We examined adolescents’ knowledge regarding the origin of HIV/AIDS and correlates of beliefs surrounding conspiracy theories in Soweto, South Africa. Now, a decade post-AIDS denialism, South Africa has the largest antiretroviral therapy roll-out worldwide. However, conspiracy theories stemming from past AIDS denialism may impact HIV prevention and treatment efforts.
Study participants were recruited through the Kganya Motsha Adolescent Health Centre and the Perinatal HIV Research Unit’s Botsha Bophelo Adolescent Health Study (BBAHS). Adolescents were eligible to participate if aged 14–19 years and living in Soweto. We calculated the proportion of adolescents who correctly believed that HIV originated from non-human primates, and used contingency table analysis and logistic regression modeling to describe correlates associated with accurate knowledge and beliefs in conspiracy theories.
Of 830 adolescents, 168 (20.2%) participants correctly identified HIV as originating from chimpanzees and one third (n = 71, 8.6%) believed in a conspiracy theory about the origins of HIV, including that it originated from the US government (2.3%), the pharmaceutical industry (2.2%), a vaccine (2.1%), space (1.5%), and a scientist (0.6%). Participants who were more likely to correctly identify the origin of HIV were older, men, and unemployed. Participants who were men, unemployed or students, and who had a parent or close relative who had died of HIV, were more likely to believe in a conspiracy theory regarding the origins of HIV.
Adolescents living in Soweto did not have high levels of accurate knowledge regarding the origins of HIV/AIDS and conspiracy beliefs were present among a small minority of participants. Accurate knowledge of the origins of HIV and debunking myths are important for improving uptake of HIV prevention tools in this population.
Citation: Hogg R, Nkala B, Dietrich J, Collins A, Closson K, Cui Z, et al. (2017) Conspiracy beliefs and knowledge about HIV origins among adolescents in Soweto, South Africa. PLoS ONE 12(2): e0165087. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0165087
Editor: Matthew Law, University of New South Wales, AUSTRALIA
Received: October 2, 2015; Accepted: September 27, 2016; Published: February 2, 2017
Copyright: © 2017 Hogg et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Data Availability: To protect patient confidentiality data are available upon request from The BC Centre for Excellence in HIV/AIDS data steward and privacy officer. Requests for data access may be sent to firstname.lastname@example.org.
Funding: We would like to acknowledge the financial support from the Canadian Institutes for Health Research (grant number 230513) and Simon Fraser University, through a President Research award to Dr. Cari Miller; and the in-kind support from Kganya Motsha Adolescent Centre and the Perinatal HIV Research Unit in Soweto, South Africa. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Denialist claims and conspiracy theories regarding the origins of HIV/AIDS–identified as skepticism or rejection of biomedical HIV research and treatments–have a widespread history embedded in socio-cultural, political, and religious contexts. For example, poverty , witchcraft , racial and ethnic oppression [3–5], and antiretroviral medications [1, 6, 7] have often been cited as the source of HIV/AIDS. Such claims have gained acceptance among a significant sub-set of people, including scientists, physicians, and political leaders, notably within the South African context [3, 8, 9].
South Africa continues to experience the world’s most devastating HIV epidemic [10, 11]. AIDS denialism–particularly under past president Thabo Mbeki [3, 8, 12, 13]–has had devastating consequences for South Africans, including a ‘science war’ (i.e. traditional medicine versus antiretroviral medications)  that delayed the roll-out of prevention of mother-to-child transmission (PMTCT) and antiretroviral therapy (ART) [1, 8, 14–16], and spurred the uptake of various non-evidence based “cures” for HIV (e.g. ‘virgin cleansing’) . Nattrass  has explored the extent to which Mbeki’s AIDS denialist policies impacted AIDS mortality and morbidity in South Africa, finding that an earlier roll out of PMTCT and ARVs (i.e. 1998 versus 2001) would have averted an additional 171,000 HIV infections and prevented approximately 56,000 AIDS-related deaths between 1999 and 2007 . Additionally, a study by Chigwedere and colleagues  obtained similar findings, estimating that 330,000 lives were lost to HIV/AIDS and 35,000 babies were born with HIV in South Africa between 2000 and 2005 due to the delay in PMTCT and political inadequacies for country-wide roll out of ART.
By the end of 2014, after approximately 9 years of ART roll-out, 6.8 million people were living with HIV and 140,000 people had died from AIDS in South Africa . Nearly one in five adults aged 15 to 49 years (18.9%) were living with the disease in the country, and among those aged 15 to 24 years, nearly one in ten were infected with HIV . HIV prevention among adolescents is thus a top priority for non-governmental organizations and public health researchers, as the largest percentage of newly HIV-infected people worldwide are aged 15 to 29 years [20, 21].
Understanding the continued impact of AIDS denialism and conspiracy beliefs on the people of South Africa, notably the next generation of South Africans, is of particular importance. HIV prevention is premised on individuals’ abilities to transform their behaviours (e.g. use of condoms during intercourse) based on accurate and evidence-based information [22, 23]. As such, AIDS denialism and conspiracy theories may create obstacles to HIV prevention and treatment efforts, specifically in the South African context which has an extensive history of suspicion and fear originating from Apartheid discourses and racial divisions [9, 24, 25]. It is thus important to understand young people’s knowledge and beliefs about HIV to better prevent new infections. This study examines the relationships between the knowledge that adolescents living in Soweto, South Africa hold in relation to the origins of HIV and related conspiracy theories, and examines potential underlying predictors of HIV knowledge and conspiracy beliefs.
Data presented are from the Botsha Bophelo Adolescent Health Study (BBAHS), a cross-sectional observational study exploring socio-behavioural characteristics, HIV testing patterns, and sexual and reproductive health among adolescents (aged 14–19 years) living in Soweto, South Africa. Soweto, a compilation of urban townships established under the apartheid government , has approximately 1.2 million residents; 24.7% of whom are 14 years of age and younger . Such demographics, as well as the historical and political backdrop of Soweto, provide an important context in which to explore adolescents’ understandings of the origins of HIV.
Study participants were recruited through the USAID-funded Kganya Motsha Adolescent Centre (KMAC) and the Perinatal HIV Research Unit’s (PHRUs) BBAHS. Adolescents were sampled from all formal and identified informal townships within Soweto using a targeted sampling strategy to ensure age, gender, and neighborhood targets were met. Participants were eligible if aged 14–19 years, living in one of 41 formal and informal neighbourhoods within Soweto, and able to provide informed consent (aged 18–19 years) or parental/caregiver consent and assent to participate (aged <18 years). Recruitment remained open until a sample size of 830 was achieved. Interview-administered surveys were conducted in English using iPads or desktop computers, and took approximately 45–60 minutes. Participants were given an honorarium of 50 ZAR for transportation and associated participation costs. Ethical approval was obtained from the University of Witwatersrand (South Africa) and Simon Fraser University (Canada) research ethics boards.
Our principal outcome variable was the dichotomous measure of correctly answering the origin of HIV; namely, that HIV originated from apes and monkeys. Our secondary outcome variable, believing in a conspiracy theory, was created based on groups of other answers relating to a specific theory. Participants believing HIV originated from the US government, the pharmaceutical industry, a vaccine, space, and a scientist were coded as conspiracy beliefs, while remaining participants were classified as not believing in a conspiracy (yes vs. no).
Our explanatory variables included: socio-demographic variables (i.e. age, gender, sexual orientation, education [having grade 8 or higher], employment); living conditions (i.e. living in a shack, food security, HIV in family); and knowledge of HIV. Knowledge of HIV was based on correctly answering all questions to a previously validated 18-item knowledge questionnaire which includes HIV-specific questions relating to HIV prevention, anal sex, and HIV transmission (Study Cronbach alpha = 0.55) .
Summary statistics and contingency tables were used to describe the data. Fisher’s exact tests and chi-squared tests were used to determine bivariate associations between each outcome and the explanatory variables. Multivariable logistic regression was subsequently used to identify independent predictors of each outcome among all participants. Model selection was done by choosing the model that minimized Akaike’s information criteria (AIC). All statistical analyses were conducted in SAS version 9.3 (Cary, North Carolina, USA). Data are presented within categories as frequencies [n (%)] or as median and first to third quartile range (Q1-Q3).
Surveys were conducted with 830 participants between March 2010 and March 2012. The cohort was comprised of 355 (42.8%) young men with a median age of 17 years (Q1-Q3: 16–18). Most respondents (n = 455, 55.0%), were in or had completed high school.
Table 1 presents frequencies for beliefs on the origins of HIV. Of the 830 eligible participants, 168 (20.2%) correctly identified HIV as originating in non-human primates and 71 (8.6%) participants believed in a conspiracy theory, including HIV originating from the US government (2.3%), the pharmaceutical industry (2.2%), a vaccine (2.1%), space (1.5%), and a scientist (0.6%).
In the bivariable analysis exploring associations with correctly identifying the origins of HIV (shown in Table 2), correctly answering the origins of HIV was associated with being a man compared to being a woman (56.6% versus 39.9%, p <0.001), being older in age (18–19 years of age) compared to being younger in age (14–15 years of age) (60.7% versus 46.9%, p = 0.006), and being non-employed compared to being a student (20.4% versus 8.8%, p < 0.001). Additionally, Table 3 highlights that participants who were men, unemployed or students, and had a parent or close relative that had died of HIV were correlated with beliefs in conspiracy theories. Reporting high food insecurity was also significantly associated with believing in a conspiracy theory, however it was not selected in the multivariable model.
Table 4 illustrates to results of the multivariable model. Participants who were older (adjusted Odds Ratio [aOR]: 1.70; 95% Confidence Interval [CI]: 1.05–2.75), men (aOR: 2.08; 95% CI: 1.47–2.96), and non-employed (compared to being students, aOR: 2.05, 95% CI: 1.25–3.37; compared to being employed, aOR: 3.55, 95% CI: 1.11–11.36) were more likely to correctly identify the origins of HIV. Additionally, men (aOR: 2.72; 95% CI: 1.60–4.65), those employed (compared to being a student, aOR: 3.79, 95% CI: 1.37–10.50; compared to being unemployed, aOR: 11.26, 95% CI: 2.46–51.59), and those who had a parent or close relative die of HIV (aOR: 2.17; 95% CI: 1.29–3.67) were more likely to believe in a conspiracy origin.
One in five adolescents correctly identified HIV as originating in monkeys and apes and less than one in ten believed in conspiracy theories about HIV’s origin. Participants who correctly identified the origin of HIV were more likely to be older, men, and unemployed. However, conspiracy beliefs were more likely among men, participants who were unemployed or students, and participants who had a parent or close relative who had died of HIV.
Consistent with previous research on individuals’ understandings of HIV/AIDS, particularly among adolescents in South Africa [29–34], our findings demonstrate that adolescents in Soweto remain poorly informed about HIV despite the profound effect of the HIV epidemic on this generation . This underscores how there has been minimal improvement in fully eliminating denialist beliefs and conspiracy theories on the origins of HIV/AIDS with a knowledge gap remaining despite numerous HIV prevention efforts and interventions in South Africa [9, 35, 36]. In particular, these shortcomings indicate that prevention efforts have inadequately addressed the impact of historical, political, and cultural contexts that shape individuals’ conceptualization of illness and disease and multiple kinds of knowledge [13, 37]. Additionally, our findings suggest that the lack of improvement in HIV knowledge among adolescents in South Africa in recent years may remain too low for widespread improvements in HIV prevention uptake among this age group. However, additional research is needed to better understand the impact of conspiracy theory beliefs on HIV prevention successes and failures.
Our findings highlight that adolescents, regardless of sex, showed fairly low HIV knowledge, with less than 2% of participants (14, Q1-Q3: 12–15) able to correctly answer all HIV knowledge questions. Socio-structural factors (e.g. poverty, unemployment, food insecurity) may impact adolescents’ knowledge of HIV/AIDS, which is in line with previous research [36, 38, 39]. For example, participants facing high levels of food insecurity and poverty may need to seek employment opportunities to meet subsistence needs. As such, the association between employment and being unaware of the correct origins of HIV may be related to fewer learning opportunities for adolescents out of school. Increased peer-educational outreach programmes  may be beneficial in addressing HIV conspiracy theories and knowledge, particularly for participants who are no longer students.
This is further concerning for adolescent women who were less likely to have accurate knowledge about the origin of HIV, but who are more likely to be impacted by HIV in South Africa. Previous studies have shown that young, Black South African women acquire HIV from five to seven years earlier than their young male peers due to various socio-economic and cultural factors (e.g. intergenerational sexual partnerships, income inequities) . As such, there is a need for targeted, culturally relevant HIV/AIDS education and prevention efforts, as well as structural interventions to address socio-structural conditions faced by our cohort.
This study has several limitations that should be noted. First, the study sample may not be representative of all adolescents in Soweto, despite targeted sampling of formal and informal townships that considered age, gender, and neighborhood characteristics. Second, due to our study sample and study context, our findings may not be generalizable to adolescents elsewhere in South Africa. Third, the modest honorarium offered for study participation (50 ZAR, approximately $6 CAD) may have yielded an over-representation of individuals in need of financial assistance. Fourth, socially desirable responding and recall bias may have affected some of the study variables. Additionally, participants may have been reticent when discussing HIV or uncertain of HIV origins, which may have impacted responses. However, these may have been limited by the use of interviewers who were close to participants’ ages.
Our data provide important insights into conspiracy beliefs among Soweto adolescents and their determinants. As noted here, almost one in ten adolescents believed in contradictory conspiracy theories about the origins of HIV, and only one in five adolescents could correctly identify HIV as originating in monkeys and apes. Debunking such myths that may impede HIV prevention and treatment among adolescents in this setting will require increased culturally relevant educational efforts by the South African government and by NGOs that represent them.
The investigators of the Botsha Bophelo study wish to thank the adolescent participants for generously sharing their time and insight with us. We also wish to thank the study coordinators, Mazo Tshabalala and Matamela Makongoza, and research assistant Samantha Eady. Also we would like to acknowledge the financial support from the Canadian Institutes for Health Research (grant number 230513) and Simon Fraser University, through a President Research award to Dr. Cari Miller; and the in-kind support from Kganya Motsha Adolescent Centre and the Perinatal HIV Research Unit in Soweto, South Africa.
- Conceptualization: RSH BN JD SK ZC JC AK GG CLM.
- Data curation: SK ZC JC.
- Formal analysis: RSH BN JD SK ZC AK GG CLM.
- Funding acquisition: GG CLM.
- Investigation: RSH BN JD SK ZC JC AK GG CLM.
- Methodology: RSH BN JD SK ZC JC AK GG CLM.
- Project administration: RSH GG CLM JC ZC SK.
- Resources: RSH GG CLM.
- Software: SK ZC.
- Supervision: RSH GG CLM.
- Validation: RSH BN JD AC KC ZC JC SK BB AP AK GG CLM.
- Visualization: RSH BN JD SK ZC JC AK GG CLM.
- Writing – original draft: RSH AC KC CLM.
- Writing – review & editing: RSH BN JD AC KC ZC SK BB AP AK GG CLM.
- 1. Nattrass N. Are country reputations for good and bad leadership on AIDS deserved? An exploratory quantitative analysis. J Public Health (Oxf). 2008;30(4): 398–406.
- 2. Ashforth A. An epidemic of witchcraft? Implications of AIDS for the post-apartheid state. African Studies. 2002;61(1): 121–144.
- 3. Nattrass N. The AIDS conspiracy: science fights back. New York: Columbia University Press; 2012.
- 4. Grebe E, Nattrass N. AIDS conspiracy beliefs and unsafe sex in Cape Town. AIDS Behav. 2012;16(3): 761–773. pmid:21538083
- 5. Niehaus I, Jonsson G. Dr. Wouter Basson, Americans, and wild beasts: men's conspiracy theories of HIV/AIDS in the South African Lowveld. Med Anthropol. 2005;24(2): 179–208. pmid:16019570
- 6. Duesberg P. HIV is not the cause of AIDS. Science. 1988;241(4865): 514–517. pmid:3399880
- 7. Duesberg P, Rasnick D. The AIDS dilemma: drug diseases blamed on a passenger virus. Genetica. 1998;104(2): 85–132. pmid:10220905
- 8. Nattrass N. Mortal combat: AIDS denialism and the struggle for antiretrovirals in South Africa. Scottsville: University of KwaZulu-Natal Press; 2007.
- 9. Geffen N. Debunking delusions: the inside story of the Treatment Action Campaign. Auckland Park: Jacana Media; 2010.
- 10. UNAIDS. HIV and AIDS estimates (2014); 2014. Available from: http://www.unaids.org/sites/default/files/media_asset/UNAIDS_FactSheet_en.pdf.
- 11. Vermund SH. Massive benefits of antiretroviral therapy in Africa. J Infect Dis. 2014;209(4): 483–485. pmid:24307740
- 12. Presidential AIDS Advisory Panel. Presidential AIDS Advisory Panel Report: A synthesis report of the deliberations by the panel of experts invited by the President of the Republic of South Africa, the Honourable Mr. Thabo Mbeki; 2001. Available from: http://www.virusmyth.com/aids/hiv/panel/aidsreport.pdf.
- 13. Green L. Beyond South Africa's 'indigenous knowledge—science' wars. S Afr J Sci. 2012;108(7/8).
- 14. Heywood M. The price of denial. Development Update. 2004;5(3): 93–122.
- 15. Cameron E. A witness to AIDS. New York: I.B. Tauris; 2005.
- 16. Gevisser M. Thabo Mbeki: a dream deferred. Cape Town: Jonathan Ball Publishers; 2007.
- 17. Leclerc-Madlala S. On the virgin cleansing myth: gendered bodies, AIDS and ethnomedicine. Afr J AIDS Res. 2002;1(2): 87–95. pmid:25871812
- 18. Nattrass N. AIDS and the scientific governance of medicine in post-apartheid South Africa. African Affairs. 2008;107(427): 157–176.
- 19. Chigwedere P, Seage GR, Gruskin S, Lee TH, Essex M. Estimating the lost benefits of antiretroviral drug use in South Africa. J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr. 2008;49(4): 410–415. pmid:19186354
- 20. Catalano RF, Fagan AA, Gavin LE, Greenberg MT, Irwin CE Jr, Ross DA, et al. Worldwide application of prevention science in adolescent health. Lancet. 2012;379(9826): 1653–1664. pmid:22538180
- 21. Kleinert S. Adolescent health: an opportunity not to be missed. Lancet. 2007;369(9567): 1057–1058. pmid:17398287
- 22. Kudo Y. Effectiveness of a condom use educational program developed on the basis of the Information-Motivation-Behavioral Skills model. Jpn J Nurs Sci. 2013;10(1): 24–40. pmid:23735087
- 23. Magnani R, Macintyre K, Karim AM, Brown L, Hutchinson P, Kaufman C, et al. The impact of life skills education on adolescent sexual risk behaviors in KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa. J Adolesc Health. 2005;36(4): 289–304. pmid:15780784
- 24. Hodes R. Understanding Aids conspiracies: the ciritcal value of postmodernism. Sci Cult. 2013;22(2): 261–266.
- 25. Fassin D. When bodies remember: experiences andp olitics of AIDS in South Africa. Berkeley: University of California Press; 2007.
- 26. Gilbert A, Crankshaw O. Comparing South African and Latin American experience: migration and housing mobility in Soweto. Urban Studies. 1999;36(13): 2375–2400.
- 27. City of Johannesburg. Census 2011—main place "Soweto"; 2011. Available from: http://census2011.adrianfrith.com/place/798026.
- 28. Carey MP, Schroder KEE. Development and psychometric evaluation of the brief HIV knowledge questionnaire. AIDS Educ Prev. 2002;14(2): 172–182. pmid:12000234
- 29. St Lawrence JS. African-American adolescents' knowledge, health-related attitudes, sexual behavior, and contraceptive decisions: implications for the prevention of adolescent HIV infection. J Consult Clin Psychol. 1993;61(1): 104–112. pmid:8450095
- 30. Swart-Kruger J, Richter LM. AIDS-related knowledge, attitudes and behaviour among South African street youth: reflections on power, sexuality and the autonomous self. Soc Sci Med. 1997;45(6): 957–966. pmid:9255928
- 31. Simbayi LC, Kalichman SC, Jooste S, Cherry C, Mfecane S, Cain D. Risk factors for HIV-AIDS among youth in Cape Town, South Africa. AIDS Behav. 2005;9(1): 53–61. pmid:15812613
- 32. Steinberg J. Three letter plague: a young man's journey through a great epidemic. London: Vintage Books; 2008.
- 33. Roos J, Pretorius H, Visser M. A proposed strategy for changing high-risk sexual behaviour among students at tertiary institutions: a qualitative investigation with a vew to developing a preventative programme. J Compr Health. 1995;6(2): 81–89.
- 34. Leclerc-Madlala S. Infect one, infect all: Zulu youth response to the AIDS epidemic in South Africa. Med Anthropol. 1997;17: 363–380. pmid:9241993
- 35. Tlllotson J, Maharaj P. Barriers to HIV/AIDS protective behaviour among African adolescent males in township secondary schools in Durban, South Africa. Society in Transition. 2001;32(1): 83–100.
- 36. Eaton L, Flisher AJ, Aaro LE. Unsafe sexual behaviour in South African youth. Soc Sci Med. 2003;56(1): 149–165. pmid:12435558
- 37. Leclerc-Madlala S. The art of medicine: silver bullets, glass beads, and strengthening Africa's HIV response. Lancet. 2014;383: 1203–1204. pmid:24712031
- 38. Wood K, Maepa J, Jewkes R. Adolescent sex and contraceptive experiences: perspectives of teenagers and clinic nurses in the Northern Province. Pretoria: Centre for Epidemiological Research in South Africa; 1997.
- 39. Du Plessis GE, Meyer-Weitz AJ, Steyn M. Study of knowledge, attitudes, perceptions and beliefs regarding HIV and AIDS (KABP) among the general public. Pretoria: Human Sciences Research Council; 1993.
- 40. Campbell C, MacPhail C. Peer education, gender and the development of critical consciousness: participatory HIV prevention by South African youth. Soc Sci Med. 2002;55(2): 331–345. pmid:12144146
- 41. Shisana O, Rehle T, Simbayi LC, Zuma K, Jooste S, Pillay-van-Wyk V, et al. South African national HIV prevalence, incidence, behaviour and bommunication survey 2008: a turning tide among teenagers? Cape Town: HSRC Press; 2009.