Advertisement
Browse Subject Areas
?

Click through the PLOS taxonomy to find articles in your field.

For more information about PLOS Subject Areas, click here.

  • Loading metrics

Transcriptomic Analysis Reveals Novel Mechanistic Insight into Murine Biological Responses to Multi-Walled Carbon Nanotubes in Lungs and Cultured Lung Epithelial Cells

  • Sarah Søs Poulsen,

    Affiliations National Research Centre for the Working Environment, Copenhagen, Denmark, Department of Science, Systems and Models, Roskilde University, Roskilde, Denmark

  • Nicklas R. Jacobsen,

    Affiliation National Research Centre for the Working Environment, Copenhagen, Denmark

  • Sarah Labib,

    Affiliation Environmental and Radiation Health Sciences Directorate, Health Canada, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada

  • Dongmei Wu,

    Affiliation Environmental and Radiation Health Sciences Directorate, Health Canada, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada

  • Mainul Husain,

    Affiliation Environmental and Radiation Health Sciences Directorate, Health Canada, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada

  • Andrew Williams,

    Affiliation Environmental and Radiation Health Sciences Directorate, Health Canada, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada

  • Jesper P. Bøgelund,

    Affiliation Danish Technological Institute, Taastrup, Taastrup, Denmark

  • Ole Andersen,

    Affiliation Department of Science, Systems and Models, Roskilde University, Roskilde, Denmark

  • Carsten Købler,

    Affiliation Department of Micro- and Nanotechnology, Technical University of Denmark, Kgs. Lyngby, Denmark

  • Kristian Mølhave,

    Affiliation Department of Micro- and Nanotechnology, Technical University of Denmark, Kgs. Lyngby, Denmark

  • Zdenka O. Kyjovska,

    Affiliation National Research Centre for the Working Environment, Copenhagen, Denmark

  • Anne T. Saber,

    Affiliation National Research Centre for the Working Environment, Copenhagen, Denmark

  • Håkan Wallin,

    Affiliations National Research Centre for the Working Environment, Copenhagen, Denmark, Department of Public Health, University of Copenhagen, Copenhagen, Denmark

  • Carole L. Yauk,

    Affiliation Environmental and Radiation Health Sciences Directorate, Health Canada, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada

  • Ulla Vogel,

    Affiliations National Research Centre for the Working Environment, Copenhagen, Denmark, Department of Micro- and Nanotechnology, Technical University of Denmark, Kgs. Lyngby, Denmark

  •  [ ... ],
  • Sabina Halappanavar

    sabina.halappanavar@hc-sc.gc.ca

    Affiliation Environmental and Radiation Health Sciences Directorate, Health Canada, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada

  • [ view all ]
  • [ view less ]

Transcriptomic Analysis Reveals Novel Mechanistic Insight into Murine Biological Responses to Multi-Walled Carbon Nanotubes in Lungs and Cultured Lung Epithelial Cells

  • Sarah Søs Poulsen, 
  • Nicklas R. Jacobsen, 
  • Sarah Labib, 
  • Dongmei Wu, 
  • Mainul Husain, 
  • Andrew Williams, 
  • Jesper P. Bøgelund, 
  • Ole Andersen, 
  • Carsten Købler, 
  • Kristian Mølhave
PLOS
x

Abstract

There is great interest in substituting animal work with in vitro experimentation in human health risk assessment; however, there are only few comparisons of in vitro and in vivo biological responses to engineered nanomaterials. We used high-content genomics tools to compare in vivo pulmonary responses of multiwalled carbon nanotubes (MWCNT) to those in vitro in cultured lung epithelial cells (FE1) at the global transcriptomic level. Primary size, surface area and other properties of MWCNT- XNRI -7 (Mitsui7) were characterized using DLS, SEM and TEM. Mice were exposed via a single intratracheal instillation to 18, 54, or 162 μg of Mitsui7/mouse. FE1 cells were incubated with 12.5, 25 and 100 μg/ml of Mitsui7. Tissue and cell samples were collected at 24 hours post-exposure. DNA microarrays were employed to establish mechanistic differences and similarities between the two models. Microarray results were confirmed using gene-specific RT-qPCR. Bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) fluid was assessed for indications of inflammation in vivo. A strong dose-dependent activation of acute phase and inflammation response was observed in mouse lungs reflective mainly of an inflammatory response as observed in BAL. In vitro, a wide variety of core cellular functions were affected including transcription, cell cycle, and cellular growth and proliferation. Oxidative stress, fibrosis and inflammation processes were altered in both models. Although there were similarities observed between the two models at the pathway-level, the specific genes altered under these pathways were different, suggesting that the underlying mechanisms of responses are different in cells in culture and the lung tissue. Our results suggest that careful consideration should be given in selecting relevant endpoints when substituting animal with in vitro testing.

Introduction

It is anticipated that the widespread use of engineered nanomaterials (ENM) in consumer products will lead to increased human exposure as a result of environmental contamination and using consumer goods containing ENM. Because of their nano size and distinct physico-chemical properties, exposure to ENM is suggested to cause different toxic responses than exposure to their larger counterparts. However, hazard characterization and human health risk assessment of ENM is hampered by a lack of validated toxicological methods for assessing ENM, and a lack of appropriate dose metrics and methodologies for sample preparation (reviewed in 1). Indeed, it has been estimated that it would require billions of dollars and close to 50 years to employ traditional toxicological methods to assess the ENM currently on the market [2]. Thus, there is an urgent need for the development of rapid alternative testing strategies.

Many efforts have been made to develop inexpensive, rapid, and simple in vitro screening assays to assess and predict ENM-induced toxicity. Although limited in number, studies comparing in vitro and in vivo biological responses following ENM exposure have found generally poor concordance between the two test systems [3,4]; these experiments question the relevance of in vitro findings to in vivo health effects for ENM. For example, Seagrave et al. [3] found that diesel exhaust particle extracts were less toxic in in vitro tests in rat alveolar macrophages, but more toxic in rat lungs [3]. Sayes et al. [4] reported little correlation in the toxicological properties of five different types of fine- and nano-particles following in vivo instillation of rats compared to in vitro exposures using three different cell culture models (rat lung epithelial cells, rat primary alveolar macrophages and co-culture of lung epithelial and primary alveolar macrophages) [4]. Broadly different responses were also reported for in vivo compared to in vitro exposures to fine zinc oxide particles, and to fullerene, carbon nanotubes (CNT), gold and silver nanoparticles [5,6], reviewed in 7,8. Differences in in vitro and in vivo responses may be expected because in vivo studies evaluate toxicity in whole organisms or organs with complicated interplay between multiple cell types, whereas in vitro studies primarily focus on understanding the response of a single cell type isolated from a specific organ. It should also be noted that the comparisons described above are limited to a small set of biological endpoints that include inflammatory markers, oxidative stress, cytotoxicity and markers of tissue damage.

In contrast to the studies described above, there appears to be agreement between the in vitro and in vivo models for the evaluation of genotoxic potential of nanomaterials (reviewed in 9). These findings suggest that careful selection of cell types, toxicity endpoints and knowledge of the related tissue physiology is important to derive meaningful comparisons. Moreover, the data demonstrate that the biological responses and pathologies associated with exposure to ENM are complex, and involve perturbations of several pathways and functions. The use of systems biology approaches to gain knowledge of the intricate relationship between the pathways leading to toxicity in these systems is required not only to understand the underlying etiologies of ENM-induced effects, but also to validate the relevance of in vitro results, undertaken to predict in vivo risk.

CNTs are cylindrical carbon allotropes. Their nano size, high aspect ratio (length/width), and fibre shape render their properties asbestos-like resulting in potentially higher toxicity than larger sized particles [10-12]. CNTs are categorized as either single-walled (SWCNT, single sheet of graphene) or multi-walled (MWCNT, multiple sheets of graphene) based on their wall numbers. MWCNT, which are the focus of the current study, are widely used in many industrial and biomedical applications [11,13,14] and consequently, occupational exposure to MWCNT has increased. In vivo animal exposure models clearly demonstrate that inhalation or instillation of MWCNT into the lungs induces inflammation, persistent interstitial fibrosis, and granuloma formation in rodents [15-20]. Studies on mice given intraperitoneal injections of MWCNT of different shapes and lengths into the mesothelial lining of the peritoneal cavity show that length and diameter are important for the infiltration of inflammatory cells into the lungs and lung fluid [21,22] inciting inflammation. MWCNT are biopersistent, cause chronic tissue injury and at least in some situations, are carcinogenic. Indeed, it was recently shown that p53 heterozygous mice or rats given intraperitoneal or intrascrotal injection of MWCNT develop mesotheliomas in a dose-dependent manner [23,24] (NIOSH bulletin). For these reasons, we believe that at the doses tested, MWCNT should be considered as causing serious health effects and possibly being carcinogenic.

The primary objective of the present study was to delineate the mechanisms underlying the biological responses of an in vitro lung epithelial monolayer cell culture model, relevant to the in vivo lung tissue response, following exposure to MWCNT to shed light on the utility of in vitro models to predict adversity in vivo. MWCNT- XNRI -7 (Mitsui7) was used as a model MWCNT particle. To accomplish our objective, we characterized global transcriptional responses in the lungs of C57BL/6 mice exposed to Mitsui7 and compared them to transcriptional profiles from mouse lung epithelial cells exposed to Mitsui7 in culture. C57BL/6 mice were used to study in vivo effects because all of our previous and ongoing in vivo studies on different particle types have been conducted on this strain. Therefore, the results of this study will also enable consistent and systematic comparisons of biological responses across particle types. The mouse lung epithelial cell line FE1 was used to investigate in vitro responses to Mitsui7. FE1 is a spontaneously immortalized lung epithelial cell line derived from a normal healthy MutaTMMouse. This cell line retains key endogenous metabolic capacity and p53 signalling, and presents both a type I and type II alveolar phenotype. Because the Muta™Mouse model contains a lacZ mutation reporter transgene, this cell line also enables an assessment of the mutagenic effects of nanomaterials and has been extensively used in our laboratory for studying the genotoxicity of chemicals and nanomaterials [25-31].

In vitro doses were chosen based on their relevance to in vivo lung burden and also to reflect the doses reported in the literature. DNA microarrays were used to examine the responsive biological pathways and functions altered in FE1 cells incubated in the presence of 12.5, 25, 100 µg/ml Mitsui7 relative to lung tissues exposed via intratracheal instillation to 18, 54, 162 µg/mouse Mitsui7. Samples were collected at 24 hours post-exposure. Statistical and systems biology tools were employed to provide a global foot-print of Mitsui7-responsive pulmonary transcriptome in the two widely studied models. In vivo characterization of lung inflammation and validation of microarray results by RT-qPCR were further used to support the conclusions derived.

Materials and Methods

Material characteristics

The MWCNT used in this study is a MWCNT- XNRI-7; lot 05072001K28, Hadoga Chemical industry (formerly known as Mitsui). In this study it will be referred to as Mitsui7. Chemical composition and length of the same [18] and a different batch [23] have been published previously and results are summarized in Table 1. In brief, the average particle length of Mitsui7, as reported by the manufacturer, is 3-5 μm. One gram of Mitsui7 corresponds to 3.55 x 1011 particles and consists of particles with an average width of ca. 100 nm. Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM) revealed that the median length of Mitsui7 is 3.86 μm with 27.5% of Mitsui7 particles having lengths longer than 5 μm [23]. The numbers of walls vary from 20 to 50 [18]. Major impurities as determined by the collision type Inductively Coupled Plasma Mass Spectrometry, Combustion Ion Chromatography and trace metal analysis included Fe: (0.3%), Na: 0.4% S: ca. 470 ppm and Cl: ca. 20 ppm (18) [23].

ReferencesDispersionTube lengthTube Width ± SDImpurities
Mitsui, Tokyo, JapanNDSegments; 3-5 μm longNDND
Tagaki et al. 20085% Triton X-10027.5% longer than 5 μm100 nmFe: 0.35% S: 0.047%
Porter et al. 2010PBS and dispersion mediaMedian length: 3.86 μm49±13.4 nmFe: 0.32% Na: 0.41%

Table 1. Known characteristics of MWCNT-Mitsui-7.

ND: Not Determined
CSV
Download CSV

Characterization of Mitsui7 in dispersion medium

Scanning Electron Microscopy.

Size and the level of agglomeration was evaluated by Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) using a Zeiss Ultra 55 (Carl Zeiss Microscopy GmbH, Germany) SEM equipped with a field emission electron source. High vacuum conditions were applied and a secondary electron detector was used for image acquisition. Samples were prepared on a carbon tape surface and coated with a conductive layer of Au with approximately 20 nm thickness. Mitsui7 as dry pristine powders and dispersed in the exposure media, was analyzed by SEM.

Preparation of Mitsui7 exposure stock

For in vitro exposures.

Immediately before the treatment, Mitsui7 suspensions were prepared as follows. A total of 8.9 mg of Mitsui7 was suspended in 2.6 ml of cell culture media to a total stock concentration of 3.4 mg/ml. Particle suspensions were prepared by sonication of Mitsui7 stock concentrations using a S-450D sonifier (Branson Ultrasonics Corp., Danbury, CT, USA) equipped with a disruptor horn (Model Number: 101-147-037) for a total of 4 minutes at amplitude of 10%, with alternating 10 s pulses and pauses on ice.

For in vivo exposures.

Particles were suspended by sonication in 1 ml of MilliQ water containing 0.9% NaCl and 10% v/v acellular broncho alveolar lavage (BAL) fluid collected from C57BL/6 mice. Naïve C57BL/6 mice were flushed twice with 0.6 ml of 0.9% NaCl to obtain approximately 1 ml of BAL. BAL was centrifuged at 400 G for 10 min at 4°C to remove cells and the supernatant was used in the dispersant liquid. The Mitsui7 (4.05 mg/ml) suspension was sonicated on ice using a Branson Sonifier S-450D equipped with a disruptor horn (Model number: 101-147-037) for a total of 4 minutes at amplitude of 10%, with alternating 10 s pulses and pauses. This suspension was used for the high dose (162 µg) and diluted 1:3 in vehicle for the medium (54 µg) dose and diluted further 1:3 for the low dose (18 µg). Between the dilutions the suspensions were mixed by pipetting. Vehicle control solutions were prepared with 0.9% NaCl and 10% acellular BAL fluid and sonicated as described above.

Dose selection

Table 2 summarizes the doses chosen for in vivo and in vitro exposures.

In vivo exposure dosesIn vitro exposure concentrations
µg/animal1625418µg/ml1002512.5
mg/kg8.12.70.9mg/kgNRNRNR
(assuming an average mouse weighs 20 g)
mg/kg mouse lung59119765.7mg/kgNRNRNR
(assuming an average lung weighs 274 mg)
µg/cm2 (lung surface: 82 cm2)1.980.660.22µg/cm2 (4-wells Petri dish: 21.8cm2, 6.8 ml)31.197.83.9

Table 2. Comparison of in vivo and in vitro doses.

NR: Not Relevant
CSV
Download CSV

In vivo.

Mice were exposed to 18, 54 or 162 µg of Mitsui7/animal by single intratracheal instillation (these doses are also referred to as low, medium, and high respectively, in the text where appropriate). The doses were selected based on our previous studies [32-36] and reflect 8 h time weighted average (TWA) for carbon black particles (3.5 mg/m3) in an occupational setting in Denmark. The lung of an average female C57BL/6 mouse of 20 g weighs 274 mg with an average surface area of 82 cm2. Thus, using surface area of exposure as a parameter, the doses chosen in the study can be expressed as 0.22, 0.66 and 1.98 µg of Mitsui7/cm2 of lung surface area, respectively.

In vitro.

Cells were exposed to 12.5, 25.0 and 100 µg Mitsui7/ml (these doses are also referred to as low, medium, and high respectively in the text where appropriate). These concentrations were selected based on the concentration ranges used in the literature that are demonstrated to induce some degree of cellular response, but that are well below the concentrations that induce cytotoxicity (data not shown). Monolayers were exposed in a 4-well Petri dish consisting of 21.8 cm2 total surface area. The exposure was carried out in a total volume of 6.8 ml. The in vitro concentrations amount to 3.9, 7.8 and 31.19 µg/cm2 of Petri dish. Thus, the highest in vivo dose (1.98 µg/cm2) was approximately half of the lowest in vitro concentration used (3.9 µg/cm2), based on µg Mitsui7/cm2 area.

Cell culture, exposure and sample collection

The development of the MutaTMMouse lung epithelial cell line (FE1) and its characterization has been previously described [37]. The FE1 epithelial cells were cultivated in DMEM/F-12 + GlutaMaxTM-1 (Fisher Scientific Biotech Line A/S, 21765037, Slangerup, Denmark) supplemented with 2% fetal bovine serum (In Vitro AS, B1-04-007-1A, Fredensborg, Denmark), 1% penicillin/streptomycin solution (In Vitro AS, B1-03-031-1B, Fredensborg, Denmark) and 100 ng/μl murine epidermal growth factor (Sigma-Aldrich, E4127-1MG, Broendby, Denmark). Cells were maintained in T150 bottle (Thermo Fisher Scientific, NUN-156502, Roskilde, Denmark) at 37.0°C with 5% CO2 and 90% humidity. Media was replaced every 2-3 days to ensure proper growth conditions.

FE1 cells were seeded at 105 cells/ml density to a total of 6.81 ml/well in the 4-well plates (NUNC, Thermo Scientific, Hvidovre, Denmark, 167-063) and incubated at 37°C for 24 hours. The next day cells were examined for overall natural appearance and growth. At the time of treatment, cells showed ~ 80% confluency. Cells were incubated with 0, 12.5, 25, and 100 µg Mitsui7/ml for 24 h. Following the incubation, cells were trypsinized and centrifuged to collect cell pellets. The cell pellets were stored at -80°C until further use. Three individual experiments were conducted (cells were exposed in separate experiments).

Animals

Ethics Statement.

All procedure complied with EC Directive 86/609/EEC and Danish laws regulating experiments on animals (permit 2010/561-1779). Mice did not display any signs of respiratory distress, lethargy or any other physical symptoms following exposure.

Female C57BL/6 mice aged 5-7 weeks were obtained from Taconic (Ry, Denmark). The mice were allowed to acclimatize for 1-3 weeks before the experiment. All mice were given food (Altromin no. 1324, Christian Petersen, Denmark) and water ad libitum during the whole experiment. Mice were group-housed in polypropylene cages with sawdust bedding at controlled temperature 21±1°C and humidity 50±10% with a 12-h light:12-h dark cycle. Experiments were initiated at 8 weeks of age.

Animal exposure and tissue collection.

Mice were intratracheally instilled as previously described for other nanomaterials [33,38]. In brief, mice were anesthetized by subcutaneous injection of 0.2 ml of Hypnorm® (fentanyl citrate 0.315 mg/ml and fluanisone 10 mg/ml, Janssen Pharma) and Dormicum® (Midazolam 5 mg/mL, Roche) in sterile water. The mice were kept on their back at a 40-degree angle on a hot plate (37 °C) during the entire procedure. Mice were exposed to 18, 54 and 162 µg of Mitsui7 via a single intratracheal instillation. A 40 µl suspension was instilled followed by 150 μl air with a 250 µl SGE glass syringe (250F-LT-GT, MicroLab, Aarhus, Denmark). Control animals were instilled with vehicle (0.9% NaCl with 10% BAL). After the instillation catheter was removed, breathing was observed in order to assure that the delivered material did not block the airways. Mice were allowed to recover for 24 hours before sacrifice. For tissue collection, mice were anaesthetized with Hypnorm/Dormicum as described above and killed by exsanguination via intracardiac puncture. The right lung lobes were snap-frozen in cryotubes in liquid N2 and stored at -80°C.

All animal procedures followed the guidelines for the care and handling of laboratory animals established by the Danish government. The Animal Experiment Inspectorate under the Ministry of Justice approved the study (#2010/561-1779). 

Additional animal exposures and tissue collection for validation by RT-qPCR

The doses chosen for both in vivo (18, 54 and 162 µg of Mitsui7/animal) and in vitro (12.5, 25, and 100 µg of Mitsui7/ml) were high [18], therefore, additional animal exposures to lower doses of Mitsui7 were carried out. Mice were exposed to 2 and 6 µg of Mitsui7 via single intratracheal instillation and samples were collected at 24 hours following the exposure. In vitro, cells were incubated with 0.00125, 0.125 and 1.25 µg of Mitsui7/ ml and cells were harvested at 24 hours post-exposure time point. Exposure of animals and sample collection is described above. Tissue samples collected from this exposure were used for validation by RT-qPCR.

Transmission Electron Microscopy

For transmission electron microscopy (TEM), mice were euthanized and lungs were fixed for a week in a 2% glutaraldehyde buffered fixative (pH 7.2) via trachea. Fixed lung was cut in small pieces and a standard Electron Microscope embedding procedure was carried out. Samples were rinsed in 0.15 M phosphate buffer followed by a wash with 0.15 M sodium cacodylate. Post-fixation and osmofication were carried out in 2% osmium tetroxide in 0.05 M potassium ferricyanide for 2 hours. Following osmofication, samples were rinsed in deionized water and placed in 1% uranyl acetate in water overnight at 5 °C. The following day samples were gradually dehydrated in ethanol and lastly in propylene oxide. Embedding was performed in propylene oxide diluted Epon, until 100% Epon 812 was used before polymerisation at 60 °C for 24 hours. Samples were cut into approximately 80 nm sections for TEM using an ultramicrotome with a diamond knife. Sections were stained with uranyl acetate and lead citrate, and imaged using a CM 100 BioTwin instrument from Philips operated at 80 kV accelerating voltage.

BAL cell counts

Infiltration of inflammatory cells into lung lining fluid was determined by BAL done immediately after cardiac puncture and collection of blood. The statistical analyses were performed in SAS version 9.2 (SAS Institute Inc., Cary, NC, USA). Statistical significance was calculated using a non-parametric one-way ANOVA with a post-hoc Tukey-type experimental comparison test.

Total RNA extraction

Total RNA was isolated from cell samples (n = 6 replicates per concentration) and from lung tissue of 72 mice in total (n = 6 mice per dose group). Isolations were done using TRIzol reagent (Invitrogen, Carlsbad, CA, USA) and purified using the RNeasy MiniKit (Qiagen, Mississauga, ON, Canada ) as described by the manufacturer. An on-column DNase treatment was applied (Qiagen, Mississauga, ON, Canada). All RNA samples showing A260/280 ratios between 2.0 and 2.15 were further analysed for RNA integrity using an Agilent 2100 Bioanalyzer (Agilent Technologies, Mississauga, ON, Canada). RNA integrity numbers above 7.0 were used in the experiment. If the RNA samples didn’t reach the criteria, new RNA extractions from the lung tissue or cell culture were performed. Total RNA was stored at -80°C until analysis.

Microarray Hybridization

Total RNA (200 ng) from each sample (n=6 per group) and from universal reference RNA (UMRR, Stratagene, Mississauga, ON, Canada) was used to synthesize double-stranded cDNA and cyanine labeled cRNA using the Agilent Linear Amplification kit (Agilent Technologies, Mississauga, ON, Canada ). Reference RNA was labeled with cyanine 3-CTP and experimental samples were labeled with cyanine 5-CTP (Agilent Technologies Inc., Mississauga, ON, Canada). The cyanine-labeled cRNA was in vitro transcribed using T7 polymerase and purified using RNeasy mini kits (Qiagen). Sample and reference targets (825 ng) were combined and hybridized to Agilent 8 x 66K oligonucleotide microarrays (Agilent Technologies Inc., Mississauga, ON, Canada) for 17 hours at 65°C. The arrays were washed according to supplier instructions and then scanned on an Agilent G2505B scanner at 5 µm resolution. Data were acquired using Agilent Feature Extraction software version 9.5.3.1

Statistical Analysis of Microarray Data

A reference design [39-41] with the sample labelled with Cy5 and the reference labelled with Cy3 was used to analyze the data. The quantified data for each array was read into R [42,43]. The median signal intensity without background subtraction was used in this analysis and probes with technical replicates were averaged using the median. The background for each array was measured using the (-)3xSLv1 probe. Spots with median signal intensities less than the trimmed mean (trim = 5%) plus three trimmed standard deviations of the (-)3xSLv1 probe were flagged as below detection (i.e., absent). The total number of flagged spots, the median signal intensity and standard deviation for the (-)3xSLv1 probe for each array were recorded. Other microarray level summary statistics included the median signal to noise ratio (log2 scale) and the median signal intensity for each channel as well as the median absolute deviation. Differentially expressed genes between the control and treated groups were determined using the MAANOVA library [44]. The ANOVA model included treatment and a slide effect. This model was applied to the log2 of the relative intensities. The Fs statistic [45], a shrinkage estimator for the gene-specific variance components was used. The p-values for all the statistical tests were estimated using the permutation method (30,000 permutations with residual shuffling). These p-values were then adjusted for multiple comparisons by using the false discovery rate approach (FDR) [46]. Estimated marginal means, also known as least square means [47,48], were estimated for each group. These means are a function of the model parameters and are adjusted for the other factors in the model such as day of hybridization. The least square means were then used to estimate the fold change for each contrast that was tested.

Quantitative Real Time (qRT)-PCR array validation

Fifty-four individual genes from each cells and tissues were selected for further validation by RT-qPCR using custom RT2 Profiler PCR Arrays and a BioRad CFX96 Real-Time PCR detection system. The genes selected were statistically significant in the DNA microarray analysis for at least one condition and were associated with three biological functions: oxidative stress, inflammation and fibrosis. A custom RT2 Profiler PCR Array plate, the RT2 First Strand Kit and RT2 SYBR® Green qPCR Mastermix (QIAGEN Sciences, Maryland, USA) were used. Hypoxanthine-guanine phosphoribosyltransferase (Hprt), actin β (Actb) and glyceraldehyde 3-phosphate dehydrogenase (Gapdh) were used as reference genes for normalization and were selected based on their stable expression levels in the treated and control samples in the microarray results. A threshold value was set to 102. The final RT-qPCR validation group consisted of a sample size of n=3 for both cells (individual passages) and tissues (individual animals).

Results and Discussion

We exposed mice and mouse lung epithelial cells in culture to three different doses of Mitsui7 to evaluate the efficacy of in vitro models to predict in vivo outcomes following exposure to ENM. Lung tissues and cell lysates were collected 24 hours post-exposure. Global gene expression profiling was employed to characterize the molecular differences and similarities between in vivo and in vitro models as they relate to the existing mechanistic information available on the MWCNT-induced toxic effects.

Dose and concentration selection

In vivo doses chosen for this study were based on our previous studies and reflect 1, 3, and 9 days of 8 h time weighted exposure limit for carbon black particles (3.5 mg/m3) in an occupational setting in Denmark. In vitro doses were chosen to mimic the total lung surface area available for exposure to particles (Table 2). At present, there are no occupational exposure limits specified for MWCNT in Denmark. Taking into consideration the MWCNT aerosol levels found in an occupational environment, the mass median aerodynamic diameter of MWCNT, and the surface area of human alveolar epithelium, Porter et al. [18] calculated that exposure of mice to 10 µg MWCNT is close to one month of human exposure to aerosol concentrations of 400 µg/m3 MWCNT in the work environment [18,49]. Mice exposed to 10 µg of MWCNT exhibit transient inflammation, which subsides at 7 days post-exposure. In contrast, mice exposed to 20 and 40 µg MWCNT displayed prolonged inflammation up to 56 days post-exposure, and fibrosis-like conditions are observed following exposure to 80 µg MWCNT [18,50]. The Mitsui7 instillation doses used in the present study span this entire exposure range [18,50].

An aerosol concentration of 440 µg/m3 is approximately equivalent to human alveolar epithelium exposed to 226 µg/m2 MWCNT per month, which is less than 1 µg/ml concentration for cells exposed in culture medium [18]. Thus, according to these calculations, the in vitro Mistui7 concentrations chosen in the present study are approximately an order of magnitude higher than potential human exposures (the lowest concentration being 3.9 µg/ml), as well as approximately an order of magnitude higher than the mouse in vivo exposures. However, we note that the lowest in vitro dose (12.5 µg) is similar to the highest in vivo dose (162 µg) delivered. These very high doses were chosen because they reflect the present literature on MWCNT-induced effects.

Mitsui7 characteristics in the dispersion medium

The particle size of Mitsui7 in the in vivo and in vitro exposure dispersion medium was determined using dynamic light scattering (DLS; File S1). The DLS technique measures spherical hydrodynamic diameter and since Mitsui7 exhibit rod-like shapes, it is not clear what the size-spectra of Mitsui7 generated by DLS corresponds to. Size scatter may very well include signals arising from more than one MWCNT dimension and metal impurities; however, the sizes may reflect the hydrodynamic equivalent size distributions. The distribution used in this study is number size distribution. The DLS is used only as an indication of the successful dispersion of the MWCNT and caution must be exercised when interpreting DLS data.

The DLS of unfiltered Mitsui7 in the in vivo exposure medium (0.9% NaCl with 10% BAL) showed a slightly skewed unimodal size distribution with a peak size at ca. 5000 nm (Figure S1A). The average zeta size was 8719.8 nm. The polydispersity index (PDI) was 1.0, indicating the presence of large Mitsui7 agglomerates of different sizes. After filtration through a 3.1 μm filter, DLS showed a multimodal size distribution with peak sizes at ca. 600 nm, 1000 nm, and 2000 nm, and an average zeta size of 1701.8 nm, thus indicating the presence of smaller agglomerates (Figure S1A). A PDI of 0.658 was found, demonstrating better dispersion after filtration. The in vivo exposure medium was analyzed separately and showed a bimodal size distribution with peak sizes at ca. 85 nm and 250 nm, an average zeta size of 389.9 nm (Figure S1B), and a PDI of 0.717, indicating protein agglomerates of various sizes. Filtration of the exposure medium through a 0.2 μm filter revealed the presence of smaller proteins with peak sizes of 25 nm and 55 nm, and an average zeta size of 67.2 nm.

The in vitro exposure medium (DMEM-F12 cell culture medium with 2% fetal bovine serum) was also analyzed with and without Mitsui7. The analysis of unfiltered Mitsui7 in the in vitro exposure medium showed a unimodal size distribution with a peak size at ca. 370 nm (Figure S1C). The average zeta size was 368.6 nm and the PDI was 0.406, indicating well-dispersed Mitsui7. A separate analysis of in vitro exposure medium alone showed a unimodal size distribution with a peak size of 5.5 and a zeta average of 14.5 (Figure S1D).

SEM was performed on both pristine Mitsui7 and Mitsui7 in the exposure medium used for both in vivo and in vitro exposures. At all magnifications Mitsui7 appeared intertwined and agglomerated, with both long and straight, and bended tubes (Figures 1A and 1B). Crystalline impurities were observed on the Mitsui7 that may have originated from the dried exposure medium. SEM images of the pristine Mitsui7 are shown in Figure 2A-C. At low quantities, the pristine Mitsui7 appeared long and straight, but at the higher densities agglomerates were observed, with somewhat intertwined and bended tubes. Figures 3A and 3B show light microscopy images of Mitsui7 dispersed by sonication in the in vitro exposure medium. Samples appeared well-dispersed at all doses. Cytotoxicity following exposure to the indicated doses of Mitsui7 was assessed in vitro previously and revealed no toxicity (NR Jacobsen, unpublished).

thumbnail
Figure 1. SEM images of Mitsui7 in the in vivo exposure medium.

(A) High density behavior of Mitsui7 (B) Long, straight, and bended tubes are visible. Impurities seen on the MWCNTs may be dried materials from the exposure medium.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0080452.g001

thumbnail
Figure 2. SEM images of dry, pristine Mitsui7.

(A) Mitsui7 at high density. (B) A close-up of MWCNT at high density. (C) Mitsui7 behavior at low density.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0080452.g002

thumbnail
Figure 3. Light microscopy images of Mitsui7 dispersed in the in vitro exposure medium after sonication.

(A) 100 μg/milliliter (31.19 µg/cm2) concentration (B) 12.5 μg/ml concentration (3.9 µg/cm2). Bars represent 50μm.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0080452.g003

TEM was performed on both pristine Mitsui7 tubes and in the lung lining of the mice intratracheally instilled with Mitsui7. As with SEM, the pristine Mitsui7 appeared long and straight, and although agglomeration was observed, the rigid structure remained (Figure 4A). Diameter of the pristine tubes was measured to 74.4 nm (SD 27.2). Images of Mitsui7 found inside a cell three days after exposure are shown in Figures 4B, the MWCNTs have been partially dislodged during ultramicrotomy. An image of Mitsui7 enclosed in an alveolar macrophage three days after exposure are shown in Figures 4C. No tubes are seen penetrating the macrophage, but several tubes appear to have been engulfed and are enclosed in vesicles. This clearly shows interaction between Mitsui7 and inflammatory cells in the alveolar region.

thumbnail
Figure 4. TEM images.

(A) Pristine Mitsui7 (B) Mitsui7 MWCNTs interacting with cells in the lung lining fluid (Black arrows). The MWCNTs have been partially dislodged during ultramicrotomy (C) Macrophage containing engulfed Mitsui7 in vesicle (red arrow).

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0080452.g004

BAL fluid cellular composition

BAL fluid was collected from Mistui7-instilled mice 24 hours after the exposure to assess the recruitment of inflammatory cells into the lung lumen. The total number of cells, neutrophils, macrophages, eosinophils, and lymphocytes were counted and the results are shown in Table 3. The lung inflammatory response was characterized by an increase in the total number of cells that was predominantly the result of a dose-dependent increase in neutrophils (7.2 - 18.2-fold increase over controls). Although a statistically significant increase in the total number of eosinophils was observed in all the dose groups compared to the vehicle treated controls (129.3, 77 and 7.3-fold increase at 18, 54 and 162 μg doses (0.22, 0.66 and 1.98 µg/cm2), respectively), an inverted dose response was found, with the highest eosinophil influx found at the lowest dose. Specifically, a 17.6-fold reduction in the number of eosinophils was observed from the lowest dose to the highest dose. A similar trend was observed for the total number of lymphocytes; there was a non-significant increase in the number of lymphocytes in the BAL of the low dose group mice (1.8 fold increase over matched controls) that decreased significantly with increasing dose (0.4 fold compared to matched controls at the high dose). In contrast, the total number of macrophages decreased in a dose-dependent manner relative to controls with a significant decrease found in the highest dose group (0.6 fold) compared to the vehicle treated matched controls.

Cell typesDose (µg/animal)
Control1854162
Neutrophils x 103 (%)7.7 ± 1.7 (10.4)55.1 ± 10.6 (38.6)*60.6 ± 4.5 (44.5)*140.2 ± 31.9 (71.8)*
Macrophages x 103 (%)53.2 ± 2.5 (72.1)38.2 ± 5.1 (26.8)37.4 ± 7.4 (27.8)30.3 ± 8.5 (15.5)*
Eosinophils x 103 (%)0.3 ± 0.1 (0.4)38.8 ± 10.7 (27.2)*23.1 ± 11.1 (17.1)*2.2 ± 0.5 (1.1)*#
Lymphocytes x 103 (%)1.6 ± 0.5 (2.2)2.8 ± 0.5 (2.0)1.7 ± 0.5 (1.3)0.6 ± 0.3 (0.3)*#
Total BAL Cell x 10373.8 ± 3.6142.8 ± 22.3*134.7 ± 19.5*195.3 ± 40.8*

Table 3. Differential cellular counts in the bronchoalveolar lavage fluid.

Statistically significant (P<0.05) difference between (*) treated and controls, and (#) low (18 µg) and high (162 µg) doses.
CSV
Download CSV

Our results showing increased neutrophil and decreased macrophage populations are consistent with Ma-Hock et al. [11]. However, these studies did not show increases in eosinophils. Although a sharp increase in the total number of eosinophils following exposure to low dose of Mitusi7 may be indicative of allergic airway inflammation [51], it is not clear from the observations why eosinophilia decreased with increasing dose. A similar decline in the total number of eosinophils in the lungs of rats exposed to increasing doses of nano-SiO2 was reported [52]. In a murine model of asthma, polymerized liposome nanoparticles were shown to mimic physiological ligand 1 and bind to P selectin on activated airway endothelium. Furthermore, competitive binding of nanoparticles to P selectin was shown to inhibit eosinophil activation resulting in reduced eosinophil-mediated inflammatory response, a hallmark of allergic airway disease [53]. These results support the hypothesis that high doses of Mitsui7 could be competing with physiologic- ligand 1 (required for activation of P selectin) to bind to P selectin on the activated endothelium thereby inhibiting the recruitment of eosinophils into the BAL. A similar argument can also be made for the observed decreases in the lymphocyte population at higher doses.

Microarray analysis

All microarray data have been deposited in the NCBI Gene Expression Omnibus database and can be accessed through the accession number GSE47000. A total of 4,259 of the 60,000 probes on the array were expressed (where expressed is defined as probes having signal intensities above background in 4 out of 5 samples in at least one experiment condition) in both cells and tissues. Differentially expressed genes were identified using MAANOVA; a probe was considered to be differentially expressed if its normalized signal intensities in treated samples were significantly different from control values following FDR adjustment, with P ≤ 0.05, and the relative change in expression (fold change) was at least ±1.5 in either direction.

Overview of in vivo microarray results

In general, a high degree of reproducibility was observed within control and treated replicates. A total of 1635 unique genes represented by 2104 probes were significantly differentially expressed in the lungs following exposure to 18, 54, and 162 µg of Mitsui7 at the 24 hours post-exposure time point. A total of 601 (383 genes down-regulated and 219 up-regulated), 114 (35 down-regulated and 79 up-regulated) and 1353 (754 down-regulated and 601 up-regulated) genes were differentially expressed in the 18, 54, and 162 µg dose groups, respectively. These genes are listed in the Table S1. Only 46 genes were commonly differentially expressed in all three dose groups (Figure 5A). Most of the genes in this list exhibited a dose-response and were mainly associated with acute phase response, immune cell trafficking, lung hypersensitivity, and hematological system functions. Increased expression of acute phase response genes (including Saa1, Saa3 and Timp1) has also been reported in the lungs of mice exposed to nano-sized titanium dioxide [54,55] and nano- particles of carbon black [56], suggesting acute phase genes are sensitive markers of exposure to nanoparticles [57]. A list of the significant genes that were responsive in all dose groups is provided in Table 4.

thumbnail
Figure 5. Overview of response in the lung tissue.

(A) Venn diagram showing the overlapping differentially expressed genes (FDR P ≤ 0.05 and fold change ≥ 1.5) in response to low (18 µg, green), medium (54 µg, blue), and high (162 µg, red) doses of Mitsui7 in the lung tissues. (B-C) Gene ontology (GO) analysis of differentially expressed genes. (B) Commonly regulated GO biological processes, and (C) GO biological processes unique to the low, medium, and high dose groups. Numbers in parentheses represent number of genes altered in that process.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0080452.g005

Gene symbolEntrez IDAverage fold change compared to matched controls
18 µg/mouse54 µg/mouse162 µg/mouse
A130040M12Rik3192691.82.32.7
Adamts42409131.82.43.5
Adm115351.92.23.0
Asgr111889-2.2-3.1-2.3
Bcl3120511.61.71.7
Ccdc129232016-3.0-2.3-2.7
Ccl11202923.05.23.4
Ccl17202953.53.42.8
Ccl2202963.65.34.0
Ccl7203065.56.94.3
Ch25h126422.73.14.0
Cldn854420-2.0-1.8-2.0
Ctps517972.02.72.9
Cxcl1148252.33.94.7
Entpd872090-2.0-2.1-2.4
Gm20451000390962.12.54.4
Gm23711000396871.72.12.8
Gm34591000416632.02.73.9
Gm41481000429842.02.13.0
Gm43821000433532.11.92.5
Gm44991000435242.02.53.6
Gprasp167298-1.6-1.7-2.6
Has1151161.92.31.8
Hbegf152001.82.62.0
Il6161932.63.96.2
Klhl2475785-1.9-1.9-1.8
Mt2177502.711.727.5
Myb17863-1.9-2.1-2.2
Osbpl699031-1.8-1.6-1.9
Rgs16197341.82.12.5
Rrbp1819101.61.61.6
Serpina3g207153.23.43.4
Serpinf120317-1.7-1.7-1.7
Six420474-1.7-1.7-2.1
Slc26a4239859.07.75.3
Slc30a2230810-2.2-1.9-1.9
Slc39a142130531.62.33.7
Saa1202083.87.012.3
Saa3202109.912.345.6
Timp1218577.79.711.7
Tnfrsf12a272791.62.42.7
Tnfsf9219502.02.12.4
Trib12117701.51.71.6
Trmt61a3281621.81.81.7
Tubb6679511.81.81.6
Tyro322174-1.6-1.6-2.0

Table 4. Differentially expressed genes common across all three doses.

CSV
Download CSV

We analyzed the gene ontology (GO) classifications of all of the differentially expressed genes to identify themes in the global pulmonary gene expression patterns following exposure to Mitsui7. The processes affected by MWCNT are shown in Figures 5B and 5C, and include ‘common’ (i.e., occurring in more than one group) and ‘unique’ (i.e., occurring in one dose group only) processes, respectively. Processes involved in chemotaxis [GO: 6935], immune response [GO: 6955], inflammatory response [GO: 6954], oxidative reduction [GO: 55114] and behavior [GO: 7610] were over-represented among all the dose groups (Figure 5B). In addition, several unique GO processes were over-represented within a dose group (Figure 5C). In the low dose group, the top biological processes altered consisted of 70 genes involved in cell cycle and was associated with five specific GO terms: cell cycle [GO: 7049], cell cycle process [GO: 22402], cell cycle phase [GO: 22403], M phase [GO: 279], and cell division [GO: 51301]. The other over-represented biological processes in the low dose group included: microtubules [GO: 7017], nucleosome assembly [GO: 6334], meiosis [GO: 7126], ear morphogenesis [GO: 42471], regulation of cell substrate adhesion [GO: 10810], and complement activation, alternate pathway [GO: 6957]. In the medium dose group, negative regulation of cell proliferation [GO: 42127] and positive regulation of response to stimulus [GO: 48584] were uniquely enriched with 14 genes in each of the processes. Unique biological processes affected in the high dose group included: cell motion [GO: 6928], vasculature development [GO: 1944], response to hormone stimulus [GO: 9725], regulation of inflammatory response [GO: 50727], and negative regulation of response to stimulus [GO: 48585].

In order to understand the functional significance of these GO changes, Ingenuity Pathway Analysis (IPA Reference) was employed to identify biological networks, functions, and pathways affected in all of the dose groups. Table 5 shows a summary of the top functions and processes altered in the three dose groups 24 hours following the exposure to Mitsui7. This analysis revealed that biological functions such as, cellular movement, cellular growth and proliferation, and cell-to-cell signaling were commonly affected across the dose groups. Closer examination of these differentially expressed genes under each of the functional categories in common revealed that they are actually specifically involved in immune and inflammation related responses. Analysis of biological pathways revealed significant enrichment of genes in the pyrimidine ribonucleotides de novo synthesis, aryl hydrocarbon receptor signaling, and LPS/IL-1 mediated inhibition of RXR signaling pathways in the low dose group. In the medium dose group, genes involved in the acute phase response signaling, chemokine signaling and IL-17 signaling pathways were significantly enriched. Finally, retinol biosynthesis, neuregulin signaling, and acute phase response signaling were the most affected pathways in the high dose group.

Canonical PathwaysNetworks
Dose Group  Name  No. of Genes*   Name  No. of Genes*
18 μgPyrimidine ribonucleotides de novo biosynthesis7Organismal injury and abnormalities27
Aryl hydrocarbon receptor signaling13Cell-to-cell signaling and interaction, immune cell trafficking25
LPS/IL-1 mediated inhibition of RXR function16Cancer, respiratory disease, cell cycle22
Glutathione-mediated detoxification4Embryonic development, organ development, organismal development22
LXR/RXR activation9Cell cycle, cancer19
Estrogen-mediated S-phase entry4Cellular assembly and organization, cellular function and maintenance, connective tissue development and function18
54 μgAcute phase response signaling9Cellular movement, immune cell trafficking24
Chemokine signaling5Cancer, organ morphology16
IL-17 signaling5Organismal injury and abnormalities, inflammatory response16
Pyrimidine ribonucleotide de novo biosynthesis3Lipid metabolism, molecular transport, small molecule biochemistry6
LXR/RXR activation5Cell morphology, cell-mediated immune response1
Retinoate biosynthesis I3Cell-to-cell signaling and interaction, cellular assembly and organization1
162 μgRetinol biosynthesis10Cellular movement, cellular assembly and organization, cellular function and maintenance33
Neuregulin signaling16Cellular movement, cell death and survival, drug metabolism30
Acute phase response signaling23Infectious disease, organismal injury and abnormalities, cell morphology29
Role of tissue factor in cancer16Lipid metabolism, molecular transport, small molecule biochemistry29
Aldosterone signaling in epithelial cells20Cellular development, cellular growth and proliferation28
Glucocorticoid receptor signaling29Cell-mediated immune response, cellular development, cellular function and maintenance28

Table 5. Significantly enriched canonical pathways and networks in in vivo exposure.

*Number of genes significantly regulated in each pathway or network
CSV
Download CSV

A detailed study of a subset of genes implicated in the processes mentioned above revealed dose-specific responses ranging from imbalances in nucleotide synthesis in the low dose to inflammation, angiogenesis and lipid metabolism related effects in the high dose. For instance, we found significant down-regulation of adenylate kinase 8 (-2.1 fold), ectonucleoside triphosphate diphosphohydrolase 2 and 8 (-1.9 and -2.0 fold), and nucleoside diphosphate kinase 5 (-2.1) in the low dose. These genes are actively involved in the synthesis and metabolism of uridine-5’-triphosphate (UTP) and adenosine triphosphate (ATP) nucleotides required for the maintenance of ion homeostasis in the lungs [58,59]. Decreased synthesis and depletion of pyrimidine nucleotides prevents blockade of the epithelial sodium channels, increase alveolar fluid clearance and clearance of lung edema in mice infected with respiratory syncytial virus and influenza A virus [58-60]. Metabolism of adenine nucleotides in human airway epithelial surfaces plays a role in the regulation of mucociliary clearance related epithelial functions. Imbalances in this pathway can lead to inhibition of sodium ion transport leading to accumulation of alveolar fluid and pulmonary edema. Excess ATP in the lung fluids is suggested to contribute to the onset of inflammation in humans suffering from pulmonary pathology including alveolar damage, inflammation and edema (reviewed in 61. Enrichment of de novo pyrimidine synthesis pathway in the low dose group may thus reflect a non-specific cellular response to invasion of lungs with particles, possibly an effort leading to their clearance. In the medium dose, a dramatic up-regulation of several acute phase and inflammation associated genes such as Saa3 (12.3-fold), Saa1 (7.0 fold), Saa2 (12.0 fold), Il6 (4-fold), Ccl7 (7.0 fold), Ccl11 (5-fold), Ccl13 (6.0 fold), and Ccl24 (10.0 fold) was noted. These changes suggest an active recruitment of inflammatory cells to the site of exposure aiding in clearance efforts. These genes are also affected by the high dose. However, in addition to a significant up-regulation of genes implicated in acute phase and inflammation pathway in the high dose, down regulation of carboxylesterases 2C and 2E (-1.7, -2.1 fold), dehydrogenase reductase (-1.6 fold), retinol binding proteins 1 and 7 (-1.7, -2.4 fold), lecithin retinol acyltransferase (-3.0 fold) and up-regulation of esterase D (1.65 fold), lipoprotein lipase (2.5 fold), lipase-hormone sensitive (2.5 fold), amphiregulin (3.0 fold), epiregulin (2.8 fold) were noted. These genes are involved in functions such as angiogenesis, lipid metabolism, and cellular proliferation. Combined analysis of all genes altered under these pathways using the GeneGo Metacore map creator tool revealed that of the 80 genes associated with the pathways described above, 60 were commonly regulated by E2f1 (a cell cycle regulatory transcription factor), Il6 (an inflammatory modulator) and C-myc (an oncogene). We note that these regulators were also significantly differentially expressed in the treated groups (Figure 6).

thumbnail
Figure 6. Gene network.

Combined analysis of all significantly differentially expressed genes associated with angiogenesis, lipid metabolism, and cellular proliferation pathways in lungs in the high dose group. Analysis was conducted and the network was built using GeneGo Metacore map creator. The figure shows that the majority of the genes are commonly regulated by E2f1, Il6 and C-myc. Hexagons represent physical and functional interactions: TR – transcription regulation, IE - influence on expression, B – binding, and GR – group. The green arrows represent positive regulation/activation, the brown arrows represent negative regulation/inhibition and the grey arrows represent unspecified regulation.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0080452.g006

In general, the above results reveal a clear distinction in tissue response across the doses. The response in the lowest (18 μg or 0.22 µg/cm2) dose was marked by a negative regulation of the cell cycle process, in parallel with changes in the nucleotide metabolism and synthesis pathways. Cell cycle arrest and imbalance of nucleotide metabolism can be viewed as early regulatory signals initiating an organism’s defense functions including phagocytic mopping and airway clearance mechanisms in lungs. This was evident in the medium dose (54 μg or 0.66 µg/cm2), which showed positive regulation of acute phase response and inflammatory mediators. In the high dose (162 μg or 1.98 µg/cm2), the overall response was much greater than the other two dose groups and included simultaneous enrichment of several biological processes including inflammation, acute phase response, angiogenesis, pro-and anti-fibrotic factors, and anti-oxidants.

Overview of in vitro microarray results

Lung epithelial cell monolayers were exposed to 12.5 (low), 25.0 (medium) and 100 μg (high) Mitsui7/ml (corresponding to 3.9, 7.8 and 31.19 µg/cm2, respectively) for 24h as described in methods and materials. MAANOVA analysis was applied to identify differentially expressed genes. This gene list was filtered to remove probes that were below our detection threshold (i.e., probes that were not expressed above background levels). This analysis revealed a total of 1931 unique genes represented by 2413 probes that were significantly differentially expressed (FDR adjusted P<0.05 and ±1.5 fold change) in the cells exposed to 12.5, 25 or 100 μg Mitsui7/ml (3.9, 7.8 and 31.19 µg/cm2). A dose-dependent increase in transcriptional effects was found, with a total of 782 (432 genes down-regulated and 350 up-regulated), 1337 (682 down-regulated and 655 up-regulated), and 1721 (921 down-regulated and 801 up-regulated) genes differentially expressed in the 12.5, 25 and 100 μg Mitsui7/ml (3.9, 7.8 and 31.19 µg/cm2) groups, respectively. The full list of significant genes is available in Table S2. A total of 565 genes were affected by every concentration of Mitsui7 (Figure 7A). Most of the genes that were affected in the medium and high concentration groups were also affected in the low concentration group (Figure 7A) and were mainly associated with Aryl hydrocarbon receptor (AHR) signaling, glutathione mediated detoxification, acute phase response signaling, cholesterol biosynthesis, hepatic fibrosis/hepatic stellate activation, and NRF2 mediated oxidative stress response. A list of genes affected in common for every concentration analyzed is provided in Table S3.

thumbnail
Figure 7. Overview of response in FE1 cells.

(A) Venn diagram showing the overlapping differentially expressed genes (FDR P ≤ 0.05 and fold change ≥ 1.5) in response to low (12.5 µg, green), medium (25 µg, blue), and high (100 µg, red) doses of Mitsui7 in vitro. (B-C) Gene ontology (GO) analysis of differentially expressed genes. (B) Commonly regulated GO biological processes (C) GO biological processes unique to the high dose group. Numbers in parentheses represent number of genes altered in that process.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0080452.g007

To be consistent with the analysis conducted on in vivo microarray results, we employed GO functional classification to assign specific functional or biological processes to the differentially expressed genes following in vitro exposure to Mitsui7. The common and unique biological processes significantly enriched in different exposure groups across the dose groups are shown in Figures 7B and 7C. Processes involved in steroid biosynthetic process [GO: 16126], vasculature development [GO: 1944], regulation of cell proliferation [GO: 42127], response to protein stimulus [GO: 51789], and ncRNA metabolic process [GO: 34660] were the commonly over-represented GO groups (i.e., consistently appearing within two or three exposure groups) and consisted of 96 genes. In the medium and high concentration groups these processes were further represented with GO terms such as blood vessel morphogenesis [GO: 48514], angiogenesis [GO: 1525], and positive regulation of cellular proliferation [GO: 8284]. Several GO processes were uniquely altered in the high concentration group and included oxidation reduction [GO: 55114], response to hypoxia [GO: 1666, GO: 70482], cell cycle arrest [GO: 7050], cell death [GO: 8219, GO: 16265, GO: 12501], organ development [GO: 48568, GO: 60348, GO: 42724, GO: 51216, GO: 1501, GO: 48705], extracellular matrix organization [GO: 30198], regulation of activity [GO: 51338, GO: 45859, GO: 43549, GO: 44092], and lipid biosynthetic process [GO: 8610]. Of particular interest, and in contrast to our in vivo findings, analysis of GO processes and functions revealed a high degree of overlap across the exposure groups, with exceptions generally only occurring at the highest concentration. This suggests that although the number of genes and the magnitude of change (i.e., fold change) exhibited a dose-response, there was no accompanying concentration-dependent increment in the nature of toxicity. Thus, the results indicate that the lowest concentration itself was capable of inducing a similar response/toxicity as what was observed in the medium and high exposure groups.

To identify potential biological pathways affected by MWCNT exposure in lung epithelial cells, the significant gene list (Table S2) was overlaid onto molecular canonical pathways in IPA. Four major canonical pathways were identified as commonly affected in all the three dose groups: hepatic fibrosis/hepatic stellate cell activation, aryl hydrocarbon receptor signaling, super pathway of cholesterol biosynthesis, and glutathione-mediated detoxification. The majority of the genes implicated in these pathways were down-regulated. Table 6 lists all of the genes involved in these four pathways. Gene interaction networks were then created to visualize the linkages between the different genes and pathways using the IPA network tool. Figure 8 shows the three top scoring networks within each concentration merged into a single concentration-specific meta-network. In the low concentration, organ development, cardiovascular system development and function, and cancer networks were merged. The network consisted of several nodes including: C-fos, Crem1, Ctgf, Cebpa, and Ahr. In the medium exposure group, cellular growth and proliferation, organismal development and drug metabolism, and glutathione depletion networks were merged. This network consisted of core nodes including; alpha catenin, Ptgs2, Ahr, Myc, and Nrf2. In the high concentration, cellular development, lipid metabolism, cell cycle and tissue development networks were merged with Cebpa and Cebpb, Hmga1, Ptgs2, and Fos as the main nodes.

Canonical PathwaysGene names*
Hepatic Fibrosis/Hepatic Stellate Cell ActivationActa2, Ccl5, Col1a1, Col1a2, Col3a1, Ctgf, Cxcr3, Edn1, Fas, Fgf1, Figf, Igf1, Il1r1, Il1rl1, Il4r, Lama1, Lbp, Met, Mmp13, Myh10, Myl6b, Pdgfa, Pdgfc, Pdgfra, Pdgfrb, Rela, Serpinb2, Smad4, Tgfb2, Tgfb3, Tnfrsf11b, Tnfrsf1a, Vcam1, Vegfa
Aryl Hydrocarbon Receptor Signaling Ahr, Aldh1a1, Aldh3b1, Aldh4a1, Aldh6a1, Aldh7a1, Aldh9a1, Ccnd1, Ccnd3, Cdkn1A, Cyp1b1, Esr1, Fas, Fos, Gsta3, Gsta5, Gstm1, Gstm3, Gsto1, Gsto2, Gstt1, Hsp90b1, Hspb2, Jun, Mdm2, Mgst1, Myc, Nfe2l2, Nqo2, Rela, Tgfb2, Tgfb3, Tgm2
Superpathway of Cholesterol BiosynthesisAcat2/Acat3, Dhcr7, Dhcr24, Ebp, Fdft1, Fdps, Hadhb, Hmgcs1, Hsd17b7, Idi1, Lss, Msmo1, Mvd, Mvk, Nsdhl, Pmvk, Sc5dl, Sqle, Tm7sf2
Glutathione-Mediated DetoxificationGsta3, Gsta4, Gsta5, Gstm1, Gstm3, Gsto1, Gsto2, Gstt1, Gstt3, Gstz1, Mgst1

Table 6. Top four canonical pathways affected in all three doses in vitro.

*Genes associated with each of the pathways are presented.
CSV
Download CSV
thumbnail
Figure 8. Top three biological networks in vitro.

The networks were generated by merging the top three networks in each of the dose and were based on the connectivity between each gene and the molecular interaction knowledge base in IPA. Nodes are highlighted in large bold font. Green indicates down-regulation and red indicates up-regulation.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0080452.g008

Overall, in vitro lung epithelial cells showed a robust response to Mitsui7 with alterations in numerous critical functions including gene expression (expression of many transcription factors were altered), metabolism, cellular growth and proliferation, and these changes were found in genes involved in numerous potential diseases such as cancer and fibrosis. However, the response was not dose-dependent; major biological processes and functions altered in the high (100 μg/ml or 31.19 µg/cm2) concentration were also altered significantly in the lowest (12.5 μg/ml or 3.9 µg/cm2) exposure group, suggesting that the lowest dose chosen was sufficiently high to cause the severe cellular damage.

Comparison of gene expression profiles of in vivo lung tissue and in vitro lung epithelial cells

In order to determine the relevance of responses observed in cultured lung epithelial cells following exposure to Mitsui7 to in vivo lung responses, we analysed all differentially expressed genes (compared to unexposed control) from both cell cultures and tissues using IPA’s function analysis tool. Three categories were included in the analysis: Diseases and Disorders, Molecular and Cellular Functions and Physiological System Development and Function. More than 10 individual high-level processes were significantly enriched and in common to both cell cultures and tissues under each of the three categories. We filtered these high level individual functions by 1) removing redundant functions with overlapping genes, and 2) removing functions that were not directly relevant to the present study (e.g. renal diseases, auditory diseases etc.). The final list of the top most significantly affected high-level biological functions are shown in Figures 9A and 9B.

thumbnail
Figure 9. Comparison of biological functions and networks altered in vitro and in vivo.

Top 10 biological functions altered in lung epithelial cells (A, C, E) and in the lung tissue (B, D, F). The spatial visualization of gene network associated with the biological functions cellular growth and proliferation (C-D) and cancer (E-F). Grey lines connect the significantly differentially expressed genes to the annotation terms associated with each biological function.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0080452.g009

Since the objective was to directly compare the responses in both cells in culture and tissues, we chose to analyze two high-level functions in detail systematically. Cellular growth and proliferation was one of the top high-level functions under the Molecular and Cellular functions category. A total of 155, 214 and 274 genes in the low, medium, and high concentrations in vitro, and 32, 36 and 211 genes in the low, medium, and high doses in vivo were associated with cellular growth and proliferation. In cell cultures, this function was enriched with annotation terms such as proliferation of cells, muscle cells, fibroblasts, connective tissue cells, and mesenchymal cells (Figure 9C). In the lung tissues however, cellular growth and proliferation function was associated with annotation terms such as proliferation of cells, tumor cells, immune cells, blood cells and proliferation of mononuclear leukocytes (Figure 9D). We then analysed the high-level function given the name ‘cancer’ that was significantly enriched in both cell cultures and tissues under the Diseases and Disorders category. A total of 103, 163, and 220 genes in the low, medium, and high concentrations in vitro, and 60, 40, and 159 genes in the low, medium, and high concentrations in vivo were associated with this function. This function was associated with terms such as cancer, epithelial neoplasia, cell transformation, solid tumor, and metastasis both in vivo and in vitro (Figures 9E and 9F). In tissues, annotation terms included growth of tumour, neoplasia of cells, carcinoma, metastasis and other related terms for this function. Further systematic analysis of all of the genes associated with cellular growth and proliferation and cancer revealed that in vitro these genes primarily include transcription factors and transcription regulators. In contrast, genes affected in vivo were grouped primarily into two categories involved with growth factors and inflammatory modulators in addition to other secretory molecules. In keeping with this result we found significant enrichment of the function ‘gene expression’ in cells in culture, with > 200 genes in this category compared to approximately 10 genes associated with ‘gene expression’ function in tissues (Figure 10). Our analysis clearly demonstrates that significantly more genes are associated with cell signalling in vivo compared to in vitro following Mitsui7 exposure. These results indicate that although most of the genes altered in both in vivo and in vitro belong to the same functional categories, suggesting a similar biological response to Mitsui7, the underlying mechanisms and the outcome of such alteration could potentially be different in the two systems studied.

thumbnail
Figure 10. The total number of genes perturbed in the categories of gene expression and cellular signalling functions.

Green: low dose (12.5 µg in vitro, 18 µg in vivo), blue: medium dose (25 µg in vitro, 54 µg in vivo), and red: high dose (100 µg in vitro, 162 µg in vivo).

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0080452.g010

We explored the in vitro and in vivo data sets to identify potential commonalities in the two systems that may contribute to the same biological outcome, and thus point to the specific relevance of this cell culture model. We conducted a detailed analysis of the responsive genes in the top five significantly enriched canonical pathways affected in both cells and lung tissues. This downstream analysis was limited to the top five affected pathways to minimize the number of interpretations. The top five pathways included: hepatic fibrosis/hepatic stellate activation, AHR signalling, glutathione mediated detoxification, superpathways of cholesterol synthesis, and LPS/IL-1 mediated inhibition of RAR function. Since hepatic fibrosis/hepatic stellate activation and LPS/IL-1 mediated inhibition of RAR function showed a high amount of overlap (i.e., genes functioning in both pathways), we excluded the latter from the analysis. Our examination of all of the genes grouped under each of these pathways revealed that these genes are all regulated by a common nuclear receptor, AHR, and are associated with four major biological processes regulated by the AHR: cell cycle regulation, xenobiotic metabolism, inflammation, and tissue fibrosis (Figure 11). While the common genes involved in cell cycle regulation were similarly up-regulated in both tissues and cell cultures exposed to Mitsui7, genes involved in glutathione mediated detoxification and fibrosis were down-regulated in both systems. Although changes in expression of genes associated with similar functions (cell cycle, inflammation and fibrosis) were observed across all of the concentrations, perturbation of cell cycle and xenobiotic metabolism processes were only observed in the low dose group in the lung tissues, and perturbations in inflammation and fibrosis were only observed at the high dose in vivo. These results confirm our earlier interpretation that there was a dose dependent transition in response/toxicity in tissues, but there was no such dose-related transition of biological functions (by IPA) in cell cultures.

thumbnail
Figure 11. Differentially expressed genes associated with five top canonical pathways derived from IPA analysis.

Genes are categorized into four major functions (cell cycle regulation-orange, xenobiotic metabolism-green, inflammation-violet, and tissue fibrosis-blue). All genes in both models are regulated by a common transcription factor, AHR. Genes highlighted with green indicate down-regulation and genes highlighted with red indicate up-regulation. The transcription factor AHR is down-regulated in cells, suggesting negative regulation of the downstream functions in cells.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0080452.g011

In addition to the analysis described above, we also examined our gene lists for markers of inflammation, oxidative stress, and tissue damage (fibrosis) since these effects are the well-characterized endpoints for both tissues and cells in culture following exposure to MWCNT. More than 100 genes that are known to be associated with each of these characteristic markers of MWCNT were used to build a heat-map (Figure 12) to visualize the similarities and differences between the test systems. Only the genes that showed significant expression changes in either cell cultures and/or the lung tissues treated with Mitsui7 (in at least one exposure group) are shown in color (red up-regulated; green down-regulated; grey no change). Although the total number of genes altered in each of these pathways was somewhat similar between the two models, differentially expressed genes in vitro were associated mainly with positive regulation of oxidative stress and fibrosis. In the lung tissues, perturbed genes were associated predominantly with pro-inflammation. Although the lung tissue showed significant alteration in the expression of a number of genes in the fibrosis category, expression profile was indicative of negative regulation of fibrosis. ROS generation and oxidative stress have been proposed to be the primary mode of action of many ENM [1], where a balance between enzyme-mediated ROS generation and ROS detoxification by antioxidant enzymes and the level of intracellular antioxidants such as glutathione regulate intracellular ROS-mediated stress. Up-regulation of antioxidant enzymes including SOD, catalase, GPx and thioredoxin is considered as indication of adaptation to oxidative stress [62]. In the lung tissue, oxidative stress-associated genes, such as Sod2, Ucp2, and Ucp3, were up-regulated. SOD2 is localized to mitochondria and transforms superoxide radicals into hydrogen peroxide that in turn are converted to water and oxygen by catalase or glutathione peroxidase. Uncoupling protein 2 and 3 (UCP-2, -3) are the major components of the electron transport chain. Ucp genes act to uncouple the proton gradient in the inner mitochondrial membrane, allowing protons to re-enter the mitochondrial matrix thereby regulating build-up of ROS in cells [63,64]. Similar mitochondrial respiration leakage and up-regulation of mitochondria-specific antioxidants such as SOD2 has been reported in mice intratracheally instilled with SWCNT [65]. The results suggest that the oxidative stress observed in vivo was potentially due to mitochondrial respiration leakage. In contrast, Sod1 and Sod3 were down-regulated in vitro and Hmox1, Sqstm1, Srxn1, Txnip, Txnrd1, Txnrd3 were up-regulated. These differences suggest that broadly different mechanisms are driving the oxidative stress in vitro. However, it is important to note that the observed differences could also be due to the different time points investigated in the two systems. Further work considering early time points is warranted to rectify these conclusions.

thumbnail
Figure 12. Gene heatmap comparing differentially expressed genes in the categories of fibrosis, inflammation and oxidative stress.

Red represents up-regulation, green represents down-regulation and grey represents no change in the expression.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0080452.g012

A similar contradiction in the underlying mechanisms involved in the function ‘fibrosis’ was also observed in the two systems. Matrix metalloproteinases (MMPs) were up-regulated in cells in culture, whereas, the expression of inhibitors of metalloproteinases (TIMP) was increased in the lung tissue. A profound increase in the expression of several acute phase stress genes (Saa, Cxcls and Ccls), chemokines, and cytokines was observed in the lung tissue, mainly reflecting chemotaxis and infiltration of inflammatory cells into the lungs. However, in contrast, increased expression of inflammatory genes was associated with epithelial activation (e.g., Ccl5, Ptgs2) in vitro. Overall, these results suggest different mechanisms, varying degrees of severity in response and potentially different biological outcomes to Mitsui7 exposure in epithelial cells in culture and lung tissue.

In order to understand if the observed discrepancies between the models were due to basal level differences in the expression of genes in the two systems studied, we compared gene expression profiles of vehicle treated controls of lung epithelial cells and mouse lung tissues. We found that 60% of the genes had comparable expression levels (15,972 of 26,409 analyzed), which included genes implicated in the inflammatory and acute phase responses. Thus, differences in expression were observed for 40% of the genes (Table S4) and these genes were mainly associated with biological processes such as Cellular growth and proliferation, Cancer, Cell death and survival, Cell cycle and Cellular movement in lung epithelial cells, which mainly reflect the consequences of cellular immortalization processes. These results imply that altered basal expression levels in thousands of genes involved in Growth and Proliferation, Cell cycle and other important biological functions may play a critical role in how cells in culture respond to external stimuli such as nanomaterials. The high basal levels of expression of several growth and survival factors may provide protection against cellular injury caused by exposure to nanomaterials. This hypothesis was supported by the observed lack of response in cells treated with very low concentrations of MWCNT (described below, Table 7 and 8). In contrast, changes in the expression of important acute phase and inflammatory genes were observed in lung tissues even at the very low doses. Our results suggest that data from single cell models must be interpreted with caution.

 Genes2μg   6 μg  18 μg54 μg162 μg
PCR arrayPCR arrayPCR arrayMicroarray  PCR arrayMicroarray  PCR arrayMicroarray
Saa35.5--9.9215.812.3348.745.6
Cxcl5--66.9-188.85.381.54.1
Cxcl1--8.02.320.53.922.14.7
Ccl2-3.614.53.5-5.021.93.9
Ccl7-8.0-5.565.96.920.24.3
Il6-2.0-2.8-4.016.16.5
Timp1-3.0-7.7-9.713.111.7
Ccl11-4.4-3.015.65.25.33.4
Saa1---3.8-7.05.012.3
Ccl173.15.27.83.57.53.44.92.8
Ccl31.9-3.71.9--4.62.4
Lox--2.1-1.8-3.82.4
Myc1.5-1.9-2.0-3.01.9
Cd14--2.4-2.7-2.92.0
Ccl19------2.72.5
Il33---2.83.8-2.6-
Cxcl10-2.4-4.513.86.02.5-
Thbs1--1.9--2.92.42.1
Ctgf------2.42.0
Gclc-1.32.1---2.21.8
Fth1------2.02.3
Ptgs1------1.92.8
Nox4----1.8-3.6--1.7-
Ltb--1.5-----2.2-2.1
Serpinh1--1.8----2.6-2.2
Tnfsf10-----2.3--4.5-2.8
Timp3--1.5-1.7--2.0--2.3
Sod2-------1.8
Ucp2---1.6--2.0--2.2
Cxcl13----5.3--3.8
Prdx6--1.8-2.4-1.5-3.0--1.5
Ucp3--1.7-2.5--2.0--2.2
Edn1--1.7---2.5--1.9
Itga3-----1.7--2.1
C3-1.8-2.32.8---

Table 7. RT-qPCR validation of genes in lung tissue.

Only significantly differentially expressed genes are shown (FDR P<0.05, fold change >1.5 in either direction). Data were normalized using Hprt, Gapdh, and Actb as reference genes.
CSV
Download CSV
 Genes0.001250.1251.2512.525.0100.0
PCR arrayPCR arrayPCR arrayPCR arrayMicroarrayPCR arrayMicroarrayPCR arrayMicroarray
Mmp13--1.615.09.718.212.727.610.6
Serpine1---7.32.95.93.910.15.0
Ccl5---2.33.04.32.78.03.4
Ctgf---3.93.05.44.37.74.6
Mmp3--2.933.13.55.33.97.03.0
Sqstm1---4.01.84.12.06.22.6
Grem1--1.72.42.53.42.45.52.5
Tgif1---5.52.04.42.35.02.5
Hmox1---2.7-3.12.14.72.5
Myc---4.11.83.02.84.62.6
Tnfrsf11b----1.72.13.02.24.32.0
Jun----2.32.82.83.73.0
Ptgs2---5.42.52.62.93.72.6
Spp1---3.32.03.2-3.5-
Fos---1.5-7.8-2.7-3.11.8
Vegfa-----2.2-2.71.6
Edn1---1.52.22.62.52.72.2
Txnip---2.5-2.0-2.61.7
Txnrd1---3.11.72.21.92.52.1
Srxn1-----1.71.52.11.5
Txnrd3---2.9-2.01.72.11.8
Cebpb-------1.81.6
Cygb---1.7-1.6-1.61.8-1.6
Cx3cl1-----2.4-1.8-2.4-1.5-2.3
Plat-----1.6-1.8-1.6-1.5-1.5
C3----2.8-2.0-1.7-2.1-1.7-2.2
Il1r1----2.2-1.7-2.1-1.7-1.9-2.0
Cxcl12----5.6--1.9-2.3-2.1-3.0
Col3a1----8.6-1.8-2.1-2.4-2.3-3.3
Il18----9.6-1.8-2.5-2.0-2.4-2.4
Smad6----3.6-1.8-2.4-2.1-2.5-2.7
Tgfb3----5.0--2.4-1.9-2.5-2.7
Il15----3.0-1.5-2.6-1.5-2.7-1.5
Idh1----4.9--2.3-1.9-3.0-2.0
Dcn----4.9--2.7-3.4-3.1-4.7
Aox1----4.5-2.4-4.1-3.2-3.7-3.2
Tgfb2----7.9-1.7-3.5-2.3-4.6-3.4
Il33----67.3-3.6--4.4-13.0-6.8
Col1a2----5.6-1.7--2.4--2.8
Gpx7----2.3-----1.8
Pdgfa----1.7-1.5----1.5
Cxcr3---1.61.51.9---

Table 8. RT-qPCR validation of genes in cells.

Only significantly differentially expressed genes are shown (FDR P<0.05, fold change >1.5 in either direction). Data were normalized using Gapdh and Actb as reference genes.
CSV
Download CSV

Validation of microarray results by RT-qPCR

We validated 42 genes altered in cell cultures and 42 genes in tissues (84 in total) categorised under three main established markers of MWCNT-induced effects: oxidative stress, inflammation, and fibrosis. A complete list of genes validated by RT-qPCR is provided in Table S5. Because the exposures used in the DNA microarray analysis are considered to be high compared to the expected exposure levels in the environment, we included a range of lower (lower than 12.5 μg/ml in in vitro and lower than 18 μg/mouse in vivo) exposure levels for RT-qPCR validation. The final validation by RT-qPCR included 0.0125, 0.125, 1.25, 12.5, 25 and 100 µg/ml in FE1 cells, and 2, 6, 18, 54, 162 µg/mouse in vivo. The RT-qPCR results were broadly consistent with the microarray results (Tables 7 and 8). Interestingly, in cell cultures, no significant changes were observed, with the exception of moderate down-regulation of Mmp3 and up-regulation of Cx3cl1 at the lowest concentration (0.0125 µg/ml) tested, (we note that the direction of change for Cx3cl1 was reversed at the higher concentrations). In order to confirm that lack of response in FE1 cells following low concentration exposures was not due to the analysis of only a subset of genes associated with a few biological effects, global analysis of gene expression analysis was performed (as described above) on the lower concentration (0.0125, 0.125, 1.25 µg/ml) groups. The microarray analysis (data not shown) confirmed the subtle response observed by RT-qPCR. In contrast, in the lung tissues, several genes (Saa3, C3, Cxcl10, Myc, Ccl3, Ccl17, Ccl11, Timp1, IL6, Ccl7, Ccl2 and Cxcl5) involved in acute phase and inflammation were significantly up-regulated even at the lowest concentrations tested (2 µg/mouse). The data suggest that the lung tissue is generally more sensitive to Mitsui7 exposure than the FE1 lung epithelial cells and that these genes can potentially be used as sensitive markers of exposure to Mitsui7 and like particles.

Perspectives

Despite the urgent need for rapid in vitro assays that are predictive of in vivo toxicity for ENM testing, few in vitro validation exercises have been conducted to comprehensively characterize mechanistic similarities and differences for ENM-exposed cells in culture compared to tissues from live model organisms exposed to ENM. Existing publications on this topic have been limited to a small selection of biological endpoints that include inflammation, oxidative stress, and tissue damage (reviewed in 9,66-68). In these existing studies, the in vivo lung toxicity assays applied have generally consisted of analysis of BAL fluid for markers of inflammation (infiltration of inflammatory cells, increased production of cytokines and chemokines), oxidative stress (oxidative stress markers, DNA damage), and cytotoxicity (LDH and alkaline phosphatase). These measurements are then analyzed in parallel in cells exposed in vitro to the same substance. For example, Wang et al. [15], measured markers of fibrosis in lung tissues and in different lung cell culture models and found good agreement between the profibrogenic responses in vitro and in vivo [15]. In another study, Horie et al. [69] measured levels of hydroperoxy octadecadienoate (tHODE), an indicator of oxidative stress, in rat lungs exposed to nickel nanoparticles and in cells exposed in Petri culture dishes. They showed comparable increases in tHODE 24 hours after the exposure to particles in vivo and in vitro [69]. However, although similar perturbations were described in vitro and in vivo in the above studies, the magnitude of response between the lung tissue and cells in culture in the above studies was different. These differences in the magnitude of response may occur because of difficulties in matching the predicted particle-exposed lung surface area to the surface area of Petri dishes in which the cells are incubated. Moreover, in vivo studies evaluated toxicity in complex multi-cellular tissues; whereas, in vitro studies primarily focus on understanding the response of a single cell type isolated from a specific organ.

In the present study, we exposed mice via instillation and incubated mouse lung epithelial cells in culture dishes to three different doses of Mitsui7. Our in vivo to in vitro dose comparison was based on the total lung surface area and the total surface area of the Petri dish in which cells were exposed (Table 2). Unlike previous studies, we analyzed the global gene expression response to Mitsui7 in lung tissue and cells using comprehensive and high-content DNA microarrays to globally characterize potential mechanistic differences in response. Three major concepts emerged from this analysis: (1) the primary toxic response in vivo was an early acute phase and inflammation dose-response which was not activated in vitro; (2) the in vitro model is less responsive than the in vivo at lower doses and does not show a dose-response pattern in the induction of toxicity pathways at increasingly higher concentrations; and (3) both models respond by activating similar core cellular functions (oxidative stress and fibrosis) at the pathway level, however, regulation of most individual genes, the underlying mechanisms and consequent nature of the biological response are different. We suggest that careful consideration should be given to the in vitro concentrations selected, the types of cells used, and the endpoints studied when deriving regulatory decisions for ENM such as Mitsui7.

Supporting Information

File S1.

Characterization of Mitsui7 in dispersion medium.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0080452.s001

(PDF)

Figure S1.

DLS measurements of Mitsui7 in different dispersion medium.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0080452.s002

(PDF)

Table S1.

Genes differentially expressed in vivo.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0080452.s003

(XLS)

Table S2.

Genes differentially expressed in vitro.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0080452.s004

(XLS)

Table S3.

Genes commonly enriched in the three dose groups in vitro.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0080452.s005

(XLS)

Table S4.

List of genes showing differential expression in control lung epithelial cells vs control lung tissue samples.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0080452.s006

(XLS)

Table S5.

List of genes validated by RT-PCR in lung tissue and in lung epithelial cells.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0080452.s007

(XLS)

Acknowledgments

The authors thank Michael Guldbrandsen and Anne-Karin Asp for technical assistance, and Dr. Nikolai Chepelev and Dr. Sourav Mukherjee for critically reviewing the manuscript.

Author Contributions

Conceived and designed the experiments: SSP NRJ HW UV SH. Performed the experiments: SSP NRJ DW MH JPB OA CK KM ZOK ATS. Analyzed the data: SSP SL MH AW SH. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: SH CLY HW UV. Wrote the manuscript: SSP SH. Revisited the manuscript critically for important intellectual content, and approved the final manuscript: SSP NRJ SL DW MH AW JPB OA CK KM ZOK ATS CLY HW UV SH..

References

  1. 1. Nel A, Xia T, Mädler L, Li N (2006) Toxic potential of materials at the nanolevel. Science 311: 622-627. doi:https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1114397. PubMed: 16456071.
  2. 2. Choi JY, Ramachandran G, Kandlikar M (2009) The impact of toxicity testing costs on nanomaterial regulation. Environ Sci Technol 43: 3030-3034. doi:https://doi.org/10.1021/es802388s. PubMed: 19534109.
  3. 3. Seagrave J, McDonald JD, Mauderly JL (2005) In vitro versus in vivo exposure to combustion emissions. Exp Toxicol Pathol 57 Suppl 1: 233-238. doi:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.etp.2005.05.011. PubMed: 16092731.
  4. 4. Sayes CM, Reed KL, Warheit DB (2007) Assessing toxicity of fine and nanoparticles: comparing in vitro measurements to in vivo pulmonary toxicity profiles. Toxicol Sci 97: 163-180. doi:https://doi.org/10.1093/toxsci/kfm018. PubMed: 17301066.
  5. 5. Warheit DB, Sayes CM, Reed KL (2009) Nanoscale and fine zinc oxide particles: can in vitro assays accurately forecast lung hazards following inhalation exposures? Environ Sci Technol 43: 7939-7945. doi:https://doi.org/10.1021/es901453p. PubMed: 19921917.
  6. 6. Sayes CM, Marchione AA, Reed KL, Warheit DB (2007b) Comparative pulmonary toxicity assessments of C60 water suspensions in rats: few differences in fullerene toxicity in vivo in contrast to in vitro profiles. Nano Lett 7: 2399-2406. doi:https://doi.org/10.1021/nl0710710. PubMed: 17630811.
  7. 7. Johnston HJ, Hutchison GR, Christensen FM, Peters S, Hankin S et al. (2010) A critical review of the biological mechanisms underlying the in vivo and in vitro toxicity of carbon nanotubes: The contribution of physico-chemical characteristics. Nanotoxicology 4: 207-246. doi:https://doi.org/10.3109/17435390903569639. PubMed: 20795897.
  8. 8. Johnston HJ, Hutchison G, Christensen FM, Peters S, Hankin S et al. (2010) A review of the in vivo and in vitro toxicity of silver and gold particulates: particle attributes and biological mechanisms responsible for the observed toxicity. Crit Rev Toxicol 40: 328-346. doi:https://doi.org/10.3109/10408440903453074. PubMed: 20128631.
  9. 9. Park MV, Lankveld DP, van Loveren H, de Jong WH (2009) The status of in vitro toxicity studies in the risk assessment of nanomaterials. Nanomedicine (Lond) 4: 669-685. doi:https://doi.org/10.2217/nnm.09.40. PubMed: 19663595.
  10. 10. Mitchell LA, Gao J, Wal RV, Gigliotti A, Burchiel SW et al. (2007) Pulmonary and systemic immune response to inhaled multiwalled carbon nanotubes. Toxicol Sci 100: 203-214. doi:https://doi.org/10.1093/toxsci/kfm196. PubMed: 17660506.
  11. 11. Ma-Hock L, Treumann S, Strauss V, Brill S, Luizi F et al. (2009) Inhalation toxicity of multiwall carbon nanotubes in rats exposed for 3 months. Toxicol Sci 112: 468-481. doi:https://doi.org/10.1093/toxsci/kfp146. PubMed: 19584127.
  12. 12. Aschberger K, Johnston HJ, Stone V, Aitken RJ, Hankin SM et al. (2010) Review of carbon nanotubes toxicity and exposure--appraisal of human health risk assessment based on open literature. Crit Rev Toxicol 40: 759-790. doi:https://doi.org/10.3109/10408444.2010.506638. PubMed: 20860524.
  13. 13. Nasibulin AG, Pikhitsa PV, Jiang H, Brown DP, Krasheninnikov AV et al. (2007) A novel hybrid carbon material. Nat Nanotechnol 2: 156-161. doi:https://doi.org/10.1038/nnano.2007.37. PubMed: 18654245.
  14. 14. Dresselhaus MS, Dresselhaus G, Charlier JC, Hernandez E (2004) Electronic, thermal and mechanical properties of carbon nanotubes. Philos Trans A Math Phys Eng Sci 362: 2065-2098.
  15. 15. Wang X, Xia T, Ntim SA, Ji Z, Lin S et al. (2011) Dispersal state of multiwalled carbon nanotubes elicits profibrogenic cellular responses that correlate with fibrogenesis biomarkers and fibrosis in the murine lung. ACS Nano 5: 9772-9787. doi:https://doi.org/10.1021/nn2033055. PubMed: 22047207.
  16. 16. Wang X, Katwa P, Podila R, Chen P, Ke PC et al. (2011) Multi-walled carbon nanotube instillation impairs pulmonary function in C57BL/6 mice. Part Fibres Toxicol 8: 24. doi:https://doi.org/10.1186/1743-8977-8-24. PubMed: 21851604.
  17. 17. Reddy AR, Reddy YN, Krishna DR, Himabindu V (2012) Pulmonary toxicity assessment of multiwalled carbon nanotubes in rats following intratracheal instillation. Environ Toxicol 27: 211-219. doi:https://doi.org/10.1002/tox.20632. PubMed: 20862737.
  18. 18. Porter DW, Hubbs AF, Mercer RR, Wu N, Wolfarth MG et al. (2010) Mouse pulmonary dose- and time course-responses induced by exposure to multi-walled carbon nanotubes. Toxicology 269: 136-147. doi:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tox.2009.10.017. PubMed: 19857541.
  19. 19. Pauluhn J (2010) Subchronic 13-week inhalation exposure of rats to multiwalled carbon nanotubes: toxic effects are determined by density of agglomerate structures, not fibrillar structures. Toxicol Sci 113: 226-242. doi:https://doi.org/10.1093/toxsci/kfp247. PubMed: 19822600.
  20. 20. Pauluhn J (2010) Multi-walled carbon nanotubes (Baytubes): approach for derivation of occupational exposure limit. Regul Toxicol Pharmacol 57: 78-89. doi:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.yrtph.2009.12.012. PubMed: 20074606.
  21. 21. Yamashita K, Yoshioka Y, Higashisaka K, Morishita Y, Yoshida T et al. (2010) Carbon nanotubes elicit DNA damage and inflammatory response relative to their size and shape. Inflammation 33: 276-280. doi:https://doi.org/10.1007/s10753-010-9182-7. PubMed: 20174859.
  22. 22. Poland CA, Duffin R, Kinloch I, Maynard A, Wallace WA et al. (2008) Carbon nanotubes introduced into the abdominal cavity of mice show asbestos-like pathogenicity in a pilot study. Nat Nanotechnol 3: 423-428. doi:https://doi.org/10.1038/nnano.2008.111. PubMed: 18654567.
  23. 23. Takagi A, Hirose A, Nishimura T, Fukumori N, Ogata A et al. (2008) Induction of mesothelioma in p53+/- mouse by intraperitoneal application of multi-wall carbon nanotube. J Toxicol Sci 33: 105-116. doi:https://doi.org/10.2131/jts.33.105. PubMed: 18303189.
  24. 24. Takagi A, Hirose A, Futakuchi M, Tsuda H, Kanno J (2012) Dose-dependent mesothelioma induction by intraperitoneal administration of multi-wall carbon nanotubes in p53 heterozygous mice. Cancer Sci 103: 1440-1444. doi:https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1349-7006.2012.02318.x. PubMed: 22537085.
  25. 25. Yauk CL, Williams A, Buick JK, Chen G, Maertens RM et al. (2011) Genetic toxicology and toxicogenomic analysis of three cigarette smoke condensates in vitro reveals few differences among full-flavor, blonde, and light products. Environ Mol Mutagen 53: 281-296. PubMed: 22431010.
  26. 26. Maertens RM, White PA, Williams A, Yauk CL (2013) A global toxicogenomic analysis investigating the mechanistic differences between tobacco and marijuana smoke condensates in vitro. Toxicology 308C: 60-73.
  27. 27. Jacobsen NR, White PA, Gingerich J, Møller P, Saber AT et al. (2011) Mutation spectrum in FE1-MUTA(TM) Mouse lung epithelial cells exposed to nanoparticulate carbon black. Environ Mol Mutagen 52: 331-337. doi:https://doi.org/10.1002/em.20629. PubMed: 20963790.
  28. 28. Berndt-Weis ML, Kauri LM, Williams A, White P, Douglas G et al. (2009) Global transcriptional characterization of a mouse pulmonary epithelial cell line for use in genetic toxicology. Toxicol Vitro 23: 816-833. doi:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tiv.2009.04.008. PubMed: 19406224.
  29. 29. Arlt VM, Gingerich J, Schmeiser HH, Phillips DH, Douglas GR et al. (2008) Genotoxicity of 3-nitrobenzanthrone and 3-aminobenzanthrone in MutaMouse and lung epithelial cells derived from MutaMouse. Mutagenesis 23: 483-490. doi:https://doi.org/10.1093/mutage/gen037. PubMed: 18635558.
  30. 30. Jacobsen NR, Saber AT, White P, Møller P, Pojana G et al. (2007) Increased mutant frequency by carbon black, but not quartz, in the lacZ and cII transgenes of muta™mouse lung epithelial cells. Environ Mol Mutagen 48: 451-461. doi:https://doi.org/10.1002/em.20300. PubMed: 17584883.
  31. 31. Jacobsen NR, Møller P, Cohn CA, Loft S, Vogel U et al. (2008) Diesel exhaust particles are mutagenic in FE1-Muta™Mouse lung epithelial cells. Mutat Res 641: 54-57. doi:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.mrfmmm.2008.03.001. PubMed: 18423769.
  32. 32. Saber AT, Koponen IK, Jensen KA, Jacobsen NR, Mikkelsen L et al. (2011) Inflammatory and genotoxic effects of sanding dust generated from nanoparticle-containing paints and lacquers. Nanotoxicology 6: 776-788. PubMed: 21995293.
  33. 33. Saber AT, Jensen KA, Jacobsen NR, Birkedal R, Mikkelsen L et al. (2012) Inflammatory and genotoxic effects of nanoparticles designed for inclusion in paints and lacquers. Nanotoxicology 6: 453-471. doi:https://doi.org/10.3109/17435390.2011.587900. PubMed: 21649461.
  34. 34. Saber AT, Jacobsen NR, Mortensen A, Szarek J, Jackson P et al. (2012) Nanotitanium dioxide toxicity in mouse lung is reduced in sanding dust from paint. Part Fibres Toxicol 9: 4. doi:https://doi.org/10.1186/1743-8977-9-4. PubMed: 22300483.
  35. 35. Bourdon JA, Saber AT, Jacobsen NR, Jensen KA, Madsen AM et al. (2012) Carbon black nanoparticle instillation induces sustained inflammation and genotoxicity in mouse lung and liver. Part Fibres Toxicol 9: 5. doi:https://doi.org/10.1186/1743-8977-9-5. PubMed: 22300514.
  36. 36. Jackson P, Hougaard KS, Boisen AM, Jacobsen NR, Jensen KA et al. (2012) Pulmonary exposure to carbon black by inhalation or instillation in pregnant mice: Effects on liver DNA strand breaks in dams and offspring. Nanotoxicology 6: 486-500. doi:https://doi.org/10.3109/17435390.2011.587902. PubMed: 21649560.
  37. 37. White PA, Douglas GR, Gingerich J, Parfett C, Shwed P et al. (2003) Development and characterization of a stable epithelial cell line from Muta Mouse lung. Environ Mol Mutagen 42: 166-184. doi:https://doi.org/10.1002/em.10185. PubMed: 14556224.
  38. 38. Jacobsen N, Moller P, Jensen K, Vogel U, Ladefoged O et al. (2009) Lung inflammation and genotoxicity following pulmonary exposure to nanoparticles in ApoE-/- mice. Part Fibres Toxicol 6: 2. doi:https://doi.org/10.1186/1743-8977-6-2.
  39. 39. Kerr MK, Churchill GA (2007) Statistical design and the analysis of gene expression microarray data. Genet Res 89: 509-514. doi:https://doi.org/10.1017/S0016672308009713. PubMed: 18976541.
  40. 40. Kerr MK, Churchill GA (2001) Statistical design and the analysis of gene expression microarray data. Genet Res 77: 123-128. PubMed: 11355567.
  41. 41. Kerr MK (2003) Design considerations for efficient and effective microarray studies. Biometrics 59: 822-828. doi:https://doi.org/10.1111/j.0006-341X.2003.00096.x. PubMed: 14969460.
  42. 42. Yang YH, Dudoit S, Luu P, Lin DM, Peng V et al. (2002) Normalization for cDNA microarray data: a robust composite method addressing single and multiple slide systematic variation. Nucleic Acids Res 30: e15. doi:https://doi.org/10.1093/nar/30.4.e15. PubMed: 11842121.
  43. 43. R-Development-Core-Team (2009) R: A language and environment for statistical computing. Vienna, Austria:. R Foundation for Statistical Computing.
  44. 44. Wu H, Kerr M, Cui X, Churchill G (2003) Maanova: A software package for the analysis of spotted cdna microarray experiments. NY: Springer Verlag. pp. 313-341.
  45. 45. Cui X, Hwang JT, Qiu J, Blades NJ, Churchill GA (2005) Improved statistical tests for differential gene expression by shrinking variance components estimates. Biostat Engl Oxf, 6: 59-75. PubMed: 15618528.
  46. 46. Benjamini Y, Hochberg Y (1995) Controlling the false discovery rate: a practical and powerful approach to multiple testing. J R Stat Soc B Stat Methodol) 57: 289-300.
  47. 47. Searle SR, Speed FM, Milliken GA (1980) The population marginal means in the linear model: An alternative to least squares means Am Stat 34: 216-221. doi:https://doi.org/10.1080/00031305.1980.10483031.
  48. 48. Goodnight JH, Harvey WR, editors (1978) Least-Squares Means in the Fixed-Effects General Linear Models, SAS Technical Report. p. R. -103 . Cary, NC: SAS Institute Inc.
  49. 49. Han JH, Lee EJ, Lee JH, So KP, Lee YH et al. (2008) Monitoring multiwalled carbon nanotube exposure in carbon nanotube research facility. Inhal Toxicol 20: 741-749. doi:https://doi.org/10.1080/08958370801942238. PubMed: 18569096.
  50. 50. Mercer RR, Hubbs AF, Scabilloni JF, Wang L, Battelli LA et al. (2011) Pulmonary fibrotic response to aspiration of multi-walled carbon nanotubes. Part Fibres Toxicol 8: 21. PubMed: 21781304.
  51. 51. Gleich GJ, Loegering DA (1984) Immunobiology of eosinophils. Annu Rev Immunol 2: 429-459. doi:https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev.iy.02.040184.002241. PubMed: 6399849.
  52. 52. Han B, Guo J, Abrahaley T, Qin L, Wang L et al. (2011) Adverse effect of nano-silicon dioxide on lung function of rats with or without ovalbumin immunization. PLOS ONE 6: e17236. doi:https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0017236. PubMed: 21359146.
  53. 53. John AE, Lukacs NW, Berlin AA, Palecanda A, Bargatze RF et al. (2003) Discovery of a potent nanoparticle P-selectin antagonist with anti-inflammatory effects in allergic airway disease. FASEB J 17: 2296-2298. PubMed: 14563683.
  54. 54. Halappanavar S, Jackson P, Williams A, Jensen KA, Hougaard KS et al. (2010) Pulmonary response to surface-coated nanotitanium dioxide particles includes induction of acute phase response genes, inflammatory cascades, and changes in microRNAs: a toxicogenomic study. Environ Mol Mutagen 52: 425-439. PubMed: 21259345.
  55. 55. Husain M, Saber AT, Guo C, Jacobsen NR, Jensen KA et al. (2013) Pulmonary instillation of low doses of titanium dioxide nanoparticles in mice leads to particle retention and gene expression changes in the absence of inflammation. Toxicol Appl Pharmacol 269: 250-262. doi:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.taap.2013.03.018. PubMed: 23557971.
  56. 56. Bourdon JA, Halappanavar S, Saber AT, Jacobsen NR, Williams A et al. (2012) Hepatic and pulmonary toxicogenomic profiles in mice intratracheally instilled with carbon black nanoparticles reveal pulmonary inflammation, acute phase response, and alterations in lipid homeostasis. Toxicol Sci 127: 474-484. doi:https://doi.org/10.1093/toxsci/kfs119. PubMed: 22461453.
  57. 57. Saber AT, Lamson JS, Jacobsen NR, Ravn-Haren G, Hougaard KS et al. (2013) Particle-Induced Pulmonary Acute Phase Response Correlates with Neutrophil Influx Linking Inhaled Particles and Cardiovascular Risk. PLOS ONE 8: e69020. doi:https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0069020. PubMed: 23894396.
  58. 58. Wolk KE, Lazarowski ER, Traylor ZP, Yu EN, Jewell NA et al. (2008) Influenza A virus inhibits alveolar fluid clearance in BALB/c mice. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 178: 969-976. doi:https://doi.org/10.1164/rccm.200803-455OC. PubMed: 18689466.
  59. 59. Davis IC, Lazarowski ER, Hickman-Davis JM, Fortenberry JA, Chen FP et al. (2006) Leflunomide prevents alveolar fluid clearance inhibition by respiratory syncytial virus. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 173: 673-682. doi:https://doi.org/10.1164/rccm.200508-1200OC. PubMed: 16387801.
  60. 60. Davis IC, Lazarowski ER, Chen FP, Hickman-Davis JM, Sullender WM et al. (2007) Post-infection A77-1726 blocks pathophysiologic sequelae of respiratory syncytial virus infection. Am J Respir Cell Mol Biol 37: 379-386. doi:https://doi.org/10.1165/rcmb.2007-0142OC. PubMed: 17541010.
  61. 61. Button B, Boucher RC (2008) Role of mechanical stress in regulating airway surface hydration and mucus clearance rates. Respir Physiol Neurobiol 163: 189-201. doi:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resp.2008.04.020. PubMed: 18585484.
  62. 62. Ma Q (2010) Transcriptional responses to oxidative stress: pathological and toxicological implications. Pharmacol Ther 125: 376-393. doi:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pharmthera.2009.11.004. PubMed: 19945483.
  63. 63. Echtay KS, Roussel D, St-Pierre J, Jekabsons MB, Cadenas S et al. (2002) Superoxide activates mitochondrial uncoupling proteins. Nature 415: 96-99. doi:https://doi.org/10.1038/415096a. PubMed: 11780125.
  64. 64. Echtay KS, Murphy MP, Smith RA, Talbot DA, Brand MD (2002) Superoxide activates mitochondrial uncoupling protein 2 from the matrix side. Studies using targeted antioxidants. J Biol Chem 277: 47129-47135. doi:https://doi.org/10.1074/jbc.M208262200. PubMed: 12372827.
  65. 65. Chou CC, Hsiao HY, Hong QS, Chen CH, Peng YW et al. (2008) Single-walled carbon nanotubes can induce pulmonary injury in mouse model. Nano Lett 8: 437-445. doi:https://doi.org/10.1021/nl0723634. PubMed: 18225938.
  66. 66. Snyder-Talkington BN, Qian Y, Castranova V, Guo NL (2012) New perspectives for in vitro risk assessment of multiwalled carbon nanotubes: application of coculture and bioinformatics. J Toxicol Environ Health B Crit Rev 15: 468-492. doi:https://doi.org/10.1080/10937404.2012.736856. PubMed: 23190270.
  67. 67. Maurer-Jones MA, Haynes CL (2012) Toward correlation in in vivo and in vitro nanotoxicology studies. J Law Med Ethics 40: 795-801. PubMed: 23289681.
  68. 68. Han X, Corson N, Wade-Mercer P, Gelein R, Jiang J et al. (2012) Assessing the relevance of in vitro studies in nanotoxicology by examining correlations between in vitro and in vivo data. Toxicology 297: 1-9. doi:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tox.2012.03.006. PubMed: 22487507.
  69. 69. Horie M, Fukui H, Nishio K, Endoh S, Kato H et al. (2011) Evaluation of acute oxidative stress induced by NiO nanoparticles in vivo and in vitro. J Occup Health 53: 64-74. doi:https://doi.org/10.1539/joh.L10121. PubMed: 21233593.