In the coming decades, environmental change like warming and acidification will affect life in the ocean. While data on single stressor effects on fish are accumulating rapidly, we still know relatively little about interactive effects of multiple drivers. Of particular concern in this context are the early life stages of fish, for which direct effects of increased CO2 on growth and development have been observed. Whether these effects are further modified by elevated temperature was investigated here for the larvae of Atlantic herring (Clupea harengus), a commercially important fish species. Over a period of 32 days, larval survival, growth in size and weight, and instantaneous growth rate were assessed in a crossed experimental design of two temperatures (10°C and 12°C) with two CO2 levels (400 μatm and 900 μatm CO2) at food levels mimicking natural levels using natural prey. Elevated temperature alone led to increased swimming activity, as well as decreased survival and instantaneous growth rate (Gi). The comparatively high sensitivity to elevated temperature in this study may have been influenced by low food levels offered to the larvae. Larval size, Gi and swimming activity were not affected by CO2, indicating tolerance of this species to projected "end of the century" CO2 levels. A synergistic effect of elevated temperature and CO2 was found for larval weight, where no effect of elevated CO2 concentrations was detected in the 12°C treatment, but a negative CO2 effect was found in the 10°C treatment. Contrasting CO2 effects were found for survival between the two temperatures. Under ambient CO2 conditions survival was increased at 12°C compared to 10°C. In general, CO2 effects were minor and considered negligible compared to the effect of temperature under these mimicked natural food conditions. These findings emphasize the need to include biotic factors such as energy supply via prey availability in future studies on interactive effects of multiple stressors.
Citation: Sswat M, Stiasny MH, Jutfelt F, Riebesell U, Clemmesen C (2018) Growth performance and survival of larval Atlantic herring, under the combined effects of elevated temperatures and CO2. PLoS ONE 13(1): e0191947. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0191947
Editor: Heather M. Patterson, Department of Agriculture and Water Resources, AUSTRALIA
Received: August 22, 2016; Accepted: January 15, 2018; Published: January 25, 2018
Copyright: © 2018 Sswat et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Data Availability: The data used and presented in this study are accessible via the PANGEA database (https://doi.pangaea.de/10.1594/PANGAEA.882302).
Funding: The study was jointly funded by Association of European Marine Biological Laboratories (http://www.assemblemarine.org) ASSEMBLE grant no. 227799 given to C. Clemmesen and M. Sswat and the Federal Ministry of Education and Research BMBF (FKZ 03F06550) in the framework of the coordinated projects BIOACID II (http://www.bioacid.de).
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Ocean warming (OW) and acidification (OA), both caused by rising atmospheric CO2 levels [1,2], will intensify in the future. Sea surface temperature is projected to increase by at least 1.5°C while seawater pH could decrease by 0.4, when pCO2 levels of ~800 μatm are reached by the year 2100 [3,4]. These environmental changes will likely interact in their effects on fish populations and are therefore of great interest to society due to the socio-economic value of fishing and other ecosystem services [5,6]. The early developmental stages of fish (eggs and larvae) are of particular importance for ecosystems and fisheries since they represent a critical bottleneck for recruitment [7,8]. The performance of fish species and their developmental stages should be best around their abiotic and biotic optimum . The theoretical optimal temperature of a species corresponds to optimal  or even suboptimal  growth temperatures and may interact with future CO2 concentrations, as observed for larval European sea bass (Dicentrarchus labrax)  and Senegalese sole (Solea senegalensis) . Larval European sea bass displayed higher survival at increased temperatures and elevated pCO2 levels, leading to heavier juveniles in the warm treatment and lower aerobic scope under elevated pCO2 levels . In contrast, the early life stages of Senegalese sole showed strong negative impacts of increased pCO2 and temperatures on hatching success and survival, while larval growth and metabolism were positively affected by increased temperature but negatively affected by increased pCO2 . A synergistic effect of elevated temperature and pCO2 was detected as an increase in skeletal deformities and otolith size . Although few studies have tested the interaction of increased temperature and pCO2 for the early life stages of fish, these two exemplary studies highlight the complexity in the interacting effects of temperature and pCO2.
Considerably more information is available on the single effect of increased pCO2 on early developmental stages of fish, which, in general, are thought to be most susceptible to changes in pH and therefore most vulnerable to OA [14,15]. This can be attributed to the fact that gills, the main organ for pH regulation, are not yet functional during early larval development and thus larvae have to rely on other regulatory mechanisms (e.g. via cutaneous chloride cells) [16,17]. Detrimental effects of elevated CO2 levels (e.g. organ damage  and increased embryonic mortality [19,20]) have been reported for the larvae of a range of fish species. Impacts of OA on behaviour [21,22] were related to an interaction between CO2 and neurotransmitter function . However, few or no effects of OA have been found for the larvae of several other species for several parameters [24–28], demonstrating that larval responses may be species specific.
Intraspecific differences in the effect of OA have also been reported, for example, in the early developmental stages of Atlantic herring (Clupea harengus) one of the most important economic fish species in the North Atlantic . No evidence of negative OA impacts, even at 4600 μatm CO2, was found for Baltic Sea herring eggs and larvae at hatch on several parameters like hatch rate and size. However, nutritional condition in terms of RNA:DNA  and egg survival  was found to be negatively affected. In older larvae of Norwegian spring-spawning herring, in contrast, a negative effect on growth, development, condition and tissue formation was observed at CO2 levels >1800 μatm CO2 , while swimming kinematics and proteome structure were unaffected [33,34]. As a coastal bottom-spawning species the eggs and newly hatched larvae of herring can already encounter CO2 levels higher than expected for the end of the century, due to the seasonal variation and biological activity in coastal areas, especially in the Baltic Sea [35,36], which could explain the above mentioned differences in response to OA in performance between populations. It is therefore important to study these variable responses in relation to temperature and pCO2 changes to better understand the potential effects on recruitment of fish populations in a future ocean.
In this study, survival and performance of larval Atlantic herring was investigated under ambient and elevated CO2-concentrations (400 and 900μatm pCO2) within two temperature regimes (10 and 12°C). We developed three hypotheses to test in this study: 1. Elevated CO2 levels negatively affect length, weight, instantaneous growth rate, development and survival, while increasing swimming activity; 2. These traits are negatively affected in the higher temperature treatment due to the natural food conditions; and 3. This leads to a synergistic negative effect of elevated CO2 concentrations and higher temperatures.
Materials and methods
The experiment was performed at the Sven Lovén Centre for Marine Sciences in Kristineberg, Sweden from April to June 2013. The brood stock herring originated from the Oslo-Fjord close to the Biological Station Drøbak, University of Oslo and were caught using a gillnet on April, 22nd 2013 at a depth of ~30m, at the southern tip of Søndre Kaholmen, roughly located at 59°40'29" N and 10°36'22" E. The dead, ready-to-spawn herring were transported on ice to the Sven Lovén Centre, where fertilization was performed four hours later. The eggs from five females were stripped separately on 150 plastic plates with an area of 6 cm2 and ~150 eggs per plate. Subsequently, the sperm from five males was used to create a total of 25 distinct families, each on six egg plates. Fertilization was performed in seawater of the two CO2 treatments (~400 μatm and ~900 μatm CO2), already in line with the experimental CO2 treatment of the larvae after hatch to include possible effects on sperm motility and fertilization success. To synchronize the time of hatching, egg incubation was performed at ambient CO2 (400 μatm) conditions and 10°C. Herring have an egg development of ~130 degree days, which means 13 days at 10°C and 11 days at 12°C. This two day difference in hatching would have meant variation in prey levels per day. Different times of hatching would thus have been problematic to directly relate differences between larvae to treatment effects.
For the larval rearing two temperatures (10 and 12°C) and two CO2-levels (ambient: 400 μatm and elevated: 900 μatm CO2) were fully crossed with 3 replicates, resulting in twelve tanks in total. The treatments are hereafter named according to their temperature and CO2 conditions: 10/400, 10/900, 12/400 and 12/900. The two temperature treatments are within the preferred range (8–12°C) of Atlantic herring larvae described by Mehner et al. . At the time of peak hatch (more than 50% of larvae hatched) the larvae were distributed randomly into plastic bags, which were lowered into the rearing tanks to allow for temperature acclimatization prior to introduction. Larvae were kept at the CO2 level at which the eggs had been fertilized, but were randomly distributed between the replicates. The rearing water was taken from the fjord (inlet at 30 m depth); temperature was adjusted before UV treatment and filtration (pore size 500 μm, 50 μm, 20 μm and 5 μm). The treated water was distributed to the rearing tanks of 90 L via twelve individual header tanks of 50 L, where CO2 manipulation took place. The pH probes were installed in the header tanks, which were connected to a computer-based pH-manipulation-system (IKS COMPUTERSYSTEME GMBH). The IKS system constantly measured pH in the header tanks. If the system detected deviations from the set target pH of 7.8 for the high CO2 treatments, CO2 was injected into the header tanks via opening of a magnetic valve. Additional air bubbling in the header tanks assured mixing and air-water oxygen equilibration. Constant bubbling with tiny pores provided gentle stirring of the rearing tanks, and the daily siphoning of dead prey items and other particles ensured a clean environment for the larvae. Mean water flow-through rate was 200 ml/min per individual header and respective rearing tank, leading to a renewal time of water per rearing tank of ten hours. The light was set according to natural, ambient hours of daylight (16 to 17 hours per day with mean light intensities of 18 μE). Temperature and pH were measured in each tank daily (WTW pH/Cond 340i/3320, WTW Wissenschaftlich-Technische Werkstätten GmbH), while pCO2 was measured every five days using a method described by Green and Jutfelt  using infra-red CO2 absorbance (Vaisala, Helsinki, Finland). Temperature, pH and CO2 measurements were taken at the same time by lowering the probes in the rearing tank approximately 5cm below the water surface. The probes were left inside the tank until values were stable. Measurements were taken in the morning before feeding and syphoning, but pH was checked occasionally during the day to assure stable conditions. Temperature and measured pCO2 over time are shown in (Fig 1A and 1B). pCO2 was additionally calculated at the beginning and the end of the experiment using the free software CO2SYS  with the set constants of  refitted by Dickson & Millero  and the measured parameters dissolved inorganic carbon (DIC) and total alkalinity (Table 1) based on the Best Practices Guide .
Temperature (a) and measured pCO2 (b) per treatment combination (mean and standard error) over the experimental period against days post hatch.
Herring larvae were fed three times per day with natural plankton pumped from the fjord and concentrated with a Hydrotech plankton filter. The prey consisted mainly of calanoid copepod nauplii and copepodites with a size range of 70–200 μm, which are natural prey for herring larvae [43–46]. Per day, mean prey densities of 147 items L-1 (minimum 44 and maximum 300 prey items L-1 at 8 DPH (days post hatch) and 11 DPH, respectively) of rearing water were achieved in each tank (Fig 2) and grazed down till the next feeding event. Mean prey densities were above the critical prey density for herring, estimated as 10 prey items L-1 [47,48]. Laurence  describes a natural range of 5–80 nauplii L-1, which defines this study to be close to natural prey densities and considerably lower than in other studies with ~2000 prey items L-1 [32,50]. The low prey densities are also depicted by low standardized RNA/DNA ratios (sRD) during the study, a proxy for larval nutritional condition, (Fig 3C). Additionally a solution of a green algae Nannochloropsis sp. (6*105 cells L-1) was given to create "green water" conditions during the whole experiment, which were shown to have a positive effect on fish larvae , also recently shown for first feeding herring .
Herring larvae performance per treatment combination of two temperatures, 10°C and 12°C, and CO2 levels, 400μatm and 900μatm pCO2, (mean ± standard deviation) for the whole experimental period against days post hatch: a) standard length SL (mm), b) dry weight DW (mg), c) nutritional condition sRD, d) instantaneous growth rate Gi and e) survival. The vertical line represents the separation into phases I and II.
Sampling & analysis
Each morning the dead larvae were collected by siphoning the tank floors and counted to calculate mortality rates. Sampling was conducted approximately every five days. After anaesthetization with tricaine methanesulfonate (MS-222) and before storage at minus 80°C, a photograph of each individual larva was taken with a digital camera attached to a stereomicroscope (Olympus SZX 7 with Olympus DP 26 Camera and Olympus Stream Essentials Software). Standard length (SL) measurements were taken from calibrated photos of each larva with the open source software Image J . Developmental stages were determined according to Doyle  and the proportional contribution of each developmental stage was calculated. Dry weight (DW) was measured for each individual larva on a micro balance (Sartorius SC 2 micro balance, Sartorius AG, Göttingen, Germany; precision ±0.1 μg) after freeze drying (Christ Alpha 1–4 freeze dryer, Martin Christ Gefriertrocknungsanlagen GmbH, Osterrode, Germany). The same larvae were later used for nucleic acid analysis according to the protocol described in Malzahn et al. . As an indicator of nutritional condition, the ratio of the nucleic acids RNA and DNA (RD), defined as the number of protein biosynthesis machinery per cell was standardized to sRD according to Caldarone et al. : sRD = 0.92 × RD. Since different temperatures can lead to different activities of these protein biosynthesis units, different estimated growth rates resulting from the total amount of RNA were expected. To compare resulting growth rates from the two temperature treatments, dry weight related instantaneous growth rates (Gi) of the larvae were calculated  based on the following relationship:
With Gi being the instantaneous growth rate, sRD the intercalibrated standardized RNA/DNA ratio and T the temperature determined at the sampling time. A resulting Gi-value of 0 would mean no growth at all and a value of 1 resembles the doubling of the weight of the larva per day. Details on the number of larvae analysed per parameter are given in S1 Table. The swimming activity was measured for the survivors by automated video tracking software similar to the methods described in detail in Sundin & Jutfelt . Briefly, six larvae per tank were carefully transferred from the rearing tanks into individual circular chambers (diameter: 35 mm, 10 mm water height). As the larvae are transparent the chambers were placed on a black background and lit by light ramps from the sides, making the larvae appear white. This provided sufficient contrast for reliable tracking of larval movements. The larvae were left undisturbed for 20 min, during which time they were monitored using a firewire camera (Dragonfly 2, Pointgray, Richmond BC, Canada), connected to a computer mounted above the chambers. The software (Zebralab, Viewpoint, Lyon, France) measured all movements of each larva (all movements over a certain threshold to avoid image noise being counted as larval movements). The sampling frequency was 30 frames per second. The software calculated the integrated swimming activity per minute, meaning all motion was detected during this time, which was then averaged for each larva during the 20 minutes interval and used for further analysis (S1 Fig).
The experiment was divided into two phases based on the nutritional condition (sRD) of the larvae at a time before and after 22 DPH, where a point of inflexion in sRD was observed (Fig 3). Phase I is characterized by a decline, while phase II shows an increasing trend in sRD. To relate larval age in DPH to the larval development we chose to state degree days for selected events, which is the cumulative sum of mean daily temperatures for a given age in DPH, according to Fuiman et al.  the best comparison of ontogenetic stages within a species.
In the 12/400-treatment a high mortality event in one of the replicate tanks occurred at 21 DPH. The remaining larvae of this tank were sampled until the end of the experiment. In contrast to the two other replicates from 12/400, this tank experienced a strong increase in length, weight and nutritional condition in the second phase, which indicates an effect of this high mortality event, probably due to increased food availability per each individual larva. Since the causes for the higher mortality are unknown and triplicated treatments do not allow for an identification of outliers, the data from this tank are therefore included in the analyses.
For statistical analyses of growth and development over time, a repeated-measures ANOVA was applied as a linear-mixed-effect model. Here, the two experimental treatments "Temperature" and "CO2" as well as "Time" in DPH were used as fixed factors. By choosing "Tank number" as a random factor, dependency of measurements at different time points was taken into account as well as possible "tank-effects". The models were fitted to the data using means of standard length, dry weight and Gi and developmental status per tank and sampling day. Mean developmental status was calculated by attributing continuous numbering to the "Doyle stages", i.e. the Doyle stage 1a = 1, 1b = 2, …, 3b = 8. For data analysed by the repeated-measures-ANOVA approach (linear-mixed-effect models) F- and p-values as well as degrees of freedom (DF) are given (Table 2, S2 Table). Table 2 only shows the significant factors, while in the supplement S2 Table all factors are listed.
Only significant factors are shown for the different parameters with the respective F-values and p-values. The factors listed are additive for the described models. The complete table can be found in S2 Table.
Swimming activity was measured at the end of the experiment. For the statistical analysis of the activity patterns, the averaged swimming activity of each single larva was used in an ANCOVA approach to include the additional covariate standard length. The assumptions of an ANCOVA, homogeneity of variance, normality and independency of covariates, were assessed visually. The respective likeliness of fit (R2), DF, F and p-values are displayed (Table 2, S3 Table). In both approaches, repeated-measures ANOVA and ANCOVA, the best model was detected by searching for the smallest Akaike Information Criterion, if differences compared to the more complex models were not significant. For the survival analysis Cox proportional hazards model was chosen (Table 3), with exp(coef) being the ratio between mean survival of one treatment group to another and therefore showing which group has a better survival. Exp(coef)>1 in this case means that the described group (treatment combination) shows a lower survival than the reference group. The survival analysis was repeated for both temperatures separately to discriminate between combined effects of temperature and CO2. The significance level for all statistical analysis was set to p<0.05. The statistical analyses were performed for the whole experimental period and for phase I and phase II separately, based on the above mentioned distinction in nutritional condition (sRD).
Treatment values of 12/900 refer to °C/μatm CO2 and the given interaction.
Animal welfare was assured by performing the experiment according to the guidelines of the ethics permit (number 332–2012) with a separate permit for the behavioural part of the study (number 151–2011), both issued by the Swedish Board of Agriculture "Jordbruksverket"). In order to minimize stress, specimens were anaesthetized using MS-222 before handling and fixation. The species (Clupea harengus) used is not endangered and was obtained from a local registered and licensed fisherman (license ID = 977 224 357).
Effect on larval size
Herring larvae started with a mean SL of 9.6 mm ± 0.5 SD at 2 DPH and reached 13.1 mm ± 0.8 SD after 32 DPH (Fig 3A). The increasing size with age was validated by the significant effect of time (Table 2). Neither temperature nor CO2 alone, or in combination, showed a statistically significant effect on larval size (Table 2)(Fig 3A).
Effect on larval dry weight
Mean larval DW increased over time from 0.14 ± 0.03 mg at 2 DPH to 0.31 ± 0.09 mg at 32 DPH (Fig 3B). A significant interaction effect of temperature and CO2 on DW was detected for phase I (p<0.05). This interaction of temperature and CO2 on DW, however, was not significant for phase II or the whole period (Table 2). The combined effect of temperature and CO2 in phase I was visible at 10°C with higher DW in the ambient compared to the high CO2 treatment, which could not be seen at 12°C.
Instantaneous growth rate
The development of Gi over time is represented by values of 0.093 ± 0.028 at 2 DPH, -0.003 ± 0.022 at 22 DPH and 0.028 ± 0.027 at 32 DPH (Fig 3D). In phase I when Gi was declining, temperature was found to have a significant effect over time with in general lower Gi values at 12°C (Table 2). During this phase no significant CO2 effect was detected (S2 Table). From 22 DPH (10°C = ~225 degree days; 12°C = ~270 degree days) when Gi values were lowest until the end of the study, Gi values were increasing (phase II) with a stronger increase at 12°C (p = 0.05) (S2 Table).
The larval survival displayed a steady decline until the end of the experiment (Fig 3E). Survival was significantly lower in 12/400 and 12/900 than in 10/400 and 10/900 for the whole period and in each separate phase (Table 3). A significant interaction of temperature and CO2 was found for the whole period and phase I. Higher survival was detected in 10/900 than in 10/400 over the whole period, though there were no significant effects in the single phases I and II. 12/400 showed significantly higher survival than 12/900 only in phase I, but not for the whole period and phase II (Table 3). The difference in survival between CO2 treatments was in the range of 1–2 days, while ~6 days separate the two temperature treatments. Also confidence intervals depicted the difference between CO2 treatments in 10°C as small compared to the effect of temperature (Fig 3E).
The activity of the larvae at the end of the experiment (28–30 DPH) was higher in 12/400 and 12/900, and also increased significantly with larval length (Fig 4; Table 2; S3 Table). The significant interaction of these two factors can be seen as an increasing temperature effect on the activity of longer larvae. No significant effect of CO2 on activity was detected.
The lines show the linear correlation between swimming activity and standard length for each treatment.
The development of the larvae was categorized by determining the Doyle stages. A similar development was found in all treatments with the majority of the larvae reaching stage 2c at the end of the experiment (Fig 5). In phase I a significant interaction of temperature and time was detected, being reflected in slightly more developed larvae at 2 and 12 DPH in the 10°C treatments (Table 2).
Relative contribution per developmental stage and treatment for selected sampling days: (a) 2 DPH, (b) 12 DPH, (c) 22 DPH and (d) 32 DPH.
Effect of temperature
Although a direct negative effect of warming on Atlantic herring is thought to be unlikely due to the broad thermal tolerance , and both temperatures in the experiment were in the preferred range of herring [37,61], a negative effect of higher temperature on survival and instantaneous growth rate was found in this study. The temperature effects detected in the first phase of the experiment on instantaneous growth rate and survival may originate from different response times in yolk utilization  and the switch from endogenous to exogenous feeding mode . After this critical first-feeding stage, the general agreement in the literature states that increasing growth is related to higher prey densities and temperatures within the thermal window of the species . One possible reason for the negative temperature effects observed in this study could be increased energy demand at elevated temperatures correlated to increased metabolic rates [63,64], but may also be due to increased activity in the warmer temperature causing higher metabolic rates. As elevated swimming activity in warm water was detected in this study, such a mechanism could be plausible.
The positive effect of temperature on growth, regardless of the prey densities, described in an individual based model for herring , is different to our findings, but may be explained by lower prey densities in our study than specified in the model. Usually studies on the effect of temperature on larval growth are performed at ad libitum food densities, so the energy required for processes such as growth and metabolism is provided  and a positive effect of temperature on growth can be observed [66–68]. The low food levels in the current study limited energy supply, and an increased energy demand in the higher temperature may not have been met. When comparing growth of larvae in the current study to those in Fox et al. , similar larval sizes were found in their low food treatment at the same age and temperature, indicating that energy availability was limiting growth in the current study. The effect of low food availability is also supported by the low values of Gi, resembling bad feeding conditions [70–72] and the delayed larval development in the warm treatment. Therefore, the negative effect of higher temperature is likely a combined direct effect of temperature, as well as increased energy demand. The relatively high Gi values found in our study right after hatch most likely relate to the endogenous feeding of the larvae on yolk , while the slight increase in growth potential to the end of our study cannot be explained by absolute higher food densities, but may result from increasing encounter rates  and improvement in hydrodynamic constraints for feeding .
Effect of CO2
Herring larval dry weight was negatively impacted at CO2 levels projected for the end of the century (~900 μatm CO2), though this effect was only significant in the 10°C treatment and during the first phase of our study. These findings are in concordance with the literature [30,32], and may result from an increased energy demand for osmoregulation during the first days after hatch . For example, Frommel et al.  found a negative effect on growth in dry weight and suspected altered organ functionality in the pancreas, liver and kidneys, as underlying mechanisms, while a positive effect on growth was assumed to indicate altered pathways in protein and lipid biosynthesis . Both of these mechanisms may affect larval growth efficiency and survival. The interaction of low energy supply needs to be taken into account, which calls for a more thorough investigation into how effects of different temperatures and elevated CO2 concentrations interact at different food levels. The fact that larval herring swimming activity (this study) and swimming kinematics  were unaffected by CO2 fits with recent findings that many temperate species appear behaviourally robust to increased CO2 concentrations [34,58,76–79], despite the negative effects on behaviour that have been reported in several tropical fishes (e.g. ). It is unclear why temperate species would be more robust to higher CO2 levels than tropical species. It could be due to temperate fish living in more variable environments (e.g. seasonal changes in temperature, oxygen and pCO2, food density, nutrients), which may require higher ability for phenotypic plasticity than species in less variable environments. This apparent difference between tropical and temperate species may also be an artefact due to differences between studies (e.g. methodological differences, researcher and publication biases, “the decline effect” where early publications on a topic typically overestimate the effect sizes, or phylogenetic differences of the species used from different geographical areas.
Distinct negative effects of OA on survival were found for the important forage fish Atlantic silverside  and two populations of the economically important Atlantic cod , while in our study survival of Atlantic herring larvae showed contrasting effects depending on the temperature, indicating interspecific differences. A negative CO2 effect on survival was detected at 12°C, but a positive effect was detected at 10°C, which calls for a careful interpretation of the data and further research on this topic. Differences in survival between CO2 treatments ranged between 1–2 days, which is close to the detection limit of survival rates in our study, since dead larvae were sampled on a daily basis. In general, the effect of CO2 was small compared to the effect of temperature in our study, as can be seen in the small effect sizes of the CO2 treatments.
Ocean warming has been suggested to increase total energy expenditure for metabolism , while ocean acidification has been hypothesized to mainly increase energy expenditure for osmoregulation . Limited energy uptake due to low prey availability, combined with an increased energy demand, may result in less energy available in total for growth and maintenance. Reduced growth rates at higher temperatures in herring have also been reported by Høie et al. . In general, survival can be matched to the growth potential in this study, with larvae in poor condition at a higher risk for starvation . Additionally, the risk of starvation may increase at elevated temperatures, thereby lowering survival, as shown for two age groups of herring larvae . Probably owing to the increased risk of starvation, one of the replicates in the warmer treatment of our study experienced a high mortality at 21 DPH and afterwards showed a strong increase in growth. Two possible explanations for this scenario are an increase in food items per individual or selection for larvae with a lower starvation potential. A selection for phenotypes with better growth at unfavourable prey availability has been shown in the field for larval Atlantic cod G. morhua  and in mesocosms for larval herring . An increased energy demand, at elevated temperature or CO2 conditions, may thus have the potential to select for specific phenotypes and could especially interact with altered energy supply in terms of food availability.
Although there was an indication for a negative CO2 effect on larval dry weight in our study, the overall result is that herring larvae were tolerant to end of the century CO2 conditions (Hypothesis 1). This was especially true when the larvae's response was compared to the negative impact of elevated temperatures due to low food supply (Hypothesis 2), with impacts on instantaneous growth rate and survival. A synergistic effect of elevated temperatures and CO2 concentrations (Hypothesis 3) was indicated for herring larval dry weight and survival, but calls for more detailed investigation, with a focus on selection processes. The comparatively small effect of end of the century CO2 concentrations on herring larval performance might be explained by the abiotic conditions already experienced through their life cycle as a bottom spawning species. The diverse results on possible effects of OA on the performance of this economically important species reported in the literature could be explained by differences in biological responses depending on applied OA scenarios, population and life stages. These results also support the propositions that Atlantic herring may be tolerant to future OA scenarios. For a full understanding of the potential impacts of OA on fish larvae, indirect effects via food web interactions will need to be considered and may have the potential to additionally affect performance of early life stages in fish.
S1 Table. Number of larvae per sampling.
Number of larvae per replicate (Tank) and sampling day in days post hatch (DPH) used for the respective analysis (SL = standard length, DW = dry weight, Gi = growth potential, Doyle = developmental stage; Swimming activity was only measured once at the end).
S2 Table. Complete results for repeated-measures ANOVA.
Outcome of the best fitting repeated-measures ANOVA model for the different parameters with the respective degrees of freedom (DF), F-values and p-values. The factors listed are additive for the described models, e.g. Length~Time+Temp+CO2+Temp*CO2.
S3 Table. Complete results for ANCOVA.
Outcome of the best fitting ANCOVA model for swimming activity with the respective likeliness of fit (R2), degrees of freedom (DF), F-values and p-values. The factors listed are additive for the described model.
S1 Fig. Swimming activity over time.
Mean (±sd) swimming activity per minute for four treatment combinations of temperature (10°C vs. 12°C) and CO2 (400 μatm vs. 900 μatm pCO2), measured over a 20 minute time interval.
We thank the Sven Lovén Centre for Marine Sciences in Kristineberg for providing us with a professional working environment. We are grateful for the crucial help by the team from the Biological Station Drøbak lead by Hans Erik Karlsen in catching the fish for this experiment. Since this study was conducted in parallel to the KOSMOS experiment we want to acknowledge the great support by the team on-site as well as at GEOMAR in Kiel. The study was jointly funded by Association of European Marine Biological Laboratories (http://www.assemblemarine.org) ASSEMBLE grant no. 227799 given to C. Clemmesen and M. Sswat and the Federal Ministry of Education and Research BMBF (FKZ 03F06550) in the framework of the coordinated projects BIOACID II (http://www.bioacid.de).
- 1. Le Quéré C, Moriarty R, Andrew RM, Peters GP, Ciais P, Friedlingstein P, et al. Global carbon budget 2014. Earth Syst Sci Data. 2014;7: 521–610.
Dlugokencky E, Tans P. Recent Global CO2. In: NOAA/ESRL [Internet]. 2015 [cited 4 Nov 2016] p. http://www.esrl.noaa.gov/gmd/ccgg/trends/global.ht. Available: www.esrl.noaa.gov/gmd/ccgg/trends/
- 3. Howes EL, Joos F, Eakin CM, Gattuso J-P. An updated synthesis of the observed and projected impacts of climate change on the chemical, physical and biological processes in the oceans. Front Mar Sci. 2015;2: 1–27.
Stocker TF, Qin D, Plattner G-K, Tignor M, Allen SK, Boschung J, et al. IPCC, 2013: Summary for Policymakers. In: Climate Change 2013: The Physical Science Basis. Contribution of Working Group I to the Fifth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Cambridge Univ Press Cambridge, United Kingdom New York, NY, USA. 2013; 1–29. 10.1017/CBO9781107415324
- 5. Haigh R, Ianson D, Holt CA, Neate HE, Edwards AM. Effects of Ocean Acidification on Temperate Coastal Marine Ecosystems and Fisheries in the Northeast Pacific. PLoS One. 2015;10: e0117533. pmid:25671596
- 6. Koenigstein S, Ruth M, Gößling-Reisemann S. Stakeholder-informed ecosystem modelling of ocean warming and acidification impacts in the Barents Sea region. Front Mar Sci. 2016;
- 7. Shepherd JG, Cushing DH. A mechanism for density-dependent survival of larval fish as the basis of a stock-recruitment relationship. ICES J Mar Sci. 1980;39: 160–167.
Houde ED. Fish Early Life Dynamics and Recruitment Variability. American Fisheries Society Symposium. 1987. p. 2: 17–29.
- 9. Pörtner H-O, Peck MA. Climate change effects on fishes and fisheries : towards a cause-and-effect understanding. J Fish Biol. 2010;77: 1745–1779. pmid:21078088
- 10. Jobling M. Temperature tolerance and the final preferendum-rapid methods for the assessment of optimum growth temperatures. J Fish Biol. 1981;19: 439–455.
- 11. Martin TL, Huey RB. Why “Suboptimal” Is Optimal: Jensen’s Inequality and Ectotherm Thermal Preferences. Am Nat. 2008;171: 102–118. pmid:18271721
- 12. Pope EC, Ellis RP, Scolamacchia M, Scolding JWS, Keay A, Chingombe P, et al. Is the perceived resiliency of fish larvae to ocean acidification masking more subtle effects? Biogeosciences Discuss. 2013;10: 17043–17070.
- 13. Pimentel MS, Faleiro F, Dionísio G, Repolho T, Pousão P, Machado J, et al. Defective skeletogenesis and oversized otoliths in fish early stages in a changing ocean. J Exp Biol. 2014; pmid:24625652
- 14. Kikkawa T, Kita J, Ishimatsu A. Comparison of the lethal effect of CO2 and acidification on red sea bream (Pagrus major) during the early developmental stages. Mar Pollut Bull. 2004;48: 108–10. pmid:14725881
Brown DJA, Sadler K. Fish survival in acid waters. In: Morris R, editor. Conference Symp on Acid Toxicity and Aquatic Animals,. 1989. pp. 31–44.
Finn RN, Kapoor BG. Fish larval physiology. Enfield, NH: Science Publishers; 2008.
- 17. Wales W, Tytler P. Changes in chloride cell distribution during early larval stages of Clupea harengus. J Fish Biol. 1996;49: 801–814.
- 18. Frommel AY, Maneja R, Lowe D, Malzahn AM, Geffen AJ, Folkvord A, et al. Severe tissue damage in Atlantic cod larvae under increasing ocean acidification. Nat Clim Chang. Nature Publishing Group; 2011;2: 42–46.
- 19. Forsgren E, Dupont S, Jutfelt F, Amundsen T. Elevated CO2 affects embryonic development and larval phototaxis in a temperate marine fish. Ecol Evol. 2013;3: 3637–3646. pmid:24198929
- 20. Stiasny MH, Mittermayer FH, Sswat M, Voss R, Jutfelt F, Chierici M, et al. Ocean acidification effects on Atlantic cod larval survival and recruitment to the fished population. PLoS One. 2016;11: 1–11.
- 21. Welch MJ, Watson S-A, Welsh JQ, Mccormick MI, Munday PL. Effects of elevated CO2 on fish behaviour undiminished by transgenerational acclimation. Nat Clim Chang. 2014;4: 2–5.
- 22. Pimentel M, Pegado M, Repolho T, Rosa R. Impact of ocean acidification in the metabolism and swimming behavior of the dolphinfish (Coryphaena hippurus) early larvae. Mar Biol. 2014;161: 725–729.
- 23. Nilsson GE, Dixson DL, Domenici P, McCormick MI, Sørensen C, Watson S- A, et al. Near-future carbon dioxide levels alter fish behaviour by interfering with neurotransmitter function. Nat Clim Chang. Nature Publishing Group; 2012;2: 201–204.
- 24. Munday PL, Donelson JM, Dixson DL, Endo GGK. Effects of ocean acidification on the early life history of a tropical marine fish. Proc Biol Sci. 2009;276: 3275–83. pmid:19556256
- 25. Bignami S, Sponaugle S, Cowen RK. Effects of ocean acidification on the larvae of a high-value pelagic fisheries species, mahi-mahi Coryphaena hippurus. Aquat Biol. 2014;21: 249–260.
- 26. Hurst TP, Fernandez ER, Mathis JT. Effects of ocean acidification on hatch size and larval growth of walleye pollock (Theragra chalcogramma). ICES J Mar Sci. 2013;70: 812–822.
- 27. Schade FM, Clemmesen C, Wegner MK. Within- and transgenerational effects of ocean acidification on life history of marine three-spined stickleback (Gasterosteus aculeatus). Mar Biol. 2014;
- 28. Frommel AY, Schubert A, Piatkowski U, Clemmesen C. Egg and early larval stages of Baltic cod, Gadus morhua, are robust to high levels of ocean acidification. Mar Biol. 2012;160: 1825–1834.
- 29. Whitehead PJP. FAO Species Catalogue: Vol. 7 Clupeoid Fishes of the World. FAO Fish synopsis. 1985;7: 303.
- 30. Franke A, Clemmesen C. Effect of ocean acidification on early life stages of Atlantic herring (Clupea harengus L.). Biogeosciences. 2011;8: 3697–3707.
Bodenstein S. Effects of ocean acidification and temperature on chloride cells in Atlantic herring (Clupea harengus) embryos and larva. Christian- Albrechts-University of Kiel, Kiel, Germany. 2012.
- 32. Frommel AY, Maneja R, Lowe D, Pascoe CK, Geffen AJ, Folkvord A, et al. Organ damage in Atlantic herring larvae as a result of ocean acidification. Ecol Appl. 2014;24: 1131–1143. pmid:25154101
- 33. Maneja RH, Dineshram R, Vengatesen T, Skiftesvik A, Clemmesen C, Geffen AJ, et al. The proteome of Atlantic herring (Clupea harengus L.) larvae is resistant to elevated pCO2. Mar Pollut Bull. Elsevier Ltd; 2014; 2–8. pmid:25110053
- 34. Maneja R, Frommel A, Browman HI, Geffen AJ, Folkvord A, Piatkowski U, et al. The swimming kinematics and foraging behavior of larval Atlantic herring, Clupea harengus L., are resilient to elevated pCO2. J Exp Mar Bio Ecol. Elsevier B.V.; 2015;466: 42–48.
- 35. Melzner F, Göbel S, Langenbuch M, Gutowska MA, Pörtner H-O, Lucassen M. Swimming performance in Atlantic Cod (Gadus morhua) following long-term (4–12 months) acclimation to elevated seawater PCO2. Aquat Toxicol. 2009;92: 30–37. pmid:19223084
von Dewitz B. A historical reconstruction of the Baltic Sea pH environment experienced by marine organisms. Christian- Albrechts-University of Kiel, Kiel, Germany. 2012.
- 37. Mehner T, Busch S, Clemmesen C, Helland IP, Hölker F, Ohlberger J, et al. Ecological commonalities among pelagic fishes: Comparison of freshwater ciscoes and marine herring and sprat. Mar Biol. 2012;159: 2583–2603.
- 38. Green L, Jutfelt F. Elevated carbon dioxide affects the plasma composition and behaviour of a shark. Biol Lett. 2014;10: 20140538. pmid:25232027
Pierrot D, Lewis E, Wallace DWR. MS Excel program developed for CO2 system calculations. ORNL/CDIAC-105a. Oak Ridge, Tennessee: Carbon Dioxide Information Analysis Center, Oak Ridge National Laboratory, US Department of Energy; 2006. https://doi.org/10.3334/CDIAC/otg.CO2SYS_XLS_CDIAC105a
- 40. Mehrbach C, Culberson CH, Hawley JE, Pytkowicz RM. Measurement of the apparent dissociation constants of carbonic acid in seawater at atmospheric pressure. Limnol Oceanogr. 1973;18: 897–907.
- 41. Dickson AG, Millero FJ. A comparison of the equilibrium constants for the dissociation of carbonic acid in seawater media. Deep Sea Res Part A, Oceanogr Res Pap. 1987;34: 1733–1743.
- 42. Riebesell U, Fabry VJ, Hansson L. Guide to best practices for ocean acidification research and data reporting. Eur Comm. 2010; 181–200.
- 43. Checkley DM. Selective Feeding by Atlantic Herring (Clupea harengus) Larvae on Zooplankton in Natural Assemblages. Mar Ecol Prog Ser. 1982;9: 245–253.
- 44. Cohen RE, Lough RG. Prey Field of Larval Herring Clupea harengus on a Continental Shelf Spawning Area. Mar Ecol—Prog Ser. 1983;10: 211–22.
- 45. Last JM. The food of twenty species of fish larvae in the west-central North Sea. FishResTechRep,MAFF DirectFishRes, Lowestoft. 1980; 44 pp-44 pp.
- 46. Sherman K, Perkins H. Seasonal variations in the food of juvenile herring in coastal waters of Maine. Trans Am Fish Soc. 1971;
Rosenthal H, Hempel G. Experimental studies in feeding and food requirements of herring larvae (Clupea harengus L.). In: Steele JH, editor. Symp Marine food chains. Edinburgh: Oliver and Boyd; 1970. pp. 344–364.
- 48. Werner RG, Blaxter JHS. Growth and Survival of Larval Herring (Clupea harengus) in Relation to Prey Density. Can J Fish Aquat Sci. NRC Research Press Ottawa, Canada; 1980;37: 1063–1069.
- 49. Laurence GC. Nutrition and trophodynamics of larval fish-review, concepts, strategic recommendations and opinions. A Contrib to fish Ecol III. 1982;
- 50. Høie H, Folkvord A, Johannesen A. Maternal, paternal and temperature effects on otolith size of young herring (Clupea harengus L.) larvae. J Exp Mar Bio Ecol. 1999;234: 167–184.
- 51. Naas KE, Næss T, Harboe T. Enhanced first feeding of halibut larvae (Hippoglossus hippoglossus L.) in green water. Aquaculture. 1992;105: 143–156.
- 52. Illing B, Moyano M, Niemax J, Peck MA. Direct effects of microalgae and protists on herring (Clupea harengus) yolk sac larvae. PLoS One. 2015;10: 1–11. pmid:26035592
- 53. Abràmoff MD, Magalhães PJ, Ram SJ. Image processing with imageJ. Biophotonics Int. 2004;11: 36–41.
- 54. Doyle MJ. A morphological staging system for the larval development of the herring, Clupea harengus L. J Mar Biol Assoc United Kingdom. 1977;57: 859–867.
- 55. Malzahn AM, Clemmesen C, Rosenthal H. Temperature effects on growth and nucleic acids in laboratory-reared larval coregonid fish. Mar Ecol Prog Ser. 2003;259: 285–293.
- 56. Caldarone EM, Clemmesen CM, Berdalet E, Miller TJ, Folkvord A, Holt GJ, et al. Intercalibration of four spectrofluorometric protocols for measuring RNA/DNA ratios in larval and juvenile fish. Limnol Oceanogr Methods. 2006;4: 153–163.
- 57. Buckley LJ, Caldarone EM, Clemmesen C. Multi-species larval fish growth model based on temperature and fluorometrically derived RNA/DNA ratios: results from a meta-analysis. Mar Ecol Prog Ser. 2008;371: 221–232.
- 58. Sundin J, Jutfelt F. 9–28 d of exposure to elevated pCO2 reduces avoidance of predator odour but had no effect on behavioural lateralization or swimming activity in a temperate wrasse (Ctenolabrus rupestris). ICES J Mar Sci. 2015;73: 620–632.
- 59. Fuiman LA, Poling KR, Higgs DM. Quantifying Developmental Progress for Comparative Studies of Larval Fishes. Copeia. 1998;3: 602–611.
- 60. Peck MA, Kanstinger P, Holste L, Martin M. Thermal windows supporting survival of the earliest life stages of Baltic herring (Clupea harengus). ICES J Mar Sci. 2012;
- 61. Reid RN, Cargnelli LM, Griesbach SJ, Packer DB, Johnson DL, Zetlin CA, et al. Atlantic Herring, Clupea harengus, Life History and Habitat Characteristics. NOAA Tech Memo. 1999;NMFS-TM-12: 1–48.
- 62. Fey DP. Differences in temperature conditions and somatic growth rate of larval and early juvenile spring-spawned herring from the Vistula Lagoon, Baltic Sea manifested in the otolith to fish size relationship. J Fish Biol. 2001;58: 1257–1273.
- 63. Almatar SM. Effects of acute changes in temperature and salinity on the oxygen uptake of larvae of herring (Clupea harengus) and plaice (Pleuronectes platessa). Mar Biol. 1984;80: 117–124.
- 64. Kiørboe T, Munk P, Richardson K. Respiration and growth of larval herring Clupea harengus: relation between specific dynamic action and growth efficiency. MarEcolProgSer. 1987;40: 1–10.
- 65. Hufnagl M, Peck MA. Physiological individual-based modelling of larval Atlantic herring (Clupea harengus) foraging and growth: Insights on climate-driven life-history scheduling. ICES J Mar Sci. 2011;68: 1170–1188.
- 66. Oeberst R, Dickey-Collas M, Nash RDM. Mean daily growth of herring larvae in relation to temperature over a range of 5–20°C, based on weekly repeated cruises in the Greifswalder Bodden. ICES J Mar Sci. 2009;66: 1696–1701.
- 67. Folkvord A, Johannessen A, Moksness E. Temperature-dependent otolith growth in Norwegian spring-spawning herring (Clupea harengus L.) larvae. Sarsia. 2004;89: 297–310.
- 68. Feet PØ, Ugland KI, Moksness E. Accuracy of age estimates in spring spawning herring (Clupea harengus L.) reared under different prey densities. Fish Res. 2002;56: 59–67.
- 69. Fox CJ, Folkvord A, Geffen AJ. Otolith micro-increment formation in herring Clupea harengus larvae in relation to growth rate. Mar Ecol Prog Ser. 2003;264: 83–94.
- 70. Folkvord A, Rukan K, Johannessen A, Moksness E. Early life history of herring larvae in contrasting feeding environments determined by otolith microstructure analysis. J Fish Biol. 1997;51: 250–263.
- 71. Kiørboe T, Munk P. Feeding and growth of larval herring, Clupea harengus, in relation to density of copepod nauplii. Environ Biol Fishes. 1986;17: 133–139.
- 72. Clemmesen C. The effect of food availability, age or size on the RNA/DNA ratio of individually measured herring larvae: laboratory calibration. Mar Biol. 1994;118: 377–382.
- 73. Johnson DW, Grorud-Colvert K, Sponaugle S, Semmens BX. Phenotypic variation and selective mortality as major drivers of recruitment variability in fishes. Ecol Lett. 2014;17: 743–755. pmid:24674603
- 74. China V, Holzman R. Hydrodynamic starvation in first-feeding larval fishes. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2014;111: 8083–8. pmid:24843180
- 75. Kreiss CM, Michael K, Jutfelt F, Motyka R, Dupont S, Pörtner H-O. Ocean warming and acidification modulate energy budget and gill ion regulatory mechanisms in Atlantic cod (Gadus morhua). J Comp Physiol B. Springer Berlin Heidelberg; 2015;185: 767–781. pmid:26219611
- 76. Maneja RH, Frommel a. Y, Browman HI, Clemmesen C, Geffen a. J, Folkvord a., et al. The swimming kinematics of larval Atlantic cod, Gadus morhua L., are resilient to elevated seawater pCO2. Mar Biol. 2012;
- 77. Jutfelt F, Hedgärde M. Atlantic cod actively avoid CO 2 and predator odour, even after long-term CO2 exposure. Front Zool. 2013;10: 1–8.
- 78. Jutfelt F, Hedgärde M. Juvenile Atlantic cod behavior appears robust to near-future CO2 levels. Front Zool. 2015;12: 11. pmid:27408612
- 79. Näslund J, Lindström E, Lai F, Jutfelt F. Behavioural responses to simulated bird attacks in marine three-spined sticklebacks after exposure to high CO2 levels. Mar Freshw Res. 2015;66: 877–885.
- 80. Munday PL, Pratchett MS, Dixson DL, Donelson JM, Endo GGK, Reynolds AD, et al. Elevated CO2 affects the behavior of an ecologically and economically important coral reef fish. Mar Biol. 2013;160: 2137–2144.
- 81. Baumann H, Talmage SC, Gobler CJ. Reduced early life growth and survival in a fish in direct response to increased carbon dioxide. Nat Clim Chang. Nature Publishing Group; 2011;2: 38–41.
- 82. Clark TD, Sandblom E, Jutfelt F. Aerobic scope measurements of fishes in an era of climate change: respirometry, relevance and recommendations. J Exp Biol. 2013;216: 2771–2782. pmid:23842625
- 83. Suneetha K-B, Folkvord A, Johannessen A. Responsiveness of selected condition measures of herring, Clupea harengus, larvae to starvation in relation to ontogeny and temperature. Environ Biol Fishes. 1999;54: 191–204.
- 84. Meekan MG, Fortier L. Selection for fast growth during the larval life of Atlantic cod Gadus morhua on the Scotian Shelf. Mar Ecol Ser. 1996;137: 25–37.