African Americans have higher rates of asthma prevalence, morbidity, and mortality in comparison with other racial groups. We sought to characterize endotypes of childhood asthma severity in African American patients in an inner-city pediatric asthma population. Baseline blood neutrophils, blood eosinophils, and 38 serum cytokine levels were measured in a sample of 235 asthmatic children (6–17 years) enrolled in the NIAID (National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases)-sponsored Asthma Phenotypes in the Inner City (APIC) study (ICAC (Inner City Asthma Consortium)-19). Cytokines were quantified using a MILLIPLEX panel and analyzed on a Luminex analyzer. Patients were classified as Easy-to-Control or Difficult-to-Control based on the required dose of controller medications over one year of prospective management. A multivariate variable selection procedure was used to select cytokines associated with Difficult-to-Control versus Easy-to-Control asthma, adjusting for age, sex, blood eosinophils, and blood neutrophils. In inner-city African American children, 12 cytokines were significant predictors of Difficult-to-Control asthma (n = 235). CXCL-1, IL-5, IL-8, and IL-17A were positively associated with Difficult-to-Control asthma, while IL-4 and IL-13 were positively associated with Easy-to-Control asthma. Using likelihood ratio testing, it was observed that in addition to blood eosinophils and neutrophils, serum cytokines improved the fit of the model. In an inner-city pediatric population, serum cytokines significantly contributed to the definition of Difficult-to-Control asthma endotypes in African American children. Mixed responses characterized by TH2 (IL-5) and TH17-associated cytokines were associated with Difficult-to-Control asthma. Collectively, these data may contribute to risk stratification of Difficult-to-Control asthma in the African American population.
Citation: Brown KR, Krouse RZ, Calatroni A, Visness CM, Sivaprasad U, Kercsmar CM, et al. (2017) Endotypes of difficult-to-control asthma in inner-city African American children. PLoS ONE 12(7): e0180778. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0180778
Editor: Heinz Fehrenbach, Forschungszentrum Borstel Leibniz-Zentrum fur Medizin und Biowissenschaften, GERMANY
Received: January 13, 2017; Accepted: June 21, 2017; Published: July 7, 2017
This is an open access article, free of all copyright, and may be freely reproduced, distributed, transmitted, modified, built upon, or otherwise used by anyone for any lawful purpose. The work is made available under the Creative Commons CC0 public domain dedication.
Data Availability: Data are from the Asthma Phenotypes in the Inner City (APIC) study (ICAC-19). The analysis data to reproduce the cytokine-related results of the manuscript is provided within the paper and its Supporting Information files.
Funding: This project has been funded with Federal funds from the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases (www.niaid.nih.gov), National Institutes of Health (www.nih.gov), Department of Health and Human Services (www.hhs.gov), under contract numbers HHSN272200900052C and HHSN272201000052I, 1UM1AI114271-01 and UM2AI117870. Additional support was provided by the National Center for Research Resources (www.ncrr.nih.gov), and National Center for Advancing Translational Sciences (https://ncats.nih.gov), National Institutes of Health, under grants NCRR/NIH UL1TR000451, UL1RR025780, UL1TR000075, NCATS/NIH UL1TR001079, NCATS/NIH UL1TR000154, UL1TR001082, UL1TR000077-04, UL1TR000040, UL1TR000150, and UL1TR001105. Glaxo SmithKline (GSK) (www.gsk.com) provided Ventolin, Flovent, Advair and Flonase under a clinical trial agreement with NIH NIAID. This research was supported in part by the Cincinnati Children’s Research Foundation and the Cincinnati Biobank, as well as the Better Outcomes for Children Biorepository. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: Glaxo SmithKline (GSK) (www.gsk.com) provided Ventolin, Flovent, Advair and Flonase under a clinical trial agreement with NIH NIAID. There are no patents, products in development or marketed products to declare. This does not alter the authors' adherence to all the PLOS ONE policies on sharing data and materials.
Asthma is a heterogeneous disease comprised of varying clinical, cellular, and molecular phenotypes. Cluster analyses of well-characterized asthma cohorts have identified several distinct clinical phenotypes in adults and children, but they have limited ability to improve management or guide treatment choices because the phenotypes often overlap and do not necessarily relate to specific underlying pathophysiologic mechanisms[2–4]. Further, although cluster studies have identified distinct molecular phenotypes of severe asthma, these phenotypes have not proven to vary by race despite the differing clinical phenotypes. Recently, it has been suggested that the asthma burden seen in urban US populations may be largely explained by demographic factors such as race rather than by environmental factors secondary to living in an urban location[5, 6]. Accordingly, a comparable prevalence of asthma was found in urban and rural populations of African Americans teenagers. African Americans have higher rates of asthma prevalence, morbidity, and mortality in comparison with other racial groups in America[8–10]. It has been suggested that this racial disparity cannot be explained solely by socioeconomic or environmental factors with black race being reported as an independent risk factor for asthma[11, 12]. Collectively, these findings suggest that immunologic profiles that characterize asthma in African Americans may predispose to more severe or difficult to control phenotypes. Interestingly, higher TH17 activation was reported in Asians versus European Americans with atopic dermatitis, suggesting a racial difference in immunologic mechanisms of disease.
The Asthma Phenotypes in Children (APIC) Study, which was conducted by the NIAID-funded Inner City Asthma Consortium, offered us an opportunity to specifically characterize asthma immunophenotypes in African American children as 64% of APIC participants are African American. Towards this goal, we characterized serum cytokine profiles in a subset of 235 children out of the 717 children (33%) enrolled in APIC. Our findings indicate that serum cytokine concentrations, in addition to blood neutrophils and eosinophils, may be helpful in defining Difficult-to-Control asthma endotypes in African American inner-city children.
IRB approval was obtained from the following institutions: Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, Department of Pediatrics, Baltimore, MD; Boston University School of Medicine, Boston, MA; Ann and Robert H. Lurie Children's Hospital of Chicago, Chicago, IL; Cincinnati Children's Hospital Medical Center, Department of Pediatrics, University of Cincinnati, Cincinnati, OH; University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center, Dallas, TX; National Jewish Health, Denver, CO, and Children's Hospital Colorado and University of Colorado School of Medicine, Aurora, CO; Henry Ford Health System, Detroit, MI; College of Physicians and Surgeons, Columbia University, New York, NY; and Children's National Health System, Washington, DC. Written informed consent was obtained from the parent or legal guardian of each child. The subjects included in this study were enrolled in the APIC Study which is an epidemiologic, multi-center, longitudinal study designed to define phenotypic characteristics of Difficult-to-Control asthma among children receiving one year of guideline-based therapy for asthma and rhinitis/rhinosinusitis. A detailed description of study methods including recruitment, enrollment, and data collection (skin testing, spirometry, and exhaled nitric oxide) is described in the primary manuscript for the APIC study. Seven hundred and seventeen subjects from 9 clinical sites (Baltimore MD, Boston MA, Chicago IL, Cincinnati OH, Dallas TX, Denver CO, Detroit MI, New York NY, Washington DC) were enrolled in APIC. Study approval was granted by each center’s Institutional Review Board. Enrolled children were between the ages of 6 to 17 years with physician-diagnosed asthma. Participants were required to report 2 or more episodes of short-acting beta-agonist administration within the 12 months prior to the screening visit (exclusive of exercise-induced symptom use), have insurance coverage, and reside in a pre-selected urban recruitment census to qualify for entry into the study. Only participants who identified as non-Hispanic African American were included in this analysis and 235 subjects were enrolled as suggested by sample size calculations necessary for statistical power of at least 90% based on our previously published results. Comparative data for other races were not included because, of the remaining 129 subjects, only 6 subjects were non-Hispanic white, 17 were of other or mixed race, and 106 were Hispanic with race unidentified.
Protocol-defined asthma and rhinitis management was started at the time of screening. Asthma and rhinitis treatment algorithms were based on the NAEPP Expert Panel Report-3 (EPR-3) and the Rhinitis and its Impact on Asthma (ARIA) 2008 guidelines[16, 17]. Based on study treatment guidelines for asthma and rhinitis, patients were provided with prescribed medications (Flovent® Diskus® (fluticasone), Advair™ Diskus (fluticasone propionate, salmeterol), Ventolin® HFA (albuterol), Flonase® Nasal Spray (fluticasone), cetirizine, montelukast). Demonstration of medication adherence was required for study enrollment and was assessed at the enrollment visit following a 4-week run-in period. Subsequently, asthma control was evaluated at 6 clinical study visits at 2-month intervals at which time clinicians prescribed medications based on the level of asthma control and medication compliance over the previous two months. Asthma control was assessed based on asthma symptoms, albuterol use, use of systemic corticosteroids, FEV1 (forced expiratory volume), and current asthma therapy. Classification of subjects occurred following the last study visit. Participants requiring ≤ 50 mcg twice daily of fluticasone, montelukast only, or needing no controller medication at four or more of the six post-baseline study visits, were classified as having Easy-to-Control asthma. Children requiring ≥ 250 mcg twice daily of fluticasone at four or more of six post-baseline study visits were classified as Difficult-to-Control asthma. Children who did not fall into either classification were considered indeterminate and were not included in the analysis.
Of the 717 subjects enrolled in APIC, 510 randomly selected subjects had blood analyzed for cytokines. Of these 510 subjects, 502 had complete data for demographics, blood eosinophils, blood neutrophils, and serum cytokines. Less than 4 baseline visits were done in 38 patients and an additional 100 patients were excluded from our analysis as their treatment classification was indeterminate. Out of these 364 subjects, 235 were African American, of which 108 subjects were classified as Easy-to-Control and 127 subjects were classified as Difficult-to-Control.
Blood collection and analysis
Whole blood was collected by venipuncture at the enrollment visit. Blood for cytokine analysis was collected into serum separator tubes and centrifuged and aliquoted into cryovials following a standard protocol during or immediately following the study visit. Serum aliquots were frozen and stored at -80°C pending shipment to the biorepository and subsequently to the analyzing laboratory. As freeze-thaw cycles can alter cytokine measures, samples in our analysis were not freeze-thawed. Total numbers of eosinophils and neutrophils were determined by the product of the differential and total cell count. Using 25 μL of participant serum, cytokines were quantified according to the manufacturer’s instructions using a premixed 38 Plex MILLIPLEX MAP Human Cytokine/Chemokine Magnetic Bead Panel (Millipore Corporation, Billerica, MA) and analyzed on a Luminex 100/200 analyzer (BioRad, Hercules, CA). Serum cytokine concentrations were determined using Bio-plex 6.1 software (BioRad, Hercules, CA). A similar approach for analyzing cytokines in BAL (bronchoalveolar lavage) fluid from asthmatics has been used previously. Cytokines included in the analysis are listed in S1 Table.
As shown in S1 Fig, cytokine replicate pairs had a good agreement and were averaged to produce a single result for analysis. Cytokine values were skewed based on a diagnostic plot (S2 Fig) and the result of a Shapiro-Wilk test and were, therefore, log-transformed for statistical tests and models. For analysis purposes, results below detection were assigned a value of the lower limit of detection divided by the square root of 2, and results above detection were assigned a value equal to the upper limit of detection.Overall, 22% of cytokine values were below the lower limit of detection and 2% were above the upper limit of detection. The percentage of values above the lower limit of detection by inflammatory marker is displayed in S1 Table and S2 Fig.
To compare differences in baseline characteristics and demographics between Difficult-to-Control and Easy-to-Control asthma, chi-square or Fisher exact tests were used for categorical variables, and t-tests or Wilcoxon tests were used for normally distributed and non-normally distributed continuous variables, respectively. Normality of baseline characteristics and demographics was determined by assessing the skewness of variables. Univariate logistic regression was used to estimate the association with Difficult-to-Control asthma for blood eosinophils, neutrophils, and each of the 38 cytokines. Due to the exploratory nature of the analysis, no attempts were made to adjust for multiple comparisons.
Logistic models were fit using Difficult-to-Control versus Easy-to-Control as the outcome and demographics, blood eosinophils, blood neutrophils, and/or cytokines as covariates. Nested models were compared using likelihood ratio testing, which compares the goodness of fit of two models. The glmnet procedure was used to fit a multiple logistic regression model with an elastic-net penalty, which is a combination of lasso and ridge regression penalties. This technique is particularly efficient for feature selection in data with collinearity and/or many features, in order to select the most relevant cytokines for distinguishing Easy-to-Control versus Difficult-to-Control asthma after adjusting for age, sex, blood eosinophils, and blood neutrophils[21, 22]. Adjustments were performed by including the listed variables in the model, so that the relationships between cytokines and Difficult-to-control asthma were free of confounding. Repeated 10-fold cross validation was used to prevent overfitting and select the best penalty parameters. R version 3.3.3 was used for analyses.
Demographic and baseline characteristics of study population
The African American children included in this study were a randomly selected subset of subjects in the APIC study conducted by the Inner City Asthma Consortium (ICAC). Demographic data from the 235 children comprising our study subset were compared to the entire African American APIC population (N = 311) and no significant differences were observed (data included in S2 Table). Demographic features and baseline characteristics were compared between the Difficult-to-Control and Easy-to-Control populations in our analysis population (Table 1). When compared to Easy-to-Control, Difficult-to-Control participants reported use of more asthma controller medications (p<0.001), had higher rates of oral corticosteroid courses for asthma (p<0.0001), higher total serum IgE (p = 0.004), and lower FEV1 (p<0.001) and FEV1/FVC (p<0.001) at study entry. Difficult-to-Control participants were more likely to have allergic rhinitis (p<0.001) as well as aeroallergen (p = 0.005) sensitization at study entry. No differences were observed between the Easy-to-Control and Difficult-to-Control groups with regards to sex, age, income, BMI (body mass index) percentile, family history of asthma, age at asthma diagnosis, personal diagnosis of eczema, asthma-related hospitalizations, FeNO (fractional exhaled nitric oxide), or food sensitization.
Blood concentrations of eosinophils and neutrophils differ by treatment classification
Children with Difficult-to-Control asthma had higher numbers of blood eosinophils (p = 0.02) and neutrophils (p = 0.02) (Table 2) when compared to children with Easy-to-Control asthma. There was no correlation between eosinophil and neutrophil counts. The probability of Difficult-to-Control asthma was greater as blood eosinophil and neutrophil concentrations increased (Fig 1). Since systemic corticosteroids can alter blood neutrophil and eosinophil counts, we examined corticosteroid use among participants. Seven percent of subjects received an oral corticosteroid course in the month prior to their blood draw. Receiving an oral corticosteroid course in the month prior to the blood draw was not associated with significantly elevated or lower neutrophil
Graphical representation of blood eosinophil and neutrophil concentrations and the probability of Difficult-to-Control asthma. Values from all 235 subjects in the analysis are included. The blood neutrophil and eosinophil counts were not correlated in this population (Pearson correlation = 0.11, p = 0.11).
Serum cytokine concentrations differ by treatment classification
IL-12p40 (p = 0.005), IL-13 (p = 0.04), IL-1β (p = 0.02), and IL-4 (p = 0.03) were increased in those with Easy-to-Control asthma (Table 3). No cytokines were positively associated with Difficult-to-Control asthma. A multivariate feature selection procedure was used to determine which cytokines were most predictive of Difficult-to-Control versus Easy-to-Control asthma (Table 4). IL-5, IFN-γ (interferon gamma) and TH17 (CXCL-1, IL-17A, IL-8) associated cytokines were positively associated with Difficult-to-Control asthma; while EGF (epidermal growth factor), eotaxin, IL-lβ, IL-4, IL-12p40, IL-13, and MDC (macrophage-derived chemokine) were positively associated with Easy-to-Control asthma.
Definition of Difficult-to-Control childhood asthma endotypes using blood eosinophils, neutrophils, and serum cytokines
To ascertain whether cytokines bring added value to the definition of the Difficult-to-Control childhood asthma endotype in our African American cohort, models with the outcome of Difficult-to-Control asthma were compared using likelihood ratio tests (Table 5). Age, sex, blood eosinophils, and neutrophils, and/or selected serum cytokines were included in all models. Cytokines selected by the multivariate feature selection procedure were the only cytokines included in the models. The model including only demographics was not significantly different than the null model. The addition of blood eosinophils and neutrophils significantly improved the fit of the model (p = 0.006). The addition of selected cytokines further improved the fit of the model when compared to the model containing only demographics and blood eosinophils and neutrophils (p<0.001). Thus the addition of CXCL-1, IFN-γ, IL-5, IL-17A, EGF, eotaxin, IL-lβ, IL-4, IL-12p40, IL-13, and MDC serum concentrations to blood eosinophils and neutrophils adds significant value to the definition of the Difficult-to-Control asthma endotype.
Despite the strong racial disparities observed in asthma morbidity, previous studies have not characterized immunophenotypes of Difficult-to-Control asthma in African American children[23, 24]. We found that although blood eosinophils and neutrophils were useful biomarkers of Difficult-to-Control asthma, serum cytokines significantly enhanced the definition of Difficult-to-Control asthma. Mixed responses characterized by IL-5 and IL-17 upregulation were associated with Difficult-to-Control disease while IL-4 and IL-13 were associated with Easy-to-Control asthma. This data may contribute to the ability to risk stratify this population of Difficult-to-Control asthmatics. These findings may have important treatment implications as they suggest consideration of the use of biologics to target multiple inflammatory pathways in African American children with Difficult-to-Control asthma.
Increased eosinophils or neutrophils have been reported in sputum of severe and poorly controlled asthmatics[25, 26] and increased blood neutrophils and eosinophils have been associated with severe asthma in children. Similarly, we found increased blood neutrophils and eosinophils in the Difficult-to-Control population.
Difficult-to-Control asthma was positively associated with cytokines/chemokines (CXCL-1, IL-17A, and IL-8) previously described to be associated with neutrophilic inflammation. Association of increased IL-8 with severe asthma has previously been reported in adults and children[19, 26, 28]. Previous analysis of airway secretion samples from predominantly African American children with asthma showed that, in addition to other cytokines and chemokines, Differential CXCL-1 and IL-8 concentrations characterized severe compared to moderate asthma. Increased IL-17A has been implicated in severe asthma by prior studies[29, 30].
Traditionally, TH2-associated inflammation has been implicated in the pathogenesis of asthma . In our study, IL-4 and IL-13 were positively associated with Easy-to-Control asthma. Primarily TH2-associated asthma is generally glucocorticoid responsive, while TH2/TH17 predominant asthma may be resistant to corticosteroid treatment[32, 33]. In our population, Difficult-to-Control asthma was positively associated with a combination of TH2 and TH17-associated inflammatory markers. TH17 inflammation has been associated with neutrophilic inflammation and corticosteroid unresponsive asthma[30, 34]. Recent data from our group and others suggests that this may actually be due to a unique population of cells that co-produce TH2 and TH17 cytokines[15, 33, 35]. Brandt et al. reported the presence of IL-13+IL-17A+ double producing T-cells in the lungs of mice co-exposed to house dust mite and diesel exhaust particles. Studies have implicated dual-positive TH2/TH17 cells in steroid resistant asthma. Irvin et al. analyzed the infiltrating T helper cells in the BAL fluid from asthmatic patients and assessed their response to steroid treatment in vitro. They found that dual-positive TH2/TH17 (IL-4+/IL-17+) cells and IL-17A were present at a higher frequency in the BALF from steroid-resistant asthmatic patients. These TH2/TH17 cells were resistant to DEX (dexamethasone)-induced cell death during an in vitro incubation and the TH2/TH17 predominant subgroup of patients manifested the most severe form of asthma. We found an association between IL-17 and IL-5 with difficult-to-control asthma, in comparison to previous studies which report IL-4+IL-17+ or IL-13IL-17+ T-cell populations. TH2 cells are classically regarded as a homogenous population, however, multiple recent studies have challenged this notion. Notably, the only partial overlap between IL-4+ and IL-5+ cells was observed in CD4+163- cells from BAL of asthmatics in the study by Irvin et al. This suggests there is some degree of nonsynchronous production of TH2 cytokines in T-cell populations, which may in part explain our TH2-asscoiated cytokine findings. Further, pathogenic IL-5+ TH2 cells have been shown to be central to the development of eosinophilic airway inflammation and possess a greater ability to promote inflammation.
We were unable to compare immunophenotypes between racial groups as the APIC population is 64% African American with the remainder of the population being racially heterogeneous. However, analysis of a smaller and heterogeneous population of non-African American in the APIC study showed a differing cytokine profile, which urges consideration of whether Difficult-to-Control asthma phenotypes differ by race. Further validation of these findings in another cohort and comparison to a non-African American comparison group should be pursued. Previous reports have shown that the effect sizes of genetic variants which relate to asthma significantly differ between non-European and European populations. Notably, racial differences in TH2/TH17 inflammatory pathways have been reported in atopic dermatitis whereby Asian patients had a higher induction of TH17 /TH22-associated cytokines compared to patients of European ancestry.
In this study, we focused on African Americans, however, data from 129 non-African American APIC subjects were analyzed using the same statistical procedures. The racial heterogeneity and small size of this population in comparison to the African American population limited the reliability of this data, which was not included in the manuscript for this reason. However, it is interesting to note that a different cytokine profile was identified in the non-African American population. IL-1RA was positively associated with Difficult-to-Control disease and IL-5 was positively associated with Easy-to-Control asthma.
Our study has several unique strengths. These include features inherent to the APIC study from which the patients were enrolled. APIC enrolled inner-city children, a population disproportionately affected by asthma morbidity and mortality. Since the majority of APIC study participants were African American, we were positioned to characterize inflammatory profiles in at-risk African American children with asthma. APIC is a multi-center, longitudinal study, which allowed for a prospective evaluation over an entire year, designed to assess numerous parameters to identify factors that promote Difficult-to-Control asthma. APIC subjects received standardized, algorithm-based management of asthma and allergic rhinitis for one year. Further, peripheral blood characterization was obtained at baseline, which allows consideration for validation of this method to be used as a predictive model for assessing asthma control in a clinical setting. Additionally, blood samples are more likely to reflect systemic inflammation than bronchial biopsies or washings and have been previously reported to be associated with airway inflammation, asthma phenotype, and asthma severity[39, 40].
Our study also has some important limitations. We cannot control for the potential effects of inhaled or oral corticosteroids on the concentrations of chemokines, cytokines, and granulocytes observed in our study. Seven percent of subjects in our population were on an oral corticosteroid in the month prior to their blood draw. We did not see any impact of oral corticosteroids on blood neutrophils or eosinophils in this subset and oral corticosteroids are more likely to alter blood granulocytes than inhaled corticosteroids in the month prior to their blood draw. Furthermore, use of blood samples for testing for granulocyte and inflammatory mediators, as in our study, would, in theory, be less susceptible to the effects of inhaled corticosteroids when compared to studies utilizing samples obtained from the airways (sputum, BAL, bronchial tissue). A previous study showed no association between the use of inhaled corticosteroids and sputum neutrophil percentage. Also, Hastie et al. reported no significant effect of inhaled corticosteroid use on sputum cell counts or inflammatory mediator levels.
Additionally, as is true with other studies assessing cytokines, cytokine concentrations are relatively low which can lead to difficulty in detection. Percent of values above the lower limit of detection for cytokines measured in the study are included in S1 Table and are comparable to levels seen in other studies. Our analysis did not account for potential confounders which may have impacted specific cytokine values such as season in which blood was drawn and the presence of acute respiratory infection. However, the degree of influence that season has on inflammatory cells and cytokines is unclear with previous research suggesting there was no alteration in TH17 and TH1 responses during pollen season in patients with allergic respiratory disease. Also, due to the exploratory nature of this analysis, we did not adjust for multiplicity in the univariate tests shown in Table 3. Although we acknowledge that the resulting p-values insufficiently control for type I error (false positives), they have minimal contribution to the main analysis, which is the prediction model. We feel that the methodology used for building the prediction model adequately addresses the issue of multiplicity. Finally, as we measured serum cytokine concentrations and did not isolate and phenotype T-cells, we cannot definitively prove that the cytokines were secreted from TH-cells as opposed to other immune cells.
The need for risk stratification, refinement of the definition of asthma endotypes, and novel therapeutic agents that target the biological mechanisms underlying the severe asthma phenotype has been highlighted by experts. Results of this study can be used in conjunction with other research to improve risk stratification in this asthmatic population. The data herein urge the consideration of using multiple biologic treatments for Difficult-to-Control asthma in African American children. Given the association of IL-17A and IL-5 with Difficult-to-Control asthma in African American children in our inner-city population, therapeutics targeting IL-17 and IL-5 should be considered. A trial of brodalumab, a human anti–IL-17 receptor A monoclonal antibody, in poorly controlled moderate to severe asthmatics did not show significant improvement in primary or secondary endpoints. However, it may show efficacy in a trial of African American asthmatics with elevated serum IL-17. Further, our data suggest that anti-IL-5 may be most effective in African Americans. Targeting both TH2 and TH17 associated pathways of inflammation has been suggested previously given the concern that isolated targeting of TH2 cytokines may promote TH17-associated corticosteroid resistant neutrophilic airway inflammation[45, 46]. Furthermore, combined targeting of TH2 and TH17 inflammation has been suggested based on race in treatment of atopic dermatitis.
In summary, we have identified systemic cellular and cytokine/chemokine inflammatory profiles among inner-city African American children with Easy-to-Control and Difficult-to-Control asthma. Our study highlights the need to consider targeting multiple inflammatory pathways in the treatment of Difficult-to-Control pediatric asthma in the African American population.
S1 Table. Mean, lower limit of detection, and proportion of values above the lower limit of detection, overall and by inflammatory marker.
S2 Table. Comparison of African American subjects in the full APIC study population and the cytokine subsample.
S1 Fig. Replicate agreement by inflammatory marker.
Scatter plot of replicate A versus replicate B. Each panel represents a different cytokine, and each circle represents a pair of replicate values. The forty-five-degree line through the origin represents perfect agreement. Annotated values are the concordance coefficient correlation and associated 95% confidence interval.
S2 Fig. Cytokine distributions and proportion of cytokines above the lower limit of detection.
Left and middle panels display the distribution of values on the original scale and a log-10 scale, respectively. The spread of values is represented by boxplots, where the black dot represents the median, the gray box represents the interquartile range, the whiskers extend to 1.5 times the interquartile range, and individual tick marks represent data points beyond the 1.5*IQR threshold. Right panel contains the percentage of values above the lower limit of detection.
S3 Fig. Result of feature selection procedure.
Each line represents one of the 38 inflammatory markers. A non-zero beta coefficient (y-axis) represents statistical significance. As lambda grows (x-axis moves to the right), the penalty on the coefficients increases, driving irrelevant predictors to zero. Lines are truncated at the optimal lambda selected by repeated cross-validation (-2.97). At this level, 12 significant cytokines remain. Line color represents association with Difficult-to-Control (red = negative, blue = positive).
S1 File. Zip file of analysis data and metadata.
The CSV file (anly_cyto_share.csv) contains the core data for the analysis population of N = 235. The structure of the data is 1 record per participant per cytokine. The corresponding PDF file (anly_cyto_share.pdf) contains metadata, including names, labels, and distributions of each variable.
- 1. Wenzel SE. Asthma: defining of the persistent adult phenotypes. Lancet (London, England). 2006;368(9537):804–13. Epub 2006/08/29. pmid:16935691.
- 2. Bourdin A, Molinari N, Vachier I, Varrin M, Marin G, Gamez AS, et al. Prognostic value of cluster analysis of severe asthma phenotypes. The Journal of allergy and clinical immunology. 2014;134(5):1043–50. Epub 2014/07/06. pmid:24985405.
- 3. Moore WC, Meyers DA, Wenzel SE, Teague WG, Li H, Li X, et al. Identification of asthma phenotypes using cluster analysis in the Severe Asthma Research Program. American journal of respiratory and critical care medicine. 2010;181(4):315–23. Epub 2009/11/07. pmid:19892860; PubMed Central PMCID: PMCPmc2822971.
- 4. Fitzpatrick AM, Teague WG, Meyers DA, Peters SP, Li X, Li H, et al. Heterogeneity of severe asthma in childhood: confirmation by cluster analysis of children in the National Institutes of Health/National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute Severe Asthma Research Program. The Journal of allergy and clinical immunology. 2011;127(2):382–9.e1-13. Epub 2011/01/05. pmid:21195471; PubMed Central PMCID: PMCPmc3060668.
- 5. Keet CA, McCormack MC, Pollack CE, Peng RD, McGowan E, Matsui EC. Neighborhood poverty, urban residence, race/ethnicity, and asthma: Rethinking the inner-city asthma epidemic. The Journal of allergy and clinical immunology. 2015;135(3):655–62. Epub 2015/01/27. pmid:25617226; PubMed Central PMCID: PMCPmc4391373.
- 6. Sheehan WJ, Phipatanakul W. Difficult-to-control asthma: epidemiology and its link with environmental factors. Current opinion in allergy and clinical immunology. 2015;15(5):397–401. Epub 2015/08/01. pmid:26226354; PubMed Central PMCID: PMCPmc4551573.
- 7. Ownby DR, Tingen MS, Havstad S, Waller JL, Johnson CC, Joseph CL. Comparison of asthma prevalence among African American teenage youth attending public high schools in rural Georgia and urban Detroit. The Journal of allergy and clinical immunology. 2015;136(3):595–600.e3. Epub 2015/04/01. pmid:25825215; PubMed Central PMCID: PMCPmc4562865.
- 8. Moorman JE, Zahran H, Truman BI, Molla MT. Current asthma prevalence—United States, 2006–2008. Morbidity and mortality weekly report Surveillance summaries (Washington, DC: 2002). 2011;60 Suppl:84–6. Epub 2011/03/25. pmid:21430629.
- 9. Redd SC. Asthma in the United States: burden and current theories. Environmental health perspectives. 2002;110 Suppl 4:557–60. Epub 2002/08/27. pmid:12194886; PubMed Central PMCID: PMCPmc1241205.
- 10. Lenoir M, McGill CL, Graham LM Jr., Foggs M, Robinson S, Crim C, et al. A new focus on assessing and treating asthma control in the African-American community: a call to action. Journal of the National Medical Association. 2008;100(9 Suppl):1–23. Epub 2008/10/18. pmid:18924317.
- 11. Ray NF, Thamer M, Fadillioglu B, Gergen PJ. Race, income, urbanicity, and asthma hospitalization in California: a small area analysis. Chest. 1998;113(5):1277–84. Epub 1998/05/22. pmid:9596306.
- 12. Pino-Yanes M, Thakur N, Gignoux CR, Galanter JM, Roth LA, Eng C, et al. Genetic ancestry influences asthma susceptibility and lung function among Latinos. The Journal of allergy and clinical immunology. 2015;135(1):228–35. Epub 2014/10/11. pmid:25301036; PubMed Central PMCID: PMCPmc4289103.
- 13. Noda S, Suarez-Farinas M, Ungar B, Kim SJ, de Guzman Strong C, Xu H, et al. The Asian atopic dermatitis phenotype combines features of atopic dermatitis and psoriasis with increased T17 polarization. The Journal of allergy and clinical immunology. 2015. Epub 2015/10/03. pmid:26428954.
- 14. Pongracic JA, Krouse RZ, Babineau DC, Zoratti EM, Cohen RT, Wood RA, et al. Distinguishing characteristics of Difficult-to-control asthma in inner-city children and adolescents. The Journal of allergy and clinical immunology. 2016;In Press.
- 15. Brandt EB, Kovacic MB, Lee GB, Gibson AM, Acciani TH, Le Cras TD, et al. Diesel exhaust particle induction of IL-17A contributes to severe asthma. The Journal of allergy and clinical immunology. 2013;132(5):1194–204.e2. Epub 2013/09/26. pmid:24060272; PubMed Central PMCID: PMCPmc3845500.
- 16. Expert Panel Report 3 (EPR-3): Guidelines for the Diagnosis and Management of Asthma-Summary Report 2007. The Journal of allergy and clinical immunology. 2007;120(5 Suppl):S94–138. Epub 2007/12/06. pmid:17983880.
- 17. Bousquet J, Khaltaev N, Cruz AA, Denburg J, Fokkens WJ, Togias A, et al. Allergic Rhinitis and its Impact on Asthma (ARIA) 2008 update (in collaboration with the World Health Organization, GA(2)LEN and AllerGen). Allergy. 2008;63 Suppl 86:8–160. Epub 2008/03/26. pmid:18331513.
- 18. Parkitny L, McAuley JH, Kelly PJ, Di Pietro F, Cameron B, Moseley GL. Multiplex cytokine concentration measurement: how much do the medium and handling matter? Mediators of inflammation. 2013;2013:890706. pmid:24191133; PubMed Central PMCID: PMC3804442.
- 19. Fitzpatrick AM, Higgins M, Holguin F, Brown LA, Teague WG. The molecular phenotype of severe asthma in children. The Journal of allergy and clinical immunology. 2010;125(4):851–7.e18. Epub 2010/04/08. pmid:20371397; PubMed Central PMCID: PMCPmc2851636.
- 20. Hornung R, Reed L. Estimation of average concentration in the presence of nondetectable values. Appl Occup Environ Hyg. 1990;5(1):46–51.
- 21. Hastie T, Tibshirani R, Friedman JH. The elements of statistical learning: data mining, inference, and prediction. 2nd ed. New York: Springer; 2009.
- 22. Zou H, Hastie T. Regularization and variable selection via the elastic net. J Roy Stat Soc B. 2005;67:301–20.
- 23. Hill TD, Graham LM, Divgi V. Racial disparities in pediatric asthma: a review of the literature. Curr Allergy Asthma Rep. 2011;11(1):85–90. Epub 2010/11/26. pmid:21107764.
- 24. Woodruff PG, Khashayar R, Lazarus SC, Janson S, Avila P, Boushey HA, et al. Relationship between airway inflammation, hyperresponsiveness, and obstruction in asthma. The Journal of allergy and clinical immunology. 2001;108(5):753–8. Epub 2001/11/03. pmid:11692100.
- 25. Green RH, Brightling CE, Woltmann G, Parker D, Wardlaw AJ, Pavord ID. Analysis of induced sputum in adults with asthma: identification of subgroup with isolated sputum neutrophilia and poor response to inhaled corticosteroids. Thorax. 2002;57(10):875–9. Epub 2002/09/27. PubMed Central PMCID: PMCPmc1746199. pmid:12324674
- 26. Jatakanon A, Uasuf C, Maziak W, Lim S, Chung KF, Barnes PJ. Neutrophilic inflammation in severe persistent asthma. American journal of respiratory and critical care medicine. 1999;160(5 Pt 1):1532–9. Epub 1999/11/11. pmid:10556116.
- 27. Just J, Gouvis-Echraghi R, Rouve S, Wanin S, Moreau D, Annesi-Maesano I. Two novel, severe asthma phenotypes identified during childhood using a clustering approach. The European respiratory journal. 2012;40(1):55–60. Epub 2012/01/24. pmid:22267763.
- 28. Hosoki K, Ying S, Corrigan C, Qi H, Kurosky A, Jennings K, et al. Analysis of a Panel of 48 Cytokines in BAL Fluids Specifically Identifies IL-8 Levels as the Only Cytokine that Distinguishes Controlled Asthma from Uncontrolled Asthma, and Correlates Inversely with FEV1. PloS one. 2015;10(5):e0126035. Epub 2015/05/27. pmid:26011707; PubMed Central PMCID: PMCPmc4444276.
- 29. Al-Ramli W, Prefontaine D, Chouiali F, Martin JG, Olivenstein R, Lemiere C, et al. T(H)17-associated cytokines (IL-17A and IL-17F) in severe asthma. The Journal of allergy and clinical immunology. 2009;123(5):1185–7. Epub 2009/04/14. pmid:19361847.
- 30. Chambers ES, Nanzer AM, Pfeffer PE, Richards DF, Timms PM, Martineau AR, et al. Distinct endotypes of steroid-resistant asthma characterized by IL-17A(high) and IFN-gamma(high) immunophenotypes: Potential benefits of calcitriol. The Journal of allergy and clinical immunology. 2015;136(3):628–37.e4. Epub 2015/03/17. pmid:25772594; PubMed Central PMCID: PMCPmc4559139.
- 31. Robinson DS, Hamid Q, Ying S, Tsicopoulos A, Barkans J, Bentley AM, et al. Predominant TH2-like bronchoalveolar T-lymphocyte population in atopic asthma. The New England journal of medicine. 1992;326(5):298–304. Epub 1992/01/30. pmid:1530827.
- 32. Gelfand EW, Alam R. The other side of asthma: Steroid-refractory disease in the absence of TH2-mediated inflammation. The Journal of allergy and clinical immunology. 2015;135(5):1196–8. Epub 2015/03/17. pmid:25772592.
- 33. Irvin C, Zafar I, Good J, Rollins D, Christianson C, Gorska MM, et al. Increased frequency of dual-positive TH2/TH17 cells in bronchoalveolar lavage fluid characterizes a population of patients with severe asthma. The Journal of allergy and clinical immunology. 2014;134(5):1175–86.e7. Epub 2014/07/22. pmid:25042748; PubMed Central PMCID: PMCPmc4254017.
- 34. Mizutani N, Nabe T, Yoshino S. IL-17A promotes the exacerbation of IL-33-induced airway hyperresponsiveness by enhancing neutrophilic inflammation via CXCR2 signaling in mice. Journal of immunology (Baltimore, Md: 1950). 2014;192(4):1372–84. Epub 2014/01/22. pmid:24446518.
- 35. Brandt EB, Biagini Myers JM, Acciani TH, Ryan PH, Sivaprasad U, Ruff B, et al. Exposure to allergen and diesel exhaust particles potentiates secondary allergen-specific memory responses, promoting asthma susceptibility. The Journal of allergy and clinical immunology. 2015;136(2):295–303 e7. pmid:25748065; PubMed Central PMCID: PMC4530081.
- 36. Endo Y, Hirahara K, Yagi R, Tumes DJ, Nakayama T. Pathogenic memory type Th2 cells in allergic inflammation. Trends in immunology. 2014;35(2):69–78. Epub 2013/12/18. pmid:24332592.
- 37. Rosenberg NA, Huang L, Jewett EM, Szpiech ZA, Jankovic I, Boehnke M. Genome-wide association studies in diverse populations. Nature reviews Genetics. 2010;11(5):356–66. Epub 2010/04/17. pmid:20395969; PubMed Central PMCID: PMCPmc3079573.
- 38. Busse WW. The National Institutes of Allergy and Infectious Diseases networks on asthma in inner-city children: an approach to improved care. The Journal of allergy and clinical immunology. 2010;125(3):529–37; quiz 38–9. Epub 2010/03/17. pmid:20226289; PubMed Central PMCID: PMCPmc2854660.
- 39. Chien JW, Lin CY, Yang KD, Lin CH, Kao JK, Tsai YG. Increased IL-17A secreting CD4+ T cells, serum IL-17 levels and exhaled nitric oxide are correlated with childhood asthma severity. Clinical and experimental allergy: journal of the British Society for Allergy and Clinical Immunology. 2013;43(9):1018–26. Epub 2013/08/21. pmid:23957337.
- 40. Agache I, Strasser DS, Klenk A, Agache C, Farine H, Ciobanu C, et al. Serum IL-5 and IL-13 consistently serve as the best predictors for the blood eosinophilia phenotype in adult asthmatics. Allergy. 2016;71(8):1192–202. Epub 2016/04/10. pmid:27060452.
- 41. Hastie AT, Moore WC, Meyers DA, Vestal PL, Li H, Peters SP, et al. Analyses of asthma severity phenotypes and inflammatory proteins in subjects stratified by sputum granulocytes. The Journal of allergy and clinical immunology. 2010;125(5):1028–36 e13. pmid:20398920; PubMed Central PMCID: PMC2878277.
- 42. Schramm A, Jasiewicz-Honkisz B, Osmenda G, Wilk G, Siedlinski M, Sagan A, et al. Th17 responses are not altered by natural exposure to seasonal allergens in pollen-sensitive patients. Allergy Asthma Clin Immunol. 2016;12:55. pmid:27799958; PubMed Central PMCID: PMCPMC5078933.
- 43. Levy BD, Noel PJ, Freemer MM, Cloutier MM, Georas SN, Jarjour NN, et al. Future Research Directions in Asthma: An NHLBI Working Group Report. American journal of respiratory and critical care medicine. 2015. Epub 2015/08/26. pmid:26305520.
- 44. Busse WW, Holgate S, Kerwin E, Chon Y, Feng J, Lin J, et al. Randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled study of brodalumab, a human anti-IL-17 receptor monoclonal antibody, in moderate to severe asthma. American journal of respiratory and critical care medicine. 2013;188(11):1294–302. Epub 2013/11/10. pmid:24200404.
- 45. Newcomb DC, Boswell MG, Huckabee MM, Goleniewska K, Dulek DE, Reiss S, et al. IL-13 regulates Th17 secretion of IL-17A in an IL-10-dependent manner. Journal of immunology (Baltimore, Md: 1950). 2012;188(3):1027–35. Epub 2012/01/03. pmid:22210911; PubMed Central PMCID: PMCPmc3262924.
- 46. Choy DF, Hart KM, Borthwick LA, Shikotra A, Nagarkar DR, Siddiqui S, et al. TH2 and TH17 inflammatory pathways are reciprocally regulated in asthma. Science translational medicine. 2015;7(301):301ra129. pmid:26290411.