, mechanisms and function. Res Microbiol 2007:767–78. pmid:17997281
- 18. Matthey N, Blokesch M. The DNA-uptake process of naturally component Vibrio cholerae. Trends Microbiol 2016;24:98–110. pmid:26614677
- 19. Bhaya D, Bianco NR, Bryant D, Grossman A. Type IV pilus biogenesis and motility in the cyanobacterium Synechocystis sp PCC6803. Mol Microbiol 2000;37:941–51. pmid:10972813
- 20. Yoshihara S, Geng XX, Okamoto S, Yura K, Murata T, Go M, et al. Mutational analysis of genes involved in pilus structure, motility and transformation competency in the unicellular motile cyanobacterium Synechocystis sp PCC 6803. Plant Cell Physiol 2001;42:63–73. pmid:11158445
- 21. Okamoto S, Ohmori M. The cyanobacterial PilT protein responsible for cell motility and transformation hydrolyzes ATP. Plant Cell Physiol. 2002;43: 1127–36. pmid:12407192
- 22. Nakasugi K, Svenson CJ, Neilan BA. The competence gene, comF, from Synechocystis sp strain PCC 6803 is involved in natural transformation, phototactic motility and piliation. Microbiol-Sgm 2006;152:3623–31.
- 23. Taton A, Erikson C, Yang Y, Rubin BE, Rifkin SA, Golden JW, et al. The circadian clock and darkness control natural competence in cyanobacteria. Nat Comm 2020;11(1).
- 24. Wendt KE, Pakrasi HB. Genomics approaches to deciphering natural transformation in cyanobacteria. Front Microbiol 2019;10:7.
- 25. Griese M, Lange C, Soppa J. Ploidy in cyanobacteria. FEMS Microbiol Lett 2011;323(2):124–31. pmid:22092711
- 26. Chen AH, Afonso B, Silver PA, Savage DF. Spatial and temporal organization of chromosome duplication and segregation in the cyanobacterium Synechococcus elongatus PCC 7942. PLoS ONE 2012;7:e47837. pmid:23112856
- 27. Sukenik A, Kaplan-Levy RN, Welch JM, Post AF. Massive multiplication of genome and ribosomes in dormant cells (akinetes) of Aphanizomenon ovalisporum (cyanobacteria). ISME J. 2012;6(3):670–9. pmid:21975597
- 28. Watanabe S, Ohbayashi R, Kanesaki Y, Saito N, Chibazakura T, Soga T, et al. Intensive DNA replication and metabolism during the lag phase in cyanobacteria. PLOS ONE. 2015;10(9):e0136800. pmid:26331851
- 29. Zerulla K, Ludt K, Soppa J. The ploidy level of Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803 is highly variable and is influenced by growth phase and by chemical and physical external parameters. Microbiology. 2016;162(5):730–9. pmid:26919857
- 30. Soppa J. Polyploidy in archaea and bacteria: about desiccation resistance, giant cell size, long-term survival, enforcement by a eukaryotic host and additional aspects. J Mol Microbiol Biotechnol. 2014;24:409–19. pmid:25732342
- 31. Cassier-Chauvat C, Veaudor T, Chauvat F. Comparative genomics of DNA recombination and repair in cyanobacteria: biotechnological implications. Front Microbiol 2016;7:1809. pmid:27881980
- 32. Nies F, Worner S, Wunsch N, Armant O, Sharma V, Hesselschwerdt A, et al. Characterization of Phormidium lacuna strains from the North Sea and the Mediterranean Sea for biotechnological applications. Proc Biochem 2017;59:194–206.
- 33. Gupta S, Agrawal SC. Motility in Oscillatoria salina as affected by different factors. Folia Microbiol 2006;51:565–71.
- 34. Wilde A, Fiedler B, Börner T. The cyanobacterial phytochrome Cph2 inhibits phototaxis towards blue light. Mol Microbiol 2002;44:981–8. pmid:12010493
- 35. Schaefer MR, Chiangg GG, Cobley JG, Grossman AR. Plasmids from two morphologically distinct cyanobacterial strains share a novel replication origin. J Bacteriol. 1993;175:5701–5. pmid:8366056
- 36. Vieira J, Messing J. The Puc plasmids, an M13mp7-derived system for insertion mutagenesis and sequencing with synthetic universal primers. Gene. 1982;19(3):259–68. pmid:6295879
- 37. Camacho C, Coulouris G, Avagyan V, Ma N, Papadopoulos J, Bealer K, et al. BLAST+: architecture and applications. BMC Bioinformatics. 2009;10:421. pmid:20003500
- 38. Wilson WD, Tanious FA, Barton HJ, Strekowski L, Boykin DW, Jones RL. Binding of 4',6-diamidino -2-phenylindole (DAPI) to GC and mixed sequences in DNA- intercalation of a classical groove-binding molecule. JACS. 1989;111:5008–10.
- 39. Fujita Y, Takahashi Y, Chuganji M, Matsubara H. The Nifh-Like (Frxc) Gene is involved in the biosynthesis of chlorophyll in the filamentous cyanobacterium Plectonema boryanum. Plant Cell Physiol. 1992;33:81–92.
- 40. Toyomizu M, Suzuki K, Kawata Y, Kojima H, Akiba Y. Effective transformation of the cyanobacterium Spirulina platensis using electroporation. J Appl Phycol. 2001;13:209–14.
- 41. Ravindran CR, Suguna S, Shanmugasundaram S. Electroporation as a tool to transfer the plasmid pRL489 in Oscillatoria MKU 277. J Microbiol Methods. 2006;66:174–6. pmid:16406130
- 42. Ishida K, Christiansen G, Yoshida WY, Kurmayer R, Welker M, Valls N, et al. Biosynthesis and structure of aeruginoside 126A and 126B, cyanobacterial peptide glycosides bearing a 2-carboxy-6-hydroxyoctahydroindole moiety. Chem Biol. 2007;14: 565–76. pmid:17524987
- 43. Vermaas W. Molecular genetics of the cyanobacterium Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803: Principles and possible biotechnology applications. Journal of Applied Phycology. 1996;8: 263–73.
- 44. Sarnaik A, Nambissan V, Pandit R, Lali A. Recombinant Synechococcus elongatus PCC 7942 for improved zeaxanthin production under natural light conditions. Algal Res. 2018;36:139–51.
- 45. Hussain A, Shah ST, Rahman H, Irshad M, Iqbal A. Effect of IAA on in vitro growth and colonization of Nostoc in plant roots. Front Plant Sci 2015;6:9.
- 46. Khetkorn W, Rastogi RP, Incharoensakdi A, Lindblad P, Madamwar D, Pandey A, et al. Microalgal hydrogen production—a review. Bioresource Technology 2017;243:1194–206. pmid:28774676
- 47. Zang XN, Liu B, Liu SM, Arunakumara K, Zhang XC. Optimum conditions for transformation of Synechocystis sp PCC 6803. J Microbiol 2007;45:241–5. pmid:17618230
- 48. Dada AC, Ahmad A, Usup G, Heng LY, Hamid R. High-level aminoglycoside resistance and virulence characteristics among Enterococci isolated from recreational beaches in Malaysia. Environ Monit Assess 2013;185:7427–43. pmid:23417753
- 49. Chazotte B. Labeling nuclear DNA using DAPI. Cold Spring Harb Protoc. 2011;2011: pdb.prot5556.
- 50. Lee LS, Garnett HM. Estimation of total DNA in crude extracts of plant leaf tissue using DAPI fluorimetry. J Biochem Biophys Meth 1993;26: 249–60. pmid:8409197
- 51. Tanious FA, Veal JM, Buczak H, Ratmeyer LS, Wilson WD. DAPI (4',6-diamidino-2-phenylindole) binds differentially to DNA and RNA—minor groove binding at AT sites and intercalation at AU sites. Biochemistry. 1992;31:3103–12. pmid:1372825
- 52. Sargent EC, Hitchcock A, Johansson SA, Langlois R, Moore CM, LaRoche J, et al. Evidence for polyploidy in the globally important diazotroph Trichodesmium. Fems Microbiology Letters. 2016;363:7.
- 53. Roca AI, Cox MM, Brenner SL. The RecA protein: structure and function. Crit Rev Biochem Mol Bio. 1990;25:11996–2002
- 54. Brendel V, Brocchieri L, Sandler SJ, Clark AJ, Karlin S. Evolutionary comparisons of RecA-like proteins across all major kingdoms of living organisms. J Mol Evol 1997;44:528–41. pmid:9115177
- 55. Johnston C, Martin B, Fichant G, Polard P, Claverys JP. Bacterial transformation: distribution, shared mechanisms and divergent control. Nat Rev Microbiol 2014;12:181–96. pmid:24509783
- 56. Dubnau D, Blokesch M. Mechanisms of DNA Uptake by naturally competent bacteria. Annual Rev Genet 2019;53:217–237.
- 57. Khayatan B, Meeks JC, Risser DD. Evidence that a modified type IV pilus-like system powers gliding motility and polysaccharide secretion in filamentous cyanobacteria. Mol Microbiol. 2015;98:1021–36. pmid:26331359
- 58. Elhai J, Vepritskiy A, Muro-Pastor AM, Flores E, Wolk CP. Reduction of conjugal transfer efficiency by three restriction activities of Anabaena sp. strain PCC 7120. J Bacteriol. 1997;179: 1998–2005. pmid:9068647
- 59. Jeamton W, Dulsawat S, Tanticharoen M, Vonshak A, Cheevadhanarak S. Overcoming intrinsic restriction enzyme barriers enhances transformation efficiency in Arthrospira platensis C1. Plant and Cell Physiology. 2017;58: 822–30. pmid:28158667
- 60. Kufryk GI, Sachet M, Schmetterer G, Vermaas WFJ. Transformation of the cyanobacterium Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803 as a tool for genetic mapping: optimization of efficiency. FEMS Microbiology Letters. 2002;206: 215–9. pmid:11814666
- 61. Knoot CJ, Biswas S, Pakrasi HB. Tunable Repression of key photosynthetic processes using Cas12a CRISPR interference in the fast-growing cyanobacterium Synechococcus sp. UTEX 2973. ACS Synth Biol. 2020;9: 132–43. pmid:31829621
- 62. Wendt KE, Ungerer J, Cobb RE, Zhao H, Pakrasi HB. CRISPR/Cas9 mediated targeted mutagenesis of the fast growing cyanobacterium Synechococcus elongatus UTEX 2973. Microb Cell Fact. 2016; 15: 115. pmid:27339038
- 63. Ungerer J, Pakrasi HB. Cpf1 Is A Versatile Tool for CRISPR Genome Editing Across Diverse Species of Cyanobacteria. Sci Rep. 2016:39681.