The objective of this study was to evaluate the macronutrients composition, fatty acid and amino acid profiles, and essential minerals content of all vegan foods for dogs and cats available in the Brazilian market, and to compare results with FEDIAF (2019) and AAFCO (2019) recommendations. Four vegan pet foods were assessed (three for dogs and one for cats). The comparisons were made in a descriptive manner. All foods met the minimum recommendations for macronutrients. Arachidonic acid was not reported in any food label. Regarding the FEDIAF recommendations, one food for dogs had low calcium, another had low potassium and a third had low sodium. The cat food presented potassium content lower than recommended. The Ca:P ratio did not meet the minimum recommendation of FEDIAF (2019) and AAFCO (2019) in any of the dog’s foods analyzed, and the cat food also did not present the minimum recommendation based on FEDIAF (2019). Copper concentrations exceeded the legal limit in all foods. Zinc concentrations exceeded this limit in two foods (one for dogs and one for cats) and iron levels exceeded the legal limit in one dog food. One of the dog foods did not meet the minimum recommendation for methionine and the cat food did not meet the minimum recommendation for arginine. In addition, when the amount of nutrients consumed by animals with low energy requirements was simulated, in addition to the same non-conformities described above, it was observed that the cat food does not meet the minimum recommended of protein and taurine in unit/Kg0.67. It was concluded that all foods analyzed had one or more nutrients below the recommended levels and some presented zinc and copper excess, therefore, these foods should not be recommended for dogs and cats, because dietary deficiencies found may lead to health risks for dogs and cats. Furthermore, manufacturers should review their formulations to ensure the nutritional adequacy of these foods.
Citation: Zafalon RVA, Risolia LW, Vendramini THA, Ayres Rodrigues RB, Pedrinelli V, Teixeira FA, et al. (2020) Nutritional inadequacies in commercial vegan foods for dogs and cats. PLoS ONE 15(1): e0227046. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0227046
Editor: Nicoletta Righini, Universidad Nacional Autonoma de Mexico Instituto de Investigaciones en Ecosistemas y Sustentabilidad, MEXICO
Received: October 7, 2019; Accepted: December 10, 2019; Published: January 17, 2020
Copyright: © 2020 Zafalon et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Data Availability: All relevant data are within the manuscript and its Supporting Information files.
Funding: The author(s) received no specific funding for this work.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Veganism is considered a strict form of vegetarianism and involves practices other than changes in the dietary regimen. Adepts of this movement exclude meat, seafood, eggs, dairy products, and all other animal products from their diet. Among the reasons that lead to the adoption of this lifestyle are health concerns, sustainability/environmental preservation, empathy for animals and ethical concerns .
According to a survey, around 14% of Brazilians declare themselves as vegetarian or vegan and this number seems to be growing . The ethical appeal of veganism is also reflected in the search for foods that are free of animal origin ingredients for pets, which can have negative implications on animal health, especially in cats that are obligate carnivores. In spite of nutritional challenges, the number of supporters of pet vegan foods has increased , as well as the number of commercial diets of this segment commercially available.
Considering the physiology of dogs and cats, which classifies them respectively as facultative and obligate carnivores, the adequacy of vegetarian / vegan diets in supplying the minimum requirement of essential nutrients is questionable. The proper formulation of this type of food is a challenge since several of these nutrients are found mainly in ingredients of animal origin. A previous study found that only two out of 12 commercial vegetarian foods met the recommendations of the species for which they were intended .
The increase of adherents to veganism has stimulated the development of nutritionally complete and balanced plant-based diets that meet both the minimal nutritional requirements of dogs and cats, and vegan ethical constraints. Almost half of pet owners interested in providing plant-based diets seek more information to ensure the nutritional adequacy of these foods , which demonstrates their concern about the pet food quality. Nevertheless, only few studies have evaluated the composition of vegan foods or the impact of these diets on pet health. Thus, the objective of this study was to evaluate the macronutrient composition, fatty acids and amino acids profile, and essential minerals contents of vegan pet foods available in the Brazilian market, and to assess their compliance to recommended allowances for dogs and cats.
Material and methods
A survey was conducted to gather all vegan commercial dry extruded pet foods registered in Brazil. First, the key words “vegan” and “pet food” were used to search all foods that fit into this category in the Brazilian ministry of agriculture database. Next, a telephone survey with the major pet food distributors in the country was carried out to confirm these foods were available. Based on this survey, there were only four dry extruded vegan pet foods commercially available (three for dogs and one for cats) in the Brazilian market. A bag of each vegan pet food brand was purchased (ranging from 3 to 15 kg) at a local store. The nutritional composition of each food is described in Table 1.
The four foods were ground in a hammermill equipped with a 1 mm sieve. Dry matter was determined in an oven at 105°C (Fanen 315, São Paulo, Brazil) for eight hours according to AOAC . Crude protein (CP) analysis was performed by the Kjeldahl method . The ether extract was performed by the Soxhlet method after acid hydrolysis, and ash was determined using a muffle furnace at 550°C . The crude fiber was determined according to the Weende method . All analyses were performed in duplicate, and repetition was performed when the coefficient of variation was greater than 5.0%.
Determination of fatty acid profile.
The fatty acid profile of the foods was determined by gas chromatography, according to ISO , at the Laboratory of Biochemistry of Microorganisms and Plants, Department of Technology at the School of Agrarian and Veterinary Sciences of the São Paulo State University "Júlio de Mesquita Filho" (Jaboticabal, SP, Brazil).
Determination of minerals.
Samples were prepared by a wet method prior to mineral analyses. A 200mg sample was conditioned in a 100mL test with 4mL of concentrated nitric acid (HNO3) solution. After this process, the tubes rested for 30 minutes. Next, samples were placed on a heating plate and boiled until the volume of nitric acid was reduced by about half. Then, tubes were cooled and 1mL of perchloric acid (HClO4) was added to each sample, which was reheated until the sample volume reached 2mL, and cooled again.
After sample preparation, calcium (Ca), phosphorus (P), potassium (K), sodium (Na), magnesium (Mg), iron (Fe), manganese (Mn), copper (Cu) and zinc (Zn) were determined by inductively coupled plasma optical emission spectrometry (ICP-OES; ICPE-9000, Shimadzu do Brasil, Barueri, SP, Brazil). The operational conditions are presented in Table 2. In order to ensure the accuracy of the results, Milli-Q water was used to flush the system between each analysis, and the system was cleaned with a 1.0% nitric acid solution after every five samples analyzed.
The calibration curves were prepared through standardized multi-element solutions of 100mg/L for the elements Ca, Cl, Cu, Fe, K, Mg, Mn, Na, P, and Zn. Calibration curves were prepared from 0.1 to 5mg/L for Cu, Zn, Fe, and Mn, and from 0.5 to 100mg/L for Ca, P, Mg, Na and K.
Chloride (Cl) and iodine (I) were not measured because the digestion methodology employed does not allow it due to these elements’ high ionization energy. For example, in iodine, only 29.0% of atoms are ionized in argon plasma . Selenium was not measured because it would require a hydride generator coupled to ICP-OES, which was not available to us. The preparation of the wet solution samples, as well as the ICP-OES analyses, were carried out at the Multi-user Laboratory of Animal Nutrition and Bromatology of the Department of Animal Nutrition and Production at the School of Veterinary Medicine and Animal Science at the University of São Paulo (Pirassununga, SP, Brazil).
Determination of the amino acid profile.
The amino acid profile was determined by high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) according to Spitze et al.  at the Monogastric Nutrition Laboratory of the Department of Animal Nutrition and Production at the School of Veterinary Medicine and Animal Science at the University of São Paulo (Pirassununga, SP, Brazil).
The results were reported in unit per 100 grams of dry matter (DM). It was also calculated how much of each nutrient each food provides in units per kg of metabolic weight for animals with low energy requirement, based on 80kcal/kg0.75 and 52kcal/kg0.67 of MER for dogs and cats, respectively . Although FEDIAF (2019)  recommendations in units per 100g of DM takes into account only the equations 95kcal/kg0.75 and 110kcal/kg0.75 for dogs, and 75kcal/kg0.67 and 100kcal/kg0.67 for cats, FEDIAF (2019)  also reports that there are animals which can present lower metabolizable energy requirement (MER). Therefore, we chose to use the equations for low energy requirement to ensure that all these animals would be receiving at least the minimum of each essential nutrient per day. The metabolizable energy of the foods were estimated by the most current method described in the NRC .
The results of the laboratory analyses of the vegan foods for dogs, the FEDIAF  and AAFCO  recommendations in unit per 100 grams of dry matter are described in Table 3. All foods analyzed met the recommendations of the FEDIAF  and AAFCO  for CP and fat.
One vegan dog food (Food A) had a methionine and calcium deficiency according to the minimum recommendations by FEDIAF  for adult dog maintenance. All evaluated dog foods had Ca:P ratios below the minimum recommendations by FEDIAF  and AAFCO .
In regard to Cu, all foods evaluated exceeded the maximum safe recommendations for inclusion of this mineral in dog foods based on FEDIAF . These maximum recommendations are based on the legal limits of the European Union in compliance with the Regulation 1831/2003/EC. Based on these same recommendations, one of the foods (Food A) also had excess Zn, and Food C presented Fe excess.
The nutrient analysis of the only commercial vegan food available on the Brazilian market formulated for cats and the recommended nutrient levels for adult cat maintenance by the FEDIAF  and AAFCO  in unit per 100 grams of dry matter are described in Table 4.
The cat food evaluated did not contain any arachidonic acid in its composition, which is an essential fatty acid for this species and has a minimum recommendation for cats by FEDIAF  and AAFCO .
The vegan cat food also presented values of calcium and calcium:phosphorus ratio below the minimum recommended by FEDIAF . Potassium was also lower than the minimum recommendations of FEDIAF  and AAFCO . Furthermore, when taking into consideration the maximum recommendations, based on the legal limits of the European Union in compliance with regulation 1831/2003/EC, the vegan food for cats presented copper and zinc levels above recommendation.
The vegan cat diet only supplied 75.4% of the minimum protein required for a cat with an energy requirement of 52 kcal/kg0.67 (Table 6). Arginine deficiency was also observed, for which the cat food supplied only 59.0% of the minimum recommendations for a vegan cat with an energy requirement of 52 kcal/kg0.67. Besides these deficiencies, the amino sulphonic acid taurine was also below the minimum recommendation. Regarding the nutrient recommendations per kg of metabolic weight for animals with lower MER, the same deficiencies were observed when comparing to results in unit per 100 grams of dry matter.
Veganism can be considered a strict form of vegetarianism, where an individual is not allowed to eat any food products or derivatives of animal origin. The humanization of pets has led around ¼ of vegan pet owners to seek a similar diet for their animals in the US , leading to some growth in the vegan market. However, it is challenging to formulate a complete and balanced diet for facultative or obligate carnivores based on plants. In the present study, we can highlight that commercial products available for dogs and cats that claim to be vegan may have some inconsistency. In the ingredient composition statement on the label, food C claims to contain vitamin D3. Vitamin D is presented in two forms in nature: cholecalciferol (vitamin D3), found in animal products and tissues, and ergocalciferol (vitamin D2), found in products of plant origin . Thus, the presence of vitamin D3 indicates animal sourcing, which should not be present in a vegan product by definition. This demonstrates the contestable truth of the evaluated product.
Laboratory analyses of the four vegan foods showed that none of them met all of the nutritional recommendations of FEDIAF  and AAFCO (2019)  for the species for which they were intended. Levels below the minimum recommendation for various nutrients were observed, including amino acids such as arginine and methionine, and minerals such as calcium, potassium and sodium. The main findings of this study were levels below the detection limit for arachidonic acid (essential for cats), as well as failure to comply with the minimum recommendation for the Ca:P ratio in all analyzed foods.
Arachidonic acid (AA) is an essential fatty acid for cats because these animals have a low delta-6-desaturase enzyme activity, which is responsible for the conversion of linoleic acid into AA. Fats of animal origin are good sources of AA, whereas vegetable oils are absent. The study of lipid metabolism in felines instigated the interest of the scientific community in the 1970s, when Rivers et al.  observed while studying liver samples that cats had very low activity of delta-6-dessaturase enzyme. After this discovery, effects of low AA diets for cats were studied and it was shown that AA deficiency in cats can result in thrombocytopenia, impairment of platelet aggregation and inability to conceive . Pawlosky and Salem  fed AA-free diets supplemented with 1% corn oil to cats before mating and throughout gestation. All females cycled and mated, but a high incidence of congenital defects and low litter viability were observed. The vegan foods analyzed in our study used soybean oil as the only source of fat, so it was expected that AA would not be detected in these products. Some marine algae such as Ascophyllum nodosum may contain AA and could, therefore, be used as a source of this fatty acid. On the label of the commercial vegan cat food analyzed, it was stated that there was an inclusion of algae meal, although the information about which species of algae and the amount added were not included. Unlike the US, Brazilian laws do not require that ingredients are added in order of highest to lowest percent inclusion.
All foods presented a Ca:P ratio below the minimum (1:1) recommended by FEDIAF . Regarding Ca, two foods (one for dogs and one for cats) presented concentrations below recommendations. A similar result was found by Gray et al. , who analyzed two commercial vegan foods for cats and one of them presented calcium concentrations well below the minimum recommended for the species. In general, by-products of animal origin have higher calcium concentrations when compared to products of plant origin , which may explain the results found. However, according to the labels of all diets, there was an inclusion of calcium supplementation in the form of calcium carbonate and dicalcium phosphate. These were not sufficient to achieve above the minimum recommendation. In humans, it has been shown that vegan people consume less calcium  and present lower bone mineral density [18,19] compared to non-vegans, which may increase the risk of bone fracture .
The Ca:P ratio below the minimum recommendation and the low concentrations of Ca in the diet may result in secondary nutritional hyperparathyroidism (SNH) in dogs and cats [21, 22]. This abnormality was quite common in the past because of unbalanced diets provided to pets [22, 23, 24, 25, 26]. However, SNH is uncommon nowadays due to the large use of complete and balanced commercial foods that supply the animal's calcium requirements. The SNH may result in rubber jaw syndrome, a group of lesions characterized by the loss of the lamina dura of the teeth. Symptoms include loose teeth, osteopenia of the skull bones, and a rubbery aspect of the jaw in consequence of the replacement of the mineral structure by fibrous tissue . Furthermore, hypocalcemia is usually present in this syndrome, which can cause muscle spasms, convulsion, and osteopenia, which causes bone fractures .
One of the dog foods did not meet the minimum recommendation for the amino acid methionine. This result was expected since methionine occurs at low levels in vegetable protein based diets . The product label of this food stated that DL-methionine was supplemented, and yet its concentrations were below the minimum recommendation. Currently, there is a concern regarding methionine for dogs since the low consumption of this amino acid may be indirectly related to an increased risk of developing dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM) . Methionine is a precursor of taurine, an important amino acid for myocardial function [28, 29]. Dogs are able to synthesize taurine from sulfur amino acids such as methionine and cysteine, mainly in the liver and central nervous system, through the transsulfuration pathway . The relationship between taurine deficiency and DCM in dogs was first studied by Kramer et al. , who observed that a subset of dogs with DCM had taurine deficiency. Further studies have shown that taurine supplementation for dogs with DCM associated with the deficiency of this amino acid resulted in resolution of myocardial changes and allowed the removal of support medication for most of these dogs [29, 31, 32, 33]. This data suggest a direct link between taurine deficiency and DCM development. Fascetti et al.  assessed three taurine-deficient Golden Retrievers that were fed a vegetarian diet formulated by the owner, and according to the authors this deficiency may have occurred due to possible low dietary sulfur amino acids precursors of taurine.
Although taurine deficiency may occur as a consequence of dietary deficiency of methionine or cysteine, there are other nutritional factors that may be involved, such as decreased bioavailability of these sulfur amino acids, abnormal enterohepatic bile acid recycling, altered taurine intestinal metabolism and urinary loss of taurine [27, 34]. In the present study, the vegan food with low methionine concentration may represent a risk factor for the development of DCM. In addition, this food presented a high inclusion of soybean meal in its composition, which was the main protein ingredient used in its formulation. It has been observed in cats that soy protein decreases plasma taurine concentrations as a consequence of increased bile acid loss that is conjugated to taurine through microbial degradation and acceleration of cholecystokinin-mediated bile acid turnover . Moreover, methionine is the limiting amino acid of most legumes like soybean. Thus, the high inclusion of this ingredient may also possibly contribute to the development of DCM.
The analyzed cat food did not meet the minimum recommendation for arginine. This result corroborates a previous study by Gray et al. . The low arginine was expected because this amino acid is usually found in small amounts in plant-based diets, and according to the product label the food was not supplemented with arginine. Cats are more sensitive to arginine deficiency than dogs [9, 36]. Arginine acts as a precursor of ornithine, which is an intermediate in the urea cycle. This allows large quantities of ammonia from a high-protein meal to be converted to urea before excretion . Lack of arginine in cats may lead to hyperammonemia and severe uremia, causing symptoms such as emesis, ataxia, muscle spasms, and hyperesthesia. . The higher sensitivity of cats to arginine-deficient diets may be explained by two reasons. First, most animals are able to use glutamate and proline as precursors for the synthesis of ornithine in the intestinal mucosa, but cats are unable to utilize these amino acids as precursors because they have low pyrroline-5-carboxylate synthetase enzyme activity in their intestinal mucosa . In addition, cats present low activity of another essential enzyme for this process, the ornithine aminotransferase . Furthermore, felines are unable to synthesize arginine from ornithine, even if they consume a diet with high amounts of ornithine. It occurs due to the fact that cats are unable to synthesize citrulline in the intestinal mucosa, a molecule that acts as a precursor in the synthesis of arginine from ornithine. Although they produce citrulline in the liver, this molecule is unable to exit the hepatocytes and be transported to the kidneys, where conversion to arginine could potentially occur .
In addition to the nutritional recommendation based on DM, FEDIAF  also has recommendations on a per kg of metabolic weight for dogs and cats. This is important since recommendations based on DM for cats take into account a MER of 75kcal/kg0.67 and 100kcal/kg0.67, but some cats may present lower MER due to a sedentary lifestyle, neutering/spaying or sometimes pathological conditions that lead to hyporexia. Hence, FEDIAF  suggests that MER of inactive adult cats can also range from 52 to 75kcal per kg of metabolic weight. Loureiro et al.  reported a mean MER for adult cats of 59.5±2.2 Kcal/BW0.67/day. For dogs, this comparison is also important, since nutritional recommendations based on DM take into account the energy requirement of 95kcal/kg0.75 and 110kcal/kg0.75, but there are animals with lower energy requirements. According to the recommendations by FEDIAF , the MER of inactive dogs can vary from 80 to 120kcal/kg0.75. Pedrinelli et al.  observed mean MER for adult dogs of 86.1±19.8 kcal/BW0.75. For those animals with low MER, the nutrient concentrations in the food should be higher, to ensure the intake of at least the minimum requirements. Therefore, in the present study a comparison was made among foods’ nutritional composition and recommendations per kg of metabolic weight for cats with MER of 52kcal/kg0.67, and dogs with MER of 80kcal/kg0.75, as mentioned by FEDIAF .
The results on a per kg of metabolic weight basis showed values of protein and taurine below the minimum recommendation in the cat food, in addition to the same deficiencies found in the results per unit of DM. This data corroborates with a study by Loureiro et al. , in which they observed that a commercial food with 28% CP on a DM basis did not meet the minimum recommendation of protein intake in g/kg0.67, although it did support the requirement for CP based on DM. This happened due to the low amount of food ingested by these animals to maintain weight, which had an average MER of 59.5 kcal/kg0.67. In that study, cats that consumed the protein deficient diet during a 60-day period lost 90 grams of lean body mass. It was also observed that the protein intake required to maintain stable lean body mass was 5.17g/kg0.67, higher than that provided by the vegan food analyzed in our study for cats. Based on the work by Loureiro et al. , it is possible that the intake of the vegan cat food evaluated in the present study may lead to lean body mass loss in cats with low energy requirements, despite presenting 36.3% of CP on a DM basis.
Regarding taurine consumption below the recommendation per kg0.67, two previous studies have also observed a deficiency of this amino sulphonic acid in commercial vegetarian and vegan cat foods [16, 43]. This is a serious implication when feeding cats a plant-based diet. In the work by Wakefield et al. , they measured blood taurine concentrations of cats that were fed vegetarian diets and observed that, of the 17 cats evaluated, three had taurine concentrations below the reference range.
Taurine is an amino sulphonic acid that is only found in animal products. In cat foods, even with the inclusion of animal ingredients, taurine supplementation is usually required to achieve the minimum requirement for this amino acid. In the case of diets without animal products, taurine supplementation becomes mandatory. The vegan cat food analyzed in this study had taurine supplementation, however, the concentration found was below the recommendation, based on unit per kg0.67 for cats with MER of 52kcal/kg0.67.
Taurine plays an essential role in the digestive system of cats. This species conjugates bile acids exclusively with taurine, unlike dogs that may occasionally conjugate bile salts with glycine [16, 45]. The intestinal lumen microbial degradation increases the loss of taurine in cats . In addition, cats show limited hepatic production of taurine from sulfur amino acids, such as methionine and cysteine, which results from the low activity of the enzyme cysteine dioxygenase. This low enzymatic activity limits the production of cysteine sulfate, an intermediate in taurine synthesis. Felines also have limited activity of cysteine sulfinic acid decarboxylase, an enzyme responsible for converting cysteine sulfate to taurine. Additionally, cats have a high activity of aspartate aminotransferase, which transforms cysteine sulfate into pyruvate, rather than allowing it to be decarboxylated to hypotaurine, and therefore into taurine [46, 47, 48]. All these associated factors result in a dietary requirement for taurine in felines.
It is important to emphasize that the cat vegan food analyzed may also be a risk factor for taurine deficiency due to its high inclusion of soybean meal. It is known that soy protein may decrease plasma concentrations of taurine in cats when compared to casein, which seems to be related to increased use of taurine for conjugation of bile acids, increased intestinal loss of taurine by microbial degradation and accelerated cholecystokinin-mediated turnover of bile acids [35, 49, 50]. Therefore, caution with supplementation of taurine in vegan foods with high inclusion of soy protein should be even greater.
In cats, dietary deficiency of taurine may lead to cardiac abnormalities such as dilated cardiomyopathy, since taurine is related to myocardial function and it is essential for the maintenance of cardiac contractility [51, 52]. Novotny et al.  fed a taurine deficient diet to 23 cats over a period of 6 to 15 months and most of the animals presented decreased myocardial function assessed by echocardiography.
Taurine also plays an important role in maintaining the structural integrity of the retina. Dietary deficiency of this amino sulphonic acid can lead to photoreceptor cell degeneration [54, 55, 56, 57, 58]. In a study carried out by Jacobson et al. , eight male cats were fed a taurine deficient diet for 5 to 9 months and all animals developed abnormalities in the retina detected by fundoscopy and electroretinography. In addition, taurine deficiency can impair the reproductive performance of cats with consequences on kitten development .
In the present study, nutrient digestibility and bioavailability were not assessed. However, it is generally recognized that plant protein sources have lower digestibility compared to animal protein [43, 60]. Funaba et al.  observed in adult cats that a diet in which meat meal was used as a protein source resulted in higher apparent nitrogen absorption and retention, and higher dry matter digestibility when compared to a corn gluten meal based diet. In another study conducted by Bednar et al. , when comparing the digestibility of different protein sources by adult dogs, total tract crude protein digestibility of poultry meal was greater than soybean meal, poultry by-product meal, and beef and bone meal (87.5% vs average 82.2%). These authors also observed lower organic matter digestibility for the soybean meal treatment. Hill et al.  observed that the partial replacement of beef with textured soy protein (100% beef vs 57% soy textured protein and 43% beef) in canned foods fed to cannulated dogs had a decrease in the total tract apparent digestibility of crude protein, energy, dry matter, sodium, potassium and iron. These authors also observed lower pre-cecal apparent digestibility of essential amino acids arginine, histidine, isoleucine, leucine, valine, lysine, phenylalanine and threonine (tryptophan and methionine were not assessed) when dogs were fed the textured soy protein treatment. These data suggest that even if vegan food has nutrient concentrations above the minimum recommendations of FEDIAF and AAFCO, there may still be a risk of nutritional deficiency due to the lower digestibility and bioavailability of vegetable-based nutrients.
Vitamin analyses were not performed in the present study. However, the label of the vegan cat food (Food D) reported vitamin D inclusion in the form of vitamin D2 (ergocalciferol), which is present in vegetables. It is known that vitamin D2 in cats is not as efficient at maintaining 25(OH)D serum concentrations as vitamin D3 (cholecalciferol) . According to Morris , the efficiency of use of ergocalciferol for synthesis of 25(OH)D is 0.7 that of cholecalciferol in the cat. The 25(OH)D is an intermediate metabolite of vitamin D. It is synthesized in the liver and converted to 1,25(OH)2D in the proximal renal tubules . 1,25(OH)2D is the active metabolite that performs classical hormonal functions related to bone metabolism and calcium and phosphorus homeostasis in the body, in addition to non-classical functions such as immune-modulating activity [66,67,68], protection against autoimmune reactions [69, 70], antitumoral activity [71,72,73,74] and anti-inflammatory activity [75,76]. Because of this peculiarity of cats in relation to vitamin D metabolism, if the analyzed vegan food included vitamin D2 in their formula, this may likely result in long-term vitamin D deficiency.
Concentrations of copper and zinc higher than legal limits of FEDIAF were found in the diets evaluated, and one vegan dog food had iron concentrations above the legal limit of FEDIAF. There is insufficient information in the literature about the safe upper limit or nutritional limit for copper, zinc and iron intake for dogs and cats, so it is not known if levels observed in these foods may imply health risks for dogs and cats. However, transition metals like copper are known to cause oxidative damage when in excess , which can potentially lead to liver cell damage or death, and abnormalities associated with oxidative stress.
The limitations of the present study were that some essential nutrients were not quantified in the vegan diets, such as water-soluble and fat-soluble vitamins, as well as minerals iodine, chloride and selenium.
In conclusion, all foods tested had one or more nutrients lower than what is recommended, while some presented excess zinc and copper. Although these foods are commercially available in the Brazilian market, they should not be recommended for dogs and cats, because dietary inadequacies observed may lead to health risks and even death. Furthermore, manufacturers should review their formulations to ensure the nutritional adequacy of these foods.
We would like to thank Renata Maria Consentino Conti and Simi Luisa Durante Aflalo for technical assistance.
- 1. Dodd AS, Cave NJ, Adolphe JL, et al. Plant-based (vegan) diets for pets: A survey of pet owner attitudes and feeding practices. PloS one 2019;14(1), e0210806. pmid:30645644
- 2. IBOPE INTELIGÊNCIA—pesquisa de opinião pública sobre o vegetarianismo- JOB0416/2018 BRASIL.
- 3. Kienzle E, & Engelhard RA. Field study on the nutrition of vegetarian dogs and cats in Europe. Compendium on Continuing Education for the Practicing Veterinarian 2001; 23(9), 81–81.
- 4. AOAC. Official methods of analysis. 2006 (AOAC International, 2006).
- 5. Williams R. D. & Olmsted W. H. A biochemical method for determining indigestible residue (crude fiber) in feces: lignin, cellulose, and non-water soluble hemicelluloses. J. Biol. Chem. 1935; 108, 635–666.
- 6. Animal, I. S. O., and Vegetable Fats. "Oils-Preparation of Methyl Esters of Fatty Acids (method ISO 5509)." Geneva: International Organization for Standardization (1978).
- 7. Montaser A. Inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry. Washington D.C., EUA: Wiley-VCH, 1998.
- 8. Spitze AR, Wong DL, Rogers QR, et al. Taurine concentrations in animal feed ingredients; cooking influences taurine content. J Anim Physiol Anim Nutr (Berl) 2003; 87:251–262.
- 9. FEDIAF. Nutritional Guidelines for Complete and Complementary Pet Food for Cats and Dogs, 2019. (Fédération Européenne de l’Industrie des Aliments pour Animaux Familiers, 2019).
- 10. National Research Council. Nutrient requirements of dogs and cats. National Academies Press, 2006.
- 11. Association of American Feed Control Officials. AAFCO dog food nutrient profiles. In: 2019 official publication. Oxford, Ind: Association of American Feed Control Officials, 2019.
- 12. Parker VJ, Rudinsky AJ, Chew DJ. Vitamin D metabolism in canine and feline medicine. Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association 2017, 250(11), 1259–1269. pmid:28509634
- 13. Rivers JPW, Sinclair AJ & Crawford MA. Inability of the cat to desaturate essential fatty acids. Nature 1875; 258(5531), 171.
- 14. MacDonald ML, Anderson BC, Rogers QR, et al. Essential fatty acid requirements of cats: pathology of essential fatty acid deficiency. American journal of veterinary research 1984; 45(7), 1310–1317. pmid:24049889
- 15. Pawlosky RJ, & Salem N Jr. Is dietary arachidonic acid necessary for feline reproduction. The Journal of nutrition 1996; 126(suppl_4), 1081S–1085S.
- 16. Gray CM, Sellon RK & Freeman LM. Nutritional adequacy of two vegan diets for cats. Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association 2004; 225(11), 1670–1675. pmid:15626215
- 17. Davey GK, Spencer EA, Appleby PN et al. EPIC–Oxford: lifestyle characteristics and nutrient intakes in a cohort of 33 883 meat-eaters and 31 546 non meat-eaters in the UK. Public health nutrition 2003; 6(3), 259–268. pmid:12740075
- 18. Chiu JF, Lan SJ, Yang CY, et al. Long-term vegetarian diet and bone mineral density in postmenopausal Taiwanese women. Calcif Tissue Int 1997; 60:245–9. pmid:9069160
- 19. Lau EMC, Kwok T, Woo J, Ho SC. Bone mineral density in Chinese elderly female vegetarians, vegans, lacto-vegetarians and omnivores. Eur J Clin Nutr 1998; 52:60–4. pmid:9481534
- 20. Craig WJ. Health effects of vegan diets. The American journal of clinical nutrition 2009; 89(5), 1627S–1633S. pmid:19279075
- 21. NAP RC & HAZEWINKEHL AW. Growth and skeletal development in the dog in relation to nutrition; a review. Veterinary Quarterly 1994; 1. 50–59.
- 22. Tomsa K, Glaus T, Hauser et al. Nutritional secondary hyperparathyroidism in six cats. Journal of small animal practice 1999; 40(11), 533–539. pmid:10649598
- 23. Svanberg G, Lindhe J, Hugoson A et al. Effect of nutritional hyperparathyroidism on experimental periodontitis in the dog. European Journal of Oral Sciences 1973; 81(2), 155–162.
- 24. Cook SD, Skinner HB, Haddad RJ. A quantitative histologic study of osteoporosis produced by nutritional secondary hyperparathyroidism in dogs. Clin Orthop 1983; 175:105–120.
- 25. Kawaguchi K, Braga IS III, Takahashi A, et al. Nutritional secondary hyperparathyroidism occurring in a strain of German shepherd puppies. Japanese Journal of Veterinary Research 1993; 41(2–4), 89–96. pmid:8139162
- 26. Fornel-Thibaud P, Blanchard G, Escoffier-Chateau L et al. Unusual case of osteopenia associated with nutritional calcium and vitamin D deficiency in an adult dog. Journal of the American Animal Hospital Association 2007; 43(1), 52–60. pmid:17209086
- 27. Freeman LM, Stern JA, Fries R et al. Diet-associated dilated cardiomyopathy in dogs: what do we know?. Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association 2018; 253(11), 1390–1394. pmid:30451613
- 28. Hayes KC. Taurine nutrition. Nutr Res Rev 1988; 1:99–113. pmid:19094361
- 29. Fascetti AJ, Reed JR, Rogers QR et al. Taurine deficiency in dogs with dilated cardiomyopathy: 12 cases (1997–2001). Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association 2003; 223(8), 1137–1141. pmid:14584743
- 30. Kramer GA, Kittleson MD, Fox PR et al. Plasma taurine concentrations in normal dogs and in dogs with heart disease. Journal of veterinary internal medicine 1995; 9(4), 253–258. pmid:8523322
- 31. Bélanger MC, Ouellet M, Queney G et al. Taurine-deficient dilated cardiomyopathy in a family of golden retrievers. Journal of the American Animal Hospital Association 2005; 41(5), 284–291. pmid:16141179
- 32. Kittleson MD, Keene B, Pion PD et al. Results of the multicenter spaniel trial (MUST): taurine‐and carnitine‐responsive dilated cardiomyopathy in American cocker spaniels with decreased plasma taurine concentration. Journal of Veterinary Internal Medicine 1997; 11(4), 204–211. pmid:9298474
- 33. Backus RC et al. Taurine deficiency in Newfoundlands fed commercially available complete and balanced diets. Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association 2003; 223.8: 1130–1136. pmid:14584742
- 34. Ko KS, Fascetti AJ. Dietary beet pulp decreases taurine status in dogs fed low protein diet. J Anim Sci Technol 2016; 58:29. pmid:27489723
- 35. Kim SW, Morris JG, Rogers QR. Dietary soybean protein decreases plasma taurine in cats. J Nutr 1995; 125:2831–2837. pmid:7472663
- 36. Czarnecki GL and Baker DH. Urea cycle function in the dog with emphasis on the role of arginine. J. Nutr. 1984; 114:581–590. pmid:6699739
- 37. Morris JG. Nutritional and metabolic responses to arginine in carnivores. J. utr. 1985; 115:524–531.
- 38. Morris JG & Rogers QR. Ammonia intoxication in the near-adult cat as a result of a dietary deficiency of arginine. Science 1978; 199(4327), 431–432. pmid:619464
- 39. Rogers R. and Phang JM. Deficiency of pyrroline-5-carboxylale synthase in the intestinal mucosa of the cat. J. Nutr. 1985; 115: 146–150. pmid:3965666
- 40. Kirk CA, Debraekeleer J, Armstrong PJ. Normal cats. In: Hand MS, Thatcher CD, Remillard RL, et al, eds. Small animal clinical nutrition. 4th ed. Philadelphia: WB Saunders Co, 2000; 291–347.
- 41. Loureiro BA, Garcia CA, Peres FM et al. Markers of protein metabolism in adult cats fed diets with different protein and starch contentes. in Proceedings. 22nd Congress of the European Society Of Veterinary and Comparative Nutrition 2018; 123–123.
- 42. Pedrinelli V, Porsani MYH, Lima DM et al. Predictive equations of maintenance energy requirement of healthy and chronically ill adult dogs. in Proceedings. 22nd Congress of the European Society Of Veterinary and Comparative Nutrition 2018; 236–236.
- 43. Kanakubo K, Fascetti AJ & Larsen JA. Assessment of protein and amino acid concentrations and labeling adequacy of commercial vegetarian diets formulated for dogs and cats. Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association 2015; 247(4), 385–392. pmid:26225610
- 44. Wakefield LA, Shofer FS, & Michel KE. (2006). Evaluation of cats fed vegetarian diets and attitudes of their caregivers. Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association 2006; 229(1), 70–73. pmid:16817716
- 45. Rentschler LA, Hirschberger LL & Stipanuk MH. Response of the kitten to dietary taurine depletion: effects on renal reabsorption, bile acid conjugation and activities of enzymes involved in taurine synthesis. Comparative biochemistry and physiology. B, Comparative biochemistry 1986; 84(3), 319–325. pmid:3743026
- 46. Morris JG, Rogers QR, Kim SW, et al. Dietary taurine requirement of cats is determined by microbial degradation of taurine in the gut. Vet Clin Nutr 1994; 1:118–127.
- 47. Morris JH and Rogers QR. The metabolic basis for the taurine requirement of cats. Taurine 1992. Springer, Boston, MA. 33–44.
- 48. Pion PD, Sanderson SL, Kittleson MD. The effectiveness of taurine and levocarnitine in dogs with heart disease. Vet Clin North Am Small Anim Pract 1998; 28:1495–1514. pmid:10098250
- 49. Hickman MA, Bruss ML, Morris JG, et al. Dietary protein source (soybean vs. casein) and taurine status affect kinetics of the enterohepatic circulation of taurocholic acid in cats. J Nutr 1992; 122:1019–1028. pmid:1552356
- 50. Backus RC, Rogers QR, Rosenquist GL, et al. Diets causing taurine depletion in cats substantially elevate postprandial plasma cholecystokinin (CCK) concentration. J Nutr 1995; 125:2650–2657. pmid:7562102
- 51. Schaffer SW, Jong CJ, Ramila KC et al. Physiological roles of taurine in heart and muscle. Journal of Biomedical Science 2010; 17(1), S2.
- 52. Schaffer SW, Shimada-Takaura K, Jong CJ et al. Impaired energy metabolism of the taurine-deficient heart. Amino Acids 2016; 48(2), 549–558. pmid:26475290
- 53. Novotny MJ, Hogan PM & Flannigan G. Echocardiographic evidence for myocardial failure induced by taurine deficiency in domestic cats. Canadian Journal of Veterinary Research 1994; 58(1), 6. pmid:8143255
- 54. Hayes KC, Carey RE and Schmidt SY. Retinal degeneration associated with taurine deficiency in the cat. Science 1975; 188.4191: 949–951. pmid:1138364
- 55. Barnett KC and Burger IH. Taurine deficiency retinopathy in the cat. Journal of Small Animal Practice 1980; 21.10: 521–534. pmid:7464066
- 56. Hayes KC. Nutritional problems in cats: taurine deficiency and vitamin A excess. The Canadian Veterinary Journal 1982; 23.1: 2. pmid:7039812
- 57. Imaki H, Moretz RC, Wisniewski HM et al. Feline maternal taurine deficiency: effects on retina and tapetum of the offspring. Developmental neuroscience 1986; 8(3), 160–181. pmid:3769817
- 58. Jacobson SG, Kemp CM, Borruat FX et al. Rhodopsin topography and rod-mediated function in cats with the retinal degeneration of taurine deficiency. Experimental eye research 1987; 45(4), 481–490. pmid:3428381
- 59. Sturman JÁ and Jeffrey MM. High dietary taurine effects on feline tissue taurine concentrations and reproductive performance. The Journal of nutrition 1992; 122.1: 82–88. pmid:1729475
- 60. Neirinck K, Istasse L, Gabriel A, Van Eenaeme C, Bienfait JM. Amino acid composition and digestibility of four protein sources for dogs. The Journal of nutrition 1991, 121(suppl_11), S64–S65.
- 61. Funaba M, Matsumoto C, Matsuki K, Gotoh K, Kaneko M, Iriki T, et al. Comparison of corn gluten meal and meat meal as a protein source in dry foods formulated for cats. American journal of veterinary research 2002, 63(9), 1247–1251. pmid:12224854
- 62. Bednar GE, Murray SM, Patil AR, Flickinger EA, Merchen NR, & Fahey GC Jr. Selected animal and plant protein sources affect nutrient digestibility and fecal characteristics of ileally cannulated dogs. Archives of Animal Nutrition 2000, 53(2), 127–140. pmid:10849867
- 63. Hill RC, Burrows CF, Ellison GW, Bauer JE. The effect of texturized vegetable protein from soy on nutrient digestibility compared to beef in cannulated dogs. Journal of animal science 2001, 79(8), 2162–2171. pmid:11518225
- 64. Morris JG. Cats discriminate between cholecalciferol and ergocalciferol. Journal of animal physiology and animal nutrition 2002; 86:229–238. pmid:15379909
- 65. Brito Galvao JF, Nagode LA, Schenck PA et al. Calcitriol, calcidiol, parathyroid hormone, and fibroblast growth factor‐23 interactions in chronic kidney disease. Journal of Veterinary Emergency and Critical Care 2013; 23(2), 134–162. pmid:23566108
- 66. Liu PT, Stenger S, Li H et al. Toll-like receptor triggering of a vitamin D-mediated human antimicrobial response. Science 2006; 3111:770–1773.
- 67. Motlagh BM, Ahangaran NA & Froushani SMA. Calcitriol modulates the effects of bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stem cells on macrophage functions. Iranian journal of basic medical sciences 2015; 18(7), 672. pmid:26351558
- 68. Rodriguez-Cortes A, Martori C, Martinez-Florez A et al. Canine Leishmaniasis Progression is Associated with Vitamin D Deficiency. Scientific reports 2017; 7:3346. pmid:28611427
- 69. Pludowski P, Holick MF, Pilz S et al. Vitamin D effects on musculoskeletal health, immunity, autoimmunity, cardiovascular disease, cancer, fertility, pregnancy, dementia and mortality—a review of recent evidence. Autoimmunity reviews 2013; 12:976–989. pmid:23542507
- 70. Laws EJ, Kathrani A, Harcourt-Brown TR et al. 25‐Hydroxy vitamin D3 serum concentration in dogs with acute polyradiculoneuritis compared to matched controls. Journal of Small Animal Practice 2018; 59:222–227. pmid:29171025
- 71. Kunakornsawat S, Rosol TJ, Capen CC et al. Effects of 1, 25 (OH) 2D3, EB1089, and analog V on PTHrP production, PTHrP mRNA expression and cell growth in SCC 2/88. Anticancer research 2001; 21(5), 3355–3363. pmid:11848494
- 72. Kunakornsawat S, Rosol TJ, Capen CC et al. Effects of 1, 25 (OH) 2D3, 25OHD3, and EB1089 on cell growth and Vitamin D receptor mRNA and 1α-hydroxylase mRNA expression in primary cultures of the canine prostate. The Journal of steroid biochemistry and molecular biology 2004; 89, 409–412. pmid:15225811
- 73. Rassnick KM, Muindi JP, Johnson CS et al. In vitro and in vivo evaluation of combined calcitriol and cisplatin in dogs with spontaneously occurring tumors. Cancer chemotherapy and pharmacology 2008; 62:881–891. pmid:18246349
- 74. Malone EK, Rassnick KM, Wakshlag JJ et al. Calcitriol (1, 25‐dihydroxycholecalciferol) enhances mast cell tumor chemotherapy and receptor tyrosine kinase inhibitor activity in vitro and has single‐agent activity against spontaneously occurring canine mast cell tumors. Veterinary and comparative oncology 2010; 8:209–220. pmid:20691028
- 75. Jaffey J, Amorim J & DeClue AE. In vitro effects of vitamin D on phagocytosis, TLR4, and cytokine production. J Vet Intern Med 2017; 31(4), 775.
- 76. Jaffey JÁ, Amorim J, Declue AE. Effect of calcitriol on in vitro whole blood cytokine production in critically ill dogs. The Veterinary Journal 2018, v. 236, p. 31–36. pmid:29871746
- 77. Dirksen K, Fieten H. Canine copper-associated hepatitis. Veterinary Clinics: Small Animal Practice. 2017 May 1;47(3):631–44.