Understanding mechanisms of resistance to M. tuberculosis (M.tb) infection in humans could identify novel therapeutic strategies as it has for other infectious diseases, such as HIV.
To compare the early transcriptional response of M.tb-infected monocytes between Ugandan household contacts of tuberculosis patients who demonstrate clinical resistance to M.tb infection (cases) and matched controls with latent tuberculosis infection.
Cases (n = 10) and controls (n = 18) were selected from a long-term household contact study in which cases did not convert their tuberculin skin test (TST) or develop tuberculosis over two years of follow up. We obtained genome-wide transcriptional profiles of M.tb-infected peripheral blood monocytes and used Gene Set Enrichment Analysis and interaction networks to identify cellular processes associated with resistance to clinical M.tb infection.
Measurements and main results
We discovered gene sets associated with histone deacetylases that were differentially expressed when comparing resistant and susceptible subjects. We used small molecule inhibitors to demonstrate that histone deacetylase function is important for the pro-inflammatory response to in-vitro M.tb infection in human monocytes.
Monocytes from individuals who appear to resist clinical M.tb infection differentially activate pathways controlled by histone deacetylase in response to in-vitro M.tb infection when compared to those who are susceptible and develop latent tuberculosis. These data identify a potential cellular mechanism underlying the clinical phenomenon of resistance to M.tb infection despite known exposure to an infectious contact.
Citation: Seshadri C, Sedaghat N, Campo M, Peterson G, Wells RD, Olson GS, et al. (2017) Transcriptional networks are associated with resistance to Mycobacterium tuberculosis infection. PLoS ONE 12(4): e0175844. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0175844
Editor: Selvakumar Subbian, Rutgers Biomedical and Health Sciences, UNITED STATES
Received: November 15, 2016; Accepted: March 31, 2017; Published: April 17, 2017
Copyright: © 2017 Seshadri et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Data Availability: The data discussed in this publication have been deposited in NCBI's Gene Expression Omnibus (GEO) in MIAME-compliant format and are accessible through GEO Series accession number GSE76873. Additionally, detailed analysis code is available at https://github.com/seshadrilab.
Funding: This work was supported by the Tuberculosis Research Unit, Case Western Reserve University, established with funds from the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, National Institutes of Health, and Department of Health and Human Services [N01-AI-95383 and HHSN266200700022C/N01- AI-70022]. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Despite the availability of cost-effective drugs and a safe vaccine, Mycobacterium tuberculosis (M.tb) was responsible for over 1.5 million deaths worldwide in 2014. Understanding mechanisms of pathogenesis could lead to the development of more effective interventions. Animal studies have revealed the importance of IFN-γ and TNF- α for controlling mycobacterial replication[2–4]. These are supplemented by studies of humans who are hypersusceptible to mycobacterial infection as a result of rare genetic mutations in IFN-γ signaling pathways or pharmacologic blockage of TNF-α. Further, co-infection with HIV has emerged as a major reason for the resurgence in tuberculosis, and this effect is not purely due to T-cell depletion[6–10]. Collectively, these studies have only uncovered a partial understanding of the mechanisms underlying susceptibility to mycobacterial infection and disease.
Historically, significant breakthroughs have emerged by studying mechanisms of resistance to infections. A contemporary example is protection of individuals with CCR5Δ32 from HIV infection[11,12]. This discovery led directly to the development of CCR5 inhibitors as drugs. With respect to tuberculosis, individuals may resist initial infection with M.tb or resist the progression from infection to disease. However, mechanisms of resistance to M.tb infection are difficult to study for a number of reasons. First, the diagnosis of M.tb infection is based on an immune response to M.tb proteins rather than direct microbiologic confirmation because there is no test that measures the presence of M.tb in-vivo. Second, because it is an airborne disease, exposure is difficult to quantify and requires extensive epidemiologic investigation. Nevertheless, there have been some attempts to identify individuals who might be able to resist clinical M.tb infection. In the pre-antibiotic era with epidemic rates of tuberculosis in the population, some individuals never demonstrated a positive tuberculin skin test (TST), including workers at tuberculosis hospitals. A genetic linkage study in South Africa revealed a locus on chromosome 11p14 that was associated with a lack of TST reactivity.
More recently, our group established a longitudinal cohort in Uganda in which we identified household contacts of tuberculosis patients and followed them prospectively[16,17]. Among 2585 household contacts of 872 index cases, we identified 255 (9.9%) that were persistently TST negative on repeated testing over at least two years of follow-up. These individuals also did not develop active disease during this time. We hypothesized that there might be a genetic basis to this phenotype, and published a genome-wide linkage study in which we identified two chromosomal loci associated with a negative TST. Even though the TST reflects T-cell memory to mycobacterial antigens, the genetic associations suggest host-intrinsic factors may govern TST conversion after exposure. These data led us to consider whether there might be functional differences in the cellular response to in-vitro M.tb infection between these two clinical groups. Here, we conducted a comparative transcriptomic study and identified differentially expressed gene sets associated with a persistently negative TST. These data revealed that a cellular pathway involving inhibition of histone deactylase is selectively induced among individuals with apparent clinical resistance to M.tb infection.
Materials and methods
We previously published full details of the Kawempe Community Health Study[16,17]. Briefly, newly diagnosed tuberculosis patients were identified at the Uganda National Referral Tuberculosis Treatment Center at Upper Mulago Hospital in Kampala, Uganda. The index cases were enrolled if they had culture confirmed pulmonary tuberculosis and had at least one household contact living with them. Between 2002 and 2012, 2585 household contacts were enrolled and followed prospectively for up to two years for development of tuberculosis disease or diagnosis of latent tuberculosis infection by serial TSTs at 0, 3, 6, 12, 18,and 24 months. This study did not include M.tb-specific interferon gamma release assays (IGRA) because these were not commercially available at the onset of this study. Among all household contacts, 28.5% (N = 737) were TST negative at the initial visit and 34.5% of this group (N = 255) remained TST negative over two years of follow-up. For this study, we define subjects with a persistently negative TST as ‘cases’ and subjects with a positive TST as ‘controls.’ We obtained cryopreserved peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) obtained at enrollment from a convenience samples of 22 cases and 30 controls based on the availability of PBMC for the proposed studies. Demographic and clinical characteristics are shown in Table 1. All subjects were HIV-uninfected. Accumulated epidemiologic risk was calculated using a method originally developed for children under 15 and an adapted version for adults over age 15[20,21]. Because only five individuals were less than 15 years old in this analysis, we report only the adult risk scores. Evidence of past BCG vaccination was based on presence of a characteristic scar. BMI was calculated based on weight and height upon enrollment.
In-vitro infection and RNA extraction
Archived PBMC were thawed and washed twice with RPMI supplemented with 10% fetal calf serum (Atlas Biologicals). Cell viability as determined by trypan blue staining was greater than 80%. Monocytes expressing CD14 were isolated by positive selection (Miltenyi). Depending on the yield, between 500,000 and one million monocytes were plated in duplicate in a 24-well tissue culture plate and rested overnight at 37°C, 5% CO2. The next day, cells were mock-infected or infected with virulent M. tuberculosis strain H37Rv at a multiplicity of infection (MOI) 10:1. After a six-hour incubation at 37°C, 5% CO2, the total RNA was harvested using TRIzol-LS (Invitrogen). We did not observe significant toxicity at this early time point (data not shown). TRIzol samples were stored at -80°C until all infections were completed. To minimize batch effects, equal numbers of cases and controls were processed on each of six days and frozen aliquots of M.tb were used for infections.
TRIzol samples were thawed and the contents transferred to Phase Lock Gel tubes (5PRIME GmbH) and supplemented with 0.2 ml chloroform (Fisher Scientific). Phase Lock Gel tubes were spun at 12,000g for 15 minutes at 4°C and the upper aqueous layer transferred to a 2ml Eppendorf tube. An equal volume of 70% ethanol was added dropwise and mixed by tapping. The contents of this Eppendorf tube were then processed using RNeasy Mini Kit (Qiagen) according the manufacturer’s instructions with the following modifications. DNA digestion was performed with DNAse I (Qiagen) and the final elution was performed twice with 30ul RNase-free water to maximize the yield. Subsequently, RNA was dried down in a Speedvac and resuspended in 10ul water before assessing purity, integrity, and yield. The average RNA Integrity Number (RIN) as measured by Bioanalyzer was 8 and the average yield as measured by Nanodrop was 153 ng.
Microarrays data processing and analysis
Total RNA (50-100ng) was transcribed into complementary DNA, labeled, and hybridized onto Illumina HT-12 v3 microarrays according to the manufacturer’s instructions. This platform includes 48,804 probes covering more than 20,000 annotated genes and 12,000 expressed sequence tags. The initial dataset consisted of 13 case and 22 control subjects, each with paired microarrays from media-treated or M.tb-treated monocytes. Thus, a total of seventy RNA samples were submitted to the Genomics Core at the Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center in Seattle, WA. Four samples did not meet pre-specified quality control criteria after labeling so sixty-six samples underwent hybridization. Principal components analysis revealed a batch effect among ten samples, so these were removed from downstream analysis (S1 Fig). Thus, the final discovery dataset consisted of 10 case and 18 control subjects. Full details regarding data processing and expression analysis, including Limma, Signaling Pathway Interaction Analysis (SPIA), and Gene Set Enrichment Analysis (GSEA), are described in Supplementary Methods[22–25]. SPIA and GSEA examined the enrichment of 137 and 4726 gene sets, respectively. The data discussed in this publication have been deposited in NCBI's Gene Expression Omnibus (GEO) in MIAME-compliant format and are accessible through GEO Series accession number GSE76873[26–28].
To delineate interactions among enriched pathways, genes in all enriched pathway, as well as interactions among genes, were extracted from KEGG using the ‘graphite’ package in R. Pathways were considered enriched in either cases and controls samples if they were found significant at FDR 10% by SPIA because of the small number of pathways considered by this method. FDR threshold was set at 20% for GSEA for the purposes of hypothesis generation and in the spirit of the original publications . Connectedness between pairs of pathways was defined based on the number of genes common between both pathways. To quantify the overlap between pathways, we used the Jaccard Index, i.e. the ratio of the number of genes common between the two pathways over the total number of genes in both pathways. To obtain an interpretable network, an edge between a pair of pathways was drawn if the Jaccard index was at least 0.1.
Human monocytes were isolated from peripheral blood of healthy volunteers by Ficoll gradient separation followed by positive selection using human anti-CD14 antibody assisted magnetic bead separation (Miltenyi Biotec, Auburn, CA). Human pro-monocytic cell line U937 (American Type Culture Collection, ATCC CRL-1593.2) and isolated monocytes were maintained in cell culture at 37°C and 5% CO2 in RPMI 1640 medium containing 10% FCS. Cells were pretreated with 4-phenylbutyrate (Tocris), sodium butyrate (Sigma), or depsipeptide (Sigma) for 1 hour and then stimulated with LPS (List Biological) and M.tb whole cell lysate (BEI resources) in the case of U937s or live M.tb strain H37Rv (D. Sherman) at a multiplicity of infection (MOI) of 2.5 in the case of monocytes for 24 hours. These MOIs were optimized in preliminary experiments to balance the production of inflammatory cytokines and cellular toxicity (data not shown). Subsequently, supernatants were harvested and cytokines (IL-6, TNF, IL-1β) quantified by ELISA (R&D Systems, Minneapolis, MN). Each sample was assayed in duplicate, and experiments shown were performed at least twice to ensure reproducibility. Phenylbutyrate and sodium butyrate were dissolved in water, and depsipeptide was dissolved in DMSO.
The institutional review boards (IRB) at University Hospitals of Cleveland Medical Center and the Uganda Council for Science and Technology approved the Ugandan study. All individuals in the Ugandan study provided written informed consent, including written consent from the parents of study participants. The lab-based investigations described here were further approved by the IRB at the University of Washington.
Bacterial growth assay
M.tb strain Erdman was transformed with vector encoding the bacterial luciferase operon, and frozen stocks were generously provided Dr. Jeffery Cox (UCSF). We confirmed a linear relationship between relative light units (RLU) and colony forming units (CFU) (data not shown). To analyze the effect of phenylbutyrate, sodium butyrate, depsipeptide, and rifampin (final concentration of 0.1 ug/ml) in broth culture, bacterial stock cultures were thawed and diluted to an OD600 of 0.005 in 7H9+GAT media containing Difco Middlebrook 7H9 Broth (BD) containing BBL Middlebrook ADC enrichment (BD), 0.05% Tween 80 (Sigma), and 0.2% Glycerol. Next, we made serial dilutions of each drug to a final concentration of 10X in 7H9+GAT supplemented with 10% DMSO. In a 96-well U-bottom tissue culture plate (Falcon), 180 ul of the diluted bacterial culture was added to each well and 20 ul of each drug was added at 1/10 volume (in duplicate). For the 1% (MIC 99) control, 200 ul of diluted bacterial culture was added to each well. Plates were incubated at 37C° 5% CO2 for 8 days at which time cultures were transferred to 96-well white well plates (Nunc, 136101) and relative light units (RLUs) were measured using a plate reader (Synergy H4, BioTek).
The early transcriptional response to in-vitro M.tb infection is broadly conserved among cases and controls
We isolated peripheral blood monocytes from 10 cases and 18 controls, infected them with live M.tb for six hours, and measured genome-wide transcriptional profiles (Fig 1a and Table 1). Principal components analysis revealed that infection was the greatest source of variability in the data, accounting for 40% in PC1, and this was much greater than any technical variable, such as batch, RNA quality, or RNA yield (Fig 1b and data not shown). Notably, TST status did not differentiate samples within the first two principal components (Fig 1b). Among TST-negative subjects we observed 3490 induced and 4543 suppressed genes after M.tb infection with FDR 10%. Among TST-positive subjects we observed 4199 induced and 5408 suppressed genes after M.tb infection with FDR 10%. We then used Signaling Pathway Impact Analysis (SPIA) to investigate whether these genes represented canonical pathways that were differentially activated or suppressed (perturbed) between cases and controls subjects. The advantage of SPIA is the ability to take into account the natural topology of a biological network by simultaneously accounting for genes that are both induced and suppressed in the same pathway. We found 12 KEGG pathways that were significantly perturbed among control subjects, and a subset of these was also perturbed among cases (S2 Fig). We generated network graphs using pathways that were significantly enriched at FDR 10% (Fig 1c). We found that a core group of 11 highly connected biological processes are similarly perturbed in monocytes derived from both cases and controls. Additionally, 16 pathways were preferentially perturbed among controls and three pathways were specifically perturbed among cases. A closer review of the data revealed that some of these groups-specific pathways were also perturbed in the other group but at an FDR cut-off just beyond the threshold value of 10% (data not shown). Taken together, these data reveal that the early transcriptional response to in-vitro M.tb infection is highly conserved but some processes may be associated with either a positive or negative TST among tuberculosis household contacts in Uganda.
(A) Schematic of study design. CD14+ monocytes from cases or controls were isolated from cryopreserved PBMC and exposed to either media or M.tb strain H37Rv for six hours prior to harvesting total RNA for transcriptional profiling with Illumina HT-12 microarrays. (B) Principal components analysis was performed on quantile normalized data and reveals M.tb infection as the major source of variability in the data. (C). Network diagram generated from KEGG pathways identified through Signaling Pathway Interaction Analysis (SPIA) reveals that largely overlapping cellular processes are perturbed after infection. The color of each node represents the status of the pathway as either activated (red) or inhibited (blue). The size of the node is proportional to the number of genes in the pathway.
Gene set enrichment analysis reveals pathways uniquely associated with resistance to clinical M.tb infection
To expand our analysis, we collapsed the data by subtracting background values of gene expression in media control wells to compare fold changes in gene expression after in-vitro M.tb infection between cases and controls. We found 210 genes that were differentially expressed at a nominal p-value of 0.05; however, after correcting for multiple hypothesis testing using the Benjamini-Hochberg method, none of these were statistically significant (data not shown). This highlights the limitations of a gene-by-gene approach in an experimental setting where we have a priori knowledge that a substantial fraction of observed changes in gene expression are shared between the two groups (Fig 1c). To expand to a gene-set based analysis not just limited to KEGG pathways, we employed Gene Set Enrichment Analysis (GSEA), which has the additional advantage of dichotomizing the background-subtracted data according to TST status, which is our variable of interest. Using GSEA, we found 24 and 27 gene sets uniquely associated with controls and cases at FDR 20%, respectively (Table 2 and S1 Table). The knowledge base accessed by GSEA includes both experimentally derived as well as manually curated gene sets that are often overlapping, so we constructed an interaction network of the gene sets enriched among cases. The degree of overlap, the size and significance of the pathways, and the number of their neighboring pathways are depicted in Fig 2a. The most significantly enriched (gene set 1) among cases subjects is ‘JOSEPH_RESPONSE_TO_SODIUM_BUTYRATE_DN,’ a study of the effects of sodium butyrate on gene expression in a lung cancer cell line. We constructed a Venn Diagram of the subnetwork centered on this gene set to highlight the biological processes and gene-gene interactions. Notably, we found that ‘JOSEPH’ interacted with innate inflammatory signaling through well-known mediators, such as IL-6 and TRAF6 (Fig 2b). ‘JOSEPH’ also interacted with lysosomal function through its effects on alpha-glucosidase (GAA). We also found a second HDAC-related gene set that was enriched among cases (PEART_HDAC-PROLIFERATION_CLUSTER_UP, FDR 0.036). To confirm the robustness of these associations, we performed a sensitivity analysis in which we included the ten samples that were removed because of batch effects (S1 Fig). We found 26 gene sets enriched among cases of which seven overlapped with our primary results, including ‘JOSEPH’ (S1 Table). We also performed network analysis using the EnrichmentMap Cytoscape App and results were identical to that shown in Fig 2A (data not shown) . Finally, we found cellular processes associated with HDAC function in gene sets associated with controls, suggesting that these functions may be central for the innate immune response to mycobacteria (DELLA_RESPONSE_TO_TSA_AND_BUTYRATE AND PID_HDAC_CLASSII_PATHWAY) (S2 Table). These analyses suggest that a set of biological processes centered on the effects of HDACi on cells are differentially expressed in monocytes when comparing M.tb-resistant and M.tb-susceptible individuals after in-vitro infection with M.tb.
(A) A network diagram was generated from the results of GSEA listed in Table 2 with a FDR < 20%. In this network, each node corresponds to a gene set (pathway); an edge is drawn between two gene sets with a black line if the genes in the two gene sets overlap. Here, the diameter of each node corresponds to the relative number of genes in each gene set; the degree of blue color shading in the perimeter of each node represents the number of its neighbors (number of gene sets whose members overlap); the degree of central red color shading reflects significance (FDR value); and the thickness of each edge corresponds to the number of genes shared by the two neighboring gene sets (proportional to the Jaccard Index between pathways). Gene set 1 is ‘JOSEPH_RESPONSE_TO_SODIUM_BUTYRATE.’ (B) Venn diagram centered on the ‘JOSEPH’ gene set and its 6 neighboring gene sets in diagram. Each shaded area corresponds to a gene set, and edges between pairs of genes correspond to gene-gene interactions defined in KEGG, obtained using the ‘graphite’ R-package. Genes present in the gene set but absent from the KEGG database are not shown for clarity. The location of HDAC1, GAA, TRAF6, and IL-6 are highlighted along with their neighbors.
Histone deacetylase inhibitors regulate the pro-inflammatory response of human monocytes to in-vitro M.tb infection
The results from GSEA include gene sets that were induced and suppressed after treatment of cells with HDACi, so the predicted direction of effect in the setting of mycobacterial infection is not clear. We hypothesized that histone deacetylase function might be important for generating an inflammatory response to in-vitro mycobacterial infection. Because the availability of primary cells from cases and controls were limited, we first tested this hypothesis using human cell lines. IL-6 production from U937 cells in response to stimulation with LPS or M.tb lysate was inhibited by sodium butyrate in a dose-dependent fashion (Fig 3a). Notably, TNF-α production was not inhibited, ruling out a global toxic effect of inhibiting histone deacetylase function. These results are consistent with the known anti-inflammatory effects of HDACi and inhibitory effects on IL-6 production[31,32]. To generalize these findings, we tested two other HDACi that are FDA-approved for clinical use. Depsipeptide also showed dose-dependent inhibition of IL-6 production but not TNF-α (Fig 3b). Inhibition of both IL-6 and TNF-α was seen with phenylbutyrate but only at the highest dose tested, suggesting a toxic effect of this compound (Fig 3c). To address whether HDACi have direct effects on mycobacterial growth, we performed experiments using a strain of M.tb that has been engineered to constitutively express bacterial luciferase. We found dose-dependent inhibition of M.tb growth using phenylbutyrate and observed a minimum inhibitory concentration (MIC) of 1.25mM (Fig 4a). These data are consistent with published data and validate our system. We also observed some dose-dependent inhibition with sodium butyrate, but the calculated MIC was 25-50mM (Fig 4b). Finally, we observed no inhibition of growth with depsipeptide at doses that were sufficient for suppressing IL-6 production (Fig 4c). These data reveal that some clinically approved HDACi potently inhibit IL-6 production after contact with microbial products without a significant effect on mycobacterial growth.
U937 cells were stimulated with media alone, LPS at a final concentration of 100 ng/ml, or M.tb whole cell lysate at a final concentration of 25 μg/ml after one hour pre-treatment with titrating doses of histone-deacetylase inhibitors. IL-6 and TNF-α were quantified in supernatants harvested after 18 hours for (A) sodium butyrate, (B), depsipeptide, and (C) phenylbutyrate. These data are representative of at least three independent experiments.
The effect of histone deacetylase inhibitors (A) depsipeptide, (B) sodium butyrate, and (C) phenylbutyrate on mycobacterial growth in broth culture was measured using an autoluminescent strain of M.tb that has been stably transfected with the bacterial Lux operon. Controls included rifampin (RIF) at a final concentration of 1 microgram/ml and 1% of the inoculum (1%) to assess the minimum inhibitory concentration 99% (MIC99—dashed line). The asterix indicates the first dose at which luminescence is not significantly different from or less than the 1% inoculum. M.tb was grown in media supplemented with titrating doses of HDACi for seven days prior to measuring relative light units (RLU). Results are representative of at least three independent experiments.
To directly investigate the link between HDACi and M.tb infection of human monocytes as suggested by our microarray data, we treated monocytes from ten healthy donors with HDACi prior to in-vitro infection with M.tb. Analysis of cultured supernatants after overnight incubation revealed strong inhibition of IL-6 and TNF-α production by depsipeptide and sodium butyrate (Fig 5a and 5b). Notably, IL-1β production was either not affected (sodium butyrate) or increased (depsipeptide), ruling out a toxic effect of the compounds (Fig 5c). These data support a direct role for HDACs in regulating the inflammatory response of human mononuclear phagocytes to in-vitro mycobacterial infection.
CD14+ peripheral blood monocytes from ten healthy adults were infected with M.tb strain H37Rv at a multiplicity of infection of 2.5:1 for 24 hours after one hour pre-treatment of histone deacetylase inhibitors (HDACi) depsipeptide and sodium butyrate at a final concentration of 50 ng/ml and 5mM, respectively. Cultured supernatants were tested for production of the pro-inflammatory cytokines (A) IL-6, (B) TNF-α, and (C) IL-1β. Results are representative of two replicate experiments. (*p<0.05, ***p<0.001, ****p<0.0001 by two-tailed Mann-Whitney test).
We compared the early transcriptional response to in-vitro M.tb infection in monocytes derived from M.tb-susceptible and M.tb-resistant household contacts in Uganda. We found a number of sub-cellular processes that are associated with resistance to M.tb using complementary systems biology approaches. Specifically, we show that inhibition of histone deactylase function is important for the early innate immune response to in-vitro M.tb infection. Our results demonstrate a feasible approach to understanding innate immune mechanisms underlying the phenomenon of apparent resistance to clinical M.tb infection in humans.
We identified histone deacetylase function as important for the innate immune response to in-vitro M.tb infection. A recent study revealed that phenylbutyrate was bacteriostatic against M.tb in culture and restricted intracellular growth in macrophages. Knockdown of HDAC1 in a human macrophage cell line has been shown to reduce survival of intracellular M.tb. In addition, adjunctive treatment with phenylbutyrate and Vitamin D3 were associated with higher rates of sputum culture conversion in a randomized controlled clinical trial of pulmonary tuberculosis patients. Our results confirm the growth inhibitory potential of phenylbutyrate and reveal the therapeutic potential of other HDACi. In contrast to phenylbutyrate, sodium butyrate and depsipeptide potently inhibited the monocyte immune response to in-vitro M.tb infection without affecting growth in broth culture. Depsipeptide is structurally distinct from the butyrate compounds and was recently FDA approved for the treatment of cutaneous T-cell lymphoma. As a class, butyrate compounds exhibit low-affinity interactions with HDAC proteins and have largely been surpassed by pharmacologically optimized drugs for the treatment of cancer. Our results suggest that HDACi other than phenylbutyrate may also have potential as host-directed therapies for tuberculosis. However, several aspects of our results warrant caution when considering off-label use of HDACi as host-directed therapy for clinical M.tb infection. First, we found a mostly anti-inflammatory effect in-vitro that may not predict effects in-vivo. A recent study of HDACi showed a similar discordance that did not predict increased survival in a sepsis model. Second, we also found HDAC-related gene sets associated with the control subjects (gene sets 17 and 19 in S2 Table). These results highlight that the balance between infection and inflammation modulated by histone deacetylation is likely a critical determinant in clinical outcomes after clinical M.tb infection.
One limitation of our study design is that the cases we selected were younger than the control subjects, potentially confounding the association between transcriptional networks and resistance to M.tb (Table 1). However, none of the subjects in this study were younger than ten years old, and we could not discern any differences in transcriptional profiles when stratified by age (S3 Fig). It is well known that TST has decreased sensitivity in children under the age of two, but there is no evidence that this is true for older children. Further, innate immune responses to inflammatory stimuli are blunted in infants and neonates but not children over five with nearly mature immune systems. We have also previously shown that innate immune responses are similar between cases and controls in our cohort regardless of age. Thus, it is less likely that our results are substantially confounded by age though larger studies in which samples are matched by age are required. Another potential limitation is that we cannot formally quantify the exposure of individuals who failed to convert their TST. However, we previously demonstrated no difference in a validated epidemiologic risk score between controls and cases subjects in our cohort. The specific subjects studied here all showed comparable levels of high exposure to M.tb (Table 1). Our study involved hundreds of household contacts of tuberculosis cases that were followed longitudinally for two years, but the TST is at best an imperfect assessment of the presence of viable mycobacteria in the host. These results suggest that future studies should include an additional measure of clinical infection, such as IGRA, and more than two years of follow-up would make our clinical definition even more rigorous. Finally, we were unable to use GSEA to validate a hypothesis about the role of HDACi, and a small sample size precluded the use of other pathway topology or machine learning approaches might have provided complementary results. Future experiments with larger sample sizes are required to confirm and extend the statistical associations reported here.
Studying the cellular mechanisms underlying apparent clinical resistance to M.tb infection has been a major advance for the field. By combining rigorous case definitions with longitudinal follow-up, hypothesis-generating systems biology approaches, and hypothesis-testing laboratory experiments, we were able to identify the central role of HDAC function in the innate immune response to M.tb. Our data suggest that a balanced inflammatory response to initial infection with M.tb may influence long-term clinical outcomes. We expect that further laboratory investigation of differentially expressed gene sets will uncover additional mechanisms that might translate into therapies for tuberculosis as well as identifying biomarkers of heightened resistance to M.tb infection.
S2 Fig. Results of Signaling Pathway Interaction Analysis (SPIA).
S3 Fig. Principal components plot stratified by age and treatment.
S1 Table. GSEA results including samples that were previously discarded due to batch effect.
S2 Table. Gene sets preferentially associated with susceptible controls who develop latent tuberculosis infection.
The authors would like to thank Jeff Delrow, Alyssa Dawson, and Ryan Basom at the Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center DNA Core for assistance with Illumina microarray data generation and processing and Reiling Liao for assistance with BSL-3 experiments. We gratefully acknowledge the invaluable contribution made by the Kawempe study team’s medical officers, health visitors, laboratory and data personnel in Uganda and USA: Dr. Lorna Nshuti, Dr. Sarah Zalwango, Dr. Mary Nsereko, Dr. Roy Mugerwa, Dr. Moses Joloba, Dr. Alphose Okwera, Dr. Brenda Okwera, Dr. Christopher Whalen, Allan Chiunda, LaShaunda Malone, Bonnie Thiel, Mark Breda, Dennis Dobbs, Hussein Kisingo, Mary Rutaro, Albert Muganda, Richard Bamuhimbisa, Yusuf Mulumba, Deborah Nsamba, Barbara Kyeyune, Faith Kintu, Gladys Mpalanyi, Janet Mukose, Grace Tumusiime, Pierre Peters, Joy Baseke, Annet Kawuma, Saidah Menya, Joan Nassuna, Karen Morgan, Alfred Etwom, Micheal Angel Mugerwa, Keith Chervenak, and Lisa Kucharski. We would like to acknowledge and thank Dr. Francis Adatu Engwau, Head of the Uganda National Tuberculosis and Leprosy Program, for his support of this project and the medical officers, nurses and counselors at the National Tuberculosis Treatment Centre, Mulago Hospital, the Ugandan National Tuberculosis and Leprosy Program, and the Uganda Tuberculosis Investigation Bacteriological Unit, Wandegeya, for their contributions to this study. This study would not be possible without the generous participation of the Ugandan TB patients and their families.
- Conceptualization: CS MC GP RDW TRH.
- Data curation: CS.
- Formal analysis: CS GSO NS AS.
- Funding acquisition: WHB.
- Investigation: CS MC GP RDW.
- Resources: DRS CMS HMK WHB.
- Writing – original draft: CS.
- Writing – review & editing: CS TRH.
- 1. WHO (2015) Global Tuberculosis Report.
- 2. Mogues T, Goodrich ME, Ryan L, LaCourse R, North RJ (2001) The relative importance of T cell subsets in immunity and immunopathology of airborne Mycobacterium tuberculosis infection in mice. J Exp Med 193: 271–280. pmid:11157048
- 3. Flynn JL, Goldstein MM, Chan J, Triebold KJ, Pfeffer K, et al. (1995) Tumor necrosis factor-alpha is required in the protective immune response against Mycobacterium tuberculosis in mice. Immunity 2: 561–572. pmid:7540941
- 4. Flynn JL, Chan J, Triebold KJ, Dalton DK, Stewart TA, et al. (1993) An essential role for interferon gamma in resistance to Mycobacterium tuberculosis infection. J Exp Med 178: 2249–2254. pmid:7504064
- 5. Casanova JL, Abel L (2002) Genetic dissection of immunity to mycobacteria: the human model. Annu Rev Immunol 20: 581–620. pmid:11861613
- 6. Havlir DV, Barnes PF (1999) Tuberculosis in patients with human immunodeficiency virus infection. N Engl J Med 340: 367–373. pmid:9929528
- 7. Jones BE, Young SM, Antoniskis D, Davidson PT, Kramer F, et al. (1993) Relationship of the manifestations of tuberculosis to CD4 cell counts in patients with human immunodeficiency virus infection. Am Rev Respir Dis 148: 1292–1297. pmid:7902049
- 8. Leroy V, Salmi LR, Dupon M, Sentilhes A, Texier-Maugein J, et al. (1997) Progression of human immunodeficiency virus infection in patients with tuberculosis disease. A cohort study in Bordeaux, France, 1988–1994. The Groupe d'Epidemiologie Clinique du Sida en Aquitaine (GECSA). Am J Epidemiol 145: 293–300. pmid:9054232
- 9. Toossi Z (2003) Virological and immunological impact of tuberculosis on human immunodeficiency virus type 1 disease. J Infect Dis 188: 1146–1155. pmid:14551885
- 10. Zumla A, Raviglione M, Hafner R, von Reyn CF (2013) Tuberculosis. N Engl J Med 368: 745–755. pmid:23425167
- 11. Liu R, Paxton WA, Choe S, Ceradini D, Martin SR, et al. (1996) Homozygous defect in HIV-1 coreceptor accounts for resistance of some multiply-exposed individuals to HIV-1 infection. Cell 86: 367–377. pmid:8756719
- 12. Samson M, Libert F, Doranz BJ, Rucker J, Liesnard C, et al. (1996) Resistance to HIV-1 infection in caucasian individuals bearing mutant alleles of the CCR-5 chemokine receptor gene. Nature 382: 722–725. pmid:8751444
- 13. Gulick RM, Lalezari J, Goodrich J, Clumeck N, DeJesus E, et al. (2008) Maraviroc for previously treated patients with R5 HIV-1 infection. N Engl J Med 359: 1429–1441. pmid:18832244
- 14. Heimbeck J (1948) BCG vaccination of nurses. Tubercle 29: 84–88. pmid:18909014
- 15. Cobat A, Gallant CJ, Simkin L, Black GF, Stanley K, et al. (2009) Two loci control tuberculin skin test reactivity in an area hyperendemic for tuberculosis. J Exp Med 206: 2583–2591. pmid:19901083
- 16. Whalen CC, Chiunda A, Zalwango S, Nshuti L, Jones-Lopez E, et al. (2006) Immune correlates of acute Mycobacterium tuberculosis infection in household contacts in Kampala, Uganda. Am J Trop Med Hyg 75: 55–61. pmid:16837709
- 17. Stein CM, Hall NB, Malone LL, Mupere E (2013) The household contact study design for genetic epidemiological studies of infectious diseases. Front Genet 4: 61. pmid:23641253
- 18. Stein CM, Zalwango S, Malone LL, Won S, Mayanja-Kizza H, et al. (2008) Genome scan of M. tuberculosis infection and disease in Ugandans. PLoS One 3: e4094. pmid:19116662
- 19. Chheng P, Nsereko M, Malone LL, Okware B, Zalwango S, et al. (2015) Tuberculosis case finding in first-degree relative contacts not living with index tuberculosis cases in Kampala, Uganda. Clin Epidemiol 7: 411–419. pmid:26508888
- 20. Mandalakas AM, Kirchner HL, Lombard C, Walzl G, Grewal HM, et al. (2012) Well-quantified tuberculosis exposure is a reliable surrogate measure of tuberculosis infection. Int J Tuberc Lung Dis 16: 1033–1039. pmid:22692027
- 21. Ma N, Zalwango S, Malone LL, Nsereko M, Wampande EM, et al. (2014) Clinical and epidemiological characteristics of individuals resistant to M. tuberculosis infection in a longitudinal TB household contact study in Kampala, Uganda. BMC Infect Dis 14: 352. pmid:24970328
- 22. Ritchie ME, Phipson B, Wu D, Hu Y, Law CW, et al. (2015) limma powers differential expression analyses for RNA-sequencing and microarray studies. Nucleic Acids Res 43: e47. pmid:25605792
- 23. Tarca AL, Draghici S, Khatri P, Hassan SS, Mittal P, et al. (2009) A novel signaling pathway impact analysis. Bioinformatics 25: 75–82. pmid:18990722
- 24. Mootha VK, Lindgren CM, Eriksson KF, Subramanian A, Sihag S, et al. (2003) PGC-1alpha-responsive genes involved in oxidative phosphorylation are coordinately downregulated in human diabetes. Nat Genet 34: 267–273. pmid:12808457
- 25. Subramanian A, Tamayo P, Mootha VK, Mukherjee S, Ebert BL, et al. (2005) Gene set enrichment analysis: a knowledge-based approach for interpreting genome-wide expression profiles. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 102: 15545–15550. pmid:16199517
- 26. Edgar R, Domrachev M, Lash AE (2002) Gene Expression Omnibus: NCBI gene expression and hybridization array data repository. Nucleic Acids Res 30: 207–210. pmid:11752295
- 27. Barrett T, Wilhite SE, Ledoux P, Evangelista C, Kim IF, et al. (2013) NCBI GEO: archive for functional genomics data sets—update. Nucleic Acids Res 41: D991–995. pmid:23193258
- 28. R Development Core Team (2010) R: A language and environment for statistical computing. Vienna, Austria: R Foundation for Statistical Computing.
- 29. Sales G, Calura E, Cavalieri D, Romualdi C (2012) graphite—a Bioconductor package to convert pathway topology to gene network. BMC Bioinformatics 13: 20. pmid:22292714
- 30. Merico D, Isserlin R, Stueker O, Emili A, Bader GD (2010) Enrichment map: a network-based method for gene-set enrichment visualization and interpretation. PLoS One 5: e13984. pmid:21085593
- 31. Grabiec AM, Krausz S, de Jager W, Burakowski T, Groot D, et al. (2010) Histone deacetylase inhibitors suppress inflammatory activation of rheumatoid arthritis patient synovial macrophages and tissue. J Immunol 184: 2718–2728. pmid:20100935
- 32. Mombelli M, Lugrin J, Rubino I, Chanson AL, Giddey M, et al. (2011) Histone deacetylase inhibitors impair antibacterial defenses of macrophages. J Infect Dis 204: 1367–1374. pmid:21921209
- 33. Coussens AK, Wilkinson RJ, Martineau AR (2015) Phenylbutyrate Is Bacteriostatic against Mycobacterium tuberculosis and Regulates the Macrophage Response to Infection, Synergistically with 25-Hydroxy-Vitamin D3. PLoS Pathog 11: e1005007. pmid:26133770
- 34. Chandran A, Antony C, Jose L, Mundayoor S, Natarajan K, et al. (2015) Mycobacterium tuberculosis Infection Induces HDAC1-Mediated Suppression of IL-12B Gene Expression in Macrophages. Front Cell Infect Microbiol 5: 90. pmid:26697414
- 35. Mily A, Rekha RS, Kamal SM, Arifuzzaman AS, Rahim Z, et al. (2015) Significant Effects of Oral Phenylbutyrate and Vitamin D3 Adjunctive Therapy in Pulmonary Tuberculosis: A Randomized Controlled Trial. PLoS One 10: e0138340. pmid:26394045
- 36. Whittaker SJ, Demierre MF, Kim EJ, Rook AH, Lerner A, et al. (2010) Final results from a multicenter, international, pivotal study of romidepsin in refractory cutaneous T-cell lymphoma. J Clin Oncol 28: 4485–4491. pmid:20697094
- 37. Roger T, Lugrin J, Le Roy D, Goy G, Mombelli M, et al. (2011) Histone deacetylase inhibitors impair innate immune responses to Toll-like receptor agonists and to infection. Blood 117: 1205–1217. pmid:20956800
- 38. Steiner P, Rao M, Victoria MS, Jabbar H, Steiner M (1980) Persistently negative tuberculin reactions: their presence among children with culture positive for Mycobacterium tuberculosis (tuberculin-negative tuberculosis). Am J Dis Child 134: 747–750. pmid:7405911
- 39. Shey MS, Nemes E, Whatney W, de Kock M, Africa H, et al. (2014) Maturation of innate responses to mycobacteria over the first nine months of life. J Immunol 192: 4833–4843. pmid:24733845
- 40. Mahan CS, Zalwango S, Thiel BA, Malone LL, Chervenak KA, et al. (2012) Innate and adaptive immune responses during acute M. tuberculosis infection in adult household contacts in Kampala, Uganda. Am J Trop Med Hyg 86: 690–697. pmid:22492155