Advertisement
Browse Subject Areas
?

Click through the PLOS taxonomy to find articles in your field.

For more information about PLOS Subject Areas, click here.

  • Loading metrics

Risk Assessment of Genetically Engineered Maize Resistant to Diabrotica spp.: Influence on Above-Ground Arthropods in the Czech Republic

  • Zdeňka Svobodová ,

    svobodova@entu.cas.cz

    Affiliations Faculty of Science, University of South Bohemia, České Budějovice, Czech Republic, Institute of Entomology, Biology Centre CAS, České Budějovice, Czech Republic

  • Oxana Skoková Habuštová,

    Affiliation Institute of Entomology, Biology Centre CAS, České Budějovice, Czech Republic

  • William D. Hutchison,

    Affiliation Department of Entomology, University of Minnesota, St. Paul, Minnesota, United States of America

  • Hany M. Hussein,

    Affiliation Institute of Entomology, Biology Centre CAS, České Budějovice, Czech Republic

  • František Sehnal

    Affiliations Faculty of Science, University of South Bohemia, České Budějovice, Czech Republic, Institute of Entomology, Biology Centre CAS, České Budějovice, Czech Republic

Risk Assessment of Genetically Engineered Maize Resistant to Diabrotica spp.: Influence on Above-Ground Arthropods in the Czech Republic

  • Zdeňka Svobodová, 
  • Oxana Skoková Habuštová, 
  • William D. Hutchison, 
  • Hany M. Hussein, 
  • František Sehnal
PLOS
x

Abstract

Transgenic maize MON88017, expressing the Cry3Bb1 toxin from Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt maize), confers resistance to corn rootworms (Diabrotica spp.) and provides tolerance to the herbicide glyphosate. However, prior to commercialization, substantial assessment of potential effects on non-target organisms within agroecosystems is required. The MON88017 event was therefore evaluated under field conditions in Southern Bohemia in 2009–2011, to detect possible impacts on the above-ground arthropod species. The study compared MON88017, its near-isogenic non-Bt hybrid DK315 (treated or not treated with the soil insecticide Dursban 10G) and two non-Bt reference hybrids (KIPOUS and PR38N86). Each hybrid was grown on five 0.5 ha plots distributed in a 14-ha field with a Latin square design. Semiquantitative ELISA was used to verify Cry3Bb1 toxin levels in the Bt maize. The species spectrum of non-target invertebrates changed during seasons and was affected by weather conditions. The thrips Frankliniella occidentalis was the most abundant species in all three successive years. The next most common species were aphids Rhopalosiphum padi and Metopolophium dirhodum. Frequently observed predators included Orius spp. and several species within the Coccinellidae. Throughout the three-year study, analysis of variance indicated some significant differences (P<0.05). Multivariate analysis showed that the abundance and diversity of plant dwelling insects was similar in maize with the same genetic background, for both Bt (MON88017) and non-Bt (DK315) untreated or insecticide treated. KIPOUS and PR38N86 showed some differences in species abundance relative to the Bt maize and its near-isogenic hybrid. However, the effect of management regime on arthropod community was insignificant and accounted only for a negligible portion of the variability.

Introduction

Transgenic maize expressing insecticidal toxins such as Cry1Ab or Cry3Bb1, will likely be an important novel pest management technology in Europe because chemical control for lepidopteran and coleopteran pest species is more expensive, generally provides inconsistent efficiency and poses environmental risks [1]. The recent threat of the highly adaptive invasive pest, the western corn rootworm (WCR), Diabrotica virgifera virgifera LeConte (Coleoptera: Chrysomelidae), has become a particularly significant concern, given its continued spread in Europe. This species is one of the most destructive insect pests of maize in the U.S. [2]. Following the detection of D. v. virgifera in Serbia in 1992, the pest has expanded its range to several other European countries [3], including the Czech Republic in 2002 [4].

The insecticidal spectrum of Cry3Bb1, derived from Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt) subsp. kumamotoensis, includes larvae of the Colorado potato beetle (Leptinotarsa decemlineata) and the corn rootworm species (Diabrotica spp.) [5,6]. Previous research on Cry3Bb1 has shown that it was effective in reducing the number of D. v. virgifera larvae under field conditions [7]. However, larval mortality was rarely 100%, and the first report on D. v. virgifera resistance in field populations in the central U.S. has been published [8]. Another concern with Cry3Bb1 maize is the possibility of variable Bt expression under different environmental conditions [9].

Cry3Bb1 expressed in MON88017 was modified to increase efficiency. It is different from the original Bt toxin in six amino acid positions, and from the Cry3Bb1 in MON863 in a single amino acid position [9]. The MON863 event was approved for commercial use in the United States in 2003, and MON88017 in 2005. Both events are registered and authorized in the EU as genetically modified food and feed but not for planting. In the EU, MON863 is currently in the renewal stage of authorization as a food and feed, while the expiration date for MON88017 is October 2019 [10]. The process to approve Cry3Bb1 maize for the commercial cultivation in the EU is still ongoing, even though the dossier was submitted in 2008 [1]. Prior to approval, extensive field studies are generally required and should be performed to evaluate Bt maize in European agroecosystems and under EU production practices.

Laboratory studies designed to assess potential negative effects of Cry3Bb1 have been previously conducted for plant dwelling arthropods or for predators living on the soil surface [1121]. Although Cry3Bb1 was detected in non-target phytophagous and predatory species [1822], no detrimental effects on their development or reproduction were observed. Such studies were conducted in many countries, including several European laboratories [1821]. On the other hand, large-scale and long-term field trials focusing on the comparison of transgenic plants with near-isogenic hybrids, and with conventional pest management have declined sharply in the EU since 1999 [23]. The setback of research in many EU countries might be attributed to the numerous bureaucratic requirements for the conduct of biosafety testing and to the risk of vandalism of field experiments with GM crops [24]. In some cases, negative public opinion about GM crops [25] can also play a role in authorization despite a high adoption rate among growers in many countries worldwide [26], and a growing number of significant cumulative benefits from planting GM crops [2630].

Given the concerns regarding potential non-target impacts of GM maize in the Czech Republic, the purpose of our study was to examine the extent to which the abundance of non-target, above-ground arthropods might be affected by Bt maize expressing Cry3Bb1 under field conditions. We compared arthropod abundance throughout three growing seasons for Cry3Bb1 Bt maize its near-isogenic hybrid and two reference non-Bt hybrids. We also tested the effect of soil insecticide chlorpyrifos applied as a preventive measure against D. v. virgifera. We confirmed that soil application of insecticide at planting does not affect plant dwelling species substantially [31]. We also verified the statement that differences between hybrids are more pronounced than the effect of transgene expression [22].

Materials and Methods

Experimental design and agricultural management

The Ministry of the Environment of the Czech Republic approved this study (permission No. 78379/ENV/08 issued on January 12, 2009, European notification number B/CZ/08/03). The study was performed in 2009–2011 on 25 plots in Southern Bohemia in the vicinity of České Budějovice on part of the privately owned land block 6201/1 cultivated by the Agricultural Company Dubné a.s. The average annual temperature was about 11°C and the average annual precipitation 550 mm. Temperature and precipitation were measured 13 km away from the field by the Hydrometeorological Institute in České Budějovice.

A 14-ha rectangular field was divided with the aid of GPS into twenty five 0.5 ha (63 x 81 m) plots arranged in 5 columns (63 m wide) and 5 rows (81 m wide) separated by 2–3 m strips of bare land (see [32]). One of the shorter sides of the rectangle was adjacent to a forest; the other sides were flanked by wheat fields. The Latin square design was slightly disturbed by the presence of drainage wells in nine plots and a hunting lookout in one plot. Genetically engineered Bt and herbicide tolerant maize, MON88017 (YieldGard VT Rootworm/RR2, MONSANTO Technology LLC, St. Louis, MO, USA), its near-isogenic hybrid DK315 untreated or treated with the wide-spectrum soil insecticide Dursban 10G (a.i. chlorpyrifos, 20 kg/ha), and the conventional reference hybrids KIPOUS (KWS SAAT AG, Einbeck, Germany) and PR38N86 (DuPont Pioneer, Johnston, IA, USA) were each planted in 5 randomly distributed plots. Insecticide was applied simultaneously with maize seed sowing. Field margins were seeded with the early maize hybrid DKC2870 (MONSANTO Technology LLC, St. Louis, MO, USA).

Planting commenced when the average day temperature reached 10°C on May 11 in 2009, and May 6 in 2011. In 2010, planting was postponed to June 10 (25°C) because of inclement weather conditions unsuitable for sowing. Standard treatments with pre- and postemergence herbicides and a fertilizer were used (see [32]). In 2009, plants in the waxy stage of kernel ripening (dough stage, BBCH 85, [33]) were shredded to pieces smaller than 1 cm and ploughed into the soil on the same plot where the respective maize hybrid had been grown. In the following two years, all experimental plots including field margins were harvested and used for biogas production. Remains after biogas production (digestate) were ploughed into the field. Each plot was planted with the same maize hybrid in all three successive years.

Monitoring of non-target organisms

The presence of plant dwelling insects was recorded at the leaf stage development BBCH 14 (four leaves unfolded), BBCH 16 (six leaves unfolded), BBCH 65 (middle of flowering) and BBCH 85 (dough stage). The sampling at BBCH 14 was omitted in 2009 due to exceptionally rainy June which made sample collection impossible. On each sample date, 10 randomly selected plants per plot were individually covered with sacs made from synthetic fabric (available in three sizes) and closed tightly. This method was successfully used in previous field experiments [34,35]. Two to three plants randomly chosen in each plot were taken with the root system and inspected for the presence of root pests. Plants were transported to the laboratory and visually inspected on the same day to estimate the presence of arthropods. The sacs with plants were held in a cold room (4°C) and taken out just before insect collection for identification and counting. Insect mobility was substantially reduced by chilling and most specimens dropped to the sack bottom.

Adult parasitoids and predators were monitored by using yellow sticky traps (Bio Plantella, Unichem d.o.o., Slovenia). Two pieces of two-sided sticky traps (240 x 180 mm) were placed on plants at a height of 1.8 m in the centre of each plot in the middle of July and first half of August at BBCH 53 (heading stage) and BBCH 65, for a total of 14 days at each growth stage.

Monitoring of the target species, Diabrotica virgifera virgifera

The occurrence of D. v. virgifera was monitored with 10 pheromone traps (Csalomon PAL, Plant Protection Institute, Centre for Agricultural Research, Hungarian Academy of Sciences, Hungary) which were placed on plants at the margins of the experimental area in early July and removed just before harvest. The traps with synthetic sex pheromone attract males and are recommended for D. v. virgifera monitoring [36].

Toxin measurements

The amount of Cry3Bb1 toxin was measured in maize (roots, aerial roots, stem and leaves) at the time of arthropod collections (three times in 2009 and four times in 2010 and 2011). Samples of pollen, tassels and stigmas were taken once per season (BBCH 65) and samples of grain were taken twice per season (BBCH 65, BBCH 85). One sample was taken from each Bt maize plot at each sample date, from all other plots twice per year (mix sample per management regime), in maize stage BBCH 14 (BBCH 16 in 2009) and BBCH 85. The samples were stored at −20°C for not more than 60 days before analysis. No reduction in the level of Cry3Bb1 toxin in Bt maize pollen stored at −20°C for 49 days, was reported [11]. At the beginning of our study we confirmed the stability of toxin content in maize tissues stored at −20°C for 60 days (data not shown).

Toxin content in collected samples was measured with the commercial Bt-Cry3Bb1 ELISA PathoScreen kit (Agdia Inc., Elkhart, IN, USA). For all plant samples, 1 g tissue was homogenized in a Homex device (Bioreba AG, Switzerland) in 10 ml of the extraction buffer (PBST) provided with the kit. The mash was centrifuged (Hettrich Zentrifugen, EBA 12R) at 8 080 x g for 5 min, at 4°C. The supernatant was diluted differentially because we assumed changes in the Cry3Bb1 content during maize development [9]. Samples from the BBCH 14 growth stages were diluted 1:8 000 and those from the BBCH 16, 65 and 85 stages at 1:25 000–50 000. Samples were analysed according to the manufacturer’s protocol.

Positive control sample provided by Agdia Inc. contained approximately 40 ng/ml Cry3Bb1 and enabled semiquantitative measurements. A two-fold dilution series ranging from 0.3125 to 40 ng/ml was prepared to construct a standard curve. Absorbance was determined by ELISA reader (Spectra MAX 340 PC, λ = 650 nm). GraphPad Prism 5 (GraphPad Software Inc., San Diego, CA, USA) was used for interpolation of the concentration from the standard curve. The limit of detection was determined as a triple of the standard deviation of the control value.

Statistical analyses

GraphPad Prism 5 was used for descriptive statistics and Statistica 8 (StatSoft Inc., Tulsa, OK, USA) for the analysis of variance (Factorial ANOVA, data from sample dates were summed, factors: year and management regime) of arthropod abundance (log transformation of data recorded from sticky traps). The post-hoc Tukey HSD tests were also processed in Statistica 8. Concentration of Cry3Bb1 toxin in plant tissues was compared using Main effects ANOVA (factors: year, sample date, plant tissue).

The ecological preferences were assessed in CANOCO for Windows 4.5 (Biometris—Plant Research International, Wageningen, The Netherlands). Linear character of arthropods community was confirmed by detrended correspondence analysis (DCA: detrending by segments, log transformation, downweight rare species). The Monte Carlo permutation test, MCPT (log transformed species data, 999 permutations, forward selection) with environmental variables: time series (number of days since the sowing day marked as number 1), year, maize hybrid, plot position within the field and plot disturbance by the presence of the drainage wells or hunting lookout were employed in the multivariate redundancy data analysis (RDA) with plant numbers or sticky traps as covariates. RDA was in partial shape (covariate’s influence was subtracted) and split-plot design [37]. Variables describing geographical disposition were tested to verify the independence of species abundance on these environmental variables. 5% level of significance was considered in all statistical tests.

Results

Community of plant dwelling non-target arthropods

Nine different orders of arthropods were recorded on all maize hybrids, including Bt maize (Table 1, numbers of individuals per plant are provided in S1 Table). The plant-sucking western flower thrips (Frankliniella occidentalis) was common in all plots, with highest abundance at the BBCH 65 stage or before (Fig 1). Approximately 15, 25 and 19 thrips per plant were found in the midsummer in 2009, 2010 and 2011 respectively. The lowest abundance of F. occidentalis was on reference hybrid PR38N86, but the differences were not statistically significant (Table 1).

thumbnail
Table 1. Numbers (mean per management regime and year ± SD) of arthropod counts (management regimes are explained in Material and Methods) in three consecutive years (2009–2011), and the results of the analysis of variance for differences in arthropod abundance among plots with different management regimes.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0130656.t001

thumbnail
Fig 1. Seasonal fluctuations of common plant dwelling insects in the trial years.

Number of individuals per sample date (50 plants per management regime). A: Western flower thrips (Frankliniella occidentalis). B: Aphids (Aphididae: Metopolophium dirhodum, Rhopalosiphum padi, Sitobion avenae). C: Orius spp. D: Green lacewings (Chrysopidae)

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0130656.g001

The abundance of aphids (Aphididae) was high in 2009 and 2011 (Fig 1). Aphids were predominantly represented by the bird cherry-oat aphid (Rhopalosiphum padi) and the rose-grain aphid (Metopolophium dirhodum). Both species reached their highest numbers in maize stage BBCH 16 (29 and 22 individuals per plant in 2009 and 2011, respectively (Fig 1). The abundance of M. dirhodum was similar on MON88017 and its near-isogenic hybrid, untreated or treated with insecticide, and was slightly different from both reference hybrids, albeit insignificantly (Table 1). R. padi was most abundant on the reference hybrid KIPOUS but differences from other hybrids were not significant (Table 1). Interaction between year and management regime was significant (F(8,60) = 2.7, P = 0.01) because more individuals of R. padi on the reference hybrid KIPOUS were recorded only in 2009.

The 3rd collected aphid species, Sitobion avenae, was not as common as M. dirhodum and R. padi. Its abundance was similar on plots with different management regimes. Interaction was significant (F(8,60) = 2.2, P = 0.04) because number of S. avenae was higher on the near-isogenic hybrid DK315 in 2009.

Eggs and larvae of the European corn borer (ECB, Ostrinia nubilalis) were detected in all plots (Table 1); in not significantly lower numbers on MON88017 and the near-isogenic hybrid DK315.

Plant dwelling predators included several generalists, of which Orius spp. were most common (Table 1). Densities of Orius spp. peaked in maize stage BBCH 65 and even later in stage BBCH 85 in 2011 (Fig 1). The abundance of Orius spp. was highest on MON88017—significantly higher than on the reference hybrid PR38N86 (Table 1).

Many adults of lady beetles (Coccinellidae) and green lacewings (Chrysopidae) flew away during collection of the plant samples. Nevertheless, a high proportion of the Coccinellidae counts consisted of adults. Their numbers decreased during the season. Very few larvae were found despite the fact that wooden marker sticks placed at the edges of plots harbored high numbers of Coccinellidae pupae, particularly in 2011. Most counts of green lacewings were limited to the egg stage. The highest number of individuals was found on near-isogenic hybrid DK315 treated with insecticide—it was significantly higher than on MON88017 and the reference hybrid KIPOUS. Results of separate statistical analysis of predators and other monitored arthropods are listed in Table 1. Besides the above mentioned significant differences the abundance of plant dwelling non-target arthropods was similar on plots with different management regimes. Interaction was significant for larval Syrphidae (F(8,60) = 2.1, P = 0.05) that occurred in highest number on the reference hybrid PR38N86 in 2009.

Confirmation of the linear character of arthropod community (DCA: length of gradient: 2.8) was followed by integrated analysis of ecological preferences of plant dwelling arthropods implemented using a partial RDA. From the percentage of explained variability it is clear that arthropods did not prefer or avoided any specific Bt or non-Bt management regime (Table 2). However, two separate clusters of centroids for management regimes in Fig 2 show that the abundance of plant dwelling insects was similar in the genetically related hybrids—MON88017 and DK315, untreated or treated with insecticide. The reference hybrids KIPOUS and PR38N86 were somewhat different from the Bt maize and its near-isogenic hybrid, but similar to each other. The total contribution of management regimes to the explained variability was small (Table 2). The cluster of centroids near the intersection of the ordination space (crossing of the first and second axis) confirms low explanatory power of management regimes. Many other factors which could influence arthropod distributions in the field were rejected as well (plot position within the field, plot disturbance by the presence of the drainage wells or hunting lookout). Most of the variability in arthropod distributions was explained by the sample date and year.

thumbnail
Table 2. Results of Monte Carlo permutation tests (MCPT) in RDA analyses.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0130656.t002

thumbnail
Fig 2. Redundancy analysis of the spatial and temporal distribution of plant dwelling arthropods.

Horizontal line indicates years and sample date and vertical line the management regimes.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0130656.g002

Monitoring of parasitoids and predators on yellow sticky traps

Representatives of five insect orders of natural enemies were recorded on the sticky traps (Table 3, numbers of individuals per sticky trap are provided in S2 Table). The fly family Syrphidae, with the dominating marmalade hoverfly (Episyrphus balteatus), was particularly common. Scaeva pyrastri and two Sphaerophoria species were recorded less frequently. Although syrphid numbers were low in 2010 with 262 adults, 2139 and 3022 individuals were trapped in 2009 and 2011, respectively. Statistical analysis of abundance revealed significantly higher numbers of Syrphidae on the near-isogenic hybrid DK315 than on the reference hybrids KIPOUS.

thumbnail
Table 3. Numbers (mean per management regime and year ± SD) of predators and parasitoids collected in the sticky traps during the growing season in each trial year (2009–2011), and the results of analysis of variance for differences in abundance among plots with diverse management regimes (management regimes are explained in Material and Methods).

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0130656.t003

Only 20 adult parasitoids (Ichneumonidae and Braconidae) were collected in 2009. In subsequent years, the number of captured specimens increased to 198 individuals in 2010 and to 331 in 2011. Similar to the parasitoids and Syrphidae, aphid predators Chrysoperla carnea (Chrysopidae) and Micromus variegatus (Hemerobiidae) were found more frequently in 2011 than in 2009 and 2010 (including visual sampling, Fig 1). Lady beetles (Coccinellidae) were collected in low numbers in 2010 and 2011. Propylaea quatuordecimpunctata was the most common lady beetle found on sticky traps, followed by the invasive Harmonia axyridis. Coccinella septempunctata, generally the most common Czech lady beetle, was recorded only sporadically, similarly to Adalia bipunctata, Coccinella quinquepunctata and Hippodamia variegata. The scorpion fly Panorpa communis (Panorpidae) was less abundant on the near-isogenic hybrid DK315 with insecticide than on the reference hybrid PR38N86. Abundance of other arthropods was similar on all plots, irrespective of the management regime (Table 3) and interaction was also insignificant.

The partial RDA (DCA: length of gradient: 1.7) indicated slightly higher, but also insignificant, explanatory power of management regimes than was found in the previous analyses (Table 2). The comparison is approximate because arthropod communities were grossly disproportionate for both abundance and the number of detected taxa.

Monitoring of D. v. virgifera

No D. v. virgifera was detected with the use of pheromone traps in any of the three years. No other evidence of D. v. virgifera presence, such as larval feeding damage on roots or adult feeding on stigmas or silk tissue was found.

Concentration of Cry3Bb1 toxin in plant tissues

The content of toxin in different parts of the Bt maize plants fluctuated around 25 μg per 1 gram fresh plant tissue. Highest expression of Cry3Bb1 toxin was recorded in the leaves (36.28 μg g-1) and roots (30.74 μg g-1). Average amounts of Cry3Bb1 toxin determined in all three years are shown in Table 4. Level of Cry3Bb1 expression in different parts of maize plants during seasons 2009–2011 is provided in (S3, S4 and S5 Tables). Small standard deviations indicate that the differences between samples (growth stage) were minimal (F(3,218) = 0.49, P = 0.69) but differences between years were recorded (F(2,218) = 11.7, P<10–4). The limit of detection was estimated to be 0.08 ng per 1 g of fresh tissue. No toxin was detected in the near-isogenic and in the reference hybrids.

thumbnail
Table 4. Content of Cry3Bb1 determined by ELISA in indicated tissues of MON88017 maize grown in the field in 2009–2011.

Mean (± SD) value per sample (growth stage).

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0130656.t004

Discussion

The range of taxonomic groups of phytophagous insects and their predators found in this study fits with records available for maize in the database of non-target arthropod species occurring in arable crops across Europe [38]. Our data are also similar to the results of trials conducted in the U.S. [14,31,39]. The consistence of our findings with the results of other studies, especially in Europe, could be important for developing an appropriate post market monitoring plan, as required by EU legislation [40].

Although we performed exhausting monitoring of the above-ground arthropods, we did not include assemblages of insects active at night. Other collection methods would be needed for such studies. The use of light traps that are a usual tool for night insect trapping, is probably not suitable for manipulative experiment because it is unlikely that light traps would attract insects separately from each plot.

Two significant differences in the abundance of arthropods (Orius spp., Syrphidae) were found between maize hybrids. Consistent and significant influence of the hybrid type was previously found in the field densities of the herbivorous plant bug Trigonotylus caelestialium [22]. We were unable to assess possible hybrid influence on the bug abundance because we failed to capture sufficient number of specimens for the analysis of variance. It is possible that the population density of Miridae bugs was low in our field but we cannot exclude that their numbers were underestimated due to the sampling methodology we used. The counts of spiders (Araneae), adult lady beetles (Coccinellidae) and green lacewings (Chrysopidae) were probably also undervalued. We even did not find any leafhoppers (Cicadellidae) and adult Syrphidae. We are aware of the shortcomings of our methodology [34] but it is nevertheless suitable and effective for sampling herbivores that are in direct contact with plant tissue expressing the insecticidal toxin. Supplementation of this method with suitable sticky traps allows monitoring of flying herbivores, predators, parasitoids and pollinators. Aphids accounted for ca. 40% of all insects collected in this study. The size of aphid populations varied between the plots, probably due to aphid mobility and random plant colonization followed by rapid population growth. No effect of Bt hybrid on aphid abundance was observed in our study, consistently with previous investigations [31]. Also, a review article concluded that there are no significant effects of Bt maize on aphids [41] and that the risk of Bt maize to aphids and their predators is negligible.

Approximately 50% of all insect specimens found on each maize plant consisted of F. occidentalis. Thrips abundance on MON88017 was not different from other management regimes. Similar thrips insensitivity was documented for Bt maize expressing Cry1Ab [34]. We are not aware of any previous publications addressing the effect of Cry3Bb1 Bt maize on F. occidentalis.

According to the statistical analysis of our data, the presence of Cry3Bb1 had no effect on the abundance of predators and parasitoids except for Orius spp. and Chrysopidae, whose abundance was actually highest and lowest, respectively, on the Bt hybrid MON88017. Higher abundance of Orius spp. in Bt maize was previously recorded [42,43]. However, lack of effect was found in meta-analysis [44] that included data from 13 field trials in Spain, one of them with higher abundance of Orius spp. in Bt maize. It was suggested that higher Orius spp. densities in Bt maize could be related to their preference for ears and silks free from lepidopteran feeding [42,43]. It is not satisfactory explanation in case of maize resistant to corn rootworms. A laboratory study found increased fecundity and shorter nymphal development of Orius majusculus feeding on diets (leaves, pollen, Tetranychus urticae) containing Cry1Ab [45], suggesting that the occasionally observed higher abundance of Orius spp. in Bt maize could be due to unidentified differences in food properties. Laboratory assessment of Orius spp. response to Bt maize expressing other Cry toxins could help to solve this puzzle. Significantly less green lacewings (Chrysopidae) were found on sticky traps in the genetically modified Roundup Ready soybean than in the standard soybean cultivars [42]. However, other authors [14,31,39] did not find any substantial difference in the visual counts of Orius insidiosus and C. carnea [39] on the Cry3Bb1 maize and its near-isogenic hybrid.

Numerous studies focused on Coccinellidae because they include key predatory species used for biological control of various pests worldwide [46] and because beetles are the target of Cry3Bb1-expressing Bt crop. Several precise tritrophic experiments providing worst-case exposure conditions did not reveal any negative effect of purified Cry toxins and Bt maize on Coccinellidae (for example [20,21]). Exposure to the Cry toxins in the field is generally low for lady beetles that feed aphids as their major food source because aphids contain only trace amounts of Cry toxins [41]. None of the field trials conducted with Cry3Bb1 Bt maize disclosed an effect on Coccinellidae [14,31,39,47]. However, there are specialist predators of spider mites, containing high level of Cry toxins, such as Stethorus punctillum. Negative effect of Cry3Bb1 on S. punctillum fed to T. urticae was not confirmed—on the contrary, female beetles had a shorter pre-oviposition period and increased fecundity and fertility [20]. It should be mentioned that S. punctillum is not on the list of species found in above mentioned field trials. We also did not find this species on the sticky traps.

Parasitoid numbers caught by the sticky traps were relatively low in our study, particularly in the first year. Previous laboratory studies had demonstrated safety of Cry1Ab, Cry1Ac and Cry3B to Braconidae [48,49], Cry1C to Ichneumonidae [50] and Cry9Aa to Tachinidae (Diptera) [51]. However, the need to perform tests in a more realistic scenario was emphasized [51]. In previous studies, MON810 maize did not alter the aphid—parasitoid ratio and had no effect on aphid parasitism in the field [52]. No effect on braconid abundance was found in maize expressing Cry3Bb1 [38]. Results of several other studies were reviewed and meta-analysed to show no significant reduction of parasitoids not specialized for target pests of Bt maize [28,53].

Overall catches of adult predators were also low, except for Syrphidae. The decrease in their abundance in 2010 could be due to the low occurrence of aphids, common prey of their larvae, in that year—the nectar-feeding adults efficiently locate and lay their eggs close to aphid colonies [54]. The density of Syrphidae was independent of Cry3Bb1 expression, similar to previous study [31].

The soil treatment with a non-systemic insecticide performed in our study did not affect species abundance, except for significantly lower numbers of P. communis by comparison with the reference hybrid PR38N86. The abundance of Chrysopidae monitored by visual samplings was highest on the near-isogenic hybrid DK315 treated with the insecticide but this was not confirmed by insect samplings with the sticky traps. Insecticide applications to soil usually exert damaging effect on the ground-dwelling arthropods [55]. Our study shows that soil insecticide applied during maize sowing does not have negative effects on the plant dwelling arthropods, although the lower abundance of P. communis should be verified.

The content of Cry3Bb1 in transgenic plants depends on many variables including climate and weather conditions, maize genotype, tissue and growth phase; measurements are also affected by the extraction method [9,56]. These factors account for high variability of detected amounts of Cry3Bb1 in different studies [9,14,20,57]. Young tissue contained more Cry3Bb1 than the old tissue and significant differences in the level of expression among years were detected [9]. We did not find high variation during the season, but the variation between years was confirmed.

The region infested with D. v. virgifera in the Czech Republic continues to expand. The species was found 90 km away from our plots in 2010 and only within 35 km in 2011 [58]. Diabrotica v. virgifera is an invasive pest coming from outside Europe without specialized predators or parasitoids; biological control agents are also lacking in North America [59]. In the newly occupied territories, D. v. virgifera is apparently consumed by general predators but there is no evidence for an increase of their population density [31]. Hence, there is no reason to believe that the predator community would change, at least initially, with the advance of D. v. virgifera. Diabrotica-resistant Bt maize may potentially result in reduced abundance of general predators due to absence of their potential prey. Nevertheless, comparison with the effect of conventional pest management on such predators is necessary.

GM crops have significant potential for effective pest management while conserving beneficial natural enemies, including the diversity of generalist parasitoids and predators [28,60]. However, implementation of any GM event in most European countries has been hindered by fears of unpredictable environmental damage. The mistrust might be overcome by research such as this study but educational programs for growers and policy makers are also required. The deployment of GM maize MON88017, expressing the Cry3Bb1 toxin is a promising strategy for controlling a new and dangerous pest that continues to spread in Europe in spite of insecticide treatments. The toleration of current GM maize to the herbicide glyphosate provides an additional advantage for growers. Our analyses showed mostly similarity of abundance and diversity of above-ground arthropods in maize with the same genetic background, for both Bt (MON88017) and non-Bt (DK315) untreated or insecticide treated. Hybrids KIPOUS and PR38N86 showed some differences in species abundance relative to the Bt maize and its near-isogenic hybrid; this was probably due to the distinct hybrids’ characteristics. Since we did not detect any detrimental environmental effect of MON88017, this GM crop should be acceptable in the EU as the best alternative for curbing the spread of D. v. virgifera.

Supporting Information

S1 Table. Visual sampling of plant dwelling non-target arthropods.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0130656.s001

(XLS)

S2 Table. Monitoring of parasitoids and predators on yellow sticky traps.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0130656.s002

(XLS)

S3 Table. Cry3Bb1 measurement in plant tissues in 2009.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0130656.s003

(XLS)

S4 Table. Cry3Bb1 measurement in plant tissues in 2010.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0130656.s004

(XLS)

S5 Table. Cry3Bb1 measurement in plant tissues in 2011.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0130656.s005

(XLS)

Acknowledgments

We are grateful to Dr. Jiří Zelený for identification of insects found on yellow sticky traps, Ing. Radka Tanzer Fabiánová and Dr. Moataz Mostafa for their help with the field work and Dr. Zdeněk Faltýnek Fric, Dr. Jan Okrouhlík and Dr. Lukáš Spitzer for statistical advice.

Author Contributions

Conceived and designed the experiments: OSH FS. Performed the experiments: OSH ZS HMH. Analyzed the data: ZS OSH. Wrote the paper: ZS FS WDH OSH HMH.

References

  1. 1. Meissle M, Romeis J, Bigler F. Bt maize and integrated pest management—a European perspective. Pest Manag Sci. 2011; 67: 1049–1058. pmid:21710684
  2. 2. Gray ME, Sappington TW, Miller NJ, Moeser J, Bohn MO. Adaptation and invasiveness of western corn rootworm: Intensifying research on a worsening pest. Annu Rev Entomol. 2009; 54: 303–321. pmid:19067634
  3. 3. Edwards CR, Kiss J. Diabrotica virgifera virgifera LeConte in Europe 2011. IWGO. 2012. Available: http://www.iwgo.org/. Accessed 12 August 2013.
  4. 4. Koubová D. Bázlivec kukuřičný —nebezpečný škůdce kukuřice [Western corn rootworm—dangerous pest of maize]. Institute of Agricultural Economics and Information´s factsheets. Prague: Institute of Agricultural Economics and Information. 2006. Available: http://www.agronavigator.cz/attachments/Bazlivec_kukuricny.pdf. Accessed 12 August 2013.
  5. 5. Meissle M, Romeis J. Insecticidal activity of Cry3Bb1 expressed in Bt maize on larvae of the Colorado potato beetle, Leptinotarsa decemlineata. Entomol Exp Appl. 2009; 131: 308–319.
  6. 6. Vaughn T, Cavato T, Brar G, Coombe T, DeGooyer T, Ford S, et al. A method of controlling corn rootworm feeding using a Bacillus thuringiensis protein expressed in transgenic maize. Crop Sci. 2005; 45: 931–938.
  7. 7. Clark TL, Frank DL, French BW, Meinke LJ, Moellenbeck D, Vaughn TT, et al. Mortality impact of MON863 transgenic maize roots on western corn rootworm larvae in the field. J Appl Entomol. 2012; 136: 721–729.
  8. 8. Gassmann AJ, Petzold-Maxwell JL, Keweshan RS, Dunbar MW. Field-evolved resistance to Bt maize by western corn rootworm. PLOS ONE. 2011; 6: e22629. pmid:21829470
  9. 9. Nguyen H, Jehle JA. Expression of Cry3Bb1 in transgenic corn MON88017. J Agric Food Chem. 2009; 57: 9990–9996. pmid:19813729
  10. 10. EU Register of authorised GMOs. European Commision. Available: http://ec.europa.eu/food/dyna/gm_register/index_en.cfm. Accessed 12 August 2013.
  11. 11. Duan JJ, Head G, McKee MJ, Nickson TE, Martin JW, Sayegh FS. Evaluation of dietary effects of transgenic corn pollen expressing Cry3Bb1 protein on a non-target ladybird beetle, Coleomegilla maculata. Entomol Exp Appl. 2002; 104: 271–280.
  12. 12. Lundgren JG, Wiedenmann RN. Coleopteran-specific Cry3Bb toxin from transgenic corn pollen does not affect the fitness of a nontarget species, Coleomegilla maculata DeGeer (Coleoptera: Coccinellidae). Environ Entomol. 2002; 31: 1213–1218.
  13. 13. Lundgren JG, Wiedenmann RN. Tritrophic interactions among Bt (Cry3Bb1) corn, aphid prey, and the predator Coleomegilla maculata (Coleoptera: Coccinellidae). Environ Entomol. 2005; 34: 1621–1625.
  14. 14. Ahmad A, Wilde GE, Whitworth RJ, Zolnerowich G. Effect of corn hybrids expressing the coleopteran-specific Cry3Bb1 protein for corn rootworm control on aboveground insect predators. J Econ Entomol. 2006; 99: 1085–1095. pmid:16937659
  15. 15. Duan JJ, Paradise MS, Lundgren JG, Bookout JT, Jiang CJ, Wiedenmann RN. Assessing nontarget impacts of Bt corn resistant to corn rootworms: Tier-1 testing with larvae of Poecilus chalcites (Coleoptera: Carabidae). Environ Entomol. 2006; 35: 135–142.
  16. 16. Shirai Y. Laboratory evaluation of effects of transgenic Bt corn pollen on two non-target herbivorous beetles, Epilachna vigintioctopunctata (Coccinellidae) and Galerucella vittaticollis (Chrysomelidae). Appl Entomol Zool. 2006; 41: 607–611.
  17. 17. Duan JJ, Teixeira D, Huesing JE, Jiang CJ. Assessing the risk to nontarget organisms from Bt corn resistant to corn rootworms (Coleoptera: Chrysomelidae): Tier-I testing with Orius insidiosus (Heteroptera: Anthocoridae). Environ Entomol. 2008; 37: 838–844. pmid:18559191
  18. 18. Li Y, Meissle M, Romeis J. Consumption of Bt maize pollen expressing Cry1Ab or Cry3Bb1 does not harm adult green lacewings, Chrysoperla carnea (Neuroptera: Chrysopidae). PLOS ONE. 2008; 3: e2909. pmid:18682800
  19. 19. Meissle M, Romeis J. The web-building spider Theridion impressum (Araneae: Theridiidae) is not adversely affected by Bt maize resistant to corn rootworms. Plant Biotechnol J. 2009; 7: 645–656.
  20. 20. Li Y, Romeis J. Bt maize expressing Cry3Bb1 does not harm the spider mite, Tetranychus urticae, or its ladybird beetle predator, Stethorus punctillum. Biol Control. 2010; 53: 337–344. pmid:21793345
  21. 21. Álvarez-Alfageme F, Bigler F, Romeis J. Laboratory toxicity studies demonstrate no adverse effects of Cry1Ab and Cry3Bb1 to larvae of Adalia bipunctata (Coleoptera: Coccinellidae): the importance of study design. Transgenic Res. 2011; 20: 467–479. pmid:20740377
  22. 22. Rauschen S, Schultheis E, Pagel-Wieder S, Schuphan I, Eber S. Impact of Bt-corn MON88017 in comparison to three conventional lines on Trigonotylus caelestialium (Kirkaldy) (Heteroptera: Miridae) field densities. Transgenic Res. 2009; 18: 203–214. pmid:18668336
  23. 23. Marshall A. Drought-tolerant varieties begin global march. Nat Biotechnol. 2014; 32: 308. pmid:24211474
  24. 24. Romeis J, Meissle M, Brunner S, Tschamper D, Winzeler M. Plant biotechnology: research behind fence. Trends Biotechnol. 2013; 31: 222–224. pmid:23473928
  25. 25. Marris C. Public views on GMOs: deconstructing the myths. EMBO Rep. 2001; 2: 545–548. pmid:11463731
  26. 26. James C. Global status of commercialized biotech/GM crops: 2012. ISAAA Brief No. 44: Executive Summary. Ithaca: ISAAA; 2012.
  27. 27. Shelton AM, Zhao JZ, Roush RT. Economic, ecological, food safety, and social consequences of the deployment of Bt transgenic plants. Annu Rev Entomol. 2002; 47: 845–881. pmid:11729093
  28. 28. Naranjo SE. Impacts of Bt crops on non-target organisms and insecticide use patterns. CAB Reviews: Perspectives in Agriculture, Veterinary Science, Nutrition and Natural Resources. 2009; 4:
  29. 29. Hutchison WD, Burkness EC, Mitchell PD, Moon RD, Leslie TW, Fleischer SJ, et al. Areawide suppression of European corn borer with Bt maize reaps savings to non-Bt maize growers. Science. 2010; 330. 222–225. pmid:20929774
  30. 30. Brookes G, Barfoot P. The income and production effects of biotech crops globally 1996–2010. GM Crops Food. 2012; 3: 265–272. pmid:22750951
  31. 31. Bhatti MA, Duan J, Head G, Jiang C, Mckee MJ, Nickson T. Field evaluation of the impact of corn rootworm (Coleoptera: Chrysomelidae)—protected Bt corn on foliage-dwelling arthropods. Environ Entomol. 2005; 34: 1336–1345.
  32. 32. Svobodová Z, Habuštová O, Sehnal F, Holec M, Hussein HM. Epigeic spiders are not affected by the genetically modified maize MON 88017. J Appl Entomol. 2013; 137: 56–67.
  33. 33. Lancashire PD, Bleiholder H, van den Boom T, Langelüddecke P, Stauss R, Weber E, et al. An uniform decimal code for growth stages of crops and weeds. Ann Appl Biol. 1991; 119: 561–601.
  34. 34. Habuštová O, Doležal P, Spitzer L, Svobodová Z, Hussein HM, Sehnal F. Impact of Cry1Ab toxin expression on the non-target insects dwelling on maize plants. J Appl Entomol. 2014; 138: 164–172.
  35. 35. Meissle M, Lang A. Comparing methods to evaluate the effects of Bt maize and insecticide on spider assemblages. Agric Ecosyst Environ. 2005; 107: 359–370.
  36. 36. Traps developed for catching Diabrotica v. virgifera. The Plant Protection Institute Centre for Agricultural Research of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences. Available: http://www.csalomontraps.com/7diabroticatraps/diabroticatraps.htm#pals. Accessed 12 August 2013.
  37. 37. Lepš J, Šmilauer P. Multivariate analysis of ecological data using CANOCO. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 2003.
  38. 38. Meissle M, Álvarez-Alfageme F, Malone LA, Romeis J. Establishing a database of bio-ecological information on non-target arthropod species to support the environmental risk assessment of genetically modified crops in the EU. Supporting Publications 2012: EN-334. European Food Safety Authority (EFSA); 2012. Available: http://www.efsa.europa.eu/en/supporting/pub/334e.htm. Accessed 19 January 2015.
  39. 39. Al-Deeb MA, Wilde GE. Effect of Bt corn expressing the Cry3Bb1 toxin for corn rootworm control on aboveground nontarget arthropods. Environ Entomol. 2003; 32: 1164–1170.
  40. 40. Sanvido O, Romeis J, Bigler F. An approach for post-market monitoring of potential environmental effects of Bt-maize expressing Cry1Ab on natural enemies. J Appl Entomol. 2009; 133: 236–248.
  41. 41. Romeis J, Meissle M. Non-target risk assessment of Bt crops—Cry protein uptake by aphids. J Appl Entomol. 2011; 135: 1–6.
  42. 42. Jasinski JB, Eisley JB, Young CE, Kovach J, Willson H. Select nontarget arthropod abundance in transgenic and nontransgenic field crops in Ohio. Environ Entomol. 2003; 32: 407–411.
  43. 43. de la Poza M, Pons X, Farinós GP, López C, Ortego F, Eizaguirre M, et al. Impact of farm-scale Bt maize on abundance of predatory arthropods in Spain. Crop Prot. 2005; 24: 677–684.
  44. 44. Comas C, Lumbierres B, Pons X, Albajes R. No effects of Bacillus thuringiensis maize on nontarget organisms in the field in southern Europe: a meta-analysis of 26 arthropod taxa. Transgenic Res. 2014; 23: 135–143. pmid:23904218
  45. 45. Lumbierres B, Albajes R, Pons X. Positive effect of Cry1Ab-expressing Bt maize on the development and reproduction of the predator Orius majusculus under laboratory conditions. Biol Control. 2012; 63: 150–156.
  46. 46. Obrycki JJ, Kring TJ. Predaceous Coccinellidae in biological control. Annu Rev Entomol. 1998; 43: 295–321. pmid:15012392
  47. 47. McManus BL, Fuller BW, Boetel MA, French BW, Ellsbury MM, Head GP. Abundance of Coleomegilla maculata (Coleoptera: Coccinellidae) in corn rootworm-resistant Cry3Bb1 maize. J Econ Entomol. 2005; 98: 1992–1998. pmid:16539124
  48. 48. Steinbrecher I. Effects of Bt transgenes on herbivorous insect-parasitoid interactions. Doctoral Thesis. University of Göttingen. 2004. Available: https://ediss.uni-goettingen.de/bitstream/handle/11858/00-1735-0000-0006-AB4C-3/steinbrecher.pdf?sequence=1.
  49. 49. Schuler TH, Potting RPJ, Denholm I, Clark SJ, Clark AJ, Stewart CN, et al. Tritrophic choice experiments with Bt plants, the diamondback moth (Plutella xylostella) and the parasitoid Cotesia plutellae. Transgenic Res. 2003; 12: 351–361. pmid:12779123
  50. 50. Chen M, Zhao J-Z, Collins HL, Earle ED, Cao J, Shelton AM. A Critical assessment of the effects of Bt transgenic plants on parasitoids. PLOS ONE. 2008; 3: e2284. pmid:18523682
  51. 51. Marchetti E, Alberghini S, Battisti A, Squartini A, Dindo ML. Susceptibility of adult Exorista larvarum to conventional and transgenic Bacillus thuringiensis galleriae toxin. Bull Insectology. 2012; 65: 133–137.
  52. 52. Lumbierres B, Starý P, Pons X. Effect of Bt maize on the plant-aphid-parasitoid trithrophic relationships. BioControl. 2011; 56: 133–143.
  53. 53. Wolfenbarger LL, Naranjo SE, Lundgren JG, Bitzer RJ, Watrud LS. Bt crop effects on functional guilds of non-target arthropods: A Meta-analysis. PLOS ONE. 2008; 3: e2118. pmid:18461164
  54. 54. Bugg R, Colfer RG, Chaney WE, Smith HA, Cannon J. Flower flies (Syrphidae) and other biological control agents for aphids in vegetable crops. Oakland: The Regents of the University of California Division of Agriculture and Natural Resources.2008. Available: http://anrcatalog.ucdavis.edu/pdf/8285.pdf. Accessed 28 August 2013.
  55. 55. Bhatti MA, Duan J, Head G, Jiang C, Mckee MJ, Nickson TE, et al. Field evaluation of the impact of corn rootworm (Coleoptera: Chrysomelidae)–protected Bt corn on ground-dwelling invertebrates. Environ Entomol. 2005; 34: 1325–1335.
  56. 56. Franz TM. Effect of nitrogen on Bt gene expression in corn roots, resulting trait performance against corn rootworms (Diabrotica spp.), and transgenic hybrid performance. M. Sc. Thesis, University of Minnesota. 2013. Available: http://conservancy.umn.edu/bitstream/handle/11299/162342/Franz_umn_0130M_13473.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y.
  57. 57. Prihoda KR, Coats JR. Fate of Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt) Cry3Bb1 protein in a soil microcosm. Chemosphere. 2008; 73: 1102–1107. pmid:18768202
  58. 58. Kroutil P. Výsledky průzkumu výskytu bázlivce kukuřičného (Diabrotica virgifera virgifera) v ČR v roce 2011 [Results of D. v. virgifera monitoring in the Czech Republic in 2011]. Annual report of State Phytosanitary administration of the Czech Republic. Prague: State Phytosanitary administration of the Czech Republic. 2011. Available: http://eagri.cz/public/web/file/140765/Bazlivec_kukuricny_v_CR_v_roce_2011_final.pdf. Accessed 12 August 2013.
  59. 59. Kuhlmann U, van der Burgt WACM. Possibilities for biological control of the western corn rootworm, Diabrotica virgifera virgifera LeConte, in Central Europe. Biocontrol News and Information. 1998; 19: 59N–68N.
  60. 60. Naranjo SE. Long-term assessment of the effects of transgenic Bt cotton on the function of the natural enemy community. Environ Entomol. 2005; 34: 1211–1223.