In studies using isolated ovarian granulosa and thecal cells it is important to assess the degree of cross contamination. Marker genes commonly used for granulosa cells include FSHR, CYP19A1 and AMH while CYP17A1 and INSL3 are used for thecal cells. To increase the number of marker genes available we compared expression microarray data from isolated theca interna with that from granulosa cells of bovine small (n = 10 for both theca and granulosa cells; 3-5 mm) and large (n = 4 for both theca and granulosa cells, > 9 mm) antral follicles. Validation was conducted by qRT-PCR analyses. Known markers such as CYP19A1, FSHR and NR5A2 and another 11 genes (LOC404103, MGARP, GLDC, CHST8, CSN2, GPX3, SLC35G1, CA8, CLGN, FAM78A, SLC16A3) were common to the lists of the 50 most up regulated genes in granulosa cells from both follicle sizes. The expression in theca interna was more consistent than in granulosa cells between the two follicle sizes. Many genes up regulated in theca interna were common to both sizes of follicles (MGP, DCN, ASPN, ALDH1A1, COL1A2, FN1, COL3A1, OGN, APOD, COL5A2, IGF2, NID1, LHFP, ACTA2, DUSP12, ACTG2, SPARCL1, FILIP1L, EGFLAM, ADAMDEC1, HPGD, COL12A1, FBLN5, RAMP2, COL15A1, PLK2, COL6A3, LOXL1, RARRES1, FLI1, LAMA2). Many of these were stromal extracellular matrix genes. MGARP, GLDC, CHST8, GPX3 were identified as new potential markers for granulosa cells, while FBLN5, OGN, RAMP2 were significantly elevated in the theca interna.
Citation: Hatzirodos N, Hummitzsch K, Irving-Rodgers HF, Rodgers RJ (2015) Transcriptome Comparisons Identify New Cell Markers for Theca Interna and Granulosa Cells from Small and Large Antral Ovarian Follicles. PLoS ONE 10(3): e0119800. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0119800
Academic Editor: Meijia Zhang, China Agricultural University, CHINA
Received: October 14, 2014; Accepted: January 29, 2015; Published: March 16, 2015
Copyright: © 2015 Hatzirodos et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited
Data Availability: The CEL files can be obtained from the Gene Expression Omnibus (GEO) under series records GSE39589 and GSE49505 for granulosa and theca interna data, respectively.
Funding: Funding provided by National Health and Medical Research Council of Autralia, https://www.nhmrc.gov.au/, Australian Research Council of Australia, http://www.arc.gov.au/ and The University of Adelaide, http://www.adelaide.edu.au/. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
It is well known that ovarian follicles are formed during fetal development and initially are composed of an oocyte, arrested in meiosis and surrounded by a single layer of granulosa cells all enveloped by the follicular basal lamina . Each day a number of follicles are activated to resume growth and development . The granulosa cells replicate and eventually a fluid-filled antral cavity develops. It is surrounded by multiple layers of epithelial granulosa cells. Specialized stromal layers, the theca interna and externa, develop outside of the follicular basal lamina. The theca interna is composed of capillaries, fibroblasts, immune cells and specialized steroidogenic cells . These steroidogenic cells produce androgens and also insulin-like-3 (INSL3). This commences when the theca interna is first recognizable as a distinct tissue layer and continues up until ovulation of the follicle . The granulosa cells only mature into steroidogenic cells during the last 5% of their follicular development in the weeks leading up to ovulation . At this stage, the granulosa cells develop the capacity to convert the thecal-derived androgens into estrogens. This splitting of the steroidogenic pathway between the thecal cells and the granulosa cells is known as the two cell theory of estradiol production .
Much of our knowledge of both theca and granulosa cells comes from analysis of isolated cells and their in vitro culture. The isolation typically involves extruding granulosa cells from ruptured follicles in small animal species or physically scraping them from the follicular basal lamina in follicles that have been split open in large animal species. If these processes are conducted carefully very little contamination of the granulosa cells with thecal cells occurs. Also, if not conducted thoroughly then the isolated cells are not representative of the in vivo cells as the antrally-situated cells can have different properties to those located basally in the membrana granulosa . Additionally, the theca interna layer can be isolated by removal of the granulosa cells and dissection of the theca interna away from the externa. Cross contamination of granulosa cells with cells from the theca interna and vice versa is always a concern and is often confirmed retrospectively by quantitation of markers for the theca interna and for granulosa cells (examples include [8–12]).
To identify granulosa cell contamination of the theca cell preparations expression of cytochrome P450aromatase or its encoding gene CYP19A1 and FSH receptor (FSHR) are often used. The standard marker of thecal contamination of granulosa cell preparations is cytochrome P450 17α-hydroxylase or its encoding gene CYP17A1. Insulin like 3 (INSL3) is also exclusively expressed in the steroidogenic cells of the theca interna  and is an appropriate thecal cell marker. There is definitely a need for identifying additional markers of granulosa cells as aromatase/CYP19A1 is up regulated in large antral follicles , reducing its utility when working with much smaller antral follicles. Furthermore in very large follicles approaching ovulation, CYP19A1 expression is reduced like during early atresia , which is a disadvantage when working with these follicle types. In follicles aromatase is exclusively expressed in granulosa cells, excluding suiform species , but its changing levels of expression during follicle growth and atresia makes it less than ideal as a marker. Thus additional markers of both theca and granulosa cells would be useful to have.
The goal of the current study was to examine the transcriptomes of granulosa cells and theca interna derived from both small (3–5 mm) and large (> 9 mm) healthy bovine follicles and to identify additional genes differentially expressed between granulosa cells and theca interna. The transcriptome analyses used the same type of Affymetrix platforms for all samples examined as recently published by us [15–18].
Materials and Methods
Tissues and cells, RNA extraction and array hybridization
Granulosa cells and intact theca interna were previously isolated from four different groups of individual healthy follicles (n = 10 for theca interna and n = 10 for granulosa cells from follicles 3–5 mm, n = 4 from theca interna and n = 4 from granulosa cells from follicles > 9 mm) obtained from an abattoir according to previously described methods [16,17]. The health status of the follicles was confirmed by histological examination of a portion of the follicle wall. It was based on the number of apoptotic figures observed in the membrana granulosa [19,20]. RNA was extracted from granulosa cells and theca interna of each follicle preparation and 2 μg of RNA per sample was processed for hybridization to Bovine Affymetrix Genome Array (Australian Genomics Research Facility, Parkville, Australia and ACRF Cancer Genomics facility, Adelaide, Australia) [16,17]. The CEL files can be obtained from the Gene Expression Omnibus (GEO) under series records GSE39589 and GSE49505 for granulosa and theca interna data, respectively.
Affymetrix CEL file data were pre-processed in Partek Genomics Suite (version beta 6.6, St Louis, Missouri, USA) using RMA  background summarization, with quantile normalization and log base 2 transformation and mean probe set summarization with adjustment for GC content. Spike-in hybridization intensities on all arrays were within acceptable quality control limits.
One-way ANOVA using method of moments estimation was conducted to determine the differentially-expressed probe sets between group comparisons. Post-hoc testing for multiple corrections was performed using the step-up Benjamini-Hochberg False Discovery Rate (FDR) method. P values less than 0.05 were considered to be statistically significant. Probe sets which were 4-fold different between granulosa cells and theca interna in small and large antral follicles were selected as differentially regulated. Intensity values for a unique probe set were assigned to each gene on the basis of maximum average intensity across all the arrays. Only genes annotated under Release 34 of the Affymetrix annotations of the Bovine Genome Array (Release Date, 10/24/13) were included in the lists of differentially-regulated genes.
Measurement of gene expression by quantitative real-time polymerase chain reaction (qRT-PCR)
Total RNA (200 ng) from granulosa cells and theca interna of small (n = 10 each) and large (n = 5 and 4, respectively, and all from different animals) healthy follicles was extracted and used to synthesize cDNA as detailed previously . All samples for qRT-PCR were identical to the samples used for the microarray apart from small follicle granulosa cells where limited amounts of RNA were obtained and additional small healthy follicles (n = 10) were obtained to isolate more RNA. In addition, an extra sample was included in the large follicle granulosa cell group for the PCR analyses (thus n = 5). Real time RT-PCR assays were designed against 11 genes using web based software and quantitative RT-PCR values were determined from the geometric mean of 2-ΔΔCt of the target genes to the cyclophilin A (PPIA) and glyceraldehyde phosphate dehydrogenase (GAPDH) as performed previously . The sequence information of the primers is shown in Table 1 and the genes were chosen to represent some genes known to be differentially expressed and other genes with diverse cell functions.
Volcano plots (log fold change in normalized signal intensity versus statistical significance P value) of small versus large follicles for granulosa cells and theca interna are shown in Fig. 1A and B, respectively. Many genes were differentially expressed in granulosa cells between small and large follicles, whilst only relatively few were changed by follicle size in the theca interna (Fig. 1). Volcano plots of granulosa cells versus theca interna from small and large antral follicles are shown in Fig. 2A and B, respectively. Many genes were differentially expressed between granulosa cells and theca interna at both follicle sizes (Fig. 2).
The X-axis represents the fold-change between small and large follicles and the Y-axis represents the FDR P value for statistical significance for differences in gene expression across the arrays.
Differentially expressed genes
Comparisons of array data between theca interna and granulosa cells from small and large healthy follicles were conducted and the fifty most differentially-expressed genes are listed in Tables 2 to 5. The complete list and full gene names and mean intensities on arrays are presented in S1 and S2 Tables. A number of genes were differentially expressed in granulosa cells at both sizes of follicles (Tables 2 and 3; S1 and S2 Tables) and included known genes such as CYP19A1, FSHR and NR5A2. Another 11 genes were common to both lists for the small and large follicles (LOC404103, MGARP, GLDC, CHST8, CSN2, GPX3, SLC35G1, CA8, CLGN, FAM78A, SLC16A3; Tables 2 and 3). As previously reported  theca interna is more uniform from small to large follicles. We found 30 genes (MGP, DCN, ASPN, ALDH1A1, COL1A2, FN1, COL3A1, OGN, APOD, COL5A2, IGF2, NID1, LHFP, ACTA2, DUSP12, ACTG2, SPARCL1, FILIP1L, EGFLAM, ADAMDEC1, HPGD, COL12A1, FBLN5, RAMP2, COL15A1, PLK2, COL6A3, LOXL1, RARRES1, FLI1, LAMA2) out of 50 that were common to both sizes of follicles (Tables 4 and 5). Genes up regulated in theca included the stromal matrix genes such as DCN, COL1A2 and COL3A1.
Verification of differentially expressed genes by qRT-PCR
A number of genes that were differentially up regulated in the granulosa cells (MGARP, GLDC, CHST8, GPX3 and FSHR) or in the theca interna (FBLN5, OGN, RAMP2 and CYP17A1) for both follicles sizes were selected and their mRNA levels examined in granulosa cells (Fig. 3) and theca interna (Fig. 4) isolated from small and large follicles. In this group of genes two were chosen as well known makers of granulosa cells (FSHR) and thecal cells (CYP17). The mRNA levels, relative to housekeeping genes GAPDH and PPIA and the array signal intensities are shown in Figs. 3 and 4. These results show that the microarray and the qRT-PCR data agree remarkably well in relative terms for all the genes examined, thus confirming that microarray analyses have indeed identified genes which are differentially expressed between granulosa cells and theca interna.
The data are shown as the mean ± SEM (n = 10 for small follicle group, n = 4 for large follicle group, GC = granulosa cells, TI = theca interna). qRT-PCR values were determined from the geometric mean of 2-ΔΔCt of the target genes to the cyclophilin A (PPIA) and glyceraldehyde phosphate dehydrogenase (GAPDH), and the microarray values are signal intensities (normalized but not log transformed). Significantly different results for qRT-PCR were determined by one-way ANOVA with Tukey’s post hoc test. The P values for the microarray results were corrected for multiple testing using the FDR. All values which were statistically different from each other are indicated by the different alphabetical symbols in the graphs.
The data are shown as the mean ± SEM (n = 10 for small follicle group, n = 5 for large follicle group, GC = granulosa cells, TI = theca interna). qRT-PCR values were determined from the geometric mean of 2-ΔΔCt of the target genes to the cyclophilin A (PPIA) and glyceraldehyde phosphate dehydrogenase (GAPDH), and the microarray values are signal intensities (normalized but not log transformed). Significantly different results for qRT-PCR were determined by one-way ANOVA with Tukey’s post hoc test. The P values for the microarray results were corrected for multiple testing using the FDR. All values which are statistically different from each other are indicated by different alphabetical symbols in the graphs.
Isolation of granulosa and thecal cells by dissection has been used extensively to identify their separate roles in folliculogenesis and to examine the regulation of their growth and development. The degree to which cross contamination can confound the data varies from experiment to experiment and not all authors assess contamination, or need to, particularly if examining genes or molecules which have been well characterized in follicles. However, purity can matter substantially and many authors have assessed the purity of the cell preparations (examples include [8–12]). However, additional markers of these cell types at different stages of follicle growth would be useful to advance research on these cells. To identify such genes we compared granulosa cells and theca interna of two sizes of bovine follicles. These were derived from bovine follicles validated by histology as healthy [15,18]. The purity of the cell types had previously been confirmed [15,18]. RNA microarrays were conducted under similar conditions for the different cell and follicle types and the results from these arrays were validated previously [16,17].
Volcano plots identified that granulosa cells from small and large follicles differed substantially in their transcriptomes, unlike theca interna which was uniform. This initially seems counter intuitive as the mural granulosa cells being an epithelial layer are cellularly homogeneous, whereas the theca interna is a stromal layer with many different cell types. However, the significant changes in the granulosa cells with follicle size, probably reflects their important changing roles in follicular growth at the stages examined. Comparing the transcriptomes of theca interna and granulosa cells at each size, identified that their transcriptomes were very different in both the small and large follicles, with thousands of genes differentially expressed between the two cell types (P < 0.05, > 2 fold).
We focused on the 50 most differentially-expressed genes (full list is in the S1 and S2 Tables) between granulosa cells and theca interna within each follicle size group and identified genes common to both sizes of follicles. The genes up regulated in granulosa cells were all more than 7 fold up regulated and those up regulated in the theca interna were all greater than 28 fold up regulated. Of the short lists of up regulated genes for the two follicle sizes only 14 were common to both sizes of follicles for granulosa cells and included genes (CYP19A1, FSHR and NR5A2) known to be differentially up regulated in granulosa cells. The theca interna, which had much more uniform transcriptomes between the two sizes, had 30 genes in common to both short lists. Many of the genes up regulated in the theca interna were collagens and associated genes (COL1A2, COL3A1, COL5A2, COL6A3, COL12A1, COL15A1, DCN), other extracellular matrix genes (LAMA2, NID1, FBLN5, FN1, MGP, ASPN, OGN, EGFLAM) or encoding enzymes that process extracellular matrix (ADAMDEC1, LOXL1). Whilst these are good candidates for indicating the presence of cells derived from the theca interna in a preparation of granulosa cells some of these genes are also likely to be expressed in the ovarian stroma as the theca interna is a stromal layer . Therefore some of these genes are not likely to be thecal-specific markers but certainly can be used to identify thecal contamination of preparations of granulosa cells.
A number of genes were selected for validation by quantitative RT-PCR for differential expression between granulosa cells and theca interna in both small and large follicles. These genes displayed relatively high array intensity in a particular cell type and are not well characterized in terms of ovarian function. MGARP, GLDC, CHST8, GPX3 and the known differentially-expressed gene in granulosa cells, FSHR, were substantially greater in granulosa cells than theca interna as determined by both RT-PCR and microarray analyses and for both sizes of follicles. MGARP, or ovary specific acidic protein (OSAP) , and CHST8, a sulfotransferase, were up regulated in large follicles in the current study and have been shown previously . GLDC, which encodes glycine decarboxylase, was increased in small follicles which correspond to a less differentiated phenotype, more similar to pluripotent cells . The extracellular matrix protein genes, FBLN5 and OGN, and RAMP2, the adrenomedullin co-receptor, and the known differentially-expressed gene in theca interna, CYP17A1, were substantially greater in theca interna than in granulosa cells as determined by both qRT-PCR and microarray analyses and for both sizes of follicles. Thus these results confirm that the microarray analyses were correctly identifying genes differentially expressed in granulosa cells and in theca interna.
Thus in summary, we have identified a substantial number of genes which are differentially expressed between granulosa cells and the theca interna. This information will aid future studies of these cells, identifying the degree of cross contamination and providing a list of genes of interest for further study.
S1 Table. List of genes > 4-fold differentially-expressed in granulosa cells compared with theca interna in small follicles with FDR P < 0.05.
Gene name, ID, fold change and mean array intensities are presented.
Conceived and designed the experiments: NH KH HFI-R RJR. Performed the experiments: NH KH HFI-R. Analyzed the data: NH KH HFI-R RJR. Wrote the paper: NH KH HFI-R RJR.
- 1. Hummitzsch K, Irving-Rodgers HF, Hatzirodos N, Bonner W, Sabatier L, Reinhardt DP, et al. A new model of development of the mammalian ovary and follicles. PLoS One 2013; 8: e55578. pmid:23409002
- 2. Faddy MJ, Gosden RG A mathematical model of follicle dynamics in the human ovary. Hum Reprod 1995; 10: 770–775. pmid:7650119
- 3. Young JM, McNeilly AS Theca: the forgotten cell of the ovarian follicle. Reproduction 2010; 140: 489–504. pmid:20628033
- 4. Irving-Rodgers HF, Bathgate RA, Ivell R, Domagalski R, Rodgers RJ Dynamic changes in the expression of relaxin-like factor (INSL3), cholesterol side-chain cleavage cytochrome p450, and 3beta-hydroxysteroid dehydrogenase in bovine ovarian follicles during growth and atresia. Biol Reprod 2002; 66: 934–943. pmid:11906911
- 5. Bao B, Garverick HA Expression of steroidogenic enzyme and gonadotropin receptor genes in bovine follicles during ovarian follicular waves: a review. J Anim Sci 1998; 76: 1903–1921. pmid:9690647
- 6. Hillier SG Regulation of follicular oestrogen biosynthesis: a survey of current concepts. J Endocrinol 1981; 89 Suppl: 3P–18P. pmid:7241019
- 7. Nguyen T, Lee S, Hatzirodos N, Hummitzsch K, Sullivan TR, Rodgers RJ, et al. Spatial differences within the membrana granulosa in the expression of focimatrix and steroidogenic capacity. Mol Cell Endocrinol 2012; 363: 62–73. pmid:22863478
- 8. Li SK, Hearn MT Isolation of thecal cells: an assessment of purity and steroidogenic potential. J Biochem Biophys Methods 2000; 45: 169–181. pmid:10989133
- 9. Ito K, Sekiya S The purity of granulosa cell preparation? Fertil Steril 2002; 78: 205; author reply 205–206. pmid:12095523
- 10. Kataoka N, Taii S, Kita M, Mori T Preparation of highly purified porcine theca cells. J Reprod Fertil 1994; 102: 73–79. pmid:7799329
- 11. Roberts AJ, Skinner MK Hormonal regulation of thecal cell function during antral follicle development in bovine ovaries. Endocrinology 1990; 127: 2907–2917. pmid:2249633
- 12. Ferrero H, Delgado-Rosas F, Garcia-Pascual CM, Monterde M, Zimmermann RC, Simon C, et al. Efficiency and purity provided by the existing methods for the isolation of luteinized granulosa cells: a comparative study. Hum Reprod 2012; 27: 1781–1789. pmid:22454458
- 13. Satchell L, Glister C, Bleach EC, Glencross RG, Bicknell AB, Dai Y, et al. Ovarian expression of insulin-like peptide 3 (INSL3) and its receptor (RXFP2) during development of bovine antral follicles and corpora lutea and measurement of circulating INSL3 levels during synchronized estrous cycles. Endocrinology 2013; 154: 1897–1906. pmid:23546605
- 14. Conley A, Corbin J, Smith T, Hinshelwood M, Liu Z, Simpson E Porcine aromatases: studies on tissue-specific, functionally distinct isozymes from a single gene? J Steroid Biochem Mol Biol 1997; 61: 407–413. pmid:9365218
- 15. Hatzirodos N, Hummitzsch K, Irving-Rodgers HF, Harland ML, Morris SE, Rodgers RJ Transcriptome profiling of granulosa cells from bovine ovarian follicles during atresia. BMC Genomics 2014; 15: 40. pmid:24438529
- 16. Hatzirodos N, Hummitzsch K, Irving-Rodgers HF, Rodgers RJ Transcriptome profiling of the theca interna in transition from small to large antral ovarian follicles. PLoS One 2014; 9: e97489. pmid:24830430
- 17. Hatzirodos N, Irving-Rodgers HF, Hummitzsch K, Harland ML, Morris SE, Rodgers RJ Transcriptome profiling of granulosa cells of bovine ovarian follicles during growth from small to large antral sizes. BMC Genomics 2014; 15: 24. pmid:24422759
- 18. Hatzirodos N, Irving-Rodgers HF, Hummitzsch K, Rodgers RJ Transcriptome profiling of the theca interna from bovine ovarian follicles during atresia. PLoS One 2014; 9: e99706. pmid:24956388
- 19. Irving-Rodgers HF, van Wezel IL, Mussard ML, Kinder JE, Rodgers RJ Atresia revisited: two basic patterns of atresia of bovine antral follicles. Reproduction 2001; 122: 761–775. pmid:11690537
- 20. Rodgers RJ, Irving-Rodgers HF Morphological classification of bovine ovarian follicles. Reproduction 2010; 139: 309–318. pmid:19786400
- 21. Irizarry RA, Hobbs B, Collin F, Beazer-Barclay YD, Antonellis KJ, Scherf U, et al. Exploration, normalization, and summaries of high density oligonucleotide array probe level data. Biostatistics 2003; 4: 249–264. pmid:12925520
- 22. Hummitzsch K, Anderson RA, Wu J, Telfer EE, Russell DL, Robertson SA, et al. Stem cells, progenitor cells and lineage decisions in the ovary. Endocrine Reviews 2015; 36: 65–91. pmid:25541635
- 23. Zhou M, Wang Y, Qi S, Wang J, Zhang S The expression of a mitochondria-localized glutamic acid-rich protein (MGARP/OSAP) is under the regulation of the HPG axis. Endocrinology 2011; 152: 2311–2320. pmid:21447634
- 24. Christenson LK, Gunewardena S, Hong X, Spitschak M, Baufeld A, Vanselow J Research Resource: Preovulatory LH Surge Effects on Follicular Theca and Granulosa Transcriptomes. Mol Endocrinol 2013; 27: 1153–1171. pmid:23716604
- 25. Shyh-Chang N, Locasale JW, Lyssiotis CA, Zheng Y, Teo RY, Ratanasirintrawoot S, et al. Influence of threonine metabolism on S-adenosylmethionine and histone methylation. Science 2013; 339: 222–226. pmid:23118012