Motivated by recent experimental findings, we propose a novel mechanism of embryonic pattern formation based on coupling of tissue curvature with diffusive signaling by a chemical factor. We derive a new mathematical model using energy minimization approach and show that the model generates a variety of morphogen and curvature patterns agreeing with experimentally observed structures. The mechanism proposed transcends the classical Turing concept which requires interactions between two morphogens with a significantly different diffusivity. Our studies show how biomechanical forces may replace the elusive long-range inhibitor and lead to formation of stable spatially heterogeneous structures without existence of chemical prepatterns. We propose new experimental approaches to decisively test our central hypothesis that tissue curvature and morphogen expression are coupled in a positive feedback loop.
Citation: Mercker M, Hartmann D, Marciniak-Czochra A (2013) A Mechanochemical Model for Embryonic Pattern Formation: Coupling Tissue Mechanics and Morphogen Expression. PLoS ONE 8(12): e82617. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0082617
Editor: Alexandre J. Kabla, University of Cambridge, United Kingdom
Received: August 23, 2013; Accepted: October 23, 2013; Published: December 20, 2013
Copyright: © 2013 Mercker et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: The authors acknowledge the financial support of the ViroQuant Project (German FORSYS initiative) and WIN Project “Principles in the generation of the biological form” of the Heidelberg Academy of Sciences and Humanities. MM and AM-C have been supported by the ERC Starting Grant ‘Biostruct’ and the Emmy Noether Programme of the German Research Council (DFG). The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
During the development of biological tissues, different signaling molecules are responsible and indispensable for pattern formation and shape generation . Since the seminal paper of Alan Turing  a variety of patterns in biological tissues have been studied using a framework of reaction-diffusion equations. These approaches assume that there exist diffusing signaling molecules, called morphogens, whose nonlinear interactions combined with different rates of diffusion lead to destabilization of a spatially homogeneous equilibrium and formation of spatially heterogeneous structures.
The idea looks counter-intuitive, since diffusion is expected to lead to a uniform distribution of molecules. Mathematical analysis of reaction-diffusion equations provides explanation of the phenomenon postulated by Turing. Patterns arise through a bifurcation, called diffusion-driven instability, in which a spatially homogeneous stationary solution looses stability for a certain range of diffusion coefficients and a stable spatially heterogenous stationary solution appear. The resulting structures can be monotone corresponding to the gradients in positional information or spatially periodic and their ultimate shape depends on the diffusive scaling, related to the size of domain.
The most famous embodiment of Turing's idea in a mathematical model of biological pattern formation is the activator-inhibitor model proposed by Gierer and Meinhardt . One of the key ingredients of that model, responsible for Turing type dynamics, is that the inhibitor diffuses faster than the activator, i.e. the system is regulated by a short range activation and a long range inhibition , . However, in many developmental processes, dynamic and complex tissue topologies are likely to prevent the establishment of long range inhibitor gradients . Furthermore, diffusion coefficients of typical morphogens are often found to be quite small , i.e. do not allow existence of significantly varying diffusion rates as required by the classical Turing mechanism. These observations suggest a search for a different inhibitory mechanism such as mechanical inhibition . Moreover, mechanically based laws in morphogenesis appear to be promising and powerful alternatives to purely chemical models: The latter reduce macroscopic structures to ‘blind’ by-products of spatial chemical patterns and contradict certain experimental data , .
The influence of morphogens on tissue mechanics (such as curvature) is well known. However, different studies show that the interplay is reciprocal and mechanical stress and physical forces (e.g. induced by tissue deformations) can also locally influence morphogen patterns and cell behavior , , –. Furthermore, it appears that tissues may act differently depending on directions of applied stress .
Based on these observations, we propose a model for pattern formation in biological tissues, directly coupling the expression of a morphogen with tissue mechanics. Numerical simulations of the model based on our hypothesis reveal that
- simple interplay between tissue mechanics and morphogen production can lead spontaneously to curvature and morphogen patterns with shapes depending on the size of the tissue; and
- resulting patterns are insensitive to stochastic perturbations of initial conditions.
The proposed mechanism is a promising candidate to replace the “missing” long range inhibitor in the activator-inhibitor models. Due to its robustness, the ultimate shapes are reliably generated under various conditions. Therefore, the model can explain self-organization and de novo pattern formation in the systems with the initial state close to an equilibrium.
The mechanism is currently under experimental investigation. Furthermore, the presented mathematical model and numerical approach could be used in future work to investigate the interplay of different morphomechanical models such as those discussed in ref. .
Our mathematical model combines a reaction-diffusion equation for the morphogen with an elastic gradient flow for tissue mechanics. Expanding the ideas of Cummings  we assume that the morphogen locally induces positive curvature, and in turn, this curvature induces the expression of this morphogen (c.f. Fig. 1), i.e. that there exists a positive feedback loop. Above, the terms “positive” and “negative” curvature refer to outward and inward bending, respectively, compared to the initial curvature of a tissue. More accurately, experimental data indicate that it is not tissue curvature itself but curvature modulated tissue compression that influences gene expression , . However, in order to reduce the complexity of the model and to present the basic idea, we adhere in this paper to the simplified model. Models including tissue compressibility will be subject of future research.
In combination with morphogen degradation, this mechanism leads to spontaneous curvature and morphogen patterns starting from stochastic initial conditions. Note that positive curvature induces negative curvature at the edges of the domain, replacing the effect of a long range inhibitor molecule. Red and blue color depict high and low morphogen levels, respectively.
Finite element simulations reveal that the postulated mechanism produces spontaneously a variety of curvature and morphogen patterns in an asymptotically stable way, i.e. insensitive to small changes in initial conditions. Based on a range of simulation results, we present detailed parameter studies of the model analyzing the rescaled parameter space. We identify parameters that control pattern-related scales, such as size, amount and curvature of appearing patches. Our results show that biomechanical interactions may constitute the missing link to the Turing long range inhibitor: positive curved domains induce negative curvatures at their edges; in these regions only morphogen degradation takes place (c.f. Fig. 1).
Furthermore, numerically obtained results show that dynamics as well as final curvature and morphogen patterns appear to be very similar to those observed during symmetry break in Hydra tissues. Thus, numerical results suggest that the presented mechanism could constitute a key mechanism for pattern formation in Hydra polyps. Further experimental work is needed to support the idea that the proposed mechanism indeed constitutes a key mechanism of pattern formation during embryogenesis. Corresponding experiments are suggested at the end of this paper indicated by simulations.
Materials and Methods
Let be a time-dependent parametric representation of a closed cell sheet , where the cell sheet is parameterized over the unit sphere adopting the ansatz of , , i.e. . The morphogen level is described by the function ; for each the concentration is identified with . Hence, is naturally moving with the deforming tissue, i.e. , where is the surface gradient. For convenience of the reader, detailed definitions of the used geometrical quantities are given in the Table S1 available online.
To model the curvature-dependent elastic properties of a thin cell tissue, we use a modified Helfrich energy, i.e.(1)Here, is the mean curvature and is the surface measure. constitutes the bending rigidity reflecting the stiffness of the surface, and the spontaneous curvature reflects the preferred local surface curvature. The latter e.g. depends on the shape of biological cells within the tissue: If cells are symmetrical, the tissue energetically favors a flat geometry and vanishes. However, in the case of wedge-shaped cells, the tissue prefers to be locally curved, hence holds. A detailed treatment considering the connection between the geometry of biological cells arranged in a tissue to Helfrich measures such as can be found in . Since laterally heterogeneous distributed molecules -such as morphogens- may influence the mechanical properties of the tissue, we assume (analogously to , ) that the mechanical moduli and are functions of the concentration . In first approximation we take and as linear functions of , where . The original Helfrich energy  with constant moduli and has been widely used describing the mechanics of membranes. In the following, we assume a local tissue incompressibility.
Adopting an energy point of view, the evolution of the tissue deformation up to time in is given by the following gradient flow under the constraint of local incompressibility of the tissue:(2)(3)where is the total time derivative, is a kinetic coefficient, denotes the variation with respect to the arbitrary vector , and is a local Lagrange multiplier  due to the constraint of incompressibility ( can be interpreted as pressure). Furthermore, is the surface measure where is the determinant of the first metric tensor (c.f. Table S1). Volume constraints are not considered (to account for the fact that in pattern formation experiments with Hydra tissues it appears that tissue spheres exchange internal fluid with their surroundings ). The gradient flow (2) leads to minimization of the free energy under the constraint of incompressibility (3). For detailed calculation of the variations of we refer to .
Let us now consider the dynamics of the morphogen within the tissue. In contrast to the modeling of membrane dynamics showing fluid behavior with respect to lateral flows, the evolution of morphogens is modeled separately rather than obtained by a corresponding variation of free energy. Beside the basic assumptions concerning diffusion and degradation , , , we define the morphogen production as a function depending on the surface curvature. Furthermore, we assume that initially the tissue is arranged in a mechanically relaxed configuration with curvature . Experimental findings reveal that tissue deformations may induce morphogen production , , . Thus, we postulate that the expression of can be induced by local curvatures . If both, negative and positive curvatures had induced morphogen expression, i.e. , we would have expected oscillations instead of stable patterns. Hence, induces local positive curvatures via and positive curvatures induce locally the expression of via appropriate reaction-terms, constituting a positive feedback loop (c.f. Fig. 1). Such positive feedback loops between chemical and mechanical processes during development have just been reported .
with constants . Hence, the model is given by a nonlinear PDE system of fourth order, coupling the gradient flow for tissue mechanics (2) under the constraint of local area incompressibility (3) with the reaction-diffusion equation (4) for morphogen dynamics.
In the following subsection the free energy (1) and corresponding dynamic equations (2)–(4) are nondimensionalized. This reformulation allows us, on the one hand, to identify essential parameters and characteristic properties of our system. On the other hand, it enables us to study the relative dependence of different parameters on spatial and temporal scales. To nondimensionalize the model, we replace each variable with a dimensionless quantity which is scaled with a characteristic unit of measure .
A consistency check shows that has units of energy as expected, i.e. with . Calculating the variation of we obtain for the strong formulation with .
Choosing and appropriately we can always guarantee . Furthermore, simulations show that equilibirum patterns are independent of (c.f. Fig. 1 C–D). Hence, choosing appropriately we can always yield . Moreover, restricting ourselves to the case (i.e. and ) and as well as choosing for biological reasons the total parameter space can be reduced to three independent constants, namely and .
Finite element approximation and parameter setup
Using the outlined modeling approach, we investigate numerically the effect of different model parameters, system sizes and initial conditions on pattern formation. To do so, we approximate equations (2)–(4), and more accurately, the nondimensionalized form derived in the previous subsection, to study systematically spontaneous pattern formation induced by the proposed mechanism. The corresponding total parameter space can be reduced to three independent constants and .
For spatial discretization we use a biqubic mixed parametric finite element method. The tissue surface is discretized using a quadrangular grid with grid points. For time discretization we use an adaptive semi-implicit Euler scheme. For further details to the computation scheme we refer to ref. 16, 19.
Related to the early shape of an embryo (a blastula) we assume as the initial tissue geometry the sphere with , choosing an appropriate nondimensionalization, c.f. previous subsection. Moreover, we use a stochastic distribution for the initial morphogen concentration. The corresponding values at each discretization point are chosen using the standard random generator provided by C++. is uniformly distributed in an interval with the average .
In the presented study, we restrict our studies to the case of morphogens influencing tissue curvature but not tissue rigidity, setting (i.e. and ). Moreover, we set , since neglecting long time behavior, i.e. nonlinear effects, it is sufficient to vary and . This latter represents the assumption that the tissue is initially arranged in a mechanically relaxed configuration. Furthermore, due to an appropriate nondimensionalization, we can always guarantee (c.f. previous subsection).
Results and Discussion
Here, we will work only with the nondimensionalized form of equations (2)–(4) (c.f. previous sections). To investigate the variety of patterns produced by the presented model, we have performed more than simulations using the nondimensionalized parameters and (setting , and , c.f. previous sections). Furthermore, we have considered different values of . Depending on the exact choice of parameters, simulation results show two different types of long time behavior: either the system tends to equilibrium with a symmetric medium curved pattern and seems to be stable at least for simulated times (c.f. Fig. 2 B), or strong budding appears (c.f. Fig. 2 A) and persists as long as the numerical scheme functions (the adopted numerical discretization is only able to handle medium geometry changes); it is likely that the limiting shape consists of fully budded patches, as experimentally observed e.g. during the formation of new body axes in Hydra polyps. For the corresponding simulations we have set as well as in C but in B. Using different initial conditions (i.e. different values of on an undeformed sphere) we find that the equilibrium pattern is independent of the exact choice of initial conditions (c.f. Fig. 2 C) and corresponding equilibrium patterns are very similar (c.f. Fig. 2 D). Even starting with no morphogen () and stochastically perturbed geometry yields the same result (not shown). Hence, the presented mechanism appears to be asymptotically stable and does not require the existence of any prepattern.
A: For a strong coupling between curvature and morphogen expression the system shows strong budding (numerics do not perform properly for since the approach is only able to handle medium geometry changes; the likely equilibrium shape consists of fully budded morphogen patches). B: For a weak coupling between curvature and morphogen expression the system reaches a symmetric mechanical equilibrium at . C–D: Equilibrium patterns are insensitive to different choices of initial conditions. C: Plot of total morphogen level during tissue development for different values (green dashed line), (red line) and (blue dotted line). D: Corresponding equilibrium patterns. In all simulations red and blue color depicts high and low morphogen levels, respectively.
Checking systematically the influence of the varying model parameters and on the corresponding emerging patterns, reveals the following relationships:
- The size of appearing patches can be controlled by diffusion: stepwise increase from up to (keeping and constant) results in larger patches (c.f. Fig. 3 A) and the number of patches decreases down to a minimum of two patches. Higher values of prevent the establishment of patches resulting in a nearly homogeneous sphere (results are not shown).
- The distance between the patches (and hence the number as well, but not the size) and their curvature can be controlled by the strength of coupling between curvature and morphogen expression, i.e. by the curvature dependent production : In Fig. 3 B the results of a stepwise increase from up to keeping and are shown.
- Changing does not result in striking differences in pattern formation but only influences relevant time scales, i.e. the choice of the observed steady state is independent of . This is expected since possible stationary states are independent of (the whole right hand side of equation (2) is multiplied by ). Having in mind that the approach here is based on the assumption of an overdamped motion, can be interpreted in terms of viscosities. That is, patterns are independent of the specific viscous damping.
A: Increasing diffusion by changing results in bigger morphogen patches. B–C: An increase of coupling between tissue curvature and morphogen expression via (B) results in more but still equally sized patches. In all simulations red and blue color depict high and low morphogen levels, respectively.
Investigating the dynamical behavior of the simulations reveals that all performed simulations typically follow three qualitatively different paths during evolution (c.f. Fig. 2 A–B; for the corresponding simulation we have set , and .): First, smoothing of initially stochastically distributed morphogen distribution; second, appearance of new and larger slightly curved morphogen patches; and third, distinct curvature patterns coinciding with high morphogen levels, either stabilizing at a symmetric pattern or strongly budding. Interestingly, microscopy data of evolving Hydra-reaggregates show similarities to these dynamical patterns .
Apart form the discussion concerning existence and nature of the morphogens (see Introduction), there exist previous mechanochemical models ,  conceived to explain budding processes in polyps. Also, as it is known, reaction-diffusion systems exhibit similar qualitative behavior, although under differing assumptions. In order to motivate experiments proving (or disproving) the proposed mechanism, we have performed ‘virtual experiments’ shown in Fig. 4. Since it is already known that morphogens are able to influence tissue curvature, we focus in these experiments on the effect that tissue curvature induces morphogen production (depending on the direction of tissue curvature): Forcing the tissue to bend locally outwards (e.g. using micropipettes) activates the morphogen level strikingly (Fig. 4 B) whereas inward bending prevents the establishment of morphogen patches in these regions (Fig. 4 C). However, no applied force yields randomly distributed morphogen patches (Fig. 4 A). In all corresponding simulations we have set , and as well as circular pulling and pressing force-terms in B and C, respectively.
A–C: 3D-simulations, D–F: corresponding cross-sections. A,D: Wildtype; B,E: pulling outwards; C,F: pressing inwards. In all simulations red and blue color depict high and low morphogen levels, respectively.
To summarize, in this contribution, we have proposed a new non-Turing type model for early pattern formation in tissue development. Based on recent experimental findings, the key assumption is a positive feedback loop between tissue curvature and morphogen production. We have shown numerically that this simple mechanism itself leads to various morphogen and curvature patterns resembling those observed in experiments involving spherical aggregates of Hydra-tissue. One of the aims of this paper is to motivate further experimental research to validate the presented mechanism for early pattern formation.
If it is validated by direct experimentation, for example along the lines suggested in Fig. 4, the proposed mechanism will constitute an essential step in the evolution of an initial homogeneous tissue sphere to a complex organism – one of the greatest current mysteries in biology , .
Conceived and designed the experiments: AM-C MM DH. Performed the experiments: MM. Analyzed the data: MM. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: DH MM. Wrote the paper: MM DH AM-C.
- 1. Harold FM (1995) From morphogens to morphogenesis. Microbiology 141: 2765–2778.
- 2. Turing AM (1953) The chemical basis of morphogenesis. Phil Trans R Soc London B 237: 37–72.
- 3. Gierer A, Meinhardt H (1972) A theory of biological pattern formation. Kybernetik 12: 30–39.
- 4. Desprat N, Supatto W, Pouille PA, Beaurepaire E, Farge E (2008) Tissue deformation modulates twist expression to determine anterior midgut differentiation in Drosophila embryos. Dev Cell 15: 470–477.
- 5. Gregor T, Wieschaus EF, McGregor AP, Bialek W, Tank DW (2007) Stability and nuclear dynamics of the bicoid morphogen gradient. Cell 130: 141–152.
- 6. Beloussov LV (2008) Mechanically based generative laws of morphogenesis. Phys Biol 5: 015009.
- 7. Beloussov LV, Grabovsky VI (2006) Morphomechanics: goals, basic experiments and models. Int J Dev Biol 50: 81–92.
- 8. Brouzes E, Farge E (2004) Interplay of mechanical deformation and patterned gene expression in developing embryos. Curr Opin Genet Dev 14: 367–374.
- 9. Farge E (2011) Mechanotransduction in development. Curr Top Dev Biol 95: 243–265.
- 10. Fernandez-Sanchez ME, Serman F, Ahmadi P, Farge E (2010) Mechanical induction in embryonic development and tumor growth integrative cues through molecular to multicellular interplay and evolutionary perspectives. Methods Cell Biol 98: 295–321.
- 11. Nelson CM, Jean RP, Tan JL, Liu WF, Sniadecki NJ, et al. (2005) Emergent patterns of growth controlled by multicellular form and mechanics. PNAS 102: 11594–11599.
- 12. Braybrook SA, Peaucelle A (2013) Mechano-chemical aspects of organ formation in Arabidopsis thaliana: the relationship between auxin and pectin. PLoS One 8: e57813.
- 13. Nelson CM (2011) Personal communication.
- 14. Cummings FW (1989) On surface geometry coupled to morphogen. J Theor Biol 137: 215–219.
- 15. Hartmann D (2007) Multiscale Modelling, Analysis, and Simulation in Mechanobiology. Ph.D. thesis, Heidelberg University.
- 16. Hartmann D (2010) A multiscale model for red blood cell mechanics. Biomech Model Mechanobiol 9: 1–17.
- 17. Cummings FW (2001) The interaction of surface geometry with morphogens. J Theor Biol 212: 303–313.
- 18. Mercker M, Ptashnyk M, Kühnle J, Hartmann D, Weiss M, et al. (2012) A multiscale approach to curvature modulated sorting in biological membranes. J Theo Biol 301: 67–82.
- 19. Mercker M, Marciniak-Czochra A, Hartmann D (2013) Modeling and computing of deformation dynamics of inhomogeneous biological surfaces. SIAM J Appl Math 73(5): 1768–1792.
- 20. Helfrich W (1973) Elastic properties of lipid bilayers: theory and possible experiments. Z Naturforsch [C] 28: 693–703.
- 21. Foltin G (1994) Dynamics of incompressible uid membranes. Phys Rev E Stat Phys Plasmas Fluids Relat Interdiscip Topics 49: 5243–5248.
- 22. Soriano J, Colombo C, Ott A (2006) Hydra molecular network reaches criticality at the symmetrybreaking axis-defining moment. Phys Rev Lett 97: 258102.
- 23. Alberts B, Bray D, Lewis J (2006) Molecular biology of the cell. New York: Garland Publishing, Inc.
- 24. The I, Perrimon N (2000) Morphogen diffusion: the case of the wingless protein. Nat Cell Biol 2: E79–E82.
- 25. Hobmayer B, Rentzsch F, Kuhn K, Happel CM, von Laue CC, et al. (2000) Wnt signalling molecules act in axis formation in the diploblastic metazoan Hydra. Nature 407: 186–189.
- 26. Beloussov LV, Grabovsky VI (2003) A geometro-mechanical model for pulsatile morphogenesis. Comput Methods Biomech Biomed Engin 6: 53–63.
- 27. Soriano J, Rüdiger S, Pullarkat P, Ott A (2009) Mechanogenetic coupling of Hydra symmetry breaking and driven turing instability model. Biophys J 96: 1649–1660.
- 28. Keller R (2012) Developmental biology. physical biology returns to morphogenesis. Science 338: 201–203.
- 29. Murray J (2003) Mathematical Biology II: Spatial models and biomedical applications. Heidelberg: Springer-Verlag.