http://orcid.org/0000-0002-1231-2488
Figures
Abstract
Background
The Subclass Coleoidea (Class Cephalopoda) accommodates the diverse present-day internally shelled cephalopod mollusks (Spirula, Sepia and octopuses, squids, Vampyroteuthis) and also extinct internally shelled cephalopods. Recent Spirula represents a unique coleoid retaining shell structures, a narrow marginal siphuncle and globular protoconch that signify the ancestry of the subclass Coleoidea from the Paleozoic subclass Bactritoidea. This hypothesis has been recently supported by newly recorded diverse bactritoid-like coleoids from the Carboniferous of the USA, but prior to this study no fossil cephalopod indicative of an endochochleate branch with an origin independent from subclass Bactritoidea has been reported.
Methodology/Principal findings
Two orthoconic conchs were recovered from the Early Eocene of Seymour Island at the tip of the Antarctic Peninsula, Antarctica. They have loosely mineralized organic-rich chitin-compatible microlaminated shell walls and broadly expanded central siphuncles. The morphological, ultrustructural and chemical data were determined and characterized through comparisons with extant and extinct taxa using Scanning Electron Microscopy/Energy Dispersive Spectrometry (SEM/EDS).
Conclusions/Significance
Our study presents the first evidence for an evolutionary lineage of internally shelled cephalopods with independent origin from Bactritoidea/Coleoidea, indicating convergent evolution with the subclass Coleoidea. A new subclass Paracoleoidea Doguzhaeva n. subcl. is established for accommodation of orthoconic cephalopods with the internal shell associated with a broadly expanded central siphuncle. Antarcticerida Doguzhaeva n. ord., Antarcticeratidae Doguzhaeva n. fam., Antarcticeras nordenskjoeldi Doguzhaeva n. gen., n. sp. are described within the subclass Paracoleoidea. The analysis of organic-rich shell preservation of A. nordenskjoeldi by use of SEM/EDS techniques revealed fossilization of hyposeptal cameral soft tissues. This suggests that a depositional environment favoring soft-tissue preservation was the factor enabling conservation of the weakly mineralized shell of A. nordenskjoeldi.
Citation: Doguzhaeva LA, Bengtson S, Reguero MA, Mörs T (2017) An Eocene orthocone from Antarctica shows convergent evolution of internally shelled cephalopods. PLoS ONE 12(3): e0172169. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0172169
Editor: Geerat J. Vermeij, University of California, UNITED STATES
Received: October 10, 2016; Accepted: January 31, 2017; Published: March 1, 2017
Copyright: © 2017 Doguzhaeva et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Data Availability: All relevant data are within the paper and its Supporting Information files. The figured specimens have been deposited at the Swedish Museum of Natural History and are available upon request.
Funding: This work was supported by Swedish Research Council, 2009-4447 (TM) (http://www.formas.se/en/); Argentine Research Council, PIP 0462 (MR) (http://www.conicet.gov.ar/); Argentine National Agency for Promotion of Science and Technology, PICTO-2010-0093 (MR) (http://www.agencia.mincyt.gob.ar/); and Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences (LD) (http://www.kva.se/). The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Introduction
The present-day shelled coleoid cephalopods, comprising the two genera Spirula and Sepia, have a long evolutionary history with indisputable earliest records of rostrum-bearing coleoids in the Early Carboniferous [1, 2]. Recent recognition of the Early–Late Carboniferous bactritoid-like coleoids [3–9] supports the idea that Coleoidea originated from the Bactritoidea [10–12]. The Late Carboniferous Shimanskya from Western Texas, Brewster Country, Marathon Basin; USA, has a Spirula/Sepia shell-wall type characterized by absence of nacreous layer. This shell-wall type has been earlier known in the fossil spirulid genus Adygeya from the Early Cretaceous of north-western Caucasus [13] and is atypical for the externally shelled cephalopods, in which a nacreous layer forms the bulk of the shell-wall thickness [14–20]. Thus, Shimanskya demonstrates the evolutionary stability of the Spirula/Sepia shell-wall type through a period of about 330 million years. Another Late Carboniferous coleoid genus, Donovaniconus (order Donovaniconida), retained a shell wall with nacreous layer, as in bactritoids, but secreted a rostrum-like sheath upon it and an ink sac, which is not the case with the bactritoids [4]. The chemical data that would clarify whether the original shell composition in Shimanskya and Donovaniconus was organic-rich, as in Sepia and Spirula, are yet absent. However, data are available from the cuttlebone of the Eocene cuttlefish Mississaepia to show that shell wall and septa were rich in a chitin-compatible component and had a high content of nitrogen [21, 22]. The extant Sepia secretes an ultra-lightweight, high-stiffness organic-rich biomaterial that efficiently maintains neutral buoyancy at considerable habitation depths [23–27]. In various ectocochleate cephalopods, irrespective of their systematic affiliation, the wall typically consists of the outer prismatic, nacreous and inner prismatic layers [14–20] but rare forms among them have additional layers on the standard shell wall [28–30]. These layers imply a capability to stretch the mantle onto the external shell surface, producing an internally shelled condition that, at first glance, is similar to that in Spirula and Sepia.
The present paper reports a new subclass Paracoleoidea Doguzhaeva n. subcl. It is based on a unique Early Eocene straight-shelled cephalopod, Antarcticeras nordenskjoeldi n. gen., n. sp., from Seymour Island, Antarctic, that is characterized by thin microlaminated organic-rich shell wall, non-biomineralized septa, a central broadly expanded siphuncle, and an unusually broad septal foramen. The shell wall characteristics indicate the internalization of the shell. The central siphuncle illuminates the ancestry of a new subclass from the subclass Orthoceratoidea. The phylogenetic significance of the unique Eocene cephalopod from Antarctica is discussed.
Materials and methods
Material
Two specimens of fragmentary preserved straight shells from the La Meseta Formation [31–35] on Seymour Island, Antarctica, are examined. The age of the shells is dated as Ypresian, Early Eocene (for Geological setting and Palaeoenvironment, see S1 Text [36–53]). They are stored in the collections of the Department of Palaeobiology at the Swedish Museum of Natural History under depository numbers NRM-PZ Mo 167764, NRM-PZ Mo 167765 and are available upon request. These shells are described as Antarcticeras nordenskjoeldi n. gen., sp. (see Systematic Paleontology herein). A coiled nautilid, Euciphoceras sp. (NRM-PZ Mo 167766), from the La Meseta Formation on Seymour Island is examined with the purpose to evaluate the ultrastructural preservation of the cephalopod shell material in these rocks (see Supporting materials). Recent beach-collected specimens of Spirula spirula from Cuba (NRM-PZ Mo 167767) and Sepia officinalis from south Portugal (NRM-PZ Mo 1677648) are studied for comparison of shell wall composition between modern coleoids and A. nordenskjoeldi. The specimen NRM- PZ Mo 167764,which is cut longitudinally, provided detailed information on shell structures and ultrastructures of A. nordenskjoeldi. The specimen NRM-PZ Mo 167765 is studied in surface view and gave additional evidence of enrichment of the shell wall with organic material.
Methods
The specimens were analyzed using light microscopes and SEM/EDS. Complete description of the material and methods are given in the Supporting Online Material (S1 Text).
Nomenclatural Acts
The electronic edition of this article conforms to the requirements of the amended International Code of Zoological Nomenclature, and hence the new names contained herein are available under that Code from the electronic edition of this article. This published work and the nomenclatural acts it contains have been registered in ZooBank, the online registration system for the ICZN. The ZooBank LSIDs (Life Science Identifiers) can be resolved and the associated information viewed through any standard web browser by appending the LSID to the prefix “http://zoobank.org/”. The LSID for this publication is: urn:lsid:zoobank.org:pub:955FB82C-06BA-4CA8-8E63-C1145DC31376. The electronic edition of this work was published in a journal with an ISSN, and has been archived and is available from the following digital repositories: PubMed Central, LOCKSS, DiVA (http://www.diva-portal.org/).
Results
Scanning Electron Microscopy/Energy Dispersive Spectrometry (SEM/EDS)
Analyses of A. nordenskjoeldi under SEM/EDS revealed a unique combination of morphological, ultrastructural and chemical traits; they are: (1, 2) chambered, longiconic conch; (3, 4, 5) thin microlaminated shell wall, having no nacreous layer; (6, 7) a central/or slightly sub-central, broadly expanded siphuncle; (8) notably large (0.6 shell diameter) septal foramen, 2–6 times wider than that of all other known cephalopods; (9, 10, 11) deep, thin, organic septa; (12, 13) thin suborthochoanitic septal necks; (14, 15) thin non-mineralized connecting rings; (16) inorganic-organic mural, epi- and hyposeptal cameral deposits; (17) hyposeptal cameral soft tissues; (18) lack of endosiphuncular deposits; (19, 20) lack of a rostrum and pro-ostracum; (21) irregular mineralization of the shell wall evidenced by the variable content of calcium (5.4% -27.8%); (22) inorganic-organic shell wall composition indicated by high content of nitrogen (up to 7. 8%) and additionally by lower (less than 1%) content of manganese, iron, nickel, copper, zinc, barium, thallium and lead (Figs 1A–1G, 2A–2C, 3, 4A–4C, 5A–5C and 6A–6G; S1, S2A, S2B, S3, S4A, S4B, S6A, S6B and S8A–S8H Figs; Table 1).
A–C, G, NRM-PZ Mo 167764; D, E, NRM-PZ Mo 167765; Early Eocene (Ypresian); Seymour Island, Antarctica. A, An orthoconic shell fragment with three complete chambers, thin semi-transparent shell wall and lobate sutures. B, Partially exposed septum and broad central septal neck at the adapical shell fracture. C, Deep septa and broad central septal necks indicative of a central broadly expanded siphuncle; longitudinal section. D, An orthoconic shell with lobate sutures. E, Close-up of D, thin semi-transparent shell-wall with inserted grains of a matrix indicative of a loosely mineralized shell wall. F, Sketch of internal shell structure. G, Close-up of left side of shell on C. Cr, connecting ring (dot line); ch, chamber outside siphuncle (blue); s, septum (green); sf, septal foramen; si, siphuncle (yellow); sw, shell wall (black).
NRM-PZ Mo 167764. Early Eocene (Ypresian); Seymour Island, Antarctica. A, Microlaminated shell wall (to the left) and prismatic cameral deposits on each side of septum; B, C, Close-up of A; ch1, ch2, the first and the second preserved cameras; ecd, episeptal cameral deposits; hcd, hyposeptal cameral deposits; mcd, mural cameral deposits; s, septum; sw, shell wall.
NRM-PZ Mo 167764. Early Eocene (Ypresian); Seymour Island, Antarctica. Microlaminated shell wall; longitudinal shell section; outer shell surface to the left; inner shell surface to the right; direction towards shell aperture is top right corner.
NRM-PZ Mo 167764. Early Eocene (Ypresian); Seymour Island, Antarctica. A, Prismatic epi- and hyposeptal cameral deposits and microlaminated, microgranular cameral soft tissues; median shell section. B, C, Close-up of A. Cst, cameral soft tissue remains; ecd, episeptal cameral deposits; hcd, hyposeptal cameral deposits; s, septum; sn, suborthohoanitic septal neck.
NRM-PZ Mo 167764. Early Eocene (Ypresian); Seymour Island, Antarctica. Hyposeptal cameral soft tissues. A, general view. B, C, enlargements of A to show a microglobular ultrastructure of cameral soft tissues, median shell section. Cst, cameral soft tissue; ecd, episeptal cameral deposits; hcd, hyposeptal cameral deposits.
(NRM-PZ Mo 167764). The organic-rich shell composition evidenced by high content of nitrogen in the shell wall (A, B) and episeptal cameral deposits at places near septal neck (C, D) and shell wall (E–G).
The prismatic mural, epi- and hyposeptal cameral deposits have, in comparison with the shell wall, higher average values of calcium (24% and 16.6%, respectively), carbon (27.6% and 18. 4%), nitrogen (7.05% and 4. 7%), magnesium (0.9% and 0.4%), potassium (0.9% and 0.2%), approximately similar values of oxygen (55.2% and 59.9%) and strontium (0.2% and 0.2%), but lower average values of copper (0.1% and 0.5%), zinc (0.5% and 0.7%), and lead (0.2% and 0.4%) (Fig 6A–6H; Table 1). The differences between the cameral deposits and the shell wall indicate an originally different chemical composition of these two shell structures. The contents of calcium and carbon, which are 1.5 times higher in epi- and hyposeptal cameral deposits than in the shell wall (Fig 6A–6H; Table 1), suggest stronger mineralization of the cameral deposits and largely organic composition of the shell wall. Besides, the epi- and hyposeptal cameral deposits have lower values of the elements known not to be used in the shells of extant cephalopods: copper, zinc, and lead (Table 1). This may indicate that the epi- and hyposeptal cameral deposits are less contaminated by metals than the shell wall. In recent coleoids soft tissues are easily contaminated by metals from the seawater [54–56], thus the occurrence of metals in the shell wall of A. nordenskjoeldi may be due to contamination of the organic matter. The tested orthocone is characterized by a high content of nitrogen (Fig 6A–6G; S8A–S8G Fig; Table 1): up to 8% in the shell wall and in the matrix in the siphuncle. However, the highest values of nitrogen are detected in mural, epi- and hyposeptal cameral deposits (12.8%) and the wing-like structure (10.8%). In contrast to the orthocone, nitrogen is missing in the shell wall of Euciphoceras (S5, S7A and S7B Figs).
Thus, the organic-rich composition of the microlaminated shell wall of A. nordenskjoeldi is evidenced by the variable content of calcium and high content of nitrogen (up to 8%), which is a reliable indicator of non-fossilized organic material [57]. Copper, zinc and lead in the shell-wall similarly suggest that it originally contained an amount of organic material.
Comparison of shell structures between A. nordenskjoeldi and other recent and fossil cephalopods
Inorganic-organic (no nacre), or calcium carbonate (with nacreous layer) shell wall.
Of the characters revealed in A. nordenskjoeldi (see above), the traits known in Spirula (Fig 7A; [13, 27]), Sepia (Figs 7B, 8 and 9); [13, 21–23]) and extinct coleoids [6, 9, 13, 21–25, 55–60] are: inorganic-organic shell wall material (Table 1); shell wall lacking nacreous layer (Figs 2A–2C and 3; S8A and S8B Fig), septa without columnar nacre (Figs 4A–4C, 5A and 5B; S3, S6A and S6B Figs) and with relatively high content of nitrogen, which is a reliable indicator of non-fossilized organic substance [21, 23, 57]. In contrast, the nautilid Euciphoceras (S5, S10 and S11 Figs) lacks the listed characteristics above.
High content of organics indicated by high content of nitrogen (in percent of total weight) in (A) shell wall of Spirula spirula, Cuba, and (B) mural part of septum of Sepia officinalis, East Atlantic, Portugal.
High content of organics indicated by high content of nitrogen (in percent of total weight) in septum (EDS data); p, pillar zone; s, septum.
High content of organics in dorsal shield indicated by high content of nitrogen (in percent of total weight) (EDS data).
Thus, with respect to its inorganic–organic shell-wall composition, A. nordenskjoeldi is comparable with the shelled coleoids Spirula (Fig 7A), Sepia (Figs 7B, 8 and 9; [22, 23]) and the Eocene Mississaepia [21, 22] but differs from the ectocochleates herein exemplified by the Eocene nautilid Euciphoceras sp. (S5, S10 and S11 Figs).
Organic-rich septa (no columnar nacre), or septa with columnar nacre.
In having organic-rich septa (Figs 4A and 5A–5C; S3, S6A and S6B Figs), A. nordenskjoeldi is similar to the Eocene coleoid Mississaepia [21, 22], Spirula [61], Sepia [27] and the Late Carboniferous belemnoid Donovanicous [4], which have septa formed by lamellar-fibrillar nacre [27]. In contrast, the ectocochleate cephalopods have columnar nacreous septa [14–20].
Large or small septal foramen.
A notably large (0.6 shell diameter) septal foramen (Fig 1C and 1F), 2–6 times bigger than that of all other cephalopods (S5 and S9 Figs), distinguishes the studied cephalopod from known coleoids as well as ectocochleates. In Spirula and in fossil coleoids, the septal foramen is about 0.1–0.2 shell diameter [61–66]; in Paleozoic ectocochleate cephalopods, including those with a broadly expanded central siphuncle (S9 Fig), it is 0.1–0.4 of the shell diameter [67, 68].
Central or marginal siphuncle.
The central, or slightly sub–central, siphuncle (Fig 1A, 1C, 1F; S2A Fig) distinguishes A. nordenskjoeldi from Sepia, which has a siphonal zone instead of a tubular siphuncle, from the Late Cretaceous–Cenozoic belosaepiids, spirulirostrids, belemnoseids, missisaepiids and spirulids, in which a tubular siphuncle is marginal, or sub-marginal [13, 22, 62–66, 69–73]; from Mesozoic orthoconic cephalopods, with the exception of the Early Cretaceous orthocerid Zhuravlevia insperata, which has, however, a small (about 0.1–0.2 shell diameter) septal foramen and columnar nacre in shell wall and septa [18], and from Carboniferous coleoids (2–4, 6, 9).
Thus, in having a central/or slightly sub-central siphuncle, A. nordenskjoeldi is similar to the Ordovician–Early Cretaceous subclasses Orthoceratoidea and Actinoceratoidea but differs from the? Ordovician, Silurian–Late Permian Bactritoidea [49] and? Late Devonian, Early Carboniferous–Recent Coleoidea.
Broadly expanded or narrow siphuncle.
The broadly expended siphuncle distinguishes A. nordenskjoeldi from Spirula and Late Carboniferous and Cretaceous spirulids, which have a narrow siphuncle [3, 13, 61, 63, 65].
The broadly expended siphuncle is a joint feature of A. nordenskjoeldi (Fig 1C and 1F), Orthoceratoidea and Actinoceratoiea (67, 68, 74). However, the endosiphuncular deposits that are weakly developed in some orthocerids but well developed in actinocerids (67, 68, 74) are missing in A. nordenskjoeldi. Therefore, there is more similarity of central siphuncle structure between A. nordenskjoeldi and orthocerids than between this genus and actinocerids.
Discussion
The inorganic–organic shell-wall composition characterizes Recent Spirula, Sepia, and Eocene Mississaepia (Coleoidea), and is herein shown in A. nordenskjoeldi; hence these cephalopods are similar with respect to shell-wall material. In addition, a microlaminated shell ultrastructure apparently resulting from a high content of the chitin component in septa of Spirula and shell-wall and septa in Sepia, and of the chitin-comparable component in shell wall/septa in Mississaepia, is here shown to be a character of A. nordenskjoeldi as well. However, in having no external shell structure that would protect the thin laminated shell wall from the outside (Fig 1A, 1B, 1D, 1E; S2B, S4A and S4B Figs), A. nordenskjoeldi differs from three above-mentioned genera, as in Sepia (Fig 8B) and Mississaepia a dorsal shield coats the outer shell surface; in Spirula, this is the outer plate [13]. In the diverse Early Carboniferous–Late Cretaceous superorder Belemnoidea, a rostrum was secreted above the shell wall. Therefore, A. nordenskjoeldi has a microlaminated shell wall structure and in vivo organic-rich shell-wall composition, which indicate the internal shell position, as in coleoids, but in having no outer protective shell structure it is unique among cephalopods. It is worth noting that microlaminated organic-rich material is unknown in ectocochleates but typical for pro-ostraca of belemnoids and is therefore an attribute of the internal shell [56, 58–60]. The thin film-like non-mineralized septa of A. nordenskjoeldi (Figs 4A and 5A; S3 Fig) are most similar to those of the Eocene Mississaepia [22] and Recent Sepia (Figs 7B and 8). The prismatic cameral deposits enriched in organics are like those of belemnites [66]. The thin septal necks of A. nordenskjoeldi (Figs 4A, 5A and 6A; S6B Fig) are yet unknown in any other cephalopods. In Spirula, well-mineralized long holochoanitic septal necks consisting of lamellar-fibrillar nacre are strongly attached to the shell wall [61]. In Sepia, the thin septa are achoanitic and formed by lamellar-fibrillar nacre [27]. In the Eocene sepiid Mississaepia, lamellar-fibrillar nacre lines thin chitinous septa [22].
Comparison of shell structures between A. nordenskjoeldi and other Recent and fossil cephalopods (see above) shows that the Spirula/Sepia type of shell characters, such as: organic-rich shell wall and septa, lack of nacreous layer in shell wall and lack of columnar nacre in septa, would have identified the Eocene A. nordenskjoeldi as a coleoid. However, the central, broadly expanded siphuncle in A. nordenskjoeldi speaks against membership of the subclass Coleoidea, thought to be derived from Palaeozoic bactritoids having narrow marginal siphuncles [10, 11]. Rather, these features suggest an origin in Paleozoic Orthoceratoidea possessing central or slightly sub-central siphuncles that are broadly expanded in some forms (S9 Fig) and free from endosiphuncular deposits.
The investigated Early Eocene orthoconic cephalopod A. nordenskjoeldi reveals the crisis characterized by "a prolonged interval during which the group virtually completely disappears from the paleontological record…the group became so restricted in taxonomic scope and in habitat that fossil representatives are great rarities or have not yet been identified at all" [74]. A new higher-order taxon is warranted for A. nordenskjoeldi as it shows non-complementary relationship between the morphological (central siphuncle) and ultrastructural (coleoid type shell wall and septum composition and ultrastructures) traits that suppresses its affiliation to any known high-level taxon in the class Cephalopoda. The placement of A. nordenskjoeldi either within a high-level taxon characterized with a marginal siphuncle and coleoid type shell wall composition (Coleoidea) or in a high-level taxon characterized by the Nautilus-like ectocochleate shell wall composition and ultrastructure would equally in every case conflict with a monophyly of the subclasses Coleoidea or Ortoceratoidea. The subclass Coleoidea Bather has been based on an assumed unique event of shell internalization in the evolution of cephalopods. The find of A. nordenskjoeldi indicates a second event of shell internalization indicative of a new taxon of equal rank to Coleoidea, herein described as subclass Paracoleoidea.
Based on A. nordenskjoeldi, after the Late Cretaceous mass extinction, there were three, rather than two, evolutionary lineages of internally shelled cephalopods: the Spirula, Sepia and Antarcticeras lineages. They are characterized by apparently different strategies of buoyancy regulation and, therefore, by different swimming activity. In the Spirula lineage, the buoyancy regulation strategy involves the usage of a narrow tubular siphuncle inherited from the bactritoid ancestors but enforced by means of elongation of the septal necks and strengthening of the septal neck/shell wall conjunction [61]. The living members of this lineage inhabited large depths diapasons–from several meters to about 1500 m. However, they have less broad geographic distribution and limited biodiversity than Sepia. In the Sepia lineage, the buoyancy regulation strategy apparently involved the transformation of a tubular siphuncle into a more effective “open” siphonal zone that allowed overcoming the limited capacities of the tubular siphuncle. This strategy is thought to be the most effective way of buoyancy regulation and is associated with extensive geographic distribution and high taxonomical diversity of living representatives [27]. In the Antarcticeras lineage, the buoyancy strategy evidently involved the usage of a broadly expanded siphuncle modified by means of significant broadening of the septal foramen.
The presence of a coleoid-like organic-rich shell wall in an Eocene straight-shelled cephalopod having central or slightly sub-central broadly expended siphuncle, seemingly derived from ectocochleate forms outside the bactritoids, prompts a reevaluation of the evolutionary history of Cephalopoda with respect to internalization of the shell, up till now thought to be a unique event in cephalopod evolution [10, 11, 63, 65, 70–75]. Internalization of the shell may have happened at least twice, followed by parallel or convergent evolution of shell ultrastructures and composition. The highly diverse Ammonoidea, extinct by the end of the Cretaceous, are generally accepted as a sister group to Coleoidea [10, 11], and although evidence is available for at least partial encroachment of the shell-secreting mantle onto the shell exterior in some genera [28–30], ammonoids are fundamentally ectocochleates, as are bactritoids and orthoceroids. The organic-rich shell, so far known as a coleoid-type shell structure resulting from the internalization of the shell, therefore turns out to be convergent. An alternative interpretation is that the condition of a narrow siphuncle and septal foramen, otherwise known to be stable in bactritoid and coleoid cephalopods, has been modified in the Antarcticeras lineage to produce a hitherto unknown type of internally shelled cephalopod that has overcome the limitations of the condition by expanding the siphuncle and septal foramen to allow for efficient buoyancy control. In this interpretation, the broadly expanded central siphuncle is a convergent feature with that of orthoceratoids. Of these two interpretations, the first one is, in our opinion, more probable. Convergence of habitat-related features is common among recent coleoids [76]. Thus, we suggest that a separate evolutionary lineage of internally shelled cephalopods, characterized by original inorganic–organic shell composition and broadly expanded central siphuncles, originated in the Late Paleozoic. It survived the end-Triassic and Cretaceous mass extinctions and lived on at least into the Early Eocene. Potential descendants of A. nordenskjoeldi among extant coleoids are not obvious; the lineage is most probably extinct. Although this lineage is so far indicated by a single Early Eocene A. nordenskjoeldi in Antarctica, the unique extra-ordinal combination of morphological, ultrastructural and chemical traits of the shell in this form motivates the erection of a new high-level taxon of equal rank with Coleoidea, which is described herein as subclass Paracoleoidea.
Recently described extinct forms [9, 22, 65, 69, 70, 72, 73] essentially increased fossil records of Coleoidea but yielded no taxa with a central siphuncle similar to A. nordenskjoeldi. In vivo inorganic-organic shell composition, in combination with physical and geochemical factors within the depositional environment that are favorable for soft-tissue fossilization, likely contributed to the preservation of A. nordenskjoeldi. The composition of the shell wall of A. nordenskjoeldi cannot yet be characterized in more detail; however, it is similar to the chitin in the aptychi, rather than to the shell wall, of the juvenile ammonites characterized by the aragonite shell composition (Fig 10).
Ip, inner prismatic layer; na, nacreous layer; op, outer prismatic layer.
Systematic paleontology
Subclass Paracoleoidea Doguzhaeva n. subcl.
(Monotypic; diagnosis as for order.)
Order Antarcticerida Doguzhaeva n. ord.
(Monotypic; diagnosis as for family.)
Family Antarcticeridae Doguzhaeva n. fam.
urn:lsid:zoobank.org:act:30BC128F-3E2F-45CC-B384-E40F9FDFC464
(Monotypic; diagnosis as for genus.)
Genus Antarcticeras Doguzhaeva n. gen.
urn:lsid:zoobank.org:act:CC19DF36-765C-464E-8CB7-13667CE9F522
(Diagnosis as for type species.)
Derivation of generic name. After the Swedish South Polar Expedition vessel “Antarctic”.
Type and only species Antarcticeras nordenskjoeldi n. sp.
Species Antarcticeras nordenskjoeldi Doguzhaeva n. gen., n. sp.
urn:lsid:zoobank.org:act:1CDE8B47-2D2D-46B1-B745-BF9F3CD5FC66
(Figs 1A–1G, 2A–2C, 3, 4A–4C, 5A–5C and 6A–6C; S1–S3, S4A, S4B and S6A Figs; Table 1)
Diagnosis: Shell inorganic-organic, longiconic; angle of expansion 3–7°; smooth surface; rounded cross-section; no constrictions at sutures; shell wall thin, inorganic-organic, microlaminated, without nacreous layer; siphuncle central, or slightly sub-central, broadly expanded; septal foramen broad, rounded, about 0.6 of shell diameter; septal necks thin, non-mineralized, suborthochoanitic; connecting rings thin, non-mineralized; septa thin, supposedly chitinous, deeply concave; sutures transverse or indistinctly inclined; with two deep broad lobes; epi- and hyposeptal, and mural cameral deposits present.
Derivation of specific name: In honor of Otto Nordenskjöld, leader of the Swedish South Polar Expedition 1901–1903.
Holotype: NRM-PZ Mo 167764.
Paratype: NRM-PZ Mo 167765.
Repository. Swedish Museum of Natural History, Department of Palaeobiology; Stockholm.
Locality and horizon: NRM 8, below IAA 1/90 (Ungulate Site), Seymour Island, Graham Land, Antarctica. Cucullaea I shell bed, TELM 4, Ypresian, early Eocene, Paleogene.
Conclusions
Our study presents the first evidence of an internally shelled fossil cephalopod with central siphuncle. SEM/EDS analyses of longiconic shells of the Eocene cephalopod A. nordenskjoeldi show an organic-rich microlaminated shell wall that indicates its secretion as an internal shell, like that of Recent Sepia. It is associated with thin non-mineralized septa. A. nordenskjoeldi indicates a previously unknown evolutionary lineage of internally shelled cephalopods with broadly expanded central or slightly sub-central siphuncle, herein described as subclass Paracoleoidea Doguzhaeva. This lineage supposedly originated within Late Paleozoic externally shelled Orthoceratoidea with central siphuncle broadly expanded between septa and free from endosiphuncular deposits. It evolved independently from the Bactritoidea/Coleoidea lineage. A. nordenskjoeldi shows that the endocochleate condition was not restricted to coleoids.
Supporting information
S1 Text. Materials and methods.
Geological setting and depositional environment.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0172169.s001
(PDF)
S1 Fig. Antarcticeras nordenskjoeldi n. sp.; Early Eocene; Seymour Island, Antarctica.
NRM–PZ Mo 167764. Lateral view through semi-transparent shell wall on four lobate sutures. Ch, chamber; ml, mandible–like structure; s, septum; sn, septal neck.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0172169.s002
(TIF)
S2 Fig. Antarcticeras nordenskjoeldi n. sp.; Early Eocene; Seymour Island, Antarctica.
NRM–PZ Mo 167764. Transverse adapical (A) and adoral (B) shell fractures showing rounded shell cross section, broad septal neck attached to the shell wall on A and mandible–like structure on B.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0172169.s003
(TIF)
S3 Fig. Antarcticeras nordenskjoeldi n. sp.; Early Eocene; Seymour Island, Antarctica.
NRM–PZ Mo 167764. The traces of thin organic structure-less septum squeezed between prismatic episeptal cameral deposits (right side) and granular hyposeptal cameral soft tissue remains (left side) at septal neck. Cst, cameral soft tissue remains; ecd, episeptal cameral deposits; s, septum; sn, septal neck.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0172169.s004
(TIF)
S4 Fig. Antarcticeras nordenskjoeldi n. sp.; Early Eocene; Antarctica, Seymour Island.
NRM–PZ Mo 167765. A, Ventrolateral view on the partially exposed chambers of the phragmocone with extensive mural cameral deposits. B, Enlargement of Fig 1E to show remains of thin brown organic septa. C, chamber; mcd, mural cameral deposits; os, organic septum; sw. shell wall.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0172169.s005
(TIF)
S5 Fig. Euciphoceras sp.; Early Eocene; Antarctica, Seymour Island.
NRM–PZ Mo 167766. Median shell section showing sub-central narrow siphuncle.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0172169.s006
(TIF)
S6 Fig. Antarcticeras nordenskjoeldi n. sp.; Early Eocene; Antarctica, Seymour Island.
NRM–PZ Mo 167764–2. A, hyposeptal cameral soft tissues lining the adapical septal surface. B, enlargement of A showing thin suborthochoanitic septal neck and microglobular ultrastructure of hyposeptal cameral soft tissue. Ch, chamber; hcst, hyposeptal cameral soft tissue; s, septum; sn, cyrtochoanitic septal neck.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0172169.s007
(TIF)
S7 Fig. EDS data on elemental composition of a mandible-like structure on S2B.
Note a peak of nitrogen indicative of non-fossilized organic material [57].
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0172169.s008
(TIF)
S8 Fig. Antarcticeras nordenskjoeldi n. sp.; Early Eocene; Seymour Island, Antarctica.
NRM–PZ Mo 167764. Energy-dispersive spectrometry data on chemical composition of shell wall (in percent of total weight).
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0172169.s009
(TIF)
S9 Fig. A central, broadly expanded siphuncle of the Late Devonian pseudorthocerid Arpaoceras; R. Arpa, Armenia.
Median shell section ([43]; modified). esd, episeptal cameral deposits; hsd, hyposeptal cameral deposits; s, septum; sf, siphuncular foramen; si, siphuncle; sn, septal neck.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0172169.s010
(TIF)
S10 Fig. Euciphoceras sp.; Early Eocene; Antarctica, Seymour Island.
NRM–PZ Mo 167766. Columnar nacre of shell wall, median shell section.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0172169.s011
(TIF)
S11 Fig. Euciphoceras sp.; early Eocene; Antarctica, Seymour Island.
NRM–PZ Mo 167766. Energy-dispersive spectrometer data on shell wall chemical composition. A, median shell section showing position of the spectrum taken. Ch, chamber of the phragmocone; s, septum; sw, shell wall. B, An energy-dispersive spectrometer graph showing spectrum 2 in A.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0172169.s012
(TIF)
Acknowledgments
J. Hagström (Swedish Museum of Natural History, Stockholm), J. J. Moly (Natural History Museum, La Plata), S. Santillana (Argentine Antarctic Institute, Buenos Aires) and C. Tambussi (National University, Córdoba) participated in the field work. We are grateful for constructive criticism and helpful comments from our academic editor Geerat J. Vermeij, reviewer Helmut Keupp (Freie Universität Berlin), as well as an anonymous reviewer.
Author Contributions
- Conceptualization: LD.
- Funding acquisition: LD TM MAR.
- Investigation: LD SB TM.
- Methodology: LD.
- Project administration: LD SB TM MAR.
- Resources: TM MAR.
- Supervision: LD.
- Validation: LD.
- Visualization: LD.
- Writing – original draft: LD SB TM.
- Writing – review & editing: LD SB.
References
- 1. Flower RH, Gordon MJ. More Mississippian belemnites. J Paleontol.1959; 33: 809–842.
- 2. Doguzhaeva LA, Mapes RH, Mutvei H. Shell morphology and ultrastructure of the Early Carboniferous coleoid Hematites Flower and Gordon, 1959 (Hematitida ord. nov.) from Midcontinent (USA). Abh Geol Bundesanst Wien 2002; 57: 299–320.
- 3.
Doguzhaeva LA, Mapes RH, Mutvei H. A Late Carboniferous spirulid coleoid from the Southern Mid-continent (USA). In: Olόriz F, Rodríguez-Tovar FJ, editors. Advancing Research on Living and Fossil Cephalopods. 1999: 47–57. NY, Boston, Dordrecht, L, Moscow: Kluwer Acad/Plenum Publ.
- 4. Doguzhaeva LA, Mapes RH, Mutvei H. The shell and ink sac morphology and ultrastructure of the Late Pennsylvanian cephalopod Donovaniconus and its phylogenetic significance. Berliner Paläobiol Abh. 2003; 3: 61–78.
- 5.
Doguzhaeva LA, Mapes RH, Mutvei H. A Late Carboniferous Coleoid Cephalopod from the Mazon Creek Lagerstätte (USA), with a radula, arm hooks, mantle tissues, and ink. In: Landman NH, Davis RA, Mapes RH, editors. Cephalopods Present and Past: New Insights and Fresh Perspectives. New York: Springer; 2007. pp. 121–143.
- 6.
Doguzhaeva LA, Mapes RH, Mutvei H. Evolutionary patterns of Carboniferous coleoid cephalopods based on their diversity and morphological plasticity. In: Tanabe K, Shigeta Y, Sasaki T, Hirano H, editors. Cephalopods Present and Past. Tokyo: Tokai Univ. Press; 2010. pp. 171–180.
- 7.
Mapes RH, Weller EA, Doguzhaeva LA. Early Carboniferous (Late Namurian) coleoid cephalopods showing a tentacle with arm hooks and an ink sac from Montana, USA. In: Tanabe K, Shigeta Y, Sasaki T, Hirano H, editors.Cephalopods Present and Past. Tokyo: Tokai Univ. Press; 2010. pp. 155–170.
- 8. Mapes RH, Doguzhaeva LA, Mutvei H, Pabian RK. A new Late Carboniferous coleoid preserved with an ink sac from Nebraska, USA. Ferrantia. 2010; 59: 126–136.
- 9. Mutvei H, Mapes RH, Doguzhaeva LA. Shell structures in Carboniferous bactritid-like coleoids (Cephalopoda) from South Central USA. GFF. 2012; 134: 201–216.
- 10. Berthold T, Engeser T. Phylogenetic analysis and systematization of Cephalopoda. Verh Naturwiss Ver Hamburg NS. 1987; 29: 187–220.
- 11. Engeser T. Phylogeny of the fossil coleoid Cephalopoda (Mollusca). Berliner geowiss Abh A. 1990; 124: 123–191.
- 12. Young RE, Vecchione M, Donovan DT. The evolution of coleoid cephalopods and their present biodiversity and ecology. J Marine Sci. 1998; 20: 393–420.
- 13. Doguzhaeva LA. Two Early Cretaceous spirulid coleoids of the north-western Caucasus: Their shell ultrastructure and evolutionary implication. Palaeontol. 1996; 39: 681–707.
- 14. Erben HK, Flajs G, Siehl A. Die frühontogenetische Entwicklung der Schalenstruktur ectocochleater Cephalopoden. Palaeontogr A. 1971; 132: 1–54.
- 15. Ristedt H. Zum Bau der orthoceriden Cephalopoden. Palaeontogr A. 1971; 137: 155–195.
- 16. Mutvei H. Ultrastructural studies on cephalopod shells. Part II. Orthoconic Cephalopoda from the Pennsylvanian Buckhorn Asphalt. Bull Geol Inst Univ Uppsala NS. 1972; 9: 263–272.
- 17.
Blind W. Comparative investigations on the shell morphology and structure of Nautilus pompilius, Orthoceras sp., Pseudorthoceras sp., and Kioceras sp.. In: Weidmann J, Kullmann J, editors. Cephalopods Present and Past. Stuttgart: E. Schweizerbart’sche Verlagsbuchhandlung (Nägele u. Obermiller). 1988; pp. 273–282.
- 18. Doguzhaeva LA. An Early Cretaceous orthocerid cephalopod from north-western Caucasus. Palaeontol. 1994; 37: 887–899.
- 19. Mutvei H, Doguzhaeva LA. Early ontogeny of shell ultrastructure in Nautilus pompilius. Palaeontogr A. 1997; 246: 33–52.
- 20.
Kulicki C, Tanabe K, Landman NH, Kaim A. Ammonoid Shell Microstructure In: Klug C, Korn D, De Baets K et al., editors. Ammonoid Paleobiology: From anatomy to ecology. Topics in Geobiology. 2015; 43: pp. 321–357.
- 21. Weaver PG, Doguzhaeva LA, Lawver DR, Tacker RC, Ciampaglio CN, Crate JM, Zheng W. Characterization of organics consistent with b-chitin preserved in the Late Eocene cuttlefish Mississaepia mississippiensis. PLoS ONE. 2011; 6 (11): e28195. pmid:22132239
- 22. Doguzhaeva LA, Weaver PG, Ciampaglio CN. A unique late Eocene coleoid cephalopod Mississaepia from Mississippi, USA: New data on cuttlebone structure, and their phylogenetic implications. Acta Pal Pol. 2014; 59: 147–162.
- 23. Florek M, Formal E, Gómez-Romero P, Zieba E, Paszkowicz W, Lekki J, Nowak J, Kuczumow A. Complementary micro-structural and chemical analyses of Sepia officinalis endoskeleton. Mater Sci Eng C Biomim Supramol Syst. 2009; 29: 1220–1226.
- 24. Cadman J, Zhou S, Chen Y, Li Q. Cuttlebone: characterization, application and development of biomimetic materials. J Bionic Eng. 2012; 9: 367–376.
- 25. Checa AG, Cartwright JHE, Sánchez-Almazo I, Andrade JP, Ruiz-Raya F. The cuttlefish Sepia officinalis (Sepiidae, Cephalopoda) constructs cuttlebone from a liquid-crystal precursor. Sci Rep. 2015; 5: 11513. pmid:26086668
- 26. Doguzhaeva LA, Mutvei H. Connecting stripes: an organic skeletal structure in Sepia from Red Sea. Geobios. 2012; 45: 13–17.
- 27. Doguzhaeva LA, Dunca E. Siphonal zone structure in the cuttlebone of Sepia officinalis. Swiss J Palaeont. 2015.
- 28. Drushchits VV, Doguzhaeva LA, Mikhailova IA. Unusual coating layers in ammonoids. Paleontol Zh 1978; 2: 36–44.
- 29. Doguzhaeva LA, Mutvei H. Organization of the soft body in Aconeceras (Ammonitina), interpreted on the basis of shell morphology and muscle scars. 1991. Palaeontogr A; 218: 17
- 30.
Doguzhaeva LA, Mutvei H. The additional external layers indicative of “endochochleate experiments” in some ammonoids. In: Klug C, Korn D, De Baets K et al., editors. Ammonoid Paleobiology: From anatomy to ecology. Topics in Geobiology. 2015; 43. pp. 593–609. Springer.
- 31.
Reguero M, Goin F, Acosta Hospitaleche C, Dutra T. & Marenssi S. Late Cretaceous/ Palaeogene west Antarctica terrestrial biota and its intercontinental affinities. Springer Briefs in Earth System Sciences, London. 2013: 120 pp.
- 32. Schwarzhans W, Mörs T, Engelbrecht A, Reguero M, Kriwet J. Before the freeze: the otoliths from the Eocene of Seymour Island, Antarctica, reveal dominance of gadiform fishes (Teleostei). J Syst Palaeontol. 2016; 1–24.
- 33. Dingle R, Lavelle M. Antarctic Peninsula cryosphere: early Oligocene (c. 30 Ma) initiation and a revised glacial chronology. J Geol Soc Lond. 1998; 155: 433–437.
- 34. Ivany LC, Lohmann KC, Hasiuk F, Blake DB, Glass A, Aronson RB, Moody RM. Eocene climaterecord of a high southern latitude continental shelf: Seymour Island, Antarctica. Geol Soc Amer Bull. 2008 June; 120: 659–678.
- 35. Dutton AL, Lohmann K, Zinsmeister WJ. Stable isotope and minor element proxies for Eocene climate of Seymour Island Antarctica. Paleoceanogr. 2002 May; 17(2): 1–13.
- 36.
Elliot DH. Tectonic setting and evolution of the James Ross Basin, northern Antarctic Peninsula. In: Feldmann RM, Woodburne MO, editors. Geology and Paleontology of Seymour Island, Antarctic Peninsula. Geol Soc of America. 1988; 169: pp. 541–555.
- 37. Del Valle RA, Elliot DH, Macdonald DIM. Sedimentary basins on the east flank of the Antarctic Peninsula: proposed nomenclature. Antarct Sci. 1992; 4: 477–478.
- 38. Hathway B. Continental rift to back-arc basin: Jurassic–Cretaceous stratigraphical and structural evolution of the Larsen Basin, Antarctic Peninsula. J Geol Soc Lond. 2000; 157: 417–432.
- 39.
Elliot DH, Trautman TA. Lower Tertiary strata on Seymour Island, AntarcticPeninsula. In: Craddock C, editor. Antarctic Geoscience. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press. 1982: pp. 287–297.
- 40. Ivany LC, Van Simaeys S, Domack EW, Samson SD. Evidence for an earliest Oligocene ice sheeton the Antarctic Peninsula. Geol. 2006; 34(5): 377–380.
- 41.
Marenssi SA, Santillana SN, Rinaldi CA. Stratigraphy of the La Meseta Formation (Eocene), Marambio (Seymour) Island, Antarctica. In: Casadio S, editor. Paleógeno de América del Sur y de la Península Antártica. Buenos Aires: Asociación Paleontológica Argentina, Publicación Especial. 1998; 5: pp. 137–146.
- 42. Marenssi SA, Net LI, Santillana SN. Provenance, depositional and palaeogeographic controls on sandstone composition in an incised valley system: the Eocene La Meseta Formation, Seymour Island Antarctica. Sed Geol. 2002; 150(3–4): 301–321.
- 43.
Marenssi SA. Eustatically-controlled sedimentation recorded by Eocene strata of the James Ross Basin, Antarctica. In: Francis JE, Pirrie D, Crame JA, editors. Cretaceous-Tertiary high-latitude palaeoenvironments, James Ross Basin, Antarctica. Geological Society of London, Special Publications. 2006; 258: pp. 125–133.
- 44. Stilwell JD, Zinsmeister WJ. Molluscan systematics and biostratigraphy: Lower Tertiary LaMeseta Formation, Seymour Island, Antarctic Peninsula. Antarct Res Ser. 1992; 55: 1–152.
- 45.
Sadler P. Geometry and stratification of uppermost Cretaceous and Palaeogene units of Seymour Island, northern Antarctic Peninsula. In: Feldmann RM, Woodburne MO, editors. Geology and paleontology of Seymour Island, Antarctic Peninsula. Geological Society of America, Mem. 1988; 169: pp. 303–320566.
- 46. Gelfo JN, Mörs T, Lorente M, López GM, Reguero M. The oldest mammals from Antarctica, early Eocene of La Meseta Formation, Seymour Island. Palaeontol. 2015; 58:101–110.
- 47. Reguero MA, Marenssi SA, Santillana SN. Weddellian marine/coastal vertebrates diversity from a basal horizon (Ypresian, Eocene) of the Cucullaea I Allomember, La Meseta formation, Seymour (Marambio) Island, Antarctica. Rev Peru Biol. 2012; 19: 275–284.
- 48. Bomfleur B, Mörs T, Ferraguti M, Reguero MA, McLoughlin S. Fossilized spermatozoa preserved in a 50-myr-old annelid cocoon from Antarctica. Biol Lett. 2015; 11:20150431. pmid:26179804
- 49. Douglas PMJ, Affek HP, Ivany LC, Houben AJP, Sijp WP, Sluijs A, Schouten S, Pagani M. Pronounced zonal heterogeneity in Eocene southern high-latitude sea surface temperatures. PNAS 2014 May; 111 (18): 6582–6587. pmid:24753570
- 50. Bijl PK, Pross J, Warnaar J, Stickley CE, Huber M, Guerstein R, Houben AJP, Appy S, Visscher H, Brinkhuis H. Environmental forcings of Paleogene Southern Ocean dinoflagellate biogeography. Paleoceanogr. 2011; 26: 1–12.
- 51.
Montes M, Nozal F, Santillana S, Marenssi S, Olivero E. 2013. Mapa Geologico de la isla Marambio (Seymour) Escala 1:20.000 Primera Edicion. Serie Cartografica Geocientıfica Antartica. Madrid-Instituto Geologico y Minero de Espana; Buenos Aires-Instituto Antartico Argentino.
- 52.
Gelfo JN, Reguero MA, López GM, Carlini AA, Ciancio MR, Chornogubsky L, Bond M, Goin FJ, Tejedor MF. Eocene mammals and continental strata from Patagonia and Antarctic Peninsula. In: AlbrightIII LB, editor. Papers on Geology, Vertebrate Paleontology and Biostratigraphy, in Honor of Michael O. Woodburne. Mus North Arizona Bull. 2009; 64: 567–592.
- 53. Tejedor MF, Goin FJ, Gelfo JN, López GM, Bond M, Carlini AA, Scillato-Yané GJ, Woodburne MO, Chornogubsky L, Aragón E, Reguero MA, Czaplewski NJ, Vincon S, Martin GM, Ciancio MR. New Early Eocene mammalian fauna from western Patagonia, Argentina. Am Mus Novit. 2009; 3638: 1–43.
- 54. Jinadasa BKKK. Concentration of trace metals in the squids (Loligo duvauceli, Sepioteuthis lessoniana) and cuttlefish (Sepia latimanus) from the North-Western coast of Sri Lanka. J Aquatic Sci. 2014; 2(2): 5–10.
- 55. Doguzhaeva LA, Bengtson S. The capsule: an organic skeletal structure in the Late Cretaceous belemnite Gonioteuthis from North-West Germany. Palaeontol. 2011; 54: 397–415.
- 56. Doguzhaeva LA. The original composition of the pro-ostracum of an early Sinemurian belemnite from Belgium deduced from mode of fossilization and ultrastructure. Palaeontol. 2012; 55: 249–260.
- 57.
Oehler DZ, Robert F, Mostefaoui S, Meibom A, Selo M, Mckay DS, Gibson EK. Nanoisms opens a new window for deciphering organic matter in terrestrial and extraterrestrial samples. In: Seckbach J, Walsh M, editors. From Fossils to Astrobiology: Records of Life on Earth and Search for Extraterrestrial Biosignatures. 2009; 7–23. Springer.
- 58. Doguzhaeva LA, Mutvei H, Donovan DT. Pro-ostracum, muscular mantle and conotheca in the Middle Jurassic belemnite Megateuthis. Abh Geol Bundesanst Wien. 2002; 57: 321–339.
- 59. Doguzhaeva LA, Donovan DT, Mutvei H. Ultrastructure of Belemnotheutis from the Oxford Clay (Callovian), England, as a key for elucidating the origin of the pro-ostracum. Acta Univ Carol Geol. 2002; 49: 95–105.
- 60. Doguzhaeva LA, Summesberger H. Pro-ostraca of Triassic belemnoids (Cephalopoda) from Northern Calcareous Alps, with observations on their mode of preservation in an environment of northern Tethys which allowed for carboniferous of non-biomineralized structures. N Jb Geol Paläontol, Abh. 2012; 266: 31–38.
- 61. Doguzhaeva LA. The evolutionary morphology of siphonal tube in Spirulida (Cephalopoda, Coleoidea). Rev Paléobiol. 2000; 8: 83–94.
- 62. Jeletzky JA. New or poorly understood Tertiary sepiids from Southeastern United States and Mexico. Univ Kansas Paleontol Contrib Moll. 1969; 41: 1–39.
- 63. Jeletzky JA. Comparative morphology, phylogeny and classification of fossil Coleoidea. Paleontol Contrib Univ Kansas Moll. 1966; 7: 1–162
- 64. Fornasiero M, Vicariotto M. A new species of Spirulirostra (Cephalopoda Coleoidea) from the venetian middle Eocene (Italy). Mem Sci Geol. 1997; 49: 65–72.
- 65. Fuchs D, Keupp H, Trask P, Tanabe K. Taxonomy, morphology and phylogeny of Late Cretaceous spirulid coleoids (Cephalopoda) from Greenland and Canada. Palaeontol. 2012; 55: 285–303.
- 66. Doguzhaeva LA, Weis R, Delsate D, Mariotti N. Embryonic shell structure of Early–Middle Jurassic belemnites, and its significance for belemnite expansion and diversification in the Jurassic. Lethaia. 2014; 47: 49–65.
- 67.
Zhuravleva FA, Doguzhaeva LA. Cameral deposits in Pseudorthocerida and Actinocerida in scanning electron microscope. In: Rozanov AJ, Shevyrev AA, editors. Fossil Cephalopods: Recent Advances in their study. Moscow: Russian Academy of Science, Paleontological Institute. 1999: pp. 213–270. [Russian with English Abstract].
- 68.
Teichert C, Kummel B., Sweet WC, Furnish WM, Glenister BF, Erben HK, Ziller DEN. Description of subclasses and orders. Treatise on Invertebrate Paleontology. Pt K Mollusca 3. Geol Soc of America and Univ Kansas Press. 1964: pp. K127–K505.
- 69. Yancey TE, Garvie Ch, Wicksten M. The Middle Eocene Belosaepia ungula (Cephalopoda: Coleoida) from Texas: Structure, ontogeny and function. J Paleont. 2010; 84(2): 267–287.
- 70. Košťák M, Jagt JWM, Speijer RP, Stassen P, Steurbaut E. New Paleocene Sepiid Coleoids (Cephalopoda) from Egypt: Evolutionary Significance and Origin of the Sepiid ‘Rostrum’. PlosOne. 2013; 8: 11: 1–19.
- 71. Fuchs D, Keupp H, Weise F. Protoconch morphology of Conoteuthis (Diplobelida, Coleoidea) and its implications on the presumed origin of the Sepiida. Cretaceous Research. 2012; 34: 200–207.
- 72. Fuchs D, Iba Y, Ifrim C, Nishimura T, Kennedy W, Keupp H, Stinnesbeck W, Tanabe K. Longibelus gen. nov., a new Cretaceous coleoid genus linking Belemnoidea and early Decabrachia. Palaeontol. 2013; 56(5): 1081–1106.
- 73. Fuchs D, Košťák M. Amphispirula gen. nov. from the Eocene of southern Moravia (Czech Republic): a new ancestor of the Recent deep-sea squid Spirula?, J Syst Palaeontol. 2015
- 74.
Teichert C. Main features of cephalopod evolution. In Clarke MR and Trueman ER, editors. Paleontology and neontology of cephalopods. 1988; 12: 1179. Academic Press, San Diego. 225 pp.
- 75. Kröger B, Vinter J, Fuchs D. Cephalopod origin and evolution: a congruent picture emerging from fossils, development and molecules. BioEssays. 2011; 33: 602–613. pmid:21681989
- 76. Lindgren AR, Pankey MS, Hochberg FG, Oakley TH. A muli-gene phylogeny of Cephalopoda supports convergent morphological evolution in association with multiple habitat shifts in the marine environment. BMC Evol Biol. 2012.