Human antibody response to measles vaccine is highly variable in the population. Host genes contribute to inter-individual antibody response variation. The killer cell immunoglobulin-like receptors (KIR) are recognized to interact with HLA molecules and possibly influence humoral immune response to viral antigens. To expand on and improve our previous work with HLA genes, and to explore the genetic contribution of KIR genes to the inter-individual variability in measles vaccine-induced antibody responses, we performed a large population-based study in 2,506 healthy immunized subjects (ages 11 to 41 years) to identify HLA and KIR associations with measles vaccine-induced neutralizing antibodies. After correcting for the large number of statistical tests of allele effects on measles-specific neutralizing antibody titers, no statistically significant associations were found for either HLA or KIR loci. However, suggestive associations worthy of follow-up in other cohorts include B*57:01, DQB1*06:02, and DRB1*15:05 alleles. Specifically, the B*57:01 allele (1,040 mIU/mL; p = 0.0002) was suggestive of an association with lower measles antibody titer. In contrast, the DQB1*06:02 (1,349 mIU/mL; p = 0.0004) and DRB1*15:05 (2,547 mIU/mL; p = 0.0004) alleles were suggestive of an association with higher measles antibodies. Notably, the associations with KIR genotypes were strongly nonsignificant, suggesting that KIR loci in terms of copy number and haplotypes are not likely to play a major role in antibody response to measles vaccination. These findings refine our knowledge of the role of HLA and KIR alleles in measles vaccine-induced immunity.
Citation: Ovsyannikova IG, Schaid DJ, Larrabee BR, Haralambieva IH, Kennedy RB, Poland GA (2017) A large population-based association study between HLA and KIR genotypes and measles vaccine antibody responses. PLoS ONE 12(2): e0171261. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0171261
Editor: Güher Saruhan-Direskeneli, Istanbul University, TURKEY
Received: August 4, 2016; Accepted: January 17, 2017; Published: February 3, 2017
Copyright: © 2017 Ovsyannikova et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Data Availability: All data files are available from the ImmPort database (https://immport.niaid.nih.gov; Study #:SDY614).
Funding: Research reported in this publication was supported by the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases of the National Institutes of Health under Award Number R01AI033144 and R37AI048793. The content is solely the responsibility of the authors and does not necessarily represent the official views of the National Institutes of Health.
Competing interests: Dr. Poland is the chair of a Safety Evaluation Committee for novel investigational vaccine trials being conducted by Merck Research Laboratories. Dr. Poland offers consultative advice on vaccine development to Merck & Co. Inc., CSL Biotherapies, Avianax, Dynavax, Novartis Vaccines and Therapeutics, Emergent Biosolutions, Adjuvance, Microdermis, Seqirus, NewLink, Protein Sciences, GSK Vaccines, and Sanofi Pasteur. Drs. Poland and Ovsyannikova hold two patents related to measles and vaccinia peptide research. Dr. Kennedy has received funding from Merck Research Laboratories to study waning immunity to measles and mumps vaccine. These activities have been reviewed by the Mayo Clinic Conflict of Interest Review Board and are conducted in compliance with Mayo Clinic Conflict of Interest policies. This research has been reviewed by the Mayo Clinic Conflict of Interest Review Board and was conducted in compliance with Mayo Clinic Conflict of Interest policies. This does not alter our adherence to PLOS ONE policies on sharing data and materials.
Host genetic factors are believed to be responsible for up to 90% of measles vaccine-induced inter-individual antibody response variations . Among these genetic factors, the Human Leukocyte Antigen (HLA) genes (on chromosome 6p21) have been a focus of interest since these highly polymorphic HLA genes play an important role in the regulation of immune response, including immunity to measles virus . The main role of HLA class I and class II molecules is to present antigens to CD8+ and CD4+ T cells, respectively, thus initiating adaptive immune responses . There is a large body of evidence demonstrating that immune responses to measles vaccine are in part, guided by polymorphisms of the HLA genes [4–8]. In this regard, several HLA class I (B*57:01, B*35:03) and class II (DQB1*06:02, DQB1*03:03, DRB1*07:01, DRB1*15:01) alleles have been consistently associated with variations in measles virus-specific antibody responses following measles vaccination .
While HLA alleles are highly polymorphic and difficult to fully investigate due to scarcity of some alleles, the functional consequences of the genes are less diverse. It is known that the type of peptides that HLA can bind—and the effectiveness of those bonds—is influenced by the shape of the binding region and the amino acids present in these regions that act to anchor peptides. This information allows us to view HLA in terms of downstream biological consequences and to re-categorize HLA alleles into “supertypes” based on their affinity to bind certain peptides. This simplified and practical view of the data may be more powerful and may offer more realistic information than the information gained by attempting to comprehend the impact of each individual allele .
Immune responses to measles are also influenced by various immunoregulatory genes (TLR, TRIM, CD46, SLAM, CD209, and others) [10–16]. Among these genes are the highly polymorphic immunoglobulin-like receptors (KIRs) expressed on the surface of natural killer (NK) cells . A family of ~15 inhibitory and activating KIR polymorphic genes (located on chromosome 19q13.4) are expressed on human NK cells, which are important for antiviral innate and adaptive immune responses . Unlike cytotoxic T cells, NK cells do not recognize specific pathogens, but instead express inhibitory KIR receptors that recognize polymorphic HLA class I ligands [19, 20]. NK receptors of the KIR family are known to interact with specific motifs on classical HLA class I (A, B, and C) molecules, and possibly influence immune response outcomes [21, 22]. To date, the involvement of the KIR genes in measles vaccine-induced immunity is unknown.
Several of our studies have demonstrated potential associations between HLA alleles and variations in measles vaccine-induced antibody responses [4, 5, 8]. Given the significance of the KIR genes for viral immunity/infection, we examined data previously obtained from three separate cohorts and examined whether variation within the KIR genes influences measles vaccine-induced antibody responses. Our goal was to examine HLA associations with humoral immune response outcome (neutralizing antibody titer) in a large population-based combined cohort of measles-mumps-rubella (MMR)-immunized subjects and to determine if KIR genotypes are associated with measles vaccine-induced antibodies.
Materials and methods
Subjects from previously described cohorts were used for this study [10, 23, 24]. The combined study cohort was a large population-based sample of 3,191 healthy children, older adolescents, and adults (age 11 to 41 years) consisting of three independent cohorts: a Rochester cohort (n = 1,062); a San Diego cohort (n = 1,071); and a U.S. cohort (n = 1,058). The recruitment efforts, demographic and clinical characteristics of these cohorts have been previously published [10, 23, 24]. Specifically, 1,062 healthy children and young adults, ranging in age from 11 to 22 years, were recruited from Rochester, MN, between 2001–2009 (Rochester cohort), as previously published [8, 13]. Parental consent was obtained for all participants and each subject had written records of having received two doses of measles-mumps-rubella (MMR, Merck) vaccine. Of the 1,062 subjects for this study, 935 (88%) were successfully genotyped, assayed for immune response outcomes, and determined to have European ancestry (Table 1). The San Diego cohort consisted of 1,071 healthy older adolescents and healthy adults (age 18 to 40 years) enrolled by the Naval Health Research Center (NHRC) between 2005–2006, from armed forces personnel in San Diego, CA, as previously published [23, 25]. After excluding subjects without immune response outcome data and creating a subset of subjects with European ancestry, 695 (65%) subjects (San Diego cohort) remained for analysis. The U.S. cohort consisted of 1,058 healthy adults from the U.S. military (age 19 to 41 years) enrolled between 2010–2011 . These subjects from the U.S. military represent a cross section of the U.S. population with proven MMR vaccine-induced immunity. Of the 1,058 individuals (US cohort), 876 (83%) subjects were successfully genotyped, assayed for immune response outcomes, and determined to have European ancestry using the STRUCTURE software . The Institutional Review Boards of the Mayo Clinic (Rochester, MN) and the Naval Health Research Center (San Diego, CA) approved the study; written informed consent was obtained from each subject, from the parents of all children who participated in the study, as well as written assent from age-appropriate participants.
Measles-specific antibody assay
The methods described herein are similar or identical to those published for our previous studies [27, 28]. Neutralizing antibodies against measles virus (MV) were measured by a fluorescence-based plaque reduction microneutralization assay (PRMN) using a recombinant, GFP-expressing MV [27, 28]. The plates were scanned and counted on an automated Olympus IX71 Fluorescent microscope using the Image-Pro Plus Software Version 6.3 (Media Cybernetics; Rockville, MD). The 50% end-point titer (Neutralizing Doze, ND50) was calculated automatically using Karber’s formula, and transformed into mIU/mL (using the 3rd WHO international measles antibody standard), as previously published [27, 28]. The variability of the PRMN assay in our laboratory, calculated as a coefficient of variation (CV) based on the log-transformed ND50 values of the third WHO standard, was 5.7% .
HLA genotype assessment
For the Rochester and San Diego cohorts, HLA class I (A, B, and C) and class II (DRB1, DQA1, DQB1, DPA1, and DPB1) genotyping was performed by high-resolution PCR-SSP (Invitrogen; Carlsbad, CA), as previously described [29–31]. For the Rochester cohort, 249 subjects with European ancestry did not have HLA genotyping data (subjects were not genotyped for HLA); for these subjects, we imputed their HLA genotypes to four-digit allele codes (see below). For the U.S. cohort, HLA class I and class II allele genotyping was performed using high-throughput, high-fidelity genotyping with deep-sequencing technology that combines the advantage of long-range amplification with the power of high-throughput Illumina sequencing platforms that were developed at the Stanford Genome Technology Center (Stanford School of Medicine; Palo Alto, CA) [24, 32].
Imputation of HLA
For the 249 subjects from the Rochester cohort without HLA data, we imputed their four-digit alleles at HLA loci A, B, C, DRB1, DQA1, DQB1, DPA1, and DPB1. Imputation was achieved with the SNP2HLA software using the Type-I Diabetes Genetics Consortium reference panel (n = 5,225) kindly provided by Jia, et al . To perform imputation, we used all of the SNPs we had available for chromosome 6 in the HLA region based on a prior genome-wide association study (GWAS) [23, 25].
Imputation of KIR types
The KIR genes are tandemly arrayed in a region of about 150 kb on chromosome 19q13.4. Because the genes have a high level of sequence similarity, the genes evolve by non-allelic homologous recombination, which explains the expansion and contraction of the KIR locus in terms of copy number . We used the KIR*IMP software  to impute variables representing different definitions of KIR loci, including KIR gene copy number, KIR A or B haplotype, and gene-content haplotypes.
Twelve of the imputed genes are denoted: KIR2DS2, KIR2DL2, KIR2DL3, KIR2DP1, KIR2DL1, KIR3DP1, KIR2DL4, KIR3DS1, KIR2DL5, KIR2DS3, KIR2DS5, and KIR2DS1. The single digit after KIR corresponds to the immunoglobulin domain followed by the letter “D” for domain. A letter of L, S, or P is added to signify long or short cytoplasmic tail, or pseudogene, respectively. A final digit is added to distinguish between genes encoding the same protein structure. A thirteenth gene is denoted KIR3DL1ex4 or KIR3DL1ex9, which targeted copy number in exons 4 or 9, respectively, of the gene KIR3DL1. A 14th gene, KIR2DS4, was referred to as KIR2DS4DEL or KIR2DS4WT, corresponding to a 22-bp frameshift deletion or wild-type form, respectively. Another assay for this same gene detected both forms, and is denoted KIR2DS4TOTAL. In addition to these 14 genes, two types of haplotypes were imputed. The A/B haplotype denotes stable copy number (A haplotype), versus extensive copy number variation and many gene rearrangements. Different centromeric and telomeric motifs, which differ in the content and arrangement of genes, compose the KIR haplotypes. Further details of the KIR nomenclature and genomic structure are provided elsewhere .
To perform the imputation, we used prior GWAS SNPs to impute all SNPs genome-wide, then restricted to the imputed SNPs that had an imputation allele-dosage R2 of at least 0.8 (a measure of highly accurate imputation). Of the 301 SNPs that the KIR*IMP software used for imputation, we had 185 SNPs that were either measured or imputed well. The imputation accuracy was at least 90% for the majority of the KIR genes for each of the three cohorts, with imputation accuracy approximately 80% for the KIR haplotypes.
Genetic ancestry and population stratification
Because the reference panels that are used to impute either HLA or KIR alleles contain only subjects with European ancestry, we restricted our analyses to those with European ancestry. We calculated European ancestry based on SNP data available from a prior GWAS. Genetic data was used to assign ancestry groups (African, European, or Asian) for individuals using the STRUCTURE software , and using the 1000 Genomes data as a reference. These estimates were done within cohort and platform (San Diego/550, San Diego/650, US/Omni 2.5, Rochester/Omni 1). Others  have shown that it is necessary to prune the SNPs used for eigenvectors to avoid having sample eigenvectors determined by clusters of SNPs at specific locations, such as the lactose intolerance gene, or polymorphic inversion regions. The SNPs used for STRUCTURE and eigenvectors were selected by LD pruning from an initial pool consisting of all autosomal SNPs with the following filters: SNPs with a minor allele frequency (MAF) < 5% were excluded; influential SNPs were removed (according to the following chromosome regions:chromosome 8 [bp 1–12700000], chromosome 2 [bp 129900001–136800000, 5700000–33500000], chromosome 4 [0900001–44900000]); and correlation (r2) pruning was used to subset to uncorrelated SNPs. These SNPs were input to the STRUCTURE program  to make ancestry “triangle” plots that depict the admixture proportions of ancestry groups for each subject. Subjects were classified into major ancestry groups based on the largest estimated STRUCTURE ancestry proportion.
Eigenvectors were estimated within ancestry groups and platform strata for refined control of population stratification. For this step, SNPs with a MAF < 0.01 were excluded, SNPs with a Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium (HWE) p-value < 0.001 were excluded, INDELS were removed, and pruning according to variance inflation factors was used. These data were then used with smartPCA to produce a set of eigenvectors using the normalization formulas of Price et al. , following the procedures of EIGENSTRAT. Tracy-Widom statistics were computed to potentially include eigenvectors to adjust for covariates if they had a p-value < 0.05.
To achieve the greatest power to detect HLA or KIR alleles associated with measles immune response phenotypes, we pooled our data across the three cohorts. To remove the effects of potential confounders so that the cohorts could be combined, we first screened for potential confounders relevant to each ancestry group and cohort. Possible confounders were screened for their association with the trait as follows. Any categorical variable with a very large number of categories was binned using hierarchical clustering on the estimated regression coefficients. All categorical variables were coded as dummy variables such that the most common category was used as baseline. Univariate linear models were then used to evaluate potential confounders. Variables that were marginally associated with the trait with a p-value < 0.1 were then included in backwards selection with a p-value threshold of 0.1. This somewhat liberal p-value threshold achieves the goal of controlling for potential confounding covariates. For the final association models, the covariates used for adjustment differed by cohort. For the San Diego cohort, we adjusted for subject year of birth, the operator that ran the assays, and having self-reported Asian, Hawaiian, or Pacific Islander ancestry. For the Rochester cohort, we adjusted for population stratification eigenvectors, self-reported Native American or Native Alaskan ancestry, operator, and assay run. For the US cohort, we adjusted for design factors (needing to repeat a sample, plate, and plate position), population stratification (eigenvectors and self-reported ancestry), type of vaccine, and subject age. Residuals from the adjusted model were used as the primary adjusted traits for analyses. HLA supertype variables were constructed for locus A and locus B using the amino acid sequences available from IPD such that HLA alleles within a given HLA locus that shared peptide binding specificity were grouped together [38, 39]. See S1 Table for grouping of HLA-B alleles into supertype categories.
The associations of HLA loci and alleles with a trait were evaluated by regression models by using the most frequent allele as a baseline, and all other alleles were coded according to the dose of the allele. Rare alleles (counts less than five) were grouped together into a rare-allele category. Four approaches were used to test associations: 1) a global test that simultaneously tested all alleles of a locus with the trait; 2) a global test that simultaneously tested all supertypes of a locus with the trait; 3) an allele test that tested the association of each allele within a locus with the trait; 4) a supertype test that tested the association of each supertype within a locus with the trait. The advantage of the global test is that it has more power to detect an effect if multiple alleles are associated, whereas the allele test is more powerful if only a single allele is associated. The tests of individual alleles or supertype categories were provided by the Wald statistic for each allele/supertype in the model. To control for multiple testing, we used the Bonferroni correction. For the HLA loci, there were eight global locus tests that required a p-value < 0.006 to achieve statistical significance; for KIR, there were 17 global tests that required a p-value < 0.003 for statistical significance. For the alleles tested, for the HLA loci, there were 249 allele-specific tests, resulting in a p-value < 0.0002 for statistical significance. We recognized that there might be some dependence among the tested alleles. Based on a method that considers the correlation among alleles within each locus , the estimated number of independent tests was the same as the actual number. For the KIR alleles and haplotypes, there were 27 allele/haplotype-specific tests, resulting in a p-value < 0.001 that is required for corrected statistical significance. Statistical analyses were performed with the R statistical software version 3.2.0 and PLINK .
Characteristics of subjects
Our study cohort consisted of healthy children, adolescents, and adults between 11 and 41 years of age. Among 2,506 subjects enrolled into this study and retained in the analyses, because they had both antibody titer and genotype data available, 1,807 (72%) were male and 2,162 (86%) self-identified as Caucasian (Table 1). The mean neutralizing antibody titer for this cohort was 1,271 mIU/mL (SD; 1,652 mIU/mL). The median age at second (last) MMR vaccination was 18 years. There were no significant differences in neutralizing antibody titers between males and females in this cohort (p = 0.89).
Associations of HLA genotypes with measles antibodies
The association of each HLA allele with measles antibody titer is summarized in Fig 1, which depicts the–log10(p-value) for each of the alleles. This figure illustrates that the alleles from HLA loci B, DQB1, and DRB1 tend to have smaller p-values than alleles from the other loci. The quantile-quantile plot in Fig 2 shows that the p-values from all HLA alleles tend to be much more extreme than expected when there is no association of HLA alleles with measles antibody titers. Because we adjusted for potential population stratification, the departure of the p-values in Fig 2 from the diagonal line suggests that there are multiple HLA alleles associated with measles antibodies.
The y-axis illustrates the–log10(p-value) for the association of an allele with neutralizing antibody titer based on linear regression of antibody titer on the dose of each allele. The Bonferroni threshold is based on 0.05/248.
The p-values result from regression of neutralizing antibody titer on the dose of each allele, along with adjusting covariates that include eigenvectors to adjust for population stratification. The departure of the observed p-values from the diagonal line illustrates that many observed p-values departed from those expected when the null hypothesis of no association is true.
Table 2 shows outcomes for associations between HLA alleles with measles antibody titers across study cohorts, with presented results restricted to those alleles that had p-values ≤ 0.001. The global tests (threshold p-value < 0.0002) did not detect significant associations of HLA loci with antibody titers. For the HLA-B locus, we found four alleles with p-value < 0.001: B*07:02, B*35:17, B*40:01, and B*57:01. The effects of these alleles are represented by the regression coefficients from a regression model with the most frequent allele at a locus serving as a baseline, and all other alleles coded according to their dose in a genotype. A negative coefficient indicates that an allele is associated with a lower level of neutralizing antibody than the baseline allele, and a positive coefficient indicates the opposite effect. For each of these four alleles, the direction of the effects were consistent across all three cohorts, with each of the four alleles associated with a lower level of neutralizing antibody compared to the baseline allele: B*07:02.
Results are presented for alleles that have p-values < 0.001 for association with neutralizing antibody titers.
The HLA-C locus had two alleles, C*06:02 and C*08:02, with p-value < 0.001; both of these alleles had lower antibody levels compared to the baseline allele, C*07:02. Because there is strong linkage disequilibrium among the alleles from the HLA-B and HLA-C loci, we evaluated the joint effects of B alleles and C alleles, adjusted for each other. We focused on the B alleles that had small p-values (B*35:17, B*40:01, and B*57:01), and C alleles that also had small p-values (C*06:02 and C*08:02). The results showed that the B alleles retained small p-values (all p-values <0.006), while the effects of the C alleles dramatically diminished (p-values > 0.3), suggesting that the effects of the C alleles might be driven primarily by their associations with the B alleles.
At the HLA-DQA1 locus, the allele DQA1*05:05 had a lower antibody level than the baseline allele DQA1*01:02. At the HLA-DQB1 locus, the allele DQB1*06:02 had a higher level of antibody compared to the baseline allele DQB1*03:01. Finally, at the HLA-DRB1 locus, the low frequency allele DRB1*15:05 had a higher antibody level than the baseline allele DRB1*07:01. These suggestive associations must be carefully considered due to the absence of significant global tests.
There was no evidence of HLA-A supertype association with neutralizing antibody titers (global p-value, 0.99; allele p-value range of 0.76 to 0.93) (data not shown). In contrast, there were suggestive associations between neutralizing antibody titers and the HLA-B supertype at both the global (p = 0.003) and the individual supertype levels. The alleles contributing to each supertype category at locus B can be found in S1 Table. We observed an increase in neutralizing antibody titer for HLA B7 supertype (baseline) relative to all other supertypes, while all other HLA-B supertype categories were associated with a lower neutralizing antibody titer. This is consistent with the allelic-level trends. The p-values for the category-level associations are given in S2 Table. In particular, B44 (1,204 mIU/mL; p = 0.0085) and B58 (1,207 mIU/mL; p = 0.0018) supertypes demonstrated the strongest associations with lower mean titers of measles antibodies.
Associations of KIR genotypes with measles antibodies
The association of each KIR allele and haplotype with measles antibody titers is summarized in Fig 3. This figure illustrates that the KIR alleles and haplotypes show no evidence of association with measles antibody titer. This is further illustrated in Fig 4, which shows that the p-values are generally close to (or below) the diagonal in the quantile-quantile plot. We interpret this to mean that none of the KIR alleles and haplotypes are associated with measles antibody titers. This quantile-quantile plot also shows that we have controlled for population stratification, as upward departure from the diagonal would be expected if we had not adequately controlled for population stratification. More detailed results on the associations between KIR genotypes/haplotypes and measles-specific antibody titers are presented in Table 3. Because the effects of KIR loci were dramatically negative (smallest p-value over all 17 tested KIR loci was 0.13), we chose not to explore combinations of HLA and KIR alleles.
The y-axis illustrates the–log10(p-value) for the association of an allele or haplotype with neutralizing antibody titer based on linear regression of antibody titer on the dose of each allele or haplotypes. The Bonferroni threshold is based on 0.05/27.
The p-values result from regression of neutralizing antibody titer on the dose of each allele or haplotype, along with adjusting covariates that include eigenvectors to adjust for population stratification. The observed p-values were close to the diagonal line, suggesting that the observed p-values had a distribution that would be expected when the null hypothesis of no association is true.
We have previously described associations of HLA alleles with inter-individual variation in humoral immune response to measles vaccine. To expand upon our prior work, we performed a pooled analysis—with a much larger sample size—of the association of HLA loci with vaccine-induced immune measures using data obtained from three separate cohorts in order to maximize power. In addition, we examined HLA in terms of peptide-binding specificities through the use of HLA supertypes. Finally, we examined whether variation within the KIR genes, which display extensive genetic diversity, influences measles vaccine-induced antibody responses.
In this large cohort, we demonstrated suggestive associations between several allelic variants of the HLA-B, -DQB1, and -DRB1 loci and neutralizing antibody titers. HLA-B (*57:01), HLA-DQB1 (*06:02), and DRB1 (*15:05) alleles were associated with variation in antibodies, even after adjusting for relevant covariates. This study also showed that HLA-B supertypes (B44, B58) were marginally associated with measles antibodies. Although the associations of antibody titers with individual HLA loci or alleles did not achieve statistical significance according to the strict Bonferroni criterion, there is suggestive evidence that multiple alleles at the HLA loci are associated with neutralizing antibody titers, as illustrated by the excessive number of small p-values in the quantile-quantile plot. Despite our large study, the power to detect associations was limited by several factors. First, the small allele frequencies of some of the HLA alleles limit power. Second, global tests of an HLA locus can have reduced power when there are many alleles, of which only a small subset of alleles are associated with antibody titers.
In contrast to the multiple HLA alleles associated with response to measles vaccination, we were unable to find any evidence for associations of KIR loci or haplotypes with measles antibody titers. In this regard, it is worth noting that some KIR alleles are not expressed on the surface (NK cells and T lymphocytes), may not play a role in B cell development and antibody production, and/or may not be functional. Alternative approaches, including studies of functionally relevant KIR/HLA pairs based on the KIR/HLA allele frequencies, might be needed to understand the relationship between KIR alleles and their HLA ligand genes .
HLA associations found in this large combined cohort (n = 2,506) were compared to the ones previously found in a dataset of 346 Rochester cohort subjects (this Rochester cohort is part of the combined cohort of 2,506) . Finding B*57:01 and DQB1*06:02 allele associations in both the smaller (n = 346) and combined (n = 2,506) cohorts could be indicative that these alleles (B*57:01 and DQB1*06:02) are associated with the neutralizing antibody phenotype. Also, the DRB1*15 allele appears to be in linkage disequilibrium (LD) with the HLA-DQB1*06:02 allele. Similarly, we found suggestive associations between several alleles from the HLA-B locus that belong to the major HLA-B supertypes (alleles with overlapping peptide-binding specificities), such as B44 (*40:01) and B58 (*57:01), which were previously found in a small dataset of Rochester cohort subjects (n = 346) that is part of this large combined cohort . The nature of the association between HLA class I alleles and neutralizing antibody responses is not clear, as CD8+ T cell activity is not usually associated with humoral immunity. It can be proposed that antigen-presenting cells may present exogenous MV overlapping epitopes via cross-presentation by both class I and class II HLA molecules, as was recently described for the exogenous HIV-1 antigen . By identifying genetically restricted MV-derived peptides, it may be possible to develop new multi-peptide HLA supertype vaccines administered with specific adjuvants [45, 46]. Studies have also shown that CD8+ T cell responses correlate with viral RNA levels in MV-infected macaques . One possible explanation is that T cell responses facilitate viral clearance and thereby alter the availability of MV antigen for surface immunoglobulin on B cells. This may indirectly affect B cell activation and antibody production.
The strength of this work is that we have improved upon the rigor of our prior studies. In this current work, we utilized model selection to select the most relevant covariates to adjust for while evaluating the role of HLA or KIR alleles. We have also carefully controlled for the effects of population stratification by restricting to subjects with European ancestry by using a combination of the STRUCTURE race categorization and self-declared race, and by adjusting for population stratification in the analyses using eigenvectors estimated from genome-wide SNP measurements from a prior GWAS. We comprehensively examined the association of KIR and HLA genes on MV-induced immunity via state-of-the-art imputation methods. No previous measles vaccine studies have utilized an imputation approach to understand MV immunity. We pooled all of our available data across well-characterized and independent cohorts to gain power to detect associations. Additionally, we utilized an improved high-throughput uniform assay to reliably quantify neutralizing antibody titers. Although this assay does not measure all antibodies that may influence viral clearance and protection (i.e., antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity/ADCC antibodies) , it is the currently accepted "gold standard" assay in measles serology and provides measures (neutralizing antibody titers) used as correlates of protection against measles [28, 49]. Finally, we have been more conservative in our thresholds for statistical significance and acknowledged the issue of multiple testing.
While our study has many strengths, limitations are also present. We had insufficient numbers of other racial groups to conduct an independent study of response. Further studies are required to examine KIR/HLA allelic associations with measles vaccine immune response phenotypes in cohorts of different ancestry. Greater sample size and an increased sampling of other races are advisable to resolve these problems. Numerous statistical tests were carried out for this study; therefore, the probability of false-positive results is present. Also, the association between specific HLA alleles, such as B*35:17 and DRB1*15:05, must be interpreted with extreme caution due to the low frequency of these alleles. The low frequency of these alleles may imply that this association is unlikely to be informative in understanding the mechanisms of measles vaccine-induced antibody response. Even so, many of the associations discussed were observed in our previous measles vaccine studies with smaller subsets of these cohorts and less rigorous techniques, and our results make sense biologically in the context of what is known for the role of HLA in the vaccine-induced immunity framework. This lends confidence to our findings [8, 43].
In conclusion, our results demonstrate that alleles at the HLA-B (*57:01), -DQB1 (*06:02), and -DRB1 (*15:05) loci show some level of association with neutralizing antibody response, albeit at levels that do not achieve statistical significance. Based on the totality of all tested HLA alleles, there is evidence that the effects of HLA alleles on neutralizing antibody response are not simple chance occurrences, but rather a large number of alleles having small to modest effect sizes. Future studies will determine the direct effects and downstream functional consequences on neutralizing antibody phenotype of HLA (and other gene polymorphisms) that we have identified in the combined Rochester, San Diego, and U.S. cohorts. Knowledge about the immunogenetic impact of gene polymorphisms promises to lead to an enhanced mechanistic understanding of the immune response to MV, generate general principles and insights into the immunogenicity of other live viral vaccines, and inform the directed development of vaccine candidates against measles and other viruses.
S1 Table. The HLA alleles contributing to each supertype category at the B locus.
We thank the Mayo Clinic Vaccine Research Group staff and the study participants. We thank Caroline L. Vitse for her editorial assistance with this manuscript. Copyright 2017 Mayo Foundation for Medical Education and Research
- Conceptualization: IO GAP DS RK IH.
- Formal analysis: DS BL.
- Funding acquisition: GAP.
- Investigation: IO GAP RK IH.
- Methodology: IO DS BL.
- Project administration: IO GAP.
- Software: DS BL.
- Validation: DS BL.
- Writing – original draft: IO DS BL GAP.
- Writing – review & editing: IO DS BL GAP RK IH.
- 1. Tan PL, Jacobson RM, Poland GA, Jacobsen SJ, Pankratz SV. Twin studies of immunogenicity—determining the genetic contribution to vaccine failure. Vaccine. 2001;19:2434–9. pmid:11257374
- 2. Poland GA, Ovsyannikova IG, Jacobson RM, Smith DI. Heterogeneity in vaccine immune response: the role of immunogenetics and the emerging field of vaccinomics. Clin PharmacolTher. 2007;82(6):653–64.
- 3. Germain RN. MHC-dependent antigen processing and peptide presentation: Providing ligands for T lymphocyte activation. Cell. 1994;76:287–99. pmid:8293464
- 4. Poland GA, Ovsyannikova IG, Jacobson RM, Vierkant RA, Jacobsen SJ, Pankratz VS, et al. Identification of an association between HLA class II alleles and low antibody levels after measles immunization. Vaccine. [S0264410X01003462 pii]. 2001;20(3–4):430–8. pmid:11672906
- 5. Ovsyannikova IG, Jacobson RM, Vierkant RA, Pankratz SV, Jacobsen SJ, Poland GA. Associations between human leukocyte antigen (HLA) alleles and very high levels of measles antibody following vaccination. Vaccine. 2004;22:1914–20. pmid:15121303
- 6. Ovsyannikova IG, Pankratz SV, Vierkant R, Jacobson RM, Poland GA. Human leukocyte antigen haplotypes in the genetic control of immune response to measles-mumps-rubella vaccine. J Infect Dis. 2006;193(5):655–63. pmid:16453260
- 7. Ovsyannikova IG, Jacobson RM, Ryan JE, Vierkant RA, Pankratz VS, Poland GA. Human Leukocyte Antigen and Interleukin 2, 10 and 12p40 cytokine responses to measles: Is there evidence of the HLA effect? Cytokine. 2006;36:173–9. pmid:17234427
- 8. Ovsyannikova IG, Pankratz VS, Vierkant RA, Jacobson RM, Poland GA. Consistency of HLA associations between two independent measles vaccine cohorts: a replication study. Vaccine. 2012;30(12):2146–52. pmid:22285888
- 9. Sidney J, Peters B, Frahm N, Brander C, Sette A. HLA class I supertypes: a revised and updated classification. BMC Immunol. 2008;9:1. pmid:18211710
- 10. Ovsyannikova IG, Haralambieva IH, Vierkant RA, O'Byrne MM, Jacobson RM, Poland GA. The association of CD46, SLAM, and CD209 cellular receptor gene SNPs with variations in measles vaccine-induced immune responses—a replication study and examination of novel polymorphisms. Human Hered. 2011;72(3):206–23.
- 11. Ovsyannikova IG, Haralambieva IH, Vierkant RA, Pankratz VS, Poland GA. The role of polymorphisms in toll-like receptors and their associated intracellular signaling genes in measles vaccine immunity. Hum Genet. 2011;130(4):547–61. pmid:21424379
- 12. Ovsyannikova IG, Haralambieva IH, Vierkant RA, O'Byrne MM, Jacobson RM, Poland GA. Effects of vitamin A and D receptor gene polymorphisms/haplotypes on immune responses to measles vaccine. Pharmacogenet Genomics. 2012;22(1):20–31. pmid:22082653
- 13. Ovsyannikova IG, Haralambieva IH, Vierkant RA, O'Byrne MM, Poland GA. Associations between polymorphisms in the antiviral TRIM genes and measles vaccine immunity. Hum Immunol. 2013 Jun;74(6):768–74. pmid:23416095
- 14. Clifford HD, Hayden CM, Khoo SK, Zhang G, Le Souef PN, Richmond P. CD46 measles virus receptor polymorphisms influence receptor protein expression and primary measles vaccine responses in naive Australian children. ClinVaccine Immunol. 2012;19(5):704–10.
- 15. Clifford HD, Hayden CM, Khoo SK, Naniche D, Mandomando IM, Zhang G, et al. Polymorphisms in key innate immune genes and their effects on measles vaccine responses and vaccine failure in children from Mozambique. Vaccine. 2012 Sep 21;30(43):6180–5. pmid:22871352
- 16. Clifford HD, Yerkovich ST, Khoo SK, Zhang G, Upham J, Le Souef PN, et al. Toll-like receptor 7 and 8 polymorphisms: associations with functional effects and cellular and antibody responses to measles virus and vaccine. Immunogenetics. 2012;64(3):219–28. pmid:21947541
- 17. Parham P. Immunogenetics of killer-cell immunoglobulin-like receptors. Tissue Antigens. [126 pii]. 2003;62(3):194–200. pmid:12956873
- 18. Aranda-Romo S, Garcia-Sepulveda CA, Comas-Garcia A, Lovato-Salas F, Salgado-Bustamante M, Gomez-Gomez A, et al. Killer-cell immunoglobulin-like receptors (KIR) in severe A (H1N1) 2009 influenza infections. Immunogenetics. 2012;64(9):653–62. pmid:22652695
- 19. Jamil KM, Khakoo SI. KIR/HLA interactions and pathogen immunity. J Biomed Biotechnol. 2011;2011:298348. pmid:21629750
- 20. Gardiner CM. Killer cell immunoglobulin-like receptors on NK cells: the how, where and why. Int J Immunogenet. 2008;35(1):1–8. pmid:18093180
- 21. Ahlenstiel G, Martin MP, Gao X, Carrington M, Rehermann B. Distinct KIR/HLA compound genotypes affect the kinetics of human antiviral natural killer cell responses. J Clin Invest. 2008;118(3):1017–26. pmid:18246204
- 22. de Wit J, Borghans J, Kesmir C, van Baarle D. Editorial: Role of HLA and KIR in Viral Infections. Front Immunol. 2016;7(286).
- 23. Ovsyannikova IG, Kennedy RB, O'Byrne M, Jacobson RM, Pankratz VS, Poland GA. Genome-wide association study of antibody response to smallpox vaccine. Vaccine. 2012;30(28):4182–9. pmid:22542470
- 24. Ovsyannikova IG, Pankrantz VS, Salk HM, Kennedy RB, Poland GA. HLA alleles associated with the adaptive immune response to smallpox vaccine: a replication study. Hum Genet. 2014;133(9):1083–92. pmid:24880604
- 25. Kennedy RB, Ovsyannikova IG, Shane PV, Haralambieva IH, Vierkant RA, Poland GA. Genome-wide analysis of polymorphisms associated with cytokine responses in smallpox vaccine recipients. Hum Genet. 2012;131(9):1403–21. pmid:22610502
- 26. Pritchard JK, Stephens M, Donnelly P. Inference of population structure using multilocus genotype data. Genetics. 2000;155(2):945–59. pmid:10835412
- 27. Haralambieva IH, Ovsyannikova IG, Vierkant RA, Poland GA. Development of a novel efficient fluorescence-based plaque reduction microneutralization assay for measles immunity. Clin Vaccine Immunol. 2008;15(7):1054–9. pmid:18463223
- 28. Haralambieva IH, Ovsyannikova IG, O'Byrne M, Pankratz VS, Jacobson RM, Poland GA. A large observational study to concurrently assess persistence of measles specific B-cell and T-cell immunity in individuals following two doses of MMR vaccine. Vaccine. 2011;29(27):4485–91. pmid:21539880
- 29. Ovsyannikova IG, Ryan JE, Vierkant RA, Pankratz SV, Jacobson RM, Poland GA. Immunologic significance of HLA class I genes in measles virus-specific IFN-gamma and IL-4 cytokine immune responses. Immunogenetics. 2005;57(11):828–36. pmid:16331510
- 30. Ovsyannikova IG, Jacobson RM, Ryan JE, Vierkant RA, Pankratz VS, Jacobsen SJ, et al. HLA class II alleles and measles virus-specific cytokine immune response following two doses of measles vaccine. Immunogenetics. 2005;56:798–807. pmid:15712014
- 31. Ovsyannikova IG, Vierkant RA, Pankratz VS, Jacobson RM, Poland GA. Human leukocyte antigen genotypes in the genetic control of adaptive immune responses to smallpox vaccine. J InfectDis. 2011;203(11):1546–55.
- 32. Wang C, Krishnakumar S, Wilhelmy J, Babrzadeh F, Stepanyan L, Su LF, et al. High-throughput, high-fidelity HLA genotyping with deep sequencing. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 2012;109(22):8676–81. pmid:22589303
- 33. Jia X, Han B, Onengut-Gumuscu S, Chen WM, Concannon PJ, Rich SS, et al. Imputing amino acid polymorphisms in human leukocyte antigens. PLos ONE. 2013;8(6):e64683. pmid:23762245
- 34. Khakoo SI, Carrington M. KIR and disease: a model system or system of models? Immunological Reviews. 2006;214:186–201. pmid:17100885
- 35. Vukcevic D, Traherne JA, Naess S, Ellinghaus E, Kamatani Y, Dilthey A, et al. Imputation of KIR Types from SNP Variation Data. Am J Hum Genet. 2015 Oct 1;97(4):593–607. pmid:26430804
- 36. Novembre J, Johnson T, Bryc K, Kutalik Z, Boyko AR, Auton A, et al. Genes mirror geography within Europe. Nature. 2008 Nov 6;456(7218):98–101. pmid:18758442
- 37. Price AL, Patterson NJ, Plenge RM, Weinblatt ME, Shadick NA, Reich D. Principal components analysis corrects for stratification in genome-wide association studies. Nature Genet. 2006;38(8):904–9. pmid:16862161
- 38. EMBL-EBI. IPD-IMGT/HLA Database. http://www.ebi.ac.uk/ipd/imgt/hla/. Wellcome Genome Campus, Hinxton, Cabridgeshire, United Kingdom; 2016. Date accessed: June 13, 2016.
- 39. Sette A, Sidney J. Nine major HLA class I supertypes account for the vast preponderance of HLA-A and -B polymorphism. Immunogenetics. 1999;50(3–4):201–12. pmid:10602880
- 40. Li J, Ji L. Adjusting multiple testing in multilocus analyses using the eigenvalues of a correlation matrix. Heredity (Edinb). 2005 Sep;95(3):221–7.
- 41. Purcell S, Neale B, Todd-Brown K, Thomas L, Ferreira MA, Bender D, et al. PLINK: a tool set for whole-genome association and population-based linkage analyses. Am J Hum Genet. 2007;81(3):559–75. pmid:17701901
- 42. Single RM, Martin MP, Meyer D, Gao X, Carrington M. Methods for assessing gene content diversity of KIR with examples from a global set of populations. Immunogenetics. 2008 Dec;60(12):711–25. pmid:18797862
- 43. Ovsyannikova IG, Jacobson RM, Vierkant RA, Pankratz VS, Poland GA. HLA supertypes and immune responses to measles-mumps-rubella viral vaccine: Findings and implications for vaccine design. Vaccine. 2007;25 (16):3090–100. pmid:17280755
- 44. SenGupta D, Norris PJ, Suscovich TJ, Hassan-Zahraee M, Moffett HF, Trocha A, et al. Heat shock protein-mediated cross-presentation of exogenous HIV antigen on HLA class I and class II. J Immunol. 2004 Aug 1;173(3):1987–93. pmid:15265933
- 45. Ovsyannikova IG, Johnson KL, Muddiman DC, Vierkant RA, Poland GA. Identification and characterization of novel, naturally processed measles virus class II HLA-DRB1 peptides. J Virol. 2004;78(1):42–51. pmid:14671086
- 46. Johnson KL, Ovsyannikova IG, Poland G, Muddiman DC. Identification of class II HLA-DRB1*03-bound measles virus peptides by 2D-liquid chromatography tandem mass spectrometry. J Proteome Res. 2005;4:2243–9. pmid:16335972
- 47. Lin WH, Pan CH, Adams RJ, Laube BL, Griffin DE. Vaccine-induced measles virus-specific T cells do not prevent infection or disease but facilitate subsequent clearance of viral RNA. MBio. 2014 Apr 15;5(2):e01047. pmid:24736226
- 48. Forthal DN, Landucci G, Katz J, Tilles JG. Comparison of measles virus-specific antibodies with antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity and neutralizing functions. J Infect Dis. 1993 Oct;168(4):1020–3. pmid:8376813
- 49. Ward BJ, Aouchiche S, Martel N, Bertley FM, Bautista-Lopez N, Serhir B, et al. Measurement of measles virus-specific neutralizing antibodies: evaluation of the syncytium inhibition assay in comparison with the plaque reduction neutralization test. Diagn Microbiol Infect Dis. 1999;33(3):147–52. pmid:10092962