Advertisement
Browse Subject Areas
?

Click through the PLOS taxonomy to find articles in your field.

For more information about PLOS Subject Areas, click here.

  • Loading metrics

A role for the tfs3 ICE-encoded type IV secretion system in pro-inflammatory signalling by the Helicobacter pylori Ser/Thr kinase, CtkA

  • Maher N. Alandiyjany,

    Roles Data curation, Formal analysis, Funding acquisition, Investigation, Writing – review & editing

    Current address: Laboratory Medicine Department, Faculty of Applied Medical Sciences, Umm Al-Qura University, Al Abdeyah, Makkah, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia

    Affiliation NIHR Nottingham Digestive Diseases Biomedical Research Unit, Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust and University of Nottingham, Nottingham, United Kingdom

  • Nicola J. Croxall,

    Roles Formal analysis, Investigation

    Affiliation NIHR Nottingham Digestive Diseases Biomedical Research Unit, Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust and University of Nottingham, Nottingham, United Kingdom

  • Jane I. Grove,

    Roles Formal analysis, Investigation, Supervision, Writing – review & editing

    Affiliation NIHR Nottingham Digestive Diseases Biomedical Research Unit, Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust and University of Nottingham, Nottingham, United Kingdom

  • Robin M. Delahay

    Roles Conceptualization, Formal analysis, Funding acquisition, Investigation, Project administration, Writing – original draft, Writing – review & editing

    rob.delahay@nottingham.ac.uk

    Affiliation NIHR Nottingham Digestive Diseases Biomedical Research Unit, Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust and University of Nottingham, Nottingham, United Kingdom

A role for the tfs3 ICE-encoded type IV secretion system in pro-inflammatory signalling by the Helicobacter pylori Ser/Thr kinase, CtkA

  • Maher N. Alandiyjany, 
  • Nicola J. Croxall, 
  • Jane I. Grove, 
  • Robin M. Delahay
PLOS
x

Abstract

Two distinct type IV secretion systems (T4SSs) can be identified in certain Helicobacter pylori strains, encoded on mobile genetic elements termed tfs3 and tfs4. Although their function remains unknown, both have been implicated in clinical outcomes of H. pylori infection. Here we provide evidence that the Tfs3 T4SS is required for activity of the pro-inflammatory Ser/Thr kinase protein, CtkA, in a gastric epithelial cell infection model. Previously, purified recombinant CtkA protein has been shown to upregulate NF-kappaB signalling and induce TNF-alpha and IL-8 cytokine secretion from cultured macrophages suggesting that it may potentiate the H. pylori-mediated inflammatory response. In this study, we show that CtkA expressed from its native host, H. pylori has a similar capacity for stimulation of a pro-inflammatory response from gastric epithelial cells. CtkA interaction was found to be dependent upon a complement of tfs3 T4SS genes, but independent of the T4SSs encoded by either tfs4 or the cag pathogenicity island. Moreover, the availability of CtkA for host cell interaction was shown to be conditional upon the carboxyl-terminus of CtkA, encoding a putative conserved secretion signal common to other variably encoded Tfs3 proteins. Collectively, our observations indicate a role for the Tfs3 T4SS in CtkA-mediated pro-inflammatory signalling by H. pylori and identify CtkA as a likely Tfs3 T4SS secretion substrate.

Introduction

Persistent infection of the gastric mucosa of up to half of all humans with Helicobacter pylori is a predisposing factor for a range of severe gastroduodenal diseases including peptic ulcer disease and gastric cancer [1, 2]. Determination of a particular disease outcome is considered to involve a complex interplay between bacterial, host and environmental factors [3, 4]. Of the bacterial factors, a subset of surface-associated and secreted proteins are of prominent importance for defining the pathogenic potential of a particular infecting H. pylori strain and include the cag type IV secretion system (T4SS) and its secreted effector protein CagA, the vacuolating cytotoxin VacA and the adhesins BabA and SabA [410]. The variable activity of these virulence proteins has been associated with the extent of damage to the gastric mucosa and severity of the host inflammatory response. More recently, other H. pylori proteins such as Tipα [11] and cell translocating kinase A (CtkA) [12, 13] have also been described to induce pro-inflammatory responses from host cells. Whereas the tipα gene appears conserved in H. pylori genomes, the ctkA gene is considerably more variable in different geographic populations and comprises part of the subset of strain-specific genes that contributes to the extreme genetic diversity of H. pylori strains [1219].

Perhaps the best studied of these latter proteins, CtkA, has been shown to be highly expressed in response to H. pylori interaction with the gerbil gastric mucosa in an in vivo study [20]. Work using recombinant CtkA protein (rCtkA) has also demonstrated dose-dependent induction of pro-inflammatory cytokine TNF-α and IL-8 secretion from cultured macrophage and mononuclear cells [12, 13] and pro-inflammatory and pro-apoptotic responses from mouse macrophages [21]. These studies suggest that CtkA may contribute to chronic gastric inflammation and H. pylori persistence, thereby increasing the risk of inflammation-associated outcomes such as atrophy and gastric cancer. Indeed, the gene encoding ctkA (jhp0940 in reference H. pylori strain J99) has been reported to have a positive association with increased risk of gastric cancer in some populations [14] and decreased risk for duodenal ulcer [19].

Structural solution of C-terminally truncated rCtkA and further mechanistic studies identified it to be both a Ser/Thr and tyrosine kinase capable of auto-phosphorylation [12, 21]. Interestingly, rCtkA has a capacity to self-translocate across the membrane of cultured epithelial cells and is presumed to elicit host responses through direct engagement of intracellular signalling molecules.

A large number of strain-specific genes are now known to be encoded within complete or remnant transmissible genetic elements variously referred to as conjugative transposons (TnPZs) or self-transmissible genomic islands [2224]. Two have been described, termed tfs3 and tfs4, both of which comprise a full complement of genes encoding Vir-homologous T4SS assembly proteins in addition to a variable number of cargo genes of unknown function. The gene encoding the VirB4 ATPase component of the putative Tfs4 T4SS, dupA, has been associated with increased risk for duodenal ulcer in several geographically distinct patient populations [25] suggesting that activity of a Tfs4 T4SS may be important for clinical outcome. However, the functional activity of the Tfs4 T4SS remains undefined, although dupA+ strains have been reported to demonstrate both increased survival at low pH and upregulation of IL-8 secretion from gastric epithelial cells [26]. Upregulation of pro-inflammatory signalling has also been reported as a feature of certain strains bearing tfs3 [23]. Further mechanistic studies have implicated the putative Tfs4 T4SS in transfer of the tfs4 cluster [24], and identified catalytically active tfs4-encoded protein components such as the XerD integrase [24] and VirD2 relaxase [27] relevant to this function. These proteins are similarly encoded by tfs3, indicating that both elements may have a propensity for dissemination within the H. pylori population by a conjugative-like mechanism analogous to that of integrative and conjugative elements (ICEs) [27, 28]. Thus, gain or loss of tfs3 and tfs4 ICE-like clusters, each comprising 30–40 genes, could be anticipated to significantly contribute to the genetic diversity of H. pylori strains, providing a means for rapid augmentation or disposal of genotypic and phenotypic characteristics that may influence strain fitness and the nature of the interaction with its host.

The current known functional activity of CtkA, both with respect to its catalytic activity and interaction with cultured human cells, derives from the study of recombinant protein (rCtkA) overexpressed and purified from a heterologous bacterial host [12, 13]. However, whilst providing important mechanistic insight, such studies do not allow for assessment of CtkA activity in the context of H. pylori infection and have not been confirmed to reflect the activity of native CtkA protein. Therefore, in this study we aimed to develop an infection model to facilitate study of CtkA expressed from its native H. pylori host, and further, to determine factors important for its subsequent interaction with host eukaryotic cells. We show that ctkA is a variable but constituent component of the tfs3 ICE and demonstrate that pro-inflammatory signalling by gastric epithelial cells in response to CtkA expressed from H. pylori requires both CtkA C-terminal sequence and the complement of Tfs3 T4SS genes.

Materials and methods

Chemicals and reagents were obtained from Sigma-Aldrich unless otherwise stated.

Bacterial strains, cell lines and growth conditions

Bacterial strains used in this study are described in S1 Table. H. pylori strains were cultured with minimal passage on Blood Agar Base No. 2 containing 5% (vol/vol) horse blood (Oxoid) or in 25 cm2 flasks in RPMI 1640 medium supplemented with 5% heat-inactivated fetal calf serum with shaking at 37°C in a microaerobic environment. Escherichia coli strains were grown at 37°C in Luria broth or agar. All media was supplemented with ampicillin (50–100 μg ml-1), kanamycin (50 μg ml-1) or chloramphenicol (30 μg ml-1) as required.

The human gastric epithelial MKN28 [29] and AGS cell lines (ATCC CRL-1739) were maintained in RPMI 1640 and F12-HAM medium respectively, supplemented with 10% heat-inactivated fetal calf serum and 2 mM L-glutamine (Invitrogen). Cell monolayers were grown at 37°C in a 5% CO2 humidified atmosphere. H. pylori strain 64 was isolated from human gastric biopsy specimens as described previously [30].

Oligonucleotides

The oligonucleotides used in this study are listed in S2 Table.

Sequence analyses

Genome sequences were retrieved from the NCBI database (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed) from where BLASTP/N searches were also performed using default parameters. Multiple sequence alignments were performed using Clustal Omega (http://www.ebi.ac.uk/Tools/msa/clustalo/) and pairwise alignments using the EMBOSS Needle alignment tool (http://www.ebi.ac.uk/Tools/psa/emboss_needle/). Alignments were shaded using Boxshade version 3.3.1 (http://mobyle.pasteur.fr/cgi-bin/portal.py?#forms::boxshade).

Molecular techniques

DNA manipulations were performed by standard techniques in E. coli strain XL1-Blue. Genomic DNA from H. pylori strains for use as PCR template was prepared after 48 h plate culture using a genomic DNA preparation kit (Sigma). Taq DNA polymerase (New England BioLabs) was used for PCR-based typing of H. pylori strains according to manufacturer’s recommendations using the oligonucleotide typing primer (‘TP-‘) pairs listed in S2 Table.

The gsk-ctkA or 3’ truncated gsk-ctkA1-906 inserts were amplified from strain J99 using Phusion DNA polymerase (New England BioLabs) and primers GSK-ctkANdF and ctkASR, then initially introduced into NdeI/SalI sites of pSB14 by directional cloning to create plasmid pSB14-gsk-ctkA.

For construction of pGEM-cagE::kan, a partial cagE gene (cagE257-1966) was amplified from strain 26695 using the Expand High Fidelity PCR kit (Roche) with typing primers TP-cagEF/TP-cagER, then TA-cloned to pGEM-TEasy. Primers cagEiPXmR/cagEiPXhF were next used to remove a central segment of cagE by inverse PCR, at the same time introducing XmaI and XhoI sites into which a kanamycin resistance cassette, amplified with primers kanXmBF/kanXhR, was subsequently inserted. To generate pGEM-cagE::gsk-ctkA-kan, the gsk-ctkA insert fused to the H. pylori flaA promotor sequence in pSB14-gsk-ctkA was amplified using primers SBflaAXmF/apha3R, then cloned to XmaI/BamHI sites of pGEM-cagE::kan. For pGEM-cagE::gsk-ctkA1-906-kan, insert was instead amplified using primers SBflaAXmF/ctkABR2, then cloned in the same way. For pGEM-virB9::cat, the tfs3 virB9 gene was amplified from H. pylori strain AB5 using primers tfs3virB9F/tfs3virB9R, then TA-cloned to pGEM-TEasy. The inverse PCR primer pair tfs3B9iPXmR/tfs3B9iPXhF was then used to introduce central XmaI and XhoI sites into which a chloramphenicol resistance cassette was cloned. pGEM-based constructs were introduced into H. pylori strains using either electroporation or natural transformation.

In vitro culture and secretion experiments

MKN28 or AGS human gastric epithelial cells were seeded into 24 wells at 5 x 104 cells/well 24 h before experiments for assessment of cytokine, or 25 cm2 flasks at 7 x 105 cells/flask for secretion experiments. Relevant H. pylori strains were added to cell monolayers at a multiplicity of infection (MOI) of 50:1 unless otherwise stated. Sampled cell culture supernatants were assessed for IL-8 or TNF-α levels using Human IL-8 CytoSet or Human TNF-α ELISA kits (Invitrogen). Cell culture supernatants for protein analysis were 0.2 μM filtered prior to 5 min incubation with 5 μl Strataclean resin (Agilent Technologies). Resin was pelleted by centrifugation, resuspended in 2X sample loading buffer then boiled for 5 min in preparation for 12% SDS-PAGE/Western immunoblot analysis using anti-GSK-3β (Cell Signalling Technology Inc), anti-GAPDH or anti-CagA (Santa-Cruz Biotechnology) antibodies.

Inhibitor studies

Chemical inhibitors 6 amino-4-(4-phenoxyphenylethylamino) quinazoline (1 μM; NF-κB activation inhibitor, Merck-Millipore), U0126 (10μM; MEK1 inhibitor) and SP600125 (10μM; c-Jun-N-terminal kinase [JNK] inhibitor) were added to epithelial cell monolayers 1 h before and throughout the infection period. Control cells were treated with an equivalent volume of DMSO (inhibitor solvent) alone in the same manner both in the presence and absence of H. pylori infection.

Statistical analysis

Statistical analyses were performed using GraphPad Prism 6.00 (GraphPad Software, California, USA). Means and SDs were used to describe in vitro data and subsequently analysed using Student’s t-test or one-way analysis of variance with Dunnett’s post hoc test for multiple comparisons as appropriate. A p value ≤0.05 was taken to denote statistical significance.

Results

CtkA is variably encoded by the tfs3 ICE

In a previous PCR-based survey, the prevalence of the ctkA gene was found to vary widely in different geographic populations, ranging from 1.5% (Brazil) to 100% (South Africa) [13]. Significant population and regional variation is further suggested here by protein and nucleotide BLASTP/N searches for ctkA sequence in the >500 H. pylori genomes in GenBank, currently identifying a total of only 30 sequences, predominantly in strains originating from Asian (Malaysia, Japan and India) and South American (Colombia and Peru) countries. Sequence conservation between all homologues is high (93–99% identity over the entire sequence) and similarly observed between the H. pylori ctkA and a homologous gene present in two genome sequenced strains of H. cetorum (MIT 99–5656 and MIT 00–7128).

Further examination of the genetic context of ctkA shows it to be located close to xer and virD2 genes towards the end of the tfs3 ICE in H. pylori and both H. cetorum genomes (Fig 1A). However, although consistently located immediately 5’ proximal to the pz36 gene in tfs3 (as assigned in the original annotation of tfs3 from strain PeCan18b, accession number AF487344), the genetic context downstream of ctkA appears more variable; although occurring in addition to the existing complement of tfs3 genes in several strains, most often, the presence of ctkA is coincident with the loss of either pz37 or pz37-39.

thumbnail
Fig 1. Genetic context of ctkA in H. pylori tfs3 ICE gene clusters.

(A) The tfs3 ICE of H. pylori strain PeCan18b. Genes are annotated according to the ‘pz’ gene designation (pz1-41) initially used to describe the tfs3 gene cluster of strain PeCan18b. Corresponding genes in selected reference genomes are provided in S3 Table. vir-homologous genes (virB2-11 [T4SS assembly], virD4, virD2 [relaxase], virC1 [ancillary relaxosome protein]), encoding key components associated with the putative Tfs3 T4SS are coloured red and labelled accordingly. (B) The variable context of ctkA within comparable ends of the tfs3 ICE gene cluster is shown for representative strains with reference to a strain lacking ctkA (PeCan18). Additional ctkA+ strain genomes in GenBank with an equivalent organisation of genes to those shown are indicated in parentheses after the named reference strains and are as follows; CPY1313 (CPY6261, UM038, UM066, UM085, UM370, UM411, FD577, FD703, A-27, L7, 83, 22, J99), OK310 (UM303R/S, BM013A/B, FD506, ML3, 59, F32, UM096), PZ5080 (NQ4076, NQ4099, NQ4200) and SJM180 (Puno135), Puno120, PZ5026 (H-1, H-16, H-18, H-36, P-2, P-26, Aklavik117, Shi112, PeCan4), H. cetorum (strains MIT 00–7128 and MIT 99–5656). NCBI GenBank Accession numbers for strain sequences shown are; PeCan18 (AF487344 and CP00347), CPY1313 (AKNK01), OK310 (AP012601), PZ5080 (ASYV01), SJM180 (CP002073), Puno120 (CP002980), PZ5026 (ASYT01) and Helicobacter cetorum MIT 00–7128 (CP003479).

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0182144.g001

In tfs3 types where pz37-39 are absent, ctkA is arranged in reverse orientation with respect to the tfs3 xer gene, in a position more frequently occupied by homologues of the pz39 gene or more rarely, a gene with homology to the Fic superfamily of encoded proteins (Accession pfma02661, E-value 7.39e-06). This latter includes cell division proteins and components of addiction (toxin/antitoxin) modules involved in prophage/plasmid stability. Whereas ctkA and fic occur rarely in the genomes sequenced to date, the pz39 gene is relatively abundant by comparison (> 100 sequences identified in GenBank by BLASTP) and of the three, seems to be most commonly associated with the tfs3 cluster. Considering this variation, the tfs3 ICE can be broadly classified by ctkA, fic and pz39 presence/absence and genetic disposition into the eight variant types illustrated in Fig 1B.

Although not obviously related, CtkA, PZ39 and Fic notably all share a conserved stretch of 27 residues at the extreme C-terminus of each protein (Fig 2), over which CtkA is 66.7% and 77.8% identical to the equivalent region of PZ39 and Fic respectively. BLASTP of CtkA sequence also identifies Ser/Thr kinase homologues in many other gastrointestinal organisms, including Helicobacter bizzeronii, Enterococcus faecium and Clostridium sp. which share sequence similarity over the entire length of the protein (~50% identity) except for the extreme C-terminal sequence, which is either absent or sequence divergent. This suggests that the C-terminal tail is an acquired feature peculiar to these H. pylori proteins, and by virtue of its sequence conservation, may present a downstream recombination site for generation of some of the observed variation in tfs3 gene content.

thumbnail
Fig 2. Sequence alignments showing conservation of C-terminal sequence between tfs3 ICE-encoded proteins.

Sequence alignment demonstrates conservation in the last 25 C-terminal amino acid residues of CtkA, PZ39 and Fic proteins encoded in tfs3 gene clusters from a representative selection of H. pylori strains.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0182144.g002

CtkA expressed from tfs3+ H. pylori strains induces pro-inflammatory cytokine secretion independently of the Cag type IV secretion system

Given the association of ctkA with the tfs3 ICE (Fig 1), and the evident ability of rCtkA to interact with host immune cells [12, 13], we considered that CtkA might require T4SS components of the tfs3 ICE for its release from H. pylori. As a first step to investigate this, a strategy was developed to enable expression and facile detection of CtkA from tfs3+/cag T4SS–H. pylori strain backgrounds. A requirement for Cag T4SS mutant strains was considered important since the cagPAI-encoded T4SS is well known to stimulate a potent pro-inflammatory cytokine response [3133] which would likely confound assessment of the substantially more modest pro-inflammatory responses previously reported as a consequence of rCtkA interaction [12, 13].

Accordingly, we first examined a selection of H. pylori strains for the presence of tfs3 by PCR typing of eight tfs3 genes located at intervals along the length of the ca. 40kbp tfs3 ICE. Three strains (AB31, AB5, 10A) typed positive for all eight markers suggesting the presence of complete tfs3 gene clusters and one strain was found to lack tfs3 altogether (64) (Table 1). These strains were additionally typed for markers of the tfs4 ICE and cagPAI-encoded T4SSs. ctkA could not be detected in any strain background except for the PCR control strain J99, which is known to contain an extensively rearranged and fragmented mosaic tfs3/4 gene cluster [27, 28].

Next, we generated a construct comprising the H. pylori flaA promotor fused to a 5’-gsk-tagged ctkA sequence amplified from strain J99, cloned adjacent to a kanamycin resistance cassette and flanked by 5’ and 3’ ends of cagE in the pGEMT-Easy cloning vector. Subsequent transformation of the tfs3-typed H. pylori (cagE+) strains with the pGEMcagE::gsk-ctkA-kan plasmid resulted in efficient insertional inactivation of cagE with the ctkA expression cassette in each, enabling constitutive in cis expression of ctkA in single copy with concomitant inactivation of the Cag T4SS. An equivalent set of cagE deletions were also constructed more conventionally by insertional inactivation with the kanamycin resistance cassette alone for use in control studies.

Each of the four GSK-CtkA expressing cagE mutant strains, AB31ΔcagE::gsk-ctkA-kan, AB5ΔcagE::gsk-ctkA-kan, 10AΔcagE::gsk-ctkA-kan and 64ΔcagE::gsk-ctkA-kan were then incubated in co-culture with MKN28 gastric epithelial cell monolayers for 48 h, in parallel with their respective parent strain or cagE isogenic mutants. Subsequent assay of supernatants for IL-8 cytokine secretion showed a trend towards increased levels of IL-8 in response to co-culture with the CtkA-expressing strains compared to the cagE mutants alone in all three tfs3+ strains (Fig 3). However, the difference only reached significance with the AB5 strain pair. IL-8 levels were not observed to increase in the tfs3- strain 64ΔcagE::gsk-ctkA-kan despite broadly equivalent expression of GSK-CtkA.

thumbnail
Fig 3. CtkA expressed from H. pylori stimulates pro-inflammatory cytokine secretion from gastric epithelial cells.

Wild-type H. pylori, cagE-deficient strains and isogenic derivatives constitutively expressing GSK-CtkA were assessed for their ability to induce IL-8 secretion from MKN28 cells in co-culture. Supernatants were sampled 48 h post infection and assayed for IL-8 secretion. In comparison with the parent cagE mutants alone, all tfs3(+) strains expressing GSK-CtkA (AB31, 10A, AB5) showed a trend towards induction of elevated levels of IL-8 when expressing GSK-CtkA, whereas a tfs3(-) strain (64) did not. The difference in levels of induced IL-8 due to GSK-CtkA expression was significant when expressed from strain AB5. Levels of IL-8 attributable to GSK-CtkA were modest relative to cagPAI-mediated responses from all wild-type strains. Graph shows means and SDs from three independent experiments, each performed in triplicate.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0182144.g003

Interestingly, the level of IL-8 secreted in response to infection of gastric epithelial cells with AB5ΔcagE::gsk-ctkA-kan was broadly comparable with levels previously observed from stimulation of immune cells using purified rCtkA [12, 13]. Notably, however, these levels were modest compared with the potent stimulation attributable to the Cag T4SS, which in this study were found to be ~6x higher following infection with the AB5 wildtype (cag+) strain (mean IL-8 concentrations of 3853 pg/mL vs 658 pg/mL for wildtype and cagE mutant respectively). These results indicate that CtkA, when expressed from H. pylori, can stimulate pro-inflammatory cytokine secretion from gastric epithelial cells and that CtkA-mediated induction of IL-8 secretion, although modest, occurs independently of either the Cag or putative Tfs4 T4SS.

CtkA expressed from H. pylori induces IL-8 secretion by activation of NF-κB

Previous studies using both recombinant and transfected CtkA established that induction of cytokine secretion in response to CtkA stimulation is mediated by NF-κB signalling [12]. Since both physical/biochemical properties of CtkA and the manner in which it is presented to a host cell may differ following expression and presumably secretion from a native H. pylori host compared with either transfected or rCtkA expressed and purified from a heterologous host (Escherichia coli), it was important to confirm that the underlying mechanism of host-cell stimulation by both native and recombinant proteins was analogous.

To investigate this, the MKN28 gastric epithelial cell co-culture model was again employed to examine the effect of selective inhibition of signalling pathways in the CtkA-mediated secretion of IL-8. The AB5 strain background was used for these experiments since we had observed a greater effect of GSK-CtkA-mediated induction of IL-8 secretion from this strain compared with other strains (Fig 3) and advantageously, AB5 appeared to also lack components of the Tfs4 T4SS (Table 1), enabling any possible contribution from this related system to be discounted.

Parallel MKN28 co-cultures with the AB5ΔcagE::gsk-ctkA-kan strain were incubated in the presence or absence of specific pharmacologic inhibitors of NF-κB activation and of the MAP kinases MEK1 and JNK. Assessment of IL-8 levels in the supernatants of infected monolayers showed that NF-κB inhibition significantly reduced induction of IL-8 secretion in response to AB5ΔcagE::gsk-ctkA-kan infection, essentially to baseline levels (Fig 4). Conversely, inhibitors of JNK and MEK1 had negligible effects, indicating that pathways involving these kinases, including Toll-like receptor signalling, are not significantly involved in CtkA-mediated IL-8 cytokine responses. These results therefore indicate that H. pylori expressed CtkA engages with host cells to induce pro-inflammatory signalling in a similar manner as rCtkA.

thumbnail
Fig 4. Signalling pathways involved in CtkA-mediated stimulation of IL-8 secretion.

MKN28 cell monolayers remained untreated (-), or were treated with chemical inhibitors for NF-κB (6 amino-4-(4-phenoxyphenylethylamino) quinazoline), JNK (SP600125) and MEK1 (U0126) for 1 h before and during infection with H. pylori strain AB5ΔcagE::gsk-ctkA. IL-8 levels were subsequently assessed by ELISA. Basal levels of IL-8 detected in uninfected supernatants are also indicated for reference (‘Cells’). Graph shows means and SDs from three independent experiments, each performed in triplicate. p values indicate significant differences in the presence of inhibitor compared with infection alone.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0182144.g004

CtkA interaction with gastric epithelial MKN28 cells requires the Tfs3 T4SS

To more formally investigate the role of the putative Tfs3 T4SS in CtkA-mediated pro-inflammatory signalling, we targeted the tfs3-encoded virB9 homologous gene in strain AB5 for insertional inactivation with a chloramphenicol resistance cassette. VirB9 is an essential structural component required for substrate selection and assembly of the T4SS complex [34]. Close examination of the genetic context of the virB9 gene in the genome sequence of strain PeCan18 indicates it to be located centrally within a large putative operon spanning at least genes pz5-pz21 (Fig 1A). As insertional inactivation of virB9 likely evokes polar effects on downstream genes, including others also required for T4SS assembly/activity (virB10, virB11, virD4) the resulting mutant, termed AB5ΔvirB9ΔcagE::gsk-ctkA for brevity, was confidently considered to be entirely abrogated in T4SS function.

Notably, assay of supernatants following co-culture of AB5ΔvirB9ΔcagE::gsk-ctkA with MKN28 cell monolayers as before determined that VirB9/Tfs3 T4SS mutation totally abrogated induction of IL-8 secretion by the AB5ΔvirB9ΔcagE::gsk-ctkA strain (Fig 5A), providing the first indication for involvement of the Tfs3 T4SS in pro-inflammatory signalling by CtkA.

thumbnail
Fig 5. Pro-inflammatory signalling in response to CtkA requires the Tfs3 type IV secretion system and the C-terminus of CtkA.

MKN28 cells were co-cultured with H. pylori AB5ΔcagE derivative strains (MOI = 20) for 48 or 72 h prior to determination of IL-8 concentrations in supernatants by ELISA. Both inactivation of (A) tfs3 virB9 and (B) deletion of the last 23 C-terminal amino acid residues of CtkA in strain AB5ΔcagE::gsk-ctkA(1–906) resulted in abrogation of IL-8 secretion. (C) Similar effects were observed following co-culture of the complement of AB5 strains with gastric AGS cells although IL-8 responses for all strains were markedly lower. Graph shows means and SDs from three independent experiments, each performed in triplicate. p values indicate significant differences in IL-8 levels compared to the AB5ΔcagE::gsk-ctkA strain. (D) Western immunoblot analysis of 100X concentrated supernatants from H. pylori strains AB5ΔcagE, AB5ΔcagE:gsk-ctkA, AB5ΔvirB9ΔcagE:gsk-ctkA and AB5ΔcagE:gsk-ctkA1-906 (Lanes 1–4 respectively) grown in RPMI 1640. Blots were probed with anti-GSK, anti-GAPDH and anti-CagA specific antiserum. Detection of GAPDH and CagA in supernatants indicates non-secretory release of intracellular protein in all strain backgrounds.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0182144.g005

Cell monolayers from these experiments were also assessed for the presence of intracellular/translocated CtkA by immunoblot of lysates with phospho-GSK antibodies as reported previously for CagA (Hohlfeld et al., 2006). However, despite evident host cell interaction by CtkA, host-specific phosphorylation of the GSK tag could not be obviously detected in epithelial cell monolayers infected with the AB5ΔcagE::gsk-ctkA-kan strain, possibly due to low levels of intracellular CtkA protein.

In view of this, we focused on defining other correlates of CtkA export from H. pylori and next considered properties of T4SS secretion substrates that enable their recognition by a cognate T4SS. Many T4SS secreted proteins, including the majority of Agrobacterium tumefaciens T4SS substrates comprise a C-terminal secretion signal characterised by clusters of positively charged residues which are considered to mediate electrostatic contacts with the coupling protein/VirD4 component of the T4SS [3537]. Consistently, CtkA sequence also comprises an equivalent charged cluster (KRRR) in the last four C-terminal residues of the protein similarly shared with both PZ39 and Fic (Fig 2). Therefore, accounting for any possible requirement for broader sequence context, we next generated a mutant CtkA lacking the last 23 C-terminal residues and introduced this into cagE of strain AB5 for in cis expression as before. Subsequent assay of IL-8 secretion from MKN28 monolayers infected with strain AB5ΔcagE::gsk-ctkA1-906 indicated a similar abrogation of IL-8 levels as we observed for the Tfs3 T4SS mutant AB5ΔvirB9ΔcagE::gsk-ctkA strain (Fig 5B), demonstrating the importance of the C-terminal tail for CtkA activity in the context of H. pylori infection. Co-culture of the complement of AB5 wild-type and mutant strains with gastric AGS cells showed similar effects for each strain (Fig 5C) although IL-8 levels for all strains were lower compared with levels observed from MKN28 cells.

Since previous studies had reported dose-dependent induction of both IL-8 and TNF-α secretion from cultured macrophage and mononuclear cells in response to treatment with rCtkA [12, 13] co-culture supernatants were also assayed for the presence of TNF-α. However, in contrast to observations with immune cells, TNF-α could not be detected in supernatants following co-culture of any strain with either MKN28 or AGS cell lines within the detectable limits of the assay (>3 pg/mL).

Finally, to investigate CtkA release independently of the presence of host cells, the complement of AB5ΔcagE::gsk-ctkA strain backgrounds were incubated in RPMI 1640 for 24 h to simulate co-culture growth conditions, then 100X concentrated culture supernatants examined for the presence of GSK-CtkA proteins using anti-GSK antibodies. Surprisingly, GSK-CtkA was apparent in the supernatants of all strains at broadly equivalent levels (Fig 5D, top panel). However, further examination also revealed the presence of both GAPDH and CagA, similarly at roughly equivalent levels in all supernatant samples (Fig 5D, middle and bottom panels). As secretion of CagA is dependent upon the Cag T4SS and host cell contact [6, 7, 38] we conclude that its presence in supernatants, and that of cytosolic GAPDH, is indicative of non-secretory release, due perhaps to either presence of outer membrane vesicles, or a tendency of strain AB5 towards lysis in liquid culture. However, although precluding direct examination of host-cell dependent stimulation of CtkA secretion in the AB5 background, it remains notable that the level of CtkA protein present in supernatants is not sufficient to appreciably stimulate IL-8 secretion from epithelial cells (Fig 5A and 5B). Therefore, supernatant-free CtkA in this assay does not appear to account for the cytokine response observed from co-culture with AB5ΔcagE::gsk-ctkA.

Collectively, these results indicate that both tfs3 ICE-encoded T4SS assembly proteins and C-terminal CtkA sequence may be specifically required for delivery of CtkA to host cells for subsequent interaction and stimulation of CtkA-mediated responses.

Discussion

The tfs3 and tfs4 gene clusters are considered to be self-transmissible integrative and conjugative elements which are variably distributed in diverse H. pylori strains. Although both tfs ICEs comprise a complement of vir-homologous genes encoding likely components of a T4SS, the role of these systems and identification of the proteins they secrete has not been determined. Here, we provide the first evidence of a role for the putative Tfs3 T4SS in promoting host cell interaction of the pro-inflammatory protein CtkA.

The ctkA gene has been identified in several studies as a potential marker of gastroduodenal disease and the encoded product, expressed and purified as recombinant protein from a heterologous host, shown to induce pro-inflammatory cytokine secretion from human macrophage and monocyte cell lines [12, 13]. In this study, we show that CtkA expressed from its native H. pylori host has similar activity as rCtkA, providing important perspective for these previous observations in the context of H. pylori infection. Moreover, this work determines that CtkA activity is similarly directed to gastric epithelial cells and further indicates that native-host expressed CtkA has no apparent species-specific requirement for post-translational modification or assisted structural folding, either through the contribution of a species or T4SS-specific chaperone or the mechanism of CtkA export itself.

Of particular consequence, we demonstrate that induction of CtkA-dependent IL-8 secretion is almost entirely abrogated in the Tfs3 T4SS mutant strain AB5ΔvirB9ΔcagE::gsk-ctkA (Fig 5A). This observation provides the first indication of a functional role for the Tfs3 T4SS as a virulence-associated secretion system and identifies host-interacting CtkA as a putative Tfs3 T4SS effector substrate.

This idea is further supported by the finding that deletion of the C-terminus of CtkA also abolishes the IL-8 phenotype (Fig 5B). Previous work with rCtkA reported that the C-terminal tail of the protein (residues 301–325) was not required for either the ability of rCtkA to translocate across the host plasma membrane or for the subsequent enhancement of NF-κB activity or cytokine secretion [12]. Consequently, the lack of stimulation due to CtkA C-terminal truncation observed in our infection model likely reflects reduced availability of CtkA, which in the context of our collective results, we consider to be consistent with a CtkA-secretion defect.

Our inability to detect host-mediated phosphorylation of the CtkA GSK-tag in infected monolayers, in spite of highly reproducible, albeit modest, pro-inflammatory stimulation by CtkA, was initially puzzling. However, the limited pro-inflammatory responses that we observe may be indicative of a general low abundance of intracellular CtkA, possibly due to an unknown deficiency in our experimental model or as a reflection of actual, physiologically low levels of CtkA which relate to the role of CtkA in H. pylori infection.

Paradoxically, whereas non-secretory CtkA is present at various levels in the supernatants of all strains examined, the cell-free released protein appears insufficient to stimulate epithelial cells in co-culture (Fig 5). This is in apparent contrast to observations with rCtkA [12, 13]. However, these latter studies observed cytokine effects from co-culture with PBMCs and differentiated Thp1 macrophage-like cells rather than gastric epithelial cells, and effects were most readily detected using concentrations of rCtkA upwards of 0.5μg ml-1 of protein, which is likely to be far in excess of the levels of native protein released into supernatants from H. pylori in our experiments. Regardless, that CtkA free in the supernatant does not significantly stimulate IL-8 secretion from MKN28 cells in co-culture further emphasises a requirement for the Tfs3 T4SS and importantly suggests that CtkA secretion occurs closely proximal to the host cell rather than freely into the surrounding medium. Presumably, the levels of IL-8 attributable to CtkA we observe in the presence of H. pylori reflects a dose-dependent delivery of CtkA, although whether this is achieved by CtkA export to the surface of either the attached bacterial or host cell, or directly to the host cytoplasm is presently undetermined. However, as previous studies have clearly indicated an ability of rCtkA to self-translocate across the host plasma membrane [12], it seems reasonable that Tfs3 T4SSmediated delivery of CtkA to the host cell surface would be sufficient for promotion of subsequent CtkA activities.

We have shown in this study that the C-terminal sequence of the CtkA protein potentially comprises a signal for T4SS-mediated secretion. T4SS secretion signals are invariably located at the extreme C-terminus of the secretion substrate. This is the case for the H. pylori CagA protein [39] and numerous secretion substrates of the archetypal A. tumefaciens Vir T4SS [37]. Whereas the secretion signal remains largely indistinct, the C-terminal sequence of all these proteins tend to share a charge bias of positive residues, commonly require a hydrophobic or proline residue in the -3 or -4 position relative to the terminal amino acid, and are predicted to lack structure [3537, 40, 41]. These features are considered to facilitate solvent accessibility of the C-terminus, enabling its productive interaction with the VirD4 type IV coupling protein (T4CP) receptor via charged amino acid contacts [37]. Notably, these features are all evident in the conserved C-terminal sequence of CtkA, which displays both a bias of positively-charged amino acids (KRRR) and a proline residue, albeit in the -5 position (Fig 2). Furthermore, the crystal structure of CtkA is C-terminally truncated due to lack of electron density in the last 25 residues, consistent with secondary structure prediction indicating that this region of CtkA is intrinsically disordered. As the characteristic C-terminal signal sequence is absent from homologous Ser/Thr kinases from other gastrointestinal bacteria, we speculate that it may be an acquired feature that confers secretion competence, thereby marking CtkA for recognition as a T4SS secretion substrate. Other tfs3-encoded proteins PZ39 and Fic which also share conserved C-terminal sequence (Fig 2) may similarly be highlighted as candidate secretion substrates, although a role for these proteins in host interaction and virulence has yet to be explored.

The repertoire of proteins secreted by a particular pathogen significantly contributes to the nature and outcome of its interaction with a host. Many studies indicate that H. pylori strains encoding the VirB4 (i.e. DupA) component of the Tfs4 T4SS, and most likely the Tfs4 T4SS itself, are more strongly associated with a risk of duodenal ulcer disease [25]. However, no equivalent studies to our awareness have overtly reported the disease association of tfs3 virB4 or any other (vir gene) marker of the Tfs3 T4SS, although several have reported an association of ctkA with increased or decreased risk of gastroduodenal disease in some populations [14, 16, 18, 19]. Of these, the study of Occhialini et al [14] indicated an association of ctkA (jhp0940) with strains isolated from gastric cancer patients, where 42% of strains encoded jhp0940 compared with none of the gastritis isolates. Advantageously, their data also included the distribution of several other tfs3 genes including jhp0937 encoding the putative Tfs3 VirB6 protein (S3 Table), which, as a likely component required for T4SS assembly can be considered a marker for the Tfs3 T4SS. Re-examination of the data finds jhp0937 present in 70.5% of gastric cancer isolates compared with 48% of gastritis isolates and significantly, all but one of the isolates which also encoded CtkA. There is therefore some suggestion that the presence of the Tfs3 T4SS also correlates with an increased risk for gastroduodenal disease in certain populations, and certainly those in which CtkA appears important for disease risk. In view of this and our collective findings, it would be relevant to examine the distribution of a broader subset of tfs3 genes in different patient populations to more definitively assess the importance of the Tfs3 T4SS and the proteins it secretes in defining the virulence potential of particular H. pylori strains.

Acknowledgments

This work was supported by the Medical Research Council [grant number G0901104] (https://www.mrc.ac.uk/) to RMD. We thank members of the Helicobacter Research Group, Nottingham for helpful discussions and comments during this study.

References

  1. 1. Blaser MJ, Atherton JC. Helicobacter pylori persistence: biology and disease. J Clin Invest. 2004; 113(3): 321–33. pmid:14755326
  2. 2. Blaser MJ, Perez-Perez GI, Kleanthous H, Cover TL, Peek RM, Chyou PH, et al. Infection with Helicobacter pylori strains possessing cagA is associated with an increased risk of developing adenocarcinoma of the stomach. Cancer Res. 1995; 55(10): 2111–5. pmid:7743510
  3. 3. Houghton J, Wang TC. Helicobacter pylori and gastric cancer: a new paradigm for inflammation-associated epithelial cancers. Gastroenterology. 2005; 128(6): 1567–78. S0016508505004634. pmid:15887152
  4. 4. Bridge DR, Merrell DS. Polymorphism in the Helicobacter pylori CagA and VacA toxins and disease. Gut Microbes. 2013; 4(2): 101–17. pmid:23380646
  5. 5. Censini S, Lange C, Xiang Z, Crabtree JE, Ghiara P, Borodovsky M, et al. cag, a pathogenicity island of Helicobacter pylori, encodes type I-specific and disease-associated virulence factors. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 1996; 93(25): 14648–53. pmid:8962108
  6. 6. Odenbreit S, Puls J, Sedlmaier B, Gerland E, Fischer W, Haas R. Translocation of Helicobacter pylori CagA into gastric epithelial cells by type IV secretion. Science. 2000; 287(5457): 1497–500. pmid:10688800
  7. 7. Stein M, Rappuoli R, Covacci A. Tyrosine phosphorylation of the Helicobacter pylori CagA antigen after cag-driven host cell translocation. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2000; 97(3): 1263–8. pmid:10655519
  8. 8. Kwok T, Zabler D, Urman S, Rohde M, Hartig R, Wessler S, et al. Helicobacter exploits integrin for type IV secretion and kinase activation. Nature. 2007; 449(7164): 862–6. pmid:17943123
  9. 9. Ilver D, Arnqvist A, Ogren J, Frick IM, Kersulyte D, Incecik ET, et al. Helicobacter pylori adhesin binding fucosylated histo-blood group antigens revealed by retagging. Science. 1998; 279(5349): 373–7. pmid:9430586
  10. 10. Mahdavi J, Sonden B, Hurtig M, Olfat FO, Forsberg L, Roche N, et al. Helicobacter pylori SabA adhesin in persistent infection and chronic inflammation. Science. 2002; 297(5581): 573–8. pmid:12142529
  11. 11. Suganuma M, Kurusu M, Suzuki K, Nishizono A, Murakami K, Fujioka T, et al. New tumor necrosis factor-alpha-inducing protein released from Helicobacter pylori for gastric cancer progression. J Cancer Res Clin Oncol. 2005; 131(5): 305–13. pmid:15616827
  12. 12. Kim do J, Park KS, Kim JH, Yang SH, Yoon JY, Han BG, et al. Helicobacter pylori proinflammatory protein up-regulates NF-kappaB as a cell-translocating Ser/Thr kinase. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2010; 107(50): 21418–23. pmid:21098302
  13. 13. Rizwan M, Alvi A, Ahmed N. Novel protein antigen (JHP940) from the genomic plasticity region of Helicobacter pylori induces tumor necrosis factor alpha and interleukin-8 secretion by human macrophages. J Bacteriol. 2008; 190(3): 1146–51. pmid:17993522
  14. 14. Occhialini A, Marais A, Alm R, Garcia F, Sierra R, Megraud F. Distribution of open reading frames of plasticity region of strain J99 in Helicobacter pylori strains isolated from gastric carcinoma and gastritis patients in Costa Rica. Infect Immun. 2000; 68(11): 6240–9. pmid:11035731
  15. 15. Santos A, Queiroz DM, Menard A, Marais A, Rocha GA, Oliveira CA, et al. New pathogenicity marker found in the plasticity region of the Helicobacter pylori genome. J Clin Microbiol. 2003; 41(4): 1651–5. pmid:12682156
  16. 16. Romo-Gonzalez C, Salama NR, Burgeno-Ferreira J, Ponce-Castaneda V, Lazcano-Ponce E, Camorlinga-Ponce M, et al. Differences in genome content among Helicobacter pylori isolates from patients with gastritis, duodenal ulcer, or gastric cancer reveal novel disease-associated genes. Infect Immun. 2009; 77(5): 2201–11. pmid:19237517
  17. 17. Alvi A, Ansari SA, Ehtesham NZ, Rizwan M, Devi S, Sechi LA, et al. Concurrent proinflammatory and apoptotic activity of a Helicobacter pylori protein (HP986) points to its role in chronic persistence. PLoS One. 2011; 6(7): e22530. pmid:21789261
  18. 18. Yakoob J, Abbas Z, Naz S, Islam M, Abid S, Jafri W. Associations between the Plasticity Region Genes of Helicobacter pylori and Gastroduodenal Diseases in a High-Prevalence Area. Gut Liver. 2010; 4(3): 345–50. pmid:20981211
  19. 19. Sugimoto M, Watada M, Jung SW, Graham DY, Yamaoka Y. Role of Helicobacter pylori plasticity region genes in development of gastroduodenal diseases. J Clin Microbiol. 2012; 50(2): 441–8. pmid:22116145
  20. 20. Graham JE, Peek RM Jr., Krishna U, Cover TL. Global analysis of Helicobacter pylori gene expression in human gastric mucosa. Gastroenterology. 2002; 123(5): 1637–48. S0016508502002974. pmid:12404238
  21. 21. Tenguria S, Ansari SA, Khan N, Ranjan A, Devi S, Tegtmeyer N, et al. Helicobacter pylori cell translocating kinase (CtkA/JHP0940) is pro-apoptotic in mouse macrophages and acts as auto-phosphorylating tyrosine kinase. Int J Med Microbiol. 2014; 304(8): 1066–76. pmid:25172221
  22. 22. Kersulyte D, Velapatino B, Mukhopadhyay AK, Cahuayme L, Bussalleu A, Combe J, et al. Cluster of type IV secretion genes in Helicobacter pylori's plasticity zone. J Bacteriol. 2003; 185(13): 3764–72. pmid:12813069
  23. 23. Kersulyte D, Lee W, Subramaniam D, Anant S, Herrera P, Cabrera L, et al. Helicobacter pylori's plasticity zones are novel transposable elements. PLoS One. 2009; 4(9): e6859. pmid:19727398
  24. 24. Fischer W, Windhager L, Rohrer S, Zeiller M, Karnholz A, Hoffmann R, et al. Strain-specific genes of Helicobacter pylori: genome evolution driven by a novel type IV secretion system and genomic island transfer. Nucleic Acids Res. 2010; 38(18): 6089–101. pmid:20478826
  25. 25. Shiota S, Matsunari O, Watada M, Hanada K, Yamaoka Y. Systematic review and meta-analysis: the relationship between the Helicobacter pylori dupA gene and clinical outcomes. Gut Pathog. 2010; 2(1): 13. pmid:21040520
  26. 26. Lu H, Hsu PI, Graham DY, Yamaoka Y. Duodenal ulcer promoting gene of Helicobacter pylori. Gastroenterology. 2005; 128(4): 833–48. S0016508505000296. pmid:15825067
  27. 27. Grove JI, Alandiyjany MN, Delahay RM. Site-specific relaxase activity of a VirD2-like protein encoded within the tfs4 genomic island of Helicobacter pylori. J Biol Chem. 2013; 288(37): 26385–96. pmid:23900838
  28. 28. Fischer W, Breithaupt U, Kern B, Smith SI, Spicher C, Haas R. A comprehensive analysis of Helicobacter pylori plasticity zones reveals that they are integrating conjugative elements with intermediate integration specificity. BMC Genomics. 2014; 15: 310. pmid:24767410
  29. 29. Yokozaki H. Molecular characteristics of eight gastric cancer cell lines established in Japan. Pathol Int. 2000; 50(10): 767–77. pmid:11107048
  30. 30. Cook KW, Letley DP, Ingram RJ, Staples E, Skjoldmose H, Atherton JC, et al. CCL20/CCR6-mediated migration of regulatory T cells to the Helicobacter pylori-infected human gastric mucosa. Gut. 2014; 63(10): 1550–9. pmid:24436142
  31. 31. Gorrell RJ, Guan J, Xin Y, Tafreshi MA, Hutton ML, McGuckin MA, et al. A novel NOD1- and CagA-independent pathway of interleukin-8 induction mediated by the Helicobacter pylori type IV secretion system. Cell Microbiol. 2012; 15(4): 554–70. pmid:23107019
  32. 32. Brandt S, Kwok T, Hartig R, Konig W, Backert S. NF-kappaB activation and potentiation of proinflammatory responses by the Helicobacter pylori CagA protein. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2005; 102(26): 9300–5. pmid:15972330
  33. 33. Viala J, Chaput C, Boneca IG, Cardona A, Girardin SE, Moran AP, et al. Nod1 responds to peptidoglycan delivered by the Helicobacter pylori cag pathogenicity island. Nat Immunol. 2004; 5(11): 1166–74. pmid:15489856
  34. 34. Jakubowski SJ, Cascales E, Krishnamoorthy V, Christie PJ. Agrobacterium tumefaciens VirB9, an outer-membrane-associated component of a type IV secretion system, regulates substrate selection and T-pilus biogenesis. J Bacteriol. 2005; 187(10): 3486–95. pmid:15866936
  35. 35. Simone M, McCullen CA, Stahl LE, Binns AN. The carboxy-terminus of VirE2 from Agrobacterium tumefaciens is required for its transport to host cells by the virB-encoded type IV transport system. Mol Microbiol. 2001; 41(6): 1283–93. pmid:11580834
  36. 36. Vergunst AC, van Lier MC, den Dulk-Ras A, Stuve TA, Ouwehand A, Hooykaas PJ. Positive charge is an important feature of the C-terminal transport signal of the VirB/D4-translocated proteins of Agrobacterium. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2005; 102(3): 832–7. pmid:15644442
  37. 37. Christie PJ. Type IV secretion: the Agrobacterium VirB/D4 and related conjugation systems. Biochim Biophys Acta. 2004; 1694(1–3): 219–34. pmid:15546668
  38. 38. Fischer W, Puls J, Buhrdorf R, Gebert B, Odenbreit S, Haas R. Systematic mutagenesis of the Helicobacter pylori cag pathogenicity island: essential genes for CagA translocation in host cells and induction of interleukin-8. Mol Microbiol. 2001; 42(5): 1337–48. pmid:11886563
  39. 39. Hohlfeld S, Pattis I, Puls J, Plano GV, Haas R, Fischer W. A C-terminal translocation signal is necessary, but not sufficient for type IV secretion of the Helicobacter pylori CagA protein. Mol Microbiol. 2006; 59(5): 1624–37. pmid:16469000
  40. 40. Atmakuri K, Ding Z, Christie PJ. VirE2, a type IV secretion substrate, interacts with the VirD4 transfer protein at cell poles of Agrobacterium tumefaciens. Mol Microbiol. 2003; 49(6): 1699–713. pmid:12950931
  41. 41. Alvarez-Martinez CE, Christie PJ. Biological diversity of prokaryotic type IV secretion systems. Microbiol Mol Biol Rev. 2009; 73(4): 775–808. pmid:19946141