Halyomorpha halys (Stål) (Heteroptera: Pentatomidae), the brown marmorated stink bug, is an invasive agricultural and nuisance pest rapidly expanding its incidence in North America. This voracious pest poses a significant threat to rural and urban agriculture, especially to specialty crops such as apples, grapes and ornamentals, as well as staple crops including soybean and corn. The object of this study was to generate transcript sequence resources for H. halys. RNA-seq libraries derived from distinct developmental stages and sexes were sequenced and assembled into 248,569 putatively unique transcripts (PUTs). PUTs were segmented into three disjoint tiers of varying reliability, with 4,794 classified as gold tier (highest quality), 16,878 as silver, and 14,357 as bronze. The gold-tier PUTs associated with 2,580 distinct non-redundant protein sequences from the NCBI NR database—1,785 of these (69%) mapped to annotated UniProtKB database proteins, from which 1,273 unique Pfam families and 459 unique Molecular Function GO terms were encountered. Of the silver tier's 6,527 PUTs associated with unique proteins, 4,193 mapped to UniProtKB (64%), from which 1,941 and 640 unique Pfam and Molecular Function GO terms were extracted. H. halys PUTs related to important life processes like immunity, endocrinology, reproduction, development, behavior, neurotransmission, neurotoxicity, olfaction, and small RNA pathways were validated through quantitative Real-Time PCR (qRT-PCR) for differential expression during distinct life stages (eggs, 2nd instar nymphs, 4th instar nymphs, female adults, male adults). PUTs similar to hypothetical proteins identified in symbiont microbes, including Pantoea and Nosema species, were more abundantly expressed in adults versus nymphs. These comprehensive H. halys transcriptomic resources can be utilized to aid development of novel control methodologies to disrupt life processes; to conduct reverse genetic screens to determine host gene function; and to design environmentally unobtrusive means to control host populations or target specific H. halys life stages, such as molecular biopesticides.
Citation: Sparks ME, Shelby KS, Kuhar D, Gundersen-Rindal DE (2014) Transcriptome of the Invasive Brown Marmorated Stink Bug, Halyomorpha halys (Stål) (Heteroptera: Pentatomidae). PLoS ONE 9(11): e111646. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0111646
Editor: Omprakash Mittapalli, The Ohio State University/OARDC, United States of America
Received: June 30, 2014; Accepted: October 3, 2014; Published: November 11, 2014
This is an open-access article, free of all copyright, and may be freely reproduced, distributed, transmitted, modified, built upon, or otherwise used by anyone for any lawful purpose. The work is made available under the Creative Commons CC0 public domain dedication.
Data Availability: The authors confirm that all data underlying the findings are fully available without restriction. These data have been made available at the NCBI Sequence Read Archive [SRA BioProject Acc. No. SRP040652].
Funding: The authors have no support or funding to report.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Halyomorpha halys (Stål) (Heteroptera: Pentatomidae), the brown marmorated stink bug (BMSB), is an invasive insect native to Asia (China, Taiwan, Korea, and Japan) that has emerged in the last decade as an important major insect pest in the United States, Canada and Europe and has become the top invasive insect research priority for the USDA Agricultural Research Service. H. halys is a polyphagous piercing/sucking feeder having over 300 known plant hosts. It poses a considerable ecological and economic threat—tens of billions of dollars annually—to specialty crops such as apples, stone and pome fruits, grapes, ornamental plants, vegetables, seed crops, as well as such staple crops as soybean and corn. H. halys has rapidly expanded its range from the original single point of accidental introduction and establishment in the Allentown, Pennsylvania area in the late 1990s . Damage has been particularly extensive in the U.S. Mid-Atlantic Region (DE, MD, PA, NJ, VA, and WV) and this voracious pest continues to spread. Currently, H. halys has been detected in 40 states and Canada , as well as Europe . In addition to its status as a major invasive agricultural pest, H. halys is also considered a structural nuisance pest as it invades homes and indoor spaces in high numbers in fall to overwinter as adults before re-emerging in spring .
The threat to agriculture from spread of H. halys populations has continued to increase, spurring development of management tools; these include traditional classical biological control strategies using natural enemies or predators , as well as development of novel management tools including pheromone lures for monitoring and trapping , , and newer biologically- and genetically-based control methods employing entomopathogenic  or molecular  biopesticides. The characterization of H. halys genomic and transcriptomic sequence data has been needed to aid development of novel, specifically-targeted, effective and environmentally sound means to mitigate the extensive damage produced by this insect, and to slow its aggressive geographic expansion. Because H. halys represents one of a broad group of agriculturally significant, highly invasive stink bug pests of the insect family Pentatomidae—which include southern green stink bug (Nezara viridula), green stink bug (Chinavia hilaris) , brown stink bug (Euschistus servus), and red-banded stink bug (Piezodorus guildinii), to name a few— the H. halys transcriptome is needed as a reference transcriptome for genetic marker development and comparative analyses of the functional array of transcripts deployed by this class of insects. The current study obtained a comprehensive RNA-Seq transcriptome dataset from four distinct H. halys developmental life stages (2nd instar nymphs, 4th instar nymphs, adult females, adult males); a set of high quality H. halys gene structures was delineated and functionally annotated, and the transcriptome-level activity at each developmental stage was assessed and compared. Differentially expressed transcripts were further validated across developmental stages by quantitative real time PCR (qRT-PCR) analyses to gain insight into stage-specific genes that could serve as targets for improved biopesticides. In addition, these H. halys transcript resources will be critical for annotation of the H. halys genome (currently in process), as well as enabling identification of inherent defense mechanisms against proposed control measures, the ability to defend against entomopathogens, and mechanisms that may enable resistance development.
Results and Discussion
Qualitative analysis of H. halys RNA-Seq data
Figure 1 shows the RNA-Seq assembly and analysis pipeline used in this study, which is further detailed in Materials and Methods. The 439,615,225 RNA-Seq reads surviving quality control procedures were assembled into a total of 248,569 putatively unique transcripts (PUTs). Of these, 4,794 were classified into the gold tier, 16,878 into the silver, and 14,357 into the bronze. The gold-tier PUTs associated with 2,580 distinct non-redundant protein sequences obtained from the NCBI NR database—1,785 of these NR proteins (69%) could be mapped to annotated proteins in the Swiss-Prot subset of the UniProtKB database, from which 1,273 unique Pfam families and 459 unique GO terms from the Molecular Function aspect were encountered. (Gold-tier PUT sequences and their associated annotations are available in Table S1.) The process was similarly repeated for the silver-tiered data: Of the silver tier's 6,527 unique GI numbers, 4,193 mapped to UniProtKB entries (64%), from which 1,941 and 640 unique Pfam and Molecular Function-specific GO terms were extracted. Figures 2 and 3 illustrate the relative abundances of the ten most frequently encountered Pfam family definitions and GO Molecular Function terms encountered in this data set, respectively.
Following data cleaning and assembly into putatively unique transcripts (PUTs), the H. halys gene space captured by these data was functionally annotated using information collected from the highly reliable Swiss-Prot subset of UniProtKB. RNA-Seq data was also used quantitatively, in order to identify potential differentially expressed genes for further validation using qRT-PCR assays.
For each of the gold and silver PUT tiers, the ten Pfam families most frequently encountered among associated Swiss-Prot exemplars, and their relative abundances, are indicated.
Terms obtained from the Molecular Function aspect of the Gene Ontology were analyzed for their frequency of occurrence in this PUT dataset. The ten terms most frequently encountered among associated Swiss-Prot exemplars, and their relative abundances, are presented.
A total of 31 genes were apparently highly differentially expressed, exhibiting a 20-fold or greater difference in expression levels in the 2nd-instar versus 4th-instar comparison. In the nymphs versus adult comparison, 41 genes were highly (20+ fold) differentially expressed; in the nymphs versus adults comparison, 150 genes were highly differentially expressed. Table 1 shows the five genes having the greatest level of perturbation for each of the three comparisons made, and Table S1 shows RNA-Seq-inferred fold differences in gene expression as observed for all genes.
qRT-PCR-based validation of H. halys expressed transcripts
Numerous H. halys differentially expressed transcripts were associated with functions in critical life processes, including immune response, endocrinology, reproduction, growth, development, behavior, neurotransmission, neurotoxicity, olfaction, detoxification, insecticide resistance, and other categories. Individual H. halys transcripts examined using gene-specific primers (detailed in Table S2) displayed a variety of interesting differential expression patterns observed in males versus females and across discrete developmental stages, and these correlated well to initial RNA-seq profiles. For example, various tubulin-related and heat shock protein genes were found to be more highly expressed in males versus females; females had higher expression levels of orthodenticle; the egg-related gene, vitellogenin-2; and a decaprenyl diphosphate synthase subunit 1-like gene associated with coenzyme Q production . A LIM homeobox transcription factor beta gene was found preferentially expressed in early nymphal stages (Figure 4). Most patterns were expected; for example, vitellogenin encodes the vitellin protein present in oocytes, and is expressed as an egg yolk precursor in female insects and in the hemolymph of drones and sterile worker bees, as well as in other insects , . LIM homeobox transcription factor beta, highly expressed in early instar nymphs, is an evolutionarily conserved gene important in gene regulation during embryonic and early stages of development , particularly limb development. The phosphopantothenoylcysteine decarboxylase/phosphopantothenate-cysteine ligase, which functions in coenzyme A biosynthesis, was preferentially highly expressed in H. halys eggs and appears to have originated from gammaproteobacteria. The high levels of expression in eggs with substantial expression in adult females suggest this could be associated with symbionts vertically transmitted to eggs by adult females , .
Three biological replicates with three technical replicates each were performed. Bar height denotes the mean average of sample-specific 2-ΔCt values, and error bars represent the standard error of the mean. Thirty-two selected transcripts are shown including certain genes predominantly expressed in adult males (e.g., Golgi phosphoprotein 3-like and tubulin beta chain); predominantly expressed in adult females (e.g., orthodonticle proteins, vitellogenin-2, decaprenyl diphosphate synthase subunit 1-like); predominantly expressed in nymphs (e.g., LIM-homeobox transcription factor beta, BTB/POZ domain containing protein KCTD16-like); and those differentially expressed across various life stages (e.g., apolipoprotein D-like, neuronal calcium sensor). The transcript identified as TcasGA2_TC003453 associates with the NCBI NR protein having GI no. 270004135.
Detection of abundant symbiont-associated H. halys transcripts: Pantoea, Nosema, and other spp. and a novel iflavirus
A large percentage of abundantly expressed H. halys transcripts originated from apparent microbial organisms, including Pantoea and Nosema species as well as other microbes (Nosema transcripts detailed in Tables 1 and 2, additional microbial transcripts detailed in Table S3). This was not surprising based on recent evidence highlighting the importance of gut symbionts in the overall survival and success of H. halys in the field : Surface sterilization of eggs to remove vertically transmitted gut colonizing bacteria (primarily Pantoea agglomerans) resulted in smaller clutches in the first generation and dramatically reduced survivorship in the second generation. Bansal et al  recently examined the gammaproteobacterial endosymbiont harbored in midgut gastric caeca and identified Candidatus “Pantoea carbekii”, a close relative of P. agglomerans, as the primary bacterial symbiont of H. halys based on 16S rRNA sequences. In the present H. halys transcriptome data, more than 50 PUTs similar to hypothetical proteins from various Pantoea species were identified and were more abundantly expressed in adults versus nymphs (nymphs: 2nd and 4th instars combined). Over 20 PUTs similar to hypothetical proteins of Nosema ceranae, a honeybee parasite, were also more abundantly expressed in H. halys adults versus nymphs, as well as PUTs homologous to ribosomal and histone proteins identified in the silkworm parasite, Nosema bombycis (Table 2 and Table S1). PCR amplification of 18S rRNA confirmed presence of a novel Nosema species in H. halys adults—these genes were preferentially expressed in males relative to females (Figure 5). Interestingly, several H. halys individuals field collected in Maryland did not display detectable Nosema species infections (data not shown), which may indicate the Beltsville lab colony is distinct in this regard. No Wolbachia-associated transcripts were identified in the H. halys transcriptome, nor were any detected by DNA PCR using Wolbachia-specific primers (data not shown), though Wolbachia have been observed in association with H. halys . Finally, by similar comparative PUT analyses and methodologies, a novel RNA iflavirus was recognized and discovered as being associated with H. halys; this iflavirus was the subject of a prior publication .
A) PCR confirmation of a Nosema sp. 18S rRNA gene from cDNA. Amplicon sequencing confirmed a Nosema origin of the 472bp band (data not shown). B) qRT-PCR amplification of a histone protein gene similar to a homologous instance from Nosema bombycis. C) qRT-PCR amplification of a protein similar to a hypothetical protein identified in Nosema ceranae.
Immunity-related transcripts identified in H. halys non-induced and immune-induced transcriptome
Insects have complex immune systems that enable them to defend against infections by microbial pathogens. These immune responses are critical to insect survival and must be overcome to effect biological control; thus immune-related PUTs were examined in detail for H. halys. All key components of the innate insect immune response were identified in H. halys, including core immune signaling, cellular response/immobilization, and RNA interference pathways (discussed separately below). The immune response is triggered in response to systemic infection by pathogen-associated molecular patterns (PAMPs) such as bacterial cell wall or flagellar components in the presence of host damage-associated molecular patterns and chemokines . Pattern recognition receptors located on hemocytes and other tissues bind PAMPs, activating signal transduction pathways that induce antimicrobial peptide biosynthesis. Insects possess an innate immune defense separated into humoral and cell-mediated responses, which may be constitutive or induced following microbial incursion. Though no attempt was made in this study to induce the H. halys immune response with microbial elicitors, it was expected that some constitutively expressed components would be present. Surprisingly, several inducible response components were noted in non-immune-stimulated H. halys (Figure 4). It is possible that expression of inducible immune pathway gene components is elevated in response to the possible presence of microbial pathogens, including species from the genus Pantoea (summarized in Tables 1 and 2, as well as Table S3). Among the PAMPS, pattern recognition receptors, and immune-associated PUTs expressed in the non-immune-induced H. halys transcriptome were peptidoglycan recognition protein S2, peptidoglycan-recognition protein precursor, and pattern recognition serine proteinase precursor. Increased expression of selected putative immune-related PUTs was subsequently confirmed by qRT-PCR of immune-induced male and female adults 24 hours following immune induction by non-sterile septic puncture (Figure 6). Proteins responsible for immune recognition of foreign glycoproteins were identified, including C-type lectins, hemocytin, scavenger receptor, and leucine-rich repeat proteins. C-type lectin was up-regulated 4.2-fold and a scavenger receptor PUT up-regulated 2.6-fold in immune-induced adult males (Figure 6).
Three biological replicates with three technical replicates were performed. Bar height denotes the mean average of sample-specific 2-ΔCt values, and error bars represent the standard error of the mean. Twenty-eight selected transcripts are shown including those associated with immune response (e.g., toll, vitellogenin, ecdysone response nuclear receptor, group III chitinase-like, metalloprotease, ecdysone receptor isoform A, DOPA decarboxylase, Adam 17-like, ABC transporter, scavenger receptor class B, ACYP1004583, arginine kinase, C-type lectin, ferritin, innexin); energy metabolism (e.g., methionine-r-sulfoxide reductase, glutathione reductase family, dual oxidase, peroxiredoxin-4-4like, arginine kinase, glutathione-s-transferase, protein disulfide isomerase); and the oxidative stress response (e.g., Met-r-sulfoxide reductase, catalase, dual oxidase, peroxiredoxin-4-4like, nitric oxide synthase, superoxide dismutase, ferritin). The transcript identified as ACYPI004583 associates with the NCBI NR protein having GI no. 239791403.
Pathogen invasion activates core innate immune signaling pathways, including Toll, Imd, and JAK/STAT . These pathways effect the production of a suite of antimicrobial peptides, enzymes, and inhibitors that limit growth of pathogens . H. halys PUTs homologous to Toll pathway components included nuclear factor kappa-B kinase, spaetzle, spaetzle 4, spatzle 5, dorsal and snake. PUTs homologous to antibacterial peptides of other insects identified included an antibacterial peptide homolog of Tribolium castaneum hyphantrin and a lysozyme transcript—these are normally expressed at extremely low levels in uninfected insects, but were relatively abundant in H. halys. Immune stimulation slightly up-regulated a Toll-like PUT by 1.2-fold in adult males and 1.5-fold in females (Figure 6). Within Heteroptera, the model insect Rhodnius prolixus, closely related to H. halys, has been shown to possess components of the insect signal transduction eicosanoid pathway interacting with trypanosomal and bacterial infection , . Homologs of eicosanoid pathway components were noted in the H. halys non-induced transcriptome assembly, including a calcium-independent phospholipase A2 enzyme, phospholipase A2-activating protein, 15-hydroxyprostaglandin dehydrogenase, prostaglandin E synthase, prostaglandin GH synthase, and prostaglandin reductase.
Many constitutively expressed proteins related to the cellular mobilization response (phagocytosis, autophagy, melanization, and coagulation) were sampled in H. halys, such as homologs of cadherin, annexin, cell adhesion molecule 3, hemicentins and beta-integrins. PUTs encoding an engulfment and cell motility protein and lingerer were identified. A PUT corresponding to an insect gap junction protein, innexin, was identified, suggesting monomers involved in gap junction formation following cellular activation were present; this innexin was up-regulated 3.9-fold in immune-stimulated males, but was not up-regulated in immune-stimulated females (Figure 6). Components of the melanization reaction, which is catalysed by phenoloxidase and initiates synthesis of melanin, leading to crosslinked proteins and cytotoxic free radicals , , , were numerous. Transcripts corresponding to prophenoloxidase, putative serpins, and serine proteases of the prophenoloxidase regulatory cascade were recognized: these included a full length homolog of prophenol oxidase subunit 2, as well as prophenoloxidase activating factor, serpins, clip-domain serine protease, and hemolymph proteinase-5. Clip-domain serine protease expression was increased 3.2-fold as a result of activation of the immune response (Figure 6). Additional melanization pathway enzymes such as DOPA decarboxylase, dopamine N-acetyltransferase, and dopachrome conversion enzyme, and laccases were up-regulated; DOPA decarboxylase was increased 1.8-fold in females and 4.3-fold in immune-stimulated males (Figure 6). Additionally laccase, multicopper oxidases, Ebony, and proteins associated with cuticular melanization and coloration were identified, with laccase transcription elevated 3.1-fold in immune-stimulated males (Figure 6). Phenoloxidase-activated hemolymph coagulation defence pathways are utilized against multicellular invaders . Components of these pathways were identified in H. halys, including transcripts encoding anticoagulant serine protease, clotting factor B-like, coagulation factor XI, proclotting enzyme-like, limulus clotting factor c and a multiple coagulation factor deficiency protein.
Cytotoxic reactive oxygen and nitrogen species generated by hemocytes and other tissues elicit a non-specific defense against all invaders . H. halys PUTs similar to the plasma membrane reactive oxygen generator NADPH oxidase, which drives the respiratory burst phenomenon , and nitric oxide synthase, an antimicrobial free nitrogen radical generator , were identified. Enzymes responsible for inactivation of reactive oxygen species—for example, superoxide dismutase (up-regulated 1.7-fold in immune-stimulated females; 6.2-fold in males) and catalase (up-regulated 1.4-fold in immune-stimulated males and females)—were identified. Dual oxidase transcripts were elevated 2.1-fold in females, and 4.8-fold in immune-stimulated males (Figure 6). A transcript encoding the iron storage and transporting protein ferritin was up-regulated 3.9-fold in immune-stimulated males (Figure 6).
Up-regulation of arginine kinase transcription suggested that immune stimulation altered energy metabolism. Arginine kinase levels were elevated 2.3-fold and 2.7-fold, respectively, in immune-stimulated males and females (Figure 6).
Transcripts Related to Endocrinology, Reproduction, Growth and Development
Both male and female adults were sampled separately, resulting in identification of assemblies homologous to reproduction-related transcripts of other insects. Proteins required for vitellogenesis, follicle and egg maturation–including vitellogenin and vitellogenin carboxypeptidases, vitelline membrane proteins, and chorion peroxidases–were identified. qRT-PCR results demonstrated differential expression of vitellogenin in adult females (Figure 4). This protein is synthesized and secreted by the fat body and shuttled to developing follicles in the ovaries. Vitellogenin transcripts were up-regulated by septic puncture of adult females (Figure 6), which was expected since its increased transcription is a known insect antibacterial response . Transcripts encoding components of the male reproductive system also were noted, among them testis- and spermatogenesis-related proteins; sperm membrane proteins; sperm flagellar components; and ejaculatory and accessory gland proteins comprising proteases and aconitase.
H. halys undergoes incomplete metamorphosis, molting through five nymphal stadia to become an adult. Insect molting is rigorously choreographed, regulated by precise timing of release of several peptide hormones, and coordinated fluctuations in the titers of both juvenile hormone and ecdysone. Disruption of the molting process through chemical means, including growth and development hormone mimics, has been a promising method of insect control . Plant-expressed RNAi targeting the insect-specific metamorphosis regulation gene HaHR3 was shown to be lethal in Helicoverpa armigera . Thus, acquisition of tools to study this vital life process in H. halys was an objective of this study. Inclusion of an RNA pool containing earlier nymphal instars and molting individuals allowed sampling of H. halys nymphal and adult cuticular proteins, resulting in the identification of PUTs putatively involved in cuticle assembly, pigmentation and integrity (e.g., chitin synthase, chitin deacetylase, chitotriosidase, laccases, cuticulins). Peritrophin and chitin-binding peritrophin precursor PUTs were also identified. Peptide hormones and corresponding receptors utilized during development and molting were recognized in H. halys, including prothoracicotropic hormone, allatostatin and its receptor, bursicon, eclosion hormone, and ecdysis triggering hormone precursor. Contigs orthologous to enzymes in the insect steroid synthesis/degradation pathways also were identified (17-β-hydroxysteroid dehydrogenases, 7-dehydrocholesterol reductase, sterol desaturases, and sterol o-acyltransferases) as well as PUTs similar to the isoprenoid juvenile hormone (JH) synthesis and degradation enzymes of other insects, including JH acid methyltransferases, JH epoxide hydrolases, JH esterases, epoxide hydrolases, and farnesoic acid O-methyltransferase. Also present were homologs of known haemocoelic hormone transporters such as lipophorins, JH binding proteins, oxysterol binding proteins and sterol carrier proteins.
Additional peptide hormones and receptors involved in regulation of metabolism were identified, including leptin receptor-like protein, calcitonin and its receptor, cardioacceleratory peptide receptor, gonadotropin-releasing hormone receptor-like, PDGF- and VEGF-related factors, octopamine receptor, retinoid X receptor, and tachykinin receptor. Also present were PUTs for the corticotropin releasing factor/diuretic hormone and CAPA receptor, 5-hydroxytryptamine receptor system regulating diuresis in R. prolixus . H. halys PUTs for insulin and mTOR pathways involved in energy metabolism included glycogen synthase, glycogen debranching enzyme, glycogen phosphorylase, trehalase, trehalose 6-phosphate synthase, insulin-like peptide, insulin-like peptide receptor, insulin receptor substrate, and insulin-degrading enzyme.
Eggs were included as a developmental stage in qRT-PCR analyses, though sampling all stages of embryonic development was not undertaken. A number of H. halys PUTs homologous to developmental proteins identified in other insects were identified, including instances of armadillo, caudal, bicaudal, bicoid, decapentaplegic, mothers against decapentaplegic, and ultrabithorax. Availability of these sequences should facilitate evolutionary developmental (evo-devo) studies using hemipteran bugs as an experimental system.
Transcripts Related to Behavior, Neurotransmission, Neurotoxicity, and Olfaction
Insect nervous systems have a critical role in coordinating all behaviors, from vision and locomotion, to mating and host plant location. Many PUTs similar to neurotransmitter receptors, G-protein coupled receptors, and enzymes involved in neurotransmitter synthesis/degradation were identified. Resistance to (or detoxification of) insecticides and plant-based toxic secondary metabolites are major contributors to the survival of herbivorous insects. Insect detoxification enzymes include cytochrome P450s and esterases, and many distinct homologs of these were present in H. halys. Glutathione S-transferase transcript levels were elevated 9.8-fold in females subjected to septic puncture, and 6.1-fold in males (Figure 6). Numerous multidrug transporters and ABC transporters responsible for xenobiotics efflux were noted. Transcripts encoding genes involved in olfaction and gustation were also present, including odorant binding and receptor PUTs, olfactory receptors, pheromone binding and degrading enzymes, and signal transduction pathway intermediates.
Transcripts Related to Small RNA Pathways
Components either directly composing or associated with the double-stranded (ds) RNA processing systems required for effective gene silencing in insects were present in H. halys. Transcripts encoding proteins involved in dsRNA cleavage and endonuclease activity, including cytoplasmic subunit argonaute-2, piwi, dicer-2, helicases, and RISC-loading complex subunits, were discernable. Interestingly, no sid or sid-like  PUTs were detected; these have been reported in all insect systems (except dipterans) to be involved in initial dsRNA uptake and transport pathways . PUTs for scavenger receptors and lipophorins, thought to have roles in cellular uptake of RNA , , were found in H. halys assemblies.
Insect transcriptomes have become critical for evaluation of differential transcript expression profiles for biotechnological use , and a principal motivation in this study was to identify suitable gene silencing targets for ongoing H. halys control research efforts. Numerous differentially-expressed or stage-specific PUTs identified constitute excellent targets for further experimentation. For example, dsRNA synthesized from Anthonomus grandis chitin synthase 1 gene has been shown in injected cotton boll weevil female adults to silence chitin synthase 1, and has similarly been reported for silencing the laccase gene . Both transcripts are highly and differentially expressed in H. halys. Several bacterial symbiont-associated transcripts also represent gene silencing targets, including those associated with symbiont microbial species.
Collectively, the H. halys transcriptome identifies a wide variety of differentially expressed transcripts, providing a reliable source of candidate genes involved in key physiological processes. This resource will enable multiple control projects for this insect pest, especially those targeting specific life stages, including identification and characterization of pathological agents with possible utility for the biological control of H. halys populations  and the identification of novel RNAi targets, including both bacterial symbionts and key H. halys transcripts associated with specific life stages or sexes. These sequence resources will also facilitate annotation of the H. halys genome, and provide a needed reference for comparative transcriptomics with other species of stink bug pests. Likewise, genes induced in certain H. halys life stages (e.g., vitellogenin-2 and tubulin) or associated with specific biological systems (e.g., ecdysone-related peptide binding proteins, laccase, chitin synthase and cytochrome p450) represent key genes for further assessment, and RNAi-based gene knockdown experiments are currently in progress. If they prove to be sufficiently species-specific, these genes could suggest possible targets for RNAi-mediated gene disruption that may be useful towards diminishing this destructive insect pest.
Materials and Methods
Insect Rearing and Dissection
H. halys (BMSB) insects were reared as previously described  in a colony maintained at USDA-ARS in the Beltsville Agricultural Research Center, Beltsville, MD; this colony was established in 2007 from adults collected in Allentown, PA, and supplemented annually with several Beltsville, MD-collected individuals. Briefly, insects were reared in ventilated plastic cylinders (21×21 cm OD) on a diet of organic green beans, shelled sunflower and buckwheat seeds (2∶1, w/w), and distilled water supplied in cotton-stopped shell vials. Eggs were collected weekly, hatched in plastic Petri dishes with a water vial and, after molting to second-instars, nymphs were transferred to larger rearing cages for the remaining four instars. Adults, males and females were separated 1 to 2 days post emergence, and subsequently maintained in different containers. Insects were maintained in Thermo Forma chambers (Thermo Fisher Scientific) at 25°C and 72% relative humidity, under a 16L:8D photoperiod. Insects of all developmental life stages were collected for RNA extraction, including eggs that originated from a single non-washed egg mass collected <20h after laying. Four discrete developmental life stages were selected for transcriptome analyses: 2nd-instar nymphs, 4th-instar nymphs, adult males and adult females. Adult males and females were seven days old and had reached maturity. A separate set of adult male and female individuals were also immune-stimulated by septic puncture to the ventral side using a non-sterile minutien pin, followed by RNA extraction 24 hours after puncture, to facilitate analyses of immunity-related and other transcripts.
In each of the four developmental life stages characterized, five individuals were pooled and placed in a tube on ice to calm the insects. Tubes were then placed in liquid nitrogen for approximately 30 sec. Denaturing solution provided from the Totally RNA kit (Life Technologies, Grand Island, NY) was added to the tubes totaling 5 ml. Using an ultra-turrax T25, samples were homogenized until all individuals were fully dispersed (1–2 min., depending on insect size) and samples were placed on ice. RNA was extracted immediately thereafter following the Totally RNA protocol. RNAs were aliquoted as 10 µg in 100 µl of DEPC-treated water and stored at −80°C until sent to University of Georgia Genomics Facility for RNA-seq processing.
RNA-Seq Library Construction and Sequencing
TruSeq RNA libraries were prepared from total RNA. rRNA depletion was performed, and SE100 reads were sequenced from resulting libraries using an Illumina HiSeq 1000 instrument. These data have been made available at the NCBI Sequence Read Archive [SRA BioProject Acc. No. SRP040652].
The FASTX-toolkit (http://hannonlab.cshl.edu/fastx_toolkit) was used to clean sequenced reads. The process eliminated artifact reads, and terminal spans of bases having Phred scores less than 21 were clipped, thereby forcing read ends to have error rates of less than 1%. Trimmed reads of less than 36 bases were purged, as were reads for which 10% or more of bases had a Phred score of 20 or less. Among surviving reads, bases having Phred quality scores of less than 21 were masked with the symbol ‘N’. In total, 58% of reads originally sequenced were retained for analysis, as well as 58% of bases originally sequenced (see Table 3).
Sequence Analysis and de novo assembly of transcripts
Figure 1 presents a graphical overview of the RNA-Seq data analysis approach used. Cleaned RNA-Seq reads were globally pooled and assembled into putatively unique transcripts (PUTs) using the Trinity assembler . These were aligned to the non-redundant protein database, NCBI NR, using Blastx . Homology information was used to identify PUTs that were likely non-spurious, and these were partitioned into three mutually exclusive sets on the basis of alignment quality. The gold-tier gene set represented the most highly reliable set of transcripts, and inclusion required that the associated Blastx hit consisted of a single high-scoring segment pair (HSP), that the PUT query was at least 300 bases in length, that the alignment's subject sequence (i.e., an NR protein) was at least 100 amino acid residues in length, that 75% or more of aligned residues were positively similar, and that the ratio of hit length to subject sequence length was at least 90%. Only the top-scoring hit per PUT was considered. End sequences from PUTs that were not incorporated into Blastx-derived alignments were clipped, and the remaining coding sequences were translated into high-quality H. halys protein sequences using the EMBOSS package's Transeq utility . For inclusion in the silver-tier gene class, a PUT had to be at least 100 nucleotides in length and exhibit a hit length covering at least 75% of the NR subject sequence's length. Finally, PUTs of the bronze-tier class were required to be at least 100 nucleotides long and have a hit covering at least 30% of the NR protein's length.
To identify functional capacity in the gold-tiered data, GI numbers for these PUTs' best NCBI NR exemplars were mapped to UniProtKB entries using the “ID Mapping” tab from the UniProt website . These mappings enabled the transfer of associated GO, Pfam and KEGG annotation terms from UniProtKB entries onto H. halys gold-tier PUTs. Immune-, developmental- and olfaction-related transcripts contained in the silver and bronze data tiers were identified using GO and InterPro descriptors generated with Blast2GO . Significant hits were confirmed by multiple sequence alignment to homologous arthropod transcripts.
Sample-specific Gene Expression Quantification
Following quantitative protocols established in a previous insect transcriptome investigation , RNA-Seq data were used to suggest potentially up- or down-regulated genes among the gold-tier gene set. Three comparisons were performed: 4th instar against 2nd instar, adult female against adult male, and nymph against adult. No pooling of sequencing lanes was necessary for the first two of these comparisons, though for the last, the 4th and 2nd instar nymph data were pooled to create the nymphal representation, and the adult female and male samples were pooled to create the adult test set. To generate sample-specific gene expression levels, unassembled, cleaned reads were aligned to trimmed gold-tier PUT sequences using Blat . An aligned read incremented a PUT's digital expression level if not less than 95% of its length aligned with 100% sequence identity. If a read mapped to multiple PUTs under these criteria, only its highest-scoring alignment was considered. (If multiple alignments shared this highest score, at most one representative PUT was chosen on an arbitrary basis.) In cases where multiple gold-tier PUTs corresponded to the same NR protein—resulting from such phenomena as gene duplication or alternative splicing—then the counts of all such PUTs were summed and attributed to the responsible protein coding gene. Normalization of the resulting digital expression counts was performed by dividing each protein coding gene's absolute digital count by the total number of unassembled, cleaned reads in the sample. Fold differences in relative gene expression levels were ranked to suggest differentially expressed H. halys genes. These candidate transcripts were then flagged for further inspection using qRT-PCR.
Validation of select transcripts using quantitative real-time PCR (qRT-PCR)
A panel of H. halys genes having RNA-Seq fold-level changes suggesting significant differential gene expression was statistically validated using qRT-PCR analysis, performed using three biological and three technical replicates. Quantitative real-time expression experiments were conducted using primers designed from PUT templates with PrimerPlex 2.62 (PREMIER Biosoft, Palo Alto, CA); primer sequences are provided in Table S2. In addition to 2nd and 4th instar, adult male and adult female cDNAs, qRT-PCR was performed for an egg mass sample. Reactions were conducted using an ABI 7500 Real Time PCR System (Applied Biosystems, Carlsbad CA). For each replicate, first strand cDNA was synthesized from 1–5 ug RNA using Superscript Reverse Transcriptase II (Life Technologies, Carlsbad, CA). Each qRT-PCR reaction consisted of 6.25 µl of Power SYBR Green PCR Master Mix (Life Technologies, Carlsbad, CA), 50 ng of diluted cDNA and 1 µM of each primer in a total volume of 12.5 µl. Reactions were performed in triplicate to ensure consistent technical replication and run in 96-well plates under the following conditions: 50°C for 2 min, 95°C for 10 min, and 40 cycles of 95°C for 15 sec and 60°C for 1 min. Melting curves (60°C to 95°C) were derived for each reaction to ensure a single product. Relative gene expression was evaluated with DataAssist Software version 3.0 (Applied Biosystems/Life Technologies), using H. halys 18S rRNA and the ER-associated endoreticulocalbin housekeeping gene  as endogenous controls for RNA load and gene expression, respectively. 18S rRNA is commonly used for control purposes in quantitative eukaryotic transcriptome studies , and endoreticulocalbin was bioinformatically identified as a quality expression control gene for H. halys normalization—its transcription level was shown to be the most minimally perturbed across all three comparisons and suitable primers could be designed for it using the PrimerPlex software. A basic geometric argument demonstrated its expression consistency: Because fold changes in gene expression levels were calculated by placing the greater abundance level in the ratio's numerator, these ratios are strictly ≥1 for instances in which counts were detected in both samples being compared (i.e., both numerator and denominator were positive-valued). Thus, in three-dimensional space, an idealized reference point denoting an unperturbed transcript is (x,y,z) = (1,1,1), where x, y and z denote 4th instar versus 2nd instar, adult female versus adult male, and nymph versus adult comparisons, respectively. Reticulocalbin minimized the Euclidean distance from this reference point (data not shown), which was calculated using the equation:in which variables x, y and z correspond to the absolute fold change values for the three comparisons listed above.
Halyomorpha halys gold-tier PUTs BLAST2GO annotations using the NCBI NR database.
Primers designed in this study for Halyomorpha halys qRT-PCR transcript validation, including GenBank gene identifying information for each transcript.
Select microbial-origin transcripts identified in the Halyomorpha halys transcriptome that exhibit possible differential gene expression according to fold changes in RNA-Seq read abundances. Data are presented for three comparisons: 2nd instar versus 4th instar, male adults versus female adults, and adults (males and females combined) versus nymphs (2nd and 4th instar combined).
The authors thank Robert Bennett and Megan Herlihy for rearing insects used in this study.
Conceived and designed the experiments: DEGR. Performed the experiments: MES KSS DK. Analyzed the data: MES KSS DK DEGR. Wrote the paper: MES KSS DK DEGR.
- 1. Xu J, Fonseca DM, Hamilton GC, Hoelmer KA, Nielson AL (2014) Tracing the origin of US brown marmorated stink bugs, Halyomorpha halys. Biological Invasions 16: 153–166.
- 2. Leskey TC, Hamilton G, Nielsen A, Polk D, Rodrigues-Saona C, et al. (2012) Pest status of the brown marmorated stink bug, Halyomorpha halys (Stål) in the USA. Outlooks on Pest Management 23: 218–226.
- 3. Zhu G, Bu W, Gao Y, Liu G (2012) Potential geographic distribution of brown marmorated stink bug invasion (Halymorpha halys). PLOS One 7: e31246.
- 4. Khrimian A, Zhang A, Weber DC, Ho H-Y, Aldrich JR, et al. (2014) Discovery of the aggregation pheromone of the brown marmorated stink bug (Halyomorpha halys) through the creation of stereoisomeric libraries of 1-bisabolen-3-ols. Journal of Natural Products (in press). doi: 10.1021/np5003753
- 5. Weber DC, Leskey TC, Cabrera Walsh G, Khrimian A (2014) Synergy of aggregation pheromone with methyl (E,E,Z)-2,4,6-decatrienoate in attraction of Halyomorpha halys (Hemiptera: Pentatomidae). Journal of Economic Entomology 107: 1061–1068.
- 6. Gouli V, Gouli S, Skinner M, Hamilton G, Kim JS, et al. (2012) Virulence of select entomopathogenic fungi to the brown marmorated stink bug, Halyomorpha halys (Stal) (Heteroptera: Pentatomidae). Pest Manag Sci 68: 155–157.
- 7. Hunter WB, VanEngelsdorp D, Hayes J, Westervelt, et al (2010) Large-scale field application of RNAi technology reducing Israeli Acute Paralysis Virus disease in Honey Bees (Apis mellifera, Hymenoptera: Apidae). PLOS Pathogens 6: e1001160.
- 8. van Kretschmar JBD, Donahue KV, Cabrera AR, Magalhaes LC, Sorenson CE, et al. (2012) Illumina sequencing of green stink bug nymph and adult cDNA to identify potential RNAi gene targets. Beltwide Cotton Conf: 1090–1096.
- 9. Zhang H, Li ZX (2013) In vitro and in vivo characterization of a novel insect decaprenyl diphosphate synthase: a two major step catalytic mechanism is proposed. Biochem Biophys Res Commun 442: 105–111
- 10. Engels W, Kaatz H, Zillikens A, Simoes ZLP, Trube A, et al. (1990) Honey bee reproduction: vitellogenin and caste-specific regulation of fertility. Advances in Invertebrate Reproduction 5: 495–502.
- 11. Hrassnigg N, Crailsheim K (2005) Differences in drone and worker physiology in honeybees (Apis mellifera). Apidologie 36: 255–277.
- 12. Hobert O, Westphal H (2000) Functions of LIM-homeobox genes. Trends Genet 16(2): 75–83.
- 13. Taylor CM, Coffey PL, DeLay BD, Dively GP (2014) The Importance of Gut Symbionts in the Development of the Brown Marmorated Stink Bug, Halyomorpha halys (Stål). PLoS ONE 9(3): e90312
- 14. Bansal R, Michel AP, Sabree ZL (2014) The Crypt-Dwelling Primary Bacterial Symbiont of the Polyphagous Pentatomid Pest Halyomorpha halys (Hemiptera: Pentatomidae). Environmental Entomology 43(3): 617–625.
- 15. Sparks ME, Gundersen-Rindal DE, Harrison RL (2013) Complete genome sequence of a novel Iflavirus from the transcriptome of Halymorpha halys, the brown marmorated stink bug. Genome Announcements 1: e00910–00913.
- 16. Blander JM, Sander LE (2012) Beyond pattern recognition: five immune checkpoints for scaling the microbial threat. Nature Revs Immunol 12: 215–225.
- 17. Jiang H, Vilcinskas A, Kanost MR (2011) Immunity in Lepidopteran insects. Invertebrate Immunity. pp.163–180.
- 18. Deffarari MS, Lee DH, Fernandes CL, Orchard I, Carlini CR (2013) A phospholipase A2 gene is linked to jack bean urease toxicity in the Chagas' disease vector Rhodnius prolixus. Biochimica Biophysica Acta 1840: 396–405.
- 19. Garcia ES, Castro DP, Figueiredo MB, Genta FA, Azambuja P (2009) Trypanosoma rangeli: a new perspective for styding the modulation of immune reactions of Rhodnius prolixus. Parasites and Vectors 2: 33.
- 20. Nappi AJ, Christensen BM (2005) Melanogenesis and associated cytotoxic reactions: Applications to insect innate immunity. Insect Biochemistry and Molecular Biology 35: 443–449.
- 21. Kanost MR, Gorman MJ (2008) Phenoloxidases in insect immunity. In: Beckage N, editor.Insect Immunology. 1 ed.New York: Academic Press. pp.69–96.
- 22. Schmidt O, Soderhall K, Theopold U, Faye I (2010) Role of adhesion in arthropod immune recognition. Annual Review of Entomology 54: 485–504.
- 23. Broderick NA, Welchman DP, Lemaitre B (2009) Recognition and response to microbial infection in Drosophila. In: Rolff J, Reynolds SE, editors.Insect Infection and Immunity: Evolution, Ecology, and Mechanisms.New York: Oxford University Press. pp.13–33.
- 24. Renwick J, Reeves EP, Wientjes FB, Kavanagh K (2007) Translocation of proteins homologous to human neutrophil p47phox and p67phox to the cell membrane in activated hemocytes of Galleria mellonella. Dev Comp Immunol 31: 347–359.
- 25. Eleftherianos I, Felfoldi G, ffrench-Constant RH, Reynolds SE (2009) Induced nitric oxide synthesis in the gut of Manduca sexta protects against oral infection by the bacterial pathogen Photorhabdus luminescens. Insect Molecular Biology 18: 507–516.
- 26. Singh NK, Pakkianathan BC, Kumar M, Prasad T, Kannan M, et al. (2013) Vitellogenin from the Silkworm, Bombyx mori: An Effective Anti-Bacterial Agent. PLoS ONE 8: e73005
- 27. Xiong Y, Zeng H, Zhang Y, Xu D, Qiu D (2013) Silencing the HaHR3 Gene by Transgenic Plant-mediated RNAi to Disrupt Helicoverpa armigera Development. Int J Biol Sci 9: 370–381
- 28. Paluzzi J-PV, Young P, Defferrari MS, Orchard I, Carlini CR, et al. (2012) Investigation of the potential involvement of eicosanoid metabolites in anti-diuretic hormone signaling in Rhodnius prolixus. Peptides 34: 127–134.
- 29. Winston WM, Molodowitch C, Hunter CP (2002) Systemic RNAi in C. elegans requires the putative transmembrane protein SID-1. Science 295(5564): 2456–2459
- 30. Zha W, Peng X, Chen R, Du B, Zhu L, et al. (2011) Knockdown of Midgut Genes by dsRNA Transgenic Plant-Mediated RNA Interference in the Hemipteran Insect Nilaparvata lugens. PLoS ONE 6(5): e20504
- 31. Wynant N, Duressa TF, Santos D, Van Duppen J, Proost P, et al. (2014) Lipophorins can adhere to dsRNA, bacteria and fungi present in the hemolymph of the desert locust: A role as general scavenger for pathogens in the open body cavity. Journal of Insect Physiology 64: 7–13
- 32. Wynant N, Santos D, Van Wielendaele P, Vanden Broeck J (2014) Scavenger receptor-mediated endocytosis facilitates RNA interference in the desert locust, Schistocerca gregaria. Insect Molecular Biology 23: 320–329
- 33. Firmino AAP, Fonseca FCA, Pepino de Macedo L, Coelho RR, de Souza JDA Jr, et al. (2013) Transcriptome Analysis in Cotton Boll Weevil (Anthonomus grandis) and RNA Interference in Insect Pests. PLoS One 8(12): e85079
- 34. Grabherr MG, Haas BJ, Yassour M, Levin JZ, Thompson DA, et al. (2011) Full-length transcriptome assembly from RNA-Seq data without a reference genome. Nature Biotechnology 8: 469–477.
- 35. Altschul SF, Madden TL, Schaffer AA, Zhang J, Zhang Z, et al. (1997) Gapped BLAST and PSI-BLAST: a new generation of protein database search programs. Nucleic Acids Res 25: 3389–3402.
- 36. Rice P, Longden I, Bleasby A (2000) EMBOSS: the European Molecular Biology Open Software Suite. Trends Genet 16: 276–277.
- 37. The Uniprot Consortium (2012) Update on activities at the Universal Protein Resource (UniProt) in 2013. Nucleic Acids Res 41: D43–D47.
- 38. Gotz S, Garcia-Gomez JM, Terol J, Williams TD, Naagaraj SH, et al. (2008) High-throughput functional annotation and data mining with the Blast2GO suite. Nucleic Acids Res 36: 3420–3435.
- 39. Sparks ME, Blackburn MB, Kuhar D, Gundersen-Rindal DE (2013) Transcriptome of the Lymantria dispar (Gypsy Moth) Larval Midgut in Response to Infection by Bacillus thuringiensis. PLOS One 8(5): e61190
- 40. Kent WJ (2002) BLAT—the BLAST-like alignment tool. Genome Res 12: 656–664.
- 41. Ozawa M, Muramatsu T (1993) Reticulocalbin, a novel endoplasmic resident Ca(2+)-binding protein with multiple EF-hand motifs and carboxyl-terminal HDEL sequence. Journal of Biological Chemistry 268: 699–705.
- 42. Matoušková P, Bártíková H, Boušová I, Hanušová V, Szotáková B, et al. (2014) Reference Genes for Real-Time PCR Quantification of Messenger RNAs and MicroRNAs in Mouse Model of Obesity. PLOS One 9(1): e86033