http://orcid.org/0000-0003-2186-1072
Figures
Abstract
Background
A total of 3,419 new HIV diagnoses were reported in Germany in 2016, with migrants from sub-Saharan Africa (misSA) accounting for 14.1%. To understand the driving factors behind the epidemiological situation, we conducted a quantitative cross-sectional survey on knowledge, attitudes, behavior, and practices regarding HIV and sexually transmitted infections (STIs) among misSA living in six German cities utilizing participatory health research.
Methods
Participants were recruited by peer researchers. Levels of knowledge, information needs, and preferred methods of information dissemination were analyzed to inform future prevention planning. Additionally, we analyzed sexual behavior and other risk factors for contracting HIV and STIs. The results may facilitate the formulation of targeted prevention messages in the future.
Results
We included 2,432 participants in the analysis. General knowledge about HIV was adequate, as 86.9% were aware of the presented information. Statements about HIV co-infections were prior knowledge for 53.4% of the participants and about German HIV policies and HIV testing for 54.7%. Knowledge about other STIs differed, ranging from 69.6% who have ever heard of gonorrhea to 23.8% who have ever heard of genital warts. Groups with particular knowledge gaps were i) younger misSA, ii) recent migrants, iii) misSA without regular access to the German health care system, iv) misSA of lower socioeconomic status, and v) misSA with Muslim religious affiliation. The majority of participants reported information needs (72.8%), and 71.3% wanted to obtain this information from health professionals. Male misSA were more likely to report five or more sexual partners compared to females. Less than half of participants reported always using condoms with non-steady sexual partners (46.8%). Reasons for not using condoms differed between males and females. A considerable proportion of females (16.3%) and males (6.8%) experienced sexualized violence. More than one fourth of women (26.9%) were affected by female genital mutilation/cutting.
Discussion
Future prevention planning should focus on sub-groups with particular knowledge gaps, recognizing their preferred methods of information dissemination. Prevention messages for male misSA should focus on their own risk perception and for female misSA on empowerment, e.g. to negotiate condom use.
Citation: Koschollek C, Kuehne A, Müllerschön J, Amoah S, Batemona-Abeke H, Dela Bursi T, et al. (2020) Knowledge, information needs and behavior regarding HIV and sexually transmitted infections among migrants from sub-Saharan Africa living in Germany: Results of a participatory health research survey. PLoS ONE 15(1): e0227178. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0227178
Editor: Joel Msafiri Francis, University of the Witwatersrand, SOUTH AFRICA
Received: December 20, 2018; Accepted: December 13, 2019; Published: January 27, 2020
Copyright: © 2020 Koschollek et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Data Availability: All data used in this study are available for download from the Zenodo repository (https://zenodo.org/record/3601477#.XiH2E8hKhaQ).
Funding: The study was funded by the German Ministry of Health. The funding was granted to the Robert Koch Institute, Berlin, dated August 13, 2014 for the study "KABP (knowledge, attitudes, behaviour and practices)-study with optional HIV/STI-testing among migrants from sub-Saharan Africa living in Germany (MisSA-study)". The funds are budgeted in the federal budget 2014, chapter 1502, title 68618 - Research and projects for identification and elimination of AIDS and other sexual transmitted infections, project lead: Claudia Santos-Hövener, Grant number: ZMVI5-2514-AUK-001. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Background
HIV and STIs among migrants from sub-Saharan Africa living in Germany
Globally, 36.7 million people were living with HIV in 2016 according to UNAIDS; two in three of these people were living in sub-Saharan Africa (69.5%) [1]. In the same year, 14.4% of reported cases from 30 EU/EEA countries originated from sub-Saharan Africa [2].
In Germany, 3,419 new HIV diagnoses were reported to the Robert Koch Institute (RKI) in 2016, and 3,235 notifications included information on country of origin; of these, 14.9% were migrants from sub-Saharan Africa (n = 483) [3]. The HIV epidemic in Germany is concentrated within sub-populations, mostly affecting men having sex with men. However, the transmission route for every fourth diagnosis in 2016 was heterosexual transmission, and among these 51.8% originated from sub-Saharan Africa [3]. The majority of these cases acquired the infection in sub-Saharan Africa (68.5%), whereas 6.3% of the infections were most likely contracted in Germany [3]. However, the literature suggests substantial underreporting of the host country as the country of HIV infection [4–8]. It was estimated that 88,400 people were living with HIV in Germany in 2016, including 6,400 migrants from sub-Saharan Africa (7.2%) who acquired their infection outside of Germany [9]. Between 2014 and 2016, 789 AIDS cases were voluntarily reported to the RKI by medical HIV specialists in Germany [3]. Among these, 13% of cases originated from sub-Saharan Africa [3]. Although the presented data on HIV is limited, as no baseline data regarding HIV tests conducted within a year exist, the data suggest a high vulnerability of migrants from sub-Saharan Africa for contracting HIV abroad but also in Germany [3, 10].
Estimates on the incidence or prevalence of sexually transmitted infections (STIs) among migrants from sub-Saharan Africa in Germany do not exist. Migrants from sub-Saharan Africa accounted for only a small proportion of 0.3% of reported cases of syphilis in Germany between 2002 and 2013 [11].
Migrants with a citizenship of a sub-Saharan African country represent only a small proportion of 0.4% of the population in Germany [12,13]. Even though this figure does not include migrants originating from sub-Saharan Africa with German citizenship or with an undocumented legal status, the ratio of HIV diagnoses or people living with HIV and population size is much higher than that of the general population. Therefore, migrants from sub-Saharan Africa are disproportionately affected by HIV in Germany, and surveillance and prevention in this population are particularly important.
From behavioral surveillance to community-based participatory health research
Surveillance data as well as previous research suggest that migrants from sub-Saharan Africa in Germany are more likely to be diagnosed and treated at a later stage of HIV than persons of German origin [2, 8, 14]. Lack of knowledge about transmission routes or limited access to health services as well as fear and stigma might play a role for ongoing HIV transmissions and might be, next to others, reasons for late presentation. The World Health Organization (WHO) and the European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control (ECDC) recommend complementing routine HIV and STI surveillance data with indicator-based data on behavior and practices to understand the driving factors behind the epidemiological situation [15–19].
Surveys on knowledge, attitudes, behaviors, and practices (KABP) regarding HIV and STIs for the general population do not include migrants from sub-Saharan Africa sufficiently [20]. Other European countries such as the UK facing the same challenges started to actively involve the target population in planning and conducting the study within population based surveys [21–23], as recommended by the WHO and the ECDC [16, 17]. Community-based participatory health research (CBPHR) involves community members from the beginning of study planning, during study implementation up to interpretation of results, as well as in the development of recommendations [24–29]. So far in Germany, only small CBPHR surveys among migrants from sub-Saharan Africa have been carried out on the local level [24, 30, 31].
Thus, we utilized CBPHR, involving members of African communities; stakeholders in HIV prevention, counseling and testing; and researchers in the fields of HIV for the development and piloting of the study design. Both are described elsewhere [32, 33]. In 2014, we started the cross-sectional, full-scale study to identify KABP regarding HIV and STIs among migrants from sub-Saharan Africa in six German cities and regions to facilitate the development of targeted interventions for African communities in Germany.
Objectives
Within this paper, we aim i) to describe the level of knowledge about HIV and STIs among migrants from sub-Saharan Africa living in Germany and ii) to determine sub-groups with particular knowledge gaps. Furthermore, we describe iii) information needs and preferred methods of information dissemination in order to inform future prevention planning. Additionally, we aim iv) to describe behavioral patterns and other risk factors, that is, sexualized violence and female genital mutilation/cutting (FGM/C), that are associated with higher risks of contracting HIV and STIs, in order to facilitate the formulation of targeted prevention messages for migrants from sub-Saharan Africa living in Germany.
Methodology
Study design and sampling procedures
We conducted a cross-sectional survey among migrants from sub-Saharan Africa living in Germany on KABP regarding HIV, viral hepatitis (HEP), and other STIs. Participants were recruited by trained peer researchers, that is, members of local African communities, in six German cities and regions. Study cities were chosen according to the number of migrants with citizenship of a sub-Saharan African country who were officially registered in the respective city or region at the end of 2013 according to foreigners’ statistics, including Munich, the Rhine-Ruhr region, Cologne, Berlin, Frankfurt am Main, and the region of Hanover. In every city, we collaborated with a local partner organization that was responsible for research operations, that is, recruiting of a local study coordinator and peer researchers as well as the organization of different meetings for process evaluation.
Data collection took place successively in the different study cities between January 2015 and May 2016. To carry out data collection, the partner organization, the RKI, and peer researchers from either the pilot study or from former study cities trained peer researchers of the subsequent study city in a two-day training on research ethics, study goals, the questionnaire, HIV, HEP, STIs, and recruitment strategies. After training, the peer researchers started recruitment at locations that were identified in community mapping during the training (e.g., churches, mosques, shops, associations, sports clubs) using convenience sampling. After obtaining verbal consent by participants, they either handed out the paper-based questionnaires for self-completion or carried out face-to-face or telephone interviews. Participants chose their preferred mode of administration; peer researchers used the same questionnaire for conducting an interview or self-completion. Questionnaires were available in German, English, and French; in addition, peer researchers were proficient in several African languages, such as Swahili, Lingala, or Twi. Questionnaires were sent back to the RKI in post-paid envelopes. We compared gender and countries of birth of recruited participants to data of official foreigners’ statistics [34] on a weekly basis and provided weekly feedback to the partner organization and peer researchers. This was done to steer recruitment in order to firstly reach the larger communities regarding countries of origin and an appropriate gender ratio corresponding to official statistics and secondly to create heterogeneity regarding other sociodemographic characteristics, such as in terms of different religious affiliations or different health insurance statuses. We made rigorous attempts to reach a heterogeneous sample, and encouraged peer researchers to recruit more people of possibly underrepresented groups. Details on the study design and sampling can be found elsewhere [35, 36]. Full ethical clearance was granted by the Ethical Committee at the medical school of Charité, Berlin, in November 2014 (EA4/105/14).
Questionnaire and measurements
The questionnaire included indicators for behavioral surveillance in migrant and ethnic minority populations recommended by the ECDC [17]. It consisted of questions on sociodemographic characteristics; knowledge about HIV, HEP, and STIs; testing for these infections; sexual behavior and other risk factors in terms of contracting HIV, HEP, and STIs; behavior towards people living with HIV and self-reported information needs; and preferred methods of information dissemination (see [35] for a full list of indicators). The questions were partially adapted from a survey used within the BASS-Line study in the UK with migrants from sub-Saharan Africa [22] and partially developed by the working group. Within this paper, we focus on knowledge about HIV and STIs, including self-reported information needs and preferred methods of information dissemination, as well as on sexual behavior and other risk factors, as presented in Table 1.
Knowledge about HIV was determined by presenting true statements and participants were asked if they knew the information before (e.g. “Aids is caused by a virus called HIV” with the answer categories “I knew this already”, “I was not sure if that was true or not”, “I didn’t know this”, and “I do not understand this statement”). Knowledge about other STIs was ascertained by the question “Which of the sexually transmitted diseases have you heard about apart from HIV?”.
Data analysis
All data were entered into the VOXCO interviewer web™, an online survey and data collection software. Data entry was checked by a second person at the RKI. After data cleaning, data analysis was performed using Stata version 14.
The calculated sample size for all six study cities and regions was 3,009 participants; calculations are described elsewhere [35].
Questionnaires were eligible for inclusion in the study if there were no missing or ambiguous answers regarding sex, whether at least one of the participants’ parents was born in a sub-Saharan African country, and at least 60% of the questionnaire was filled in.
Questionnaires were excluded from analysis for all participants i) not born in a sub-Saharan African country or with missing or ambiguous answers regarding their country of birth, as well as ii) those reporting living in Germany since birth or with missing or ambiguous answers regarding their length of stay in Germany. We also excluded iii) participants with missing or ambiguous answers in at least one of the categories of age or education.
For the descriptive analysis of the study population, we used chi-squared tests to examine differences between males and females in terms of sociodemographic characteristics. Differences in medians were analysed using Mann Whitney-U tests.
To analyze knowledge about HIV, statements were summarized in three sections–general knowledge about HIV, knowledge about co-infections, and knowledge about German HIV policies and HIV testing–as displayed in Table 1. The five STIs were also summarized and are reported under the section regarding knowledge about STIs. In the following analyses, we calculated the aggregated number of positive answers (“I knew this already” vs. all other answers for HIV and “I have already heard of this STI” vs. all other answers) per section. We used a logistic two-level model with random effects, that is, participants on the first level and their answers on the second level. Models for multivariable analysis (MVA) were developed using forward regression and thus stepwise integration of characteristics that proved to be significant in univariable analysis (UVA) using a significance level of p ≤ 0.05. Adjusted odds ratios (aOR) and 95% confidence intervals (CI) were calculated. We included gender next to (sociodemographic) variables that were significant in UVA in all four sections: age, educational level, length of stay in Germany, German language proficiency, monthly net income, health insurance status and religious affiliation.
Self-reported information needs were analyzed descriptively. Preferred methods of information dissemination were grouped as displayed in Table 1. To detect differences between sub-groups, UVA was performed; unadjusted odds ratios (OR) and 95% CI were calculated.
Indicators describing sexual behavior and sexualized violence were stratified by sex. The numbers of male and female sexual partners were aggregated to the total number of sexual partners. Unadjusted OR and 95% CI were calculated to examine differences in behavioral and risk patterns between males and females. Within the group of women, we stratified FGM/C by age, educational level, length of stay in Germany, health insurance status, and religious affiliation, and we calculated unadjusted OR and 95% CI to identify factors associated with FGM/C.
Results
Study population
We received 3,178 questionnaires at the RKI, of which 3,040 were eligible for inclusion in the study; 48 were excluded due to incompleteness, and in 90 questionnaires there was missing information on sex and/or the sub-Saharan African country of birth of at least one parent. After excluding participants for their i) country of birth (n = 329), ii) length of stay in Germany (n = 67), and iii) age and/or education (n = 212) as described above, the final sample size was 2,432 participants.
Sociodemographic characteristics
Of the total sample, 45.5% were female, the median age was 32 years, and the median length of stay in Germany was nine years. Females and males differed markedly in terms of age, educational level, length of stay in Germany, monthly net income, health insurance status, and religious affiliation (Table 2). Good or very good German language proficiency was reported by 47.8% of the participants. Participants were born in 43 different sub-Saharan African countries; the main countries of birth were Ghana (13.9%), Nigeria (13.6%), and Cameroon (11.7%).
Knowledge about HIV
Of all the participants, 86.9% had knowledge of the eight general statements on HIV. The least known was the information that there is no cure for HIV infection (80.7%), while the information that HIV can be transmitted through sexual intercourse was known most frequently (94.9%). MVA showed associations between general knowledge about HIV and health insurance status, age, educational level, German language proficiency, religious affiliation, monthly net income, and length of stay in Germany (Table 3).
Both statements on HIV co-infections were known by 53.4% of the participants. Of all the participants, 55.6% knew that people with HIV have an increased risk of contracting tuberculosis, and 52.2% knew that people who have an STI have an increased risk of contracting HIV. In MVA, age, educational level, religious affiliation, German language proficiency, and length of stay in Germany were associated with knowledge about HIV co-infections (Table 3).
Both statements about German HIV policies and HIV testing were known by 54.7% of the participants. Of all the participants, 56.2% knew that Africans cannot be deported from Germany just for having HIV, and 53.2% knew that one can get tested for HIV anonymously and for free at the local Public Health Departments. Factors associated with knowledge about German HIV policies and HIV testing in MVA were length of stay in Germany, age, religious affiliation, educational level, and German language proficiency (Table 4).
Knowledge about STIs
While gonorrhoea (69.6%) and syphilis (65.8%) were known by the majority of the participants, herpes (37.0%), chlamydia (25.0%), and genital warts (23.8%) were less likely to be known. Overall, 14.4% of participants reported not knowing any of the presented STIs. In MVA, knowledge about STIs was associated with educational level, age, health insurance status, monthly net income, religious affiliation, sex, and German language proficiency (Table 4).
Information needs and methods of information dissemination
Overall, 72.8% of participants indicated a need for more information about HIV and STIs (n = 1,771). Participants younger than 36 years of age were less likely to state information needs (18–25 vs. 36–45 years: 71.2% vs. 77.8%; OR = 0.71; 95% CI: 0.54–0.93 | 26–35 vs. 36–45 years: 72.2% vs. 77.8%; OR = 0.74; 95% CI: 0.58–0.94). Other sociodemographic factors showed no impact.
Among those who wanted more information about HIV and STIs 1,728 indicated at least one topic. Most relevant was the risk of transmission of HEP (66.7%), followed by the risk of transmission of HIV (56.3%) and the risk of transmission of other STIs (53.5%). Further relevant topics were means of protection against HIV and STIs (44.1%), transmission risks of tuberculosis (42.0%), and about medical treatment for HIV and HEP (40.2%). Information about options to support people living with HIV (33.2%), testing and diagnostic options (28.8%), FGM/C (24.3%), and options to support family members of people living with HIV (22.3%) were less often reported.
At least one preferred method of information dissemination was stated by 1,712 participants who wanted to know more about HIV and STIs. The majority wanted to receive the information from health professionals (71.3%), followed by participation in a workshop (50.6%) and new media (47.6%); new media was more likely to be stated by younger participants and those with higher educational levels. Classic and print media (40.0%) and obtaining more information from the personal environment (29.3%) were less often reported; obtaining information from the personal environment was more likely to be reported by participants with lower educational levels (for more details, see S1 Table).
Sexual behavior and other risk factors
The majority of the participants reported having had sex, while 101 participants reported that they have never had sex before. Among those who have ever had sex, the majority also had sex within the last 12 months. Females were more likely to report sex with (one or more) steady sexual partner(s), while males more frequently reported having had sex with non-steady sexual partner(s); they were also more likely to report having had sex with steady and non-steady sexual partners (Table 5). Females were more likely to report having had sex with only one sexual partner, while males more frequently reported having had sex with more than five sexual partners within the last year (Table 5).
Of those who had sex with non-steady sexual partners in the last 12 months, less than half reported that they always used condoms. Among all participants who ever had sex, less than half of males and less than one third of females reported that they used a condom during their last intercourse (Table 5). Participants provided different reasons for not using condoms; females were more likely to state that they were faithful to their partner, their partner did not want to use condoms, or that they wanted to get pregnant. Males were more likely to state that they would not use condoms as they “wanted to feel their partner”. Males were more likely to state that they always use condoms (Table 5).
Sexualized violence was experienced by 16.3% of women (168/1,029) and 6.6% of males (82/1,237). Females most often had experienced sexualized violence in their country of origin, while males most often reported having experienced sexualized violence in Germany (Table 5).
FGM/C was reported by 26.9% of women (281/1,044). Women with Muslim religious affiliation, without regular health insurance, and with a shorter length of stay in Germany and lower educational levels were more likely to be affected (Table 5).
Discussion
Utilizing community-based participatory health research allowed us to recruit a heterogeneous sample of migrants from sub-Saharan Africa in six cities and regions in Germany. A total of 45.5% of the sample were female, which reflected the official data of German foreigners’ statistics in 2013, which reports 46% females with a citizenship of a sub-Saharan African country [34]. The three main countries of birth within our sample were Ghana, Nigeria, and Cameroon and they made a proportion of 39.2%. According to the foreigners’ statistics, citizenships of these countries accounted for 35.8% of all migrants with a citizenship of a sub-Saharan African country in Germany [34].
We found adequate levels of knowledge about general statements on HIV and knowledge gaps regarding HIV co-infections and about German HIV policies and HIV testing. Knowledge gaps were also found regarding STIs; common STIs such as chlamydia and genital warts were only known by one fourth of participants. In line with these results, the majority of participants stated information needs about HIV and STIs. In addition, we found more sexual risk behavior among male compared to female participants and considerable proportions of participants being affected by other risk factors for contracting HIV and STIs.
Knowledge about HIV and STIs and knowledge gaps among sub-groups
We identified sub-groups with particular knowledge gaps: i) migrants from sub-Saharan Africa of younger age, ii) recent migrants, iii) migrants from sub-Saharan Africa without regular access to the German health care system, iv) migrants from sub-Saharan Africa with lower socioeconomic status, and v) migrants from sub-Saharan Africa with Muslim religious affiliation.
We observed an association between younger age and lower levels of knowledge about HIV and STIs. This association is well described in previous studies conducted in sub-Saharan African countries and in the UK [37–41] and is common among the German general population as well [20]. Lower knowledge in younger age groups might be a result of the fact that knowledge accumulates with age. Lower German language proficiency was associated with lower knowledge about HIV in all three sections. If migrants do not bring this knowledge from their countries of origin, information about these topics for the general population might not be accessible for migrant groups, especially if language barriers exist [17]. Furthermore, shorter length of stay in Germany was associated with lower levels of knowledge regarding German HIV policies and HIV testing. And lower levels of knowledge were also found among those without regular access to the German health care system. This group includes asylum seekers who need a medical treatment voucher from social welfare offices and those with an undocumented legal status, whom we might have captured by the proxy of having no health insurance at all. Knowledge gaps might exist due to challenges other than HIV that may play a more important role in the lives of people having recently migrated to or seeking asylum in Germany, that is, their residence status or the need to find work. Especially for migrants with an undocumented legal status, the fear of deportation and the associated stress [42] can be an important barrier in seeking information about HIV prevention. Correlations between lower knowledge about HIV and STIs and lower levels of education and income are widely described in the literature [39, 41, 43–46] and were also found within our study. Information about HIV and STIs might be accessed and comprehended more easily by people with higher educational levels. For those with lower income, issues other than HIV and STIs might be the main focus of their lives. In addition, we found lower levels of knowledge about HIV and STIs among Muslim participants, similar to the UK [23]. Lack of knowledge about HIV and STIs remains a challenge that needs to be addressed in communities where sexual behavior is seen as a private matter that is not talked about, which often is the case in many Muslim communities [47, 48].
Reaching sub-groups with information about HIV and STIs
The preferred methods of information dissemination among all participants were medical professionals and counseling centers. This supports the necessity of a smooth and efficient integration into the general health care system for all migrants irrespective of their health insurance status [49] to ensure the dissemination of important information [50,51] and linkage to testing and care [52,53]. Political solutions are necessary to tackle this issue, such as by granting full access to the health care system for asylum seekers, by prohibiting reporting to the foreigners’ registration offices when migrants without residence permit seek care, or by the introduction of anonymous medical cards given out by clearing houses and financed by emergency funds [54]. The second most often reported method of obtaining information about HIV and STIs was workshops. Offering these in shared accommodations for asylum seekers could be an effective way of knowledge dissemination, as recent migrants showed less knowledge. Workshops should be offered in different languages to also reach those with lower German language proficiency, who showed knowledge gaps within our study. Participants, especially younger ones, also wished to obtain information about HIV and STIs via new media, which might reflect their higher affection to new media. Younger participants showed less knowledge but less often expressed information needs, which might indicate a reduced perception of being at risk. However, by using new media, that is, mhealth channels for prevention they might be reached as well. Promising approaches of sending prevention messages regarding HIV and STIs on youths’ cell phones from Australia [55] or the US [56, 57] could be adapted for Germany, to address youth and particularly migrant youth. Although getting informed about HIV and STIs through the personal environment was less often stated by participants, future involvement of peer researchers in doing prevention work in their communities might be a useful way to reach those who do not actively seek information about HIV and STIs, such as through visiting workshops or counseling centers. In Germany there are already some model HIV prevention projects working with members of African communities [24, 58–60]. This could be put into general practice for HIV prevention with migrant communities. Additionally, discussing HIV in the communities increases the likelihood of getting tested [53]. The involvement of religious leaders in prevention planning might also be a promising approach to de-stigmatize topics related to HIV infections [47, 61]. A successful HIV prevention program under the involvement of pastors that is being established in African churches in Germany could be adapted and implemented in mosques [58, 60].
Sexual behavior and other risk factors
Males showed higher levels of sexual risk behavior than females. These results are consistent with our findings from the pilot study [33] and with those from other European studies [22, 23, 62–64]. Comparable data on sexual risk behavior within the German general population are scarce. One study found more concurrent sexual contacts for males, although in this study the majority had reported consistent condom use with non-steady sexual partners (82%) [65].
Reasons for not using condoms differed between males and females, and our findings suggest difficulties in negotiating condom use for females, which might be a result of male dominance. This is supported by two reviews on studies conducted internationally and in sub-Saharan African countries, respectively, which found that gender inequality, gender norms, and associated difficulties to talk about sexuality make it challenging for women to insist on condom use [66, 67]. Studies have shown that the experience of sexualized violence, especially within partnerships, may further hinder women from insisting on condom use as they might fear further violence [68, 69].
Being affected by sexualized violence was reported by more than 10% of study participants. The occurrence of sexualized violence in armed conflicts is widely described [70, 71] and might have been the case for participants in our study, who reported to have experienced sexualized violence in their countries of origin. Moreover, inequalities, which might lead to dependencies within partnerships, may also lead to sexualized violence [69, 72]. This might be the case for those who reported to have experienced sexualized violence in Germany. The finding that male migrants from sub-Saharan Africa most often have had experienced sexualized violence in Germany should be further investigated.
Overall, our results call for gender-sensitive prevention strategies focused on the reduction of sexual risk behavior among males and empowerment for women in sexual relationships.
Limitations
Some limitations have to be taken into account when interpreting our findings. Due to convenience sampling and uncertainties regarding the composition of African communities in Germany, our results might not be representative for all migrants from sub-Saharan Africa living in Germany, and there surely is a selection bias. Requirements for statistical measurements like OR may therefore not be completely fulfilled, and proportions as well as CI may reflect tendencies rather than statistical truth. However, with regards to gender and country of birth, our sample reflects well the official data [34]. We were able to include more migrants from sub-Saharan Africa with lower educational levels than was possible in other European studies [22, 23, 64]; thus, our results may include less educational bias. In terms of other sociodemographic characteristics, steering recruitment allowed us to obtain a heterogeneous sample.
Using true statements to capture knowledge about HIV and STIs may have led to an overestimation of knowledge. For us and our collaborating partners, it was more important to use the study as an intervention that increases knowledge, as migrants from sub-Saharan Africa taking part in the survey may not be reached by future interventions.
Social desirability bias may have led to an overestimation of knowledge, especially in interviews, and also might have influenced answers in the section on sexual behavior. We controlled for the mode of survey administration but did not find any evidence suggesting social desirability or information bias might have impacted the results. Recall bias might have influenced answers in the section on sexual behavior as well, and participants, for example, might have over- or underestimated the number of sexual partners they have had within the last 12 months. Another limiting factor in our study on sexual health is that we did not ask for sexual orientation, as our collaborating partners recommended us not to do so.
Another limiting factor was the availability of the questionnaire in only three languages, which might have led to exclusion of potential participants who did not want to answer the questions in a face-to-face or telephone interview but were not proficient in one of these languages.
Conclusion
Utilizing CBPHR enabled us to identify knowledge gaps regarding HIV and STIs within a heterogeneous sample of migrants from sub-Saharan Africa living in six German cities and regions; additionally, we found sexual risk behavior especially among male participants and different risk factors for contracting HIV and STIs among female migrants from sub-Saharan Africa such as difficulties in negotiating condom use and sexualized violence. Groups with particular knowledge gaps were i) younger migrants from sub-Saharan Africa, ii) recent migrants, iii) those without regular access to the German health care system, iv) migrants from sub-Saharan Africa with lower socioeconomic status, and iv) those with Muslim religious affiliation. These groups should be addressed with targeted interventions, taking into account their preferred methods of information dissemination, that is, medical professionals and counseling centers. Young migrants from sub-Saharan Africa could be reached via mhealth channels. Male participants reported sexual risk behavior more frequently than females, and prevention messages for male migrants from sub-Saharan Africa should focus on their own risk perception. For female migrants from sub-Saharan Africa, prevention messages should focus on empowerment to enhance their ability to, for example, negotiate condom use. In the context of ongoing global migration, future prevention and intervention planning for migrants from sub-Saharan Africa living in Germany should consider the findings of our study and specifically target migrant groups most at risk.
Supporting information
S1 Table. Univariable analyses: Preferred methods of information dissemination stratified by sociodemographic characteristics of the participants of the misSA study in Germany, 2014–2016, n = 1,712.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0227178.s001
(DOC)
Acknowledgments
The authors first of all would like to thank the peer researchers; without their engagement, this study would not have been possible. We would also like to thank our collaborating partner organizations as well as the members of the working group for supporting this project and giving us advice in developing and conducting this study: Robert Akpabli, Alphonsine Bakambamba, Johann Fontaine, Tanja Gangarova, Line Göttke, Silke Gräser, Holger Hanck, Hans Hengelein, Silke Klumb, Gesa Kupfer, Elizabeth Lolo, Clement Matweta, Pierre Mayamba, Rosaline M’Bayo, Brigitte Menze, Hapsatou Oudini, Omer Idrissa Ouedraogo, Gerhard Peters, Katja Römer, Antje Sanogo, Ute Schwartz, Nozomi Spennemann, Ursula von Rüden, Hella von Unger, Mara Wiebe, and Michael Wright. We also thank Matthias an der Heiden for the sample size calculation and giving us statistical advice. Finally we want to thank all participants who took the time to take part in this survey.
References
- 1.
UNAIDS Joint United Nations Programme on HIV/AIDS, UNAIDS Data 2017. Geneva, Switzerland; 2017.
- 2.
European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control and World Health Organization Regional Office for Europe, HIV/Aids surveillance in Europe 2017, 2016 data. Solna, Sweden & Copenhagen, Denmark; 2017.
- 3. Robert Koch-Institut. HIV-Jahresbericht 2016. Epidemiologisches Bulletin. 2017; 39: 431–453.
- 4. Rice BD, Elford J, Yin Z, Delpech VC. A new method to assign country of HIV infection among heterosexuals born abroad and diagnosed with HIV. AIDS. 2012; 26(15): 1961–1966. pmid:22781226
- 5. Fakoya I, Alvarez-del Arco D, Woode-Owusu M, Monge S, Rivero-Montesdeoca Y, Delpech V, et al. A systematic review of post-migration acquisition of HIV among migrants from countries with generalised HIV epidemics living in Europe: implications for effectively managing HIV prevention programmes and policy. BMC Public Health. 2015; 15: 561. pmid:26085030
- 6. Alvarez-del Arco D, Fakoya I, Thomadakis C, Pantazis N, Touloumi G, Gennotte AF, et al. High levels of postmigration HIV acquisition within nine European countries. AIDS. 2017; 31(14): 1979–1988. pmid:28857779
- 7.
European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control. Sexual transmission of HIV within migrant groups in the EU/EEA and implications for effective interventions. Solna, Sweden; 2013.
- 8. Zeitlmann N, Gunsenheimer-Bartmeyer B, Santos-Hövener C, Kollan C, an der Heiden M; ClinSurv Study group. CD4-cell counts and presence of AIDS in HIV-positive patients entering specialized care—a comparison of migrant groups in the German ClinSurv HIV Cohort Study, 1999–2013. BMC Infectious Diseases. 2016; 16(1): 739. pmid:27927190
- 9. an der Heiden M, Marcus U, Kollan C, Schmidt D, Voß L, Gunsenheimer-Bartmeyer B, et al. Schätzung der Zahl der HIV-Neuinfektionen und der Gesamtzahln von Menschen mit HIV in Deutschland, Stand Ende 2016. Epidemiologisches Bulletin. 2017; 47: 531–545.
- 10. Robert Koch-Institut. HIV bei Migranten in Deutschland. Epidemiologisches Bulletin. 2012; 3: 19–21.
- 11. Kuehne A, Fiebig L, Jansen K, Koschollek C, Santos-Hövener C. [Migration and infectious disease surveillance in Germany: Analyses of Tuberculosis, HIV and Syphilis surveillance data]. Bundesgesundheitsblatt—Gesundheitsforschung–Gesundheitsschutz. 2015; 1–9.
- 12.
Statistisches Bundesamt (Destatis), Ausländer: Kreise, Stichtag, Geschlecht, Ländergruppierungen/Staatsangehörigkeit (12521–0041). Wiesbaden, Germany: Statistisches Bundesamt (Destatis); 2016.
- 13.
Statistisches Bundesamt (Destatis), Bevölkerung: Deutschland, Stichtag (12411–0001). Wiesbaden, Germany: Statistisches Bundesamt (Destatis); 2016.
- 14. Hernando V, Alvárez-del Arco D, Alejos B, Monge S, Amato-Gauci AJ, Noori T, et al. HIV infection in migrant populations in the European Union and European Economic Area in 2007–2012: an epidemic on the move. Journal of Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndromes. 2015; 70(2): 204–211. pmid:26068723
- 15. Rehle T, Lazzari S, Dallabetta G, Asamoah-Odei E. Second-generation HIV surveillance: better data for decision-making. Bulletin of the World Health Organization. 2004; 82(2): 121–127. pmid:15042234
- 16.
World Health Organization and UNAIDS Joint United Nations Programme on HIV/AIDS. Guidelines for Second Generation HIV Surveillance. Geneva, Switzerland; 2000.
- 17.
European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control. Technical Report: Mapping of HIV/STI behavioural surveillance in Europe. Stockholm, Sweden; 2009.
- 18. Garnett GP, Garcia-Calleja JM, Rehle T, Gregson S. Behavioural data as an adjunct to HIV surveillance data. Sexually Transmitted Infections. 2006; 82(suppl 1): i57–i62. pmid:16581762
- 19. Zaba B, Slaymaker E, Urassa M, Boerma JT. The role of behavioral data in HIV surveillance. AIDS. 2005; 19: S39–S52. pmid:15930840
- 20.
Bundeszentrale für Gesundheitliche Aufklärung. Aids im öffentlichen Bewusstsein der Bundesrepublik Deutschland 2007. Wissen, Einstellungen und Verhalten zum Schutz vor Aids. Cologne, Germany; 2008.
- 21. Fenton KA, Chinouya M, Davidson O, Copas A; MAYISHA study team. HIV testing and high risk sexual behaviour among London's migrant African communities: a participatory research study. Sexually Transmitted Infections. 2002; 78(4): 241–245. pmid:12181459
- 22.
Dodds C, Hickson F, Weatherburn P, Reid D, Hammond G, Jessup K, et al. BASS Line 2007 survey: Assessing the sexual HIV prevention needs of African people in England. London, UK; 2008.
- 23.
Hickson F, Owuor J, Weatherburn P, Reid D, Hammond G, Jessup K. Bass Line 2008–09: assessing the sexual HIV prevention needs of African people in England. London, UK; 2009.
- 24.
von Unger H, Gangarova T. PaKoMi Handbook, HIV Prevention for & with migrants. Berlin, Germany; 2012.
- 25.
International Collaboration for Participatory Health Research (ICPHR). Position Paper 1: What is Participatory Health Research? Version Mai 2013. Berlin, Germany; 2013.
- 26.
Minkler M, Wallerstein N, editors. Community Based Participatory Research for Health. San Francisco: Jossey; 2003.
- 27. Wright MT, Block M, von Unger H. Stufen der Partizipation in der Gesundheitsförderung: Ein Modell zur Beurteilung von Beteiligung. Infodienst für Gesundheitsförderung. 2007; 3: 4–5.
- 28. von Unger H. Participatory Health Research with Immigrant Communities in Germany. International Journal of Action Research. 2012; 8(3): 266–287.
- 29. Leung MW, Yen IH, Minkler M. Community based participatory research: a promising approach for increasing epidemiology's relevance in the 21st century. International Journal of Epidemiology. 2004; 33(3): 499–506. pmid:15155709
- 30.
Gräser S, Krischke N, Wohlrab C. HIV/AIDS-Prävention und Versorgung für Migrantinnen und Migranten aus Sub-Sahara Afrika. Eine Pilotstudie zur Evaluation des ‚Afrika-Projekts’ des Gesundheitsamtes Bremen. Bremen, Germany; 2009.
- 31. Koch-Göppert G, Gräser S, Krischke N. [Barriers and Ressources in Utilisation of HIV-Prevention Services for African Migrants]. Gesundheitswesen. 2015; 77(S 01): S33–S4. pmid:23970392
- 32. Santos-Hövener C, Marcus U, Koschollek C, Oudini H, Wiebe M, Ouedraogo OI, et al. [Designing a study on sexual health with Africans living in Germany—A participatory process]. Prävention und Gesundheitsförderung. 2015; 10: 68.
- 33. Santos-Hövener C, Marcus U, Koschollek C, Oudini H, Wiebe M, Ouedraogo OI, et al. Determinants of HIV, viral hepatitis and STI prevention needs among African migrants in Germany; a cross-sectional survey on knowledge, attitudes, behaviors and practices. BMC Public Health. 2015; 15:753. pmid:26246382
- 34.
Statistisches Bundesamt (Destatis). Ausländer: Kreise, Stichtag, Geschlecht, Ländergruppierungen/Staatsangehörigkeit (12521–0041). Wiesbaden, Germany: Statistisches Bundesamt (Destatis); 2013.
- 35. Santos-Hövener C, Koschollek C, Kuehne A, Thorlie A, Bremer V. Knowledge, Attitude, Behavior, and Practices Regarding HIV, Viral Hepatitis, and Sexually Transmitted Infections Among Migrants From Sub-Saharan Africa Living in Germany: A Multicenter Survey Protocol. JMIR Research Protocols. 2017; 6(5): e80. pmid:28465279
- 36. Koschollek C, Kuehne A, Amoah S, Batemona-Abeke H, Dela Bursi T, Mayamba P, et al. From peer to peer: Reaching migrants from sub-Saharan Africa with research on sexual health utilizing community-based participatory health research. Survey Methods: Insights from the Field. 2019; Retrieved from: https://surveyinsights.org/?p = 10812.
- 37.
United Nations Children's Fund. Opportunity in Crisis: Preventing HIV from early adolescence to young adulthood. New York, USA; 2011.
- 38. Zuma K, Shisana O, Rehle TM, Simbayi LC, Jooste S, Zungu N, et al. New insights into HIV epidemic in South Africa: key findings from the National HIV Prevalence, Incidence and Behaviour Survey, 2012. African Journal of AIDS Research. 2016; 15(1): 67–75. pmid:27002359
- 39. Oginni AB, Adebajo SB, Ahonsi BA. Trends and Determinants of Comprehensive Knowledge of HIV among Adolescents and Young Adults in Nigeria: 2003–2013. African Journal of Reproductive Health. 2017; 21(2): 26–34. pmid:29624937
- 40. Wagner AD, Mugo C, Bluemer-Miroite S, Mutiti PM, Wamalwa DC, Bukusi D, et al. Continuous quality improvement intervention for adolescent and young adult HIV testing services in Kenya improves HIV knowledge. AIDS. 2017; 31(S3): S243–252. pmid:28665882
- 41.
Bourne A, Reid D, Weatherburn P. African Health & Sex Survey 2013–2014: Headline findings. London, UK; 2014.
- 42. Kuehne A, Huschke S, Bullinger M. Subjective health of undocumented migratns in Germany—a mixed mehrods approach. BMC Public Health. 2015; 15: 926. pmid:26386952
- 43. Cicciò L, Sera D. Assessing the knowledge and behavior towards HIV/AIDS among youth in Northern Uganda: a cross-sectional survey. Giornale Italiano di Medicina Tropicale. 2010; 15(1/4): 29–34.
- 44. Glick P, Randriamamonjy J, Sahn DE. Determinants of HIV knowledge and condom use among women in Madagascar: an analysis using matched household and community data. African Development Review. 2009; 21(1): 147–179.
- 45. Dimbuene ZT, Defo BK. Fostering accurate HIV/AIDS knowledge among unmarried youths in Cameroon: Do family environment and peers matter? BMC Public Health. 2011; 11(1): 348. pmid:21595931
- 46. Oljira L, Berhane Y, Worku A. Assessment of comprehensive HIV/AIDS knowledge level among in‐school adolescents in eastern Ethiopia. Journal of the International AIDS Society. 2013; 16(1): 17349. pmid:23517715
- 47. Hasnain M. Cultural Approach to HIV/AIDS Harm Reduction in Muslim Countries. Harm Reduction Journal. 2005; 2: 23. pmid:16253145
- 48. Kamarulzaman A. Fighting the HIV epidemic in the Islamic world. The Lancet. 2013; 381(9883): 2058–2060.
- 49. Müllerschön J, Koschollek C, Santos-Hövener C, Kuehne A, Müller-Nordhorn J, Bremer V. Impact of health insurance status among migrants from sub-Saharan Africa on access to health care and HIV testing in Germany: a participatory cross-sectional survey. BMC International Health and Human Rights. 2019; 19(1): 10. pmid:30832665
- 50. Burns FM, Johnson AM, Nazroo J, Ainsworth J, Anderson J, Fakoya A, et al. Missed opportunities for earlier HIV diagnosis within primary and secondary healthcare settings in the UK. AIDS. 2008; 22(1): 115–22. pmid:18090399
- 51. Loos J, Manirankunda L, Hendrickx K, Remmen R, Nöstlinger C. HIV testing in primary care: feasibility and acceptability of provider initiated HIV testing and counseling for sub-Saharan African migrants. AIDS Education and Prevention. 2014; 26(1): 81–93. pmid:24450280
- 52. Castelli F, Sulis G. Migration and infectious diseases. Clinical Microbiology and Infection. 2017; 23(5): 283–289. pmid:28336382
- 53. Kuehne A, Koschollek C, Santos-Hövener C, Thorlie A, Müllerschön J, Mputu Tshibadi C, et al. Impact of HIV knowledge and stigma on the uptake of HIV testing–Results from a community-based participatory research survey among migrants from sub-Saharan Africa in Germany. PloS One. 2018; 13(4): e0194244. pmid:29641527
- 54. Suess A, Ruiz Pérez I, Ruiz Azarola A, March Cerdà JC. The right of access to health care for undocumented migrants: a revision of comparative analysis in the European context. European Journal of Public Health. 2014; 24(5): 712–720. pmid:24723691
- 55. Gold J, Lim MS, Hellard ME, Hocking JS, Keogh L. What's in a message? Delivering sexual health promotion to young people in Australia via text messaging. BMC Public Health. 2010; 10: 792. pmid:21190584
- 56. Levine D, McCright J, Dobkin L, Woodruff AJ, Klausner JD. SEXINFO: A Sexual Health Text Messaging Service for San Francisco Youth. American Journal of Public Health. 2008; 98(3): 393–395. pmid:18235068
- 57. Juzang I, Fortune T, Black S, Wright E, Bull S. A pilot programme using mobile phones for HIV prevention. Journal of Telemedicine and Telecare. 2011; 17(3): 150–153. pmid:21270049
- 58.
Deutsche AIDS-Hilfe e.V, editor. Your Health, Your Faith. Berlin, Germany; 2019.
- 59.
Deutsche AIDS-Hilfe e.V, editor. MuMM, Migrantinnen und Migranten als Multiplikator_innen für die HIV/STI-Prävention. Berlin, Germany; 2013.
- 60.
Deutsche AIDS-Hilfe e.V., editor. Aufsuchende Präventionsarbeit in afrikanischen Communities in Köln und im Umland. Berlin, Germany; 2007.
- 61. Abu‐Moghli F, Nabolsi M, Khalaf I, Suliman W. Islamic religious leaders’ knowledge and attitudes towards AIDS and their perception of people living with HIV/AIDS: a qualitative study. Scandinavian Journal of Caring Sciences. 2010; 24(4): 655–662. pmid:20409060
- 62. Loos J, Nöstlinger C, Vuylsteke B, Deblonde J, Ndungu M, Kint I, et al. First HIV prevalence estimates of a representative sample of adult sub-Saharan African migrants in a European city. Results of a community-based, cross-sectional study in Antwerp, Belgium. PLoS One. 2017; 12(4): e0174677. pmid:28380051
- 63. Sadler KE, McGarrigle CA, Elam G, Ssanyu-Sseruma W, Davidson O, Nichols T, et al. Sexual behaviour and HIV infection in black-Africans in England: results from the Mayisha II survey of sexual attitudes and lifestyles. Sexually Transmitted Infections. 2007; 83(7): 523–529. pmid:17932129
- 64.
Simonson T, Dubois-Arber F, Jeannin A, Bodenmann P, Bize R. Comportements face au VIH/sida parmi les migrants originaires d'Afrique subsaharienne en Suisse. Enquête ANSWER 2013–2014. Lausanne, Institut universitaire de médecine sociale et préventive, 2015. ISSN 1660-7104.
- 65. Haversath J, Gärttner KM, Kliem S, Vasterling I, Strauss B, Kröger C. Sexual Behavior in Germany: Results of a Representative Survey. Deutsches Ärzteblatt International. 2017; 114(33–34): 545–550. pmid:28855044
- 66. Maticka-Tyndale E. Condoms in sub-Saharan Africa. Sexual Health. 2012; 9(1): 59–72. pmid:22348634
- 67. Sarkar NN. Barriers to condom use. The European Journal of Contraception & Reproductive Health Care. 2008; 13(2): 114–122. pmid:18465472
- 68. Kalichman SC, Williams EA, Cherry C, Belcher L, Nachimson D. Sexual coercion, domestic violence, and negotiating condom use among low-income African American women. Journal of Women's Health. 1998; 7(3): 371–378. pmid:9580917
- 69. Swan H, O’Connell DJ. The impact of intimate partner violence on women’s condom negotiation efficacy. Journal of Interpersonal Violence. 2012; 27(4): 775–792. pmid:21987514
- 70.
Bastick M, Grimm K, Kunz R. Sexual Violance in Armed Conflict—Global Overview and Implications for the Security Sector. Geneva, Switzerland: Geneva Centre for the Democratic Control of Armed Forces; 2001.
- 71. Sivakumaran S. Sexual Violence Against Men in Armed Conflict. European Journal of International Law. 2007; 18(2): 253–276.
- 72. Jewkes R, Flood M, Lang J. From work with men and boys to changes of social norms and reduction of inequities in gender relations: a conceptual shift in prevention of violence against women and girls. Lancet. 2015; 385(9977): 1580–1589. pmid:25467578