The formation of dental caries is mainly caused by dietary habits and therefore, may contain information for dietary reconstructions of fossil hominids. This study investigates the caries lesion in the 12.5 Ma old type specimen of Dryopithecus carinthiacus Mottl 1957 (Primates, Hominidae) from St. Stefan (Austria). Potential food sources are identified on associated palynological data, which allow conclusions about food quality, sugar availability and the hominid metabolism during the Middle Miocene. Using micro computed tomography (μCT) and scanning electron microscopy (SEM) we provide a detailed analysis and characterization of the individuals’ caries type. Its lesion is compared with a dataset of 311 wild chimpanzees, indicating morphological and etiological differences in caries formation between both species. The affected molar of D. carinthiacus reveals features known from severe dental caries in humans: (1) Cavitation with steep walls and smooth surface; (2) Reparative dentine at the roof of the pulp chamber; (3) Sclerotic dentine below the cavitation; (4) Association with dental calculus and (5) Unilateral usage of the healthy right tooth row. Its advanced primary caries, initiating on the intact enamel surface, indicates a frequent intake of highly cariogenic sugar-rich fruits, which likely exceeds the frugivory of extant chimpanzees. This finding corresponds with the associated palynological record, which infers a habitat with nearly year-round supply (9–10 months/year) of high quality foods (>carbohydrates; < fibers). Our conclusions challenge the model of a step-wise increase in dietary quality during hominid evolution and support the uricase hypothesis, which discusses the hominid autapomorphy of a fructose-based fat accumulation for periods of starvation. This model receives further validation by the identification of soft-tissue preservation, interpreted as fossilized white adipose cells, in the articulated hominid skeleton of Oreopithecus bamboli from Italy.
Citation: Fuss J, Uhlig G, Böhme M (2018) Earliest evidence of caries lesion in hominids reveal sugar-rich diet for a Middle Miocene dryopithecine from Europe. PLoS ONE 13(8): e0203307. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0203307
Editor: Colin Johnson, Oregon State University, UNITED STATES
Received: March 2, 2018; Accepted: August 17, 2018; Published: August 30, 2018
Copyright: © 2018 Fuss et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Data Availability: All relevant data are within the paper and its Supporting Information files.
Funding: The authors received no specific funding for this work.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Dental caries is a prevalent disease in current societies, reflecting the oral health and dietary conditions of an individual. Although scarce in the fossil record, its occurrence can also give rare insights into the dietary preferences of extinct taxa . Rare records of fossil hominid dental caries are restricted to hominins from the Pleistocene epoch [2–4]. Here we describe a considerably older caries lesion from the Middle Miocene stem-hominine Dryopithecus carinthiacus (Fig 1) from St. Stefan (Lavanttal Basin, Carinthia, Austria). It is the earliest documented caries disease in hominids dating back to the Early Sarmatian (Serravallian, late Middle Miocene) at 12.5 Ma. Its primary formation on the intact enamel surface indicates a highly cariogenic diet of D. carinthiacus, supposedly rich in sugar-rich fruits. For comparison, we developed a database of caries type frequencies for a large population of wild chimpanzees (Pan troglodytes verus, n = 311), known as the most frugivorous extant great apes. Based on palynological data from St. Stefan, we draw inferences about the seasonal availability of fruits and honey, and discuss the potential diet of D. carinthiacus in the framework of hominid metabolism. Our results provide conclusions about the dryopithecine metabolism, supporting the uricase hypothesis [5, 6] and offering new insights into the dietary evolution of early hominids.
a, Carious left m1. b, right m1 without caries lesion, graphically isolated from mandibular bone.
1.1. Hominoid dietary evolution
Hominoids occupied the European continent for about 10 million years during which continental environments, vegetation, and climate changed dramatically. They initially entered the continent at 15.9 Ma (earliest Langhian; recalibrated according to ), when it was a paratropical rainforest environment at the start of the Miocene Climatic Optimum . Their last appearance is recorded at 7.175 Ma (earliest Messinian) from a savannah biome of post-Pikermian time [9, 10] as well as from the late Messinian (5.7 Ma) Trachilos footprints , suggesting substantial shifts in hominid diet and physiology during their presence in Europe.
Extant hominids show a wealth of dietary adaptions that range from diverse vegetal diets (leaves, fruits, tubers) to animal prey (invertebrates and small vertebrates). All living primates are largely territorial and thus, need to cope with the local food resources . Some taxa are specialists that concentrate on certain resources. Today, these dietary specialists mainly occur in low latitudinal forest habitats that show rather low seasonal changes (mainly in rainfall) and a high plant and animal diversity . The high diversity implies high competition for resources, but also allows a specialization on certain food items to reduce dietary competition. In habitats that are more temperate the diversity and interspecies competition is less . However, the availability of resources is subject to larger fluctuations due to seasonal changes in temperature and day length. Primates adapted to such conditions have a larger home range  and are able to use a wider, seasonally varying food spectrum.
Likewise, the fossil hominoid record shows similar and even more extreme adaptions to a wider range of resources . Studies in dentognathic morphology of fossil hominoids suggest a general shift from soft to hard object feeders during the Early to Late Miocene . This shift in anatomy reflects the underlying major changes in habitat and climate with which hominoids had to cope with [8, 10]. The early phase of primate evolution, from Eocene to Oligocene, was represented by small insectivores, followed by folivores with sharp-ridged teeth that were adapted to chop leaves and probably small invertebrates . During the early Miocene, the broader cusps of early hominoids like Proconsul were well suited to pulp fruits and might have been more suitable for a slightly larger food spectrum. However, the lack of shearing blades reduced their ability to adequately process leaf tissue . Similar to their folivorous precursors, their thin enamel, the small teeth and the gracile mandibles were not suitable for abrasive food and hard mastication. However, during the late Early Miocene, afropithecine taxa (Afropithecus, Heliopithecus) developed larger jaws  and for the first time thick enameled teeth . During the Middle Miocene, thick enameled equatorines (Equatorius, Nacholapithecus) and kenyapithecines (Griphopithecus, Kenyapithecus) populated East Africa, Anatolia and Europe [8, 20, 21]. Tooth morphology, enamel thickness and microstructure indicate a diet composed of hard and abrasive food [16, 22, 23]. During the Middle to Late Miocene of Asia, sivapithecines enhanced this adaption with the thick enameled and low-cusped teeth, probably an adaption to intensified seasonality and more opened habitats . Contemporaneously, some of the diverse European dryopithecines (Dryopithecus, Hispanopithecus, Rudapithecus) from early Late Miocene showed rather thin enameled teeth with broad cusps, reminding of the dentition of the largely frugivorous extant chimpanzee [15, 24]. Microwear analyses of incisors and molars infer an intermediate position between frugivores/mixed feeders and hard-object feeders [22, 25]. In contrast, the Middle Miocene dryopithecines Pierolapithecus and Anoiapithecus are characterized as arboreal hard-object feeders, based on the molar microwear and their thicker enamel [22, 26].
The shift towards a hard-object consumption clearly increased during the later parts of the Late Miocene, particularly in Eurasian hominids like Ankarapithecus, Ouranopithecus and Graecopithecus [9, 15, 27, 28]. Their thick-enameled and partially megadont molars enabled them to masticate on fibrous underground foods and highly abrasive grit that becomes ubiquitous with the near-ground eating and the increasing aridity during the Tortonian and Early Messinian [10, 22, 25].
1.2. The Hominid fructose and uric acid metabolic system
Dietary changes during the hominoid evolution are still visible in the physiology of extant hominids, including our own species. An important impact on our current metabolic system might have been the Middle Miocene introduction of a fructose-based diet:
The metabolic pathways of fructose and uric acid are intimately connected. Fructose naturally occurs as monosaccharide in food like fruits and honey, or together with glucose as the disaccharide saccharose (sucrose). Once ingested and resorbed, fructose is instantly converted into fructose-1-phosphate through depletion of ATP to ADP/AMP, resulting in a lack of ATP. ADP/AMP is then, over few more steps, converted into uric acid . This process is accompanied by systemic oxidative stress [30, 31]. Uric acid itself is a high effective anti-oxidant  and stimulates the further degradation of fructose. According, there exists a positive feedback interdependency between fructose and uric acid. Both block the degradation of fatty acids (fructose through the lack of ATP, uric acid inhibits an essential key enzyme) and both rather stimulate lipogenesis . In fact, a fructose-rich diet leads to significant more body fat gain in comparison to an iso-caloric fructose-free diet [34, 35]. High uric acid serum levels also lead to an elevated blood pressure. Furthermore, it is discussed that individuals with elevated uric acid levels may be more active, excitement seeking and venturous in comparison to individuals having lower uric acid levels . In many organisms, uric acid is depleted by the enzyme uricase. In early hominids, however, several pseudogenization events of uricase appeared, finally resulting in a knockout of uricase function and thus permanent elevated serum uric acid levels around 15 Ma . It is hypothesized that the uricase knockout in hominids may have provided a significant survival advantage for upcoming times of food shortage . In an environment where fructose and other short chain carbohydrates are only seasonally available, high uric acid levels allow an accelerated accumulation of fat stores and a more effective utilization of the attainable nutrition. Elevated blood pressure as well as increased activity and venturesomeness may provide an additional advantage for early hominids. Furthermore, it is discussed that high uric acid serum levels may be associated with a higher intelligence [38, 39]. Anyway, it is widely accepted that uric acid is a highly potent neuroprotective agent [38, 40, 41]. Due to its ability to penetrate the blood-brain-barrier, uric acid is considered to decrease the risk of neurodegenerative diseases [38, 42–44]. The fact that a fructose-rich diet rapidly increases fat stores is also found in the seasonal changing food pattern of hibernating and migrating animals . For example, in autumn, migrating songbirds switch from insect or seed based food to fruits to accelerate the accumulation of body fat, which is supposed to be the main energy reserve during long distance migration .
1.3. Caries formation
Due to its common occurrence in modern humans, the process of caries formation is intensively studied in both, extant and extinct humans (e.g. [47, 48]). Caries is the demineralization of dental hard tissue (enamel, cementum and dentine) due to organic acids formed by bacteria in dental plaque . Usually, these pathogenic bacteria (e.g. Streptococcus mutans) are already present in the healthy oral microflora. The dental hard tissue is only affected, if the homeostasis of the oral flora is disturbed. A diet rich in carbohydrates and a low oral pH may cause this disequilibrium. The anaerobic metabolism of particular bacteria, such as S. mutans, converts sugar into organic acids. These acids are lowering the pH of the plaque biofilm and the saliva and demineralize the calcium hydroxyapatite in particular sites of the dentition. Dental plaque preferentially adheres in the interdental spaces, gingival margins and occlusal grooves causing caries lesions typically at these sites. Without treatment, the dissolution of dental hard tissue progresses and leads to the formation of deep cavities . A deep cavity exposing the dentine is the last stage of a carious enamel lesion. In human teeth it needs about 3–4 years to reach this stadium , albeit this penetration time can be far more variable depending on the individual risk status .
In modern humans, caries mostly appears in children and mature adults; young adults are less affected. In children occlusal and interstitial caries dominates, while adults are mainly affected by cervical caries [48, 52]. In adult humans, as well as in non-human primates, the prevalence of caries increases with age . Partially, this is related to the nature of caries as a progressive disease. The proceeding cavitation can pause, but it cannot be restored. Thereby, cavitation increases with age if not treated. Another cause for age-related caries lesions is the way caries is initiated. The formation of caries can be classified in two types : The primary caries initiates on the intact enamel surface. It is common in captured animals and humans, but rare in the wild. The secondary caries is prevalent in wild animals and relates to enamel fractures and/or tooth wear, which proceeds with age. Thereby, cariogenic bacteria may infiltrate the exposed dentine and damage the enamel on a larger area. In turn, a high wear rate might remove occlusal caries, if it develops slowly .
1.4. Cariogenic diet
A cariogenic diet is characterized by a high content of quickly fermentable carbohydrates (e.g. fructose, glucose, sucrose, or cooked starch) and the easy adherence on tooth surfaces. The frequent consumption of such substances lowers the pH of the saliva and thereby, favors the multiplication of cariogenic oral bacteria at the expense of beneficial strains .
A key cause of today’s caries lesions in humans is our diet that is rich in free sugars. Beside these refined sugars, the naturally present sugars (e.g. in fruits or honey) and starch-containing foods are supposed to be cariogenic. However, the role of starch as a cariogenic or co-cariogenic substance is complex. The starch granules first need a mechanical and heat treatment to become effectively cariogenic [50, 55]. This process of gelatinization releases the glucose polymers amylose and amylopectin, which makes them susceptible to the enzymatic breakdown . As an elaborated food preparation is required for this, starch can largely be ignored as a major source of caries in wild animals.
1.5. Caries in fossil hominins
Caries is an ancient disease, not only restricted to the human clade, but also known from a variety of extant and extinct animals. Early records of potential carious destruction of dental hard tissue come from diverse groups of Palaeozoic and Mesozoic animals [56, 57] and Neogene mammals like bovids and bears [1, 58]. However, the incidence in wild animals is very rare compared to modern humans [53, 59, 60]. Dental caries is one of the most prevalent diseases in present societies. Its widespread emergence is a young phenomenon, initiated by the industrial era and mainly associated with the increased consumption of sugar-rich food . Caries is a common oral disease of humans since about 10,000 years, associated with the shift from hunter-gatherers to agriculturalists [4, 47, 62, 63]. Until the Late Paleolithic, early modern humans rarely had caries [64–66]. Older caries lesions are documented in ~60ka old H. neanderthalensis (e.g. [67, 68]) albeit they are not as prevalent as in modern humans . The previously earliest caries lesions in hominids are described in Homo rhodesiensis (ca. 650ka-160ka) [62, 69], Gigantopithecus blacki (1.2Ma-310ka) [70, 71], Homo erectus, Paranthropus robustus (ca. 1.5 Ma) , and early Homo from Dmanisi (1.77 Ma) , all from the Pleistocene epoch.
1.6. Caries in non-human primate dentition
Most studies on caries are aimed for the humans’ dental health, but even if caries is mostly reported from hominin teeth, it also affects non-human dentition [53, 60, 73]. Numerous studies examined the formation of caries on a variety of laboratory animals (e.g. rodents, lagomorphs, primates ). However, these experiments are designed to simulate the human conditions and usually, cannot be transferred to wild animals. Further, there are indications that captured/domestic animals and animals living close to human settings may tend to show a higher incidence of caries compared to the wild ones [53, 60]. This suggests human diet and waste disposal as main culprits for their caries formation. Another possibility is the transmission of zoonotic oral bacteria from humans to animals . In the wild, animals show considerably less caries lesions than humans. Beside dietary differences, other factors like a more alkaline saliva, a differing oral microflora and/or tooth surfaces less susceptible to plaque formation may be related to the rare occurrence in wild animals . Experiments on various laboratory animals show that their teeth may generally be prone to primary caries, but heavy dental wear, a short life span and/or a frequent tooth change may additionally prevent its formation . Supposedly, these inhibiting processes are intensified under natural conditions.
The occurrence and frequency of caries in extant primates is reported in several studies, which are largely covered and summarized in Miles and Grigson . Among extant great apes, caries lesions mainly occur in chimpanzees, whose diet is rich in fruits. The folivorous gorillas are less affected [48, 53]; Pongo, which is intermediate in diet between Pan and Gorilla shows an intermediate caries frequency . Crovella and Ardito  showed that in adult wild primates (Prosimii, Platyrrhini, and Catarrhini), almost every second individual has dental calculus, while only 7.4% have caries. Extant great apes can have occlusal caries, but in contrast to the primary occlusal caries prevailing in modern human teeth, wild great apes generally show severe secondary occlusal caries that is initiated by enhanced dental wear or fractures. The occurrence of severe interstitial/cervical caries is even more frequent, albeit still rare [53, 74]. While primary caries is so far unreported in fossil great apes, the previously earliest evidence of dental calculus in hominids comes from the Miocene Sivapithecus sivalensis from the Siwaliks of NW Pakistan [75, 76] and dates back to ~8.7–9.3 Ma.
2. St. Stefan
2.1. Geological setting, stratigraphy and age
The hominid fossil locality St. Stefan is situated in the Lavanttal Basin (Carinthia, Austria), at the western margin of the Central Paratethys realm. Due to the underground coal mining till 1968, several vertebrate fossils were exposed including the type specimen of D. carinthiacus . The Lavanttal Basin covers an area of about 1000 km2. The geological structure, sedimentology and stratigraphy of this area are well studied (e.g. [78–81]). The alpine mountain ranges Koralpe and Saualpe confine the southern part of the Lavanttal Basin (including the St. Stefan sub-basin); the Packalpe and the Seetaler Alps confine the northern part. These bordering mountains are the visible outcrops of an underlying synclinal structure that forms the crystalline bedrock of the Lavanttal Basin. Tectonics and sediments divide the southern Lavanttal in two areas : The ‘Mulden’ area (St. Stefan sub-basin (N) and Andersdorf-Ettendorf sub-basin (S)) and the ‘Granitztal’-beds.
The deposits of the St. Stefan sub-basin comprise marine, brackish and freshwater sediments (marls, sands and gravels) of Middle to Late Miocene age (?Karpatian, Badenian to Pannonian), intercalated by productive coal seams. As part of the Central Paratethys, the Lavanttal Basin underwent considerable tectonic, environmental and climatic changes [82, 83]. During the Late Badenian, the Central Paratethys got largely isolated from the Tethys Ocean, but a narrow connectivity remained at the Slovenian strait [84, 85]. The base of the Sarmatian, dated to 12.65 Ma  was characterized by a dramatic extinction event of marine taxa  initiated by the tectonically and eustatic driven full connection to brackish waters of the Eastern Paratethys . Restricted oceanic connectivity and fluctuations in humidity during the Sarmatian  resulted in a changing Paratethyan water chemistry up to hypersaline and alkaline conditions . Short-term marine transgressions and Eastern Paratethyan connectivity introduced mollusc and foraminifera assemblages that allow a biostratigraphic zonation of the Sarmatian in the Central Paratethys [89, 90].
The Sarmatian sediments in the Lavanttal Basin intercalate between thick Late Badenian and Early Pannonian freshwater deposits (Fig 2). Three lithologic units and five brown-coal seams characterize the nearly 300 m thick Sarmatian sequence. Both lower units, the Mohrensternia beds and the Pirinella beds, compose of lacustrine sediments containing brackish intervals with foraminifers and mollusks correlating to the earliest Sarmatian Mohrensternia bio-zone . Three coal seams (Totz seam, lower, and upper seam) developed during marginal lacustrine conditions in the Mohrensternia beds. The Pirenella beds were followed by an erosional phase without depositions . This phase of tectonic reorganization in the southern Alps ended with the discordant deposition of the two Kuchl seams and accompanied sediments, which are assigned to the Late Sarmatian .
During underground coal mining activities, the sedimentary sequence of St. Stefan has provided three vertebrate bearing horizons within an only eight meter thick sequence (Fig 2 and [77, 91–93]): (1) lower bed, (2) upper seam, and (3) phosphorite (nodule) horizon.
The lower bed is positioned directly below the upper seam and consists of marl. Its uppermost part revealed findings of three mammalian species: Anchiterium aurelianense (Equidae), Listriodon splendens (Suidae) and Euprox furcatus (Cervidae). The hominid Dryopithecus carinthiacus and Listriodon splendens were found within the upper coal seam. Further vertebrate fossils (Amphicyonidae, Gomphotherium angustidens, Deinotherium levius, Anisodon grande, Brachypotherium brachyphus, Lartetotherium sansaniense, Listriodon splendens, Dorcatherium naui,?Palaeomeryx sp., Moschidae indet. and Testudo sp.) came from the phosphorite horizon about 4 meters above the upper seam [77, 91–93].
With a thickness of 260m, both lower units (Mohrensternia and Pirenella beds) cover large parts of the Early Sarmatian between 12.65–~12.35 Ma (Mohrensternia Zone). This gives a sedimentation rate of 0.87m/ky. Assuming a continuous sedimentation , the age of the three vertebrate horizons, which are ~110m above the base of Sarmatian, can be approximated to ~12.5 Ma. Thereby, St. Stefan provides with D. carinthiacus the stratigraphic earliest representative of the dryopithecine clade.
2.2. Palaeo-vegetation of St. Stefan
The palaeobotanic records from the Sarmatian of the Lavanttal comprise leaves , spores and pollen studied from the phosphorite nodule horizon . We refer this palynologic data to the Dryopithecus environment, because the phosphorite horizon is situated about four meters above the upper seam, which suggests a younger age, compared to the fossil ape, by only a few thousand years. The palynoflora is very diverse and comprises more than 170 taxa [78, 96–99]. The high taxonomic resolution is due to exceptional 3D pollen-preservation in phosphorite nodules, enabling the identification of taxa using both light microscopy and scanning electron microscopy . These botanical data point to mixed mesophytic forests in the coastal lowlands , dominated by Fagaceae (evergreen and deciduous Quercus, Fagus, Castanea) and Juglandaceae (Carya, Pterocarya, Engelhardia, Juglans).
3. Material and methods
3.1. Dryopithecus carinthiacus, Mottl 1957
The studied object LMK-Pal 5508 is the type specimen of the Middle Miocene hominid Dryopithecus (fontani) carinthiacus Mottl 1957 from St. Stefan (Carinthia, Austria). It is a partial right mandible with p3, p4 and m1 and isolated right i1, left c, p3, p4 and m1 of the same individual. A partial right m2, reported in Mottl , is missing today. The focus of this study is on the carious left m1. The holotype is housed in the collection of the ‘Landesmuseum für Kärnten’ in Klagenfurt am Wörthersee (Austria).
A detailed analysis of the caries morphology was performed to exclude other destructions of dental hart tissue that might have a similar appearance like attritional or post-mortem defects. Further, potential calculus deposits on the tooth surface are identified based on their cavernous and spherical surface structure. Therefore, the tooth surface of the studied object was examined with stereo light microscopy (LM) and scanning electron microscopy (SEM). Before SEM imaging, the specimen was mechanically cleaned with a soft brush and water in order to remove loose particles from surface. The cleaned specimen was placed on an aluminum stub and imaged in the LEO-1450VP scanning electron microscope at the Department of Geoscience (University of Tübingen, Germany). The specimen was left uncoated due to curatorial reasons.
Further surface features including microwear were examined with the laser-scanning microscope Keyence VK-X 130K at the Department of Geoscience (CCA-BW, University of Tübingen, Germany). The device has a confocal aperture and a 658nm red laser. The wear facets 9 and 10 of the right and left m1 were scanned using a 20x objective that covered an area of 698 x 524 μm, 1024 x 768 pixel and a vertical resolution of 0.005 μm. The numerical system of wear facets follows [100, 101]. Image processing was done with the Keyence software VK-Analyzer 3.8. The photosimulations were reduced to an area of 400 x 400 μm and were constricted to the laser intensity. Thereby, the actual surface topology was visualized in grey scale without being overlain by colors, textures and light incidence.
Internal dental structures of the left m1 of LMK-Pal 5508 were visualized based on X-ray microtomographic (μCT) scans. The isolated tooth was scanned with the GE Phoenix v|tome|x s μCT scanner at the Institute for Archaeological science at the University of Tübingen. The μCT-scan was performed at 170 kV and 170 μA with a resolution of 32.56 μm. No corrections for artefacts were necessary. The conversion into 3D volumes and the segmentation work has been performed in Avizo 8.0. The different materials (enamel, dentine, and pulp chamber) were semi-automatically segmented applying surface determination, region growing and masking tools. The linear measurements were done on the virtual 3D model with the 3D measuring tool in Avizo 8.0.
3.2. Pan troglodytes verus, Schwarz 1934
The comparative samples of Pan troglodytes verus came from the Senckenberg skull collection of Liberian chimpanzees in Frankfurt a. M. (Germany). The observed specimens were wild caught individuals including juveniles and adults. Only specimens with at least one erupted and unfractured tooth were used for the counting. Thereby, from a total of n = 365 observed individuals (S1 Table), there were n = 311 individuals (32 juveniles and 279 adults) with complete or partial dentition. As many individuals featured pre- and post-mortem loss of teeth, we did not count the caries frequency per individual, but the frequency per total number of observed teeth. In total n = 3259 erupted teeth were sighted (n = 2890 permanent; n = 369 deciduous).
We differentiated between three types of caries cavities: (1) interstitial/cervical, (2) secondary occlusal and (3) primary occlusal. Caries cavities in the dental root or enamel, which are positioned in the interdental spaces or on the cervices were classified as interstitial/cervical. Secondary occlusal cavities were defined as being positioned on the occlusal enamel/dentine surface and being related to heavy occlusal wear or fractures. Primary occlusal caries initiates on intact, largely unworn occlusal enamel surfaces.
The presence of caries was determined macroscopically and with a hand lens. Only advanced caries lesions that already formed cavities in the dental hard tissue were counted, as earlier stages are difficult to identify by this technique. Further, there could be a slight underestimation of interstitial caries, as tight interdental spaces might have hidden the lesions from the superficial inspection. As the focus of this article is on the primary caries of D. carinthiacus, we did not apply more extended analyses on hidden interstitial caries here.
3.3. Sugar content of food sources
To evaluate the sugar contents (fructose, glucose, saccharose) of fruit-producing plant taxa identified in the palynological record of St. Stefan, we consulted nutritional databases for common fruit types , whereas those contents for rarely consumed fruits were extracted from specialized publications (Arbutus, ; Toddalia, ). All sugar contents are given for fresh fruits.
4.1. Caries morphology in LMK-Pal 5508
The dental morphology of D. carinthiacus shows the general dryopithecine characters of narrow and tall-crowned incisors, a buccolingual compressed canine and thinly enameled molars with broad and laterally positioned cusps [77, 105, 106]. It differs from other dryopithecine taxa particularly by its dental dimensions, which are considerably below other dryopithecine specimens . In its first description, Mottl  mentioned the severe caries lesion in the left m1 of LMK-Pal 5508. It shows a cavitated pit on the occlusal surface between metaconid and entoconid. The cavitation penetrates the clearly visible EDJ and exposes large parts of dentine. The cavitation through the enamel and the dentine has a maximum diameter of 3.3 mm and 2.4 mm, respectively. The walls are steep and the surface has a smooth etched appearance, as known from acid-producing cariogenic bacteria like Streptococcus sp. and Lactobacillus spp. Examination with μCT, SEM and stereomicroscopy revealed further morphologies also known from extant human caries lesions:
- Primary caries. The dental crown of the left m1 shows no fractures and only little occlusal wear. The caries lesion initiated on the intact and largely unworn occlusal enamel surface. This contrasts to secondary caries, which initiates on enamel fractures or dentine exposures due to advanced wear.
- Unilateral mastication. The left m1 is only slightly worn with a small cuspal dentine exposure on the hypoconulid (Fig 1A). The right m1 shows larger dentine exposures on the buccal cusps (protoconid, hypoconid, hypoconulid; Fig 1B). The other teeth (incisive, canine, p3s and p4s) remain largely unworn, exhibiting only small occlusal and/or interstitial wear facets. None of these teeth exhibit lesions or fractures. The crushing facets in both m1 show little microwear and the wear pattern slightly differs between the left and the right m1 (Fig 3). The wear facets of the right m1 (facet 9 and 10) are largely covered by a thin patina. Where visible, the actual enamel surface is well preserved showing enamel prisms and scratch-dominated microwear; pits are virtually absent here. In contrast, facet 9 of the left m1 shows a polished surface with a large number of fine scratches and a considerable amount of pits (Fig 3B).
- Plugged dentine. The dentine affected by the caries shows an increased density in the μCT-section (bright zone below the cavity; Fig 4). A hardening of dentine is a typical process when dentine is exposed due to caries or wear. In this zone of sclerosis, mineralized materials plug the dentine tubules and reduce the migration of external substances and microorganisms into the pulp. Calcified bacteria that invaded into the dentine can additionally increase its density. Probably, post mortal, diagenetic processes may also lead to an increase in density by impregnating mineralized waters.
- Reparative dentine. The pulp chamber shows an irregular depression in the area below the caries cavity (Fig 5), indicating an accumulation of reparative dentine on the pulp chamber roof. Reparative dentine appears early after the caries penetrated the enamel cap down to the dentine . This reparative mechanism protects the pulp chamber from potential contaminations. This means that the pulp of LMK-Pal 5508 was threatened by bacterial infections.
- Dental calculus. The carious left m1 preserves a macroscopically visible mesiobuccal accretion on the interstitial enamel surface that we interpret as a supra-gingival dental calculus (Fig 6C). No accretions like dental calculus are seen on the other teeth, but they might have been removed during previous preparation work. Under the SEM, further calculus deposits are detected in pits of the occlusal enamel (Fig 6A and 6B) and the mesiobuccal enamel surface (Fig 6C and 6D) of the left m1. The dental calculus shows the characteristic cavernous and spherical deposits that are accumulated by microbiota (Fig 6B and 6D).
a, Facet 10 of the left m1, showing inconspicuous scratches and enamel prisms. b, Facet 9 of the left m1, showing fine scratches and pits on a polished enamel surface. c, Facet 10 of the right m1, showing pits and broad scratches entirely covered by a rough patina. d, Facet 9 of the right m1, showing scratches and enamel prisms partially covered by a thin patina. Each photosimulation is 400μm x 400μm; scale bar = 50 μm, magnification = 20x, height differences (0–40μm) in grey-scale.
Left: μCT-based reconstruction of the left m1 in occlusal view. Enamel cap colored in grey and dentine exposures colored in brown. The mesiodistal section A-B passes through the caries cavity. Right: Corresponding μCT section from A to B showing the caries lesion and internal structures.
An irregular depression (circled) distal to the mesiolingual pulp horn indicates accumulation of reparative dentine on the pulp chamber roof below the caries lesion.
a, Occlusal view into the caries cavity. b, Surface details of occlusal dental calculus close to the caries cavity. c, Supra-gingival calculus (above arrow) on the mesiobuccal enamel surface. d, Surface details of mesiobuccal calculus and scratch dominated microwear on the enamel surface.
4.2. Caries frequency in Pan troglodytes verus
Our examination of 311 chimpanzees revealed 16 individuals with carious teeth. From a total of n = 2890 permanent teeth and n = 369 deciduous teeth, caries cavities occur in 1.38% (n = 40) of the permanent teeth (Fig 7) and are absent in the deciduous ones. With 0.17% (n = 5) of total permanent teeth, the primary occlusal caries is very rare, followed by the frequency of secondary occlusal caries (0.21%; n = 6). With n = 29 teeth, cervical/interstitial caries is more frequent, constituting 1% of the total permanent teeth (Fig 7).
Within the permanent teeth (n = 2890), interstitial/cervical caries occurs in 1.00% (n = 29), secondary occlusal caries in 0.21% (n = 6) and primary occlusal caries in 0.17% (n = 5).
The most severe caries lesions, featuring deep cavities with large diameters of several millimeters, belong to the secondary occlusal type and the interstitial/cervical type. The primary occlusal caries is less pronounced, featuring only shallow or tiny pits of less than one millimeter in diameter (Fig 8).
4.3. Potential sources of cariogenic sugars
Searching for potential food plants in published floral lists [78, 98, 99] revealed at least nine palynological taxa from various plant orders (Rosales, Fagales, Vitales, Ericales, and Sapindales), which produced fruits that contained considerable amounts of mono- and/or disaccharides. We identified the following taxa (Fig 9): Prunus sp. 1 and 2 (e.g. cherry, apricot, plum, peach, almond; Rosales), Vitis sp. (grape; Vitales), Elaeagnus sp. (oleaster/Russian olive; Rosales), Morus cf. nigra (black mulberry; Rosales), Arbutus sp. (strawberry tree, Ericales), Castanea sp. (chestnut; Fagales), Carya sp. (hickory; Fagales), Toddalia sp. (orange climber; Sapindales). Especially members of Rosales, Vitales, and Ericales are rich in monosaccharides and their content of fructose reach, or exceed 50% of all non-structural carbohydrates, whereas fruits of Fagales and Sapindales are dominated by disaccharides (Fig 9).
Prunus sp. 1 refers to early ripening (P. avium, P. cerasus, P. armeniaca) and Prunus sp. 2 to late ripening species (P. spinosa, P. domestica, P. syriaca). The average sugar content of fruits available per month is displayed in the second diagram from above. The top diagram represents the number of melliferous tree and climber species per flowering month (S2 Table) and the number of sugar containing fruit species per ripening month.
All nine fruits ripe on a seasonal basis and estimations of their fruiting time suggest availability for at least seven months (June-December; Fig 9). With five to six species of available sweet fruits, the most diverse season is autumn (September-October), whereas mean sugar and monosaccharide contents remain high in all fruiting months. The relative proportion of fructose is highest during December (56% of total sugar), caused by the fructose dominated strawberry tree (Arbutus unedo).
Availability of honey.
The nutritional availability of honey for extinct hominids cannot be directly documented. However, if the diversity and abundance of melliferous plants are high, honey will be available and will probably be consumed by hominids . The taxonomic resolution of the palynological record is too low to estimate the importance of melliferous herbs. However, the Lavanttal palynoflora provides at least 46 potential melliferous tree and climber taxa (see S2 Table), which notably include the most abundant arboreal elements like Quercus ssp., Carya sp., Fagus sp., Castanea sp., Ulmus sp., and Pinus ssp. comprising about 50% of recorded pollen grains . We therefore suggest that honey might have been nutritionally available to D. carinthiacus. Furthermore, the season of honey availability was estimated based on the flowering months of documented melliferous taxa (see S2 Table). The flowering periods center between early spring to early summer (March–July; Fig 9), with maximum diversity of blooming melliferous species and therefore honey availability during April and May (26 and 27 taxa respectively).
5.1. Etiology of caries for D. carinthiacus
In general, caries is a multifactorial disease, which cannot be narrowed down to a single cause. Dietary preferences, physiological differences due to age and sex, or individual susceptibility to plaque and caries formation (e.g. tooth surface morphology, enamel quality, oral flora and other predispositions) might be responsible for carious teeth.
Age, dental wear and diet.
In wild great apes, severe caries mostly occurs interstitial/cervical or in teeth where dentine is exposed due to heavy wear or fractures (Fig 7 and Miles and Grigson ). These formation types of ‘interstitial/cervical’ and ‘secondary occlusal’ are particularly prevalent in old individuals [53, 74]. This pattern is consistent with our dataset of Liberian chimpanzees (S1 Table), which shows intense caries only in permanent and often heavily worn teeth, while juveniles are completely unaffected. The increasing incidence and severity of caries with age can partially be explained by the progressive course of the cavitation process in a steady state of risk, as it may apply to animals and Pleistocene hominins. Further, the increasingly worn teeth expose a greater area of dentine. Compared to enamel, dentine shows a lower degree of mineralization which accompanies with a higher susceptibility to plaque and caries in worn teeth. In turn, intense dental wear might catch up the cavitation process and counteract against it . The major cause of caries in D. carinthiacus grounds on other, mainly diet specific factors. Contrasting to the prevailing cases of caries in extant wild apes, LMK-Pal 5508 is a young adult (largely unworn teeth, at least m2 erupted as evident from the distal interstitial wear facet on both m1). Its carious left m1 is largely unworn and shows no fractures that could have facilitate caries initiation. This infers that the caries affected the intact occlusal enamel and hence, can be described as primary caries . Primary caries is a common disease of humans in recent industrial societies, but rather unusual for wild animals. This is confirmed by our results on caries frequencies in extant chimpanzees, where only 0.17% of investigated teeth show primary caries lesions (Fig 7). Furthermore, observed primary caries in Pan troglodytes verus (Fig 8) is found to be less pronounced compared to D. carinthiacus, which suggests less severe cariogenic effects for affected individuals of chimpanzees.
The growing incidence of primary caries in human history clearly correlates with the increased consumption of cocked starch and sugar-rich products [53, 62]. This may indicate that the deep primary caries in LMK-Pal 5508 has a dietary etiology, as well. Sugar-rich fruits could have been a possible natural source. Inferred from caries formation in humans , it can be assumed that the advanced cavitation in LMK-Pal 5508 needed several years to form. Accordingly, we assume a repetitive consumption of carbohydrates for this individual.
Certainly, irrevocable inferences about the dietary niche of D. carinthicacus are hampered by the single specimen known from this species. However, the overall dental morphology of D. carinthiacus coincides with our assumption, showing the characteristic frugivorous configuration of small teeth with thin enamel  and broad cusps. Tentatively, the largely scratch dominated microwear-pattern in D. carinthiacus infers a rather soft diet that included some leaves (Fig 3). This might be supported by the presence of patina layers, which are common in leaf-eating monkeys like Colobus . Their patinas are interpreted as a mechanism to protect the enamel from lateral abrasion .
Although questionable, the single known individual of D. carinthiacus is discussed to be a female D. fontani, due to a similar morphology, but its smaller size [77, 109]. Female primates tend to have a higher frequency of caries than males, due to physiological and behavioral reasons [62, 74]. Medical studies on humans indicate that hormonal fluctuations during menstruation and pregnancy influence the chemical composition and amount of saliva [62, 110]. This may lead to xerostomy and a low pH, which promote the formation of caries. An additional, more controversial factor is the potential calcium deficiency that might occur during pregnancy and lactation [110, 111]. Beside such physiological factors, also dietary differences between sexes might influence the incidence of caries. Stoner  documented a higher frequency of caries and other dental pathologies in adult female orangutan. She explains this by observations that females eat more fruits compared to males, which concentrate more on bark and ground resources.
5.2. Dietary inferences for D. carinthiacus
Apart from honey, the most cariogenic diets available in the environment of D. carinthicus were ripe fruits. The palynological record of St. Stefan documents at least nine plants that may have served as source of consumable, sugar-rich fruits (Fig 9). The diversity of these fruits was highest during the autumn and mean sugar content was high all the fruiting season (seven month from June-December). Thus, the mixed mesophytic forest of the early Sarmatian Lavanttal Basin, with its seasonal fruiting trees and honey, provided diverse sugar resources for up to nine or ten months a year, from late spring to early winter. Sugar-rich fruits have been unavailable in late winter and spring times and honey was rare from late summer to late winter. Interestingly, fructose was the dominant sugar in fruits only in December, suggesting enhanced lipogenesis just before the starvation season in late winter. Given the northern latitude of the Lavanttal, we think that especially the late winter months (January, February), which received considerably less insolation during short days, held risk of starvation. This would demand catabolism of fat reserves (as described for the tropical Pongo pygmaeus by Vogel, Knott ). Foraging on fructose-rich fruits of the genera Prunus, Vitis, Elaeagnus, Morus, and Arbutus could has generated these fat reserves. Especially the latter taxon may potentially represent a key-species, since it was responsible for the fructose surplus in December, just before the inferred starvation period.
5.3. Food quality, foraging strategies and metabolism
Both morphologic (enamel thickness, cusp morphology, enamel microstructure, caries lesion) and environmental data characterize D. carinthiacus as a frugivore, preferentially feeding on high-quality, sugar-rich fruits, similar to chimpanzees [113, 114]. As the fleshy fruits of the identified taxa are low in fiber content (1–9% ), we further expect seasonally low fiber values in the diet of D. carinthiacus, contrasting to the frugivorous, though fibrous diet of chimpanzees . According, D. carinthiacus indicates that foraging on high quality foods was already present in early hominids. Moreover, this strategy combined with a change in purine metabolism might have been a first step to cope with the increasing seasonality during the Miocene.
Temporal and spatial variation in the food supply requires a high flexibility in behavior, ranging and diet of primates . In such habitats, larger-sized apes like D. carinthiacus have several advantages compared to small-bodied primates. A large gut allow them to process less digestible diets like leaves . In times of food scarcity, large primates show a larger range to track their resources. Further, their larger body-fat stores enable them to withstand periods of starvation .
In contrast to specialized folivores, D. carinthiacus showed a more flexible diet dominated by fruits. Its generalized tooth morphology facilitated the processing of these high-quality foods, though its thin enamel made it prone to caries disease.
As revealed by palynology, available fruits derived from trees and climbers, suggesting further a canopy feeding adaptation. Most feeding trees (except Castanea and Carya) can be regarded as small- to medium sized (5 to 12 m high), with fruit concentration on small terminal branches (Fig 10). We therefore assume that D. carinthiacus developed skills for terminal branch eating, such as a form of suspensory posture. Known from several extant platyrrhines, cercopithecids and all extant hominoids, hindlimb- and forelimb-suspensory is an ideal adaption for a better weight distribution on small supports and well suited to collect food items below terminal branches .
Trees that dominate the pollen spectra  are shown in grey scales. Trees, shrubs, and vines producing sugar-containing fruits are colored. Note that the dominant source of sugar-rich fruits is the shrub layer.
As a major fall-back food, the extant frugivorous primates of the tropics largely depend on young leaves . However, in the higher latitudes of St. Stefan, the production of young leaves might not bridge the time of food scarcity during late winter. If this is the case, other strategies like the switch to low-quality foods or the early build-up of fat reserves were required .
Due to its frugivory and body size, as well as its carbohydrate-rich habitat with high predictability of the fruiting season, D. carinthiacus is predestined to rely on the early storage of fat reserves to endure periods of starvation. The hominid fructose and uric acid metabolism stimulate lipogenesis and lead to elevated body fat accumulation, relative to iso-caloric fructose-poor diet (see chapter 1.3.). We have shown that the potential food of D. carinthiacus was rich in fructose, especially in early winter month, which is related to the typically Mediterranean tree Arbutus and others. This led us speculate that D. carinthiacus and potentially other European hominids may have seasonally accumulated substantial adipose tissue. Identification of large adipocyte-like structures in preserved soft-tissue from the Late Miocene ape Oreopithecus bamboli (Fig 11)  corroborate this hypothesis. Their large size (up to 60 μm) and spherical shape would characterize them as white adipose cells (lipids), responsible for energy storage, in contrast to the smaller and polygonal brown adipose cells, which are involved in thermogenesis .
The type of D. carinthiacus (LMK-Pal 5508) dates to the Early Sarmatian (Middle Miocene) at ~12.5 Ma, thus being the earliest known representative of the dryopithecine clade. Furthermore, this specimen shows the earliest record of primary dental caries and calculus in a hominid. The caries lesion in D. carinthiacus is indicated on features known from severe dental caries in humans: (1) The cavitation has a smooth surface and steep walls due to erosion by acids; (2) Reparative dentine at the roof of the pulp chamber; (3) Probably plugged dentine, due to caries undermining the enamel; (4) Association with dental calculus at different sites on the enamel surface; (5) Unilateral usage of the healthy, right tooth row indicates that LMK-Pal 5508 may have suffered on toothache.
The main culprit of this caries, the frequent consumption of highly cariogenic food (sugar-rich diets like fruits or honey), is indicated by the presence of deep primary caries that initiated on the intact enamel surface. This caries morphology contrasts to the rare and weakly developed primary caries in Pan troglodytes verus and the common interstitial/cervical and secondary caries that initiates by lesions or dental wear. According, we infer a highly frugivorous diet for D. carinthiacus, which likely exceeds the frugivory of extant chimpanzees.
The palynological record of St. Stefan indicates a seasonally rich fructiferous flora that would have allowed the reliance on a highly frugivorous diet during nine or ten months a year. Such a nutrition corresponds to the uricase-hypothesis of Johnson and Andrews , which discusses the hominid specific development of a fructose-based metabolism to build up fat reserves for periods of starvation. This adaption is characterized by the loss of a functional uricase enzyme during the Middle Miocene  and likely evolved in the seasonally driven habitats of Eurasia . Beside D. carinthiacus, this adaption might have been present in many other European hominids as documented by the potential white adipose tissue of Oreopithecus bamboli. Further, the quality of the diet available to D. carinthiacus was superior (high carbohydrate, low fiber) to that of living great apes, suggesting that the model of step-wise increase in dietary quality  during hominid evolution has to be modified.
S1 Table. Counting of caries cavity types in permanent and deciduous teeth of Pan troglodytes verus SCHWARZ 1934, from the Senckenberg skull collection of Liberian chimpanzees.
The authors are indebted to Thomas Jerger, Claudia Dojen and Alexandra Krug from the Landesmuseum Kärnten for their kind loan of the type specimen of D. carinthiacus, without it would not be possible to carry out this study. Our gratitude also goes to Ottmar Kullmer and Christine Hemm for providing excess to comparative chimpanzee samples in the Senckenberg Collection in Frankfurt a.M. We thank Katerina Harvati and Wieland Binczik for μCT scanning at the INA, University of Tübingen. Hartmut Schulz is thanked for producing the SEM-images at the University of Tübingen. Many thanks go to Christoph Berthold and Tobias Kiemle, who friendly provided excess to the Laserscanning microscope at the CCA-BW, University of Tübingen. Wolfgang Gerber (University of Tübingen) is thanked for taking the photographs.
- 1. Wang X, Rybczynski N, Harington CR, White SC, Tedford RH. A basal ursine bear (Protarctos abstrusus) from the Pliocene High Arctic reveals Eurasian affinities and a diet rich in fermentable sugars. Scientific reports. 2017;7(1):17722. pmid:29255278
- 2. Oxilia G, Peresani M, Romandini M, Matteucci C, Spiteri CD, Henry AG, et al. Earliest evidence of dental caries manipulation in the Late Upper Palaeolithic. Scientific reports. 2015;5:12150. pmid:26179739
- 3. Oxilia G, Fiorillo F, Boschin F, Boaretto E, Apicella SA, Matteucci C, et al. The dawn of dentistry in the late upper Paleolithic: An early case of pathological intervention at Riparo Fredian. American journal of physical anthropology. 2017;163(3):446–61. pmid:28345756
- 4. Humphrey LT, De Groote I, Morales J, Barton N, Collcutt S, Ramsey CB, et al. Earliest evidence for caries and exploitation of starchy foods in Pleistocene hunter-gatherers from Morocco. PNAS. 2013;111(3):954–9.
- 5. Johnson RJ, Andrews P, Benner SA, Oliver W. Theodore E. Woodward Award. The evolution of obesity: insights from the Mid-Miocene. Transactions of the american clinical and climatological association. 2010;121:295–308. pmid:20697570
- 6. Johnson RJ, Andrews P. Fructose, uricase, and the Back-to-Africa hypothesis. Evolutionary Anthropology: Issues, News, and Reviews. 2010;19(6):250–7.
- 7. Reichenbacher B, Krijgsman W, Lataster Y, Pippèrr M, Van Baak CGC, Chang L, et al. A new magnetostratigraphic framework for the Lower Miocene (Burdigalian/Ottnangian, Karpatian) in the North Alpine Foreland Basin. Swiss Journal of Geosciences. 2013;106(2):309–34.
- 8. Böhme M, Aziz HA, Prieto J, Bachtadse V, Schweigert G. Bio-magnetostratigraphy and environment of the oldest Eurasian hominoid from the Early Miocene of Engelswies (Germany). Journal of human evolution. 2011;61(3):332–9. pmid:21665243
- 9. Fuss J, Spassov N, Begun DR, Böhme M. Potential hominin affinities of Graecopithecus from the Late Miocene of Europe. PloS one. 2017;12(5):e0177127. pmid:28531170
- 10. Böhme M, Spassov N, Ebner M, Geraads D, Hristova L, Kirscher U, et al. Messinian age and savannah environment of the possible hominin Graecopithecus from Europe. PloS one. 2017;12(5):e0177347. pmid:28531204
- 11. Gierliński GD, Niedźwiedzki G, Lockley MG, Athanassiou A, Fassoulas C, Dubicka Z, et al. Possible hominin footprints from the late Miocene (c. 5.7 Ma) of Crete? Proceedings of the Geologists' Association. 2017.
- 12. Bates BC. Territorial behavior in primates: a review of recent field studies. Primates. 1970;11(3):271–84.
- 13. Van Schaik CP, Pfannes KR. Tropical climates and phenology: a primate perspective. In: Brockman DK, Van Schaik CP, editors. Seasonality in Primates: Cambridge University Press; 2005.
- 14. Fleagle JG. Primate Adaption and Evolution. 3 ed: Elsevier Academic Press; 2013.
- 15. Ungar PS, Kay RF. The dietary adaptions of European Miocene catarrhines. Proc Natl Adad Sci USA. 1995;92:5479–81.
- 16. Andrews P, Martin L. Hominoid dietary evolution. In: Andrews P, Martin L, Aiello L, Scandrett AE, editors. Philosophical Transactions: Biological Sciences. Foraging Strategies and Natural Diet of Monkeys, Apes and Humans. 334: The Royal Society; 1991. p. 199–209.
- 17. Kay RF. Diets of early Miocene African hominoids. Nature. 1977;268:628–30.
- 18. Leakey RE, Leakey MG. A new Miocene hominoid from Kenya. Nature. 1986;324:143–6.
- 19. Smith TM, Martin LB, Leakey MG. Enamel thickness, microstructure and development in Afropithecus turkanensis. Journal of human evolution. 2003;44(3):283–306. pmid:12657518
- 20. Kelley J, Ward S, Brown B, Hill A, Duren DL. Dental remains of Equatorius africanus from Kipsaramon, Tugen Hills, Baringo District, Kenya. Journal of human evolution. 2002;42(1–2):39–62. pmid:11795967
- 21. Heizmann EP, Begun DR. The oldest Eurasian hominoid. Journal of human evolution. 2001;41(5):463–81. pmid:11681862
- 22. DeMiguel D, Alba DM, Moya-Sola S. Dietary specialization during the evolution of Western Eurasian hominoids and the extinction of European Great Apes. PloS one. 2014;9(5):e97442. pmid:24848272
- 23. Martin LB, Olejniczak AJ, Maas MC. Enamel thickness and microstructure in pitheciin primates, with comments on dietary adaptions of the middle Miocene hominoid Kenyapithecus. Journal of human evolution. 2003;45(2003):351–67.
- 24. Begun DR. Relations among the great apes and humans: new interpretations based on the fossil great ape dryopithecus. yearbool of physical anthropology. 1994;37:11–63.
- 25. Ungar PS. Dental microwear of European Miocene catarrhines: evidence for diets and tooth use. Journal of human evolution. 1996;31:335–66.
- 26. Alba DM, Fortuny J, Moya-Sola S. Enamel thickness in the Middle Miocene great apes Anoiapithecus, Pierolapithecus and Dryopithecus. Proceedings Biological sciences / The Royal Society. 2010;277(1691):2237–45.
- 27. Merceron G. A New Method of Dental Microwear Analysis: Application to Extant Primates and Ouranopithecus macedoniensis (Late Miocene of Greece). Palaios. 2005;20(6):551–61.
- 28. Begun DR, Güleç E. Restoration of the type and palate of Ankarapithecus meteai: Taxonomic and phylogenetic implications. American Journal of Physical Anthropology. 1998;105:279–314. pmid:9545074
- 29. Ishimoto T, Lanaspa MA, Rivard CJ, Roncal-Jimenez CA, Orlicky DJ, Cicerchi C, et al. High-fat and high-sucrose (western) diet induces steatohepatitis that is dependent on fructokinase. Hepatology. 2013;58(5):1632–43. pmid:23813872
- 30. Lanaspa MA, Sanchez-Lozada LG, Choi YJ, Cicerchi C, Kanbay M, Roncal-Jimenez CA, et al. Uric acid induces hepatic steatosis by generation of mitochondrial oxidative stress: potential role in fructose-dependent and -independent fatty liver. The Journal of biological chemistry. 2012;287(48):40732–44. pmid:23035112
- 31. Choi YJ, Shin HS, Choi HS, Park JW, Jo I, Oh ES, et al. Uric acid induces fat accumulation via generation of endoplasmic reticulum stress and SREBP-1c activation in hepatocytes. Laboratory investigation; a journal of technical methods and pathology. 2014;94(10):1114–25. pmid:25111690
- 32. Ames BN, Cathcart R, Schwiers E, Hochstein P. Uric acid provides an antioxidant defense in humans against oxidant- and radical-caused aging and cancer: a hypothesis. Proc NatL Acad Sci USA. 1981;78(11):6858–62. pmid:6947260
- 33. Lanaspa MA, Sanchez-Lozada LG, Cicerchi C, Li N, Roncal-Jimenez CA, Ishimoto T, et al. Uric acid stimulates fructokinase and accelerates fructose metabolism in the development of fatty liver. PloS one. 2012;7(10):e47948. pmid:23112875
- 34. Nakagawa T, Hu H, Zharikov S, Tuttle KR, Short RA, Glushakova O, et al. A causal role for uric acid in fructose-induced metabolic syndrome. American journal of physiology Renal physiology. 2006;290(3):F625–31. pmid:16234313
- 35. Roncal-Jimenez CA, Lanaspa MA, Rivard CJ, Nakagawa T, Sanchez-Lozada LG, Jalal D, et al. Sucrose induces fatty liver and pancreatic inflammation in male breeder rats independent of excess energy intake. Metabolism: clinical and experimental. 2011;60(9):1259–70.
- 36. Sutin AR, Cutler RG, Camandola S, Uda M, Feldman NH, Cucca F, et al. Impulsivity is associated with uric acid: evidence from humans and mice. Biological psychiatry. 2014;75(1):31–7. pmid:23582268
- 37. Kratzer JT, Lanaspa MA, Murphy MN, Cicerchi C, Graves CL, Tipton PA, et al. Evolutionary history and metabolic insights of ancient mammalian uricases. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America. 2014;111(10):3763–8. pmid:24550457
- 38. Álvarez-Lario B, Macarrón-Vicente J. Uric acid and evolution. Rheumatology. 2010;49(11):2010–5. pmid:20627967
- 39. Sofaer AJ, Emery AEH. Genes for super-intelligence? Journal of Medical Genetics. 1981;18:410–3. pmid:7334499
- 40. Glantzounis GK, Tsimoyiannis EC, Kappas AM, Galaris DA. Uric Acid and Oxidative Stress. Current Pharmaceutical Design. 2005;11:4145–51. pmid:16375736
- 41. Pacher P, Beckman JS, Liaudet L. Nitric oxide and peroxynitrite in health and disease. Physiological reviews. 2007;87(1):315–424. pmid:17237348
- 42. Kutzing MK, Firestein BL. Altered uric acid levels and disease states. The Journal of pharmacology and experimental therapeutics. 2008;324(1):1–7. pmid:17890445
- 43. Abraham A, Drory VE. Influence of serum uric acid levels on prognosis and survival in amyotrophic lateral sclerosis: a meta-analysis. Journal of neurology. 2014;261(6):1133–8. pmid:24699859
- 44. Keizman D, Ish-Shalom M, Berliner S, Maimon N, Vered Y, Artamonov I, et al. Low uric acid levels in serum of patients with ALS: further evidence for oxidative stress? Journal of the neurological sciences. 2009;285(1–2):95–9. pmid:19552925
- 45. Martin SL. Mammalian hibernation: a naturally reversible model for insulin resistance in man? Diabetes & vascular disease research. 2008;5(2):76–81.
- 46. Bairlein F. How to get fat: nutritional mechanisms of seasonal fat accumulation in migratory songbirds. Die Naturwissenschaften. 2002;89(1):1–10. pmid:12008967
- 47. Hillson S. The current state of dental decay. In: Irish JD, Nelson GC, editors. Technique and Application in Dental Anthropology. New York: Cambridge University Press; 2008. p. 111–35.
- 48. Hillson S. Dental disease. In: Hillson S, editor. Dental Anthropology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 1996. p. 254–87.
- 49. Arens U. Oral health: diet and other factors. Report of the British Nutrition foundation Task Force. Amsterdam: Elsevier Science Publishing Company; 1998.
- 50. Goldberg M. Understanding Dental Caries. Paris, France: Springer; 2016. 249 p.
- 51. Pitts NB, Zero DT, Marsh PD, Ekstrand K, Weintraub JA, Ramos-Gomez F, et al. Dental caries. Nature Reviews Disease Primers. 2017;3:1–16.
- 52. Moynihan P, Petersen PE. Diet, nutrition and the prevention of dental diseases. Public Health Nutrition. 2007;7(1a).
- 53. Miles AEW, Grigson C. Colyer's Variations and Diseases of the Teeth of animals. revised ed. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 1990. 672 p.
- 54. Powell ML. The Analysis of Dental Wear and Caries for Dietary Reconstruction. In: Gilbert J R. I., MJ H., editors. The analysis of prehistoric diets. Orlando, Florida: Academic Press; 1985. p. 307–38.
- 55. Lingström P, van Houte J, Kasuya T. Food starches and dental caries. Critical Reviews in Oral Biology and Medicine. 2000;11:366–80. pmid:11021636
- 56. Kemp A, Berrell RW. Lungfish as environmental indicators. In: A G., Schultze H-P, Wilson MVH, editors. Fishes Mesozoic 5—Global Diversity and Evolution. München, Germany: Dr. Friedrich Pfeil; 2013. p. 499–508.
- 57. Kear BP. Dental caries in an Early Cretaceous ichthyosaur. Alcheringa. 2001;25(4):387–90.
- 58. Sala Burgos N, Cuevas González J, Martínez L. Estudio paleopatológico de una hemimandíbula de Tethytragus (Artiodactyla, Mammalia) del Mioceno Medio de Somosaguas (Pozuelo de Alarcón, Madrid). Coloquios de Paleontologia. 2007;57:7–14.
- 59. Yamasaki Y, Nomura R, Nakano K, Naka S, Matsumoto-Nakano M, Asai F, et al. Distribution of periodontopathic bacterial species in dogs and their owners. Arch Oral Biol. 2012;57(9):1183–8. pmid:22417880
- 60. Crovella S, Ardito G. Frequencies of oral pathologies in a sample of 767 non-human primates. Primates. 1994;35(2):225–30.
- 61. Cordain L, Eaton SB, Sebastian A, Mann N, Lindeberg S, Watkins BA, et al. Origin and evolution of Western diet: health implications for the 21st century. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition. 2005;81:341–54. pmid:15699220
- 62. Lanfranco LP, Eggers S. Caries through time: An Anthropological Overview. In: Li M-Y, editor. Contemporary Approach to Dental Caries: InTech; 2012.
- 63. Adler CJ, Dobney K, Weyrich LS, Kaidonis J, Walker AW, Haak W, et al. Sequencing ancient calcified dental plaque shows changes in oral microbiota with dietary shifts of the Neolithic and Industrial revolutions. Nature genetics. 2013;45(4):450–5, 5e1. pmid:23416520
- 64. Trinkaus E, Pinilla B. Dental Caries in the Qafzeh 3 Middle Paleolithic Modern Human. Paléorient. 2009;35(1):69–76.
- 65. Brothwell DR. The macroscopic dental pathology of some earlier human populations. In: Brothwell DR, editor. Dental anthropology. Oxford: Pergamon Press; 1963. p. 271–88.
- 66. Margvelashvili A, Zollikofer CP, Lordkipanidze D, Tafforeau P, Ponce de Leon MS. Comparative analysis of dentognathic pathologies in the Dmanisi mandibles. American Journal of Physical Anthropology. 2016;160(2):229–53. pmid:26919277
- 67. Tillier A- M, Arensburg B, Rak Y, Vandermeersch B. Middle Palaeolithic dental caries: new evidence from Kebara (Mount Carmel, Israel). Journal of human evolution. 1995;29:189–92.
- 68. Trinkaus E, Smith RJ, Lebel S. Dental Caries in the Aubesier 5 Neandertal Primary Molar. Journal of Archaeological Science. 2000;27(11):1017–21.
- 69. Lacy SA. The oral pathological conditions of the Broken Hill (Kabwe) 1 cranium. International Journal of Paleopathology. 2014;7:57–63. pmid:29539491
- 70. Han K, Zhao L. Dental caries of Gigantopithecus blacki from Hubei Province of China. Acta Anthropologica Sinica. 2002;21(3):191–7.
- 71. Rink WJ, Wei W, Bekken D, Jones HL. Geochronology of Ailuropoda–Stegodon fauna and Gigantopithecus in Guangxi Province, southern China. Quaternary Research. 2008;69(03):377–87.
- 72. Grine FE, Gwinnett AJ, Oaks JH. Early hominid dental pathology: Interproximal caries in 1.5 million-year old Paranthropus robustus from Swartkrans. Archives of Oral Biology. 1990;35(5):381–6. pmid:2196866
- 73. Kilgore L. Dental pathologies in ten free-ranging chimpanzees from Gombe National Park, Tanzania. American journal of physical anthropology. 1989;80:219–27. pmid:2801914
- 74. Stoner KE. Dental Pathology in Pongo satyrus borneensis. American Journal of Physical Anthropology. 1995;98:307–21. pmid:8572155
- 75. Hershkovitz I, Kelly J, Latimer B, Rothschild BM, Simpson S, Polak J, et al. Oral bacteria in Miocene Sivapithecus. Journal of human evolution. 1997;33:507–12. pmid:9361257
- 76. Pilbeam D. New hominoid skull material from the Miocene of Pakistan. Nature. 1982;295:232–4. pmid:6799831
- 77. Mottl M. Bericht über die neuen Menschenaffenfunde aus Österreich, von St. Stefan im Lavanttal, Kärnten. Carinthia II. 1957;67:39–84.
- 78. Klaus W. Zur Mikroflora des Unter-Sarmat am Alpen-Südostrand. Beiträge zur Paläontologie von Österreich. 1984;11:289–419.
- 79. Beck-Mannagetta P. Zur Geologie und Paläontologie des Tertiärs des unteren Lavanttales. Jahrbuch Geol B A. 1952.
- 80. Bassier H. Die Kohleflöze des Lavanttales: Montanuniversität Leoben; 1964.
- 81. Bechtel A, Reischenbacher D, Sachsenhofer RF, Gratzer R, Lücke A, Püttmann W. Relations of petrographical and geochemical parameters in the middle Miocene Lavanttal lignite (Austria). International Journal of Coal Geology. 2007;70(4):325–49.
- 82. Reischenbacher D, Sachsenhofer RF. Basin formation during the post-collisional evolution of the Eastern Alps: the example of the Lavanttal Basin. International Journal of Earth Sciences. 2012;102(2):517–43.
- 83. Böhme M, Ilg A, Winklhofer M. Late Miocene “washhouse” climate in Europe. Earth and Planetary Science Letters. 2008;275(3–4):393–401.
- 84. Rögl F. Palaeogeographic considerations for Mediterranean and Paratethys Seaways (Oligocene to Miocene). Ann Naturhist Mus Wien. 1998;99(A):279–310.
- 85. Bartol M, Mikuž V, Horvat A. Palaeontological evidence of communication between the Central Paratethys and the Mediterranean in the late Badenian/early Serravalian. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology. 2014;394:144–57.
- 86. Palcu DV, Tulbure M, Bartol M, Kouwenhoven TJ, Krijgsman W. The Badenian–Sarmatian Extinction Event in the Carpathian foredeep basin of Romania: Paleogeographic changes in the Paratethys domain. Global and Planetary Change. 2015;133:346–58.
- 87. Harzhauser M, Piller WE. Benchmark data of a changing sea—Palaeogeography, Palaeobiogeography and events in the Central Paratethys during the Miocene. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology. 2007;253(1–2):8–31.
- 88. Piller WE, Harzhauser M. The myth of the brackish Sarmatian Sea. Terra Nova. 2005;17(5):450–5.
- 89. Papp A. Die Altersstellung der fossilführenden Schichten. In: Beck-Mannagetta P, editor. Zur Geologie und Paläontologie des Tertiärs des unteren Lavanttales. Wien: Jahrbuch Geol. B. A.; 1952. p. 5–28.
- 90. Harzhauser M, Piller WE. Integrated stratigraphy of the Sarmatian (Upper Middle Miocene) in the western Central Para Paratethys. Stratigraphy. 2004;1(1):65–86.
- 91. Mottl M. Neue Säugetierfunde aus dem Jungtertiär der Steiermark, IV. Protragocerus erstmals im Sarmat der Steiermark, mit Berücksichtigung der übrigen Säugetierfunde aus der Umgebung von Hartberg. Mitteilungen des Museums für Bergbau Geologie und Technik, Joanneum, Graz. 1958;19:3–16.
- 92. Mottl M. Weitere Säugetierreste aus dem Sarmat von St-Stefan im Lavanttal, Kärnten. Carinthia II. 1958;68:46–8.
- 93. Mottl M. Dorcatherium aus dem unteren Sarmat von St. Stefan im Lavanttal. Carinthia II. 1964;74:22–4.
- 94. Aiglstorfer M, Rössner GE, Böhme M. Dorcatherium naui and pecoran ruminants from the late Middle Miocene Gratkorn locality (Austria). Palaeobiodiversity and Palaeoenvironments. 2014;94(1):83–123.
- 95. Berger W. Jungtertiäre Pflanzenreste aus dem unteren Lavanttal in Ostkärnten. Neues Jahrbuch für Geologie und Paläontologie—Abhandlungen. 1955;100(3):402–30.
- 96. Grímsson F, Zetter R, Baal C. Combined LM and SEM study of the Middle Miocene (Sarmatian) palynoflora from the Lavanttal Basin, Austria: Part I. Bryophyta, Lycopodiophyta, Pteridophyta, Ginkgophyta, and Gnetophyta. Grana. 2011;50(2):102–28.
- 97. Grímsson F, Zetter R. Combined LM and SEM study of the Middle Miocene (Sarmatian) palynoflora from the Lavanttal Basin, Austria: Part II. Pinophyta (Cupressaceae, Pinaceae and Sciadopityaceae). Grana. 2011;50(4):262–310.
- 98. Grímsson F, Meller B, Bouchal JM, Zetter R. Combined LM and SEM study of the middle Miocene (Sarmatian) palynoflora from the Lavanttal Basin, Austria: part III. Magnoliophyta 1 –Magnoliales to Fabales. Grana. 2015;54(2):85–128.
- 99. Grímsson F, Grimm GW, Meller B, Bouchal JM, Zetter R. Combined LM and SEM study of the middle Miocene (Sarmatian) palynoflora from the Lavanttal Basin, Austria: part IV. Magnoliophyta 2 –Fagales to Rosales. Grana. 2015;55(2):101–63.
- 100. Maier W, Schneck G. Functional morphology of hominoid dentitions. Journal of human evolution. 1982;11:693–6.
- 101. Maier W, Schneck G. Konstruktionsmorphologische Untersuchungen am Gebiß der hominoiden Primaten. Zeitschrift für Morphologie und Anthropologie. 1981;72(2):127–69. pmid:7314796
- 102. Souci SW, Fachmann W, Kraut H. Food composition and nutrition tables: Die Zusammensetzung der Lebensmittel—Nährwert-Tabellen La composition des aliments—Tableaux des valeurs nutritives. Stuttgart: MedPharmScientific Publishers; 2016.
- 103. Ayaz FA, Kucukislamoglu M, Reunanen M. Sugar, Non-volatile and Phenolic Acids Composition of Strawberry Tree (Arbutus unedo L. var.ellipsoidea) Fruits. Journal of Food Composition and Analysis. 2000;13(2):171–7.
- 104. Mahapatra AK, Mishra S, Basak UC, Panda PC. Nutrient analysis of some selected wild edible fruits of deciduous forests of India: an explorative study towards non conventional bio-nutrition. Advance Journal of Food Science and Technology. 2012;4(1):15–21.
- 105. Begun DR. European hominoids. In: Hartwig WC, editor. The Primate Fossil Record. Touro University College of Osteopathic Medicine, California: Cambridge University Press; 2002. p. 339–68.
- 106. Nagatoshi K. Molar Enamel Thickness in European Miocene and Extant Hominoidea. International Journal of Primatology. 1990;11(4):283–94.
- 107. Marlowe FW, Berbesque JC, Wood B, Crittenden A, Porter C, Mabulla A. Honey, Hadza, hunter-gatherers, and human evolution. Journal of human evolution. 2014;71:119–28. pmid:24746602
- 108. Galbany J, Pérez-Pérez A. buccal enamel microwear variability in cercopithecoidea primates as a reflection of dietary habits in forested and open savanna environments. Anthropologie. 2004;XLII(1):13–9.
- 109. Andrews P, Harrison T, Delson E, Bernor RL, Martin L. Distribution and Biochronology of European and Southwest Asian Miocene catarrhines. In: Bernor RL, Fahlbusch V, Mittmann H-W, editors. The Evolution of Western Eurasian Neogene Mammal Faunas. New York: Columbia University Press; 1996. p. 168–207.
- 110. Lukacs JR. Sex differences in dental caries experience: clinical evidence, complex etiology. Clinical oral investigations. 2011;15(5):649–56. pmid:20652339
- 111. Lukacs JR, Largaespada LL. Explaining sex differences in dental caries prevalence: saliva, hormones, and "life-history" etiologies. American journal of human biology: the official journal of the Human Biology Council. 2006;18(4):540–55.
- 112. Vogel ER, Knott CD, Crowley BE, Blakely MD, Larsen MD, Dominy NJ. Bornean orangutans on the brink of protein bankruptcy. Biology letters. 2012;8(3):333–6. pmid:22171019
- 113. Milton K. Diet and primate evolution. Scientific American. 1993;269:86–93.
- 114. Milton K. Micronutrient intakes of wild primates: are humans different? Comparative Biochemistry and Physiology Part A: Molecular & Integrative Physiology. 2003;136(1):47–59.
- 115. Conklin-Brittain Wrangham RW, Smith CC. A two-stage model of increased dietary quality in early hominid evolution: the role of fiber. In: Ungar PS, Teaford M, editors. Human diet—its origin and evolution. London: Bergin & Garvey; 2002. p. 61–76.
- 116. Hemingway CA, Bynum N. The influence of seasonality on primate diet and ranging. In: Brockman DK, van Schaik CP, editors. Seasonality in Primates: studies of living and extinct human and non-human primates: Cambridge University Press; 2005. p. 57.
- 117. Youlatos D. Suspensory Posture. In: Fuentes A, editor. The International Encyclopedia of Primatology: John Wiley & Sons, Inc.; 2017. p. 1–2.
- 118. Hanya G, Tsuji Y, Grueter CC. Fruiting and flushing phenology in Asian tropical and temperate forests: implications for primate ecology. Primates. 2013;54(2):101–10. pmid:23354470
- 119. Teichmüller M. Die Oreopithecus-führende Kohle von Baccinello bei Grosseto (Toskana/Italien). Geologisches Jahrbuch. 1962;80:69–110.
- 120. Cannon B, Nedergaard J. Brown adipose tissue: function and physiological significance. Physiological Review. 2004;84:277–359.
- 121. Oda M, Satta Y, Takenaka O, Takahata N. Loss of urate oxidase activity in hominoids and its evolutionary implications. Molecular biology and evolution. 2002;19:640–53. pmid:11961098