25 Jun 2018: Schnitzler A, Granado J, Putelat O, Arbogast RM, Drucker D, et al. (2018) Correction: Genetic diversity, genetic structure and diet of ancient and contemporary red deer (Cervus elaphus L.) from north-eastern France. PLOS ONE 13(6): e0199945. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0199945 View correction
In north-eastern France, red deer (Cervus elaphus L.) populations were rebuilt from a few hundred individuals, which have subsisted in remote valleys of the Vosges mountains, and to a lesser extent from individuals escaped from private enclosures; at present times, this species occupies large areas, mainly in the Vosges Mountains. In this study, we examined the population dynamics of red deer in the Vosges Mountains using ancient and contemporary mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) from 140 samples (23 ancient + 117 modern) spanning the last 7’000 years. In addition, we reconstructed the feeding habits and the habitat of red deer since the beginning of agriculture applying isotopic analyses in order to establish a basis for current environmental management strategies. We show that past and present red deer in the Vosges Mountains belong to mtDNA haplogroup A, suggesting that they originated from the Iberian refugium after the last glacial maximum (LGM). Palaeogenetic analysis of ancient bone material revealed the presence of two distinct haplotypes with different temporal distributions. Individuals belonging to the two haplotype groups apparently occupied two different habitats over at least 7’000 years. AM6 correlates with an ecological type that feeds in densely forested mountain landscapes, while AM235 correlates with feeding in lowland landscapes, composed of a mixture of meadows and riverine, herb-rich woodlands. Our results suggest that red deer of north-eastern France was able to adapt, over the long term, to these different habitat types, possibly due to efficient ethological barriers. Modern haplotype patterns support the historical record that red deer has been exposed to strong anthropogenic influences as a major game species.
Citation: Schnitzler A, Granado J, Putelat O, Arbogast R-M, Drucker D, Eberhard A, et al. (2018) Genetic diversity, genetic structure and diet of ancient and contemporary red deer (Cervus elaphus L.) from north-eastern France. PLoS ONE 13(1): e0189278. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0189278
Editor: Tzen-Yuh Chiang, National Cheng Kung University, TAIWAN
Received: July 16, 2017; Accepted: November 23, 2017; Published: January 5, 2018
Copyright: © 2018 Schnitzler et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Data Availability: All relevant data are within the paper and its Supporting Information files; Accession numbers GenBank: MF359564-MF359583 and MF177755-MF177853.
Funding: This work was supported by Fédération départementale des chasseurs du Bas-Rhin(67) Haut –Rhin (68), Moselle (57), Meurthe et Moselle (54), Vosges (88), Haute Saône (70), Territoire de Belfort (90), Fédération nationale des chasseurs. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Red deer (Cervus elaphus L.) is currently one of the most widespread European ungulate species and its evolutionary history is relatively well established [1, 2, 3, 4, 5]. Molecular studies revealed the existence of at least three distinct mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) lineages (so called matrilines) in Europe reflecting the main refugia during the Last Glacial Maximum (LGM) and the early Late glacial (25,000–14,700 years ago) in Iberia (lineage A), the Balkan region (lineage C) and the Mediterranean (lineage B) [3, 5, 6]. Lineage B has originally been attributed to red deer from Sardinia/N-Africa, but has recently been associated, based on ancient DNA material from mainland Italy, to red deer from the Italian refugial lineage . The existence of a fourth potential mtDNA lineage was proposed for the Middle East . Following the LGM, the Iberian lineage A) colonized the British Isles and parts of Central Europe, while the eastern lineage (haplogroup C) from the Balkans colonized south-east central Europe and the Carpathians, reaching as far north as Austria, Hungary and the Czech Republic. In addition, northern areas may have acted as cryptic refugia in North-West Europe through the LGM .The Bavarian-Bohemian region was identified as part of a suture zone between western and eastern European red deer matrilines . However, a detailed sampling for molecular analyses is missing from other regions of Central Europe, including the region from the North of the Swiss Alps to the East of France [3, 4, 5, 9].
As a major game species, red deer has been exposed to a variety of anthropogenic pressures across the whole of Europe. Hunting pressure and habitat alterations have been particularly strong during the last centuries, driving many populations to extinction or confinement in small areas. These anthropogenic influences have greatly influenced the genetic diversity and structure of red deer populations across Europe [11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16].
Red deer slowly recovered after the Second World War, thanks to protective laws, hunting reserves and restocking with foreign specimens . The increase of forest areas and the extinction of natural predators also facilitated a rapid population expansion, at least at a local level. Overall in France after the Second World War, the expansion of red deer has been highly variable, fluctuating in response to e.g., the local hunting laws or forestry demands. Mountainous areas have repeatedly acted as retreats of threatened native red deer populations as it was the case in the Vosges Mountains, where a few hundred (300–500) individuals survived in remote summits . After the 1950s, the population expanded rapidly to an estimated population size of more than 20,000 relatively free ranging individuals in 2015–2016 (data compiled from results of shooting, published by the directions of territories of the Vosges).
Facing the increase of browsing damage, modern forestry calls for a strong reduction of red deer densities, arguing that the species originally lived in grassy landscapes and are not indigenous to the forest . Red deer is, however, known to be an opportunistic mixed feeder, adapted ethologically or ecologically to a large range of habitats [19, 20, 21], and recognized as a central element of forest functioning, for its positive impact on vegetational composition and structure if also exposed to predation risks [22, 23, 24].
In this study we aimed to reconstruct the history of north-eastern France red deer populations, using ancient and contemporary mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) sequences covering the last 7’000 years. More precisely, our goals were (i) to explore the maternal lineage(s) of the red deer population in this region through time; (ii) to identify changes in spatial and temporal structures, and the genetic (haplotype and nucleotide) diversity; and (iii) to analyse the feeding habits, through the inspection of carbon and nitrogen stable isotope ratios in archaeological samples to understand ungulate-vegetation correlations throughout millennia in the Vosges and the adjacent plains. Indeed Plants growing under the dense, closed canopy are known to exhibit lower 13C abundances compared to the same plant groups growing in anthropogenic landscapes, generally composed of mosaics of meadows and species-rich small woodlands. As 13C/12C ratios (expressed as δ13C values) measured on the collagen of large herbivores reflect aspects of their diet, it can be used for evaluating the degree of vegetation canopy closure (the so-called “canopy effect”) in the areas where they used to forage . The carbon isotope signature can also be used to track the presence of dense forest through time [26, 27, 28]. Differences in δ15N values of bone collagen of large herbivores are also interesting because they reflect soil composition and altitudinal gradients where the consumed plants used to grow [29, 30]. In particular, red deer living at higher altitude in the Vosges massif are thus expected to exhibit lower δ15N than those dwelling at lower altitude. For instance, important variations in δ13C and δ15N values were described in red deer bone collagen from the Late glacial and the early Holocene in north-eastern France and neighbouring areas when the climate became warmer and vegetation cover denser e.g. [31, 32].
The north-east of France: Natural context
Geology and soil characteristics
The Vosges Mountains (47°40’ to 48°50’N, 6°40’E to 7°30’E) form a long ridge with a continuous crest line (a maximum elevation of 1424 m above sea level (asl.) at their highest point) (Fig 1). These mountains consist of a central area of magmatic rocks, such as granite and gneiss; sandstone covers the northern part of the mountain ranges. In the adjacent Rhine rift valley east of the Vosges, landscapes correspond to a variety of nested terraces of different ages, altitudes and soil characteristics (loess or alluvial sediments) depending on the local geology and river dynamics [33, 34, 35].
Pie charts on the right side show the relative distributions of ancient haplotypes AM235 and AM6, based on concatenated cyt b and d-loop 256 bp. Pie charts on the left side show the relative distribution of modern haplotypes (AM1 to AM5) based on combined 680 bp cyt b and 785 bp d-loop sequences. The sex of modern male samples is added when they are culled near or in a territory from which they are not originated. Drawing: Delphine Souan, Archéologie Alsace, France (Maps ASTER, Nasa).
Mean annual temperatures range from 9°C at 400 m (asl.) to 4°C at 1200 m asl. Depending on elevation, mean winter temperatures range between -6°C and -1°C, while mean summer temperatures range between 8°C to 14°C. The western windward slopes of the Vosges Mountains are characterised by an oceanic climate with 800–1000 mm precipitation annually, which increases to 2000 mm towards the crest. As a consequence of the crest effect, the climate is semi-continental with a mean annual temperature of 11°C and less than 700 mm precipitation annually in the Rhine rift valley.
In the Vosges, the dominant forest types are beech fir forests (above 500 m asl.), beech/oak shady forests (above 350 m asl.). The lowland loessic terraces and Rhine riverine terraces (150 m asl) are dominated by thermophilous oak/ash/hornbeam forests. These lowland forests are naturally rich in herbaceous species in their understory, due to the properties of their canopies (i.e. light species and heterogeneous architecture, in particular in alluvial environment [36, 37]). Lowland forests were subjected to deforestation from the Neolithic times onwards . As a result, landscapes of the Rhine plain and loessic terraces have been composed of a mixture of meadows and species-rich woodlands since millennia.
The history of red deer
Red deer was regularly recorded at archaeozoological sites of the Rhine plain and adjacent hill foots from the Neolithic to the early Middle Ages [39, 40, 41, 42, 43, 44, 45] (S1 Text and S1 Table). The species was abundant during historical times until the beginning of the 18th century, then declined after the French Revolution through overhunting [46, 47]. At the very end of the 19th century, red deer populations nearly went extinct in France. German texts of the 1880s recorded the survival of a few hundred individuals in the Donon massif in the north of the Vosges . Red deer survived also in a few private forests of adjacent plains such as Arc-en-Barrois, in the south-west of the Vosges, where hunting with hounds was practiced.
Material and methods
This research did not involve purposeful killing of animals. Samples of modern red deer were gathered from dead free-ranging red deer legally shot by hunters during the depopulation management plan launched by the regional prefects. Therefore animals were not killed specifically for the study, and the sampling and the study of the gathered material (muscle and tongue tissues) did not require an additional approval of the ethics committee.
We extracted DNA of muscle or tongue tissues of 117 red deer individuals (for details see S2 Table; Fig 1) from 1. the Vosges mountains, namely the “Donon Massif” (48° 30’N; 7° 09’ 54 E, altitude: 1009 m), “La Petite-Pierre” (48° 51’N, 7° 19’E, altitude: 397 m), “Cornimont /La Bresse” (48° 00’ N, 6° 52’ E, altitude: 1363 m), 2. The Lorraine plateau, namely « Rambervillers” (48° 20’ N, 6° 38’E, altitude: 272 m) and the “Parroy massif” (48° 41’ N, 6° 36’ E, altitude: 303 m) 3. a transitional region of low altitude between the “Donon” and “Parroy” massifs (S3 Table; Fig 1). All animals were hunted between October 2013 and January 2014. Note that there is no physical or ecological barrier between all these sites.
We analysed mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) as well as carbon and nitrogen stable isotopes (expressed as δ13C and δ15N values) of 23 archaeological bones from the following archaeological sites in Alsace region: Marlenheim (48° 37’N; 7°29’E, altitude: 270 m); Entzheim (48° 31’N, 7°37’ E, altitude: 153 m), Erstein (48° 25’N, 7°39’ E, altitude: 157 m), Rosheim (48° 29’N, 7°28’ E, altitude: 164 m), Ostheim (48° 09’N, 7°22’E, altitude: 186 m).
Bones were dated by archaeological typology from the Neolithic (end of 6th and beginning of 5th millennium BC), the final Bronze Age (1026–1010 BC), the Iron Age (Hallstatt D3-La Tène A1, 475 BC), and the early Middle Age (600–750 AD) (S1 Text and S1 Table; Fig 2).
Mitochondrial haplotype genealogy based on the mitochondrial control region and a maximum likelihood phylogenetic analysis. The haplotypes detected in red deer from the Vosges are indicated in red, all other haplotypes were taken from . Haplotypes belonging to haplotype lineage A are indicated in black, those of haplotype lineages B, C are depicted in grey. Note that some of the haplotypes initially identified by Skog et al. 2009 have collapsed into a single haplotype in our analyses, which is due to the use of a shorter sequences alignment in our analysis to match the length of the newly obtained sequences.
Modern sample. Preparation, DNA extraction and PCR analysis.
Modern samples were processed at two different laboratories in Bern and in Basel. These are different to the laboratories in which the historical samples were processed, in order to avoid cross-contamination. Additionally, genetic sexing of five modern samples was performed at the Leibniz Institute for Zoo- and Wildlife Research (IZW), Berlin, Germany. The details of the protocols have been performed independently and are, hence, independently reported in the following sections.At the Institute of Genetics, University of Bern, processing was as follows: DNA was isolated from thin and small pieces (~0.5 cm3) of tongue or muscle tissue of 24 modern red deer samples (DEER 094–117) by using the Nucleon Bacc2 kit following the manufacturer’s instructions. The cytochrome b region (cyt b) was amplified using the primers cerni cytoB A1: GAAAAACCATCGTTGTCATTCA  and cerni cytoB B2a: GGAGGTTRGTAGCTCTCCTTTT (modified ) and the AmpliTaq Gold 360 Master Mix (Applied Biosystems) with the following conditions: 20 μl volume containing 1 μl of each primer (final concentration 0.5 μM), 10 μl ATG Mastermix (AmpliTaq Gold 360 Master Mix), 2 μl of 360 GC enhancer, 4 μl of H2O, and 2 μl of 10-fold diluted template DNA. PCR amplifications were modified according to : starting with a denaturation step at 95°C for 10 min followed by 35 reaction cycles (denaturing at 95°C for 45 s, annealing at 54°C for 45 s, and extension at 72°C for 70 s) and final extension for 10 min at 72°C. Following treatment with shrimp alkaline phosphatase (Roche) and exonuclease I (New England Biolabs) PCR products were Sanger sequenced by Microsynth (Balgach, Switzerland) using PCR primers as sequencing primers (in both directions).
At the Zoological Institute, University of Basel, processing was as follows: a fraction (~0.5 cm3) of anonymous tongue or muscle tissue of 93 samples (DEER 001-DEER 093) was digested using Proteinase K and the total DNA was obtained by means of a high-salt extraction method . DNA concentration was assessed for each sample using a NanoDrop spectrometer (NanoDrop Products, Thermo Scientific). The mtDNA sequence of the cytochrome b region (cyt b) was amplified over a length of 680 bp (forward sequence) using the previously published primers cerni cytoB A1 and cerni cytoB B2  on a Veriti cycler (Applied Biosystem) using REDTaq DNA polymerase (Sigma-Aldrich). PCR amplification was performed following . First, a denaturation step at 94°C for 3 min was performed, followed by 35 reaction cycles (denaturing at 94°C for 45 s, annealing at 54°C for 45 s, and extension at 72°C for 70 s) and concluding with a final extension step of 3 min at 72°C. PCR fragments were purified using ExoSAP-IT (USB, Thermo Fisher Scientific). The PCR fragments were subsequently sequenced with the BigDye sequencing chemistry (Applied Biosystems) and analyzed on a genetic analyzer (ABI 3130 xl, Applied Biosystems). The cyt b sequence of 105 out of the total 117 red deer samples was successfully determined (for details see S2 Table). A partial sequence (785 bp) of the mitochondrial control region (D-loop) was determined for 99 individuals, following the PCR protocol of  and using primers CE-CR-FOR and CE-CR-REV  (for details see S3 Table). In total for 93 individuals sequences from both markers were available.
DNA sequences were inspected by eye in CodoneCode Aligner (version 3.5.6, CodonCode Corporation) and, when available, forward and reverse sequence reads were assembled. Sequence alignment was done with ClustalW as implemented in the software MEGA (version 6.06: ). Identical sequences were collapsed into mitochondrial haplotypes based on an initial round of phylogenetic analyses with MEGA. The so identified control region haplotypes were combined with the available sequence data from , and trimmed to the sequence length used by these authors. We then established a haplotyped genealogy following the method described in  on the basis of a maximum likelihood tree obtained with PAUP*  and the GTR + I model of molecular evolution (based on a model selection test implemented in MEGA). This analysis was only performed for the control region haplotypes, as many more sequences covering a larger geographic area are available on GenBank for this marker compared to cyt b. Modern red deer sequences are available at GenBank under accession numbers: MF177755-MF177853.
At the Leibniz Institute for Zoo- and Wildlife Research (IZW), Berlin, Germany, processing of genetic sexing was as follows: data about sex were only available for 45 red deer samples, and some critical samples lack this information. Indeed knowledge of the sex is important for evaluating the possible persistence of haplotypes in a given population, only possible by the presence of females. We have thus completed this information by selecting five samples, which were genetically sexed using the zfx/zfy loci according to .
Archaeological samples. Preparation, DNA extraction and PCR analysis
The 23 ancient red deer samples were processed at IPAS (Basel, Switzerland), following accepted standards in a DNA research [56, 57] established at IPAS, e.g. . Sample preparations including DNA extractions and pre-PCR steps were performed in dedicated a DNA facility that was physically separated from post-PCR laboratories.
A few millimetres of the outer surface of red deer bones were removed with sand paper and bone powder was obtained by drilling into the sanded area at moderate speed using a Dremel tool. Silica-based DNA extractions followed the User-Developed Protocol: “Purification of total DNA from compact animal bone using the DNeasy® Blood & Tissue Kit” (Qiagen, Basel, Switzerland) for less than 100 mg. Every four to five samples one mock extraction was performed. The yield was about 150–200 μl per sample after purification of extracts with AE buffer (provided from the Kit) on 30 kDa centrifugal filters (Amicon/Millipore, Zug, Switzerland). Extracts were stored at -20°C.
Two mtDNA fragments, one within the cytochrome b (cyt b) gene (168 bp) and one within the mitochondrial d-loop (94 bp) that are located within a longer segment of cyt b (430 bp) and d-loop (328–333 bp) DNA, previously targeted by , were amplified. To obtain the cyt b fragment two primer pairs were used to generate two smaller overlapping PCR fragments: RD cyt b A forward (5’-GTTGTCATTCAACTACAAGAA-3’) and cyt b A2R reverse (5’-TCCTAGTAATGAGCCGAAATT-3’) (98 bp-fragment); cyt b forward (5’-AACAACGCATTTATTGACCTC-3’) and cyt b reverse (5’-TGCTGTTATTGTATCAGATGTAT-3’) (100 bp). Both fragments were concatenated to a single fragment of 168 bp (position 14’157–14’324 of reference sequence GenBank AB245427). The d-loop fragment (94 bp) was amplified by using primer pair CR 2 forward (5’-ATCAAGAACTTTATCAGTATTAAATT-3’) and CR 2aR reverse (5’-ATGTACTATAAGCGCATAAR-3’) (position 15492–15585 of reference sequence GenBank AB245427). All primers used were taken or modified from . Finally, the concatenation of both marker fragments into a single trimmed fragment of 256 bp allowed for distinction of the three major European Cervus elaphus mitochondrial lineages A, B and C, diagnostic positions according to .
PCR amplifications were performed in a Mastercycler pro S (Eppendorf, Allschwil, Switzerland) in 25 μl volumes with 5–8 μl DNA sample, 2 μM each primer, 400 μM dNTP Mix (Promega, Dübendorf, Switzerland), 1.5 U AmpliTaq Gold, 1× GeneAmp PCR Gold buffer (150 mM Tris-HCl, 500 mM KCL, pH 8.0) and 2 mM MgCl2 (all from Applied Biosystems, Hombrechtikon, Switzerland). PCR started with a 12-min initial denaturing step, followed by 70 cycles of denaturing at 94°C for 1 min, annealing at 50°C– 52°C for 1 min, extension at 72°C for 1 min, with a final extension of 5 min at 72°C. Every amplification included non-template controls (at least one per four to five samples). For reliability and authentication of sequences, at least two PCR products from two independent extractions were analysed. Extract and PCR controls were without PCR product of the expected size. Because longer cyt b fragments of red deer (276 bp and 477 bp) could be generated repeatedly from three samples (CER9, CER17 and CER21, data not shown) indicative of modern DNA contamination, these samples were withdrawn from further analysis.
Amplicons were visualized on and gel purified from 3% agarose gel by using MinElute Gel Extraction Kit (Qiagen, Basel, Switzerland). Products were directly Sanger sequenced by Microsynth (Balgach, Switzerland) using the same PCR primers as used in amplification reactions, but to which a non-specific 40-bp nucleotide tail (5’-AACTGACTAAACTAGGTGCCACGTCGTGAAAGTCTGACAA-3’) had been added to the 5’-end .
Sequences were aligned with BioEdit  using the Cervus elaphus reference mitochondrial genome AB245427. Concatenated sequences of 256 bp generated in this work (20 ancient and 93 modern sequences; samples with missing data were excluded, see S3 Table) along with published ancient and modern red deer sequences representing the European range of the species  were used to build a median joining network  with NETWORK 5.001 using default weight for all characters except character 1 which was weighted with 50 . Diversity measures nucleotide diversity (ND), and haplotype diversity (Ht div) were calculated with Arlequin 184.108.40.206  using the concatenated 256 bp fragment. Ancient sequences were compared to modern red deer sequences from the five Vosges populations.
Ancient red deer sequences have accession numbers: GenBank: MF359564-MF359583.
Sample preparation and stable isotope analysis.
For each ancient bone specimen, a small fragment was cut with a rotating tool equipped with a circular diamond-coated blade, ultrasonicated in acetone and water, rinsed with distilled water, dried and crushed to a powder of 0.7 mm grain size . Then, an aliquot of around 5 mg was used to measure the nitrogen content (%N) of the whole bone, in order to screen out samples with excessive collagen loss [65, 66]. For instance, fresh bones contain around 4% nitrogen, while ancient bones with less than 0.4% nitrogen usually fail to yield good collagen, and bones with 0.4 to 1% may or may not yield good collagen depending on the context.
The measurements were performed using a Vario EL III elemental analyser using Sulfanilic acid from Merck as internal standard. The mean standard errors were lower than 0.05% for %N. The collagen was purified according to a well-established protocol by . The elemental and isotopic measurements were performed at the Isotope Geochemistry working group of the Department of Geosciences at the University of Tübingen (Germany), using an elemental analyser NC 2500 connected to a Thermo Quest Delta+XL mass spectrometer. The elemental ratios C/N were calculated as atomic ratios. The isotopic ratios are expressed using the “δ” (delta) value as follows:
The international references are V-PDB for δ13C values, and atmospheric nitrogen (AIR) for δ15N values. Measurements were normalized to δ13C values of USGS24 (13C = -16.00‰) and to δ15N values of IAEA 305A (δ15N = 39.80‰). The reproducibility was ±0.1‰ for δ13C measurements and ±0.2‰ for δ15N measurements, based on multiple analyses of purified collagen from modern bones.
The reliability of the isotopic signatures of the extracted collagen was addressed using their chemical composition (%C, %N, and C/N ratios). These values must be similar to those of collagen extracted from fresh bone to be considered reliable for isotopic measurements and radiocarbon dating. Several studies have shown that collagen with atomic C/N ratios lower than 2.9 or higher than 3.6 is altered or contaminated, and should be discarded, as well as extracts with %N < 5% [67, 68].
Non-parametric Wilcoxon paired test was performed with software JMP 13.0
Genetic composition and spatial distribution of modern red deer haplotypes
Modern red deer mtDNA haplotype analysis.
In total, we obtained mtDNA sequences for most of the 117 modern samples (105 in cyt b and 99 in the control region). All sequences clustered into the western European red deer haplotype A (see haplotype genealogy based on 785 bp of the control region sequences in Fig 2).
The cyt b sequences of the modern Vosges red deer samples grouped into three distinct mtDNA haplotypes, tentatively named AVc1 (n = 18), AVc2 (n = 23) and AVc3 (n = 64); four haplotypes were found in the d-loop, tentatively named AVd1 (n = 19), AVd2 (n = 19), AVd3 (n = 60) and AVd4 (n = 1)(data not shown). As both markers from the same individuals were sequenced, we also performed an analysis with the two mtDNA markers combined, resulting in five combined haplotypes which we tentatively named AM1 (AVc1/AVd1, n = 17; AVc1/unknown, n = 1; unknown/AVd1, n = 1); AM2 (AVc2/AVd2, n = 18; AcV2/unknown, n = 3; unknown/AVd2, n = 1); AM3 (AVc3/AVd3, n = 56; AVc3/unknown, n = 8; unknown/AVd3, n = 4); AM4 (AVc2/AVd1, n = 1); AM5 (AVc2/AVd4, n = 1) (S2 Table). When compared to available records in GenBank, AVc1 and AVd1 are unique, AVc2 and AVd2 are ubiquitous throughout western Europe (matching haplotype A3C (680 bp) and AD1 (332 bp), respectively, see Maximum likelihood tree Fig 3, and ). AVc3 and AVd3 match haplotypes A4C (680 bp) and AA9 (332 bp), respectively  previously reported only from France (i.e. La Petite-Pierre). Based on 331 bp of d-loop AVd4 showed 100% similarity to red deer sequences from Poland (HQ534304, HQ534309, HQ534310, KX496902, KX496903, KX496905, KX496915) [69, 70], and the Czech Republic (KM410131) .
The networks includes ancient red deer (haplotypes of the A clade from the Vosges (AM235 = orange; AM6 = white), modern red deer from the Vosges (red = AM1, yellow = AM2, dark blue = AM3, green = AM4, grey = AM5), published western-central European ancient and modern haplotypes from the A and C clades (modern A clade = grey blue, modern C clade = olive, ancient A clade = light green, ancient C clade = light blue; data from . The size of the circles are proportional to the number of individuals, dashes indicate mutational steps.
Spatial distribution of maternal lineages.
According to our analyses, the mtDNA haplotypes show strong spatial distribution (Fig 1). AM3 is widely distributed in the Vosges (a total of 56 individuals), with the highest number of animals in the “Donon” (22 individuals), followed by “Cornimont/La Bresse” (south) and “La Petite Pierre” (15 and 15 individuals, respectively). One female with haplotype AM3 was found in “Rambervillers”, and 3 males between the “Donon” and “Parroy”.
AM1 and AM2 were affiliated to 17 and 18 individuals, respectively. Red deer with AM1 were found only near “Rambervillers”, while AM2 was more widely distributed in the south of the Vosges. Interestingly, AM2 is absent in the “Donon” massif, except for one male individual (sample 068) hunted between the south of “Parroy” and the “Donon”.
AM4 and AM5 are both rare and located in the south of the studied area. In “Rambervillers”, the only found AM4 haplotype (sample 025) was a female. In “Cornimont/la Bresse”, only the male individual (sample 111) was identified as AM5 haplotype.
Genetic composition of red deer from the Neolithic to early Medieval times.
Cyt b and d-loop mtDNA fragments were reliably amplified and sequenced from 20 ancient samples (out of 23) coming from all periods tested, that are, the Neolithic, Bronze Age, Iron Age, and Early Middle Age periods (S1 Table).
Based on the 168 bp cyt b sequences all ancient red deer belong to the Western European haplogroup A and share the same haplotype. The 94 bp d-loop fragment was chosen to capture diversity and two haplotype groups were identified differing at position 15547 of the reference sequence AB245427. Sequences with the presence of nucleotide base Thymine “T” at that position (15547) are named AM235 to indicate identity to haplotypes AM2, 3 and 5 of modern red deer from the Vosges within the concatenated 256 bp fragment (GenBank MF359564-MF359583). The network shows that AM235 is frequent in ancient and modern Europe (Fig 3). Sequences with the presence of nucleotide base Cytosine “C” at that specific position are named AM6 to indicate a haplotype not found in our modern red deer dataset, and which is also very rare elsewhere today (Fig 3). It corresponds to three modern individuals from Eastern Europe (KF133877-KF133949, KF133875-KF133947, KF133878-KF133950.
Because of the presence of only two haplotypes defined by a mutation at one position, diversity measures are very low: Ht div = 0.39 ± 0.08, ND = 0.0015 ± 0.0016, and far below of Western / Central European archaeological red deer. There is zero diversity in the Bronze Age-Iron Age and diversity measures in Neolithic and Medieval times are similarly low. However, keeping in mind the low sample size, diversity might be higher. Compared to modern red deer of the Vosges, ancient diversity measures are slightly higher than the “Rambervillers” population, all other modern red deer population have zero diversity within 256 bp fragment (Diversity measures Table 1, Figs 1 and 3).
Haplotypes AM235 and AM6 differ in their spatio-temporal distribution. While AM235 is ubiquitously present at all sites and time periods, AM6 was identified at only three sites (i.e Rosheim, Ostheim, Marlenheim, all situated close to the Vosges Mountains) and two time periods, the Neolithic and Early Medieval periods (Fig 1 and S1 Table).
Diet composition of red deer from the Neolithic to early Middle Age times.
Nitrogen content in fossil bones ranged from 0.6 to 3.1% (S1 Table) indicating limited to very good collagen preservation. Based on previous negative experience with bones in a similar preservation stage, most specimens with less than 1% nitrogen content were not selected for collagen extraction. Therefore we selected only one of the three bones (i.e. CER16 and not 14 and 15) from the Marlenheim individuals, namely the one that had the highest nitrogen content. Altogether, collagen extraction was performed for eighteen bones, two of which yielded residues with too low % C and % N indicating diagenetic alteration (CER17 and CER23, both from the Rosheim site). Finally, the collagen isotopic values of sixteen red deer bones were used for palaeobiological investigations. For these samples, the δ13C values ranged from -23.9 to -20.8‰ and the δ15N values ranged from 3.2 to 8.6‰ (S1 Table), which is a large range for an herbivorous species. In sites where at least three specimens were analyzed (Entzheim-Geispolsheim, Ostheim and Rosheim), the δ13C and δ15N values exhibited large ranges, with δ13C values crossing the threshold value of -22‰ taken as an indication of foraging under closed canopy.
Interestingly, the δ13C and δ15N values of red deer that belong to the two different haplotypes exhibited clear differences. The specimens belonging to haplotype AM235 had higher δ13C and δ15N values when compared to those belonging to haplotype AM6, the p-values being 0.061 and 0.0112 (Wilcoxon each pair) for δ13C and δ15N, respectively. The differences were therefore statistically significant for δ15N and with a trend for statistical significance for δ13C. In contrast, neither the δ15N values, nor the δ13C values differed significantly according to the chronological periods: none of the p-values was lower than 0.07 and 0.28 for δ13C and δ15N values respectively, when pairs were tested (Wilcoxon method; DF = 1 for both cases (D13C and d15N).
Analysis of the relationship between genetic differentiation and diet composition.
As shown in Fig 4, the AM6 haplotype seems to correlate with an “ecotype” that feeds preferentially in forested habitats while AM235 possibly correlates with an “ecotype” that select a variety of lowland habitats, from meadows to herb-rich woodlands.
Ellipses are drawn manually to encompass samples with the same haplotype. One ellipse (below) corresponds to individuals living deep in the forest (mostly browser habits); the other (above) individuals living in open habitats or open (plain) or herb-rich woodlands of the adjacent plains.
Mitochondrial DNA cyt b and d-loop diversity patterns were studied in a range of regional red deer populations across Europe [1–16, 20]. Here we combine ancient and modern mtDNA d-loop data with isotopic data to infer temporal female lineage history, to compare historical sources with genetic data and to assess habitat exploitation in the past.
Our genetic analyses revealed that ancient and modern red deer samples belong to mtDNA haplogroup A suggesting that this haplogroup persisted during a period of at least 7000-years and suggest that the Vosges Mountains were re-colonized after the LGM from red deer derived from the Iberian refugium. In addition, our data suggest that no mixing, at least in the matriline, occurred with red deer population from other refugial origins. Since we did not detect lineage C haplotypes in that area (neither in the modern nor in the archaeological samples), the suture zone between these two groups is rather not located in north eastern France. Our choice of markers cannot exclude the possibility of mixing between local red deer stocks on a shorter temporal scale, including hybridization between populations from cryptic refugia.
Interestingly, only two and five mtDNA haplotype groups were present in ancient and modern samples of red deer, respectively, in the Vosges Mountains, both belonging to haplogroup/lineage A. This represents only a small fraction of the broad diversity of haplogroup A maternal lineages observed from archaeological samples before and after the LGM in western Europe [9, 15], or for example from Scotland  and Iberia . However, due to the limited number of ancient samples, ancient diversity may be underestimated.
Possible explanations for this observation are a) the present day population has been re-colonized from a limited number of individuals maternal lineages from the Iberian refugium, also (perhaps) local refugia populations in the Vosges, combined with a loss of haplotypes through time  and b) the source population was large and genetically diverse but bottlenecks have occurred several times in the past, as shown in [40, 74]. According to the present state of knowledge of red deer history, we are not in the position to determine which of these two scenarios is more likely.
Regarding a combined interpretation of the isotopic and genetic analyses, the results further hint towards a tentative correlation between dietary (e.g. habitat type and the associated composition of plants) and genetic differentiation, with a potential for a “canopy effect” leading herbivores in forest mountain habitat (i.e. AM6) to have different isotopic values than those in lowland mixed landscapes (i.e. AM235). AM6 shows also a more restrictive habitat range than AM235, with a more specialized diet regime confined to forests of altitude.
Interestingly, no obvious ecological barrier has been identified that would prevent the free movement between the mountains and adjacent plains. It is thus conceivable that the driving force that may have led to the observed haplotype patterns is ethological. In polygynous species such as red deer mating is nonrandom because females are philopatric, while males tend to disperse. In red deer, females aggregate in matrilineal groups, promoting a social learning in offspring with respect to how and where exploiting familiar plant resources [75, 76, 77, 78]. These matrilineal groups probably also interbred [79, 80]. Similar conclusions suggesting that ecological features can constrain gene flow, in relation with habitat preferences, were published for other mammals in the world (e.g. [81, 82]). The diet differentiation however does not mean that populations with AM235 and AM6 haplotypes did not interact. Mountain populations of red deer usually migrate towards low altitudes during winter, which happens, however, outside the period of reproduction . We suggest here that a nuclear DNA analysis could shed light on this issue.
A novel result is the persistence (several millennia) of geographically isolated populations of red deer in the Vosges Mountains. With regard to the ancient haplotypes, it might be speculated that such habitat partitioning may have lasted until the extinction of AM6, possibly perhaps too specialized and thus less adaptable to the changing environments after 1000 AD (among possible changes, let us quote Little Ice Age or increasing impact of humans on the natural world) or, alternatively, much later, during fauna overhunting after the French revolution. Another hypothesis would be the possibility of fungal, viral or bacterial infections to which specialized populations are particularly susceptible. This would illustrate the importance of genetic factors in clinical manifestations, and their influence on evolution [84, 85, 86].
The modern haplotype structure in the Vosges can largely be explained by historical events: Haplotype AM3 found shelter in the “Donon” and probably expanded as soon as overhunting stopped, which could explain its wide distribution in the north and the south of the Vosges. The relative frequency and relatively wide distribution of AM2 in the South of the Vosges Mountains suggest that there might have been a second refugium, other than the one in “Donon” massif, during the period of overhunting of the 19th century. With regard to  we assume that this native haplotype has persisted in the former private hunting forest of “Arc-en-Barrois”, known since 1900 (François Klein, personal communication). It is possible that from this artificial refugium, red deer has expanded towards “Parroy” (at a distance of 150 km) and to the South of the Vosges (“Cornimont/La Bresse”; “Rambervillers”). This expansion possibly extended towards the South, as far from the “Donon” massif, where red deer had been exterminated . That northward extension of haplotype AM2 was possibly prevented by the presence of local haplotype AM3.
Overall, our results hint towards the situation that behavioral difference associated with habitat choice, have influenced historical and present day population structure in red deer in Central Europe [72, 73]. While haplotypes AM1 and AM4 are still present in modern populations yet restricted to the south of the Vosges near “Rambervillers”. AM1 and AM4 haplotypes correspond to novel haplotypes from eastern geographic areas. AM1 in particular was favoured by successive owners from the hunting “Domaine de la Verrerie”, close to “Rambervillers”. The proportion of this haplotype in the sampling reveals that this population has been well established here. The lower frequency of AM4 can be explained by a selection by hunters. However as the individual AM4 killed here (025) was a female, this haplotype is also established in this adjacent part of the Vosges. Nevertheless the “Rambervillers” red deer population appears rather artificial. The probability of any presence of ancient AM5 haplotype is very low, because it was not observed in modern red deer in the Vosges. Indeed male 111 (haplotype AM5) found in “Cornimont/la Bresse” shows 100% similarity with red deer sequences from Poland (HQ534304, HQ534309, HQ534310) (GENBANK) based on its AVd4 haplotype. Many Polish individuals were kept in numerous small enclosures of the Vosges, from which male 111 has escaped (François Klein, personal communication). As it was a male, this haplotype was not established there.
AM3 is rare in this region compared to the north: only one female (022) was found. As for AM4, this indicates the presence of a small established population.
In conclusion, this study provides phylogeographical and ecological insights on the red deer population through time in North-eastern France. More precisely, we found that 1. despite heavy reduction in population size due to over-hunting in the last centuries red deer managed to survive and persist in the Vosges, with haplogroup A continuing to be present since Neolithic times. 2. Red deer lived on the very long term in a large range of forest habitats, from dense shady mountain forests to more open lowland forest habitats, thus exploiting a large variety of food sources. We thus suggest that these red deer populations should be protected against artificial selection or translocation in order to avoid loss of presumably populations. Future management strategies should avoid the elimination of lowland populations for increasing timber production. Together with reasonable hunting laws, more natural forestry practices and the return of a viable density of predators, these measures would allow the maintenance of red deer at reasonable densities in its whole habitat range.
S1 Text. Characteristics of archaeological sites yielding red deer samples.
S1 Table. Sample information, genetic data and δ13C and δ15N isotope profiles (%) for 23 subfossil bones of red deer analyzed in this study.
Values in italics (CER17, CER 23) correspond to collagen with chemical composition outside the reliability range, therefore the δ13C and δ15N values are not considered for palaeobiological implications.
S2 Table. Location and genetic data for 117 modern samples of red deer analyzed in this study.
We thank Arne Ludwig and Dietmar Lieckfeldt (IZW Berlin), for the active support with sexing and Tosso Leeb (University of Berne) for the use of his lab.
We warmly thank and are grateful to the seven Departmental Federations of Hunters covering the French Vosges massif (French departments: Meurthe-et-Moselle, Moselle, Bas-Rhin, Haut-Rhin, Haute-Saône, Territoire de Belfort, Vosges) and the French National Federation of Hunters for collecting samples and for the funding of this study. We especially thank Corinne Barnet of the Vosges Federation of Hunters for the administrative and financial management of this file.
We also thank Delphne Souan (Archeologie Alsace) for the drawing of Fig 1, François Klein (CNERA “Deer and boars” Director, at the French National Hunting and Wildlife Office) for the constructive, interesting and enthusiastic interviews we had during the development of these discussions. Many thanks to Ben Jenning for the correction of the English language in the manuscript.
- 1. Sommer RS, Nadachowski A. Glacial refugia of mammals in Europe: evidence from fossil records. Mammal Rev. 2006; 36(4):251–65.
- 2. Sommer RS, Zachos FE, Street M, Joris O, Skog A, Benecke N. Late Quaternary distribution dynamics and phylogeography of the red deer (Cervus elaphus) in Europe. Quaternary Sci Rev. 2008; 27(7–8):714–33.
- 3. Skog A, Zachos FE, Rueness EK, Feulner PGD, Mysterud A, Langvatn R, et al. Phylogeography of red deer (Cervus elaphus) in Europe. J Biogeogr. 2009; 36:66–77.
- 4. Niedzialkowska M, Jedrzejewska B, Honnen AC, Otto T, Sidorovich VE, Perzanowski K, et al. Molecular biogeography of red deer Cervus elaphus from eastern Europe: insights from mitochondrial DNA sequences. Acta Theriol. 2011; 56(1):1–12. pmid:21350595
- 5. Zachos FE, Hartl G. Phylogeography, population genetics and conservation of the European red deer Cervus elaphus. Mammal Rev. 2011; 41(2): 138–50.
- 6. Taberlet P, Fumagalli L, Wust-Saucy AG, Cosson JF. Comparative phylogeography and postglacial colonization routes in Europe. Mol Ecol. 1998; 7:453–64. pmid:9628000
- 7. Doan K, Zachos F E, Wilkens B, Vigne JD, Piotrowska N, Stankovic A, Jedrzejewska B, Stefaniak K, Niedzialkowska M. Phylogeography of the Tyrrhenian red deer (Cervus elaphus corsicanus) resolved using ancient DNA of radiocarbon-dated subfossils. Sci Rep. 2017; 7 (1): 2331. pmid:28539631
- 8. Ludt CJ, Schroeder W, Rottmann O, Kuehn R. Mitochondrial DNA phylogeography of red deer (Cervus elaphus). Mol Phylogenet Evol. 2004; 31(3):1064–83. pmid:15120401
- 9. Meiri M, Lister AM, Higham TF, Stewart JR, Straus LG, Obermaier H, et al. Late-glacial recolonization and phylogeography of European red deer (Cervus elaphus L.). Mol Ecol. 2013; 22(18):4711–22. pmid:23927498
- 10. Fickel J, Bubliy OA, Stache A, Noventa T, Jirsa A, Heurich M. Crossing the border? Structure of the red deer (Cervus elaphus) population from the Bavarian-Bohemian forest ecosystem. Mamm Biol. 2012; 77:211–20.
- 11. Leduc D, Klein F. Origines des populations de cerfs présentes en France. Faune sauvage, 2004; 264: 27–28.
- 12. Hartl GB, Zachos F, Nadlinger K. Genetic diversity in European red deer (Cervus elaphus L.): anthropogenic influences on natural populations. CR Biologies. 2003; 326: 37–42.
- 13. Haanes H, Roed KH, Flagstad O, Rosef O. 2010a. Genetic structure in an expanding cervid population after population reduction. Conserv Genet. 11:11–20.
- 14. Dellicour S, Frantz AC, Colyn M, Bertouille S, Chaumont F, Flamand MC. Population structure and genetic diversity of red deer (Cervus elaphus) in forest fragments in north-western France. Conserv Genet. 2011; 12:1287–97.
- 15. Rosvold J, Roed KH, Jufthammer AK, Andersen R, Stenoien H. Reconstructing the history of a fragmented and heavily exploited red deer population using ancient and contemporary DNA. BMC Evol Biol. 2012; 12:1–12.
- 16. Queiros J, Vicente J, Boadella M, Gortázar C, Alves PC. The impact of management practices and past demographic history on the genetic diversity of red deer (Cervus elaphus): an assessment of population and individual fitness. Biol J Linnean Soc. 2013; 11, 1: 209–223.
- 17. Jung P. Historique de l’implantation du cerf dans le massif vosgien. Internal report, Fédération de chasse du Bas-Rhin, France; 1984.
- 18. Roucher F. Cervidés et forêt. Rétablir une harmonie. AgroParistech, Nancy; 2013.
- 19. Gebert C, Verheyden-Tixier H. Variations of diet composition of red deer (Cervus elaphus L.) in Europe. Mammal Rev. 2001; 31(3–4): 189–201.
- 20. Luccarini S, Mauri L, Ciuti S, Lamberti P, Apollonio M. Red deer (Cervus elaphus) spatial use in the Italian Alps: home range patterns, seasonal migrations, and effects of snow and winter feeding. Ethol Ecol Evol. 2006; 18(2): 127–45.
- 21. Auguste P. Les Cervidae (Mammalia, Cetartiodactyla) du gisement pléistocène moyen final de l’aven de Romain-la-Roche (Doubs, France). Revue de Paléobiologie de Genève, 2010; 29(2): 619–53.
- 22. Gehrardt P, Arnold JM, Hackländer K, Hochbichler E. Determinants of deer impact in European forests. A systematic literature analysis. Forest Ecol Manag. 2013; 310:173–186.
- 23. Heuzé P, Schnitzler A, Klein F. Consequences of increased deer browsing winter on silver fir and spruce regeneration in the Southern Vosges mountains: Implications for forest management. Ann For Sci. 2005b; 62:175–81.
- 24. Ripple WJ, Larsen EJ, Renkin RA, Smith DW. Trophic cascades among wolves, elk and aspen on Yellowstone National Park’s northern range. Biol. Conserv. 2001; 102: 227–234.
- 25. Vogel JC. Isotopic assessment of the dietary habits of ungulates. S Afr J Sci. 1978; 74: 298–301.
- 26. Drucker DG, Bridault A, Hobson KA, Szuma E, Bocherens H. Can Carbon-13 in large herbivore reflect the canopy effect in temperate and boreal ecosystems? Evidence from modern and ancient ungulates. Palaeoecol Palaeogeog Palaeocl. 2008; 266: 69–82.
- 27. Drucker DG, Bocherens H. Carbon stable isotopes of mammal bones as tracers of canopy development and habitat use in temperate and boreal contexts. In: Creighton JD, Roney PJ, editors. Forest canopies: forest production, Ecosystem health, and climate conditions. Nova Science Publishers 2009. p 103–109.
- 28. Doppler T, Gerling C, Heyd V, Knipper C, Kuhn T, Lehmann MF, Pike AWG, Schibler J. Landscape opening and herding strategies: Carbon isotope analyses of herbivore bone collagen from the Neolithic and Bronze Age lakeshore site of Zurich-Mozartstrasse, Switzerland. Quatern Int. 2017; 436:18–28.
- 29. Sah SP, Brumme R. Altitudinal gradients of natural abundance of stable isotopes of nirogen and carbon in the needles and soil of a pine forest in Nepal. J For Sci. 2003; 49(1): 19–26.
- 30. Zech M, Bimüller C, Hemp A, Samimi C, Broesike C, Hörold C, Zech W. Human and climate impact on 15N natural abundance of plants and soils in high-mountain ecosystems: a short review and two examples from the Eastern Pamirs and Mt. Kilimanjaro. Isot Environ Healt S 2011; 47(3): 286–96.
- 31. Drucker DG, Bocherens H, Bridault A, Billiou D. Carbon and nitrogen isotopic composition of red deer (Cervus elaphus) collagen as a tool for tracking palaeoenvironmental change during the Late-Glacial and Early Holocene in the northern Jura (France). Palaeogeogr Palaeocl. Palaeoecol. 2003; 195:375–88.
- 32. Drucker DG, Bridault A, Cupillard C, Hujic A, Bocherens H. Evolution of habitat and environment of red deer (Cervus elaphus) during the late Glacial and early Holocene in eastern France (French Jura and the western Alps) using multi-isotope analysis (13C, 15N, 18O, 34S) of archaeological remains. Quatern Int. 2011; 245:288–78.
- 33. Carbiener R. Les sols du Massif du Hohneck, leurs rapports avec le tapis végétal. Le Hohneck. Aspects physiques, biologiques et humains. Association Philomathique d’Alsace et de Lorraine, Strasbourg, 1963:103–54.
- 34. Sell Y, Berchtold JP, Callot H, Hoff M, Gall JC, Walter JM. L’Alsace et les Vosges. Géologie, milieux naturels, flore et faune. Delachaux et Nestlé, Lausanne, 1998.
- 35. Bonneau M, Faivre P, Gury M, Hétier JM, Le Tacon F. Carte pédologique de la France à 1/100000. Notice explicative, Saint-Die. INRA, Service d’Etude des Sols et de la Carte Pédologique de la France. 11.1978.
- 36. Schnitzler A, Closset D, Gafta D, Cristea V, Schwoehrer C. Dynamique des populations et mosaique forestière en hêtraie-sapinière préservée. Une comparaison entre Vosges et Carpates. Rev Ecol-Terre Vie, 2004; 59: 213–29.
- 37. Bœuf R. Les végétations forestières d’Alsace. Office National des Forêts (editor), Imprimerie Scheuer, Drulingen; 2014.
- 38. Nocus N. Forêts et Sociétés aux étages planitiaires et collinéens de l’Alsace du Néolithique au haut Moyen Âge: approche dendro-anthracologique. Thesis, National Muséum of Natural History of Paris; 2014.
- 39. Arbogast RM. L’habitat rubané de Rosheim « Sainte Odile ». Etude de la faune. Cahiers de l’association Pour la Promotion de la recherche archéologique en Alsace. 2001; 16:51–76.
- 40. Arbogast RM. La chasse au cerf au Néolithique. Un gibier par excellence. In: Chasses, Archeopages 28, INRAP Paris; 2010.
- 41. Putelat O. La faune. In: Landolt M. editor, Entzheim-Geispolsheim (Alsace, Bas-Rhin). Aéroparc (LIDL-CUS). Rapport de fouille préventive. Vol. 3. Les occupations protohistoriques. Sélestat, Pôle d’Archéologie Interdépartemental Rhénan: 2007, p 304–325.
- 42. Putelat O. Archéozoologie. In: Croutsch C. editor, Erstein Grasweg-PAE. Les occupations de la fin du IIIe millénaire et de l’âge du Bronze. Rapport final d’opération. Sélestat, PAIR, 2008, p: 61–68, 126–32, 219–26; 367–80.
- 43. Putelat O. Geispolsheim (Bas-Rhin) « Schwobenfeld ». Archéozoologie. In: Landolt M. editor, Entzheim—Geispolsheim, Bas-Rhin. Lotissement d’activités du quadrant 4. Entzheim « In der Klamm » et Geispolsheim « Schwobenfeld ». Des habitats et une nécropole néolithiques, des habitats protohistoriques, un habitat antique, un habitat et une aire funéraire mérovingiens, une position fortifiée allemande de la Première Guerre Mondiale. Rapport de fouille préventive. Sélestat, Pôle d’Archéologie Interdépartemental Rhénan, Vol 1: 71–77; Vol 3, 110, 323–328, Vol. 4, 32, 64, 72, 82: 170; 2013.
- 44. Putelat O. Les relations homme-animal dans le monde des vivants et des morts. Étude archéozoologique des établissements et des regroupements funéraires ruraux de l’Arc jurassien et de la Plaine d’Alsace, de la fin de l’Antiquité tardive au premier Moyen Âge. Thesis, University of Paris 1, Panthéon-Sorbonne; 2015.
- 45. Putelat O, Guthmann E. Première note sur les ossements animaux. In: Logel T. editor—Ostheim, Haut-Rhin, Birgelsgaerten, RD 416-rue de Strasbourg. Rapport de fouille préventive. Vol. 2. Le Haut Moyen Âge et la période moderne. Sélestat, Pôle d’Archéologie Interdépartemental Rhénan: 161–90; 2013.
- 46. Jehin P. Les forêts des Vosges du Nord du Moyen Age à la Révolution. Milieux, usages, exploitations. Presses Universitaires de Strasbourg; 2005.
- 47. Titeux G, Jehin P. Le livre d’or de la chasse en Alsace. Deux mille ans d’art et d’histoire. Strasbourg, La Nuée Bleue/DNA; 2008.
- 48. Hartl GB, Lang G, Klein F, Willing R. Relationships between allozymes, heterozygosity, and morphological characters in red deer (Cervus elaphus) and the influence of selective hunting on allele frequency distribution. Heredity 1991; 66: 343–360 pmid:1880046
- 49. Hartl GB, Klein F, Willing R, Appollonio M, Lang G. Allozymes and the genetics of antler development in red deer (Cervus elaphus). J. Zool. 1995; 237, 1: 83–100
- 50. Bruford MW, Hanotte O, Brookfield JFY, Burke T. Multilocus and single-locus DNA fingerprinting; molecular genetic analysis of populations, a practical approach. In Hoelzel AR (editor), Oxford University Press, Oxford: 1998, p 287–336.
- 51. McDevitt AD, Edwards CJ, O’Toole P, O’Sullivan P, O’Reilly C, Carden RF. Genetic structure of, and hybridisation between, red (Cervus elaphus) and sika (Cervus nippon) deer in Ireland. Mamm Biol—Z Saugetierkd. 2009; 74(4): 263–73.
- 52. Tamura K, Stecher G, Peterson D, Filipski A, Kuma S. MEGA6: Molecular Evolutionary Genetics Analysis Version 6.0. Mol Biol Evol. 2013; 30(12): 2725–29. pmid:24132122
- 53. Salzburger W., Ewing GB, Haeseler von A. The performance of phylogenetic algorithms in estimating haplotype genealogies with migration. Mol Ecol. 2011; 20: 1952–63. pmid:21457168
- 54. Swofford DL PAUP*. Phylogenetic Analysis Using Parsimony (*and Other Methods). 2002. Version 4. Sinauer Associates, Sunderland, Massachusetts.
- 55. Kim BJ, Lee H, Lee S-d. Species- and sex-specific multiple pcr amplifications of partial cytochrome b gene and Zfx/Zfy introns from invasive and non-invasive samples of Korean ungulates. Genes Genom. 2009; 31(5): 369–75.
- 56. Gilbert MT, Bandelt HJ, Hofreiter M, Barnes I. Assessing ancient DNA studies. Trends Ecol Evol. 2005; 20(10): 541–44. pmid:16701432
- 57. Shapiro B, Hofreiter M (editors). Ancient DNA—Methods and Protocols. New York, Springer, 2012.
- 58. Schibler J, Elsner J, Schlumbaum A. Incorporation of aurochs into a cattle herd in Neolithic Europe: single event or breeding? Sci Rep-UK. 2014; 4: 5798.
- 59. Binladen J, Gilbert MT, Campos PF, Willerslev E. 5’-tailed sequencing primers improve sequencing quality of PCR products. Biotechniques. 2007; 42(2): 174, 6. pmid:17373481
- 60. http://www.mbio.ncsu.edu/bioedit/bioedit.html
- 61. Bandelt H-J, Macaulay V, Richards M. Median networks: Speedy construction and greedy reduction, one simulation, and two case studies from human mtDNA. Mol Phylogenet Evol. 2000; 16(1): 8–28. pmid:10877936
- 62. http://www.fluxus-engineering.com/sharenet.htm
- 63. Excoffier L, Lischer HEL. Arlequin suite ver 3.5: a new series of programs to perform population genetics analyses under Linux and Windows. Mol Ecol Resour. 2010; 10: 564–67. pmid:21565059
- 64. Bocherens H, Billiou D, Patou-Mathis M, Bonjean D, Otte M, Mariotti A. Paleobiological implications of the isotopic signatures (13C, 15N) of fossil mammal collagen in Scladina Cave (Sclayn, Belgium). Quaternary Res. 1997; 48:370–80.
- 65. Bocherens H, Drucker DG, Billiou D, Moussa I. Une nouvelle approche pour évaluer l’état de conservation de l’os et du collagène pour les mesures isotopiques (datation au radiocarbone, isotopes stables du carbone et de l’azote). L’Anthropologie, 2005; 109:557–67.
- 66. Bocherens H, Drucker DG, Billiou D, Geneste JM, Kervazo B. Grotte Chauvet (Ardèche, France): a "natural experiment" for bone diagenesis in karstic context. Paleogeogr Palaeocl. 2008; 266:220–26.
- 67. DeNiro MJ. Postmortem preservation and alteration of in-vivo bone collagen isotope ratios in relation to palaeodietary reconstruction. Nature 1985; 317:806–09.
- 68. Ambrose SH. Preparation and characterization of bone and tooth collagen for isotopic analysis. J Archaeol Sci. 1990; 17:431–51.
- 69. Biedrzycka A, Solarz W, Okarma H. Hybridization between native and introduced species of deer in Eastern Europe. J Mammal 2012; 93(5):1331–41.
- 70. Borowski Z, Swislocka M, Matosiuk M, Mirski P, Krysiuk K, Czajkowska M, Borkowska A, Ratkiewicz M. Purifying Selection, Density Blocking and Unnoticed Mitochondrial DNA Diversity in the Red Deer, Cervus elaphus. PLoS One 2016; 11(9):e0163191 pmid:27649313
- 71. Krojerova-Prokesova J, Barancekova M, Koubek P. An admixture of eastern and western European red deer lineages as a result of postglacial recolonisation of the Czech Republic (Central Europe) J Hered. 2015;106(4):375–85. pmid:25918430
- 72. Pérez-Espona S, Pérez-Barberia FJ, Goodall-Copestake WP, Jiggins CD, Gordon IJ. Genetic diversity and population structure of Scottish Highland red deer (Cervus elaphus) populations: a mitochondrial survey. Heredity 2009; 102(2):199–210. pmid:19002206
- 73. Carranza J, Salinas M, De Andres D, Perez-Gonzalez J. Iberian red deer: paraphyletic nature at mtDNA but nuclear markers support its genetic identity. Ecol Evol. 2016; 6 (4):905–22. pmid:26843924
- 74. Arbogast RM, Petrequin P. La chasse du cerf au néolithique dans le Jura: gestion d’une population sauvage. In: Exploitation des animaux sauvages à travers le temps. Desse J. Audouin-Rouzeau F. (editors), Actes des XIIIe rencontres internationales d’Archéologie et d’Histoire d’Antibes. International symposium (L’homme et l’Animal), Juan-les-pins. 1992, Antibes, APDCA; 1993, p 221–32.
- 75. Chesser RK Gene diversity and female philopatry. Genetics 1991; 127:2437–47.
- 76. Chesser RK, Smith MH, Johns PE, Manlove MN, Straney DO, Baccus R. Spatial, temporal, and age-dependent heterozygosity of beta-hemoglobine in white-tailed deer. J Wildlife Manage. 1982; 46:983–90.
- 77. Frantz AC, Hamann JL, Klein F. Fine-scale genetic structure of red deer (Cervus elaphus) in a French temperate forest. Eur J Wildlife Res. 2008; 54: 44–52.
- 78. Thurfjell H, Ciuti S, Boyce MS. Learning from the mistakes of others: How female elk (Cervus elaphus) adjust behaviour with age to avoid hunters. PLoS One. 2017;12(6):e0178082. Epub 2017/06/15. pmid:28614406
- 79. Clutton-Brock TH. Review lecture: mammalian mating systems. Proc R Soc Lond B. 1989; 236:339–72. pmid:2567517
- 80. Schreiber A, Klein F, Lang G. Transferrin polymorphism of red deer in France: evidence for spatial genetic microstructure of an autochthonous herd. Genet Sel Evol. 1994; 26:187–203.
- 81. Storz JF. Genetic Consequences of Mammalian Social Structure. J Mammal. 1999; 80(2): 553–69.
- 82. Pilot M, Jedrzejewski W, Sidorovich VE, Maier-Augenstein W, Hoelzel AR. Dietary differentiation and the evolution of population genetic structure in a highly mobile carnivore. PloS One 2012; 7(6):1–11.
- 83. Hamann JL, Klein F, Saint-Andrieux C. Domaine vital diurne et déplacements de biches (Cervus elaphus) sur le secteur de la Petite Pierre (Bas-Rhin). Gibier Faune Sauvage 1997,1–15.
- 84. Lang G. Gestion des populations de cervidés. Réflexions sur des problèmes de polymorphisme génétique. Thesis, University Louis Pasteur, Strasbourg,1987.
- 85. Fernandez-de-Mera IG, Vicente J, Perez de la Lastra JM, Mangold AJ, Narango V, Fierro Y, de la Fuente J, Gortazar C. Reduced major histocompatibility complex class II polymorphism in a hunter-managed isolated Iberian red deer population. J Zool. 2009; 277: 157–70.
- 86. Templeton AR, Hemmer H, Mace G, Seal U, Shields WM, Woddrufe DS. Local adaptation, coadaptation, and population boundaries. Zoo Biol. 1986; 5:115–25.