Arthritic lesions have been frequently diagnosed in the fossil record, with spondyloarthropathy (a type of erosive and pan-mammalian arthritis) being one of the most common types described to date for mammals, though not restricted to this group. Here, we identify spondyloarthropathy in fossil bones from the late Pleistocene in Brazil assignable to a large glyptodont individual. Bone erosions in the peripheral joints (viz., the ulna, radius, left femur and tibiae-fibulae) associated with osteosclerosis allow the diagnosis of spondyloarthropathy. The presence of osteophytes in seven bones of the forelimbs (viz., the ulna and radius) and hind limbs (viz., the tibiae-fibulae, left femur and patellae) and a subchondral cyst in one element (viz., the left femur) indicate secondary osteoarthritis. A calcified deposition on the articular surface of the left patella indicates the presence of calcium pyrophosphate deposition disease, which, like the observed osteoarthritic alterations, likely represents a complication of spondyloarthropathy. This is the first report of spondyloarthropathy for xenarthrans.
Citation: Barbosa FHdS, Porpino KdO, Fragoso ABL, Oliveira EV (2014) Arthritis in a Glyptodont (Mammalia, Xenarthra, Cingulata). PLoS ONE 9(2): e88646. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0088646
Editor: Kornelius Kupczik, Friedrich-Schiller-University Jena, Germany
Received: August 12, 2013; Accepted: January 8, 2014; Published: February 13, 2014
Copyright: © 2014 Barbosa et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: With the exception of a Master grant (number 149684/2011) conceded by Conselho Nacional de Desenvolvimento Científico e Tecnológico (CNPq/http://www.cnpq.br/) to the first author (FHS Barbosa), the authors' research was carried out without any resources provided by funding agencies or institutions. CNPq had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Arthritis includes a wide variety of joint diseases, including those in which the proliferation of new bone is the main feature (osteoarthritis) and those in which the key characteristic is bone erosion , . Among the latter type, spondyloarthropathy is one of the most common pathologies. It is an inflammatory form of arthritis encompassing several diseases that share common morphological and immunological alterations , . It is characterized by the propensity to form new bone, to ossify insertion sites of tendons or ligaments, to erode or asymmetrically fuse peripheral joints and to present articular lesions in the vertebral column and the sacroiliac joint –. Such alterations are associated with a specific histocompatibility antigen, HLA-B27 –. It has been recognized in several groups of fossils and living mammals, ranging from marsupials to proboscideans, perissodactylans, and primates, among several others , , from the Paleocene to the present . However, its earliest appearances in the fossil records are in archosaurs from the Triassic and Jurassic periods , .
In the Pleistocene in Brazil, arthritics lesions in xenarthrans, a mammalian group formed by sloths, anteaters, armadillos, giant armadillos and glyptodonts, have been sparsely documented –. In this paper, we report a case of spondyloarthropathy in a glyptodont, one of the most abundant and diversified members of the Pleistocene megafauna of South America. This account represents the first documentation of spondyloarthropathy in large xenarthrans. In addition, this finding broadens the geographic distribution of spondyloarthropathy in extinct mammals, insofar as the previous well-documented reports of this disease have been restricted to North America, Europe and Asia .
Materials and Methods
The glyptodontid remains studied here were collected together with bones of other mammalian taxa in a limestone cave in the Lajedo da Escada site, Rio Grande do Norte state, Brazil (Fig. 1), during expeditions in the late 1960s. The Lajedo da Escada site (UTM 642516, 9424502) is composed of two karstic pavements formed by carbonate rocks belonging to the Jandaíra Formation (Apodi Group, Potiguar Basin) with a total area of 5 km2 . In these pavements, there are several small caves filled with clayish sediment. The fossil accumulations in these sediments are composed mostly of mammalian remains belonging to species typical of the Quaternary of the Brazilian Intertropical Region . Comparable findings known from other continental fossil accumulations in deposits in northeastern Brazil (viz., in caves and tank deposits ) have traditionally been dated as Late Pleistocene . This inferred age concurs with most absolute age estimations of bones collected in caves and tank deposit accumulations from this region , .
Specimens Studied and Taxonomic Assignment
The material studied is housed in the Onofre Lopes Vertebrate Paleontology Collection of the Museu Câmara Cascudo, Natal, Rio Grande do Norte state, Brazil, and was released for this study by the curator in charge of this collection (M.F.C.F. Santos). It includes twenty-seven postcranial bones that were found in association with elements of an exoskeleton during the original excavation . The elements of the exoskeleton are composed of osteoderms from the dorsal carapace and caudal rings assigned to the Glyptodontinae genus Glyptotherium . The morphology of the postcranial bones is compatible with that of Pleistocene Glyptodontinae genera and contrasts with the morphology of representatives of other genera found in the Pleistocene deposits of northeastern Brazil, such as Panochthus and Hoplophorus, by presenting features such as comparatively short metapodials, a calcaneus with the peroneal tubercule being absent and a short, wide sulcus for the calcaneal tendon of the gastrocnemious muscle , . Because there are no other remains of glyptodonts at the Lajedo da Escada site and because all glyptodontid material was found in association with the aforementioned osteoderms, it appears more parsimonious to assign the postcranial bones studied here to the same genus as the osteoderms. Apart from the fact that these postcranial elements were collected in association, we believe that they belong to a single individual for two additional reasons: a) among them, there are several paired postcranial homologous bones presenting comparable dimensions (viz., the right and left patellae, the left and right tibiae-fibulae, the right and left calcanei, the right and left naviculars and the right and left radii; see below) and several articulating bones forming part of a hind limb (viz., the left patella, left tibia-fibula and left femur) and a forelimb (viz., the right radius and right ulna); and b) an examination of the epiphysis–diaphysis fusion grade (to the long bones) and the centrum–disk fusion grade (to the vertebrae) suggest that all analyzed bones are in the same ontogenetic stage (viz., a mature stage).
The postcranial elements studied include the following: MCC 176-177-178-182-410-415-V metapodials; MCC 232-237-238-239-240-242-V caudal vertebrae; MCC 337-V fragment of a pelvis; MCC 389-V left navicular; MCC 464-V right patella; MCC 467-V fragment of a right navicular; MCC 473-V left patella; MCC 481-V right radius; MCC 482-V proximal half of a left radius; MCC 485-V right calcaneus; MCC 491-V right ulna; MCC 862-V axis; MCC 1087-V proximal half of a right humerus; MCC 1515-V left tibia-fibula; MCC 1555-V left calcaneus; MCC 1560-V left femur; and MCC 1561-V right tibia-fibula.
All specimens were analyzed through a visual inspection. Additionally, the specimens MCC 473-V (left patella), MCC 481-V (right radius), MCC 482-V (proximal half of a left radius), MCC 491-V (right ulna) and MCC 1560-V (left femur) were submitted to a radiologic evaluation using an X-ray apparatus (Siemens Heliophos 4 S, 500 Ma, 125 Kv). The greater trochanter and a small portion of the diaphysis of the left femur MCC 1560-V, as well as the entire fibular portions of the left (MCC 1515-V) and right (MCC 1561-V) tibiae-fibulae, were restored in plaster. These restored parts were not taken into account in our analysis.
Among the examined skeletal elements, eight presented pathological lesions: the right patella (MCC 464-V), the left patella (MCC 473-V), the right radius (MCC 481-V), the proximal half of the left radius (MCC 482-V), the right ulna (MCC 491-V), the left tibia-fibula (MCC 1515-V), the left femur (MCC 1560-V), and the right tibia-fibula (MCC 1561-V).
The right ulna shows bone erosion and remodeling on the lateral surface of the proximal epiphysis extending from the most proximal portion of the trochlear notch to the distal margin of the radial notch (Fig. 2A). Its medial border also shows some bone growth. The lateral border of the articular surface for the radial notch of the ulna in the right radius shows remarkable bone erosion and remodeling, which extends medially (Fig. 3A). The eroded region shows smooth, rounded edges, with small, shallow, elliptical holes. In the left radius, similar alterations are observed in the homologous articulation, but they are less remarkable than in the right radius (Fig. 3C). In the X-ray images, it is possible to recognize sclerosis in the affected articular surfaces of both the right radius and ulna, represented by areas with increased bone density marked by enhanced radiopacity (Fig. 2B and 3B).
(A) A detail of the trochlear and radial notch in a cranial view; (B) Lateral radiography. The large white arrow indicate bone erosion, the smaller white arrow indicates bone growth and the black arrow indicates sclerosis. Scale bar in the detail A = 1 cm.
(A) A detail of the proximal epiphysis of the right radius MCC 481-V in caudal view; (B) Cranio-caudal radiography of the right radius MCC 481-V; (C) A detail of the proximal epiphysis left radius MCC 482-V in caudal view. Scale bars in the details A and C = 1 cm.
Hind limb elements
Cranially, the left femur presents bone growth in almost all margins of the head and of the trochlea (Fig. 4A and 4B). Additionally, there is well-marked bone erosion in the medial border of the trochlea and small pits on the proximal and lateral portions of its surface (Fig. 4B). Caudally, bone growth similar to that on the head is observed on the margins of the lateral and medial condyles (Fig. 4C), with some differences concerning their extension: in the former, the growth is limited to the lateral and proximal borders; in the latter, it is observed along all borders except for a small area on the distal border. The radiographic evaluation of the left femur reveals a small lytic lesion in the lateral condyle, which likely represents a degenerative subchondral cyst (Figs. 4D and 4E).
(A) A detail of the femoral head in proximal view; (B) a detail of the trochlea in cranial view; (C) A detail of the condyles in caudal view; (D) Cranio-caudal radiography of the femur; (E) Lateral radiography. The white arrows indicate osteophytes, the white arrowhead indicates bone erosion and the black arrows indicate subchondral cysts. Scale bars = 5 cm.
In the patellae (Figs. 5A-C), bone growth is present along the margins of the articular surface of the femoral trochlea. It is more evident in the right patella than in the left one because, in the latter, the borders of the articular surface were strongly eroded by taphonomic processes (Fig. 5B). In the X-ray images, scleroses are less noticeable (Fig. 5C) in contrast to the macroscopic evidence. Additionally, in the left patella (MCC 473-V), there is a small calcific deposition on the articular surface of the trochlea next to the lateral border (Fig. 5C).
(A) Right patella MCC 464-V in caudal view; (B) left patella MCC 473-V in caudal view; (C) Cranio-caudal radiography of the left patella. The white arrows indicate osteophytes, and the red circle indicates calcium deposition. Scale bar = 5 cm.
In the tibiae-fibulae, erosions and new bone formations are present on the preserved borders of the lateral and medial condyles (Fig. 6A and 6B). On the other hand, the astragalar facets of both tibiae-fibulae present no sign of bone alteration.
Despite the fact that spondyloarthropathy is a type of arthritis characterized mostly by erosive lesions in the vertebral column and the sacroiliac joint, it can be identified by the presence of asymmetrical pauciarticular peripheral joint erosion or fusion in cases where there are no vertebral or sacroiliitis lesions , . We have identified well-marked erosive lesions characteristic of spondyloarthropathy on the trochlear notch of the right ulna, the lateral border of the articular surface of the right radius for the radial notch of the ulna and on the homologous articulation of the left radius, as well as on the borders of the lateral and medial condyles of the tibiae-fibulae. On the right ulna and on the right and left radii, these degenerative alterations are surrounded by irregular bone growth. Additionally, the X-ray images allowed the recognition of bone sclerosis associated with these lesions on the articular surfaces of the forelimb, evidencing the occurrence of bone reaction in those elements.
As previously mentioned, spondyloarthropathy is a type of arthritis that encompass several varieties of arthritis: ankylosing spondylitis, Reiter’s syndrome, psoriatic arthritis, arthritis associated with inflammatory bowel disease and undifferentiated spondyloarthropathy , . However, to differentiate among the types of spondyloarthropathy is not always possible, especially when the evidence is based only on skeletal remains. When the available material is limited to bones, as in most paleontological cases, the distinction is based on the observation of patterns of bone alterations in the joints of the spine and the sacroiliac joint , . Unfortunately, the only preserved components of the axial skeleton associated with the forelimb and hind limb elements described here are the caudal vertebrae, which present no noticeable alterations.
When spondyloarthropathy is not associated with vertebral and sacroiliac lesions, it can be confused with rheumatoid arthritis (a polyarticular, erosive arthritis) , , . However, bone-reactive sclerosis at the borders of the lesions, as evidenced by the X-ray images of the affected skeletal elements studied here (Figs. 2B and 3B), is absent in rheumatoid arthritis . Moreover, subchondral erosion, like that observed in the left femur, is rare in rheumatoid arthritis , thus allowing us to eliminate it as the cause of the observed lesions.
Interestingly, all of the specimens analyzed present osteophytes on at least one of their articular margins—the sole exceptions were the ulna and radii, where the observed bone reactions may not be osteophytes but, instead, the reactive bone typical of spondyloarthropathy (Fig. 2 and 3). The presence of osteophytes in synovial joints is characteristic of osteoarthritis, a non-inflammatory and non-erosive type of arthritis . Moreover, there is a subchondral cyst in the lateral condyle of the left femur (Fig. 4D and 4E), a type of lesion that has been related to complications or an advanced stage of osteoarthritis . The absence of grooved and eburnated articular surfaces suggests that the osteoarthritis was not severe, and it may have developed as a secondary complication to the spondyloarthropathy, which can be clearly differentiated from osteoarthritis by the presence of erosive lesions; therefore, spondyloarthropathy can be considered the primary disease in the studied case. In addition, it is worth noting that osteoarthritis is quite uncommon in fossil and free-ranging living mammals and is apparently more characteristic of artificially restrained animals , .
The presence of calcific concretions on the joint surface of the left patella (Fig. 5B) is compatible with calcium pyrophosphate deposition disease (CPPD). This disease is a type of crystalline arthritis recognized by the presence of a calcified sheet deposited on the articular surface, radiocarpal articular surface indentation and calcific concretions on the joint surface , . In the present case, CPPD, like the osteoarthritis, seems to be a secondary phenomenon—i.e., such alterations represent a complication of spondyloarthropathy.
Spondyloarthropathy has been associated to individual (e.g. body mass) and ecological (e.g. life history traits) characteristics of mammalian species . Previous studies on several extinct and extant mammalian groups ,  suggest that spondyloarthropathy is a pan-mammalian disease but not directly related to body mass. However, a recent comparative study revealed statistically significant results for spondyloarthropathy as more prevalent in large-bodied primates and carnivores . The overweight caused by the large body mass is an appealing explanation for the presence of spondyloarthropathy in the large-bodied glyptodont studied here. In fact, large-bodied mammals are also more exposed to infections  for several reasons, including greater food consumption (thus increasing the risk of ingesting pathogenic organisms) and stress related to joint damage that could facilitate the development of local infectious disease . Nevertheless, further studies including cingulates with different body masses would be necessary to test the correlation of spondyloarthropathy/large body mass in this group.
Concerning previous arthritis cases in large Xenarthrans and other representatives of the South American megafauna, there are some previous identifications, such as osteoarthritis in the vertebrae of Megatheriidae , in a right humerus of Mylodon  and metacarpals of Panochthus  as well as osteochondritis dissecans in a left radius and left femoral head of Toxodon, a right femur of Mylodon and a pelvis fragment of Glyptodon . In some of these reports , , subchondral erosions on facets joints are described as one of the main lesions identified. This type of lesion is more compatible with spondyloarthropathy than with osteoarthritis (which is a non-erosive disease)  or osteochondritis dissecans. Although spondyloarthropathy may be the likely diagnosis for some of the aforementioned reports of arthritic lesions, a more detailed analysis of the referenced material would be crucial for a sound conclusion. Thus, the spondyloarthropathy case reported in this paper is, to our knowledge, the first formal description of this disease for large Xenarthrans and for the South American megafauna.
Visual examination and radiologic analysis of several postcranial bones assignable to a single individual of Glyptotherium from Lajedo da Escada site, northeastern Brazil, evidenced three types of arthritis: one type of inflammatory arthritis (spondyloarthropathy), one type of crystalline arthritis (calcium pyrophosphate deposition disease) and one proliferative arthritis (osteoarthritis). Spondyloarthropathy, considered the primary disease, is diagnosed by the presence of bone erosions in a right ulna, right and left radii, a left femur and both right and left tibiae-fibulae and is associated with bone sclerosis (in the right ulna and radii). Calcium pyrophosphate deposition disease was diagnosed by the presence of calcium deposition observed on the articular surface of the left patella. Finally, osteoarthritis was identified by the presence of osteophytes in the left femur, in the right and left patellae, and in both tibiae-fibulae. This represents the first case of spondyloarthropathy formally reported in Xenarthrans.
We thank M.F.C.F. Santos (Museu Câmara Cascudo), who kindly gave us access to the specimen studied here; to L.H.M. Silva for his support during the examination of the material; to F.J.V. Sousa (Clínica de Raios-X e Ultra-Som) for crucial help in the radiographic evaluation; and H.I. Araújo-Júnior and G.A. Pacheco for helping with the discussion and the creation of the figures. B.M. Rothschild, R.A. Fariña and S.F. Vizcaíno are thanked for their thoughtful comments and suggestions, which greatly improved this paper.
Conceived and designed the experiments: FHdSB KdOP ABLF EVO. Analyzed the data: FHdSB KdOP ABLF EVO. Wrote the paper: FHdSB KdOP ABLF EVO.
- 1. Waldron T (2009) Palaeopathology. New York, Cambridge University Press.
- 2. Rothschild BM, Martin LD (2006) Skeletal impact of disease. Albuquerque, New Mexico Museum of Natural History & Science, Division of the Department of cultural affairs, 226 p. (Bulletim 33).
- 3. Ortner DJ (2003) Methods used in the analysis of the skeletal lesions. In: Ortner DJ, editor. Identification of pathological condictions in human skeletal remains. San Diego: Academic Press. pp. 45–63.
- 4. Rothschild BM, Rothschild C (2000) Spondyloarthropathy as a transmammalian phenomenon, reproducible in its manifestations across species lines. J Paleopath 11: 103–104.
- 5. Rothschild B, Hao-wen T, Tao D, Xiaoting Z (2013) Arthritis through geologic time and its environmental implications. J Anc Dis Prev Remedies 1: 1–3.
- 6. Rothschild B, Helbling M, Miles C (2002) Spondyloarthropathy in the Jurassic. Lancet 360: 1454.
- 7. Cisneros JC, Cabral UG, De Beer F, Damiani R, Fortier Dc (2010) Spondarthritis in the Triassic. PLoS One 5: 5.
- 8. Ferigolo J (1985) Paleopatologia em preguiças terrícolas: Artrose. In: Congresso Brasileiro de Paleontologia. Rio de Janeiro: Coletânea de Trabalhos Paleontológicos, p. 43–49.
- 9. Ferigolo J (1992) Non-human vertebrate paleopathology of some Brazilian Pleistocene Mammals. In: Araújo AJG, Ferreira LF, coordinators. Paleopatologia, Paleoepidemiologia. Estudos multidisciplinares, Rio de Janeiro: Panorama. Escola Nacional de Saúde Pública, Fundação Oswaldo Cruz. p. 213–234.
- 10. Henriques DDR, Soares AA, Mello MGS (1998) Registros de reação óssea em Panochthus BURMEISTER, 1866 do Pleistoceno do Estado da Paraíba. Acta Geol Leopol XXI(46/47): 149–155.
- 11. Carvalho JNC (1966) Considerações sobre a fauna pleistocênica do Lajedo da Escada. In: Arquivos do Instituto de Antropologia, Natal: Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Norte, p. 303–313.
- 12. Cartelle C (1999) Pleistocene mammals of the Cerrado and Caatinga of Brazil. In: Eisenberg, JB, Redford, KH. editors. Mammals of the Neotropics. The Central Tropics. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. 3: p. 27–46.
- 13. Araújo-Júnior HI, Porpino KO, Ximenes CL, Bergqvist LP (2013) Unveiling the taphonomy of elusive natural tank deposits: A study case in the Pleistocene of northeastern Brazil. Palaeogeogr Palaeoclimatol Palaeoecol 378: 52–74.
- 14. Auler AS, Piló LB, Smart PL, Wang X, Hoffmann D, et al. (2006) U-series dating and taphonomy of Quaternary vertebrates from Brazilian caves. Palaeogeogr Palaeoclimatol Palaeoecol 240: 508–522.
- 15. Ribeiro RC, Kinoshita A, Figueiredo AMG, Carvalho IS, Baffa O (2012) Electron spin resonance dating of the late Quaternary megafauna fossils from Baixa Grande, Bahia, Brasil, Quat Int In press.
- 16. Oliveira EV, Porpino KO, Barreto AF, Silva FM (2010) On the presence of Glyptotherium in the late Pleistocene of Northeastern Brazil, and the status of “Glyptodon” and “Chlamydotherium”. Paleobiogeografic implications. N Jb Geo Paläont Abh 258(3): 353–363.
- 17. Porpino KO, Bergqvist LP (2002) Novos achados de Panochthus (Mammalia, Cingulata, Glyptodontoidea) no Nordeste do Brasil. Rev Bras Paleontol 4: 51–62.
- 18. Porpino KO, Fernicola JC, Bergqvist LP (2010) Revisiting the intertropical Brazilian species Hoplophorus euphractus (Cingulata, Glyptodontoidea) and the phylogenetic affinities of Hoplophorus. J Vertebr Paleontol 30: 911–927.
- 19. Rothschild BM, Rothschild C, Woods RJ (2001) Inflammatory arthritis in canids: spondyloarthropathy inflammatory arthritis in canids. J Zoo Wildl Med 32: 58–64.
- 20. Rothschild BM, Panza R (2006) Osteoarthritis is for the birds. Clin Rheumatol 25: 645–647.
- 21. Hart DJ, Spector TD (1995) The classification and assessment of osteoarthritis. Baillieres Clin Rheumatol 9: 407–432.
- 22. Rothschild MD, Woods RJ, Rothschild C (1992) Calcium pyrophosphate deposition disease: description in defleshed skeletons. Clin Exp Rheumatol 10: 557–564.
- 23. Nunn CL, Rothschild BM, Gittleman JL (2006) Why are some species more commonly afflicted by arthritis than others? A comparative study of spondyloarthropathy in primates and carnivores. J Evol Biol 20: 460–470.
- 24. Rothschild BM, Prothero DR, Rothschild C, Rothschild BM, Donald R (2001) Paleopathology Origins of spondyloarthropathy in Perissodactyla. Clin Exp Rheumatol: 4–8.
- 25. Moore SL, Wilson K (2002) Parasites as a viability cost of sexual selection in natural populations of mammals. Science 297: 2015–2018.