Soil pollution by trace elements (TEs) from mining and industrial activity is widespread and presents a risk to humans and ecosystems. The use of trees to immobilize TEs (phytostabilization) is a low-cost and effective method of soil remediation. We aimed to determine the chemical composition of leaves and flower buds of Eucalyptus camaldulensis in seven sites along the Guadiamar River valley (SW Spain), an area contaminated by a mine-spill in 1998. E. camaldulensis trees in the spill-affected area and adjacent non affected areas were growing on a variety of soils with pH from 5.6 to 8.1 with low concentration of plant nutrients. The spill affected soils contained up to 1069 mg kg-1 of As and 4086 mg kg-1 of Pb. E. camaldulensis tolerated elevated TE concentrations in soil and, compared to other species growing in the same environment, had low TE concentrations in the aerial portions. Besides tolerance to soil contamination, E. camaldulensis had low bioaccumulation coefficients for soil contaminants. TE concentrations in the aboveground portions were below levels reported to be toxic to plants or ecosystems. Flower buds had even lower TE concentrations than leaves. Despite the relatively low concentration of TEs in leaves they were significantly correlated with the soil extractable (0.01 M CaCl2) Cd, Mn and Zn (but not Cu and Pb). The general features of this tree species: tolerance to impoverished and contaminated soils, fast growth and deep root system, and low transfer of TEs from soil to aboveground organs makes it suitable for phytostabilization of soils contaminated by TEs. In addition, eucalyptus leaves could be used for biomonitoring the soil extractability of Cd, Mn and Zn but not Cu or Pb.
Citation: Madejón P, Marañón T, Navarro-Fernández CM, Domínguez MT, Alegre JM, Robinson B, et al. (2017) Potential of Eucalyptus camaldulensis for phytostabilization and biomonitoring of trace-element contaminated soils. PLoS ONE 12(6): e0180240. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0180240
Editor: Jorge Paz-Ferreiro, RMIT University, AUSTRALIA
Received: March 22, 2017; Accepted: June 12, 2017; Published: June 30, 2017
Copyright: © 2017 Madejón et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Data Availability: All relevant data are within the paper and its Supporting Information files.
Funding: This work has been funded by the European Union Seventh Framework Programme (FP7/2007-2013) under grant agreement n° 603498 (RECARE), and by the Spanish Ministry of Economy and Competitiveness, project RESTECO (CGL-2014-52858-R).
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Soil pollution is a global environmental issue, with remediation costs in the EU alone estimated at €6 billion / yr . This expense is justified because decontamination of heavy metals and other pollutants is imperative for eliminating or mitigating their negative effects on the environment and human health. Most of the physical and chemical methods for soil decontamination are prohibitively expensive for vast areas and may result in secondary pollution . For these reasons, phytostabilization (use of plants to reduce the mobility and toxicity of soil contaminants) has been the subject of much research in the last two decades due to its low environmental disturbance and is relatively low cost compared to other remediation technologies [3, 4].
Phytostabilization may be especially useful for riparian areas, where the limited accessibility to riverbanks makes the application of other remediation approaches particularly difficult. Remediation of these areas should be prioritized, as they are highly dynamic systems where pollutants can be easily mobilized and transported by runoff waters following natural hydrological cycles , which can lead to the large-scale spread of pollutants across river basins. The use of woody plant species in these habitats is recommended because of their large root systems, which contribute to soil physical stabilization of riverbanks [6, 7].
The choice of plant species is one of the most important factors determining the success of phytostabilization . Ideally, the species used should be native plants adapted to local environmental conditions , and they should exclude the entry of contaminants into the aboveground biomass.
The chemical composition of leaves or other plant parts can indicate the presence of contaminants in the environment and they are widely used as biomonitors [9–13]. An organism is considered as biomonitor when contains information on the quantitative aspects of the quality of the environment .
Due to a long history of mining activity, heavy metal pollution is a common environmental problem in Mediterranean countries . Many recent studies have evaluated the feasibility of different native Mediterranean species for phytostabilization [15–17]. The restoration program established at the Guadiamar Valley (SW Spain) is one of the largest soil remediation initiatives conducted in the Mediterranean region, and phytostabilization was the most important technology . Due to a mine spill, about 6 million m3 of sludge and acidic waters containing high concentrations As, Cd, Cu, Tl, and Zn, escaped into the Guadiamar River and contaminated ca. 2000 ha of arable and pastureland. Afterwards, the affected land was cleaned up, retired from cultivation, and planted with native shrubs and trees (see Materials and Method section for further details). Eucalyptus plantations (mainly of Eucalyptus camaldulensis and some E. globulus) were also removed, with exception of those trees growing in riparian areas with difficult access.
The wide distribution of E. camaldulensis trees within the Guadiamar valley, in a variety of soil types and with different levels of contamination, made that species suitable for studying plant-soil relationships. In general, eucalyptus species are good candidates for phytostabilization due to their rapid development of extensive root systems, which contributes to the physical stabilization of soils and riverbanks, their relatively high tolerance of TE contamination and nutrient imbalances in the growing substrate, and their ease of establishment on contaminated soils [19, 20]. In addition, their high essential oil content and lack of adapted herbivores outside their native range (Australia) may be an advantage for phytostabilization because there is less risk that the contaminants are transferred to the food chain. The possibility of gaining profit from the trees through the production of fuel, fibre, paper, timber or essential oils would allow a phytomanagement of the contaminated land  (see more information about the study species on Methods section). This field study fill a knowledge gap about the trace element uptake of eucalyptus trees growing on trace-elements contaminated soils, in a Mediterranean climate.
We aimed to elucidate the response of Eucalyptus camaldulensis to different levels of soil contamination and environmental conditions, in order to evaluate its potential for phytostabilization and as biomonitor of TEs. For comparative purposes we also studied a native willow (Salix purpurea) growing in the same contaminated sites.
Specifically, we sought to determine:
- the range of environmental conditions where E. camaldulensis can be found in the Guadiamar valley; for example, whether the concentration of TEs in soil was above intervention values.
- the effect of site conditions on the chemical composition of various tissues.
- whether the chemical composition of E. camaldulensis leaf tissue indicates nutrient deficiencies or TE toxicity.
- the bioaccumulation coefficients for soil-borne contaminants and suitability of E. camaldulensis for phytostabilization.
- the suitability of E. camaldulensis for biomonitoring TEs in soil.
Materials and methods
The Guadiamar River valley (SW Spain) lies inside the Iberian Pyrite Belt, the largest massive sulphide province in Western Europe. The area has a Mediterranean climate with mild rainy winters and warm dry summers (an annual average of about 2900 h of sunshine and maximum values of solar radiation exceeding 1000 W m-2). Average annual temperature is 19°C (minimum monthly mean of 9°C in January, and maximum of 27°C in July) and annual average rainfall is 484 mm. Soils are mostly neutral or slightly alkaline in the southern part while they are acidic in the northern part. In 1998, the failure of a large mine tailing dam at Aznalcóllar (Seville) released about 6 million m3 of TE-polluted sludge into the Agrio and Guadiamar Rivers (see general description of the accident in ). After the accident, a reclamation project included the removal of the polluted topsoil, the application of soil amendments to promote TE stabilization, and the afforestation with native woody plant species . Finally, the Regional Administration designed the remediated area (2706.8 ha) as protected, establishing the Guadiamar Green Corridor (GGC) .
Most of the remediation operations focused on the floodplain of both rivers, accompanied by a vast research and monitoring programme. Soil contamination was significantly reduced and the TE concentrations in planted shrubs and trees were mostly below guideline values . The riverbanks and channels were more difficult than the floodplains to access and remediate. There were still some extremely acid soils (pH ≈ 3), due to the periodical oxidation of sludge that could not be removed, as well as considerable residual contamination .
Riparian forests in the Guadiamar River are mainly composed by eucalyptus (Eucalyptus camaldulensis) from old plantations, mixed with native white poplars (Populus alba), narrow-leafed ashes (Fraxinus angustifolia), field elms (Ulmus minor) and willows (Salix spp.).
Eucalyptus camaldulensis Dehnh. (river red gum) is a tree native from Australia which has been widely planted around the world. It belongs to a genus, in the Myrtaceae family, with about 800 species, all of them restricted to Australasia. Eucalypts are evergreen, fast-growing, deep-rooting trees, tolerant of poor soil conditions, drought and moderate salinity . Their plantations provide pulp, paper, timber, fuel wood, essential oil, medicine, bioenergy and nectar for honeybees, and mitigate human pressures on native forests. They are the most widely planted hardwood forest trees in the world, covering more than 15 million ha in 100 countries [24–26].
Their low tolerance to cold temperatures has restricted E. camaldulensis plantations in temperate environments. For example, in Europe they have been planted mainly in southern countries, like Portugal, Spain, Italy and Greece. About 633,000 ha planted in Spain, produce annually more than 4 million m3 of timber .
Eucalyptus species have been proposed for phytostabilization of contaminated soils because of their moderate to low rates of heavy metal accumulation into aboveground biomass, thus reducing the risk of transmission of contaminants into the food web [20, 28]. However, some eucalyptus trees could accumulate, under experimental conditions, a certain amount of heavy metals into their shoots [20, 29, 30]. The suitability of the chosen species should be evaluated for the particular conditions and the type of contaminants.
Outside of their native habitats, eucalyptus leaves, rich in secondary compounds, are rarely consumed by herbivores, so minimizing the potential risk for the food web. On the other hand, during flowering the nectar attracts bees and it is an important source of the commonly consumed and sold “eucalyptus honey” . That food should be also monitored for heavy metals toxicity.
The massive plantations of exotic eucalypt trees out of their natural range have raised several environmental issues related to the destruction of native ecosystems and biodiversity loss, reduction of water availability (sometimes planted for draining swampy places), increasing fire risk, and promoting unsustainable timber production . Nevertheless, in riparian areas the eucalyptus trees can contribute to soil phytostabilization, along with other species.
Salix purpurea L. (purple willow) is a deciduous arborescent shrub, up to 6 m height, growing on wet places, river and lake margins, distributed for almost all Europe, northern Africa and West Asia. Willows are fast-growing woody plants with the known capacity to accumulate significant amounts of certain TEs into aboveground biomass, and therefore they have been widely used for phytoremediation [33–37].
Plant and soil sampling
Seven sampling sites were selected along the Guadiamar basin (Fig 1). Two of these sites were chosen in locations that were not affected by the mine-spill (C1 and C2, control sites). Site C1 was located in rocky slopes near an ephemeral stream, upwards of the Aznalcóllar mine. While site C2 was at the southern edge of the basin (29 km away from the mine), on a sandy plain outside of the affected area. Five sites (S1 to S5) were selected within the area affected by the spill. Site S1 was close to the broken dam, origin of the spill, in the river Agrio. Site S2 was located downwards (3 km away from the dam), where Agrio joins to the main Guadiamar river; that spot was highly contaminated during the cleaning operations, used as temporary storage of sludge (Fig 2A). Site S3 was located in a fenced control plot where the sludge was not removed, for research and monitoring purposes (13 km away from the dam). Sites S4 and S5 were located downstream, at 22 and 25 km respectively from the tailing pond (see coordinates in S1 Table).
Location of the seven sampling sites within the Guadiamar Basin, indicating the area affected by the mine spill in red.
A, sampled tree at site S2; B, details of leaves; C, details of flowers; D, soil core with sludge contamination from site S3.
At each site, three E. camaldulensis individuals were selected, more than 10 m apart, and marked. Sampling of leaves and soils occurred in November 2015 (17 years after the accident) and samples of flower buds were taken in April 2016 (Fig 2B and 2C). A general description of the sampled trees (height, trunk size (DBH), and leaf traits) is shown in the S2 Table. For comparison, S. purpurea trees were sampled at the same dates in the two sites (S1 and S2) where they coexisted with E. camaldulensis.
Leaves and flower buds were collected from the outer canopy at ca. 5m height. In general, leaves of the outer canopy tend to accumulate more mineral elements than those of the inner canopy, due to their higher transpiration rates . The rhizosphere of each tree was sampled using a spiral auger at two depths (0–20 and 20–40 cm), at three points around the trunk base; they were combined to make one composite soil sample per tree and depth.
Sample processing and analysis
Samples of leaves and flower buds were washed with distilled water for approximately 10 s, dried at 70°C for at least 48 h, and ground. Total N was measured by Kjeldahl digestion. TEs (As, Cd, Cu, Mn, Pb and Zn) and macronutrients (S, P, K, Ca and Mg) were determined by inductively coupled plasma spectrophotometry (ICP-OES: Varian ICP 720-ES: simultaneous ICP-OES with axially viewed plasma) after digestion of plant tissues by wet oxidation with concentrated HNO3. Plant digestion was carried out with a Digiprep MS block digestor (SPS Science) equipped with a temperature-time programmable controller and polypropylene digestion tubes. The accuracy of the analytical method was determined using a plant reference material: INCT-ONTL-5 (Tobacco leaves). Recovery rates for reference plant samples ranged between 90 and 103%.
A subsample of leaves from the same trees was used to measure two functional traits: leaf mass per area (LMA) as indicator of the tree growth rate  and the isotopic ratio of carbon (δ 13C) which provides a time-integrated measure of the tree water use efficiency . A sample of 6–8 leaves by tree was scanned and analyzed with Image-Pro 4.5 (Media Cybernetic Inc. USA); they were oven-dried at 70°C, weighed and the ratio between mass and area was calculated; see methods in . The isostopic ratio of carbon (δ 13C) was measured in combusted leaf samples at 1020°C using a continuous flow isotope-ratio mass spectrometry system by means of Flash HT Plus elemental analyzer coupled to a Delta-V Advantage isotope ratio mass spectrometer via a CONFLO IV interface (Thermo Fisher Scientific, Bremen, Germany). The analytical measurement error was ±0.1‰ for δ13C.
Soil samples were oven-dried at 40°C and sieved to <2 mm for physico-chemical analysis; a subsample was then ground to <60 μm for S and TE determination. Soil pH was measured in a 1:2.5 soil-water suspension by using a pH meter (CRISON micropH 2002). Size particle distribution was analyzed by the hydrometer method . Total C content was determined by using a LECO TruSpec CHN analyzer, and carbonate content by the manometric method . Organic C was calculated as the difference between total C and the C contained in carbonates. Total N was determined by Kjeldahl digestion . Available P was estimated by the Olsen method , and available K was determined by atomic absorption spectrophotometry after extraction with 1M ammonium acetate .
Sulphur and total content of TEs in soils was determined by ICP-OES after digesting the samples (<60 μm fraction) with a mixture of concentrated HNO3 and HCl (‘aqua regia’) in a Digiprep MS block digestor (SPS Science) equipped with a temperature-time programmable controller and polypropylene digestion tubes. ‘Aqua regia’ digestion does not extract those TEs associated with silicates . Nevertheless, this method is widely accepted to characterize TE concentrations in soil pollution studies, because the silicate-binding metals have less environmental implications. These concentrations are referred to as ‘pseudototal’ concentrations. The quality of the analysis was assessed using the reference soil sample ERM-CC141 (Loam soil). Obtained recoveries ranged from 95.3% to 101%. Bioavailability of selected TEs was estimated by extraction with 0.01 M CaCl2 solution (1/10 soil/solution ratio, fraction < 2 mm) and analysis by ICP-OES .
Differences among sites in soil and plant (leaf and flower bud) chemical composition were tested by one-way ANOVA and post-hoc Tukey tests (P < 0.05). Data normality and homogeneity of variance were verified by means of Kolmogorov–Smirnov and Levene tests, respectively. When data did not meet normality they were logarithmic transformed. In the case of Mn, even after transformation did not meet normality, therefore Kruskal–Wallis tests were used for comparison of means.
Factorial ANOVAs were applied to test for differences in TE composition between plant organs (leaves versus flower buds) and between sites, and to test for possible interactions between both factors (organ × site interaction). For Mn and As, which showed a high heterogeneity between organs and /or across sites, linear models using generalized least squares were fitted, with the nlme package in R 3.1.2. In these models, a variance structure parameter was added to account for heterogeneity of model residuals between organs and/or sites . Significance level was p < 0.05.
Bivariate relationships between TE concentrations in soils and plants were explored using Spearman correlational analysis. The overall pattern of covariation of the TEs in leaves and flower buds was explored by Principal Component Analysis. In order to remove closure effects in chemical compositional data, dataset was previously transformed using the centred-log ratio transformation function of R package “rgr”. All statistical analyses were conducted using the program SPSS 23.0 for Windows.
To evaluate soil pollution severity, we used the pollution load index (PLI) as defined by Tomlinson . This index is based on the concentration factor (CF) of each metal (As, Cd, Cu, Pb and Zn), which is defined as the ratio between the concentration of the metal in each soil and the background values for the region . For each sampling site, PLI is calculated as the nth root of the product of the obtained CFs for each element. Values of PLI close to 1 indicate heavy metal loads near the background level, while values above 1 indicate soil pollution .
For a general comparison background values for total concentrations (median, normal soils of the world) were taken from , and available concentrations from unaffected soils of SW Spain from . Intervention values for Andalusian soils (total concentrations) were taken from , and permitted water soluble levels from , except the value for Mn which refers to the critical level (CaCl2 extracted) that can affect many plants .
In order to estimate what proportion of the total soil metal concentration was available and transferred to leaves and flower buds, the transfer coefficient (TC) was calculated. This is defined as the ratio of metal concentration in the plant [M]plant to the total metal concentration in the soil [M]soil . The TC of TEs was compared between E. camaldulensis and S. purpurea.
General soil properties and pollution levels
E. camaldulensis trees were growing (planted before the mine accident) in a wide variety of soils within the Guadiamar basin (S1 Table). Soil acidity ranged from low pH (5.6) in the rocky slopes of site C1 to the basicity (pH 8.1) of the sandy plains, site C2. Texture was also variable between sandy loam and silty clay. Fertility was higher in the sites from the southern, lower part of the river (S3, S4 and S5), having clayey texture and relatively higher values of organic carbon (13–30 g kg-1), nitrogen (1.2–2.5 g kg-1) and available K (186–473 mg kg-1). However, available phosphorus was low across all sites, ranging from 1 mg kg-1 (in deeper soils of C1, C2 and S3) to 15 mg kg-1 (in topsoil of S5).
The contamination within the study area was variable (S1 Fig), from cleanness (PLI below unity) in the sites non-affected by the mine spill (C1 and C2) to highly contaminated (PLI up to 11) in the deeper soil of the spill-affected and non-remediated plot (S3). Contamination increased with soil depth (except in site S2).
Total concentrations of sulphur and TEs were significantly different between the sites, at both soil depths (Table 1 and S3 Table). The greatest variability between plots for As, Pb and S occurred deeper in the soil profile (20–40 cm). Thus, the non-remediated plot S3 had the highest subsoil concentrations of arsenic (1,069 mg kg-1), lead (4,086 mg kg-1) and sulphur (53,635 mg kg-1), compared with the lowest values of clean sites (1.6 mg kg-1 As and 6 mg kg-1 Pb in site C2, and 65 mg kg-1 S in site C1). Both As and Pb maximum values surpassed the Andalusian intervention thresholds (Table 1), .
The pattern of variation in the TE concentration at the top 20cm were similar to the deeper layer, with TE concentrations being in general lower in the 0-20cm layer. The maximum concentrations in topsoil of As, Cd, Pb and S were found at the non-remediated plot S3. Other elements varied in the spatial contamination patterns of topsoil, Cu had the maximum value (223 mg kg-1) in site S2, Mn had its maximum (1,477 mg kg-1) in site S1 and Zn peaked (742 mg kg-1) at site S5 (S3 Table).
The extractability of TEs (CaCl2 extraction) was generally two orders of magnitude lower than total values. In the case of As, extractable values were below detection limits. There were significant differences between sites in the extractability of TEs, with exception of Pb (Table 1). The most variable elements (with highest F values) were S (ranging from 1 to 5,068 mg kg-1) and Mn (from 0.2 to 26 mg kg-1) in the topsoil (S4 Table). Availabilities of Cd and Zn were relatively high, and clearly surpassed the permitted levels (for Andalusian soils) : maximum of 0.14 mg kg-1 Cd above the critical 0.03 mg kg-1 level, and maximum of 14 mg kg-1 Zn above the permitted 0.5 level (Table 1).
Chemical composition of leaves and flower buds
Concentrations of the 12 studied elements in leaves and flower buds of E. camaldulensis differed significantly between sites (Table 2; for more details see S5 and S6 Tables). The greatest inter-site differences (highest F values) were found for Zn, Cu and As, and the lowest for the nutrients Mg, Ca and S. With the exception of K, element concentrations in leaves and flower buds differed significantly between sites. The highest between-organ differences were found for the non-essential and toxic elements As and Cd. There were significant site-organ interactions for seven out of 12 elements.
The general variation in the chemical composition, between sites and between leaves and flowers, is shown in Fig 3. The first axis of the Principal Component Analysis (PCA) explained the 44.7% of the variance and was mainly defined positively by the concentrations of nutrients N, Ca, K, Mg and P, and negatively by Cd, Pb and As. There was a general trend of highest trace element accumulation in leaves from contaminated sites. The second PCA axis explained 20.1% of the variance and was related to Cu, Cd and Zn (positive), and S (negative) concentrations.
Symbols are circles for leaves and squares for flower buds; those sampled in contaminated sites are indicated in black and those in clean sites in white. Vectors represent the eigenvector coefficients (multiplied by two, for clarity) of the 12 elements.
For a more detailed analysis of the differences among sites and between flowers and leaves, we have separated macronutrients (N, P, S, K, Ca and Mg) and TEs (As, Cd, Cu, Mn, Pb and Zn).
Macronutrient concentrations were greater in leaves than in flower buds, except for P and K. E. camaldulensis foliar levels of S, K, Ca and Mg were above the limit considered adequate for normal growth in all the seven sites . However, N and P values could indicate some nutrient deficiency (Fig 4).
Significant differences (p < 0.05) among sites for leaves composition (black bars) are marked with lower case letter, while difference for flowers buds (grey bars) are in capital letters. As reference for each nutrient, a dotted line indicates the lower limit of the range considered adequate for E. camaldulensis normal growth .
As expected, the concentration of TEs in E. camaldulensis leaves and flower buds were significantly lower in the clean sites, in particular in site C2, than in those affected by the mine spill. Flower buds tended to accumulate lower concentrations than leaves, especially of the non-essential elements As and Pb (Fig 5).
Significant differences (p < 0.05) among sites for leaves composition (black bars) are marked with lower case letter, while difference for flowers buds (grey bars) are in capital letters. As reference for TE, a dotted line indicates the lower limit of the range considered toxic for plants .
The contaminated site S2 was remarkable for the highest values of TEs in leaves, in particular of Zn, Cu and Mn, above the phytotoxicity levels . The case of Mn, which had high foliar values in trees from non-affected rocky slopes (site C1), could indicate a geological origin. Other TEs of known toxicity like As, Cd and Pb were accumulated at safe levels.
Soil and plant relations
The transfer coefficients (TC) from soil to leaves indicate the accumulation (>1) or exclusion (<1) of the particular TE by E. camaldulensis. In most cases, the transfer was low and TEs present in soil were not accumulated in E. camaldulensis leaves. The relevant exception was the high accumulation of Mn in site S2 (TC of 4–5). The relatively high TC values obtained in non-affected sites (Cd in site C1 and Zn in site C2) correspond to low absolute values in both soil and leaves and therefore of lower importance. Arsenic and Pb showed the lowest coefficients, indicating a limited transfer of both elements from soils to E. camaldulensis leaves (Table 3).
The comparative values of TC for S. purpurea reflected a high transfer and accumulation of Cd and Zn in willow leaves, with maximum of 19 for Cd and 5 for Zn (in site S2). The concentration of Cd in leaves of S. purpurea (mean of 7 mg kg-1 in site S2) was about 15 times higher than in E. camaldulensis, and above the phytotoxicity threshold (5 mg kg-1). Similarly, Zn concentration in willow leaves was about six times higher than in E. camaldulensis, both surpassing the phytotoxicity level (100 mg kg-1) in site S2 (S7 Table).
The concentration of a determined TE in the E. camaldulensis leaves can be used as bioindicator if it is significantly correlated with its concentration in soil. Thus Cd, Mn and Zn levels in leaves indicated (i.e., they were significantly correlated with) the available concentration of that TE in soil, at the two depths (Table 4). Leaf As was also correlated, but with total concentration of As in soil (extractable concentration was below detection limit and correlation could not be calculated). However, the correlation leaf-soil was not significant for Cu and Pb, neither for total nor extractable soil values.
Heterogeneity of soil conditions
Eucalyptus camaldulensis is a generalist tree species, which can grow in a variety of soil conditions [23, 28, 60]. In the study area, E. camaldulensis demonstrated the capacity to grow in soils with contrasting pH (values from 5.6 to 8.1) and texture (sandy to clayey). They thrived on impoverished soils, in particular with organic N concentration below 1 g kg-1, a value considered as low for most soils in the Southern Spain. In most cases, the soil C/N ratio was > 15, which can be indicative of a very low N availability .
Levels of P availability were also low . However, K concentrations were at ‘critical’ or ‘low’ levels in the sandy soils, especially at the deep soil, and normal, or even high levels in the more silty-clayey soils. In general, the organic matter content surpassed the critical value of 20 g kg-1 (see  for critical and low values of soil nutrients, and  for general overview of soil fertility of the study area).
The study area was contaminated by a mine-spill on 1998, and despite the soil cleaning and remediation operations, there was still residual contamination (18 years later), in particular in the riparian areas . Soil samples taken from the E. camaldulensis rhizosphere had high total concentrations of some TEs. In particular, As reached up to 765 mg kg-1 (at site S5) well above the Andalusian intervention value of 50 mg kg-1, and Pb had maximum values of 1790 mg kg-1 (site S5) and 1189 mg kg-1 (site S4) surpassing the intervention value of 500 mg kg-1 . Soil acidity would increase the bioavailability of trace elements and therefore their potential toxicity .
The total S concentration in soil was high (up to 17501 mg kg-1 at S5) reflecting the pyritic origin and S-enrichment of the mine sludge . The highest values of total Mn in soil were found at the non-contaminated rocky site (C1; up to 1705 mg kg-1) and is likely of geologic origin; however that natural concentration is >500 mg kg-1, a limit for which ecological investigation has been recommended .
Variability in chemical composition of leaves and flower buds
The concentration of mineral elements in E. camaldulensis leaves can indicate the nutrient status of the tree as well as to detect potential toxicity by TEs ([58, 59, 64]. Nitrogen and P had relatively low concentrations in the studied E. camaldulensis trees indicating some deficiency. While the levels of K, Ca, Mg and S in leaves were adequate for a normal growth of this species . The relatively high concentration of Ca in leaves can help the trees to tolerate the high concentration of TEs in the soil solution, due to the potential protective action of Ca against the toxicity of metals and metalloids [65, 66].
Despite the high total concentration of As and Pb in soils, the E. camaldulensis leaves accumulated relatively low amounts of those elements, with values below the phytotoxicity level. However, the maximum values of Cu, Mn and Zn measured in leaves of some trees (site S2) reached phytotoxic levels. At that particular site, the soil was acidic (pH 6.3) and low in organic C (8.5 g kg-1), thereby increasing the availability of TEs. Both factors, especially pH, are key determinants of the bioavailability of trace elements in soil . In addition, trees were growing close to the river and therefore maintaining high transpiration rates and high transfer rates of TEs from deep soil through the deep sinker roots typical of Eucalyptus species . Nevertheless, those high levels of Cu, Mn and Zn found at that particular site do not necessarily imply a toxic response, because the so-called “phytotoxic ranges” are illustrative guidelines that may vary across species, depending on specific adaptations .
The high accumulation of Mn into leaves seems to be a particular feature of Eucalyptus species, which has been previously reported [68–70], probably associated with a high tolerance of that element. The highest values of leaf Mn reflected the Mn-enrichment of soils and apparently were of geologic origin, independent of the mine-spill. The acidity of soils contributed to the Mn solubilization in the soil matrix [59, 71]. The maximum value of Mn measured here for E. camaldulensis leaves (1772 mg kg-1) can be compared with those found for other species, such as E. globulus (4000 mg kg-1; ) and the hybrid E. grandis × E. urophylla (13500 mg kg-1) .
Flower buds had a significantly different chemical composition than leaves, with exception of potassium. Transport of mineral elements differs among leaves and reproductive structures; for instance, flowers and fruits usually have weak xylem but strong phloem translocation activities . Non-essential elements, such as As and Pb, had lower concentrations in the flower buds, probably reflecting the action of a physiological barrier impeding their translocation to the seeds [73, 74]. However, there are some studies showing a high accumulation of TEs in flowers and seeds [75, 76]. In addition, metals and metalloids can be transferred to pollen grains and nectar, potentially affecting the composition of apiary products .
Potential for phytostabilization.
Trees within the Eucalyptus genus present many of the features to be selected for phytostabilization in Mediterranean environments: tolerance to high concentrations of contaminants, ability to develop an extensive root system, low maintenance requirements, relatively high transpiration rates, relatively long growing period, ability for self-propagation, and adaptation to local climate . Despite the low concentrations of soil nutrients and the relatively high concentration of some TEs (As, Pb and Mn) E. camaldulensis grew without toxicity symptoms in all the sites of the study area. They showed plasticity in tree growth and leaf morphology along the Guadiamar basin (S2 Table). In the soils with higher fertility (lower part of the river, sites S4 and S5), trees were taller and with larger trunks; leaves of lower LMA indicated higher relative growth rate . On the contrary, trees on drier slopes (site C1) were smaller and showed water stress (lower absolute values of δ13C) .
Phytostabilization aims to immobilize TEs within the plant rhizosphere, and thus reducing their bioavailability and minimizing the exposure of livestock, wildlife, and human populations to them . To be suitable for phytostabilization, the transfer of TEs from soil to aboveground plant organs must be low (TC<1) . Our results show that E. camaldulensis is appropriate for the phytoestabilization of soils contaminated by Cd, As and Pb; given the relatively low levels of accumulation of these elements recorded in the aboveground biomass. Previous studies have also highlighted the ability of this and other Eucalyptus species for the phytostabilization of TEs on contaminated soils [28, 81, 82]. In contrast, the studied willow (Salix purpurea) accumulated high concentrations of foliar Cd (up to 10.9 mg kg-1) and Zn (maximum of 1126 mg kg-1); therefore this native species, which has naturally revegetated the riparian area, would not be suitable for planting and phytostabilizing contaminated sites.
Manganese is an essential element but in high concentration can induce some toxicity; e.g., a threshold of 1370 mg g-1 of Mn in the diet reduced the survival of moth larvae . Although Eucalyptus leaves are rarely consumed outside its native habitat, some phytophagous insects feeding on them could, in turn, provide a Mn-rich diet for birds .
The assessment of the phytostabilization ability of a plant species is usually limited to the analysis of metal accumulation into foliage. However, other organs that may be consumed by herbivores or, indirectly, by humans should also be investigated. Eucalyptus honey is commonly produced for human consumption [85, 86]. We found that the flower buds effectively excluded As and Pb, and that Cd concentration was below the threshold value for human consumption (0.5 mg kg-1 dw, based on ). This indicates that the concentrations of these elements in nectar and therefore potential toxicity are likely to be low. However, further analyses of nectar, pollen and honey, in particular of the accumulating Mn, are needed to confirm its safety for human consumption.
The banks and channels of the Guadiamar River have acid soils and residual contamination, originated from the mine-spill. Appropriate management should include application of soil amendments for pH correction, and revegetation of the riverbanks to ensure mechanical stabilization, and to reduce soil losses through water erosion . Existing E. camaldulensis trees can play a role in soil phytostabilization of this fragile ecosystem.
Potential for biomonitoring of soil pollution.
Biomonitors are defined as organisms that contain information on the quantitative aspects of the quality of the environment . For most plants, except metal excluders , the accumulation of a TE in a particular plant organ confirms its availability in the soil. The general advantages of biomonitoring are: the permanent and common occurrence of an organism in the field, even in remote areas, the ease of sampling, and the absence of any necessary expensive technical equipment [9, 12]. Thus, biomonitors can be used to detect low concentrations that are not always easy to measure directly using chemical extraction techniques; even if they are measurable as total levels, their ecological relevance is often difficult to determine from soil concentrations. As far as we know, there is no information about the potential use of eucalyptus, widely planted in all types of soil, for biomonitoring soil pollution.
E. camaldulensis leaves were good indicators (with high correlation values) of soil concentration for As, Cd, Mn and Zn (Table 4). Manganese in flower buds also had a remarkably high correlation with extractable Mn in soil. Although Mn uptake is metabolically controlled, passive absorption is also likely to occur, especially when concentrations in the soil solution are high and within the phytotoxic range . The results suggest that on the Guadiamar study area E. camaldulensis leaves and flower buds could be used to biomonitor Mn availability in soil.
Potential biomonitoring of Cd and Zn in soils is relatively common in plants because these elements are passively absorbed through the roots and freely translocated to leaves and other plant organs . Thus, E. camaldulensis leaves are also biondicators of soil Cd and Zn in the Guadiamar soils. In previous studies, white poplar (Populus alba), a native tree in the riparian Guadiamar forests, has been proposed for bioindication of soil Cd and Zn [11, 12].
In contrast, the weakness of the relationships between soil and plant concentrations for Cu and Pb is likely due to the high effectivity of the retention of these elements in plant roots . Therefore E. camaldulensis leaves are not bioindicators for soil Cu and Pb.
E. camaldulensis is a good candidate for the phytostabilization and biomonitoring of TE contaminated soils because of its tolerance to a wide variety of soil conditions, rapid growth rate, and low rates of herbivory. Despite the high soil concentration of some toxic TEs, such as As and Pb (surpassing the intervention values), their accumulation in leaves of E. camaldulensis were relatively low, and below toxic levels. The exception was Mn, which accumulated in E. camaldulensis leaves in two sites, apparently from geologic origin and independent of the spill contamination, but it should require some specific monitoring and caution. In general, the accumulation of TEs in flower buds was even lower than in leaves. Although the general concentration of TEs in leaves was low, there were some significant relationships with the soil extractability of Cd, Mn and Zn; therefore, E. camaldulensis is valuable for biomonitoring of those three elements.
S1 Fig. Values of pollution load index (PLI) for two soil depths at the seven sites sampled in the Guadiamar River valley (SW Spain).
S1 Table. General soil parameters analyzed at two depths (0–20 and 20-40cm) of the seven sampling sites with specific location indicated below.
Mean values ± SE; n = 3 except for N, Org. C and texture with a single value from a composite sample.
S2 Table. Allometric measures of E. camaldulensis trees in each sampling site (mean values ± SE; n = 3).
Tree height, trunk diameter at breast height (DBH), leaf mass per area (LMA) and leaf concentration of 13C.
S3 Table. Total concentration (mean ±SE) of nine TEs at the seven study sites of the Guadiamar Valley.
Maximum and minimum values are indicated between brackets.
S4 Table. Available concentrations of S and five trace elements at each sampling site (mg kg-1; mean values ± SE).
Range for each element in parenthesis. Abbreviation dl means detection limit.
S5 Table. Macronutrient concentrations in leaves and flower buds at each sampling site (g 100g-1; mean values ± SE).
Range for each element in parenthesis.
S6 Table. Trace element concentrations in leaves and flower buds at each sampling site (mg kg-1; mean values ± SE).
Range for each element in parenthesis.
We thank the staff of Guadiamar Green Corridor for facilities and support to carry out the fieldwork. Isotopic analysis was carried out in the LIE of EBD(CSIC), multielemental analysis of soil and plant samples in the IRNAS Analysis Service. We are grateful to Pilar Burgos, Patricia Puente and Cristina García for their help at different stages of the study.
- 1. Panagos P, Hiederer R, Van Liedekerke M, Bampa F. Review Article Contaminated Sites in Europe: Review of the Current Situation Based on Data Collected through a European Network. J Environ Public Health. 2013; Artical ID:1–11. pmid:23843802
- 2. Wu G, Kang H, Zhang X, Shao H, Chu L, Ruan C. A critical review on the bio-removal of hazardous heavy metals from contaminated soils: Issues, progress, eco-environmental concerns and opportunities. J Hazard Mater. 2010; 174(1–3):1–8. pmid:19864055
- 3. Bolan NS, Park JH, Robinson B, Naidu R, Huh KY. Phytostabilization. A green approach to contaminant containment. Adv Agron. 2011;112: 45–204.
- 4. Ali H, Khan E, Sajad MA. Phytoremediation of heavy metals-Concepts and applications. Chemosphere. 2013; 91(7): 869–81. pmid:23466085
- 5. Macklin MG, Brewer PA, Hudson-Edwards KA, Bird G, Coulthard TJ, Dennis IA, et al. A geomorphological approach to the management of rivers contaminated by metal mining. Geomorphology. 2006; 79(3): 423–447.
- 6. Pulford ID, Watson C. Phytoremediation of heavy metal-contaminated land by trees—A review. Environ Int. 2003; 29(4): 529–40. pmid:12705950
- 7. Domínguez MT, Alegre JM, Madejón P, Madejón E, Burgos P, Cabrera F, Marañón T, Murillo JM. River banks and channels as hotspots of soil pollution after large-scale remediation of a river basin. Geoderma. 2016; 261: 133–40.
- 8. Mendez MO, Maier RM. Phytoremediation of mine tailings in temperate and arid environments. Rev Environ Sci Biotechnol. 2008; 7(1): 47–59.
- 9. Wolterbeek B. Biomonitoring of trace element air pollution: Principles, possibilities and perspectives. Environ Pollut. 2002; 120: 11–21. pmid:12199457
- 10. Markert BA, Breure AM, Zechmeister HG. Definitions, strategies and principles for bioindication/biomonitoring of the environment. In: Markert BA, Breure AM, Zechmeister HG, editors. Bioindicators and Biomonitors. Oxford: Elsevier Science; 2003. pp. 3–39.
- 11. Madejón P, Marañón T, Murillo JM, Robinson B. White poplar (Populus alba) as a biomonitor of trace elements in contaminated riparian forests. Environ Pollut. 2004;132(1): 145–155. pmid:15276282
- 12. Madejón P, Marañón T, Murillo JM, Robinson B. In defence of plants as biomonitors of soil quality. Environl Pollut. 2006; 143: 1–3.
- 13. Madejón P, Ciadamidaro L, Marañón T, Murillo JM. Long-term biomonitoring of soil contamination using poplar trees: accumulation of trace elements in leaves and fruits. Int J Phytoremediation. 2013; 15(6): 602–614. pmid:23819300
- 14. Doumas P, Munoz M, Banni M, Becerra S, Bruneel O, Casiot C, et al. Polymetallic pollution from abandoned mines in Mediterranean regions: a multidisciplinary approach to environmental risks. Regional Environmental Change. 2016; 1–16.
- 15. Madejón P, Burgos P, Cabrera F, Madejón E. Phytostabilization of amended soils polluted with trace elements using the Mediterranean shrub: Rosmarinus officinalis. Int J Phytoremediation. 2009; 11(6):542–557. pmid:19810354
- 16. Moreno-Jiménez E, Esteban E, Carpena-Ruiz RO, Lobo MC, Peñalosa JM. Phytostabilisation with Mediterranean shrubs and liming improved soil quality in a pot experiment with a pyrite mine soil. J Hazard Mater. 2012; 201–202: 52–59. pmid:22178372
- 17. Heckenroth A, Rabier J, Dutoit T, Torre F, Prudent P, Laffont-Schwob I. Selection of native plants with phytoremediation potential for highly contaminated Mediterranean soil restoration: Tools for a non-destructive and integrative approach. J Environ Manage. 2016; 183: 850–63. pmid:27665125
- 18. Domínguez MT, Marañón T, Murillo JM, Schulin R, Robinson BH. Trace element accumulation in woody plants of the Guadiamar Valley, SW Spain: A large-scale phytomanagement case study. Environ Pollut. 2008; 152(1): 50–9. pmid:17602809
- 19. Flege A. Forest recultivation of coal-mined land: Problems and prospects. In: Haigh MJ, editors. Reclaimed Land. Rotterdam: A.A. Balkema; 2000. pp. 291–337.
- 20. Arriagada CA, Herrera MA, Ocampo JA. Beneficial effect of saprobe and arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi on growth of Eucalyptus globulus co-cultured with Glycine max in soil contaminated with heavy metals. J Environ Manage. 2007; 84(1): 93–99 pmid:16837125
- 21. Grimalt JO, Ferrer M, MacPherson E. The mine tailing accident in Aznalcollar. Sci Total Environ. 1999; 242(1–3): 3–11. pmid:10635575
- 22. Arenas JM, Montes C, Borja F. The Guadiamar Green Corridor. From an ecological disaster to a newly designated natural protected area. Seville: Regional Ministry of the Environment of the Junta de Andalucía; 2003
- 23. Navarro A, Stellacci AM, Campi P, Vitti C, Modugno F, Mastrorilli M. Feasibility of SRC Species for Growing in Mediterranean Conditions. Bioenergy Res. 2016; 9: 208–223.
- 24. Davidson J. Ecological aspects of Eucalyptus plantations. In: Proceedings of the regional expert consultation on Eucalyptus. FAO. 1993. Vol. 1, pp. 35–60.
- 25. Turnbull J W, Booth TH. Eucalypts in cultivation: an overview. In: Coppen JJW,editor. Eucalyptus: the genus Eucalyptus. London: Taylor & Francis; 2002. pp. 52–74.
- 26. Myburg AA, Grattapaglia D, Tuskan GA, Hellsten U, Hayes RD, Grimwood J, et al. The genome of Eucalyptus grandis. Nature. 2014; 510 (7505).
- 27. SECF. Situación de los bosques y del sector forestal en España. Sociedad Española de Ciencias Forestales; 2010. Available from: http://www.secforestales.org/content/informe-isfe
- 28. King DJ, Doronila AI, Feenstra C, Baker AJM, Woodrow IE. Phytostabilisation of arsenical gold mine tailings using four Eucalyptus species: Growth, arsenic uptake and availability after five years. Sci Total Environ. 2008;406 (1–2): 35–42. pmid:18801558
- 29. Fine P, Rathod PH, Beriozkin A, Mingelgrin U. Uptake of cadmium by hydroponically grown, mature Eucalyptus camaldulensis saplings and the effect of organic ligands. Int J Phytoremediation. 2013; 15(6):585–601 pmid:23819299
- 30. Mok H-F, Majumder R, Laidlaw WS, Gregory D, Baker AJM, Arndt SK. Native Australian species are effective in extracting multiple heavy metals from biosolids. Int J Phytoremediation. 2012; 15: 615–632.
- 31. Meindl GA, Ashman TL. The effects of aluminum and nickel in nectar on the foraging behavior of bumblebees. Environ Pollut. 2013; 177: 78–81. pmid:23466735
- 32. Stanturf JA, Vance ED, Fox TR, Kirst M. Eucalyptus beyond its native range: Environmental issues in exotic bioenergy plantations. Int J For Res. 2013; 463030: 1–5.
- 33. Robinson BH, Mills TM, Petit D, Fung LE, Green SR, Clothier BE. Natural and induced cadmium-accumulation in poplar and willow: Implications for phytoremediation. Plant Soil. 2000; 227(1–2): 301–306.
- 34. Lepp NW, Madejón P. Cadmium and zinc in vegetation and litter of a voluntary woodland that has developed on contaminated sediment-derived soil. J Environ Qual. 2007; 36(4): 1123–1131. pmid:17596620
- 35. Meers E, Vandecasteele B, Ruttens A, Vangronsveld J, Tack FMG. Potential of five willow species (Salix spp.) for phytoextraction of heavy metals. Environ Exp Bot. 2007; 60(1): 57–68.
- 36. Mleczek M, Rissmann I, Rutkowski P, Kaczmarek Z, Golinski P. Accumulation of selected heavy metals by different genotypes of Salix. Environ Exp Bot. 2009; 66(2): 289–296.
- 37. Wahsha M, Bini C, Argese E, Minello F, Fontana S, Wahsheh H. Heavy metals accumulation in willows growing on Spolic Technosols from the abandoned Imperina Valley mine in Italy. J Geochemical Explor. 2012; 123:19–24.
- 38. Bargagli R. Trace elements in terrestrial plants: An ecophysiological approach to biomonitoring and biorecovery. Berlin: Springer-Verlag; 1998
- 39. Poorter H, Niinemets Ü, Poorter L, Wright IJ, Villar R. Causes and consequences of variation in leaf mass per area (LMA): a meta-analysis. New Phytol. 2009; 182: 565–588. pmid:19434804
- 40. Farquhar GD, O’Leary MH, Berry JA. On the Relationship Between Carbon Isotope Discrimination and the Intercellular Carbon Dioxide Concentration in Leaves. Aust J Plant Physiol. 1982; 9(2): 121–137.
- 41. Pérez-Harguindeguy N, Díaz S, Garnier E, Lavorel S, Poorter H, Jaureguiberry P, et al. New handbook for standardised measurement of plant functional traits worldwide. Aust J Bot. 2013; 61(3): 167–234.
- 42. Gee GW, Bauder JW. Particle size analysis by hydrometer: a simplified method for routine textural analysis and a sensitivity test of measurement parameters. Soil Sci Soc Am J. 1979; 43: 1004–1007.
- 43. Demolon A, Leroux D. Guide pour L'étude Experimental des Sols. Paris: Gautier Villars; 1952.
- 44. Hesse PR. A textbook of soil chemical analysis. New York: Chemical Publishing Co. Inc.; 1971
- 45. Olsen SR, Cole CV, Watanabe FS, Dean LA. Estimation of available phosphorus in soils by extraction with sodium bicarbonate. U.S. Department of Agriculture. Report 939; 1954
- 46. Dewis J, Freitas F. Physical and chemical methods of soil and water analysis. Roma: Soils Bull. No. 10. FAO; 1970.
- 47. Reimann C, Caritat P. Chemical elements in the environment. Factsheets for the geochemist and environmental scientist. Berlin: Springer-Verlag; 1998
- 48. Houba VJG, Temminghoff EJM, Gaikhorst G., van Vark W. Soil analysis procedures using 0.01 M calcium chloride as extraction reagent. Commun Soil Sci Plant Anal 2000; 31 (9–10): 1299–396.
- 49. Zuur A, Ieno EN, Walker N, Saveliev A, Smith GM. Mixed Effects Models and extensions in Ecology with R. New York, USA: Springer-Verlag; 2009.
- 50. Tomlinson DL, Wilson JG, Harris CR, Jeffrey DW. Problems in the assessments of heavy metal levels in estuaries and formation of a pollution index. Helgol Meeresunters. 1980; 33: 566–575.
- 51. Cabrera F, Clemente L, Díaz Barrientos E, López R, Murillo JM. Heavy metal pollution of soils affected by the Guadiamar toxic flood. Sci Total Environ. 1999; 242:117–129 pmid:10635579
- 52. Bowen HJM. Environmental chemistry of the elements. London: Academic Press; 1979.
- 53. Ciadamidaro L, Madejón E, Robinson B, Madejón P. Soil plant interactions of Populus alba in contrasting environments. J Environ Manage. 2014; 132: 329–37. pmid:24333744
- 54. Aguilar J, Dorronsoro C, Gómez-Ariza JL, Galán E. Los criterios y estándares para declarar un suelo contaminado en Andalucía y la metodología y técnica de toma de muestras y análisis para su investigación. Investigación y Desarrollo Medioambiental en Andalucía. Sevilla: Servicio de Publicaciones de la Universidad de Sevilla; 1999.
- 55. Aguilar J, Dorronsoro C, Fernández E, Fernández J, García I, Martín F, et al. Soil pollution by a pyrite mine spill in Spain: Evolution in time. Environ Pollut. 2004; 132(3): 395–401. pmid:15325455
- 56. Hazelton P, Murphy B. Interpreting soil test results. What do all the numbers mean?. Collingwood, Australia: CSIRO Publishing; 2007.
- 57. Adriano DC. Trace Elements in Terrestrial Environments: Biochemistry Bioavailability and Risks of Metals. New York: Springer-Verlag; 2001.
- 58. Reuter DJ, Robinson JB. Plant analysis. An interpretation manual. Australia: CSIRO Publishing; 1997
- 59. Kabata-Pendias A, Pendias H. Trace Elements in Soils and Plants, 4 th ed. Boca Raton: CRC Press; 2011
- 60. Pietrini F, Iori V, Bianconi D, Mughini G, Massacci A, Zacchini M. Assessment of physiological and biochemical responses, metal tolerance and accumulation in two eucalypt hybrid clones for phytoremediation of cadmium-contaminated waters. J Environ Manage. 2015; 162: 221–231 pmid:26253590
- 61. CAC (Consejería de Agricultura y Comercio). Interpretación de análisis de suelo, foliar y de aguas de riego. Consejería de Agricultura y Comercio, Junta de Extremadura. Madrid: Mundi Prensa; 1992.
- 62. Domínguez MT, Madejón P, Marañón T, Murillo JM. Afforestation of a trace-element polluted area in SW Spain: Woody plant performance and trace element accumulation. Eur J For Res. 2010a; 129(1):47–59.
- 63. Teh T, Nik Norulaini NAR, Shahadat M, Wong Y, Mohd Omar AK. Risk assessment of metal contamination in soil and groundwater in Asia: A review of recent trends as well as existing environmental laws and regulations. Pedosphere. 2016; 26(4): 431–450.
- 64. Domínguez MT, Marañón T, Murillo JM, Schulin R, Robinson BH. Nutritional status of mediterranean trees growing in a contaminated and remediated area. Water Air Soil Pollut. 2010b; 205(1–4): 305–21.
- 65. Mengel K, Kirkby EA. Principles of plant nutrition. Bern: International Potash Institute; 1987.
- 66. Carbonell AA, Aarabi MA, Delaune RD, Gambrell RP, Patrick WH. Arsenic in wetland vegetation: Availability, phytotoxicity, uptake and effects on plant growth and nutrition. Sci Total Environ. 1998; 217(3): 189–199.
- 67. Bren LJ. Modelling the influence of River Murray management on the Barmah river red gum forests. Australian-Forestry. 1991; 54(1–2): 9–15.
- 68. Reichman SM, Menzies NW, Asher CJ, Mulligan DR. Seedling responses of four Australian tree species to toxic concentrations of manganese in solution culture. Plant Soil. 2004; 258(1–2): 341–350.
- 69. Xie Q, Li Z, Yang L, Lv J, Jobe TO, Wang Q. A newly identified passive hyperaccumulator Eucalyptus grandis x E. urophylla under manganese stress. PLoS One. 2015;10(9). pmid:26327118
- 70. Madejón P, Alaejos J, García-Álbala J, Fernández M, Madejón E. Three-year study of fast-growing trees in degraded soils amended with composts: Effects on soil fertility and productivity. J Environ Manage. 2016; 169: 18–26. pmid:26716572
- 71. Lambers H, Hayes PE, Laliberté E, Oliveira RS, Turner BL. Leaf manganese accumulation and phosphorus-acquisition efficiency. Trends Plant Sci. 2015; 20(2): 83–90. pmid:25466977
- 72. Deng THB, Tang YT, van der Ent A, Sterckeman T, Echevarria G, Morel JL, et al. Nickel translocation via the phloem in the hyperaccumulator Noccaea caerulescens (Brassicaceae). Plant Soil. 2016; 404(1–2): 35–45.
- 73. Ernst WHO, Verkleij JAC, Schat H. Metal Tolerance in Plants. Acta Bot Neer. 1992; 41(3): 229–48.
- 74. Madejón P, Murillo JM, Marañón T, Cabrera F, Soriano MA. Trace element and nutrient accumulation in sunflower plants two years after the Aznalcóllar mine spill. Sci Total Environ. 2003; 307(1–3): 239–257. pmid:12711438
- 75. Madejón P, Murillo JM, Marañón T, Lepp NW. Factors affecting accumulation of thallium and other trace elements in two wild Brassicaceae spontaneously growing on soils contaminated by tailings dam waste. Chemosphere. 2007; 67(1): 20–28. pmid:17123576
- 76. Bačeva K, Stafilov T, Matevski V. Bioaccumulation of Heavy Metals by Endemic Viola Species from the Soil in the Vicinity of the As-Sb-Tl Mine “Allchar”, Republic of Macedonia. Int J Phytoremediation. 2014; 16(4): 347–365 pmid:24912236
- 77. Pilon-Smits E. Phytoremediation. Annu Rev Plant Biol. 2005; 56(1): 15–39.
- 78. Domínguez MT, Aponte C, Pérez-Ramos IM, García LV, Villar R, Marañón T. Relationships between leaf morphological traits, nutrient concentrations and isotopic signatures for Mediterranean woody plant species and communities. Plant Soil. 2012; 357:407–424.
- 79. Wong MH. Ecological restoration of mine degraded soils, with emphasis on metal contaminated soils. Chemosphere. 2003;50(6): 775–80. pmid:12688490
- 80. Chaney RL, Baklanov IA. Phytoremediation and Phytomining: Status and Promise. Adv Bot Res [Internet]. 2017. Available from: http://linkinghub.elsevier.com/retrieve/pii/S0065229616301252
- 81. Meeinkuirt W, Kruatrachue M, Pichtel J, Phusantisampan T, Saengwilai P. Influence of organic amendments on phytostabilization of Cd-contaminated soil by Eucalyptus camaldulensis. ScienceAsia. 2016; 42: 83–91.
- 82. Meeinkuirt W, Pokethitiyook P, Kruatrachue M, Tanhan P, Chaiyarat R. Phytostabilization of a Pb-contaminated mine tailing by various tree species in pot and field trial experiments. Int J Phytoremediation. 2012; 14: 925–938. pmid:22908655
- 83. Coleman C M, Boyd R S, Eubanks M D. Extending the elemental defense hypothesis: dietary metal concentrations below hyperaccumulator levels could harm herbivores. J Chem Ecol. 2005; 31:1669–1681. pmid:16222801
- 84. Stone C., Bacon P. E. Relationships among moisture stress, insect herbivory, foliar cineole content and the growth of river red gum Eucalyptus camaldulensis. J Appl Ecol, 1994; 31: 604–612
- 85. Terrab A, González AG, Díez MJ, Heredia FJ. Mineral content and electrical conductivity of the honeys produced in Northwest Morocco and their contribution to the characterisation of unifloral honeys. J Sci Food Agric. 2003; 83(7): 637–43.
- 86. Terrab A, Hernanz D, Heredia FJ. Inductively coupled plasma optical emission spectrometric determination of minerals in thyme honeys and their contribution to geographical discrimination. J Agric Food Chem. 2004; 52: 3441–3445. pmid:15161212
- 87. EU. Commission Regulation (EU) No 488/2014 of 12 May 2014 amending Regulation (EC) No 1881/2006 as regards maximum levels of cadmium in foodstuffs. Official Journal of European Union L138/78; 2014. Available from: http://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/en/TXT/?uri=CELEX:32014R0488. Cited 17 March 2017.
- 88. Baker AJM, McGrath SP, Reeves RD, Smith JAC. Metal hyperaccumulator plants: a review of the ecology and physiology of a biological resource for phytoremediation of metal polluted-soils. In: Terry N, Bañuelos G, editors. Phytoremediation of contaminated soil and water. London: Lewis Publishers; 2000. pp. 85–107.
- 89. Das P, Samantaray S, Rout GR. Studies on cadmium toxicity in plants: A review. 98, Environ Pollut. 1997; 98: 29–36. pmid:15093342