Edward Jenner and his contemporaries believed that his variolae vaccinae originated in horses and molecular analyses show that modern vaccinia virus (VACV) strains share common ancestry with horsepox virus (HPXV). Given concerns relating to the toxicity of modern VACV vaccines, we asked whether an HPXV-based vaccine might provide a superior alternative. Since HPXV may be extinct and the only specimen of HPXV that has been identified is unavailable for investigation, we explored whether HPXV could be obtained by large-scale gene synthesis. Ten large (10–30 kb) fragments of DNA were synthesized based on the HPXV sequence along with two 157 nt VACV terminal sequences, and were recombined into a live synthetic chimeric HPXV (scHPXV) in cells infected with Shope fibroma virus (SFV). Sequencing of the 212 kbp scHPXV confirmed it encoded a faithful copy of the input DNA. We believe this is the first complete synthesis of a poxvirus using synthetic biology approaches. This scHPXV produced smaller plaques, produced less extracellular virus and exhibited less virulence in mice than VACV, but still provided vaccine protection against a lethal VACV challenge. Collectively, these findings support further development of scHPXV as a novel replication-proficient smallpox vaccine.
Citation: Noyce RS, Lederman S, Evans DH (2018) Construction of an infectious horsepox virus vaccine from chemically synthesized DNA fragments. PLoS ONE 13(1): e0188453. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0188453
Editor: Volker Thiel, Universitat Bern, SWITZERLAND
Received: September 18, 2017; Accepted: November 7, 2017; Published: January 19, 2018
Copyright: © 2018 Noyce et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Data Availability: All relevant data are within the paper and its Supporting Information files. The sequence of the reactivated virus can be retrieved from GenBank using accession number KY349117. All of the raw sequencing data files are available via the SRA database using accession number SRP128888 (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/sra/SRP128888).
Funding: This work was performed under a research agreement with Tonix Pharmaceuticals. The funder played a role in the formulation of the project, the decision to publish, and preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: We have read the journal’s policy and the authors of this manuscript have the following competing interests: DHE and RDN provide consultation services to Tonix Pharmaceuticals Ltd. SL is the co-founder, CEO and chairman of Tonix Pharmaceuticals Ltd. A US patent application (Synthetic chimeric poxviruses; Application No.: 62/434,794; first provisional filed November 2, 2016) has been filed on behalf of the Governors of the University of Alberta and Tonix Pharmaceuticals claiming the three authors as co-inventors. This does not alter our adherence to PLOS ONE policies on sharing data and materials. The DNAs and reconstructed HPXV strains can be provided upon request. Please direct all such enquiries to Dr. S. Lederman, c/o Tonix Pharmaceuticals.
There had long been speculation regarding the origins of Jenner’s variolae vaccine [1, 2], until sequencing data showed close similarities between VACV and a Mongolian HPXV specimen [3–5]. Jenner noted that farriers sometimes milked cows and that material from the equine disease could produce a vesicular disease in cows from which variolae vaccinae was derived. Loy  and Bell  subsequently showed that horsepox could vaccinate humans against smallpox and these meticulous studies raise the question of whether HPXV might still serve as a live smallpox vaccine. Most of today’s VACV stocks comprise swarms of viruses that are products of ~200 years of cultivation in animals along with selection for growth in humans, and have probably evolved far from Jenner’s virus. These replication-proficient and human-adapted VACV strains can cause myopericarditis in otherwise healthy individuals  and are harmful in immunocompromised populations . Therefore, a safer live vaccine would permit its more widespread use. However, only one specimen of HPXV has ever been identified and sequenced , very little is known about its biological properties, and the disease may have been accidentally extirpated . This challenge led us to explore whether a replicating HPXV could be recovered by genome synthesis and might also exhibit vaccine properties.
Gene synthesis has revolutionized the study of microbes including viruses such as ΦX174, polio, and influenza [11–13]. However, poxviruses represent special challenges because of the size (many exceed 200 kbp) and the difficulty of cloning features such as the mismatched hairpin telomeres [14, 15]. Poxviruses also cannot simply be recovered from transfected cells, as the DNA is not infectious. What has been long known is that a cell infected with one poxvirus can reactivate a second, if that second virus has been rendered inert by damaging the particles  or extracting the DNA [17–19]. One can also perform the reactivation in cells that support the growth of different helper and reactivated viruses and then use differences in host range to separate the two. We have previously shown that SFV-infected cells offer such an advantage while providing an environment capable of assembling VACV from virus-derived restriction fragments .
Here we found that a replicating synthetic-chimeric HPXV with VACV hairpins can be rescued from SFV-infected cells using chemically synthesized DNA fragments. This scHPXV produced smaller plaques and less secondary plaque formation in vitro. In mice, scHPXV was less virulent compared to a known vaccine strain of VACV, but still provided vaccine protection against a lethal VACV challenge. Collectively, these findings support further development of scHPXV as a novel replication-proficient smallpox vaccine.
Materials and methods
Viruses and cell culture
SFV strain Kasza, VACV strain Western Reserve (WR), BSC-40, HeLa, Vero, and human embryonic lung (HEL) fibroblasts were originally obtained from the American Type Culture Collection. VACV strain DPP15 is from laboratory stocks  and cowpox virus (strain Brighton Red) was a gift from M. Barry and came originally from D. Pickup. Buffalo green monkey kidney (BGMK) cells were obtained from Diagnostic Hybrids (Athens, OH, USA). BSC-40 and BGMK cells were propagated at 37°C in 5% CO2 in minimal essential medium (MEM) supplemented with L-glutamine, nonessential amino acids, sodium pyruvate, antibiotics and antimycotics, and 5% fetal calf serum (FCS; ThermoFisher Scientific). HeLa and HEL cells were propagated at 37°C in 5% CO2 in Dulbecco’s modified Eagle’s medium (DMEM) supplemented with L-glutamine, antibiotics and antimycotics, and 10% FCS. Vero cells were propagated at 37°C in 5% CO2 in DMEM supplemented with L-glutamine, antibiotics and antimycotics and 5% FCS. All of the cells tested negative for mycoplasma by polymerase chain reaction.
Synthetic chimeric (sc) HPXV genome design
The design of the scHPXV genome was based on the published sequence for HPXV strain MNR-76 [GenBank accession DQ792504] . We divided the 212,633 bp genome into ten fragments (Fig 1a) sharing at least 1.0 kbp of overlapping sequence with each adjacent fragment (Table 1). This provides sufficient homology to support recombination between the co-transfected fragments . The terminal 40 bp from the HPXV sequence (5’-TTTATTAAATTTTACTATTTATTTAGTGTCTAGAAAAAAA-3’) was not included in the synthetic ITR fragments. Standard cloning and ligation reactions were used to ligate the VACV terminal hairpins onto the ITRs (described below).
(a) Cloned synthetic DNA fragments used to assemble HPXV. Nine different clones were synthesized spanning all but the first and last 40 bp in GenBank entry DQ792504, each overlapping the adjacent fragment by ~1 kbp. All of the AarI and BsaI restriction sites were eliminated from fragments 1A to 7, inclusive, using silent mutations and the same strategy was used to add AvaI and StuI sites in Frag_2. To facilitate virus recovery a gene encoding a YFP-gpt fusion protein was inserted into Frag_3, at the site of the HPXV thymidine kinase locus. An additional HPXV095 fragment spans the thymidine kinase locus and was subsequently used to delete and replace the YFP-gpt marker using homologous recombination. (b) Synthetic hairpin telomeres. Because the HPXV genome was not sequenced to the ends, we substituted two hairpin sequences based upon those reported for VACV strain WR (green coloured nucleotides). These are called “fast” and “slow” forms based upon their electrophoretic properties. The nucleotides coloured in black come from the HPXV genome sequence and provide an element essential for telomere resolution.
Each fragment was chemically synthesized and sub-cloned into a plasmid flanked by SfiI restriction sites. To aid assembly and provide a mechanism to distinguish scHPXV from other orthopoxviruses, the AarI and BsaI restriction sites were silently mutated in all of the fragments (S1 Table), except for the two ITR-encoding fragments (Fig 1). We chose not to mutate the BsaI restriction sites in the ITRs (and there are no native AarI sites), in case these regions contain sequence-specific recognition sites that serve other unknown purposes beyond protein coding.
A cassette encoding a protein consisting of yellow fluorescent protein fused to guanine phosphoribosyltransferase protein (YFP-gpt) and under the control of a poxvirus early-late promoter  was introduced into the HPXV095 (thymidine kinase) locus within GA_Fragment_3, so that any reactivated viruses could be detected using fluorescence. We also used silent single nucleotide substitutions to create two new restriction sites in the HPXV044 gene sequence, at positions 44,512 (AvaI) and 45,061 (StuI), for future use as potential cloning sites.
Preparation of HPXV DNA fragments
All of the HPXV DNAs were synthesized by GeneArt and supplied as plasmid clones in E. coli. The HPXV fragments were digested free of the cloning vectors and purified using a QiaexII kit in preparation for transfection. The Slow (S) and Fast (F) forms of the VACV terminal hairpin loops were purchased from Integrated DNA Technologies as 157 nucleotide DNA fragments. These hairpin ends were added to the left and right ITR fragments, in a random orientation using DNA ligase and in a manner that retained all of the original published HPXV sequence. Agarose gel electrophoresis was used to demonstrate that the VACV terminal hairpins were successfully added to the cloned ITR fragments (S1 Fig).
Reactivation of VACV/HPXV hybrid viruses in SFV-infected cells
The infection and transfection reactions were performed as described previously using SFV-infected BGMK cells . The Lipofectamine 2000 complexes (ThermoFisher Scientific) contained ~0.5 μg of each of the digested HPXV DNA fragments along with 0.5 μg of purified VACV WR genomic DNA. One day after transfecting the cells, the media was replaced with fresh MEM containing 5% FCS and the cells returned to the incubator for four more days. The viruses were harvested by freeze thaw, diluted and re-plated on BSC-40 cells under 0.9% agar, and any fluorescent plaques plaque purified at least three times. To rapidly confirm the presence of HPXV DNA in the reactivated viruses, PCR primers were designed flanking all of the BsaI sites disrupted in the HPXV clones (S2 Table), but which are retained at the homologous sites in VACV. Virus DNA was extracted from three different hybrid (i.e. fluorescent) viruses, as well from VACV, subjected to PCR amplification, and digested with BsaI. The reaction products were analyzed by agarose gel electrophoresis using SYBR® safe stain to visualize DNA.
Reactivation of scHPXV in SFV-infected cells
The infection and transfection reactions were performed as described above except using 5 μg total HPXV DNA fragments, in equimolar ratios, and omitting the VACV DNA. After an additional four days of culture in replenished MEM, the infected cells were scraped into the culture medium and the virus released using three cycles of freeze-thaw. The cell extract was diluted in serum-free MEM and aliquots plated on BSC-40 cells. One hour post infection, the inoculum was replaced with MEM containing 5% FCS and 0.9% noble agar and cultured for five days. Fluorescent plaques were visualized under an inverted microscope and individual plaques were picked for further analysis. These scHPXV YFP-gpt::095 viruses were subsequently plaque purified three times using yellow fluorescence as the selection criterion. Three different clones were retained from three separate transfections and annotated as “plaque picks” 1-to-3 (i.e. PP1.1, PP2.1, and PP3.1)
Restriction digestion and pulse-field gel electrophoresis (PFGE) analysis of scHPXV
The viruses were purified using sucrose gradients and genomic DNA prepared as described . For pulse-field gel electrophoresis (PFGE), 100ng of viral genomic DNA was digested with BsaI or HindIII for 2h at 37°C and separated using 1% Seakem Gold agarose gels, cast and run in half-strength Tris-borate-EDTA electrophoresis buffer. The DNA was resolved on a CHEF DR-III apparatus (BioRad) at 5.7V/cm for 9.5h at 14°C, using a switching time gradient of 1 to 10s, a linear ramping factor, and a 120° angle. This separates DNAs from 1kbp to >200kbp. The DNA was visualized with SYBR® gold stain.
Virus DNA isolation, genome sequencing, and analysis
Virus DNA was extracted from each of eight sucrose-gradient purified virus preparations using proteinase K followed by phenol-chloroform. The amount of DNA was determined using a Qubit dsDNA HS assay kit (ThermoFisher Scientific) and then each genome was sequenced at the University of Alberta. Sequencing libraries were generated using a Nextera Tagmentation kit (Epicentre Biotechnologies) and paired end sequencing (2x300bp) performed using an Illumina MiSeq platform with an average read depth of 3,100 reads·nt-1 across the genome and ~190 reads·nt-1 in the F- and S-hairpins. The raw sequence reads were trimmed and initially mapped to the HPXV reference sequence using CLC Genomics Workbench 8.5 software. All nucleotide insertions, deletions, and substitutions within the scHPXV YFP-gpt::095 sequence were verified against the HPXV reference sequence. Genome Annotation Transfer Utility software (GATU)  was used to transfer the reference annotation to our assembled genome sequences.
Production of a wild-type recombinant scHPXV
The YFP-gpt selection marker was removed using homologous recombination. To do this, we synthesized a 1349 bp DNA fragment encoding HPXV nucleotides 91573–92921 (ThermoFisher Scientific) and encompassing the HPXV095 gene plus ~400 bp of homology flanking either side of the thymidine kinase locus (Fig 1). This DNA was cloned into a commercial vector provided by GeneArt. To replace the YFP-gpt cassette, BSC-40 cells were infected with scHPXV YFP-gpt::095 and then transfected with 2 μg of linearized plasmid using Lipofectamine 2000 (ThermoFisher Scientific). The virus progeny were harvested two days later and the non-fluorescent viruses were isolated using three rounds of plaque purification under agar. The PCR and primers that targeted sequences flanking the HPXV095 gene locus (5’-CCTATTAGATACATAGATCCTCGTCG-3’ and 5’-CGGTTTATCTAACGACACAACATC-3’) were used to show that we had restored the wild-type locus. The scHPXV genome sequence containing the VACV F- and S-terminal hairpins arbitrarily placed at the left and right termini of the genome, respectively, has been deposited in GenBank as accession number KY349117.
Virus growth properties and plaque size measurements
To measure virus growth, near confluent monolayers of BSC-40, HeLa, HEL fibroblasts, and Vero cells were infected at 0.01 PFU/cell with the indicated viruses. The cells were harvested at different time points and the yield of infectious particles was determined by plaque assay on BSC-40 cells. To measure plaque size, BSC-40 cells were infected for 3 days with the indicated viruses at 50 PFU/60mm dish and then the cells were fixed and stained with crystal violet. A digital image of each dish was obtained and the plaque areas were determined using FIJI software . In each condition at least 8 plaques per virus were measured in three independent experiments.
Murine intranasal model of scHPXV infection
Six-to-eight week old BALB/c mice were purchased from Charles River Laboratories. Groups of five mice were intranasally infected (or mock infected) with 5×103 PFU VACV (strain WR), 1×107 VACV (strain DPP15 ), or 1×105 PFU, 1×106 PFU, or 1×107 PFU of scHPXV YFP-gpt::095 or scHPXV in 10μl of PBS. The mice were weighed daily for 28 days, and the following clinical signs were scored: ruffled fur, difficulty breathing, reduced mobility, and pox lesions. All of these mice were subsequently challenged intranasally with 1 × 106 PFU VACV (strain WR) and monitored daily as described above for 14 days. Mice that lost 25% of the initial weight were euthanized.
For plaque reduction and neutralization tests, blood was collected from each of the mice via the saphenous vein at day 16 post-vaccination and equal quantities were pooled within each cohort. The serum was heated at 56°C for 30 min and then 2-fold serial dilutions prepared in serum-free media. The diluted serum (50μL) was mixed with 50 μL of serum-free media containing ~75 pfu of VACV strain WR, incubated at 37°C for 60 min, and then plated on BSC-40 cells. The plaques were counted two days later and the PRNT50 estimated from the interpolated dilution that would produce a 50% reduction in virus titer.
Biosafety, biosecurity and animal care
All of the studies concerning the reconstruction of HPXV were conducted with the knowledge and approval of the University of Alberta Biosafety Officers. All work was performed under Containment Level 2 physical and operational conditions in compliance with the Canadian Biosafety Standard as published by the Public Health Agency of Canada and the Canadian Food Inspection Agency of Canada, with the additional voluntary precaution of prohibiting researchers' contact with horses or cattle. As part of the institution's Human Pathogens and Toxins Act license to work with pathogens, the University of Alberta submitted a plan detailing how it administratively manages and controls biosafety and biosecurity risks, which was considered acceptable by the Public Health Agency of Canada. These ongoing efforts were also disclosed to the World Health Organization (WHO) through DE’s participation in activities relating to the Advisory Committee on Variola Virus Research. All of the animal experiments were reviewed and approved by the University of Alberta Animal Care and Use Committee and Research Ethics Office.
scHPXV design strategy
Given that the toxicity of modern VACV vaccines limits their use, and molecular analyses show that modern VACV vaccine strains share common ancestry with HPXV, we asked whether a HPXV-based vaccine might provide a safer alternative. Using the HPXV (strain WNR-76) sequence  we divided the 212,633 bp genome into 10-overlapping DNAs sharing ~1 kbp of flanking homology (Fig 1). Each fragment was synthesized and cloned into a bacterial vector. To facilitate the assembly of these clones we deleted all of the AarI or BsaI sites in fragments 1–7 using silent mutations, but did not mutate the BsaI sites in the two inverted terminal repeat (ITR) fragments, as these regions contain elements required for genome replication and resolution. In addition we used silent substitutions to introduce AvaI and StuI sites into the HPXV044 gene and replaced HPXV095 in Frag_3 with sequences encoding yellow fluorescent protein fused to guanine phosphoribosyltransferase protein (YFP-gpt) . HPXV095 encodes the HPXV homolog of the non-essential VACV J2R gene.
As a proof of principle, co-transfection of HPXV Frag_3 along with VACV genomic DNA into SFV-infected BGMK cells led to the recovery of a hybrid virus (VACV/HPXV+Frag_3), validating the selection strategy (Fig 2). The addition of other HPXV synthetic DNA fragments along with genomic DNA from this hybrid virus, however, did not result in complete incorporation of the HPXV fragment lacking BsaI sites into the genomes of these hybrid virus clones (Fig 2a). Instead, these viruses exhibited a “patchy” pattern of DNA integration, similar to what is detected in virus-by-virus crosses (Fig 2b) . This patchy pattern is easily detected because of the sequence polymorphisms that differentiate HPXV from VACV. These sequence differences are illustrated by an alignment of the two viruses (Fig 2c).
a. A PCR-based screening approach was used to identify hybrid and reactivated viruses. PCR primers were designed to target both HPXV and VACV (S2 Table) and used to amplify DNA segments spanning the BsaI sites that were disrupted in the synthetic HPXV clones. Following PCR amplification, the products were digested with BsaI to differentiate VACV sequences (which cut) from HPXV (which do not cut). The VACV/HPXV hybrids exhibit a mix of BsaI sensitive and resistant sites whereas a reactivated scHPXV YFP-gpt::095 clone is fully BsaI resistant. b. Sequence mapping of HPXV inserts in VACV strain WR. Virus genomes were sequenced using an Illumina platform, assembled, and LAGAN  and “Base-by-Base”  software were used to align and generate the maps shown. Places where VACV sequences (white) have been replaced by HPXV sequences are colour coded according to the difference. The first hybrid virus (“VACV/HPXV + fragment 3”) was obtained by co-transfecting VACV DNA plus HPXV Frag_3 (Fig 1) into SFV-infected cells. The green-tagged insertion encodes the YFP-gpt selection marker. Clones 1–3 were obtained by purifying the DNA from this first hybrid genome and transfecting it again, along with HPXV fragments 2, 4, 5, and 7, into SFV-infected cells. c. Genomic sequence comparison of scHPXV YFP-gpt::095 to VACV WR.
The HPXV ITRs presented more challenges, because the available HPXV genome was not sequenced through the hairpin ends. The HPXV sequence stops at a feature needed for concatemer resolution [28, 29], which in VACV is located ~60 nt from the end of the genome and it is identical to the putative resolution site in the HPXV sequence. Given the similarities between the two viruses, we tested whether VACV hairpins could substitute for the missing HPXV ends. The fast [F] and slow [S] VACV hairpins (Fig 1b) were synthesized and these two 157 nt oligonucleotides were ligated onto the left and right HPXV ITR fragments using standard molecular biology techniques. This produced four combinations of ITR-hairpin species with joints that copied the desired chimera and with no adventitious sequences (S1 Fig). We pooled these DNAs in reactivation reactions.
We then transfected an equimolar mix of all ten HPXV fragments into SFV-infected cells to test whether these synthetic HPXV fragments could be recombined into replication-competent viruses. Five days later, the virus mix was harvested and re-plated on BSC-40 cells, where Orthopoxviruses will form plaques. Although this process is inefficient compared to transfection of complete poxvirus genomes into cells where we and others can get up to 106 pfu/μg [18, 19], we obtained from 0-to-4 fluorescent plaques on the BSC-40 cells, in each of six replicate experiments, or ~30 pfu/μg of transfected DNA. Judging by pulse field gel electrophoresis these viruses appeared to be chimeras that encoded synthetic HPXV sequences bounded by HPXV/VACV hairpin ends (Fig 3a). We sequenced five viruses from two reactivation reactions and all faithfully replicated the sequence of the input clones. We confirmed that this method doesn't introduce SFV DNA into the reactivated viruses  and the only mutations detected were those we had incorporated by design, for example novel AvaI and StuI sites in HPXV044 (S2 Fig). Our Illumina sequencing also detected reads extending completely through the VACV-derived hairpin telomeres. The 1:1 distribution of F- and S-reads in each of the five reactivated viruses suggests that both ends are required to produce a virus (Fig 3b and S3 Table). However, because of the way that these sequences are produced by fragmentation of a pool of viruses bearing inverted terminal repeats, it is not possible to establish how they are oriented or distributed with respect to any particular individual genome.
a. Pulsed field gel electrophoretic analysis. Three independent HPXV clones plus a VACV (strain WR) control virus were purified and then left either untreated, or digested with BsaI or HindIII. The larger size of HPXV relative to VACV is apparent in the uncut samples, and the absence of nearly all of the BsaI sites in the HPXV clones is also apparent. The selective manner in which only the BsaI sites were modified by gene synthesis is illustrated by the retention of all the HindIII restriction sites in scHPXV YFP-gpt::095. The HindIII digest also demonstrates the similarities between HPXV and VACV as illustrated by the related digestion patterns. The faint DNA bands marked with asterisks (*) are from monkey cell mitochondria, which co-purify with poxvirus particles. b. Sequence reads associated with the hairpin telomeres. The viruses were sequenced using Illumina technology and the genomes assembled using CLC genomics software. A subset of the longest sequencing reads, extending beyond the known end of the HPXV sequence, are shown aligned against a poly·dC template. (This method captures sequences extending beyond the point where the reference sequence ends.) These reads span the entire length of the unfolded hairpins as was provided using synthetic oligonucleotides. Because of the inverted terminal duplications, all of the reads “pile up” together. Both F- and S-forms of the VACV hairpin are detected and the ratio of F- to S-reads in this region was 1.03±0.01 (SEM) in eight different virus-sequencing reactions.
We subsequently synthesized a 1,349 bp DNA encoding the HPXV095 locus along with flanking sequences (Fig 1a) and transfected it into cells infected with one of the reactivated HPXV. Three non-fluorescent recombinant viruses were recovered and purified, and PCR and sequencing were used to confirm that we had restored the wild-type HPXV095 gene. This “synthetic and chimeric” virus was labeled scHPXV to differentiate it from the reactivated thymidine kinase deficient parent virus (scHPXV YFP-gpt::095) and the native virus (HPXV strain WNR-76).
scHPXV growth properties in vitro
There are no publications that extensively compare the properties of HPXV with other Orthopoxviruses. We used VACV strain Western Reserve, DPP15 (a VACV Dryvax™ clone resembling ACAM2000 ), and cowpox strain Brighton for comparison purposes. The most obvious difference related to plaque size, scHPXV YFP-gpt::095 and scHPXV formed plaques that are significantly smaller than other Orthopoxviruses on BSC-40 cells (Fig 4a and 4b). The scHPXV small plaque phenotype appears identical to what has been reported for authentic HPXV . Different VACV strains also produce extracellular viruses that form smaller secondary plaques . These are not produced by scHPXV strains (Fig 4b) and the reasons for this difference are not obvious since all of the known genes regulating extracellular enveloped virus production  are found in HPXV. Interestingly the small plaque phenotype is not reflected in multi-step growth curves, at least on BSC-40 cells where both scHPXV YFP-gpt::095 and scHPXV grew as well as the other viruses. The virus grew to somewhat lower titers on primary human fibroblasts and Vero cells, and least well on HeLa cells (Fig 4c). The finding that scHPXV does not produce secondary plaques (a characteristic feature of extracellular enveloped virus producing viruses), may be of relevance given that this property affects virulence .
a. Plaque size measurements. BSC-40 cells were infected with the indicated viruses and cultured for three days. The dishes were stained and the plaque areas measured using a scanned digital image. Approximately 8 plaques were measured per virus treatment from three independent infections (closed circles). A similar independent experiment comparing scHPXV YFP-gpt::095 and scHPXV to VACV WR was also completed as described above (open circles). DPP15 is a VACV clone isolated from Dryvax vaccine and CPXV is cowpox virus (strain Brighton Red). scHPXV YFP-gpt::095 and scHPXV form plaques that are significantly smaller than any of the other two viruses tested. Statistically significant differences are noted (****P2 0.0001). b. Plaque morphology seen at three days post-infection on BSC-40 cells. The cells were fixed and stained with crystal violet. c. Multi-step growth kinetics measured using human (HEL, HeLa) or monkey (BSC-40, Vero) cells. The cells were infected at a multiplicity of infection of 0.01, the virus harvested at the indicated times, and the virus titrated on BSC-40 cells in triplicate. The error bars indicate the SEM.
Virulence and vaccine properties of scHPXV
We also tested the virulence of scHPXV and scHPXV YFP-gpt::095 in mice and whether they could protect against lethal VACV challenge. For purposes of comparison we used VACV strains WR and DPP15, which at the indicated doses, are known to cause virulence in BALB/c mice. BALB/c mice were inoculated with 105-to-107 pfu of each of the HPXV, 1×107 pfu of VACV strain DPP15, or 5×103 pfu of VACV strain WR. The mice inoculated with VACV exhibited symptoms of illness most graphically illustrated as transient weight loss and with the lower dose of VACV (WR) taking longer to elicit disease (Fig 5a). No signs of infection (e.g. weight loss, ruffled fur, or lethargy) were detected in any of the animals inoculated with either scHPXV YFP-gpt::095 (S3 Fig) or scHPXV strains (Fig 5a). All of the animals were fully recovered two weeks later. On day 16, blood samples were collected via the saphenous vein and pooled within each cohort, and titered to measure VACV-specific antibodies using a plaque reduction neutralization test (PRNT). The PRNT50 antibody titres in mice infected with 1×107 pfu of the two HPXV ranged from 1:35 (scHPXV) to 1:70 (scHPXV YFP-gpt::095), comparable to that detected in animals infected with 1×107 pfu of VACV strain DPP15 (1:20) or 5×103 pfu of VACV strain WR (1:60), and above the background in controls (~1:2). All of these animals were subsequently challenged with a lethal dose of VACV (WR) at day 30 post-infection (Fig 5b–5d and S3b–S3d Fig). All of the control animals initially treated with saline had to be euthanized due to the infection within 7 days. The animals initially exposed to 1×107 pfu of VACV (DPP15) or 5×103 pfu of VACV (WR), or 1×106 or 1×107 pfu of scHPXV showed little or no weight loss and no illness as judged by the clinical scores (Fig 5c). Mice vaccinated with 105 pfu of scHPXV YFP-gpt::095 were only partially protected from a lethal dose of VACV WR (S3d Fig), suggesting that mutating the thymidine kinase attenuates the virus in mice. We concluded that scHPXV can immunize against a lethal VACV challenge and without causing disease during the intranasal immunization step.
a. Virulence studies. Immune competent BALB/c mice (5 per group) were inoculated intranasally with the indicated viruses. scHPXV was tested using doses ranging from 105−107 pfu per mouse. Some weight loss due to illness was seen in animals inoculated with 5×103 pfu VACV strain WR (¢), or 1×107 pfu of VACV strain DPP15 (Δ), but no illness was detected in any of the animals infected with HPXV clones. b. VACV challenge studies. Four weeks after exposure to the indicated agent as shown in panel a (or mock treatment with buffered saline), the mice were exposed to a lethal dose of VACV strain WR (1×106 pfu) by the same route (day 0 in b is day 28 in graph a). The animals were monitored for signs of disease and euthanized if the weight loss exceeded 25% of the initial body weight. The scHPXV strain provided good protection at the two highest pre-challenge doses (1×106 and 1×107 pfu). c. Disease course in HPXV vaccinated mice. The mice were inspected to detect four signs of disease (ruffled fur, hunched posture, difficulty breathing, and reduced mobility) and a clinical score calculated from the sum of the individual scores averaged across all five (or surviving) mice per cohort. Little or no signs of illness were detected in mice first vaccinated with 1×106 or 1×107 pfu scHPXV d. Kaplan-Meyer analysis of survivorship. All of the mock-vaccinated (i.e. saline-treated) mice succumbed to VACV strain WR challenge, whereas treatment of animals vaccinated with either VACV strain WR, VACV strain DPP15, or all doses of scHPXV (105−107 pfu per mouse) protected 100% of the animals.
These studies were provoked by our interest in the history of Jenner’s vaccine. Contemporary accounts [6, 7] provide support for Jenner’s speculation that the vaccine probably originated as an equine disease called “grease”. Most notably Loy showed that one of two forms of grease (or horsepox) characterized by a diffuse pox reaction, provided protection against smallpox without requiring passage through cows . Modern sequencing supports this hypothesis with the one known HPXV strain most closely resembling both old French  and early American  smallpox vaccines, and sharing a common origin with all known VACV . Further support for a shared origin is provided by the observation that the I4L locus in a rare Dryvax clone (DPP17), encodes a block of sequence and a frameshift mutation that most closely resembles the homologous locus in HPXV . Using the HPXV genome sequence , synthetic DNA fragments, and methods outlined elsewhere , we have used recombination and reactivation reactions to recreate this HPXV strain. This scHPXV resembles VACV in many of its growth properties, although it produces much smaller plaques (Fig 4a) without the secondary plaques associated with extracellular virus, which may partly explain the reduced virulence. Whether the increased infectivity and virulence of VACV reflects two centuries of selection in alternative hosts, including passage in humans, is an interesting question and because VACV-HPXV hybrids are viable (Fig 2), such strains might provide a tool for identifying some of the gene(s) responsible. Of perhaps most interest is the fact that our scHPXV strain generates immune protection against lethal virus challenge (Fig 5), and if the lower virulence in mice reflects better tolerability in humans, it supports further investigation as a vaccine and vector.
The method described here could be adapted to assemble other Orthopoxviruses, and possibly other Chordopoxviruses if the right helper virus(es) and supporting cell lines can be identified. This is timely as poxviruses offer much promise as oncolytic agents [35, 36] and better ways are needed to more rapidly and extensively engineer these agents to provoke potent anti-tumour immune responses; ideally using designs based on personalized cancer neo-antigens. These synthetic approaches also provide tools for investigating certain basic features of virus genome structure (for example the mismatched and flip/flop hairpin telomeres) that are still incompletely understood 3–4 decades after they were discovered .
That said this is clearly an example of dual use research, and observations like these poses significant challenges for public health authorities. Most viruses could be assembled nowadays using reverse genetics, and these methods have been combined with gene synthesis technologies to assemble poliovirus  and other extinct pathogens like the 1918 influenza strain . Given that the sequence of variola virus has been known since 1993 , our studies show that it is clearly accessible to current synthetic biology technology, with important implications for public health and biosecurity . Our hope is that this work will promote new and informed public health discussions relating to synthetic biology, stimulate new evaluation of HPXV-based vaccines, and advance the capacity to rapidly produce next-generation vaccines and poxvirus-based therapeutics.
S1 Fig. Construction of hairpin-terminated left and right ITRs.
a. Restriction maps showing the arrangement of SfiI and PvuII restriction sites in the left and right ITR clones. b. Gel electrophoretic analysis of ligation products. The cut ITR clones were ligated with or without the fast (F) or slow (S) forms of the VACV hairpin (H.P.) oligonucleotides and then a portion of each sample was digested with PvuII to aid in detecting the small size shift associated with adding hairpin ends. We observed nearly quantitative ligation of the ITR ends to the hairpin oligonucleotides as judged by the bands running at ~1.5 kbp (“*”).
S2 Fig. Genome sequence analysis of scHPXV YFP-gpt::095.
The recovered viruses were sequenced using “Tagmentation” and Illumina technologies and the genomes assembled using CLC genomics software and both “map to reference” and de novo approaches. Shown here are a portion (~1%) of the sequence reads that mapped to the HPXV044 gene (VACV I4L homolog) in DQ792504 (top row). Fragment_2 encoded a silent T-to-G substitution mutation at position 44,512 designed to introduce a novel AvaI site into the reactivated viruses (“Consensus”). Apart from the mutations that were deliberately incorporated into the synthetic sequence, like this T-to-G substitution, no other mutations were detected by genome sequencing across the scHPXV YFP-gpt::095 or scHPXV genomes.
S3 Fig. Effect of thymidine kinase mutations on HPXV virulence and vaccine properties.
a. Virulence studies. Immune competent BALB/c mice (5 per group) were inoculated intranasally with the indicated viruses. Both scHPXV and scHPXV YFP-gpt::095 (DJ2) were tested, at doses ranging from 105−107 pfu per mouse. No illness was detected in any of the animals infected with HPXV clones. b. VACV challenge studies. Four weeks after exposure to the indicated agents as shown in panel a, the mice were exposed to a lethal dose of VACV strain WR (1×106 pfu) by the same route. (The “no challenge” controls were PBS treated and unchallenged.) The animals were monitored for signs of disease and euthanized if the weight loss exceeded 25% of the initial body weight. The animals previously treated with the scHPXV YFP-gpt::095 strain acquired only limited and dose-dependent protection from VACV strain WR, whereas the scHPXV strain provided good protection at the two highest pre-challenge doses (1×106 and 1×107 pfu). c. Disease course in HPXV-vaccinated mice. The mice were inspected to detect four signs of disease (ruffled fur, hunched posture, difficulty breathing, and reduced mobility) and a clinical score calculated from the sum of the individual scores averaged across all five (or surviving) mice per cohort. Little or no signs of illness were detected in mice first vaccinated with 1×106 or 1×107 pfu scHPXV whereas the scHPXV YFP-gpt::095 provided incomplete protection at the lower pre-challenge doses (1×105 or 1×106 pfu). d. Kaplan-Meyer analysis of survivorship. The lowest dose of scHPXV YFP-gpt::095 (1×105 pfu) provided only partial protection from a VACV challenge. All other interventions protected 100% of the animals. Note that data showing the behavior of the scHPXV strain (presented in Fig 5) are also duplicated here for comparison purposes.
S1 Table. Silent mutations created in scHPXV fragments to remove AarI and BsaI restriction sites from HPXV genome.
S2 Table. Primers used to amplify regions within VACV and HPXV that flank BsaI restriction endonuclease sites found in VACV (NC_006998).
We thank Ms. M. Desaulniers for her excellent technical assistance and members of our laboratory, and the poxvirus and synthetic biology research communities, for thoughtful discussions. The advice and guidance received from representatives of the Canadian federal agencies responsible for biosafety and biosecurity is also gratefully acknowledged. DE thanks the Canadian Institutes for Health Research, Natural Sciences & Engineering Research Council of Canada, Alberta Innovates, and the Canada Foundation for Innovation for long-term research support.
- 1. Fenner F, Henderson A, Arita I, Jezek Z, Ladnyi ID. Smallpox and its eradication. Geneva: World Health Organization; 1988. 1460 p.
- 2. Baxby D. Jenner's smallpox vaccine: the riddle of vaccinia virus and its origin. London: Heinemann Educational; 1981.
- 3. Medaglia ML, Moussatche N, Nitsche A, Dabrowski PW, Li Y, Damon IK, et al. Genomic Analysis, Phenotype, and Virulence of the Historical Brazilian Smallpox Vaccine Strain IOC: Implications for the Origins and Evolutionary Relationships of Vaccinia Virus. Journal of virology. 2015;89(23):11909–25. pmid:26378174
- 4. Tulman ER, Delhon G, Afonso CL, Lu Z, Zsak L, Sandybaev NT, et al. Genome of horsepox virus. Journal of virology. 2006;80(18):9244–58. Epub 2006/08/31. pmid:16940536
- 5. Schrick L, Tausch SH, Dabrowski PW, Damaso CR, Esparza J, Nitsche A. An Early American Smallpox Vaccine Based on Horsepox. N Engl J Med. 2017;377(15):1491–2. pmid:29020595.
- 6. Loy JG. An account of some experiments on the origin of the cow-pox: Whitby; 1801.
- 7. Bell G. A treatise on the cow-pox; containing an enumeration of the principal facts in the history of that disease; the method of communicating the infection by inoculation; and the means of distinguishing between the genuine and spurious cow-pox. The 2d ed. Edinburgh,: Longman, Hurst, Rees and Orme; etc.; 1807. xii, 143 p. p.
- 8. Murphy JG, Wright RS, Bruce GK, Baddour LM, Farrell MA, Edwards WD, et al. Eosinophilic-lymphocytic myocarditis after smallpox vaccination. Lancet. 2003;362(9393):1378–80. pmid:14585641.
- 9. Fulginiti VA, Papier A, Lane JM, Neff JM, Henderson DA. Smallpox vaccination: a review, part II. Adverse events. Clin Infect Dis. 2003;37(2):251–71. pmid:12856218.
- 10. Esparza J. Has horsepox become extinct? Vet Rec. 2013;173(11):272–3. pmid:24057497.
- 11. Smith HO, Hutchison CA 3rd, Pfannkoch C, Venter JC. Generating a synthetic genome by whole genome assembly: phiX174 bacteriophage from synthetic oligonucleotides. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2003;100(26):15440–5. pmid:14657399
- 12. Cello J, Paul AV, Wimmer E. Chemical synthesis of poliovirus cDNA: generation of infectious virus in the absence of natural template. Science. 2002;297(5583):1016–8. Epub 2002/07/13. pmid:12114528.
- 13. Tumpey TM, Basler CF, Aguilar PV, Zeng H, Solorzano A, Swayne DE, et al. Characterization of the reconstructed 1918 Spanish influenza pandemic virus. Science. 2005;310(5745):77–80. Epub 2005/10/08. pmid:16210530.
- 14. Baroudy BM, Venkatesan S, Moss B. Structure and replication of vaccinia virus telomeres. Cold Spring Harb Symp Quant Biol. 1983;47 Pt 2:723–9.
- 15. Senkevich TG, Bruno D, Martens C, Porcella SF, Wolf YI, Moss B. Mapping vaccinia virus DNA replication origins at nucleotide level by deep sequencing. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2015;112(35):10908–13. pmid:26286988
- 16. Joklik WK, Woodroofe GM, Holmes IH, Fenner F. The reactivation of poxviruses. I. Demonstration of the phenomenon and techniques of assay. Virology. 1960;11:168–84. Epub 1960/05/01. pmid:14407604.
- 17. Sam CK, Dumbell KR. Expression of poxvirus DNA in coinfected cells and marker rescue of thermosensitive mutants by subgenomic fragments of DNA. Ann Virol (Inst Past). 1981;132:135–50.
- 18. Scheiflinger F, Dorner F, Falkner FG. Construction of chimeric vaccinia viruses by molecular cloning and packaging. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America. 1992;89(21):9977–81. pmid:1438247
- 19. Yao XD, Evans DH. High-frequency genetic recombination and reactivation of orthopoxviruses from DNA fragments transfected into leporipoxvirus-infected cells. Journal of virology. 2003;77(13):7281–90. Epub 2003/06/14. pmid:12805426
- 20. Qin L, Upton C, Hazes B, Evans DH. Genomic analysis of the vaccinia virus strain variants found in Dryvax vaccine. Journal of virology. 2011;85(24):13049–60. Epub 2011/10/07. pmid:21976639
- 21. Rintoul JL, Wang J, Gammon DB, van Buuren NJ, Garson K, Jardine K, et al. A selectable and excisable marker system for the rapid creation of recombinant poxviruses. PloS one. 2011;6(9):e24643. Epub 2011/09/21. pmid:21931792
- 22. Yao XD, Evans DH. Construction of recombinant vaccinia viruses using leporipoxvirus-catalyzed recombination and reactivation of orthopoxvirus DNA. Methods Mol Biol. 2004;269:51–64. pmid:15114007.
- 23. Tcherepanov V, Ehlers A, Upton C. Genome Annotation Transfer Utility (GATU): rapid annotation of viral genomes using a closely related reference genome. BMC Genomics. 2006;7:150. Epub 2006/06/15. pmid:16772042
- 24. Schindelin J, Arganda-Carreras I, Frise E, Kaynig V, Longair M, Pietzsch T, et al. Fiji: an open-source platform for biological-image analysis. Nat Methods. 2012;9(7):676–82. pmid:22743772
- 25. Qin L, Evans DH. Genome scale patterns of recombination between coinfecting vaccinia viruses. J Virol. 2014;88(10):5277–86. pmid:24574414
- 26. Brudno M, Do CB, Cooper GM, Kim MF, Davydov E, Green ED, et al. LAGAN and Multi-LAGAN: efficient tools for large-scale multiple alignment of genomic DNA. Genome Res. 2003;13(4):721–31. Epub 2003/03/26. pmid:12654723
- 27. Brodie R, Smith AJ, Roper RL, Tcherepanov V, Upton C. Base-By-Base: single nucleotide-level analysis of whole viral genome alignments. BMC Bioinformatics. 2004;5:96. Epub 2004/07/16. pmid:15253776
- 28. DeLange AM, McFadden G. Efficient resolution of replicated poxvirus telomeres to native hairpin structures requires two inverted symmetrical copies of a core target DNA sequence. Journal of virology. 1987;61(6):1957–63. pmid:3033323
- 29. Merchlinsky M. Mutational analysis of the resolution sequence of vaccinia virus DNA: essential sequence consists of two separate AT-rich regions highly conserved among poxviruses. Journal of virology. 1990;64(10):5029–35. pmid:2398534
- 30. Trindade GS, Emerson GL, Sammons S, Frace M, Govil D, Fernandes Mota BE, et al. Serro 2 Virus Highlights the Fundamental Genomic and Biological Features of a Natural Vaccinia Virus Infecting Humans. Viruses. 2016;8(12). pmid:27973399
- 31. Smith GL, Vanderplasschen A, Law M. The formation and function of extracellular enveloped vaccinia virus. J Gen Virol. 2002;83(Pt 12):2915–31. pmid:12466468.
- 32. Parkinson JE, Smith GL. Vaccinia virus gene A36R encodes a M(r) 43–50 K protein on the surface of extracellular enveloped virus. Virology. 1994;204(1):376–90. pmid:8091668
- 33. Qin L, Favis N, Famulski J, Evans DH. Evolution of and evolutionary relationships between extant vaccinia virus strains. Journal of virology. 2015;89(3):1809–24. pmid:25410873
- 34. Anonymous. The Independent Advisory Group on Public Health Implications of Synthetic Biology Technology Related to Smallpox. Geneva: World Health Organization, 2015 Contract No.: WHO/HSE/PED/2015.1.
- 35. Potts KG, Irwin CR, Favis NA, Pink DB, Vincent KM, Lewis JD, et al. Deletion of F4L (ribonucleotide reductase) in vaccinia virus produces a selective oncolytic virus and promotes anti-tumor immunity with superior safety in bladder cancer models. EMBO Mol Med. 2017;9(5):638–54. pmid:28289079
- 36. Breitbach CJ, Parato K, Burke J, Hwang TH, Bell JC, Kirn DH. Pexa-Vec double agent engineered vaccinia: oncolytic and active immunotherapeutic. Curr Opin Virol. 2015;13:49–54. pmid:25900822.
- 37. Baroudy BM, Venkatesan S, Moss B. Incompletely base-paired flip-flop terminal loops link the two DNA strands of the vaccinia virus genome into one uninterrupted polynucleotide chain. Cell. 1982;28(2):315–24. pmid:7060133
- 38. Shchelkunov SN, Resenchuk SM, Totmenin AV, Blinov VM, Marennikova SS, Sandakhchiev LS. Comparison of the genetic maps of variola and vaccinia viruses. FEBS letters. 1993;327(3):321–4. pmid:8394246