Recent studies have shown that elevated CO2 can affect the behaviour of larval and juvenile fishes. In particular, behavioural lateralization, an expression of brain functional asymmetries, is affected by elevated CO2 in both coral reef and temperate fishes. However, the potentially interacting effects of rising temperatures and CO2 on lateralization are unknown. Here, we tested the combined effect of near-future elevated-CO2 concentrations (930 µatm) and temperature variation on behavioural lateralization of a marine damselfish, Pomacentrus wardi. Individuals exposed to one of four treatments (two CO2 levels and two temperatures) were observed in a detour test where they made repeated decisions about turning left or right. Individuals exposed to current CO2 and ambient temperature levels showed a significant right-turning bias at the population level. This biased was reversed (i.e. to the left side) in fish exposed to the elevated-CO2 treatment. Increased temperature attenuated this effect, resulting in lower values of relative lateralization. Consequently, rising temperature and elevated CO2 may have different and interactive effects on behavioural lateralization and therefore future studies on the effect of climate change on brain functions need to consider both these critical variables in order to assess the potential consequences for the ecological interactions of marine fishes.
Citation: Domenici P, Allan BJM, Watson S-A, McCormick MI, Munday PL (2014) Shifting from Right to Left: The Combined Effect of Elevated CO2 and Temperature on Behavioural Lateralization in a Coral Reef Fish. PLoS ONE 9(1): e87969. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0087969
Editor: Daniel Osorio, University of Sussex, United Kingdom
Received: September 27, 2013; Accepted: January 2, 2014; Published: January 31, 2014
Copyright: © 2014 Domenici et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: Funding was provided by the ARC Centre of Excellence for Coral Reef Studies and an ARC Discovery grant (MIM). The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
The amount of CO2 dissolved in the ocean and the average temperature of the ocean are rising as a result of increasing concentrations of atmospheric CO2 . Recent work has shown that increased CO2 levels predicted to occur in the ocean by the end of this century can have negative effects on a number of behavioural attributes of marine fishes, such as anti-predator responses , , sensory performance ,  and lateralization , . Behavioural changes induced by elevated CO2 can have significant negative consequences for survival in natural coral reef habitats  and for a range of other ecological processes, such as habitat selection, timing of settlement and navigation to resting sites , . Behavioural changes induced by elevated CO2 are reversed by treatment with an antagonist of the GABA-A receptor, suggesting that CO2 interferes with neurotransmitter function , . While temperature is known to affect the physiological performance and metabolism of coral reef fishes , little is known of its effect on behavioural tasks such as lateralization, or the potential interactive effects of elevated CO2 and ocean warming on the behaviour of marine organisms.
In fishes and other animals, individuals may show a tendency to turn more often in one direction in a T-maze (detour test), or to use the left or right limb more often when facing a specific task . This behavioural lateralization is an expression of brain asymmetry , . The degree of lateralization is likely to reflect a trade-off between the higher performance of lateralized individuals in schooling , escape responses  and multitasking , as a result of their higher cognitive performance , compared with the ability of non-lateralized individuals to deal equally well with stimuli or threats from all directions . Lateralization level can also vary according to predation pressure, with individuals from high-predation sites exhibiting stronger lateralization than those from low-predation sites . Studies of fish lateralization behaviour using the detour test have shown that many species tend to have a bias at the population level, although species with non-lateralized populations and a directional bias only at the individual level also occur . Recent work has also shown that behavioural lateralization at the individual level is disrupted by exposure to elevated CO2 , ; however, whether the effects of elevated CO2 on lateralization are influenced by water temperature is currently unknown. Projected increases in ocean temperature could interact with elevated CO2 levels to further alter the effects on behavioural lateralization. In the present study we test the interactive effects of elevated CO2 and temperature variation on individual and population-level lateralization in a coral reef damselfish.
Materials and Methods
Research was carried out under approval of the James Cook University animal ethics committee (permit: A1720) and according to the University's animal ethics guidelines. Fish collections around Lizard Island, Great Barrier Reef were carried with permission of the Great Barrier Reef Parks Authority (permit: G10/33239.1) and Queensland Government Department of Primary Industry and Fisheries (permit: 103256).
The study species Pomacentrus wardi is small planktivorous damselfish commonly found on Indo-Pacific coral reefs, where it forms extensive aggregations on the reef crest. Settlement-stage larvae of Pomacentrus wardi were collected overnight using light traps moored in open water on the western side of Lizard Island (14°40′S, 145°28′E), in the northern Great Barrier Reef, Australia, during October 2012. Juveniles were then maintained in identical rearing tanks at either control (∼405 µatm) or elevated CO2 (∼930 µatm) cross-factored with control (∼27°C) or elevated temperature (∼30°C). Control conditions were ambient for the study site at the time of the study and elevated CO2 (930 µatm) and temperature (+3°C) treatments matched projected increases by year 2100 . For fish in the elevated temperature treatment group, the temperature was raised by 1°C each 8 hours until the final temperature of ∼29.7°C was reached. This was to avoid any stress associated with rapid temperature increases. Both groups were transferred to 35-L tanks with four treatments: Control- CO2/Control-Temperature (C- CO2/C-Temp i.e. 396 μatm, 26.7°C), Control- CO2/Elevated-Temperature (C-CO2/E-Temp, i.e. 415 µatm, 29.6°C), Elevated- CO2/Control-Temperature (E- CO2/C-Temp, i.e. 921 µatm, 26.8°C) and Elevated- CO2/Elevated-Temperature (E- CO2/E-Temp, i.e. 935 µatm, 29.8°C) (Table 1) for a period of seven days. Previous work has shown that the behavioural effects of elevated CO2 are manifest within 4 days of exposure to relevant CO2 treatments, and that longer durations of exposure do not alter behavioural responses , therefore larvae were maintained in the CO2 treatments for seven consecutive days. Each tank contained 25 fish. Fish were fed ab libitum with Artemia sp. A 12 hour light and 12 hour dark regime was used.
CO2 and temperature treatments
Tanks were heated with 300-watt bar heaters. Tanks were insulated with Insulbreak to ensure stability of the chosen temperatures of 26.7°C and 29.7°C. CO2 treatments were maintained by CO2 dosing to a set pHNBS. Seawater was pumped from the ocean into 60 L sumps where it was diffused with ambient air (control) or CO2 to achieve a pH of 7.87. The pH value was selected to achieve the approximate CO2 conditions required, based on preliminary observations of total alkalinity, salinity and temperature of seawater at Lizard Island. A pH-controller (Aqua Medic, Germany) was attached to the CO2 treatment sump to maintain pH at the desired level. A solenoid injected a slow stream of CO2 into a powerhead at the bottom of the sump whenever the pH of the seawater rose above the set point. Equilibrated seawater from each sump was supplied at a rate of ∼720 ml.min−1 to four replicate 35-L aquaria, each housing a small group of larval fish. Temperature and pHNBS of each aquarium was measured daily using a pH meter (HQ40d, Hach, Colorado, USA) calibrated with fresh buffers and a temperature probe (C22, Comark, Norwich, UK). Total alkalinity of seawater was estimated by Gran titration (888 Titrando, Metrohm, Switzerland) from water samples taken twice weekly from control and treatment tanks. Alkalinity standardizations achieved accuracy within 1% of certified reference material from Dr. A. Dickson (Scripps Institution of Oceanography). Seawater p CO2 was calculated from seawater parameters in the program CO2SYS  using the constants of Mehrbach et al. , refit by Dickson and Millero . Seawater parameters are shown in Table 1.
Behavioural lateralization was evaluated using a detour test . The detour test is commonly used to evaluate behavioural asymmetries in fish and birds , . The apparatus used in this study was based on a design used previously by Bisazza et al.  and Dadda et al. , and it consists of a two-way T-maze runway which allows to score the direction of the turn (i.e. right or left) of each individual over consecutive runs. Briefly, the experimental apparatus consisted of a glass tank (60×30×40 cm, length×width×height), with a runway in the middle (25×3 cm, length×width) and at both ends of the runway (3 cm ahead of the runway) a white opaque barrier (12×12×1 cm, length×height×width, attached to a 9×9×9 cm glass square behind the barrier) was positioned perpendicular to the orientation of the runway. The runway was delimited by two glass tanks (25×13×20 cm, length×width×height) that provided partitions between the two areas in which the barriers were positioned (Fig. 1). Water in the tank was 4 cm deep. At the start of each trial, a single fish was introduced into the experimental arena and left for 2 min to become accustomed to the environment. During each trial, fish were gently maneuvered to the starting point of the runway. The fish then swam along the runway until it faced the barrier. Fish then had to make a decision to turn left or right around the barrier. Turning was scored by direct observation. The criterion used for scoring was the first turning direction taken by the fish when exiting from the runaway. Ten consecutive runs were observed for each fish, from which the score of the turning direction and the degree of lateralization were obtained. To account for any possible asymmetry in the set up, tests were carried out alternately on the two ends of the runway . Water temperature in the experimental tank was maintained at 26.8 or 29.7°C depending on the treatment. Control water (i.e. not treated with additional CO2) was used in all the detour tests. Previous studies  have shown that behavioural impairment caused by exposure to elevated CO2 lasts for several days and is not affected by testing fish in CO2-treated water versus control water.
A total of 164 individuals were used in the experiments (N = 58 for C- CO2/C-Temp; N = 40 for C- CO2/E-Temp; N = 42 for the E- CO2/C-Temp; and N = 24 for E- CO2/E-Temp). In order to compare these 4 groups with respect to their left-right preference in the detour test, we used a relative lateralization index (LR) according to the following formula : LR = [(Turn to the right−Turn to the left)/(Turn to the right+Turn to the left)]*100.
Mean LR was used to assess turning preference (i.e. bias in left or right turns) at the population level. On the basis of the LR index, individuals were classified between the extreme values of ‘100’ (fish that turned right on all 10 trials) and ‘−100’ (fish that turned left on all 10 trials). A mean LR near zero indicates that a given sample of the population is neither left- nor right-biased in its turning tendency . The LR of each group was then compared to a theoretical zero using a one sample t-test .
A sample that is not left or right biased may include individuals that are themselves right or left biased. Therefore, the absolute lateralization index (LA) of each fish was calculated to evaluate the strength of individual lateralization in the detour test irrespective of their preference for right or left turning. The LA index corresponds to the absolute value of LR, thus ranging from 0 (an individual that turned in equal proportion to the right and to the left) to 100 (an individual that turned right or left on all 10 trials). LA thus allowed us to compare the strength of the lateralization (irrespective of its direction) among groups at the individual level. Comparison among the LR and LA of all groups was carried out using two-way ANOVAs (with Temperature and CO2 as factors) and a Tukey's post-hoc test. Assumptions of normality and homogeneity of variance were examined using residual analysis.
LR values showed a significant interaction between CO2 and Temperature (F1, 160 = 10.97, P<0.01), and a significant main effect of CO2 (F1, 160 = 41.45, P<0.001), but not of temperature (F1, 160 = 0.05, P>0.5). Post-hoc tests showed significant differences between the Control-CO2/Control-Temperature group and all other groups (C-CO2/C-Temp vs. C-CO2/E-Temp, P<0.05; C-CO2/C-Temp vs. E-CO2/C-Temp, P<0.001; C-CO2/C-Temp vs. E-CO2/E-Temp, P<0.001), and between the Control-CO2/Elevated-Temperature and the Elevated-CO2/Control-Temperature group (P<0.001) (Fig. 2A). LA was not affected by CO2, temperature or an interaction between these factors (F1, 160 = 0.36; F1, 160 = 2.22; F1, 160 = 0.19, respectively, P>0.1 in all cases; Fig. 2B).
Significant differences between treatments (post–hoc test) are indicated by letters.
A bias in the relative lateralization index was found at the population level for Control-CO2/Control-Temperature, Control-CO2/Elevated-Temperature and Elevated-CO2/Control-Temperature [one sample t-tests (supplementary material): C-CO2/C-Temp, t(57) = 6.65, P<0.0001; C-CO2/E-Temp, t(39) = 4.37, P<0.0001; E-CO2/C-Temp, t(41) = 2.15, P<0.05]. However, elevated CO2 influenced the direction of lateralization; individuals from Control-CO2/Control-Temperature and Control-CO2/Elevated-Temperature had a significant preference for right turns (LR = 26.9±4.04 and 9.5±4.43, respectively), whereas individuals from Elevated-CO2/Control-Temperature had a significance preference for left turns (LR = −21.0±4.80). Individuals from the Elevated-CO2/Elevated-Temperature group did not show a significant directional bias, with their LR being not significantly different from zero (LR = −5.8±5.96; t(23) = 0.98, P>0.1).
Therefore, elevated CO2 reversed the relative lateralization bias from right to left, as indicated by the mirror images of the directionally-biased LR frequency distributions of the Control-CO2/Control-Temperature and Elevated-CO2/Control-Temperature treatments (Fig. 3A). The high-temperature treatment attenuated this effect and the two high-temperature distributions (C-CO2/E-Temp and E-CO2/E-Temp) largely overlapped (Fig. 3B).
Our work is the first one to test the effect of exposure to elevated CO2 levels in a species that is lateralized at the population level. Previous work, carried out in species that were unbiased at the population level , , show that lateralization at the individual level is disrupted by elevated CO2. Here we show that the turning direction of a species lateralized at the population level can be reversed (from right to left), with interesting implications for brain control mechanisms (see below). Furthermore, we also tested the modulating effect of temperature, and we found a significant interaction with elevated temperature, such that individuals exposed to higher temperatures showed a reduced level of relative lateralization.
Although temperature is known to have a fundamental effect on fish metabolism, activity and performance , little is known about its effect on behavioural tasks. While temperature has been shown to affect some behavioural decisions , no previous studies have tested its effect on lateralization, or how it may interact with other environmental variables to affect lateralization. Here, we show that exposure to increased temperature has a dampening effect on the lateralization level of the population, in both control and elevated CO2 treatments. This indicates a malfunction or attenuation of the turning bias as a result of elevated temperature, the mechanism of which may be related to temperature effects on the cerebral processes at the basis of the left/right choice. Although the elevated temperature used in our experiment was 3°C higher than the ambient October temperature of 27°C, P. wardi do experience temperatures around 30°C in the middle of summer. Therefore, it would be interesting to test if the attenuation of lateralization is due to the unseasonal increase in temperature, or to the high temperature per se, regardless of season/acclimation time.
The shift in right to left lateralization under elevated CO2 suggests that the altered neurotransmitter function responsible for behavioural impairment in marine fishes may generate an inversion of the functional brain asymmetry that is the basis of behavioural lateralization, as shown in Neopomacentrus azysron . A possible interpretation of these results is that the reversal from right turning bias when facing the opaque barrier (suggesting left brain control, ) to left-turning bias (suggesting right brain control) is a consequence of stress. Previous work indeed suggests that stressed animals tend to rely on the predominant use of the right hemisphere . Interestingly, the species we tested here shows a relatively low level of individual lateralization (LA around 30), compared to N. azysron (LA around 50) . This suggests that the precise mechanism responsible for individual lateralization may differ between the two species, which could explain why individual behavioral lateralization was disrupted in N. azysron  while it was reversed in P. wardi.
While CO2 does not affect the individual lateralization level (i.e. LA) of P. wardi, its effect of reversing the side bias from right to left might still have ecological implications. Population-level lateralization has been suggested to be more likely in gregarious species, because of the need to maintain group cohesion . P. wardi is not gregarious during the juvenile phase  and its population-level lateralization confirms that this pattern can also occur in non-gregarious individuals . Although the evolutionary pressure that produces such pattern of lateralization in solitary species is unknown, it may be related to asymmetries in their natural environment, e.g. in their predators . Alternatively, the population-level lateralization observed in juveniles may be the result of a carry-over effect of shoaling during the larval phase which precedes the juvenile stage only by a few days. If we assume that the LR pattern of distribution found in populations caught in the field is the result of natural selection, the decrease of LR caused by temperature is likely to diminish any advantage provided by the population-level directional bias. Similarly, side-shifts in the direction bias as a result of environmental changes, such as elevated CO2, could decrease the performance of the population.
Our results provide strong evidence that the combined effect of elevated CO2 and temperature can vary both the direction and the magnitude of lateralization in fish. Because lateralized individuals show superior performance in anti-predator responses , gregariousness , and multitasking such as foraging while performing predator vigilance , it is likely that the combined effect of CO2 and temperature will interfere with the natural behaviour of fish and this may have consequences for the outcome of important ecological interactions, such as predator-prey encounters.
Research was carried out under approval from the Great Barrier Reef Marine Park Authority, and under James Cook University ethics guidelines.
Conceived and designed the experiments: PD MIM PLM. Performed the experiments: PD BJMA. Analyzed the data: PD. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: PD BJMA SAW MIM PLM. Wrote the paper: PD BJMA SAW MIM PLM.
- 1. Doney SC (2010) The Growing Human Footprint on Coastal and Open-Ocean Biogeochemistry. Science 328: 1512–1516.
- 2. Allan BJM, Domenici P, McCormick MI, Watson SA, Munday PL (2013) Elevated CO2 Affects Predator-Prey Interactions through Altered Performance. PLoS ONE 8.
- 3. Ferrari MCO, McCormick MI, Munday PL, Meekan MG, Dixson DL, et al. (2011) Putting prey and predator into the CO2 equation - qualitative and quantitative effects of ocean acidification on predator-prey interactions. Ecol Lett 14: 1143–1148.
- 4. Simpson SD, Munday PL, Wittenrich ML, Manassa R, Dixson DL, et al. (2011) Ocean acidification erodes crucial auditory behaviour in a marine fish. Biol Lett 7: 917–920.
- 5. Munday PL, Dixson DL, Donelson JM, Jones GP, Pratchett MS, et al. (2009) Ocean acidification impairs olfactory discrimination and homing ability of a marine fish. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 106: 1848–1852.
- 6. Domenici P, Allan B, McCormick MI, Munday PL (2012) Elevated carbon dioxide affects behavioural lateralization in a coral reef fish. Biol Lett 8: 78–81.
- 7. Jutfelt F, de Souza KB, Vuylsteke A, Sturve J (2013) Behavioural Disturbances in a Temperate Fish Exposed to Sustained High-CO2 Levels. PLoS ONE 8.
- 8. Munday PL, Dixson DL, McCormick MI, Meekan M, Ferrari MCO, et al. (2010) Replenishment of fish populations is threatened by ocean acidification. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 107: 12930–12934.
- 9. Munday PL, McCormick MI, Nilsson GE (2012) Impact of global warming and rising CO2 levels on coral reef fishes: what hope for the future? J Exp Biol 215: 3865–3873.
- 10. Briffa M, de la Haye K, Munday PL (2012) High CO2 and marine animal behaviour: Potential mechanisms and ecological consequences. Mar Pollut Bull 64: 1519–1528.
- 11. Chivers DP, McCormick MI, Nilsson GE, Munday PL, Watson S-A, et al. (2013) Impaired learning of predators and lower prey survival under elevated CO2: a consequence of neurotransmitter interference. Glob Change Biol (in press).
- 12. Nilsson GE, Dixson DL, Domenici P, McCormick MI, Sorensen C, et al. (2012) Near-future carbon dioxide levels alter fish behaviour by interfering with neurotransmitter function. Nature Climate Change 2: 201–204.
- 13. Nilsson GE, Crawley N, Lunde IG, Munday PL (2009) Elevated temperature reduces the respiratory scope of coral reef fishes. Glob Change Biol 15: 1405–1412.
- 14. Vallortigara G, Rogers LJ (2005) Survival with an asymmetrical brain: Advantages and disadvantages of cerebral lateralization. Behav Brain Sci 28: 575–+.
- 15. Bisazza A, Cantalupo C, Capocchiano M, Vallortigara G (2000) Population lateralisation and social behaviour: A study with 16 species of fish. Laterality 5: 269–284.
- 16. Bisazza A, Dadda M (2005) Enhanced schooling performance in lateralized fishes. Proc R Soc Biol Sci Ser B 272: 1677–1681.
- 17. Dadda M, Koolhaas WH, Domenici P (2010) Behavioural asymmetry affects escape performance in a teleost fish. Biol Lett 6: 414–417.
- 18. Dadda M, Bisazza A (2006) Does brain asymmetry allow efficient performance of simultaneous tasks? Anim Behav 72: 523–529.
- 19. Brown C, Gardner C, Braithwaite VA (2004) Population variation in lateralized eye use in the poeciliid Brachyraphis episcopi. Proceedings of the Royal Society B-Biological Sciences 271: S455–S457.
- 20. Meinshausen M, Smith SJ, Calvin K, Daniel JS, Kainuma MLT, et al. (2011) The RCP greenhouse gas concentrations and their extensions from 1765 to 2300. Clim Change 109: 213–241.
- 21. Pierrot D, Lewis E, Wallace DWR (2006) MS Excel Program Developed for CO2 System Calculations Oak Ridge, Tennessee, USA, ORNL/CDIAC-105a Carbon Dioxide Information Analysis Center, Oak Ridge National Laboratory, US Department of Energy.
- 22. Mehrbach C, Culberso Ch, Hawley JE, Pytkowic Rm (1973) (1973) Measurement of apparent dissociation-constants of carbonic acid in seawater at atmospheric pressure. Limnol Oceanogr 18: 897–907.
- 23. Dickson AG, Millero FJ (1987) A comparison of the equilibrium-constants for the dissociation of carbonic-acid in seawater media. Deep-Sea Research Part a-Oceanographic Research Papers 34: 1733–1743.
- 24. Vallortigara G, Regolin L, Pagni P (1999) Detour behaviour, imprinting and visual lateralization in the domestic chick. Cognitive Brain Research 7: 307–320.
- 25. Bisazza A, Facchin L, Pignatti R, Vallortigara G (1998) Lateralization of detour behaviour in poeciliid fish: The effect of species, gender and sexual motivation. Behav Brain Res 91: 157–164.
- 26. Weetman D, Atkinson D, Chubb JC (1999) Water temperature influences the shoaling decisions of guppies, Poecilia reticulata, under predation threat. Anim Behav 58: 735–741.
- 27. Sale PF, Doherty PJ, Douglas WA (1980) Juvenile recruitment strategies and the coexistence of territorial pomacentrid fishes. Bull Mar Sci 30: 147–158.
- 28. Bisazza A, Pignatti R, Vallortigara G (1997) Laterality in detour behaviour: interspecific variation in poeciliid fish. Animal Behavior 54: 1273–1281.
- 29. Rogers LJ (2010) Relevance of brain and behavioural lateralization to animal welfare. Appl Anim Behav Sci 127: 1–11.