The objective of this study was to evaluate the combined effects of thermal acclimation and n-3 highly unsaturated fatty acids (n-3 HUFA) content of the food source on the aerobic capacities of fish in a thermal changing environment. The model used was the golden grey mullet Liza aurata, a species of high ecological importance in temperate coastal areas. For four months, fish were exposed to two food sources with contrasting n-3 HUFA contents (4.8% ecosapentaenoic acid EPA + docosahexaenoic acid DHA on the dry matter DM basis vs. 0.2% EPA+DHA on DM) combined with two acclimation temperatures (12°C vs. 20°C). The four experimental conditions were LH12, LH20, HH12 and HH20. Each group was then submitted to a thermal challenge consisting of successive exposures to five temperatures (9°C, 12°C, 16°C, 20°C, 24°C). At each temperature, the maximal and minimal metabolic rates, metabolic scope, and the maximum swimming speed were measured. Results showed that the cost of maintenance of basal metabolic activities was particularly higher when n-3 HUFA food content was low. Moreover, fish exposed to high acclimation temperature combined with a low n-3 HUFA dietary level (LH20) exhibited a higher aerobic scope, as well as a greater expenditure of energy to reach the same maximum swimming speed as other groups. This suggested a reduction of the amount of energy available to perform other physiological functions. This study is the first to show that the impact of lowering n-3 HUFA food content is exacerbated for fish previously acclimated to a warmer environment. It raises the question of the consequences of longer and warmer summers that have already been recorded and are still expected in temperate areas, as well as the pertinence of the lowering n-3 HUFA availability in the food web expected with global change, as a factor affecting marine organisms and communities.
Citation: Vagner M, Lacoue-Labarthe T, Zambonino Infante J-L, Mazurais D, Dubillot E, Le Delliou H, et al. (2015) Depletion of Essential Fatty Acids in the Food Source Affects Aerobic Capacities of the Golden Grey Mullet Liza aurata in a Warming Seawater Context. PLoS ONE 10(6): e0126489. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0126489
Academic Editor: Daniel E. Crocker, Sonoma State University, UNITED STATES
Received: December 19, 2014; Accepted: April 2, 2015; Published: June 1, 2015
Copyright: © 2015 Vagner et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited
Data Availability: All relevant data are within the paper and its Supporting Information files.
Funding: This study was funded by the Contrat-Plan Etat-Région (regional and national financial support), as well as by the FEDER (European Research Funding) for the first author.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Thermal tolerance varies widely among species and has been shown to be dependent on the acclimation temperature , as well as on the physiological plasticity of organisms . In temperate latitudes, ectotherms often show a high physiological plasticity to thermal tolerance, which may greatly facilitate their adaptation to new environments and buffer the effects of daily or seasonal variations of environmental temperature on physiological processes .
When exposed to environmental temperature changes, ectotherms rapidly modulate the phospholipid composition of their cell membranes in terms of highly unsaturated fatty acids of the n-3 series (n-3 HUFA) in order to maintain their physiological performances [3,4]. This adjustment of the rate of n-3 HUFA in cell membrane determines the degree of unsaturation of the phospholipid and is necessary for maintaining membrane fluidity, and consequently the membrane functionality in a thermal changing environment . For example, when the membrane fluidity tends to decrease at low temperatures, the degree of lipid unsaturation tends to increase to maintain its properties and functionality , and vice versa when the temperature increases . These lipid adjustments in cell membranes can maintain the activity of transmembrane proteins [7,8], and consequently are determinant for the maintenance of numerous physiological functions (for review see [9–11]). In marine fish, membranous n-3 HUFA are mainly represented by ecosapentaenoic acid (EPA, 20:5n-3) and docosahexaenoic acid (DHA, 22:6n-3; for reviews see [9,11]). These fatty acids have been shown to be essential for growth, survival, pigmentation, development and functionality of the brain, vision, and nervous system, as well as in resistance to stress and disease, as they are precursors of eicosanoids (for reviews see [9,11]).
Although they function as critical structural and physiological components of the cell membranes of most tissues , n-3 HUFA are weakly synthesised de novo by higher organisms, and must be brought by food. In the natural food web, they are mainly supplied by marine microalgae, and especially by the dominating diatoms [12,13]. Several studies showed that n-3 HUFA present in the food source largely influenced swimming and metabolic performances that are essential to allow fish to migrate, feed, reproduce, or avoid predators [14–18]. However, these results are often conflicting, which may be related to the thermal environment of fish. For example, low levels of n-3 HUFA in the diet (replaced by a high rate of monounsaturated FA: oleic acid), and thus in cardiac tissue, led to higher swimming and cardiac performance of sea bass Dicentrarchus labrax acclimated to 20°C [16,17]. These authors suggested a more efficient oxidation of monounsaturated FAs when compared to polyunsaturated FAs in order to provide the necessary energy to the animal. A similar result was observed from a study performed at 9°C in Atlantic salmon [19,20]. However, a contrary result was measured in the same species tested at 10–12°C . These different results for the same species could be due to the fact that the melting point of oleic acid is around 13°C, which would imply better membrane fluidity and thus modified physiological performance when the temperature is close to 13°C. These previous studies suggested some evidence of interactions between n-3 HUFA membrane content and thermal history on the physiology of marine organisms. However, little is known about the relative importance and potential interacting effects between temperature and n-3 HUFA food content on fish performance.
This investigation is of particular importance given the actual and predicted ecological context in temperate coastal areas. It is now known that summers are warmer and longer in these areas, and that an increase of 3°C in ocean water is predicted for the end of this century . In the area of the Pertuis Charentais, located at the Atlantic mid-coast of France, and renowned for shellfish production and fisheries, this warming would lead to fish experiencing increasing seasonal temperature variations from ~8–20°C , to ~11–23°C . Moreover, over the last twenty years, several studies have shown that modification of physicochemical parameters related to global change (e.g. increasing temperature, pH; decreasing salinity and oxygen saturation) led to a decreasing n-3 HUFA profile in diatoms, as well as to a decrease of their biomass in favor of more-adapted species such as cyanobacteria [23–26] (for review see ). This would lead to a lowering n-3 HUFA availability at the base of the food web, which may propagate to higher trophic levels, because, in all animals, it is well known that the fatty acid (FA) composition of the tissue is a reflection of their diet . This would then lead to variability in the membranous n-3 HUFA content of higher consumers, despite the fact that membrane lipids are regulated to a large extent. Consequently, this would induce changes in membrane structure and function of higher consumers, which have been shown to further impact individual physiological performances.
In this context, the objective of this study was to evaluate the combined effect of thermal acclimation and n-3 HUFA content in food source on the membrane composition of the skeletal muscle and their potential consequences on physiological performance of the golden grey mullet, in terms of swimming and respiratory performances, in a thermal changing environment. The chosen species is of high ecological importance in the studied area as well as in European coastal areas because it is a microalgae grazer and a trophic vector of organic matter from intertidal to subtidal areas [29,30]. Because of its diet, the mullet may be directly subject to the variability of n-3 HUFA availability in primary producers, as no intermediate trophic steps will buffer their biochemical variability.
Materials and Methods
To reach this objective, fish were exposed during four months to two contrasting n-3 HUFA dietary contents combined with two acclimation temperatures representative of mean winter and summer temperatures in the Pertuis Charentais. Then, fish were submitted to a thermal challenge consisting of successive exposures to five temperatures covering both seasonal changes of water temperature and the temperatures expected during the last of the century in the studied area [21,22]. At each temperature and for each fish, minimal and maximal oxygen consumption (MO2min and MO2max respectively), maximum swimming speed Umax, and ventilation rate fv were measured.
All fish manipulations were performed according to the Animal Care Committee of France (ACCF). No specific permissions were required from departmental service of fisheries to collect mullets Liza aurata in their natural environment, as this is not a protected or endangered species, and as few fish were collected (n = 160 individuals) regarding their abundance in this fishing area. The protocol was approved by the ACCF (approval number: 17-300-2). All fish manipulations were performed under anesthesia (tricaine methane sulphonate MS-222; 0.1 g L-1, Sigma-Aldrich, St Quentin-Fallavier, France), and all efforts were made to minimize suffering.
Juvenile golden grey mullets [initial mean weight ± standard error (SE): 6.1 ± 0.2 g; initial mean standard length ± SE: 7.0 ± 0.1 cm] were caught in marine coastal area of La Rochelle (France) in 2012 and transported in aerated tank to our laboratory (Institut du Littoral et de l’Environnement, UMR 7266 CNRS-Université de La Rochelle, France) where all experiments were conducted. Upon arrival, the fish were transferred into four indoor tanks (volume: 400 L; n = 40 fish per tank) that were individually supplied with aerated recirculated sand-filtered natural seawater and equipped with an external biological filter (Eheim professional 3 2080, Eheim, Deizisau, Germany). They were progressively acclimated to the water tank temperature, which was kept constant by a recirculating water system (TECO TR20, Conselice, Italy), and maintained in a temperature-controlled room (20°C) exposed to a 12L:12D photoperiod cycle. Temperature (18.7 ± 0.04°C), salinity (29.3 ± 0.5) and oxygen (87.9 ± 2.6% air saturation) were monitored daily using a conductimeter (WTW model Oxi 340i, Weildeim, Germany). After a few days of acclimation to the experimental structure, each of the four initial tanks was separated in two tanks (n = 8 tanks in total with n = 20 fish per tank), and water temperature was progressively modified until 12°C (12.5 ± 0.1°C; n = 4 tanks), or 20°C (19.8 ± 0.1°C; n = 4 tanks). Fish were fed with a commercial diet (Le Gouessant aquaculture, Lamballe, France) once a day for three weeks.
Then, fish were progressively fed with two experimental isolipidic and isoproteic diets contrasting by their n-3 HUFA content, and made at the Ifremer-PFOM unit, UMR 6539 LEMAR (Plouzané, France): A high HUFA diet (HH: 4.8% EPA + DHA on dry matter basis), and a low-n-3 HUFA diet (LH: 0.2% EPA + DHA on dry matter basis DMB) which was obtained by replacing the fish oil present in the HH diet by soybean oil. For each of these two diets, 2 tanks per experimental temperature were fed for four months (2% of biomass day-1). Thus, the four experimental conditions were reared in duplicate and called HH20, LH20, HH12 and LH12. The diets were formulated taking a standard diet as a reference (1.2% EPA+DHA on DMB) that was previously formulated  according to the needs of other species, as the needs of L. aurata are not well known. The composition and FA content of the two experimental HH and LH diets are summarized in S1 Table.
At the beginning of the experiment (T0), lipid analysis was performed on the muscle of 10 randomly sampled fish. After the four month experimental period, lipid analysis was performed on the muscle of 13 individuals randomly sampled for each experimental condition.
For each fish, whole frozen muscle was homogenized rapidly with a Hobart mixer in order to maintain a low temperature and then more accurately using a Polytron (PT 2100 Bioblock, Illkirch, France). A representative portion (~ 5g) was taken for lipid analysis and ~ 3g was taken for dry weight measurements (105°C in an oven for 24h). Lipid analysis was conducted on duplicates. Extraction of total lipids was performed automatically (Accelerated Solvent Extractor 350 Dionex, Fisher Scientific, Illkirch, France) according to the Folch method , with chloroform being replaced by dichloro-methane. The separation of neutral NL and polar lipids PL was performed on fish samples according to the procedure described by Juaneda and Roquelin . The total lipids TL extracts were fractionated on silica cartridges (Chromabond SiOH, Macherey-Nagel, Hoerdt, France), NL were eluted by chloroform and PL by methanol. Fatty acid methyl esters (FAME) of TL, NL and PL were prepared by saponification and then methylation. All FAMEs were separated by gas chromatography (GC Clarus 500 Perkin-Elmer, Villebon-sur-Yvette, France) with a flame ionisation detector, BPX 70 capillary column: 25 m x 0.22 mm i.d. x 0.25μm film thickness; split-splitless injector, with helium as a carrier gas. The injector and detector temperatures were 220 and 260°C, respectively. The temperature of the oven was initially 50°C, and then increased to 180°C in increments of 15°C min-1; here, it was maintained for 5 min, and then finally increased to 220°C in increments of 3°C min-1. Data acquisition and handling were carried out by connecting the GC to a computer equipped with the TotalChrom workstation (Perkin-Elmer, Villebon-sur-Yvette, France). Individual FAMEs were identified by comparing the retention times of authentic standard mixtures. The results of individual FA composition were expressed as a percent of total identified FAME.
Chemical analyses of feed were performed in duplicate for each sample according to AOAC (Association of Official Analytical Chemists 1984) methods: ash (7 h at 550°C), crude fat , and crude protein (Dumas method with an Elementary NA 2000®, N × 6.25). FAME were extracted and analyzed on total lipid fraction using the previously described method.
Just before being exposed to the two experimental LH and HH diets (T0), all 24h-starved fish were anaesthetized (MS-222; 0.1 g L-1, Sigma-Aldrich, St Quentin-Fallavier, France), weighed, and pit-tagged (MS-120; biolog-id, Réseaumatique, Bernay, France). Then, each month, 24h-starved fish (n = 40 per experimental condition) were anesthetized (MS-222; 0.1 g L-1, Sigma-Aldrich, St Quentin-Fallavier, France) and individually identified using a pit-tag reader (MS-120, biolog-id, Réseaumatique, Bernay, France) before measuring fresh weight (± 0.1 g), total length, standard length (i.e. notochord length), height and width (± 0.01 cm).
The specific growth rate SGR (% day -1) was calculated for each experimental condition using Eq 1: (1)
Fish metabolic and swimming performances were assessed during a thermal challenge using a swim-tunnel respirometer (Loligo Systems, Tjele, Denmark), which was made of a respirometer and an external bath. The respirometer (volume: 10 L) was composed of (i) a swim chamber with a square working section (40 cm of length, 10 cm height, 10 cm of width) and (ii) a hydraulic system placed upstream to promote a laminar flow in the swim chamber. No correction for solid blocking effects of the fish in the working section was made, since the calculated fractional error was < 5% of the working section area . The flow in the respirometer was generated by an electric motor with a propeller. It was calibrated before the start of experiments and the speed ranged between 0 and 150 cm s-1. Temperature was kept constant by a recirculating water system from the external bath (Teco TR20, Conselice, Italy). A flush pump allowed water exchange between the respirometer and the external bath, in which water temperature and oxygenation were controlled.
Oxygen consumption measurements.
Oxygen concentration in the respirometer was continuously measured during the experiments with an oxygen probe (PreSens, GmbH, Regensburg, Germany) connected to an oxymeter (Oxy-4, PreSens, GmbH, Regensburg, Germany) transferring oxygen data every 10 s to a storage computer. The oxygen concentration was automatically adjusted according to the real-time temperature recorded in the respirometer. Oxygen consumption (MO2) was measured by intermittent-flow respirometry, based on an alternation between (i) a flushing phase (5 min) and (ii) a measuring phase (20 min), during which the flush pump was turned off, preventing the inflow of water from the external bath into the respirometer. The MO2 (mgO2 kg-1 h-1) was calculated as in [15,35] (Eq 3): (3) where Δ[O2] is the oxygen concentration decrease (mgO2 L-1) relative to the fish oxygen consumption with respect to time Δt (hours), V the swim tunnel water volume (10 L) minus the volume of the fish, and m the fish weight (kg).
For each MO2 measurement, a linear regression was adjusted (Graphical Analysis 3.4, Beaverton, OR, USA) in order to determine Δ[O2]/Δt from the graph plotting [O2] versus time. The regression coefficient of the linear relationship determined MO2 measurement accuracy. The bacterial MO2 was measured for half an hour before and after each experiment and at each temperature, and the mean was subtracted from the MO2 measured.
As respiratory metabolism depends on the animal weight, MO2 was standardized for a 100 g fish  (Eq 4): (4) where MO2cor (mgO2 kg-1 h-1) is the oxygen consumption for a corrected weight (mcor = 100 g), MO2meas is the measured MO2 (mgO2 kg-1 h-1) and mmeas is the fish weight (kg). A is the allometric exponent describing the relation between the metabolic rate and the fish weight. The A value has never been determined for Liza aurata. Therefore, we used a value of 0.8 which was previously estimated in teleosts , and already employed for L. aurata .
Experimental protocol of the thermal challenge.
The experimental protocol used is presented in Fig 1.
This diagram presents the evolution of swimming speed with time at one of the challenge temperature tested (i.e. 9°C, 12°C, 16°C, 20°C or 24°C). The different measures recorded for each fish and at each temperature are indicated in italic. MO2min: minimum oxygen consumption; MO2max: maximum oxygen consumption; Umax: maximum swimming speed; fv: ventilation rate after the MO2max challenge; EPOC: the excess post-oxygen consumption recorded during the recovery period following the swim challenge. The same protocol was repeated until each fish had been exposed to all challenge temperatures; one hour-acclimation to each new experimental challenge temperature was respected.
Next, 96h-starved fish [HH20 group: mean weight ± SE: 39.6 ± 2.3 g; mean standard length ± SE: 13.3 ± 0.2 cm, n = 11; LH20 group: mean weight ± SE: 40.2± 2.2 g; mean standard length ± SE: 13.3 ± 0.2 cm; n = 11; HH12 group: mean weight ± SE: 14.9 ± 1.1 g; mean standard length ± SE: 9.5 ± 0.3 cm, n = 11; LH12 group: mean weight ± SE: 14.9 ± 1.4 g; mean standard length ± SE: 9.4 ± 0.2 cm; n = 11] were randomly sampled in tanks using a net, and individually tested in the swim-respirometer. This long starvation period ensured that swimming performance and oxygen consumption measurements were not influenced by digestion . The day before the test, the fish were anesthetized (MS-222; 0.1 g L-1) and transferred into a plastic bag (without exposing the gills to the air, which may affect metabolism) from the indoor acclimatizing tank to the swim chamber of the swimming respirometer, in which the water temperature was similar to that of the rearing tank (i.e. 20°C or 12°C according to fish groups). After a short recovery period (about 5 min), the water flow was stabilized at a very low speed (0.5 Body Length BL s-1) and a screen darkening the upstream part of the swim chamber was placed in order to motivate the fish to occupy upstream positions. The fish were allowed to recover at this low speed for the next 4-10h during which MO2 was recorded to determine MO2min . The MO2min was considered as the lowest MO2 value recorded during this period (Fig 1).
After this period, fish were submitted to an increasing swimming speed exercise to determine MO2max (Fig 1). Swim tunnel was sealed from incoming oxygenated water from the external bath and MO2 measurements started. Water speed was progressively increased (0.5 BL min-1) until visual observation of the early stages of bursts and glide swimming suggesting that the fish was approaching its maximum aerobic swimming speed. This step was maintained for 20 min during which water speed was lightly modulated to ensure that fish was maximally challenged without being pushed to the grid at the rear of the swim tunnel. The MO2max was considered the steepest slope of water oxygen saturation vs. time obtained during a 5 min period, and Umax (BL s-1) as the highest swimming speed reached during the test. Oxygen saturation never fell below 75% of air saturation during MO2 measurements. At the end of the 20 min-swimming test, water speed was progressively decreased to 0.5 BL s-1 and water of the respirometer was renewed through the flush pump reactivation during one minute, allowing the oxygen saturation to return over 85% of air saturation (Fig 1). Then, fish were allowed to recover for 50 min, during which MO2 was recorded according to a cycle of 20 min of MO2 measuring and 5 min of recirculating water, i.e. 2 MO2 measurements were recorded (Fig 1). These MO2 measurements allowed the estimation of the excess post-exercise oxygen consumption (EPOC) by integrating (Graphical Analysis vs. 3.4; Beaverton, OR, USA) the area between the post-test recovery MO2 curve and the MO2min (0.5 BL s-1) measured before the swimming test . In addition, gill ventilation frequency (fv; beats min-1) was video-recorded (Handycam DCR-HC23E, Sony) just after maximal swimming exercise. In order to get the highest ventilation rate, the first 15 s period was manually analyzed by counting opercula openings, by two experimenters and in duplicate.
At the end of the recovery period, water temperature was progressively changed in order to measure MO2min, MO2max, EPOC, and fv at the five challenge temperatures: typically 9°C, 12°C, 16°C, 20°C and 24°C. Each new temperature was reached by increasing water temperature at a rate of ~2°C h-1 by regulating a heating system (Teco TR20, Conselice, Italy). Fish were given 1h to adjust to this new temperature (Fig 1). Then, they were held for 4-10h at this new temperature, and the protocol described above was repeated (Fig 1). In order to avoid too high temperature variations, the order at which challenge temperatures were tested depended on the temperature at which the fish were previously acclimated: Fish acclimated at 12°C were successively challenged at 12°C, 9°C, 16°C, 20°C, and 24°C, while fish reared at 20°C were successively challenged at 20°C, 24°C, 16°C, 12°C, and 9°C.
The fish were then removed from the swim tunnel, anesthetized (MS-222; 0.1 g L-1, Sigma-Aldrich, St Quentin-Fallavier, France), electronically identified, weighed and measured before being replaced in the initial tank.
For each fish and at each temperature tested during the challenge, the aerobic scope AS and the net cost of transport at maximum exercise NCOT were calculated. AS (mgO2 kg-1 h-1) was determined for each fish as MO2max—MO2min measured at the same temperature.
NCOT (mgO2 kg-1 m-1) was calculated according to Clark et al. : (5)
The data are presented as mean ± standard error (SE). The effects of diet and acclimation temperature on SGR and lipid content in fish muscles were tested using a two-way ANOVA with n = the number of fish replicates for each dietary condition Statistica software vs.7 (StatSoft, Maison-Alfort, France). Prior to ANOVA analyses, normality distribution and homeodasticity were controlled using Kolmogorov-Smirnov and the Levene test, respectively (Statistica software vs.7; StatSoft, Maison-Alfort, France). The effects of acclimation temperature, food (considered as a categorical covariate), challenge temperature (fixed effect), and factor interactions on ecophysiological variables (i.e. MO2max, MO2min, AS, Umax, NCOT, EPOC and fv max) have been tested by applying multiple linear mixed effects models, where individual fish electronic identity has been considered a random factor. When covariate interactions were not significant, a simpler model was selected according to the Akaike Interaction Criterion (AIC). All models were computed using the lme fitting routine in R freeware (lme4 package; R Core Team, 2013). The level of significance for statistical analyses was always set at α = 0.05.
All groups of fish appeared healthy and survival rate was close to 100% at the end of the experiment.
Fatty acid composition in fish
As expected, final fish FA composition reflected that of their diet, and EPA (20:5n-3) and DHA (22:6n-3) were preferentially incorporated in PL than in NL for all fish groups (one-way ANOVA: EPA: F1, 98 = 159.6; P < 0.001; DHA: F1, 98 = 70.2; P < 0.001).
Regarding the initial fish composition, and as expected, the HH diet induced an increase in n-3 HUFA and Σ n-3 FA (in particular: 20:3n-3, 20:4n-3, 22:5n-3, and 22:6n-3 FA) in fish PL, while the LH diet induced a depletion in these FA contents, but an increase in n-6 FA instead.
In both lipid classes (PL and NL), Σ SFA, 22:6n-3 FA, Σ n-3 and Σ n-3 HUFA were higher in HH than in LH fish. EPA and the ratio n-3/n-6 FA contents were significantly affected by an interaction between acclimation temperature and diet, and EPA was less incorporated in PL and NL of LH20 fish. Concerning NL, 14:0, 16:0, 16:1, Σ MUFA, 18:2n-6, and Σ n-6 FA were significantly higher in HH fish, except for Σ n-6 and 18:2n-6, which were higher in LH fish. In PL, only 18:3n-3 was significantly affected by diet and was higher in LH than in HH fish.
FA integration in fish tissue also largely depends on acclimation temperature (S3 Table). In NL class, the 18:0 FA, Σ SFA, and the ratio DHA/EPA contents in fish were higher in fish reared at 12°C, while in PL class they were more efficiently incorporated in fish reared at 20°C. However, the opposite trend was observed for 14:0 FA. Concerning NL, 16:0, 18:2n-6, Σ n-6, 22:6n-3, Σ n-3 and Σ HUFA n-3 were preferentially incorporated in 12°C-acclimated than in 20°C-acclimated fish, except for the 16:0 FA, for which the contrary was observed. Concerning PL, the 20:0 FA, 16:1 FA, 18:3n-3 FA contents were higher in fish acclimated at 20°C than in those acclimated at 12°C.
Finally, an interactive effect of diet and acclimation temperature was observed for 18:3n-3 in NL, as for 18:2n-6 and Σ n-6 in PL class.
Growth performances and body condition
As expected, the SGR and FI were significantly higher for fish reared at 20°C (Fig 2A and 2B). However, they were not affected by either the food, or by the interaction between food and acclimation temperature (P > 0.05).
Specific growth rate SGR during the four months experimental period (% day-1; Fig A; LH12: n = 17; HH12: n = 37; LH20: n = 20; HH20: n = 34), and condition factor (Fulton Index FI) at the end of the experiment for fish which performed the thermal challenge (Fig B; n = 11 for each experimental fish group) for each experimental condition: high n-3 HUFA fed fish reared at 12°C (HH12) or 20°C (HH20), and low n-3 HUFA fed fish reared at 12°C (LH12) or 20°C (LH20). Bars with different letters are significantly different: for SGR: two-way ANOVA: effect of temperature: F 1,103 = 1328.46; P < 0.001; effect of food: F 1,103 = 1.917; P = 0.17; interaction food*temperature: F 1,103 = 1.00; P = 0.32. For FI: two-way ANOVA: effect of temperature: F 1,104 = 4.4; P = 0.037; effect of food: F 1,3104 = 0.61; P = 0.44; interaction food*temperature: F 1,104 = 3.8; P = 0.053).
Swimming performances, energetics, and ventilation rate
The statistical results relative to MO2max, MO2min, AS, Umax, NCOT, and fv are reported in Table 1.
MO2min varied similarly throughout the thermal challenge in all experimental fish groups: it decreased slightly from 9°C to 12°C, and was minimal at this temperature, and then increased until 24°C (Table 1; Fig 3A). However, regardless of the challenge temperature or the acclimation temperature, MO2min was 20% lower for the HH fish than for LH. It was also almost 30% higher for the 12°C-conditioned fish than for the 20°C-conditioned fish in both dietary groups (Fig 3A).
(A) Minimal (MO2 min) and (B) maximal oxygen consumption rate (MO2 max) and (C) aerobic scope of fish acclimated at 20°C (dark symbols) and 12°C (light symbols) and fed with enriched (triangle; HH) or depleted (circle symbol; LH) n-3 HUFA regime as a function of the challenge temperature over a range from 9°C to 24°C. Regression lines are described by polynomial models of equation: AxChalTemp2 + BxChalTemp + C, where ChalTemp is the challenge temperature tested. Statistical results are reported in Table 1.
MO2max was significantly affected by an interactive effect between acclimation temperature and challenge temperature (Table 1; Fig 3B). Fish acclimated at 20°C showed an increasing MO2max all along the challenge but did not reach their maximal rate within the tested range of challenge temperatures. Among them, the LH20 fish displayed a higher increase of MO2max with challenge temperature than the HH20 (Table 1), reaching an MO2max value 30% higher than them at 24°C. Among the fish conditioned at 12°C, the LH12 displayed its highest MO2max at 20°C (232.1 ± 33.3 mg O2 kg-1 h-1), while the HH12 fish displayed a slight but continuous increase of MO2max with challenge temperature. These fish displayed their highest MO2 below 10°C (Fig 3), but their MO2max values did not exceed those of the HH20 fish at 24°C.
As for MO2max, AS was significantly affected by an interactive effect between acclimation and challenge temperature, as well as by an interactive effect between acclimation temperature and diet (Table 1; Fig 3C). Globally, AS of the LH12 fish increased from 9°C to 17.7°C (until 215.0 ± 30.0 mg O2 kg-1 h-1), while LH20 fish tented to reach a maximum at 24°C (290.4 ± 44.7 mg O2 kg-1 h-1). In contrast, HH12 and HH20 fish kept increasing their maximum AS when exposed to successive challenge temperatures (236.2 ± 24.8 mg O2 kg-1 h-1 and 268.6 ± 25.1 mg O2 kg-1 h-1 at 24°C respectively).
Umax was significantly affected by acclimation temperature but not by diet (Table 1; Fig 4A). Regardless of the challenge temperature, Umax was about 40% higher in 12°C-acclimated fish than in 20°C-acclimated group. Moreover, Umax varied similarly all along the thermal challenge at both acclimation temperatures, increasing when challenge temperature increased from 9°C to 20°C, and remaining stable when challenge temperature increased from 20°C to 24°C: Umax varied from 5.4 ± 0.2 at 9°C to 7.4 ± 0.2 BL s-1 at 24°C and from 8.6 ± 0.3 at 9°C to 10.8 ± 0.3 at 24°C BL s-1 for 20°C- and 12°C-acclimated fish, respectively.
(A) Maximal swimming speed (Umax), (B) net cost of transport at maximum exercise (NCOT), (C) post-challenge ventilation rate (fv) and (D) excess post-exercise oxygen consumption (EPOC) of fish acclimated at 20°C (dark points) and 12°C (light points) and fed with enriched (triangle symbol; HH) or depleted (circle symbol; LH) n-3 HUFA regime for four months as a function of the challenge temperature along a range from 9°C to 24°C. Regression lines for Umax are described by polynomial models of the equation: AxChalTemp2 + BxChalTemp + C, where ChalTemp is the challenge temperature tested. Statistical results are reported in Table 1.
The NCOT was stable throughout the challenge concerning 12°C-acclimated fish (from 0.05 ± 0.01 mg O2 kg-1 m-1 at 9°C to 0.05 ± 0.01 mg O2 kg-1 m-1 at 24°C; Table 1; Fig 4B). However, concerning 20°C-acclimated fish, NCOT progressively increased throughout the thermal challenge, and became progressively significantly higher in LH than in HH fish. This difference between dietary fish groups varied from 10% at 12°C, to 30% at 24°C.
As expected, the fv significantly increased with challenge temperature in all fish groups, due to the increasing metabolic demand, as shown by the global MO2max increase with challenge temperature, combined to the decreasing oxygen availability and blood oxygen affinity with increasing temperature [39,40] (Table 1; Fig 4C). The fv was not affected by diet, but was 10% to 26% higher for the 12°C-acclimated fish than for the 20°C-acclimated fish throughout the thermal challenge (Table 1; Fig 4C).
Excess post-exercise oxygen consumption (EPOC)
The EPOC was not affected by diet, and was almost stable throughout the thermal challenge concerning the 12°C-acclimated fish, ranging from 63.7 ± 39.2 and 89.5 ± 28.7 mg O2 kg-1 h-1 at 9°C, to 82.2 ± 10.5 and 106.1 ± 24.4 mg O2 kg-1 h-1 at 24°C for the LH and the HH fish, respectively (Table 1; Fig 4D). However, it significantly increased with the challenge temperature in the 20°C-acclimated fish, and was from two- to six-fold higher than in the 12°C-acclimated fish from 9°C to 24°C.
To the best of our knowledge, the present study is the first to highlight the combined effects of n-3 HUFA content in the food source and acclimation temperature on the swimming and metabolic performances of Liza aurata in a thermal changing environment. While several studies reported the effects of n-3 HUFA on fish performance, this work revealed that these effects on fish aerobic capacities are highly dependent on acclimation temperature. These results are of particular interest in the context of fish response to the natural or induced spatio-temporal variations of temperature and HUFA availability occurring in coastal areas.
This study aimed to use highly contrasting diets in terms of n-3 HUFA content, in order to observe highly contrasted physiological responses of fish. The n-3 HUFA content of the LH diet (0.2% EPA+DHA on DM) was about 24-fold lower than that of the HH diet (4.8% EPA+DHA on DM). Compared to the standard diet previously used for this species  and established from the needs known for other species (~1% EPA+DHA on DM), the LH diet was considered deficient, while the HH diet was considered rich in n-3 HUFA. The immediate consequence of feeding fish with both of these diets was the modification of the composition of the cell membrane bilayer in both LH and HH fish , , as (1) fish fed the LH diet presented the lowest n-3 HUFA content, including EPA and DHA, and (2) both of these fatty acids were preferentially incorporated in PL rather than NL in both LH and HH fish, validating their integration in cell membranes .
First, clear differences in aerobic capacities have been highlighted with respect to the acclimation temperature. Compared to 12°C-acclimated fish the 20°C-acclimated fish 1) spent much more energy (NCOT) to reach a lower swimming speed value (Umax) during effort and 2) showed a higher EPOC, revealing a higher oxygen debt during the recovery period following swimming effort. This higher EPOC indicates that the 20°C-acclimated fish relied more on anaerobic metabolism during the swim challenge than the 12°C-acclimated fish [43–45]. This means that the ionic, osmotic and biochemical imbalances in metabolites such as lactate and glycogen  were associated with swimming effort, which induced a higher MO2 to restore tissue and cellular energy balance after the swim challenge. However, this higher EPOC was not correlated with a higher fv during the recovery period [47–49], confirming that 20°C-acclimated fish have a limited capacity to increase oxygen supply at the systemic level compared to 12°C-acclimated fish for which higher fv combined with lower EPOC suggested a better capacity to recover from the test, regardless of the challenge temperature. This higher anaerobic metabolism utilization linked to a lower swimming performance may be partly explained by the lower number or diameter of oxidative fibers within the myotome, as observed following acclimation to warm waters in mosquitofish , goldfish  or striped bass . This reduced oxidative area would have then prevented swimming to be supported by aerobic muscular activity up to higher velocities, involving the recruitment of the fast anaerobic fibers.
Second, the basal metabolic cost of all fish groups increased when challenge temperature was above 15°C, implying that seawater warming may increase the cost of the maintenance of basal activities such as cardiac pump or osmoregulation for Liza aurata . Moreover, for both acclimation temperatures tested, the LH fish displayed higher MO2min regardless of the challenge temperature, suggesting that more energy is necessary to maintain vital functions when fish are exposed to deficient n-3 HUFA food sources. This is congruent with a previous result from McKenzie , who found that sturgeons and eels fed a rich n-3 HUFA diet had significantly lower basal metabolic rate than fish fed a depleted n-3 HUFA diet. These congruent results in different species indicate that dietary fatty acids can have very similar effects on metabolism in widely different taxonomic fish groups, irrespective of their thermal acclimation or temperature exposure.
The LH fish, when conditioned at 20°C (LH20), displayed a higher aerobic metabolism (showed by higher MO2max and AS) than the other fish, supporting a higher capacity for oxygen allocation towards energy-demanding activities such as swimming, foraging, growth and/or digestion . Nevertheless, these fish spent much more energy (higher NCOT) than HH20 to reach a similar maximum swimming speed (Umax), and this was even more important as the challenge temperature increased. Taken together, these results imply that the supplementary oxygen quantity available for LH20 is much more rapidly consumed to perform the same level of activity as the HH20 fish. This revealed an altered yield between oxygen-consumption and muscular work caused by depleted n-3 HUFA supply. The higher energy spent by LH20 fish to swim at the same velocity may lead to less excess energy to perform other energy-demanding activities. This is expected to be disadvantageous for mullets in a natural environment, since they have to perform concomitantly several energy-consuming actions such as migration, foraging, or predator escape. In the long-term, this little excess energy could lead to a reduction of the specific growth rate, as the excess aerobic energy is expected to be allocated to growth once other activities have been allocated . Such a reduction in growth rate has not been observed in this study, based on 4 months of acclimation, but has been previously reported in the same species following 5-months of acclimation at 20°C with the LH diet . It is noteworthy that, in our experimental conditions, the fish did not have to use their aerobic metabolism to forage (food provided in sufficient quantity) or to escape from predators. This implies that, in a natural environment where fish have to perform these other activities at the same time as swimming, an alteration of energy metabolism due to n-3 HUFA deficiency could more rapidly impact on their ecophysiological performances such as growth. Longer experimental work combined with fieldwork testing fish in their more restrictive natural environment would be valuable to validate this hypothesis and assess the time lapse for significant impact.
Thus, this study highlighted that LH fish displayed higher metabolic rates than HH fish, with higher MO2max and AS when these LH fish were acclimated at 20°C than at 12°C. This could be due to several mechanisms. First, EPA was the only FA content interactively affected by acclimation temperature and diet: it was less incorporated in the PL and NL when fish were acclimated at 20°C and fed the LH diet. Thus, the lipid composition seemed to have responded to increasing temperature with a decreasing degree of unsaturation [6–8]. Moreover, high acclimation temperature reduced the content of 18:3n-3 FA in PL, an important EPA precursor, reducing the possibility of compensating for EPA decrease by de novo production. Consequently, the lower EPA incorporation measured in the LH20 fish could have modified membrane functionality, consequently impacting the physiological performances of fish. It is worth noting that, in addition, this lower EPA incorporation in LH20 fish could lead to an alteration of their immune functions, as the EPA is a precursor of eicosanoids used to produce leukotrienes, thromboxanes and prostaglandins (for reviews see [12–14]). A second hypothesis would be a combined effect of low n-3 HUFA content in the food source and high acclimation temperature on proton leak process, which is defined as an increasing mitochondrial MO2 without increasing ATP production [54,55]. This MO2 is controlled by inner membrane permeability to protons. On one hand, the diet may have increased mitochondrial proton leak through a modification of permeability of the mitochondrial membranes. In mammals, n-3 HUFA deficiency in membrane has been previously shown to increase mitochondrial proton leak . This theory may explain the higher MO2max but the similar Umax reached by the LH fish in comparison to the HH fish. On the other hand, proton leak may have been increased by warm-acclimation temperature . Uncoupling proteins, capable of increasing proton leakage across the inner mitochondrial membrane and then reducing the aerobic ATP formation of cells, have been found in several fish species [57–60], and their level has been shown to be higher in warm-acclimated Antarctic eelpout Pachycara brachycephalum . This suggested a lower ATP production combined to a higher MO2 in these fish than in cold-acclimated group. A third hypothesis could be the higher linoleic acid concentration in the LH diet, known to increase carnitine palmitoyl transferase activity, which may improve the aerobic metabolism of FAs in red muscle [61,62]. Previous works suggested that aerobic metabolism is primarily fuelled by FA oxidation, with MUFA being preferred over SFAs, which, in turn, are preferred over HUFA as substrates [61–63]. However, this last hypothesis is not supported by our results, as MUFA or SFA contents in the muscle of LH fish were lower than in HH fish.
This study brings a set of new clues showing that the impact of a trophic source depleted in n-3 HUFA is exacerbated for fish acclimated to a warmer environment, directly impacting several physiological functions that all depend on metabolic capacities, and in the long-term may reduce ecophysiological performance, such as growth. In a natural environment, these results raise the question of the ecological consequences of longer and warmer summers already recorded and still expected in temperate areas . Indeed, warmer events led to a decreasing n-3 HUFA profile in diatoms, as well as to a decrease of their biomass in favor of the development of poor-HUFA cyanobacteria (for review see ), exposing mullets to environmental conditions that could interactively challenge their metabolism. Beyond this seasonal aspect, where fish could respond through phenotypic plasticity or relocation, this work again underlines the pertinence of the change of trophic source quality, especially within the context of the global warming, as a factor affecting living organisms and marine communities.
S1 Table. Formulation and fatty acid composition in total lipids of the two experimental diets.
Fatty acids for which the percentage was lower than 0.2% FAME are not represented. Each MUFA is represented as a sum of n-7, n-9 and n-11 FA. a Sources: fish meal LT 94: Norse (Fyllingsdalen, Norway); casein: Sigma-Aldrich (Germany); soy oil: Système U (Créteil, France); fish oil: pure cod oil Cooper (Melun, France); precooked starch: Prégéflo Roquette frères (Lestrem, France); vitamin mixture (INRA Jouy-en-Josas, France). b Vitamin mixture (g kg-1 vitamin mix): retinyl acetate, 1; cholecalciferol, 2 5; DL-α-tocopheryl acetate, 5; menadione, 1; thiamine-HCL, 0 1; riboflavin, 0 4; D-calcium panththenate, 2; pyridoxine-HCL, 0 3; cyanocobalamin, 1; niacin, 1; choline, 200; ascorbic acid (ascorbyl polyphosphate), 5; folic acid, 0 1; D-biotin, 1; meso-inositol, 30. c Mineral mixture (g kg-1 mineral mix): KCl, 90; KI, 0 04; CaHPO4 2H2O, 500; NaCl, 40; CuSO4 5H2O, 3; ZnSO4 7H2O, 4; CoSO4, 0 02; FeSO4 7H2O, 20; MnSO4 H2O, 3; CaCo3, 215; MgOH, 124; Na2SeO3, 0 03; NaF, 1. Abbreviations: ARA: arachidonic acid; DHA docosahexaenoic acid; EPA: ecosapentaenoic acid; FA: fatty acids; HH: high n-3 HUFA diet; HUFA: highly unsaturated fatty acids; LH: low-n-3 HUFA diet; MUFA: mono-unsaturated fatty acids; SE: standard error; SFA: saturated fatty acids; TL: total lipids.
S2 Table. Fatty acid composition of Liza aurata muscle before the experiment (T0).
Total lipid TL content, neutral lipid NL content, polar lipid PL content (mg g-1 of dry weight), fatty acid profile of NL and PL (% of fatty acids methyl esters FAME) in Liza aurata white muscle at the T0 of the experiment (n = 10). Values are mean ± standard error. Abbreviations: ARA: arachidonic acid; DHA docosahexaenoic acid; EPA: ecosapentaenoic acid; HUFA: highly unsaturated fatty acids; MUFA: mono-unsaturated fatty acids; SFA: saturated fatty acids.
S3 Table. Fatty acid composition of Liza aurata muscle at the end of the experiment.
Total lipid TL content, neutral lipid NL content, polar lipid PL content (mg g-1 of dry weight), fatty acid profile of NL and PL (% of fatty acids methyl esters FAME) in Liza aurata white muscle at the end of the experiment according to rearing conditions (HH20: fish fed the high-n-3 HUFA diet and reared at 20°C, n = 14; LH20: fish fed the low-n-3 HUFA diet and reared at 20°C, n = 13; HH12: fish fed the high-n-3 HUFA diet and reared at 12°C, n = 13; and LH12: fish fed the low-n-3 HUFA diet and reared at 12°C, n = 10). Values are mean ± standard error. Statistical significance of diet (D), temperature (T), as well as the interaction between both factors (D*T) are indicated through the P, F and df values (two-way ANOVA). Significance was considered from α < 0.05 and was indicated in bold case in the table. Values containing different letters on a same row are significantly different. Abbreviations: ARA: arachidonic acid; D: diet; D*T: interaction between diet and temperature; df1: degree of freedom of numerator; df2: degree of freedom of denominator; DHA docosahexaenoic acid; EPA: ecosapentaenoic acid; HUFA: highly unsaturated fatty acids; MUFA: mono-unsaturated fatty acids; SFA: saturated fatty acids; T: temperature.
Conceived and designed the experiments: MV TLL JLZI. Performed the experiments: MV TLL HLD. Analyzed the data: MV TLL HLD. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: CL JLZI DM PQ HLD ED. Wrote the paper: MV TLL CL JLZI DM HDL.
- 1. Das T, Pal AK, Chakraborty SK, Manush SM, Sahu NP, Mukherjee SC. Thermal tolerance, growth and oxygen consumption of Labeo rohita fry (Hamilton, 1822) acclimated to four temperatures. J Therm Biol. 2005;30: 378–383.
- 2. Sollid J, Nilsson GE. Plasticity of respiratory structures—adaptive remodeling of fish gills induced by ambient oxygen and temperature. Respir Physiol Neurobiol. 2006;154: 241–251. pmid:16540380
- 3. Hazel JR, Williams EE. The role of alterations in membrane lipid composition in enabling physiological adaptation of organisms to their physical environment. Prog Lipid Res. 1990;29: 167–227. pmid:2131463
- 4. Cossins AR. Homeoviscous adaptation of biological membranes and its functional significance. Temperature adaptation of biological membranes. Portland Press. London: Cossins A. R.; 1994. pp. 63–76.
- 5. Selmi S, Mbarki R, Sadok S. Seasonal change of lipid and fatty acid composition of little tuna Euthynnus alletteratus-by-products. Nutr Health. 2008;19: 189–194. pmid:19009740
- 6. Person-Le Ruyet J, Skalli A, Dulau B, Le Bayon N, Le Delliou H, Robin JH. Does dietary n-3 highly unsaturated fatty acids level influence the European sea bass (Dicentrachus labrax) capacity to adapt to a high temperature? Aquaculture. 2004;242: 571–588. pmid:15029503
- 7. Raynard RS, Cossins AR. Homeoviscous adaptation and thermal compensation of sodium pump of trout erythrocytes. Am J Physiol. 1991;260: R916–R924. pmid:2035703
- 8. Wodtke E. Temperature adaptation of biological membranes. Compensation of the molar activity of cytochrome C oxidase in the mitochondrial energy-transducing membrane during thermal acclimation of the carp (Cyprinus carpio L.). Biochim Biophys Acta. 1991;640: 710–720.
- 9. Sargent J., Tocher DR, Bell JG. The lipids, Third edition. Fish Nutrition. Academic Press. London: Halver J.E. & Hardy R.W.; 2002. pp. 182–259.
- 10. Glencross BD. Exploring the nutritional demand for essential fatty acids by aquaculture species. Reviews in Aquaculture. 2009;1: 71–124.
- 11. Tocher DR. Fatty acid requirements in ontogeny of marine and freshwater fish. Aquac Res. 2010;41: 717–732.
- 12. Pahl SL, Lewis DM, Chen F, King KD. Heterotrophic growth and nutritional aspects of the diatom Cyclotella cryptica (Bacillariophyceae): Effect of some environmental factors. J Biosci Bioeng. 2010;109: 235–239. pmid:20159570
- 13. Crawford MA, Broadhurst CL. The role of docosahexaenoic and the marine food web as determinants of evolution and hominid brain development: the challenge for human sustainability. Nutr Health. 2012;21: 17–39. pmid:22544773
- 14. McKenzie DJ. Effects of dietary fatty acids on the respiratory and cardiovascular physiology of fish. Comp Biochem Physiol A Mol Integr Physiol. 2001;128: 605–619.
- 15. Vagner M, Zambonino-Infante J-L, Mazurais D, Imbert-Auvray N, Ouillon N, Dubillot E, et al. Reduced n-3 highly unsaturated fatty acids dietary content expected with global change reduces the metabolic capacity of the golden grey mullet. Mar Biol. 2014; pmid:25414525
- 16. Chatelier A, Imbert N, Infante JLZ, McKenzie DJ, Bois P. Effects of oleic acid on the high threshold barium current in seabass Dicentrarchus labrax ventricular myocytes. J Exp Biol. 2006;209: 4033–4039. pmid:17023597
- 17. Chatelier A. Associations between tissue fatty acid composition and physiological traits of performance and metabolism in the seabass (Dicentrarchus labrax). J Exp Biol. 2006;209: 3429–3439. pmid:16916978
- 18. Wagner G., Balfry S., Higgs D., Lall S., Farrell A. Dietary fatty acid composition affects the repeat swimming performance of Atlantic salmon in seawater. Comp Biochem Physiol A Mol Integr Physiol. 2004;137: 567–576. pmid:15123193
- 19. Dosanjh BS, Higgs DA, McKenzie DJ, Randall DJ, Eales JG, Rowshandeli N, et al. Influence of dietary blends of menhaden oil and canola oil on growth muscle lipid composition and thyroidal status of Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar) in sea water. Fish Physiol Biochem. 1998;19: 123–134.
- 20. McKenzie DJ, Higgs D., Dosanjh BS, Deacon G, Randall DJ. Dietary fatty acid composition influences swimming performance in Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar) in seawater. Fish Physiol Biochem. 1998;19: 111–122.
- 21. IPCC. Climate Change 2013: The Physical Science Basis. Contribution of Working Group I to the Fifth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, United Kingdom and New York, NY, USA. Stocker T.F., Qin D., Plattner G.-K., Tignor M., Allen S.K., Boschung J., Nauels A., Xia Y., Bex V. and Midgley P.M.; 2013. p. 1535.
- 22. Ifremer. Laboratoire Environnement Ressources des Pertuis Charentais. Bulldoser (Bulletin des Données de la Surveillance de l’Environnement et des Ressources). 2012.
- 23. Béthoux J, Gentili B, Tailliez D. Warming and freshwater budget change in the Mediterranean since the 1940s, their possible relation to the greenhouse effect. Geophys Res Lett. 1998;25: 1023–1026.
- 24. Goffart A, Hecq JH, Legendre L. Changes in the development of the winter-spring phytoplankton bloom in the Bay of Calvi (NW Mediterranean) over the last two decades: a response to changing climate? Mar Ecol Prog Ser. 2002;236: 45–60.
- 25. Gypens N, Lacroix G, Lancelot C. Causes of variability in diatom and Phaeocystis blooms in Belgian coastal waters between 1989 and 2003: A model study. J Sea Res. 2007;57: 19–35.
- 26. Gómez F, Souissi S. The impact of the 2003 summer heat wave and the 2005 late cold wave on the phytoplankton in the north-eastern English Channel. C R Biol. 2008;331: 678–685. pmid:18722987
- 27. Kainz M, Brett MT, Arts MT, editors. Lipids in Aquatic Ecosystems [Internet]. New York, NY: Springer New York; 2009. Available: http://link.springer.com/10.1007/978-0-387-89366-2
- 28. Leu E, Wängberg S-Å, Wulff A, Falk-Petersen S, Børre Ørbæk J, Hessen DO. Effects of changes in ambient PAR and UV radiation on the nutritional quality of an Arctic diatom (Thalassiosira antarctica var. borealis). J Exp Mar Biol Ecol. 2006;337: 65–81.
- 29. Lebreton B, Richard P, Galois R, Radenac G, Pfléger C, Guillou G, et al. Trophic importance of diatoms in an intertidal Zostera noltii seagrass bed: Evidence from stable isotope and fatty acid analyses. Estuar Coast Shelf Sci. 2011;92: 140–153.
- 30. Carpentier A, Como S, Dupuy C, Lefrançois C, Feunteun E. Feeding ecology of Liza spp. in a tidal flat: Evidence of the importance of primary production (biofilm) and associated meiofauna. J Sea Res. 2014;92: 86–91.
- 31. Folch J, Lees M, Sloane GH. A simple method for the isolation and purification of total lipids from animal tissues. J Biol Chem. 1957;226: 497–509. pmid:13428781
- 32. Juaneda P, Roquelin G. Rapid and convenient separation of phospholipids and non-phosphorus lipids from rat heart using silica cartridges. Lipids. 1985;20: 400–41.
- 33. Fulton TW. The rate of growth of fishes. 22nd Annual Report of the Fishery Board of Scotland. 1904. pp. 141–241.
- 34. Webb PW. Acceleration performance of rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss). J Exp Biol. 1975;63: 451–465.
- 35. Vagner M, Lefrançois C, Ferrari RS, Satta A, Domenici P. The effect of acute hypoxia on swimming stamina at optimal swimming speed in flathead grey mullet Mugil cephalus. Mar Biol. 2008;155: 183–190.
- 36. Schurmann H, Steffensen JF. Spontaneous swimming activity of Atlantic cod Gadus morhua exposed to graded hypoxia at three temperatures. J Exp Biol. 1994;197: 129–142. pmid:9317484
- 37. Beamish FWH. Influence of starvation on standard and routine oxygen consumption. Trans Am Fish Soc. 1964;93: 103–107.
- 38. Clark TD, Jeffries KM, Hinch SG, Farrell AP. Exceptional aerobic scope and cardiovascular performance of pink salmon (Oncorhynchus gorbuscha) may underlie resilience in a warming climate. J Exp Biol. 2011;214: 3074–3081. pmid:21865520
- 39. Riggs A. Properties of fish hemoglobins. Academic Press. New York; 1970. pp. 209–252.
- 40. Cerezo J, Garcia BG. The effects of oxygen levels on oxygen consumption, survival and ventilatory frequency of sharpsnout sea bream (Diplodus puntazzo Gmelin, 1789) at different conditions of temperature and fish weight. J Appl Ichtyol. 2004;20: 488–492.
- 41. Linares F, Henderson RJ. Incorporation of 14C-labelled polyunsaturated fatty acids by juvenile turbot Scophtalmus maximus (L) in vivo. J Fish Biol. 1991;38: 335–347.
- 42. Jobling M. Nutrient partitioning and the influence of feed composition on body composition. Food Intake in Fish. Blackwell Scientific. Oxford UK: Houlihan D, Boujard Jobling M; 2001. pp. 354–375.
- 43. Lee CG. Excess post-exercise oxygen consumption in adult sockeye (Oncorhynchus nerka) and coho (O. kisutch) salmon following critical speed swimming. J Exp Biol. 2003;206: 3253–3260. pmid:12909706
- 44. Luna-Acosta A, Lefrançois C, Millot S, Chatain B, Bégout M-L. Physiological response in different strains of sea bass (Dicentrarchus labrax): Swimming and aerobic metabolic capacities. Aquaculture. 2011;317: 162–167.
- 45. He W, Xia W, Cao Z-D, Fu S-J. The effect of prolonged exercise training on swimming performance and the underlying biochemical mechanisms in juvenile common carp (Cyprinus carpio). Comp Biochem Physiol A Mol Integr Physiol. 2013;166: 308–315. pmid:23838144
- 46. Lee CG. Excess post-exercise oxygen consumption in adult sockeye (Oncorhynchus nerka) and coho (O. kisutch) salmon following critical speed swimming. J Exp Biol. 2003;206: 3253–3260. pmid:12909706
- 47. Dalla Valle AZ, Rivas-Diaz R, Claireaux G. Opercular differential pressure as a predictor of metabolic oxygen demand in the starry flounder. J Fish Biol. 2003;63: 1578–1588.
- 48. Millidine KJ, Metcalfe NB, Armstrong JD. The use of ventilation frequency as an accurate indicator of metabolic rate in juvenile atlantic salmon (Salmo salar). Can J Fish Aquat Sci. 2008;65: 2081–2087.
- 49. Frisk M, Skov PV, Steffensen JF. Thermal optimum for pikeperch (Sander lucioperca) and the use of ventilation frequency as a predictor of metabolic rate. Aquaculture. 2012;324–325: 151–157.
- 50. Hammill E, Wilson RS, Johnston IA. Sustained swimming performance and muscle structure are altered by thermal acclimation in male mosquitofish. J Therm Biol. 2004;29: 251–257.
- 51. Johnston IA, Lucking M. Temperature induced variation in the distribution of different muscle fibre type in the goldfish (Carassius auratus). J Comp Physiol B. 1978;124: 111–116.
- 52. Jones PL, Sidell BD. Metabolic responses of striped bass to temperature acclimation. II. Alterations in metabolic carbon sources and distributions of fiber types in locomotory muscle. J Exp Zool. 1982;219: 163–171.
- 53. Fry FE. The effect of environmental factors on the physiology of fish. Fish Physiol. 1971;6: 1–98.
- 54. Brand MD. The contribution of the leak of protons across the mitochondrial inner membrane to standard metabolic rate. J Theor Biol. 1990;145: 267–286. pmid:2169556
- 55. Ramsey JJ, Harper M-E, Humble SJ, Koomson EK, Ram JJ, Bevilacqua L, et al. Influence of mitochondrial membrane fatty acid composition on proton leak and H2O2 production in liver. Comp Biochem Physiol B Biochem Mol Biol. 2005;140: 99–108. pmid:15621515
- 56. Fontaine EM, Moussa M, Devin A, Garcia J, Ghisolfi J, Rigoulet M, et al. Effect of polyunsaturated fatty acids deficiency on oxidative phosphorylation in rat liver mitochondria. Biochim Biophys Acta BBA-Bioenerg. 1996;1276: 181–187. pmid:8856103
- 57. Mark FC, Lucassen M, Pörtner HO. Thermal sensitivity of uncoupling protein expression in polar and temperate fish. 2006;1: 365–374. pmid:20483268
- 58. Stuart JA, Harper JA, Brindle KM, Brand MD. Uncoupling protein 2 from carp and zebrafish, ectothermic vertebrates. Biochim Biophys Acta. 1999;1413: 50–54. pmid:10524261
- 59. Liang X-F, Ogata HY, Oku H, Chen J, Hwang F. Abundant and constant expression of uncoupling protein 2 in the liver of red sea bream Pagrus major. Comp Biochem Physiol A Mol Integr Physiol. 2003;136: 655–661. pmid:14613793
- 60. Jastroch M, Withers K, Klingenspor M. Uncoupling protein 2 and 3 in marsupials: identification, phylogeny, and gene expression in response to cold and fasting in Antechinus flavipes. Physiol Genomics. 2004;17: 130–139. pmid:14970361
- 61. Sidell BD, Driezic WR. Relationship between cardiac energy metabolism and cardiac work demand in fishes. Circulation, respiration and metabolism proceedings in life science. Springer. Berlin, Heidelberg: Gilles R; 1985. pp. 386–401.
- 62. Egginton S. Effect of temperature on optimal substrate for β-oxidation. J Fish Biol. 1996;49: 753–758.
- 63. Henderson RJ, Sargent J. Chain-length specificities of mitochondrial and peroxisomal β-oxidation of fatty acids in livers of rainbow trout (Salmo gairdneri). Comp Biochem Physiol Part B Comp Biochem. 1985;82: 79–85.