Human driven changes such as increases in oceanic CO2, global warming, petroleum hydrocarbons and heavy metals may negatively affect the ability of marine calcifiers to build their skeletons/shells, especially in polar regions. We examine spatio-temporal variability of skeletal Mg-calcite in shallow water Antarctic marine invertebrates using bryozoan and spirorbids as models in a recruitment experiment of settlement tiles in East Antarctica. Mineralogies were determined for 754 specimens belonging to six bryozoan species (four cheilostome and two cyclostome species) and two spirorbid species from around Casey Station. Intra- and interspecific variability in wt% MgCO3 in calcite among most species was the largest source of variation overall. Therefore, the skeletal Mg-calcite in these taxa seem to be mainly biologically controlled. However, significant spatial variability was also found in wt% MgCO3 in calcite, possibly reflecting local environment variation from sources such as freshwater input and contaminated sediments. Species with high-Mg calcite skeletons (e.g. Beania erecta) could be particularly sensitive to multiple stressors under predictions for near-future global ocean chemistry changes such as increasing temperature, ocean acidification and pollution.
Citation: Figuerola B, Gore DB, Johnstone G, Stark JS (2019) Spatio-temporal variation of skeletal Mg-calcite in Antarctic marine calcifiers. PLoS ONE 14(5): e0210231. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0210231
Editor: Cristina Linares, University of Barcelona, SPAIN
Received: December 18, 2018; Accepted: April 21, 2019; Published: May 7, 2019
Copyright: © 2019 Figuerola et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Data Availability: All relevant data are within the manuscript.
Funding: The research visit of B. Figuerola to the Australian Antarctic Division and Macquarie University received support from a Council of Managers of National Antarctic Programs (COMNAP) Research Fellowship. This project was supported financially by the Australian Antarctic Division grant AAS 4127. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Human stressors such as contaminants and increases in oceanic CO2 will lead to significant changes in global ocean chemistry in the near future. Some of the expected consequences of the increase in oceanic CO2 are a reduction in seawater pH of 0.3–0.5 pH units by 2100, leading to changes to the carbonate system including a decrease in the carbonate saturation state (Ω)  and changes to metal speciation, availability and toxicity in seawater . These human driven changes might negatively affect the ability of marine calcifiers to build their calcified skeletons/shells. There is a need therefore to understand the basic underlying properties of organisms hypothesised to be vulnerable to such changes, for example to understand calcium carbonate mineralogy. Marine calcifiers produce a variety of mineralogical forms (polymorphs) including aragonite, calcite and calcite minerals containing a range of magnesium (Mg) content. In particular, seawater in polar regions is acidifying at a faster rate than elsewhere  and organisms at high latitudes may also be more susceptible to contamination (e.g. trace metals and Persistent Organic Pollutants (POPs)) compared to other regions due to their slower metabolism, growth and larval development and consequent slower detoxification processes, slower colonisation rates and lower deposition of wt% MgCO3 in calcite [4–8]. Synergistic effects of anthropogenic driven environmental change could mean a significant degradation or even loss of calcareous reef habitats and sediment deposits used as shelter, substrate and food for many benthic communities [5,9,10].
Seawater carbonate saturation state, pH and temperature play an important role in the incorporation of Mg into calcified structures, however, other environmental (e.g. salinity and Mg/Ca ratio in seawater) and biological (e.g. species-specific mineralogies and skeletal growth rate) factors also mediate this process [11–13]. Therefore, the extent of spatial and temporal variations in skeletal Mg-calcite, especially organisms inhabiting Antarctic waters, remains unclear.
Laboratory studies are useful in demonstrating the effects of environmental stressors in controlled conditions, for example that heavy metal toxicity may reduce growth rates of calcifying marine invertebrates [14,15]. However, experiments in the field can also contribute to our understanding of how these effects will manifest on calcified organisms living in complex ecosystems . Such studies allow simultaneous exploration of different physical, biological and anthropogenic factors (e.g. depth, species interactions and pollution) which likely interact in their resulting effects on organisms. They also allow the estimation of the importance of spatial and temporal variation in response variables (such as calcification and mineralogy), which are essential to understanding relative risks or vulnerabilities of species to climate change effects. Without an understanding of environmental variation in habitats predicted to experience environmental change, along with an understanding of natural variation in species responses, it is not possible to make predictions about how species may respond to such changes. Predicted environmental changes may well be within the boundaries of what species experience or may push them to limits of physiological tolerances.
Ecosystem engineers such as calcifying bryozoans and spirorbid polychaetes contribute to habitat structure and resilience, especially in Antarctica where these taxa are widespread and diverse [17–19]. They play important roles in creating reef frameworks and habitat complexity that enhance biodiversity and can prevent storm damage [20,21]. Spirorbid polychaetes and bryozoans are amongst the most prominent early colonizers in Antarctica  but the CaCO3 biomineralization of their calcareous tube is relatively unknown [7,22,23]. This study investigates the spatio-temporal variability in skeletal Mg-calcite in calcifying Antarctic bryozoans and spirorbid polychaetes [22,24–26]. Samples were collected from settlement panels deployed around Casey Station in East Antarctica including from undisturbed and human-impacted areas. The objectives were: (1) to test whether there is spatial variability in skeletal Mg-calcite at a range of spatial scales around Casey and at different water depths; (2) to test whether there is temporal variability (between settlement panels at 3 and 9 y) in skeletal Mg-calcite and (3) to test whether or not there are differences in mineralogy between impacted areas (sediments contaminated with petroleum hydrocarbons and heavy metals) and non-impacted areas around Casey Station.
Materials and methods
The study area is located around Casey Station (66° 17' S, 110° 32' E) in the Windmill Islands, on the coast of Wilkes Land, East Antarctica (Fig 1). The shallow marine benthic environment is a heterogeneous mosaic of sediments ranging from mud to sand, gravel, cobbles, boulders and bedrock . The experiment was conducted at five locations: Brown Bay outer and Brown Bay inner, O'Brien Bay-1 and O’Brien Bay-2 and Shannon Bay. These bays are covered by sea ice (1.2−2.0 m thick) for most of the year and are ice free for 1−2 months of the year in Brown Bay and 3−4 months in the other bays. Sea ice reduces physical disturbance of the seabed by icebergs and from wave or wind induced turbulence. Access to these sites was permitted by the Australian Antarctic Division, and the work did not involve endangered or protected species
a) Location of Windmill Islands (WI) in East Antarctica; b) the Windmill Islands area around Newcomb and O’Brien Bays showing the position of Casey station and sites in O’Brien Bay with inset c) Casey station, and Shannon and Brown Bays. The topographic data was obtained from the Australian Antarctic Data Centre (https://data.aad.gov.au/aadc/portal/drill_down.cfm?id=14) and used with permission under the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Unported License. The map was made with ArcGIS 10.4.
Brown Bay is in the southwestern corner of Newcomb Bay. The southern shore is composed of ice cliffs and its western and northern shores are an ice bank at the end of Thala Valley, the location of a former waste disposal site . During summer, a melt stream flows down Thala Valley into Brown Bay. O'Brien Bay is on the southern side of Bailey Peninsula and the shore consists of ice cliffs, 2−30 m high . Shannon Bay is bordered by ice cliffs 2−15 m high and has a wastewater outfall discharging into the ice cliff adjacent to the bay. Brown Bay and Shannon Bay are adjacent to sources of contamination (~50 m from the waste disposal site and ~100 m from the sewage outfall, respectively) and are contaminated with petroleum hydrocarbons and heavy metals which are much higher in comparison to the control sites (Table 1) . Salinity and temperature were measured in previous studies and all sites had similar oceanographic conditions, with small seasonal fluctuations in salinity (33–36‰) and temperature (-0.5 to -1.9°C) [30,31].
The settlement panels consisted of unglazed porcelain tiles (15 × 15 cm), with a slightly textured upper surface and 3 × 3 cm slightly raised grid (~1 mm high) on the lower surface (Fig 2A). Two tiles were attached 10 cm apart to the top edge of a trough made from one-half of a 40 cm long, 15 cm diameter PVC stormwater pipe (see the detailed experimental design in ). Tiles were deployed and collected by divers at 5 sites (Table 2). Three sites are known to be impacted by human activities: Brown Bay Inner (BBI) and Brown Bay Outer (BBO), ~50 m and 500 m from an abandoned waste disposal site respectively, and Shannon Bay (SB), ~100 m from a sewage outfall)(Fig 1), and have contaminated sediments (Table 1) and disturbed benthic communities [29,32]. There were two uncontaminated control sites: O'Brien Bay-2 (OB2) and O’Brien Bay-3 (OB3) in O’Brien Bay, south of Casey Station (Fig 1C). Tiles were deployed at two depths at each site (6 to 10 m and 19 to 22 m) except at BBI and BBO. Colonization and assemblage development at species level are highly site-specific and depth-dependent in Antarctica . At each depth, tiles were deployed in two plots ~20 m apart in groups of eight tiles (four troughs ~1 to 2 m apart), with a total of 32 tiles at each location (Fig 2B). It was not possible to deploy deep tiles at BBI, as there is no deep habitat near the waste disposal site, nor was it possible to deploy shallow tiles at BBO. However, at these two sites, two groups of eight tiles (in plots of four troughs) were placed ~50 m apart to examine small-scale spatial variation. Tiles were deployed between 15 November and 31 December 1997 and collected after 3 y (in December 2001) and 9 y (in November 2006). One tile was collected from each of two randomly selected troughs at each plot/depth at each sampling time (a total of eight per location).
(a) Two tiles were situated in the top of a trough formed from one-half of a PVC pipe; (b) Experimental design at each site showing groups of eight tiles, two shallow sites and two deep sites.
Collection and identification
Divers collected the tiles which were then preserved in 95% ethanol (Fig 3). Bryozoan colonies were identified to species level in the laboratory using an optical microscope and guide . In subtidal benthic communities, spirorbid polychaetes and bryozoans are characteristic early colonists and dominant species until they are outcompeted by other taxa, particularly by sponges and ascidians (Clarke 1996). Six abundant and widely distributed Antarctic bryozoan species selected for this study were the cheilostomes Arachnopusia decipiens Hayward & Thorpe, 1988, Inversiula nutrix Jullien, 1888, Beania erecta Waters, 1904, Ellisina antarctica Hastings, 1945, and the cyclostomes Disporella sp. and Idmidronea sp. Two abundant spirorbid polychaete species of the genus Spirorbis were also chosen: one morpho-species which forms closely coiled tubes (Spirorbis sp.1) and another morpho-species with tusk-shaped tubes (Spirorbis sp. 2).
Images of the tiles recovered after 6 (A-B) and 9 (C-E) years. A) A cyclostome colony of Disporella sp.; B) Spirorbid species which form closely coiled tubes (referred here as Spirorbis sp.1); C) a cyclostome colony of Idmidronea sp. and the spirorbid species which form tusk-shaped tubes (top right; Spirorbis sp. 2); D) colonies of the cheilostome Beania erecta. E) entire tile colonized by bryozoan colonies, spirorbid polychaetes and different species of sponges.
Wherever possible, three specimens of each species from each location, each depth and each time were selected for mineralogy analyses. Samples were dissected from 54 tiles with a scalpel blade and a piece (2 mm2) from the growing edge of the bryozoan colonies and entire spirorbid polychaete tubes were removed for analysis. After being air-dried, epibionts were removed to avoid mineralogical contamination.
Samples were powdered using an agate mortar and pestle and placed on a Si-crystal low background holder for analysis. X-ray diffractograms were collected from 5 to 90° 2θ with a Panalytical X'Pert Pro MPD diffractometer, using tube conditions of 45 kV, 40 mA, CuKα radiation, X'Celerator detector, Bragg Brentano geometry, and a slew rate of 5° 2θ per minute. Diffractometer performance was constrained by measurement of silver behenate and a single silicon crystal. Limits of detection vary from 0.1 to ~2 wt% depending on the crystallinity of the phase. Identification of minerals, including poorly ordered phases, was conducted using Panalytical's Highscore Plus software v2.2.4, with ICDD PDF2 and PAN-ICSD databases. Mg-Ca substitution in calcite was quantified via linear interpolation of the angle of the 104 reflection from calcite (CaCO3) (0% Mg-calcite at XX° 2θ) to magnesite (MgCO3) (100% Mg-calcite at YY° 2θ) .
Mineralogies were determined for 754 specimens belonging to six bryozoan species (four cheilostome and two cyclostome species) and two spirorbid polychaete species (Figs 4–7). All species were entirely calcitic. Skeletons were divided into low-Mg calcite (LMC; 0–4 wt% MgCO3), intermediate-Mg calcite (IMC; 4–8 wt% MgCO3) and high-Mg calcite (HMC; >8 wt% MgCO3) categories, following a common classification .
Boxes depict standard deviation around mean (mid-line); tail indicates range. Colours indicate high-Mg calcite (red), intermediate-Mg calcite (orange) and low-Mg (yellow). Letters indicate results of PERMANOVA tests and show significant differences between species, as indicated by different letters. Species that share the same letter are not significantly different.
Boxes depict standard deviation around mean (mid-line); tail indicates range. Colours indicate deep and shallow waters.*Brown Bay = BB, OB2 = O'Brien Bay -2, OB3 = O’Brien Bay-3, SB = Shannon Bay. Deep = Deep, shallow = Shall.
Boxes depict standard deviation around mean (mid-line); tail indicates range. Colours indicate deep and shallow waters. *Brown Bay = BB, OB2 = O'Brien Bay -2, OB3 = O’Brien Bay-3, SB = Shannon Bay. Deep = Deep, shallow = Shall.
Sampling and analysis of metals in sediments were done as described in Stark et al. [29,37]. Briefly, samples for heavy metal analysis were sieved through a 2mm mesh screen with clean 0.45μm filtered seawater to remove coarse material. The <2mm fraction was oven dried at 103°C and dried samples were broken with a spatula and 5g was digested in 1M HCl for 4h on a shaker plate as recommended by Scouller et al.  and Snape et al. . Extracts were filtered through a 0.45 μm cellulose nitrate filter and analysed for a range of metals by Quadrupole-ICPMS (Perkin Elmer Elan 6100-DRC). All glass and plasticware used in the processing were washed in 10% HNO3 and triple rinsed in MQ+ deionised water. Metal concentrations in procedural blanks were typically three orders of magnitude lower than in control sediments. Sampling of sediments for hydrocarbons was done as described in Stark et al.  and analysis of total petroleum hydrocarbons was done as described in Stark et al. .
To test for differences among species, year, depth and site, a 4 factor PERMANOVA [41–44] was used. The design included the fixed factors (species, year and depth) and site nested in the combination of species, year and depth. Where significant differences were found, post hoc pairwise PERMANOVA tests were performed. PERMANOVA was done on untransformed skeletal Mg-calcite using a Euclidean distance similarity matrix, which is directly analogous to a univariate ANOVA  but is well suited to unbalanced designs, such as is the case in this study (e.g. for depth). To test for differences in mineralogy between contaminated and control sites a three factor design was used with Impact (BBI, BBO and SB vs OB), Species and Site (nested in impact x species). The program PRIMER7 (V7.0.13, PRIMER-e, Quest Research Limited) was used for these analyses and the graphical displays were produced using R version 3.5.0 . The package Lattice  was called to perform some of the analysis.
Statistical analysis of mineralogy was done in a four factor design with Species, Year, Depth and Site (nested in species, year and depth) and indicated significant effects of species, depth and site but not year (Table 3). There was a strong significant difference in the mean wt% MgCO3 in calcite among species and sites (Fig 4–7; Table 3) and there was a small but significant difference among depths (Table 3). There were no significant interactions between species, year or depth (Table 3), indicating differences between species were consistent. There was no effect of year of sampling.
The design included the fixed factors (species, year and depth) and site nested in the combination of species, year and depth. PERMANOVA was done on untransformed skeletal Mg-calcite using a Euclidean distance similarity matrix. % var = Estimates of components of variation of Mg content in calcite for each factor in the analysis. Bold type indicates significant difference at p = 0.001.
Intra- and interspecific variation in skeletal Mg-calcite
Arachnopusia decipiens (n = 53), Ellisina antarctica (n = 28), Idmidronea sp. (n = 72) and Disporella sp. (n = 111), Spirorbis sp. 1 (n = 136) and sp. 2 (n = 117) had skeletons of IMC (4–8 wt% MgCO3 in calcite) (Fig 4). Of the remaining species, Beania erecta (n = 109) consisted of HMC (>8 wt% MgCO3 in calcite) and Inversiula nutrix (n = 128), of LMC (2–4 wt% MgCO3 in calcite). The pairwise tests for species showed that there is a significant difference in the mean wt% MgCO3 in calcite among most species except E. antarctica versus Spirorbis sp. 2 (PERMANOVA pairwise test: P = 0.067) and A. decipiens (P = 0.051), Spirorbis sp. 2 versus A. decipiens (P = 0.402), Spirorbis sp. 1 versus B. erecta (P = 0.154), Idmidronea sp. versus Disporella sp. (P = 0.051) (Fig 4; Table 4). Differences in skeletal Mg-calcite between species contributed to >62% of the total observed variation (Fig 4; Table 4). Variation within species (residual variation among replicates within same depth, year and site) contributed ~24% to overall variation.
Spatio-temporal analysis in skeletal Mg-calcite
Differences among sites (which are confined to comparisons among the same species, depths and years as this was a nested factor in the analysis, i.e. site was nested in species, year and depth) were significant and contributed ~9% of the variance (Table 3, Figs 5–7).
The effects of contamination on mineralogy were analysed in a three factor design with Impact, Species and Site (nested in impact x species). There was no significant overall effect difference in skeletal Mg-calcite concentrations between contaminated (sediments contaminated with petroleum hydrocarbons and heavy metals; Brown Bay Inner (BBShall) and Shannon Bay (SB)) and control sites (Brown Bay Outer (BBDeep), O'Brien Bay-2 (OB2) and O’Brien Bay-3 (OB3)) (Table 5) nor any significant difference for any individual species between contaminated and control sites (species x impact interaction, Table 5).
This study evaluates the variability of wt% MgCO3 in calcite in the skeletons of a large number of specimens of common bryozoan and spirorbid taxa in coastal Antarctic waters, one of the regions expected to be first affected by global change in the near future and where taxa may be more susceptible to contamination than lower latitudes. To our knowledge, this is the first study addressing the spatio-temporal variability of skeletal Mg-calcite using bryozoan and spirorbid polychaete species as models in an experiment of settlement tiles in Antarctica. These two taxonomic groups, and some genera and species studied here (e.g. Arachnopusia, Beania, E. antarctica), are common components of hard-substratum sessile assemblages across a wide range of cold latitudes (e.g. the South American Region) . All species had calcitic skeletons, which is consistent with our expectations from previous research on bryozoans and spirorbids from high latitudes [26,49–52]. This trend is possibly due to low temperatures favouring the deposition of calcite over aragonite as the latter is more susceptible to dissolution in cold waters .
Inter- and intraspecific variability in skeletal Mg-calcite
Inter-specific differences in the mean wt% MgCO3 in calcite were the largest source of variation overall. Remarkably, there were significant differences in the skeletal Mg-calcite between all bryozoan species except between E. antarctica and A. decipiens (which were on the borderline of a < 5% probability of significant difference) and between the two cyclostome species. There was a wide range of wt% MgCO3 in calcite measurements in the bryozoan and spirorbid polychaete species studied here, from 0.1–13.1 wt% MgCO3 in calcite. These values are not surprising for wt% MgCO3 in calcite in bryozoans, which can range from 0 to 14 [49,50], nor for spirorbids, which range from 7 to 15 . Only one species was classified as LMC (Inversiula nutrix); five as IMC (Arachnopusia decipiens, Ellisina antarctica, Disporella sp., Idmidronea sp. and Spirorbis sp. 1 and sp. 2); and one as HMC (Beania erecta). Most cheilostome bryozoans secrete IMC [49,50], which is further confirmed by this study. To our knowledge, this study also represents the first mineralogical measurements made for the species A. decipiens. Our values are within the range of wt% MgCO3 in calcite obtained by previous studies in Antarctic cheilostome bryozoans except for B. erecta, which has been reported to be IMC [26,53,54]. The skeletons of B. erecta in our study showed higher mean Mg values even though the range was highly variable (5.3–13.6 wt% MgCO3 in calcite). This species exhibits a wide geographical distribution in Antarctica and it could explain the broad range of wt% MgCO3 in calcite found here. Other studies have reported ICM and LMC skeletons in E. antarctica and I. nutrix, respectively, from King George and Adelaide Islands (Antarctic Peninsula)[24,26,50]. Significant differences were found in the skeletal Mg-calcite even between cheilostomes of the same suborder Flustrina, in B. erecta and E. antarctica, although they belong to different families (Beaniidae and Ellisinidae, respectively). Coinciding with our results on the cyclostome genera, Idmidronea sp. and Disporella sp. produced LMC and HMC in a previous study .
The next biggest source of variation was among individuals of the same species, reflecting intraspecific variability. Therefore, biological processes, also known as vital effects , seem to be the main factors controlling the skeletal Mg-calcite in these organisms and, in the case of bryozoans, at intra- and interspecific and intracolonial levels . Other studies provide corroborative evidence that the variation in the skeletal Mg-calcite in spirorbid polychaete species  and Antarctic bryozoans is partially biologically mediated [24,26].
Potential environmental influence on skeletal Mg-calcite
Differences among sites (within species) contributed less to variation in skeletal Mg-calcite than among species but was still a significant effect. Several studies have demonstrated that marine calcifiers such as bryozoans, coccoliths, foraminifera and sea stars can respond differently to a range of environmental factors (e.g. water temperature, alkalinity, salinity and Mg/Ca ratio of seawater) [12,24,25,58–60]. The small effect size of differences among sites could reflect the relatively stable environment which occurs in the water column beneath long-lived sea ice. These bays, which are covered by fast sea-ice almost all the year, have little annual variation in seawater temperatures and would therefore have little influence on the skeletal Mg contents in calcite in any species there, as suggested in previous studies focusing on cold water bryozoans [24,25]. However, the differences between sites could be due to variation in other factors such as freshwater input from summer ice melt. Freshwater inputs can affect seawater chemistry and temperature and also transport sediment into nearshore habitats. In Brown Bay for example, freshwater input from a melt stream carries sediment contaminated with metals and hydrocarbons into the bay, which has led to the contamination of sediments [29,37] within the bay and has resulted in effects on benthic communities recruiting to hard surfaces . However, more environmental data from these sites, or a broader range of environmental variation among sites, are required to disentangle the main factors influencing spatial differences in skeletal Mg.
Although depth had the least effect, it was significant, with deeper sites having slightly higher Mg content in calcite, however this result was only due to significantly higher values of Mg content in calcite of Spirorbis sp. 2 in deeper waters from three locations (BBOuter, OB2 and OB3). Other species, however, such as I. nutrix and Spirorbis sp.1 exhibited higher values from shallow control locations than deeper samples. Therefore, there was not any clear depth-related pattern. The lack of influence of depth on mineralogy found is probably due to the narrow depth range (10 m) that was sampled.
Although there was no evidence of effects of contaminated sediments on skeletal Mg-calcite concentrations, further studies covering a broader area and focusing on other species, different contaminants or higher contaminant levels are needed to evaluate whether or not the Mg content in calcite might be indirectly influenced by contaminated sediments. Heavy metal toxicity may reduce growth rates of marine invertebrates such as bryozoans and worms [14,15], due to the investment in fitness traits (e.g. growth or reproduction) which are compromised by investment in detoxification mechanisms . Also, organisms with slower growth rates tend to deposit less wt% MgCO3 in calcite . Therefore, we could expect lower skeletal Mg content in areas exposed to heavy metals. However, the absence of an effect of contamination could alternatively be due to the fact that these sessile invertebrates are growing on hard surfaces and not in direct contact with the contaminated sediments and thus limiting their exposure.
Temporal analyses in skeletal Mg-calcite
We document short term temporal analyses in skeletal Mg-calcite (over a 3 year period) for the first time in a human impacted area. Other studies investigated potential temporal variation in skeletal Mg-calcite for greater periods from 30 y to millions of years [26,50]. In our study, temporal variability in skeletal Mg was not detected. Similarly, another study evaluating temporal variability in skeletal Mg-calcite in the Antarctic bryozoan species Cellaria diversa Livingstone, 1928 and Antarcticaetos bubeccata (Rogick, 1955) over 30 y did not find any significant temporal differences . The lack of temporal variability in skeletal mineralogy means that these species would make excellent long term indicators of the potential effects of environmental change, based on the assumption that such environmental changes (e.g. ocean acidification) would affect skeletal mineralogy.
Vulnerability of the Antarctic target species in a changing world
Environmental changes could affect survival and calcification of some Antarctic marine calcifiers studied here, particularly those with HMC skeletons and low thermal tolerance [5,9,62]. Spirorbid polychaete tubes are mainly composed of the most vulnerable calcium carbonate minerals to ocean acidification (aragonite, HMC or a mixture of the two) . In our study, Beania erecta and Spirorbis sp. 1 skeletons contained a high proportion of magnesium ions (with mean wt% MgCO3 in calcite (± SD) of 8.1 ± 1.52 and 7.7 ± 0.69, respectively). The solubility of the skeletons of both species is expected to be greater than that of IMC and LMC or even of aragonite . Although some spirorbid polychaetes seem to have the ability to vary their tube mineralogy with seawater chemistry changes, such alterations may result in a deterioration of the tube hardness and elasticity . Consequently, these species are highly likely to be vulnerable to global ocean surface pH reductions of 0.3–0.5 units by the year 2100 . Experimental evidence for this is limited, but the Mediterranean bryozoan Myriapora truncata (Pallas, 1766), which has a wt% MgCO3 in calcite between 8.0 and 9.5, has been shown to be vulnerable to ocean acidification at a pH of 7.66, with significant loss of skeleton during a short-term experiment . Further work on Antarctic species is required to determine their vulnerability to such predicted changes.
There is an increase of Mg content in cheilostome bryozoans towards lower latitudes, which is attributed to the warmer seawater . Larger values of Mg in two common co-occurring Mediterranean bryozoans M. truncata and Pentapora fascialis (Pallas, 1766) were also found when the colonies were exposed to high temperatures . Spirorbid tubes also show an increase in Mg content with increasing water temperatures . In addition, there are potentially interactive effects of multiple environmental changes (e.g. warming, acidification and pollution) which should be considered as they can co-occur. The combined effects of increased temperature and reduced pH (from increased CO2 concentrations) on the widely distributed cheilostome bryozoan Jellyella tuberculata (Bosc, 1802), including from subAntarctic regions , was found to dissolve their zooids, possibly due to an increase of skeletal Mg content at high temperatures which made the skeletons more susceptible to dissolution under high CO2 . Therefore, organisms living in Antarctic coastal areas that have experienced significant warming in recent years (e.g. Western Antarctic Peninsula) could become more vulnerable to environmental changes if their Mg content increases with temperature , however it is not known whether this is occurring.
Such changes could potentially lead to shifts in community composition of calcareous marine organisms in future oceans, especially in polar regions . Species with HMC, such as B. erecta and Spirorbis sp. 1, may be particularly vulnerable to the combined effects of ocean acidification and global change, although variation in species-specific responses is anticipated. Potential decreases of some species such as B. erecta, which is widely distributed and common throughout Antarctica and has colonies which comprise dense mats and may cover large areas of substratum, could indirectly negatively impact other organisms which use their colonies as substrate, food and shelter . This could be expected in colonies living in shallow waters of some Antarctic regions more exposed to increased temperatures such as the Antarctic Peninsula. However, B. erecta, has a depth range from 0 to >1500 m , and cooler deep waters may form refugia for this and other species. Also, B. erecta is a competitive dominant species, out-competing other bryozoan species like Inversiula nutrix and other sessile organisms . Its decrease could favour other less competitive species such as I. nutrix, which may be more resilient to acidification due to lower Mg content of its skeleton and, consequently, replacing the ecological niche occupied by B. erecta.
Calcifying marine invertebrates are important components of marine ecosystems and the effects of environmental change at the species level could potentially lead to wider ecosystem level effects. Given the range and variation in mineralogy of calcifying species observed in this study, some species are likely to be more heavily affected than others. Further work is required to better understand the potential impacts of ocean acidification on marine benthic communities, particularly in areas predicted to change rapidly in the near future such as Antarctic shallow waters [71,72]. As rapid reductions in global atmospheric greenhouse gas emissions are unlikely to occur in the near future and a certain amount of climate change and ocean acidification are already assured, it is even more important for polar conservation to manage threats such as pollution that are likely to interact synergistically with climate change, and that are potentially more tractable in the short to medium term .
We thank dive teams at Casey Station for field assistance, Dr. P. D. Taylor and two anonymous reviewers for their constructive suggestions. The research visit of B. Figuerola to the Australian Antarctic Division and Macquarie University was supported by a Council of Managers of National Antarctic Programs (COMNAP) Research Fellowship. This project was supported financially by the Australian Antarctic Division grant AAS 4127.
- 1. Caldeira K, Wickett ME. Ocean model predictions of chemistry changes from carbon dioxide emissions to the atmosphere and ocean. Journal of Geophysical Research. 2005;110: 1–12.
- 2. Millero F, Woosley R, DiTrolio B, Waters J. Effect of Ocean Acidification on the Speciation of Metals in Seawater. Oceanography. 2009;22: 72–85.
- 3. Fabry V, McClintock J, Mathis J, Grebmeier J. Ocean Acidification at High Latitudes: The Bellwether. Oceanography. 2009;22: 160–171.
- 4. Chapman PM, Riddle MJ. Missing and needed: Polar marine ecotoxicology. Marine Pollution Bulletin. 2003;46: 927–928. pmid:12907184
- 5. Andersson AJ, Mackenzie FT, Bates NR. Life on the margin: Implications of ocean acidification on Mg-calcite, high latitude and cold-water marine calcifiers. Marine Ecology Progress Series. 2008;373: 265–273.
- 6. Thompson BAW, Goldsworthy PM, Riddle MJ, Snape I, Stark JS. Contamination effects by a “conventional” and a “biodegradable” lubricant oil on infaunal recruitment to Antarctic sediments: A field experiment. Journal of Experimental Marine Biology and Ecology. 2007;340: 213–226.
- 7. Stark JS. Patterns of higher taxon colonisation and development in sessile marine benthic assemblages at Casey Station, Antarctica, and their use in environmental monitoring. Marine Ecology Progress Series. 2008;365: 77–89.
- 8. Bargagli R. Antarctic ecosystems: environmental contamination, climate change, and human impact [Internet]. Ecological studies 175. Berlin: Springer-Verlag; 2005. Available: http://agris.fao.org/agris-search/search.do?recordID=US9182141
- 9. Orr JC, Fabry VJ, Aumont O, Bopp L, Doney SC, Feely R a, et al. Anthropogenic ocean acidification over the twenty-first century and its impact on calcifying organisms. Nature. 2005;437: 681–686. pmid:16193043
- 10. Ries JB. Skeletal mineralogy in a high-CO2 world. Journal of Experimental Marine Biology and Ecology. 2011;403: 54–64.
- 11. Davis KJ, Dove PM, De Yoreo JJ. The role of Mg2+ as an impurity in calcite growth. Science. 2000;290: 1134–1137. pmid:11073446
- 12. Borremans C, Hermans J, Baillon S, André L, Dubois P. Salinity effects on the Mg/Ca and Sr/Ca in starfish skeletons and the echinoderm relevance for paleoenvironmental reconstructions. Geology. 2009;37: 351–354.
- 13. Chan VBS, Thiyagarajan V, Lu XW, Zhang T, Shih K. Temperature dependent effects of elevated CO2 on shell composition and mechanical properties of Hydroides elegans: Insights from a multiple stressor experiment. PLoS ONE. 2013;8: e78945. pmid:24265732
- 14. Levinton JS, Suatoni E, Wallace W, Junkins R, Kelaher B, Allen BJ. Rapid loss of genetically based resistance to metals after the cleanup of a Superfund site. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America. 2003;100: 9889–9891. pmid:12904581
- 15. Piola RF, Johnston EL. Differential tolerance to metals among populations of the introduced bryozoan Bugula neritina. Marine Biology. 2006;148: 997–1010.
- 16. Kamenos NA, Perna G, Gambi MC, Micheli F, Kroeker KJ. Coralline algae in a naturally acidified ecosystem persist by maintaining control of skeletal mineralogy and size. Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences. 2016;283: 20161159. pmid:27733544
- 17. Clarke A, Survey BA, Cross H, Road M, Oet CCB. The distribution of Antarctic marine benthic communities. Antarctic Research Series. 1996;70: 219–230.
- 18. Barnes DKA, Griffiths HJ. Biodiversity and biogeography of southern temperate and polar bryozoans. Global Ecology and Biogeography. 2008;17: 84–99.
- 19. Figuerola B, Monleón-getino T, Ballesteros M, Avila C. Spatial patterns and diversity of bryozoan communities from the Southern Ocean: South Shetland Islands, Bouvet Island and Eastern Weddell Sea. Systematics and Biodiversity. 2012;10: 109–123.
- 20. Smith AM. Growth and calcification of marine bryozoans in a changing ocean. Biological Bulletin. 2014;226: 203–210. pmid:25070865
- 21. Wright JT, Gribben PE. Disturbance-mediated facilitation by an intertidal ecosystem engineer. Ecology. 2017;98: 2425–2436. pmid:28628212
- 22. Smith AM, Riedi MA, Winter DJ. Temperate reefs in a changing ocean: Skeletal carbonate mineralogy of serpulids. Marine Biology. 2013;160: 2281–2294.
- 23. Vinn O, Ten Hove HA, Mutvei H, Kirsimäe K. Ultrastructure and mineral composition of serpulid tubes (Polychaeta, Annelida). Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society. 2008;154: 633–650.
- 24. Loxton J, Kuklinski P, Barnes DKA, Najorka J, Jones MS, Porter JS. Variability of Mg-calcite in Antarctic bryozoan skeletons across spatial scales. Marine Ecology Progress Series. 2014;507: 169–180.
- 25. Figuerola B, Kuklinski P, Taylor P. Depth patterns in Antarctic bryozoan skeletal Mg-calcite: Can they provide an analogue for future environmental changes? Marine Ecology Progress Series. 2015;540: 109–120.
- 26. Krzeminska M, Kuklinski P, Najorka J, Iglikowska A. Skeletal Mineralogy Patterns of Antarctic Bryozoa. The Journal of Geology. 2016;124: 411–422.
- 27. Stark JS. The distribution and abundance of soft-sediment macrobenthos around Casey Station, East Antarctica. Polar Biology. 2000;23: 840–850.
- 28. Stark JS, Snape I, Riddle MJ. Abandoned Antarctic waste disposal sites: Monitoring remediation outcomes and limitations at Casey Station. Ecological Management and Restoration. 2006. p. 7:21–31.
- 29. Stark JS, Riddle MJ, Snape I, Scouller RC. Human impacts in Antartic marine soft-sediment assemblages: Correlations between multivariate biological patterns and environmental variables at Casey Station. Estuarine, Coastal and Shelf Science. 2003;56: 717–734.
- 30. Stark JS, Johnstone GJ, Palmer AS, Larner BL, Riddle MJ. Monitoring the remediation of a near shore waste disposal site in Antarctica using the amphipod Paramoera walkeri and diffusive gradients in thin films (DGTs). Marine Pollution Bulletin. 2006;52: 1595–1610. pmid:16870214
- 31. Stark JS, Roden NP, Johnstone GJ, Milnes M, Black JG, Whiteside S, et al. Carbonate chemistry of an in-situ free-ocean CO2 enrichment experiment (antFOCE) in comparison to short term variation in Antarctic coastal waters. Scientific Reports. Springer US; 2018;8: 1–16. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-017-17765-5
- 32. Stark JS, Snape I, Riddle MJ. The effects of petroleum hydrocarbon and heavy metal contamination of marine sediments on recruitment of Antarctic soft-sediment assemblages: a field experimental investigation. Journal of Experimental Marine Biology and Ecology. 2003;283: 21–50.
- 33. Bowden DA, Clarke A, Peck LS, Barnes DKA. Antarctic sessile marine benthos: colonisation and growth on artificial substrata over three years. Marine Ecology Progress Series. 2006;316: 1–16.
- 34. Hayward P. Antarctic Cheilostomatous Bryozoa. Oxford University Press, Oxford. 1995;
- 35. Mackenzie FT, Bischoff WD, Bishop FC, Loijens M, Schoonmaker J, Wollast R. Magnesian calcites: low-temperature occurrence, solubility and solid-solution behavior. Carbonates: Mineralogy and Chemistry. 1983; 97–144. Available: http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?eid=2-s2.0-0021080597&partnerID=40&md5=abf2bbd57957f8cf91519411ddd9d58e
- 36. Rucker JB, Carver RE. A Survey of the Carbonate Mineralogy of Cheilostome Bryozoa. Journal of Paleontology. Paleontological Society; 1969;43: 791–799. Available: http://www.jstor.org/stable/1302474
- 37. Stark JS, Snape I, Riddle MJ, Stark SC. Constraints on spatial variability in soft-sediment communities affected by contamination from an Antarctic waste disposal site. Marine Pollution Bulletin. 2005;50: 276–290. pmid:15757691
- 38. Scouller RC, Snape I, Stark JS, Gore DB. Evaluation of geochemical methods for discrimination of metal contamination in Antarctic marine sediments: A case study from Casey Station. Chemosphere. 2006;65: 294–309. pmid:16650458
- 39. Snape I, Scouller RC, Stark SC, Stark J, Riddle MJ, Gore DB. Characterisation of the dilute HCl extraction method for the identification of metal contamination in Antarctic marine sediments. Chemosphere. 2004;57: 491–504. pmid:15350411
- 40. Stark JS, Bridgen P, Dunshea G, Galton-Fenzi B, Hunter J, Johnstone G, et al. Dispersal and dilution of wastewater from an ocean outfall at Davis Station, Antarctica, and resulting environmental contamination. Chemosphere. Elsevier Ltd; 2016;152: 142–157. pmid:26966813
- 41. Anderson MJ. A new method for non parametric multivariate analysis of variance. Austral Ecology. 2001;26: 32–46.
- 42. Anderson MJ, Teer Braak CJF. Permutation tests for multi-factorial analysis of variance. Journal of Statistical Computation and Simulation. 2003;73: 85–113.
- 43. McArdle BH, Anderson MJ. Fitting multivariate models to community data: A comment on distance-based redundancy analysis. Ecology. 2001;82: 290–297.
- 44. Anderson MJ. Permutation tests for univariate or multivariate analysis of variance and regression. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences. 2001;58: 626–639.
- 45. Anderson MJ, Gorley RN, Clarke KR. PERMANOVA+ for PRIMER: Guide to Software and Statistical Methods. Plymouth, UK. 2008. pp. 1–214. https://doi.org/10.13564/j.cnki.issn.1672-9382.2013.01.010
- 46. R Core Team. R: A language and environment for statistical computing. R Foundation for Statistical Computing. Vienna, Austria. URL https://www.R-project.org/.; 2018.
- 47. Sarkar D. Lattice: multivariate data visualization with R. Springer, New York. Use R! 2008; https://doi.org/10.1007/978-0-387-75969-2
- 48. Figuerola B, Barnes DKA, Brickle P, Brewin PE. Bryozoan diversity around the Falkland and South Georgia Islands: Overcoming Antarctic barriers. Marine Environmental Research. Elsevier Ltd; 2017;126: 81–94. pmid:28258012
- 49. Smith AM, Key MM, Gordon DP. Skeletal mineralogy of bryozoans: Taxonomic and temporal patterns. Earth-Science Reviews. 2006;78: 287–306.
- 50. Taylor PD, James NP, Bone Y, Kuklinski P, Kyser TK. Evolving mineralogy of cheilostome bryozoans. Palaios. 2009;24: 440–452.
- 51. Kuklinski P, Taylor PD. Mineralogy of Arctic bryozoan skeletons in a global context. Facies. 2009;55: 489–500.
- 52. Bornhold BD, Milliman JD. Generic and environmental control of carbonate mineralogy in serpulid (polychaete) tubes. The Journal of Geology. 1973;81: 363–373. Available: http://www.jstor.org/stable/30084830
- 53. Borisenko Y, Gontar VI. Biogeochemistry of skeletons of coldwater Bryozoa. Biol Morya. 1991;1: 80–90.
- 54. Taylor P. New species of cheilostomate Bryozoa from Antarctica and the Subantarctic southwest Atlantic. Journal of Natural History. 2009;39: 2671–2704.
- 55. Weiner S, Dove PM. An overview of biomineralization processes and the problem of the vital effect. Reviews in Mineralogy and Geochemistry. 2003;54: 1–29.
- 56. Taylor PD, Lombardi C, Cocito S. Biomineralization in bryozoans: present, past and future. Biological Reviews. 2015;90: 1118–50. pmid:25370313
- 57. Bornhold BD, Milliman JD. Generic and environmental control of carbonate mineralogy in serpulid (polychaete) tubes. The Journal of Geology. 1973;81: 363–373.
- 58. Stoll HM, Ruiz Encinar J, Ignacio Garcia Alonso J, Rosenthal Y, Probert I, Klaas C. A first look at paleotemperature prospects from Mg in coccolith carbonate: Cleaning techniques and culture measurements. Geochemistry Geophysics Geosystems. 2001;2: 2000GC000144.
- 59. Russell AD, Hönisch B, Spero HJ, Lea DW. Effects of seawater carbonate ion concentration and temperature on shell U, Mg, and Sr in cultured planktonic foraminifera. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta. 2004;68: 4347–4361.
- 60. Stanley SM, Ries JB, Hardie LA. Seawater chemistry, coccolithophore population growth, and the origin of Cretaceous chalk. Geology. 2005;33: 593.
- 61. Sibly RM, Calow P. A life‐cycle theory of responses to stress. Biological Journal of the Linnean Society. 1989;37: 101–116.
- 62. IPCC. Global Warming of 1.5°C. Summary for Policymakers. Contribution of Working Groups I, II and III to the 48th Session of the IPCC, Incheon, Republic of Korea [Internet]. 2018. Available: http://report.ipcc.ch/sr15/pdf/sr15_spm_final.pdf
- 63. Morse JW, Andersson AJ, Mackenzie FT. Initial responses of carbonate-rich shelf sediments to rising atmospheric pCO2 and “ocean acidification”: Role of high Mg-calcites. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 70. 2006;70: 5814–5830.
- 64. Chan VBS, Li C, Lane AC, Wang Y, Lu X, Shih K, et al. CO2-driven ocean acidification alters and weakens integrity of the calcareous tubes produced by the serpulid tubeworm, Hydroides elegans. PLoS ONE. 2012;7: e42718. pmid:22912726
- 65. Lombardi C, Rodolfo-Metalpa R, Cocito S, Gambi MC, Taylor D. Structural and geochemical alterations in the Mg calcite bryozoan Myriapora truncata under elevated seawater pCO2 simulating ocean acidification. Marine Ecology. 2011;32: 211–221.
- 66. Pagès-Escolà M, Hereu B, Garrabou J, Montero-Serra I, Gori A, Gómez-Gras D, et al. Divergent responses to warming of two common co-occurring Mediterranean bryozoans. Scientific Reports. 2018;8: 17455. pmid:30498253
- 67. GBIF.org (16 October 2018) GBIF Occurrence Download.
- 68. Swezey DS, Bean JR, Ninokawa AT, Hill TM, Gaylord B, Sanford E. Interactive effects of temperature, food and skeletal mineralogy mediate biological responses to ocean acidification in a widely distributed bryozoan. Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences. 2017;284: 20162349. pmid:28424343
- 69. Meredith MP, King JC. Rapid climate change in the ocean west of the Antarctic Peninsula during the second half of the 20th century. Geophysical Research Letters. 2005;
- 70. Clark GF, Stark JS, Johnston EL. Tolerance rather than competition leads to spatial dominance of an Antarctic bryozoan. Journal of Experimental Marine Biology and Ecology. 2017;486: 222–229.
- 71. Mcneil BI, Matear RJ. Southern Ocean acidification: A tipping point at 450-ppm atmospheric CO2. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America. 2008;105: 18860–18864. pmid:19022908
- 72. Negrete-garcía G, Lovenduski NS, Hauri C, Krumhardt KM, Lauvset SK. Sudden emergence of a shallow aragonite saturation horizon in the Southern Ocean. Nature Climate Change. 2019;9: 313–317.
- 73. Bennett JR, Shaw JD, Terauds A, Smol JP, Aerts R, Bergstrom DM, et al. Polar lessons learned: long-term management based on shared threats in Arctic and Antarctic environments. Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment. 2015;13: 316–324.