Advertisement
Browse Subject Areas
?

Click through the PLOS taxonomy to find articles in your field.

For more information about PLOS Subject Areas, click here.

  • Loading metrics

Ethosomes Loaded with Cryptotanshinone for Acne Treatment through Topical Gel Formulation

  • Zhenwei Yu,

    Affiliation Department of Pharmacy, Sir Run Run Shaw Hospital, College of Medicine, Zhejiang University, Hangzhou, Zhejiang, People’s Republic of China

  • Hongyan Lv,

    Affiliation Department of Pharmacy, Sir Run Run Shaw Hospital, College of Medicine, Zhejiang University, Hangzhou, Zhejiang, People’s Republic of China

  • Gang Han ,

    hanpharm_srrsh@sina.com

    Affiliation Department of Pharmacy, Sir Run Run Shaw Hospital, College of Medicine, Zhejiang University, Hangzhou, Zhejiang, People’s Republic of China

  • Ke Ma

    Affiliation Department of Pharmacy, Sir Run Run Shaw Hospital, College of Medicine, Zhejiang University, Hangzhou, Zhejiang, People’s Republic of China

Ethosomes Loaded with Cryptotanshinone for Acne Treatment through Topical Gel Formulation

  • Zhenwei Yu, 
  • Hongyan Lv, 
  • Gang Han, 
  • Ke Ma
PLOS
x

Abstract

The aim of this study was to develop ethosomes loaded with cryptotanshinone (CPT) and formulate them as a topical gel for the treatment of acne. Ethosomes were prepared and evaluated for vesicle size, CPT loading and encapsulation efficiency. Optimized ethosomes were formulated as Carbomer 974 gels and compared with conventional hydroethanolic gels for transdermal permeation and skin deposition in vitro. The anti-acne activity and skin irritation of the gel was investigated in rabbits. Optimized ethosomes had an average vesicle size of 69.1 ± 1.9 nm with CPT loading and encapsulation efficiency of 0.445 ± 0.007 mg/mL and 40.31 ± 0.67%, respectively. The transdermal flux and skin deposition of the optimized ethosomal gel were 2.5- and 2.1-times those of conventional gels. The ethosomal gel revealed better anti-acne effect with only slight skin irritation. This study demonstrates that ethosomal formulation is an effective dermal delivery system for CPT, and that CPT ethosomal gels are promising future acne treatments.

Introduction

Acne, a multifactorial pathology that affects skin follicles in areas such as face, upper chest and back, is the most common dermatologic disorder, affecting approximately 85% of teenagers [1]. Acne is a chronic inflammatory follicular disorder of the skin, occurring in specialized pilosebaceous units that consist of the follicular canal with its rudimentary hair and a group of sebaceous glands that surround the opening of the follicle [2]. Excess production of the male hormone androgen and colonization by Propionibacterium acnes have been associated in the etiology of the disease [1, 3]. Although several molecules are available for acne treatment, the majority fail to tackle all the pathogenic factors and may cause side effects including dryness, skin irritation and photosensitivity [4].

Cryptotanshinone (CPT), a well-known diterpene quinone from the widely used traditional Chinese herb Salvia miltiorrhiza, has been reported therapeutic potentials and diverse activities [5]. CPT is effective for the clinical treatment of acne vulgaris [6]. The mechanism of CPT in treating acne may be attributed to its anti-bacterial [7, 8], anti-inflammatory [9, 10] and antiandrogen [11, 12] activities. CPT has extremely low water solubility and an absolute oral bioavailability of only about 2% in rats [13], making dermal delivery a good choice for this compound.

Stratum corneum (SC), the outermost layer of skin consisting of corneocytes surrounded by lipid bilayers, is the main barrier for drug delivery into skin [14]. Many techniques have been used to overcome the barrier formed by SC in order to improve topical drug delivery, including ethosomes. Ethosomes are phospholipid-based nano-vesicles containing a high percentage of ethanol (20%–45%), which were developed by Touitou et al [15]. The ethanol in the ethosome system makes the vesicular membranes highly flexible, allowing the ethosome to transport though pores much smaller than their diameters [16]. Ethanol is also an effective permeation enhancer [17, 18]. Several studies over the past decade have extensively demonstrated the advantage of ethosomes as carriers for topical delivery and ethosomes are able to improve drug delivery into skin layers and across skin in terms of both quantity and depth [19, 20].

In the present study, CPT is loaded in ethosomes and formulated for topical delivery for acne treatment. The physicochemical properties of the ethosomes are characterized including vesicle size, CPT loading and encapsulation efficiency. The in vitro skin permeation and deposition of CPT in ethosomal gels are also assessed. The anti-acne effect and skin irritation are investigated in an animal model.

Materials and Methods

Materials

CPT was purchased from Shanxi Angsheng Biology Medical Co., Ltd (purity 98.2%, Xian, China). Soybean phosphatidycholine (SPC, Lipoid S100) was purchased from Shanghai Toshisun Biology and Technology Co., Ltd (Shanghai, China). Oleic acid and Carbomer 974 was purchased from Aladdin Chemical Reagent Co., Ltd (Shanghai, China). Polyethylene glycol 400 (PEG-400) was purchased from Hangzhou Changzheng Chemical Company (Hangzhou, China). Trypsinase was purchased from Shanghai Sangon Biotech Company (Shanghai, China).

Preparation of CPT ethosomes

The formulations of the different ethosomes prepared are listed in Table 1. Water was slowly added in a fine stream to an ethanol solution of CPT and soybean phosphatidylcholine mixed at 700 rpm by a magnetic stirrer. Mixing was continued for an additional 15 min and then the mixture was sonicated in an ice-water bath for three cycles of 150 s using a 400 W sonotrode (2 s pulses with a 3 s interval). The mixture was passed through polycarbonate membrane filters (220 nm) three times to remove precipitated CPT.

Vesicle size and morphology

The vesicle size and polydispersity index of the ethosomes were determined in triplicate by laser scattering (Zeta sizer, Malvern Instruments, Worcestershire, UK).

CPT loading and encapsulation efficiency

The CPT loading of ethosome suspensions were determined by dilution of samples and analysis by HPLC. The encapsulation efficiency (EE) was investigated by an ultrafiltration method. An Amicon ultra centrifugal filter unit (Amicon Ultracel 3k, Millipore, Massachusetts, USA) was employed to separate ethosomes from free CPT. Briefly, 500 μL samples of ethosome suspensions were charged to the filter unit, centrifuged at 6000 rpm for 15 min and the filtrates diluted using methanol for injected into an HPLC system for CPT quantification. The EE of ethosomes was calculated based on the following formula: (1)

Where CL was the CPT loading of ethosomes, CF was the CPT concentration remaining in the filtrate and CT was the theoretical concentration of CPT. The results are expressed as the means of three independent measurements.

Preparation of ethosomal gel

A 1% carbomer gel was obtained by adding 2 mL of 10% (w/v) sodium hydroxide to a solution of 0.5 g carbomer 974 in 48 ml water. The pH value of cabomer gel was determined in triplicate using a pH meter (PHS-3D, Jingke Corporation, Shanghai, China) after dissolving 1.0 g gel in 10 mL purified water.

The ethosomal gel was prepared by adding the ethosome suspension to 1% carbomer gel at a ratio of 1:1 (v/w) and stirring until homogeneous.

Preparation of conventional hydroethanolic gel loaded with CPT as a control; CPT equivalent to the CPT loading of the F1 formulation was dissolved in 4 mL of ethanol and mixed with 10 g of 1% carbomer gel followed by addition of 6 mL of water and mixing until homogenous.

Preparation of blank ethosomal gel; F1 formulation was prepared without CPT and blank ethosomes mixed with 1% carbomer gel at a ratio of 1:1 (v/w).

In vitro study

Skin source.

Skin was obtained from the back and abdomen of a 9- to 10-day-old pig after sacrificing by injection lethal dose of sodium barbital, which was supplied by the Experimental Animal Center of Zhejiang University. The skin was excised and prepared into uniform thickness (about 1 mm) using a drum dermatome. The prepared skin contained intact epidermis and part of dermis. The skin was stored under -80°C before use. All the procedures applied to animals in this study were approved by the Experimental Animal Use Committee of Zhejiang University.

Transdermal study.

Vertical diffusion cells (diffusion area, 2.83 cm2; volume of receiving chamber, 6.8 mL) were used for an in vitro percutaneous study. Saline containing 40% PEG-400 was used as the receptor medium. The gel (1.0 g) was applied to the surface of the skin sample held at a temperature of 37°C with the receptor medium stirring at 250 rpm. The receptor medium (1 ml) was sampled at predetermined times up to 24 h, with the volume of each sample taken replenished by fresh medium. The CPT concentration in each sample was determined by HPLC-UV.

At the end of the experiment (24 h), the skin was washed with a cotton pad wetted with water, weighted, cut into small pieces and transferred to a plastic tube. A 1% trypsinase solution (1mL) was added and the tube incubated at 37°C for 4 h, then 4 mL of ethyl acetate was added, the mixture vortexed for 5 min and centrifuged for 10 min at 3000 rpm. The upper layer was transferred to a new tube and the ethyl acetate evaporated under a flow of nitrogen gas. The residue was reconstituted in 0.5 mL of methanol and subjected to HPLC analysis.

HPLC analytical conditions for CPT determination.

Chromatographic analyses were carried out using an analytical Agilent HPLC unit equipped with a G1310A isopump, a 7725iManu sampler, a GA1314A UV detector and an AT-130 column heater.

The separation was performed on a C18 column (Dikma, Lake Forest, CA, USA, 150 ×4.6 mm i.d.) in the column heater set to 40°C. The mobile phase consisted of methanol:water (85:15, v:v) at a flow rate of 1.0 mL/min. The UV detector was set to 263 nm. The method had a good linearity (r2 = 0.9995) in the range of 4–1000 ng/mL with a low limit of quantification of 4 ng/mL and low limit of detection of 1.5 ng/mL.

Anti-acne effect

An oleic acid induced acne model was used to evaluate the anti-acne effect of CPT ethosomal gels [21]. The rabbits (male, weighting about 2.5 kg) used were provided by Experimental Animal Center of Zhejiang University. Oleic acid (0.2 mL) was applied daily for 2 weeks to a 2 × 2 cm area on the underside of the pinna in the concave area just external to the ear canal. The acne model was established on 12 rabbits that were divided into 3 groups. A 0.5 g administrated of one of the three formulations (CPT loaded ethosomal gel, conventional gel and blank ethosomal gel) was applied to the acne area twice daily for 2 weeks. The rabbits were sacrificed by injection lethal dose of sodium barbital 12 hours after the last administration, the ear tissue was taken out and fixed in 4% buffered formaldehyde and routinely embedded in paraffin. Sections, 4 μm thick, were cut using rotary microtome, HM340E (Thermo Scientific, Waltham, America) and stained with hematoxylin-eosin according to guideline [22]. Briefly, the sections were dewaxed and incubated for 10 min with Harris Haematoxylin solution. Subsequently, sections were washed and stained with eosin for 2 min. The stained sections were examined using photographic microscope (Eclipse 50i equipped NIS-elements F 3.00 software, Nikon Corporation, Tokyo, Japan) at 400× magnification. The thicknesses of epidermis of each section were calculated using the equipped software. The numbers of lymphatic cell in a radon version (10 μm×10 μm) in dermis were counted.

Skin irritation test

The skin irritation test was performed according to the OECD Guideline 404 “acute dermal irritation/Corrosion” [23, 24]. Rabbits aged 17 weeks and weighting 3–3.6 kg with healthy, intact skin were used. Hair on the back of each rabbit in an area of approximately 10 × 15 cm was shaved without damaging the skin 24 h before testing. CPT ethosomal gels or blank gels were applied to the shaved area and covered with a gauze patch held by a bandage. The patch was removed 24 h later and the skin cleaned using gauze soaked in warm water. The skin response was determined in accordance with OECD guidelines at 1, 24, 48 and 72 h. The mean scores at 24, 48 and 72 h were used to obtain the primary irritation indices. Rabbits were sacrificed after the final observation and the treated skin removed for processing and histological examination. The tests were performed on three rabbits for each group.

Statistical analysis

Results were expressed as the mean ± SD for three or more experiments. Significance in the difference of the means was determined by the Student’s t-test. A value of P<0.05 was considered statistically significant.

Results

Characterization of ethosomes

Vesicle size and morphology.

The CPT loaded ethosomes were saffron yellow to dark red semitransparent suspensions (Fig 1). Vesicle sizes and polydispersity indexes (PDI) of each formulation are given in Table 2. The vesicle sizes of ethosomes ranged from 69.1 to 82.9 nm. The PDI were all less than 0.3, indicating that the vesicle population was relatively homogeneous in size.

The CPT loading and EE of the three ethosome preparations are listed in Table 2. F1 exhibited the highest drug loading and EE of the three formulations used and was selected to prepare ethosomal gels.

In vitro transdermal study

The pH value of blank cabomer gel was 7.21±0.01 (n = 3).

The in vitro transdermal permeation properties of ethosomal gels and conventional gels were investigated. Transdermal permeation properties were represented by the cumulative CPT permeation per area, plotted as a function of time (Fig 2). The cumulative permeated amounts and steady transdermal flux, which were calculated from the slopes of the regression functions of the last three points of each curve, are listed in Table 3. Ethosomal gels exhibited about 2.5-times the cumulative permeation and transdermal flux of the conventional gel, which indicated ethosomes were effective dermal delivery vesicles.

thumbnail
Fig 2.

In vitro transdermal profiles (A) and skin deposition (B) of ethosomal gel and conventional gel, (n = 6) **, P<0.01.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0159967.g002

thumbnail
Table 3. Transdermal parameters of ethosomal and conventional gels through excised pig skin (n = 6).

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0159967.t003

CPT deposition into skin by the ethosomal gels was 1.330 ± 0.344 μg/g, which was 2.1-times higher than that of the control, showing that the ethosomes increase CPT deposition into skin.

Anti-acne effect

The anti-acne effect of CPT loaded ethosomal gel is shown in Figs 3 and 4. Normal rabbit ear skin has thin multi-layer SC, the pilosebaceous orifice has no bacterial colonization, and both the pilosebaceous orifice and dermis have no inflammation (Figs 3 and 4A). Oleic acid induced acne model rabbits treated with blank ethosomal gel had neutrophil granulocytes and bacterial clotting in the pilosebaceous orifice, keratoplasia in the pilosebaceous orifice and SC, severe lymphatic cell infiltration in the dermis, and epidermis thickening (Fig 4B). Treatment with conventional gel prevented neutrophil granulocytes and bacterial clotting, and lymphatic cell infiltration in the dermis was obviously relieved (Fig 3B), but still existed in deep layer of skin (Fig 4C). However, keratoplasia in the pilosebaceous orifice and SC was present (Fig 4C), and epidermis thickening was sticked but not prevented (Fig 3A). The skin recovered normal structure after treatment with CPT loaded ethosomal gel (Fig 4D). There was no inflammation in the pilosebaceous unit and no keratoplasia in the pilosebaceous orifice and SC. Lymphatic cell infiltration in the dermis, including deep layers, was not found. Epidermis thicknesses had no significant difference with those of normal skin (Fig 3A). These results indicate that CPT loaded ethosomal gel had better anti-acne effects.

thumbnail
Fig 3.

Influence of cryptotanshinone loaded ethosomal gel on epidermis thickness (A) and lymphatic cell numbers in a radon area (10 μm×10 μm) of dermis (B). #P>0.05, *P<0.05, **P<0.01.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0159967.g003

thumbnail
Fig 4. Effect of cryptotanshinone loaded ethosomal gel on the histopathology in the rabbit ear acne model induced by oleic acid.

A: normal rabbit ear, B: acne model treated by blank ethosomal gel, C: conventional cryptotanshinone gel, D: cryptotanshinone loaded ethosomal gel. (400×).

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0159967.g004

Skin irritation

No visual dermal response, including erythema or edema, was found for either CPT ethosomal gel or blank gel treated groups. The primary irritation indexes of each group at each time point remained 0 and the CPT ethosomal gel has no skin irritation according to OECD guidelines.

The histological graphs of the skin structures of the CPT ethosomal gel and blank ethosomal gel groups were similar with untreated skin (Fig 5). Only a few lymphatic cells can be found in the treated rabbits (Fig 5B and 5C).

thumbnail
Fig 5.

Photomicrographs (400×) of hematoxylin-eosin stained normal rabbit back skin (A), rabbit skin treated with blank ethosomal gel (B) and rabbit skin treated with cryptotanshinone loaded ethosomal gel (C).

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0159967.g005

Discussion

Vesicle size is critical to topical drug delivery systems because vesicles smaller than 300 nm are able to deliver their payloads deep into layers of the skin [25]. Our ethosomes are all below 100 nm in size (Table 2), indicating that these vesicles has potential for CPT delivery into skin. Ethanol was used because it had a fluidizing effect on phospholipid bilayers [15] and made ethosomal vesicles that are smaller in size than those of liposomes. We found that phosphatidylcholine concentration also affects the ethosome size. F1 and F2 have a similar phosphatidylcholine concentration and vesicle size, while F3 has less phosphatidylcholine and bigger sized vesicles.

Drug loading and EE are key parameters that evaluate the delivery potentiality of a system. It was repoted that dermal delivery was directed related to the drug concentration in the formulation and only entrapped drugs exhibited better permeability [2628]. The EE of hydrophilic drug loaded ethosomes is reportedly about two orders of magnitude higher than that of liposomes [29]. This can be attributed to the greater retention of drugs in the ethanol present in the ethosomal core [30]. EE is depending on ethanol and lipid concentration. Increasing the ethanol concentration from 30% to 40% and lipid concentration from 2% to 4% increased EE because of increased fluidity of the membrane and the amount of membrane material. Ethanol concentration of more than 40% was not beneficial because it probably makes the vesicles more leaky [29]. The F1 formulation had the highest CPT loading and EE (Table 2), and was selected for further investigation.

Drugs should pass though the SC barrier regardless of whether the formulation has a systemic action or local effect. The ability of ethosomes to deliver CPT into and across the pig skin was investigated using vertical diffusion cells. CPT in ethosomal gels permeated though skin and possessed significantly higher transdermal flux than that of conventional gels (Fig 3A and Table 2). The difference in the content of CPT deposition in the skin at the end of the experiment was significantly greater when delivered from ethosomal gel compared with conventional gel (Table 2). The exact mechanism for better transfer across and into the skin for the ethosomes is still not clear. Ethanol was considered to play a major role in greater skin deposition and permeation because ethanol interacts with lipid molecules in the polar head group region. This effect leads to a reduction in the transition temperature of SC lipids, increasing their fluidity and decreasing the density of the lipid multilayer [15, 16, 31]. The ethanol concentrations in our ethosomal and conventional gels were similar. Skin deposition and transdermal flux of the ethosomal gel were greater, indicating that the ethosome structure is also responsible for the increased skin deposition and permeation.

The anti-acne effect of CPT loaded ethosomes was evaluated in gel form. Oleic acid induced acne in rabbit has been widely used as an animal model to determine the in vivo efficacy of anti-acne treatments [32, 33]. The histological examination of acne model skin showed inflammation, keratoplasia, bacterial colonization and epidermis thickening, which was in accordance with acne in humans (Fig 4B) [34]. CPT loaded ethosomal gels had superior anti-acne effect than conventional gels (Fig 3), and the rabbits treated with CPT loaded ethosomal gel recovered almost normal skin structure. The anti-acne effects were closely related to the trend in skin permeation and deposition of the gels. Ethosomal gel and conventional gel both relieved inflammation of the dermis, while the ethosomal gel showed better effect in the deep layers of the dermis (Fig 4). This may be attributed to the ethosomes ability to deliver CPT deep into skin layers.

Skin irritation is an important property of topical formulations. Visual inspection and scoring according to the OECD guideline showed no irritation for both CPT loaded ethosomal and blank gels. Although histological examination found lymphatic cells in the dermis of skins treated with either gel, the numbers of lymphatic cells were small and there was no other histological change (Fig 5). The CPT loaded ethosomal and blank gel have similar skin reactions, indicating that CPT itself causes no skin irritation. The skin irritation of the CPT loaded ethosomal gel can be considered as very slight and further investigation should be performed on humans to confirm the low level of irritation.

Conclusion

CPT loaded ethosomes exhibit low vesicle size, high CPT loading and EE. The skin permeation and deposition of ethosomes formulated with carbomer gel were higher than those of a conventional hydroethanolic gel. An in vivo study proved that CPT loaded ethosomal gel had better anti-acne effect than a conventional gel with only slight skin irritation. This study demonstrates that ethosomes are an effective dermal delivery system for CPT, and a CPT ethosomal gel may be a viable acne treatment in the future.

Acknowledgments

We thank Doctor Jiang Zhinong for pathological diagnosis and Edanz Group China for English editing services.

Author Contributions

Conceived and designed the experiments: GH ZWY KM. Performed the experiments: ZWY HYL. Analyzed the data: GH KM. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: ZWY GH KM. Wrote the paper: ZWY GH.

References

  1. 1. Arora MK, Yadav A, Saini V. Role of hormones in acne vulgaris. Clin Biochem. 2011;44:1035–40 pmid:21763298
  2. 2. Bloom DF. Is acne really a disease?: a theory of acne as an evolutionarily significant, high-order psychoneuroimmune interaction timed to cortical development with a crucial role in mate choice. Med Hypotheses. 2004;62:462–9 pmid:14975524
  3. 3. Liu PF, Hsieh YD, Lin YC, Two A, Shu CW, Huang CM. Propionibacterium acnes in the pathogenesis and immunotherapy of acne vulgaris. Curr Drug Metab. 2015;16:245–54 pmid:26264195
  4. 4. Valente DS IC. Novel pharmacological approaches for the treatment of acne vulgaris. Expert Opin Investig Drugs. 2014;23:1389–410 pmid:24890096
  5. 5. Cai Y, Zhang W, Chen Z, Shi Z, He C, Chen M. Recent insights into the biological activities and drug delivery systems of tanshinones. Int J Nanomedicine. 2016;11:121–30 pmid:26792989
  6. 6. Wu J, Ren HP, Zheng H, Li Y, He W. Observation of Efficiency of Tanshinone on Treating Patients with Acne Vulgaris. Chin J Derm Venereol. 2004;18:637–8
  7. 7. Lee DS, Lee SH, Noh JG, Hong SD. Antibacterial activities of cryptotanshinone and dihydrotanshinone I from a medicinal herb, Salvia miltiorrhiza Bunge. Biosci Biotechnol Biochem. 1999;63:2236–9 pmid:10664860
  8. 8. Mothana RA, Jansen R, Gruenert R, Bednarski PJ, Lindequist U. Antimicrobial and cytotoxic abietane diterpenoids from the roots of Meriandera benghalensis (Roxb.) Benth. Pharmazie. 2009;64:613–5 pmid:19827307
  9. 9. Tang S, Shen XY, Huang HQ, Xu SW, Yu Y, Zhou CH. Cryptotanshinone suppressed inflammatory cytokines secretion in RAW264.7 macrophages through inhibition of the NF-kappaB and MAPK signaling pathways. Inflammation. 2011;34:111–8 pmid:20490642
  10. 10. Li X, Lian LH, Bai T, Wu YL, Wan Y, Xie WX. Cryptotanshinone inhibits LPS-induced proinflammatory mediators via TLR4 and TAK1 signaling pathway. Int Immunopharmacol. 2011;11:1871–6 pmid:21835267
  11. 11. Wu CY, Hsieh CY, Huang KE, Chang C, Kang HY. Cryptotanshinone down-regulates androgen receptor signaling by modulating lysine-specific demethylase 1 function. Int J Cancer. 2012;131:1423–34 pmid:22052438
  12. 12. Xu D, Lin TH, Li S, Da J, Wen XQ, Ding J. Cryptotanshinone suppresses androgen receptor-mediated growth in androgen dependent and castration resistant prostate cancer cells. Cancer Lett. 2012;316:11–22 pmid:22154085
  13. 13. Zhang J, Huang M, Guan S, Bi HC, Pan Y, Duan W. A mechanistic study of the intestinal absorption of cryptotanshinone, the major active constituent of Salvia miltiorrhiza. J Pharmacol Exp Ther. 2006;317:1285–94 pmid:16497784
  14. 14. Akhtar N. Vesicles: a recently developed novel carrier for enhanced topical drug delivery. Curr Drug Deliv. 2014;11:87–97 pmid:24533724
  15. 15. Touitou E, Dayan N, Bergelson L, Godin B, Eliaz M. Ethosomes—novel vesicular carriers for enhanced delivery: characterization and skin penetration properties. J Control Release. 2000;65:403–18 pmid:10699298
  16. 16. Touitou E, Godin B, Dayan N, Weiss C, Piliponsky A, Levi-Schaffer F. Intracellular delivery mediated by an ethosomal carrier. Biomaterials. 2001;22:3053–9 pmid:11575480
  17. 17. Baek JS, Pham CV, Myung CS, Cho CW. Tadalafil-loaded nanostructured lipid carriers using permeation enhancers. Int J Pharm. 2015;495:701–9 pmid:26423175
  18. 18. Limpongsa E, Jaipakdee N, Pongjanyakul T. Skin deposition and permeation of finasteride in vitro: effects of propylene glycol, ethanol and sodium lauryl sulfate. Pharm Dev Technol. 2014;1–8
  19. 19. Choi JH, Cho SH, Yun JJ, Yu YB, Cho CW. Ethosomes and Transfersomes for Topical Delivery of Ginsenoside Rhl from Red Ginseng: Characterization and In Vitro Evaluation. J Nanosci Nanotechnol. 2015;15:5660–2 pmid:26369134
  20. 20. Zhang YT, Shen LN, Wu ZH, Zhao JH, Feng NP. Comparison of ethosomes and liposomes for skin delivery of psoralen for psoriasis therapy. Int J Pharm. 2014;471:449–52 pmid:24907596
  21. 21. Kligman AM, Kwong T. An improved rabbit ear model for assessing comedogenic substances. Br J Dermatol. 1979;100:699–702 pmid:157151
  22. 22. National Society for Histotechnology. Guideline for Haematoxylin and Eosin Staining. Bowie, Maryland. 2001. Available: http://nsh.org/sites/default/files/Guidelines_For_Hematoxylin_and_Eosin_Staining.pdf
  23. 23. Ema M, Matsuda A, Kobayashi N, Naya M, Nakanishi J. Dermal and ocular irritation and skin sensitization studies of fullerene C60 nanoparticles. Cutan Ocul Toxicol. 2013;32:128–34 pmid:23050631
  24. 24. OECD. Test No. 404: Acute Dermal Irritation/Corrosion, OECD Guidelines for the Testing of Chemicals, Section 4, OECD Publishing, Paris. 2015. Available: http://dx.doi.org/10.1787/9789264242678-en.
  25. 25. Verma DD, Verma S, Blume G, Fahr A. Particle size of liposomes influences dermal delivery of substances into skin. Int J Pharm. 2003;258:141–51 pmid:12753761
  26. 26. Ghanbarzadeh S, Hariri R, Kouhsoltani M, Shokri J, Javadzadeh Y, Hamishehkar H. Enhanced stability and dermal delivery of hydroquinone using solid lipid nanoparticles. Colloids Surf B Biointerfaces. 2015;136:1004–10 pmid:26579567
  27. 27. Babaie S, Ghanbarzadeh S, Davaran S, Kouhsoltani M, Hamishehkar H. Nanoethosomes for Dermal Delivery of Lidocaine. Adv Pharm Bull. 2015;5:549–56 pmid:26819928
  28. 28. Manca ML, Manconi M, Falchi AM, Castangia I, Valenti D, Lampis S. Close-packed vesicles for diclofenac skin delivery and fibroblast targeting. Colloids Surf B Biointerfaces. 2013;111:609–17 pmid:23907049
  29. 29. Verma P, Pathak K. Nanosized ethanolic vesicles loaded with econazole nitrate for the treatment of deep fungal infections through topical gel formulation. Nanomedicine. 2012;8:489–96 pmid:21839053
  30. 30. Dubey V, Mishra D, Jain NK. Melatonin loaded ethanolic liposomes: physicochemical characterization and enhanced transdermal delivery. Eur J Pharm Biopharm. 2007;67:398–405 pmid:17452098
  31. 31. Elsayed MM, Abdallah OY, Naggar VF, Khalafallah NM. Deformable liposomes and ethosomes: mechanism of enhanced skin delivery. Int J Pharm. 2006;322:60–6 pmid:16806755
  32. 32. Choi EH, Ahn SK, Lee SH. The changes of stratum corneum interstices and calcium distribution of follicular epithelium of experimentally induced comedones (EIC) by oleic acid. Exp Dermatol. 1997;6:29–35 pmid:9067704
  33. 33. Yamakoshi T, Makino T, Matsunaga K, Yoshihisa Y, Rehman MU, Seki T. Efficacy of chlorhexidine gluconate ointment (Oronine H((R))) for experimentally-induced comedones. Clin Cosmet Investig Dermatol. 2012;5:79–83 pmid:22936850
  34. 34. Kwon HH, Lee JB, Yoon JY, Park SY, Ryu HH, Park BM. The clinical and histological effect of home-use, combination blue-red LED phototherapy for mild-to-moderate acne vulgaris in Korean patients: a double-blind, randomized controlled trial. Br J Dermatol. 2013;168:1088–94 pmid:23278295