A novel quantitative 1H NMR (Q-NMR) combined with HPLC-MS method has been proposed for investigating the degradation process of traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) components. Through this method, in-situ monitoring of dynamics degradation process of lithospermic acid (LA), one of the popular polyphenolic acids in TCM, was realized under low oxygen condition. Additionally, this methodology was proved to be simple, rapid and specific. Degradation kinetic runs have been carried out to systematically investigate the effects of two key environmental factors, initial pH values and temperatures. Eight main degradation products of LA were detected, seven of which were tentatively structural elucidated with the help of both NMR and LC-MS in this work and salvianolic acid A (Sal A) was the primary degradation product of LA. A possible degradation pathway of LA was proposed, subsequently. The results showed that the degradation of LA followed pseudo-first-order kinetics. The apparent degradation kinetic constants increased as the initial pH value of the phosphate buffer increased. Under the given conditions, the rate constants of overall degradation as a function of temperature obeyed the Arrhenius equation. Our results proved that the Q-NMR combined with HPLC-MS method can be one of the most promising techniques for investigating degradation process of active components in TCM.
Citation: Pan J, Gong X, Qu H (2016) Degradation Kinetics and Mechanism of Lithospermic Acid under Low Oxygen Condition Using Quantitative 1H NMR with HPLC-MS. PLoS ONE 11(10): e0164421. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0164421
Editor: Israel Silman, Weizmann Institute of Science, ISRAEL
Received: July 14, 2016; Accepted: September 23, 2016; Published: October 24, 2016
Copyright: © 2016 Pan et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Data Availability: All relevant data are within the paper.
Funding: The authors would like to acknowledge the financial support of National Natural Science Foundation (No. 81273992), Public Service Technology Research and Social Development Project of Science Technology Department of Zhejiang Province (2015C33128) and Zhejiang Provincial Education Department Projects (Y201225492) on this work. The National Natural Science Foundation website address is http://www.nsfc.gov.cn/. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript. Funds were used to buy materials, chemicals, and pay labor costs.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Abbreviations: Q-NMR, quantitative 1H NMR; HPLC-MS, high performance liquid chromatography coupled with mass spectrometry; ESI, electrospray ionization; TCM, traditional Chinese medicine; LA, Lithospermic acid; Sal A, Salvianolic acid A; Sal B, Salvianolic acid B; Sal C, Salvianolic acid C; iso-Sal C, iso-Salvianolic acid C; Sal T/U, mixture of Salvianolic acid T and U; TSP, trimethylsilyl propionic acid; MCR, multivariate curve resolution
The chemical complexity and vagueness of effective compounds are major impediments to the development of traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) into modern medicine in comply with pharmaceutical standards accepted worldwide. Multi-components and multi-species of many TCMs are accountable for most of these challenges, additionally, the deficiencies in modern standardization and quality control methods for TCM are also important contributing factors . In most cases, the TCM production process consists of the following indispensable units: extraction, concentration, purification, drying and preparation. Heating and acid/alkali adjustment are commonly used in extraction step, which may cause chemical reactions such as degradation of active components, this will directly affect the quality of TCM , thus its clinical safety and efficacy cannot be guaranteed. Therefore, the study on degradation process of active components in TCM is vital for improving quality control and quality consistency of TCM during manufacture and resulted pharmaceutical product.
Mechanism and kinetics are two major questions to be addressed in a degradation study. As one of the most powerful analytical tools in study of degradation mechanism, HPLC-MS is known for rapid compound identification with the help of widely used chemical databases [3–5]. In order to perform kinetic modeling in degradation study, both reactant and degradation products should be quantitatively analyzed and HPLC-UV is the dominant technique used [6–8]. Despite of all the superb characteristics of HPLC methods, the requirement of reference compounds is a limitation of its application in quantitative analysis. Without reference compounds, chromatographic results are reported on area percent rather than weight percent, which are not accurate enough for certain studies. Meanwhile, the preparation of reference compounds for degradation products is often time consuming and sometimes impossible when these compounds are unstable. Furthermore, these analytes may undergo chemical conversions when exposed to air during sample preparation in HPLC analysis. Spectroscopic coupled with multivariate curve resolution (MCR) methods had also been applied in degradation studies [9, 10]. Nevertheless, spectra and concentration matrix of degradation products resolved from MCR often belonged to mixture of compounds rather than a single compound. Furthermore, if the reactant and degradation products show similar spectroscopic property, these methods would fail to resolve. Another frequently overlooked question is that most researchers ignored the effect of oxygen on degradation process. Their reaction system is always exposed to the air, while the operation environment in real industrial manufacturing process of TCM is under low oxygen condition since it is relatively sealed. Therefore, the kinetic results obtained from their laboratory studies offered little instructive information to real industrial manufacturing and quality control of corresponding TCM. As a consequence, there is an urgent need in developing simple, rapid and in-situ research techniques for the study of degradation process of active components in TCM.
One of the major advantages of quantitative NMR (Q-NMR) spectroscopy is its primary analytical characteristics . It is in-situ, avoiding analytes conversions during sample preparation in HPLC analysis. NMR tube is deep in length and has quite small cross-sectional area, so it can be treated as a small reactor with less contact to air. Meanwhile, NMR is structurally rich and non-intrusive, which makes the technique extremely useful to identify and characterize reaction products, gain insights into the reaction mechanisms and determine reaction kinetics. Several studies have reported on reaction monitoring using NMR spectroscopy [12–16]. In recent years, Q-NMR combined with chemometrics methods have been successfully applied in analysis of herbs and herbal preparations [17–19]. We have previously established a Q-NMR method for hydrolytic kinetic investigation of Salvianolic acid B (Sal B) . Q-NMR methods have been demonstrated to be simple, rapid, efficient and reliable.
In this work, Q-NMR combined with HPLC-MS method was proposed to investigate the degradation process of Lithospermic acid (LA, Fig 1) as an example. LA is one of the popular polyphenolic acids existed in several medicinal plants, such as Tournefortia sarmentosa Lam. , Salvia miltiorrhiza Bge. (Danshen) and Origanum vulgare L. . It is considered to be the major active constituent of T. sarmentosa, with its content being about 0.6% w/w in the dried herb . LA possesses the effects of anti-oxidation, anti-inflammation , anti-lipid-peroxidative  and anti-neuro-inflammationm . Several researchers have illustrated that Salvianolic acid A (Sal A) is degradation product of LA [25, 26]. In recent years, there is a growing interests in Sal A due to its potent bioactivities. It is reported to show highest antioxidant activity among the salvianolic acids in Danshen , and possess protective effects in cardiac diseases [28, 29]. The content of Sal A in Danshen is very low. Several methods have been reported to prepare Sal A through the degradation of Sal B [30–34]. Wang et al.  found out that compared to Sal B, LA could more easily convert to Sal A and generate fewer other products under the same conditions. Up to now, none reports have been found on the degradation kinetics of LA, not to mention the kinetics of LA transform to Sal A. A possible reason was that Sal A was not stable in aqueous solutions and could be easily oxidized .
In current study, a novel Q-NMR combined with HPLC-MS method was established to investigate the degradation process of LA in low oxygen condition. NMR tube was used as reactor and argon was bubbled into the bottom of the NMR tube to vent oxygen. The Q-NMR method was used to monitor the concentration of LA and Sal A in process samples of degradation reaction, which was in situ, without sampling. NMR along with HPLC-MS method was used for structure elucidation of degradation products. A possible degradation pathway of LA was proposed. Furthermore, the concentration of LA and Sal A were fitted and the degradation rate constants were obtained.
Materials and Methods
Reagents and chemicals
LA (lot. 140107, 99.05%), Sal A (lot. 140710, 99.53%), Danshensu (lot. 141024, 99.10%), Salvianolic acid C (Sal C, lot. 130902, 99.53%) were purchased from Shanghai Winherb Medical S & T Development Co., Ltd. (Shanghai, China). The mixture of Salvianolic acid T and U (Sal T/U) was kindly provided by Tasly Pharmaceutical Co., Ltd. (Tianjin, China). Deuterium oxide, 99.9 atom % D (D2O), contains 0.05 wt. % 3-(trimethylsilyl)propionic-2,2,3,3-d4 acid sodium salt (TSP), Phosphoric acid, Sodium phosphate dibasic dehydrate and Sodium phosphate monobasic dehydrate were bought from sigma-Aldrich Corporate (St. Louis, MO, USA). HPLC grade formic acid was purchased from ROE Scientific Inc. (Newark, DE, USA). HPLC grade acetonitrile and methanol were obtained from Merck KGaA (Darmstadt, Germany). NMR tube (Norell 502–7) and rubber tube cap (Norell SEPTA-5-W) were purchased from Norell, Inc. (Landisville, NJ, USA). Lumbar puncture needle (0.7 mm×170 mm) was purchased from Shanghai SA Medical & Plastic Instruments Co., Ltd. (Shanghai, PR China). High purity argon was purchased from Shanghai Wugang gas Co., Ltd. (Shanghai, PR China). Ultrahigh-purity water was produced using a Millipore Milli-Q System (Milford, MA, USA).
Overall experimental procedures were presented in Fig 2. It consisted of three sections as follows: (1) sample preparation, (2) structure elucidation of degradation products and proposing degradation pathway of LA, (3) degradation kinetic study of LA and Sal A.
LA was accurately weighted, dissolved using a mixture of 90% 200 mM phosphate buffer and 10% D2O (containing TSP as the internal standard for chemical shift calibration and quantitative analysis). 500 μL of the test solution was added to the NMR tube, and high purity argon was bubbled into the bottom of test solution through a lumbar puncture needle for 2 minutes to vent oxygen. After that, the NMR tube was rapidly sealed up with a rubber cap.
Degraded Samples prepared using different methods were shown in Fig 3. All samples were heated in a thermostat bath set at 91°C. LA solution was prepared using the method proposed in this work in sample set 1. LA solution was added into NMR tube without venting oxygen in sample set 2. LA solution was added into tube without venting oxygen in sample set 3. The colors of sample solutions in sample set 1 were much lighter than others. According to the results of Q-NMR and LC-MS, a portion of Sal A were oxidized in sample set 2, while the concentration of Sal A were very low in sample set 3.
HPLC-MSn instrumentation and conditions
HPLC analysis was carried out on an 1100 Series HPLC system (Agilent, Waldbronn, Germany) with diode array detector using an XBridge Shield RP18 column (2.1 mm×150 mm, 3.5 μm, Waters). The temperature of column was maintained at 35°C. UV spectra were recorded from 190 to 400 nm and the detection wavelength was set at 280 nm. The flow rate was 0.2 mL/min, and an in-line filter was used before the analytical column. A gradient elution of mobile phase A (0.1% aqueous formic acid in water) and B (acetonitrile containing 0.1% formic acid) was used. The gradient was as follows: started at 98% A and 2% B, then to 85% A and 15% B at 15 min, 80% A and 20% B at 35 min, 75% A and 25% B at 45 min, 55% A and 45% B at 65 min, 10% A and 90% B at 66 min, kept with 10% A and 90% B from 66 to 70 min. After that, the system was restored to initial conditions in 25 min.
HPLC/MSn analysis was performed with an Agilent 1100 Series HPLC and LCQ Deca XPplus ion trap mass spectrometer (Thermo Finnigan, San Jose, CA, USA) equipped with electrospray ionization (ESI) source, with Xcalibur 1.3 controlling software. Nitrogen (N2) was used as the sheath and auxiliary gas, and helium (He) was used as the damping and collision gas. HPLC conditions were the same as described above. The key MS conditions were as follows: negative ion mode, mass range m/z 95–1000. The data-dependent MS/MS and MSn events were performed on the most intense ions detected in full scan and MS/MS. ESI parameters were as follows: source voltage, 3 kV; sheath gas, 30 arbitrary units (arb); auxiliary gas, 10 arb; capillary voltage, -15V; capillary temperature, 350°C; tube lens, -30 V.
NMR instrumentation and conditions
Quantitative NMR analysis was carried out on a Bruker Avance III (500.13M) NMR spectrometer equipped with a 5 mm 1H/D-BBO probehead (Bruker BioSpin GmbH, Rheinstetten, Germany). All the samples were locked individually on 90% H2O + 10% D2O and were measured at 293.0 K. Gas flow was set at 400 L/h. The spectra were acquired in 32 scans using 32 k data points by noesypr1d pulse program with water signal suppression. The 90° pulse width was set to 14.62 μs and the acquisition time was 2.04 s. The spectra width was set to 8013 Hz. The longitudinal relaxation time T1 was determined for the protons of interest (Table 1, Fig 1). Relaxation delay time (D1) was optimized for the T1 of the longest relaxing TSP nuclei, to ensure maximum recovery of the transverse magnetization, and D1 was set to 15 s.
The stock solution (5.56 mg/mL) was prepared by dissolving an appropriate amount of LA in 200 mM phosphate buffer (pH 5.29). The calibration curve was made using seven standard solutions of different concentrations (5.00, 4.00, 3.00, 2.00, 1.00, 0.500, 0.100 mg/mL). The standard solutions were prepared by diluting an appropriate volume of stock solution with the phosphate buffer and D2O (containing TSP as the internal standard for chemical shift calibration and quantitative analysis) was added to volume percentage of 10% for each sample. Each solution was analyzed twice. The peak area values were plotted against the corresponding analyte concentrations to obtain the linear calibration. Intraday precision of the method was determined by measuring six sample of LA (2.00 mg/mL) on the same day.
Degradation experiments of LA
Twelve or more test tubes were laid in a thermostat bath at predefined temperature and were periodically withdrawn during a kinetic run. Withdrawn samples were rapidly cooled in ice to quench the reaction and were stored in an ice bath until analysis within 2 h. Each study was comprised of twelve or more assays spaced to provide change of ~ 0.1 per samples. After NMR analysis, degradation samples were diluted with an equal volume of 0.3 M phosphoric acid. 2 μL diluted samples were injected into LC-MSn system for tentative structure elucidation of the degradation products.
The influences of temperature and pH values on degradation of LA were investigated. The influence of temperature on degradation was investigated in phosphate buffer solutions at a pH value of 4.75. The reaction rate constants were calculated at 80, 91 and 100°C, respectively. The effect of pH values on degradation was determined at 91°C in phosphate buffer solutions. Specific experimental conditions were listed in Table 2. All the pH measurements were performed on a pH meter (S40 SevenMulti, Mettler-Toledo GmbH, Greifensee, Switzerland) equipped with combination pH electrode (InLab Expert Pro).
According to the results of preliminary experiment, supposing the degradation of LA followed irreversible first-order reaction kinetics, ordinary differential equation of LA concentration was obtained as follows: (1) where C1 is the concentration of LA and kr1 is the of LA.
For Sal A, it was degraded from LA and would transform to Sal C and other isomers. Assuming all these reactions follow irreversible first-order reaction kinetics, ordinary differential equation of Sal A was obtained as follows: (4) where C2 is the concentration of Sal A, kr2 is the rate constant of LA transform to Sal A, kr3 is the rate constant of Sal A transform to other compounds.
The influence of temperature on reaction rate constant was given by Arrhenius equation: (6) where A represents frequency factor, Ea stands for activation energy, R is ideal gas constant (8.314 J/mol·K) and T is temperature (K).
All data fitting were carried out using OriginLab (Pro 8, OriginLab Corp., Northampton, MA).
Results and Discussion
Identification of degradation products
HPLC chromatograms (280 nm) of degraded sample heated 12 h in Exp. No. II, IV and V (for experimental condition details see Table 2) were shown in Fig 4. A tentative assignment of the degradation products was made on basis of quasi-molecular ion [M−H]− and fragment ions obtained from LC—MSn experiments.
(a) Exp. No. II; (b) Exp. No. IV; (c) Exp. No. V.
The MS of Peak 2 showed [M-H]- at 197 and [2M-H]- at 395, it was identified as danshensu. The MS of Peak 3 showed [M-H]- at 493 and [2M-H]- at 987, it was identified as Sal A. The MS of Peak 5 showed [M-H]- at 491 and [2M-H]- at 983, it was identified as Sal C. In addition, these compounds had been further determined by comparison of retention times with those of reference compounds. MS quasi-molecular ion of peak 4 was the same as peak 5, according to the results in previous work , peak 4 was identified as iso-salvianolic acid C (iso-Sal C). The MS of peak 6 showed [M-H]- ion at 357, according to the results in Kan et al.’s  and Guo et al.’s  studies, peak 6 was identified as prolithospermic acid.
Peak 7, 8 and 9 were three degradation products easily generated at higher initial pH values. They all had the same [M-H]- at m/z 537, which suggested that they were isomers (M.W. 538). The MS/MS and MS3 spectra were also similar. They first lost 44u (CO2) from the [M−H]− ion to form the abundant [M−H−CO2]− ion at m/z 493, and then lost 198u (danshensu) to yield m/z 295, respectively. Compared to retention times with those of reference compounds, peak 8 and 9 were identified to Sal U and Sal T, which was in consistence with the results of Li et al.’s work . MS information could not support the structure elucidation of peak 7 and it was assigned as isomer of LA. Sal U and Sal T were detected as degradation products of LA for the first time in this work.
Sal A was primary degradation product of LA in our experiments. Nevertheless, constitutes of degradation products changed at different experimental conditions. Areas of peak 7–9 increased as the initial pH value of phosphate solution increased. In production of corresponding TCM preparations, process parameters could be adjusted according to production targets. If Sal A is the production targets, solution pH values should be reduced and the reaction system should be kept under low oxygen condition.
Proposed degradation mechanism
After the identification of the various LA degradation products, a possible pathway of LA degradation in water was proposed, as shown in Fig 5. LA could easily degrade to Sal A through ring opening of benzofuran and decarboxylation. Sal A could further be oxidized to Sal C and its isomers, it was in accordance with previous study . As NMR tube was not sealed, small amount of oxygen might exist in NMR tube, thus, a small part of Sal A was oxidized to Sal C and its isomers. Alternatively, LA could undergo the furan ring-opened to form Sal U and Sal T as the initial of pH of phosphate solution increased. LA could also undergo ester bond hydrolysis to produce danshensu and Prolithospermic acid. Some degradation pathways of LA had been reported by other researchers [25, 31, 32], including decarboxylation and the hydrolysis of the ester bond. While the pathway of ring-open of benzofuran in the parent compound LA to generate Sal T/U was detected for the first time in this work.
Determination of LA and Sal A using Q-NMR
Typical 1H NMR spectra of LA (A) and the degraded samples (B) were shown in Fig 6. Quantitative peaks were selected through comparing 1H NMR spectra of standard compounds with those of degraded samples. Two pairs of peaks could be used for quantification of LA (1–1, 1–2) and Sal A (3–1, 3–2). Chemical shift of quantitative peaks upfielded slightly along with the degradation went on. Assignment of quantitative peaks also referred to Zhou et al.’s  and Xiao et al.’s works . For ascertaining specificity of the quantitative peaks, 2D NMR (COSY and HSQC) were adopted, supporting the assignment of peaks used for the quantification. LA and Sal A could be quantified using the established Q-NMR method.
The linearity of the Q-NMR method was proved using linear correlation of the peak area values and seven standard solutions of LA in the concentration range of 0.100–5.00 mg/mL (r2 = 0.9997 or 0.9994 for peak 1–1 and 1–2). As quantitative NMR is a primary ratio method, linearity is of little significance for assessing the specific detector response factor for different analytes. The experiment was mainly aimed at checking the system stability for the quantitative analysis. The RSD value of intraday precision was less 1% for LA, indicating good repeatability of the Q-NMR method.
Degradation kinetics of LA
A linear relationship between natural logarithmic remaining percent of LA and degradation time was found as shown in Fig 7. The observed first-order rate constant, kr1, was determined and the results were shown in Table 2. All the determination coefficients are higher than 0.99, which means that satisfactory fitting was obtained. Degradation constant kr1 increased as initial pH value or temperature increased.
(☆)Exp. No. I; (□)Exp. No. II; (▽)Exp. No.III; (○)Exp. No. IV; (△)Exp. No. V.
The degradation rate constants at different initial pH values were shown in Table 2 (Exp. No. II, IV and V). Initial pH value also showed influences on the degradation rate of LA. LA tended to generate more degradation products as the initial of pH value of phosphate solution increased. Meanwhile stability of Sal A deteriorated with the increasing of solution pH value. These might be the partial factors which caused the variation of degradation rate constants.
The data obtained was fitted with Eq (6) and the results were shown in Table 3. The activation energy and the frequency could be further applied to predict the theoretical half-life of LA solution by assuming a similar mechanism. Half-life of LA at 25°C was predicted to be 2742 days in a phosphate buffer solution (pH 4.75). The prediction rate constant at 25°C was also shown in Table 3.
Degradation kinetics of Sal A
The time concentration data of Sal A was fitted with Eq (5) and the results were shown in Table 4 and Fig 8. All of the determination coefficients are higher than 0.98, which means that satisfactory fitting was obtained. The results of kr2/kr1 were higher than 0.5, indicating over half amount of LA converted to Sal A under our experimental conditions.
(☆)Exp. No. I; (□)Exp. No. II; (▽)Exp. No.III; (○)Exp. No. IV; (△)Exp. No. V.
The degradation rate constants at different initial pH values were shown in Table 4 (Exp. 2, 4 and 5). The results showed the stability of Sal A was highly dependent on initial pH value of phosphate buffer. Sal A easily degradated to other compound in Exp. 5.
A novel Q-NMR combined with HPLC-MS procedure has been proposed for investigating the degradation process of TCM components using LA solution as a sample system. The proposed method allowed in-situ monitoring of kinetic samples in low oxygen conditions, which was critical for the stability of easily oxidized TCM components, such as Sal A. This NMR method is simple, rapid, specific and no specific reference standards are needed for quantification of target compounds. Therefore this method can be used to investigate TCM systems containing components that are unstable or difficult to prepare.
Eight main degradation products of LA were detected, seven of which were characterized by LC-MS and compared with available reference compounds. These degradation products are proposed to form main pathway of LA, including decarboxylation, ring-open of benzofuran and the hydrolysis of the ester bond in the parent compound.
Kinetic parameters for both LA and Sal A degradation were fitted. The degradation of LA obeyed a pseudo-first-order kinetics. Degradation rate constants increased with increasing of initial pH value or temperatures. Rate constants kr1 and kr2 obeyed Arrhenius equation. The kinetics studies also indicated that Sal A was the primary degradation product of LA, which was in accordance with the results of Wang et al.’s work . Q-NMR combined with HPLC-MS method will be one of the most promising techniques for investigating degradation process of active components in TCM.
The authors like to acknowledge the financial supports of National Natural Science Foundation (No. 81273992), Public Service Technology Research and Social Development Project of Science Technology Department of Zhejiang Province (2015C33128) and Zhejiang Provincial Education Department Projects (Y201225492) on this work. The National Natural Science Foundation website address is: http://www.nsfc.gov.cn/. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript. Funds were used to buy materials, chemicals, and pay labor costs.
- Conceptualization: HQ JP.
- Formal analysis: JP XG.
- Funding acquisition: HQ JP.
- Investigation: JP.
- Methodology: JP.
- Project administration: HQ.
- Resources: HQ JP.
- Supervision: HQ.
- Validation: JP.
- Visualization: JP.
- Writing – original draft: JP.
- Writing – review & editing: HQ XG.
- 1. Straus SE. Herbal Medicines—What's in the Bottle? New Engl J Med. 2002;347(25):1997–8. pmid:12490680.
- 2. Wang M, Ren X, Gao X, Vincieri FF, Bilia AR. Stability of Active Ingredients of Traditional Chinese. Nat Prod Commun 2009;4(12):1761–76. pmid:20120121
- 3. Wang SF, Zhu YX, Shao Q, Wang Y, Fan XH, Cheng YY. Identification of chemical constituents in two traditional Chinese medicine formulae by liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry and off-line nuclear magnetic resonance. J Pharm Biomed Anal. 2016;117:255–65. pmid:26397205.
- 4. Xu JZ, Zeng SS, Chen XY, Qu HB. Isolation and identification of degradation products of salvianolic acid A by NMR and LC-MS. Fitoterapia. 2011;82(2):260–6. pmid:21034799
- 5. Yang YD, Zhu X, Zhang F, Li W, Wu Y, Ding L. Stability-indicating HPLC method development and structural elucidation of novel degradation products in posaconazole injection by LC-TOF/MS, LC-MS/MS and NMR. J Pharm Biomed Anal. 2016;125:165–77. pmid:27023129.
- 6. Guo YX, Xiu ZL, Zhang DJ, Wang H, Wang LX, Xiao HB. Kinetics and mechanism of degradation of lithospermic acid B in aqueous solution. J Pharm Biomed Anal. 2007;43(4):1249–55. pmid:17118607
- 7. Guo YX, Zhang DJ, Wang H, Xiu ZL, Wang LX, Xiao HB. Hydrolytic kinetics of lithospermic acid B extracted from roots of Salvia miltiorrhiza. J Pharm Biomed Anal. 2007;43(2):435–9. pmid:16950588
- 8. Zhou LN, Zhang X, Xu WZ, Ma XN, Jia Z, Zheng YM, et al. Studies on the Stability of Salvianolic Acid B as Potential Drug Material. Phytochem Anal. 2011;22:378–84. pmid:21226127
- 9. Zheng XT, Qu HB. Characterisation of the Degradation of Salvianolic Acid B Using an On-line Spectroscopic Analysis System and Multivariate Curve Resolution. Phytochem Anal. 2012;23(2):103–9. pmid:21692119
- 10. Zheng XT, Gong XC, Li Q, Qu HB. Application of Multivariate Curve Resolution Method in the Quantitative Monitoring Transformation of Salvianolic Acid A Using Online UV Spectroscopy and Mass Spectroscopy. Ind Eng Chem Res. 2012;51(8):3238–45.
- 11. Bharti SK, Roy R. Quantitative 1H NMR spectroscopy. Trends in Analytical Chemistry. 2012;35:4–26.
- 12. Foley DA, Wang J, Maranzano B, Zell MT, Marquez BL, Xiang YQ, et al. Online NMR and HPLC as a reaction monitoring platform for pharmaceutical process development. Anal Chem. 2013;85(19):8928–32. pmid:24003862.
- 13. Susanne F, Smith DS, Codina A. Kinetic Understanding Using NMR Reaction Profiling. Organic Process Research & Development. 2012;16(1):61–4.
- 14. Clegg IM, Gordon CM, Smith DS, Alzaga R, Codina A. NMR reaction monitoring during the development of an active pharmaceutical ingredient. Anal Methods. 2012;4(6):1498.
- 15. Charisiadis P, Tsiafoulis CG, Tzakos AG, Gerothanassis IP. Dynamic changes in composition of extracts of natural products as monitored by in situ NMR. Magn Reson Chem. 2014;52(12):764–8. pmid:25139153
- 16. Foley DA, Dunn AL, Zell MT. Reaction monitoring using online vs tube NMR spectroscopy: seriously different results. Magn Reson Chem. 2016;54(6):451–6. pmid:26248898.
- 17. Nerantzaki AA, Tsiafoulis CG, Charisiadis P, Kontogianni VG, Gerothanassis IP. Novel determination of the total phenolic content in crude plant extracts by the use of 1H NMR of the -OH spectral region. Anal Chim Acta. 2011;688(1):54–60. pmid:21296205.
- 18. Jiang MM, Jiao YJ, Wang YF, Xu L, Wang M, Zhao BC, et al. Quantitative Profiling of Polar Metabolites in Herbal Medicine Injections for Multivariate Statistical Evaluation Based on Independence Principal Component Analysis. PLOS ONE. 2014;9(8):e105412. pmid:25157567
- 19. Jiang MM, Wang CH, Zhang Y, Feng YF, Wang YF, Zhu Y. Sparse partial-least-squares discriminant analysis for different geographical origins of Salvia miltiorrhiza by 1H-NMR-based metabolomics. Phytochem Anal. 2014;25(1):50–8. pmid:23868756.
- 20. Pan JY, Gong XC, Qu HB. Quantitative 1H NMR method for hydrolytic kinetic investigation of salvianolic acid B. J Pharm Biomed Anal. 2013;85:28–32. pmid:23867115
- 21. Lin Y, Chang Y, Kuo Y. Anti-Lipid-Peroxidative Principles from Tournefortia sarmentosa. J Nat Prod. 2002;65(5):745–7. pmid:12027757
- 22. Lin YL, Wang CN, Shiao YJ, Liu TY, Wang WY. Benzolignanoid and polyphenols from Origanum vulgare. J Chin Chem Soc. 2003;50(5):1079–83.
- 23. Liu X, Chen R, Shang Y, Jiao B, Huang C. Lithospermic acid as a novel xanthine oxidase inhibitor has anti-inflammatory and hypouricemic effects in rats. Chem-Biol Interact. 2008;176(2–3):137–42. pmid:18694741
- 24. Lin YL, Tsay HJ, Lai TH, Tzeng TT, Shiao YJ. Lithospermic acid attenuates 1-methyl-4-phenylpyridine-induced neurotoxicity by blocking neuronal apoptotic and neuroinflammatory pathways. J Biomed Sci. 2015;22(1). pmid:26018660
- 25. Wang Y, Zhu JB, Fu SP, Zhang Y. Study on chemical changes of salvianolic acid B and lithospermic acid aqueous under conditions of high temperature and high pressure. China Journal of Chinese Materia Medica. 2011;36(434–438).
- 26. Zhou CX, Luo HW, Masatake N. Studies on Isolation and Identification of Water- Soluble Constituents of Salvia Miltiorrhiz a. Journal of China Pharmaceutical University. 1999;30(6):411–6.
- 27. Liu GT, Zhang TM, Wang BE, Wang YW. Protective action of seven natural phenolic compounds against peroxidative damage to biomembranes. Biochem Pharmacol. 1992;43:147–52. pmid:1739402
- 28. Teng FK, Yin Y, Cui YJ, Deng YP, Li DF, Cho KK, et al. Salvianolic acid A inhibits endothelial dysfunction and vascular remodeling in spontaneously hypertensive rats. Life Sci. 2016;144:86–93. pmid:26135625
- 29. Li YJ, Duan CL, Liu JX. Salvianolic acid A promotes the acceleration of neovascularization in the ischemic rat myocardium and the functions of endothelial progenitor cells. J Ethnopharmacol. 2014;151(1):218–27. pmid:24189032
- 30. Lu LY, Zhang H, Qian Y, Yuan Y. Isolation of Salvianolic acid A, a Minor Phenolic Carboxylic Acid of Salvia miltiorrhiza. Nat Prod Commun. 2010;5(5):805–8. pmid:20521551
- 31. Kan SD, Chen ZZ, Shao L, Li JA. Transformation of Salvianolic Acid B to Salvianolic Acid A in Aqueous Solution and theIn VitroLiver Protective Effect of the Main Products. J Food Sci. 2014;79(4):C499–C504. pmid:24689808
- 32. Xia HR, Sun LR, Lou HX, Rahman MM. Conversion of salvianolic acid B into salvianolic acid A in tissues of Radix Salviae Miltiorrhizae using high temperature, high pressure and high humidity. Phytomedicine. 2014;21(6):906–11. pmid:24548723
- 33. Liu DF, Zhang GJ, Wang Z, Liu EW, Liu P, Liu YH, et al., inventors; Jiangxi Qingfeng Pharmaceutical Co., Ltd., assignee. Catalytic conversion of Salvianolic acid B for preparation of Salvianolic acid A. China2015.
- 34. He KJ, Liu K, Han F, Chen D, Liu JF, Zhang Q, inventors; Suzhou Leina Drug Development Co., Ltd., assignee. Catalytic conversion of Salvianolic acid B for preparation of Salvianolic acid A. China2014.
- 35. Li W, Zhou SP, Jin YP, Huang XF, Zhou W, Han M, et al. Salvianolic acids T and U: A pair of atropisomeric trimeric caffeic acids derivatives from root of Salvia miltiorrhiza. Fitoterapia. 2014;98:248–53. pmid:25172105
- 36. Xiao CN, Wu M, Zhang YJ, Zhao XF, Yu J, Zheng XH. The structure-dependent self-association of five phenolic acids in aqueous solution. Magn Reson Chem. 2014;52(8):460–6. pmid:24890230