In this work we devise a classification of mouse activity patterns based on accelerometer data using Detrended Fluctuation Analysis. We use two characteristic mouse behavioural states as benchmarks in this study: waking in free activity and slow-wave sleep (SWS). In both situations we find roughly the same pattern: for short time intervals we observe high correlation in activity - a typical 1/f complex pattern - while for large time intervals there is anti-correlation. High correlation of short intervals ( to : waking state and to : SWS) is related to highly coordinated muscle activity. In the waking state we associate high correlation both to muscle activity and to mouse stereotyped movements (grooming, waking, etc.). On the other side, the observed anti-correlation over large time scales ( to : waking state and to : SWS) during SWS appears related to a feedback autonomic response. The transition from correlated regime at short scales to an anti-correlated regime at large scales during SWS is given by the respiratory cycle interval, while during the waking state this transition occurs at the time scale corresponding to the duration of the stereotyped mouse movements. Furthermore, we find that the waking state is characterized by longer time scales than SWS and by a softer transition from correlation to anti-correlation. Moreover, this soft transition in the waking state encompass a behavioural time scale window that gives rise to a multifractal pattern. We believe that the observed multifractality in mouse activity is formed by the integration of several stereotyped movements each one with a characteristic time correlation. Finally, we compare scaling properties of body acceleration fluctuation time series during sleep and wake periods for healthy mice. Interestingly, differences between sleep and wake in the scaling exponents are comparable to previous works regarding human heartbeat. Complementarily, the nature of these sleep-wake dynamics could lead to a better understanding of neuroautonomic regulation mechanisms.
Citation: Lima GZdS, Lobão-Soares B, do Nascimento GC, França ASC, Muratori L, Ribeiro S, et al. (2014) Mouse Activity across Time Scales: Fractal Scenarios. PLoS ONE 9(10): e105092. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0105092
Editor: Clayton T. Dickson, University of Alberta, Canada
Received: December 11, 2013; Accepted: July 17, 2014; Published: October 2, 2014
Copyright: © 2014 Lima et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: Financial support from Capes and Conselho Nacional de Desenvolvimento Científico e Tecnológico and FINEP are acknowledged. Gustavo Zampier dos Santos Lima and Bruno Lobão Soares was supported by Programa Primeiros Projetos of Fundação de Apoio a Pesquisa do RN (PPP-FAPERN Grant No 05/2011) and CAPES (Proc. No. BEX 11264/13-6). The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
In the last two decades the influx of ideas from complex systems physics have brought new insights into biomedical studies –. The concepts of fractals and structure of fluctuations have enlightened analysis of physiological time series, for instance: heartbeat series –, breathing records – and gait dynamics –. These three physiologic records have in common the absence of typical periodicity that could guide the characterization of the dynamics, and because of that, scientists are driven to the study of signal fluctuation. Signal fluctuation is a mathematical technique that classify fractal patterns of time series –. The output of this methodology is a fractal analysis, the extreme case of absence of order, or pattern, in signal is the white noise which has a well-defined dimension. Most intricate scenarios can rise like different fractal dimensions for distinct time intervals or multifractality - a set of fractal dimensions , . Beyond fractal dimensions, this paper is centred in exploring time scales of distinct fractal regimes and, especially, transition times between fractal scenarios considering typical states of mice sleep-wake cycle.
Specifically, in this study we focus on scaling and multifractal features in locomotor dynamics of mice activity. This approach can be useful to understand the neural, as well as environmental, aspects related to body movement in different physiological conditions. We lead in this work with accelerometer time series recorded with a device placed on the head of a mouse. Previous similar studies analysed nonlinear (multifractal) properties of heartbeat physiological dynamics , , as well as monofractal 1/f type scaling in the gait of adult individuals , . Furthermore, multifractal behaviour was found in children gait and were gradually lost with maturation . There are also earlier studies on wrist and arm motion, which, in contrast to adult gait, reported nonlinear scaling . Acceleration is a measure of animal activity, and in this way our work interfaces with the cited works about heart, breath and gait dynamics. We employ the raw accelerometer data instead of computing active versus inactive intervals as in references – because we intended to capture detailed activity patterns of individuals. In addition, our study encompasses nine orders of magnitude in the time record, from to several hours. In this way our analysis capture activity bellow the time between two successive heartbeats to the entire duration of sleep-wake cycle state. The novelty of our work consist in using fractal concepts to analyse motor activity by taking into account relevant physiologic durations like: the inter heartbeat interval, the breathing period, the typical time of stereotyped animal movements and the wake sleep duration cycle.
The main concept we employ in the analysis the accelerometer data is the fractal dimension which is connected to signal fractal correlation . The human gait is a typical expression of motor system phenomenon that exhibits high correlation ,  which reflects the repetition and coordination of the integrated action of neural and muscular system. The most illustrative picture of a high correlation movement comes from a young person walking for a short period (around 1 hour) without resting , . For an older person the gait looses correlation; the image of a limping old man whose next step seems not follow the previous one is a powerful picture of absence of correlation. Human gait also produces a somewhat artificial, but illustrative, example of anti-correlation which comes from subjects that should, by suggestion, follow an arbitrary synchronized signal; in this case, the individual attempt to correct himself to adjust the step producing a negative feedback which induces an anti-correlation trend . The examples of correlation and anti-correlation we have found in the free range behaviour mouse are similar to those of human gait. The correlation may be generally associated to skeletal activity patterns usually present in individual body movement. Complementarily, the anti-correlation may arise as a consequence of a negative feedback normally associated to the fatigue of movement, heartbeat or breathing.
In the analysis of signal auto-correlation we are driven to the concept of fractals; in this context, correlated, no-correlated or anti-correlated signals are characterized by power-law and distinct fractal dimensions . Indeed, there is a plethora of different possibilities of autocorrelation signal characteristics. As an illustration, a monofractal signal identifies an unique self-similarity index, which can correspond to correlated, no-correlated or anti-correlated behaviour. A bi-fractal data discloses two sub-sets with different correlations and fractal dimension according to the time scale and these different behaviours are typically separated by a crossover time. A multifractal time series comprises a set of many fractal dimensions for the same time scale .
Extensive analysis has shown that different correlation exponents in DFA scaling characterize the heart rate of healthy subjects and patients suffering from heart disease. Also, different exponents have been found for the wake and the sleep periods. Moreover, the crossover phenomenon in DFA scaling was reported in real physiological signal when comparing scaling properties of the cardiac dynamics during sleep and wake periods , . Furthermore, crossover patterns were observed in changing regimens from rest to exercise (heartbeat fluctuations) , between different sleep stages ,  and even across circadian phases of cardiac (eletroencephalographic signal), breathing (respiratory parameters) and locomotor dynamics . Besides, we are aware that the crossover might be an artefact of oscillatory patterns embedded in the signal. The crossover artefact was theoretically investigated , and also has been shown for real heartbeat data . On the other hand, scaling crossovers in general locomotion may be related to intrinsic mechanisms of physiological regulation, such as suprachiasmatic nucleus circadian regulation and other neural output variances . Thus, we hypothesise that mouse locomotion dynamics during waking may disclose a complex temporal organization characterized by a scale-invariant fluctuation across a range of time scales.
In this paper we work on a comprehensive analysis of motor activity of mice in free range environment using fractal and correlation concepts. We propose that signal correlation analysis could provide new insights not only for motor activity studies but also into behavioural description of rodents. In addition, fluctuation analysis can be used to identify and quantify patterns of accelerometer records, in other words, a standard model of motor activity based on time scales. Finally, the accelerometer-based DFA analysis can be used as a robust tool for evaluating promising therapies in models of motor alterations induced by drugs or in neuromuscular diseases. Some rodent models of demyelinating pathologies or neurodegenerative disorders such as Parkinson disease could be good examples of a possible benefit on this technique in a near future.
A typical time series of accelerometer record encompassing one hour is shown in Fig. 1(f). To facilitate the comparison between these data and behavioural states, hipnogram is depicted in the same plot. A visual analysis points out, as expected, that the intensity of accelerometer response is higher when the individual is awake as compared to SWS state. Our analysis was done independently for resting SWS and waking states, otherwise it is not possible to find defined patterns in the results. The two case situations are: the individual in waking state without any sleep episodes [see Fig. 2(a)] and in resting sleep state [see Fig. 2(b)], that means, the sleeping individual that does not exhibit any macroscopic movement (no arousals). We have identified these two states as benchmarks we can use to classify the phenomenology of actimetry (accelerometer records). In the following we will always refer to these states as the waking and resting SWS states, since each of this states show common characteristics. It is important to highlight the universality of our results: all time series we have analysed for all individuals share the same basic phenomenology in the waking and resting SWS states.
(a) Histological analysis. After all behavioural procedures and data collection, all implanted C57-BL6 mice were perfused and brain slices were obtained in order to confirm if LFP electrodes were inserted in M1 and S1 cortical regions and in hippocampus CA1 subfield as an inclusion criterion. (b) Surgical Matrix Electrode Implant: Under a isofurane anaesthesia, mice a rectangle was opened in cranial bones for allowing a 16-tungsten electrode matrix implant combined with an accelerometer in the headstage. Eight electrodes were placed in the S1/M1cortex (layers ) and another eight in the CA1 subfield of hippocampus. (c) Electrophysiology. One week after surgery, animals were submitted to a session of hours continuous recording in a round open field maze. They were allowed to perform their natural behaviours during the recordings, and to freely display the sleep-wake cycle. (d) LFP oscillations. All channels of hippocampus, cortex and accelerometer were displayed in real time analysis in order to verify possible problems with ground or signal generation. (e) State map generation. Real-time two-dimensional behavioural state maps were generated by plotting the following spectral ratios: x-axis, z; y-axis, . Raw LFP and EMG activity were analysed during periods of WK, SWS, and REM sleep predicted by the two-dimensional state map. (f) A typical AR (midlle) with the hypnogram generated by identification of waking (blue), SWS (red) and REM (green) sleep cluster separation (top). At bottom two zooms of the raw accelerometer signal for resting SWS state (left) and waking state (right).
(a) Sample of a time interval (600 seconds) record during a typical wake fluctuation activity for a healthy mouse. In (c), (e) and (g) we show segments of the time series for the same wake state period at small time scales to visualize self-similar (fractal) fluctuation. (b) Representative of a time interval (90 seconds) record during SWS sleep stage for the same mouse. In (d), (f) and (h) shows a sequence of segments in many time scales of this fluctuation. These fluctuations are typical examples of noise-like time series.
The essence of results concerning signal fluctuation structure is shown in Fig. 3. In this figure we explore Fourier and DFA results of a typical waking (b)–(d) and resting sleep signal (a)–(c); the signals themselves are shown in Fig. 2(a)–(b). We should invert the time reading of the x-axis when we go from DFA to Fourier pictures, for instance, a time gives frequency . The values of the DFA exponent, , corresponding to the slope of the DFA curve are shown in Fig. 2(a)–(b) (dashed lines - as an eye guide). Note within the DFA graphic as well the Fourier spectrum three different frequencies highlighted by arrows (, and ). These frequencies may be related to DFA humps and the crossover at approximately due to an oscillation pattern given by breathing . The other frequencies match the oscillation pattern of the heartbeat and muscle tremor . We also see that for all time scale the mean coefficient slope is . In 3(b) we show the DFA and Fourier spectrum of locomotor fluctuation during awake. We indicate in this figure two frequencies ( and ). The frequency may cause a small DFA hump at approximately and it is associated to the heartbeat oscillation. The another is actually a range of frequencies from 0.05 Hz to 0.7 Hz that match the oscillation pattern of physiological activities and stereotyped movements. We also note that for time scale up to 7 seconds the coefficient slope is .
In (a) we show the DFA fluctuation function of locomotor fluctuation during sleep for the time series presented in Fig. 2(b). In this figure we present the x-axis as a function of time in seconds, instead of points (1 second corresponds to n = 1000 points). In (c) shows the Fourier spectrum that display three characteristic frequencies highlighted by arrows (, and ). These frequencies are the most probable cause of the hump. The main frequency seems to be related to crossover at approximately which is the breathing cycle. Other two frequencies may match the oscillation pattern of the heartbeat () and physiological tremor (). We also note that for the full time scale the coefficient slope is . In (b) we show the DFA of locomotor fluctuation during awake from time series presented in Fig. 2(a). In (d) shows the Fourier spectrum that also display two different frequencies which are highlighted by arrows ( and ). The frequency, typical of the heartbeat, causes a slightly hump at approximately . The set at indicates a range of frequencies from 0.05 Hz to 0.7 Hz that match the oscillation pattern of physiological activities and stereotyped movements. We also note that for time scale up to 7 seconds the coefficient slope is .
The analysis of fluctuations of the accelerometer signal reveals the same basic structure for waking and SWS states. In both situations we found the presence of an Highly Correlated (HC) signal at low time scales while intermediate time scales reveals an Anti-Correlated (AC) patterns and very long times are marked by a Non Correlated (NC) signal. For the waking state the passage from HC to AC is not abrupt, we identify here a Multifractal Transition (MT) which reveals a great richness of distinct correlations. We remark that, despite a similar HC, AC and NC pattern, the waking and sleep states differ regarding their time scales and phenomenology. The time intervals for sleep states are typically shorter than waking states what is expected since sleep is mainly regulated by autonomic activity which are dominated by smaller time scales as compared to behavioural times. In what follows we show in detail these patterns that are illustrated in Fig. 4 and Fig. 5.
The fluctuation function versus the time scale size (1 second corresponds to n = 1000 points) in double logarithmic scale. The dotted lines shows the regions with different regimes. HC indicates a range in time-scale (from 0.01 s to 0.3 s) with highly correlated regime corresponding to noise (fractal range). AC indicates a range in time-scale (from 0.4 s to 5 s) with anti-correlated regime. NC indicates a range in time-scale (above 10 s) with descorrelation regime.
The fluctuation function versus the time scale size (1 second corresponds n = 1000 points) in double logarithmic scale. The dotted lines shows the regions with different regimes. HC indicates a range in time-scale (from to ) with highly correlated regime corresponding to noise (fractal range). MT indicates a range in time-scale (from to ) with multifractal behaviour. AC indicates a range in time-scale (from to ) with anti-correlated regime. Furthermore MT is a long transition regime from HC to AC regimes. In the low position at right side are inserted the main stereotyped behaviours with their average duration and standard error medium. Please note that their duration in general are less than , which fits on HC regime. The inset shows a histogram of duration of mice stereotyped movements.
(HC): The DFA technique for short times reveals a very high correlation response of the accelerometer signal. The HC is found from to in the waking state, Fig. 5, and to in sleep state, Fig. 4. This result follows the strongly correlated contraction pattern of the muscle skeletal activity. For small time scales the muscle skeletal activity is very coordinated, the short time scale of motor activity can be imagined as a chain of small movements that follow each other by necessity; for instance, each animal limb movement is strongly correlated to the movement of the limb in a previous instant. This simple picture of animal motor activity points to a high correlation in the sequence of intervals of movement. Of course, for long times individuals will follow another movement pattern breaking the correlation. In the sleep state the movement is dominated by heart and breathing movements as well as thermogenesis processes (tremor, vibration etc) which also implies in strong coordinate activity.
(AC): The high correlation of short time scale follows an anti-correlated regime. For the sleep state the transition from HC to AC can be characterized by a crossover while in the waking state the transition is smooth; a detailed approach of this transition reveals a rich multifractal structure which we discuss in detail later. The time scale of the AC regime is quite different in the two situations, for the waking state it goes from to while in the sleep case it ranges from to . The physiology behind the AC show some similarity in waking and SWS states. For the waking state the AC regime is believed to be related to a cycle of exercise and rest, once the motor physiology of free range animals normally shows this oscillatory pattern. The apparent alternation between periods of intense and relaxed activity produces a natural anti-correlated patterns in the signal. For the SWS state the anti-correlation is similar but it is probably related to the autonomic system and it is rooted in the sympathetic parasympathetic regulation of cardiac and breathing system. In a similar way, an intense cardiac activity should be succeeded, via feedback control, by a diminution in the heart rate and vice-versa .
(NC): Considering long enough time scales the accelerometer signal should loose completely its correlation. In other words, for long times the memory of initial instants should vanish. The paradigmatic signal that shows this behaviour is the white noise whose signal at time is completely independent of signal at time t, for the time step. The absence of correlation in the waking regime comes after a minutes while in the sleep state it happens after . The presence of NC in the experiment is important for checking the consistency of our results.
(MT): The multifractal transition is present only in the waking regime. This regime is characterized by a set of different correlated patterns superposed in a same time scales that ranges from to . In our observations most of the stereotyped behaviours of mice such as scratching, roaming, short walking, sniffing, span below . Inside each of these stereotyped behaviours the animal activity is in the HC regime, but the composition of several stereotyped behaviours show a more involved mathematical description. Indeed, we have found that in the typical behavioural range to where more complex phenomena take place, the animal should aggregate several stereotyped behaviours. In a behavioural perspective the succession of stereotyped movements of the MT is related to the voluntary movement of individuals. The result of this composition, each one with its proper correlation length and fractal fluctuation signature forms the multifractal pattern shown in Fig. 6.
(a) Generalized Hurst exponent h(q) for eight selected data series corresponding to mice. (b) Similar plot for the multifractal scaling exponent . (c) Multifractal spectrum for the same signals. Here, h(q), , and are obtained, respectively, through Eqs. (7), (8), and (10), and corresponds to the width of the multifractal spectrum.
Fig. 5 shows the DFA picture for signal samples of the waking state corresponding to individuals. It is notable the qualitative agreement among the curves; the HC, MT, AC sequence is clearly visible in all samples. The DFA parameter for the HC interval is while for AC is . With an auxiliary line we plot the slope, computed as the average of slopes, for HC and AC regimes. We notice that the passage from HC to AC is a curve with a smooth slope variation. In the following we mathematically describe in detail this time interval that extend approximately for . The absence of a defined slope in this interval unveils a richer geometric structure that deserves to be understood in a physiologic context. In the next paragraph we explore the computational techniques showing that, in this interval, the signal is multifractal. Indeed, the HC and the AC regimes are monofractal signal, that means, it is possible to full characterize the signal with a single index the fractal dimension of the signal which is not the case of the multifractal regime.
Multifractal behaviour in the dynamics of mice activities can be also verified through the generalized Hurst exponent , multifractal scaling exponent , and multifractal spectrum , respectively obtained through Eqs. (7), (8), and (10). Fig. 6 shows , , and for time series of mice activities obtained of time interval that extend approximately for . In this case, it is interesting to note that the decrease of with an increasing and the non linear behaviour of with are observed for all mice activity samples. The relation between and leads to a linear dependence of with . Moreover, the linear dependence gives rise to a multifractal spectrum given by a small arc, with small width 6. The absolute value for the width of the multifractal spectrum , that corresponds to the difference between the maximum and minimum , as well as the shape of the multifractal spectrum, are related to the temporal variation of the generalized Hurst exponent . Furthermore, the degree of multifractality is given by the calculus of the absolute value of the spectrum width. In this sense, the wider , more significant is the multifractality of the analysed time series . Here, the obtained width above , as signature of a rich and strong multifractal behaviour, irrespective of the individual.
Fig. 4 show the DFA graphic for seven signal samples of the resting sleep state. In this analysis we have used samples of four individuals. The curves show a typical HC, AC, NC sequence. Diversely from the previous regime, the transition from HC to AC shows a crossing over pattern in contrast with the smooth transition of the waking state. The resting sleep state can be characterized by three monofractal regimes in opposition to the waking state that needs a multifractal regime in the HC to AC transition. The that represent fluctuation function is diverse among the states. In the top of the figure, with the highest fluctuation there is the waking state, a similar picture is shown in Fig. 5. At the bottom of the same figure we have the resting SWS state with lowest fluctuations, these two curves are similar to the ones shown in Fig. 4. Above the resting SWS state we have two curves corresponding to individuals that sleep but present measurable movement. The fluctuation caused by small movement of limbs hide the AC pattern in this situation. For this state the correlation, caused by the episodic movement in the sleep, prolong the correlation in the signal for larger times. Above the SWS state and bellow the waking state we have two curves corresponding to individuals that mix waking and sleep patterns. Obviously, because of the higher fluctuation of the waking state signal dominates the statistics the DFA resemble closely the one of the waking state, but is smaller. We note that for long times individuals will show episodes of sleep and waking states and, by consequence, the accelerometer signal will necessarily loose all correlation; this situation is indicated in figure by the line .
The accelerometer analysis can be an useful, low cost and non-invasive technique that provides important hints about motor state and behaviour of a species. The main objective of this paper is, using fluctuation analysis, to propose a basic description of accelerometer measurements for a freely behaving mouse. As far as we know, this is the first time that DFA is being used to describe mice physiologic motor patterns using accelerometer signal data, an interesting way to classify activity patterns using neural networks is done in . We design a classification of activity records using two benchmarks: the free waking and the SWS resting state. However, in both sleep or waking states, we observe the same tendency: small time lags are dominated by strong motor correlation while larger times are marked by anti-correlation. For large enough periods (above ), signal becomes uncorrelated as it should be expected for this methodology. The long term objective of this study is to provide a setup to help scientist to use accelerometer records as a safe tool to understand the effect of drugs or physical therapeutics in the motor neural system. Our group, in special, intends to study drugs that simulate Parkinson disease which is well known to have a profound impact on organism motility. In the following lines, we discuss fluctuation correlation regimes in the light of physiological and behavioural events starting from small to larger time scales, and considering separately waking and sleep states.
Waking: Physiological activity and stereotyped movements
When we look at the waking DFA curve (Fig. 5) the first scale from to is an HC like regime. We situate in this interval two important physiological events: the heartbeat and breathe movements. Because in both waking and SWS recordings, heartbeat and breathe movements are set on the first HC part of DFA curve, we discuss in more details their influence when we reach SWS analysis. Another important transition point is related to mice stereotyped behaviour. Typical examples of stereotyped behaviour for this species are: short walks, grooming, rearing, resting and sniffing. We measure the duration of the stereotyped behaviours in our experiment in the interval ranging from to seconds, see Fig. 5 and 7. The average duration of stereotyped movement () defines also a turning point in the DFA of waking state (Fig. 5). Indeed, until the stereotyped movement duration waking activity is HC; in this regime the recorded activity is strongly related to skeletal muscle coordinated movement of body and limbs. We state that, in a time scale below the average duration of stereotyped behaviours, the DFA pattern is roughly monofractal, while after this breaking point (an interval from to ) we see in the curve an evolution to a more complex pattern. According to this view, in waking state, the accelerometer amplitude of these behaviours are so high that surpass the input that result from cardiac or respiratory movements. Stereotyped and basic movements usually depends largely on automatic control programs situated on basal ganglia and lower parts of the brain . Based on environmental output, internal valuation of actions and action selection, the animal may decide what will be the next movement pattern, which can be simple, frequent and stereotyped, or it can be less frequent and complex. The observation of Fig. 5 (inset) allows identification of a general duration of commonly observed mouse ethogram parameters.
In this picture we put the main physiologic and behavioural durations associated with the DFA accelerometer data curves. On the upper position we plotted regions of HC, MT and AC for waking state curve (shown in red), on the lowered position are indicated the HC, AC and NC regimes for resting sleep curve (in light green). For the resting SWS state the main physiologic event is the breathing cycle while for the waking state the main event is the behavioural time.
Waking: Complex behaviours
For the waking state we identify a distinct regime that start in and goes to that we call here complex behaviour window. This regime has a proper physiological interpretation as a composition of several stereotyped movements and gives origin to a multifractal scenario. Let us consider a rough image of fluctuation analysis technique to understand this complex behaviour. The DFA analysis is about correlation statistics over different time scales, beginning with small, milliseconds intervals, and finishing with durations of many hours. For the waking state a duration of 1 s in the accelerometer recording will probably be related to data inside a given stereotyped behaviours. On the other side, a time window of, for instance, should fulfil a sequence of four or five diverse stereotyped movements; a statistic over these different stereotyped behaviours will not produce an unique fractal exponent, but reflect the variability of this bundle of stereotyped movements, each one with a characteristic time correlation . For instance, given the stereotyped behaviours A, B, C, D, possible sequences reflecting the observed variability in a interval could be A, C, D, A; C, A, D, B; or D, A, D, C and so on, thus increasing variability and unpredictability in DFA curve. Of course, we cannot state that complex behaviour is composed exclusively by sequences of stereotyped behaviours. Complex behaviours may emerge as a natural tendency of experimentation and are associated to the learning of the environment by inspection and are associated with exploration of novelty. In this study case, novelty was linked by the round maze, which was an unknown environment for the mouse in the first minutes of exploration. For avoiding the influence of a movement pattern linked to novelty exploration, we removed the first hour of mouse activity, in which the novelty-driven exploration behaviour is more relevant. This procedure allowed us to focus on a movement pattern that is evoked when the animal is more habituated with the environment, and thus could better reflect the movement pattern which occurs more frequently in the animal routine environment.
Waking: Movement and Resting (energy saving balance)
The accelerometer record reveals an interesting physiologic feature for durations from to 1 hour: the activity is anti-correlated, AC. The first AC record in physiology using fluctuation analysis was noticed in long range human heartbeat data . In the cited work the author claims the autonomic system is responsible for the autocorrelation regulation. In this work we believe that a similar phenomenon is rooted in a general energy saving balance principle common to life organisms. In studies of locomotion related to free exercise in a running wheel mice and other rodents exhibit a voluntary drive for exercise, which are performed in temporal cycles or running and rest , . Complementarily, studies concerning locomotion in other species highlight that animals present different moving patterns in their environments. This is probably because they consider the amount of energy they could intake during food search and the exploratory risk which vary along time . We believe that these biological factors could be involved in the anticorrelation we found in waking, starting from the animal drive for exploration of a new environment allied with the demand for exercise, until the habituation with the environment, and a need for rest after a period of exploration. However, the presence of an AC regime in accelerometer record was not observed in human studies ,  probably because most records consists of individuals walking without resting evaluation. We believe that future experiments designed to observe rest and movement cycle in free behaving humans and other species should also find an AC pattern as we are now describing for mice.
Starting with small periods, as occurs in waking state, the first relevant physiological parameter is the heart beat. We situate mice heart rate in a to Hz interval ( to ) . Basal heart rate is essentially dictated by atrioventricular and sinoatrial peacemaker activity , , which occurs by spontaneous activity of autorritmic cells and nervous system autonomic control , . The observation of Fig. 4 shows that the effect of the heart beat seems not modify the slope of the DFA curve both to SWS and waking state. This might be due to the fable movement amplitude of this signal considering that the accelerometer is situated on individuals head. The major crossover time of fluctuation analysis of the resting SWS state is given by the breathing duration cycle, that immediately follows heartbeat interval. Above breathing period we capture the oscillatory muscle activity of several breathing cycles; bellow this duration the accelerometer records the muscle movement inside each breathing cycle. The movement inside breathing cycle is a typical HC patterns that is present in any highly coordinate skeletal muscle activity. The respiratory movement has a frequency from to ( to )  in mice. We believe that, due to a larger movement amplitude driven by breathe muscles, the effect of respiratory weight in accelerometer records is more intense than cardiac stimuli.
We discussed above that AC regime in SWS state can be interpreted as an artefact caused by the periodicity of breathing cycle. However, we also point out the possibility of AC phenomenon be a true feedback mechanism. Respiratory rate is controlled by specialized neuron nuclei localized in the pons and medulla oblongatta, such as pre-Böltzinger and Böltzinger complexes. These nuclei are probably responsible for different rhythm patterns, and receives also influences from other parts of the brain. These connexions can include chemoreceptors of retrotrapezoid nucleus, which are sensitive to , and Ph variation. In this way, variation of blood gases are linked to an automatic response feedback mechanism which regulates respiratory rate. Neurons coming from superior centres such as cortex and cerebellum also modulate basic respiration rhythms – and this input are also related to muscle effort and complex movements . In special, since the perception and response to oxygen and carbonic acid blood concentration may occur starting from a half second (the time space of a breathe complete cycle), this mechanism may lead per se to an alternation of breathing frequencies in a SWS or waking resting state. The variation of inputs on respiratory nuclei associated to the chemosensory feedback response might explain our findings of anti-correlation during SWS sleep.
In addition, the most prominent peaks observed in SWS Fourier analysis (Fig. 3), could be associated to breathe (first), heartbeat (second), and to physiological tremor frequencies (third). In this context, it is important to highlight that physiological tremor in mice, which has origin on basal muscle frequencies ,  can represent an important source of variation of the raw signal. This physiological frequencies also vary according to the muscle type , . We emphasize that this tremor can be perceived simply by placing an habituated mouse on the hands of the researcher.
Finally we compare the scaling properties of the activity fluctuation during sleep and wakefulness time intervals in healthy mice. Remarkably, the difference in scaling behaviour between sleep and wake periods is comparable to previous works on the human heartbeat , . Our outcomes corroborate these works that show the difference between the coefficients around . Our results shows a difference around [see Fig. 3]. Elucidating the nature of the sleep-wake dynamics can lead to a better understanding of the mechanisms of egulation of autonomic neuro-motor activity. Furthermore, these results indicate that in the transition from sleep to wake the observed phase transition in the scaling behaviour across time scales from lower to higher scaling exponent does not depend on species characteristics (whether human or mouse) that are associated with fundamental aspects of neuroautonomic regulation and sympatho-vagal balance common for mammalian species.
We use the DFA method to understand activity patterns in mice during waking and resting SWS state. Both states are marked by a high correlation (HC) pattern for short time scale and subsequent anti-correlated (AC) behaviour at large time scale. During wake we credit the HC pattern to the coordinated skeletal body movement. Exclusively for waking state, we detect a multifractal behaviour which we attribute to the composition of stereotyped movements with distinct characteristic scales. The AC regime during waking state is probably related to physiologic behavioural strategy of alternating periods of predominant movement or rest. During SWS, the DFA curve begins with HC, which is mainly attributed to cardiac and respiratory coordinated movements. For both wake and SWS the observed HC regime, which encompasses at least two decades at time scales and is characterized by very different fractal exponents for wake and SWS, is indicative of a critical behaviour with a phase transition that has been reported also in that physiological systems , .
We believe that our work will be helpful to future studies of behavioural refinement of the ethogram or concerning the action of drugs over muscle activity and motor behaviour. Once we have a clear benchmark of the normal DFA curve of mice in waking and SWS state we can analyse the effect of drugs on motor activity. Good examples of motor diseases which could be studied in the light of DFA analysis in animal models could include Parkinson, Huntington chorea, Alzheimer and tardive dyskinesia.
Materials and Methods
In these series of experiments there were used adult male mice (2–5months). Animals were housed in home cages after surgery in hs light/dark schedule, lights on at a.m. and food and drink ad libitum. This study was carried out in strict accordance with the recommendations in the Guide for the Care and Use of Laboratory Animals of the National Institutes of Health. The protocol was approved by the Committee on the Ethics of Animal Experiments IINN Intenational Institut of Neuroscience of Natal- Edmond and Lily Safra (Permit Number: 08/2010). All surgery was performed under isoflurane anaesthesia, and all efforts were made to minimize suffering.
Behavioural recordings, synchronization and identification of wake-sleep states
Behaviours were recorded using a Panasonic videocamera and AMcap software in behavioural groups. In surgery groups, video recordings were synchronized to Local Field Potentials (LFPs) and accelerometer data. This three parameters were used together for confirmation of sleep-wake states selection given by LFPs waves. Spectral analysis of sleep-wake cycle was used to identify and quantify occurrence of waking, paradoxical sleep or REM and slow wave-sleep (SWS) states, using Plexon system for multiple LFP channel processing. Online LFP spectral maps for the characterization of waking and REM/SWS sleep states in mice were employed . Animal behaviour and LFP were continuously observed and recorded in real time for 12 hours. The first 4 recording hours was used in this study for comparisons among treatments. Animals were grouped according to the following categories: WK (active exploration of the environment perceived by video and accelerometer with whisking and hippocampal alpha/theta rhythm), SWS (stillness with eyes closed and large-amplitude slow hippocampal oscillations) and REM sleep. To find the resting SWS sleep intervals we use short time windows in which motor activity remained constant. That means, we use accelerometer record to choose time windows that do not show arousals.
Open field apparatus
After one week of surgery, animals were anaesthetized with isoflurane, for connecting the tungsten wires of the electrode matrix with those of plexon multielectrode recording device. After that, animals were injected with saline (NaCl ) and were placed in an open field apparatus ( diameter and high) at a. m. and recorded for hours. This injection was made because a saline-injected animal can serve as a golden parameter for comparison with drug injected ones in further studies. During this time, animals were not disturbed in order to allow them to disclose in a free manner all the typical movement patterns of SWS and REM sleep, or waking state.
Multielectrode implantation surgery
Animals were implanted with chronic electrodes in the hippocampus ( electrodes), motor and somatosensory cortex ( electrodes each one) for intracranial local field potentials (LFPs) recordings. Matrix dimensions were , and electrodes were of length, composed of diameter tungsten coated wires, that were attached to an omnetics 16-pin connector. This matrix was implanted in a rectangular hole in the skull (bregma coordinates and right, and caudal, thus repeating the first coordinate points), under isoflurane anaesthesia. An electrode matrix was placed in animals head using liquid acrylic also with the help of three screws that were used together as ground. Also, an accelerometer with X,Y, Z axes orientation sensor was associated to the headstage, attached to male connector plugged in a head female omnetics connector. Complementarily, a ten fold pre-amplification circuitry was located in association distant from animals head, in order to reduce noise. The LFP signal at a sample rate was amplificated in a second time by a Plexon x pre-amplifier and recorded in a Plexon system for neural recording analysis.
The accelerometer device
We use a three axis accelerometer sensor (ADXL330 from Analog Devices) installed over to the connector that matches over the mice implanted electrode matrix. This provides a very tight mechanical connection to the animal head, for activities measurement. The three signals were routed from the accelerometer to the headstage using appropriated flexible wires to keep a space about 30 mm. The headstage is home-made and was designed to have channels by the use of high input impedance operational amps, and its output was electrically compatible to the plexon electrophysiological measurement system. This provides simultaneous recordings for electrophysiological signals and activities. During experiments, the headstage and its cable were kept suspended by the use of a rubber band. A correct adjusts for its strength can avoid a substantial mass load to the head of the animal. This configuration provided a good degree of flexibility and comfort for animal movements during the experiments. Both electrophysiological and inertial signals were initially conditioned in the headstage and then routed to the plexon electrophysiological system. The three axis accelerometer signals from the sensor were low pass filtered to have a frequency limit around , and for convenience all signals were acquired at a rate of .
After all behavioural data collection, all surgery animals were subject to histological preparations. Briefly, after electrophysiology recordings, animals were euthanatized in deep anaesthesia with isoflurane, and perfused with PBS pH , and paraformaldehyde ; brains were removed, freezed at and sliced at thickness. In order to confirm if electrodes were localized near CA1 hippocampus layers or at deep in the cortex Nissl staining of coronal slices was performed.
Data acquisition and treatment
This paper works with measurements of accelerometer sensor located at the head of a mouse and we use accelerometer records to make inference about physiologic state of the organism. A naive, but essential question, is what an accelerometer record? The answer of this question is not movement. The acceleration is the variation of velocity, a particle that moves at constant velocity shows zero acceleration. Acceleration, in a crude way, is related with force. In order to vary the velocity of a particle, or the limb, head or tail of an animal, it is necessary to use muscular force. Besides, an animal can stay at the same place in space but if it shakes or trembles the head the accelerometer shows intense response. In a physiologic perspective the accelerometer records skeletal muscular activity of the body. In other words, the accelerometer is a noninvasive apparatus that quantify motor activity of an organism. The accelerometer output consists in three components of the acceleration vector . For starting our mathematical analysis of data we combine the vector components in a single quantity similar to the vector module at the same time that we extract the average of each vector component. The new vector formed from the components of is defined as:(1)where is the arithmetic average of . We performed DFA as well Fourier analysis over each of the components of the acceleration and over the results are similar, our option for using comes from the robustness of the results, an analysis over the modulus of a vector is more trustful than over any of its components.
The Detrended Fluctuation Analysis DFA is an improvement of the rescaled range method used to compute the Hurst exponent. The DFA estimates Hurst exponent in a more rigorous way because it eliminate the trend in the signal before computing deviations if the signal relative to its average –. In what follows we expose DFA in some detail, let start with the a time series for the length of the vector. The first step consists in integrating the series:(2)
Where is the local average. Furthermore the new time series is divided into equal boxes of size . Inside each box of length a least-squares line is fitted using a linear function, which is called the local trend. The DFA can be adapted to detrend any continuous function, due to the bounded characteristic of the accelerometer signal a linear detrend is enough. We detrend by subtracting it from the local trend, that means:(3)
The equation above is computed for any box of size ; at the end we have a scaling relation , where is the DFA scaling exponent and this is a identical to the Hurst index , , which is related to the power spectrum exponent by , . Furthermore, the exponent represents the scaling of fluctuation according to the scale . The interpretation of in the statistical mechanic context is: corresponds to the uncorrelated white noise, the result we should expect in a null model perspective or the case of complete randomness. The case corresponds to anti-correlation while shows positive correlation. The special case corresponds to noise .
To estimate the multifractal properties of our experimental data we have calculated the multifractal spectra based on the Multifractal Fluctuation Analysis MF-DFA method , , . In a brief description of the MF-DFA method for a given time contain N data points as follows. First we integrate the time series , . Then we divide the new time series into a non-overlapping segments of size , so that . After we apply a linear regression for -th segment () to estimate the best fitting , where . In the next step we calculate the mean square fluctuation for the -th segment as:(5)
The scaling of the fluctuation function as we have shown above but now for the moment q is given by:(7)where represents a generalized Hurst exponent. Monofractal time series have a unique Hurst exponent and this is a identical to the DFA scaling exponent . In turn, for multifractal time series the value of depends nonlinearly on q. From this point, the multifractal scaling exponent can be calculate from by the relation:(8)
So, if there is a linear dependence of the spectrum with q, the time series is considered monofractal, otherwise it is multifractal. Moreover, it is possible to characterize the multifractality by considering the multifractal spectrum , where is the Holder exponent. The multifractal spectrum can be obtained from a Legendre transform of the exponent:(9)(10)
The magnitude of the multifractality in time series is usually estimated by the width of the spectrum . We deal in this paper with measurement of accelerometer record with an acquisition rate of . The typical time (period) corresponding to this frequency is . To compute , for the time scale, we start with which corresponds to a time , which is the minimal time depicted in the figures of the manuscript. Indeed, to construct it is necessary to make a statistical average and is a minimal statistical sample that produces trustable results.
Financial support from Capes and CNPq (Conselho Nacional de Desenvolvimento Científico e Tecnológico) and FINEP are acknowledged. Gustavo Zampier dos Santos Lima and Bruno Lobão was supported by Programa Primeiros Projetos of Fundação de Apoio a Pesquisa do RN (PPP-FAPERN Grant No 05/2011) and CAPES (Proc. No. BEX 11264/13-6).
Conceived and designed the experiments: BLS GCN SR. Performed the experiments: BLS GCN LM ACF. Analyzed the data: GC GCN GZ. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: SR. Wrote the paper: GC BLS GZ.
- 1. Ivanov PC, Amaral LAN, Goldberger AL, Havlin S, Rosenblum MG, et al. (1999) Multifractality in human heartbeat dynamics. Nature 399: 461–465.
- 2. Stanley HE, Amaral LAN, Goldberger AL, Havlin S, Ivanov PC, et al. (1999) Statistical physics and physiology: Monofractal and multifractal approaches. Physica A 270: 309.
- 3. Bassingthwaighte JB, Liebovitch SL, West BJ (1994) Fractal Physiology. Oxford University Press, Oxford.
- 4. Polletta BRP, Scheer FAJL, Butler MP, Shea SA, Hu K (2013) The role of the circadian system in fractal neurophysiological control. Biol Rev Camb Philos Soc 88: 873–894.
- 5. Bashan A, Bartsch RP, Kantelhardt JW, Havlin S, Ivanov PC (2012) Network physiology reveals relations between network topology and physiological function. Nature 3: 702.
- 6. Ivanov PC, Amaral LAN, Goldberger AL, Havlin S, Rosenblum MG, et al. (2001) From 1/f noise to multifractal cascades in heartbeat dynamics. Chaos 11: 641.
- 7. Peng CK, Mietus J, Hausdorf JM, Havlin S, Stanley HE, et al. (1993) Long-range anticorrelations and non-gaussian behavior of the heartbeat. Phys Rev Lett 70: 1343.
- 8. Schmitt DT, Stein PK, Ivanov PC (2009) Stratification pattern of static and scale-invariant dynamic measures of heartbeat fluctuations across sleep stages in young and elderly. IEEE Trans Biomed Eng 56: 1564–73.
- 9. Peng CK, Mietus JE, Liu Y, Lee C, Hausdorff JM, et al. (2002) Quantifying fractal dynamics of human respiration: Age and gender effects. Annales of Biomedical Engineering 30: 683.
- 10. Kantelhardt JW, Penzel T, Rostig S, Becker HF, Havlin S, et al. (2003) Breathing during rem and non-rem sleep: correlated versus uncorrelated behavior. Physica A 319: 447.
- 11. Schumann AY, Bartsch RP, Penzel T, Ivanov PC, Kantelhardt JW (2010) Aging effects on cardiac and respiratory dynamics in healthy subjects across sleep stages. Sleep 33: 943–955.
- 12. Hausdorff JM, Ashkenazy Y, Peng CK, Ivanov PC, Stanley H, et al. (2001) When human walking becomes random walking: fractal analysis and modeling of gait rhythm fluctuations. Physica A 302: 138.
- 13. Scafetta N, Marchi D, West BJ (2009) Understanding the complexity of human gait dynamics. Chaos 19: 026108.
- 14. Ashkenazy Y, Hausdorff JM, Ivanov PC, Stanley HE (2002) A stochastic model of human gait dynamics. Physica A: Statistical Mechanics and its Applications 316: : 662–670.
- 15. Ivanov PC, Ma QDY, Bartsch RP, Hausdorff JB, Amaral LAN, et al. (2009) Levels of complexity in scale-invariant neural signals. Physical Review E 79: 041920.
- 16. Peng CK, Buldyrev SV, Havlin S, Simons M, Stanley HE, et al. (1994) Mosaic organization of dna nucleotides. Phys Rev E 49: 1685.
- 17. Hu K, Ivanov PC, Chen Z, Carpena P, Stanley HE (2001) Effect of trends on detrended fluctuation analysis. Physical Review E 64: 011114.
- 18. Kantelhardt JW, Koscielny-Bunde E, Rego HHA, Havlin S, Bunde A (2001) Detecting long-range correlations with detrended fluctuation analysis. Physica A 295: 441.
- 19. Chen Z, Ivanov PC, Hu K, Stanley HE (2002) Effect of nonstationarities on detrended fluctuation analysis. Phys Rev E 65..
- 20. Mandelbrot BB (1989) Fractal geometry: what is it, and what does it do? Proc R Soc Lond 423: 3.
- 21. Hu K, Ivanov PC, Chen Z, Hilton MF, Stanley HE, et al. (2004) Non-random fluctuations and multi-scale dynamics regulation of human activity. Physica A: Statistical Mechanics and its Applications 337: 307–318.
- 22. Nakamura T, Takumi T, Takano A, Aoyagi N, Yoshiuchi K, et al. (2008) Of mice and men - universality and breakdown of behavioral organization. PlosOne 3: e2050.
- 23. Nakamura T, Kiyono K, Yoshiuchi K, Nakahara R, Struzik ZR, et al. (2007) Universal scaling law in human behavioral organization. Phys Rev Lett 99: 138103.
- 24. Anteneodo C, Chialvo DR (2009) Unraveling the fluctuations of animal motor activity. Chaos 19: 033123.
- 25. Schmitt DT, Ivanov PCIC (2007) Fractal scale-invariant and nonlinear properties of cardiac dynamics remain stable with advanced age: A new mechanistic picture of cardiac control in healthy elderly. The American Journal of Physiology - Regulatory, Integrative and Comparative Physiology 293: 1923–1937.
- 26. Ludescher J, Bogachev MI, Kantelhardt JW, Schumann AY, Bunde A (2011) On spurious and corrupted multifractality: The effects of additive noise, short-term memory and periodic trends. Physica A 390: 2480.
- 27. Ivanov PC, Bunde A, Amaral LAN, Havlin S, Fritsch-Yelle J, et al. (1999) Sleep-wake differences in scaling behavior of the human heartbeat: Analysis of terrestrial and long-term space fight data. Europhysics Letters 48: 594–600.
- 28. Bunde A, Havlin S, Kantelhardt JW, Penzel T, Peter JH, et al. (2000) Correlated and uncorrelated regions in heart-rate fluctuations during sleep. Physical Review Letters 85: 3736–3739.
- 29. Karasik R, Sapir N, Ashkenazy Y, Ivanov PC, Dvir I, et al.. (2002) Correlation differences in heartbeat fluctuations during rest and exercise. Phys Rev E 66..
- 30. Kantelhardt JW, Ashkenazy Y, Ivanov PC, Bunde A, Havlin S, et al.. (2002) Characterization of sleep stages by correlations in the magnitude and sign of heartbeat increments. Phys Rev E 65..
- 31. Ivanov PC, Hu K, Hilton MF, Shea SA, Stanley HE (2007) Endogenous circadian rhythm in human motor activity uncoupled from circadian influences on cardiac dynamics. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 104: 20702–20707.
- 32. Hu K, Scheer FAJL, Ivanov PC, Buijs RM, Shea SA (2007) The suprachiasmatic nucleus functions beyond circadian rhythm generation. Neuroscience 149: 508–517.
- 33. Ihlen EA (2012) Introduction to multifractal detrended fluctuation analysis in matlab. Frontiers in Physiology 3: 141.
- 34. Venkatraman S, Jin X, Costa RM, Carmena JM (2010) Investigating neural correlates of behavior in freely behaving rodents using inertial sensors. Journal of Neurophysiology 104: 569.
- 35. Chakravarthy VS, Joseph D, Bapi RS (2010) What do the basal ganglia do? a modeling perspective. Biol Cybern 103: 237–253.
- 36. Kantelhardt JW, Zschiegner SA, Bunde EK, Havlin S, Bunde A, et al. (2002) Multifractal detrended fluctuation analysis of nonstationary time series. Physica A 316: 87–114.
- 37. Knab AM, Bowen RS, Harrison TM, Hamilton AT, Turner MJ, et al. (2009) Repeatability of exercise behaviors in mice. Physiol Behav 98: 433–440.
- 38. Tou JC, Wade CE (2002) Determinants affecting physical activity levels in animal models. Exp Biol Med 227: 587–600.
- 39. Houston AI, McNamara JM (2014) Foraging currencies, metabolism and behavioural routines. J Anim Ecol 83: 30–40.
- 40. Tang Y, Rothbart MK, Posner MI (2012) Neural correlates of establishing, maintaining, and switching brain states. Trends in Cognitive Sciences 16: 330–337.
- 41. Boyett MR (2009) And the beat goes on the cardiac conduction system: the wiring system of the heart. Exp Physiol 24: 654–62.
- 42. Ma X, Abboud FM, Chapleau MW (2003) Neurocardiovascular regulation in mice: Experimental approaches and novel findings. Clinical and Experimental Pharmacology and Physiology 30: 885–893.
- 43. Young CN, Davisson RL (2011) In vivo assessment of neurocardiovascular regulation in the mouse: principles, progress, and prospects. Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol 24: 654–62.
- 44. Ramirez JM, Koch H, Garcia AJ, Doi A, Zanella S (2011) The role of spiking and bursting pacemakers in the neuronal control of breathing. Journal of Biol Phys 37(3): 241–61.
- 45. Smith JC, Abdala AP, Borgmann A, Rybak IA, Paton JF (2013) Brainstem respiratory networks: building blocks and microcircuits. Trends Neurosciensce 36(3): 152–62.
- 46. Garcia AJ, Zanella S, Koch H, Doi A, Ramirez JM (2010) Networks within networks: The neuronal control of breathing. J Neurosci 30(24): 8251–62.
- 47. Williams RH, Burdakov D (2008) Hypothalamic orexins/hypocretins as regulators of breathing. Expert Reviews in Molecular Medicine 10: 1–10.
- 48. McAuley JH, Rothwell JC, Marsden CD (1998) Frequency peaks of tremor, muscle vibration and electromyographic activity at 10 hz, 20 hz and 40 hz during human finger muscle contraction may reflect rhyth-micities of central neural firing. Experimental Brain Research 114: 525–541.
- 49. Fowlera SC, Birkestranda B, RChena, Mossa SJ, Vorontsovab E, et al. (2001) A force-plate actometer for quantitating rodent behaviors: illustrative data on locomotion, rotation, spatial patterning, stereotypies, and tremor. Journal of Neuroscience Methods 107: 107–124.
- 50. Beck TW, Housh TJ, Johnson GO, Cramer JT, Weir JP, et al. (2007) Does the frequency content of the surface mechanomyographic signal reflect motor unit firing rates? a brief review. Journal of Electromyography and Kinesiology 17: 1–13.
- 51. Islam A, Sundaraj K, Ahmad RB, Ahamed NU (2013) Mechanomyogram for muscle function assessment: A review. PlosOne 8: 58902.
- 52. Ivanov PC, Amaral LAN, Goldberger AL, Stanley HE (1998) Stochastic feedback and the regulation of biological rhythms. Europhys Letters 43: 363–368.
- 53. Mora T, Bialek W (2011) Are biological systems poised at criticality? J Stat Phys: 268.
- 54. Ribeiro S, Gervasoni D, Soares ES, Zhou Y, Lin SC, et al. (2004) Long-lasting novelty-induced neuronal reverberation during slow-wave sleep in multiple forebrain areas. Plos Biology 2: E24.
- 55. Xu L, Ivanov PC, Hu K, Chen Z, Carbone A, et al.. (2005) Quantifying signals with power-law correlations: A comparative study of detrended fluctuatio analysis and detrended moving average techniques. Phys Rev E 71..
- 56. Chen Z, Hu K, Carpena P, Galvan PB, Stanley HE, et al.. (2005) Effect of nonlinear filters on detrended fluctuation analysis. Phys Rev E 71..
- 57. Ma QDY, Bartsch RP, Galván PB, Yoneyama M, Ivanov PC (2010) Effect of extreme data loss on long-range correlated and anticorrelated signals quantified by detrended fluctuation analysis. Phys Rev E 81..
- 58. Xua Y, Ma QD, Schmitt DT, Galván PB, Ivanov PC (2011) Effects of coarse-graining on the scaling behavior of long-range correlated and anti-correlated signals. Physica A 390: 4057–4072.
- 59. Taqqu M, Teverovsky V, Willinger W (1995) Self-similar processes in telecommunications. Fractals 3: 785.
- 60. Talkner P, Weber RO (2000) Power spectrum and detrended fluctuation analysis: application to daily temperatures. Phys Rev E 62: 150–160.
- 61. Heneghan C, McDarby G (2000) Establishing the relation between detrended fluctuation analysis and power spectral density analysis for stochastic processes. Phys Rev E 62: 6102–6110.
- 62. Bak P, Tang C, Wiesenfeld K (1987) Self-organized criticality: An explanation of the 1/f noise. Phys Rev Lett 59: 381–384.
- 63. dos Santos Lima GZ, Correa MA, Sommer RL, Bohn F (2012) Multifractality in domain wall dynamics of a ferromagnetic film. Phys Rev E 86..
- 64. Gierałtowski J, Zebrowski JJ, Baranowski R (2012) Multiscale multifractal analysis of heart rate variability recordings with a large number of occurrences of arrhythmia. Phys Rev E 85: 021915.