The incidence of bubonic plague in Madagascar is high. This study reports the susceptibility of 32 different populations of a vector, the flea Xenopsylla cheopis (Siphonaptera: Pulicidae), to the insecticide Deltamethrin. Despite the use of Deltamethrin against fleas, plague epidemics have re-emerged in Madagascar. The majority of the study sites were located in the Malagasy highlands where most plague cases have occurred over the last 10 years. X. cheopis fleas were tested for susceptibility to Deltamethrin (0.05%): only two populations were susceptible to Deltamethrin, four populations were tolerant and 26 populations were resistant. KD50 (50% Knock-Down) and KD90 (90% Knock-Down) times were determined, and differed substantially from 9.4 to 592.4 minutes for KD50 and 10.4 min to 854.3 minutes for KD90. Susceptibility was correlated with latitude, but not with longitude, history of insecticide use nor date of sampling. Combined with the number of bubonic plague cases, our results suggest that an immediate switch to an insecticide other than Deltamethrin is required for plague vector control in Madagascar.
Citation: Boyer S, Miarinjara A, Elissa N (2014) Xenopsylla cheopis (Siphonaptera: Pulicidae) Susceptibility to Deltamethrin in Madagascar. PLoS ONE 9(11): e111998. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0111998
Editor: Érika Martins Braga, Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais, Brazil
Received: December 16, 2013; Accepted: October 9, 2014; Published: November 4, 2014
Copyright: © 2014 Boyer et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: The authors have no support or funding to report.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Ectoparasites (including ticks and fleas) are both pests and vectors of various diseases of humans, livestock, pets, and wild animals. They can transmit diverse pathogens of medical and/or veterinary significance, including viruses, bacteria, protozoa, and helminthes . Plague is one of these diseases and still remains a health problem with occasional epidemics occurring in the world. Over the last decade 82% of all cases worldwide (more than 2,000 annually, total 21,725) have been in the Democratic Republic of Congo (10,581 cases between 2000 and 2009) and Madagascar (7,182) , . In Madagascar, 2,409 cases were confirmed between 2007 and 2011, and the country declared 67% of the worldwide cases in 2012 , .
Plague is a life-threatening infectious disease caused by the Gram-negative bacterium Yersinia pestis –. It primarily affects rodents, but can also cause outbreaks in human populations. The infection is classically transmitted in the murine population by infected fleas and the risk to human increases during epizootic periods that are associated with high rodent and flea densities. At least 80 flea species are known to carry the etiological agent of the plague, although their role in disease transmission varies . For instance, the oriental rat flea Xenopsylla cheopis (Siphonaptera: Pulicidae), Rothschild, 1903, is considered to be the most efficient vector as well as the major vector to humans. Other flea species have been identified as vectors in East Africa, including the Islands of the South West Indian Ocean (Ctenophtalmus bacopus, C. cabirus, Dinopsyllus lypusus, Pulex irritans, Xenopsylla brasiliensis, X. cheopis) . Plague was introduced into Madagascar in 1898, and then spread throughout the central highlands . Two flea species are involved in the transmission of plague: X. cheopis and Synopsyllus fonquerniei (Siphonaptera, pulicidae), Wagner & Roubaud. 1932. Although X. cheopis is the main vector, the black rat is also frequently parasitized by the endemic flea S. fonquerniei, and this species contributes to the circulation of Y. pestis in the rural murine population .
Since 1947, chemical insecticides have been used to limit plague transmission during outbreaks. DDT was the first chemical insecticide used to control plague vectors in Madagascar. In 1956, the organophosphate Malathion and organochlorines were applied to plague control. At the same time, the use of the EV vaccine significantly decreased human plague cases . However, the numbers of plague cases increased, particularly in the capital Antananarivo and in the coastal city of Mahajanga, after long periods of absence: 28 and 63 years, respectively , . One of the possible causes of the increase in the incidence of human cases despite an active control campaign against plague vectors is the emergence of resistance to insecticides.
The first cases of X. cheopis resistance to DDT were described in 1965 in Madagascar and were first demonstrated in 1981 , . In 1983, X. cheopis was reported to be resistant to Malathion, Fenitrothion and Propoxur in the field , . Thus, the National Plague Control Program (NPCP) used Deltamethrin, a pyrethroid, to control plague outbreaks in the 1990s. After six years of use, insecticide susceptibility tests revealed X. cheopis resistance to Deltamethrin , . In 2000, four populations in Madagascar were assayed for susceptibility to Deltamethrin (0.025%): one population was resistant and three populations were tolerant . Pyrethroids interfere with the normal activities of nerve membranes by delaying the closing of activation gates for the sodium channel . The knock-down (KD) effect describes the insect paralysis following the arrival of the molecule at the central lymph nodes. One of the major mechanisms of pyrethroid resistance involves the loss of sensitivity of the active site of the protein targeted by pyrethroids (the voltage-gated sodium channel); this is known as knockdown resistance (kdr) . The existence of resistance mechanisms and their selection has been extensively studied in Diptera species (Drosophila and mosquito species) and in stored-product insects, but not in flea species. As already described for other insect vector species, X. cheopis in Madagascar undoubtedly displays multiple resistances against different insecticides , , .
Because Deltamethrin is the insecticide used by Malagasy NPCP, it is crucial to detect and evaluate the current status of flea population's susceptibility to this insecticide, in order to conduct appropriate and efficient vector control program. Here, we report an investigation of the susceptibility to Deltamethrin of X. cheopis in the highlands of Madagascar.
Materials and Methods
This research in Madagascar was systematically made possible thanks to extant conventions between the IPM and local governments. The rats were caught either during an epidemic event at the request of the Ministry of Health and the World Health Organization on the basis of a National Health Priority, or during an investigative mission. In this last case, a letter was sent to the local authority and local general inspector, and to the national authority of the Ministry of Health, to explain the main objective of the field mission. The mission orders were authorized by the CSB (Centre de Santé de Base), SSD (Service de Santé de District) and Fokotany authorities. Additional authorizations were not required because Rattus species are considered to be pest species (especially R. rattus and R. norvegicus) and have no protected status (see IUCN and CITES lists). Traps were set only after agreement was explicitly obtained from both the village head and the field/house owner. In cultivated fields, traps were always placed at the edge of the farmed area, so that no damage was caused to crops. Rats were caught alive in wire-mesh and Sherman traps. All animals were killed by cervical dislocation. All members of the IPM involved in the fieldwork have been trained to handle and kill rodents. The study was conducted in accordance with the guidelines (http://www.pasteur.fr/ip/easysite/pasteur/en/institut-pasteur/ethics-charter) adapted to wild rodents. Animals were treated in a humane manner, and in accordance with guidelines of the American Society of Mammalogists . No country-specific ethics agreement could be obtained because the country where sampling occurred and the IPM have no ethics committees relevant to animal experimentation.
Young mice used to feed flea population were from the Institut Pasteur de Madagascar (IPM) animal breeding facility. They were not purchased or donated, but were bred for this purpose.
Trapping rats and collection of fleas
The species Xenopsylla cheopis was collected in 32 localities in Madagascar (Figure 1). X. cheopis fleas were collected on rats trapped with Sherman traps (H.B. Sherman Trap. Inc, Tallahassee, Florida) or with wire-mesh BTS traps (Besancon Technical Service, Besancon, France). For public health and sanitary reasons, all rats trapped were killed. We used trapping protocols developed and routinely used by IPM for research on R. rattus , .
The circles represent the villages where the flea populations were caught.
To harvest fleas, the host was placed in a large and pale-colored basin, deep enough to prevent the fleas from escaping. Then, the fur was brushed systematically with an adapted hard-bristled brush until the fleas jumped out. The fleas were caught with a manual pump aspirator and transported alive in a box containing rice bran and food for the larvae. Fleas were identified to the species level under binocular magnifier with the Duchemin systematic key .
Rearing of fleas
Fleas collected in the field were reared under laboratory conditions (22–27°C; 75–80% RH). Eggs, larvae, nymphs and adults were maintained together in clear two-liter glass jars containing 200 ml sterilized rice bran. Sixty five grams of sterilized dried ox blood, 5.5 g of dried yeast and 200 g of laboratory animal diet powder were added to the litter. The litter was changed once a year. The fleas were removed to a clean jar containing new litter, counted and divided into several jars when there were more than 200 adults; this allowed the flea population to increase more quickly. To feed the adults, each jar was provided with one live young mouse for three days every week.
Adult fleas were bioassayed according to the WHO protocol . Bioassays were carried out in 18 cm glass test tubes, covered with fine mesh cloth. Groups of ten fleas were exposed for 8 hours to paper impregnated with 0.05% Deltamethrin (1.5×6 cm; Vector Control Research Unit, Penang, Malaysia) . Four replicates were carried out for each flea population. The number of dead or paralyzed fleas was counted after 10, 20, 30, 40, 60, 120, 180, 300 and 480 minutes. After the 8-hour exposure, the impregnated paper was removed (and replaced with non-impregnated filter paper). Flea mortality was scored after 24 hours. A tube with a paper impregnated with silicone oil (Vector Control Research Unit, Penang, Malaysia) was used as negative control (two replicates).
Knock Down 50 (KD50; the time by which 50% of fleas were knocked down) and KD90 (the time by which 90% of fleas were knocked down) were estimated from the counts during the 8 h exposure, and the susceptibility status was assessed after the 24 h observation , : mortality rates of 98 to 100% were considered to indicate susceptibility; 80 to 98%, tolerance; and less than 80%, resistance . The test was not validated, and the data not included, if the negative control mortality rate was over 10%. The mortality rate was corrected with the Abbott formula when control values were between 5% and 10%.
The analysis was performed with R software (R version 2.15.3 2013), and Tinn-R environment (Tinn-R Editor Version 18.104.22.168 2013).
Mean KD50 and KD90 and the standard errors for each flea population were estimated with a binomial generalized linear model (glm) analysis. This glm including a probit function is a fitted model giving a prediction and a standard error at each response probability.
Analysis of Variance (ANOVA) and Tukey's b test were used to compare survival rates. Correlations between the mortality rate, KD50 and KD90 were calculated with Pearson tests. Correlations between the sampling date and the KD50, KD90 and the mortality after 24 h were also estimated with Pearson tests. ANOVA was used to test the influence of the latitude, the longitude, and the history of Indoor Residual Spraying (IRS) treatment on the three measures of sensitivity.
Knock Down 50
KD50 values for the 32 populations were from 9.44 min to 592.35 min, and thus displayed a 63-fold difference between the flea population with the highest and that with the lowest KD50 (Table 1). Five of the 32 populations had a KD50 below 30 minutes, and six populations had KD50 values over 3 hours.
Knock Down 90
KD90 values for the 32 populations were between 10.44 min and 854.29 min (82 fold difference). The populations with the highest and the lowest KD90 values were the same as those with the highest and lowest KD50 values (Table 1) Four of the five populations with the lowest KD50 values had a KD90 value below 1 hour. Four populations had KD90 values greater than the 8 h-exposure time with a highest value with 854.29 min.
The mortality rates of the 32 populations were between 2.5% and 100%, with an average of 50.55% (Figure 2). Two of the 32 populations were susceptible to Deltamethrin: the populations from Mandroseza and Soanierana showed 100% mortality. Four populations (Ambodirano Ampefiloha, Iarinoro Tsarasaotra, Amparhimboahangy Betafo and Sahatany) were tolerant to Deltamethrin (85–92.5% mortality), and the other 26 populations (81.25% of the populations) were resistant (2.5–77.5% mortality). The mortality rate was significantly correlated with the KD50 (r = −0.588, p<0.001) and KD 90 (r = −0.549, p = 0.0011) values.
Green bars represent sensitive populations, orange bars tolerant populations and red bars resistant populations (WHO definition).
No correlation was detected between the times that fleas spent in the insectarium and their KD50, KD90 or mortality (Table 2). The effect of IRS treatment on the mortality rate, the KD50 and the KD90 was not significant (Table 3). They were significant correlations between latitude and mortality, and between longitude and the KD50.
The KD50 and KD90 on one hand, and mortality on the other, are not indicators of the same mechanisms of resistance, and therefore not the same evolutionary selections; nevertheless, the correlations between these measures are strong enough to conclude about the Deltamethrin resistance of populations in the field. The results we report are unambiguous and raise serious concerns about flea control: 81.25% of 32 tested populations were resistant to 0.05% Deltamethrin. In 2000, only one X. cheopis population was found to be resistant to Deltamethrin (0.025%) . Of the four populations tested in 2000, besides the one resistant population, three have become tolerant to a higher Deltamethrin concentration. Thus, the resistance has increased substantially. Analyses of pests with multiple resistances indicated that treatment with one insecticide can favor resistance to a second, different, insecticide; the example of DDT treatment influencing the resistance to other insecticides has been extensively studied and documented , . As the resistance of X. cheopis to DDT has been demonstrated in the central highland of Madagascar since the early 80's, our hypothesis is that X. cheopis may have acquired Deltamethrin resistance after exposure to DDT treatment.
The environmental effects and/or of the anthropic pressures undoubtedly have a role in the emergence of insecticide resistance. However, latitude was the only factor found to correlate with mortality. Note that the latitude reflects a complex combination of climatic conditions (precipitations, temperature), environmental conditions such as altitude and various ecological characteristics (plant species, human social and cultural behaviors, and agricultural practices). It is therefore difficult to determine whether the relationship between latitude and insecticide resistance is due to anthropic factors or natural selection. Anthropogenic selection pressure may result from the effects of IRS, pollution, agriculture, urbanization, insecticide spraying (public health, agriculture), and the individual or collective use of pesticides. Indeed, Gratz  reported that mosquito vector control program mainly with DDT IRS affected the susceptibility of X. cheopis to this insecticide. However, in this study we find that there is no relationship between IRS treatment history (Deltamethrin, Bendiocarb), at least over the past 17 years, and flea susceptibility to Deltamethrin. Hence, at this controversy, it is difficult to assess the main factor which induces X. cheopis resistance to Deltamethrin, and further studies must be conducted to understand the resistance mechanisms and the associated factors. Therefore, due to the ability insects to acquire cross resistance to insecticides of the same family, other pyrethroids should not be used, and the resistance of flea populations to α-Cypermethrin, Cyfluthrin, Etofenprox, λ-Cyhalothrin, or Permethrine insecticides should be assessed before any large-scale use. It would also be valuable to understand the mechanisms of insecticide resistance in flea species, and in particular multiple resistance mechanisms.
We report that only two of the 32 flea populations sampled from different locations were susceptible to Deltamethrin. Consequently, in the current context of the re-emergence of plague and the increasing numbers of human plague cases in Madagascar, Deltamethrin is ineffective against fleas. Its use in Madagascar should be stopped and the control program for plague diseases needs to change to another insecticide. Twelve insecticides will be tested in our laboratory to identify which is the most appropriate for national flea control program.
We are very grateful to the entomological technicians which done a great job with all the sampling missions and the bioassays, particularly Tojo Ramihangihajason, Etienne Tata and Mandimby Andriatsiferana Rajaonarimanana.
Conceived and designed the experiments: SB NE. Performed the experiments: AM. Analyzed the data: SB. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: SB AM NE. Wrote the paper: SB AM NE.
- 1. Cleaveland S, Laurenson MK, Taylor LH (2001) Diseases of humans and their domestic mammals: pathogen characteristics, host range and the risk of emergence. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London Series B: Biological Sciences 356(1411): 991–999.
- 2. Butler T (2013) Plague gives surprises in the first decade of the 21st century in the United States and worldwide. The American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 89(4): 788–793.
- 3. WHO (2010) Peste humaine: Examen de la morbidité et de la mortalité régionales, 2004–2009. Relevé pidémiologique hebdomadaire N° 6(85): 40–45.
- 4. Andrianaivoarimanana V, Kreppel K, Elissa N, Duplantier J-M, Carniel E, et al. (2013) Understanding the Persistence of Plague Foci in Madagascar. PLOS Neglected Tropical Diseases 7(11): e2382.
- 5. WHO (2013) World health statistics 2013: a wealth of information on global public health.
- 6. Guiyoule A, Rasoamanana B, Buchrieser C, Michel P, Chanteau S, et al. (1997) Recent emergence of new variants of Yersinia pestis in Madagascar. Journal of Clinical Microbiology 35(11): 2826–2833.
- 7. Perry RD, Fetherston JD (1997) Yersinia pestis-etiologic agent of plague. Clinical microbiology reviews 10(1): 35–66.
- 8. Carniel E (2002) La peste. Comptes Rendus Biologies 325(8): 851–853.
- 9. Gage KL, Kosoy MY (2005) Natural History of plague: Perspectives from More than a Century of Research. Annual Review of Entomology 50: 505–528.
- 10. Eisen RJ, Gage KL (2012) Transmission of Flea-Borne Zoonotic Agents. Annual Review of Entomology 57: 61–82.
- 11. Brygoo ER (1966) Epidémiologie de la peste à Madagascar. Archives de l'Institut Pasteur de Madagascar 35.
- 12. Migliani R, Ratsitorahina M, Rahalison L, Rakotoarivony I, Duchemin JB, et al. (2001) Résurgence de la peste dans le district d'Ikongo à Madagascar en 1998. 1. Aspects épidémiologiques dans la population humaine. Bulletin de la Société de Pathologie Exotique 94(2): 115–118.
- 13. Ratsitorahina M, Chanteau S, Rosso ML, Randriambelosoa J, Ratsifasoamanana L, et al. (2002) Actualités épidémiologiques de la peste à Madagascar. Archives de l'Institut Pasteur de Madagascar 68(1&2): 51–54.
- 14. Coulanges P, Clerc Y, Randrianantoanina E (1982) X. cheopis and S. fonquerniei, plague-carrying Malagasian fleas–demonstration of their resistance to DDT, dieldrin and malathion. Archives de l'Institut Pasteur de Madagascar 49(1): 171.
- 15. Fontenille D, Coulanges P (1987) Notes sur la sensibilité des puces Xenopsylla cheopis de la région d'Antananarivo à la Déltamethrine et au Propoxur. Archives de l'Institut Pasteur de Madagascar 53: 249–259.
- 16. Coulanges P, Randrianantoanina E (1984) Résistance exceptionnelle aux insecticides de puces pestigènes malgaches. Bulletin de la Société de pathologie exotique 77(5): 705–711.
- 17. Coulanges P, Randrianantoanina E (1984) Résistance des puces pestigènes malgaches aux insecticides organochlores, organophosphores et aux carbamates. Archives de l'Institut Pasteur de Madagascar 51(1): 253–260.
- 18. Ratovonjato J (1998) Sensibilité de Xenopsylla cheopis aux insecticides en milieu urbain à Madagascar. Archives de l'Institut Pasteur de Madagascar 64(1–2): 25–28.
- 19. Ratovonjato J, Duchemin JB, Duplantier J-M, Laventure S, Rabarison P, et al. (1998) Evaluation de la sensibilité des puces pestigènes malgaches aux insecticides en milieu urbain. Résultats et analyse préliminaires. Archives de l'Institut Pasteur de Madagascar 64(1–2): 29–33.
- 20. Ratovonjato J, Duchemin JB, Duplantier J-M, Chanteau S (2000) Xenopsylla cheopis (Siphonaptera: Xenopsyllinae), puces des foyers ruraux de peste des Hautes Terres malgaches: niveau de sensibilité au DDT, aux pyréthrinoïdes et aux carbamates après 50 années de lutte chimique. Arch Inst Pasteur Madagascar 66(1&2): 9–12.
- 21. Soderlund DM, Clark JM, Sheets LP, Mullin LS, Piccirillo VJ, et al. (2002) Mechanisms of pyrethroid neurotoxicity: implications for cumulative risk assessment. Toxicology 171(1): 3–59.
- 22. Kasai S, Shono T, Komagata O, Tsuda Y, Kobayashi M, et al. (2007) Insecticide resistance in potential vector mosquitoes for West Nile virus in Japan. Journal of Medical Entomology 44(5): 822–829.
- 23. Sikes RS, Gannon WL (2011) Guidelines of the American Society of Mammalogists for the use of wild mammals in research. Journal of Mammalogy 92(1): 235–253.
- 24. Rahelinirina S, Léon A, Harstskeerl RA, Sertour N, Ahmed A, et al. (2010) First isolation and direct evidence for the existence of large small-mammal reservoirs of Leptospira sp. in Madagascar. PloS one 5(11): e14111.
- 25. Tollenaere C, Brouat C, Duplantier JM, Rahalison L, Rahelinirina S, et al. (2010) Phylogeography of the introduced species Rattus rattus in the western Indian Ocean, with special emphasis on the colonization history of Madagascar. Journal of Biogeography 37(3): 398–410.
Duchemin J-B (2003) Biogéographie des puces de Madagascar. Thesis: Université de Paris XII - Val de Marne. Available: http://doxa.u-pec.fr:80/theses/th0212881.pdf
WHO (1970) Résistance aux insecticides et lutte antivectorielle: dix-septième rapport du Comité OMS d'experts des insecticides Genève: WHO. 306p p.
WHO (1981) Instructions for determining the susceptibility or resistance of fleas to insecticides. Genève: WHO. WHO/VBC/81.815 WHO/VBC/81.815. 1–6 p.
WHO (1976) Report of WHO Expert Committee: Resistance of Vectors and Reservoirs of disease to pesticide: twenty-second report of the WHO Expert Committee on Insecticides [meeting held in Geneva from 16 to 23 September 1975] Geneva: WHO.
WHO (1998) Test procedures for insecticide resistance monitoring in malaria vectors, bio-efficacy and persistence of insecticides on treated surfaces: report of the WHO informal consultation, Geneva, 28–30 September 1998. Genève: WHO. 43 p.
WHO (2011) The technical basis for coordinated action against insecticide resistance. 36 p.
- 32. Chandre F, Darriet Fdr, Manguin S, Brengues Cc, Carnevale P, et al. (1999) Pyrethroid cross resistance spectrum among populations of Anopheles gambiae ss from Cote d'Ivoire. Journal of the American Mosquito Control Association 15(1): 53–59.
- 33. Guedes RNC, Lima JOG, Santos JP, Cruz CD (1994) Inheritance of deltamethrin resistance in a Brazilian strain of maize weevil (Sitophilus zeamais Mots.). International Journal of Pest Management 40(1): 103–106.
- 34. Gratz NG, Traub R, Starcke H (1980) Problems and developments in the control of flea vectors of disease. AA Balkema 217–240.